Locality in long-distance phonotactics: evidence for modular learning
37
!"#$%&'( &* %"*+,-&.'$*#/ 01"*"'$#'&#.2 /3&-/*#/ 4"5 6"-7%$5 %/$5*&*+ !"#$% '(')**$% +%, -)%%+. /*+0). 1+%223% 4"5+.67"%6 30 8$%9)$2:(2 ; <%$#".2$6= 30 >.$:2? @3*)7A$+ BC8DEE +6 <@3%% F G(63A". HIJ KLHM H D*$,"2 +6 :%=).*N(37OPQ7BC8DEE
-
Upload
kevin-mcmullin -
Category
Technology
-
view
177 -
download
1
Transcript of Locality in long-distance phonotactics: evidence for modular learning
!"#$%&'()&*)%"*+,-&.'$*#/)01"*"'$#'&#.2)
/3&-/*#/)4"5)6"-7%$5)%/$5*&*+)
!"#$%&'(')**$%&+%,&-)%%+.&/*+0).&1+%223%&4"5+.67"%6&30&8$%9)$2:(2&;&<%$#".2$6=&30&>.$:2?&@3*)7A$+&BC8DEE&+6&<@3%%&F&G(63A".&HIJ&KLHM&
H&D*$,"2&+6&:%=).*N(37OPQ7BC8DEE&
!"#$%&'()5/%$'&"*.)&*)01"*"'$#'&#.)
• R?3%36+(:(&(3%26.+$%62&3%&3)65)6&."5."2"%6+:3%2S&2"97"%6+*&!"#"!!$%%&'!&&%&()%*!+"'(&• T%6".+(:3%2&)%,".&,$."(6&+,Q+("%(=&U"N9N&*3(+*&+22$7$*+:3%O,$22$7$*+:3%V&
• B3%;+,Q+("%6&$%6".+(:3%2&U"N9N&W&3.&@&?+.73%=X&*3%9;,$26+%("&,$22$7$*+:3%V&Y&,"'-#.*()/'!&012"'")/!+!(&
• B3%;+,Q+("%6&$%6".+(:3%2&+."&0+($*$6+6",&A=&6.$99".;6+.9"6&(*3*,/%*)4&UZ32"&[&\+*P".&KLLEJ&1+%223%&KLHLJ&>"%%"]&KLHMV&
K&
!"#$%&'()5/%$'&"*.)&*)01"*"'$#'&#.)
• 4$2(."6"&*"#"*2&30&*3(+*$6=^&UG,,"%&HIIEJ&D)_)P$&HII`J&R)**"=A*+%P&KLLEV&• ,$."(6&+,Q+("%(=&• 2=**+A*"&+,Q+("%(=&Ua2?3.6;.+%9"bV&• )%A3)%,",&Ua*3%9;.+%9"bV&
• B3%;+,Q+("%6&$%6".+(:3%2&Y&+,Q+("%(=&3%&237"&36?".&5.3Q"(:3%O:".^&• +)632"97"%6+*&:".&U0"+6)."&9"37"6.=X&)%,".25"($c(+:3%V&• 2$7$*+.$6=;A+2",&(3.."253%,"%("&(?+$%&UZ32"&[&\+*P".&KLLEX&1+%223%&KLLdJ&KLHLV&
M&
'"'#/.5/!&')0
!"#$%&'()&*)#"*."*$*')1$56"*()
• G%*=&)6"0)41&(0+]"26",&(.322;*$%9)$2:(+**=&U1+%223%&KLHLV&• aeb&Y&?+.73%=&"%03.(",X&afb&Y&?+.73%=&%36&"%03.(",&
• T75*$(+:3%+*&)%$#".2+*S&• $%6".+(:3%&$%&*3%9;.+%9"&(3%6"g62&Uh7#(#7h&"6(NV&&')/*,(!$%6".+(:3%&$%&2?3.6;.+%9"&(3%6"g6&Uh7#7hV&+2&i"**&
• 6?"&."#".2"&,3"2&%36&?3*,& E&
879:7980 879:!9:7980 87:!9:7980 879:!9:!9:7980
;)%/'(9"!/,*!<0 e& F& F& F&
$'="$'.&.0 e& e& e& e&
"#$%&'(&)! F& e& e& e&
"#$%&'(&)! F& F& F& e&
89$60%/.2)*$.$%&'()
• j.+%2#3(+*$(&%+2+*&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=S&>/3=/&UG,,"%&HIIEV&;5+6;$*" &k2(3*,;RlWm&;)n3;$'" &k,.=;RlWm&;3+2;$," &k5*+26".;RlWm &&
• <%A3)%,",&%+2+*&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=S&?/@/&U1=7+%&HIIoV&;62pA;$,$ &ki+%,".;RlWm&;62p3;$'$ &k2"i;RlWm&;3qn6)P;$'$ &k2)*P;RlWm&
o&
89$60%/.2).&:&%$*')1$56"*()
• j.+%2#3(+*$(S&A""%&)&&U+NPN+N&!3=.+X&1+=i+.,&HI`KV&A+n.;)2; &k*$"N,3i%;@r<Dm&93nB;)C; &k5)**;@r<Dm&C3,;)(; &k)5.336;@r<Dm &&
