LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper...

33
LIGO Status and Plans Barry Barish / Gary Sanders 13-May-02

Transcript of LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper...

Page 1: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

LIGOStatus and Plans

Barry Barish / Gary Sanders13-May-02

Page 2: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 2

LIGOoverall strategy

! Strategy presented to NSB by Thorne / Barish in 1994

! Search with a first generation interferometer where detection of gravitational waves are ‘plausible’» LIGO I uses demonstrated technologies» Design sensitivity h ~ 10-21

» Plan is to interleave interferometer studies and improvements with incrementally improving data runs

» Search Goal: one year of integrated data at ~ design sensitivity

! Advanced LIGO – detection “likely”» Do enabling R&D and design in parallel with LIGO I» Incremental upgrades to laser, suspensions, optics, test masses» Sensitivity: ~ 15x improvement (rate improves by ≥≥≥≥103 !!)» Time scale: operational by 2008

Page 3: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 3

Astrophysical Signaturesphysics goals

! Compact binary inspiral: “chirps”» NS-NS waveforms are well described» BH-BH need better waveforms » search technique: matched templates

! Supernovae / GRBs: “bursts”» burst signals in coincidence with signals in electromagnetic

radiation » prompt alarm (~ one hour) with neutrino detectors

! Pulsars in our galaxy: “periodic”» search for observed neutron stars (frequency, doppler shift)» all sky search (computing challenge)» r-modes

! Cosmological Signals “stochastic background”

Page 4: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 4

Known Pulsarsmaximum gravitational wave signal

Jones, gr-qc/0111007

Page 5: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 5

“Periodic Signals”pulsars sensitivity

! Pulsars in our galaxy» non axisymmetric:

10-4 < εεεε < 10-6

» science: neutron star precession; interiors

» narrow band searches best

» all sky searches

Page 6: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 6

LIGO Plansschedule

1996 Construction Underway (mostly civil)

1997 Facility Construction (vacuum system)1998 Interferometer Construction (complete facilities)1999 Construction Complete (interferometers in vacuum)2000 Detector Installation (commissioning subsystems)2001 Commission Interferometers (first coincidences)2002 Sensitivity studies (initiate short data taking runs)2003+ LIGO I data run (one year integrated data at h ~ 10-21)

2006 Begin Advanced LIGO installation

Page 7: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 7

The LIGO Observatories

LIGO Hanford Observatory [LHO]26 km north of Richland, WA

LIGO Livingston Observatory [LLO]

42 km east of Baton Rouge, LA

Page 8: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 8

Summary integrated schedule

Page 9: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 9

LIGOcosts & commitments

Page 10: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 10

LIGOcontingency vs percent complete

Page 11: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 11

Staffinghistory

Page 12: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 12

Staffinglabor distribution projections

Page 13: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 13

Major NSF ReviewsOperations Renewal - 2001

! Review of Operations Proposal! Review of Advanced R&D Proposal

» Requested $175M for 5 years of operations» Outstanding reviews –

– “The Review Panel was extremely impressed with all aspects of the LIGO Program and feels that it should receive the highest possible rating”

– “The Review Panel recommends that the NSF, even in the eventuality of overall fiscal pressures, support the LIGO program at the requested level.”

» Funding approved by NSB (Aug 01) at $160M! Annual LIGO Review

» Concentrated on computing facilities! Next review – Fall 02

Page 14: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 14

“The two goals of the program for the next five-year period were described to the Panel. The first goal is the operation ofthe LIGO I interferometers to search for gravitational waves with the strain sensitivity of h=10-21. This sensitivity is sufficient to make plausible, but not to guarantee, significant discoveries. The second goal is to pursue the R&D necessary for the design and construction of the Advanced LIGO interferometers with a 15-fold sensitivity improvement. Since the number of detectable sources is expected to scale as the cube of the sensitivity, Advanced LIGO is crucial in realizing the scientific goals of the program. The Review Panel felt thatboth of these goals are of paramount importance, and that the balance between the resources planned by LIGO on these two efforts is about right.”

NSF Review PanelLIGO Goals and Plans

Page 15: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 15

LIGO Plansschedule

1996 Construction Underway (mostly civil)1997 Facility Construction (vacuum system)1998 Interferometer Construction (complete facilities)1999 Construction Complete (interferometers in vacuum)2000 Detector Installation (commissioning subsystems)2001 Commission Interferometers (first coincidences)2002 Sensitivity studies (initiate short data taking runs)2003+ LIGO I data run (one year integrated data at h ~ 10-21)

2006 Begin LIGO II installation

Page 16: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 16

Laserstabilization

IO

10-WattLaser

PSL Interferometer

15m4 km

Tidal Wideband

! Deliver pre-stabilized laser light to the 15-m mode cleaner• Frequency fluctuations• In-band power fluctuations• Power fluctuations at 25 MHz

! Provide actuator inputs for further stabilization• Wideband• Tidal

10-1 Hz/Hz1/2 10-4 Hz/ Hz1/2 10-7 Hz/ Hz1/2

Page 17: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 17

LIGO laser

! Nd:YAG

! 1.064 µµµµm

! Output power > 8W in TEM00 mode

Page 18: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 18

Prestabalized Laserperformance

! > 25,000 hours continuous operation

! Frequency and lock very robust

! TEM00 power > 8 watts

! Non-TEM00 power < 10%

! Improvements in optical path brought noise to better than design at low frequencies

