Let's Follow Arab Democracy Wave

3

Click here to load reader

Transcript of Let's Follow Arab Democracy Wave

Page 1: Let's Follow Arab Democracy Wave

8/6/2019 Let's Follow Arab Democracy Wave

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lets-follow-arab-democracy-wave 1/3

 โ€œแ€กแ€ฌแ€›แ€• แ€œ  แ‚ˆแ€„ แ€ธแ€€   แ€กแ€™ แ€œ   แ€€ แ€… แ€ธแพแ€€แ€…   แ‚”โ€  แ€œ แ€‘ แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ  แ€ฑแ€’แ€ซแ€€ แ€แ€ฌแ€ผแ€œ แ€ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€ผแ€† 

แ€›แ€Šแ€ผแ€› แ€šแ€แ€€  แ‹ แ‹ แ‚  แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€กแ€ฌแ€ธแ€œ   แ€ธ  แ€ผแ€œ แ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแŠ  แ€ปแ€•แ€Š แ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€…แ€…  แ€แ€• แฟแ€„ แ€™ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€™แ€žแ€Š  แ€…แ€… แ€™แ€” แ€žแ€Š   แ€’ แ€™   แ€ฑแ€€แ€›แ€… แ€…แ€”แ€… แ€ฑแ€•แšแ€ผแ€‘แ€” แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€‘ แ€›แ€Šแ€ผแ€› แ€šแ€žแ€Šแ‹ 

แ€กแ€“แ€Œแ€ฌแ€” แ‹ แ‹ แ€„แ€ซแ€žแ€Š  แ€…แ€…แ€กแ€ฌแ€แ€ฌแ€›แ€„ แ€…แ€”แ€…แ€ฑแ€กแ€ฌแ€€ แ€™  แ€ผแ€œ แ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแŠ แ€’ แ€™   แ€ฑแ€€แ€›แ€…แ€›แ€›  แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€ผแ€ แ€€ แ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„ แ€กแ€ž แ€ธแ€ž แ€ธแ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€†แ€• แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„แ€ฑแ€ฑแ€”แ€žแ€ฌ  แ‚  แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€กแ€ฌแ€ธแ€œ   แ€ธ  แ€ผแ€œแ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€ แ€œแ€ฌแ€žแ€Šแ€กแ€‘  แ€ก 

 แ€•แ€ แ€…แ€ฅ  แ€™แ€•แ€€ แ€™แ€ผแ€€ แ€€  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„ แ€•แ€ซแ€™แ€Šแ‹ แ€„แ€ซแ  แ€™แ€† แ€ แ€™แ€”แ€…แ€ฑแ€žแ€ฌ  แ€ผแ€‡   แŠ  แ€œ   แ‚” แ€œแŠ  แ€แ€› แ€šแ€   แ‚” แ€ปแ€–แ€„    แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„ แ€™แ‚ˆแ€ฑแพแ€€แ€ฌแ€„   แ‚  แ€„ แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€กแ€ฌแ€ธแ€œ   แ€ธ แ€กแ€ปแ€™แ€”แ€†   แ€ธ  แ€ผแ€œ แ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€ แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€ปแ€•แ€Š แ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€…แ€… แ€กแฟแ€• แ€ธแ€  แ€„  แ€แ€• แฟแ€„ แ€™ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ€ฑแ€…แ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแŠ  แ€…แ€… แ€™แ€”แ€žแ€Š   แ€’ แ€™   แ€ฑแ€€แ€›แ€… แ€…แ€”แ€… แ€ฑแ€•แšแ€ผแ€‘แ€” แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ€ฑแ€…แ€žแ€ฌแ€ธ ( แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„แ€›แ€”  แ€•  แ€„ แ€ธแ€ปแ€–แ€แ€ž แ€  แ€„ แ€ธ แ€กแ€“แ€Œแ€ฌแ€” แ€ปแ€•  แ€ผแ€› แ€แ€†  แ€›แ€”)แ‹ 

 แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„แ€›แ€™แ€Š  แ€›แ€€ แ‹ แ‹  แ€ฑแ€…แ€ฑแ€”แ€”แ‚”แ‚แ€„    แ€แ€”แ€‚แคแ€ฑแ‚แ€ผแ€ฑแ€”แ‚” ( แ€ฑแ€…แ€ฑแ€”แ€”แ‚” แ€€   โ€œแ‚  แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ‚ แ€„    แ€ปแ€•แ€Š แ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€…แ€…แ€’แ€ 

แ€แ€ฑแ€”แ€›แ€žแ€Š    แ€  แ€„ แ€ธแ€›แ€„ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€กแ€ผแ€แ€€   แ€แ€ แ€ปแ€•แ€†แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€ฑแ€”แ‚”โ€  แ€กแ€ปแ€–แ€…  แ€žแ€ แ€™ แ€ แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€แ€”แ€‚แคแ€ฑแ‚แ€ผแ€ฑแ€”แ‚” แ€€    โ€œแ‚  แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€กแ€ผแ€ แ€€ แ€ฑแ‚แ€ผ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€ผแ€‘ แ€ธแ€™แ‚ˆแ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€ฑแ€”แ‚”โ€ แ€กแ€ปแ€–แ€… แ€žแ€ แ€™ แ€แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€žแ€กแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€…   แ€œ   แ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ€œ แ€• แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ‚  แ€„ แ€™แ€Š   แ€กแ€ฌแ€ธแ€œแ€•แ€›แ€€แ‚ แ€…แ€›แ€€ แ€€   แ€ฑแ€ผแ€› แ€ธแ€แ€š แ€ปแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€žแ€Š)แ‹ 

