May 19, 2005
-
Upload
galvin-middleton -
Category
Documents
-
view
18 -
download
2
description
Transcript of May 19, 2005
- 1 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
May 19, 2005
Exits from Public Stocks
Effectively Administering Private Equity FundsHarvard Club, New York, NY
- 2 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
Conning Capital Partners (“CCP”)
Roots go back to founding of Conning & Company in 1912, as broker-dealer serving individuals and institutions in Hartford (e.g., insurance). Merchant banking practices expanded and institutionalized with formation of the first private equity fund in 1985, separate management in 1990, and spin-out from the sponsor in 2003.
The current active funds are Fund V and Fund VI, with $530 million in commitments. Twenty-one total employees, 23 portfolio companies.
Investment focus is on financial services and healthcare services. Seeking to invest $5 to $20 million in companies with revenues of $5 to $100 million, targeting a 20% to 30% IRR with a minimum 2.5x returns.
Over eight years CFO has conducted exits from a dozen public positions. Block trades, currency hedges, option exercise, collar transactions, et al.
- 3 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
Objective
- 4 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
The Three Points to Remember
It’s not an exit until it’s cash.
Nobody does it better.
Good partners make for good experiences.
CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS- 5 -
Shares are received from: IPO
Shares of the acquirer of a portfolio company
PIPE
Follow-on investments post-IPO
Common tools: Dribble it Out
Block Trades
Stock Distributions
Secondary Offerings
Uncommon / New Tools: 10b5-1 programs
Option overwrite / covered calls
Currency hedging
Collars
Basket hedges
Block with upside
Exiting from Large and/or Illiquid Public Stock Positions
}Positions are frequently in thinly traded, small or even micro cap stocks
- 6 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
Sample Exit Using ZCF
$18 Deal Announced September 2003
$25 Shares Valued and Deal Closes November 2003
$27 December 2003
PricePer
Share
Portfolio CompanyOwnership
40% Cash
40% Stock
20% 1-Year Escrow
Shares are subject to a 6-month lockup which prohibits hedging.
Acquiror has positive EBITDA, but negligible net income.
Inve
stor
s
Sm
all-C
ap
Tec
h C
o.
- 7 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
Sample Exit Using ZCF Con’t.
Working through alternatives, basket hedging rejected.
Developed a brief on how our hedge would benefit the acquiror, who then agreed to allow this one amendment to our lock-up. No other investor pursued the possibility of hedging.
Low trading volumes forced a hedge in two tranches.
HedgedValue
VC retainsPrice
Volatility
Call Ceiling
Put Floor
Stock Price
{Tranche#1 / #2
$28.33 / $27.77
$23.15 / $22.72
OpportunityCost
EliminateRisk
+/- about 10% of average price
- 8 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
Final Pricing is the Result of an Actual Short Position
ABSOLUTELY ESSENTIAL CHINA WALL
PrivateClient
Services
MonetizationServices
Group
InvestmentBankingDivision
InstitutionalTrading
Desk
InstitutionalSales
Traders
INFORMATIONBARRIER
- 9 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
Results
Economics
Market price after expiration of lock-up
$15
Market price at expiration of hedge
$17
Weighted average floor price
$23
Incremental gain
$3.4 million
Hedge began in January, closed in December, avoiding hedge accounting
Throughout 2004, able to promise investors a year-end distribution. Early
termination available at negotiated pricing.
The $3.4 million hedge gain was 22% of 2004’s total gains.
- 10 -CONNING CAPITAL PARTNERS
Over eight years, four different equity trading partners. Our experience: We need wide-ranging products and services with an expert team. At the same time, we do few
transactions.
We hold volatile small cap stocks where our trades can move the market.
Good execution adds 2% to 5% to the value realized on exit.
Good relationships grow.
Deal partners are rotten traders.
Cut through the sales pitch: Fast execution – weak compliance department.
Best pricing and best traders – inadequate China wall.
Not the major market maker – access to the potential block buyers.
China Wall not optional.
Picking an Equity Trading Partner