Meeting Agenda of the AIR QUALITY TECHNICAL COMMITTEE … › file › 2020 › 06 ›...

24
Meeting Agenda of the AIR QUALITY TECHNICAL COMMITTEE June 24, 2020 1:00 p.m. Zoom URL: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89192275083?pwd=MkRtZlJjdHVyeCt6Z0wvc1YrQWpPZz09 Passcode: JuneAQTC Conference Line: 301-715-8592 Passcode: 89192275083# All participation will be via the Zoom meeting location due to the State of Emergency declared by Governor Polis, Public Health Orders 20-23 and 20-14 (revised), Governor Polis’ March 25, 2020 Stay at Home Order D2020 017, and CDC recommendations against gathering in large groups in order to mitigate the spread of the COVID-19 virus. Agenda items marked with indicate that additional materials were included in packets mailed to members. Please park in the large parking lot on the east side of the building and enter the east entrance to the lower level. 1. CALL TO ORDER 2. PUBLIC COMMENTS – For items not on the agenda 3. PRESENTATION Regional Air Quality Council Control Strategies – Jessica Ferko, Regional Air Quality Council 4. DISCUSSION: AQTC Membership Update 5. DISCUSSION: Strategies for the EPA Ozone Advance Program 6. STATUS OF PUBLIC OUTREACH AND AWARENESS ACTIVITIES Health Advisory Warnings Social Media Updates 7. MEMBER ENTITY ANNOUNCEMENTS 8. ITEMS FOR FUTURE AQTC MEETINGS 9. ADJOURNMENT The Meeting Room is accessible to persons with disabilities. In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), those requiring special assistance, such as large-type face print, sign language or other reasonable accommodations, may request those through the administrative offices at: 15 S 7th St, Colorado Springs, CO 80905 (719) 471-7080, at least twenty-four hours before the meeting. Si necesita ayuda con traducción, llame por favor al 719-471-7080 x126 y comuníquese con Brian Potts.

Transcript of Meeting Agenda of the AIR QUALITY TECHNICAL COMMITTEE … › file › 2020 › 06 ›...

  • Meeting Agenda of the AIR QUALITY TECHNICAL COMMITTEE

    June 24, 2020 1:00 p.m.

    Zoom URL: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89192275083?pwd=MkRtZlJjdHVyeCt6Z0wvc1YrQWpPZz09

    Passcode: JuneAQTC

    Conference Line: 301-715-8592

    Passcode: 89192275083#

    All participation will be via the Zoom meeting location due to the State of Emergency declared by Governor Polis, Public Health Orders 20-23 and 20-14 (revised), Governor Polis’ March 25, 2020 Stay at Home Order D2020 017,

    and CDC recommendations against gathering in large groups in order to mitigate the spread of the COVID-19 virus.

    Agenda items marked with indicate that additional materials were included in packets mailed to members. Please park in the large parking lot on the east side of the building and enter the east entrance to the lower level.

    1. CALL TO ORDER

    2. PUBLIC COMMENTS – For items not on the agenda

    3. PRESENTATION

    • Regional Air Quality Council Control Strategies – Jessica Ferko, Regional Air Quality Council

    4. DISCUSSION: AQTC Membership Update

    5. DISCUSSION: Strategies for the EPA Ozone Advance Program

    6. STATUS OF PUBLIC OUTREACH AND AWARENESS ACTIVITIES • Health Advisory Warnings • Social Media Updates

    7. MEMBER ENTITY ANNOUNCEMENTS

    8. ITEMS FOR FUTURE AQTC MEETINGS

    9. ADJOURNMENT

    The Meeting Room is accessible to persons with disabilities. In compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), those requiring special assistance, such as large-type face print, sign language or other reasonable accommodations, may request those through the administrative offices at: 15 S 7th St, Colorado Springs, CO 80905 (719) 471-7080, at least twenty-four hours before the meeting. Si necesita ayuda con traducción, llame por favor al 719-471-7080 x126 y comuníquese con Brian Potts.

    https://us02web.zoom.us/j/89192275083?pwd=MkRtZlJjdHVyeCt6Z0wvc1YrQWpPZz09

  • Meeting Minutes of the

    AIR QUALITY TECHNICAL COMMITTEE June 24, 2020

    1:00 p.m.

