Marijuana Mayhem webinar - 2017 - Public Health Law · Ventilation is NOT a solution to secondhand...
Transcript of Marijuana Mayhem webinar - 2017 - Public Health Law · Ventilation is NOT a solution to secondhand...
December13,2017
MARIJUANA MAYHEM:
REGULATORY LESSONS FROM TOBACCO CONTROL
THE PUBLIC HEALTH LAW CENTER
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 2
THE PUBLIC HEALTH LAW CENTER
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 3
LEGAL TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 4
LegalResearch
PolicyDevelopment,Implementation,Defense
Publications
Trainings
DirectRepresentation
Lobby
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 5
MODERATOR / SPEAKER
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 6
Kerry Cork
Senior Staff AttorneyPublic Health Law Center
FEATURED SPEAKER
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 7
Michael Tynan
Policy AnalystCenters for Disease Control & Prevention
FEATURED SPEAKER
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 8
Char Day
Program ManagerAmericans for Nonsmokers’ Rights
FEATURED SPEAKER
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 9
D.J. Wilson
Tobacco Control DirectorMassachusetts Municipal Association
AGENDA
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 10
• Overview- KerryCork• PublicHealthIssues- MichaelTynan• Smoke-freeLawConsiderations- CharDay• TakeawaysfromMassachusetts- D.J.Wilson• Q&A
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 11
MARIJUANA MAYHEM:Where We are Today
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 12
That Train has Left the Station
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 13
12/13/17 14
FEDERAL STATUS
Under Federal Controlled Substances Act• Classified as a Schedule 1 drug• Federal offense to –
– Cultivate, manufacture, distribute
– Sell, purchase, possess, or use marijuana
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 15
IMPLICATIONS OF FEDERAL STATUS
• Lack of commercial banking services– Many marijuana businesses operate solely in cash– Public safety concern from law enforcement
perspective• Disadvantageous federal income tax terms• Limited access to legal services• Possible loss of employment for off-site users• Role of marijuana use in family law proceedings
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 16
INSTITUTE OF MEDICINE
Recognizestherapeutic valueof cannabinoid drugs (primarily THC)
12/13/17 17
CONCLUSIVE OR SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE
Cannabis effective for –• Chronic pain in adults• Chemotherapy-induced nausea & vomiting• Multiple sclerosis spasticity symptoms
Nat’l Academies of Sciences, Engineering & Medicine (2017)
12/13/17 18
MODERATE EVIDENCE
Cannabis effective for –Improving short-term sleep outcomes inthose with obstructive sleep apneasyndrome, fibromyalgia, chronic pain andmultiple sclerosis
Nat’l Academies of Sciences, Engineering & Medicine (2017)
12/13/17 19
INSTITUTE OF MEDICINE
“Smoked marijuanais a crude THC delivery systemthat also deliversharmfulsubstances”
12/13/17 20
AGENDA
12/13/17Marijuana Mayhem 21
• Overview- KerryCork• PublicHealthIssues- MichaelTynan• Smoke-freeLawConsiderations- CharDay• TakeawaysfromMassachusetts- D.J.Wilson• Q&A
MarijuanaSmoking&TobaccoControl;ImpactonSmokefreeLaws
CharDay
ProgramManagerTCLCWebinarDecember2017
@ANR_Smokefree www.no-smoke.org
12/13/17 www.no-smoke.org
AmericanNonsmokers’RightsFoundation
www.no-smoke.org
FocusonHealthEffectsonNonsmokers
www.no-smoke.org
www.no-smoke.org
Whatwearenot talkingabout:
Marijuanaasmedicine Personal,privateuse
SecondhandMarijuanaSmoke• Containshundredsofchemicals• Containsmanyofthesamecancer-causingsubstances andtoxicchemicalsassecondhandtobaccosmoke,including:
www.no-smoke.org
Significantlevelsofmercury,lead,formaldehyde,benzene,hydrogencyanide,&toluene.
Similaritiesbetweentobaccoandmarijuana
• Leafcontainshighconcentrationsofoilsandwaxes– “stickyicky”
• NicotineandTHCbothsurvivecombustion• Combustioncreatescarcinogens
– Polycyclicaromatichydrocarbons– Formaldehyde– Nitrogenoxides– Heavymetals– Ultrafineparticles
Suzaynn F.Schick,PhDUniversityofCalifornia,SanFrancisco
www.no-smoke.org
www.no-smoke.org
SecondhandMarijuanaSmoke
• Containshazardousfineparticlesthatposeasignificanthealthrisktonon-smokers.
