Mastering Strategic Management Chapter 1 Mastering Strategy: Art and Science
MASTERING PROJECT MANAGEMENT - WordPress.com · 0 MASTERING PROJECT MANAGEMENT By Thomas Edison...
Transcript of MASTERING PROJECT MANAGEMENT - WordPress.com · 0 MASTERING PROJECT MANAGEMENT By Thomas Edison...
0
MASTERING
PROJECT
MANAGEMENT
By Thomas Edison Team
(Elena Dorneanu, Fadi Alhaj Ahmed, Khoa Nguyen
Naveen, Farida Saajan Ismail, Stepan Blaha)
MOTIS/IMC/IME Project
ESIEE Paris, 2013
1
2
Preface
The book you are going to read has been written by a group of students from ESIEE Paris.
Writing this book was their project.
They started on October 7th and finished on October 18th 2013. They had four half days in which
to do all the work. The chapter subjects were imposed. A four page specification gave further
guidelines.
Since 2011 over fifty such book projects have been done by students in Paris (France), Pretoria
(South Africa) and Turku (Finland).
Hopefully you, the reader, will find this one interesting and useful!
Krys Markowski, ESIEE Paris,2013
3
4
Team Name Inspiration
Thomas Alva Edison (February 11, 1847 – October 18, 1931)
The first thing that comes to mind when you hear the name Edison is a light bulb which almost
every household has nowadays. You could say he lit up our lives.
"The miracle of the millennium was providing light and power to the masses [...]. There is no
question that Edison deserves the lion's share of credit for lighting up the world. However, this
amazing accomplishment was far less related to his particular discovery of an incandescent bulb
than to his creation of the first genuinely safe and economically viable system for generating and
distributing light and power - worldwide."1
Thomas Edison‘s discovery inspires us every day in order to become brilliant and think about the
ways we can improve our life. We should never accept a thing without thinking how we can
improve it. Only after improving it, we can share it. This is what we tried to learn from Thomas
Edison and apply within this book. Hope this book will bring value to the others and not only to
the ones who created it. It should ―light up‖ the juniors or inexperienced professionals techniques
in project management field in order to help them to create a ―safe and economically viable”
project.
1 http://www.thomasedison.com/enlightened.html
5
6
Table of Contents
Preface ................................................................................... 2
Team Name Inspiration .......................................................... 4
Table of Contents ................................................................... 6
Introduction - Why Project Management? .............................. 8
The Project Cycle .......................................................... 14
PRINCE2 ...................................................................... 20
PMBOK (Project Management Knowledge Areas) ........ 23
Project Management Charter ......................................... 26
PROJECT DASHBOARD or COCKPIT ....................... 30
PROJECT PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT ................... 33
The CIFTER (Crawford Ishikawa) Index ....................... 36
Project Management Software ....................................... 39
Conflict Management in Projects ................................... 44
Risk Management in Projects ........................................ 47
Stakeholder Management in Projects ............................. 52
Project Team Structures ................................................. 56
How to Motivate a Project Team ................................... 61
Project Management 2.0 ................................................ 68
What is Agile Project Management? .............................. 71
Professional PM Associations ........................................ 78
Project Management Certification ................................. 81
References ............................................................................ 84
The Thomas Edison Team‘s Methodology ............................ 88
Thomas Edison Team Members – Mini CVs......................... 94
7
Table of Illustrations
SECTION/
CHAPTER
Illustration
no.
Illustration Name Page
SECTION 1/CHAPTER 1 Picture 1.1
Project Phases 14
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 1 Picture 2.1.1 PRINCE2 Principles 20
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 1 Picture 2.1.2 PRINCE2 Process Model 21
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 2 Picture 2.2.1 Project Management Knowledge
Areas
23
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 3 Picture 2.3.1 Project Charter Areas 26
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 3 Picture 2.3.2 Example of a Project Charter sheet 27
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 4 Picture 2.4.1 Dashboard of Sustainability 30
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 4 Picture 2.4.2 Project Dashboard 32
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 5 Picture 2.5.1 Primavera PPM Application 34
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 5 Picture 2.5.2 Relationship between PPM and PM
interlinked by program management
34
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 5 Picture 2.5.3 Overview of hierarchical position of
PPM in an organization
35
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 6 Picture 2.6.1 CIFTER Table 38
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 7 Picture 2.7.1 Project Management Tasks 39
SECTION 2/CHAPTER 7 Picture 2.7.3 Project Management Software 40
SECTION 3/CHAPTER 1 Picture 3.1.2 PM Leadership Style and Situations 45
SECTION 3/CHAPTER 2 Picture 3.2.1 Risk Matrix 48
SECTION 4/ CHAPTER 1 Picture 4 Stakeholders Categories 52
SECTION 5/ CHAPTER 1 Picture 5.1.1 Functional Organizations 57
SECTION 5/ CHAPTER 1 Picture 5.1.2 Projectized Organizations 58
SECTION 5/ CHAPTER 1 Picture 5.1.3 Matrix Organizations 58
SECTION 5/ CHAPTER 1 Picture 5.1.4 Overview of different types of
Organizations
60
SECTION 6/ CHAPTER 1 Picture 6.1.1 List of Differences between
Traditional Project Management and
Project Management 2.0
69
8
Introduction – Why Project Management?
All of history’s most impactful entrepreneurs (from Thomas Edison to Bill
Gates, Steve Jobs, or Richard Branson) were able to shape our world not only by their
inventions, but by their ability to pull in bright people, to become a sort of collaboration
machine, to invent together. The genius was in creating the context and culture for a
collaborative process that moved their inventions forward, faster.2
This book is not only a ―dictionary‖ of Project Management concepts. It is a full kit for
understanding and applying the practices. This project was ―invented‖ together in a high
multicultural environment where we tried to put value in this collaborative process. We ―moved
forward this invention” by sharing the best practices within this book.
This book is addressed to the junior, inexperienced professionals who want to start out in project
management and improve considerably their work procedures, proficiency, profits etc. Hope you
will find it easy to read and practical. It is composed of 2 parts:
In the first part you can enter in the ―project management world‖ and you will find the
definition of a project and its phases. Then we deep down into some methods that hope you will
find useful. As you proceed in reading the book, you will discover that as a project manager, you
should pay attention not only to the methods applied, but also to your team, stakeholders,
conflicts that may appear and risks. For each, you can find a special section. In addition to this,
nowadays there is a constant need to be always informed. You can find within this book
information regarding the latest practices in project management. Last but not the least, if you are
a good project manager, why shouldn‘t you be recognized? We listed in the end the Project
Management associations and the certifications you may want to apply to.
The second part contains a day-by-day ―methodology‖ of creating the book. Because this book
is a real project, you can gain knowledge from our own experience!
Hope you will enjoy reading it!
2 http://www.fastcompany.com/3004139/thomas-edisons-keys-managing-team-collaboration
9
10
PART I
PROJECT MANAGEMENT
CONCEPTS
“Being a Project Manager is like being an artist, you have the different colored
process streams combining into a work of art” (Greg Cimmarrusti)
11
12
****************************************************************************************
This first section contains only one chapter and describes the various phases - and
their sequencing - that a project must go through from beginning to end in order to
realize its objectives.
****************************************************************************************
SECTION 1
Project cycle overview
****************************************************************************************
“Because ideas have to be original only with regard to their adaptation to the
problem at hand, I am always extremely interested in how others have used
them....” (Thomas Edison)
13
14
The Project Cycle
Project management is the discipline of planning, organizing, motivating, and controlling
resources to achieve specific goals. A project is a temporary endeavor with a defined beginning
and end (usually time-constrained, and often constrained by funding or deliverables), undertaken
to meet unique goals and objectives, typically to bring about beneficial change or added value.
The temporary nature of projects stands in contrast with business as usual (or operations), which
are repetitive, permanent, or semi-permanent functional activities to produce products or services.
In practice, the management of these two systems is often quite different, and as such requires the
development of distinct technical skills and management strategies.
The project manager and project team have one shared goal: to carry out the work of the project
for the purpose of meeting the project‘s objectives. Every project has beginnings, a middle period
during which activities move the project toward completion, and an ending (either successful or
unsuccessful). A standard project typically has the following four major phases (each with its
own agenda of tasks and issues): initiation, planning, implementation, and closure. Taken
together, these phases represent the path a project takes from the beginning to its end and are
generally referred to as the project life cycle.
Picture 1.1: Project Phases
PLANNING PHASE
IMPLEMENTATION
/ EXECUTION PHASE
CLOSING PHASE
INITIATION PHASE
15
INITIATION PHASE
During the first of these phases, the initiation phase, the project objective or need is identified;
this can be a business problem or opportunity. An appropriate response to the need is documented
in a business case with recommended solution options. A feasibility study is conducted to
investigate whether each option addresses the project objective and a final recommended solution
is determined. Issues of feasibility (―can we do the project?‖) and justification (―should we do the
project?‖) are addressed. Once the recommended solution is approved, a project is initiated and a
project manager is appointed. The major deliverables and the participating work groups are
identified and the project team begins to take shape. Approval is then sought by the project
manager to move on the detailed planning phase.
PLANNING PHASE
The next phase, the planning phase, is where the project solution is further developed in as much
detail as possible and you plan the steps necessary to meet the project‘s objective. In this step, the
team identifies all of the work to be done. The project‘s tasks and resource requirements are
identified, along with the strategy for producing them. This is also referred to as scope
management. A project plan is created outlining the activities, tasks, dependencies and
timeframes. The project manager coordinates the preparation of a project budget; by providing
cost estimates for the labor, equipment and materials costs. The budget is used to monitor and
control cost expenditures during project implementation.
Once the project team has identified the work, prepared the schedule and estimated the costs, the
three fundamental components of the planning process are complete. This is an excellent time to
identify and try to deal with anything that might pose a threat to the successful completion of the
project. This is called risk management. In risk management, ―high-threat‖ potential problems are
identified along with the action that is to be taken on each high threat potential problem, either to
reduce the probability that the problem will occur or to reduce the impact on the project if it does
occur. This is also a good time to identify all project stakeholders, and to establish a
communication plan describing the information needed and the delivery method to be used to
keep the stakeholders informed.
Finally, you will want to document a quality plan; providing quality targets, assurance, and
control measures along with an acceptance plan; listing the criteria to be met to gain customer
acceptance. At this point, the project would have been planned in detail and is ready to be
executed.
