Manganese Toxicity: Recent Research I have nothing to ... · Manganese, 2012-2016 0 5 10 15 20 25...
Transcript of Manganese Toxicity: Recent Research I have nothing to ... · Manganese, 2012-2016 0 5 10 15 20 25...
2/27/2017
1
Manganese Toxicity: Recent Research AdvancesRoberto Lucchini, MD
Division Occupational Medicine
Selikoff Centers for Occupational Health
New York, USA
I have nothing to disclose
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Total attendees (417)
4
155 In-person AttendeesBelgiumBrazilCanadaChinaCosta RicaFranceGermany GreeceItalyMexico MongoliaMorocco NetherlandsNorwaySouth AfricaSouth KoreaSwedenUnited KingdomUnited Sates
261 Webcast ParticipantsAustraliaBelgium
BahiaCanada
Costa Rica Ecuador
FranceGermany
GreeceIndonesia
ItalyJamaicaMorocco
MexicoNetherlands
NepalNorway
PeruPuerto Rico
RussiaSweden
Sri LankaTanzania
United KingdomUnited StatesUCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
2
Plenaries Health Risk Assessment and Protective Standards Health Effects of Community and Workplace Exposures Children’s Health and Development New Aspects of Toxicology in Animal Models and Cellular Functions Genetic and Mechanistic Influences
Imaging and Biomarkers
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Documentary Film: Le manganisme (circa 1953)Film by Jean Rodier, J. Boyer and Richard Chenay. Made possible by Centre National du Cinema, Paris
Workplace exposure and standards
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
1st Preventive measure for Mn-air exposure
Study in 75 Pennsylvania plants (Tanaka & Lieben, 1969)
▶ 144 workers: air Mn dust/fumes > 5 mg/m3
7 cases & 15 borderline cases of manganism▶ 48 workers: air Mn dust/fumes < 5 mg/m3
0 cases
1970: 1st Industrial hygiene measure for air-Mn
US-OSHA & ACGIH: ceiling value of 5 mg Mn/m³
Harry A. Roels, Université Catholique de Louvain, Belgium
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
3
2nd Preventive measure for Mn-air exposure
1980s-1990s: Belgium, Canada, Italy & Sweden Independent epidemiologic investigations Mn-air exposures < 1 mg Mn/m³ Findings of sub/preclinical CNS changes:
decreased neuropsychological and psychomotor performances,
cognitive deficits, and mood disturbances
1995: 2nd Industrial hygiene measure for air-Mnto prevent sub/preclinical CNS manifestaions
ACGIH (TLV-TWA 8h, 1995) : 5 0.20 mg/m3 (total dust)
no change
US-OSHA (Ceiling, 1970) 5 mg/m³US-NIOSH (REL-TWA) 1 mg/m³
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
3rd Preventive measure for Mn-air exposure
Application of particle size-selective criteriafor inhalation of airborne particulate matter (PM)on industrial aerosol containing Mn particles:
- inhalable fraction : PM < 100 µm- respirable fraction: PM < 10 µm
Inhalable Respirable*EU-SCOEL (2011): 0.2 mg/m³ 0.05 mg/m³
ACGIH (2012/13): 0.2 0.1 mg/m³ 0.02 mg/m³
*Higher neurotoxic potential of fine particles (e.g., welding fume )
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Results of OSHA Compliance Monitoring for Manganese, 2012-2016
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
>0.1 >1 >5
Percent of Detectable Sam
ples
Mn Exposure (mg/m3)
N = 1,886 totalN = 62 (3%) > 1 mg/m3
N = 8 (0.4%) > 5 mg/m3
William Perry, Occupational Safety and Health Administration
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Majority are welders, millwrights, blasters
Commercial Industrial Machinery Repair
Transportation Equipment Manufacturers
Auto, Light Duty Vehicle Manufacture
Machinery Manufacturing
Fabricated Metal Products
Primary Metals Manufacture
Specialty Trade Contractors
Heavy and Civil Engineering Construction
Industry Sectors Where Mn Exposures Have Been Commonly Found
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
4
Welders exposure according to Mn forms/valence
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Highest Full-shift TWA Breathing Zone Exposure to Total Mn Inhalable Fractions (µg/m3)Oil Refinery Construction:
Job Process Sol. 0, 2+ 3+, 4+ Sum
Tank Stick, CS 28 74 250 380
Piping Stick, CS 3.3 38 18 57
Vessels Stick, CS 26 210 52 320
John HowardDirector, NIOSH
TLV= 100 µg/m3
Asphalt Tank, Respirable Mn (µg/m3)Five Welders
050
100150200250300350400
Sol Mn Mn (0,+2) Mn (+3,+4) Mn (sum)
12345TLV
20 ug/m3
Welders exposure warrant effective exposure controlVentilation improvementsMay require respiratory protection – high efficiency filtering face-piece (?); PAPR welding helmets
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
John HowardDirector, NIOSH
Nail Clippings Surrogate: Biomonitoring Welding-Mn Exposure
Man
gan
ese
(per
cen
t co
ntr
ol)
Experimental rats were exposed (2mg/rat; 1/week x 28 weeks) to different welding fumes or manganesechloride by intra-tracheal instillation (to overcome superficial contamination of nails that could occur by whole-body inhalation). Brain (striatum), blood and nail clippings were collected and subjected to elemental analysis.Manganese was detected in striatum and nail clippings but not in blood.
