Lesy Erenio Sancehz-Matute, A205 458 848 (BIA May 14, 2015)

8/9/2019 Lesy Erenio Sancehz-Matute, A205 458 848 (BIA May 14, 2015)

1/14

Ferreira, Paula Law Oice of Miguel A Elias2301 Wlliams Blvd.Suite EKenner, A 70062

Dptmnt sti

Executive Oce r Immigration Review

Board of Immigration AppealsOce of he Clek

F

HS/ICE Ofce o Chef Counsel - SNA8940 onds Dve, 5th looSan Antono TX 78239

ame: SANCEZATUTE LESY ERE. A 205-458-848

Date of his notice: 5/14/205

Enclosed is a copy of he Board's decision ad order in the above-referenced case.

Encosure

Pl Mb:Adkins-Blanch, Chares KGrant Edward RGuendesberger John

Sncerely,

D Donna CarrChef Clerk

Doce

For more unpublished BIA decisions, visitwww.irac.net/unpublished/index

Cite as: Lesy Erenio Sanchez-Matute, A205 458 848 (BIA May 14, 2015)


2/14

Pepartment Jusice Dcs f B f I Appes. Exuv ce r I ew

·F als Chh Vg

Fe A205 458 88 S Antni

re LESY ERENIO SANCEMATE

N REMOVAL PROCEEDG

APPEAL

Dte

ON EALF O RESPONDENT Pu J eer Equie

APPLICATION Repeng

MA ·20

Te repnent ppea m the miatin uge' uy 7, 201, eciin enng er mn t repen e repnent rere remve in beni n y 8, 203 e appe

i be e te prceeng repene d the recr reme.

We revie mmigrtin udge nding ct r ce er but quen f icren juent ter iue in ppe e reviee e nv 8 C .R§§ 1003( )(3)(), ii

e repnden caimed in er min t repen t excepnl circmtce prevented herm tening her Juy 8, 2013, remvl heing Rep Mt. t Repen t 3-6) Specicly repnent tru ce ere tt er tey vie her t er ndng mtin t cge venue ul be te e nt require t ten he heng; d ht er cune uered cmputer viru tt mae i cen inacceibe (Rep Mt t Repen t 36 e iatin Juge enied e mtin nding at the mere exitence a pening mtin t chge venue i nt reieve e repnent f her u t tten te eing ht the cmputer viru i n unt t exceptin crcmtce (J 2 On ppe e repnent rugh e e cune maintin her caim f exceptn crctce er ae tht he i nt require t cmpy i te prce requirement f Maer ofLoza, 19 &N Dec. 637 (A 1988), ad Lozada v. IS, 857 F 10 (1 C. 988), becuee i n ciming ineective itnce f cne ny cune incect vice cntite exceptin circmtce Rep r. a

The repndent i cect th b t d d e Unite Stte Ct f Apel r e

Fi Crcuit in e ridictn ti mter rie hve un tt te eneu vce cune my cntitute exceptin ccumce excug te repnent fre t apper a eng. See Maer of GralvaBarrera, 21 I&N Dec. 72 (1996) see alsoGavezVergara v Gonzaes, 484 Fd 78 th ir. 2007 ever in uch ceniubtnti cmpice ih Mater of Lozada, supra, i ti required. See Lara v Trominsk,

Matter o GrvaBarrera, supra, GavezVergara v Gonzaes, supra, ech f te repnent ere repreente by ne cune ad lrey cmpie i Mater oLozada, sura See GalvezVergara, supra, t 800, 800 2; see also GralvaBarrera, supra, t 7374ere the repnent i rereente by e e ce h incecty advie er n her nee t ppe r te eing d h n e y cmpnt regdng cnduct Fer i

(cntinue . . )Cite as: Lesy Erenio Sanchez-Matute, A205 458 848 (BIA May 14, 2015)


3/14

0 48 848

· 26 F3d 487 46-8 ( C 000); ee ao Heradez-Orez v Hoder 74 F.3d 644 648( C 204) Rodrguezazao Hoder 666 F3d 48 93 C 202)

Based on e oaly of e cuses s ase e ll gan e esonden's oon o eoen o esnd e n absena ode usuan o ou ua poe auo See 8 CF.

§ 003a) ee ao aer o JJ IN e 976 (BI 997) odgly e lowngodes wll be eneed

OE Te aea s susaned

FTHE OER Te oeedgs e eoened.