• <%A3)%,",S&D/%*&U1+=i+.,&HIILV&A+s;2;" &kA.$%9;RlW;MD-m&s)C;C;$6 &k(33P;RlW;HD-m &&BE+tnu;C;$6 &k2i"+.;RlW;HD-m&F+tn9;".;C;" &k2"i;RrDD;RlW;MD-m&
v&
d&
TYPOLOGY
Computational and formal methods (e.g. proofs)
Laboratory experimentation
Channel Biases
Analytic Biases
explanation
explanationhypothesistesting
hypothesistesting
hypothesistesting
hypothesistesting
hypothesisgeneration
hypothesisgeneration
`&
TYPOLOGY
Computational and formal methods (e.g. proofs)
Laboratory experimentation
Channel Biases
Analytic Biases
explanation
explanationhypothesistesting
hypothesistesting
hypothesistesting
hypothesistesting
hypothesisgeneration
hypothesisgeneration
;"$%.)$*-)"7'%&*/)
• @*+$7&• j=53*39=&30&*3(+*$6=&5+]".%2&$2&2?+5",&A=&,&/%'*'-0=*/(&(&• Z"*+6",&63&(375*"g$6=&U$%&6".72&30&03.7+*&*+%9)+9"&6?"3.=V&30&$%,$#$,)+*&6=5"2&30&%3%;+,Q+("%6&,"5"%,"%($"2&&
• C#$,"%("&• 8"+.%$%9&A$+2&(3%c.7",&$%&6i3&*+A3.+63.=&"g5".$7"%62&U+.:c($+*&*+%9)+9"&*"+.%$%9V&• Cg5N&HS&D$A$*+%6&?+.73%=&+6&,$w"."%6&,$26+%("2&• Cg5N&KS&8$u)$,&?+.73%=&+6&,$w"."%6&,$26+%("2&
• R+]".%2&30&9"%".+*$_+:3%&U3.&*+(P&6?"."30V&63&)%2""%&(3%6"g62&7$..3.&6?"&(.322;*$%9)$2:(&6=53*39=&
• Z"5*$(+6"2&+%,&"g6"%,2&5."#$3)2&c%,$%92&A=&l$%*"=&UKLHHJ&KLHKV&• l).6?".&26),$"2& I&
!"#$%&'(<)%/$5*$:&%&'()$*-)#"60%/9&'()
• R?3%36+(:(&(3%26.+$%62&(+%&,"c%"&03.7+*&*+%9)+9"2&i$6?$%&6?"&($=%&-$,/%02*&%/%!240U1"$%_&KLHLJ&Z39".2&"6&+*N&KLHLV!
• #;9.+7&(3%26.+$%62&⇔&26.$(6*=&*3(+*&UD8%V&*+%9)+9"2&• ."9)*+6"&!"'+-$"$(0($=(&G$&'!&(030&*"%96?&#&• xyF23%J&e#3$zyF23%J&F#3$z&U"N9N&xAPJ&x_6J&x9{J&"6(NV&∈&D8K&
• 5."(","%("&(3%26.+$%62&⇔&26.$(6*=&5$"("i$2"&UDR%V&*+%9)+9"2&• ."9)*+6"&($=(&G$&'!&(&30&*"%96?&#&• xye26.$,J&e+%6zhye26.$,J&F+%6z&U"N9N&x2h|J&x_h6|J&"6(NV&∈&DRK&
&
HL&
!"#$%&'()$*-)6"-7%$5)%/$5*&*+)
• j?"&*+%9)+9"2&U26.$%92"62V&,"c%",&A=&#;9.+7&(3%26.+$%62&+%,&5."(","%("&(3%26.+$%62&+."&*"+.%+A*"&$%&6?"&*$7$6&0.37&532$:#"&"#$,"%("&U-3*,&HIvdX&2""&1"$%_&KLHLV&
• hA)6&%36&A=&6?"&2+7"&6=5"&30&*"+.%$%9&+*93.$6?7&U1"$%_&KLHLV&• #;9.+7&*"+.%".&UD8%V&• 5."(","%("&*"+.%".&UDR%V&
• C#$,"%("&03.&3".$,/%&%+6)."&30&5?3%3*39$(+*&*"+.%$%9&• 2""&1"$%_&+%,&T,2+.,$&UKLHHV&03.&0).6?".&+.9)7"%62&03.&73,)*+.$6=&$%&*+%9)+9"&*"+.%$%9&U2=%6+gN&5?3%3*39=V&
HH&
!"#$%&'()&*)#"*."*$*')1$56"*()
• <%A3)%,",&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=&• T%&+9.""7"%6;A=;(3.."253%,"%("&Ur>@V&+%+*=2"2&UZ32"&[&\+*P".&KLLEJ&1+%223%&KLHLJ&>"%%"]&KLHMVJ&6?$2&$2&+&(37A$%",&"w"(6&30&• U*3(+**=&)%."26.$(6",V&@GZZ;@}@&(3%26.+$%62J&i?$(?&"26+A*$2?&+&(3.."253%,"%("&."*+:3%&U"N9N&A"6i""%&+**&ye26.$,zhye26.$,z&5+$.2V&