IMPLEMENTATION (EXECUTION) PHASE
During the third phase, the implementation phase, the project plan is put into motion and
performs the work of the project. It is important to maintain control and communicate as needed
during implementation. Progress is continuously monitored and appropriate adjustments are made
and recorded as variances from the original plan. In any project a project manager will spend
most of their time in this step. During project implementation, people are carrying out the tasks
16
and progress information is being reported through regular team meetings. The project manager
uses this information to maintain control over the direction of the project by measuring the
performance of the project activities comparing the results with the project plan and takes
corrective action as needed.
The first course of action should always be to bring the project back on course, i.e., to return it to
the original plan. If that cannot happen, the team should record variations from the original plan
and record and publish modifications to the plan. Throughout this step, project sponsors and other
key stakeholders should be kept informed of project status according to the agreed upon
frequency and format. The plan should be updated and published on a regular basis. Status
reports should always emphasize the anticipated end point in terms of cost, schedule and quality
of deliverables. Each project deliverable produced should be reviewed for quality and measured
against the acceptance criteria. Once all of the deliverables have been produced and the customer
has accepted the final solution, the project is ready for closure.
CLOSING PHASE
During the final closure, or completion phase, the emphasis is on releasing the final deliverables
to the customer, handing over project documentation to the business, terminating supplier
contracts, releasing project resources and communicating the closure of the project to all
stakeholders. The last remaining step is to conduct lessons learned studies; to examine what went
well and what didn‘t. Through this type of analysis the wisdom of experience is transferred back
to the project organization, which will help future project teams.
17
18
****************************************************************************************
Within this second section you can find just few of the many techniques that you may
use in the first phases of the project.
****************************************************************************************
SECTION 2
Project management techniques
****************************************************************************************
“It’s obvious that we don't know one millionth of one percent about anything.”
(Thomas Edison)
19
20
1. PRINCE2
Picture 2.1.1:PRINCE2 Principles
PRINCE2 is a structured approach to project management released in 1996 as a generic project
management method. It combines the original PROMPT methodology (which evolved into the
PRINCE methodology) with IBM's MITP (managing the implementation of the total project)
methodology. PRINCE2 provides a method for managing projects within a clearly defined
framework.
PRINCE2 focuses on the definition and delivery of products, in particular their quality
requirements. As such, it defines a successful project as being output-oriented (not activity- or
task-oriented) through creating an agreed set of products that define the scope of the project and
provides the basis for planning and control, that is, how then to coordinate people and activities,
how to design and supervise product delivery, and what to do if products and therefore the scope
of the project has to be adjusted if it does not develop as planned.
Each process is specified with its key inputs and outputs and with specific goals and activities to
be carried out to deliver a project's outcomes as defined by its Business Case. This allows for
continuous assessment and adjustment when deviation from the Business Case is required.
21
PRINCE2 provides a common language for all participants in the project. The governance
framework of PRINCE2 – its roles and responsibilities – are fully described and require tailoring
to suit the complexity of the project and skills of the organization.
PRINCE2 has seven important principles that contribute to project success:
1. Continued Business Justification
2. Learn from Experience
3. Defined Roles and Responsibilities
4. Manage by Stages
5. Manage by Exception
6. Focus on Products
7. Tailored to Suit the Project Environment
The principles and themes come into play in the seven PRINCE2 processes:
1. Starting up a Project
2. Initiating a Project
3. Directing a Project
4. Controlling a Stage
5. Managing Stage Boundaries
6. Managing Product Delivery
7. Closing a Project
Picture 2.1.2: PRINCE2 Process Model
PRINCE2, along with the PMBOK Guide, are the two most important project management
standards today. Both of them have lots of guidelines, recommendations, and processes for the
planning of the projects. The main goal of project management is reaching project goals with an
22
optimal use of resources. This is not possible without appropriate controls, and control is not
possible unless we plan the project ahead.
23
2. PMBOK (Project Management Knowledge Areas)
Picture 2.2.1: Project Management Knowledge Areas
The PMBOK (Project Management Knowledge Areas) recognizes 5 basic process groups and 9
knowledge areas typical of almost all projects. They are Project Integration Management, Project
Scope Management, Project Time Management, Project Cost Management, Project Quality
Management, Project Human Resource Management, Project Communications Management,
Project Risk Management, and Project Procurement Management (Project Smart, 2008). Of these
9 areas, it is my belief that Project Time Management, Project Communication Management and
Project Scope Management are the most important.
Time Management includes all processes and procedures relating to the timely completion of a
project (De Jaeger, 2008). There are several processes included with proper time management
skills and management. First, Activity Definition requires the project manager to define the
24
activities to be assigned and their estimated timeframe. Many times activities overlap one
another. Activity Sequencing demands the manager to make sure that they can schedule
appropriate details of the project in a manner that would allow the project to continue to move
forward with the most productivity as possible. Activity Resource Estimating allows the project
manager to assess the supply on hand to complete the assignment as scheduled. Schedule
Development and Control are additional functions the project manager must be mindful of when
coordinating proper Project Time Management (Project Management Institute, 2004, pg. 123).
When poor time management comes into play, delays and miscommunications can occur in the
development of a project. Time is of the essence when an alternative method of accomplishment
needs to be executed to continue project production. An inaccurate projection of Activity
Resource Estimating could prove to be a costly error. In this case, the project would be delayed
because the project moved quicker than was anticipated and consumed more resources or the
project used less than was predicted and the excess was wasted (Project Management Institute,
2004, pg. 137). In reference to trade show preparation, time management includes accounting for
travel plans, set-up and breakdown of the trade show display, and coordination of the creation of
all marketing and promotional materials for the event. These items are time sensitive and can
affect budgeting and overall project progress.
Project Communication Management involves Communications Planning or the identification of
project stakeholders needs and desires for the project as a whole. Information Distribution
requires project managers to make information concerning the project available to project
stakeholders on an as-needed basis. Performance Reporting is another aspect of project
Communications Management. The acquisition and distribution of information to project team
members is included in this area. Status reporting, progress reports, and forecasting are an
important part of communications in any project. The final processes in this area include
managing the demands of project stakeholders and keeping them informed during the production
stages (Project Management Institute, 2004, pg. 221).
When there are flaws in communication during project management phases, there are drastic
errors that can occur. If a delay in communication occurs, requested changes can take longer to
occur and prolong the progress of the project (Project Management Institute, 2004, pg. 234).
Planning for a trade show involves input from multiple parties and cooperation of these entities.
During the development stages for collateral and other marketing materials involved in the trade
show, stakeholders should be kept abreast of any and all changes pertaining to design, orientation
and the general flow of the trade show.
Project Scope Management includes Scope Planning. The scope of the project defines how the
project will be created, verified, and controlled. When we look at the Scope Definition, project
managers are responsible for creating a detailed project statement for the preliminary address of
the project at hand. This area also requires the manager to divide major project deliverables into
25
smaller sections for team members to tackle. As the objectives of the project change, this area
requires that the project manager control changes made to the scope of the project as a whole
(Project Management Institute, 2004, pg. 103).
Maintaining the Project Scope is important for accurate project progression and growth. The
scope should include only things that are necessary to the project as additional activities could be
a burden to the project and take up unnecessary time. Environmental factors and other things that
are outside the realm of forecasting can affect the scope of a project. In this aspect, the project
may need to be put on hold because of an emergency or some other unpredicted occurrence.
Project managers should prepare for scrutiny and criticism towards their general project
parameters. This preparation will only strengthen the project management scope and add
additional stability to the project plan (Project Management Institute, 2004, pg. 107).
When creating items to use for a trade show, it is imperative that the scope of the project be as
precise as possible. At the same time, it is important that the lines of communication flow freely
and be updated in a timely manner. While all knowledge areas discussed in the Project
Management Body of Knowledge, these three categories strike me as the most pertinent to trade
show development and coordination. Timing of travel, communication of needs, and scope of
project in full extent are of the utmost importance to stockholders as well as team members
involved in this production.
26
3. Project Management Charter
In project management, a project charter, project definition, or project statement is a statement of
the scope, objectives, and participants in a project. It provides a preliminary delineation of roles
and responsibilities, outlines the project objectives, identifies the main stakeholders, and defines
the authority of the project manager. It serves as a reference of authority for the future of the
project. The project charter is usually a short document that refers to more detailed documents
such as a new offering request or a request for proposal.
The purpose of the project charter is to document:
Reasons for undertaking the project
Objectives and constraints of the project
Directions concerning the solution
Identities of the main stakeholders
In-scope and out-of-scope items
High level risk management plan
Communication plan
Target project benefits
High level budget and spending authority
Picture 2.3.1: Project charter areas
27
Picture 2.3.2: Example of a Project Charter sheet
28
Guidelines to complete the Project Charter:
1. Project Context & Background
Describe the business rationale for the project, providing relevant background information
to help the reader of this document place the proposed project in the right context (e.g.
relative to strategic or operational goals of the company).
2. Expected Business Benefits
May include project benefits or specific measures associated with quality of outputs,
project process etc.
3. Project Objectives
What is the overall project goal or objective?
Specifics under deliverables, scope, success criteria should help ensure the objective is
"SMART" and clearly understood by all. (Note: to help simplify a charter, you could also
group goals, deliverables success criteria together into one section).
4. Deliverables
What are the key outputs / end products of the project? (Be as specific as possible: e.g. a
new process, a report/presentation, a system implementation, a recommendation etc.)
5. Scope
What are the boundaries of the project? Provide information that may help scale the
project and specifically address topics raised by stakeholders in terms of what is included
vs. excluded from the project. What is described here may be helpful later on when issues
of "scope creep" may need to be addressed!
6. Proposed Timeline & Key Milestones
Specify the proposed timeline and the important milestones either in text form, or (better)
using a graphical timeline so that readers of the document can quickly understand the
proposed timing.
7. Project Resources
List the key people, groups and organizations / teams that will be involved and
contributing to the project.
8. Risks
Identify all known, potential issues / risks that may affect the project. Consider
developing a risk management plan for significant risks. (Note: there is sometimes an
overlap between assumptions and risks (i.e. a risk could be an assumption that proves to
be incorrect). If it makes better sense for your project; just merge the Assumptions section
into the Risk section).
29
9. Assumptions
List any assumptions that have been made in developing the project charter, focusing on
those which may have a significant impact on the project if the assumption proves to be
wrong.