    Link to meeting video: https://youtu.be/MKuthK7kqN8

    1. CALL TO ORDER / INTRODUCTIONS

    • Meeting called to order at 1:00 p.m.

    • People in attendance: Sam Bailey, Ann Werner, Jessica McMullen, Jessica Ferko, Robin Izer, Mike Silverstein, Maigan Dunlap, Marla Luckey, Richard Yohn, Megan Carpenter, Katie Helm, Chris Welch, Victoria Chavez, Erika Alanis, Jon Hunter, Kevin Shrewsbury, Katheryn Wegner, Anton Rampage, Richard Coffin, Judith Rice-Jones, Kevin Storms, Jarek Krych

    2. PUBLIC COMMENTS

    • No comments were made.

    3. PRESENTATION

    • Regional Air Quality Council Control Strategies – Regional Air Quality Council o RAQC appointed by Governor, PPACG is the lead agency for this region o 29 board members; not a regulatory body, advisory only o Goals: 1. Ozone 2. Climate Improvements (public education & outreach) o Millions in money every year to give away to programs to attain goals o History on air quality o Program updates:

    ▪ Simple Steps ▪ Alternative fuels-Charge Ahead Colorado ▪ Mow Down Pollution ▪ Air Quality Planning-Serious Area Ozone-SIP

    o Rolling 3-year ozone design values: 70ppm is the goal o Regional Trends: 2020-2023 o Federally Enforceable Control Measures o Measures Being Evaluated o Measures Evaluated But Not Considered o Timeline control measure implementation o Robin question: Dedicated funding source?

    ▪ Response: RAQC survives on grants and asks local governments to contribute; receive about $300K/year; Helps with incentive program and administrative expenses; Compete for federal grant money through CDOT; 15 million is pass through for grant funding; Looking at how to get more money for “outside the box” applications; How to better fund raise; State legislature opportunities

    o Sam Bailey question: Any advice on how to implement without funding? How to engage the public and stakeholders?

    ▪ Response: Very hard to do with limited funds; The have asked local businesses for donations; Simple Steps Better Air Program is a program they could help us with; CMAC funding for education outreach program; Sarah Goodwin is the contact for this program and can help us with our program

    o Judith question: Asked about mowers and leaf blowers ▪ Response: RAQC has library of resources; Green contract management for incentives to go

    electric or low emissions

    https://youtu.be/MKuthK7kqN8

  • • 1:45 p.m. Sam Bailey asked to move the agenda forward

    4. DISCUSSION: AQTC Membership Update

    • Jurisdiction update: names submitted by Board

    • Two more steps: o Three non-voting at large members: environmental interest group, public transit authority and a

    business sector representative o News release for applications sent out on June 26 o Deadline is July 15th per Jessica McMullen o August: Chair discussions for this committee

    5. DISCUSSION: Strategies for the EPA Ozone Advance Program o Sam Bailey has a list in Google Docs o Spend this summer having open conversations o November/December finalize document o January 2021 submit to EPA o Conversation with Andy Gunning, start small, three themes:

    ▪ Outreach & Education ▪ Admin: funding sources ▪ Data collection: baseline data for matrix

    o These are attainable given the challenges with COVID19 and can be done virtually o Plan must be updated annually

    • Robin comment: Sorry to see transportation be dropped o Response: Can still do outreach. Transportation has funding issues. Will look at this in 2021

    • Kevin (CSU) comment: Data collection strategies: o A few strategies listed o Pandemic response and modeling o Hire consultant to evaluate economic assessment o Have DOLA funding for this o Local business survey: How are they promoting air quality policies

    • Kevin: Integrated Resource Plans from CSU for electric and gas presented to UPAC and they selected one portfolio which will be heard at the June 26th Utility Board which is expected to approve the portfolio moving forward. He can report back at the July AQTC meeting

    o Demand side management programs are meant to limit demand on CSU services. Work with large companies and other large users on reducing demand at peak times.

