Liquidity Event Options July 12, 2012 for Privately Held ... - CPA Firms · Liquidity Event Options...
Transcript of Liquidity Event Options July 12, 2012 for Privately Held ... - CPA Firms · Liquidity Event Options...
7/12/2012
1
Liquidity Event Options for Privately Held Business OwnersBKD Corporate Finance Webinar
Tony Schneider
BKD Corporate FinanceIndianapolis, IN
July 12, 2012
Tony Giordano
BKD Corporate FinanceDenver, CO
Housekeeping Items
• To receive CPEo Participate in entire webinaro Answer all 4 polling questions when they are provided
• Technical Issueso To help prevent technical issues, please close any
unnecessary programs currently running on your computer
o If you experience any technical issues, immediatelycontact L&D (via BKD [email protected])
2
7/12/2012
2
Housekeeping Items
• Other Itemso This presentation will last approximately 50 minutes,
followed by 10 minutes of questions & answerso If your question was not answered, please contact either
today’s presenter (contact information will be provided on the last slide) or our Learning and Development Team at [email protected]
3
Liquidity Event Options for Privately Held Business OwnersBKD Corporate Finance Webinar
Tony Schneider
BKD Corporate FinanceIndianapolis, IN
July 12, 2012
Tony Giordano
BKD Corporate FinanceDenver, CO
7/12/2012
3
Welcome & Overview
• Privately held companies, by their nature, have less perpetuity than their public counterparts
o Founder/CEO energies & shifts in personal desireso Wealth concentration; desire to diversifyo Competitive landscape & cost of growth
5
Welcome & Overview
• Ultimately, business owner is confronted with many important decisions, including
o How do I transfer leadership within my company?o How do I monetize value I’ve created in my
business?o What constituencies are important to me as I
orchestrate my life transition? Family, employees, community, customers, vendors,
etc.
6
7/12/2012
4
Where BKD Can Assist
• Broad spectrum of experienced personnel, helping clients navigate through succession planning & execute transactions
• BKD’s specific transaction specialty groups includeo BKD Corporate Finance, LLC
Leading advisory group in M&A & capital raising
o BKD’s ESOP Advisory Group Has helped more than 150 companies transition over $2.7B in
wealth by selling 100% of their stock to leveraged ESOP
7
BKD Corporate Finance, LLC
• Leading M&A advisory group assisting with company sales & divestures, acquisitions & capital-raising transactions
• Have closed more than $4 billion in transactions
• Typical deal values—$10 - $250(+) million range
• Uniquely qualified & staffed to bring holistic view of liquidity alternatives available
• Pride ourselves in offering solutions that achieve our clients’ objectives
8
7/12/2012
5
Polling Question 1
Is it probable that your company’s shareholders will consider monetizing some of their business value within the next five years?•Yes•No•Not Sure
9
Liquidity Event Options
7/12/2012
6
Corporate Value
• Value comes in many shapes & formso Historic valueo Economic valueo Strategic valueo Intangible valueo Synergistic valueo Exploitation value
• Managed competitive negotiation process with multiple buyers conducted by experienced intermediaries typically results in higher values for seller
o Tends to place balance of power in hands of sellero Identifies synergies between buyers & seller & allows seller to negotiate
from position of strength
11
Liquidity Event Options
• Sale of 100% (or less) to strategic buyer• Sale of 100% (or less) to financial buyer
o Majority recap o Minority recap
• Leveraged recap• Sale to management team (MBO)• ESOPs
12
7/12/2012
7
Strategic Buyers
• Operating companies that provide comparable products & services
o Often competitors, suppliers or customers
• Could also be unrelated to target or its industryo Companies looking to diversify revenue streamso Companies seeking to build upon their business
model &/or competencies to enhance earnings or reduce risks Hillenbrand, Inc. (NYSE: HI) purchase of K-Tron
(NASDAQ: KTII)13
Strategic Buyers
• Buyer motivations are multifaceted & varied, includingo Strategic positioningo Market share; new channelso New products & processeso New customers or deeper penetrationso Technologieso Scale; synergies; earnings enhancementso Management skills; corporate know-howo Diversificationo Accelerated growth & earnings
14
7/12/2012
8
Polling Question 2
What attribute of your business do you believe a strategic buyer would find most valuable?• Products offering; Innovation• Strategic Positioning• Market coverage/channels or Customers• Management Team• Superior Earnings Performance