10. High Level Estimate of Budget
Estimate of approximate cost of the project (Man / days & financial cost). Fuller costs are
often worked up during detailed project planning.
11. Reporting
Provide an overview of key reporting processes / meetings – perhaps using the table
below.
A more detailed communications plan can be worked up in the Project Plan if needed.
Benefits of building the project charter
Builds the vision and case for change
Provides a constant and consistent target for project team members
Clearly aligns team members
Indicates why a project has priority over other projects
Describes the gap between the current state and the desired state
Provides a reference point the team can continually refer back to in order to keep direction
and scope
30
4. PROJECT DASHBOARD or COCKPIT
Project Dashboard or Cockpit is a simplified and user friendly visual representation of a
company/organization‘s past and present status focusing on selected performance characteristics.
The advantage of this is that it provides the user the ability to make quick calculated decisions
just by analyzing the dashboard.
There can be several types of dashboards based on different departments in an organization
like human resources, recruiting, sales, operations, security, information technology, project
management, customer relationship management etc.
It generally consists of multiple levels of data with the highest level getting priority of visibility
and the lower levels may be accessed in case a member of the corporate wants to but is often
unavailable.
Below you can find an example of Dashboard of Sustainability:
Picture 2.4.1: Dashboard of Sustainability
31
There are 3 main types of Dashboards being used widely today:
1. Standalone Software Applications
2. Desktop Widgets/Applications
3. Browser based applications
The advantage of digital project dashboards is the ability it provides the managers to monitor all
departments in the organization associated with the project and their individual contributions
towards the project. This helps in measuring the overall performance of the organization with
specific data from each and every department and providing a digital snapshot of performance.
Other advantages of digital dashboards are:
Visual presentation of performance
Enables user to identify and correct negative trends
Measure efficiencies/inefficiencies
Ability to generate detailed reports showing new trends
Ability to make logical decisions based on collected business intelligence
Sort out strategies and organizational goals
Efficiency in time consumption is greatly increased
Complete visibility of all systems
Faster identification of data outliers and correlations
Below is another example of a project dashboard displaying the status of project and the
contribution and performance of various departments involved in the project and also the
important tasks to be completed and the issues pertaining to the various departments.
32
Picture 2.4.2: Project Dashboard
33
5. PROJECT PORTFOLIO MANAGEMENT
Project portfolio management (PPM) is the management of all the techniques and processes used
by project managers and project management offices in order to scrutinize and manage
current/proposed projects based on key characteristics to maximize financial profitability of an
organization and its operational efficiency by devising a strategy using PPM all while considering
real world limitations/factors and customer requests/constraints etc.
The terminal objective of PPM is to closely monitor and prioritize various projects and their
progress and performance to ensure they are successfully completed.
PPM has two main categories:
1. Execution based PPM
2. Planning based PPM
A PPM application/solution must support the following areas:
Portfolio Strategic Management
Portfolio Governance Management
Portfolio Performance Management
Portfolio Communication Management
Portfolio Risk Management
Majority of the software solutions on the market for PPM respect the subjects given above.
You can find below the main capabilities of PPM are:
1. Pipeline management-Aligning and selecting the projects strategically for capital investment
2. Resource management-Includes financial resources, inventory, human resources, technical
skills, production and design and their efficient use when needed
3. Change control- Change requests like new features, functions, additional resources etc. can
be granted provided they are within the operational and financial constraints of the
organization.
4. Risk management- Risk analysis of each project
5. Financial management- Financial guidelines, constraints, requirements of each project
34
These capabilities allow a project manager to efficiently utilize resources, manage time, consider
risks and the required budget all while being open to change during the course of completion of
the projects.
You can find below a couple of examples of PPM application:
Picture 2.5.1: Primavera PPM Application
Picture 2.5.2: Relationship between PPM and PM interlinked by program management
35
Picture 2.5.3: Overview of hierarchical position of PPM in an organization
There are a number of advantages of using PPM applications:
Monitoring of projects ensures proper prioritization of certain projects that will maximize
benefits of the organization.
PPM ensures projects meet short-term and long term strategic and technological goals
Knowledge gained from completed projects can be used to benefit new ones.
Standardization of processes increases efficiency and communication
Optimized resource utilisation.
36
6. The CIFTER (Crawford Ishikawa) Index
What does it mean the CIFTER index? The CIFTER is an abbreviation for Crawford-Ishikawa
Factor Table for Evaluating Roles. Also it's a guide to rating the management complexity of
individual projects. This rating system is used to differentiate between those projects that would
be considered everyday projects, and those that would require a professional PM.
This idea of complexity carries over to the other professions previously mentioned. Most parents
treat their children at home when sick with the flu. This doesn‘t make them doctors. Most adults
manage their own finances, but can‘t be considered accountants; and anyone can file a small
claims lawsuit, but that doesn‘t make them lawyers. It is as these things grow in complexity and
require more specialized training that we move to the idea of professional.
All of these issues of PM are what leads to the belief that not only should project management be
seen as a profession, but in fact, for it to continue to grow and improve, it must be viewed as one.
Using CIFTER
As it was said before, the CIFTER is a table. To use this table, you must first understand the
elements of the CIFTER.
1. Stability of the overall project context. The project context includes the project life-
cycle, the stakeholders, the degree to which the applicable methods and approaches are
known, and the wider socioeconomic environment. When the project context is unstable
— phase deliverables are poorly defined, scope changes are frequent and significant, team
members are coming and going, applicable laws and regulations are being modified —
the project management challenge increases.
Note: some aspects of “technical complexity” such as dealing with unproven concepts
would be considered here.
2. Number of distinct disciplines, methods, or approaches involved in performing the
project. Most projects involve more than one management or technical discipline; some
projects involve a large number of different disciplines. For example, a project to develop
a new drug could include medical researchers, marketing staff, manufacturing experts,
lawyers, and others. Since each discipline tends to approach its part of the project in a
different way, more disciplines means a project that is relatively more difficult to manage.
Note: some aspects of “technical complexity” such as dealing with a product with many
interacting elements would be considered here.
37
3. Magnitude of legal, social, or environmental implications from performing the
project. This factor addresses the potential external impact of the project. For example,
the potential for catastrophic failure means that the implications of constructing a nuclear
power plant close to a major urban center will likely be much greater than those of
constructing an identical plant in a remote area. The management complexity of the urban
project will be higher due to the need to deal with a larger number of stakeholders and a
more diverse stakeholder population.
4. Overall expected financial impact (positive or negative) on the project's
stakeholders. This factor accounts for one aspect of the traditional measure of ―size,‖ but
does so in relative terms. For example, a project manager in a consumer electronics start-
up is subject to more scrutiny than a project manager doing a similarly sized project for a
computer manufacturer with operations around the globe.
Note: where the impact on different stakeholders is different, this factor should be rated
according to the impact on the primary stakeholders.
5. Strategic importance of the project to the organization or organizations involved.
This factor addresses yet another aspect of ―size,‖ and again deals with it in relative rather
than absolute terms. While every project should be aligned with the organization‘s
strategic direction, not every project can be of equal importance to the organization or
organizations involved.
Note: as with financial impact, if the strategic importance for different stakeholders is
different, this factor should be rated according to the strategic importance for the primary
stakeholders.
6. Stakeholder cohesion regarding the characteristics of the product of the project.
When all or most stakeholders are in agreement about the characteristics of the product of
the project, they tend to be in agreement about the expected outcomes as well. When they
are not in agreement, or when the benefits of a product with a particular set of
characteristics are unknown or uncertain, the project management challenge is significant.
7. Number and variety of interfaces between project and other organizational entities.
In the same way that a large number of different disciplines on a project can create a
management challenge, a large number of different organizations can as well.
Note: issues of culture and language would be addressed here.
38
Picture 2.6.1: CIFTER Table
The mechanics couldn‘t be simpler. Choose the term that you think most accurately represents
the characteristics of the project under consideration. For example, if you think that the stability
of the project context is ―high,‖ that project rates a two on this first factor. Rate the other six
factors and sum the numbers. A higher score require a more skilled project manager.
The CIFTER won‘t make any decisions for you. CIFTER won‘t help you find a skilled project
manager if you don‘t have any available. But it can provide some guidance to help you make
better decisions when you do have options. In addition, you can use it to assess your current
assignments. While you probably won‘t be able to create perfect alignment, highlighting major
mismatches will at least tell you which projects you should be paying special attention to.
39
7. Project Management Software
Project Management Software has the capacity to assist the project manager, stakeholders and
users to help plan, organize and manage resource pools also to develop the estimations. Some
more functions that are useful for the project planning are:
Project management software is also used for collaboration and communication between
stakeholders.
Although project management software is used is a variety of ways, its main purpose is to
facilitate the planning and tracking of project components, stakeholders and resources.
Project management software caters to the following primary functions:
Project planning: To define a
project schedule, a project manager
(PM) may use the software to map
project tasks and visually describe
task interactions.
Task management: Allows for the
creation and assignment of tasks,
deadlines and status reports.
Document sharing and
collaboration: Productivity is
increased via a central document
repository accessed by project Picture 2.7.1: Project Management Tasks
stakeholders.
40
Calendar and contact sharing: Project timelines include scheduled meetings,
activity dates and contacts that should automatically update across all PM and
stakeholder calendars.
Bug and error management: Project management software facilitates bug and error
reporting, viewing, notifying and updating for stakeholders.
Time tracking: Software must have the ability to track time for all tasks maintain
records for third-party consultants.
Tasks and activities
One of the most common project management software tool types is scheduling tools. Scheduling
tools are used to sequence project activities and assign dates and resources to them. The detail
and sophistication of a schedule produced by a scheduling tool can vary considerably with the
project management methodology used, the features provided and the scheduling methods
supported. Scheduling tools may include support for:
Multiple dependency relationship types between activities
Resource assignment and leveling
The critical path and critical chain methods
Activity duration estimation and probability-based simulation and Activity cost
accounting
Picture 2.7.3: Project Management Software
41
Providing information
Project planning software can be expected to provide information to various people or
stakeholders, and can be used to measure and justify the level of effort required to complete the
project(s). Typical requirements might include:
Overview information on how long tasks will take to complete.
Early warning of any risks to the project and Information on workload, for planning
holidays.
Historical information on how projects have progressed, and in particular, how actual and
planned performances are related.
Optimum utilization of available resource and Cost Maintenance.