 แ€ฑแ€…แ€ฑแ€”แ€”แ‚” แ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€›แ€”  แ‹  แ‹  แ€™ แ€™แ€ฑแ€”แ€‘  แ€„แ€›แ€ฌแ€กแ€›แ€•แ‚แ€„   แ€กแ€” แ€ธแ€†   แ€ธแ€›   แ€˜แ€›แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ž   แ‚”  แ€แ€€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€€แ แ‚  แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธ แ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ‚ แ€„    แ€ปแ€•แ€Š แ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€…แ€…แ€’แ€แ€แ€ฑแ€”แ€›แ€žแ€Š    แ€  แ€„ แ€ธแ€›แ€„ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€กแ€ผแ€ แ€€  แ€แ€ แ€ปแ€•แ€† แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€˜แ€›แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€•แš  แ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€กแ€แ€”แ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ‚  แ€„แ€žแ€™    แพแ€€แ€ฌแพแ€€แ€ฌแ€ฑแ€”แฟแ€• แ€ธ แ€†แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ‹ แ€˜แ€›แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ž   แ‚”  แ€ผแ€ž แ€ฌแ€ธแ€›แ€ฌแ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€แ€„ แ€ธ (แ€ž   แ‚” แ€™แ€Ÿ แ€) แ€ฑแ€œแ€ธแ€ฅ แ€ธ  แ€‘แ€€ แ€™แ€•  แ€˜  แ€ผแ€ž แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€แ€Š แ€แ€ แ€…    แ€แ€แ€†แ€„แ€›แ€”  แ€™แ€œ   แ€•แ€ซ (แ€กแ€ปแ€แ€ฌแ€ธแ€˜แ€ฌแ€žแ€ฌแ€แ€„ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ปแ€–แ€… แ€œ แ€„ แ€œแ€Š แ€ธ  แ€™ แ€™ แ€   แ‚”  แ€€   แ€ธ  แ€ผแ€€ แ€šแ€›แ€ฌ แ€˜แ€ฌแ€žแ€ฌแ€กแ€œ   แ€€ แ€˜แ€›แ€ฌแ€ธแ€›  แ€   แ€ธแ€ฑแ€€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแŠ แ€—แ€œ โ€ฆ แ€กแ€…แ€›  แ€žแ€Š แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ž   แ‚” แ€ผแ€ž แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€€แ  แ€แ€ แ€ปแ€•แ€† แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซ)แ‹ 

 แ€แ€”แ€‚แคแ€ฑแ‚แ€ผแ€ฑแ€”แ‚” แ€ผแ€แ€„ 

 แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€›แ€” 

แ‹ 

แ‹ 

 แ€™ แ€™แ€ฑแ€”แ€‘  แ€„แ€›แ€ฌ 

 แฟแ€™แ‚•แ€›   

แ‚  แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ 

 แ€‘แ€ฌแ€ธแ€›  แ€›แ€ฌ 

แ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„แ€† 

แ€ž   แ‚” แ€” แ€ธแ‚  แ€„แ€žแ€™   แ€กแ€” แ€ธแ€†   แ€ธแ€กแ€‘ แ€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€€แ€•แ€ผแ€ž แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€€ แฟแ€• แ€ธ แ€ฑแ€กแ€•แšแ€™ แ€กแ€“แ€Œแ€ฌแ€” แ€€    แ€ผแ€› แ€แ€†  แ€†แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€แ€„ แ€ธ (แ€ž   แ‚” แ€™  แ€Ÿ แ€) แ€ฑแ€œแ€ธแ€ฅ แ€ธแ€‘แ€€ แ€™แ€•  แ€˜  แ€ผแ€ž แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€แ€Š แ€แ€ แ€…    แ€แ€แ€†แ€„แ€›แ€”  แ€™แ€œ   แ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„แ€†แ€ž   แ‚”  แ€™แ€€แ‚ แ€ฌแ€™ แ€€แ€ฌ  แ€™แ€ 