FHE OER Te ecod s eanded e oeedngs

( ..onnued)aeas ousel sll as no adsed e espoden egadng e need o oly Maer ofLozada upra

Cite as: Lesy Erenio Sanchez-Matute, A205 458 848 (BIA May 14, 2015)


4/14

UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICXECUTIVE OFFICE FOR IMMIGRATION REVIEW

IIGTION COURT

BOO DOLOROSA STREET, SITE SAN ANTONIO, TX 8

MIGUEL A. LIAS, A PROFESSIONAL LAW CORORATIO

RODRIGUZ, PAULA J, ESQ

WILLIMS BOEVARD, SUIT EKNNER, LA 6

IN THE MATTER OF

SANCHZ-MATTE, LSY EREIO

FILE A -48848

UNABE TO FORWARD NO ADRESS PROIDD

DAT: ul 4

'(:

�CHD IS A COPY OF THE DECISION OF THE IMMIGRAION JUGE THIS DCISIONIS FINAL UNLESS AN APAL IS FILD WITH THE BOARD OF IMMIGRATION APPALS

WITHIN CALENDAR DAYS OF THE DATE OF THE MAIIG OF THIS WRITN DCISIONS.

ETHE EN

SEQ i1 MB H 89 F

R01 '¥

P:NG IOR

AP.

YOUR NOTICE OF APEAL, ATTACHED DOCUMENTS AND FEE OR FE WAIVER RQUEST

MUST BE MAILED TO: BOARD OF IIGRATION APEALSOFFICE OF THE CLRK

Leesbrg Pike, Site FALLS CHURCH, VA

ATTACHED IS A COPY OF THE DECISION OF TH IMMIGRATION UDGE AS HE RESULT

OF YOUR FAILU�E TO APEAR AT YOUR SCHEDULED EPORTATIO OR REMOVAL HARING.THIS DECISION IS FINAL UNLSS A MOTION TO REOPEN IS FILED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 4(} OF TH IMMIGRATION AND NATIOAITY ACT, 8 USCSECTION ) ) IN DEORTATION PROCEDIGS OR SECTION 4{) 6)

8 USC SCTION a 6 IN RMOVA PROCEEDINGS IF YO FIE A MOTIONTO ROPN, YOUR MOTION MUST B FIL WITH THIS COURT

OTHER

IMMIGRATION CORT

8 DOLOROSA STRET, SUITE SAN ATONIO, TX 8

CC HS / ASSISANT CHI COUNSE84 FOURWINDS DR Room 4SAN ANTONIO, TX 8

FF


5/14

\ _

NIED STAES EPARTEN OF SXUIV OFFIC FOR GRATQN RVIEW

IMMIRATION CR OLRA STRET, SUITE 3

AN ANONIO, 727

TE AER OF )))))))

SANCHEZMAUE, LESY EENIO Cas No A25-458-4

RON

REMVA PROCEDNGS

CHAGE: Sction 212a)(7)A)(i)(I) of te Iiao d Nationaiy Act, asen at ie of apicao adsso, ai not n possssion of al n docuent

APPICAION FR § 1323(b): oon to ope

ON BEAF OF E RESONDENTaula Rodiuz, s.aw Ofc of Mue A Eas231 llis B, Se E

Ke, LA 72

ON BEHAF OF TE GOVENT US iation ustos EnctOc of the hf Cousl Fouwinds Di, 5 Floo

Anonio, TX 239

WEN DECSON & OE OF E IMGON JUE

I Procedual Histo

esonden s a tnty-nne yeaod a, nate d citzen of Honduas, whoeted nte ates a o ne Laeo, e, on o abou ay 2, Exh 1 nuy 5, 12, e tn of Hold Sciy () esonay seed esondetwith a Noce to Ap (NTA) can as eoable pusun to scton 212(a))(A)()I)of te Iiaton and Naoaly Act he Act), as nded, at i of aplcaton

adisson, an ot n possssio of ali n docunt Id

he N A cotains a sction t "aire o appear tat secis, nter ala, thosequeces o o p an scde es Eht NA eects ta te esonnt was adisd of consecs of non aeac Sanish lua Id

On ul , 13, e sodent was ot est e hen a was uaalable xanaio und oah Pusua t the auhoiy odd n scton 2b)5)(a) of h Act, the Co oced i abseia a od th espondet eod o t Unt Staes tooduas on e che conaid i te NT A

1


6/14

On Sepember 18 2013 e esponen rough cosel le wi the Cou a moton oeoen e emova roceengs D dd not e a resonse to the esponden's moton.

