Loading-haulage Equipment Selection in Open Pit Mines Based on Fuzzy-ToPSIS Method

8/16/2019 Loading-haulage Equipment Selection in Open Pit Mines Based on Fuzzy-ToPSIS Method

1/19

GOS P ODAR KA S UR OW C AM I M INE R AL NYM I

Tom 24 2008 Zeszyt 4!

A" AG#A$ANI %AZZAZI&' M" OSANLOO&&' #" SOLTANMO#AMMADI&&

Loading-haulage equipment selection in open pit mines basedon fuzzy-TOPSIS method

Introduction

E()*+me,t se-e.t*o, *s o,e o/ te most *m+o1t,t s+e.ts o/ o+e, +*t 3es*," M*,*,

.osts 1e m*,-y //e.te3 5y te ,)m5e1 ,3 .+.*ty o/ e()*+me,t" E()*+me,t se-e.t*o, /o1

o+e,6+*t m*,es *s 3e/*,*te-y m7o1 3e.*s*o, *. *-- *m+.t 1et-y te e.o,om*.

9*5*-*ty o/ , o+e1t*o, :A7,* et -" 200;


2/19

8 8

.osts o/ -oo=*, /te1 te e()*+me,t 3)1*, *ts )se/)- -*/e 1e ,ot t=e, *,to ..o),t:%-,.13 et -" >?8>?8;< ,3 De,5y' S.o/*e-3 :De,5y' S.o/*e-3 >??0??;??0' >??4wij" Te +1*o1*ty o/ e-eme,t .om+1e3 to *t *s e()- to o,e"

http://et.al/http://et.al/http://et.al/


3/19

8 ?

A#P meto3 *s ++-*e3 *, t*s 1ese1. /o1 .1*te1* e*t*," So' t /*1st' set )+ n.1*te1* *, te 1os ,3 .o-)m,s o/ n F n mt1*@" Te,' Pe1/o1m +*1 *se .om+1*so,s o/ --

te .1*te1* ..o13*, to te o-" Te /),3me,t- s.-e )se3 /o1 t*s +)1+ose *s so, *,

T5-e >" o1 mt1*@ o/ o13e1 n' ::n< m=es te A#P m). -ess se,s*t*9e to 7)3me,t e11o1sB *t -so

-ets o,e mes)1e 7)3me,t e11o1s 5y .-.)-t*, te .o,s*ste,.y *,3e@ o/ te .om+1*so,

mt1*@' ,3 te, .-.)-t*, te .o,s*ste,.y 1t*o"

TA%LE >

S.-e /o1 +*1 *se .om+1*so,s

TA%ELA >S=- 3- +o1,J +1m*

N)me1*.- ssessme,t L*,)*st*. me,*,

> E()- *m+o1t,t

! Mo3e1te-y mo1e *m+o1t,t

St1o,-y mo1e *m+o1t,t

; e1y st1o,-y *m+o1t,t

? E@t1eme-y mo1e *m+o1t,t

2' 4' ' 8 I,te1me3*te 9-)es o/ *m+o1t,.e

I, s+*te o/ *ts +o+)-1*ty ,3 s*m+-*.*ty *, .o,.e+t' t*s meto3 *s o/te, .1*t*.*ze3 /o1 *ts

*,5*-*ty to 3e()te-y ,3-e te *,e1e,t ),.e1t*,ty ,3 *m+1e.*s*o, sso.*te3 *t te

m++*, o/ te 3e.*s*o,6m=e1s +e1.e+t*o, to .1*s+ 9-)es" I, te t13*t*o,- /o1m)-t*o, o/

te A#P' )m, 7)3me,ts 1e 1e+1ese,te3 s .1*s+ 9-)es" #oe9e1' *, m,y +1.t*.- .ses

te )m, +1e/e1e,.e mo3e- *s ),.e1t*, ,3 3e.*s*o, m=e1s m*t 5e 1e-).t,t o1 ),5-e to

ss*, .1*s+ 9-)es to te .om+1*so, 7)3me,ts :C,' K)m1 200;


4/19

?0

T*s se.t*o, e@te,3s te TOPSIS to te /)zzy e,9*1o,me,t" We 51*e/-y 1e9*e te 1t*o,-eo/ /)zzy teo1y 5e/o1e te 3e9e-o+me,t o/ /)zzy TOPSISB s /o--os

&efinition '.1. A /)zzy seta *, ),*9e1se o/ 3*s.o)1se *s .1.te1*ze3 5y mem5e1s*+ /),.t*o, a : x< a : x< *. sso.*tes *t e. e-eme,t x *, ' 1e- ,)m5e1

*, te *,te19- 0' >" Te /),.t*o, 9-)e,a a : x< *s te1me3 te 13e o/ mem5e1s*+ o/ x *, a

:Z3e >?' 2' !