    6. STATUS OF PUBLIC OUTREACH AND AWARENESS ACTIVITIES • Health Advisory Warnings • Social Media Updates

    • Sam Bailey: Public outreach has been limited due to COVID19

    • COS is no longer a part of Action Day alerts because they are tied to Denver. COS will get Health Advisory alerts instead.

    • PPACG is still doing tele-working and social distancing

    • PPACG website carries posts, social media, and resource page

    • Meigan Dunlap Ft. Carson comment: She has found that the app, “AirVisual” is better for air notifications than other apps she has used

    7. MEMBER ENTITY ANNOUNCEMENTS

    • Jarek comment: Shared link from Manitou. Chart showing June 17th hourly and 8 hour data.One week ago had smoke from several fires affecting our ozone and we crossed the 70ppm limit. Can only have this happen four times per year.

    8. ITEMS FOR FUTURE AQTC MEETINGS

    • Sam Bailey: to invite Scott Lands to speak later this summer on ozone data 9. ADJOURNMENT

    • Next meeting: July 22nd

    • Meeting adjourned at 2:21 p.m.

  • Denver Metro/North Front Range Control MeasuresMike SilversteinExecutive Director, RAQC

    Jessica FerkoAQ Planner, RAQC

  • Regional Air Quality Council

    RAQC is the lead planning agency for the Denver Metro/North Front Range Ozone Nonattainment Area

    Governor appoints the 29 member Board

    Primary responsibilities:

    • Planning to meet air quality standards and improve climate conditions

    • Conduct public education and awareness programs

    • Implement public/private projects to reduce emissions

    • Represent and assist local governments in the air quality planning process

  • Denver Metro/North Front Range Air Quality Status

    Fine Particulates (PM2.5) Never Violated - Occasional Exceedances Do Occur

    Nitrogen Dioxide (NO2) Denver Attained in mid ‘80’s

    Sulfur Dioxide (SO2) Never Violated

    Lead (Pb) Denver Area Attained in mid ‘80’s

    Carbon Monoxide (CO) Denver, Longmont, Ft. Collins, Greeley Attained in 1990’s - Maintenance Areas

    Coarse Particulates (TSP&PM10) Denver Area Attained in 1993 – Maintenance Area

    Ozone (O3)1979 1-hour standard: 125 ppb1997 8-hour standard: 84 ppb2008 8-hour standard: 75 ppb2015 8-hour standard: 70 ppb

    Region Attained 1987 (Standard Revoked)Region Attained in 2009 (Standard Revoked)Region Out of ComplianceRegion Out of Compliance

  • Program Updates

    • Simple Steps. Better Air.• Heightened education/outreach efforts and planning for 2020• Reduced travel encouraged – teleworking and e-commerce!

    • ALT Fuels and Charge Ahead Colorado• $millions available – funding rounds throughout each year

    • Mow Down Pollution• Residential program going retail - $100,000+ budgeted!• Home Depot to supply product and area waste facilities to recycle old

    lawn mowers• Air Quality Planning

    • Numerous emission control strategies under development through a Board committee process

    • A new “serious area ozone SIP” will be developed by summer

  • 5

    PresenterPresentation NotesExamples of social media graphics and materials in toolkit

