Male/female language Waldemar Mizich. Content 1.Sex and Gender 2.Social Structures: Masculinity and...
-
Upload
norah-golden -
Category
Documents
-
view
220 -
download
1
Transcript of Male/female language Waldemar Mizich. Content 1.Sex and Gender 2.Social Structures: Masculinity and...
male/female language
Waldemar Mizich
Content
1. Sex and Gender2. Social Structures: Masculinity and Femininity3. Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of
Speech4. Speaking in Reference to Male and Female5. Nonverbal, Extra-Linguistic Messages6. Sources
Male and Female Differentiation Sex vs. Gender
Sex:Sex refers to the male and female duality of biology and
reproduction. An organism's sex reflects its biological function in reproduction, not its sexuality or other behavior.
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex)
Gender:Although "gender" is commonly used interchangeably with "sex,"
within the academic fields of cultural studies, gender studies and the social sciences in general, the term "gender" often refers to purely social rather than biological differences.
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender)
Social Structures: Masculinity and Femininity
Masculinity:Masculinity refers to qualities and behaviors judged by a
particular culture to be ideally associated with or especially appropriate to men and boys. Distinct from maleness, which is a biological and physiological classification concerned with the reproductive system, masculinity principally refers to socially acquired traits and secondary sex characteristics.
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masculinity)
Cicero: "a man's chief quality is courage"
Social Structures: Masculinity and Femininity
Femininity:Femininity refers to qualities and behaviors judged by a particular
culture to be ideally associated with or especially appropriate to women and girls. Distinct from femaleness, which is a biological and physiological classification concerned with the reproductive system, femininity principally refers to socially acquired traits and secondary sex characteristics.
(http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femininity)
In western culture: gentleness, patience, kindness Consideration of different societies and their definition of Femininity and
Masculinity
Social Structures: Masculinity and Femininity
• Masculinity and Femininity are relative terms:
- some women have more muscle than some men- some women weigh more than some men- some men have finer hand movement than some women- some men are more patience than some women- some women are more courageous than some men
examples: rainforrest, Japan
Social Structures: Masculinity and Femininity
female language male and female language male language
• the majority of people use a combination of male and female language
females only some females, some males males
only
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
Slyles of speech are influenced by many factors such as:- geographical dimensions (place)- temporal dimensions (age, time)- context of situation (the how, when, where, the who
with, the what, under what circumstances)Influence by gender:one must consider:• The gender of the speaker• The gender of the hearer• The gender of the audience• The gender of the person referred to or spoken of
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
Examples/exercise:
• A man talks to a man:„Lets get sloshed!“ (short, vulgar, NOT
impolite)„I don‘t like this topic at all.“ (formal behaviour,
audience, statement)„He was a hell of a man!“ (talking about s.o.,
compliment)
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
• A woman talks to a woman:„Let‘s meet for a make up party next saturday.“
(informative, polite)„Do you mind if we change the topic.“
(formal behaviour, audience, politeness)
„The guy I met in the elevator had a very bad attitude.“ (honest, polite, bad experience)
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
• A man talks to a woman„Would you like to have another drink?“
(polite, playing a role, thinking of own interest)
„We will discuss the topic tomorrow if you don‘t mind.“ (politeness, formality,
audience)„He is a very strange person.“
(covering own antipathy with politeness)
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
• A woman talks to a man„You should hurry up honey.“
(indicating time pressure, polite, hidden
information)„I will announce my decision tomorrow at 2 pm.“
(formal, audience, informative)
„It was an interesting experience to meet him.“ (polite description of a bad experience, hiding emotions)
exercise
Pretend to be the opposite sex than you are and write a short message to your boy/girlfriend using female/male language.
Explain what makes your message sound like a man/woman.