Page 19: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 19

Lock Acquisition

Page 20: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 20

E7 Run SummaryLIGO + GEO Interferometers

Singles dataAll segments Segments >15min

L1 locked 284hrs (71%) 249hrs (62%)L1 clean 265hrs (61%) 231hrs (53%)L1 longest clean segment: 3:58

H1 locked 294hrs (72%) 231hrs (57%)H1 clean 267hrs (62%) 206hrs (48%) H1 longest clean segment: 4:04

H2 locked 214hrs (53%) 157hrs (39%)H2 clean 162hrs (38%) 125hrs (28%)H2 longest clean segment: 7:24

Coincidence DataAll segments Segments >15min

2X: H2, L1locked 160hrs (39%) 99hrs (24%)clean 113hrs (26%) 70hrs (16%)H2,L1 longest clean segment: 1:50

3X : L1+H1+ H2locked 140hrs (35%) 72hrs (18%)clean 93hrs (21%) 46hrs (11%) L1+H1+ H2 : longest clean segment: 1:18

4X: L1+H1+ H2 +GEO:77 hrs (23 %) 26.1 hrs (7.81 %)

28 Dec 2001 - 14 Jan 2002 (402 hr)

Page 21: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 21

LIGO I the noise floor

! Interferometry is limited by three fundamental noise sources

" seismic noise at the lowest frequencies" thermal noise at intermediate frequencies" shot noise at high frequencies

!Many other noise sources lurk underneath and must be controlled as the instrument is improved

Page 22: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 22

Engineering Test Run2 weeks – Jan 02

PRELIMINARY

2 Km Hanford

4 Km Livingston

4 Km Hanford

Page 23: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 23

Strain Spectra for E7comparison with design sensitivity

LIGO I Design

Page 24: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 24

An earthquake occurred, starting at UTC 17:38.

The plot shows the band limited rmsoutput in counts over the 0.1- 0.3Hz band for four seismometer channels. We turned off lock acquisition and are waiting for the ground motion to calm down.

From electronic logbook 2-Jan-02

Engineering Rundetecting earthquakes

Page 25: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 25

17:03:03

01/02/2002

=========================================================================

Seismo-Watch

Earthquake Alert Bulletin No. 02-64441

=========================================================================

Preliminary data indicates a significant earthquake has occurred:

Regional Location: VANUATU ISLANDS

Magnitude: 7.3M

Greenwich Mean Date: 2002/01/02

Greenwich Mean Time: 17:22:50

Latitude: 17.78S

Longitude: 167.83E

Focal depth: 33.0km

Analysis Quality: A

Source: National Earthquake Information Center (USGS-NEIC)

Seismo-Watch, Your Source for Earthquake News and Information.

Visit http://www.seismo-watch.com

=========================================================================

All data are preliminary and subject to change.

Analysis Quality: A (good), B (fair), C (poor), D (bad)

Magnitude: Ml (local or Richter magnitude), Lg (mblg), Md (duration),

=========================================================================

Page 26: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 26

Detecting the Earth Tides Sun and Moon

Page 27: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 27

Stochastic Backgroundprojected sensitivities evolution

Page 28: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 28

Improvements LHO 2K – Jan 02preliminary

• Closedfeedback loopfrom arms tolaser frequency

• Reallocationof gains withinlength controlservo system

Page 29: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 29

Interferometer SensitivitiesEvolution of TAMA

Page 30: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 30

Noise Levelcontributing components

Page 31: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 31

Run Plancommissioning & data taking

! • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits”» 29 June - 15 July» 2.5 weeks - comparable to E7» Target sensitivity: 200x design

! • Science 2 run: 44 TB data “Upper Limits”» 22 November - 6 January 2003» 8 weeks -- 15% of 1 yr» Target sensitivity: 20x design

! • Science 3 run: 142 TB data “Search Run”» 1 July 2003 -- 1January 2004» 26 weeks -- 50% of 1 yr» Target sensitivity: 5x design

Page 32: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 32

LIGO Scientific CollaborationLIGO I

US Universities:! Caltech LIGO/CaRT/CEGG/CACR! Carleton! Cornell! Cal State University Dominguez Hills! Florida• Louisiana State! Louisiana Tech! Michigan! MIT LIGO! Oregon! Penn State! Southern! Syracuse! Texas-Brownsville! Wisconsin-Milwaukee

International Members:! ACIGA (Australia)! GEO 600 (UK/Germany)! IUCAA (Pune, India)

US Agencies & Institutions! FNAL (DOE)! Goddard-GGWAG (NASA)! Harvard-Smithsonian

International partners (haveMOUs with LIGO Laboratory):

! TAMA (Japan)! Virgo (France/Italy)

21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members

Page 33: LIGOBCBAct/talks02/Baltimore02/...TEM00 power > 8 watts! ... • Science 1 run: 13 TB data “Upper Limits ... Virgo (France/Italy) 21 Institutions, 26 Groups, 281 Members.

13-May-02 Baltimore / Koonin Briefing 33

LIGOsummary

! LIGO construction completed in 2000

! LIGO commissioning and testing ‘on track’

! Engineering test runs underway, during period when emphasis is on commissioning, detector sensitivity and reliability.

! Short upper limit data runs interleaved

! First Science Search Run : first search run will begin during 2003

! Significant improvements in sensitivity ~ 2008