Meditation: Questions and Answers

download Meditation: Questions and Answers

of 65

Transcript of Meditation: Questions and Answers

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    1/65

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    2/65

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    3/65

    MEDITATION

    ByTumuluru Krishna Murty

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    4/65

    Tumuluru Krishna Murty

    Ansuya

    C-66 Durgabai Deshmukh Colony

    Hyderabad - 500 007

    Mobile: +91 9391087255e-mail: [email protected]

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    5/65

    5

    Table of contents

    MEDITATION 3

    Goal of Mankind 9

    How to reach the Goal? 9

    What is the knowledge, when it is said the goal of mankind

    is knowledge? 10

    Atma Jnana : 10

    Brahman alone is knowledge: 10

    Unity of Jiva and Brahman: 10

    Merging of self in the over-self: 10

    How is it achieved? 11

    Where and how to search for this goal: 11

    Where does this knowledge exist? 11

    Knowledge exists in mind: 12

    Mind 12

    Mind is responsible: 12

    What is its nature? 12

    Mind causes both bondage and liberation: 12

    Subject the mind to intellect, it disintegrates: 12

    What is Sadhana? 13

    Sadhana is Yoga: 13

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    6/65

    6

    Yoga defined: 13

    Yoga is discipline: 13

    Different modes of Yoga: 13Karma Yoga (Path of Action) 13

    Bhakthi Yoga (The path of Devotion) 14

    Jnana Yoga (The Path of Knowledge) 14

    Raja Yoga 14

    Ashtanga Yogathe eight steps: 15

    Meditation or Dhana 20

    Object of Meditation 21

    "Yathabhimatadhyanadva" 21

    "Paramaariu Parama Mahatvaantesya Vashikaraah" 21

    Personal and Impersonal Meditation 21

    Yoga Sutra 28: 'Tajjapastadartha bhavanam' 22

    Forms of Meditation 23

    Importance or purpose of Meditation or Dhyana 24

    Control of Mind 27

    Prayers and Meditation: 30

    Concentration vs. Meditation 31

    Concentration and one-pointedness are the keys 33

    First develop confidence in your own self 36

    Contemplation 36

    Patanjali lists obstacles to Yoga: 37

    Regulations: 38

    Aids to Meditation: 39

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    7/65

    7

    Place and Time of Meditation 41

    Environment: 42

    How to Meditate: 43

    Method of Meditation: 43

    Vivekananda's prescription: 46

    Baba's advice: 48

    Meditation on Jyothi 49

    Bhagawan Sri Sathya Sai Baba Advice on Jyoti Dhyana And

    Soham Dhyana 51Conserve energy by all possible means 52

    Do not judge by external standards: 54

    Perseverance is sure success: 55

    The Three Paths of Meditation 56

    The pure, serene (Sathwic) path 56

    The passionate, restless (rajasic) path 56

    The ignorant (tamasic) path 57

    Meditation as cognized by other Faiths 58

    Christianity: 58

    Zoroastrian 58

    Suffism: 59

    Islam: 59

    Spanish Mystics: 60

    Yogavasishtha : 60

    Samadhi: 61

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    8/65

    8

    Samyama: 61

    Highest state of existence: 62

    Samadhi is your property 62

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    9/65

    9

    MeditationGoal of Mankind

    "The Goal of Mankind is Knowledge". (CW of SV Vol.1, p.

    27)

    The Vedas lay down four goals before man: dharma

    (righteousness), artha (wealth), kama (desire) and moksha

    (liberation). (SSS Vol.9, p. 93)

    As the rivers have the sea as their goal, Jivas have Brahman

    as their goal. Permanent joy can never be received by the

    conscious Jiva from material objects. Moksha is the

    acquisition of permanent joy. It is also called the attainment

    of Brahman. (G.V. Pg.229)

    How to reach the Goal?

    The goal of Moksha or attainment of Brahman can be

    reached by Karma, Bhakthi and Jnana Marga. All these paths

    lead us to the goal. (GV, p. 229)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    10/65

    10

    What is the knowledge, when it is said the goal of

    mankind is knowledge?

    Atma Jnana :

    Fixed exclusive devotion to Godhead can come only to those

    who have no attachment to the wild phantasmagoria of name

    and form, which is called the World. That alone can win

    Atma Jnana. (GV, p. 229)

    Brahman alone is knowledge:

    The knowledge of Atma or the knowledge that relates to

    Brahman and the knowledge that gives you some idea of

    Paramatma alone is knowledge and that is what the Veda

    says. Everything else cannot come under the description of

    knowledge. Mere recitation of the mantras contained in the

    Veda cannot be called knowledge. In other words, true

    education is that which connects Karma Yoga with theBrahma Yoga. (SSB 1974 Part II, p. 198)

    Unity of Jiva and Brahman:

    Bhagawan says,He who delves deep into the unity of theJiva and the Brahman has certainly discovered the goal of

    Life. (UV, pp. 63-64)

    Merging of self in the over-self:

    Bhagawan says "whoeversubdues his egoism, conquers his

    selfish desires, destroys his bestial feelings and impulses and

    the gives us the natural tendency to regard body as the self,

    his is surely the path of Dharma; -he knows that the goal of

    Dharma is the merging ofthe wave in the sea, the merging

    ofthe self in the Over-self". (DV, p. 4)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    11/65

    11

    How is it achieved?

    Inquiry is the method. Knowledge is acquired by

    uninterrupted Inquiry. One should constantly be engaged in

    the Inquiry of the nature of Brahman: the reality of the I. (JV,

    p. 1)

    Through Viveka (discrimination) and Vichara (inquiry), one

    achieves Vijnana (higher wisdom) and through Vijnana, one

    is able to grasp the Truth, to realise the Atma, to know the

    Atma. That is the ultimate goal of all Life, the stage that is

    beyond the Past, Present and Future. (JV, p. 20)

    Where and how to search for this goal:

    Bhagawan sys in (SSS Vol.2, p. 56) that one need not march

    towards the goal. It is not some place where you have to go.

    It is just the opening of the eye, the removal of the veil, the

    waking from the dream, the lighting of thejnana deepa (lightof spiritual wisdom).

    The Upanishads themselves declare, Jnaanaad eve thu

    kaivalyam; By Knowledge alone can freedom be won.

    (UV, p. 2)

    Where does this knowledge exist?

    Knowledge is inherent in man. No knowledge comes from

    Outside; it is all inside. What we say a man 'knows' should in

    strict psychological language be what he 'discovers' or

    'unveils', what man learns is really what he discovers taking

    the cover off his own Soul, which is a mine of infinite

    knowledge. (CWBSSB, p. 28)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    12/65

    12

    Knowledge exists in mind:

    Newton discovered the law of Gravitation. It was in his

    mind; the time came and he found it out. "All know ledge

    that the world has ever received comes from the mind; the

    infinite library of the Universe is in your mind". "All

    knowledge, secular and spiritual is in the human mind". like

    fire in a piece of flint knowledge exists in the mind;

    suggestion is the friction which brings it out (CW of SV

    Vol.1, p. 28)

    Mind

    Mind is responsible:

    For this knowledge, mind is responsible.

    What is its nature?

    It is a bundle of desires. The mind is a bundle of wishes.Unless these wishes are removed by their roots, there is no

    hope of destroying the mind, which is a great obstacle in the

    path of spiritual progress. (GV, p. 40)

    Mind causes both bondage and liberation:

    Mana eva manushyaanaam Kaaranam bandha mokshayoh:

    for men, the mind it is that causes bondage and grantsliberation. (JV, p. 19)

    Subject the mind to intellect, it disintegrates:

    The mind is the source of delusion; it deludes and binds. If

    the mind is subjected to the intellect then it disintegrates and

    disappears, leaving the field dear for the illumination that

    reveals, that "we and they are but He or It." As long as the

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    13/65

    13

    world is seen as manifold, sadhana, to overcome the faulty

    vision is essential. (SSS Vol.2, p. 448)

    What is Sadhana?

    Sadhana is just replacement of bad tendencies of the mind by

    divine attributes of the Atma. (CW of SV Vol.1, p. 96)

    Sadhana is Yoga:

    Yoga means union of the individual self with the Universal

    Self, Jivatma with Paramatma, and the human with theDivine. The innate and latent divinity in man blossoms and

    manifests itself through Yoga. (The Path Divine p. 18)

    Yoga defined:

    Patanjali defines Yoga as "chitta vrithi nirodhaha -'Calming

    down of all turbulent agitations of the mind. (The Path

    Divine Pg. 20)

    Yoga is discipline:

    Yoga therefore involves in disciplining the body, mind and

    spirit. Yoga is therefore Sadhana, the physical, mental and

    spiritual practices that lead to the final consummation

    namely the self or God-Realisation. (The Path Divine Pg. 18)

    Different modes of Yoga:

    Karma Yoga (Path of Action)

    It helps one to attain purity of mind through giving up the

    desire for the fruit of ones actions. A desire infested mind is

    bondage and a desire free mind is liberation. Hence, Karma

    Yoga directs us to do all our duties as a means to please God,without any ego of doer-ship, remembering that the energy,

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    14/65

    14

    intelligence, strength, to do all work emanate from God

    alone.