II oton to eoen

n n aenta orde of removal may be rescne only (i on a oton to eoen ledwin 180 days aer e ae o the oer o remova f he alen emonsrates hat he ue toappe was because o exceptonal ccmsces or (i on a oton to reoen led at y tme he alen deonsaes at she dd no receve noice n accordance wh raah (1 or(2 o secion 239(a o the Act or te alien emonstrates hat she was n edeal or tate csodyand te ilre o apear was ogh no ult of he ow N § 240(b(C; 8 C.R.§ 1003.23(b((i

A Notce

Consel the esonent oes not claim a lack o notice. See Resonents Moton to

Reopen. Notce was propely sent to counsel on May 21 2013 Exht 4 Because notce to eesonent's cose of ecord is eee noice to e resondent the Cou nds tat notce ofheaing was propely prove to he esonen See 8 C.R. § 1292.(a Mate of Baoco19 &N ec 255 259 (B 1985

B. Excetona Crcumtance

ess an 180 days between he dae e Cour odered e responden remoed n aenta an the ae the resonen le her motion o reoen ad heree the resonen'smotion to reopen base on excetonal crcumstces s not tmebared. N § 40(b(5(C 8CR. § 1003.23(b(4(i.

Counsel r he esponden clams wo exceptional crcstnces ept the resondentom apeng at he heang and should ecuse her ilre o apear ee esonden's Motono Reopen. Frst counsel clams tere wa a penng moton to chage enue bere the Cour. See d. Second counsel r he esponent clams tha a comuter rs deleted er comtercaendar data. See

Cosel clams she le the moion o change venue oer thy days bere the hengnd that it was stll enng on the date o he erng. See Resonent's Moton to Reopen.owever he moton to cange venue was led wih he Cou on Jne 17 013 wch s less than 30 ays bere the July 8 2013 hearing See Exhbt 8. The moton to chage venue was

also no endng on he ate o te hearng See Exhibt 9. he Cort denied the moton tochnge enue by wen orer on June 28 2013 an hat order was maled to cousel on July 22013 e hus hee was no a penng moon to chage venue on July 8 201 when theCou ordere he respondent emoe n aena en if ere were a penng moion tochnge venue bere he Cou he mee submsson of a moton to change venue oes noeieve te esponden o er obgaon to apea a eng. Se Patel v INS 80 F2d 804806 (th C 986 Mattr of Rvea 9 & Dec. 688 (A 1988 (resonent coul notmeey assume he moton a enue cnge wod e rante. ntl he moton ocane enue s ned e esponden s eqed o aend he eng d

2


7/14

-

n rega o he compuer vrus counsel clams he compuer crash caused er o lose allo her calena aa as o June 26 203 See Responen's oion o Reopen Counsel clamss loss o aa peene he om llown up wh he Cour aou he moon o changevene avsng he respone wen o appear r e hearng See id Bu counsel as noexplane why she no smply revew e les o ecreae he calenar aer her aa was los

See d Counsel also as no explane why she no avse he clen o appear r herheang on uly , 203 when cosel ha alreay eceve he wren orer enyng e moono cange venue See Ex 9

e esponen has no esalshe any exceponal crcusances ha woul excuse helue o appea ee N 2) 5C); C.F R 0323) ))

ae:

ccongly he llowng ore s heey enere

ORDER

IT IS HRBY ODED a he responens moo o eopen s DENIED

v

L ' I 20

3

Glen P cPhalne aes Immraon uge


8/14

Dmn s

ecve Oce r Immigron Revie

oard o mmgaon AppaO.c o h Crk

507 Lesburg Pik. Sut 2000al Chc, Vna 2030

ELGAO-ZARO NORVN ALEXANERC / O S CUSOY

S/CE Offic of Chief Cous C2 Ws Va Bur Sr

2200 SEMNARY AENUEWOOSOCK, L 60098

Chicago L 6060

Name: ELGAO-ZARO NORV ALE . A 206-016-31

ae of his oice: /1/201

Eclosed s coy of he Bords decision nd oder in he bovereferenced cse

Encosre

P MbGendesberger Joh

Sncerey

D o ctADonn CrrChief Clerk

Doke


9/14

U.S. Dmt ofJusticeExecuve Oce r Imiaton Revew

Flls Chc, Vrga 2053

Fle: 206 016 315 Ciago,

Decson of e Bod o Imo Appeal

Dae:

Y 14In e: NOV AXAND DLGADOZATO aka Non Delgado

IN OAL POCEDGS

APP

ON BHAF OF RSPONDENT Po se

ON BHALF OF DHS: Ks LnsleyAsss Cef Counsel

esonden, a nae d zen of Guaea, apeals e deso of e IiaonJuge, daed Decee 17, 2014, odeng s eoal o e Une Saes e esponensaeal wic s oosed y e Depaen of Hoeland Seuy ("DHS), wll e dissse

As nal ae, we ejec e esponden's asseon a e Iion Judge ae a"ey uik deson n s ase Te esonden was seed w e Noe o Apea(NTA) on Augus 5, 204 (Ex. 1). ese poeedgs wee connued on Seebe 9, 204,Sepebe 30, 204, Ooe 23, 204, Noebe 8, 204, d Deee 9, 2014 Oeall, e

eod ees a e ion Judge poded e esonden wi a susa aoun of e o oain ounse d a se ade a s eo o ensue a e o se esonden undesood e nae d uose of ese poeedings C Maer CB, 25 &N De 888(BIA 2012) (oldng a alen d no ae suen e o on ounse wee e wasodee eoed w 10 days of eng seed e NTA)

We e gon Judges decson On ape, e esponen does no ase yguen wic pesuades s Bod o ds e Igao Judges oldg a e ssuje o elef o eoal eause e s en wo s esen n s oy wou engae o oled y an iaon oe o wo ed a any e o ple oe asdesaed y e Aoey Gene (J a 1-3 x. 1) See seon 22(a)(6)(A)() of eIaon and Naonal A, 8 U.SC § 1182(a)(6)(A)() see als seon 29 of e A,8 u.sc § 136.

1 e DHS adised s Bod a, on Feb 12, 201, e esponden as eoed o e Unid Saes Howee, e esonden as no updaed s addess w s Boad Asu, is deson wl e aed o h a e deenon ee n oodsock, Illos wee e

was ed a e e a e ed s appeal. As we dee e appeal o e ely, we onclude a, dese e esonens eoal o e Uned Saes, we ae jusdion o onse s apeal Maer Diazarcia, 2 &N De 794 (BIA 212)


10/14

0 1 315

On apeal, the respondent es to nonmat staus er secon 1(a(5 of hect, 8 US.C. § 11(a(5(U. oeve, he has not mely acate s cient cts,i.e., hvig been a vicm of a cime an oviing assisce to a eocement, to emonsteat he is otentaly egbe r said nonmmiant statu. As such, "good case has not beensho to exist to conue tese roceedings in ore to ord e resondent to reqest

U nonimmigt sttu om Unite Sates Cizenshi mmiton Seces. S

8 C. .R.§ 1003.9, 140.; o Shz So 5 I&N Dec 80, 815 (B 1 (ecoing that aien seeking U noimmiant sttus should not be te a contuce "s a datoy tactic to resa he conclion of emov roceedings hee it is nkey hat his ication il be te.

If e esondent believes tat he shoud be aoe U noit saus, he is not recue om ling a Petiton r U Nonimint Stus (o -918 om abroa arove, he contact e Unite tes embassy avng urisicton over the e hee he socated e pocessing insctions S 8 C.R. § 1414(c(5(i( Hoeve, e eason set above, e fe Iation Judge's ecision orderng te esponent's

removal om te Unite States to utema. The long oer s entered.

OER: e resondents aea is disissed

�

OR


11/14

UIE STATES DEPAREN O JUSCEEXETIVE OCE FOR IMGRAON REVIEW

UITED STATES IMIGRATO CORTCICAGO IOS

Fe A2663

I he ater of

NO RVN ALEXNER EGAOZ RTO

RESPONET )

