Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth...

36
Mahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh Gandhi, Kendra Scurfield Ramesh Iyer, CEO Mahindra & Mahindra Financial Services Limited Mumbai, India January 7 th , 2015 Strategy 2020

Transcript of Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth...

Page 1: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

Mahindra Finance

A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on!

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh Gandhi, Kendra Scurfield

Ramesh Iyer, CEO Mahindra & Mahindra Financial Services Limited

Mumbai, India

January 7th, 2015

Strategy 2020

Page 2: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

2

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Why are we here today?

To help Mahindra Financial Services accelerate profitable growth…

…leveraging off its core-competencies and the technical know-how of Tech Mahindra…

…all the time working towards Mahindra Group’s vision of being a global Top 50 brand!

How can we accelerate growth and drive brand recognition?

Page 3: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

3

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Mahindra Rise!

Expand presence in rural markets • Consumer education • New products • Acquisition

Develop technological capabilities with Tech Mahindra • Software for payment bank • Mobile banking platform

International expansion in developing countries • Rural

Page 4: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

4

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Executive Summary

STRATEGY MICRO-STRATEGY DETAILS

Rural India Expansion -Large rural market (47% untapped) -Low presence in Southern India -Organic growth in N & W, Acquisition 1st in S, then E

Education & Awareness

-The value of savings, how new products work, etc. -Will require staff training through external agency

Geo India -Core competency in rural, not highly competitive urban

International -Start exploring suitable markets in Yr. 3

Products Insurance -Home insurance (to tie in with Home Finance product) -Group/Village insurance (H2O, Grain, Power, etc. costs)

Tech Leverage

Internal Software -Payment Bank systems tie-in, new region intel, etc.

Mobile Banking -Telephone (Voice), SMS, Smartphone App (NO NFC!)

Overall INR 118M revenue projection!

Page 5: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

5

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Alternatives

Urban Rural Domestic International

Page 6: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

6

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Alternatives

Urban Rural Domestic International

To help parent become a global brand we need to expand!

Page 7: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

The Finer Details Let Andrea explain our strategy in a little more detail

Page 8: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

8

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Mahindra Rise!

Expand presence in rural markets • Consumer education • New products • Acquisition

Develop technological capabilities with Tech Mahindra • Software for payment bank • Mobile banking platform

International expansion in developing countries • Rural

Page 9: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

9

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

The Indian Market

´  Young: the average age is 30

´  Contains 21% of the worlds unbanked population

´  Only 53% bank account penetration

Rural India:

´  Low education (10th grade) – low literacy, need high trust

´  69% of the population

´  Villages organized in clusters – clusters are scattered

´  Average income of 10,000 Rs.

´  Industries are focused on agriculture and small trading

Mahindra Finance has built a reputation and trust in the rural market.

Page 10: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

10

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Expand Presence in Rural Markets

Consumer Education:

´ There is low financial literacy in rural India

´ Educate consumers on the importance of saving

´ Collect 100Rs/month (equivalent of $2) ´ Once your technology platforms and payment bank have been developed this can be

done through automatic withdrawal

´ This will increase your total volume of deposits

´ Will need to train your sales force

´ Develop simple education materials with visuals and take language variances into account

Educating consumers on the importance of saving will increase trust and volume of deposits

Page 11: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

11

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Expand Presence in Rural Markets

Organic Growth

´ Focus on north and west regions where you already have a strong hold

´ 2/3 of villages are available for you to reach

´ Utilize your trusted brand and face to face business model when most are moving towards online platforms

Acquisition

´  In the south where you don’t yet have a strong presence

´ Will give you instant access to a large base of rural customers when revenue growth has been slowing

Growth can make Mahindra one of the top financial services company in India

Page 12: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

12

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

New Products

Home Insurance

´  Complementary product to home finance mortgages

´  Homes for all by 2022 will result in 42M new rural homes in the next 7 years

´  Consider customizable and flexible arrangements where the value of the mortgages increases as home completions are undertaken

Group Insurance

´  The village can take out insurance against increasing prices in water, power, or grain