    Bhakthi Yoga (The path of Devotion)Bhakthi Yoga is cultivation, intensification and experiencing

    of a sense of total surrender to the Lord. One should have a

    conviction and feeling that he is but an instrument in the

    hands of Almighty. The heart should be suffused with

    selfless devotion and love for the Lord (and all His creation).

    Our success or failure is not our concern, ours is only to do

    our duty with discipline and devotion. Everything is to be

    crucified, he must pray as Christ did: "Father let Thy will be

    done'.

    Jnana Yoga (The Path of Knowledge)

    Jnana Yoga is an intellectual enquiry into the nature of the

    reality, negating everything else (not self) and trying to

    intuitively cognise or experience the reality, the Self. The

    path is also termed as Neti, Neti not this, not this Marg.

    Raja Yoga

    Raja Yoga is disciplining the mind and awakening the

    intellect. It has eight limbs and is called Ashtanga Yoga

    (Yama, Niyama, Asana. Pranayama, Pratyahara, Dharana,

    Dhyana and Samadhi). The first five practices are called

    Bahiranga Sadhana and are Hatha Voga practices.

    Hatha Voga is disciplining the human body by Pranavama,

    Asanas, Shatkarmas (six purifications) and awakening the

    Kundalini. This is preliminary stage to Raja yoga. The

    shatkarmas are also exercises besides Pranayama to cleanse

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    15/65

    15

    the impurities of the body and are known as Neti, Dhoti,

    Basti, Nyoli, Bhasrika and Trataka.

    The latter three practices Dharana, Dhyana and Samadhi are

    called Antaranga Sadhana, the inner and internal practices

    being the special features of Raja Voga, the controlling of the

    mind. (The Path Divine, Pg. 22)

    It is the blending and balancing action! Emotion and intellect

    (Karma, Bhakthi and .Jnana) for the purpose of mentalpurification, regeneration and personality integration. (The

    Path Divine, Pg. 20)

    Ashtanga Yogathe eight steps1:

    The eight steps are

    1. Yama: moral and ethical disciplines (non-killing,

    truthfulness, non-stealing, continence and non-receivingof gifts),

    2. Niyama: religious disciplines (cleanliness, contentment,

    austerity, study and self-surrender to God),

    3. Asana or posture,

    4. Pranayama or control of Prana,

    5. Pratyahara or restraint of the senses from their objects,

    6. Dharana or fixing the mind on a spot,

    7. Dhyana or meditation and

    8. Samadhi or super-consciousness.

    1

    For fuller appreciation of Ashtanga Yogasee The Complete Works ofSwami Vivekananda by Swami Vivekananda Vol. 1 p.169-194 and

    Prasanthi Vahini p.66-76.

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    16/65

    16

    The Yama and Niyama are moral trainings; without these as

    the basis no practice of Yoga will succeed. As these two

    become established, the Yogi will begin to realise the fruits

    of his practice; without these it will never bear fruit. A Yogi

    must not think of injuring anyone, by thought, word, or deed.

    Mercy shall not be for men alone, but shall go beyond, and

    embrace the whole world.

    The next step is Asana, posture. A series of exercises,

    physical and mental, is to be gone through every day, untilcertain higher states are reached. Therefore it is quite

    necessary that we should find a posture in which we can

    remain long. That posture which is the easiest for one should

    be the one chosen. For thinking, a certain posture may be

    very easy for one man, while to another it may be very

    difficult. We will find later on that during the study of these

    psychological matters a good deal of activity goes on in the

    body. Nerve currents will have to be displaced and given a

    new channel. New sorts of vibrations will begin; the whole

    constitution will be remodelled as it were. But the main part

    of the activity will lie along the spinal column, so that the

    one thing necessary for the posture is to hold the spinal

    column free, sitting erect, holding the three parts thechest, neck, and head in a straight line. Let the whole

    weight of the body be supported by the ribs, and then you

    have easy natural postures with the spine straight. You will

    easily see that you cannot think very high thoughts with the

    chest in. This portion of the Yoga is a little similar to the

    Hatha-Yoga which deals entirely with the physical body, its

    aim being to make the physical body very strong. We havenothing to do with it here, because its practices are very

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    17/65

    17

    difficult, and cannot be learned in a day, and, after all, do not

    lead to much spiritual growth. There is not one muscle in the

    body over which a man cannot establish a perfect control.

    The heart can be made to stop or go on at his bidding, and

    each part of the organism can be similarly controlled.

    Next comes, Pranayama, controlling the breathing. What has

    that to do with concentrating the powers of the mind? Breath

    is like the fly-wheel of this machine, the body. In a big

    engine you find the fly-wheel first moving, and that motion isconveyed to finer and finer machinery until the most delicate

    and finest mechanism in the machine is in motion. The breath

    is that fly-wheel, supplying and regulating the motive power

    to everything in this body.

    The next step is called Pratyahara. What is this? You know

    how perceptions come. First of all there are the external

    instruments, then the internal organs acting in the body

    through the brain centres, and there is the mind. When these

    come together and attach themselves to some external object,

    then we perceive it. At the same time it is a very difficult

    thing to concentrate the mind and attach it to one organ only;

    the mind is a slave.

    The first lesson, then, is to sit for some time and let the mind

    run on. The mind is bubbling up all the time. It is like that

    monkey jumping about. Let the monkey jump as much as he

    can; you simply wait and watch. Knowledge is power, says

    the proverb, and that is true. Until you know what the mind is

    doing you cannot control it. Give it the rein; many hideousthoughts may come into it; you will be astonished that it was

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    18/65

    18

    possible for you to think such thoughts. But you will find that

    each day the mind's vagaries are becoming less and less

    violent, that each day it is becoming calmer. This controlling

    of the mind, and not allowing it to join itself to the centres, is

    Pratyahara. How is this practiced? It is a tremendous work,

    not to be done in a day. Only after a patient, continuous

    struggle for years can we succeed.

    After you have practiced Pratyahara for a time, take the next

    step, the Dharana, holding the mind to certain points. What ismeant by holding the mind to certain points? Forcing the

    mind to feel certain parts of the body to the exclusion of

    others. For instance, try to feel only the hand, to the

    exclusion of other parts of the body. When the Chitta, or

    mind-stuff, is confined and limited to a certain place it is

    Dharana. This Dharana is of various sorts, and along with it,

    it is better to have a little play of the imagination.

    Dhyana or meditation is the 7th step in the Raja Yoga. After

    Pratyahara and Dharana, we come toDhyana, meditation.

    These ideas have to be understood in Dhyana, or meditation.

    We hear a sound. First, there is the external vibration;second, the nerve motion that carries it to the mind; third, the

    reaction from the mind, along with which flashes the

    knowledge of the object which was the external cause of

    these different changes from the ethereal vibrations to the

    mental reactions. These three are called in Yoga, Shaba

    (sound), Artha (meaning), and Jnana (knowledge). In the

    language of physics and physiology they are called theethereal vibration, the motion in the nerve and brain, and the

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    19/65

    19

    mental reaction. Now these, though distinct processes, have

    become mixed up in such a fashion as to become quite

    indistinct. In fact, we cannot now perceive any of these, we

    only perceive their combined effect, what we call the external

    object. Every act of perception includes these three, and there

    is no reason why we should not be able to distinguish them.

    When, by the previous preparations, it becomes strong and

    controlled, and has the power of finer perception, the mind

    should be employed in meditation. This meditation mustbegin with gross objects and slowly rise to finer and finer,

    until it becomes objectless. The mind should first be

    employed in perceiving the external causes of sensations,

    then the internal motions, and then its own reaction. When it

    has succeeded in perceiving the external causes of sensations

    by themselves, the mind will acquire the power of perceiving

    all fine material existences, all fine bodies and forms. When

    it can succeed in perceiving the motions inside by

    themselves, it will gain the control of all mental waves, in

    itself or in others, even before they have translated

    themselves into physical energy; and when he will be able to

    perceive the mental reaction by itself, the Yogi will acquire

    the knowledge of everything, as every sensible object, andevery thought is the result of this reaction. Then will he have

    seen the very foundations of his mind, and it will be under

    his perfect control. Different powers will come to the Yogi,

    and if he yields to the temptations of any one of these, the

    road to his further progress will be barred. Such is the evil of

    running after enjoyments. But if he is strong enough to reject

    even these miraculous powers, he will attain to the goal ofYoga, the complete suppression of the waves in the ocean of

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    20/65

    20

    the mind. Then the glory of the soul, undisturbed by the

    distractions of the mind, or motions of the body, will shine in

    its full effulgence; and the Yogi will find himself as he is and

    as he always was, the essence of knowledge, the immortal,

    and the all-pervading.

    Samadhi is the property of every human being nay, every

    animal. There is no difference now between us and those

    who have no religion, because we have no experience. What

    is concentration good for, save to bring us to this experience?Each one of the steps to attain Samadhi has been reasoned

    out, properly adjusted, scientifically organised, and, when

    faithfully practiced, will surely lead us to the desired end.