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
John HowardDirector, NIOSH
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Nail Clips for Biomonitoring ofWelding-related Mn Exposure
Experimental rats were exposed (2mg/rat; 1/week x 28 weeks) to different welding fumes or manganesechloride by intra-tracheal instillation (to overcome superficial contamination of nails that could occur bywhole-body inhalation). Brain regions (striatum and midbrain) and nail clippings were collected andsubjected to analysis of manganese content.
John HowardDirector, NIOSH
2/27/2017
5
Updating the NIOSH REL!
NIOSH quantitative risk assessment:- Conducted using best available data
- On subclinical neurobehavioral changes
- Provides an array of risk levels
- With two-tier REL (inhalable/respirable)?
- Peer-reviewed
- Public input encouraged
- Considers analytical achievability
NIOSH topic page: Welding and manganese www.cdc.gov/niosh/topics/welding/
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Brain Imaging in welders
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
0.000
0.002
0.004
0.006
0.008
0.010
0.012
0.014
ControlMn-Exposed WorkersMn-Exposed Welders
Caudate Anterior Putamen
Posterior Putamen
Av
era
ge
Ki V
alu
e, A
dju
ste
d f
or
Ag
e
*
FDOPA PET including Symptomatic Welders and Mn-Exposed Workers
Criswell SR, Perlmutter JS, Videen TO. Neurology. 2011;76:1296-301.
Average FDOPA PET Ki by region for controls, welders, and workers. * = different from controls, p < 0.01
Criswell et. al, in submission
Susan R. Criswell Washington U
Saint Louis
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Increase in UPDRS3 Score Due to Welding Fume Exposure by Years as a Welder
Brad A. RacetteWashington U Saint Louis
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
6
Cumulative Mn exposure to welding fume at estimated Mn concentrations (0.14 mg Mn/m3) near some regulatory thresholds appeared to increase progression of parkinsonism in a dose-dependent manner.
Workers performing Flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) may be at particularly greater risk of developing progressive parkinsonism.
More stringent workplace monitoring of Mn exposures, greater use of personal protective equipment and ventilation, and systematic worker assessment may be indicated to reduce morbidity.
What do we call this syndrome?
Racette et al.Dose-dependent progression of parkinsonism in manganese-
exposed welders. Neurology. 2016 Dec 28.
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Indiana cohort(Lafayette, IN, US)
NumberMean airborne Mn
[mg/m3]Mean years of exposure Mean age
Controls 22 0.007 ± 0.001 0 35 ± 11
Welders (low exp) 17 0.09 ± 0.03 12 ± 7 39 ± 10
Welders (high exp) 15 0.23 ± 0.19 15 ± 9 43 ± 11
A: Recruitment of welders and controls:• From same local truck trailer manufacturer, male only• Welders: more than 3 years of welding history Controls: no exposure history
PD cohort Number Males / femalesRange of disease onset
(years)Mean age
(years)
PD patients 19 9 F 0.75- 11 63.7 ± 9.1
controls 18 7 F N/A 59.7 ± 10.2
B: Recruitment of PD patients and controls:• Patients: Mild PD, recruited from neurological clinic; male and female• 12 hours off medication, some patients drug naiive• Controls: usually spouses or friends of patients, no exposure history, no neurol or
psych. history
Ulrike Dydak, Purdue University
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Mn Toe Nail Levels
*P = 0.0018
Eric Ward, Frank Rosenthal Purdue University
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Exposure versus Toe Nail Mn
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Mn in Toe nail clippings may serve as reliable biomarker of exposure
It gives information about exposure over the past year, but also on lifetime cumulative exposure
Correlations were adjusted for age, sex, race, cigarette smoking and dietary Mn intake
Past year exposure Cumulative exposure
p = 0.002 p = 0.006
2/27/2017
7
Neurological Exam: UPDRS-III
Uniform Parkinson Disease Rating Scale – Part III (motor assessment)
Note: a UPDRS score < 15 is not considered pathological!