5/19

• ••

•• • • •

Q QC > C nC 2 :<

A A

A

Q Q x>> x>n> x

> 2

x 2 > Q Q x2 n x 2 22

!

~ xQ Q x x x!> !n!2 !!

C !

x> !

x 2 !~ D

A Q Q> x xm 2 2 m xm m xmn

!


6/19

? >

W =w >'w 2'w !'"""' wn :<

e1e xij' i >' 2' """' m' j >' 2' """' n ,3 w j >' 2' """' n 1e -*,)*st*. t1*,)-1 /)zzy

,)m5e1s' xij :aij ' bij 'cij< ,3 w j :w j> 'w j2 ' wj!' 2' """' m' j >' 2' """' n< /o1 -te1,t*9es*t 1es+e.t to .1*te1* ,3 te ++1o+1*te -*,)*st*. 91*5-es :w j' j >' 2' """' n< /o1 te

e*t o/ te .1*te1*"

Te /)zzy -*,)*st*. 1t*, xij +1ese19es te +1o+e1ty tt te 1,es o/ ,o1m-*ze3t1*,)-1 /)zzy ,)m5e1s 5e-o, to 0' >B t)s' te1e *s ,o ,ee3 /o1 ,o1m-*zt*o, +1o.e3)1e" o1 t*s *,st,.e' te D 3e/*,e3 5y E()t*o, >! *s e()*9-e,t to te

R 3 e / * , e 3 5 y E ( ) t * o ,> "

Step $( Co,st1).t te e*te3 ,o1m-*ze3 /)zzy 3e.*s*o, mt1*@" Te e*te3 ,o16m-*ze3 9-)e v *s .-.)-te3 5y E()t*o, >"

Step )( I3e,t*/y +os*t*9e *3e- :A&< ,3 ,et*9e *3e- :A H < so-)t*o,s" Te /)zzy +os*t*9e6*3e- so-)t*o, :PIS' A&< ,3 te /)zzy ,et*9e6*3e- so-)t*o, :NIS' A H < 1e

so, s E()t*o,s ? ,3 >0

A& v :& > ' v & 2 ' v & ! '"""' v & n < = :?<m@ v ij i = > ' 2 '"""' m ' j = > ' 2 '"""' ni

A H :vT ' v* 'v! '"""' v; < = m*, vij i =>' 2'"""' m' j =>' 2'"""' n :>0> >2 > j >n~

• • • v • • • v2 ij in

•

•

• .

•

v r v r ••• v r ••• v r > >> 2 >2 j > j n >n

v r v r ••• v r ••• v r

> 2> 2 22 j 2 j n 2 n•

•

•

••

•

•

•v >r m> v 2 r m 2 ••• v j r mj

:8<

v ~v vi > i


7/19

? 2

Ste+ 4 C-.)-te se+1t*o, mes)1es" Te 3*st,.e o/ e. -te1,t*9e /1om A & ,3 A H ., 5e .)11e,t-y .-.)-te3 )s*, E()t*o,s >> ,3 >2"

>

j

Ste+ C-.)-te s*m*-1*t*es to *3e- so-)t*o," T*s ste+ so-9es te s*m*-1*t*es to ,

*3e- so-)t*o, 5y E()t*o, >!

d CC ______

i d d ~ &i i

Ste+ R,= +1e/e1e,.e o13e1" Coose , -te1,t*9e *t m@*m)m CC i& o1 1,=

-te1,t*9es ..o13*, to CC i& *, 3es.e,3*, o13e1"

2 " 2 " )z z y m e m 5e 1 s * + / ),. t * o,

Te 3e.*s*o, m=e1s )se te -*,)*st*. 91*5-es to e9-)te te *m+o1t,.e o/ tt1*5)tes

,3 te 1t*,s o/ -te1,t*9es *t 1es+e.t to 91*o)s tt1*5)tes" Te +1ese,t st)3y s o,-y

+1e.*se 9-)es /o1 te +e1/o1m,.e 1t*,s ,3 /o1 te tt1*5)te e*ts" I, o13e1 to *--)st1te

te *3e o/ /)zzy MACD' e 3e-*5e1te-y t1,s/o1m te e@*st*, +1e.*se 9-)es to /*9e6

-e9e-s' /)zzy -*,)*st*. 91*5-es69e1y -o :L><i >' 2' """' m

d jn

i :>!


8/19

? !

