Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

28
Machining Process Optimization Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303 with ISO 10303 - - 238 238 Leon Leon Xu Xu The Boeing Company The Boeing Company Copyright Copyright ; ; The Boeing Company. All rights reserved The Boeing Company. All rights reserved

Transcript of Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Page 1: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Machining Process Optimization Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303with ISO 10303--238238

Leon Leon XuXuThe Boeing CompanyThe Boeing Company

Copyright Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedThe Boeing Company. All rights reserved

Page 2: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 22

Machining Process OptimizationMachining Process Optimization

Machining ParametersMachining Parameters

Machine ConstraintsMachine Constraints

ProductivityProductivity

Cutting ForceCutting Force

Page 3: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 33

Machining System ConstraintsMachining System Constraints

Cutting tools

Machine/spindle capability

System structural dynamics

-Spindle power, torque and speed-Spindle bearings-Tool holder-Axis torque and speed

-Machine/spindle/fixture-Cutting tool/holder/spindle

-Edge rigidity-Surface velocity-Rotational speed-Wear

Page 4: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 44

Affecting FactorsAffecting Factors

Machining parameters

Material properties

Cutting tool dimensions

Page 5: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 55

Cutting Parameters and Path GeometryCutting Parameters and Path Geometry

Removed MaterialAxial Depth

Radial Depth

Center Line

Rotation Speed

Feed Rate

Page 6: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 66

Information in MInformation in M--G Code (ISO 6983)G Code (ISO 6983)Rotation Speed

Feed Rate

Center Line

N1 G49N1 G49N2 T10M6N2 T10M6N3 G90N3 G90N4 G43.5H10I0J0K1N4 G43.5H10I0J0K1N5 M3S7958N5 M3S7958N6 G1X0Y0Z30F0N6 G1X0Y0Z30F0N7 X99.8497YN7 X99.8497Y--149.3009Z10149.3009Z10N8 G0Z4N8 G0Z4N9 ZN9 Z--22N10 G1ZN10 G1Z--4F8355.94F8355.9N11 X89.8497YN11 X89.8497Y--165.6804165.6804N12 X88.6399YN12 X88.6399Y--167.6621167.6621N13 X84.5787YN13 X84.5787Y--173.9364173.9364N14 X79.9216YN14 X79.9216Y--180.683180.683N15 X75.4355YN15 X75.4355Y--186.7118186.7118N16 X69.814YN16 X69.814Y--193.8761193.8761N17 X65.1231YN17 X65.1231Y--199.3388199.3388N18 X62.8337YN18 X62.8337Y--201.9142201.9142N19 X53.9447YN19 X53.9447Y--211.9142211.9142……………………

Page 7: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 77

Information in ISO 10303Information in ISO 10303--238238

Removed MaterialAxial Depth

Radial Depth

Rotation Speed

Feed Rate

Center Line

Page 8: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 88

CrossCross--Sectional Area in ISO 10303Sectional Area in ISO 10303--238238

ISO 10303-238:2007 Technical Corrigendum 1

Page 9: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 99

Examples of CrossExamples of Cross--Sectional AreaSectional Area

ADmax

RDmax

CG CG CG

ADmax ADmax

RDmax RDmax

Page 10: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1010

Engagement LocationsEngagement Locations

Page 11: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1111

Engagement StartEngagement Start--End ConditionsEnd Conditions

RD RDRD RD

Climb Milling Conventional Milling Slotting (Channel Cutting) Center Cutting

Page 12: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1212

Maximum Engagement ConditionsMaximum Engagement Conditions

RD

AD

RD

Page 13: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1313

Current Optimization ProcessCurrent Optimization Process

STEP-NCWork Plan(Original)

3-D Stock Model

ISO 6983NC Program

(Original)

3-DSimulation

STEP-NCWork Plan

(Cross-Section)

STEP-NCWork Plan

(Optimized)Optimization

Cross-Section

ISO 6983NC Program(Optimized)

CNC Machine

Page 14: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1414

Future Optimization ProcessFuture Optimization Process

STEP-NCWork Plan

(Cross-Section)

STEP-NCWork Plan

(Optimized)Optimization CNC Machine

Page 15: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1515

Optimization MethodsOptimization Methods

Volume Based OptimizationVolume Based OptimizationForce Based OptimizationForce Based OptimizationTool Wear OptimizationTool Wear OptimizationConstant Chip OptimizationConstant Chip OptimizationUserUser--defined Optimizationdefined Optimization

Page 16: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1616

Radial ChipRadial Chip--Thinning CompensationThinning Compensation

tp

tm tm’

fd fd’

tp’

RDRD

Page 17: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1717

Axial ChipAxial Chip--Thinning CompensationThinning Compensation

tp

tm tm’

fd fd’

tp’

ADAD

Page 18: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1818

Feed/Tooth Feed/Tooth vsvs Radial ImmersionRadial Immersion

-

0.025

0.050

0.075

0.100

0.125

0.150

0.175

0.200

0% 25% 50% 75% 100%

fz(m

m)

D=10mm

D=8mm

Page 19: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 1919

Feed and Radial Depth (T7)Feed and Radial Depth (T7)

0100200300400500600700800900

1000

1 41 81 121 161 201 241 281 321 361 401 441 481 521 561 601 641 681

Orig

Opt

0123456789

10

1 39 77 115 153 191 229 267 305 343 381 419 457 495 533 571 609 647 685

RD

Page 20: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2020

Feed and Radial Depth (T9)Feed and Radial Depth (T9)

0

200

400

600

800

1000

1200

1400

1600

1 41 81 121 161 201 241 281 321 361 401 441 481 521 561 601 641 681

Orig

Opt

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

1 39 77 115 153 191 229 267 305 343 381 419 457 495 533 571 609 647 685

RD

Page 21: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2121

Feed OptimizationFeed Optimization

Page 22: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2222

Optimization for Different MachinesOptimization for Different Machines

Machining

NCProgram

Opt. NCProgram

Optimization

Machining

Opt. NCProgram

Optimization

Machining

Opt. NCProgram

Optimization

STEP-NC

Page 23: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2323

Optimization of Different ProgramsOptimization of Different Programs

NCProgram

Machining

Opt. NCProgram

Optimization

NCProgram

NCProgram

STEP-NC STEP-NCSTEP-NC

Page 24: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2424

Machining Process OptimizationMachining Process Optimization

Design Programming MachiningCADModel

NCProgram

-- Feed and speedFeed and speed

Page 25: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2525

Machining Planning OptimizationMachining Planning Optimization

Design Programming MachiningCADModel

NCProgram

-- Feed and speedFeed and speed-- Path trajectory, radial and axial depths, number of Path trajectory, radial and axial depths, number of

passespasses……

Page 26: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2626

Machining Design OptimizationMachining Design Optimization

Design Programming MachiningCADModel

NCProgram

-- ““Machining friendlyMachining friendly”” feature designfeature design

Page 27: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2727

Total Manufacturing OptimizationTotal Manufacturing Optimization

Design Programming MachiningCADModel

NCProgram

Page 28: Machining Process Optimization with ISO 10303-238

Copyright The Boeing Company. All rights reservedCopyright The Boeing Company. All rights reserved 2828

Thank you!Thank you!