Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

23
http://www.bluegrassbit.com/projects/ industry/steel_mills/ //s2.webstarts.com/schifffarmsNE / http://www.ipexneb.com/ranches.html Using existing technology we can make the Keystone XL Pipeline safe and predictable… …while improving the environment, creating jobs and generating revenue.

description

Solutions for the Keystone XL pipeline.

Transcript of Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

Page 1: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://www.bluegrassbit.com/projects/industry/steel_mills/

http://s2.webstarts.com/schifffarmsNE/

http://www.ipexneb.com/ranches.html

Using existing technology we can make the Keystone XL Pipeline safe and predictable…

…while improving the environment, creating jobs and generating revenue.

Page 2: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

…two types of pipelines, those that leak

and those that are going to leak. We

can make a third type. A pipe line that

contains leaks.

Most pipelines, regardless of what they contain, are designed with a typical life span of 25 years. When they do begin to fail, they do so slowly beginning with leaks at poor construction joints, corrosion points and small structural material cracks, and gradually progress to a catastrophic ending. http://www.enotes.com/topic/Leak_detection

We know its going to leak…

Shell’s Mississippi oil spill due to out-

and-out negligence

Jun 13th, 2010 by John Donovan.

http://royaldutchshellplc.com/2010/06/13/shells-mississippi-oil-spill-due-to-out-and-out-negligence/

…landowners, upset by last month's oil spill in Michigan, are urging the Obama administration to deny a proposal…

http://mtlowdown.blogspot.com/2010/08/protests-spew-over-montana-gulf.html

Chevron Pipe Line Co. …About 100 barrels of oil spilled from

the 15,000 barrel-a-day line in Salt Lake City Wednesday,

local fire officials had said. That is the second spill in the

same line in seven months. Last June, the line leaked about

800 barrels of crude oil into Red Butte Creek

Page 3: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

…two types of pipelines, those that leak

and those that are going to leak. We

can make a third type. A pipe line that

contains leaks.

Most pipelines, regardless of what they contain, are designed with a typical life span of 25 years. When they do begin to fail, they do so slowly beginning with leaks at poor construction joints, corrosion points and small structural material cracks, and gradually progress to a catastrophic ending. http://www.enotes.com/topic/Leak_detection

We know its going to leak…

Shell’s Mississippi oil spill due to out-

and-out negligence

Jun 13th, 2010 by John Donovan.

http://royaldutchshellplc.com/2010/06/13/shells-mississippi-oil-spill-due-to-out-and-out-negligence/

Another Keystone Pipeline Leak in Nebraska December 7, 2010 http://tarsandspipelines.wordpress.com/2010/12/07/another-keystone-pipeline-leak-in-nebraska/

…landowners, upset by last month's oil spill in Michigan, are urging the Obama administration to deny a proposal…

http://mtlowdown.blogspot.com/2010/08/protests-spew-over-montana-gulf.html

Chevron Pipe Line Co. …About 100 barrels of oil spilled from

the 15,000 barrel-a-day line in Salt Lake City Wednesday,

local fire officials had said. That is the second spill in the

same line in seven months. Last June, the line leaked about

800 barrels of crude oil into Red Butte Creek

Page 4: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

…two types of pipelines, those that leak

and those that are going to leak. We

can make a third type. A pipe line that

contains leaks.

Most pipelines, regardless of what they contain, are designed with a typical life span of 25 years. When they do begin to fail, they do so slowly beginning with leaks at poor construction joints, corrosion points and small structural material cracks, and gradually progress to a catastrophic ending. http://www.enotes.com/topic/Leak_detection

We know its going to leak…

Shell’s Mississippi oil spill due to out-

and-out negligence

Jun 13th, 2010 by John Donovan.

http://royaldutchshellplc.com/2010/06/13/shells-mississippi-oil-spill-due-to-out-and-out-negligence/

Another Keystone Pipeline Leak in Nebraska December 7, 2010 http://tarsandspipelines.wordpress.com/2010/12/07/another-keystone-pipeline-leak-in-nebraska/

…landowners, upset by last month's oil spill in Michigan, are urging the Obama administration to deny a proposal…

http://mtlowdown.blogspot.com/2010/08/protests-spew-over-montana-gulf.html

Chevron Pipe Line Co. …About 100 barrels of oil spilled from

the 15,000 barrel-a-day line in Salt Lake City Wednesday,

local fire officials had said. That is the second spill in the

same line in seven months. Last June, the line leaked about

800 barrels of crude oil into Red Butte Creek

…but we can plan for it and contain it.