    Then will all sorrows cease, all miseries vanish; the seeds for

    actions will be burnt, and the soul will be free for ever.

    All the different steps in Yoga are intended to bring us

    scientifically to the super-conscious state, or Samadhi. (CW

    of SV Vol.1, p. 185)

    Meditation or Dhana

    Meditation is derived from the Latin word MEDITARI

    which means, 'to heal. (Paths of Meditation, p. 12)

    Meditation is both Science and Art of healing. To meditate is

    to set in motion processes that lead to the restoration of ones

    well-being physical mental and spiritual. (Paths of

    Meditation, p. 13)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    21/65

    21

    Object of Meditation

    Swami Vivekananda commenting on Yoga Sutra 1-39 on

    pages 227-228 in Chapter I, Concentration: Its Spiritual Uses

    from The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda (Vol. 1).

    "Yathabhimatadhyanadva"

    Or by the meditation on anything that appeals to one as good.

    This does not mean any wicked subject, but anything good

    that you like, any place that you like best, any scenery that

    you like best, any idea that you like best, anything that will

    concentrate the mind.

    "Paramaariu Parama Mahatvaantesya Vashikaraah"

    The Yogi's mind thus meditating, becomes unobstructed

    from the atomic to the infinite.

    The mind, by this practice, easily contemplates the most

    minute, as well as the biggest thing. Thus the mind-waves

    become fainter.

    Personal and Impersonal Meditation

    There are various stages of meditation, Swamiji points out

    how the first would be the gross, the second the fine and thenon to the still finer object. The objects of meditation, Swami

    Vivekananda says, can both be personal and impersonal.

    If it be personal, usually it is, the form of a god or a goddess,

    an Incarnation of a God or a God-man or perfected being

    who has attained the consummation of spiritual life. The

    name and, form of such beings play an important role in the

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    22/65

    22

    , .-,;,,

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    23/65

    23

    destroyed, all the massive vibrations disappear; the sun,

    moon, stars, and earth, melt down; but the vibrations remain

    in the atoms. Each atom performs the same function as the

    big worlds do. So even when the vibrations of the Chitta

    subside, its molecular vibrations go on, and when they get

    the impulse, come out again. We can now understand what is

    meant by repetition. It is the greatest stimulus that can be

    given to the spiritual Samskaras. "One moment of company

    with the holy makes a ship to cross this ocean of life." Such

    is the power of association. So this repetition of Om, andthinking of its meaning, is keeping good company in your

    own mind. Study, and then meditate on what you have

    studied. Thus light will come to you, the Self will become

    manifest. (CW of SV Vol.1, pp. 219-220)

    Forms of Meditation

    There are two kinds of meditation, one on the formless Godand the other on God with form. But meditation on the

    formless God is extremely difficult.

    There is another form of meditation known as the Vishnu

    Yoga. The eyes are fixed on the tip of the nose. Half the look

    is directed inwards, and the other half outward. This is how

    one meditates on God with form. (Paths of Meditation, p. 2)

    In Dhyana or meditation, there are three factors: the

    meditator, the process of meditation and the object of

    meditation. Of these three, the first two factors are constant

    in any form of meditation. (Paths to Meditation, p. 23)

    Inquiry suggested by Ramana Maharshi. The RamanaMaharshi enquiry by itself is not good. It must be combined

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    24/65

    24

    with meditation. Meditation, for its proper practice, should be

    at the same place at the same time. In that way, it will surely

    be successful. If one is away from home in travel, in his mind

    he can go to the accustomed places - no matter where he is.

    To search for truth is needless. Truth is every place at all

    times. One must live truth not search for it. 'Kohum'(who am

    I) is the cry of the new born child. After a lifetime of

    Sadhana, the old man says Sohum' (I am God). When

    away from Swami, by remembering Him doing this or that,

    the battery is recharged. That also is genuine meditation.Meditation is constant inner inquiry as to who am I, what is

    true, what is ego action, what is loving and what is harsh.

    Meditation is thinking on spiritual principles, searching out

    the application to what Baba says and the like. (CWBSSB, p.

    169)

    Importance or purpose of Meditation or Dhyana

    The importance of dhyana should also be recognised.

    Dhyana is an infallible aid to spiritual progress. Freedom

    from the consequence of karma can be attained through

    dhyana. This freedom enables the sadhaka to acquire shanti

    or inner tranquillity. The sweetness of the experience of inner

    tranquillity is derived from the fruits ofdhyana. (SSVahini)

    (SSB 1979, p. 108)

    The purpose of dhyana is to unite the jiva with Easwara.

    (SSB 1979, p. 112)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    25/65

    25

    Whether of the Formful or the Formless, if it is one-pointed,

    devoid of deviations, it is entitled to be called Dhyana.

    (PraV, p. 85)

    Man is endowed with unlimited powers. Not a single person

    is without them! But the road is missed when one is unaware

    of this truth. To gain awareness of this power, one must join

    the company of the holy, one must strive in spiritual practice

    (sadhana), and one must practise repetition of the divine

    name and meditation. (DhyV, p. 6)

    Meditation (dhyana) is the process by which it is trained to

    acquire concentration. As a result of meditation on the

    highest Atma (Paramatma), the mind will withdraw from

    sense objects and the sensory world. Just at that time, the

    intellect (buddhi) must assert its authority and command the

    mind (manas) not to entertain any feeling except the thought

    of the Fundamental Basis. (DhyV, p. 7)

    Meditation should be performed enthusiastically, with full

    faith and care, and strictly according to the disciplines laid

    down. If this is done, it will bestow not only all happiness

    and all victory but even the vision of the Lord. (DhyV, p. 8)

    The feelings that arise in the mind, which are classified as

    serene, restless, and ignorant (Sathwic, rajasic, and tamasic),

    also have to be watched and cleansed. The restlessness and

    ignorance have to be uprooted. Meditation is the weapon for

    this task. The path of meditation (dhyana-marga) will

    destroy ignorance (a-jnana), and it will grant the individualunion with the Godhead (Brahmaikyatha). (DhyV, p. 113)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    26/65

    26

    Meditation is the removal of attachment; it is perfected by

    the suppression of the modifications. Also by non-attachment

    and practice, meditation is perfected. (Paths to Meditation,

    p.8)

    Meditation is a constant remembrance (of the thing meditated

    upon) flowing like an unbroken stream of oil poured from

    one vessel to another (Paths to Meditation, p.9)

    Meditation is the focussing of the mind on some object. If the

    mind acquires concentration on one object, it can be so

    concentrated on any object whatsoever. (Paths to Meditation,

    p.10)

    Meditation is the soul of spiritual life. A life without reins is

    like a boat without rudder. (Paths to Meditation, p.24)

    Concentration is the essence of Meditation. (Paths to

    Meditation, p.26)

    Real meditation is getting absorbed in God as the only

    thought, the only goal. God only, only God. Think God,breathe God, love God, live God. (CWBSSB, p. 167)

    For, in meditation you first get sense control. And yoga will

    help you with the body and when the mind is steady,

    concentration will come automatically. When you get such

    concentration, then you get peace of mind. (CWBSSB, p. 30)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    27/65

    27

    'The mind that dwells on sense objects gets stuck in them.

    The mind that remembers Me constantly, gets dissolved in

    Me, says Krishna to Uddhava. (Paths to Meditation, p.31)

    Only meditation has the capacity to make one transcend the

    vicissitudes of time and space and make one ever the same

    equanimous individual, as if one is another Creator himself.

    (DhyV, p. 17)

    The finale of Meditation is spiritual illumination and itslanguage is silence. "Silence is Brahman, say the seers.

    (Paths to Meditation, p.33)

    Meditation is the means and the method by which the soul

    unveils the layers of ignorance covering it and discovers the

    essential divinity of its own being, by a threefold process of

    Sravana (hearing), manana (reflection) and nidhidyasana

    (Meditation) (Paths to Meditation, p.35)

    Meditation according to Swami Vivekananda is the power

    which enables us to resist all this (manifold manifestation of

    alluring names and forms, which distract our minds from our

    chosen paths) (CW of SV Vol.4, p. 248)

    Meditation is concentration of mind and its innate powers.

    (Paths of Meditation, p.37)

    Control of Mind

    How hard it is to control the mind! Well has it beencompared to the maddened monkey? The human mind is like

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    28/65

    28

    that monkey, incessantly active by its own nature; then it

    becomes drunk with the wine of desire, thus increasing its

    turbulence. After desire takes possession comes the sting of

    the scorpion of jealousy at the success of others, and last of

    all the demon of pride enters the mind, making it think itself

    of all importance. How hard to control such a mind! (CW of

    SV Vol.1, p. 174)

    The bottom of a lake we cannot see, because its surface is

    covered with ripples. It is only possible for us to catch aglimpse of the bottom, when the ripples have subsided, and

    the water is calm. If the water is muddy or is agitated all the

    time, the bottom will not be seen. If it is clear, and there are

    no waves, we shall see the bottom. The bottom of the lake is

    our own true Self; the lake is the Chitta and the waves the

    Vrittis. (CW of SV Vol.1, p. 202)

    Meditation is one of the great means of controlling the

    raising of these (thought) waves. By meditation, you can

    make the mind subdue these waves and if you go on

    practising meditation for days, and months, and years, until it

    becomes a habit, until it will come in spite of yourself, anger

    and hatred will be controlled and checked. (CW of SV Vol.1,pp. 242-243)

    "The mind is a lake and every stone that drops into it raises

    waves. These waves do not let us see what we are. The full

    moon is reflected in the water of the lake, but the surface is

    so disturbed that we do not see the reflection clearly. Let it

    calm. Do not let nature raise the wave. Keep quiet and thenafter a little while, she will give up. Then we know what we

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    29/65

    29

    are. God is there already, but the mind is so agitated always

    running after senses. You close the senses and yet you whirl

    and whirl about. Just this moment, I think I am alright and I

    will meditate upon God, then my mind goes to New York to

    think about the things I have done there in the past. These

    waves are to be stopped by the power of meditation". (CW of

    SV Vol.1, p. 248)

    Meditation is the gate that opens that infinite joy to us.

