Long-Term Walraven PhotometryofCataclysmicVariables · 2010-03-24 · white dwarf. Such matter,...
Transcript of Long-Term Walraven PhotometryofCataclysmicVariables · 2010-03-24 · white dwarf. Such matter,...
Kormendy, J., 1977 c, Astrophys. J. 218, 333.lonsdale, C. J., Helou, G., Good, J. C. and
Rice, W. 1985, "Catalogued galaxies andquasars observed in the IRAS Survey", JPlpublication D. 1932.
Matthews, T.A., Morgan, W. M. and Schmidt,M., 1964, Astrophys. J. 140,35.
Möllenhoff, C., 1982, Astron. Astrophys. 108,130.
Neugebauer, G. et al., 1984, Astrophys. J.278, l1.
Nieto, J.-L. and lelievre, G., 1982, Astron.Astrophys. 109,95.
Phillips, M. M., 1979, Astrophys. J. 227,l121.
Sandage, A., 1961, Hubble Atlas of galaxies,Carnegie Institution of Washington Publication 618.
Sandage, A., 1975, in Galaxies and the Universe, Sandage, A., Sandage, M. and Kristian, J. eds. University of Chicago Press;p.1.
Sandage, A. and Tammann, G.A., 1981, Arevised Shapley-Ames cata/og of brightgalaxies, Carnegie Institution of Washington Publication 635.
Schneider, D. P., Gunn, J. E. and Hoessel,J. G., 1983, Astrophys. J. 264, 337.
Schweizer, F., 1980, Astrophys. J. 237, 303.
Shobbrook, R. R., 1963, The ObservatolY, 83,36.
Varnas, S. R., Bertola, F., Galletta, G., Freeman, K. C. and Carter, D., 1987, Astrophys.J. 313, 69.
de Vaucouleurs, G., 1953, The Observatory,73, 252.
de Vaucouleurs, G., 1959, Handbuch derPhysik 53, 311.
de Vaucouleurs, G., 1987, lAU Symp. 127,p.3.
Westerlund, B. E. and Smith, L. F., 1964, Austra/ian J. Phys.. 17, 340.
Long-Term Walraven Photometry of Cataclysmic Variabless. VAN AMERONGEN and J. VAN PARAOIJS,Astronomicallnstitute "Anton Pannekoek", University ofAmsterdam, the Netherlands
Figure 1: A sketch of the structure of a cataclysmic binary. Matter from the secondary falls intothe potential weil of the white dwarf and hits the accretion disk at the bright 01' "hot" spot.
Ouring the last seven years we havebeen observing cataclysmic variables(CV's) with the Walraven photometerbehind the gO-cm Outch telescope at LaSilla. An advantage of this photometriesystem for strongly variable blue sources is that it allows simultaneous detection in five passbands, extending fromthe optical (5400 A) to the ultraviolet(3200 A). We have observed these CV'sby monitoring them for several hours,and reduced the measurements differentially with respect to nearby comparison stars.
Results obtained so far include measurements of changes in the rotationperiods of accreting white dwarfs inCV's, quite strong upper limits to secular changes in optical brightness ofdwarf novae (ON) between outbursts,and the recognition that accretion instabilities similar to ON outbursts alsooccur in systems not classified as such.
Introduction
Cataclysmic variables are close binary stars consisting of a white dwarfand a low-mass « 1 MG) near-mainsequence companion. This "secondary"star fills its so-called Roche lobe, i. e. thecritical equipotential surface, outsidewhich matter is no longer bound to thestar (see Fig. 1). At the point on the linethrough the two stellar centres, wherethe Roche lobes of the secondary andthe white dwarf touch each other, matter from the secondary can easily fallinto the gravitational potential weil of thewhite dwarf.
Such matter, flowing from the secondary star, has angular momentum withrespect to the white dwarf, due to theorbital revolution of the binary. It willtherefore settle into a more or less Kep-
44
lerian orbit around the white dwarf. It isgenerally believed that viscous processes give rise to exchange of angularmomentum, by which an initially formedring spreads and forms a flat disk-likeconfiguration, the accretion disk,around the white dwarf. Matter transferred from the secundary gradually spirals inward along quasi-Keplerian orbits.Ouring this diffusion of the particles, theother half is radiated away.
