M E M O R A N D U M - nfpa.org · PDF fileMacDonald, Quadrini, Randall, Robbins, Ronan, Shea,...

download M E M O R A N D U M - nfpa.org · PDF fileMacDonald, Quadrini, Randall, Robbins, Ronan, Shea, ... Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A. Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard

If you can't read please download the document

Transcript of M E M O R A N D U M - nfpa.org · PDF fileMacDonald, Quadrini, Randall, Robbins, Ronan, Shea,...

  • National Fire Protection Association 1 Batterymarch Park, Quincy, MA 02169-7471 Phone: 617-770-3000 Fax: 617-770-0700 www.nfpa.org

    M E M O R A N D U M TO: NFPA Technical Committee on Semiconductor and Related Facilities FROM: Colleen Kelly, Administrator, Technical Projects DATE: November 14, 2013 SUBJECT: NFPA 318 SD TC Ballot Circulation (A2014) The November 12, 2013 date for receipt of the NFPA 318 Second Draft ballot has passed. The preliminary Second Draft ballot results are shown on the attached report. 30 Members Eligible to Vote 18 Ballots Not Returned (Aho, Backstrom, Brown, Dryden, Fox, Joo, Kidd, Lattanzio,

    MacDonald, Quadrini, Randall, Robbins, Ronan, Shea, Trammell, Vogel, White, Wyman)

    In accordance with the NFPA Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards, attached are reasons for negative votes for review so you may change your ballot if you wish. Abstentions and affirmative comments are also included. Ballots received from alternate members are not included unless the ballot from the principal member was not received. If you wish to change your vote, the change must be received at NFPA on or before November 21, 2013. Members who have not returned a ballot may do so now. Such changes should be submitted through the NFPA Vote.net Ballot Site, The return of ballots is required by the Regulations Governing the Development of NFPA Standards.

  • 318 SCR-AAA Second Draft Ballot Circulation (A2014)

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    SR-11, Section No. 2.2, See SR-11

    Total Voted : 12

    For two-third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 8

    For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 16

    For two-third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 8

    For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 16

    Results by Revision

    SR-8, Global Comment, See SR-8

    Total Voted : 12

    Page 1 of 13

    http://submittals.nfpa.org/TerraViewWeb/FormLaunch?id=/TerraView/Content/318-2012.ditamap/2/C1381325487089.xml&viewmode=nfpa/xslt/nfpaviewmode.xslhttp://submittals.nfpa.org/TerraViewWeb/FormLaunch?id=/TerraView/Content/318-2012.ditamap/2/C1379089587190.xml&viewmode=nfpa/xslt/nfpaviewmode.xsl

  • 318 SCR-AAA Second Draft Ballot Circulation (A2014)

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    SR-25, New Section after 2.3.2, See SR-25

    Total Voted : 12

    For two-third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 8

    For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 16

    For two-third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 8

    For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 16

    SR-24, Section No. 2.3.1, See SR-24

    Total Voted : 12

    Page 2 of 13

    http://submittals.nfpa.org/TerraViewWeb/FormLaunch?id=/TerraView/Content/318-2012.ditamap/2/C1381411471579.xml&viewmode=nfpa/xslt/nfpaviewmode.xslhttp://submittals.nfpa.org/TerraViewWeb/FormLaunch?id=/TerraView/Content/318-2012.ditamap/2/C1381409976899.xml&viewmode=nfpa/xslt/nfpaviewmode.xsl

  • 318 SCR-AAA Second Draft Ballot Circulation (A2014)

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    SR-1, Section No. 2.3.4, See SR-1

    Total Voted : 12

    For two-third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 8

    For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 16

    For two-third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 8

    For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 16

    SR-13, Section No. 2.3.3, See SR-13

    Total Voted : 12

    Page 3 of 13

    http://submittals.nfpa.org/TerraViewWeb/FormLaunch?id=/TerraView/Content/318-2012.ditamap/2/C1378909900905.xml&viewmode=nfpa/xslt/nfpaviewmode.xslhttp://submittals.nfpa.org/TerraViewWeb/FormLaunch?id=/TerraView/Content/318-2012.ditamap/2/C1381338806617.xml&viewmode=nfpa/xslt/nfpaviewmode.xsl

  • 318 SCR-AAA Second Draft Ballot Circulation (A2014)

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    SR-12, Section No. 2.4, See SR-12

    Total Voted : 12

    For two-third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 8

    For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 16

    For two-third majority election, the affirmative votes needed are 8

    For Simple majority, the affirmative votes needed are 16

    SR-26, Section No. 2.3.6, See SR-26

    Total Voted : 12

    Page 4 of 13

    http://submittals.nfpa.org/TerraViewWeb/FormLaunch?id=/TerraView/Content/318-2012.ditamap/2/C1381336639769.xml&viewmode=nfpa/xslt/nfpaviewmode.xslhttp://submittals.nfpa.org/TerraViewWeb/FormLaunch?id=/TerraView/Content/318-2012.ditamap/2/C1381411687132.xml&viewmode=nfpa/xslt/nfpaviewmode.xsl

  • 318 SCR-AAA Second Draft Ballot Circulation (A2014)

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affirmative with Comment 0

    Negative 0

    Abstain 0

    Eligible to Vote: 30

    Not Returned : 18

    Matthew T. Wyman,Lawrence E. Shea,Rodney D.

    Randall,Jeffrey S. Kidd,Gordon C. Robbins,Stephen L.

    Fox,Alastair R. Brown,Wayne J. Aho,Derek A.

    White,Norman J. MacDonald, III,Joshua C.

    Vogel,John G. Ronan,Robert G. Backstrom,David A.

    Quadrini,Steve C. Dryden,Richard M.

    Lattanzio,Steven R. Trammell,Younghoon Joo

    Vote Selection Votes Comments

    Affirmative 12

    Affir