    Prayers, ceremonies and all the other forms of worship aresimply kindergartens of meditation. Slowly and gradually we

    are to train ourselves. It is no joke - not a question of a day or

    years or may be of births. Never mind! The pull must go on.

    (CW of SV Vol.1, p. 248)

    Meditation is the focussing of the mind on some object. If the

    mind acquires concentration on one object, it can be so

    concentrated on any object what-so-ever. (CW of SV Vol.VI,

    p. 487)

    Control the mind, cut off the senses, then you are a Yogi;

    after that, all the rest will come. Refuse to hear, to see, to

    smell, to taste; take away the mental power from the externalorgans. You continually do it unconsciously as when your

    mind is absorbed; so you can learn to do it consciously. The

    mind can put the senses where it pleases. Get rid of the

    fundamental superstition that we are obliged to act through

    the body. (CW of SV Vol.VII, p. 71)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    30/65

    30

    Meditation is the technique for diverting the wayward,

    destructive mind into planned and constructive channels

    planned channels

    "As a lamp placed in a windless place does not flicker" - is a

    simile used to describe the Yogi of controlled mind,

    practising Yoga in the Self. (BhaG, p. Shloka 19 chapter VI)

    By practice, men can bring even the heart under control until

    it will just beat at will slowly or quickly or almost stop. (CW

    of SV Vol.1, p. 179)

    "The Yogi teaches that the mind has a higher state of

    existence beyond reason, a super conscious state; and when

    the mind gets to that higher state, then this knowledge comes

    to man metaphysical and transcendental knowledge comes to

    that man. (CW of SV Vol.1, p. 183)

    Prayers and Meditation:

    Prayer is essentially a supplication to an external Being or

    Power. It is a yearning of the heart for things it lacks. It is

    importuning a Higher Potency to fulfil our wants and desires.

    But meditation has no element of begging in it. It is a re-

    orientation of the mind for producing the knowledge by

    which all that is rightly needed is acquired. It is a purified

    mind calling upon the wisdom that dwells within. While

    prayer is addressed to an out side Power, meditation seeks

    conscious union with the Truth inside. Desire is the motive

    force for all action. But whereas in prayer the desire is self-

    centred, in meditation one 'attaches one's belt to .the Power

    house of the Universe. (Paths of Meditation, p.17)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    31/65

    31

    Concentration vs. Meditation

    Meditation is often misunderstood to be the same as

    concentration. Concentration is essential for ordinary

    sensory perceptions and it is something that we have and

    utilise while performing the most ordinary and routine acts.

    For example, we concentrate when we read a book, write a

    letter, drive a car or eat our food. Concentration comes

    naturally to us in the process of perceiving through the five

    senses and no particular exertion or special practice is

    required for it. It is incorrect, therefore, to equateconcentration with meditation at which only the spiritual

    adepts excel.

    Meditation is a process which obtains at a much higher

    plane than human sensory perception. Being a mental

    process that involves seeing through the senses,

    concentration may be regarded as being below or within the

    realms of the senses, while meditation is beyond or above

    the world of the senses. If meditation were as easy as

    concentration, the great rishis of the past would not have

    practised various austerities and subjected themselves to

    innumerable difficulties in the deep forests. (SSB 1979, p.

    81)

    By concentration we mean the preliminary exercises in

    one-pointedness of thought which must of necessity

    precede success in meditation. Before an instrument can

    be used, it must be torqued properly. The mind with

    which contemplation is achieved must first be trained to

    develop the power of converging all its energies at any

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    32/65

    32

    required point. Not that concentration per se has any

    ethical orspiritual value. It is indeed a common requisite

    for progress in any field of art or science.

    Concentration gives us power; it is up to us to put it to the

    highest use. And the highest use of a concentrated mind is in

    meditation.

    Concentration is only a process. It is useful in daily life at all

    levels but has no moral or spiritual significance. Meditation,on the contrary, produces a state of consciousness in which

    the spiritual point of view alone counts.

    Meditation means reflection; concentration is the essence of

    meditation. (Paths of Meditations, p.17, 18 & 19)

    Concentration means when all senses and desires fall away

    and there is only God. The concentration of Ramakrishna

    Paramahamsa was naturally so strong that he grew something

    of a tail when meditating on Hanuman, the monkey. His

    body was just a changing bubble; his concentration was so

    strong, Special work on con centration need not be a part of

    meditation. Concentration is already in force wherever mind,intelligence and senses are used. "Without it you could not

    even walk. It needs no special practice. "It is below the

    senses'. Meditation is above the senses". In between

    concentration and meditation, like a separation between

    the two is' contemplation'. Concentration to contemplation

    then meditation. As long as one thinks 'I am meditating', that

    is in the mind and is not meditation. As long as one knows heis meditating, he is not meditating. In that absorption in God,

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    33/65

    33

    one puts aside every form and merges into God. In that

    process, the mind naturally stops. (CWBSSB, p. 168)

    Without concentration, nothing can be done. And we use thatconcentration throughout the day. Concentration is difficult

    in spiritual matters because the mind is outward turned and

    by desire, the mind clings to objects. But the mind can be

    trained to concentrate inwardly and the heart can be cultured

    to grow with love for God. This can be by Sadhana.

    (CWBSSB, p. 171)

    It is not practical to attempt to concentrate on that which has

    no form. To concentrate on the Jyoti, is an illustration. The

    object of concentration can be sound, form orjyoti etc. It

    needs to be something concrete. It is not easy to fix the mind

    on the abstract. (CWBSSB, p. 173)

    Even the pettiest of tasks need for its fulfilment the quality ofconcentration. (DhyV, p. 5)

    Sri Krishna said, "You have only to concentrate over the act

    and carry it out as you can. To act and only to act is the duty

    imposed on you'. That was the immortal nectarine advice of

    the Lord. (SSVahini, p. 137)

    Concentration and one-pointedness are the keys

    Every minute, from inside and outside, promptings and

    temptations arise and accumulate in people. One cannot

    attend to all of them at the same time, so one fixes attention

    on only the most important one. This is called concentration

    (avadhana). Concentration is needed to grasp any subject

    well. Purposefully directing attention on a subject and fixing

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    34/65

    34

    it there is one-pointedness (ekagratha). This is also a

    condition of the mind. Concentration and one-pointedness

    help to focus effort on any selected task. (DhyV, p. 12)

    Concentration is essential for all. It is the foundation of all

    successful endeavour. It is needed not only for meditation but

    even for worldly affairs and ordinary living. Whatever the

    task one is engaged in, doing it with concentration will

    develop both self-confidence and self-respect, for they are

    the result of the attitude of ones own mind. The mind may

    lean on either the bad or the good, and concentrated attention

    must be employed to keep the mind attached only to good

    prompting. Success or failure in the good task depends upon

    one-pointedness.

    One-pointedness will increase power and skill. But it cannot

    be won without conquering the worldly cravings that distract

    the mind. This one-pointedness, this conquest of the mind, is

    acquired by the exercise of meditation. (DhyV, p. 13)

    Concentration is only a process. It is useful in daily life at all

    levels, but has no moral or spiritual significance. Meditation,

    on the contrary, produces a state of consciousness in which

    the spiritual point of view alone counts. (Paths of Meditation

    Pg-19)

    Many people think that concentration is the same thing as

    meditation but there is no such connection between

    concentration and meditation. Concentration is something

    which is below your senses, whereas meditation is something

    which is above your senses. But many are under the false

    impression that concentration is identical with meditation,

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    35/65

    35

    and they take to a wrong path. Concentration is something

    which we use involuntarily in our daily, normal, routine life.

    Just look at this, I am now reading the newspaper. My eyes

    are looking at the letters. My hand is holding the paper. My

    Intelligence is thinking now. Mind is also thinking. Thus

    when the eyes are doing their work, the hand is doing its

    work, when the Intelligence is doing its work, and the mind

    is also doing its work, then I am able to get the contents of

    the newspaper. It means, if I want to get at the matter that is

    contained in the newspaper, all these enumerated senses areconcentrated and they are all coordinated and are working on

    the newspaper.