This radiation from the accretion diskgenerally dominates the optical and UVluminosity of cataclysmic variables. Thekinetic energy of the inflowing material iseventually dissipated close to the whitedwarf surface, e. g. in a transition regionfrom the accretion disk to the whitedwarf surface.
Based on observational characteristics, cataclysmic variables have beendivided into several groups. Ouring ourobserving project, we have paid most ofour attention to the following types ofcataclysmic variables:
DwarfNovae
In the dwarf-nova systems the accretion rate onto the white dwarf changes
in a spasmodic way. Long time intervallsof the order of months of a low accretionrate (and therefore luminosity) are interrupted by outbursts, lasting for a fewdays to about two weeks, during whichthe accretion rate increases by a largefactor (see Fig. 2).
Intermediate Polars
In these cataclysmic variables thewhite dwarf has a magnetic field that isstrong enough to dominate the motionof the inflowing matter within a certaindistance from its centre. Within this"magnetospheric radius" the matter ischanneled onto regions near themagnetic poles of the white dwarf. Inside this magnetosphere an accurationdisk cannot exist; what fraction of theaccretion disk remains depends on thesize of the magnetosphere, relative tothat of the Roche lobe around the whitedwarf.
Brightness Variations
Most cataclysmic variables with anaccretion disk show brightness variations with the orbital period, which are
1 . 1
1 . 3
1 .0
1 .2
0.9+
novae, the SU UMa systems, that showtwo rather different types of outbursts(superoutbursts and "normal" outbursts). Superoutbursts are differentfrom normal outbursts - in their rate ofoeeurrenee (Iess often), their duration(Ionger), and their maximum luminosity(higher). Apart from this, it is found thatduring superoutburst, the optieal brightness is strongly modulated; these soealled superhumps reeur with aperiodthat is slightly longer than the orbitalperiod; also this superhump period isnot exaetly eonstant, but inereasesthrough the superoutburst. Thesuperhumps have always been a bigproblem, whieh resisted theoretieians'attempts to model them. However, reeently Whitehurst has proposed that thesuperhump phenomenon might be theresult of a mass-transfer burst from theseeondary, leading to a slowly preeessing, more or less eeeentrie disk, as theresult of tidal distortion by the seeondary of the orbits of partieles in the outerdisk regions [4]. His model sueeessfuilyaeeounts for many of the strange properties of the superhumps.
Our Walraven observations of thesuperoutburst of VW Hyi, which weredone in five ehannels simultaneously,have led to the diseovery of anotherstrange property of superhumps: thewhole superhump-modulation lighteurve arrives later when seen at longerwavelengths. The total shift from 3200 Ato 5400 A is + 0.06 in phase of thesuperhump period [5]. We eannot offeran explanation for this finding.
Intermediate Polars
In intermediate polars the influenee ofthe white-dwarf magnetie field does not
2
5083.8
++
2446000
5083.7
I I I;
1 . 2
1 . 1
1 . 3
through the disk to the white dwarf.During quieseenee, when the aeeretionrate onto the white dwarf equals themass transfer rate from the seeondary,no seeular ehanges are expeeted in theaeeretion disk's state.
One of the aims of our long-termphotometrie projeet of eataelysmie variables was an attempt to distinguish between these two types of model, bystudying the possible seeular brightnessvariations of dwarf novae in quieseenee.For this purpose we have observed thesystem VW Hyi during 42 nights over atime interval of 4 months, during whieh 5outbursts oeeured. These observationswere eoordinated with observationswith EXOSAT, Voyager, IUE, and Walraven [3] (see Fig. 2). The main outeome ofthis study is that there is no evidenee fora signifieant trend in the optieal brightness from the system between outbursts (see Fig. 4). The same was foundin the X-ray and UV observations (if anychange is diseernable it is a seeulardeerease, not an inerease). This result isnot easy to reeoneile with simple versions of the disk-instability model.
At the end of our eampaign VW Hyiwent into a so-ealled superoutburst. VWHyi belongs to a subgroup of dwarf
1 .0
o.8 '-------'-----'---~----'----__'----J 0 . 85083.9
0.9
Figure 3: Modulations of the Walraven-B-band brightness of the intermediate polar V 1223 Sgron 1982 April 24. A long-term modulation with the binary revolution period of 3.4 hours (0.14day) and a modulation with the beat period between the white rotation period and the orbitalperiod, of 13.2 minutes (0.0092 day), can be seen. The flux is given in flux units of a localcomparison star; time is given in HJD-2440000).