• T4CBjylz;@@&(3%26.+$%62&A+%%$%9&,$2+9.""7"%6&A"6i""%&(3.."253%,"%62&U"N9N&$%&y~+%6zV&
• 1"."&i"&+A26.+(6&+i+=&0.37&)%%"("22+.=&(375*$(+:3%2&+.$2$%9&0.37&6?"&r>@&03.7+*$27&
• Cw"(:#"*=S&(3%26.+$%62&+9+$%26&,$2+9.""$%9&($=(&G$&'!&(&UDRKV&• "N9N&xye26.$,"%6J&�+%6".$3.zhye26.$,"%6J&F�+%6".$3.z&• ,$2(3#".+A*"&A=&+&1%&!&.&'!&0,&/%'&%&U1"$%_&KLHLV& HK&
!"#$%&'()&*)#"*."*$*')1$56"*()
• aj.+%2#3(+*$(b&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=&• D=**+A*"&+,Q+("%(=^&UZ32"&[&\+*P".&KLLEJ&>"%%"]&KLHMV&
• 2+7"&7"(?+%$27&+2&03.&)%A3)%,",&?+.73%=J&A)6&?$9?;.+%P",&(3%26.+$%6&URZGÄT'TjÅV&*$7$62&(3.."253%,"%("&63&Ç;+,Q+("%6&5+$.2&
• j.+%2#3(+*$(&U@;:".V&+,Q+("%(=^&U1+%223%&KLHLV&• "N9N&*3(+**=&."26.$(6",&@GZZ;@}@&(3%26.+$%62J&"26+A*$2?$%9&(3.."253%,"%("&3%*=&A"6i""%&2"97"%62&2"5+.+6",&A=&+6&7326&+i"*&U"N9N&$%&+**&@ye26.$,zW@ye26.$,z&2"u)"%("2V&
• @+%&A"&(+26&+2&)%*-%/3&(3%26.+$%62&UD8MV&• "N9N&xye26.$,"%6J&�+%6".$3.zyF(3%23%+%6+*zye26.$,"%6J&F�+%6".$3.z&• ,$2(3#".+A*"&A=&+%&!#-%/30,&/%'&%&
• +*6".%+:#"*=J&+2&A$9.+7&(3%26.+$%62&3%&+&(3%23%+%6&:".&UjD8KV&• (0N&1+="2&[&\$*23%&UKLL`V&3%i"*&?+.73%=&• 2""&1"$%_&"6&+*N&UKLHHV&3%&6?"&:".;A+2",&26.$(6*=&*3(+*&UjD8V&(*+22&
HM&
!/$5*&*+):&$.)$*-)'(0"%"+()
• 1=536?"2$2S&j?"&)%+]"26",&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=&6=5"&$2&U,$+(?.3%$(+**=&+%,&2=%(?.3%$(+**=V&*'/!!&((*=,&&,)"&63&+%&/'/,4+!0=*/(&35".+:%9&$%&5?3%36+(:(&*"+.%$%9&• $%(375+:A*"&i$6?&5."(","%("&*"+.%".&UDRV&73,)*"&• $%(375+:A*"&i$6?&#;9.+7&*"+.%".&UD8V&73,)*"&
• -$#"%&"#$,"%("&30&$%6".+(:3%&$%&*3%9;.+%9"&(3%6"g62J&*"+.%".&i$**&*'H&%&6?+6&$%6".+(:3%&?3*,2&$%&@W@&(3%6"g62&+2&i"**&• A)6&%36&U%"("22+.$*=V&#$("&#".2+É&
HE&
879:7980 879:!9:7980 87:!9:7980 879:!9:!9:7980
a6.+%2#3(+*$(b& e& F& F& F&
)%A3)%,",& e& e& e& e&
"#$%&'(&)! F& e& e& e&
!/$5*&*+):&$.)$*-)'(0"%"+()
• 1=536?"2$2S&j?"&)%+]"26",&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=&6=5"&$2&U,$+(?.3%$(+**=&+%,&2=%(?.3%$(+**=V&*'/!!&((*=,&&,)"&63&+%&/'/,4+!0=*/(&35".+:%9&$%&5?3%36+(:(&*"+.%$%9&• $%(375+:A*"&i$6?&5."(","%("&*"+.%".&UDRV&73,)*"&• $%(375+:A*"&i$6?&#;9.+7&*"+.%".&UD8V&73,)*"&
• -$#"%&"#$,"%("&30&$%6".+(:3%&$%&*3%9;.+%9"&(3%6"g62J&*"+.%".&i$**&*'H&%&6?+6&$%6".+(:3%&?3*,2&$%&@W@&(3%6"g62&+2&i"**&• A)6&%36&U%"("22+.$*=V&#$("&#".2+É&
Ho&
879:7980 879:!9:7980 87:!9:7980 879:!9:!9:7980
a6.+%2#3(+*$(b& e& F& F& F&
)%A3)%,",& e& e& e& e&
"#$%&'(&)! F& e& e& e&
!