Project Management Software Final Point
There are plenty of project management softwares which can be installed on desktop computers,
also some web-based platform is also created and currently being developed to help this
management can be run more convenient and easier to implement. Here are some project
management softwares: Genius Project, Microsoft Project, One Desk, PlanBox… So
regardless of whether people are looking for the best project management softwares, it is the best
solution if one enterprise can choose the one that suits the current needs, type and size of the
project.
42
****************************************************************************************
This section contains three chapters and that tackle the 3 aspects of a project that need
to be taken into account especially in the early phase of a project: manage risks,
conflicts while preserving the quality
****************************************************************************************
SECTION 3
Best quality with minimum conflicts
and risks
******************************************************************************
“Results ? Why, man, I have gotten lots of results! If I find 10,000 ways
something won't work, I haven't failed. I am not discouraged, because every
wrong attempt discarded is often a step forward....” (Thomas Edison)
43
44
1. Conflict Management in Projects
Conflicts in Project Management is inevitable, this potential of conflicts exists because it
involves individuals that come from different backgrounds and orientations, they work together
on the projects to complete complex tasks. There are many causes of conflicts in team projects
such as the attitudes, expectations, perceptions, and some other human factors (human resources
and personalities). So that proper skills have to be carried out in order to assist the project
managers and other organization members to handle and solve those conflicts effectively.
How to deal with conflicts in project management
It depends on the management of project manager, the structure of organization. A list below is
carried out to indicate the methods that we can use to handle conflicts.
Conflict Sources How to deal with them
Conflict Over Project Priorities:
Differences in long term and short
term goal and activities sequencing
Develop a planning compatible with long term
strategies.
Conflict over technical opinions
and performances:
Performance related, design, code
review related differences.
Develop a standard guideline, best practices and
review mechanism.
Conflict over human resources:
Staffing opinions and where to
source them from.
We can use some techniques in order to deal with this
such as WBS and responsibility matrix, RACI, PMO
that help in getting resources
Conflicts over cost and budget:
Conflict over cost estimates from
support areas regarding work
breakdown structures and
estimating techniques.
Develop overall budgets supported by detailed budget
and cost estimates of subproject tasks and activities.
Conflict over schedules:
The disagreements about timing,
sequencing, and scheduling of
project related tasks.
Develop an overall schedule that integrates schedules
for subprojects with staffing and other life
constraints.
Personality conflict:
The disagreements on
interpersonal issues
Emphasize team building and create an environment
that emphasizes respect, diversity, and equality.
45
Approaches to conflicts
There are 5 approaches that can be taken into account in order to eliminate conflicts.
Picture 3.1.2: PM Leadership style and Situations
Avoidance Approach: Stay out of conflict; remain neutral on issues. Employed by
individuals those do not have enough invested in the issue to see value in the conflict.
Often used when the conflict is not critical or is perceived to be beyond their capacity to
manage.
Smoothing/Accommodation Approach: Entirely yielding to the conflicting point of
view. Seeking to preserve personal relationships even when it does benefit project tasks
and objectives.
Compromise Approach: Assumes that no solution can be achieved that will yield
complete satisfaction for all participants involves. Attempts to balance personal
relationships and project success when one or both may be compromised in the conflict.
Compromising
Temporary solutions
For backup if collaboration fails
When you can‘t win or don‘t have enough time
when others are as strong as you are
46
To maintain your relationship with your opponent
When you‘re not sure you are right
When you get nothing if don‘t
When goals are moderately high
Collaborating
When you both get at least what you want and maybe more.
To gain commitment and create a common power base
When there is enough time and skills are complementary
To maintain future relationships
Confronting/ problem solving
To reduce overall project costs
To gain commitment and create a common power base
When there is mutual trust, respect and confidence
Forcing
When you are sure that you are right.
When an emergency situation exists (Do or die)
When stakes are high and issues are important
When you are stronger
To gain status or demonstrate position power
When the acceptance is unimportant
47
2. Risk Management in Projects
Risk is inevitable in a business organization when undertaking projects. However, the project
manager needs to ensure that risks are kept to a minimal. Project risk management is an important
aspect of project management. Project risk can be defined as an unforeseen event or activity that
can impact the project's progress, result or outcome in a positive or negative way. A risk can be
assessed using two factors: impact and probability. If the probability is 1, it is an issue. This
means that risk is already materialized. If the probability is zero, this means that risk will not
happen and should be removed from the risk planning.
Not all the time the project managers have to deal with negative risks, when the negative risks are
identified, project managers need to come up with the planning as well as resolutions to handle
the risks.
Project Risk Management
The project managers can plan the strategy based on 4 steps of Risk management, these 4 steps
can handle the risks effectively in an organization.
Risk Identification
Risk Quantification
Risk Response
Risk Monitoring and Control
Details of 4 Steps of Risk Management:
Risk Identification:
Managers face many difficulties when it comes to identifying and naming the risks that occur
when undertaking projects. These risks could be resolved through structured or unstructured
brainstorming or strategies. It's important to understand that risks pertaining to the project can
only be handled by the project manager and other stakeholders of the project.
The risks that often impact a project are supplier risk, resource risk and budget risk. Supplier risk
would refer to risks that can occur in case the supplier is not meeting the timeline to supply the
resources required. Resource risk occurs when the human resource used in the project is not
48
enough or not skilled enough. Budget risk would refer to risks that can occur if the costs are more
than what was budgeted.
Risk Quantification:
Risks can be evaluated based on quantity. Project
managers need to analyze the likely chances of a
risk occurring with the help of a matrix.
Using the matrix, the project manager can
categorize the risk into four categories as Low,
Medium, High and Critical. The probability of
occurrence and the impact on the project are the
two parameters used for placing the risk in the
matrix categories. As an example, if a risk
occurrence is low (probability = 2) and it has the
highest impact (impact = 4), the risk can be
categorized as 'High'.
Picture 3.2.1: Risk matrix
Risk Response:
Strategies to reduce the risk to minimal, there are four risks strategies which can be used.
Risks can be avoided
Pass on the risk
Take corrective measures to reduce the impact of risks
Acknowledge the risk
Risk Monitoring and Control:
Risks can be monitored on a continuous basis to check if any change is made. New risks can be
identified through the constant monitoring and assessing mechanisms.
Risk Register:
Often project managers will compile a document, which outlines the risks involved and the
strategies in place. This document is vital as it provides a huge deal of information. Risk register
will often consist of diagrams to aid the reader as to the types of risks that are dealt by the
organization and the course of action taken. The risk register should be freely accessible for all
the members of the project team.
49
50
****************************************************************************************
The fourth section contains one chapter that tackles the stakeholders’ involvement
within a project.
****************************************************************************************
SECTION 4
Stakeholders
*******************************************************************************
“Pretty much everything will come to him who hustles while he waits. I believe
that restlessness is discontent, and discontent is merely the first necessity of
progress. Show me a thoroughly satisfied man and I will show you a failure.”
(Thomas Edison)
51
52
Stakeholder Management in Projects
Picture 4: Stakeholders categories
A Stakeholder can be a person, a group, or an organization that may be affected, or have any kind
interest in the project or in project‘s outcome either directly or indirectly.
All stakeholders are not equal, every stakeholder has his own expectations, and requirements, and
he should be handled the way he expects. Knowing them, their needs, expectations, and
requirements increase the chance of a project‘s success. If any important stakeholder is missed
then in later stages the project manager may face many difficulties e.g. causing a delay in project,
cost overrun, and in the most severe case – the project may be terminated.
A stakeholder can be:
A sponsor
Project team
Higher management
End user of the project‘s outcome
Someone affected by the project, or the project‘s outcome
Someone who has any kind of interest in the project, or the project‘s outcome
Stakeholders can be grouped into two categories:
53
Internal, and
External
Internal Stakeholders
External Stakeholders
A sponsor
Internal customer or client (if project
arose due to internal need of an
organization)
Project team
A program manager
A portfolio manager
Management
Other group‘s manager internal to the
organization; e.g. functional manager,
operational manager, admin manger,
etc.
External customer or client (if project
arose due to a contract)
End users of project‘s outcome
Supplier
Sub-contractors
Government
Local communities
Media
It is extremely important for the project manager to identify all stakeholders at the beginning of
the project and create a stakeholder management strategy to manage them as early as possible. It
will help him to run his project smoothly. Stakeholders can be positive or negative. A positive
stakeholder sees the project‘s positive side, benefited by its success, and helps the project team to
successfully complete the project. On the other hand, a negative stakeholder sees the negative
outcome of the project, may be negatively affected by the project, and he will be less likely to see
your project being completed successfully.
In some projects the general public will be a stakeholder, and in this case the project manager has
to consult public figures, or their leaders to better understand their needs, and expectations. If the
project manager fails to do so, it may cause big trouble for him in the later stages of projects.
Some examples of these kinds of projects are – mining, environment, road, rail or dam building
related projects. Hence, a project manager must identify all stakeholders at a very early stage of
the project, and document their requirements, interests, involvement, expectations, type of
influence, power, possible impact, and communication requirements in the stakeholder register. It
should be noted that some of these stakeholders will have minimum interest, or influence on the
project; however, the project manager has to take care of them as well because no one knows
when they will become the dominant stakeholders.
54
****************************************************************************************
The fifth section contains information on different types of teams in an organization
and different techniques to motivate them.
****************************************************************************************
SECTION 5
Resources
****************************************************************************************
“Many of life's failures are experienced by people who did not realize how
close they were to success when they gave up.” (Thomas Edison)
55
56
1. Project Team Structures
Within the corporate realm, organizational structures are both complex and varied. Much of the
structure that makes up the internal mechanics of any organization is often the result of various
preferences of the upper management along with carryover from previous management
individuals.
As companies grow, the complexity of their organizational structures can grow just as organically
and in many cases, a uniform ‗common‘ structure is not always apparent. Additionally, for
certain companies and industries, segmentation between various divisions is often the logical and
desired outcome depending on the overall portfolio strategy and product offerings.
From the standpoint of the project manager, it is often daunting to navigate the organizational
waters and depending on the layout, the job of the project manager as well as the tactics they use
to accomplish their job may have to adjust to accommodate the various ways things are being
done and how they are organized.
With that being said, project managers may not have a say in what type of structure they would
prefer to operate in. Oftentimes, that is dictated for them. But in a general sense, what structure
would, from the project manager‘s perspective be ‗most‘ ideal?
