Exhibit 32 USA Today: Objectives of charter schools with Turkish ties questioned 08/17/2010

Pages 1 2

Home News Travel Money Sports

News Education

Q&A

Fethullah Gulen responded to questions from USA TODAY's Greg Toppo that were submitted through an intermediary.

Q: Would he reflect on his connection to the U.S. public charter schools inspired by the Gulen movement?

A: First of all, I do not approve the title "Gulen Movement" given to the civil society movement that I call "volunteers' movement." I see myself one of its participants. There might be some educators who have listened to or read my thoughts on humanity, peace, mutual respect, the culture of coexistence, and keeping the human values alive, and have come to the United States for various reasons and work at private or public schools. In fact, I have heard from the media that there are such educators.

I have no idea about the number of such educators in the United States. My relation to them is not different from the one between me and any academician working at a U.S. university who may somehow value my thoughts. Those are individuals whom I do not know personally, though they may be familiar with and may think that they benefit from my books and speeches.

Q: Does he take pride in the schools, which are quickly multiplying and are generally high-performing?

A: I do not have specific knowledge about the schools which are referred to in the question, nor about their academic successes. If they are successful in contributing to human well-being, love, social peace and harmony, I would applaud that. Indeed, I wish any activities contributing to the shared human values to be successful, whether they are in the field of education or any other fields of human endeavor. I do not differentiate between ethnic or religious backgrounds in this concern. This is a consequence of my being human.

Q: How does he feel about the school leaders' recent assertions in the U.S. press that the schools have "no organic connection" to Mr. Gulen or the movement?

A: I do not regularly follow the U.S. press. It is well-known that I have no relation with any institution in the form of ownership, board membership, or any similar kind. For many decades, I have expressed my ideas and opinions about social issues facing humanity. Many people have listened to my speeches and read my works. I do not approve that those who are familiar with and share these ideas and opinions to any extent, or the institutions they work at, should be viewed as connected with my person.

CHARTER SCHOOLS BY THE NUMBERS

5,043: Total public schools founded, or "chartered," by universities, private groups or even teachers in the USA

1,536,099: Number of students

39: Number of states in which charters exist, plus the District of Columbia

Source: Center for Education Reform, a D.C. charter-school advocacy group

Enlarge Fgulen.com

Charter schools inspired by Fethullah Gulen operate in 100 countries, including the USA.

Share

Add to Mixx

Facebook

Twitter

More

Cars Auto Financing Event Tickets Jobs Real Estate Online Degrees Shopping

Search How do I find it? Subscribe to paper

Videos you may be interested in

$140s TO $350s

EducationGet information on education programs that could help you increase your earning power.

Quick Degree Finder Select a Degree Level Select a Category Select a Subject

Find Now!

Objectives of charter schools with Turkish ties questionedUpdated 8/17/2010 9:36 AM | Comment | Recommend E-mail | Print |

By Greg Toppo, USA TODAY

They have generic, forward-sounding names like Horizon Science Academy, Pioneer Charter School of Science and Beehive Science & Technology Academy.

Quietly established over the past decade by a loosely affiliated group of Turkish-American educators, these 100 or so publicly funded charter schools in 25 states are often among the top-performing public schools in their towns.

The schools educate as many as 35,000 students taken together they'd make up the largest charter school network in the USA and have imported thousands of Turkish educators over the past decade.

But the success of the schools at times has been clouded by nagging questions about what ties the schools may have to a reclusive Muslim leader in his late 60s living in exile in rural Pennsylvania.

Described by turns as a moderate Turkish nationalist, a peacemaker and "contemporary Islam's Billy Graham," Fethullah Glen has long pushed for Islam to occupy a more central role in Turkish society. Followers of the so-called Glen Movement operate an "education, media and business network" in more than 100 countries, says University of Oregon sociologist Joshua Hendrick.