15
Strategic Buyers
• Primary advantages o Potentially, deep universe of buyerso Perspectives of risks & returns among candidate buyers
can vary significantlyo Long-term investment horizonso Often lower return hurdleso May be motivated to grow in industry with average or
below-average prospectso Often, can bring deeper management talento Typically, cash buyers with lower transitional demands
16
7/12/2012
9
Strategic Buyers
• Issueso Confidentialityo Tire kickers; data seekerso Protecting sensitive performance data, IP, know-howo Industry knowledge—double edge swordo Consolidation more prevalento What is current management’s role going forward?o Is there a good culture fit?o Potential loss of jobs
17
Financial Buyers
• Firms with capital & resources that look to buy companies & recognize rewarding investment returns by utilizing value-creation strategies & exit plans
• Financial buyers can vary significantlyo Traditional buyout fundso Firms with “buy & hold” strategieso Firms with existing holdingso Generalists vs. industry-specific fundso Firms with CEO partnerso Special situation funds
18
7/12/2012
10
Financial Buyers
• Hold periods often relatively short (generally, 3-7 years, although there are many buy & hold firms)
• Leverage is often deployed to enhance returns
• Financial buyers usually become strategic buyers as they execute their growth strategies
• PEGs have closed roughly 10%-20% of middle market deals in past 10 years
19
Financial Buyers
• In general, PEGs have been successful investors in middle market
o Disciplined buyers (pay for quality; shy from average)o “Inspire” performance (“scoreboard & clock” theory)o Plan for outcome; execute for results
• This success has led to expanding universe of PEGs & large pool of capital to deploy
• Current overhang is roughly $425 billion
20
7/12/2012
11
Polling Question 3
What are your observations/perceptions of private equity buyers?• Effective drivers of value creation• Lead value creation, but question strategies and
tactics• Inadequate stewards of long-term value creation• N/A
21
Financial Buyers
• Primary advantageso Large universe of efficient buyerso Hot deals can garner aggressive biddingo Equity stakes for incumbent management;
noteworthy wealth creationo Solid capital resourceso Pay for excellenceo Very focused growth agendaso Need management teams & infrastructure
22
7/12/2012
12
Financial Buyers
• Issueso More need to sell industry attributes; due diligence
scrutinyo Use of leverageo Aggressive growth & earnings enhancements is hard
worko Must have capable management teamo Center of influence?o Possibility of near-term & medium-term sale
23
Recapitalizations
• Portion of equity is purchased & selling shareholder(s) often retain meaningful stake & continue to operate company
• Popular for owners who desire to diversify their personal wealth, yet remain active in growing business & recognizing future wealth
24
7/12/2012
13
Majority Recap
• Selling majority stake o Advantages
Provide liquidity to ownership by buying out existing investors Retain minority equity position that could potentially double or
triple in value in 5 to 10 years New investors provide capital/resources & will work with
management to formulate growth plan & assist in execution Key management remains with company (2- to 3-year transition
period) with board representation If platform transaction, company typically continues to operate
independently
25
Majority Recap
• Issueso New investor now controls companyo New investor will most likely leverage balance sheet
(but operating risk now lies with new investor)o Could experience major restructuring if acquired by
portfolio company
26
7/12/2012
14
Minority Recap
• Sell minority equity stakeo Advantages Ownership retains control New investor can provide resources (financial &
operating) o Issues Will most likely see lower enterprise valuation due to
minority investment Operate with some leverage
27
Leverage Recap
• Leverage recap (leverage company & pay dividend/buy out shareholders)
o Advantages Do not give up any equity (potentially minority stake – 25%) Allows for liquidity event to owners without a sale
o Issues Have to service debt prior to distributions Financial covenants can impact operating flexibility Company more susceptible to macro events—industry or macro
economic events Risk of bankruptcy
28
7/12/2012
15
MBOs
• Owners often recognize team’s leadership contributed greatly to his or her wealth creation