    Not only this, if one wants to drive a car, unless one has

    concentration, one cannot drive a car on the road. All the

    normal routines, like walking, talking, reading, writing,

    eating, all these things we do only as result of concentration.If concentration like this is part and parcel of your daily life,

    then what is that we practise to get concentration? What we

    have to practice is something which is beyond these normal

    senses. We must rise from being below the senses (that is the

    state of concentration) to the senses (that is, the middle

    position, called contemplation); and from there we must rise

    above the senses, that is called meditation.

    Between concentration and meditation there is border area

    which covers both and that is the area of contemplation. To

    be in that area of contemplation is to free yourself of worldly

    attachments. If you break away all the worldly attachments---

    all the routine attachments in the world---then you will enter

    the region of contemplation. When you have completely

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    36/65

    36

    broken away ALL your attachments, you break through this

    area of contemplation and you get into the area of meditation.

    First develop confidence in your own selfThese steps can also be described as starting from self-

    confidence, and then getting self-satisfaction and then self-

    sacrifice, and the last step is self-realisation. The ultimate

    step of self-realisation depends upon the base of self-

    confidence. You must therefore develop as a first step

    confidence in your own self. Without having and developing

    confidence in your own self, if all the time you are talking of

    some power being with someone and some other power

    being with someone else, if in this way you travel all the time

    and depend upon power which is with someone else, when

    are you going to acquire any power and confidence in your

    own self. Peace and bliss are within you they are not

    something which is external to you. (SSS Vol.9, pp. 185-187)

    Contemplation

    The contemplation of the Lord must proceed in union with

    the dharmic life. This type of life has no need for status,

    scholarship, or vanity. The latter only lead people astray. It is

    only through this life that the mind and the intellect can becontrolled, the knowledge (Vidhya) ofAtma cultivated, and

    the will sublimated. (DhyV, p. 24)

    Contemplate on the vision of Atma and reach up to the

    Thuriya stage of consciousness. Then Naama, Rupa, Vasthu,

    Bhava, all get merged in the One All-pervasive All-inclusive

    Atma. (UV, p. 31)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    37/65

    37

    Arjuna! People think that the worship of God with Form

    and Attributes is quite enough. This discipline will only be of

    some help. It will guide the person along the road only for a

    little while. For the Lord will not condescend to grant

    Liberation for just this!

    For, he who aims at Liberation must first give up attachment

    to the body. Without that, the Atmic stage cannot be attained.

    The identification with the body is the expression of

    ignorance. The Atma must be recognised as distinct from the

    Prakruthi (nature).

    The craving for objective pleasure which is based on the

    unreal value attached to Prakruthi has to be removed by

    Dhyanam and Thapas. When that craving is lost, the

    individual becomes like the dry nut, inside the coconut shell,

    which becomes loose and unattached both to the shell and the

    fibre outside it. It does not germinate or sprout again. It will

    remain forever without being spoilt. The individual has no

    more birth and consequent death. That is to say, he will be

    liberated. Becoming like that dry nut inside the shell is the

    stage calledJivan muktha, of Liberation while alive.

    The contemplation of the Godhead as above and beyond all

    attributes is necessary for the attainment of Jivanmukthi.

    (GV, p. 9)

    Patanjali lists obstacles to Yoga:

    The yoga-sutra enumerates several impediments on the path

    of yoga. They are:

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    38/65

    38

    1. Vyadhi (physical sickness);

    2. Styana (languor);

    3. Samsaya (doubts and misgivings;

    4. Pramada (heedlessness);

    5. alasya (sloth);

    6. avirati (absence of dispassion);

    7. bhranti-darsana (hallucinations);

    8. alabdha-bhumikatva (non-attainment of the stage of

    communion' in spite of effort;

    9. Anavasthitatva (instability).

    How to overcome these impediments? Vyadhi can be

    overcome by proper medicines and diet, styana by

    discrimination and will power, samsaya by faith in the

    scripture, the guru and oneself, pramada by external

    vigilance, alasya by healthy physical activity, avirati by

    reflecting on the transient and evil nature of sense-pleasuresand bhranti-darsana by right perception. Alabdha-

    bhumikatva and anavasthitatva are more serious obstacles.

    Guidance from the guru or advanced souls and prayer and

    self-analysis will help to eradicate them. (CW of SV Vol.1,

    pp. 221-222)

    Regulations:

    Yoga is not possible for him who eats too much, nor for him

    who does not eat at all, nor for him who sleeps too much; nor

    for him who is always awake. (BhaG, pp. 16 Shloka, Chapter

    VI) Yoga becomes the destroyer of pain for him who is

    moderate in eating and recreation, who is moderate in his

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    39/65

    39

    exertion during his actions, who is moderate in sleep and

    wakefulness. (BhaG, pp. 17 Shloka, Chapter VI)

    Aids to Meditation2:

    "Having in a clean spot established a firm seat of his own,

    neither too high nor too low, made of a cloth, a skin and kusa

    grass; one over the other".

    "There, having made the mind and the senses controlled,

    being seated on the seat let Sadhaka practice Yoga, for thepurification of the self.

    "After the external seat has been described, let the Sadhaka

    hold the body, head and neck erect and still, gazing at the tip

    of nose, without looking around".

    "Serene-minded, fearless, firm in the view of Brahmacharya,

    having con trolled the mind, thinking on ME as the Supreme

    Goal".

    Yajnavalkya says:

    "After practicing the postures as desired, according to rules,

    then, O Gargi, the man who has conquered the posture will

    practice Pranayama.

    "Seated in an easy posture, on a (deer or tiger) skin, placed

    on Kusha grass, worshipping Ganapati with fruits and

    sweetmeats, placing the right palm on the left, holding the

    throat and head in the same line, the lips closed and firm,

    2Bhagavat Gita, Chapter VI- 11 to 14. (Swami Chinmayanada

    Commentary)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    40/65

    40

    facing the east or the north, the eyes fixed on the tip of the

    nose, avoiding too much food or fasting, the Nadis should be

    purified, without which the practice will be fruitless.

    Thinking of the (seed-word) "Hum," at the junction of

    Pingala and Ida (the right and the left nostrils), the Ida should

    be filled with external air in twelve Matras (seconds); then

    the Yogi meditates on fire in the same place with the word

    "Rung," and while meditating thus, slowly ejects the air

    through the Pingala (right nostril). Again filling in through

    the Pingala the air should be slowly ejected through the Ida,in the same way. This should be practiced for three or four

    years, or three or four months, according to the directions of

    a Guru, in secret (alone in a room), in the early morning, at

    midday, in the evening, and at midnight (until) the nerves

    become purified. Lightness of body, clear complexion, good

    appetite, hearing of the Nada, are the signs of the purification

    of nerves. Then should be practiced Pranayama composed of

    Rechaka (exhalation), Kumbhaka (retention), and Puraka

    (inhalation). Joining the Prana with the Apana is Pranayama.

    "In sixteen Matras filling the body from the head to the feet,

    in thirty-two Matras the Prana is to be thrown out, and with

    sixty-four the Kurnbhaka should be made.

    "There is another Pranayama in which the Kumbhaka should

    first be made with sixty-four Matras, then the Prana should

    be thrown out with sixteen, and the body next filled with

    sixteen Matras.

    "By Pranayama impurities of the body are thrown out; by

    Dharana the impurities of the mind; by Pratyahara impurities

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    41/65

    41

    of attachment; and by Samadhi is taken off everything that

    hides the lordship of the Soul." (CW of SV Vol.1, pp. 309-

    310)

    Place and Time of Meditation

    A fence is placed around a young tree to protect it. The same

    precautions must be observed in meditation. People think it is

    all right to meditate in any place. There are currents, there is

    will power. There is a strong current passing into the earth.

    Because of this, the earth exerts a strong attraction. In

    meditation it is advisable to insulate oneself from such

    currents. For this reason, meditators sit on a plank and cover

    their shoulders with a woollen shawl. Once the person has

    grown strong in his meditation, he may sit anywhere and not

    suffer for it. (CWBSSB, pp. 171-172)

    For the establishment of oneself in the contemplation of the

    Omnipresent Lord, there is no limitations of time or space.

    There is nothing like a holy place or a special time for this.

    Wherever the mind revels in the contemplation of the divine

    that is the Holy Place! Whenever it does so, that is the

    auspicious moment! There and then, one must meditate on

    the Lord.

    That is why it has been announced already before:

    Na kaala niyame yaathraa,

    Na desasya sthalasya cha

    Yathraasya ramathe chiththam,

    Thathra dhyaane na kevalam.

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    42/65

    42

    For meditation on God, there is no fixed time or place. When

    and where the mind so desires, then and there is the time and

    place. (Prema Vahini, p. 80)

    Brahma Muhurta means early morning, between 3 - 6 a.m. It

    means that the senses are quiet, not yet agitated by the day

    and mind is quiet from sleep. But the hour should not be

    taken and changed around, taking one time today and another

    time tomorrow. A half hour in the morning and a half hour in

    the evening is enough for sitting meditation. If done all day

    along, it will lose its attraction after a couple of years. The

    spiritual practice should be varied for interest. Some bhajan,

    some repetition of the Name of the Lord, some time spent in

    the company of spiritual people and so on. Just as in daily

    life some variety makes the day interesting. (CWBSSB, p.

