Matt Jeppson / Shutterstock - Constant Contact

11/30/2016 Settlement Reached In Annapolis 'Snake House' Case

http://www.inman.com/2016/11/29/settlement-reached-annapolis-snake-house-case/?utm_source=inbrief&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=inbrief&utm_content… 1/4

Matt Jeppson / Shutterstock.com

AGENT NEWS BRIEF

Settlement reached in Annapolis ‘snake house’ caseThe buyers accepted an undisclosed sum to drop the casePUBLISHED 1 DAY AGO

BY MARIAN MCPHERSON ! STAFF WRITER

97SHARES

Key Takeaways

Annapolis couple Jeffery and Jody Brooks reached an undisclosed settlement in a lawsuit against real estate agent

Barbara Van Horn.

The Brooks claimed Van Horn purposefully failed to disclose a recurring snake infestation that had plagued the

house for at least eight years.

Maryland law requires sellers and their agents to disclose latent defects and material facts to buyers and buyers'

agents.

Get Inman via Facebook Messenger Our top headlines delivered once a day. é BY CAREYBOT

Send to Messenger

Mark Bergman Not you?

Where’s Samuel L. Jackson when you need him?

In April 2015, Jeffery and Jody Brooks discovered a den of black rat snakes between the walls of their newly bought

Annapolis home.



The eight snakes that the couple discovered were seven feet long and have life spans of up to 25 years, according to a

report by the Capital Gazette.

From fall to spring in ‘the snake house’

The couple said the final home inspection that took place in November before closing revealed no evidence of snakes.

But once spring came, the couple began hearing a sound coming from the walls where the snakes nested to escape the

winter’s cold.

The Brooks moved out of the home and filed a $2 million lawsuit against listing agent Barbara Van Horn for failing to

disclose a recurring issue with snake infestations.

Van Horn says she had no knowledge of the snakes, but the Brooks contested her claims with statements from multiple

previous renters who complained about finding snakes, snake skins and feces. One renter, Rich Booker, even dubbed the

home “the snake house.”

Settling the case

The case was set to go to trial on Nov. 14, but on Nov. 9, the Brooks’ lawyer, Genevieve H.R. Lindner, filed to voluntarily

dismiss the suit and settle for an undisclosed amount.

“We’re all pleased that it’s been resolved,” said Van Horn’s attorney, Barbara Johnson Palmer.

If both parties had decided to take the case to trial, it seems that the Brooks had a good chance of coming out on the

winning side.

According to Maryland law, sellers and their agents must disclose latent defects and material facts to buyers and their

agents, and it seems the Brooks’ snake infestation would be covered under each provision.

The Maryland Association of Realtors says: “A latent defect is a condition that, one is not reasonably discoverable on

careful visual inspection and two would pose a direct threat to the health or safety of the purchaser or occupant.”

Additionally, material facts are defined as a fact “that would affect the buyer’s decision to buy, the price the buyer would be

willing to pay, or other terms to which a buyer would agree.”

Lastly, Maryland law states a real estate licensee must disclose to all parties material facts the licensee knows or should

have known.

The “snake house.” (Photo credit: Paul W. Gillespie / Capital Gazette)



Another case in California

This isn’t the only seller disclosure lawsuit that has taken over the internet this year.

In June, Laura and Richard Coté of Monterey, California, filed a civil complaint against the seller, Sean Ford, and their

buyer’s agent, Herbert Aronson, for failing to disclose that a murder took place at their home more than 16 years ago, and

that the murderer had buried the body in the backyard.

The Cotés initially rented the home in 1998, and after 18 months, the couple decided to purchase the home for $339,000.

In court documents, the couple said their landlord pressured them to “close on the sale quickly,” and that Aronson had to

have known about the highly publicized murders since he’s been a Realtor in Monterey for over 30 years.

The case is ongoing, but like Maryland, California requires disclosure of material facts — although Maryland does not

require disclosure surrounding murders, and California does if the murder occurred in the past three years.

Email Marian McPherson

97SHARES

Comments

3 Comments Sort by

Countrywide Properties GroupWe have our very own "Snake House" in Rexburg Idaho too. It's been on national news and on Animal Planet. Love a good snake story!

Like · Reply · 1 · 23 hrs

Eric Axelson · Associate Broker at Keller Williams Realty, Inc.It should be noted that the last sentence is misleading. In Maryland, the law does not consider a murder a "material fact." In California, it does, ifit occurred in the last three years.Like · Reply · 9 hrs

Amber Taufen · Editor-in-Chief at Inman NewsThank you for clarifying; story updated!Like · Reply · 6 hrs

Paolo Nascimbeni · Project Manager at Life in Italy LLCGood story. About one year ago a couple was arrested in Florida for lying on their disclosures. The house had a sinkhole. The sellers tookinsurance money to fix the sinkhole, but instead of fixing the sinkhole they pocketed the money and sold the house to a family.

Oldest

Add a comment...



Inman 101 Contact Us Support Advertise Sponsor Contributors

Code of Conduct

© 2016 All Rights Reserved | Privacy | Legal

LA HS

SF

DC

RELATED ARTICLES

How would you sell a 'murder house'? | ON MAY 2, 2016

Backyard body unearths home's bloody past -- and a disclosure lawsuit | ON JUN 23, 2016

SkySlope rolls out new disclosure document tool for agents | ON AUG 31, 2016

Full disclosure: Maryland has new open house disclosure laws | ON SEP 29, 2016

BY BERNICE ROSS

BY CAROLINE FEENEY !

BY MARIAN MCPHERSON !

BY BRITT CHESTER !

insurance money to fix the sinkhole, but instead of fixing the sinkhole they pocketed the money and sold the house to a family.Like · Reply · 6 hrs

Facebook Comments Plugin

Matt Jeppson / Shutterstock - Constant Contact

Documents

Transcript of Matt Jeppson / Shutterstock - Constant Contact