TA%LE 2T1,s/o1mt*o, /o1 /)zzy mem5e1s*+ /),.t*o,s

TA%ELA 2

P1ze=szt!.e,*e 3- /),=.7* 1ozmyty.

R,= Att1*5)te 13e Mem5e1s*+ /),.t*o,

e1y Lo :L< > :0"00' 0">0' 0"2<

Lo :L< 2 :0">' 0"!0' 0"4<

Me3*)m :M< ! :0"!' 0"0' 0"<

#* :#< 4 :0"' 0";0' 0"8<

e1y #* :#< :0";' 0"?0' >"00<

). pplicaion of fuzzy TOPSIS method in sungun copper mine

! " > " S ) , ) , . o + + e 1 m * , e - o . t * o ,

S),), m*,e *s o,e o/ te -1est .o++e1 3e+os*ts o/ I1, *. *s -o.te3 *, te ,o1t6

est o/ te .o),t1y .-ose to Aze15*7,' A1me,* ,3 T)1=ey 5o13e1s" Te.,*.- ,3

e.o,om*.- st)3*es e1e so, tt te most ++1o+1*te o/ m*,*, meto3 /o1 t*s 3e+os*t

*s o+e, +*t m*,*, meto3" %y t*s meto3 !84 m*--*o, to,s o/ o1e *t 0" +e1.e,te o/ .o++e1 13e ., 5e m*,e3" Tot- m*,es -*/e est*mte3 to 5e !> ye1s *t ,,)-

+1o3).t*o, o/ ; m*--*o, to,s *, /*1st ye1s ,3 >4 m*--*o, to,s /o1 1em*,*, ye1s" D)1*,

t*s +e1*o3 80 m*--*o, to,s o/ ste m)st 5e 1emo9e3" So' te ste to o1e 1t*o *, t*s

m*,e *s >"8> :#ose*,*e et -" 200


9/19

?4

*" >" A#P mo3e- /o1 -o3*,6)-*, system se-e.t*o,

Rys" >" Mo3e- A#P 3- y5o1) system) z!3),=) o3sty

Tese mt1*.es 1e .o,st1).te3 5y , e@+e1t tem" Us*, t*s ++1o.' , e9-)t*o,

tem o/ /o)1 mem5e1s o 1e /1e()e,t-y *,9o-9e3 *, e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, *, te +1t*.)-1

o+e, +*t m*,e o+e1t*o, s )se3" It 3ese19e3 me,t*o,B -- o/ tem 9e e()- *m+1ess*o, *,

3e.*s*o, m=*, +1o.ess"

! " ! " E 9 - ) t * o, + 1 o. e 3) 1 e 5y / )z z y T O P S I S * , s ),), . o++e 1 m * ,e

I, t*s st)3y' te,ty to tt1*5)tes ,3 t1ee -te1,t*9es e1e .o,s*3e1e3" A#P mo3e-

s )se3 to tt1*5)te e*t*, 5e.)se We*t o/ tt1*5)te so)-3 5e *9e, to 3e.*s*o,

m=e1s /o1 ++-*.t*o, /)zzy TOPSIS meto3"

o1 te /*1st ste+ o/ t*s meto3o-oy' te 3e.*s*o, mt1*@' 1e+1ese,t*, te +e1/o1m,.e

9-)es o/ e. -te1,t*9e *t 1es+e.t to e. .1*te1*o,' *s .om+)te3"

T5-e ! *s so*, t*1tee, tt1*5)tes 1e te sm--e1 te 5ette1 ty+e .1*te1* ,3 ,*,e

tt1*5)tes 1e te -1e1 te 5ette1 ty+e .1*te1*"

I, o13e1 to t1,s/o1m te +e1/o1m,.e 1t*,s to /)zzy -*,)*st*. 91*5-es s 3*s.)sse3 *,

te +1e9*o)s se.t*o,' te +e1/o1m,.e 1t*,s *, T5-e ! 1e ,o1m-*ze3 *,to te 1,e o/

0'> 5y E()t*o,s >4 ,3 > :Ce, >???4<

te -1e1 te 5ette1 ty+em@ x —m*, x ij ij


10/19

r ij

-m@ x xij ij te sm--e1 te 5ette1 ty+e

?

:>> 0">4

S*+me,t :.!< 0"2! 0"28> 0"2?2

I,s)1,.e:.4< 0">4> 0">> 0">4

M*,te,,.e :.< 0">88 0"20> 0">;

L5o1:.< 0">88 0">> 0">4

E-e.t1*.- :.;< 0"04; 0"20> 0"2!