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
Sc
ore
Parkinson Study
PD Controls PD Patients
*p < 0.001
18190
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
UP
DR
S S
core
UPDRSLocal Welders
Control Welder
22 31
p = 0.07
Ulrike Dydak, Purdue University
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Significant elevation of UPDRS scores in high exposure group!
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
UP
DR
S S
core
Control Low Exp.Welder High Exp. Welder
*p=0.03
**p<0.01
N=22 N=14N=17
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
UP
DR
S S
core
Control Welder
N=22 N=31
p=0.07
Uniform Parkinson Disease Rating Scale – Part III (motor assessment)
By Plant
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
R1 (~Brain Mn) Comparison
No significance was found
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
GP left GP right SN left SN right FWMleft
FWMright
R1
rela
xati
on ti
me
(1/s
))
Comparison of R1 at different brain regions PD
Control
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
GP left GP right SN left SN right FWM left FWM right
R1
rela
xati
on ti
me
(1/s
)
R1 in different brain regions welders
w control
p=0.0048p=0.0022
p<0.0001 p=0.0003
WelderControl PD Patient
PD patients - CtrlWelders - CtrlUCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Correlation of MRI R1 versus past 3 months exposure
Frontal Cortex
R-square 0.5 P-value <0.01
Correlation of Brain Manganese vs Exposure
Relation of R1 relaxation rate
correlated significantly with
occupational exposure
Correlations were found between
the R1 relaxation rate and Mn
exposure over the past 3 months in
the regions responsible for
behavioral and motor deficits:
o Inferior Frontal Cortex (R=0.5, p<0.01)
o Motor Cortex (R=0.4, p=0.02)
No correlation is found between R1 and exposure 7-12 months ago
No correlation in the Globus Pallidus!
Chien-Lin Yeh, Purdue University
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
8
Neurobehavioralassessment in community exposure
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Demographic & Biological Measures by Cohort
Marietta & Cambridge, OH
N=410
East Liverpool, OH
N=106
Female 46% 61%
Caucasian 94% 83%
Biological measures GM ± GSD GM ± GSD
Hair Mn (ng/g) 416.51 ± 2.44 360.22 ± 2.17
Blood Mn (µg/L) 9.67 ± 1.27 10.06 ± 1.30
Blood Pb (µg/dL) 0.82 ± 1.58 1.13 ± 1.96
Serum Cotinine (µg/L) 0.08 ± 7.84 0.76 ± 6.12
Marietta and Cambridge biomarkers: n=310-370East Liverpool biomarkers: n=67-98
Erin Haynes, U Cincinnati
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Penalized splines for hair and blood Mn levels in association with WISC-IV outcome measures. All models include both hair Mn and blood Mn, plus ln serum creatinine, blood Pb, and community residence. (A) Full Scale IQ (n = 295), also adjusted for sex, parent’s IQ, parent education, parent confidence t-score.
The solid line represents the estimate with the 95% confidence interval indicated by dotted lines. The distributions of Mn levels are indicated by vertical lines on the x-axis.
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
9
(B) Perceptual Reasoning (n = 298) also adjusted for parent’s IQ; and
(C) Processing Speed (n = 272), also adjusted for sex, ln serum ferritin, parent confidence t-score, birth weight.
The solid line represents the estimate with the 95% confidence interval indicated by dotted lines. The distributions of Mn levels are indicated by vertical lines on the x-axis.
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Residents: “We are very concerned”
In Chicago, nearly 20,000 people live within a 1-mile radius of SH Bell’s South Avenue O Terminal, which, according to the company’s website, is its second largest warehousing facility. Nearly two-thirds of those people are living below the poverty level, and almost 90 percent are minorities, according to EPA. Of those living within 1 mile of the facility, more than 6,000 are children.