Top administrators say they have no official ties to Glen. And Glen himself denies any connection to the schools. Still, documents available at various foundation websites and in federal forms required of non-profit groups show that virtually all of the schools have opened or operate with the aid of Glen-inspired "dialogue" groups, local non-profits that promote Turkish culture. In one case, the Ohio-based Horizon Science Academy of Springfield in 2005 signed a five-year building lease with the parent organization of Chicago's Niagara Foundation, which promotes Glen's philosophy of "peace, mutual respect, the culture of coexistence." Glen is the foundation's honorary president. In many cases, charter school board members also serve as dialogue group leaders.

Education officials who are familiar with them say the schools aren't trying to proselytize for Glen's vision of Turkey. While Turkish language and culture are often offered in the curriculum, there's no evidence the schools teach Islam.

Nelson Smith, former president of the National Alliance of Public Charter Schools, a Washington, D.C.-based advocacy group, sees no evidence of an "active network. What I do see is a really impressive group of educators."

The Turkish-affiliated schools focus on math and science and often appear as top scorers on standardized tests. Still, lawmakers, researchers and parents are beginning to put the schools under the microscope for hiring practices they import hundreds of teachers from Turkey each year and for steps they take to keep their academic profile high.

The schools' unacknowledged ties to Glen, they say, mock public schools' spirit of transparency.

"That's what I was always asking for," says Kelly Wayment, a former board member and parent at Beehive Science & Technology Academy in Holladay, Utah. He has pressed for more than a year to get the school to acknowledge ties to Glen. "I said, 'Parents have a right to know.' "

Wayment says Beehive removed him from the board last year after he began investigating the decision to fire a popular Spanish teacher, saying it was based on a single classroom visit by the Tustin, Calif.-based Accord Institute of Education Research, an education services company with ties to a chain of California charter schools inspired by Glen. He complained to Utah state Rep. Jim Dunnigan, a Republican lawmaker, who launched an audit of charter school governance the audit is ongoing.

But Beehive's Karlene Welker says Wayment "removed himself (from the board) by pulling his students out of the school."

Utah's State Charter School Board launched an investigation last year after American teachers complained that Turkish colleagues got hiring and promotion preferences.

The charter school board looked into Beehive's ties to Islam and found them "circumstantial," but a financial probe found that the school was $337,000 in the red and that Accord officials had loaned it thousands. The board last April revoked its charter, but in June voted to keep the school open on probation.

Dunnigan, the state lawmaker who requested the legislative audit, says the financial details, such as personal loans and

by TaboolaPromoted Links

Watch 737 MAX take off on first flight

The NFL's Super Bowl soccer controversy

The Fastest Way To Pay Off $10,LendingTree

More videos

College Blog Best Value Colleges Student Engagement

Become a member of the USA TODAY community now!

Log in | Become a memberWhat's this?

Objectives of charter schools with Turkish ties questioned - USATODAY.com

2/1/2016http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/education/2010-08-17-turkishfinal17_CV_N.htm

Exhibit 32, Page 1 of 2

EDUCATION NEWS ON TWITTER

To view this presentation, you need to install the Flash plug-in

GET IT NOW

Mixx

public funds spent recruiting overseas faculty, are what concern him. "When they're in such financial difficulty, should they spend $53,000 to bring these people over from another country?"

But questions about hiring and academics also have arisen in Arizona, where Daisy Education Corp. runs five schools and has received certifications for 120 H-1B visas for foreign teachers since 2002, records show. In Texas, the Cosmos Foundation has filed 1,157 H1-B applications since 2001. It operates 25 Harmony schools statewide. Since 2001, Harmony has imported 731 employees using H-1Bs, surpassing all other secondary

education providers nationwide. Parents last year also accused one Harmony school of "pushing out" underperforming students a charge the Texas Education Agency confirmed.

Ed Fuller, a University of Texas-Austin researcher, found that Harmony schools throughout Texas had an "extraordinarily high" student attrition rate of about 50% for students in grades six through eight.

"It's not hard to be 'exemplary' if you lose all the kids who aren't performing," Fuller says.

Crossing the line?

At minimum, the rapid growth of the Turkish-affiliated schools shows how the freewheeling world of charter schools has changed the face of K-12 education in the USA.