T1*,*, :.8< 0"0?4 0">20 0"088

)e-s :.?< 0"282 0">20 0">4

P1o3).t*o, :.>0< 0">88 0"!2> 0"2?2

Mte1*- s*ze :.>>< 0"2! 0"080 0"2!!

Mo*st)1e :.>2< 0">4> 0">> 0"204

#)-e 3*st,.e :.>!< 0">88 0">20 0">>;

E,9*1o,me,t :.>4< 0"2! 0">> 0">>;

G1o),3 .o,3*t*o, :.>< 0"!2? 0"20> 0">>;

Wete1 .o,3*t*o, :.>< 0"!2? 0"20> 0">;

Use/)- -*/e :.>;< 0"2! 0"!> 0"!;?

-e@*5*-*ty :.>8< 0"282 0">> 0"08

A9*-5*-*ty :.>?< 0"2! 0"24> 0"204

Ut*-*zt*o, :.20< 0">88 0"!2> 0"2!

S)++o1t :.2>< 0">4> 0"20> 0"2!!


11/19

Co,t*,)es o/ m*,*, :.22< 0">4> 0"20> 0"2?2

?

TA%LE 4

No1m-*ze3 3e.*s*o, mt1*@ /o1 /)zzy TOPSIS ,-ys*s

TA%ELA 4

M.*e1z z,o1m-*zo,e7 3e.yz7* 3- 1ozmyte7 ,-*zy TOPSIS

A-te1,t*9e

C1*te1*System A> System A2 System A! C1*te1* e*t :w j<

%s*. +1*.e 0"!!! 0"28 0"2;! 0">;

Comm*ss*o, 0"; 0";>4 0";2; 0"0>

S*+me,t 0"!!! 0"28 0"2;! 0"02I,s)1,.e 0"; 0";>4 0";2; 0"04;

M*,te,,.e 0"00 0";> 0"! 0"0?>

L5o1 0"00 0";>4 0";2; 0"0>

E-e.t1*.- >"000 0";> 0"!4 0"0;4

T1*,*, 0"8!! 0"8; 0"?0? 0"02?

)e-s 0">; 0"8; 0";2; 0">!>

P1o3).t*o, 0"00 0"8; 0";2; 0"02

Mte1*- s*ze 0"; 0"000 0"4 0"024

Mo*st)1e 0"; 0";>4 0"4 0"0>?

#)-e 3*st,.e 0"00 0"8; 0"8>8 0"00

E,9*1o,me,t 0"; 0"28 0">82 0"0>

G1o),3 .o,3*t*o, >"000 0"42? 0">82 0"04

Wete1 .o,3*t*o, 0"000 0";> 0"! 0"0>8

Use/)- -*/e 0"; >"000 >"000 0"0>0

-e@*5*-*ty 0"8!! 0"28 0"000 0"028

A9*-5*-*ty 0"; 0";> 0"4 0"0>?

Ut*-*zt*o, 0"00 0"8; 0"! 0"0!

S)++o1t 0"; 0";> 0"4 0"02

Co,t*,)es o/ m*,*, 0"!!! 0"42? 0";2; 0"0>;

91*5-e *s te, t1,s/o1me3 *,to /)zzy t1*,)-1 mem5e1s*+ /),.t*o, s so, *, T5-e

" T*s *s te /*1st ste+ o/ te /)zzy TOPSIS ,-ys*s" Te /)zzy tt1*5)te e*t *s -so

.o--e.te3 *, T5-e "


12/19

Te se.o,3 ste+ *, te ,-ys*s *s to /*,3 te e*te3 /)zzy 3e.*s*o, mt1*@" Te

1es)-t*, /)zzy e*te3 3e.*s*o, mt1*@ *s so, s T5-e 5y )s*, E()t*o, !"

A..o13*, to T5-e ' e =,o tt te e-eme,ts vij ' V i' j 1e ,o1m-*ze3 +os*t*9et1*,)-1 /)zzy ,)m5e1s ,3 te*1 1,es 5e-o, to te .-ose3 *,te19- 0'>" T)s' e


13/19

9 7

TABLE 5 Decision matrix usin !u""# $inuistic variab$es

TABELA 5

%acier" dec#"ji " w#&or"#staniem ro"m#t#c' "mienn#c' $inwist#c"n#c'

A$ternative

Criteria(#stem A) (#stem A* (#stem A+ Criteria wei't ,w j -

Basic .rice ,/0)51/0+/1 /025- ,/0)51/0+/1 /025- ,/0)51 /0+/1 /025- ,/0751/09/1 )0//-

Commission ,/0551 /07/1 /035- ,/0551 /07/1 /035- ,/0551 /07/1 / 035- ,/0//1 /0)/1 /0*5-