 แ€แ€•แ€›แ€• แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€ผแ€› แ€แ€†  แ€†แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ‹   แ€œ   แ€ปแ€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€ปแ€แ€ฑแ€กแ€ฑแ€”แพแ€€แ€ฌแ€„     แ€™แ€ แ€แ€•แ€›แ€• แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€ผแ€› แ€แ€†  แ€†แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€ผแ€แ€„   แ€™แ€›แ€œ แ€„  แ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„แ‚แ€„   แ€กแ€” แ€ธแ€†   แ€ธแ€ฑแ€”แ€›แ€ฌแ€™  แ€œแ€™ แ€ธแ€ปแ€–แ€แ€ฑแ€œ แ€ฌแ€€ แ€›แ€„ แ€ธ  แ€ผแ€› แ€แ€†  แ€†แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€œแ€™ แ€ธแ€ปแ€–แ€แ€ฑแ€œ แ€ฌแ€€ แ€›แ€” แ€•แ€„ แ€กแ€แ€€แ€กแ€แ€›    แ€œแ€ฌแ€•แ€ซแ€€  แ€…แ€€แ€˜ แ€ธแŠ แ€†   แ€€ แ€ฌแ€ธแ€€  แ€ž   แ‚”แ€ฑแ€žแ€ฌ  แ€šแ€ฌแ€ฅ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€€   แ€ฑแ€ปแ€–แ€ธแ€Šแ€„ แ€ธแ€ผแ€… แ€ฌ  แ€… แ€ธแ€”แ€„ แ€ธแ  แ€ผแ€› แ€แ€†  แ€†แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซ (แ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„  แ€™แ€›  แ€ฑแ€žแ€ฌ  แฟแ€™แ‚•แ€ผแ€› แ€ฌแ€ฑแ€”  แ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€”แ‚แ€„   แ€™  แ€ฑแ€…แ€ฑแ€”แ€”แ‚” แ€œ แ€•แ€„แ€” แ€ธแ€…แ€ฅแ€กแ€  แ€„ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌ  แ€™แ€•แ€€ แ€™แ€ผแ€€ แ€€ แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ผแ€› แ€€ แ€•แ€ซ)แ‹ 

 แ€ค  แ€ฑแ€…แ€”แ‚แ€„    แ€แ€”แ€‚แคแ€ฑแ‚แ€ผแ€ฑแ€”แ‚” แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€›แ€” แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€žแ€Š   แ€œ แ€‘ แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ  แ€•แ€‘แ€™แ€กแ€†แ€„   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€แ€…แ€ฑแ€šแ€ฌแ€€ แ€™  แ€แ€…แ€›แ€ฌแŠ  แ€แ€…แ€›แ€ฌแ€™  แ€แ€…แ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„แŠ  แ€แ€…แ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„ แ€™  แ€แ€…แ€ฑแ€žแ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแŠ  แ€แ€…แ€ฑแ€žแ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€™  แ€แ€žแ€” แ€ธแŠ  แ€แ€žแ€” แ€ธแ€™  แ€ 

 แ€  แ€„ แ€ธแ€แ€ปแ€•แ€Š แ€œ   แ€ธ  แ€•แ€ซแ€แ€„แ€†แ€„แ‚แ‚Š    แ€œแ€ฌแ€žแ€Šแ€กแ€‘  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ€€    แ€œแ€€แ€†แ€„   แ€€แ€™ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแŠ  แ€™แ€ฑ แ€แ€•แ€ซแŠ   แ€กแ€•แ€ แ€…แ€ฅ  แ€™แ€•แ€€ แ€™  แ€ผแ€€ แ€€ แ€กแ€แ€”แ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ผแ€› แ€€แ€ฑแ€กแ€ฌแ€„  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€แ€” แ€ธแ‚แ‚ˆ   แ€ธแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌ แ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€แ€  แ€„ แ€ธแ€แ€ปแ€•แ€Š แ€œ   แ€ธ  แ€•แ€ซแ€แ€„ แ€œแ€ฌแ€žแ€Šแ€กแ€‘ ( แ†) แ€œ  แพแ€€แ€ฌ แ€แ€„ แพแ€€แ€ฌแ€™แ€Šแ‹ (แ) แ‚ แ€…  แพแ€€แ€ฌแ€แ€„ แพแ€€แ€ฌแ€™แ€ŠแŠ  แ€ผแ€‡   แ€›  แ€›   แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ผแ€› แ€€ แ€•แ€ซ (แ€ฑแ€’แ€ฑแšแ€กแ€ฌแ€„แ€†แ€” แ€ธแ€… แพแ€€แ€Šแ‚แ€„   แ€กแ€™ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€’ แ€™   แ€ฑแ€€แ€›แ€… แ€กแ€ผแ€–    แ‚”แ€แ€• แ€แ€„ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€•แ€ซ   แ€•แ€ซแ€แ€„ แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แพแ€€แ€™แ€Šแ€†   แ€œ แ€„  แ€กแ€  แ€„ แ€ธแ€กแ€‘แ€€แ€กแ€ผแ€œแ€” แ€ปแ€–แ€… แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€œ แ€‘ แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•  แ€œแ€„ แ€œแ€„ แ€ปแ€™แ€” แ€ปแ€™แ€” แ€กแ€›  แ€” แ€ปแ€™แ€„   แ€แ€€ แ€œแ€ฌแ€™แ€Š แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€žแ€Š)แ‹ 

Page 2: Let's Follow Arab Democracy Wave

8/6/2019 Let's Follow Arab Democracy Wave

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lets-follow-arab-democracy-wave 2/3