=/'1"-"%"+()
• D%+I!*/,#12"'","-40,&/%'*'-0"g5".$7"%62&U2""&'3."63%&[&R+6".&KLHK+JA&03.&3#".#$"iV&• )2$%9&a53#".6=&30&2:7)*)2b&5+.+,$97&U\$*23%&KLLvV&63&6"26&03.&9"%".+*$_+:3%&63&(3%6"g62&%36&"%(3)%6".",&$%&6.+$%$%9&,+6+&
• Z"5*$(+6"2&l$%*"=&UKLHHJ&KLHKVJ&A)6&i$6?&+&73,$c",&+%,&+.9)+A*=&$75.3#",&,"2$9%&• G).&26),=S&*"+.%$%9&63&+55*=&?+.73%=&+*6".%+:3%2&$%&26"7J&A+2",&3%&6?"&2)Ñg&
• l$%*"=S&*"+.%$%9&63&(+6"93.$_"&26"7&2?+5"2&A=&(?3$("&30&2)Ñg&+*6".%+%6&
• r%+*=2$2&30&."2)*62&• (375+.$23%2&i$6?&@3%6.3*&9.3)5&63&0+(63.&3)6&8H&A$+2&3.&36?".&(3%03)%,2&UZ"A".&[&R"..)(?"6&KLLMJ&l$%%&[&1),23%&!+7&KLL`V&
• 7$g",;"w"(62&*39$2:(&."9."22$3%&73,"**$%9&UÖ+"9".&KLL`V& Hv&
890/5&6/*')>2)?&:&%$*')1$56"*()
• D:7)*$&• Z"(3.,",&A=&+&7+*"&%+:#"&C%9*$2?&25"+P".&• <%+i+."&30&6?"&5+]".%&$%&6?"&*+%9)+9"&
• M&2=**+A*"&k#".A2m&U@W@W@WV&• Ü5J6JPJAJ,J9áJ&Ü2J|á&+%,&Ü$J"J+J3J)á&
• ji3&2)Ñg"2S&5+26&6"26&y;2)z&+%,&0)6)."&6"%2"&y;|$z&• D)Ñg;63;.336&?+.73%=&i?"%&6?"&.336&(3%6+$%2&+&2$A$*+%6&• A)9+23J&A)9+23;2)J&A)9+|3;|$&
• r**&2:7)*$&26."22;$%$:+*&
Hd&
@5"#/-75/)A)B)01$./.)
• R.+(:("&5?+2"&• T%26.)(:3%&3%&5+26&+%,&0)6)."&6"%2"&03.&K&2=**+A*"&.3362&
• B3%"&30&6?"2"&(3%6+$%",&2$A$*+%62&
• j.+$%$%9&5?+2"&• 1"+.&+%,&."5"+6&HKL&#".A&6.$5*"62&6i$("&"+(?&• j.$5*"62&A"9+%&i$6?&6?"&#".A&.336J&03**3i",&A=&6?"&6i3&2)Ñg",&03.72&U(3)%6".A+*+%(",&03.&3.,".V&
• j36+*&30&dKL&UHKL&g&M&g&KV&5.3,)(:3%2O5+.:($5+%6&• j"2:%9&5?+2"&• W".A&.336&03**3i",&A=&6i3&(?3$("2&03.&6?"&k(3.."(6m&(3%Q)9+:3%&• >36?&(?3$("2&?+,&6?"&2+7"&2)Ñg&
• G%"&?+,&?+.73%=J&3%"&26+=",&0+$6?0)*&i$6?3)6&?+.73%=&• 5+:23&F&5+:23|$J&5+:|3|$&
H`&
C5$&*&*+)#"*-&'&"*.)
• 83(+*&F&HL&5+.:($5+%62&• 1+*0&30&.3362&i"."&(#(#D#&U3%"&2)Ñg&6.$99".2&?+.73%=V&• 1+*0&30&.3362&i"."&(#(#(#&U.3362&26+=&0+$6?0)*V&
• B3%*3(+*&F&HL&5+.:($5+%62&• 1+*0&30&.3362&i"."&(#D#(#&• 1+*0&i"."&(#(#(#&
• @3%6.3*&F&HL&5+.:($5+%62&• j.+$%",&3%*=&3%&(#(#(#&.336&(3%6+$%$%9&%3&2$A$*+%62&• B3&"#$,"%("&30&+%&+*6".%+:3%&&
HI&
89$60%/).'&67%&)
• j.+$%$%9&5?+2"&• 83(+*S&A)9+23J&A)9+23;2)J&A)9+|3;|$&• B3%*3(+*S&A)2+93J&A)2+93;2)J&A)|+93;|$&• @3%6.3*S&A)9+53J&A)9+53;2)J&A)9+53;|$&
• j"2:%9&5?+2"&U2+7"&03.&+**&(3%,$:3%2V&• HL&$6"72&+6&"+(?&,$26+%("&• 5+:23&F&5+:23|$J&5+:|3|$&• A3|+P$&F&A32+P$2)J&A3|+P$2)&• 2+5)P3&F&|+5)P3|$J&2+5)P3|$&
KL&
D/.7%'.)A)?&:&%$*')1$56"*()
KH&1 = cvcvSv-Sv 2 = cvSvcv-Sv 3 = Svcvcv-Sv
Training groupControl (cvcvcv-Sv)Local (cvcvSv-Sv)Nonlocal (cvSvcv-Sv)
Locality (Test Items)
Pro
porti
on o
f har
mon
y re
spon
ses
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
E*$%(.&.)