“That stretch where the company is, there are homes right across the street from [S.H. Bell]. “said Annmarie Garza, an East Side resident and mother who has been spreading the word about manganese to other parents in the neighborhood. There are some poor people who live there because nobody else wants to live in front of that. And I worry about their kids, knowing that this company has this stuff coming out.”
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Birgit Clauss Henn, U Boston
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
10
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
The PHIME CohortPublic Health Impact of Metal Exposure(PI: Roberto Lucchini, Donald Smith, Robert Wright)
• Cross‐sectional study of 720 children ages 11‐14 yrs
• Mn measured in environmental & biological samples
• Neuropsychological & behavioral assessment
SMR Parkinsonism vs. Mn in dust p=0.005
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Saliva Mn negatively associated with verbal learning & memory
Linear regression models adjusted for age, sex, SES, ln‐blood Pb; Ln‐transformed saliva Mn.*p<0.10, **p<0.05
Associations between Saliva Mn & California Verbal Learning Test
Adjusted Beta (95% CI)
Total words recalled -1.22 (-1.85 to -0.58)**
Words recalled after trial 5 -0.30 (-0.46 to -0.14)**
Words recalled with short recall -0.30 (-0.48 to -0.13)**
Words recalled with long recall -0.32 (-0.49 to -0.15)**
Errors: perseverations -0.29 (-0.80 to 0.22)
Errors: intrusions 0.24 (-0.05 to 0.54)
• No consistent associations with other biomarkers
2/27/2017
11
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Mathilda Chiu, Mount Sinai
2/27/2017
12
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
13
New Bedford Cohort Study (NBC)
• 788 newborns enrolled at birth 1993-1998
• Maternal residence in towns next to PCB-contaminated New BedfordHarbor
• Assess relation early life exposure to PCBs, OC pesticides and metalswith child neurodevelopment andgrowth
49
Susan Korrick, Harvard School PH
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Prenatal Mn and Behavior at Age 8 in the New Bedford Cohort
Prenatal Mn exposures associated with: Increased risk of ADHD-associated behavior on Conners
Behavioral Rating Scale – Teachers only among girls Suggestive decrements on WISC FD (attention/working
memory) only among girls Suggestive evidence that postnatal (not prenatal) Pb
exposure may enhance Mn’s CRS-T and WISC FD associations in girls
No association with Continuous Performance Test measures of attention or impulse control
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Penalized Splines of Cord Blood Manganese & ADHD symptoms at 8 yrs
We do not know very much about the effects of women’s occupational exposure to Mn
• Women compose 37% of the Guangxi manganese-exposedworkers healthy cohort (Lv et al, 2014) and 35% of the highexposure category (Wang et al, 2015)
• In 2010, women made up 21% of workers in manganese mines in India (Labour Bureau, Government of India, 2012)
• A Canadian study reported elevated urinary Mn concentrations in 132 women apprentice welders (Arrandale et al, 2014)
We know little about women’s possible Mn exposures in other occupations.
SEX DIFFERENCES Donna Mergler, Université du Québec à Montréal
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
2/27/2017
14
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
PROGRESS Birth CohortProgramming Research in Obesity, Growth, Environment and Social Stressors(Pis Robert Wright, Rosalind Wright, Andrea Baccarelli, Martha M. Téllez‐Rojo)
Marcela Tamayo y Ortiz, National Inst Public Health, Mexico
Prenatal Depression and Neurodevelopment
• Has been linked to lower IQ, negative emotionality, and Bayley IIMental Development Index scores.
• Prevalence of depression in pregnant women in the MexicanSocial Security Institute was 23.3% 2
• National Institute of Perinatology 21.7% of pregnant women havea probable depressive episode 3
• 10% of pregnant women suffer from depression (weeks 6 to 10and in the third trimester of pregnancy) 4
1 Makrides etal2010,Nulman etal2012,Nulman etal.2015,Greenata.2016,Bhang etal20162Ortega,Lartigue andFigueroa2001 3QuiñonesDelgadoandLopez‐Trejo20154Dossettetal.2008,Ceballos‐Martínez,etal.2010),Olhaberry,etal.2013.