  • Rolling 3-Year Ozone Design Values

    6

    4th-High 8-Hour Average Ozone Concentrations 3-Year Average Design Value

    Monitor 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020* 2016-2018 2017-2019 2018-2020Chatfield State Park 78 74 83 78 62 78 78 74NREL 83 74 80 75 65 79 76 73Rocky Flats 79 75 81 72 63 78 76 72Fort Collins - West 76 75 81 71 70 77 75 74Highland 72 72 77 73 61 73 74 70Welch 75 75 66 72 59 72 71 65Greeley - Weld Tower 67 74 72 65 60 71 70 65Rocky Mtn. Nat'l Park 69 67 74 65 61 70 68 66Aurora East 66 69 72 66 60 69 69 66CAMP 70 67 71 67 54 69 68 64La Casa 69 69 72 65 56 70 68 64Fort Collins - CSU 70 66 72 64 59 69 67 65Welby 66 68 69 60 59 67 65 62Boulder Reservoir1 73 77 69 63 75 73 69Blackhawk2 69 63 69 66

    1 Boulder Reservoir monitor started operations August 20162 Blackhawk monitor started operations July 2019*Current as of 6/9/20

    Red = exceeds 75 ppb standardYellow = exceeds 70 ppb standard

    PresenterPresentation NotesThanks, mike. Hi all! So as mike mentioned the Denver metro north front range is working to come into compliance with  two national ambient air quality standards, more commonly referred to as NAAQS. These are the 2008 ozone standard of 75 parts per billion and the 2015 ozone standard of 70 parts per billionTo demonstrate attainment the area needs to have a design value at or lower than the standardFor ozone, the design value is defined as the 3 year average of the 4th highest 8 hour average ozone concentration.

    Here we have two tables showing our 4th high 8 hour average concentrations from 2016 through early June 2020 and our recent design values. Currently we are squeaking into attainment for the 75 ppb standard in the Denver metro north front range, and are not in attainment with the 70 ppb standard. As 70 parts per billion is our goal, we continue to evaluate and implement bold new strategies to reduce emissions of air pollutants.

  • Regional Trends (2010-2023)

    7

    PresenterPresentation NotesOzone is a tricky pollutant to manage as there are a lot of factors at play. As ozone is a by product of a reaction between volatile organic compounds, or VOCs, and nitrogen oxides in the presence of sunlight we need to consider the emissions of both VOC and Nox, while also considering where they are being generated and when. This graph here is our best attempt at presenting all the trends we analyze for our planning purposes.

    We have the ozone design values, our daily emission rates of voc and nox, which are our ozone precursors, population of folks in the nonattainment area, and, since our largest emission sources come from oil and gas operations and mobile sources, we have our oil and gas production rate and daily vehicle miles traveled trends as well

  • Federally Enforceable Control Measures

    • Federal On- and Non-Road Engine Standards and Regulations• AQCC Regulation No. 11 – Vehicle Inspection/Maintenance

    Programs• 7.8 Reid Vapor Pressure (RVP) with 1 PSI Ethanol Waiver Fuel

    Standard• Stage 1 Vapor Recovery Regulations• AQCC Regulation No. 7 – Oil and Gas Regulations• Regional Haze SIP Provisions• Other Stationary Source Regulations (Reg. No. 3, 6, 7 and 8)• AQCC Regulation No. 21 – Low VOC Architectural and Industrial

    Maintenance (AIM) Coatings and Consumer Products

    PresenterPresentation NotesWe have a lot of different strategies in play in the Denver metro north front range area, so for the purposes of this presentation I opted to present control measures we have in place in the Denver metro north front range in three categories: federally enforceable control measures, state enforced control measures, and measures that have been considered/are being developed for implementation as part of our current planning efforts.

    I also want to say that we are actively in the process of developing our Serious SIP under the 2008 standard and as a part of that we put together a detailed write up of all the strategies I am going through today. ’d be happy to send you all a link to the document for your more indepth review. I can drop it in the chat at the end of my presentation.

    On this slide here we have are federally enforced control measure. These measures are federally enforceable as they are federal mandates such as the engine standards, or they are provisions that are included in our state implementation plan. If there’s interest I can go a little deeper into why some control measures are included in the SIP and some aren’t or I can move along.

