llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J...

26
1"-' ... rmh ... tli 2- ! '2..1j 1)0 .. "J'U'\'1..................... . . . . 'lrlJ 413 12 lUl. 2559 d .!< _1"'.\ 11 'YI fJ !l1IlJ'U1i'.i'J:IJ" SI Q '" 0 l'JfJ'W / - C 1-rt'fJ [J [if i'l.l'.iPl'l'1'.il'lJ lUJl 0 llfl'j cJ\JVI:"n. &,,\un: #JRw'

Transcript of llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J...

Page 1: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

1"-' ~~\I~ ...rmh~t1

lilUr.~hn'lv11tJ~1'l10~~ iL~:;5~M\'1t11

... tli 2- ! '2..1j 1)0~···~·······i··~······(f{:K·~·[(t«··· .. "J'U'\'1..................... . .

. #~ . H''l.Jlh'fJmn~ 'm~1J1J

~lV1J~l11'J-A'"Ji'l.l (~llf1. ;1JWf1~l'J'illf1mfJ'U'fJf1) f'lJ~ 'lrlJ 413 1'U~ 12 lUl. 2559

d • .!< _1"'.\ 11 qSl~ 1'J'fJ~ 'l.J'f)~'1"Jl'J ~u 1l1l~ltlf1~l'.if11'Jm'JfJlm'H)'1 "f11~lJmlJ'J~1J1J'n'lj'f11'J 'YI fJ !l1IlJ'U1i'.i'J:IJ"

.~ SI Q ~ '" 0

"J'U'Vlfll'l1'W~~ l'JfJ'W ~m'l1l'.im1J /- C 1-rt'fJ 1'l.l'Jfl~"l'JWl [J I~t) hh~~llij'Unn [if l~'f) i'l.l'.iPl'l'1'.il'lJ

lUJl 0llfl'j

cJ\JVI:"n. t15u'&i~1'll1l1)b\lVIU &,,\un:

#JRw'

Page 2: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

'" m.1u

D

91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J

1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1

/ '- ...

D

m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219

"' "' 1'W'YI 12 :I.I.fl. 2559

"' "' 0 1'W'Ylf1111'Wfl /

1"4ei 1t11f1flltil'W f111 [B/ 1viei 1u1flm111

11lJll'H'H\lJ

Page 3: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

I I <::I OJ <::I

'Vl_fl~--Q~_Q®_._Q'9;:>/}_~-®~-----------------------------------------1'U'Vl __ _®@ __ J.)fl11~1l! __ ~~<t'~-----------------------------

b~il-:l_~[!?[~J1m1bJ,6~~k'€1JJm~o1TIJ)jUJf.!b~-~-~'-m'nl~iil~;rumJ6l!m1\~m1VfkU'.Yl1JP:~AJJ.'~-------------------------------

('U1..:i6'1'Vil31 'V'l6'lflru1'Um) II CU II C!CU

QJ!i.f II 0 O..l.<:::t.

~1~'U1flfl~"ll1~B1'U1~fl11'UflU1~11

' -rm~111"lln11bb'Vl'U ere.J1'U1~m1na..:inm..:i

'IJ

6'11irn..:i1'U'l.1i;Y~m~'Vl11..:ibn~~1bbfi~6'1~mcl

Page 4: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

~1tii:.J11 vHn~me:in 13!n~~VJE b"U~urublje:i..:i ?1111<fin?1.n1ti&iururu&ibbvl..:i'll1&i bb'1~bll'Ll 'i IV llV IV

m-11116n Trn1~ty1'l.!flru~n111116m 1'U~vi1111'1ln11bb~'l.!~'U 1\?lu11 ti1 ti'Vl1..:ii 'll1n111'l.!m1~1111 'l.!1

"1.lt1..:Jflru~m11116n11u~vi111161lfl11bb~'l.!~'U bde:i n'l.! ti1ti'l.! 1€l<t:<t:~ bbG'I~ 1\?l b~ti'Ub~ti..:iuvi m1111 'l.!1116111

"m.10. m1u~vi111161lm1bb~'U~'U 61'U61l." ti~ @) uuu~ @) b~©'U~G'l11"111 - B''l.!111"111 1€lit:it:~ 1 uvh.Ue:ib~©..:i '

"m1u f1Ttl1~uu11'1l n111 vi ti1 Vtb u·1.m.Ju1111" 6.J'\J '\J

1 i.Jm1d i:.J111M~~11ru1LL'11L ~i.J11 LBn6111m1u11mti, bb"1~'Uvim1111 i.J1116111~..:in~11