 แ€™แ€’ แ€šแ€ฌแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแŠ   แ€… แ€แ€‡แ€„ แ€‚แ€ฌแ€”แ€š แ€œแ€… แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ž   แ‚” แ€ฑแ€™แ€ แ€ฌแ€›แ€•แ€แ€แ€€  แ‹ แ‹  แ€œ แ€‘ แ€œแ‚ˆ แ€•แ€› แ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ‚ˆ แ€กแ€›  แ€” แ€ปแ€™แ‚‡แ€„   แ€œแ€ฌแ€žแ€Šแ‚แ€„  แ€กแ€™   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€™ แ€ธ  แ€…   แ€ปแ€–แ€„    แ€™ แ€ แ€แ€™ แ€ธแ€แ€„ แฟแ€• แ€ธ แ‚  แ€„แ€„ แ€แ€€แ€ฌแ€™แ€’ แ€šแ€ฌแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ž   แ‚”  แ€แ€„ แ€ปแ€•แ‚  แ€„แ€›แ€”  แ‚€แ€€แ€ธแ€•แ€™ แ€ธแ€กแ€ฌแ€ธแ€‘ แ€แ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ‹ 

 แ€•แ€‘แ€™แ€กแ€†แ€„   แ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€žแ€ แ€ปแ€•แ€›แ€”แ€กแ€แ€€ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ   แ‹  แ‹  แ€กแ€‘แ€€ แ€•แ€ซ  แ€•แ€‘แ€™แ€กแ€†แ€„    แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ‚ แ€…แ€ แ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€ฑแ€กแ€ฌแ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ€ก 

แ€แ€€ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€€   แ€žแ€ แ€ปแ€•แ€•แ€ซแ‹  

แ€˜แ€›แ€ฌแ€ธแ€– แ€ธแ€ผแ€ž แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€€แ€›แ€ฌแ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€ฑแ€…แŠ แ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„แ€กแ€” แ€ธแ€ž   แ‚”  แ€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€€แ€•แ€›แ€ฌแ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€ฑแ€… แ€กแ€แ€” แพแ€€แ€ฌแ€ปแ€™แ€„   แ€œแ€ฌแฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€œ   แ€€  แ€•แ€ซแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ผแ€› แ€€แ€ž  แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€œแ€ฌแ€žแ€Šแ‚แ€„  แ€กแ€™    แ€…แ€… แ€แ€•แŠ แ€›  แ€œ   แ€ปแ€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€แ€‘แ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ‚ˆ แŠ  แพแ€€แ‚•แ€ผแ€–   แ‚”แŠ  แ€ผแ€… แ€™ แ€ธแ€กแ€ฌแ€ธแ€›แ€„ แ€   แ‚”แ แ€ฑแ€…แ€ฌแ€„   แพแ€€แ€Š  แ€แ€›แ€™แ‚ˆ  แ€œแ€Š แ€ธ  แ€•   แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€œแ€ฌแ€™แ€Š แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€ฑแ€›แ‚•แ€†แ€€ แ€™แ€ผแ€ž แ€ฌแ€ธแ€› แ€†  แ€žแ€Š แ€™ แ€ธ  แ€แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ปแ€™แ€… แ€• แ€แ€†   แ‚” แ€œแ€ฌแ€™แ‚ˆ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ   แพแ€€แ€ฑแ€ผแ€ แ‚” แ€œแ€ฌแ€›แ€™แ€Š แ€ปแ€–แ€… แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€‘  แ€กแ€แ€ซแ€™ แ€ธแ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€œ   แ€ปแ€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแŠ  แ€ฑแ€…แ€ฌแ€„   แพแ€€แ€Š  แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ‚ แ€„    แ€‘ แ€• แ€   แ€€แ€›แ€„แ€†  แ€„ แ€™แ‚ˆ แ€™แ€ปแ€•แ€˜  แ€˜แ€›แ€ฌแ€ธแ‚แ€„   แ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„  แ€€   แ€กแ€” แ€ธแ€†   แ€ธแ€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€€แ€•แแ€›แ€žแ€Š   แ€ฑแ€”แ€›แ€ฌแ€กแ€‘แ€žแ€ฌ  แ€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€€แ€• แฟแ€• แ€ธ แ€กแ€•แ€ แ€…แ€ฅ  แ€™แ€•แ€€ แ€™แ€ผแ€€ แ€€  แ€œแ€™ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€œ แ€ฌแ€€  แ€กแ€“แ€Œแ€ฌแ€” แ€ปแ€•  แ€†แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ‹   แ€š แ€ แ€ผแ€…แ€กแ€†   แ€ธ   แ€œ   แ€ปแ€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ    แ€แฟแ€™แ‚•แ€œ   แ€ธแ€” แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ€ธ  แ€แ€œแ€ฌแ€œ แ€„ แ€œแ€Š แ€ธ  แ€ฑแพแ€€แ€ฌแ€€แ€ผแ€›  แ‚•แ€แ€” แ€œแ‚ˆ แ€• แ€ปแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€™แ€›  แ€˜ แ€ฑแ€œ แ€ฌแ€€ แ€œ   แ‚”แ€›แ€žแ€Š   แ€ฑแ€”แ€›แ€ฌแ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€†แ€€แ€ฑแ€œ แ€ฌแ€€ แ€€แ€ฌ แ€กแ€ž แ€ แ€ แ€กแ€“แ€Œแ€ฌแ€” แ€ปแ€•แ€† แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ‹ 

 แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€’ แ€ แ€šแ€กแ€†แ€„    แ‹  แ‹  แ€œ   แ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ผแ€› แ€€แ€žแ€Š    แ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ   แ€ฑแ€แ€ปแ€–แ€ธแ€ฑแ€ปแ€–แ€ธ  แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ปแ€•แ€ฌแ€ธแ€œแ€ฌแฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€œแ€กแ€„แ€กแ€ฌแ€ธ แ€žแ€ž 

แ€žแ€ฌแ€žแ€ฌ  แ€   แ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€œแ€ฌแ€ แ€” แ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€€    แ€ฑแ€›แ€ฑแ‚•แ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แ€™แ€Š  แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ ( แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•แ€ฑแ€–แ€ฌ แ€™แ€Š  แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ )  แ€™แ€ฑแ€แ€•แšแ€œแ€ฌแ€™แ€Š แ€ปแ€–แ€… แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€ฑแ€ผแ€€ แ€ธแ€ฑแพแ€€แ€ฌแ€ž   แ€  แ€„แ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€™แ€Š  แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ   แ€ฑแ€•แšแ€œแ€ฌแ€™แ€Š แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€†  แ€„ แ€ธแ€˜ แ€แ€ฑแ€‘แ€ฌแ€„แŠ  แ€กแ€œ แ€€  แ€„แ€› แ€™แ€Š  แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ  แ€ฑแ€•แšแ€œแ€ฌแ€™แ€Š แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€คแ€กแ€†แ€„   แ€ผแ€แ€„ โ€ฆ

โ€œแ‚แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅแ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธ แ€œแ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธ โ€ฆ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธโ€

โ€œแ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€แ€„แ€ธแ€…แ€… แ€แ€• แฟแ€„แ€™แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธ โ€ฆ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธโ€  แ€   แ‚” แ€€   แ€กแ€…แ€ปแ€•  แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€†  แ€›แ€„ แ€ธ  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„แ€žแ€„  แ€žแ€Šแ‹ 

 แ€ฑแ€คแ€”แ€›แ€ฌแ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€กแ€‘ แ€ธแ€žแ€ แ€‘แ€ฌแ€ธแ€›แ€™แ€Š แ€™ แ€ฌ  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€ฑแ€–แ€ฌแ€žแ€Š  แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€žแ€Š  แ€กแ€แ€ฑแ€กแ€šแ€ฌแ€„  แ€…แ€…แ€ก แ€• แ€…แ€’แ€œแ€”แ€ฑแ€ผแ€ แ€œแ€ฌแ€ธแŠ  แ€™ แ€™ แ€   แ‚” แ€€   แ€กแ€™แ€” แ€แ€€แ€š แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แ€™แ‚ˆแ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€™แ€Š  แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€œแ€ฌแ€ธ  แ€†  แ€žแ€Š แ€€   แ€ฑแ€žแ€แ€ฌแ€ผแ€… แ€ฌ แ€กแ€€แ€แ€แ€ฑแ€œ แ€œแ€ฌแ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€™ แ€™ แ€   แ‚” แ€€   

แ€กแ€™แ€” แ€แ€€แ€š แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แ€™แ‚ˆแ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€™แ€Š  แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ  แ€ฑแ€žแ€แ€ฌแ€žแ€Šแ€†   แ€œ แ€„   แ€ฑแ€…แ€”แŠ  แ€แ€”แ€‚แคแ€ฑแ‚แ€ผแ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€• แ€แ€„ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€‘ แ€™  แ€œ   แ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ€›แ€ž  แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€”แ‚แ€„    แ€œ   แ€ปแ€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€”แ€กแ€‘แ€ฌแ€ธแ€€   แ€žแ€ แ‚€แ€€ แ€ธแ‚€แ€€ แ€ธแŠ แ€กแ€€แ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ€ธแŠ  แ€™แ€€ แ€…แ€›แ€„แ€›แ€„ แ€ปแ€–แ€„    แ€œ   แ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ€กแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€•แ€ธ  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•     แ€แ€„ แ€•แ€ซแ‹  แ€œ   แ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ€›แ€”  แ€…   แ€ธแ€ผแ€›แ€ฑแ‚•แ€žแ€ธแ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€”แ‚แ€„    แ€™ แ€™ แ€   แ‚”  แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ฑแ€”แ€žแ€Š    แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€•แ€‘แ€™แ€กแ€†แ€„   แ€€  แ€žแ€ฌ  แ€™แ€•แ€€ แ€™  แ€ผแ€€ แ€€  แ€œ แ€• แ€ปแ€™แ€กแ€  แ€„ แ€ธ แ€†แ€€ แ€œแ€€ แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แ€•แ€ซแ‹ 

 แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€ แ€šแ€กแ€†แ€„    แ‹  แ‹  แ€คแ€กแ€†แ€„   แ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€” แ€ธแ€…แ€”แ€กแ€…   แ€ธแ€›  แ€™แ€„ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€แ€ซแ€„ แ€ธแ€ผแ€… แ€•  แ€ผแ€€ แ€ฌแ€€แฟแ€• แ€ธ แ€˜ แ€œ แ€ธแ€†  แ€„ แ€ธ  แ€ แ€ธแ€œแ€ฌ แ‚  แ€„แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€คแ€กแ€†แ€„   แ€€   แ€†แ€€ แ€œแ€€ แ€œ   แ€€ แ€•แ€ซ  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„แ€›แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€”แ‚แ€„   แ€ฑแ€›แ‚Š แ€แ€ซแ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€„แ€ž แ€ƒแ€ฌแ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€แ€” แ€ธแ€€ 

 แ€€  แ€ž   แ‚” โ€œแ‚ แ€œ   แ€ธแ€… แ€ แ€แ€™ แ€ธ แ€ฑแ€กแ€ธแ€แ€™ แ€ธแพแ€€แ€•แ€ซแ€ฑแ€…โ€ แ€ฑแ€œแ€ฌแ€€แ‚แ€„    แ€™แ€ฑแ€›แ€แ€ฌแ€˜ โ€ฆ

โ€œแ‚แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅแ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธ แ€œแ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธ โ€ฆ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธโ€

โ€œแ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€แ€„แ€ธแ€…แ€… แ€แ€• แฟแ€„แ€™แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธ โ€ฆ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธโ€

โ€œแ‚แ€แ€แˆ แ€ฑแ€กแ€ปแ€แ€แ€ฅแ€ฑแ€•แ€’ แ€–แ€€แ€žแ€™แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธ โ€ฆ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธโ€

โ€œแ€…แ€…แ€™แ€”แ€žแ€Š แ€’แ€™แ€ฑแ€€แ€›แ€…แ€…แ€”แ€… แ€ฑแ€•แšแ€‘แ€”แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธ โ€ฆ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธ แ€’แ€ฑแ€กแ€›แ€ธโ€

Page 3: Let's Follow Arab Democracy Wave

8/6/2019 Let's Follow Arab Democracy Wave

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/lets-follow-arab-democracy-wave 3/3

โ€ฆ  แ€…แ€žแ€Š แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€กแ€‘   แ€   แ€ธแ€ แ€ฑแ‚•แ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€†    แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„แ€žแ€„  แ€žแ€Šแ‹ แ€กแพแ€€แ€™ แ€ธแ€กแ€›แ€™ แ€ธ แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ€ฑแ€•แ€ซแ€„ แ€ธแ€…   แ€€   แ€ž   แ€ธแ  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€แ€„ แ€›แ€”  แ‚€แ€€แ€ธแ€…แ€ฌแ€ธแ€žแ€„  แ€žแ€Š (แ€กแ€ฌแ€›แ€• แ€œ แ€‘แ  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€• แ€แ€„ แ€•   แ€€   แ€ฑแ€œ แ€œแ€ฌแ€•แ€ซ)แ‹  แ€…แ€…แ€ก แ€• แ€…แ แ€กแ€€ แ€ธแ€… แ€ธแ€ผแ€• แ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ‚ แ€„   แ€ฑแ€’แ€ซแ€€ แ€  แ€„  แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ (แ€ฑแ€กแ€†แ€ฌแ€€แ€กแ€ก  แŠ  แ€šแ€ฌแ€ฅแŠ  แ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€ž แ€œ แ€‘ แ€€   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€™ แ€ธแ€…   แ€ปแ€–แ€„   แ€’ แ€€แกแ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€ฑแ€”แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ )  แ€€   แ€กแ€“ แ€€แ€•แ€… แ€™ แ€ แ€‘แ€ฌแ€ธแฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€™ แ€™  แ€   แ‚”แ€‰แ€ฌแ€ แ€ผแ€… แ€™ แ€ธแ€›  แ€žแ€™    แ€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€žแ€ฌ แ€œแ€Š แ€ธแ€ฑแ€€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแŠ  แ€š   แพแ€€แ€Š แ€… แ€แ€แ€›แ€žแ€Š   แ€›แ€ฑแ€˜แ€ฌแ€›แ€˜แ€€แ€แ€„ แ€ธ  แ€ แ€แ€†แ€€แแ€ฑแ€žแ€ฌ 

 แ€œแ€Š แ€ธแ€ฑแ€€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธ 

แ€ฑแ€”แ‚”แ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€Šแ€•แ€ซ 

 แ€œแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€™แ‚ˆแ€›  แ€›   

 แฟแ€–แ€แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„แ€žแ€„  แ€žแ€Šแ‹ 

แ€กแ€…   แ€ธแ€›แ€šแ‚แ€›แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€•แ€ซแ€„ แ€ธแ€…   

