Making Arguments About Literature
Transcript of Making Arguments About Literature
-
8/10/2019 Making Arguments About Literature
1/8
"
!"#$%&' )*++,-, #./0/1- 223 #./0/1- 415 6/0,.4.7 80957
!"#$%& ()&*+,%-. (/0*- 1$-,)"-*),
:).,40,5 ;7 != ? @40/, @,,.41A 454B0,5 ;7 C,11/D,. E4+*7F
"#$% $# &'()*$+, -./01/ 2/34/5 67/ 1/8649:1 9; 6741 10..0?)@ 6706 02/ 460.484A/B 0:B 4: ?208C/61D
$7/1/ 02/ :96/1 69 >9E 2/F02B4:F B/=026
F-A/)&A2=%@ G+&%0#C HIIJ@
90+#+ 5+(E-&C' K246/2L1 M/;/2/:8/C K%4 -A@ G)#%(7+0& =%+%- L#0M-&$0%N ('$%), -A0%0)#@ HIOH@
#,;=/0,=3
F7+(E 4%%:>22, (9E21/ 040/*1=3
R)'&$- -S:-(%+%0)#$ +&- +&%0('7+%-A 0# %4- :&-/+%)&N (4+:%-& T%4- (4+:%-& %4+% :&-(-A-$ %4- U/0&$%V (4+:%-&W )/ %4-
G)#%(7+0& =%+%- L#0M-&$0%N -A0%0)# )/' K246/2L1 M/;/2/:8/D 37-+$- &-+A %40$ (4+:%-& M-&N (+&-/'77N +$ 0% 0$ +#
-$$-#%0+7 $'::7-,-#% %) N)'& $N77+/B40/*13
NP:B434BE0. 4:162E86921 302> 1.4F76.> 9: 066/:B0:8/ 0:B 8.011 =026484=0649: =9.484/1QQ:9 QQ795/3/2G 0 ;E..> 02648E.06/B =9.48> 6706 /T=.04:1 4:162E86921L /T=/860649:1 0:B
89:1/UE/:8/1 ;92
QB%%-#A+#(- 0$ -S:-(%-A@ "#Q(7+$$ ?&0%0#8C A0$('$$0)#C +#A )((+$0)#+7 7-(%'&-$ :&)M0A-
0#/)&,+%0)# +#A :&)(-$$-$ -$$-#%0+7 %) '#A-&$%+#A0#8 %4- %-S%$ +#A %) ?&0%0#8 $%&)#8 -$$+N$@
=%'A-#%$ (+# -S:-(% /0#+7 8&+A- :-#+7%0-$ /)& ,0$$0#8 ,)&- %4+# )#- )& %?) (7+$$-$@
Q=0,07+&7NC $%'A-#% :+&%0(0:+%0)# 0$ 40847N M+7'-A 0# /0&$%QN-+& ?&0%0#8 (7+$$-$@ =:-+E0#8 0# (7+$$ 0$+# -S(-77-#% ?+N %) U%&N )'%V 0A-+$ +#A %) 8+0# M+7'+
-
8/10/2019 Making Arguments About Literature
2/8
#
/T=/86/B 6706 XYQZY[ 9; 67/ F20B/ 89:1416 9; 67/ =926;9.49 0:B /110>1D -926;9.491 179E.B ?/ 59267 \] Q R][ 9; F20B/
0:B /110>1 YYQ XY[ 9; 67/ F20B/D $7/ 2/
-
8/10/2019 Making Arguments About Literature
3/8
$
O*.0D*+/*3 Z4- :)&%/)70) +$$08#,-#% ?077 +$E N)' %) /'&%4-& &-M0$- %?) '#0% -$$+N$ +#A %) ?&0%- + %?)Q %) %4&--Q:+8-
&-/7-(%0M- -$$+N@ Z4- :)&%/)70) ?077 j'$%0(- T%?) %) %4&-- ?--E$W
Z4-,+%0( L#0% b>' M0414: 4: $7/ @E:> 9)(',-#%-A 6$$+N T%4&-- ?--E$W
L#0% J> 3)&%/)70) 1-M0-? T)#- ?--EW
8,V,59+, WW P,04/+=
X1/0 %3 6/0,.409., *1 Y4 4B/:64;> 6791/
-
8/10/2019 Making Arguments About Literature
4/8
%
#,,S J1,R )+4== J1,3 210.*59>0/*1 0* X1/0 %
"# (7+$$> Z4-)A)&- 1)-%4E-C kGN 3+:+a$ ;+7%Xk ThHbW@ "#Q(7+$$ ?&0%0#8@ 5+7/ %4- $%'A-#%$ ?077 &-(-0M- )#- $-% )/
`'-$%0)#$ +#A 4+7/ %4- $%'A-#%$ ?077 &-(-0M- +#)%4-&@ e$741 52464:F 54.. 89:1416 9; 659 B4;;/2/:6 2/0B4:F1QQ14G 0?E143/ 31D .934:F ;067/2D $7/ =94:6