Page 5: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

We already require in situ catastrophic spill containment for stationary petroleum tanks.

http://www.sarvabioremed.com/spillremed-industrial/bioremediation-of-a-contained-open-water-spill-in-a-mine/bioremediation-of-a-contained-open-water-spill-in-a-mine/

http://news.thomasnet.com/fullstory/Spill-Containment-Berm-offers-drive-in-drive-out-operation-18936

http://www.emd.saccounty.net/EnvComp/HM/AST.html

Industrial

Farm

Portable

http://www.aegweb.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=4252

http://www.aquastore.com/leachate.html

http://www.enpac.com/stinger-railberm

Page 6: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

We already require in situ catastrophic spill containment for stationary petroleum tanks.

http://www.sarvabioremed.com/spillremed-industrial/bioremediation-of-a-contained-open-water-spill-in-a-mine/bioremediation-of-a-contained-open-water-spill-in-a-mine/

http://news.thomasnet.com/fullstory/Spill-Containment-Berm-offers-drive-in-drive-out-operation-18936

http://www.emd.saccounty.net/EnvComp/HM/AST.html

Industrial

Farm

Portable

http://www.aegweb.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=4252

http://www.aquastore.com/leachate.html

http://www.enpac.com/stinger-railberm

How is a pipeline not a stationary tank?

Page 7: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

We already require in situ catastrophic spill containment for stationary petroleum tanks.

http://www.sarvabioremed.com/spillremed-industrial/bioremediation-of-a-contained-open-water-spill-in-a-mine/bioremediation-of-a-contained-open-water-spill-in-a-mine/

http://news.thomasnet.com/fullstory/Spill-Containment-Berm-offers-drive-in-drive-out-operation-18936

http://www.emd.saccounty.net/EnvComp/HM/AST.html

Industrial

Farm

Portable

http://www.aegweb.org/i4a/pages/index.cfm?pageid=4252

http://www.aquastore.com/leachate.html

http://www.enpac.com/stinger-railberm

How is a pipeline not a stationary tank?

A pipeline can potentially deliver a lot more oil in a shorter amount of time, leaks can go undetected for years and there is no in situ containment regulation. A pipeline is much more dangerous than a stationary tank.

Page 8: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

How do you contain 250 miles of pipeline?

http://www.prweb.com/releases/2008/10/prweb1391454.htm

http://sierranebraska.org/?p=827

Page 9: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://www.dust-control-inc.com/Landfill-liner.htm

http://weymouthreliefroad.wordpress.com/tag/park-and-ride/

http://www.sedimentremediation.com/GeosyntheticClayLiners.aspxhttp://www.englining.co.za/index.php/canals

http://www.geocheminc.com/canals.htm

http://deereault.com/ditch-canal-design/farmers-high-line-canal.php

We already line canals, landfills, ponds…

A protective underlayment could contain and channel leaks.

Page 10: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://www.dust-control-inc.com/Landfill-liner.htm

http://weymouthreliefroad.wordpress.com/tag/park-and-ride/

http://www.sedimentremediation.com/GeosyntheticClayLiners.aspxhttp://www.englining.co.za/index.php/canals

http://www.geocheminc.com/canals.htm

http://deereault.com/ditch-canal-design/farmers-high-line-canal.php

We already line canals, landfills, ponds…

A protective underlayment could contain and channel leaks.The technology already exists.

Page 11: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://freeassociationdesign.wordpress.com/2010/02/

http://www.prweb.com/releases/2008/10/prweb1391454.htm

The area to be lined for a pipeline is much less

http://www.tencate.com/1844/TenCate-Geosynthetics/Region-Europe/en/en-TenCate-Geosynthetics-Europe/Applications/Reinforcement/Pipeline-construction

and it has already been done.

Page 12: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://freeassociationdesign.wordpress.com/2010/02/

http://www.prweb.com/releases/2008/10/prweb1391454.htm

The area to be lined for a pipeline is much less

http://www.tencate.com/1844/TenCate-Geosynthetics/Region-Europe/en/en-TenCate-Geosynthetics-Europe/Applications/Reinforcement/Pipeline-construction

and it has already been done.

The technology already exists.

Page 13: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

Leaks captured by the underlayment could be funneled to underground tanks or holding ponds.

http://www.marylandaviation.com/_media/client/communityrelations/opes/retention_pond.jpg http://bluegreenbldg.org/wp-content/uploads/

2008/08/bguvparkingswale.jpg

http://www.envirotank.com.au/underground_storage_tanks.htm

http://www.fextex.com/

http://www.america.gov/st/energy-english/2008/March/20080312162449WRybakcuh0.8249105.html

Even Wal-Mart builds containment ponds

Page 14: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

Leaks captured by the underlayment could be funneled to underground tanks or holding ponds.

http://www.marylandaviation.com/_media/client/communityrelations/opes/retention_pond.jpg http://bluegreenbldg.org/wp-content/uploads/

2008/08/bguvparkingswale.jpg

http://www.envirotank.com.au/underground_storage_tanks.htm

http://www.fextex.com/

http://www.america.gov/st/energy-english/2008/March/20080312162449WRybakcuh0.8249105.html

The technology already exists.