6111 m1~~ ~tl11 u1-tl'LJw1ti61li.J'1 'l.!n11LJn1LJ1~'U'U11'1ln111 vi ti1 VfilLJ1~~VJ5.n1~ b ~11:ff i.J© ch..:i b ll'LI1'Lio1111 ':..!'U '\J

eJ'U "il~i:i ..:i v.J "'~ €l fl11~ ~'l.!1 bb~ ~ b "il~tyn11VIU1€l ti 1..:J cY..:i E:i'l.!"1.J€l..:JD)~ b 'Vl P!61!1&ii1u1 'Li i:.J1l~..:J"lle:Ji:i..:i611b'lJ1 b €l fl6'!11

n11'U11mti, bb'1~1116111~..:in~111111 Vfvl1'LI b ~©mru11-ffLJ1~ 1ti61ltl~111~b ~'l.!6111m1~e:i 1 'Li '

"' C\ - ~. . ),_ _J '-? ~m1m©n ~,......_..____ )

cl3!n~~Vli b~~lltydfo..:i)

6'!111<fin6'!.nTw~utytY~bb'Vi..:i61!1~

(m11115n11'U~V11111'1in11LL~'l.!~'U)

- hn.l • v')IA~~ fl>IJ91U

• 00. ~.nV· t1.\J~l.\:.)~J\\..L~U1,~o,V1~\IJ~~J

U· 4,,, ... 5~ ('Ll1tJ61.ri''Vl~ th~t11~'Y15)

'\J

t1fl't>in~:::yi~1'1 bm::J (91 ".lbb6'1~61'lr1mru

Page 5: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

o bBf1gl11'V11.:i11csunTa

o 'l.J1~glun11ru-ru11csun11

0 bb1.:J"il.:Jb"il - fl11~~.:J~'Ll 'U q

05/11/58

Page 6: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

0 A11~Vl~1t.16ll€l~'a~'U'U11~n11

0 m1n~1n6'1n11'U~Vl1111~fl11

o cs:: bmV161flm1.W~u1tl'a~b'VlA

o ~n1wi:lruV11'a~uu11~m11 'Vlt.1 .,

0 A11~Vl~1t.16ll€l~n1'aUl}~tJ

0 A11~Vl~1t.16ll€l~fl11Un~tJ'a~'U'U'a1~fl11

o fl1'atlfi'atl'a~Uu'a1~flT~6lleN~Vl-r~m~'1fl1 ~~ ~

om1~~ - bb u1~~m1un~u'a~uu'a1~m16lle:i~~Vl~!m~1m

o Ai1~"i11b tlu~~e:i~i.iflT'aun~u'a~uu'a1"11fl111 'Vlt.1

o A11~ b tl'l..!~16lle:i~ m'aun~u'a~uu'a1~fl111 'Vl t.1

o bb 'l..!1~~m1u'1V11111"11m1bb uu1 Vi:W

o w1~ 'a1 ~fl q ~~fl .1 11~1 t.1 V161 fl bfl ru sz.1bbG'l~15fl11u'1V111vi e:i fl 1 'a .Q 21 ~ .c:::l.c:I

'U1Vl11'U1'1.Jb~B~'Vl~ 'W. A. lfilc:t'cs::'b

0 bU1Vl~1t.16lle:i~n11u'1V11'au1mi'.ie:i~~~ 'W.R. lfilct'cs:b

o bU1V1~1t.1m'atJl}~tJ1~uu11~n111 'Vlt.1 'W.R. lfil<i:'CS::<i:'

o ~-atlb u1V1~1t.1m1tJn1tJ1~uu11~m11 'Vlt.1~#1€l~m1 ~ ~~

o bb 'W1A11~~~nTatJn1tJ'a~uu11~m11'Vlt.11 ~b tl'l..!1'1.Ju·fi~ ~~ ~

05/11/58

2

Page 7: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

o6i'n'etru~A'W~

O"A'W~" (6lJeJ.:J61:Wb~'OJ~1"1)

o f'111:W'Vl:W1 cisuei.:i 'OJ~crn11~

OtJ1~~16l'OJ~Cl511~-if1116lfn11'lAl~b~€l'W

"' \OIB

_. ei.:i fln11'lh~ bJl'Vl'Vl~.:i~il n11:5' ~~1 ~'lHh'W1'0J'VliJ,1~

(911~f'111:w°111'W1qJ bu'lAl1~~1'W iln~1~b u tiu .Veiu.:i A'u1 'Wn11

tJ l] u~ .:i 1 'W bb ~ ~ b ~ 1'Vlii,1~tJl]u~.:i1 'W 'OJ~~ ei .:iii \OJ ru a :w u~

05111/58

3

Page 8: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

. ' 05/11!58

(PUBLIC MANAGEMENT)

