Media PowerPoint Evaluation
-
Upload
joshua-seymour-greenwood -
Category
Documents
-
view
212 -
download
0
Transcript of Media PowerPoint Evaluation
The Original Plan
What have you learned from your audience feedback?
Questionnaire Did you understand the plot? Explain your
answer if possible Did you think the costumes were effective?
Explain your answer if possible Did you think the settings varied enough?
Explain your answer if possible Did you think there was a good range of
camera angles/shots? Explain your answer if possible
RESULTS Notable replies: I didn’t really understand why the people were going into the woods or the use of the yoghurt
Did you understand the plot?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: The masks were a good thing to include on the actors and adds a paranormal effect
Did you think the costumes were ef -fective?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: Most videos take place in more than one location, perhaps you could have added another location besides the woods
Do you think the settings varied enough?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: I think there is a good range of camera shots
Do you think there was a good range of camera angle/shots?
NoYes
What we learnt from the questionnaire
We understood that we need to make the video more understandable.
The thought to add a range of locations, or at least more than just one has arisen. However, we will still being using the same woods because that is where the narrative is set
Preliminary music video
What have you learned from your audience feedback?
Questionnaire Did you think the transitions were effective?
Explain your answer if possibleDid you understand the narrative? If not, what
could make it more understandable?Did you think the music video did a good job of
representing the genre of indie electronic? Explain your answer if possible
Did you think the less saturated parts of the video had a good effect? Explain your answer if possible
RESULTS Notable replies: The transitions seemed bland , the long black pauses weren’t effective in my opinion and it seemed very poorly made
Did you understand the plot?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: I didn’t understand because I didn’t understand the characters roles in their environment
Did you understand the narrative?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: I don’t think that it was a good representation of the genre as it didn’t follow traditional format in contemporary music mainstreams music videos
Did the music video fit the genre?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: I thought it was a good effect, but it was too strong and the exposure was overwhelming
Did the parts that were less saturated have a good effect?
NoYes
What we learnt from the questionnaire
We need to make sharper transitions which are more focused as well as diverse, giving it a more professional look.
We will need to explain the narrative as best as possible while also leaving it indistinct. Though, we will need to make it more obvious to an audience so they can understand what’s going on.
We also need to lessen the level of the less saturated sections of the music video, making the images less exposed.
Band Website
What have you learned from your audience feedback?
Questionnaire Was the website easy to navigate?Was it clear to see the genre of BEATPOLICE?Was it similar to any other websites from
contemporary artists?Were there enough modern elements
included?Was the writing style of the text relevant to
the genre?
RESULTS Notable replies: The website was easy to use and had an understandable , basic layout. Although, the text could have possibly been bigger
Was the website easy to navigate?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: The darker colour scheme demonstrated a traditional indie ‘look’, but the lack of colour didn’t make it clear it was indie electronic
Did you understand the narrative?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: It was obvious of the influence from contemporary artists websites by using the same format for the headings
Did the website resemble contemporary artists?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: I believe there should have been more social media links to reach a wider audience
Were there enough modern elements included?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: I thought the writing styles match those of other indie artists, but the article was bare and could have used more articles
Did the writing style of the text match the genre?
NoYes
What we learnt from the questionnaire
We need to include more social media links on our band website as well as more articles as the type of writing style fit the genre
From the feedback, we decided not to add a colourful theme to the website as it wouldn’t fit the genre code and conventions
Digipak
What have you learned from your audience feedback?
Questionnaire Did the digipak show the genre of the band?
Explain your answer if possibleDid the colour scheme suit the band?
Explain your answer if possible Were the images manipulated well? Explain
your answer if possibleWas the font suitable? Explain your answer if
possible
RESULTS Notable replies: The digipak visibly relates to the website and music video and the dark ‘moody’ image
Did the digipak show the genre of the band?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: The colour scheme suited the band, but it made the text less visible
Did the colour scheme suit the band?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: I liked the way the images were manipulated and the filters also worked well
Were the images manipulated well?