• Fineparticlescan:• Bebreatheddeeplyintothelungs
• Causelungirritation,asthmaattacks,&increaseriskofrespiratoryinfection.
• Exacerbaterespiratoryconditionslikeasthma,bronchitis,orCOPD.
HealthEffectsofSecondhandExposure• Secondhandmarijuanasmokeexposureimpairsbloodvesselfunction. Ithasagreaterandlonger-lastingeffectonbloodvesselfunctionthanexposuretosecondhandtobaccosmoke.
• PeoplewhoareexposedtosecondhandmarijuanasmokecanhavedetectablelevelsofTHCintheirbloodandurine.
www.no-smoke.org
www.no-smoke.org
www.no-smoke.org
OvercomingPerceivedBarriers
Themarijuanacontrolmovementisinasimilarplacethatnonsmokers’rightsadvocateswereinthe1970’s.
Seeminglyuphillbattleagainstatsunamioflawslegalizingrecreationalmarijuana.
TobaccoIndustryInterferenceTactics• PolicyDiversion
• Weakpolicylanguageintendedtogivetheappearanceof“doingsomething“toaddresstheproblem
• Divertingthepolicydebateawayfromhealth
• “ThirdPartyEndorsers”• Restaurant,Beverage,RetailAssociations• State&localfrontgroups
• Propagandamachine• Economicscareinfo—sales,jobs,tourism• Healthscaretactics:“QuitorDie”argument• Attacksonsciencethrough3rd partyalliesorscientists• Individualrights/anti-bureaucracy/anti-governmentarguments
• Othertactics• Litigation• Electoralactivity– councilraces,referenda,initiative• Preemption www.no-smoke.org
NewIndustry,SimilarScript
www.no-smoke.org
O
www.no-smoke.org
NormalizingMarijuanaUse
Marijuanacocktailsandotheralcoholbeverages…“Toensureeven non-smokers canenjoythedrink,Lagunitas workedwithvapecartridgecompany,CannaCraft,toseparatethefragmentcompoundscalledterpenes,fromtheTHCwhichgetsyouhigh…theweedgivesasubtle,distinctiveflavor.”
www.no-smoke.org
www.no-smoke.org
www.no-smoke.org
www.no-smoke.org
DisguisingMarijuanatolooklikeVapepens/e-cigarettes
www.no-smoke.org
ElectronicSmokingDevices
www.no-smoke.org
§ THCoilsanddryherbsarebeinginhaledviaelectronicsmokingdevices(andexhaledintotheenvironment).
§ “E-cigarettesformarijuanaarealreadywidelyavailable,butthemCig isdifferent.It'ssomethingofahybridbetweenane-cigandajoint,inthatyoucanput"dryherb"initandheatittotheedgeofcombustion.”
HazeDualforleafandoilsorwaxes
E-joint
www.no-smoke.orgRecreationalMarijuanaLegalized
VentilationisNOTasolutiontosecondhandsmokeorsecondhandaerosol
“Ataminimum,establishandmaintainsmoke-freeworkplacesthatprotectthoseinworkplacesfromsecondhandexposurestotobaccosmokeandairborneemissionsfrome-cigarettesandotherelectronicnicotinedeliverysystems.Smoke-freezonesshouldencompass(1)allindoorareaswithoutexceptions(i.e.,noindoorsmokingareasofanykind,evenifseparatelyenclosedand/orventilated),(2)allareasimmediatelyoutsidebuildingentrancesandairintakes,and(3)allworkvehicles.Additionally,ashtraysshouldberemovedfromtheseareas.”
www.no-smoke.org
• Legalizationandcommercializationofmarijuanaisposingproblemsforpublichealthingeneral.
• Smokeissmoke.Marijuanasmokeisaformofindoorairpollution.
• Peopleshouldnothavetobreathesecondhandmarijuanasmokeatwork,inpublic,orathome.
• Marijuanasmokingshouldbeprohibitedinallsmokefreeenvironments.