11 il
2445950
! .i I·
3 ~--r----------.------------r-,-"-~ 3'.
lL--"- ---'- .1....- .-1
2445900
2
Figure 2: An overview of the optical observations of the SU UMa-type dwarf nova VW Hyiduring July-November 1984, when the source went into a normal outburst 4 times and finallywent into a superoutburst. Drawn is the Walraven-B-flux in log F", with F,. in units of milliJansky's, against Heliocentric Julian Day.
due to a so-ealled "bright spot" at theouter edge of the disk, where it is hit bythe stream of matter flowing in from theseeondary (see Fig. 1). In systems with amagnetized white dwarf the light eanalso be modulated with the white dwarfrotation period, due to the higheremissivity from the magnetie pole regions and their general non-alignmentwith the rotation axis of the star. In thesesystems the light ean also be modulatedwith a third period, the beat period between the white dwarf rotation periodand the binary revolution period, whiehis the rotation period of the white dwarfin the referenee frame of the binary.Modulations with the beat period aredue to proeessing of eleetromagnetieradiation from the rotating white dwarfby parts of the binary system thatare not distributed axially-symmetriearound the white dwarf, e. g. the seeondary and the bright spot on the aeeretion disk's outer rim (see Fig. 3 for anexample of these modulations).
DwarfNovae
Two types of models have been proposed to explain the outbursts of dwarfnovae. In the disk-instability model [1]the aeeretion disk ean exist in two different modes, eorresponding to a highand a low value of the mass aeeretionrate through it. In the quieseent state theaeeretion rate through the disk is smaller than the the mass transfer rate fromthe seeondary, so that the density in thedisk builds up steadily. Coupled to thisseeular inerease of the density one expeets an inerease of its brightness(mainly in the optieal and UV). When thedensity has reaehed a partieular value,the disk eannot remain in this state oflow aeeretion, but suddenly switehes toastate with a high aeeretion rate. Duringthis outburst the mass aeeretion rateonto the white dwarf is higher than themass transfer rate from the seeondary.When the density has declined suffieiently, the disk returns to its quieseentstate. In the mass-transfer-instabilitymodel [2], the outbursts are explainedby mass-transfer bursts from the seeondary, which are direetly transported
45
Figure 4: VW Hyi. The residual flux in theWalraven-B band, averaged over one orbitalcycle, relative to the overall average orbitallight curve, is given against the relative phasein time between two successive normal outbursts. Apart from the decline of the flux afteran outburst, no rising or falling trend is seenin the brightness of VW Hyi during the quiescent state of the dwarf nova.
-1 010- 5 N
Figure 5: The deviations (O-C, in units of0.0001 day) of the optical beat pulse arrivaltimes in the intermediate polar V1223 5grfrom a linear fit against their cycle-number(N). The parabolic curve drawn gives an estimate of the rate of increase of the white dwarfrotation period (spin-down). The spin periodis 0.0092 day.
15
10O-C
5
t0
-5
-1 0
time scale of the binary; therefore thesechanges in the mass transfer rateshould occur very often in the lifetime ofthe binary [6]. As there is no reason whythis should only happen in intermediatepolars, it is likely to occur in all cataclysmic variables.
A possible explanation for long-termvariations in the mass transfer rate fromthe secondary, might be the occurrenceof thermonuclear flashes on the surfaceof the white dwarf (classical nova outbursts), in which about 10-5 MG is lost.These classical novae possibly lead toan increasing separation of the two starsand a temporary disconnection of thesecondary from its Roche lobe, so thatthe mass transfer process stops (or atleast becomes much smaller) [7]. In thefollowing stage of "hybernation" of thecataclysmic variable, the two stars willgradually come closer to one another asthe result of loss of orbital angularmomentum, due to emission of gravitational radiation and to magnetic braking,and mass transfer will restart when thesecondary again touches its Rochelobe.