@). fl11:W b6'1:We:lil1fl (Equity)

lD. fl11:WbU'W:W119l'HiTW (Standardization) ""

m. fl11:Wbthi.:Jb6'1 (Transparency)

cs:. 1°111:!.JbU'Wmn.:i (Neutrality)

·-- .. ---~-----------·--~-------

·. __ ·--··-·········

Page 9: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

''

0 f;jf16l.11ITTh'U1~ ( 1~'U'U/oLJ1':i16/.lf111)

o n:ufl'W6B'1'W1~ 'lJ

o 1-Un!J-a~b u~rn ll'W'Vi~ n

o i;t~1.:iei1ru1:5'n-;i

o 61.1~1~~1'WB'1'W1~ ... 0 hl~B.:Jbb'li.:ith.J

o bvl:u.:iut.h~:u1ru'Vlntl •

0U1~61.1161.1'U1~iili'l1'W~1:U/~11~i;lB'U

ohm "n11:u1.flu1si"

~ 0 "" 0 bt:.J~~f111/B1'W1~'W~:U

O 1~b1il:UBfl1rl/btl'Wn11l.l/L u~.:i1i;i . . 0 61.1B'Uf111BBf1fl1~.:J/~-!Jf111

0 ~~~'U51'W~'U > 51'U11l.I

o °l.11~m1th~m'W+~1miei~~ O n11~~~'W1~+~-!lf111bU'W°l.IB.:i~iiei1'U1~

'lJ

05/11/58

5

Page 10: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

0 btJ'W'a~bUf!UtlJ)D'~~1nn11~6'l~W56UB~~TW

o <i1'1tJ1tJri'Wmnn11tl~~1ru~1u o -a~uuBtl5~.tib~B~vJ1 'W'Vln-a~li1u

' "' '

o hlblltJtl1~6ZJ16tlhrn 0 h.ibtJ'Wl"l11~~B~n11U1~6ZJ16ll'W+i;r~l"I~

o 'lll'll1fl~T1..iij~1mnu1 tJ o "U'l~bb -a~:u~t:u1ri11m.J~~u/m1bbozl~-Uu

"' '

01~'U'UVl11:U6lB'U/tl-a~djw:..ig:i hJiitl-a~~'VIBJl1W

01~uum111h~1u1ll~~l'lli~n'Vlt]~~ - 1"ll1m1 - 1llbU'W6l'fng:i

o ~~~B~1uriri6'lmnn--J11~uuHhu11~ '

05/11/58

6

Page 11: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

o -a~b uCJu+15t1nu~.:i1u6116'l~ CJ 1~~u~eim-ab u~CJ'Wbb t1&i.:i

o 6ll1wi~l"l'Wfl~~~tum-at1Jju~.:i1u O~t"]'l3~ - vi6'i'n1"111m-a i11:1J11.Ut1u-a~uu1~1~~m

o 6ll1wiwn:1J~mde.i.:i b 'W'W 1CJu1mb&i~bb~m1u

OtiCJ:l.J'a~'U'U Top down > bottom up

o 1~1~1"111~i1~rum-aiisi1'W~1~6llei.:in11"1bein"11'W .,

0 f111tl~~tl~~1'LI:l.J11~1~~&1 b W'a1~fl1UCJ~+119!l'LI611:l.l6llB.:JB.:Jflf11

bb&i~Ufl&i1n11 u~ n-a~~u ' '

o 1"11-a 1 ollb ~fl 1u1&i~6'1116'l'Wb'Vll"l1~bnwi~&i~eim-ab tl~CJ'Wbb tl&i.:i

0il~Vl1"il1f16'1J111~bb1wi6\'t1:1J~1'LI~'LI 61 ~i'.i~&if1'a~~'U

(~.:Jfl:l.J bl"l'a'l3:0fl"il f111biJB.:J) .. 0 fi1u CJ :l.J~'lfl:l.J 1 ~CJ ~'I bb~b 'LIB~~ f111CJ n ~ ei.:i/~iJB'1'W1"il/~mh~ 1CJ "lltJ

"'

05/11/58

7

Page 12: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

"" 'V!~1crn.:i

~ bb 'U1Vl1.:Jfl1':i:il ~ fl1':itl'U6'l.fl11~ 'V!~B 6'lfJ1'U.f11'\i'l~ ~1':i.:JB ~ 'U

b~ei1 ~bn~t:-ig:i1911~btl1VJmci 1,1,g:i~l'l'lm.h~6l.:il°1~~.:iH ~1CJlBfl1':i~ '