• High performing teams in solid companies can execute rewarding deals
• Personal capital investments do not need to be large, but they do need to be meaningful/painful
• Capital resources (Sr. & Jr. debt & private equity) to facilitate deals for solid, well-managed companies
• Main element in MBO is controlo Equity rewards can be far more rewarding if team controls deal &
pursues capital partners in competitive process29
MBOs
• Advantages o Operating control continuity & stabilityo Reward most meaningful long-term contributorso Company maintains culture & community presenceo Due diligence issues are rare, as are purchase price
modificationso All cash, FMV deals do not have to be compromisedo Can retain small equity stake in Newcoo Balance sheet integrity can be maintained
30
7/12/2012
16
MBOs
• Issueso Lack of strategic valueo Requires capable team with demonstrated resultso Team needs to have clear vision & articulate a
compelling plan
31
32
ESOPs
• Advantageso Retain control & continue to run company (regardless of
level of ESOP ownership)o Favorable tax treatment
Reduce or even eliminate corporate income tax Company repays acquisition debt with pre-tax dollars Interest & principal on acquisition debt is tax deductible
o Preserve culture, jobs & communityo Provide stockholder liquidity (over time) tax efficientlyo Reward key management & long-term employeeso Uniquely position company for growth via acquisitions
7/12/2012
17
ESOPs
• Issueso Sale company at fair market value; could potentially ‘leave money on the table’
o Stockholder liquidity may be realized over time, not immediate
33
Liquidity Events Conclusions
• Often once-in-a-lifetime decision• Issues are complex & impact many who have contributed to
success of enterprise• Emotional aspects are real• Getting it right is perfect stepping stone to next chapter of
life• There are no go-to plans or established formulas/rules
o Assessing client’s situation, objectives, dynamics of company & its industry are critical steps
o Approach should be tailored to client’s desires
34
7/12/2012
18
Polling Question 4
If you were to consider a nonfamily liquidity event, which option do you believe would be the likely path?• Sale to a Strategic Buyer• Sale to a Financial Buyer• Recap• Management Buyout• ESOP
35
Current Market Conditions
7/12/2012
19
Current Market Conditions
• Challenges of last recession have caused many to take very strategic look at their industry
o What are growth prospects of industry?o What will it take to get to or remain competitive force in
industry?o How will profits be affected by changing landscape?
• Many are making decision of whether they should be, or could be, a consolidator
• Others are assessing strategic alternatives
37
General M&A Trends
• Overall market conditionso Recent M&A cycles have been 5 to 7 years & we are in
middle stages of next cycle
o M&A conditions improved in 2011 & trends indicate accelerated activity in second half of 2012
o Lenders have been active in M&A lending with competitive pricing available
o Potential increase in capital gains tax rates should influence activity in 2012
38
7/12/2012
20
U.S. M&A Activity
Source: Dealogic; Mergers & Acquisitions market analysis, Q1 2012
39
General M&A Trends
• Private equity firms have significant capital to invest
• S&P 500 companies have $2 trillion in cash on balance sheets & are increasing acquisition activity
• Current M&A market presents both opportunities & challenges o Companies that maintained or improved earnings over last 12 to 24
months are highly valued in today’s M&A environment
o Pent up demand for acquisitions for both strategic & financial buyers/investors
o Uncertainty surrounding European debt crisis & general trends in U.S. economy reflected in volatility of U.S. debt & equity markets—direct impact on M&A market
40
7/12/2012
21
$425B of Private Equity Cash to Invest
Source: Pitchbook
41
Private Equity EBITDA Multiples
Source: GF Data Resources, May 2012
42
7/12/2012
22
Credit Markets
Source: Dealogic; Mergers and Acquisitions market analysis, Q1 2012
43
Credit Markets
Source: GF Data Resources, May 2012
44
7/12/2012
23
Conclusion
• We understand o Privately held businesses & different succession
alternatives availableo Importance of tailoring succession solution that fits
client’s unique goals & objectiveso Importance of coordinating with estate, tax &
overall wealth planning• BKD can provide seamless approach to solving our
clients’ succession needs
45
QUESTIONS?