There are often varied structures that exist in the corporate realm. These structures are sometimes
ad hoc and often times overlap and sometimes even contradict each other when examining them
from the top down. Yet at a foundational level, the different types of organizational structures can
often be summarized into three specific types, which are defined as follows:
57
A. Functional Organization
This is an extremely common organizational
structure where team members work for a
specific department (engineering, human resources,
information technology, etc) and will in turn be
assigned or ‗loaned‘ to a specific project manager
as needed. In many cases, a project manager may
be ‗embedded‘ into a functional team if needed
and will often not work in areas outside of that team‘s Picture 5.1.1
scope. In this type of structure, the department managers and functional leaders carry the most
sway and the project manager in this circumstance is in a relatively weak role.
Benefits
Usually, team members will have a deeper expertise by function
Many members will be very specialized in their specific skill sets
Good career path for the individual contributors and functional managers
Drawbacks
Very little efficacy to the project manager role
Projects themselves are generally prioritized rather low
Resources can often be removed from a project at a moment‘s notice
Poor career path for the project manager
58
B. Projectised Organization
From this standpoint, the organization is actually
structured in and around the projects themselves,
as opposed to the functional breakdowns by deliverables.
In this structure, the project manager is not only the
manager of the project, but will often operate as the
department manager as well, with individuals working
on his/her projects reporting directly to him or her.
In this type of structure, the project manager carries the most sway. Picture 5.1.2
Benefits
Project manager has more authority
Far easier for project communication to occur
Issues with resources are less of a problem
Drawbacks
Less of a career path for individual contributors
Less specialization; team members are more ‗jack of all trades‘
Less specific loyalty to project outcomes
C. Matrix Org
The final structure is essentially a combination of
the aforementioned functional and projectized
structures. Essentially, both functional managers
and project managers exist for projects and
programs. There are varying degrees of a matrix
structure as well. A ‗strong matrix‘ has the project
manager carrying a little more clout while the
‗weak matrix‘ has the project manager with
a little less influence. The happy medium is the
‗balanced matrix‘ where the project manager and
the functional manager are peers and equals. Picture 5.1.3
59
Benefits
Is often the ‗best of both worlds‘ option, carrying benefits of both standard structures
Project managers can get deep expertise and function across varying company programs
Good career paths for team members, functional managers and project managers
Drawbacks
More overhead due to some duplication of efforts between functional and project managers
Can lead to some confusion with resources reporting to a functional manager while having
dotted lines to project managers, essentially giving them more than one manager to answer to
(Office Space anyone?!)
Can lead to contention between functional and project managers if disagreements arise
So which is the Best?
The answer to this will vary depending on who you ask. From our point of view as project and
program managers, we will likely bias towards the projectized structure. But is that one honestly
the best?
If one examines things and attempts a best of breed analysis, the matrix organization is often
thought of as the best of both worlds, provided it leans more towards the balanced or strong
matrix structure. In this case, not only does the project manager function in a more authoritative
capacity, team members and functional managers are equally afforded career paths that suit their
desires. As such, while a matrix may not be the ‗uper project manager‘ option, it does appear to
be the best overall option. One has to consider that a project‘s success often depends on certain
intangibles, including the satisfaction of the team members. Individual contributors working in
projectized organizations may become disillusioned with their options and decide to take their
business elsewhere. This can of course have dire consequences for the success of the project.
One other point of notice adding additional credence to the matrix organization is unlike the other
types, the project manager can also examine career opportunities that may span beyond their
existing role. Maybe they discover that being a functional manager is something they would like
to experiment with. Or perhaps ancillary roles such as product management, sales, and so forth.
While transitions can occur in other org structures, the very nature of a matrix usually indicates
that the Human Resources department has defined various career paths well, providing numerous
options for those in the company.
60
Picture 5.1.4: Overview of different types of organizations
Which org structure is superior will always be a point of debate amongst peers in the industry.
The point of this article is more to give views based on the project manager‘s perspective, as
opposed to taking sides on the veracity of a particular organizational layout. How one function in
any structure is many times up to the individual and how they perform and adapt in the structure
they reside. But having some knowledge of the different types of structures can give more
guidance to the project manager when they are determining what is best for them in their career
path.
61
2. How to Motivate a Project Team
Many project efforts require cooperation from more than one member of the work force. If you
have appointed a team to accomplish a project task, you will likely have the added challenge of
ensuring that the group is committed as a whole to the task. If they appear to lack of motivation,
you must work to overcome this issue because if you do not they will likely not invest adequate
energy or effort into the project.
Motivation can be the determining factor for the level of success a team achieves. In most cases,
a successful team/group will have been motivated from start to finish. There are some basic ―laws
of motivation‖ that need to be understood to maximize and keep a team motivated to achieve.
Laws of Motivation
1. An individual has to be motivated in order to motivate others: A person cannot expect to
motivate others if he/she is not individually motivated. To successfully evaluate what is
needed to motivate others, it is pertinent to consider the type of person that might
motivate you. Is this the type of person that might arrive before anyone else, who is
enthusiastic, positive, always has some sort of good news to pass on, is loyal to the group,
and leads by example? As a member of a group, each person cannot expect to move the
other members of the group to be motivated if he/she not motivated him/herself. If in a
group dynamic, there is not a single individual that has motivation to perform or to
complete the purpose of the group, that group is destined to fail. Richard Denney states in
his book, Motivate to Win, that ―if you want to motivate another person, you have to be
motivated yourself.‖
2. Motivation requires a goal: Without a specific goal in mind, it is impossible for a group or
team to be motivated. Although they might feel motivated, without a specific reason for
working or something they are working towards, their motivation serves little purpose.
Richard Denney points out that although this may seem like common sense, it is common
sense that is not commonly recognized. He also points out that motivation is about
striving towards the future and without a goal, there is no purpose. As an example,
consider a team sport where there is no competition or league that they can be a part of.
What motivation does the team have to practice and work as a team. The goal that most
62
team sports have is to be the best compared to their competition. If there is no one to
compete against, there is no reason to compete. The motivation to perform is lost. The
goal to be the best compared to your competition is a vital component of the group or
teams motivation.
3. Motivation, Once Established, Never Lasts: Motivation should be an ongoing process. It
cannot be a once a year booster. Groups must come together on a frequent basis to discuss
their strengths and weaknesses and draw up plans of action and self-improvement for the
future. Conducting a 360-degree appraisal as a group can be one way to ensure that each
member is staying focused and makes necessary adjustments to their behavior. This gives
each group or team member an opportunity to assess the performance and contribution of
the other group or team members. Group members may need to be trained on this process
for it to be worthwhile, effective and motivational, but this investment can lead to more
motivated groups. Just because a group or team is motivated today does not mean that
they will be motivated tomorrow. It is important that groups and teams understand the
power of motivation, understand themselves as individuals, how they feel and why they
react the way they do. Group or team members must understand what makes them happy
or unhappy and what inspires them to do just a little bit more. It is also important to
understand what demotivates individuals and as frequently as possible try to take steps to
prevent it from happening.
4. Motivation Requires Recognition: People will strive harder for recognition than for
almost any other single thing in life. Consider a parents whose child brings home a picture
that they have painted at school. If that parent admires the picture, shows it to other
members of the family and pins it up on the wall, they have now motivated that child and
may begin to see more pictures. A genuine compliment is a form of recognition and it
takes a thoughtful person to give another a compliment. Small-minded people are unable
to recognize the achievements of others.
5. Participation Motivates: It is vital to get people involved and to seek their opinions. When
working in groups or teams it is important that an environment is established that gives
each group member an opportunity to express and share their ideas. People who are
listened to and are given an opportunity to actively participate, are more effective and are
more motivated. Julian Richer, founder of hi-fi retailer, Richer Sounds, says that when he
started his company 100 percent of the ideas came from him. Now, 90 percent of how the
company is run, including its systems and procedures, comes from his people. All
members of his staff are required to give 20 ideas per year for improvement. For each idea
they are rewarded a minimum amount, that increases based on the value of the idea. Every
idea presented is given a response within three days indicating why the idea could not be
implemented or whether further action would be taken. The consequence of this was a
steady stream of innovation, but even more important is that Richer Sounds has an
incredibly high staff retention rate. There is usually a list of people waiting for a vacancy.
6. Seeing Progression Motivates: When individuals progress as a group, moving forward
and achieving, they will always be more motivated. When they are going backwards and
not making progress, people are naturally less motivated. All members of the group must
learn from the past, but realize that they cannot change it. Instead, they must turn it to
their advantage and learn from it. Learning to focus on the slightest progress, whatever it
63
may be, allows a team to stay motivated. This law must be used, worked on, managed and
planned in order to maintain a high level of motivation.
7. Challenge Only Motivates if there is a Potential to Win: If targets for results are set to
high, they may actually have a de-motivating effect. If the consensus of the group or team
is that the targets are out of reach or impossible to achieve, de-motivation will be the
result. Competitions and challenges can certainly be motivating and can inspire people to
greater activity. People will rise to the occasion. Challenge groups or teams to get
something worthwhile done and nine times out of ten they will do it. Sometimes, the work
itself is a motivator, such as responsibility, challenge or a feeling of doing something
worthwhile. One can make a person‘s work more challenging by giving them the biggest
job they can handle and with this responsibility must come some credit of achievement
when the job is done.
8. Everybody Has a Motivational Fuse: Everyone can be motivated. Everyone has a fuse, it
is just a matter of knowing how to ignite it. At some point it may not be cost-effective to
continue trying to motivate a group or team to into greater activity or performance. It is a
person‘s attitude to a job that makes the difference. A person can quite emphatically state
and believe that theirs is the worst job humanity has ever created. Yet another person
taking on that same job with a different attitude will say and believe it is a great job and
will consider himself or herself fortunate to have it.
9. Group Belonging Motivates: People want to have a sense of belonging. The smaller the
group or team, the greater the loyalty, motivation and effort. Extra-curricular activities
can be used to draw people together.
10. Inspired Leaders are Motivational: This is not necessarily a manager. Leaders are those
that inspire others to action. Leaders are willing to take risks, are continually looking for
new challenges and opportunities. People are much more likely to be motivated when
there is inspired leadership. Leaders will defend others in their group and take full
responsibility for criticism.