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
• Each sex is bilingual- not two languages but two different ways of
speaking formal vernacular
- the more you use fomal language the more it becomes a part of your vernacular, not vice versa
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
Difference in treating infants and talking to them- different responses
Examples:• A father (low voice) speaking to his little son„Come here, you little nut!“„Hey fruitcake!“Respond (low voice) of the son: „Yes dad.“• A father (low voice) speaking to his little daughter„Come here princess.“„Who is daddy‘s sunshine?“Respond (low voice) of the daughter: „I‘m coming daddy.“
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
• A mother (high voice) speaking to her son:„Come here Franky.“Respond (high voice) of the son: „I‘m coming mummy.“
• A mother (high voice) speaking to her daughter:„Would you like an apple Anna?“Respond (high voice) of the daughter: „Yes mummy.“
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
Tags:- Women use tags differently than man
women:- Use facilitative tags, which have no informational function but an important
interactional function more often than men„Quite a nice room to sit in actually, isn‘t it.“- Expressing personal opinion and value-judgement, does not require
confirmation from anyone elsemen:
- Use tags to acquire information in the first place„You were in Canada last year, weren‘t you?“- Mentioning a fact, which you already know, asking for further information
about this fact
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
Baby talk:Used to show a certain relationship or to control
another human being.- women use it more frequently than males- mothers may use it to sons longer than to their
daughters- men may use it to their car, or their gun, or when
they are drunk- fathers may use it to their small daughters
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
Patronizing: (male stereotype)Often used with children, the mentally incompetent,
hospitalized patients, females - Anchorman introduces a female newscaster as„lovely Jane Doe.“- Female reporter completed her part, the anchorman
acknowledges it with, „Thank you, dear!“ You wouldn‘t use it to a professional colleague However: can be considered as a complement as well Pattern is reversed when a man becomes ill
Sociolect Differences: Dialogues and Styles of Speech
Explanations: (male stereotype)Men are forever explaning things to women.• Men as givers of information, not receivers• dominates conversation
Language of apology: (more used by women)Women are always asking for pardon, whether or not
they are to blame for something is not the issue.But: Conversational Rituals, therefore also used by
men
Speaking in Reference to Male and Female
How is you „Father“? „He“ is fine.Where is your „Mother“? „She“ is in the bedroom.Where is my „book“? „It‘s“ on the desk.I met Alex yesterday. „We“ played ball.Where are Ben and Kelly? „They“ are still at school.
Non-specific persons:Someone tried to get in, didn‘t (he, she, they)?Someone owes you money, doesn‘t (she, he, they)?
Speaking in Reference to Male and Female
Explanation:
Dinosaur SyndromeDinosaurs come in both sexes. We still refer to a Dinosaur as “he”.
“when we say ‘he,’ we mean both sexes”
Nonverbal, Extra-Linguistic Messages
Paralanguage: Comprises all extra-speech sounds or modifications of speech.
These may be separate sounds such as whistling, yelling, or ‚tsk-tsk‘. Paralanguage may also consist of modifying features accompanying speech in the way of quality of voice, pitch, or loudness – vocal expressions that add emotional and attitudinal meaning to the verbal expression.
(Key, 1996)
Nonverbal, Extra-Linguistic Messages
Examples:Biologically conditioned: High pitch, thin quality of a woman’s voice = like that of a child
Socially conditioned: female behavior often coincides with children’s behavior
- Women use a higher than usual pitch to indicate innocence, femininity, and helplessness
men use an exaggerated low pitch to signal masculinity teen-age boys lower their pitch to appear tough Imitation of the other sex
„Yes dear, I‘ll be down in a minute“ imitated by a man„Aw, just one more little drink.“ imitated by a woman
Whistle to call someone
Nonverbal, Extra-Linguistic Messages
Kinesics:Is body language, any movement from muscular or skeletal shift. These body movements result in such acts as postural expression, facial expression, and gestures.
(Key 1996)• Can hardly be described in general• Consideration of temporal and cross-cultural differences
Example:children’s games, certain hand movements
Nonverbal, Extra-Linguistic Messages
Postural behavior:Women:• women very often tilt their heads (i.e. greeting)
- convey an attitude of coyness or submissiveness• closed legs when sitting
- clothes effect the walking and sitting posture (i.e. mini skirt)Men:• men stand and sit with their legs apart
Nonverbal, Extra-Linguistic Messages
facial expressions:- Men and women interprete these aspects of communication
in the same way- Provide important social and emotional information- Indicate positive and negative mood signs
mouth:- women smile more than men throughout their lifetime
eye contact:- The meeting of eyes arouses strong emotions- Different meaning in different cultures
sourceso http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/feminism-language/o Mary Ritchie, Key. 1996. Male/Female Language: With a Comprehenssive
Bibliography 2nd ed. Lanham, MD: Scarecrow Presso Wolfram, Walt and Natalie Schilling-Estes. 1998. American English.
Dialects and Variation. Oxford: Blackwello Ronald, Wardhaugh. 1998. An Introduction to Sociolinguistics. Oxford:
Blackwello http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masculinityo http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Femininityo Deborah, Tannen. 1995. Talking from 9 to 5. London: Virago Presso Coates & Cameron. 1991. Women in their speech communities. London:
Longman