9; 67/ /T/2841/ 41 \b 69 1795 16EB/:61 795 UE/1649:1 ./0B 4:6/2=2/60649:1G Rb 69 74F7.4F76 795 67/
C:95./BF/ 5/ ?24:F 4:69 67/ =9/< 0;;/861 4:6/2=2/60649:G 0:B Sb 69 F/6 16EB/:61 69 ?/F4: 69 4B/:64;>
=02648E.02 .4:/1 92 592B1 69 1E==926 67/42 4:6/2=2/60649:1D ';6/2 592C4:F 0.9:/ 69 0:15/2 67/ 592C17//6G16EB/:61 54.. F/6 4: 1
-
8/10/2019 Making Arguments About Literature
5/8
&
"# (7+$$> 1-M0-? )/ +#A :&+(%0(- 0# ?&0%0#8 ()#M-#%0)#$ /)& ?&0%0#8 70%-&+&N 0#%-&:&-%+%0)# :+:-&$C +::&):&0+%-
(0%+%0)#C +#A :7+80+&0$,@ 90$('$$0)# )/ :+:-&$ +#A ?)&E #--A-A /)& %4- /0#+7 A&+/%@
5),-?)&E> ;&0%- /0#+7 A&+/% TbQJ :+8-$W@ F- $'&- %) $'0/*1 0* X1/0 [
"# (7+$$> R)77-(% -$$+N O@ "#%&)A'(%0)# %) %4- L#0%
5),-?)&E> 1-+A R4+&7-$ 3-&&+'7%a$ k\0%%7- 1-A 10A0#8 5))ACk ThIJWC j+E)< +#A ;074-, n&0,,a$ k\0%%7- 1-A R+:k
ThIfWC +#A B#8-7+ R+&%-&a$ kZ4- R),:+#N )/ ;)7M-$k ThOHW@ eP:162E86921 87991/ 69 01C 16EB/:61 69
2/0B 659 0BB4649:0. *466./ M/B 16924/1 a ;29< /467/2 f0287/21W1 K41/ K9 $0./1
;29< '29E:B 67/ K92.BG `/. M/> 0:B g/11./2W1 #:8/ )=9: ' $4 10%'+7 Z4-)&0$% 1-+A0#8 +#A P-,0#0$% Z4-)&0$% &-+A0#8 TP)& /-,0#0$% &-+A0#8C )#- $'88-$%0)# 0$ U10%'+7
Z4-)&N +#A 3&+(%0(-C 22???@A080%+7Q e90$('$$0)#@ n&)': B(%0M0%N[@ O@ Z+7E0#8 +
-
8/10/2019 Making Arguments About Literature
6/8
'
A&+/%@
#,,S Y/K,R )+4== HL*3 #./0/1- #*.S=V*B
"# R7+$$> 90$('$$0)# +#A +(%0M0%N /)& ?)&E0#8 ?0%4 %4- &)'84 A&+/%$@
5),-?)&E> G0AQ3&)(-$$ 9&+/%@ 37-+$- -,+07 0% %) T-,+07 +AA&-$$W 90$('$$0)# )/ 4),-?)&E +#A 0#%&)A'(%0)# )/ %-S%$ )# 8-#A-& +#A q'$%0(-@
5),-?)&E> 1-+A G+S0#- 5)#8 l0#8$%)#C k*) *+,- ;),+#k Tbf^W +#A R4+&7)%%- 3-&E0#$ n07,+#C kZ4- D-77)?
;+77:+:-&k TgHbW@ eZ4-$- %?) A0//-&-#% $%)&0-$C 90$('$$0)# +#A +(%0M0%N /)& ?)&E0#8 ?0%4 %4- &)'84 A&+/%$@ 5),-?)&E> G0AQ3&)(-$$ 9&+/%@ 37-+$- -,+07 0% %)
T-,+07 +AA&-$$W
-
8/10/2019 Making Arguments About Literature
7/8
(
"# R7+$$> n&)': &-M0-? )/ )#- +'%4)& +#A :--& &-M0-?@
5),-?)&E> P0#+7 R):N T$' =,+77 8&)': ?)&E (),:+&0#8 %4- :)-,$@
5),-?)&E> F-80# &-+A0#8 \)&&+0#- 5+#$ 90$('$$0)# )/ 4),-?)&E +#A :7+N
5),-?)&E> P0#0$4 &-+A0#8' M0414: 4: 67/ @E: TbOHQbbOW ;&0%- + HQ:+8- &-$:)#$- %) %4- :7+NC 3--& 1-M0-? +#A A0$('$$0)# )/ +::&):&0+%- A)(',-#%+%0)#
#,,S HL,+K,R )+4== HL*3 P*>9
-
8/10/2019 Making Arguments About Literature
8/8
)
#,,S HV/.0,,1R )+4== HL*3 O*.0D*+/* $,K/,L
3)&%/)70) 0$ A'- )# -S+, A+N@
e;407- %4-&- +&- /)'&%--# ?--E$ 0# %4- $-,-$%-&C %40$ $N77+