Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income (Slides)
-
Upload
barcelona-graduate-school-of-economics-gse -
Category
Economy & Finance
-
view
282 -
download
1
description
Transcript of Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income (Slides)
Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income
Gregor Schubert
June 27, 2014
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 1 / 23
Motivation
In the mid-20th century, economists considered it an empirical‘stylized fact’ that labor shares of income were constant (e.g. Kaldor(1961))
I “For a long time, the idea accepted by most economists anduncritically repeated in textbooks was that the relative shares of laborand capital in national income were quite stable over the long run.”– Thomas Piketty (2014), “Capital in the Twenty-First Century”
In theory, Cobb-Douglas production function with competitive factormarkets implies constant factor shares of income
BUT: Recent data show large variations in the labor share bothwithin and between countries (e.g. Karabarbounis & Neiman (2014))
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 2 / 23
Motivation
-6-4
-20
2
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010
Corporate LS Total LS
Change in the Labor Share since 1975 (in ppt)
Source: Author’s calculation based on data from Karabarbounis & Neiman (2014)
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 3 / 23
Motivation
Several different explanations have been advanced to explain thesechanges in the labor share:
I Capital account openness (e.g. Jayadev(2007)) and trade shares(Harrison (2005))
I Relative price of investment goods (Karabarbounis & Neiman (2014))I Decline in Unionization and rise of offshoring (Elsby et al. (2013))
This paper provides a new explanation based on changes inmacroeconomic risk over time
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 4 / 23
This Paper
1 Develops a tractable theoretical model of the determination of thelabor share of income, incorporating risk premia for macroeconomicfluctuations into factor supply functions
2 Identifies two macro-risk factors that should affect the labor share:I Inflation varianceI Covariance of inflation and productivity shocks
3 Tests the predicted effect of these macro-risk factors empirically incross-country panel of OECD countries (1975-2010)
I Compares alternative explanations for variations in the labor shareagainst macro-risk story
I Explores impact of macro-risk factors on labor force participation rate
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 5 / 23
Theoretical Model - Key Assumptions
Both workers and capital investors are risk-averse
Workers’ household income comes from wages, while capital investors’income depends on firm profitability and aggregate productivityshocks
CES production technology with low elasticity of substitution (σ < 1):
Yt = θt
[(1 − α)L
σ−1σ
t + αKσ−1σ
t
] σσ−1
Nominal wages are determined in advance before inflation shocks areobserved
Workers are heterogeneous with regard to risk aversion and firms canwage-discriminate between workers based on reservation wage
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 6 / 23
Theoretical Results1 Higher inflation risk leads to a lower labor share of income
I Workers demand higher risk premium proportional to their risk aversionI Difference between marginal wage and average wage increases, which
decreases the non-capital share of income going to labor
LD
LS(σ2π,3)
LS2(σ2π,2)
LS1(σ2π,3)
L∗2
w∗2
Ut
LI2
Labor Force
Wage
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 7 / 23
Theoretical Results2 Higher covariance between inflation and productivity growth leads to
a lower labor share of incomeI Capital investors demand higher risk premium because single firm
profits become more correlated with the overall portfolio performanceI Capital share of income increases with rental rate due to low elasticity
of substitution
LD2 (r2)
LD1 (r1)
LS
L∗2
w∗2
Ut
LI2
Labor Force
Wage
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 8 / 23
Theoretical Results
3 Higher out-of-work benefits lead to a higher labor share of income.I Higher wage demanded at every level of risk aversion raises non-capital
share of income due to low elasticity of substitution
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 9 / 23
Empirical Strategy
Data:I Unbalanced panel of 18 OECD countries for 1975-2010I Focus on corporate labor share (CLS) to avoid measurement issues for
unincorp. businesses
Estimation: IV regression in first differences, instrumenting forlagged diff. of CLS using 2nd and 3rd lags of CLS and unemp. rate
Specification
sL,t = δ0 + δ1sL,t−1 + δ2σθ,π,t + δ3σπ,t + δ4Ut + β′Xt + ui + εt
I sL,t : Labor share of income (in %)I σθ,π,t : Covariance of RGDP growth and CPI inflation (5 years trailing)I σπ,t : Standard deviation of CPI inflation (5 years trailing)I Ut : Social expenditures (% of GDP)I Xt : Control variables (e.g. GDP(PPP) per cap., Population, Risk-free
interest rate)I ui : Country-fixed effect
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 10 / 23
Empirical Results
Estimated effects of the macro-risk factors on the labor share areconsistently negative and statistically and economically significant
I Results are robust to controlling for alternative drivers of CLSvariations: Trade Share, Cap. Acc. Openness, Union Density, RelativePrice of Inv. Goods
A one standard deviation (SD) increase in inflation risk decreases thelabor share by 1.3-2.0 ppt (0.4-0.6 SD)
A one SD increase in the covariance risk decreases the labor share by1.6-1.9 ppt (0.5-0.6 SD)
Higher social expenditures increase the labor share
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 11 / 23
Conclusions
1 Macroeconomic risk affects the labor share of incomeI Macroeconomic policy may matter for distribution questions
2 Changes in the labor share may reflect changing risk premiaI Variations in the labor share can be neutral for worker welfare
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 12 / 23
Thank you for your attention!