MarijuanaSmokinginPolicies&Laws
RegulatingMarijuanalikeTobacco
www.no-smoke.org
CaliforniaSenateBill(SB162)bySenatorBenAllen,D-SantaMonica:
• Prohibitsbillboardsalonghighways• Prohibitsfalseormisleadingadvertising• Prohibitsadvertising cannabisonbrandedmerchandise,including
clothingandhats• Prohibitsmarketing thatsuggestsaproductwascultivatedina
certainappellationwhenitwasn’t• Prohibitspublishingadsthatare“attractivetochildren”orthat
encouragepeopleunderage21toconsumecannabis,advertisingonsignswithin1,000feetofadaycare,K-12school,aplaygroundoryouthcenter
Wewouldalsosuggestuseexcisetaxesforpreventionandcessationcampaigns,retailerlicensingandadditionalzoningrules,andprohibitmarijuanauseinsmokefree environments.
www.no-smoke.org
RecreationalMarijuanaLegalized
[email protected]/marijuana
www.no-smoke.org
OppositionArguments• Marijuanaisnatural andthereforecannotbeharmful
• Marijuanasmokeisdifferent fromtobaccosmoke
• Marijuanasmokeisnotasbad /dirtyastobaccosmoke
• Thereisno/ notenoughscience todocumenthazardsofsecondhandmarijuanasmokeexposure
• Thereisnosecondhand high frommarijuanasmoke
• Noonehasdied frommarijuanasecondhandsmoke
• Justputinaventilation systemthenitsallgood
www.no-smoke.org
Conclusions• Consideracampaignfocusedonnonsmokers’rightsvs.anindustryfocusedonprofitsoverhealth.
• Includemarijuanaindefinitionsof“smoking”insmokefreelaws.
• Bepreparedformarijuanaindustrytactics:• Pushtoexpandlegality&normalizemarijuanause• Denyhealthconcerns• Weakensmokefreelaws→allowmarijuanasmoking
• Sticktohealthmessagesaboutsecondhandsmoke,evenwhenreferringtouseofmedicalmarijuana.
§ Marijuana,legalornot,createssecondhandsmoke.§ Thereisscienceabouttheparticulatemattercreatedbysecondhand
marijuanasmoke,andmoreiscoming.§ Thereisscienceaboutthehealtheffectsofsecondhandmarijuana
smoke,andmoreiscoming.§ Ifwetrulywanttohavesafe,healthy,smokefreespaces,thenthey
shouldbedevoidofparticulatemattercreatedbytobaccocigarettesmoke,marijuanasmoke,andsecondhandaerosolfromelectronicsmokingdevices.
§ Researchdemonstratesthatventilationsystemscannotremoveallofthehazardousgases,toxins,andparticulatemattercreatedbysecondhandsmokeandaerosol;therefore,ventilationisnotasolution.Smokefree environmentsprotectworkersandpatronsfromexposuretosecondhandsmokeandaerosol.
ConclusionsandRecommendations
www.no-smoke.org
MedicalandAdult-UseofCannabisinMassachusetts
December13,2017
D.J.Wilson,TobaccoControlDirector
DavidLakeman,LegislativeAnalyst
MassachusettsMunicipalAssociation
ChrisWalsh,EditorialDirectorofMarijuanaBusinessDailysaidatCSP’sTotalNicotineConference:
• “Thisisaprofessionalindustrynow...”• 2016election:“Thiswillmovequickly.”“...Morethan50%ofAmericanssupportrecreationalmarijuana.”
• “Atsomepoint,legislatureswillhavetoaddressthat.”• Industrywillgenerate$14billionto$17billionin2016,accordingtoWalsh.
• “Babyboomersarehugeforthisindustry.”Wideconsumerbase.
• “Absolutely,BigTobaccoislookingatthis.”• “Theyknowhowtocultivatecrops,theyknowhowtomarketadultproducts,theyknowhowtodistribute.”
DPH’sMedical MarijuanaProgram
• Ballotinitiative2012– 63%to37%- only2outof351municipalitiesvotedno.
• ProgramhousedandregulatedatDepartmentofPublicHealth.• Ediblesnotconsidered“food”forpurposesofFoodCode.
• Localsdonotneedtoenforce,unlesstheywantto.• Localpermittingandregulationallowed.
• Nopreemption• Non-refundablestateapplicationfeeof$30,000.• Annualstateregistrationfeeof$50,000– supportsfundingDPHprogram.
RecreationalMarijuanaQuestion:
ResultsofNovember2016ballotquestion“toregulatecannabislikealcohol”260–yes/91-no
“AnActtoEnsureSafeAccesstoMedical andAdult-UseofMarijuanaintheCommonwealth”effective:12.12.2016- amended7.28.2017
• HousedattheOfficeoftheTreasury(whereABCCislocated).• CannabisControlCommission(CCC)of5memberswithfollowingbackgrounds:
• StevenJ.Hoffman,Chair:retiredBainandCompanyexecutive• KayDoyle,J.D.,formerDPHattorneyforMedicalMarijuanaProgram• JenniferFlanagan,formerlegislator• ShaleenTitle,co-founderofTHCStaffing,cannabisadvocate• BritteMcBride,formerassistantattorneygeneral
• CommissionappointsExecutiveDirector,SeanCollins,J.D.• Chieffinancialandaccountofficerandotheremployees.
