Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

42
Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek Nicolas Jondet , University of Strathclyde / CREATe Theme 3: Public/Intermediary Enabled Copyright Enforcement Lead investigator: Professor Lilian Edwards Presentation prepared for the CREATe Researchers Conference and Empirical Capacity Building Event (Edinburgh) – 13 & 14 June 2013 Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

description

The difficulties I face, as a legal academic, to deal with large amounts of empirical data. Trying to map and assess the breadth, depth and quality of legal services offering access to copyrighted content, such a music, films, books, video games. Collecting, presenting and making sense of large amount of data across several jurisdictions.

Transcript of Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Page 1: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek Nicolas Jondet, University of Strathclyde / CREATe

Theme 3: Public/Intermediary Enabled Copyright Enforcement

Lead investigator: Professor Lilian Edwards

Presentation prepared for the CREATe Researchers Conference and Empirical Capacity

Building Event (Edinburgh) – 13 & 14 June 2013

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 2: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

1. The project

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 3: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

1. The project

• Mapping the legal offer for digital content

- How to access copyrighted digital content legally in the EU

- The idea: is the level of piracy function of the quality of the legal offer in any given jurisdiction?

- Comparative analysis between countries

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 4: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

1. The project

• Challenges in terms of scope

- Subject matter is very large (covers music, movies, books, video games…)

- Many delivery systems and payment options (download, streaming, free, subscription on desktops, tablets, phones, consoles…)

- Starting point: the UK and France and then the whole of the 27 EU members

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 5: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

1. The project

• Challenges in terms of methodology

- Finding the information

- Collecting the information

- Presenting the information

- Analysing the information

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 6: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

1. The project

• An example of my work or of the challenges

- Access to music

- 60+ services in the UK alone

- Many of main services are available in many jurisdictions

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 7: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

2. The (potential) tools

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 8: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Me

Page 9: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Source: Saul Goodman from Breaking

Bad, AMC, Matt Copa

Trained

as a

lawyer

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 10: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

I use

Page 11: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 12: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 13: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 14: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

I have to master

Page 15: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Source: tecktite

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 17: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

I have to investigate

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 18: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Source: Sandal IT Services

Databases

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 19: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Source: earthfamilyalpha

Big Data

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 21: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

The database systems I am aware (and wary) of

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 22: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

3. How I started

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 23: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

a) Text in Word

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 24: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 25: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

b) Table in Word

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 26: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 27: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

b) Table in Word

• Advantages

- Familiar / Easy to set up

- Footnotes; Footnotes with Zotero

- Comments appear where they should

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 28: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

b) Table in Word

• Drawbacks

- Lack of flexibility (hard to add new columns/rows/ cell)

- Not adapted for big data sets (what happens when you go to the next page; scrolling down forever)

- Many footnotes eat up the page

- Not many functionalities (not much you can do with the data when it is in)

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 29: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

4. What I am doing now: Excel

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 30: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 31: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

4.What I am doing now: Excel

• Drawbacks

- How to do footnotes?

- How to make it look as nice as on Word?

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 32: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

4.What I am doing now: Excel

• Advantages

- Flexibility

- Autofill

- Handle much more data

- Much more functionalities I do not know about (relational data, presentation-wise….)

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 33: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

5. Should I go to the next level and create a relational database?

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 34: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

5. Relational database?

• Potential Benefits

- Do a searchable database with filters (by jurisdiction, type of content, payment options, compatible device and formats…)

- Visualisation / Infographics (PDF, HTML….) offline and online

- Understanding Big data?

- Examples of what I want to do

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 37: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 38: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 39: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

5. Relational database?

• Is it worth the effort?

- Time / Benefit

- Stick to Excel / switch to Access – SQL

- Sharing data between Excel and Access

- How to reference sources in a publishing compatible way, ie as good or better than footnotes, in Excel or Access?

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 40: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Where I am at

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 41: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013

Page 42: Mapping the legal offer for digital content: Desperately Seeking a Database Geek

Source: Microsoft Tech Support

Nicolas Jondet - 13 June 2013