0·24C-220·20C.180.16O. 140.120.100.080.060.C4C.02
tttt+/++tJ+ ~::::-O·OG-C.C8
G. 100.' 1 .0
F0·24 r +0.22ro.to0.18 + +
0.160.140.120.100.08o.oG +
0.04 ++
0.020.00
-O.Ctr-C.04r-c.CGi0.0 ro.lol~
0.["
00 All Cataclysmic VariablesBurst?
Figure 6: 5pectral continuum flux, close, to the Hydrogen-alpha emission line, of the intermediate polar V1223 5gr during six successive nights of observations with the Boiler & Chivensspectrograph behind the 1.S-m E50 telescope. Flux is given in linear arbitrary units againsttime in units of days. The decline of a burst is visible in the 4th night of observations (on 1984Aug 31). Ouring the declination of the flux, the more or less sinusoidal orbital modulation of thelight is visible.
extend to the secondary. Consequently,matter spiralling inward in the outeraccretion disk region becomes connected to the magnetic field (and willcorotate with the white dwarf) only within the magnetosphere of the whitedwarf. When it is connected, it eitherlooses angular momentum to the whitedwarf or gains angular momentum fromit. This accretion torque accelerates ordecelerates the white dwarf's rotation,until the white dwarf has reached anequilibrium period at which the nettorque vanishes (this equilibrium perioddepends on the magnetic field strengthand the mass accretion rate).
From our long-term observations ofintermediate polars we found that thewhite dwarf in V1223 Sgr spins down,while in H2252-035 it spins up (seeFig. 5); Pakull & Beuermann also found adown-spinning white dwarf in H2215086. Previous to our observations, onlyspin-ups of accreting magnetized whitedwarfs had been found. From modelswhich link the accretion torque to therate of change of the spin period of thewhite dwarf, we found that the whitedwarfs do not spin close to their equilibrium spin rate. One way in which thesewhite dwarfs could be unable to reachtheir equilibrium spin period, is by largechanges in the mass accretion rate. Weestimate that such equal changes in themass transfer rate take place on timescales less than 105 - 6 years, which isvery short compared with the evolution
Ouring recent observations of the intermediate polar TV Col we encountereda surprising feature, only seen once before in this system. Within one week thissource showed two outbursts, thatlooked remarkably similar [8]. Bothbursts lasted less than about half a day,and reached an amplitude of 2 magnitudes; they last therefore much shorterand are less luminous than dwarf novaoutbursts. We have in 1984 also detected a similar short burst in V1223Sgr, with the same characteristics as thebursts in TV Col (see Fig. 6). In additionto the photometry, the observers (H.Schwarz of ESO and M. Heemskerk of
1'1it""f" .i '
Uv Amsterdam) collected spectra of thesecond outburst. From the spectral lineinformation obtained, it became clearthat this outburst developed in a different way than normal dwarf nova outbursts do.
It is attractive to relate the differencesin the outburst characteristics of the intermediate polars and dwarf novae, withthe difference in their accretion diskstructure. It looks as if the absence of aninner disk in the intermediate polars precludes the full development of the burstas areal dwarf-nova outburst.
It appears valuable to follow thecataclysmic (physically) variable
46
binaries, to see how they behave on along time scale. The spasmodic emission of radiation due to the unstablemass transfer/accretion process, makesit necessary to open the observing window a bit more in order to detect crucialphenomena at the right moment. Fromthe long-term behaviour of these systems we have probably been able toderive information on their evolutionaryscenario.
Reterences
[1] Osaki, Y., 1974. Publ. Astron. SOG. Japan,26,429.
[2] Bath, G. T., 1975. Mon. Not. R. Astr. SOG.,171,311.
[3] Pringle, J. E., Bateson, F. M., Hassall,B.J.M., Heise, J., Holberg, J.B., Polidan,R. S., van Amerongen, S. F., van derWoerd, H., van Paradijs, J., and Verbunt, F., 1987. Mon. Not. R. Astr. SOG.,225,73.
van Amerangen, S., Damen, E., Graot, M.,Kraakman, H., and van Paradijs, J., 1987.Mon. Not. R. Astr. SOG., 225, 93.
Verbunt, F., Hassall, B.J. M., Marang, F.,Pringle, J. E., and Warner, B., 1987. Mon.Not. R. Astr. SOG., 225, 113.
Polidan, R. S., and Holberg, J. B., 1987. Mon.Not. R. Astr. SOG., 225, 131.
van der Woerd, H., and Heise, J., 1987. Mon.Not. R. Astr. SOG., 225, 141.
[4] Whitehurst, R., 1987. In preparation (preprint).
Honey, W. B., Charles, P.A., Whitehurst, R.,Barrett, P. E., and Smale, A. P., 1988. Mon.Not. R. Astr. SOG., 231, 1.
[5] van Amerongen, S., Bovenschen, H., andvan Paradijs, J., 1987. Mon. Not. R. Astr.SOG., 229, 245.