    Great so our federally enforceable measures include:

    Cheat Sheet:Stage 1 vapor – mandates capture vapors released from unloading transport tankers at gas stationsRegional Haze – control provisions for Electricity Generating UnitsOther Stat. Sources - Boilers, Incinerators, Graphic Arts, Pharmaceutical Synthesis, Solvents, Turbines, Kilns, Engines

  • Implemented, Non-Federally Enforceable Measures

    Source Type Measure

    Stationary Energy Efficiency/Renewables Policies and ProgramsState-Only Requirements of AQCC Regulation No. 7Minor Source Reasonably Available Control Technology - AQCC Regulation No. 3Small Business Assistance Program

    Mobile Sources Clean Air FleetsCharge Ahead ColoradoALT Fuels ColoradoDiesel Inspection/Maintenance – AQCC Regulation No. 12Low and Zero Emissions Vehicles – AQCC Regulation No. 20Electric Cars/Scooters/Bikes

    Lawn and Garden Mow Down Pollution: Residential Lawn Mower Exchange ProgramMow Down Pollution: Commercial Lawn and Garden Program

    Education & Outreach

    Simple Steps. Better Air. Ozone Education and Outreach ProgramOzone Forecast Advisory – Voluntary Emission Reduction Actions

    Transportation Transportation Demand Management ProgramBicycle and Pedestrian FacilitiesLand Use Planning and DevelopmentTransit Measures

    PresenterPresentation NotesOn this slide here we have our state-only enforceable measures. I broke these down by source type to make it a little easier to follow. So for stationary sources we have…

    Energy Efficiency/Renewables Policies and Programs – transition to renewable energyState-Only Requirements of AQCC Regulation No. 7 – oil and gas controls asMinor Source Reasonably Available Control Technology - AQCC Regulation No. 3 – this is a bit of a catch all outlining controls for various stationary sourcesSmall Business Assistance Program – this refers to the program run by the CDPHE that helps small businesses understand and comply with air and other environmental regulations

    Next we have our mobile source programs. Mike highlighted those run by the RAQC including… We also have our diesel IM program and the newly instated LEV/ZEV mandate as well as various electric car, scooter and bike programs being established in the area.

    Transportation Demand Management (Way2Go and VanGo)

  • Measures Being EvaluatedStrategy Strategy Summary

    Oil and Gas

    SHER Team/Pneumatic Task ForceContinued collaborative effort between the CDPHE and industry to assess viable control strategies for the oil and gas sector.

    Inspection and Maintenance (I/M)

    Lower cut points for gas vehicles* Tighter limits of vehicle emission levels

    Diesel I/M Program for NOx* Expand inspection of diesel vehicles to include NOx testing

    Fuels

    Low-Emissions Diesel Fuel* Implement a low emission diesel fuel standard

    Low Carbon Fuels Implement a low carbon fuel standard in the NAA

    Low-RVP Fuels* Implement a low Reid Vapor Pressure (RVP) fuel standard in the NAA

    *Strategy actively being advanced through Control Strategy Committee

    PresenterPresentation Notes

    So now we are getting into the strategies that are currently under evaluation and development as part of planning efforts aimed at 2023.

    Back in the fall of 2019 the raqc established the control strategy committee. This committee is made up of our board members and other stakeholders from the community. We came up with a list of any conceivable control measure and started our evaluation process from there that you will see listed out on these next few slides. For strategies that passed an initial “sniff test” if you would, the RAQC staff prepared white papers looking at the cost/benefit of each strategy, the feasibility of implementation, what would need to be done to advance the strategy from a regulatory/legislative standpoint, and if the strategy promoted environmental justice. Those are denoted on this list with an asterisk. All of those papers are available on our website and I’ll chat the link for that as well.