แ€›แ€•แ€†  แ€„ แ€ธแ€žแ€Šแ€กแ€‘ 

แ€›แ€Šแ€ผแ€› แ€š แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€žแ€„  แ€žแ€Šแ‹  แ€คแ€กแ€†แ€„  แ€กแ€‘  แ€œ   แ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ผแ€› แ€€แ€›แ€”  แ€…   แ€ธแ€ผแ€›  แ‚•แ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€”แ‚แ€„   แ€™  แ€™ แ€™ แ€   แ‚” แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ฑแ€”แ€žแ€Š    แ€•แ€‘แ€™แ€กแ€†แ€„   แ€€    แ€œ แ€•แแ€›แ€žแ€Š  แ€ฑแ€”แ€›แ€ฌแ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€™แ€•แ€€ แ€™แ€ผแ€€ แ€€ แ€†แ€€ แ€œแ€€ แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แ€กแ€„แ€กแ€ฌแ€ธแ€ปแ€•แ€•แ€ซแ‹ 

แ€กแ€“ แ€€แ€™ แ€ฌ  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•แ€กแ€›  แ€” แ€ปแ€™แ€„  แ€žแ€‘แ€€ แ€ปแ€™แ€„   แ€œแ€ฌแฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€™ แ€™ แ€   แ‚” แ€ฑแ€แ€ฌแ€„ แ€ธแ€†  แ€žแ€Š   แ‚  แ€„แ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€€แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€ฌแ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ   แ€ผแ€œ แ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€ แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแŠ  แ‚แ€แ€แˆ แ€ฑแ€กแ€ปแ€แ€แ€ฅแ€ฑแ€•แ€’แ€–แ€€แ€ž แ€™ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแŠ  แ€…แ€… แ€™แ€”แ€žแ€Š   แ€’ แ€™   แ€ฑแ€€แ€›แ€… แ€…แ€”แ€… แ€ฑแ€–แ€ฌแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€€   แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€” แ€ธแ€…แ€”แ€กแ€…   แ€ธแ€›แ€™  แ€œ   แ€€แ€ฑแ€œแ€ฌแ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแ€œแ€ฌแ€žแ€Šแ€กแ€‘ ( แ€š แ€ แ€ผแ€…แ€กแ€†   แ€ธ แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€žแ€” แ€ธแ€…แ€”แ€กแ€…   แ€ธแ€›  แ€ปแ€•แ€ แ€€แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€™ แ€™ แ€   แ‚” แ€ฑแ€แ€ซแ€„ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ  แ€ฅ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€žแ€Š    แพแ€€แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ปแ€–แ€แ€กแ€…   แ€ธแ€›  แ€ฑแ€•แšแ€œแ€ฌแ€žแ€Šแ€กแ€‘)  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€กแ€›  แ€” แ€€    แ€ฑแ€œ แ€ฌ แ€แ€™แ€•แ€…แ€˜  แ€ฑแ€”แ‚” แ€…แ€ฅแ€›แ€€แ€†แ€€  แ€œแ€™ แ€ธ แ€ฑแ€•แšแ€ผแ€‘ แ€€แ ( แ€ผแ€‘ แ€€ แ€œ   แ‚”แ€›แ€žแ€Š   แ€ฑแ€”แ€›แ€ฌแ€ž   แ‚”  แ€ผแ€‘ แ€€แ) แ€ผแ€‡   แ€›  แ€›  แŠ แ€žแ€  แ€›  แ€›  แŠ แ€กแ€€แ€„ แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ€ธแ€•แ€ซแ€ธ  แ€œ แ€•แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€›แ€” แ€•แ€„ แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€žแ€Š (แ€ฑแ€›แ‚Š  แ€แ€ซแ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€„ แ€แ€” แ€ธแ€€แ€€  แ€ž   แ‚”  แ€ฑแ€ผแ€ แ‚”แ€†  แ€ฑแ€ผแ€† แ€ธแ€ฑแ‚แ€ผ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€›แ€ธแ€กแ€ž แพแ€€แ€ฌแ€ธแ€žแ€Šแ‚แ€„    แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€กแ€›  แ€” แ€€    แ€ฑแ€œ แ€ฌ แ€แ€™แ€•แ€…แ€˜  แ€™ แ€™ แ€   แ‚” แ€œ   แ€œแ€ฌแ€ธ 

แ€แ€€ แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธ  แ€กแ€™แ€” แ€แ€€แ€š แ€›แ€›  แ€žแ€Šแ€กแ€‘  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•    แ€แ€„แ€›แ€” แ€•แ€„ แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€žแ€Š)แ‹ 

 แ€คแ€ผแ€แ€„  แ€ฑแ€€แ€”แ€ฌแ  โ€œแ€กแ€ฌแ€›แ€• แ€œ  แ‚ˆแ€„ แ€ธแ€€   แ€กแ€™ แ€œ   แ€€ แ€… แ€ธแพแ€€แ€…   แ‚”โ€   แ€œ แ€‘ แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ€กแพแ€€ แ€ปแ€•แ€แ€€   แฟแ€• แ€ธแ€•แ€ซแฟแ€•แ‹ 