ResponsibilitiesofCCC
• Promulgateregulationspriortolicensing.• Superviseindustry.• Implementstatelicensingsystem.• Issuelicensestooperate.• Investigateandenforceviolations.
CannabisAdvisoryBoard(25)
• ExecutiveDirector• CommissionerofPublicHealth• DepartmentofHousingandEconomicDevelopment
• CommissionerofRevenue• CommissionerofAgriculturalResources
• Statepolicerepresentative• MassachusettsMunicipalAssociation
• MassachusettsPatientAdvocacyAlliance
• QualifyingMedicalMarijuanaPatient
• ACLUofMassachusetts
• Marijuanacultivationexpert• Marijuanaretailingexpert• Marijuanamanufacturingexpert• Expertinlaboratorysciencesandtoxicology
• Legalexpertinrepresentingmarijuanabusinesses
• Expertinminoritybusinessdevelopment
• Expertineconomicdevelopmentstrategiesforunder-resourcedcommunities.
• Expertinfarming• Expertinmunicipallawenforcement
• Experienceinimpairmentdetectionandevaluation
CannabisAdvisoryBoard(continued)• Expertinsocialjustice
• Expertincriminaljusticereform• Tomitigatedisproportionateimpactofdrugprosecutionsoncommunitiesofcolor
• Expertinminority-ownedbusinesses
• Expertinwomen-ownedbusinesses
• Expertinpreventionandtreatmentofsubstanceusedisorders
FundingMechanism
• 20%taxonproduct.• 10.75excisetaxonretailmarijuanasales.
• 6.25%salestax.• 3%localtaxifdesiredbymunicipality.
LocalControl
1. LocalitymaynotprohibitanRMDlicensedbyJuly1,2017,frombecomingarecreationalmarijuanastore.HeadstartforRMD’s?
2. Maynotlimittolessthan20%ofthenumberofretailoff-premisesalcoholicbeveragelicenses(packagestores)issuedunderG.L.c.138(orprohibit)thenumberofmarijuanastores,except:1. Ifthecity/townvotedFOR legalization,votersatannualorspecialelectioncanvotethebylaw
orordinanceupordown.2. IfcityortownvotedAGAINSTlegalizationBoardofSelectmenorCityCouncilcanprohibit
marijuanaestablishments.
3. Mayrequire“communityimpactfee’”1. Mustberelatedtocostsimposedoncommunity;notmorethan3%ofgrosssalesof
establishmentorbeeffectiveformorethan5years.
4. Can’trequiresignagemorerestrictivethanalcoholsignage.
LocalControl(continued)
5. Canpassreasonablezoningordinancesandby-laws.5. Temporarymoratoriaenactedindozensofcity/towns.
6. Cannotbe“unreasonablyimpracticable.”5. “subjectlicenseestounreasonableriskorrequiresuchahighinvestmentofrisk,
money,timeoranyotherresourceorassetthatareasonablyprudentbusinesspersonwouldnotoperateamarijuanaestablishment.”5. Whatdoesthismean?
7. Canenforcethefoodcode.5. Butwhataboutmedicalmarijuana?6. CurrentDPHregulationssaymedicalmarijuanaediblesarenotfood.
CCCwilldevelopregulationstoaddress:
• Licensingrequirements• Whogetsalicense– “expeditedreview”forRMD’s?
• Minimumsecurityrequirements• Healthandsafetystandards(inconsultationwithDPH)• Requirementsforpackaging,includingcertifiedchild-resistantandresealable
• Requirethedivisionofeachservingssothatapersoncanidentifyasingleserving
• Banuseofbrightcolors,cartooncharacters• Assurepackagingisopaqueorplainindesign
LabelingRequirements
• SymbolorrecognizablemarkissuedbytheCCC• Warningthatproductisharmfultochildren• Nameandcontactinformationofcultivatorormanufacturer• Labthattestedtheproduct• Certificationthatproductmeetstestingstandards• Uniquebatchnumber• Listofingredients• PercentageofTHCineachserving• Disclaimer–productnotFDAapproved
IllegalonFederalLevel
• U.S.AttorneyGeneralforcontinuedControlledSubstancecategorization
• Cashbusiness– bankswon’ttouchit.• Previousadministration’sstandardoperatingproceduresvs.currentadministration.
• Proceedatyourownrisk.
AdvertisingRequirements• Notrestrictedlikewearewithtobaccobecauseproductisstillillegalfederally.
