Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant •...
Transcript of Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant •...
![Page 1: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Think. Learn. Succeed.
Surface Congestion Reduction Analysis & Modeling (SCRAM) Team:
Karen DavisGreg HaubnerJames Hingst
Bill JudgeChris Zalewski
Marine Highway SystemA Multimodal Short Sea Freight Shipping System
1 April 2010 – Progress Update
![Page 2: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 2
Agenda – 1 April 2010• Introduction• Short project status update• Interim project briefing
• Update to our first build toward our final briefing• Slides will be populated as the project develops
![Page 3: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 3
Project Summary• This project will validate the Multimodal Short Sea
Freight Shipping (MSSFS) concept in the I-95 corridor region• Customer desires a scalable discrete
event simulation of one or two potential marine highways along this corridor, with an accompanying assessment of their viability based on cost, time, and freight volume.
• (Update) After meeting with our client, reliability is the main driver, not necessarily time or cost
• (Update) Advised to think about the benefits to the truck drivers
Warehouse(origin)
Warehouse(destination)
Seaor
Road
![Page 4: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 4
Technical Approach
Decision Analysis ToolExcel
DataGathering
Marine Terminal
SimulationArena
Analysis
RecommendationsMultimodalSimulation
Arena Deliverables
@
Final Presentation
Final Report
Project Website
![Page 5: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 5
Where we are at…• Data
• Reviewing additional freight/market data• Data scrubbing and refining
• Tools• Testing the Prototype Decision Analysis Tool• Initializing Data Migration into Decision Analysis Tool• Developing a discrete event simulation
– Simulations are functional but need some fidelity and scalability enhancements– Meet with Dr. Chen for detailed simulation scrub tomorrow
• Briefing• Building towards the final presentation
• Report• Integrating results and findings into our template
• Web site• Continuation of updating the draft website with final deliverables
![Page 6: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 6
Schedule
![Page 7: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 7
Schedule (continued)
![Page 8: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
EVM
![Page 9: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Near Term Progress Goals• 1-Week
• Meet with our client for confirmation on proposed simulation• Finalize data scrubbing• Continue work on decision analysis tool and simulation
• 2-Weeks• Add onto status briefing for Dry Run of Final Presentation• Add onto final report shell• Analyze results• Schedule final meeting with client to present our draft dry run
![Page 10: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
May 5th Build
![Page 11: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Background• With the recent exponential growth in GDP, a huge burden has
been placed on the domestic transportation system• The following projections are published on the DOT Maritime
Administration (MARAD) website• Expected volume of trucks on Interstate Highway System is expected to
double between now and 2035• According to MARAD Trucks account for 40% of the time Americans
spend in traffic• In 2007, 60% of federal highway funding went towards maintenance, vice
new construction• Road expansion is not always feasible
• One solution – the underutilized marine highways• DOT established a framework to provide federal support to expand the
use of America’s Marine HighwaysLimited Highway Capacity + Road Maintenance Costs + Traffic Congestion = Marine
Highways
![Page 12: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Problem Statement• This project will validate the Multimodal Short Sea
Freight Shipping (MSSFS) concept in the I-95 corridor region• The SCRAM Team will help
validate the MSSFS concept through the use of simulation and optimization
• We will select one inland and one marine route that will serve to reduce traffic bottlenecks in and around I-95 and explore options for moving fright traffic to marine highways
Warehouse(origin)
Warehouse(destination)
Seaor
Road
SCRAM = Surface Congestion Reduction Analysis & Modeling
![Page 13: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Assumptions / Limitations• Freight transportation data is split evenly in each direction• No induced traffic resulting from any cargo moved off the