*******

 แ€…แ€…แ€กแ€ฌแ€แ€ฌแ€›แ€„ แ€…แ€”แ€…แ€ฑแ€กแ€ฌแ€€ แ€™ แ€กแ€™แ€” แ€แ€€แ€š  แ€ผแ€œ แ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€ แ€œ  แ€ž  แ€ปแ€•แ€Š แ€ผแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€ปแ€•แ€Š แ€•แ€™  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€แ€„ แ€Šแ€กแ€… แ€€  แ€ฑแ€™แ€ฌแ€„ แ‚ แ€™แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€”แ€”แ‚”  แ€กแ€‘แ€€ แ€•แ€ซ  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€€    แ€š   แพแ€€แ€Š แ€•แ€ซแ€€  แ€–แ€แ‚แ‚ˆ แฟแ€• แ€ธแ€ แ€” แ€€แ€…แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€™แ€Šแ€ž แ‚” แ€€   แ€™  แ€  แ€„ แ€•แ€„ แ€…แ€›แ€ฌแ€™  แ€œ  แ€˜  แ€…แ€แ€„แ€ฑแ€กแ€€แ€ฌแ€„แ€กแ€‘แ€Šแ€ฑแ€–แ€ฌ แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ผแ€› แ€€แ‚  แ€„ แฟแ€• แ€ปแ€–แ€… แ€•แ€ซแ€แ€šแ‹  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ€ฑแ€ผแ€ แ€€    แ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€ž แ€œ แ€‘ แ€‘ แ€กแ€ปแ€™แ€” แ€†   แ€ธ  แ€• แ‚•แ‚   แ‚”แ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€€แ€›  แ€ฑแ€กแ€ฌแ€„ แ€œแ€Š แ€ธ  แ€œแ€€แ€†แ€„   แ€€แ€™ แ€ธ  แ€•   แ‚”แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแพแ€ฑแ€€แ€…แ€œ   แ€•แ€ซแ€แ€šแ‹  แ€œ   แ€€ แ€•แ€ซแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„แ€ผแ€›แ€€ แ€œแ€ฌแ€ฑแ€กแ€ฌแ€„  แ€œแ€Š แ€ธ  แ€œแ€žแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€œแ€แ€„ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€„ แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€…แ€Š แ€ธแ‚   แ€ธแ€œแ‚ˆ   แ‚”แ€ฑแ€†แ€ฌแ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแพแ€ฑแ€€แ€…แ€œ   แ€•แ€ซแ€แ€šแ‹ 

 แ€ปแ€™แ€” แ€™แ€ฌแ€ปแ€•แ€Š  แ€…แ€…แ€กแ€ฌแ€แ€ฌแ€›แ€„ แ€…แ€”แ€…แ€ฑแ€กแ€ฌแ€€ แ€™ แ€กแ€™แ€” แ€แ€€แ€š  แ€ผแ€œ แ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€ แฟแ€• แ€ธ  แ€…แ€… แ€™แ€” แ€    แ€’ แ€™   แ€ฑแ€€แ€›แ€… แ€…แ€”แ€…  แ€ฑแ€•แšแ€ผแ€‘แ€” แ€ธ  แ€œแ€ฌแ€แ€ฌแ€€    แ€ปแ€™แ€„แ€ฑแ€ผแ€ แ‚” แ€œ   แ€    แ€™แ€’ แ€šแ€ฌแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€ฑแ€กแ€”แ€”แ‚” แ€œแ€Š แ€ธ  โ€œแ€กแ€ฌแ€›แ€• แ€œ  แ‚ˆแ€„ แ€ธแ€€   แ€กแ€™ แ€œ   แ€€ แ€… แ€ธแพแ€€แ€…   แ‚”โ€  แ€†   แ€   แ€กแ€‘แ€€ แ€•แ€ซ  แ€œ แ€‘  แ€   แ€€ แ€ผแ€•   แ€”แ€Š แ€ธแ€”แ€ฌแ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€€    แ€ปแ€•แ€Šแ€ž แ€™แ€ฌแ€ธแ€‘แ€ž   แ‚”  แ€•   แ€™  แ€ฑแ€›แ€ฌแ€€แ€›  แ€ฑแ€กแ€ฌแ€„  แ€‘ แ€ แ€œแ‚Šแ€„   แ€แ€„แ€†แ€€แ€ฑแ€•แ€ธแพแ€€แ€–   แ‚” แ€กแ‚ แ€ธแ€กแ€ผแ€Š แ€ แ€ฑแ€™แ€ แ€ฌ แ€›แ€•แ€ แ€•แ€” แพแ€€แ€ฌแ€ธแ€กแ€• แ€•แ€ซแ€แ€šแ‹ 

 โ€œ แ€แ€€แ€š แ€ปแ€–แ€…แ€แ€„   แ€แ€€แ€š แ€œ แ€• แ€กแ€Ÿ แ€ แ€ผแ€œ แ€แ€ฑแ€ปแ€™แ€ฌแ€€ แ€™แ€Šโ€ 

แ€ฑแ€’แ€ซแ€€ แ€แ€ฌแ€ผแ€œ แ€ แ€ธแ€ฑแ€ผแ€†