('i.ment ,/0)51/0+/1 /025- ,/0)51/0+/1 /025- ,/0)51 /0+/1 /025- ,/0551/07/1 /035-

4nsurance ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0551 /07/1 /035- ,/0551/07/1 /035-

%aintenance ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0551 /07/1 /035- ,/0751/09/1 )0//-

Labor ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0551 /07/1 /035- ,/0551/07/1 /035-

E$ectrica$ ,/0751/09/1 )0// - ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0)51/ 0+/1 /025- ,/0551/07/1 /035-

Trainin ,/0751 /09/1 )0// - ,/0751/09/1 )0//- ,/0751/ 09/1 )0//- ,/0+51/05/1 /05-

6ue$s ,/0//1/0)/1 /0*5- ,/0751/09/1 )0//- ,/0551 /07/1 /035- ,/0751/09/1 )0//-

roduction ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0751/09/1 )0//- ,/0551 /07/1 /035- ,/0+51/05/1 /05-

%ateria$ si"e ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0//1/0)/1 /0*5- ,/0+51 /05/1 /05- ,/0+51/05/1 /05-

%oisture ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0+51 /05/1 /05- ,/0)51/0+/1 /025-

8au$ae distance ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0751/09/1 )0//- ,/0751 /09/1 )0//- ,/0551/07/1 /035-

Environment ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0)51/0+/1 /025- ,/0//1 /0)/1 /0*5- ,/0//1/0)/1 /0*5-

round condition ,/0751/09/1 )0// - ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0//1 /0)/1 /0*5- ,/0+51/05/1 /05-

Weat'er condition ,/0//1/0)/1 /0*5- ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0551/ 07/1 /035- ,/0)51/0+/1 /025-

:se!u$ $i!e ,/0551 /07/1 /035- ,/0751 /09/1 )0//- ,/0751 /09/1 ) 0//- ,/0//1 /0)/1 /0*5-

6$exibi$it# ,/0751/09/1 )0//- ,/0)51/0+/1 /025- ,/0//1 /0)/1 /0*5- ,/0+51/05/1 /05-

Avai$abi$it# ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0+51 /05/1 /05- ,/0)51/0+/1 /025-

:ti$i"ation ,/0+51 /05/1 /05- ,/0751 /09/1 )0//- ,/0551 /07/1 / 035- ,/0+51 /05/1 /05-

(u..ort ,/0551/07/1 /035- ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0+51 /05/1 /05- ,/0+51/05/1 /05-

Continues o! minin ,/0)51/0+/1 /025- ,/0+51/05/1 /05- ,/0551/ 07/1 /035- ,/0)51/0+/1 /025-


14/19

? 8

TA%LE )zzy6e*te3 3e.*s*o, mt1*@

TA%ELA

M.*e1z 3e.yz7* 1ozmyty. o,y.

A-te1,t*9e

C1*te1*System A> System A2 System A!