• '$g",;"w"(62&*39$2:(&."9."22$3%&73,"*&• '3,"*2&6?"&*39&3,,2&30&(?332$%9&6?"&6"26&$6"7&i$6?&?+.73%=&
• l$g",&"w"(62&• j.+$%$%9&9.3)5S&@3%6.3*J&83(+*J&B3%*3(+*&• j"26&$6"7&,$26+%("S&H&UhD#;D#VJ&K&UhD#(#;D#VJ&3.&M&UD#(#(#;D#V&• -.3)5&g&4$26+%("&$%6".+(:3%&
• Z+%,37&"w"(62&• Z+%,37&A=;2)AQ"(6&$%6".("562&• Z+%,37&A=;2)AQ"(6&2*35"2&03.&i?"6?".&6?"&?+.73%=&."253%2"&i+2&6?"&H26&3.&K%,&35:3%&
KK&
C1/)="-/%)
KM&
l$g",&"w"(62&30&7$g",&*39$6&73,"*&U>+2"*$%"&30&(3%6.3*&9.3)5&3%&,$26+%("&H&6"26&$6"72V&BY`KdX&ML&D)AQ"(62X&*39;*$P"*$?33,&;EvLNv&&
J(+3/)&0 KJ0 L%MNOPOQ0
T%6".("56& ;HNoLE& LNMMv& àLNLLHx&
4$26+%("&K& LNvHM& LNMvI& LNLId&
4$26+%("&M& ;LNdIE& LNEEv& LNLdo&
83(+*&6.+$%$%9& HNv`v& LNEEM& àLNLLHx&
B3%83(+*&6.+$%$%9& HNHvL& LNEEo& LNLLIx&
83(+*&g&4$26+%("&K& ;HNM`M& LNE`L& LNLLMx&
83(+*&g&4$26+%("&M& ;HNML`& LNo`K& LNLKox&
B3%*3(+*&g&4$26+%("&K& ;LNoEI& LNE`E& LNKod&
B3%*3(+*&g&4$26+%("&M& LNKod& LNoEd& LNvM`&
F1$')'1&.)6"-/%).1"G.)
KE&1 = cvcvSv-Sv 2 = cvSvcv-Sv 3 = Svcvcv-Sv
Training groupControl (cvcvcv-Sv)Local (cvcvSv-Sv)Nonlocal (cvSvcv-Sv)
Locality (Test Items)
Pro
porti
on o
f har
mon
y re
spon
ses
0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
?&:&%$*')3.H)%&I7&-)#"*'5$.'.)
• Cg5".$7"%6&H&U+%,&l$%*"=&KLHHJ&KLHKX&2""&+*23&8+$&KLHKV&)2",&+%&+.:c($+*&(*=*,/')02/%3"'4&5+]".%S&y2zN&y|z&• 7326&0."u)"%6&6=5"&30&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=&A=&0+.&U1+%223%&KLHLV&
• Cg5".$7"%6&K&)2"2&,*G$*.02/%3"'4S&y*zN&y.z&• +*23&+]"26",J&6?3)9?&*"22&0."u)"%6&U"N9N&>)P)2)X&G,,"%&HIIEV&
• '3:#+:3%S&• ."5*$(+6"&c%,$%92&$%&,$w"."%6&5?3%":(O0"+6).+*&,$7"%2$3%&
• 237"i?+6&*"22&2+*$"%6&2"97"%6&(*+22&U*$u)$,2&,3&%36&a26+%,&3)6b&+(3)2:(+**=&6?"&i+=&2$A$*+%62&,3V&
• 5+.6&30&A$99".&26),=&(3%6.+2:%9&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=&i$6?&%3%;+,Q+("%6&.*((*3*,/+"'&5+]".%2&U1"$%_&KLHLX&>"%%"]&KLHMV&• 2$A$*+%6&,$22$7$*+:3%&#$.6)+**=&)%+]"26",&• *$u)$,&?+.73%=&+%,&,$22$7$*+:3%&A36?&.3A)26*=&+]"26",&
Ko&
890/5&6/*')J2)!&I7&-)1$56"*()
• D$7$*+.&,"2$9%&63&Cg5".$7"%6&H&• j?.""&5?+2"2&U5.+(:("J&6.+$%$%9J&6"2:%9V&• j?.""&(3%,$:3%2&U83(+*J&B3%*3(+*J&@3%6.3*&F&HK&2)AQ"(62&"+(?V&
• D:7)*$&• @W@W@W&#".A&.3362&
• Ü5J6JPJAJ,J9J7J%áJ&Ü*J.á&+%,&Ü$J"J3J)á&• ji3&2)Ñg"2&U5+26&6"%2"&;.)J&0)6)."&6"%2"&;*$V&• Z"(3.,",&A=&03).&25"+P".2&UK&7+*"J&K&0"7+*"V&
Kv&
K/.&+*)
• j.+$%$%9&• HIK&6.$5*"62&$%&6.+$%$%9&5?+2"&Uodv&636+*X&0"i".&6?+%&"g5".$7"%6&HV&
• 83(+*&9.3)5&.3362S&oLâ&(#(#8#J&oLâ&(#(#(#&• B3%*3(+*&9.3)5S&oLâ&(#8#(#J&oLâ&(#(#(#&• @3%6.3*&9.3)5S&r**&(#(#(#&U%3&*$u)$,2V&
• j"2:%9&• Iv&636+*&6.$+*2&UMK&+6&"+(?&,$26+%("V&
• 1+*0&?+,&+&0+$6?0)*&.336&."2)*6&$%&?+.73%=&• 1+*0&?+,&+&0+$6?0)*&.336&."2)*6&$%&,$2?+.73%=&
• C#"%*=&,$26.$A)6",&+73%9&25"+P".J&.336&*$u)$,J&2)Ñg&
Kd&
D/.7%'.)A)!&I7&-)1$56"*()
K`&1 = cvcvLv-Lv 2 = cvLvcv-Lv 3 = Lvcvcv-Lv
Training groupControl (cvcvcv-Lv)Local (cvcvLv-Lv)Nonlocal (cvLvcv-Lv)
Locality (Test Items)
Pro
porti
on o
f har
mon
y re
spon
ses
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
E*$%(.&.)