[6] van Amerongen, S., Augusteijn, T., andvan Paradijs, J., 1987. Mon. Not. R. Astr.SOG., 228, 377.
[7] Shara, M. M., Livio, M., Moffat, A. F. J.,and Orio, M., 1986. Astrophys. J., 311,163.
[8] Schwarz, H. E., and Heemskerk, M. H. M.,1987. lAU. Circular No. 4508.
Schwarz, H. E., van Amerangen, S. F.,Heemskerk, H. M., and van Paradijs, J.,1988. Astr. Astrophys., submitted.
IRAS Molecular Clouds in the Hot Locallnterstellar MediumP. ANOREAN/ 1,2, R. FERLET1, R. LALLEMENT1,3 and A. V/OAL-MAOJAR 1
1 Institut d'Astrophysique, CNRS, Paris, France2 ESA Fellow on leave trom Dipartimento di Fisica, Universita di Roma, La Sapienza, Roma, Italy3 Service d'Aeronomie, CNRS, Verrieres le Buisson, France
1. Introduction
The picture of the nearby (d :s 100 pe)interstellar medium, as resulting fromthe observations in the wavelengthrange from X-ray to radio, consists of avery hot, low-density gas, forming a hotbUbble, filled with many cloudlets ofionized and neutral material and locatednear to an interstellar condensation (seethe "Local Interstellar Medium", NASACP-2345, 1984; and Cox and Reynolds,1987).
Only recently the existence of a coldercounterpart in the nearby gas wasargued by Magnani, Blitz and Mundi(1985), who reported the detection of alarge number of "Iocal" molecularclouds at high galactic latitude and inferred from statistical arguments an average distance of about 100 pe.
A comparison with the IRAS mapsshowed that all the high latitudemolecular clouds can be identified withthe cores of the new discovered infrared(60 and 10 ~lm) features: "the IRAScirrus" (Weiland et al., 1986).
Nearby molecular clouds are then
associated to the cold interstellar material with temperatures ranging from 14to 40 K.
In order to understand the physicalproperties of the local medium and theireffect on other observations, it is interesting to tackle the problem of the coexistence of a cold and neutral gas with ahot medium and the mixing betweenthese two gaseous phases.
The distance, the morphology andother properties of the clouds, belongingto the local interstellar medium, can bedetermined by mapping the interstellarabsorption lines toward stars at differentdistances and projected along the lineof sight to these c1ouds.
The feasibility of this procedure hasalready been demonstrated by Hobbs etal. (1986) who estimate the distance ofthe cloud Lynds 1457/8 at about 65 pe.
We selected several high latitudeelouds detected by IRAS and/or at COwavelength (2.6 mm) by Magnani, Blitzand Mundi (1985) and gathered eehellespectra of a few stars with the ESO CATtelescope at La Silla, Chile.
2. The Observations
From the IRAS HCON 1 survey (seeIRAS Explanatory Supplement, 1984),we selected those clouds at 100 f.lm,which were already detected at the COband (Magnani et al., 1985) and locatedat high galactic latitude (I b I~ 25°).
The MIDAS software package (ESOOperating Manual No. 1, 1984) has beenused to analyse the IRAS maps. Thewhole procedure of IRAS images analysis will be published elsewhere (Andreani et al., 1988).
Table 1 lists the known properties ofthe clouds from infrared and CO measurements. The position, photometry,spectral type and distance are takenfrom the Bright Star Catalogue for thebrightest programme stars, and fromthe HD Catalogue for the others. Starswere chosen to be bright, hot, and ofearly spectral type.
High-dispersion Ca 11 K and Na I Dspectra were gathered during1986-1987 with the Coude EchelleSpectrometer fed by the 1A-m CATtelescope and equipped with either a
TABlE 1. Infrared and CO Properties of the Clouds
Cloud Coordinates IRAS CO
# Name a b I b 12 ~l 25 ~l 60 ~l 100 ~l Td Ta(h) (0) (0) (0) (MJy/sr) (K) (K)
20 l1642 433 -1420 210.9 -36.5 - - .3 ± .2 11.2 ± 2.8 20 6.8126 Q-Oph 1616.3 -1948 355.5 -21.1 - - 10 ± 3 12 ±3 29 9.2113 - 1517.1 -2925 337.8 -23.04 - - 13 ± 4 12 ±4 32 6.1
47