´  Will need to work with village leaders

There is a market for complementary products

Page 13: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

13

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Technology

´  A payment bank will require software to handle deposits

´  Tech Mahindra can develop the software and a mobile platform for customers

´  Will reduce burden of sales force

´ Don’t eliminate face to face sales interactions but use platform to collect/disburse money

´  Will be adopted – young population and high cell phone usage

´  But, smart phone capabilities are not highly developed

´ Will need phone banking, SMS capabilities, and an app

´  Useful for SMEs to make payments to employees and to make deposits

´  Can be used to collect monthly savings from Mahindra customers

Technology can complement your capabilities but don’t replace your sales force

Page 14: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

14

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

International Expansion

´ You have a business model that works in rural markets ´ Face to face business model builds trust

´ Complementary products

´ Customizable to local needs

´  Identify developing and emerging countries with large rural populations, developed agriculture industry, and a lack of banking infrastructure

Your business model is transferrable to other developing markets

Page 15: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

Accept no limits Numbers you can take to the bank

Page 16: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

16

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Income Statement Analysis

6.4% 5.5% 6.8%

9.6%

14.0%

24.3% 22.0% 22.4%

17.9% 15.1%

0.0%

5.0%

10.0%

15.0%

20.0%

25.0%

30.0%

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

Income & Expenses

Provisions & write offs Net income

Focus on decreasing write- offs

Page 17: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

17

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Concerns

4%

3% 3%

4.40%

5.90%

0.60% 0.70% 1.00%

1.90%

2.40%

0%

1%

2%

3%

4%

5%

6%

7%

2011 2012 2013 2014 2015

NPA %

Gross NPA % Net NPA %

Focus on improving the credit profile of the customers by strengthening collections

Page 18: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

18

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Costs

Education and Awareness program  

Training Agency  INR 5 MN  

Mobile Banking  INR 10MN  

Additional Staff (Next 5 years)   5000  

Costs  INR

MN1997  

Page 19: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

19

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Acquisition Valuation

´  EV/EBIDTA multiple : 21.25

´  Value of Sundram finance: 225 million Rs

´  Value of Shriram City: 191 million Rs

´  Other costs: 75 million

´  End result top 2 company in terms of revenue

Assumption:

-Cost of capital 12.5 %

Page 20: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

20

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Risky Alternatives: DO NOT Enter Urban Market

´  Difficult to penetrate in a highly competitive market

´  Growth is possible by capturing new geographies- rural

´  100 smart cities will be made by converting majority of semi-urban cities

´  Difficult to build relationships with customer in urban market

Do not enter urban market

STOP

Page 21: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

21

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Risky Alternatives: DO NOT do NFC

´  (Near Field Communications)

´  Difficult to build trust with rural customers

´  Fear of loosing cards, and the fear loosing money

´  Card system not yet trusted in rural population, (however this is increasing)

´  No solid infrastructure for merchants

DO NOT do NFC

STOP

Page 22: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

22

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Mahindra Rise!

Expand presence in rural markets • Consumer education • New products • Acquisition

Develop technological capabilities with Tech Mahindra • Software for payment bank • Mobile banking platform

International expansion in developing countries • Rural

Page 23: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

How can we enable rural residents to create more value in their lives?

Page 24: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

24

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Forward Thinking

The are ideas we think are worth considering, however we are not recommending them at this time.

´  Enter consumer financing market by providing loans for consumer products, and necessary goods for small business.

´  Launch an incubator program for entrepreneurial ideas that emerge in the rural market. (Structure, a deal that give Mahindra Financing a board seat and ownership.

Future consideration, NOT NOW

Page 25: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

25

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Mahindra Rise!

Expand presence in rural markets • Consumer education • New products • Acquisition

Develop technological capabilities with Tech Mahindra • Software for payment bank • Mobile banking platform

International expansion in developing countries • Rural

Page 26: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

To be able to come a well respected financial service market we recommend that Mahindra Finance focus on expanding rurally in India, working with Mahindra IT to develop technology, and look intro entering like international markets.

Page 27: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

27

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Mahindra Finance

The importance of creating a trusted brand image with the rural population. This can be communicating, trust, understanding, and educating the rural consumer.