Decemer 17 24

IN REMOVA PROCEEINGS

CHARGES 22a6{AI pesent who havng een awfy nspeceate paoe

APPCATIOS None a this time

O BEAL OF RESPODET PRO SEO BEHA OF HS ROA YAZ

ORAL DECISIO OF E MGRATIO UGE

Te esponen n ese poceeings is a 33yearo naive an ctzen of

Gaemaa Te esponen was pace n emova poceegs upn ssuance of he

Noce o Appea ate Ags 5, 4 See Ehit Case was conne f a

peo of ime Te esponent has een etae hogu ese poceengs

Case was connue fo resoen o seek avce of a atorney Aoay e

case was se ove r he Government to pesen evence as he responen a

icae fac tha he was no emovae as cage ut ha entere e ne

Saes egay he Govee pesente evece o Sepeme 9, the passpo of


12/14

he espone an as e an 1-23 a E 3

Te esponen fnay as ough o cou a inpeson heang on

oays ae an as esife concening his mane of eny The espone oke

a peo of ie o cse shps an avee n an o o he ne Saes He

oes o eca s en he as ave in e nie Saes bu eeves as in

2005. He cae ha he as ame Ma u o epa The heeae

emaine in he Ue Saes a came o Inos fo ok e s no ae o a

ne Saes czen a she appaeny has chien on he ne SaesAe being so e esponen as ae a he s no a cze of

e ne Saes an ha e s a czen of Guaemaa He has ene ha he ave

n he Uie Saes egay oeve, e evence pesene by he Govenmen a

Ehi esashes ha hs passpo ch e avee on as isse n Janay of

2002 an epe in 007 The espoen as sse a C/B vsa o eme 8

202 ch as va one yea e avee o he Uie Saes po o e

issuance of ha vsa appaey on Sepeme 4 0 so i appeas he ay have

acay a a eaie passpo h a visa a a ee sse o hi pevosy,

e avee a eas oce on s vsa o Sepeme 8 23 a as amie hogh

Ma I is o eney sue e casscao of vsa hee ae no en samps o he

ne Saes ae e Sepebe 3 asson Tee ae nmeos saps on

e espoes passpo esaishing a he avee fo eampe an o of

Honas in ebay of 2 a Jana of 26, a ha e avee a as

amie o Gaeaa in Ags o 24 eba o 2005 ovebe of 2005

Jaua o 26 an en again Jauay 20 206 an ee ae ohe eny saps

ch his Cou has a ha e eang ooks ke n an o of ace Szean

an Geece a ae 203

A26-063 2 Decee 204


13/14

It is the respondent's bude to establs boh a lawful en ad ta e

has remaed a awful saus sce hs aval The evdece a Exhb 2 esablshes

hat he deaed he Uied Sae aer h en o Sepembe 8, 2003 ad ere s o

eidence that the was readmted to the nted Staes Te respodents passpo

epred i 2007 He has a new paspo ssued i 200 ee may have bee a

neeng asspo bt he Cou does not have ha The respodets tesmony

concerning is admissio to e ed Sates 2005 was age and he Co wod

o o ha eve he was readed in 2005 o some oer doumen tereaer, i

appea he dd travel back to Guatemala and aso hen to Hondras 2006 Based o

ths evdence I nd that he esponden is in fat removabe or beg peen n he

ied Staes witou avng bee lawuly inspeced admed o paoed his mos

recen time

he esponde s mared to a ned Sates cize bu he has ot ed

a vsa peo f hm e s not elgbe o cacelao of removal athogh e is

mared o a S ciizen He does no ave he 0 ears eeded o eabs eligb

r cacelaton o remova Responde s no arad of eig to Guatemaa e

espoden wod otenia be egible fo ouna depare, bt has indcaed tha

the s uabe to pay or hs avel to Guaemaa and accordgly aot establish

eligbi fo that orm o ee

Accodngy hen t s the ode of this Co ha he espode be

emoved fom the Uited Saes o Guatemala on he carges cotained e Noce oAppea

A2060635

EZA KLENmmgao Jdge

3 Deceber 20


14/14

-

CERTIFICATE PAGE

heeby cert tha he atached poceedg befoe JDGE E C KEI, in

the mate o:

ORVI AEXADER DEGADORTO

A206065

CHICAGO IS

was hed as here appeas and hat ths is the orgina ranscrpt thereo or he e of

he Execuive Oce Imgrato Revew

CASEY S SMTH (Tanscbe)

DEPOSITIO SERVCES c2

MARCH 26 205

Compleo Date)

Lesy Erenio Sancehz-Matute, A205 458 848 (BIA May 14, 2015)

Documents

Transcript of Lesy Erenio Sancehz-Matute, A205 458 848 (BIA May 14, 2015)