Unusual Strategies to Inspire Your Team
Sometimes, despite the best of intentions, a team loses its enthusiasm for a project. Maybe the
project has gone on too long. Perhaps the client is difficult or unpleasant. Or maybe your
team is overworked and under stress. No matter the reason, your project is in danger.
64
Unhappy teams tend to produce substandard work. But what can a Project Manager do to lift
his team‘s spirits so that they can give their best effort?
Here are four strategies that go beyond the usual ―Inspire and Reward‖ approach.
Strategy #1: Change the world together
Team members tend to get caught up in the minutiae of coding, sketching, bug-hunting, etc.
While their narrow view helps keep them focused, they need a little perspective once in a
while. Make sure to set a vision for your project and how it‘s going to change the world or
least your organization. Then share this vision with everyone on your team. Remind them of
the importance of their task and how it fits into the big picture. Login pages might not be the
sexiest of assignments, but what use is an intranet site if nobody can get inside?
Strategy #2: Forget about rewards and bonuses
The ―carrot-on-the-stick‖ philosophy might have been used to motivate people for centuries,
but it doesn‘t necessarily means that it‘s the best strategy.
Here is some food for your thoughts:
One day an old man saw that kids started playing soccer next to his house. Naturally he was
worried about the safety of his windows and the noise. The old man knew he could not force
them to stop. So, instead he offered them 5 dollars to play near his house. It was no-brainer
for the kids and they agreed. He did the same thing for the next couple of days. Then on the
fourth day, the old man told them he was sorry but he could only pay them 1 dollar. The kids
were not happy but took the money and kept playing. The fifth day, the old man announced
he could only pay 10 cents, but he would really love them to keep playing. The kids called
him a cheapskate and left. He never saw them again. It‘s a well-established fact that intrinsic
motivation works much better than the extrinsic one. This also applies to project management.
So stop just giving out bonuses and make sure your team really cares about what they do.
Strategy #3: Go watch a movie
Sometimes team members just need a break from the grind. Whether it‘s an internal Tekken
tournament or a catered barbecue, getting away from the keyboard is an excellent way to
charge up the batteries. Why not just pick a movie and take everyone on your team to the
nearest theatre. And yes, I‘m talking business hours here.
Strategy #4: Lead by Example – Clean a Toilet
A Project Manager is a leader, first and foremost. This means that you have to act as an
example to your team. While you don‘t have to be (and shouldn‘t be) the best coder, designer,
or SEO expert, you do have to be able to walk the walk, roll up your sleeves, and dive into the
project yourself. Joel Spolsky tells a great story about his army sergeant major showing him
how to clean a toilet, thus giving a lesson in real leadership.
While I‘m not suggesting you follow his example literally, you need to show your project
management team how far you‘re willing to go to get things done. It‘s important to remember
65
that teams are composed of people with their own motivations, desires, and needs. As a
Project Manager, your job is to understand your team and their potential, and do everything in
your power to make sure they reach it, whatever it takes!
66
****************************************************************************************
The sixth section contains updated information on the project management next
generation
****************************************************************************************
SECTION 6
Next generation
Project Management
****************************************************************************************
“I never perfected an invention that I did not think about in terms of the
service it might give others... I find out what the world needs, then I proceed
to invent....” (Thomas Edison)
67
68
1. Project Management 2.0
Project Management 2.0 is the ultimate new approach to Project Management. It is one branch
of evolution of project management practices, which was enabled by the emergence of Web
2.0 technologies. Such applications include: blogs, wikis, collaborative software, etc. Because of
Web 2.0 technologies, small distributed & virtual teams can work together much more efficiently
by utilizing the new-generation, usually low or no-cost Web-based project management tools.
These tools challenge the traditional view of the project manager, as Project Management 2.0
represents a dramatic increase in the ability for distributed teams' collaboration. While Web 2.0
tools and Project Management 2.0 systems may enable the project team to collaborate more
richly online, these tools often have no audit-able project management functionality, and the
Project Management 2.0 term may be a misnomer.
In the past few years, there has been much talk about ―Web 2.0.‖ According to this concept, the
World Wide Web has evolved and transformed in important ways since its early days. The key
features of Web 2.0 are collaboration, interconnectivity, and user-generated content.
A similar transformation is currently happening in the field of project management. Traditional
highly-structured, top down conceptions of managing projects are giving way in some places to a
new model, one that places less emphasis on the manager‘s role as the project‘s overseer and
more on the project team‘s ability to plan, adapt, and communicate. According to Project
Manager Planet‘s Chris Lynch, the heart of this new ―Project Management 2.0‖ is collaboration.
Despite this new conception of how a project team should work, there is still an important role
for the project manager within the framework of Project Management 2.0. Lynch says that the
best managers will be able to understand ―the fundamentals of collaboration, insight and
accountability.‖ Technical knowledge is relatively less important than these (less tangible, but no
less real) qualities when it comes to guiding and directing this newer, more democratic approach
to planning and implementing projects.
Project Management 2.0 is still a fairly new concept, and what exactly it means for the future of
project management and the businesses which employ it is still up for debate. Traditional
methods of managing projects are not far from obsolete today, nor do they seem likely to become
so anytime in the near future. However, the changes brought about by the emergence of Project
Management 2.0 mean that businesses have another important tool available to them that they
would be wise to consider.
69
Comparison of traditional project management and project management 2.0
While traditional project management structures focused on the paradigm of the project manager as
controller, Project management 2.0 stresses the concept of distributed collaboration, and the project
manager as a leader. Project management 2.0 advocates open communication. While traditional project
management often was driven by formal reporting and hierarchical structures, project management 2.0
stresses the need for access to information for the whole team. This has led to one of the many criticisms
of Project Management 2.0 - which it cannot scale to large projects. However, for distributed teams
performing agile development, which are often emergent structures, the use of rich collaborative
software may enable the development of collective intelligence
Common comparisons of traditional project management vs. project management 2.0 are listed in
the table below:
Traditional Project
Management
Project Management 2.0
Centralization of control Decentralization of control
Top-down planning Bottom-up planning
Authoritarian environment Collaborative environment
Implied structure Emergent structures
Limited/Restricted Access
to the plan
Organized/Unlimited Access to the plan
Local Access to
information
Global/Live Access to information
Limited Communications
within team
Unlimited Communications within team
Separate projects Holistic approach
Overly complex tools Easy to use tools
Rigidity of tools Flexibility of tools
Picture 6.1.1: List of Differences between Traditional Project Management and Project
Management 2.0
Traditional methods are centralized and top-down. Project Management 2.0 is decentralized and
bottom-up. Traditional methods are authoritarian: with the project manager having all ultimate
responsibility for the project. Project Management 2.0 is collaborative and team-based, with
responsibilities shared by all. The project manager, therefore, has less of a burden. Traditional
methods feature relatively little communication and access to information. Project Management
70
2.0 puts communication and ease of accessing information at the forefront of its strategy. Projects
undertaken using traditional methods follow an implied structure. In projects using the concepts
of Project Management 2.0, emergent structures become the norm. The tools used in traditional
methods are complex and inflexible. Project Management 2.0 stresses the importance of
simplicity and flexibility. In traditional methods, projects are kept separated from one another.
Project Management 2.0 urges businesses to keep in mind the ways that all projects are
interrelated.
71
2. What is Agile Project Management?
Picture 6.2.1
When it comes to agile project management roles, it‘s worth nothing that most agile processes-
Surum in particular- do not include a project manager. Without specific person assigned agile
project manager roles and responsibilities are distributed among others on project, namely the
team, the scurum master and the product owner. Within agile development, Scrum has the most
to say about exactly what is agile project management. So let‘s use Scrum as our model for
answering this question. On a Scrum project, there are three roles: product owner, ScrumMaster
and team.
The product owner is responsible for the business aspects of the project, including ensuring the
right product is being built, and in the right order. A good product owner can balance competing
priorities, is available to the team, and is empowered to make decisions about the product.
The ScrumMaster serves as the team's coach, helping team members work together in the most
effective manner possible. A good ScrumMaster views the role as one of providing a service to
the team, removing impediments to progress, facilitating meetings and discussions, and
performing typical project management duties such as tracking progress and issues.
The team itself assumes agile project management roles when determining how to best achieve
the product goals (as established by the product owner). Team members will collaboratively
decide which person should work on which tasks, which technical practices are necessary to
achieve stated quality goals, and so on.
72
So, what is ―agile‖ about this process? Agile project management divides responsibility among
more than one team member. In the case of Scrum, it‘s a project's product owner, ScrumMaster
and the rest of the team.
One of the common misperceptions about agile processes is that there is no need for agile project
management, and that agile projects run themselves. It is easy to see how an agile process‘ use of
self-organizing teams, its rapid pace, and the decreased emphasis on detailed plans lead to this
perception. In a recent egroup, a project manager at a company that was implementing agile had
been moved to another area because, ―…agile doesn‘t require management.‖ However, agile
processes still require project management. In this article we will look at the reasons why and the
types of management.
The Need for Agile Project Management
Picture 6.2.2
Project management is critical to the success of most projects, even projects following agile
processes. Without management, project teams may pursue the wrong project, may not include
the right mix of personalities or skills, may be impeded by organizational dysfunctionality, or
may not deliver as much value as possible. We are beginning to formalize these management
responsibilities. In the process, we hope that they become clearer to those beginning to
implement agile processes, without those people losing the feeling for people, collaboration, and
interactions that underlie all agile processes. The below table summarizes these Agile project
management responsibilities.
73
Picture 6.2.3
Agile Project Management and Shared Vision
Picture 6.2.4
For a team to succeed with agile development it is essential that a shared vision be established.
The vision must be shared not just among developers on the development team but also with
others within the company. Most plan-driven processes also advocate the need for a shared
vision; however, if that vision isn‘t communicated or is imprecise or changing, the project can
always fall back on its detailed (but not necessarily accurate) lists of tasks and procedures. This is
not the case on an agile project and agile project participants use the shared vision to guide their
day-to-day work much more actively.