KI&
• '$g",;"w"(62&*39$2:(&."9."22$3%&73,"*&• '3,"*2&6?"&*39&3,,2&30&(?332$%9&6?"&6"26&$6"7&i$6?&?+.73%=&
• l$g",&"w"(62&• j.+$%$%9&9.3)5S&@3%6.3*J&83(+*J&B3%*3(+*&• j"26&$6"7&,$26+%("S&H&Uh8#;8#VJ&K&Uh8#(#;8#VJ&3.&M&U8#(#(#;8#V&• T%6".+(:3%&-.3)5&g&4$26+%("&g&l+$6?0)*&5+]".%&6=5"&
• Z+%,37&"w"(62&• Z+%,37&A=;2)AQ"(6&$%6".("562&• Z+%,37&A=;2)AQ"(6&2*35"2&03.&i?"6?".&6?"&?+.73%=&."253%2"&i+2&6?"&H26&3.&K%,&35:3%&
C1/)="-/%)
ML&
RS0 TH0 L%MNRSQ0
1+.73%=&$6"7& INEv& H& LNLLKx&
l+$6?0)*&5+]".%&6=5"& EdN`v& H& àLNLLHx&
4$26+%("& MKNLE& K& àLNLLHx&
-.3)5& HdNMv& K& àLNLLHx&
l+$6?R+6&g&4$26+%("& HENMo& K& àLNLLHx&
l+$6?R+6&g&-.3)5& ENKo& K& LNHKL&
4$26+%("&g&-.3)5& HKNod& E& LNLHEx&
l+$6?R&g&4$26+%("&g&-.3)5& HINLM& E& àLNLLHx&
• r%3#+&30&73,"*&(3%c.72&6?+6&$%6".+(:3%2&30&j.+$%$%9&9.3)5&g&4$26+%("&
C1/)="-/%)
MH&
l$g",&"w"(62&30&7$g",&*39$6&73,"*&U0+$6?0)*&5+]".%&6=5"&37$]",V&U>+2"*$%"&30&(3%6.3*&9.3)5&3%&,$26+%("&H&6"26&$6"72V&BYMM``X&Mv&D)AQ"(62X&*39;*$P"*$?33,&;HdKv&&
J(+3/)&0 KJ0 L%MNOPOQ0
T%6".("56& HNHIE& LNMHL& àLNLLHx&
1+.7&@?3$("&K%,& ;LNEKd& LNHMI& LNLLox&
l+$6?0)*&$2&,$2?+.73%=& ;KNKLH& LNMKI& àLNLLH&
4$26+%("&K& LNLEE& LNMvI& LN``H&
4$26+%("&M& ;LNHIL& LNEEv& LNKI`&
83(+*&6.+$%$%9& HNLMd& LNMMv& LNLLKx&
B3%83(+*&6.+$%$%9& HNM`E& LNMMv& àLNLLHx&
83(+*&g&4$26+%("&K& ;LNvKK& LNKoI& LNLHvx&
83(+*&g&4$26+%("&M& ;LNdvv& LNKoI& LNLLMx&
B3%*3(+*&g&4$26+%("&K& LNHKM& LNKoI& LNvME&
B3%*3(+*&g&4$26+%("&M& ;LNMIM& LNKoE& LNHKK&
?766$5()"4)5/.7%'.)
MK&
• D)AQ"(62&6.+$%",&3%&*3(+*&?+.73%=&Uh@#@hV&• 8"+.%",&6?"&5+]".%&• 4$,&%36&9"%".+*$_"&U63&h@#(#@h&3.&@#(#(#@hV&• 8"+.%",&+&6.+%2#3(+*$(&5+]".%&3%*=&
• +2&+&D6.$(6*=&83(+*&UD8V&5+]".%&
• D)AQ"(62&6.+$%",&3%&%3%*3(+*&?+.73%=&U+6&h@#(#@hV&• 8"+.%",&6?"&5+]".%&• -"%".+*$_",&63&6?"&73."&*3(+*&(+2"2&Uh@#@hV&• -"%".+*$_",&63&*3%9".&,$26+%("2&+2&i"**&U@#(#(#@hV&• 8"+.%",&+%&)%A3)%,",&5+]".%&
• +2&+&D6.$(6*=&R$"("i$2"&UDRV&5+]".%&
?"6/)47'75/)/90/5&6/*'.)