NoYes
RESULTS Notable replies: The font was suitable, but meant the text was difficult to read
Was the font suitable?
NoYes
What we learnt from the questionnaire
Our chosen font and colours didn’t particularly suit each other, meaning it was difficult to read the text. To develop this, we would either need to change the font or the colour scheme, making the text easier to read.
Final Music Video
What have you learned from your audience feedback?
Questions to ask ourselves after feedback Was the narrative clear? Explain your answer if possibleDid the video transition smoothly? Explain your answer if
possibleDid the costume add to the supernatural/dark atmosphere?
Explain your answer if possibleDid the lip-syncing work effectively? (in time) explain your
answer if possibleWas there a wide range of camera, movements/angle/shots
throughout? Were the lighting, costume and setting cohesive in creating an
atmosphere? Explain your answer if possibleWas the voice over introduction effective and did it keep the
tone of the video throughout? Explain your answer if possible
Was the narrative clear?
In-keep with Katz and Lazarsfeld’s two-step-flow theory; we wanted social factors to effect the audiences’
understanding of the text. This meant that the narrative was more logical and clear and that the aim was
understood by the audience instead of them feeling that the video was composite and confusing. With a voice over at the beginning and a quote at the end, our music video was far more accommodating in helping the audience to
comprehend the narrative. The aim was to allow the audience to project their own opinion and understanding
of the text.
Did the video transition smoothly?
Our continuity was clear as well as there being two clear time lines being followed. For example one with the group of youths and a separate one with a girl on her own. The time lines were
clearer because the youths are in chronological order as once the yoghurt is poured on them they are only showed covered in
yoghurt. While the latter, with the girl on her own by a tree is vague, as she changes position and her clips are rewound at the beginning as well as her being shown covered in yoghurt at the
beginning and shown pouring it on herself at the end. This demonstrates her supernatural and odd behaviour which could be connoted that she is witch like and different to the youths.
Did the costume add to the supernatural/dark atmosphere?
The results showed that the use of makeup and face masks helped to convey the intent for the atmosphere of the video. Our choice to have the video set in the woods also helped to contribute to the dark ominous effect that we wanted to embody. On our final video the actors were
only wearing black and some results from the audience showed that it would have been more effective if all actors were wearing exactly the same outfits. It can be said that
this was a good insight into the costume choice for our video and perhaps it would give the youths a more
threatening vibe.
Did the lip-syncing work effectively?
From our audience feedback, the lip syncing was in time. However it was a bit of a surprise/confusion when a male
voice was coming out of a female actress. This was our purpose though, as we wanted her character to seem
supernatural and very odd such as the video.
Was there a wide range of camera, movements/angle/shots throughout?
From the audience feedback, it showed that there were in fact a range of camera movements/angles/shots, keeping the audiences’ attention. This was the aim as we felt that we could convey movement and excitement throughout the video in camerawork, as well as producing a text that seems professional. We wanted to demonstrate this with
our camerawork and we did this effectively
Were the lighting, costume and setting cohesive in creating an atmosphere?
This question was originally asking the audience to say if they thought the mise-en-scene corresponded and
created the lively, yet eerie atmosphere that we wanted to portray. Unpredictably, the audience felt that they all worked together well. This could have largely been a
factor of the less saturated parts in the woods, perhaps if this had not been the case and we used the natural
colours and natural lighting it would not have created the atmosphere that we were aiming for
Was the voice over introduction effective and did it keep the tone of
the video throughout?The question divided the audience as a few thought it
stripped the intended eerie/dark feeling that we aimed to demonstrate. Whereas, the rest thought it added to the eerie/dark feeling and believed it was secretly recorded
from a normal conversation a regular girl was having and part of the aim behind the video was to make it seem as if
these teenagers had in a way documented and filmed their escape from society and their coming to the wood; a reason why a handheld camera was used for the filming of
the video