The formation of the project vision is not the responsibility of the agile project manager; usually
the vision comes directly from a customer or customer proxy, such as a product manager. The
project manager, however, is usually involved in distilling the customer‘s grand vision into a
meaningful plan for everyone involved in the project. Rather than a detailed command-and-
control plan based on Gantt charts, however, the agile plan‘s purpose is to lay out an investment
vision against which management can assess and frequently adjust its investments, lay out a
common set of understandings from which emergence, adaptation and collaboration occur, and
establish expectations against which progress will be measured. The project manager works with
the customer to lay out a common set of understandings from which emergence, adaptation and
collaboration can occur. The agile project nurtures project team members to implement the vision
74
Agile Project Management and Obstacles
Imagine yourself on a bicycle pedaling along a road some warm summer day. After the ride is
done you may look back on it as having been relatively free of surprises; however, while riding
you probably had to avoid a number of obstacles: the glass in the road, the narrow shoulder, the
car turning left in front of you, and so on. Most of these obstacles are easily avoided by a little
forethought and by looking ahead on the road. You don‘t need to plan the entire trip in advance
(―At 9:43 a.m. remember to avoid the pothole on 95th Street‖) but paying attention and glancing
down the road help you avoid obstacles or even head-on collisions. Participating in an agile
project is much the same way: a little forethought and looking ahead go a long way toward
improving the journey.
Most agile processes prescribe a highly focused effort on creating a small set of features during
an ―iteration‖ or ―sprint‖ after which the team quickly regroups and decides on the set of features
for the next iteration or sprint. While iteration is ongoing the team members are expected to focus
exclusively on the current iteration.
Picture 6.2.5
While this sharp focus leads to greater productivity during the current iteration it can cause a bit
of a billiard-ball effect as the conclusion of one iteration can bounce out the start of the next. A
project manager who spends a small amount of time looking forward at the next iteration is an
excellent buffer against this effect. For example, many organizations have travel restrictions that
require plane tickets to be purchased two weeks in advance. If a team could benefit from having a
remotely located employee on site during the coming iteration the time to plan for that is during
the current iteration.
Another type of obstacle may be a team member.
While agile processes such as Extreme Programming and Scrum rely on self-organizing teams,
an agile project manager cannot simply turn a team loose on a project. The agile manager must
still monitor that corporate policies or project rules are followed. Participation on an agile team
does not turn all developers into model employees.
75
Picture 6.2.6
In most cases the team itself will employ some form of sanctioning on an employee who is not
working hard enough or is exhibiting other performance or behavior problems. However, in the
most severe cases the collective team usually cannot be the one to terminate or officially
reprimand an employee. Performance feedback can always be expressed in terms of team views
of the individual‘s contribution to the team (e.g., ―I‘ve discussed it with members on the team and
we do not think you are being careful enough in your unit testing‖). But if a counseling or
coaching session is necessary it is usually best when between just the project manager and the
team member.
Agile Project Management Conclusions
Picture 6.2.7
Robert Greenleaf has introduced the concept of the ―servant-leader.‖1 Perhaps this is the most
appropriate way of thinking of the agile project manager. On an agile project the project manager
does not so much manage the project as he both serves and leads the team. Perhaps this is one
reason why, anecdotally, it seems much more common to see an agile project manager also
function as a contributor to the project team (whether writing or running tests, writing code or
documentation, etc.).
Plan-driven software methodologies use a command-and-control approach to project
management. A project plan is created that lists all known tasks. The project manager‘s job then
becomes one of enforcing the plan. Changes to the plan are typically handled through ―change
control boards‖ that either reject most changes or they institute enough bureaucracy that the rate
of change is slowed to the speed that the plan-driven methodology can accommodate. There can
be no servant-leadership in this model. Project managers manage: they direct, administer and
supervise.
76
****************************************************************************************
This section contains information on the Project Management organizations and the
possible certifications they provide.
****************************************************************************************
SECTION 7
Get Certified!
**************************************************************”
“Opportunity is missed by most people because it is dressed in overalls and
looks like work. “(Thomas Edison)
77
78
1. Professional PM Associations
In this chapter we will give you an overview of some most important project management
associations. In the world there is of course many other associations or organizations, which are
trying to developed new techniques and methods in project management. But this book should be
attractive for readers, so we will mentioned only the most important. Let's have a look on them!
GAPPS - Global Alliance for Project Performance Standards
This alliance is a nonprofit organization that provides independent reference benchmarks
for project management standards and assessments. Driven entirely by volunteers, the GAPPS is
an alliance of government, private industry, professional associations, and training and academic
institutions working to develop globally applicable performance based competency standards for
project management. The GAPPS produces standards, frameworks, and comparability maps (of
other standards and frameworks) which are intended to facilitate mutual recognition of project
management qualifications and are available for download, free of charge, from their website.
GAPPS membership is open to any organization (public or private) or government agency and
maintains a listing of current members on its website. Further, the GAPPS members can be
categorized into four distinct types - Standards & Qualifications Organizations, Project
Management Professional Associations, Industry and Academic Institutions
According to the GAPPS website, their objectives are to:
1. Facilitate, develop, approve, publish, promote, maintain and review:
1. global project management standards
2. usage guidelines for project management standards, but
2. NOT consult, advise, express opinion or develop products based upon standards and guidelines
3. NOT provide training, assessment, certifications or qualifications to individuals based upon standards and
guidelines
79
The GAPPS has also produced a lot of standards, researches, and documents connected to the
topic of project management.
ICEC - International Cost Engineering Council
This council is a nonpolitical and nonprofit organization. ICEC‘s objective is
to promote cooperation between cost engineering, quantity surveying and
project management organizations. This is global and local initiative to ensure the shared well-
being of the organization and that of their individual members.
ICEC identifies itself as a Worldwide Confederation of Cost Engineering, Quantity Surveying
and Project Management Societies.
ICEC is an organization with Roster Consultative Status in the Economic and Social Council of
the United Nations.
Member societies of ICEC are generally national associations or institutes.
IPMA - International Project Management Association
This association is a non-profit, Swiss-registered organization for the promotion of project
management internationally. The IPMA is a federation of more than 50 national and
internationally oriented project management associations with over 120.000 members world-wide
as of 2012.
The association was started in 1965 in Vienna by a European group of managers, and initially
established under the name "International Management Systems Association" (IMSA). It held its
first international congress in Vienna in 1967, which was attended by professionals from 30
different countries. In 1979 the association was renamed to International Project Management
Association.
80
IPMA's focus is in the development and promotion of the project management profession. It
provides standards and establishes guidelines for the work of project management professionals
through the IPMA Competence Baseline (ICB®). The Certification Program is delivered by
National Member Associations and/or Certification Bodies in various membership countries. As
of 2012 there are more than 150,000 IPMA-certified competency-based certificates worldwide,
which are held by professionals from recognized businesses and organizations around the world.
With its unique federation approach, IPMA is an umbrella organization for independent Member
Associations from over 50 countries world-wide, each of whom represents IPMA in their
respective countries. Through IPMA, project management practitioners from all cultures and all
parts of the world can network, share ideas, and move our practice and our stakeholders forward
through effective collaboration and cooperation.
PMI - Project Management Institute
This institute is one of the most famous organizations
dealing with problems of project management. It is also a not-for-profit professional
organization for the project management profession with the purpose of advancing project
management.
The Project Management Institute (PMI) offers a range of services to the Project
Management profession such as the development of standards, research, education, publication,
networking-opportunities in local chapters, hosting conferences and training seminars, and
maintaining multiple credentials in project management. PMI has recruited volunteers to create
industry standards, such as "A Guide to the Project Management Body of Knowledge", which has
been recognized by the American National Standards Institute (ANSI).
Launched in 1984, PMI's first credential was the PMP. Over 500,000 people now hold the PMP
credential. In 2007, it earned the ANSI/ISO/IEC 17024 accreditation from the International
Organization for Standardization (ISO). Credential holders do not have to be members of PMI.
Over time, PMI has introduced many other credentials and a certification. A full, updated list can
be viewed at PMI official web site.
The standards PMI develop and publish fall into three main categories - Foundational Standards,
Practice Standards and Frameworks and PMI Standards Extensions
81
2. Project Management Certification
In this chapter we will try to provide you an overview of project management certifications. Overview of
certifications is not easy to make because each PM association have own types of certifications with
different usage and labels. For this purpose we are going to give you an overview of certifications from
one of the most known associations PMI - Project Management Institute. Short description of this
association is given in the chapter about PM associations.
In an increasingly projectized world, professional certification ensures that project managers are ready to
meet the demands of projects across the globe.
PMI offers a comprehensive certification program for project practitioners of all education and skill levels.
Currently consisting of six credentials, the program demonstrates both your commitment to the profession
and your expertise through certifying education, experience and competency. Rigorously developed by
project managers, PMI certifications ensure that you and your projects excel.
As project management is one of the top skill sets demanded by organizations around the world, this is
more important now than ever before. One-fifth of the world‘s GDP, or more than $12 trillion, is spent on
projects. And with many skilled practitioners leaving or scheduled to leave the workforce due to
retirement — a trend the Society of Human Resources (SHRM) identifies as having a major strategic
impact for 64% of organizations worldwide — there is a great demand for knowledgeable project
managers.
When these opportunities arise, certification helps make sure that you‘ll be ready. There are already more
than 460,000 PMI credential holders around the world and in every industry, from healthcare,
telecommunications and finance to IT and construction.
The 2012 PMI Pulse of the Profession study found that organizations with more than 35% PMP certified
project managers had better project performance. And according to a 2007 PricewaterhouseCoopers
survey, 80% of high-performing projects use a credentialed project manager. Make sure you‘re one of
them by earning a PMI certification. But which one should you earn? Obtaining a PMI credential is not
something to be taken lightly, whether this is your first one or you‘re moving up to a PMP® or PgMP®,
or you‘re earning a specialty credential like the PMI-ACP®, PMI-SP® or PMI-RMP®.
You need to choose the credential that best fits your knowledge and experience, as well as your future
career plans.
You can apply for any certification that matches your qualifications, and no certification serves as a
prerequisite for another. Also, you don‘t need to be a PMI member to obtain a credential, but there are
member discounts on application and credential maintenance costs.
Here is the list of potential certification from PMI:
82
The Certified Associate in Project Management (CAPM)® is a good entry-level certification if
you‘re new to project management, or still figuring out your career path.
The Project Management Professional (PMP)® is the most important globally-recognized and
independently validated credential for project managers, perfect if you have demonstrated
experience and competence in leading project teams.
The Program Management Professional (PgMP)® is designed for those who manage multiple,
complex projects to achieve strategic and organizational results.
The PMI Agile Certified Practitioner (PMI-ACP)® is designed for practitioners who utilize Agile
approaches to project management in their projects.