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Co‐Exposure to Manganese and Depression and Neurodevelopment
• Could be acting on the same dopamine pathway.• No previous studies on their prenatal co‐exposure and child
neurodevelopment.
By NIDA,Quasihuman ‐ Derivative work ofFile:DopaminePathways.png,Public Domain,https://commons.wikimedia.org/w/index.php?curid=19925266
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
No Yes p
Cognitive 93.2 ± 1.1 88.8 ± 2.3 0.000*
Language 91.3 ± 1.2 86.1 ± 2.5 0.000*
Motor 94.6 ± 1.2 90.2 ± 2.8 0.002*
6080
100
120
NO YES
Cog
nitiv
e
608
01
0012
0
NO YES
Leng
uage
6080
100
120
NO YES
Mot
orBayley III Scores by Depression
2/27/2017
15
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
80
85
90
95
100
10 20 30 40 50 10 20 30 40 50
NO YES
Cognitive Language Motor
Ba
yle
y III
sco
res
3rd trimester manganese ug/L
3T Mn and neurodevelopment stratified by depression
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
75
80
85
90
95
100
1 3 5 7 9 11 1 3 5 7 9 11
NO YES
Cognitive Language Motor
Ba
yle
y III
Cord blood Manganese (ug/L)
CORD blood Mn and neurodevelopment stratified by depression
Genetic influence
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017 UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
Does genetics matter for Mn kinetics and toxicity?
Despite under homeostatic control, blood Mn levels in the general population varies considerably (2‐5 times) between individuals.
This variation may be due to genetic variations in the SLC30A10 gene, which was recently shown to code for an important cell‐surface localized Mn efflux transporter
(Quadri et al. Am J Hum Genet. 2012; Leyva‐Illades et al. J Neurosci. 2014)
Karin Broberg, Karolinska Inst, Sweden
2/27/2017
16
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
3 adult cohorts - Bangladesh , Andes , Italy N=836
Blood Mn measured in populations world‐wide
PI: Marie Vahter PI: K Broberg/M. Vahter Roberto LucchiniPregnant women 26 years Men & women 34 years Men & women 69 years
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
3 adult cohorts - Bangladesh , Andes , Italy
SLC30A10 genotypes modify blood Mn up to 18%
AA CCCTTT
rs2275707 rs12064812
p=0.012
p=0.027 p=0.023
CC/AC
% B
loo
dM
nco
nc
rela
tive
re
fere
nce
gen
oty
pe
% B
loo
dM
nco
nc
rela
tive
re
fere
nce
gen
oty
pe
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
SLC30A10 and SLC39A8modify blood Mn up to 60%
Wahlberg et al. in preparation
N=717, adj for age, sex, ferritin, Mn in soil
rs227507 rs12064812 rs13107325Combined genotypes
GG GA AAAA CA CCn=415 n=225 n=32 n=324 n=299 n=57
TT TC CC CC CT/TTn=561 n=116
Low Medium Highn=86 n=548 n=29
% d
iffe
ren
ce
p<0.001 p<0.001 p=0.002 p<0.001
Blood Mn
SLC30A10 SLC39A8
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
SLC30A10 variation influences finger tapping and sway in Italian elderly
rs2275707 AC/CC open eyes 10% more sway p=0.065closed eyes 15% more sway p=0.033
rs12064812 CT/CC better speed finger tappingnon‐dominant hand 8.7% p=0.084dominant hand 10.8% p=0.025
SLC30A10 seems to modify Mn toxicity
2/27/2017
17
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
SLC30A10 allele associated with increasedMn in blood ‐reduced scoring in IQ subtests.
SLC30A10 allele associated with reducedMn in blood ‐increasing scoring in IQ subtests.
No gene‐environmentinteractions
SLC30A10 variation influences cognitive functions in Italian adolescents
1. What is a good surrogate for biomonitoringmanganese exposure in welders?
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
1. Blood
2. Urine
3. Hair
4. Nail
5. Saliva
2. What is the current TVL for manganese in respirable fraction?
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
1. 5 mg/m3
2. 1 mg/m3
3. 200 µg/m3
4. 100 µg/m3
5. 20 µg/m3
3. What gene can influence the variation of bloodmanganese and neurobehavioral performance?
UCSF_CME/ Presentation Slide / March 10, 2017
1. Alfa-synuclein
2. Parkin
3. SLC30A10
4. Dopamine Receptor D4
5. ATP13A2