1~1 'iifl1':i'll-rm tl~CJ'U mh.:i ':i'U bb ':i .:i uuw~'U~ 'WVi bbg:i~iJ1-iifl 1 ':iU u ' u .:i ~ u bb \91 t911 CJ fl 1 ':i 61 ~ 1 .:i bb ':i .:i u 'U ~ 1 si h -U fl ~ .:i 1-H ii fl 1 ':i cm ~ -r u

'U

~1 bU'Ufl1':i~1~tl'Ub'U'V!~~b~CJ'JoLJB.:iB~1.:i6'l~fl':ih ~.:id B1~~B.:JboU 'U'U

b1Sl1':i~CJ~'V!ti.:i 1,.yjeit-Hiimwei~~u b~CJ'U~ 'll~u~1 brn~'ll~'\Jb'll~ci'W 'U

c::::::>" fl 1 ':i\911 b U'U flT~'ll 1~~ fl ii fl11~f1~1 'Vl~ 61 1'W1~uuu~'V!111~ ci

~.:i'V!mci~~~tl~u'll':i.:i1~uu b ~ei 1-Hu11si b tl1VJ~1 CJeJ'Ub 'V!~1~6'l~ b 'Wfl11 ' . . 'W'w.1'U1'll':i~b'Vlfl" (Hahn - Beer Lee) (CO>~inlo)

c::::::> "fl 1 ':i b 'll~CJ'U bb 'll si .:i 'll~u'll 1.:i~fl~ru~"IJeN1'll u 'U'U'V!~B 1~uu 61.JeN ' 'U

1~'U'U fl 11 bi:! B .:J 1~'U'U 'U ~'V!1111'lifl11 bbSl ~ 1~'1.J'U 'U ~'Vf 11.:J1 'U 'U fl fl Sl • 1~ci m 1'll':i~611'Utl1~ 1ci'litl bbg:j~ b ~ .:i~~ 1-H'iifl11'll~utl 1 .:i b 'll~ CJ'U bb 'l.Jg:i.:i • b'UeJl'l11~11~b~'Jfl11ti':i1~~1" ('U11~.:J 'li6'lf1Sl'li1~) (1€!ct'm1€!)

'U '

05111/58

8

Page 13: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

n11un~u1~UU11~n11~B~~~~~i (~':i.i·mn1u~.:i) (l!:i<:t'"1C:.:)

' b~:W~'WU k:lct'ct'm (l°l11:W~eJ"lnT~· + bb'a>'.!OJ"lbOJ)

'U

q bbU~BBmth.J ct' ~Fi

G). Eifltl'i~aV15m'l'l ('l'l.A. li:JCi::'Ci::'m - li:iCi::'~m) ~~1..:i-r6u16l~~/1.uwil~fl ' "" '

li:J. fifln1'itlfotlj'ln1'.i-:5'~v'i1..:iutl-a:::inru('l'l.A. l!:!Ci::'~m - li:Jct'Glm) ~~ri11oif1\i18

mfl-r6 + b-Wui:.rne.iaf! ""

m. fifle.Jafle.i&l C'l'l.A. li:ict'Glm - l;:ict'll:Jml •th.Je.iaf!e.i~+11rum'l'lm'itl~u&i<iTu

Ci::'. 8fln1'ibLU'i'itlihin1'i'UeJ'l~6bU'W'!JeJ'lbeJn'lf'lJ ('l'l.A. li:Ji:film - li:Jct'mb) ' " ""

bLU'i'itl+"51..:irnn'lf'l.Jv'i1<i1'1.J1Vffo,flei~~..:iutl'i~u1ru + m.; + 1oif1ti18 " ""

'VI ~~lj +bb 'W 'd ~~fl 11tJl)~tJ 'a~'U'U116lifl116llB ~ 6l'Vi-r~i

C@o ct.J1~n1';i)

(DAVID OSBORNE + TED GAEBLER)

@). GJ~1~~ij'U16'1~GJi!uGJ'W'W + tJ-a:;;mwnii > ii1bilii1111be:i~ ... ' kl. G1~1~~ij'U16'l~bll'W"llB~tJ1:;;"lJ1"ll'Wii~1'W~1:1J + ~!?l~'WbliJ ...

ct'. GJ~1~~~u16'1~buw111n1il + bU1V1:1.11~ > n~;p:;;bu~u

ct'. GJ~1~-riju16'1~~1?1~6'1611 b ~OJ bll'WVl~n 1 ·1.m11~1?1GJ11~ut11:;;:1.11ru ...