• Nodeceptive,falseormisleadingads.
• NoadsonTV,radio,internet,billboardorsponsorshipofcharityevents
• UNLESS85%ofaudienceis“reasonablyexpected”tobemorethan21.
• Up-to-dateaudiencecompositiondata.
• Can’tportrayanyonelessthan21.
• Nomascots,cartoons,brandsponsorshipsandcelebrityendorsementsDEEMEDTOAPPEALTOAPPEALTOAPERSONLESSTHAN21.
• Nogiveaways,couponsorfreeordonatedmarijuana.
• Reasonablelocalregulationontiminganduseofilluminatedexternalsignageandneonsigns.
MarijuanaRegulationFund
• Toimplement,administerandenforcethelaw
• Publicandbehavioralhealth• Evidence-basedandevidence-informedsubstanceuseprevention,treatmentandearlyinterventionservices
• Schooldistrictsandcommunitycoalitions
• Publicsafety• Municipalpolicetraining• Preventionandtrustfund• Programingforrestorativejustice
• Jaildiversion• Workforcedevelopment• Technicalassistanceforindustry• Mentoringserviceforeconomically-disadvantagedpersonsincommunitiesdisproportionatelyimpactedbyhigharrestratesandincarcerationformarijuanaoffenses
ResearchAgendaofCCC• StudysocialandeconomictrendsofmarijuanainMassachusetts.
• Howtocloseillicitmarketplace.• Publichealthimpactsofmarijuana.
• Patternsofuse.• Methodsofconsumption.• Sourcesofpurchase.• Marijuanauseamongminors,etc.
• Conductbaselinestudy.• Incidentsofimpaireddriving.• Ownershipandemploymenttrendsinmarijuanaindustry.
Timetable• Dec.15,2016:Personaluselegal– upto12plantsinhome– upto2ouncesonperson.
• Aug.1,2017:GovernormustmakeinitialappointmentstoCAB
• Sept.1,2017:StateTreasurermustmakeinitialappointmentstoCCC.
• Mar.15,2018:CCCmustpromulgateregulations.
• Apr.1,2018:CCCmustbeginacceptinglicensingapplicationsfromallretailers,manufacturersandcultivators.Conundrum#6:
• RMD’sandprovisionalRMD’sgetan“expedited”reviewprocess.• Howdowetellthedifferencebetweennontaxableandtaxablemarijuana?
• Profitornotforprofit?
• FirstdraftofproposedCCCregulationsdue12.29.17.
• Dec.31,2018–MedicalprogrammovestoCCC–butwhataboutnow?
TobaccoInteraction#1• Usedtobecalled“drugparaphernalia.”
• Onlypermittedifretailerhadatobaccosalespermit.
• Nowcalled“marijuanaaccessories.”• “equipment,products,devicesormaterialsofanykindthatareintendedordesignedforusein...ingesting,inhalingorotherwiseintroducingmarijuanaintothehumanbody.”
• Headshopsareperfectlylegal.• Noneedfortobaccosalespermit.
TobaccoInteraction#2• Tobaccosalessampleregulationwouldbeperfectforthistopicbutlegalityofuseunclear
• TobaccoRetailersareaskingforthe“MarijuanaSalesPermit“• RetailerconfusionaroundSyntheticMarijuanaandHemp• TobaccoControlpersonnelnotfundedtoworkonmarijuana
TobaccoInteraction#3• OurcurrentStatewideSmoke-FreeWorkplaceLawusesthisdefinition:
"Smoking''or"smoke",thelightingofacigar,cigarette,pipeorothertobaccoproductorpossessingalightedcigar,cigarette,pipeorothertobaccoornon-tobaccoproductdesignedtobecombustedandinhaled.
OmnibusTobaccoBill(HB2864)
• Increaseminimumlegalsalesageto21• 66.1%ofresidentscoveredbylocalregulationthatdoesthis(156)
• Adde-cigarettestosmokefreeworkplacelaw• 56%ofresidentscoveredbylocalregulationthatdoesthis(130)
• Prohibitsaleoftobaccoinpharmacies• 67.2%ofresidentscoveredbylocalregulationthatdoesthis(152)
• Also,banRYOmachines,vendingmachines,bluntwraps• HearingbeforeJointPublicHealthCommitteeMay2017• Stillincommittee- Legislativedrops3timesaweek.
QUESTIONS?
4/12/2017
CONTACT US
12/13/17 76
651.290.7506
www.publichealthlawcenter.org
@phealthlawctr
facebook.com/publichealthlawcenter