%s*. +1*.e :0">>' 0"2;' 0"4< :0">>' 0"2;' 0"4< :0">>' 0"2;' 0"4<

Comm*ss*o, :0"00' 0"0;' 0"2>< :0"00' 0"0;' 0"2>< :0"00' 0"0;' 0"2><

S*+me,t :0"08' 0"2>' 0"!8< :0"08' 0"2>' 0"!8< :0"08' 0"2>' 0"!8<

I,s)1,.e :0"!0' 0"4?' 0";2< :0"!0' 0"4?' 0";2< :0"!0' 0"4?' 0";2<

M*,te,,.e :0"2' 0"4' 0"< :0"2' 0"4' 0"< :0"4>' 0"!' 0"8<

L5o1 :0">?' 0"!' 0"< :0"!0' 0"4?' 0";2< :0"!0' 0"4?' 0";2<

E-e.t1*.- :0";>' 0"!' 0"8< :0">?' 0"!' 0"< :0"08' 0"2>'0 "!8<

T1*,*, :0"2' 0"4' 0"< :0"2' 0"4' 0"< :0"2' 0"4'0 "<

)e-s :0"00' 0"0?' 0"2< :0"' 0"8>' >"00< :0"4>' 0"!' 0"8<

P1o3).t*o, :0">2' 0"2' 0"42< :0"2' 0"4' 0"< :0">?' 0"!' 0"<

Mte1*- s*ze :0">?' 0"!' 0"< :0"00' 0"0' 0">< :0">2' 0"2' 0"42<

Mo*st)1e :0"08' 0"2>' 0"!8< :0"08' 0"2>' 0"!8< :0"0' 0">' 0"2?<

#)-e 3*st,.e :0">?' 0"!' 0"< :0"4>' 0"!' 0"8< :0"4>' 0"!' 0"8<

,E,9*1o,me,t :0"00' 0"0;' 0"2>< :0"00' 0"0!' 0">>< :0"00' 0"0>' 0"0<

G1o),3 .o,3*t*o, :0"2' 0"4' 0"< :0">2' 0"2' 0"42< :0"00' 0"0'0 "><

Wete1 .o,3*t*o, :0"00' 0"0!' 0">>< :0"0' 0">' 0"2?< :0"08' 0"2>' 0"!8<

Use/)- -*/e :0"00' 0"0;' 0"2>< :0"00' 0"0?' 0"2< :0"00' 0"0?' 0"2<

-e@*5*-*ty :0"2' 0"4' 0"< :0"0' 0">' 0"2?< :0"00' 0"0' 0"><

A9*-5*-*ty :0"08' 0"2>' 0"!8< :0"0' 0">' 02?< :0"0' 0">' 0"2?<

Ut*-*zt*o, :0">2' 0"2' 0"42< :0"2' 0"4' 0"< :0">?' 0"!' 0"<

S)++o1t :0">?' 0"!' 0"< :0">2' 0"2' 0"42< :0">2' 0"2' 0"42<

Co,t*,)es o/ m*,*, :0"02' 0"0?' 0"20< :0"0' 0">' 0"2?< :0"08' 0"2>' 0"!8<

? ?


15/19

., 3e/*,e te /)zzy +os*t*9e6*3e- so-)t*o, :PIS' A&< ,3 te /)zzy ,et*9e6*3e- so6

-)t*o, :NIS' A H < s v & j=:>'>'>< ,3 v j- = :0'0'0' 2' """' n" T*s *s te t*13

ste+ o/ te /)zzy TOPSIS ,-ys*s"o1 te /o)1t ste+' te 3*st,.e o/ e. -te1,t*9e /1om A& ,3 A H ., 5e .)11e,t-y

.-.)-te3 )s*, E()t*o,s >> ,3 >2" Te /*/t ste+ so-9es te s*m*-1*t*es to , *3e-

so-)t*o, 5y E()t*o, >!" Te 1es)-t*, /)zzy TOPSIS ,-yses 1e s)mm1*ze3 *, T5-e ;"

A, e@m+-e *s )se3 *, o13e1 to *--)st1te Ste+s 4 ,3 .-.)-t*o,s s /o--os

d & >= !> :>-"0>>-0"2;-0"4<

V>

!:>-0- 0"0;- 0"2>- 008- 2>- 0!8-0"02- 0"0?-0"20";;0

d >- = ! :0-0">> *s .-.)-te3 /o1 t*s e@m+-e s /o--os

TA%LE ;

)zzy TOPSIS ,-ys*s

TA%ELA ;

Rozmyt ,-*z TOPSIS

A-te1,t*9e 3*V 3* H

CC i R,=*,

A> >";;0 ;">4! 0"!>> 2

A2 >"!! ;"40 0"!24 >

A! >"?!? ;"0 0"!0 !

>V

!

V >!

V >!


16/19

d

CC> d d +>

+" ;>4!+" >;;0

>

>00

> ;>4! " 0!>> " :>;


17/19

I, .o,.-)s*o,' So9e-6T1).= :A2< s 5e.ome te most 3es*15-e system mo, t1ee

-te1,t*9es *t te /*,- +e1/o1m,.e 9-)e o/ 0"!24B *-e -o3e16T1).= ,3 So9e-6

T1).=6Co,9eyo1 5e-t 9e +os*t*o,e3 t te se.o,3 ,3 t*13 1,=s *t 0"!>> ,3 0"!0 ste /*,- +e1/o1m,.e 9-)es' 1es+e.t*9e-y"

*onclusions

Te o+e, +*t e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, +1o5-em *s st1te*. *ss)e ,3 s s*,*/*.,t

*m+.ts to te o+e,6+*t 3es*, ,3 +1o3).t*o, +-,,*," Most o/ e@*t*, o+e, +*t e()*+me,t

se-e.t*o, 1e-y o, o57e.t*9e *,+)t 3t' *t -*tt-e o1 ,o s)57e.t*9e 7)3me,t' o1 /o.)s o,

s*,-e +1mete1B ,3 te1e/o1e -e3 to +oo1 e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, 3)e to te MADM ,t)1e

o/ e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, +1o5-em"