05i11158

9

Page 14: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

ii6'11'W~'J:W

CO) o. i;i~1~.r~u1fl~B ~ nunfl 1n \916'11~>nfl1wa~uu 11'lfn1'rnfl~n11 ""

Cn!J - 1~buEJu - m1'1J~u~ - 1fl1.:ii;i~1~'1)

o ~\il,J'W1ri'nEJJ11w1 Vi~~ bViEJ:WJ11fl beJn'lf'Wbb~~'IJ1~b 'Vlfl~'W

0 6'1~1~fl11:WVi~'l"leJ t:u bbri'IJ1~'111'1f'WLb6'l~i;r~fl:IJ

o 'IJ.ru'IJ1~m1u~V111e:i~ri'm1 + 'Uflflfl 1ViiJ'IJ1~~'Vl5J11w ' '

05/11/58

10

Page 15: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

0fl11b~'U b~ bb6l~fl11~ci'd'Wi1ll"LJ B~J11 A beJ fl °U'W

0 fl1~bb&tb6lfl1.f11~tJbb6l~b 'VIA b 'W b6l ~&t11&t'Wb VI fl

o bn ~'lhyV11 bb;;i ~ ~-rn n -a~viu ~ anT;iW ~'W1'l.J 1~ b 'V1 ri1 'W ~1'W ~'W 61

(bA1'l~Hin'il - A11:!.l:iJ'Wfl~ - 61~flll - fl11~fl~1 '1) d3

o nTa~111il~e:iutJ1~biJ'W~av111111~t!m o uruvi1fi1-UCJ~i;Y..:i fl~1'VICJ1 'W1~uu11"1Jm1 .,

( b oU1 "l11 ~ b~'W"l11 ~/~ n ~11CJvi-U'111'1vi1 CJJile:i ~fl e:i n)

o fl ru~ n 11~n11'1 ua~viti 1 CJ ..:i1'W b~ CJ 145ei..:i111ije)1'W11il b 'W n11~ ..:in 11

tJ~i'llbbnb"ll

05f11i58

11

Page 16: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

0 b~:um~\lbb~U kl<t'okl

r:::::::> vY-:i rHlJ~ m1:1mTa'1 'lli5'118 fl ru~

- Aru~vimn~11~bu8uu1V111'1Jei<1m8n'1

- A ru~m1:um1tllJlth~uu116llm1bb6'1~1~ bu 8'1..1'1..11'Vl11116llm1

bb~'U~'U

- fl ru~ n11:u m1-W~u11~uuu1V111116lln11bb~'W ~'LI

- flru~m1:um1tllJltl1~uuu1V111116llf11'ibb~'W~'W

-fl ru~ n 11:u m-atlfotl 1-:i1~uuu1V11111611m1 bb~'W ~'W '

- flnJ~fl'i'i:IJflT:itllJltl'i~'U'U'i1"llf11'i

'15'1'1

Oll l§:ict'cs:'ct' Ct.J~'LJt.J'j~~1n~si~) q q

c::=> m111:1J + b~:IJ'lli'l..b~nu

c::=> fl11ii W.'i.'U. u-rrn..J'i\lfl1~'Vl'i1\l/'Vl'U1\l/n1:1J '

c::=> m1ii w. 1. u. 1~b tivuu~'ll!1111"llm1bb~'LI~'LI

c::=> m1ii W.1.!J. m1u~'11111no;im1u1'Ubiiei\lvi~ (tJ 1€l<t'~)

c:::::> m1ii'Vl'1..bv\11'Un1nu~ bb61fl1'itlfotl1\ltl1~~'VIBJ11W (n. w. 'i .) ~ '

OU\l\IU'U q

c::::::> EJ\l 1~ii bb 'LI1fi~ m1tll)~tl btl~~'Ubbtl61\l b~

05111/58

Page 17: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

o "IJ:il~n11n:u~hl~1btJ'W o ufo 1ri1.:i6l~1.:i1 ~mm~6l:wi1th~~'Vl6n1'W

o ufou1.:im1u~'!t111.:i1'W 1~AsieN~1 '

o i1m1u1~bil'We.J6l+1'~e.J6l611b~~ 0 n11'U ~'Vl11.:J'UU 1~:W1 rulPIB 'U &l'WB .:i ~'VI 5f116l\PI 1m-a-W \i!J'W1U1~ b 'VI fl

'

o u1~.:i"IJ1' qJr11~ .:i h.LJ111·1m111'!Xu!Ju~'Vlu1~~1~1°111:wzje:i~\Pl~61~1.:i u-ad~"lltl1~6'11'W11:w

0 \PIB'U6l'WB.:iA11:wJi'e:i.:im1"1.JB.:iU"a~"l11"lJ'W

0U1~"l11 "ll'Wbb6l ~~.:JA:Wi16'f 1'W ~1:Wb'Wn11\PI11 :V&lB'U bb6l ~~ ~ ~ 'U b:V

05!1 '158

13

Page 18: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

bb cw1f,1 ~n1-au~vi1-a-a161JnTa "bb uu 1 vi~" (1~b~61J ~'WV1¥1~) (klctcs::'.o)