• -"%".+*$_+:3%&$%&6?"&0+("&30&!"$')&%&9*.&'!&^&• j.+$%$%9S&3#".6&"#$,"%("&03.&)%+]"26",&(37A$%+:3%&• ?+.73%=&+6&(#7#(#;7#&• '"02/%3"'4&U$N"N&0+$6?0)*&26"72V&+6&(#(#7#;7#&
• j"2:%9S&• ,3&*"+.%".2&2:**&9"%".+*$_"&?+.73%=&63&(#(#7#;7#^&
• 8"+.%$%9&30&2$75*".&U+(("22$A*"V&5+]".%&,"25$6"&3#".6&"#$,"%("&03.&73."&(375*"g&UA)6&$%+(("22$A*"V&5+]".%&• 8+$&UKLHKV&3%&ac.26;*+26b&?+.73%=&5+]".%2&• \?$6"&U$%&5."22V&3%&a2+*6+63.=b&+*6".%+:3%2&
MM&
?"6/)47'75/)/90/5&6/*'.)
• 4"c%$%9&(.$6".$3%&03.&a6.+%2#3(+*$(b&,"5"%,"%($"2&• 2=**+A*"&+,Q+("%(=^&UG,,"%&HIIEJ&Z32"&[&\+*P".&KLLEV&• +,Q+("%(=&3%&(3%23%+%6&:".O5.3Q"(:3%^&U1+%223%&KLHLX&(0N&-3*,27$6?&[&Z$99*"&KLHKV&
• +,Q+("%(=&3%&2=**+A*";(3%2:6)"%6&:".O5.3Q"(:3%^&Ua3%2"6&:".bJ&a(3,+&:".bJ&"6(N^V&
ME&
K4,,/=,&0/.5/!&'!40
7#+&%0/.5/!&'!40
7"'(+)$&')0/.5/!&'!40
(#N7#N;7#& ="2& ="2& ="2&
(#N(#7N;7#& ="2& ="2& %3&
(#N7#(N;7#& ="2& %3& ="2&
(#N7#N;(#7& ="2& %3& %3&
E#L*"G%/-+6/*'.)
• DD1Z@&T%2$9?6&-.+%6&EMoFKLHMFLEooS&a83%9;,$26+%("&5?3%36+(:(2S&*"+.%$%9&A$+2J&(?+%9"J&+%,&6=53*39=b&URTS&-)%%+.&/*+0).&1+%223%V&
• <>@&r.62&-.+,)+6"&Z"2"+.(?&ri+.,&U!"#$%&'(')**$%V&• Ö"w&1"$%_&• @+.*+&1),23%&!+7&F&<>@&8+%9)+9"&+%,&8"+.%$%9&8+A&• r*"g$2&>*+(PJ&Ö+7"2&@.$55"%J&C**+&l)%,;Z"_%$("PJ&'$(?+"*&'(r)*$w"&
• D*$,"2&+6S&:%=).*N(37OPQ7BC8DEE&
Mo&
D/4/5/*#/.)
>"%%"]J&\$**$+7&-N&KLHMN&*+''+,+-$./#0!1/#'/#$#(!2$3,/#40!$#)!'"35$1&!1/33&'6/#)&N&43(63.+*&,$22".6+:3%J&Z)69".2&<%$#".2$6=N&
l$%*"=J&D+.+N&KLHHN&j?"&5.$#$*"9",&26+6)2&30&*3(+*$6=&$%&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=N&7/"3#$-!/5!8&,/34!$#)!9$#:"$:&!voS&dEF`MN&
l$%*"=J&D+.+N&KLHKN&j"2:%9&6?"&*$7$62&30&*3%9;,$26+%("&*"+.%$%9S&*"+.%$%9&A"=3%,&6?"&6?."";2"97"%6&i$%,3iN&;/:#+.<&!=1+&!MvUEVS&dELFdovN&
l$%%J&r7=&DNJ&+%,&@+.*+&8N&1),23%&!+7N&KLL`N&j?"&().2"&30&P%3i*",9"S&c.26&*+%9)+9"&P%3i*",9"&$75+$.2&+,)*6&*"+.%".2m&)2"&30&%3#"*&26+:2:(2&03.&i3.,&2"97"%6+:3%N&;/:#+./#&HL`S&EddFEIIN&
-3*,27$6?J&Ö3?%J&+%,&Ö+23%&Z$99*"N&KLHKN&T%03.7+:3%&6?"3.":(&+55.3+(?"2&63&5?3%3*39$(+*&26.)(6)."S&6?"&(+2"&30&l$%%$2?i"*&?+.73%=N&>$("3$-!9$#:"$:&!$#)!9+#:"+'.1!?2&/34&MLS&`oIF`IvN&
1+%223%J&-)%%+.&/*+0).N&KLLdN&>*3(P$%9&"w"(62&$%&+9.""7"%6&A=&(3.."253%,"%("@!9+#:"+'.1!A#B"+34!M`UKVS&MIo;ELIN&&
1+%223%J&-)%%+.&/*+0).N&KLHLN&;/#'/#$#(!2$3,/#4C!-/#:D)+'($#1&!+#(&3$1./#!+#!62/#/-/:4N&>".P"*"=J&@rS&<%$#".2$6=&30&@+*$03.%$+&R."22N&yZ"#$2$3%&30&KLLH&,$22".6+:3%J&<N@N&>".P"*"=Nz&
1+=i+.,J&Z$(?+.,&ÖN&HI`KN&B36"2&3%&6?"&!3=.+&*+%9)+9"@!E53+F$!"#)!GH&3'&&!voS&KHHFKv`N&1+=i+.,J&Z$(?+.,&ÖN&HIILN&B36"2&3%&6?"&r+.$&*+%9)+9"N&I,/.1!-$#:"$:&!'(")+&'J&",N&A=&Z$(?+.,&ÖN&
1+=i+.,J&55N&EKoFEIMN&83%,3%S&D(?33*&30&G.$"%6+*&+%,&r0.$(+%&D6),$"2J&<%$#".2$6=&30&83%,3%N&1"$%_J&Ö"w."=N&KLHLN&8"+.%$%9&*3%9;,$26+%("&5?3%36+(:(2N&9+#:"+'.1!A#B"+34!EHUEVS&vKMFvvHN&1"$%_J&Ö"w."=&+%,&\$**$+7&T,2+.,$N&KLHHN&D"%6"%("&+%,&i3.,&(375*"g$6=N&=1+&&MMMS&KIoFKIdN&1"$%_J&Ö"w."=J&@?"6+%&Z+i+*&+%,&1".A".6&-N&j+%%".N&KLHHN&j$".;A+2",&26.$(6*=&*3(+*&(3%26.+$%62&03.&
5?3%3*39=N&J3/1&&)+#:'!/5!(2&!KL(2!E##"$-!8&&.#:!/5!(2&!E''/1+$./#!5/3!;/,6"($./#$-!9+#:"+'.1'J&55N&o`FvEN&r223($+:3%&03.&@375)6+:3%+*&8$%9)$2:(2N&
Mv&
D/4/5/*#/.)