    For the sake of time I’ll not read through all of these, but do want to highlight a few that the RAQC is giving a targeted focus to right now. In April we formed three Work Groups to champion some of our bolder and more complicated to implement strategies:Clean Air Fund Work GroupEmployer Based Trip Reduction Work Group Vehicle Inspection/Maintenance and Fuels Formulation Work Group or Vimff for short

    The VIMFF work group is the umbrella where we’re housing our mobile source strategy efforts, including the gas and diesel I/M program fuel standards updates listed on this slide

  • TransportationEco–Driving Develop and promote educational programs to encourage driving practices that

    reduce fuel use and emissions.Car–Sharing Program Enable members to use cars for personal use.Parking Supply Management Decrease parking supply and increase the price of parkingDecrease Transit Fare Structure

    Decrease transit fares

    Increased Transit Service Levels

    Increase transit service

    Pay–As–You–Drive Insurance Provide vehicle insurance based on the number of miles traveled per yearFuel Tax Pricing Raise the state tax on fuel

    Commuter Trip Reduction Mandate *

    Develop a mandatory Commuter Trip Reduction program that meets the requirements of §182((d)(1)(B) of the CAA

    Strategy Strategy Summary

    Measures Evaluated

    *Strategy actively being advanced through Control Strategy Committee

    PresenterPresentation NotesOn this slide we have the transportation focused strategies Some of these did not seem to be viable at this time but we are focusing on commuter trip reduction programs through our employer based trip reduction work group. Currently the work group is looking at establishing a more robust voluntary strategy building off of the efforts such as DRCOG’s Way 2 Go program and partnering with the state on the Can Do Colorado effort that’s been launched as part of the state’s safe reopening efforts.

    If the area is reclassified to severe however, such a program could be mandatory so the work group is also beginning to establish the framework for that.

  • Strategy Strategy Summary

    Measures Evaluated

    Local Government Policies

    Lower Emissions Diesel Equipment Specifications*

    Engage MPOs to incentivize green construction contracting policy adoption by local gov’ts

    Heavy-Equipment Usage Restrictions*

    Limit operations of heavy-duty equipment in the NAA

    Vehicle Anti-Idling Restrictions*

    Expand anti-idling policies beyond the work being done by Engines Off!

    Elective Vehicle Charging Infrastructure Building Codes*

    Develop local government ordinances to incentivize or mandate the inclusion of electric charging infrastructure in new construction

    Boating Restrictions* Limit motorized boating activity

    *Strategy actively being advanced through Control Strategy Committee

    PresenterPresentation NotesHere we have some local government policies that could lead to decreased emissions. We don’t have a work group focusing on any of these, but we have put together an online library that has example policies, model ordinances and other toolkits that can be used by local governments who are interested in developing and implementing these policies. And RAQC staff is always ready and willing to help with those efforts.

  • Outreach

    VMT Reduction Strategies/Expanded Commuter Trip ReductionPrograms*

    Increase participation in ongoing VMT reduction programs and Commuter Trip Reduction programs operated by DRCOG and NFRMPO.

    Diesel Vehicle Best Management Practices*

    Increase participation in Colorado’s existing Exemplary Maintenance program for heavy duty diesel fleets.

    Out of Area Inspection and Driver Education*

    Outreach to drivers outside of the nonattainment area to increased inspections

    CDPHE Extended Forecasting Program for the Public*

    Forecast ozone more than 1 day in advance

    Measures EvaluatedStrategy Strategy Summary

    *Strategy actively being advanced through Control Strategy Committee

    PresenterPresentation NotesHere we have some additional outreach programs that the RACT is looking at. Some of these dovetail with the work group efforts and some are championed by the RAQC’s simple steps better air program.

  • Strategy Strategy Summary

    Measures Evaluated

    Land UseIndirect Source Rule Non-Road Equipment*

    Develop an indirect source rule to address emissions from development projects

    Tree Planting Guidelines/ Urban Forest Management

    Planting certain trees and managing the urban forest can have an impact on VOC and NOX emissions.

    Cannabis Cultivation Operations*

    Asses impacts of cannabis cultivation study on ozone formation.