highways onto the waterways• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant• Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost
for reliable deliveries• A Twenty foot Equivalent Unit (TEU) is our standard for
measuring cargo• Trucker “happiness” is measurable
![Page 14: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
CSC/AMCMODELING & SIMULATION
MARINE OPERATIONSMULTIMODAL SYSTEMS
RUTGERS/CAITSFREIGHT TRAFFIC ANALYSIS
INTERMODAL SYSTEMS
THE I-95 COALITIONVIRGINIA DOT
VIRGINIA PORT AUTHORITY NEWYORK/NEWJERSEY PORT AUTHORITY
DLR - GERMAN TRANSPORTATION RESEARCH CENTER
SHORT SEA SHIPPING CRS & SI APPLICATIONS
GEOEYEWORLD LEADERS IN
IMAGERIESCRS&SI DATA SYTEMS
GMUCRS&SI TECH APPLICATIONSINFRASTRUCTURE SYSTEMS
FREIGHT ANALYSIS
Stakeholders: GMU Consortium Team
![Page 15: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
What makes this a difficult problem• Freight is generally shipped point to point
– Origin direct to destination– Some areas produce more, others accept more– Shippers pick their own (optimal?) routes
• Result is granular, fragmented shipping– Not a bad quality but difficult to understand
Ref: http://www.marad.dot.gov/ships_shipping_landing_page/mhi_home/mhp_map/mhp_map.htm
![Page 16: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
SCRAM Team
• Karen Davis• OR, 8 years of experience
• Greg Haubner• OR, 5 years of experience
• James Hingst• OR/Military Analysis, 17 years of experience
• Bill Judge• OR, 3 years of experience
• Chris Zalewski• OR/Decision Analysis, 17 years of experience
![Page 17: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Objective and Scope• Build a scalable model• Determine the feasibility of transferring land-based
freight to marine highways based on:– Cost comparison of marine and surface routes– Reliability comparison of end-to-end transportation time
(including variability) using marine and surface routes
• Estimate any environmental benefits
![Page 18: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Metrics
• Comparison of modes: short sea vs. land-based• Time (and variability)• Throughput volume• Transportation Costs
• Outcome• Assess total benefit of the alternate transportation system compared to
highway freight transportation for selected routes• Direct
• Improving reliability and lowering freight ??• Indirect
• Safety• Congestion mitigation• Emission reduction• Savings in highway maintenance costs• Truck driver “happiness”
![Page 19: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 19
Technical Approach
Decision Analysis ToolExcel
DataGathering
Marine Terminal
SimulationArena
Analysis
RecommendationsMultimodalSimulation
Arena Deliverables
@
Final Presentation
Final Report
Project Website
![Page 20: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Model – Decision Analysis Tool
• The Decision Analysis Tool will help test the viability of port-port pairs along the I-95 corridor
• The initial baseline scenarios will compare routes between Richmond, VA and Norfolk, VA
• After analysis of baseline scenario and updates made to the tool as needed, other origin/destination scenarios will be selected to test the scalability of the tool
• Current Status– Tool has been reworked to accept actual port costs– Freight data will be integrated within a week
![Page 21: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Model – Decision Analysis Tool
• Assumptions:• Speed, land and sea, degraded by congestion• Delays associated with transshipment, waiting for a ship relative to ship size• Fuel consumptions and cost• Market share relative to port proximity• Harbor maintenance tax?
• Data• County to Count freight data• Land and Sea distances• Congestion index
• Outputs• Traffic diverted from highways (congestion relief)• End to end time• Total costs• Fuel consumption• Ships necessary for certain frequency of service (integer constraints) 21
![Page 22: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 22
Model – Decision Analysis ToolAssumptions
Speed(miles per hour)land 55sea 25Transshipment delay hours per debarkland 0sea 10Transshipment cost ($/TEU)RORO 8LOLO 10Mileage(TEU*Miles / gallon)land 12ship sizes and types TEU Capacity Transshipment delay time(Hrs) Mileage(TEU*Miles/Gallon)LOLO TEU/hr loaded 20small 100 5 10medium 300 15 14large 1000 200 18RORO TEU/hr loaded 40small 75 1.875 8medium 200 106.6666667 12large 500 4.6875 16
Market share assumption relative to distance from endpoints A-B
25 0.650 0.5
100 0.4150 0.3200 0.2250 0.1
Diesel ($/gallon) 3HMT ?