1=7+%J&8+..=&'N&HIIoN&B+2+*&(3%23%+%6&?+.73%=&+6&+&,$26+%("S&6?"&(+2"&30&Å+P+N&=(")+&'!+#!E53+1$#!9+#:"+'.1'!KES&oFMLN&
Ö+"9".J&jN&l*3.$+%N&KLL`N&@+6"93.$(+*&,+6+&+%+*=2$2S&+i+=&0.37&rBGWr2&U6.+%203.7+:3%&3.&%36V&+%,&63i+.,2&*39$6&7$g",&73,"*2N&7/"3#$-!/5!8&,/34!$#)!9$#:"$:&&oIUEVS&EMEFEEvN&
8+$J&Å""P$%9&Z"9$%"N&KLHKN&*/,$+#!'6&1+M1+(4!+#!-&$3#+#:!62/#/-/:4N&43(63.+*&,$22".6+:3%J&<%$#".2$6=&30&4"*+i+."N&
'3."63%J&C**$3]N&KLL`N&r%+*=:(&A$+2&+%,&5?3%3*39$(+*&6=53*39=N&J2/#/-/:4&KoUHVS&`MFHKdN&'3."63%J&C**$3]J&+%,&Ö3"&R+6".N&KLHK+N&D6.)(6)."&+%,&2)A26+%("&$%&+.:c($+*;5?3%3*39=&*"+.%$%9N&R+.6&
TS&D6.)(6)."@!9$#:"$:&!$#)!9+#:"+'.1'!;/,6$''&vUHHVS&v`v;;dLHN&'3."63%J&C**$3]J&+%,&Ö3"&R+6".N&KLHKAN&D6.)(6)."&+%,&2)A26+%("&$%&+.:c($+*;5?3%3*39=&*"+.%$%9N&R+.6&
TTS&D)A26+%("@!9$#:"$:&!$#)!9+#:"+'.1'!;/,6$''!vUHHVS&dLK;;dH`N&G,,"%J&4+#$,N&HIIEN&r,Q+("%(=&5+.+7"6".2&$%&5?3%3*39=N&9$#:"$:&&dLUKVS&K`IFMMLN&Z"A".J&Z3*0J&+%,&R$".."&R"..)(?"6N&KLLMN&j?"&)2"&30&(3%6.3*&9.3)52&$%&+.:c($+*&9.+77+.&*"+.%$%9N&
N"$3(&3-4!7/"3#$-!/5!OP6&3+,&#($-!J'412/-/:4C!Q",$#!OP6&3+,&#($-!J'412/-/:4&ovrS&IHFHHoN&Z32"J&D?+.3%&+%,&Z+(?"*&\+*P".N&KLLEN&r&6=53*39=&30&(3%23%+%6&+9.""7"%6&+2&(3.."253%,"%("N&
9$#:"$:&&`LUMVS&EdoFoMHN&D)_)P$J&!"$$(?$.3N&HII`N&E!(46/-/:+1$-!+#<&'.:$./#!/5!)+''+,+-$./#N&43(63.+*&,$22".6+:3%J&<%$#".2$6=&
30&r.$_3%+N&\?$6"J&Ö+7"2N&T%&5."22N&C#$,"%("&03.&+&*"+.%$%9&A$+2&+9+$%26&2+*6+63.=&5?3%3*39$(+*&+*6".%+:3%2N&
;/:#+./#N&\$*23%J&@3*$%N&KLLvN&8"+.%$%9&5?3%3*39=&i$6?&2)A26+%:#"&A$+2S&+%&"g5".$7"%6+*&+%,&(375)6+:3%+*&
26),=&30&#"*+.&5+*+6+*$_+:3%N&;/:#+.<&!=1+&&MLS&IEoFI`KN&&
Md&