    Increase Development Densities, Mixed Use and Connectivity to Transportation Choices

    Connect residents with a mix of land uses and transportation options can decrease the need to use a personal single–occupant vehicle for trips.

    OtherDedicated State Funding for Air Quality*

    Develop a dedicated funding source for projects that will support the reduction of air pollutants.

    *Strategy actively being advanced through Control Strategy Committee

    PresenterPresentation NotesLast we have our land use policies that we’ve been looking at, as well as our lone “other” strategy of securing additional funding. Our Clean Air Fund workgroup is focused on developing both fundraising approaches and a legislative fee proposal for direct program implementation and innovative program development. For a lot of our programs, and strategies that have proven to be successful the efficacy is limited by budget constraints. So finding the funding to expand the reach of these programs is a strategy we’re focusing on.

  • Implemented Prior to 2011 Implemented for 2017 Implemented for 2020

    • Vehicle Inspection/Maintenance• Federal Engine Standards (On-

    and Non-Road)• 7.8 RVP Fuel Standard• Ultra Low Sulfur Diesel Standards• Stage 1 Vapor Recovery• Regulation No. 7• Other Stationary Source Regs.• Small Business Assistance

    Program• Clean Air Fleets• Diesel Inspection/Maintenance• Transit and Transportation

    Network Improvements• Bicycle and Pedestrian Facilities• Land Use Planning and

    Development• Transit Measures

    • Tier 3 Fuel Standards• Renewable Fuel Standard

    Program• Regulation No. 7 Revisions• Other Stationary Source Reg.

    Revisions• Energy Efficiency and Renewable

    Energy Policies • Regional Haze SIP Provisions• Clean Air/Clean Jobs Act• EnginesOFF! Anti Idling Measures• Charge Ahead Colorado• ALT Fuels Colorado• Mow Down Pollution• Simple Steps. Better Air.• Ozone Forecasting – Voluntary

    Emission Reduction Actions

    • Regulation No. 7 Revisions• Low VOC AIM and Consumer

    Products• Low/Zero Emission Vehicle

    Regulation Adoption• Electric Transit Infrastructure

    Timeline Control Measure Implementation

    PresenterPresentation Notes

    So to wrap this all up I want to lay our this timeline of when strategies have come into play, we’ve been working on these for over a decade. Getting good strategies in places does take time but

  • 8-H

    r A

    vg

    . Ozo

    ne in

    part

    s p

    er

    billio

    n (

    pp

    b)

    8-Hour Ozone Standard: Based on a three-year average of the annual forth-highest daily 8-hour maximum ozone concentration. *Current as of 12/31/19.

    Max. 3-yr. Avg. 4th Max

    2015 Standard

    2008 Standard

    Source: Draft 2020 inventory for the DM/NFR Serious Area Ozone State Implementation Plan (SIP) for the 2008 National Ambient Air Quality Standard (NAAQS) – under development (spring 2020)

    PresenterPresentation Notes

    it works!We can see here that our ozone concentration is trending downwards and we have achieved the previous standard of 84 ppb and are on our way to attaining 75 and eventually 70

    We can also see that we have seen a significant decrease in emissions in the past decade.

    Chart1

    1998

    1999

    2000

    2001

    2002

    2003

    2004

    2005

    2006

    2007

    2008

    2009

    2010

    2011

    2012

    2013

    2014

    2015

    2016

    2017

    2018

    2019

    DV

    84

    83

    86

    81

    83

    87

    84

    82

    81

    85

    86

    82

    78

    78

    82

    83

    82

    80

    80

    79

    79

    78

    Sheet1

    YearDV

    199884

    199983

    200086

    200181

    200283

    200387

    200484

    200582

    200681

    200785

    200886

    200982

    201078

    201178

    201282

    201383

    201482

    201580

    201680

    201779

    201879

    201978

  • June - August

    Develop strategies to reduce regional ozone.

