Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and...

30
Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra hospital organisation Ives Hubloue, MD, MSc, PhD Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels

Transcript of Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and...

Page 1: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks :

intra – hospital organisation

Ives Hubloue, MD, MSc, PhDDepartment of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and

Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels

Page 2: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

22 march 2016 (Brussels)

2

7:58

9:11

25 11 2016

Page 3: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

22 march 2016 (Brussels)

3 25 11 2016

Page 4: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

22 march 2016 (Brussels)

4 25 11 2016

Page 5: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Days after Paris attacks.....

5 25 11 2016

Page 6: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

6 25 11 2016

Page 7: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

7 25 11 2016

Page 8: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

8

1

2

25 11 2016

Page 9: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Admission capacity first hour...

4 T1

4 T2

12 T39 25 11 2016

Page 10: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

l 08h20 End daily briefingl 08h29 Deputy head nurse informs about attacks Zaventem l 08h30 Confirmation by 112 dispatch

l 08h45 Trainees and staff briefing about tasksg Clearing ED (home or admission)g Sectorisation ED according priorities

g Distribution MD in different care unitsg Brief reminder START triage and Mettag chart

l 08h47 Admission first patient (T3)l Contact ICU and OR

g OR asked to prepare 4 rooms within 1hour and to have another 4 after one hourg ICU asked to prepare 4 beds immediately and 4 within one hourg Security present and checking every entrance in the ED (outside ED)

l 09h07 Informal meeting with CEO, CMO, CNO

g Crisismeeting to be organised quicly g List of available beds in the hospitalg At that moment second attack announced

g Meeting senior staf EDl 09h30 Official meeting CEO, CMO, CNO,...

g Normal activities of the hospitalg Suspicious package at the entrance OR

g Arrival of first T1.....

10

First hour

25 11 2016

Page 11: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

l 08h20 End daily briefingl 08h29 Deputy head nurse informs about attacks Zaventem l 08h30 Confirmation by 112 dispatch

l 08h45 Trainees and staff briefing about tasksg Clearing ED (home or admission)g Sectorisation ED according priorities

g Distribution MD in different care unitsg Brief reminder START triage and Mettag chart

l 08h47 Admission first patient (T3)l Contact ICU and OR

g OR asked to prepare 4 rooms within 1hour and to have another 4 after one hourg ICU asked to prepare 4 beds immediately and 4 within one hourg Security present and checking every entrance in the ED (outside ED)

l 09h07 Informal meeting with CEO, CMO, CNO

g Crisismeeting to be organised quicly g List of available beds in the hospitalg At that moment second attack announced

g Meeting senior staf EDl 09h30 Official meeting CEO, CMO, CNO,...

g Normal activities of the hospitalg Suspicious package at the entrance OR

g Arrival of first T1.....

11

First hour

25 11 2016

Page 12: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

l 08h20 End daily briefingl 08h29 Deputy head nurse informs about attacks Zaventem l 08h30 Confirmation by 112 dispatch

l 08h45 Trainees and staff briefing about tasksg Clearing ED (home or admission)g Sectorisation ED according priorities

g Distribution MD in different care unitsg Brief reminder START triage and Mettag chart

l 08h47 Admission first patient (T3)l Contact ICU and OR

g OR asked to prepare 4 rooms within 1hour and to have another 4 after one hourg ICU asked to prepare 4 beds immediately and 4 within one hourg Security present and checking every entrance in the ED (outside ED)

l 09h07 Informal meeting with CEO, CMO, CNO

g Crisismeeting to be organised quicly g List of available beds in the hospitalg At that moment second attack announced

g Meeting senior staf EDl 09h30 Official meeting CEO, CMO, CNO,...

g Normal activities of the hospitalg Suspicious package at the entrance OR

g Arrival of first T1.....