@. ilri1'W~1:!.lb'Wn111~B1'lJ1~~1n'll1~'!J1'!J'lJ/A'W'lJBn1~uu11'!Jn11

(SHARING OF POWER)

I!:!. m~~1t:.1ehw1~ (DECENTRALIZATION)

m. b,j'W~~f;l.:J1'1J (OUTPUT) bbf;l~~f;lm::VI'U~fil'l.11~'!J1'!J'W

(OUTPUTCOME-PEOPLE) (RESULT ORIENTED)

cs:. (;l~'1J'W1~b~nbbf;l~n~~~-r~ (RIGHTSIZING) il'll1~~V15m'l"l

~. b,j'\J~G'lfl11'll~u~.:i1'W (PERFORMANCE BASED BUDGETING)

b. bb-li.:JoU'\J (MORE COMPETION)

~. 'll1~'!J1'!J'Wilri1'W~1:!.lfl~ lii'~~'Wh bbf;l::ABt:.1vi11~srnum1vi1.:i1'lJ'1JB.:ioLJ'111'!Jm

~. m!u~'4'W ri.:ib~~:!J "511m.f1u1f;l" (UPHOLD GOOD GOVERNANCE)

~. bll'Wth::'!J15'1.11vit1 (DEMOCRATIC)

@o. b~:!Jfil.f11A (EQUALITY)

@@. ~1:!.lilB 6!i1m'Vl~fil ~U'U&l'IJ'W bb'W~'W:: (FACILTATION) • @!§:J. c..Junn1~~~13.JilBn'W (NETWORKING)

@m. bU'WA11:!.l~fil.:Jfl11'1Jfil.:JU1~'!J1'!J'lJ/6i'.:iA:!J bbf;l::~~1.:JA11:!Jfi.:i'l"lBhbbrl'lh~'!J1'!J'W

(PEOPLE-SATISFACTION)

@CS:. bU'WU1::~VI5~6'l vi1b'W~.:J~A11vi1"1'forin~B.:i(OO RIGHT THING-"

EFFECTIVENESS) bviB'llfo1~~'Wrl'Ufl11bU~t:J'\JbbUM

@~. u~V111m1b~u1~r13.Jrh bbG'l::u.:ibiivi~f;l~bbVJ~~.:i mm1ri1'~bbf;l~'\.J1::LiJu1~\l! •

05/11/58

14

Page 19: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

' I V t1J <f .:::..::! .:::. .:::. V .:! .::f .::f

11~1ti'Vl~nbnruSVJbb~~15n11u';i'Vl11n'<\ln11uTwb:wei~'Vl~

.... ~ b t11~nTa

- ~61niJ~511:l..J 1-li'n£J 1~bUCJ'U'Vibth.J511mb&1~CJei:l..Jfo

- ~~nflruo11:J..J ~19lai''W1'Wfl11:J..Jflfll9i'ei~~~1:J..J ' ~

- ~~nm1:1Jfo~\916lleJU ii~\9l&l1i1n b 'Wfl11:1Jfo~\916lleiuvieia~fl:l..J bb&l ~fl 11m~v\'1

- ~~nw.n:iJl°1:1Jri11-li'VJ-rY'JCJ1n1th~~~\91 bn\9lt.J1dCJ6llth=1~61\91 ' ~ '

(~n:l..J Y>l.1.£). u k:ic.t'cs:'b :J..J1\9l11 b ) ii 6'"il tJ1~m1 ~ei

v"bn\9lt.J1~1CJ6llu61~al9l~eitJ1~61116ll'W ~ '

Vbfl\91~&1a:l..Jq'Vl~~~~eJJl11fl~~ei~~~

v" ~tJ1~~'VlfiJlTV'lbb&l~fl11:l..JR:Wfl1 b 'Wb ~~Jl11fl"il '

v 1lJii.ff 'W\9leJ'Wbb&1~m1tJ~u~~ 1wn'W f111 :J..Jlil1 b tl'W

v tJfotJ1.:in11n"iJa1'U116llm11~~'Wviei6'1m'Wn11ru '

1.,., 21

v" U1~6ll16ll'W \911Ufl'J1:l..J61~11l'J flbb&l~\9l1'J"il61BUfl'J1:l..J\9leJ~ fl11

v" iifl11U1~biJ'U~&l fl11tl!ju~ 116llfl11B tj b61:1JB

05,11158

Page 20: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

6l~tl b u1V1~1 CJ6UeJ ~n11tl~ ~tl1~uu116UnT~ 1 'VI CJ

(~~eJ~fl11)