In most cases, charters are loosely regulated in exchange for improved performance. A few schools are affiliated with religious groups or offer programs that others can't. But in several cases, a school's orientation has forced it to show that it's not crossing lines and endorsing religion. Examples:

Tarek ibn Ziyad Academy, a Minnesota charter school authorized by Islamic Relief USA, a Virginia-based aid group. In 2008, the school ran afoul of state officials who said having teachers take part in voluntary Friday prayers could give students the impression that the school endorsed Islam.

Sacramento City Unified School District in California, which for 12 years has fought a lawsuit that says the city's Waldorf schools are based on the religious beliefs of the Austrian philosopher Rudolf Steiner.

Whether such schools continue to grow is no small question, since President Obama has made charter school expansion a priority.

While the Turkish-affiliated schools disavow any connection to the Glen Movement, Glen himself maintains in legal filings that he's the inspiration behind their growth. But William Martin of Rice University in Houston says educators' assertions of "no organic connection" to Glen are accurate.

Nonetheless, he says their efforts to minimize ties to Glen, likely from fear of being branded Islamists, bring "unnecessary and probably counterproductive" suspicion. "I do not think they are a sinister organization."

In an e-mail interview, Mehmet Argin, principal of Tucson's Sonoran Science Academy, says his school's parent corporation, Daisy Education Corp., "has no legal or organic ties" with other schools. He cautions against linking charter schools founded by Turkish-Americans directly to the Glen Movement "just because Turkish-Americans may be inspired by Mr. Glen."

In an e-mail interview, Glen denied any direct connection to these schools, rejecting the notion that there is a "Glen Movement," but acknowledging there may be educators now in U.S. schools who have listened to his philosophy. "I have no relation with any institution in the form of ownership, board membership or any similar kind," he said.

A 'third force'

Glen has pushed for more dialogue between the Western and Muslim worlds, yet he is a controversial figure in Turkey.

The University of Oregon's Hendrick, whose writings explore the Glen Movement, calls him "Turkey's most famous religious personality." His movement is considered the nation's "third force" alongside the military and Turkey's ruling Adalet ve Kalknma Partisi, or AKP Party.

In 1999, after traveling to the USA for medical treatment, Glen was charged in Turkey with trying to create an Islamic state. Since then he has remained in Pennsylvania. After the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Service in 2007 denied his bid for a visa as an "alien of extraordinary ability in education," Glen sued, saying his followers "had established more than 600 educational institutions" worldwide. He eventually prevailed, earning a green card in 2008. But Turkish educators in the USA continue to disavow their ties.

"Glen is both the reason behind his schools, and he has nothing whatsoever to do with them," Hendrick says.

Selected for you by a sponsor:

Do You Have Royal Blood? Your Last Name May Tell You. (Ancestry)

Posted 8/16/2010 8:06 PM

Updated 8/17/2010 9:36 AM E-mail | Print |

To report corrections and clarifications, contact Standards Editor Brent Jones. For publication consideration in the newspaper, send comments to letters@usatoday.com. Include name, phone number, city and state for verification. To view our corrections, go to corrections.usatoday.com.

Guidelines: You share in the USA TODAY community, so please keep your comments smart and civil. Don't attack other readers personally, and keep your language decent. Use the "Report Abuse" button to make a difference. Read more.

Newspaper Home Delivery - Subscribe Today

Home News Travel Money Sports Life Tech Weather

About USATODAY.com: Site Map | FAQ | Contact Us | Jobs with Us | Terms of ServicePrivacy Policy/Your California Privacy Right | Advertise | Press Room | Developer | Media Lounge | Reprints and Permissions

News Your Way: Mobile News | Email News | Add USATODAY.com RSS feeds | Twitter | Podcasts | Widgets

Partners: USA WEEKEND | Sports Weekly | Education | Space.com | Travel Tips

Copyright 2011 USA TODAY, a division of Gannett Co. Inc.

Objectives of charter schools with Turkish ties questioned - USATODAY.com

2/1/2016http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/news/education/2010-08-17-turkishfinal17_CV_N.htm

Exhibit 32, Page 2 of 2