Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers...

58
©2013 MFMER | slide-1 Merging of Two Rivers Christianity and Hinduism Fr. Joseph P. Chacko, M.A., L.P.C, B.C.C Chaplain, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN

Transcript of Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers...

Page 1: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-1

Merging of Two Rivers

Christianity and Hinduism

Fr. Joseph P. Chacko, M.A., L.P.C, B.C.C

Chaplain, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, MN

Page 2: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-2

Learning Objectives The participants will be able understand

• Who is a Hindu?

• The differences between Popular Hinduism and Scriptural Hinduism

• The Great Two Epics: Ramayana & Maha- Bharatha

• Vedas and Vedantas

• Inculturation and Eastern attempts

• Indianization and Western attempts

Page 3: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-3

River Ganges and River Jordan

Page 4: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-4

Water = H2O

Page 5: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-5

Hinduism and Christianity

Page 6: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-6

Can HINDUISM merge with CHRISTIANITY?

Can CHRISTIANITY merge with

HINDUISM?

Page 7: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-7

Two Types of Religions

Natural Religions

• Hinduism

• Buddhism

• Paganism

• Tribal Religions

• Confucianism

Religions Revealed

• Judaism

• Christianity

• Islam

Page 8: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-8

A Point Where the Creator and the Creature Meet

Page 9: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-9

Hinduism

Page 10: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-10

Other Names for Hinduism

• Sanadhana Dharma = Eternal Religion

• Manava Dharma = Religion of Humanity

• Arya Dharma = Noble Religion

• Vaidiki Dharma = Religion of Knowledge

Page 11: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-11

Who Is A Hindu?

• Comes from the Persian language. Referred to the people who lived in the other side of River Indus or Sindu (Indus, presently in Pakistan).

• Anyone in India, who is not a Christian, Muslim, Sikh, Buddhist, Jain, Parsi (Zoroastrian), and Jew.

• Strictly speaking, though tribels are not Hindus, they are also considered as Hindus.

Page 12: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-12

Page 13: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-13

Page 14: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-14

Who Is A Hindu?

One who believes in the supremacy of VEDAS and lives in accordance with DHARMA.

(Dharma = righteousness: good moral and ethical practices in accordance with the Vedas/scriptures).

Page 15: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-15

Major Hindus Scriptures (Texts)

• PURANAS – Ancient stories

• VEDAS – Knowledge (Four Vedas)

• UPANISHADS – END OF VEDAS – Philosophical Discourses

• ITHIHASA - Epics

• JOTHISHA- Astrology

• CHARAKA SAMHITA – AYURVEDA – Medical Science

Page 16: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-16

Two Forms of Hinduism

Popular Hinduism

• Two great epics: Ramayana & Mahabharatha

• Puranas (Old Stories)

• Polytheism

• Gods and Goddesses

Scriptural Hinduism

• Vedas

• Upanishads

• Monotheistic

• Philosophical

Page 17: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-17

Popular Hinduism

Page 18: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-18

Devas (Suras) & Asuras

• Benevolent super human beings

• Shining beings

• Live in heaven

• Malevolent super human beings

• Forces of evil

• Live in Pathala (Nether world)

Page 19: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-19

God Can Appear to Humans in Multiple Names and Forms (Eshwar)

Page 20: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-20

TRIMOORTHIS: Brahma, Vishnu, Shiva

Page 21: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-21

Avatars

Whenever there is decay of righteousness O! Bharatha And a rise of unrighteousness then I manifest Myself!

For the protection of the good, for the destruction of the wicked and for the establishment of righteousness, I am born in every age (Gita IV:7-8)

The purpose of Avatar is to establish order.

Page 22: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-22

Brahma & Saraswati

Page 23: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-23

Vishnu & Lakshmi

Page 24: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-24

SHIVA & Parvathi (DURGA)

Page 25: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-25

Two Sects

• SHIVISM (Shivites)

• Worshipers of Lord Shiva

• Mainly in South India

• Vaishavism (Vaishanavites)

• Worshipers of Lord Vishnu

• Mainly in North India

Page 26: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-26

Two Great Epics

Ramayana Mahabharatha

Page 27: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-27

Scriptural Hinduism

Page 28: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-28

Four Vedas

• Rig-veda – Praises

• Sama-veda- Melodies

• Yajur-veda - Sacrifices

• Adarva-veda – Occult?

• Ayur-veda = Health (upaveda)

Page 29: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-29

Upanishids (Vedantas)

Brahman & Atman

Page 30: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-30

Brahman & Atman

• Brahman = God

• No Beginning, No End

• Omni Potent

• Omni Present

• Atman = Soul

• Inside of the creature

• Eternal (body is mortal, soul is eternal)

• Can enter into other forms (rebirth)

Page 31: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-31

Advaita Vedanta

• God (Brhaman) is One

• If you are experiencing Brahman in duality, it is because of ignorance (avidya)

Page 32: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-32

Brahman & Eshwar

• Eshwar is the personification of Brahman

• Can come in different forms (The reason for Polytheism)

• Can be a lover, protector, family deity, a holy man/woman, animal

• It is a personal God

Page 33: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-33

Page 34: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-34

Four Castes

• Brahmins – Priests

• Kshatriyas – Warriors

• Vaisias - Working class/business class

• Shudras – Subservient

Page 35: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-35

Four Goals of Life

• Dharma ( Righteousness, Duty)

• Ardha ( Security)

• Kama (Enjoyment)

• Moksha (Heaven, Liberation)

Page 36: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-36

Four Core Principles

• Dharma = Individual ethics, duties and obligations

• Samsara= Life in the world (cycle of action, reaction, birth, death, and rebirth)