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 13 / 23
Appendix
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 14 / 23
Labor Supply
Workers decide between working and receiving uncertain real incomethat varies with inflation, or certain benefits of not-working.
Standard intertemporal optimization with CRRA utility implies thatworkers with consumption process ∆ct+1
ct= δ0 − δ1νt+1 - where νt+1 is
an inflation shock - demand a risk premium such that the real wage is
E [wRt+1] ≈ Ut+1 + wN
t+1γRβδ1σ2π,t+1
where Ut is the value of not-working, γ is the degree of risk aversion,R is the risk-free IR, β is the discount factor, and σ2
π,t is the varianceof inflation shocks
Assuming that workers are uniformly distributed over risk aversion,such that kL = γ, the labor supply will be given by
LSt =wNt − Ut
wNt kRβδ1σ2
π,t
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 15 / 23
Labor Demand and Capital Risk Premium
Capital investors receive returns that are a function of profits, andtherefore of inflation shocks (e.g. dividends):
Rt+1 = Et [Rt+1] + ρ1νt+1
Standard intertemporal optimization with CRRA utility and investor
consumption process∆ckt+1
ckt= τ0 + τ1εt+1 - where εt+1 is an
aggregate productivity shock - imply a rental rate of capital of
Et [rt+1] = Et [Rt+1] − 1 = R − 1 + γβRρ1τ1σπ,θ,t+1
where ρ1,τ1 are positive constants, and σ2π,θ,t is the covariance of
inflation and productivity shocks
Taking first-order conditions of standard profit maximization problemfor the firm, we can then find the labor demand function to be
LDt =Yt
θt
[(1 − α) + α
(α
1 − α
)σ−1(w∗trt
)σ−1] σ
1−σ
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 16 / 23
Labor Share of Income
We can write the labor share of income in the following way:
sL,t =LItYt
=LIt
w∗t L∗t
w∗t L∗t
Yt=
LItw∗t L
∗t
(1 − sK ,t)
Then, we use the FOC of the firm to replace sK ,t and integrate overwage demand curve to find LIt
After simplifying, the labor share is given by
sL,t = (1 − r1−σt (αθt)
σ)Ut ln
(w∗tUt
)(w∗t − Ut)
−1
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 17 / 23
Extension: Labor Force Participation Rate
Theoretical Predictions:1 Higher inflation risk leads to a lower labor force participation rate
(LFPR)2 Higher covariance risk leads to a higher LFPR3 Higher out-of-work benefits lead to a lower LFPR
Empirical Results:I Estimated inflation risk coefficient is robustly negativeI Results for covariance risk and benefits have the right sign but are not
significantI All three effect sizes are small empirically
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 18 / 23
Empirical Results: Risk and the Labor Share Table
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 19 / 23
Empirical Results: Robustness Checks Table
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 20 / 23
Empirical Results: Labor Force Participation Table
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 21 / 23
Labor Share for Biggest OECD Economies
5560
6570
Labo
r Sha
re
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010Year
United States
5055
60La
bor S
hare
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010Year
Japan
5560
6570
Labo
r Sha
re
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010Year
Germany
5560
6570
Labo
r Sha
re
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010Year
United Kingdom
5560
6570
75La
bor S
hare
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010Year
France
5055
6065
Labo
r Sha
re
1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010Year
Italy
Labor Share of Income in Large OECD Economies
Source: Author’s calculation based on data from Karabarbounis & Neiman (2014)
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 22 / 23
Summary Statistics
Gregor Schubert Macroeconomic Risk and the Labor Share of Income June 27, 2014 23 / 23