    179)

    Environment:

    Do not worry about the unsatisfactory environment you may

    have. Of course, the place may have some drawbacks and it

    may not be ideal. But it is no use trying to run away from all

    that. You can overcome the drawbacks by training your own

    mind. Stay in your environment and pray to the Lord! Pray

    that He may fill you with His thoughts and His vision,making you ignore the defects of the environment.

    Do not seek comfort, for comfort might not be conducive to

    meditation. Learn to be comfortable in any place; that is

    better. Live in joy wherever you are; that is the way. Revel in

    the realm of your mind; worship in the mind the Lord you

    have chosen as your goal and be free of all the defects of the

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    43/65

    43

    natural or human environment! Then, no spot can be irksome

    to you, nor will any place seem disgusting.

    Pride is an insidious vice, so at the slightest inkling of the

    disease, try your best to eradicate it by retiring into a lonely

    spot and engaging yourself in meditation. Delay is

    dangerous. Even divine nectar (amrita) becomes a poison if

    the dose is delayed, says the proverb. Remember this and

    act swiftly. Meditation stills the agitated mind and makes it

    clear and full of joy. (DhyV, p. 73)

    How to Meditate:

    One should practise meditation at-least twice a day and the

    best times are when the night passes into day and day into

    night, that is, early morning and early evening. This is the

    time the body will have the tendency to become calm. The

    aspirant should not eat until meditation is practised.Overeating is to be avoided. Food that is healthy and

    conduces to the harmony of the body should be selected.

    If it is possible it is better to have a room for meditation

    alone; It should be kept holy and not used for sleeping. We

    must not enter the room until we bathe and are perfectly

    clean in body and mind. Burning incense in morning and

    evening is good. Those who cannot have a separate room for

    meditation can practice anywhere they like.

    Method of Meditation:

    The place for meditation should be a little elevated an

    inch or twofrom the ground. Place a mat ofdharbha grass

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    44/65

    44

    (a matty, long grass grown in India) on it, spread a deer-skin

    on the mat, and lay a thin white cloth on the skin.

    Sit on it in the lotus posture (padmasana). The right foot

    must be above the left and the left foot above the right. The

    fingers of the hand must be in close touch with one another

    and the hands should be placed in front. The eyes must be

    either half open or fully closed.

    Then, by means of mental massage, relax the neck,shoulders, hands, chest, teeth, stomach, fingers, back, thighs,

    knees, calves, and feet. After this, one has to meditate on

    ones own favourite name and form, with Om added. When

    this is being done, there should be no mental wanderings; one

    must be stable and quiet. No thought of past events, no trace

    of anger or hatred, and no memory of sorrow should be

    allowed to interfere. Even if they intrude, they should not be

    considered at all; to counteract them, entertain thoughts that

    will feed ones enthusiasm for meditation. Of course, this

    may appear difficult, at first.

    The best time for meditation is the quiet hours before dawn,

    between 3 and 5 a.m. One can awake, say, at 4 a.m. First ofall, sleep has to be subdued. This is very necessary. In order

    to keep the hours unchanged, one may set the alarm clock for

    4 a.m. and rise. Even then, if sleep continues to bother, its

    effect can be overcome by means of a bath in cold water. Not

    that it is essential to bathe; it is needed only when sleep gives

    much trouble.

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    45/65

    45

    If in this manner the path of meditation (dhyana) is

    rigorously followed, it is possible for one to win the grace of

    the Lord very quickly. (DhyV, pp. 8-9)

    Sadhakas should be very clear of the purpose of Japam and

    Dhyanam. Japam and Dhyanam are for acquiring one-

    pointed attention on the Lord, for casting off sensory

    attachments and for attaining the joy derived from the basis

    of all sensory objects. (DhyV, p. 68)

    First, when you sit for meditation, recite a fewshlokas on the

    Glory of God so that the agitated mind may be calmed. Then

    gradually, while doingjapam, draw before the mind's eye the

    Form which that Name represents. When your mind wanders

    away from the recital of the Name, lead it onto the picture of

    the Form. When it wanders from the form, lead it onto the

    Name. Let it dwell either on that sweetness or this. Treated

    thus it can be easily tamed. The imaginary picture you have

    drawn will get transmuted into the bhava chithra (thought

    visualisation), dear to the heart and fixed in the memory.

    Gradually it will become the saakshaathkaara chithra

    (Vision of the actual Form) when the Lord assumes that

    Form in order to fulfil your desire. This sadhana is calledjapa sahitha dhyana (meditation-cum-recitation of Name),

    and I advise you all to take it up, for it is best form ofdhyana

    for beginners.

    Within a few days you will fall in line and you will taste the

    joy of concentration. After about ten or fifteen minutes of

    this dhyana in the initial stages, and longer after some time,have some manana (contemplation) on theshanti (peace) and

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    46/65

    46

    the sowkhya (happiness) you had during the dhyana

    (meditation). (SSS Vol.1, p. 35)

    The meditation of any one of His countless names will act as

    the goad that can tame the elephant in rut and make him bend

    his knees and lift the log on his tusk. (SSS Vol.7, p. 279)

    Vivekananda's prescription:

    Where there is fire, or in water or on ground which is strewn

    with dry leaves, where there are many ant-hills, where there

    are wild animals, or danger, where four streets meet, where

    there is too much noise, where there are many wicked

    persons, Yoga must not be practiced. This applies more

    particularly to India. Do not practice when the body feels

    very lazy or ill, or when the mind is very miserable and

    sorrowful. Go to a place which is well hidden, and where

    people do not come to disturb you. Do not choose dirtyplaces. Rather choose beautiful scenery, or a room in your

    own house which is beautiful. When you practice, first salute

    all the ancient Yogis, and your own Guru, and God, and then

    begin.

    Dhyana is spoken of, and a few examples are given of what

    to meditate upon. Sit straight, and look at the tip of your

    nose. Later on we shall come to know how that concentrates

    the mind, how by controlling the two optic nerves one

    advances a long way towards the control of the arc of

    reaction, and so to the control of the will. Here are a few

    specimens of meditation. Imagine a lotus upon the top of the

    head, several inches up, with virtue as its centre, and

    knowledge as its stalk. The eight petals of the lotus are the

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    47/65

    47

    eight powers of the Yogi. Inside, the stamens and pistils are

    renunciation. If the Yogi refuses the external powers he will

    come to salvation. So the eight petals of the lotus are the

    eight powers, but the internal stamens and pistils are extreme

    renunciation, the renunciation of all these powers. Inside of

    that lotus think of the Golden One, the Almighty, the

    Intangible, He whose name is Om, the Inexpressible,

    surrounded with effulgent light. Meditate on that. Another

    meditation is given. Think of a space in your heart, and in the

    midst of that space think that a flame is burning. Think ofthat flame as your own soul and inside the flame is another

    effulgent light, and that is the Soul of your soul, God.

    Meditate upon that in the heart. Chastity, non-injury,

    forgiving even the greatest enemy, truth, faith in the Lord,

    these are all different Vrittis. Be not afraid if you are not

    perfect in all of these; work, they will come. He who has

    given up all attachment, all fear, and all anger, he whose

    whole soul has gone unto the Lord, he who has taken refuge

    in the Lord, whose heart has become purified, with

    whatsoever desire he comes to the Lord, He will grant that to

    him. Therefore worship Him through knowledge, love, or

    renunciation.

    "He who hates none, who is the friend of all, who is merciful

    to all, who has nothing of his own, who is free from egoism,

    who is even-minded in pain and pleasure, who is forbearing,

    who is always satisfied, who works always in Yoga, whose

    self has become controlled, whose will is firm, whose mind

    and intellect are given up unto Me, such a one is My beloved

    Bhakta. From whom comes no disturbance, who cannot bedisturbed by others, who is free from joy, anger, fear, and

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    48/65

    48

    anxiety, such a one is My beloved. He who does not depend

    on anything, who is pure and active, who does not care

    whether good comes or evil, and never becomes miserable,

    who has given up all efforts for himself; who is the same in

    praise or in blame, with a silent, thoughtful mind, blessed

    with what little comes in his way, homeless, for the whole

    world is his home, and who is steady in his ideas, such a one

    is My beloved Bhakta." Such alone become Yogis. (CW of

    SV Vol.1, pp. 192-193)

    Baba's advice:

    When in meditation, concentrate on the form chosen by you,

    then pass into contemplation and then into meditation. Only

    by the three states will you get there. From concentration,

    one must cross the field of contemplation to enter meditation.