@). 1~bth.i1tlm~fl£)Vl~.rn.J

boU'W ==? -rM11:W'Wru .. ""' ==? n11'U~'Vi11116llf111bb~'W~'W

==? n1'a'U~V111n~1111u1mi1e:i.:iVi~

'1"'~'1 ., ~ "" kl. b'Vlbut.l tlwrn.JVIS!flfl1'a+ni)bflru"Vl+'a~b'UCJ'U

boU'W ==> 'Vi~ncr11miiu1'1 ==> 1~bticium1:5'~~1u116!11111

6l~tl b uTv1~1 CJ6UeJ~ n11'l.J~ ~'lJ1~uu116UnTa1 'VI CJ dv

('VI \9leMf1Ta)

m. 1~btlt.!1tlwnui~~n16111n11Hm1f1(9]Hrnm1An~1~1-.'.l61

b'liu~ uu1~~1111u~V111116!11111Eiri1V11l • ~ 1111tllJJtl1~um16lln1'atJ1~bVlfl~'W

er:. 1 ~b tltJ 1 tlwn~~ tn1..lfl11Wbbsi~1\9l~tl 1~~-.'.!A b ~ei ~eM m1

boU'W~ n11'U~'Vi11tJ1~6!116ll'W

~ tJ1~6!116ll'Wi1~1'U~'J:W

~ u~V11bb'1~R11:w'il1bllu~l'i'e:i.:itJl)~tJ

==? 161'8Vlfltl+8Vl61"11&l{;l{'i/in1'Vl'UVI '

05/11158

16

Page 21: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

. '

bb 'U1'°111il ~ t9l b 'Uf111UlJlth~'lJ'lJ116Uf1Ta 1 'Vl ~

c1 ~b U'U1U511ii) cu

<». vlB.:J£iV1~'1.lbb6'1~UnU~Vl1:Wn!JVl:W1El + n!Jbnrusn + Vlsrnm1 + bb'l.l1~til

+ 1\;l~th~~.:irl + vln1V1'1.ltilH q

l!J. lii'B.:i~n~1f111:wvim~B.:i1'1.lm1unu~

b!l. vlB.:J~~1.:Jn11vi'N1'1.lb'l.l1~'1.J'l.J51'lln11vibll'W1~'U'U

Btil~B1~'1.J'l.J > 611'1.!~1

8til~mh'l.l11:w > 611'1.!~1

cs:. lii'B.:itl6'1n~.:i + ~~1.:irl1ut1:w + bb1.:J'1.:i1'11~-U'111'lln11 ~ ~

lil'n~ru~litl11liu~V11cae1011 'Vl~ cu cu q

(LEADERSHIP'S TRIAD, WILLIAMS, 1998)

bll. hrnei~1 + 11-:im~

~- "UB'UU1 > 'lNn1'a

rt:. btl~hn11-:i

05/11158

17

Page 22: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

~n~ru~~iJ1/~u~vn~t1'°11 Vi~ (~e:i) 'l.J 'l.J 'l

(LEADERSHIP'S TRIAD, WILLIAMS, 1998)

Q, Q, CV .c:L:::::1

<;;<;'. f1111'W"iluCJVl\91

GlO. fl'J1~611~1)f.l~\91~'1.Jb"iJ + 'l.J-r'IJ~'J

G)G). fl11iJ611il11f.l6'1~1.:'lbb).:j"iJ.:jb"iJ + ~'U~'J "

Q.i/ Q,0 Q

........... Jl~) + Jl~'Vl1 + Jl~~1'W-----. ~'U1U cu 'UdS

~ flf1!511~ (~B~~'U) . " ~ "il~CJ5'fi~ ("l.IB.:'l\91'1.JbB.:i)

JJihh lilil m1'1J~V111 - m-a'l.Jnfl-aB.:i - m1'\J~u~.:i1'U - ~~N1'W -

zjm~fo.:im1'\J~u~.:i1'W

.n~~1'W &1°111~'\J'a~'Wt'}~ - eJ'l.JiJ61CJ - 'IJfl~nJl1'W - 61.:ifl~ - fl1B'IJfl-r1 'Ud.3 Ci q

05/11158

18

Page 23: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

~ "riu~'!Jei<J5'U~'il::~ei'ltlluflu~1:i.l"Wtiltlti1hl61eimrn1:i.Jfil'il~1~'1:ft:.111:Writi1 "

1n'l trn:: 1:iJiJ m1iJV1:: tt:.1eiVl::t:.11uei ~1'lU1 "l tbvi"Wt:.11t:.11u'1-i1V11!1~'!JeJ'1(;l'IJ1 ~~1 u

'!JeJ'\.H'!J\;J'!Jei.:if!~o':i1iJ"