I, t*s st)3y' .om5*,t*o, o/ A#P' TOPSIS ,3 /)zzy set teo1y te.,*()es *s

*,t1o3).e3 to se-e.t te s)*t5-e -o3*,6)-e e()*+me,t *, -1e o+e, +*t m*,es" Te

meto3s ,3 e@+e1*e,.es -e1,e3 /1om te st)3y ., 5e 9-)5-e to te o+e, +*t m*,es /)t)1e

st1te*. +-,,*," Em+*1*.- 1es)-ts soe3 tt te +1o+ose3 meto3s 1e 9*5-e

++1o.es *, so-9*, te +1o+ose3 m*,*, e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, +1o5-em" TOPSIS *s

9*5-e meto3 /o1 te +1o+ose3 +1o5-em ,3 *s s)*t5-e /o1 te )se o/ +1e.*se +e1/o1m,.e

1t*,s" We, te +e1/o1m,.e 1t*,s 1e 9)e ,3 *,..)1te' te, te /)zzy TOPSIS *s

te +1e/e11e3 te.,*()e"

E. m*,*, e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, *s ),*()e *, ,t)1eB t)s' te s)..ess o/ te +1ese,t

st)3y s ,o )1,tee /o1 *ts ++-*.5*-*ty to ote1 ++-*.t*o,s" $)3*.*o)s )se o/ +1o+ose3

meto3 *s 39*se3 *, so-9*, s+e.*/*. ++-*.t*o," I, 33*t*o,' te1e e@*sts ote1 o1t

*,9est*t*, MADM meto3s /o1 m*,*, e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, +1o5-em" T*s 5e.omes o,e

o/ te /)t)1e 1ese1. o++o1t),*t*es *, t*s .-ss*.- yet *m+o1t,t 1ese1. 1e"

REERENCES

> A 7 , * A"' Os , - o o M"' 200; H A++-*.t*o, o/ A#P6TOPSIS Meto3 /o1 Lo3*,6#)-e E()*+me,t

Se-e.t*o, *, O+e, +*t M*,es" II I,te1,t*o,- M*,*, Co,9e,t*o,' Me@*.o"

2 A7 ,* A"' Os,-oo M"' A=51+o)1 M"' 200; H O+t*m*z*, -o3*, system o/Go-6e6Go1*1o, o1e m*,e o/

I1, 5y e,et*. -o1*tm" I1o, o1e .o,/e1e,.e' A)st1-*"

! %,3o+3yy S"'e,=ts)51m,*, P"' >?8;HE@+e1tsystemss3e.*s*o,*3*,s)1/.em*,e e()*+me,t

se-e.t*o," I,te1,t*o,- $o)1,- o/ M*,*,' Re.-mt*o, ,3 E,9*1o,me,t o-" >' 2' >?H>"

4 % s . e t*, A"' 2004 H A, ++-*.t*o, o/ te ,-yt*. *e11.y +1o.ess *, e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, t O1,e-*

o+e, +*t .o- m*,e" M*,*, Te.,o-oy :T1,s" I,st" M*," Met--" A?26A>??"


18/19

>0>

%s.et*, A"' Ozts A"' K,-* A"' 200 H ES .om+)te1 so/t1e )s*, /)zzy -o*. /o1 e()*+me,t se-e.t*o,*, m*,*, e,*,ee1*," Te $o)1,- o/ te So)t A/1*., I,st*t)te o/ M*,*, ,3 Met--)1y o-" >0' !H

;0"

%-,.13 %"S"' 51y.=y W"$"' >?8> H Systems e,*,ee1*, ,3 ,-ys*s" 2,3 e3*t*o, :E,-eoo3 C-*//s'

N"$" P1e,t*.e6#--' I,."' >?8>??; H S)1/.e m*,*, e()*+me,t .ost ,-ys*s *t 3e9e-o+e3 -*,e1 51e= e9e, mo3e-"

I,te1,t*o,- $o)1,- o/ M*,*,' Re.-mt*o, ,3 E,9*1o,me,t o-" >>' 2' !H8"

8 C e - e 5 * N"' >??8 H A, e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, ,3 .ost ,-ys*s system /o1 o+e, +*t .o- m*,es" I,te1,t*o,-

$o)1,- o/ M*,*,' Re.-mt*o, ,3 E,9*1o,me,t o-" >2' 4' >8>H>8;"

? C, "' K)m1 N"' 200; H G-o5- s)++-*e1 3e9e-o+me,t .o,s*3e1*, 1*s= /.to1s )s*, /)zzy e@te,3e3 A#P6

5se3 ++1o." Ome o-" !' 4' 4>;H4!>"

>0 Ce, C#" >??? H E9-)t*, e+o, systems )s*, 1,=*, /)zzy ,)m5e1s" )zzy Set System o-" >0;' 2H

!"