    There are three things: the meditator, the chosen form, and

    the process of meditation. The three should merge andbecome one, and this is the state of meditation. But, if all the

    time you feel you are meditating, this cannot be called

    meditation. When there is complete attention on the form

    chosen, that will lead to meditation. The attention of the

    mind is totally removed from the body and totally

    concentrated on the form chosen as the object of your

    meditation. (CWBSSB, p. 183)

    If you have Me as the object of meditation, sit in a

    comfortable pose, which is neither irksome nor flopping, let

    your mind dwell for some time on some good sthotras

    (hymns) or incidents from the sacred stories, so that the

    senses escaping into the tangles of worldly worries may be

    quietened and subdued. Then, with the Name on the tongue,

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    49/65

    49

    try to draw with the brush of your emotion and the hand of

    your intellect, a picture of Swami, slowly, from the cluster of

    hair to the face and neck downwards, spending time in

    contemplating each as it is getting drawn and when the

    picture is full, start from the feet up to the head again, so that

    your attention is never for a moment diverted from the Form

    you love to meditate upon. (SSS Vol.5, p. 304)

    When we think of meditation, three things are involved,

    First, there is the person who meditates, the dhyata;secondly, there is the object of meditation dhyeya; and

    thirdly, there is the process of meditation itself, dhyana. In

    true meditation, all these three should merge. The person

    who is meditating should identify himself totally with the

    object of meditation and should be unaware of even the fact

    that he is meditating. When he is meditating, his attention

    should be so rivetted to the dhyeya that he loses his own

    identity and forgets his involvement in the action (dhyana),

    too. (SSB 1979, p. 81)

    Meditation on Jyothi

    For one who desires to practise dhyana or meditation, it is

    advisable thatjyothi (light) is taken as the dhyeya or object ofmeditation and not a form of Divinity such as that of Rama,

    Krishna, or Easwara; for these forms, too, are subject to

    change and ultimately perish. Jyothi or light does not perish

    or change. Moreover, a flame can kindle a million others

    without getting extinguished and is therefore inexhaustible.

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    50/65

    50

    In this process of meditation on light, the progression must

    be from restlessness to tranquillity and from tranquillity to

    divine Effulgence. One should sit cross-legged and erect to

    ensure an easy flow of the divine force from the mooladhara

    chakra to the sahasrara chakra through the sushumna nadi.

    The aspirant should fix his gaze on the gentle flame and

    gradually close his eyes, mentally transferring or absorbing

    the flame into his heart, as it were.

    The lotus of the spiritual heart should then be imagined asblossoming in effulgent beauty dispelling with its radiance

    the dark forces of life. One should then imagine that out of

    the heart so illumined, rays of light proceed gradually to all

    parts of the body, suffusing everything with light and

    imbuing it with sacredness and purity all over. As the light

    has reached the hands, the individual ought not to do any

    wrongful acts; since the flame shines in his eyes, he cannot

    look at undesirable sights. So, also, since the jyothi has

    permeated his ears, he should not listen to evil talk. His feet,

    too, since they have been filled with light, should not tread

    upon unholy paths. Thus, this type of meditation ennobles

    man and helps him scale great spiritual heights very steadily.

    If we keep the mind busy in this manner with the task of

    carrying light to all parts of the body, it will not wander and

    will remain steady. The whole process takes about twenty to

    thirty minutes to complete. This kind of meditation should

    not be regarded as an exercise in fantasy. No doubt, in the

    beginning, imagination will be involved; but, by constant

    practice, it will be transformed into a powerful thought wave,

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    51/65

    51

    creating an indelible impression on the heart leading to union

    with God.

    The meditation should not end with the individual visualising

    the light in himself. He should see it in his friends and

    relatives and even in his enemies. He should see the whole of

    creation bathed in the resplendent light of Divinity. This

    would make him live a life full of love and happiness.

    If you so desire, you may in the initial stages, picture theform of God which is dear to you, within the flame on which

    you meditate; you must, however, realise that the form has

    got to dissolve in the light, sooner or later. You must not try

    to confine Divinity to any one particular form; you must see

    God in His all-pervasive form, as the One who resides in the

    hearts of all Divine beings. (SSB 1979, pp. 82-83)

    Bhagawan Sri Sathya Sai Baba Advice on Jyoti

    Dhyana And Soham Dhyana

    Some persons use a Jyothi (lamp) as a basis for meditation.

    The lamp reveals the oneness that is the basis of the Unity or

    the Divine as well as the multiplicity that reflects the

    manifestations of the Divine. In this method, the experience

    of bliss does not come quickly. There are three stages in this

    type of meditation: uuha (imagining the Form), bhaava

    (experiencing the Form) andsaakshaathkaara (seeing It as a

    Reality). For instance, if one wishes to meditate upon Baba,

    he first tries to imagine with the dosed eyes the figure of

    Baba as seen by him earlier. This figure vanishes within a

    few moments. In experiencing the figure, the process islonger and the impression also lasts' longer. In this process,

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    52/65

    52

    one starts envisaging the figure from head to foot and from

    the feet upwards. Gradually, by this process the picture of

    Baba gets firmly implanted and becomes an inner reality.

    While the imagining process gives only a momentary

    glimpse, the experiencing method leads to the complete

    identification of the seeker with the Divine Form.

    Awareness of the Divine results in oneness with the Divine

    (Brahmavith Brahmaiva Bhavathi). When we are

    experiencing the Divine Form, what is happening to ourmind? The mind experiences every part of the Lord from

    head to foot and ultimately becomes one with the Form.

    It is the process of identification of the mind with the Divine

    form that constitutes true meditation. Meditation is not

    merging the Form in the mind. It is merging the mind in the

    Form so that the mind as such does not exist.

    Conserve energy by all possible means

    While sitting for meditation in a group, one should not be in

    contact with anyone else. This is highly important.

    Meditation is like the process of electrifying a wire. If a live

    wire comes in contact with something, it will produce a

    shock. During meditation, spiritual energy is generated.

    How is this energy lost? It is lost through finger nails and the

    hairs on one's body. This was the reason why the ancient

    yogis (spiritually advanced persons) allowed their nails and

    hairs to grow freely. Spiritual energy has to be conserved by

    all possible means. The rishis (saints) practised silence to

    conserve the energy lost through speech.

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    53/65

    53

    Do not develop too close relationship with one another. Such

    close relationship results in intimate friendship which

    produces mutual obligations and expectations. From these

    arise the sense of ego. When expectations are not fulfilled,

    resentment emerges. When they are realised, the ego gets

    inflated. Either way, the consequences of entertaining desires

    are undesirable. When resentment grows, the discriminating

    power is weakened. One loses control over his tongue and

    indulges in all kinds of abuse. Abuse leads to sinful conduct.The whole process is generated by excessive association with

    one another.

    Young persons tend to let their minds wander hither and

    thither. They should concentrate on their studies and should

    not give their minds a free rein. They should reduce their

    worldly concerns and devote some time to meditation every

    morning and evening. This will help to purify their minds

    and set them on the road to Divinity like the river losing

    itself in the ocean, the mind must merge in the Divine. Then

    there will be no mind at all. That blissful state can be realised

    only through the path of Love. Love is God. Live in Love.

    Realisation of the power of Love is the true aim ofmeditation. That Love is utterly selfless and is dedicated to

    the Divine.

    In the practice of meditation, it should be realised that all

    cannot follow the same pattern or method. It varies according

    to the evolution and circumstances of each individual and his

    or her capacity and earnestness. Some worship the Supremeas the Universal Mother. Some look upon the Almighty as

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    54/65

    54

    Father. Some regard God as the Supreme Friend. Some

    devotees approach the Divine as the Beloved or the Master.

    Jayadeva, Gauranga and Ramakrishna Paramahamsa

    belonged to the last mentioned category. They did not

    practise meditation. They felt the presence of God

    everywhere. Where could they go for meditation? Such was

    their experience. To the true sadhaka evidence of the

    omnipresence of God can be found everywhere. By merely

    closing one's eyes, one does not engage in meditation. One

    must feel one's unity with God in one's inner being.

    Prayer is for the mind what food is for the body. Just as

    wholesome food gives health and strength to the body, prayer

    purifies the mind and strengthens the spirit. (SSS Vol.17, pp.

    34-40)

    Do not judge by external standards:

    Japam and Dhyanam should never be judged on mere

    external standards; they are to be judged by their inner

    effects. Their essence is their relationship to the Atma. The

    immortal Atmic experience should never be mixed up with

    low activities of the temporal world. Such activities deserve

    to be avoided. One should not count the cost, the time, or thetrouble. One should await the descent of the Lords grace.

    This patient waiting is itself part of the austerity (tapas) of

    meditation. Sticking unfalteringly to the vow is the austerity.

    (DhyV, p. 9)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    55/65

    55

    Perseverance is sure success:

    Swami Vivekananda gives the story of two men great god-

    sage called Narada met on his way to heaven through aforest. Just as there are sages among mankind, great Yogis,

    so there are great Yogis among the gods. Narada was a good

    Yogi, and very great. He travelled everywhere. One day he

    was passing through a forest, and saw a man who had been

    meditating until the white ants had built a huge mound round

    his body so long had he been sitting in that position. He

    said to Narada, "Where are you going?" Narada replied, "Iam going to heaven." "Then ask God when He will be

    merciful to me; when I shall attain freedom." Further on

    Narada saw another man. He was jumping about, singing,

    dancing, and said, "Oh, Narada, where are you going?" His

    voice and his gestures were wild. Narada said, "I am going to

    heaven." "Then, ask when I shall be free." Narada went on.