~ "ll1'il::bll'Uriu~ 'iJ::i'.iei::heici1.:ib~t:.111:iJ1tlf tlf ei'1iJeici1.:i~::iJ tileici1<J~::mjm.1

bb~'lbbvi61'.:iriueici1.:ihnmuiJ Principle 41t:.1 V1&i'nn11V1~.:i Vl&i'nm':ibtil boU'U 5u l\J::htl.~~n5muuflu 1n'Vln 'll hm V1~nm11V1ru., V11<J'il~t:.10-a-aiJ~ei.:ii'lmlueiu,,

" "'I

~ fl'J13.J~.!l13.J~1.!l 61 ~iie1tjb'W~\ilbl\J6VB.!lbb~6l~fl'Wbb6l~fillil~B'l.ll)u~

~'Wbtl'W'Ll~t.1 b6li'W A113.Jt.1~0113.J A113.J~ei~\il~ A113.Ji.ib'V1\ile..161 A113.J • •

05 11 '58

19

Page 24: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

05i11i58

(Merit System) 'V!~e:i1~U'Ul"Hu1ru ' '

- 'V!~nm1~b6'l~Bfl1\Pl (Equality of opportunity)

- 'V!~n\Pl11~6'11m1ri(Competence)

- 'V!~nm1~~'U\Pl~(Security of Tenure)

- 'V!~n\Pl11~bU'i.lmn~'V11~n11bi'.iei~ (Political neutrality)

~ i;;'m~ru~~u~1u'V11~~~1:v1un11m~vl1~rin#leNb'V!~1~6'1~~1~ ~ v

V1i;;'ncr11~'V!~ei~~~ FJ11n 1~vl1 b ~e:i-rn~1 bb~~ b6'1~~6'1~1 ~fl ru'll 1~ 1ti"tltl '

\9leisl'~fl~ (1°111~~1iln/w;11~-ru~~"tleiu/1111~\Pl11hlfl11) v

20

Page 25: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

(U';i~n1A1'LI';i1"llfl:\l"il1"1 <t: 'VU.J. 1€J<t:ct1€J ii <0>0 oUel)

<0> • .U1';i1"llm';i~el~~~ ~'LI 1 mi ~m5';i';i6.JvJ11 u~~~~n ~el~ b ll'Wo';i';i6.l "

1€J. oLJ1';i1"lln1';i~el~i'.i~\9lri1iin~ ~-ru~ ~"llel'U b~ 8&i&i~ 1'l.J~~1a

bTl. oLJ1';i1"lln1';i~ el~ bb8fi b~B ~cl 1'1.J ~1 BB n ~ ~ ~el'lh~ b8"lltJ6:l1'U';i16.l b 'jljij el

ci 'd'LI (9)'1.J

~. oU1';i1"lln1';i~el~ 1~bb&l1~N6lU';i~ b8"ll'Ub~ 8iJ"lle:J'U

b. oU1';i1"ll n1';i~ el~'l.Ji)u~'jlj.W111i ~ d ~fl 116.J b 1li 8~ D'';i';ill b U'U mn~'Vl1~ n1 ';j

biiel~1~u~m';j'l.J';j~"lf1"llu~18~1~bi'ie:inui)u~

1n1. .U1';i1"lln1';i~el~unu~\9l1lln~'jljlJ1811~18~el~&i~11a1';i"lle:i~

';i1"lln1';i

05,11.'58

21

Page 26: llfl'j - web.rid.go.thweb.rid.go.th/survey/pdf 57/CL57_11/222-59.pdfm.1u '" D 91 "' ~11rn1rn1:1.J 1"4ei 1u1f1Vi'il11ru1 / '-... D m'tl~rnnm1im~1111 E mJ0201.06/1219 1'W'YI "' "' 12

fl'!J~

~ .U111'llnTrVi~ ce'.Jtl11e'.Ju~V11'i/e'.Ju.:ifl'uuru'll11e'.Ju.nu~) ~ " " " ~ "d..I

01:ab1'u~.:i~fil ('Ubf.l'UJf.l/011u~V111/n11~.:io11/0111Jl)~/011"11.:i1uLllu1~uu/ V\9l~e:i1J1~ fo'lltl~hun:ui)

~ 011'\Jl)~'!.h~U'lJ)J'l!OJ)~~ (O~Vi:UJfJ/ViiObOrusn/Lb'Udfl\91/1'i;iq'\J1~~\lfl)

~ LO® N li!Vi©vi ti ~\I fl :y (V!U1f.111'll01'i/U1~'ll1'll'U)

~ tl1~L'Vl!'l'll1~5l:Y©bJVi~©

The End

05111/58

22