Rural Population

Un educated Seasonal income Low income Spread out Not trusting of

private banks

Increasing mobile/internet

connectivity

Page 28: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

28

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Marketing

´  Develop strong customer service policy and training guide

´  Focus on understanding the fears and uncertainties of the rural customer

´  Focus on TRUST and EDUCATION

´  Initiatives:

´  Advertise in stores where customers purchase supplies

´  Advertise in News Paper

´  Develop online/mobile presence

´  Launch savings education

´  Work with communities to provide jobs for the young and ambitious

Page 29: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

29

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Group Insurance

´  Reduce risk of seasonal income

´  Reduce risk of rising cost

´  Allows for budgeting

´  Hedges commodities/costs in the forward market

Page 30: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

30

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Financing the Rise of Mahindra: Year 1

Months 1-3

Develop education training guides for sales staff.

Develop new rural consumer customer packages

Start development on mobile and telephone banking

Hire new sales staff

Months 4-6

Complete training of first wave of new sales staff

Open 13 new locations

Launch new product offering

Launch customer savings education

Months 6-9

Start researching companies to acquire in the south of India.

Develop HR culture guide.

Months 10-12

Have 1000 new employees hired

Have 25 new stores opened

Have shortlist of companies to purchase made.

Year 1: Focus on India

Page 31: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

31

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Financing The Rise of Mahindra: Year 1-5

Year 1 • Expand reach in North

and west India. • Launch new product • Hire 1000

Year 2 • Acquire a company in

the South of India • Focus of the

Government housing program

• Corporate culture initiative

Year 3 • Research international

growth opportunities • Open 25 new stores • Hire 1000 new people

Year 4 • Enter international

market, with pilot program

Year 5 • Be the leader in rural

finance service • Become top finance

brand

How you become a global top brand

Page 32: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

32

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Risks and Mitigation

Risk Mitigation Likelihood Impact

Customer Default Small loans easy payback

M L

Currency/ interest fluctuations

Hedge on international markets

M h

Customer Fears Educate H L

Cyber security Secure coding M H

Telephone security Passcode and secure lines

M H

The risks can be managed

Page 33: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

33

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

You asked?

Our strategy answers all your questions!

1.  Should Mahindra Finance stick to its core rural and semi-urban market, or expand into urban markets?

1.  We say RURAL

2.  How can the company straddle being an asset financing company and a payment bank?

1.  Through integration

3.  How can you use new technology to capture new opportunity? 1.  Cross selling products

4.  Should Mahindra Finance expand to other markets like the US, RSA, SK, China OR focus on India?

1.  Focus expansion on rural population in developing nations

5.  What new capabilities does Mahindra Finance need? 1.  Tech support

Page 34: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

Enriching Lives

Page 35: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

35

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Mahindra Rise!

Expand presence in rural markets • Consumer education • New products • Acquisition

Develop technological capabilities with Tech Mahindra • Software for payment bank • Mobile banking platform

International expansion in developing countries • Rural

Page 36: Mahindra Finance Strategy 2020 - · PDF fileMahindra Finance A real-world, real rural growth strategy you can bank on! HASKAYNE H C CONSULTING Alex Walkey, Andrea Mamchur, Rishabh

36

HASKAYNE CONSULTING H C

Executive Summary

STRATEGY MICRO-STRATEGY DETAILS

Rural India Expansion -Large rural market (47% untapped) -Low presence in Southern India -Organic growth in N & W, Acquisition 1st in S, then E

Education & Awareness

-The value of savings, how new products work, etc. -Will require staff training through external agency

Geo India -Core competency in rural, not highly competitive urban

International -Start exploring suitable markets in Yr. 3

Products Insurance -Home insurance (to tie in with Home Finance product) -Group/Village insurance (H2O, Grain, Power, etc. costs)

Tech Leverage

Internal Software -Payment Bank systems tie-in, new region intel, etc.

Mobile Banking -Telephone (Voice), SMS, Smartphone App (NO NFC!)

Overall INR 118M revenue projection!