7/12/2012
24
About BKD Corporate Finance, LLC
• Subsidiary of BKD, LLP• 18-year history
• Member of FINRA & SIPC
• Professional team includeso Investment bankers
o Financial analysts
o Market analysts
BKD Corporate Finance Profile
48
7/12/2012
25
Breadth & Depth of Resources
• 30 offices in 12 states
• Approximately 250 partners
• More than 2,000 employees
• Six industry niche groupso Manufacturing & Distribution, Construction & Real Estate,
Energy, Financial Services, Health Care & Not-for-Profit
• Clients in all 50 states & internationally
• End-to-end client service proposition49
Our Services
50
7/12/2012
26
• Client revenue range—$5 million to $2 billion• National & international buyers• Praxity Alliance
o Global alliance of more than 100 independent firms in 72 countries
o Allows BKDCF & its clients direct access to foreign markets & potential counter parties
• More than $4 billion in transaction value• Hundreds of engagements• Many transactions significantly exceeded client
value expectations
Experience
51
Experience
o Manufacturingo Business Services/Consultingo Wholesale Distributiono Oil & Gaso Health Careo Food Processing &
Distributiono Auto Parts Distributiono Flexible Packagingo Telecom & Technologyo Transportation
o Constructiono Building Materialso Printingo Financial Institutionso Scrap Processingo Chemical o Grocery & Convenience
Storeso Restauranto Retailo Advertising
52
7/12/2012
27
Experience – Recent Transactions
53
Performance & Reliability
“McKesson is paying a substantial premium for the McQueary’s business. The purchase price of the deal was $190 million, implying a price/revenue ratio of 0.27x. This ratio is more than twice the comparable figures of other recent acquisitions, such as D&K by McKesson or Bellco by AmerisourceBergen. I presume an EBITDA (earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortization) multiple would reflect a similar 2x+ premium.”
— Adam J. Fein, Ph.D., Founder & PresidentPembroke Consulting, Inc.
Has been acquired by
The undersigned acted as financial advisor to McQueary Bros. in this
transaction
54
7/12/2012
28
“BKD Corporate Finance did an outstanding job helping us restructure our existing debt and secure new growth capital. Because of our rapid expansion, we were beginning to outgrow our current lenders. We needed a new lender that could refinance our existing debt and support our aggressive business plan. The BKDCF team was instrumental in this process and we couldn’t be happier about the way things have played out. BKDCF was able to create a competitive process that provided us with multiple options to consider with competitive terms. We would certainly recommend BKDCF for any business owner or management team needing help refinancing or seeking growth capital for their business.”
— Clint Lopez, CFO, ABox4U, LLC
Performance & Reliability
55
The Strategic Process
7/12/2012
29
BKDCF Services
• Preparing company for transaction• Maintaining confidentiality• Analyzing & recasting historical & projected
financial statements• Identifying right buyers• Creating competitive negotiation
environment• Managing due diligence process• Running process that results in timely &
orderly closing—exceeding client expectations
57
58
7/12/2012
30
BKD Corporate Financebkdcorporatefinance.com
Thank You
60
Continuing Professional Education (CPE) Credits
BKD, LLP is registered with the National Association of State Boards of Accountancy (NASBA) as a sponsor of continuing professional education on the National Registry of CPE Sponsors. State boards of accountancy have final authority on the acceptance of individual courses for CPE credit. Complaints regarding registered sponsors may be submitted to the National Registry of CPE Sponsors through its website: www.learningmarket.org.
The information in BKD webinars is presented by BKD professionals, but applying specific information to your
situation requires careful consideration of facts & circumstances. Consult your BKD advisor before acting
on any matters covered in these webinars.
60
7/12/2012
31
61
CPE Credit
• This presentation may be eligible for CPE credit upon verification of participant attendance; however, credits may vary depending on state guidelines
• For questions or comments regarding CPE credit, please email BKD Learning & Development Department at [email protected]
61