The PMI Risk Management Professional (PMI-RMP)® is a specialty credential that demonstrates
competence in assessing project risks, mitigating threats and capitalizing on opportunities.
The PMI Scheduling Professional (PMI-SP)® is a specialty credential for practitioners who want
to focus on developing and maintaining project schedules.
The OPM3® Professional Certification recognizes your experience with, and practical knowledge
of, organization project management and project management maturity.
PMI Certifications and ISO
The Project Management Professional (PMP)® credential scheme is accredited by the American National
Standards Institute (ANSI) against the International Organization for Standardization (ISO) 17024. The
17024 standard includes vigorous requirements for examination development and maintenance and for the
quality management systems for continuing quality assurance.
In addition, PMP credential is also registered against the ISO 9001:2000 standard for quality management
systems. This accreditation provides a third-party affirmation of quality in the development, management
and governance of the PMP®. It also gives credential holders and organizations who employ them
additional confidence in the PMP.
The 17024 standard includes vigorous requirements for examination development and maintenance and
for the quality management systems for continuing quality assurance. This distinction benefits PMP
credential holders in several ways:
83
1. It elevates the status of PMP credential holders within organizations and the global project
management community
2. It allows organizations that employ PMP credential holders to reference the PMP‘s accreditation
under ISO 17024 as a qualifier for the competence and capability of their employees
3. It assures those professionals considering the PMP that the credential is recognized by the global
business community
PM Certification programs
As it was said before, all around a world there is a many types of project management certification
programs and associations, which provides these certifications. Except already mentioned association PMI
the others like IPMA provides many variations of certificates.
Also many well-known universities like Stanford, Berkeley organize project management courses that
provide a PM certification.
84
References
1. Yahoo Voices, Jaimelynn Hitt, Yahoo Contributor Network
Mar 10, 2009, from http://voices.yahoo.com/what-9-project-management-
knowledge-areas-2666028.html
2. CTU Online. (Ed.). (ca. 2007). Phase 2 Course Material [multimedia
presentation]. Colorado Springs, CO: CTU Online. Retrieved January 22,
2008, from CTU Online, Virtual Campus, MPM401 Project Management
Theory: 0801A-03. Website:
https://campus.ctuonline.edu/MainFrame.aspx?ContentFrame=/Classroom/co
urse.aspx?Class=23719&tid=39
3. De Jaeger, J. (2008) What is PMBOK? Retrieved January 24, 2008, from
http://www.12manage.com/methods_pmi_pmbok.html
4. Gido and Clements. (2006) Successful Project Management. (3rd
ed.)
Thomson Higher Education: Mason, OH.
5. Project Management Institute (PMI). (2004) A Guide to the Project
Management Body of Knowledge. Project Management Institute: Newtown
Square, PA.
6. Project Smart. (2008) The Project Management Body of Knowledge
(PMBOK). Retrieved January 24, 2008, from
http://www.projectsmart.co.uk/pmbok.html
7. http://blogs.attask.com/wp-
content/uploads/2011/09/fcb8344c1e23c3c723944b8a48e791fb.png
8. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_charter
9. PM study circle, 2013, http://pmstudycircle.com/2012/03/stakeholders-in-
project-management-definition-and-types/
10. Dreams time, 2013, http://www.dreamstime.com/stock-images-business-
project-management-stakeholders-diagram-image17369894
11. http://programsuccess.wordpress.com/2013/03/01/the-best-structure-to-work-
under-for-the-project-manager/
85
12. http://www.lindsay-
sherwin.co.uk/project_framework/htm_5_project_management/11_project_str
uctures.html
13. Andrew Filev (January 15, 2008). "Definition of Project Management 2.0".
Retrieved 2008-01-31.
14. Leisa Reichelt (June 20, 2007). "Social Project Management". Retrieved
2008-01-31.
15. Dr. Kifah Jayyousi (September 6, 2006). "Project Management Wiki!
Everything, Everywhere and Everybody‘s Project". Retrieved 2008-01-31.
16. "Project Management 2.0 - Was it really about Project Management?". Blog.
Retrieved 16 April 2011.
17. Kathleen Haas (May, 2007). "The Blending of Traditional and Agile Project
Management". Retrieved 2008-01-31.
18. Chris Lynch (September 21, 2007). "Project Management 2.0". Retrieved
2008-01-31.
19. Tiberiu Ghioca (August 9, 2013). "PM 1.0 versus PM 2.0. What Is Next –
Project Management 3.0?". Retrieved 2013-08-09.
20. http://www.projectmanagesoft.com/faq/what-is-project-management-2.0
86
PART II
THE THOMAS EDISON TEAM’S
METHODOLOGY
We will either find a way, or make one.” (Hannibal)
87
88
The Thomas Edison Team’s Methodology
After reading carefully the instructions, we set down on the same table and discussed the book
specifications. We wanted to be sure that all of us are on the same page.
In order to better connect, we created a Closed Facebook group named Thomas Edison. We also
exchanged phone numbers and e-mail addresses. We attributed the roles as following:
We chose a coordinator (Elena) who will be in charge of assembling everyone‘s work at the end
of each day. We decided that each of us should work on small tasks on their own computer and
then we should assemble the work on one computer, in order to keep the homogeneity of the
style.
Day 1: Each of us had small tasks (mini CVs), team name, covers, and intro.
Below you can see a snapshot (Picture 1) of Thomas Edison‘s team while assembling small parts
that were sent by e-mail exactly 20 minutes before the deadline.
Picture 1
89
At the end of the day, we had a review session in order to look back and analyze the work we had
done and improve the process for the next session.
Picture 2
All the pictures, reviews, book versions in .doc and .pdf format were uploaded at the end of each
session on the Facebook group.
Day 2: Before starting to work, we took a look on the review paper we completed the previous
day. We split again the work, discussed and decided how to do it. Each of us was attributed 3
chapters. We tried to assign them in a logical way. For example, PMBOK and Price 2 were
assigned to Fadi because both of them are Project Management methods.
In the below picture (Picture 3) you can find Thomas Edison‘s team reviewing again the
specifications, even in the ―implementation‖ phase of the project.
We discovered that we should read
very carefully the specifications
beforehand and discuss together the
requirements. Also, we had to add
personal value to the book for the
next sessions (The introduction and
the blurb should be personalized).
We agreed for the next day for all
of us to bring their laptop in order
to stick together and work closely.
We decided that for the next
session we will have finalized 2
chapters by the end of the session.
90
Picture 3
Picture 4
We highlighted the specifications
that we should carefully take into
account and especially the ones we
missed during Day 1. We
completed together the review and
brainstormed new ideas at the end
of day 2(Picture 5).
91
Picture 5
Day 3: As we decided at the end of Day2, we stick to the plan and began our day by finding a
way of arranging the chapters. By this time, everyone had an idea of their chapter‘s content, even
if we did not finalize their content. After a brainstorming of about 40 minutes, we finally decided
one way of arranging the content. We created a post for each of the chapter (Picture 6) and we
draw a mind map. The below snapshot (Picture 6) was taken at the beginning of the
brainstorming session and Picture 7 was taken at the end.
We decided at the end of Day 2
that we still have to work on
chapters‘ content and discuss a way
to arrange them in order to make
the book a ―fluid‖ one. Also, we
agreed to use a single way of
adding references.
92
Picture 6
Picture 7
We started Day 3 by listing all the
chapters and a short description of
each of them in order to include them
in a generic section.
After a team-work brainstorming, we
built a mind-map. For a better
representation, we used Free Mind
tool, as you can see in Picture 8.
93
Picture 8: The book mind map using Free Mind tool
At the end of Day 3 we built a TO DO list for the next day.
Day 4: Day 4 was the one when we paid careful attention to the time. We prioritized the work
and split the tasks for the latest and small adjustments of the book.
To draw a conclusion, we can confirm that this project has gone through all the steps a regular
project should go: Define the project, the users and stakeholders. Then we defined our objectives
taking into account the timelines. We split the objectives into small tasks and allocated the
resources. Afterwards, we began implementation. When problems appeared we had to adjust our
plans by using various means of communication.
We learned that in order for a project to be successful, there needs to be a clear vision on the
objective and results, shared by all the team members. Communication is the bridge between all
the persons involved in the project. We also learned how to be efficient taking into account a
predefined timeline.
We also learned that we have to take into account the following:
We have to have a clear vision regarding the scope and the results of the project.
All those involved in the project must have a clear understanding of the responsibilities
There must be a good open communication between all those involved in the project
Motivation and performance make the difference
94
Thomas Edison Team Members – Mini CVs
Name: ALHAJ AHMED Fadi
Age: 35
Nationality: Palestine
Background: Bachelor degree in Telecommunications and
Electrical Engineering
Working Experience: Technical and Administrative fields (7 years)
Languages: Arabic, English
E-mail: [email protected]
95
Name: DORNEANU Elena
Age: 25
Nationality: Romanian
Background: Bachelor degree in Computer Science, Master in
Databases& Business Support
Working Experience: Business Intelligence field (3 Years)
Languages: English, French, Spanish, Romanian
E-mail: [email protected]
Name: BLAHA Stepan
Age: 25
Nationality: Czech
Background: Bachelor degree in Electronics and Telecommunication
Working Experience: Electronics field (summer job)
Languages: Czech, English, French
E-mail: [email protected]
96
Name: ISMAIL Faridha Begum
Age: 30
Nationality: Indian
Background: Bachelor in Computer Science & Engineering
Working Experience: Aviation Management & Administration (3 Years)
Languages: Urdu, Hindi, Tamil, English & French
E-mail: [email protected]
Name: NGUYEN Huy Khoa
Age: 24
Nationality: Vietnamese
Background: Bachelor in Computer Science
Working Experience: Software Engineer (2 years)
Languages: English, French, Vietnamese
E-mail: [email protected]
97
Name: PALANI KANYA Naveen
Age: 22
Nationality: Indian
Background: Bachelor in Engineering in Electrical and Electronics
Working Experience: Intern at Hindustan Aeronautics Limited, Bangalore, INDIA (December 2011-
January 2012)/Intern at Safran, Paris, FRANCE (May-July 2013)
Languages: English, Hindi, Tamil, French
E-mail: [email protected]
98
99
Thomas Edison
Team Members Elena Dorneanu Štěpán Bláha
Fadi Alhaj Saajan Ismail
Huy Khoa Nguyen Naveen Pk