    September -October

    Begin document development.

    November

    Finalize document and begin approval process.

    December

    Final approval from PPACG.

    January 2021

    Final document due to EPA by January 2021.

    Planning Document Development and Review

    PPACG to develop content with AQTCreview

    Research and Discussion

    AQTC to prioritize strategies

    Regional Ozone Advance Program Project Timeline

    Approval Process

    • PPACG CAC

    • PPACG Board of Directors

    • EPA Advance Program

  • Draft May 27, 2020

    Theme Initiative What does this look like? Deadline Goal

    Outreach and Education

    Renewable energy education

    Outreach and Education

    Hydrogen energy

    Transportation More EV charging stations Apply to Charge Ahead Colorado grant Find gaps in region where there are no chargers

    Transportation Develop EV charging standards

    Transportation Increase telecommuting throughout the region

    Pandemic may allow this to happen organically Use baseline data to find what businesses are not telecommuting Share resources (telecommunity policy template)

    Outreach and Education

    Promote public transportation

    Transportation Expand public transit routes

  • Data Collection Expand air monitoring with more air sensors

    Apply for funding opportunities

    Transportation/ outreach and education

    Idle reduction efforts

    Administrative Apply for funding opportunities to improve regional air quality

    PPACG staff to monitor local, State and Federal grants

    Administrative Apply or budget funding to hire more staff to assist PPACG in regional air quality

    PPACG staff to monitor local, State and Federal grants

    Data Collection Hire consultant to develop economic impact assessment of the potential impacts of going into non-attainment

    Outreach and Education

    Work with local school districts to develop air quality lesson plans

    Data Collection Survey area businesses to find what ways they are improving air quality within their organization

    Outreach and Education

    Community of Practice Host informal air quality events with local stakeholders to provide outreach and education, as well as collaborate ideas

  • with AQTC

    Outreach and Education

    Simple steps to reduce ozone precursors that everyone can take, how they can save you money and how they can protect your health

    Standard messaging that can be shared to other organizations and branded with their logos - media kits

    Data Collection and Sharing

    Have PPACG retain and manage information about air quality

    Website with meeting materials archive, reports on sources of pollution, report on numbers of electric cars in EPC, Documents of PPACG Board actions, AQTC guest presentations,etc.

    Outreach and Education

    Local Government Took Kit Provide strategies, draft policies and resolutions, etc. to make it easy to partner and participate

    Types of Strategies:

    ● Outreach and Education ● Transportation ● Data Collection ● Energy Conservation ● Preparation for nonattainment designation ● Special Projects

  • ● Incentives

    Advance Program Planning Document Sections

    1. Introduction 2. Pikes Peak Regional Air Quality Data 3. PPACG Strategies - decided at June AQTC

    a. Theme 1 b. Theme 2 c. Theme 3

    4. Other Efforts a. Local jurisdictions

    i. City of Colorado Springs EV Readiness Plan ii. Manitou Springs Climate Action Plan

    b. Colorado Springs Utilities i. Integrated Resource Plans (IRP) ii. Demand Side Management (DSM) Programs

    c. Military i. Fort Carson AQ Program ii. Peterson AQ Program

    d. Local Universities i. UCCS Ozone Garden

    e. Interest Groups i. Clean Cities Coalition

    6.20 AgendaAQTC 24-June-20 minutes2020-06-18 RAQC AQTC Presentation (3)Denver Metro/North Front Range Control MeasuresRegional Air Quality CouncilDenver Metro/North Front Range Air Quality StatusProgram UpdatesSlide Number 5Rolling 3-Year Ozone Design ValuesRegional Trends (2010-2023)Federally Enforceable Control MeasuresImplemented, Non-Federally Enforceable MeasuresMeasures Being EvaluatedMeasures EvaluatedSlide Number 12Slide Number 13Slide Number 14Slide Number 15Slide Number 16

    05272020 o3 project timelinePotential Ozone Advance Strategies