• Karma = Personal (right) actions (moral law of cause and effect)

• Moksha= Salvation

Page 37: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-37

Four Stages of Life

• Brahmacharya = Learning

• Gruhastashrama = Household affairs

• Vanaprastha = Retirement

• Sanyasa = Renunciation

Page 38: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-38

Four Ways to Attain Moksha (Salvation, Heaven)

• BHAKTI MARGA (Path of devotion)

• KARMA MARGA (Path of dutiful actions)

• JNANA MARGA (Path of knowledge – Vedas –ability to know what is real vs. illusion)

• YOGA MARGA (Controlling of mind-consciousness

Page 39: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-39

Bodhi sathva Enlightened

Self

Yogi

Yoga =

Practice

Union

Page 40: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-40

Are we able to see Jesus out of his Semitic identity?

Page 41: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-41

Jesus: the Bodhisattva (Enlightened Being)

Page 42: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-42

Inculturation

The word became flesh and dwelt among us. (John 1:14)

Page 43: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-43

Muslim Attempt

Akbar the Great (1542-1602)

His Contribution

• Included Hindus and Christians in his court

• Din-i-illahi = Divine faith : Faith derived form the teachings of Islam, Hinduism, Christianity, Jainism and Zoroastrianism.

• Practiced religious tolerance

Page 44: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-44

Socio-Religious-Political Condition

• Hinduism and Islam

• British rule

• English education, religion, and philosophy.

• Caste system, Sati, situation of women, Brahmanic supremacy.

• Contributions of Christianity to Europe (Protestant reformation)

• Anti-colonial attitude

Page 45: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-45

• Raja Ram Mohan Roy (1772 -1833)

• Father of Modern India

• Founder of Brahmo Samaj

• Assembly of worshipers of Brahman

• The (nameless) unsearchable Eternal, Immutable Being who is the Author and Preserver of the Universe

• To abolish caste system, dowry, sati

• For the emancipation of women

Page 46: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-46

Indianization (Hindu) Attempts

Page 47: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-47

• Kesabu Chandra Sen (1838-1884)

• Embraced Christian

thinking, ideas and

even British rule

• “New Dispensation” (integrating Christian and Hindu religions)

• Jesus Christ, Europe and Asia (1866)

Page 48: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-48

• Sadhu Sundhar Singh(1889 – ca.1929)

• Converted from Sikhism to Christianity (Anglican) at the age of 16.

• ‘Christianity could not penetrate India unless it was in an Indian way’

• He became a Sadhu (Mendicant).

• Though he joined an Anglican seminary, he left the seminary for not willing to wear western clerical dress

• Indian Christian mysticism

Page 49: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-49

A J Appaswamy (1891-1971)

• Bishop of Church of South India

• His father converted to Christianity

• Studied yoga and mystical practices and mingled Hindu practices with Christian belief.

• 1915 came to USA – Harvard University

K C Banerjee (1847 – 1902)

• Converted to Anglicanism

• Founder of Christo Samaj

Page 50: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-50

Manilal C Parekh (1885 – 1967)

• Converted to Anglicanism

• Hindu Church of Christ

• Jesus-Yogi (Born as Yogi)

• A Hindu Disciple of Christ (Christian- Hindu)

• Published in 1943 “A Hindu’s Portrait of Jesus Christ”

P. Chenchiah (1886-1959)

• Converted to Christianity

• Judge in Madras Presidency

• Founded Madras Christo Samaj

• Spoke against Western Christian Theology

• 1938 “Rethinking Christianity in India”

• Influenced by Teilhard de Chardin and Sri Aurobindo Ghosh

Page 51: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-51

Inculturation (Catholic) Attempts

Page 52: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-52

• Roberto de Nobili S.J. (1577-1656)

• 1605 Arrived in Goa

• Moved to Madurai and started to live and dress like a Hindu sannyasin

• He used Hindu rituals, Indian customs, local languages for Christian ceremonies

• He was vehemently opposed by fellow missionaries

• Pope Gregory XV sanctioned his reforms

Page 53: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-53

• Fr. Bede Griffith.OSB (1906 -1993)

• Received the name Swami Dayananda

• Convert from Anglicanism

• Became a Benedictine Monk

• Came to India

• One of the founders of Christian Ashram Movement

Page 54: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-54

• Henry Le Saux (1910 -1973)

• Benedictine monk

• Became Abhishiktananda

• Co-founder of Sachidananda Ashram

• Indian-Ashram movement.

Page 55: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-55

• Fr. Reymondo Panicker. S.J (1918-2010)

• "I left Europe [for India] as a Christian, I discovered I was a Hindu and returned as a Buddhist without ever having ceased to be Christian”.

• The Unknown Christ of Hinduism (1964)

Page 56: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-56

• Fr. Amalorpavadas (1932 -1990)

• Founder of Anjali Ashram, Mysore

Page 57: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-57

Some Vedic Prayers

• Om Loka samastha sughino bhavanthu = May all the world be happy

• From the unreal lead me to real

From darkness lead me to light

From death lead me to immortality

Page 58: Merging of Two Rivers - The National Association of ... - Presentation... · Merging of Two Rivers ... •Who is a Hindu? ... birth, death, and rebirth) •Karma = Personal (right)

©2013 MFMER | slide-58

Some Great Thoughts

Evam sathyam vipra bahutha vadanti = The truth is one, wise men talk about it differently.

Aham Brahmasmi = I am God or I am part of God.

Antharayamin = God who is inside.

Isavasyam idam Sarvam = God dwells everywhere.

God is Satchidananda = Existence, intellect and happiness