Even Wal-Mart builds containment ponds

Page 15: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://freeassociationdesign.wordpress.com/2010/02/

http://www.prweb.com/releases/2008/10/prweb1391454.htm

As all leaks will drain into the valleys, each valleys will need a holding tank large enough to drain the line from ridge to ridge.

Page 16: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://blogs.opb.org/repblog/

2010/07/29/talking-trash-the-rural-

economy-of-garbage/

http://specialtyfabricsreview.com/articles/0709_sw1_landfill.html

http://www.cwengineers.com/services.htm

An over matting would keep rainwater out.

http://www.hiwtc.com/products/hdpe-membrane-material-11527-180336.htm

http://www.fairfaxcounty.gov/dpwes/trash/dispcapp.htm

Page 17: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://blogs.opb.org/repblog/

2010/07/29/talking-trash-the-rural-

economy-of-garbage/

http://specialtyfabricsreview.com/articles/0709_sw1_landfill.html

http://www.cwengineers.com/services.htm

An over matting would keep rainwater out.

http://www.hiwtc.com/products/hdpe-membrane-material-11527-180336.htm

http://www.fairfaxcounty.gov/dpwes/trash/dispcapp.htm

The technology already exists.

Page 18: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://blogs.opb.org/repblog/

2010/07/29/talking-trash-the-rural-

economy-of-garbage/

http://specialtyfabricsreview.com/articles/0709_sw1_landfill.html

http://www.cwengineers.com/services.htm

http://www.toronto.ca/garbage/greenlane/album/06.htm

An over matting would also funnel fuel fumes to sensors that could detect even the smallest hydrocarbon leak.

http://halmapr.com/news/crowcon/page/4/

http://www.contros.eu/products-hydroC-PAH.html

http://www.spectronicdevices.com/OilLeak/oilleakhome.html

http://www.spectronicdevices.com/OilLeak/oilleakhome.html

Sensors already exist to detect petroleum leaks.

Gas detection and sequestration system for a landfill.

Page 19: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://blogs.opb.org/repblog/

2010/07/29/talking-trash-the-rural-

economy-of-garbage/

http://specialtyfabricsreview.com/articles/0709_sw1_landfill.html

http://www.cwengineers.com/services.htm

http://www.toronto.ca/garbage/greenlane/album/06.htm

An over matting would also funnel fuel fumes to sensors that could detect even the smallest hydrocarbon leak.

http://halmapr.com/news/crowcon/page/4/

http://www.contros.eu/products-hydroC-PAH.html

http://www.spectronicdevices.com/OilLeak/oilleakhome.html

http://www.spectronicdevices.com/OilLeak/oilleakhome.html

Sensors already exist to detect petroleum leaks.The technology already exists.

Gas detection and sequestration system for a landfill.

Page 20: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

This set aside land would be developed into a natural parks and preserves.

Improving Nebraska’s natural environment.We propose that: 1. Land should be purchased by TransCanada and donated to a state or a Nebraska NGO environmental trust. The amount of land should equal to 4 times the area of the land for which the pipeline and pipeline construction covered. Because there are a lot of competing interests in land management, it may be of some value to divide that land up among several parties. Selection of the land should be made by the awarded institutions not TransCanada .2. In addition, 4 times the area of land effected by any spill should be purchased and delivered to a Nebraska environmental trust. This assumes that the effected land was completely rehabilitated. If no spills occur, this provision will never be implemented.

http://www.centraltexasnow.com/Global/story.asp?S=13673339&clienttype=printable

http://denr.sd.gov/stimulusdenr.aspx

http://pejnolan.blogspot.com/2010/03/sandhill-cranes.html

Page 21: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

http://www.worldwildlife.org/wildworld/profiles/photos/na/na0809a.html

The technology already exists, using it will put more Nebraskans and Americans to work, improve our nation’s strength, and if done correctly, improve the natural areas of Nebraska.

We have the Technology now.

Page 22: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

Assumptions:• That the pipeline is going to be built and is going to pass through

the Sand Hills. We do not recommend that the pipeline pass through the Sand Hills. Additionally, building the pipeline over the aquifer represents a profoundly risky venture. We do think it can be built and operated in a much safer manner than proposed. (See : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jK_r0F51CFI)

• Underlayment and overlayment are made of material strong enough to withstand a blowout.

• That cutoff stations are frequent enough to allow underground storage tanks to contain all the oil between stations.

• That response time to leaks are within a timeframe that allows the integrity of the containment system to be maintained.

• That the restoration to natural areas by construction activities is 100%.

• This proposal does not address water crossings. Lack of a suitable solution would compromise the legitimacy of these proposals as it represents a huge gap in protecting Nebraska.

• This proposal does not address other environmental concerns including using alternative energy.

Page 23: Making the Keystone XL pipeline safer.

This proposal was completed as part of the requirements for the 2010 Doane College

Conservation Class