    In the course of time he came again by the same road, and

    there was the man who had been meditating with the ant-hill

    round him. He said, "Oh, Narada, did you ask the Lord about

    me?" "Oh, yes." "What did He say?" "The Lord told me that

    you would attain freedom in four more births." Then the man

    began to weep and wail, and said, "I have meditated until an

    ant-hill has grown around me, and I have four more birthsyet!" Narada went to the other man. "Did you ask my

    question?" "Oh, yes. Do you see this tamarind tree? I have to

    tell you that as many leaves as there are on that tree, so many

    times, you shall be born, and then you shall attain freedom."

    The man began to dance for joy, and said, "I shall have

    freedom after such a short time!" A voice came, "My child,

    you will have freedom this minute." That was the reward for

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    56/65

    56

    his perseverance. He was ready to work through all those

    births, nothing discouraged him. But the first man felt that

    even four more births were too long. Only perseverance, like

    that of the man who was willing to wait eons brings about the

    highest result. (CW of SV Vol.1, pp. 189-194)

    The Three Paths of Meditation

    There are three ways by which aspirants try to enter the path

    of meditation: the path of truth (Sathwic-marga), the path of

    passion and emotion (rajasic-marga) and the path of

    ignorance (tamasic-marga).

    The pure, serene (Sathwic) path

    On this path, one considers repetition of the name and

    meditation as a duty and suffers any amount of trouble for its

    sake; one is fully convinced that all this is just an illusion, soone does only good under all conditions and at all times. One

    desires only the good of all and is always loving towards all;

    one spends time uninterruptedly in the remembrance and

    meditation of the Lord. One does not crave even the fruit of

    repeating the name and meditation; one leaves it all to the

    Lord.

    The passionate, restless (rajasic) path

    Here, one craves for the fruit of ones act at every step. If the

    fruit is not available, then, gradually, laxity and disgust

    overpower the spiritual aspirant and the repetition of the

    name and meditation slowly dry up.

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    57/65

    57

    The ignorant (tamasic) path

    This path is even worse. The Lord will come into the

    memory only in times of danger or acute suffering or when

    one is the victim of loss or pain. At such times, such a person

    prays and vows to arrange this worship (puja), offer this

    particular food, or build this kind of temple to the Lord. One

    will be calculating the quantity of food placed before the

    Lord, the tribute offered at His feet, the number of

    prostrations performed, and the number of times the shrine

    was circled and ask for proportionate awards! For thosewho adopt this attitude in meditation, the mind and intellect

    can never be pure.

    Most people now follow only the passionate, restless

    (rajasic) and dull, ignorant (tamasic) paths in repeating the

    divine name and meditation. However, the very intention of

    repeating the divine name and meditation is to purify the

    mind and the intellect. In order to achieve this, the first path

    is best: pure, serene (Sathwic) meditation. When the mind

    and the intellect become pure, they will shine with the

    splendour of the understanding of theAtma. He in whom this

    understanding shines fully is called a sage (rishi). The

    knower of Atma becomes the Atma itself (BrahmavidBrahmaiva bhavathi). The goal of life, that which makes life

    worthwhile, is the understanding of the Atma or, in other

    words, the basis of the individual soul (jiva). (DhyV, pp. 10-

    11)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    58/65

    58

    Meditation as cognized by other Faiths

    Christianity:

    The term 'meditation' is used a few times in the Psalms of the

    Old Testament.

    "How much I love Thy Law

    It is the object of my meditation" (Psalm 119.97)

    "O, Eternal, I meditate on your works" (Psalm 143.5 ) (Paths

    of Meditation, p. 105)

    Jesus prayed alone and sometimes prayed the whole night.

    'Alone' may mean in solitude as is evidenced in the

    instructions Jesus gave: "When you pray, enter into thy closet

    and when thou hast shut thy door, pray to thy Father which is

    in secret, and the Father which seeth in secret shall rewardthee openly'. (Mathew VI-6)

    The insistence on 'secret' may be understood as the secret

    depth of heart where one has to retire and into which depth

    God sees. (Paths of Meditation, p. 107)

    Zoroastrian

    Ahuna Vairya- thousands of years before Zarathustra said -

    Righteous Meditation enables one to do Righteous Deeds for

    the Good of Creation and the Glory of God. (Yas.27: 13)

    Zarathustra said:

    Meditation with Pure Mind (Yas 30:2) Give us Purity

    through Righteous Mind (Meditation) (Yas 43: 2)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    59/65

    59

    Give us Purity which is the reward for Righteous Mind i.e.

    Meditation (Yas 28: 7)

    Teach us the path of Purity through Righteous Mind i.e.

    Meditation (Yas34: 12)

    Purity! When shall I see thee through the eyes of Righteous

    Mind i.e. Meditation (Yas28:5) (Paths of Meditation,

    p.182.5)

    Suffism:

    Muraquiba-i-Nizami i.e. realization of multiplicity is unity

    and unity in multiplicity. The spiritual aspirant has to

    concentrate on the phenomenal existence. By meditating on

    the concept 'I do not exist, God alone exists', he perceives

    God within. Then contemplating God without, he ushers in astate of self-forgetfulness. (Paths of Meditation, pp.214-215)

    Islam:

    God says in the Holy Quran:

    "Pray unto Me and I will hear your prayer" (40: 60)

    "Verily We created man and We know what his soulwhispers and We are nearer to him than his jugular vein"

    (50: 16)

    "Establish prayer for My remembrance" says God in Holy

    Quran (20 : 14) (Paths of Meditation, pp. 219-221)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    60/65

    60

    Spanish Mystics:

    Jesus prayed 'Our Father, that art in Heaven' (Paths of

    meditation p.131)

    Yogavasishtha :

    According to Vasishta, Brahman, the Absolute, manifests

    itself in the world. Everything originates out of, exists in,

    and finally merges into Brahman. He gives the analogy of

    the waves in the ocean. The waves arise, exit and merge into

    the ocean. (Paths of Meditation, p.65)

    Manas, mind is ever active like the ripples in the motionless

    ocean. The ocean is like the 'chit' the pure consciousness, or

    Brahman. That is, the 'Chitta', the mind has evolved from the

    'chit', the pure consciousness. The nature of manas is

    'Karma', activity. Karma is nothing but activity of the manas.

    Each activity of manas is determined by its precedingactivity and determines, in its turn the succeeding activity.

    Thus the cessation of Karma leads to cessation of manas-

    karma nase mano nasah (111-95) (Paths of Meditation p. 67)

    Vasana is the root desire, the root inclination in the manas.

    Mere Control of the body through Hatha Yoga, without

    control of mind and without the attainment of self-

    knowledge, is futile. (V. 92 38-48)

    Yoga stands for the practice in self realisation. The term

    Yoga stands for (a) the deep affirmation of one Reality

    (ekatattvatabhyasah) (b) the stopping of the movements ofthePranas', the vital currents (prananam vilayah) and (c)

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    61/65

    61

    the control of the mind (manovinigrah). Success in anyone

    of them leads to success in others also. However, he prefers

    the control of mind as the easiest and the best. Of all the

    three methods, the control of the mind is the best because it

    is easily affected and leads to peace soon. (Vla 69 : 29)

    Vasishta is emphatic that the mind can be controlled and

    dissolved by one's own efforts and not by penances,

    pilgrimages learning, sacrifices etc. (Vlb 163:8)

    The ideal of Yoga, according to Vasishta, is to be in the

    'Turiva' state, the fourth state which is the realisation of bliss

    which is the nature of pure consciousness. (Vla 128-50-51)

    Samadhi:

    Samyama:After Pratyahara and Dharana, we come to Dhyana -

    meditation. When the mind has been trained to remain fixed

    on a certain internal or external location, there comes to it

    the power of flowing in an unbroken current, as it were,

    towards that point. This state is called Dhyana. When one

    has so intensified the power of Dhyana as to be able to reject

    the external part of perception and remain meditating only

    on the internal part, the meaning, that state is called

    Samadhi. The three Dharana, Dhyana, and Samadhi

    together, are called Samyama. That is, if the mind can first

    concentrate upon an object, and then is able to continue in

    that concentration for a length of time, and then, by

    continued concentration, to dwell only on the internal part ofthe perception of which the object was the effect, everything

  • 7/30/2019 Meditation: Questions and Answers

    62/65

    62

    comes under the control of such a mind. (CW of SV Vol.1,

    p. 151)

    Highest state of existence:This meditative state is the highest state of existence. So long

    as there is desire, no real happiness can come. It is only the

    contemplative, witness-like study of objects that brings to us

    real enjoyment and happiness. The animal has its happiness

    in the senses, the man in his intellect, and the god in spiritual

    contemplation. It is only to the soul that has attained to this

    contemplative state that the world really becomes beautiful.

    To him who desires nothing, and does not mix himself up

    with them, the manifold changes of nature are one panorama

    of beauty and sublimity. (CW of SV Vol.1, pp. 186-187)

    Samadhi is your property

    Samadhi is the property of every human being nay, everyanimal. From the lowest animal to the highest angel,

    sometime or other, each one will have to come to that state,

    and then, and then alone, will real religion begin for him.

    Until then we only struggle towards that stage. (CW of SV