>> De,5y %"' S.o/*e-3 D"' >??0 H A++-*.t*o, o/ e@+e1t systems *, e()*+me,t se-e.t*o, /o1 s)1/.e 3es*,"

I,te1,t*o,- $o)1,- o/ M*,*,' Re.-mt*o, ,3 E,9*1o,me,t o-" 4' 4' >H>;>">2 #-- R"' D,e s m, 3 K"' 200! H Re-*5*-*ty Mo3e--*, o/ S)1/.e M*,*, E()*+me,t Dt Gte1*,

,3 A,-ys*s Meto3o-o*es" I,te1,t*o,- $o)1,- o/ M*,*,' Re.-mt*o, ,3 E,9*1o,me,t o-" >;' !'

>!?H>"

>! #ose*,*e S"#"' Po)11*m*, Y"' A55e #"' 200 H A++-*.t*o, o/1o.= mss *,3e@ :RM*< to 3ete1m*,e o/

5-st*, *,3e@ :%I< H A .se st)3y s),), .o++e1 m*,e H I1, MPES' +" >0>!H>0>8"

>4 #1e51 M"$"' >??0 H P1e-*m*,1y 31-*,e se-e.t*o, /o1 s)1/.e .o- m*,*, o+e1t*o," I, P1o." 2,3

I,te1,t*o,- .o,/e1e,.e o, m*,e +-,,*, ,3 e()*+me,t se-e.t*o,' C,3' >!!H4!"

> K)/m,, A"' G)+t M"M"' >?8 H I,t1o3).t*o, to /)zzy 1*tmet*. teo1y ,3 ++-*.t*o,s" Ne Yo1=' ,

Nost1,3 Re*,o-3"

> L*z ott e Y"' >?88 H E.o,om*. ,3 te.,*.- 1e-t*o,s 5etee, o+e,6+*t 3es*, ,3 e()*+me,t se-e.t*o,"

S*,- A :E3"??0 H Te A,-yt*. #*e11.y P1o.ess" M.G1 #*--' Ne Yo1="

>8 S t y T"L"' 1 s L"G"' >??4 H De.*s*o, m=*, *, e.o,om*.' +o-*t*.-' so.*-' ,3 te.,o-o*.-

e,9*1o,me,ts *t te ,-yt*. *e11.y +1o.ess" P*tts5)1' RWS P)5-*.t*o,s"

>? Sm,t %"' S1=1 %"' M)=e17 e e S"' 2002 H Se-e.t*o, o/ o+e,.st m*,*, e()*+me,t 5y m)-t*6.1*te1*

3e.*s*o,6m=*, +1o.ess" M*,*, Te.,o-oy :T1,s" I,st" M*," Met--" A' >;H2!"

2> Z3e L"A"' >? H )zzy sets" I,/o1mt*o, ,3 Co,t1o-" o-" 8' !!8H!!"

&O+, /0&/2 &O /3&45 O&ST67 6 5OPL4I*" O&5765O67*"OPT7 4 8TO&/I O/87T9 : TOPSIS

S!o = -).zoe

Meto3 1ozmyt' =o+-,* o3=1y=o' o3st' mszy,y * )1z>3ze,*

St 1esz.ze, *e

Do51 )1z>3zeJ *,y,*e1** 1,*.t 7est 7e3,> z ,7,*e7szy. 3e.yz7* )z-X3,*7>.y. +1o7e=t =o+-,*'

+-,o,*e +1o3)=.7* * +1met1y e=o,om*.z,e 1,*.t o3=1y=oeo" I,y,*e1o*e +-,)7>.y =o+-,*X zy=-e

+o-e7> , se7 *,t)*.7* * 3o*3.ze,*) +o3e7mo,*) 3e.yz7*' m*mo e 3o51 )1z>3zeJ 7est z3,*e,*em

z!oo,ym o+1tym , *e-) =1yte1*. * o5e7m)7>.ym *e-e os5" W ,*,*e7szym o+1.o,*)' s+o13 *e-)

mo3e-* =1yte1* +o3e7mo,*) z!oo,y. 3e.yz7* * mo3e-* *e-ot1y5)toy. 3- ,7513z*e7 +1e/e1o,eo

y5o1)' y51,o te.,*=X +1e/e1e,.7* =o-e7,o.* +o+1zez +o3o5*eJsto 3o 1oz*>z,* *3e-,eo

>02


19/19

:TOPSIS

Loading-haulage Equipment Selection in Open Pit Mines Based on Fuzzy-ToPSIS Method

Documents

Transcript of Loading-haulage Equipment Selection in Open Pit Mines Based on Fuzzy-ToPSIS Method