DataPair Specific infoA-B Distance(Statute Miles)Land 400Sea 350Time(hours)land 7.272727273sea 14Congestion index 0.6
Monthly shipping non cumulative volume in TEU within total distane of XX from proposed endpoints A-B B-A
25 100 5050 200 125
100 300 200150 500 250200 600 400250 800 500
CalculationsAvailable Volume A-B B-A
25 630 377.5
Monthly ShiploadsLOLOsmall 7medium 3large 1ROROsmall 9medium 4large 2
Timeland 7.3seaAverage Drayage(miles) 90.47619048 2.7steaming time 14.0Delays for various ship sizes and types Transshipment delay time(Hrs) waiting for full ship delayLOLOsmall 2.5 51.4 53.9medium 7.5 120.0 127.5large 100.0 360.0 460.0ROROsmall 0.9 40.0 40.9medium 53.3 90.0 143.3large 2.3 180.0 182.3
total time
Costland per TEU 100seaAverage Drayage(miles) 106.7599491 26.69steamingDelays for various ship sizes and types steaming costs loading costsLOLOsmall 105 105medium 75 75large 58.33333333 58.3333ROROsmall 131.25medium 87.5large 65.625
#DIV/0!total time 265.023
![Page 23: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 23
Model – Discrete Event Simulations• Two discrete event simulations will be built in Arena to measure
throughput times, costs, and resource usage• Part I
• Derive an estimate of cargo loading times at marine ports
• Part II• Validate the results of the optimization• Capture key metrics (costs & times)
![Page 24: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 24
Model – Marine Terminal Simulation• The simulation of the dock operations is important since trans-
loading containers to shipping vessels poses significant time and cost penalties
• The proposed trade-off is that while slower, the marine highway can move substantially more cargo at once, and more importantly,relieve congestion on surface routes
• The simulation will allow us to estimate how the times of surface and marine routes compare, so we can then propose recommendations to enhance the appeal of marine routes
• Currently, simulation is functional, but still in the process of adding appropriate level of detail
• Once complete, the simulation of the dock operations will be joined to shipping and truck arrival simulations
![Page 25: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 25
Model – Marine Terminal SimulationReal World Process
Port of RichmondImage Ref: http://maps.google.com
Trucks arrive at the portContainers are offloaded and held
until a ship arrivesBoat arrives at the docksContainers are moved from
storage and loaded via cranes onto the ship
Ship departs
This process is similar for theoffloading of ships
![Page 26: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 26
Model – Marine Terminal SimulationReal World
Port of RichmondImage Ref: http://maps.bing.com
Simulation: Container Arrivals
![Page 27: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 27
Model – Marine Terminal SimulationReal World Simulation: Ship Loading
Port of RichmondImage Ref: http://maps.bing.com
![Page 28: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 28
Model – Multimodal Simulation• The Route Model will help validate the Multimodal
Short Sea Freight Shipping (MSSFS) concept along the I-95 and I-64 corridors
• Simulate over a longer period of time (months) due to slow loading times for the ships
• Compare the key metrics between different destinations and freight transportation methods• Truck, RoRo, Small/Medium/Large container ships• Time to transport, # TEUs moved, Costs, Fuel used
![Page 29: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 29
Model – Multimodal SimulationReal World Simulation
Richmond / Baltimore / Port of VirginiaImage Ref: http://maps.google.com
RichmondRichmond
BaltimoreBaltimore
Port of VirginiaPort of Virginia
![Page 30: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 30
Reliability Metric• Reliability defined as the
ability to get a product from Point A to Point B in a known amount of time
• Shown are time of arrival distributions
• Further you move a TEU from the terminal, the less reliable (green, blue, red)
• For Truck movement, “+” mean times are for a destination further from the terminal, “-” are closer (more or less distance to drive)
Distance fromTerminal (miles)
Orig
in –
Por
t of V
irgin
ia
Destination – Port of Richmond
± 5 ± 10
± 5
± 10
0
0
Truck
µ=4µ+5=4.5µ−5=3.5
µ+10=5.5µ−10=2.5
![Page 31: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010 31
Metrics, Analysis, Recommendations
RoRo SmallContainer
MediumContainer
LargeContainerTruck
PoV PoR PoB PoV PoR PoB PoV PoR PoB PoV PoR PoBPoVPoRPoB
Destination Destination DestinationDestination
Orig
in
PoV: Port of Virginia // PoR: Port of Richmond // PoB: Port of Baltimore
• Want to validate multi-modal short sea shipping viability, routes, direct and indirect benefits
• If needed, recommend policy (incentives) changes that may help the viability
![Page 32: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Analysis and Sensitivity Analysis• From the Decision Analysis Tool we found…
• From the Marine Terminal Simulation we found…
• From the Multimodal Simulation we found…
![Page 33: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Findings – Roadblocks• Costs
• At this time, dock usage costs seem prohibitively high for short-sea shipping
• Shipbuilding• The U.S. currently doesn’t build many transport ships,
except for military• Would have to purchase ships from other countries
• Truck• Domestic based trucking is not standardized (i.e., various
sizes)
![Page 34: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Recommendations• Based on our analysis, we recommend
• TBD…• TBD…• TBD…
![Page 35: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Future Work• Expand the short-sea shipping problem to regions beyond
the Virginia/I-95 region.• Develop and implement the data architecture required to
“feed” the data analysis tool• Other TBD…
![Page 36: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Acknowledgements• Dr. Thirumalai• Dr. Chen• Dr. Laskey• Family & Friends
![Page 37: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
For More Information Visit• http://seor.gmu.edu/projects/grad-proj.html
![Page 38: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Questions / Comments
![Page 39: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Thank you!
![Page 40: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Backup
![Page 41: Marine Highway System - George Mason...• Ship terminal/crane reliability is constant • Manufacturers would be willing to pay more in time and/or cost for reliable deliveries •](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022041113/5f20605be549f63d7b0d26af/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
OR 680, Spring 2010
Work Breakdown Structure