12

First hour

25 11 2016

Page 13: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Casualties Zaventem

13 25 11 2016

Page 14: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Casualties Maalbeek

14 25 11 2016

Page 15: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Lessons learned (1)

l Provide good communication between all partners.

Keep in mind that failure of the mobile and TETRA-network is most likely and think about alternative means of communication.

15 25 11 2016

Page 16: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Lessons learned (2)

l Don't write a specific hospital terror plan, you can't prepare for everything.

l Keep the plan simple.

l Work on the mindset. What really requires attention is adapting to another way of looking to (pre)hospital care.g DAMAGE CONTROL

g HYPOTENSIVE RESUSCITATION

16 25 11 2016

Page 17: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Lessons learned (3)

l A good plan is important, but more important is that everybody has, and knows, its own place within the plan.

l Learn to know the other disciplines and know your assignment.

l Do not interfere with the assignment of the other.

17 25 11 2016

Page 18: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Lessons learned (4)

l Prepare the medical responders for the collective incidents and war injuries.

18 25 11 2016

Page 19: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Lessons learned (5)

l There must be a lot of attention for follow-up care for the emergency services and survivors.

l The ability to be able to bring these two groups into contact with each other should be considered.

19 25 11 2016

Page 20: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Victim and rescuer......

20 5 05 2016

Page 21: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Lessons learned (6)

l Put your money on training and logistics.

21 25 11 2016

Page 22: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Manage the visit of VIP’s....

22 25 11 2016

Page 23: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

23 25 11 2016

Page 24: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Workshop France – Belgium – Israëlseptember 2016 at SAMU Paris

24 25 11 2016

Page 25: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Reasons for such a meeting......

25

l More and more well developped medical systems experience terrorism-related medical incidents

l In spite of extended literature, there are many differences in how different countries manage critical components of such incidentsg What can we learn from each other?

g Is there room for evidence in this area?

25 11 2016

Page 26: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Pre-hospital organisation

1. Can the event scene be made “sterile”?

2. Should EMS wait until the event scene is declared “safe” by police?3. Principles for the safety of the rescue team

4. Coordination with the police

5. Should we allow or even encourage bystander help on scene?6. Should we allow or even encourage bystander transportation to

hospitals?7. What care can/should be provided on scene ? in which system ?

Scoop and RunStay and Play

Advanced Medical Post

8. What about Medical Military-Civil Cooperation ?

26 25 11 2016

Page 27: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Regulation of casualties

1. What is the optimal hospital destination?

The nearest?The reference trauma center?

2. Hospitals information and notification of casualties arrival?

3. How should we distribute casualties when there is asymmetricaldistance and hospital competence distribution?

4. What is the role of a triage hospital?5. Strategy for multiple ongoing events, in different regional context

and hospital’s capability. Should we keep hospital’s capability ?6. What could be the organization with a large number of children

among victimsTreatment capacity and competence for children?

TCCC for children?

27 25 11 2016

Page 28: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Emergency department (1)

1. Process of declaration of MCE / large MCE for the hospital and theemergency department

2. Securing the hospitals and the emergency/trauma department involved, from overattacks. Should injured people be controlled bysafety guard without wasting precious time ?

3. What technologies can PRACTICALLY help in patient and asset tracking and control?

4. Registration of patients ; research of non identified injured people

5. Coordination between professionals at the emergency rooms6. Standard procedures of radiological and biological exams at the

emergency rooms

7. Safety of the hospital and the emergency department

28 25 11 2016

Page 29: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Emergency department (2)

8. What is the role of the media in disseminating correct and timely medical information during and after the event?

9. What is the role of social media and should physicians and managers use it and how?

10. Hospital-internal problems The (trauma) surgical point of view

Are surgeons well prepared? (Damage Control Surgery)Need for a stock of materials

….11. Information for families : giving information, assuring safety,

answering the families looking for lost people

12. Training program and drills for the medical teams

…..

29 25 11 2016

Page 30: Lessons learned from the Brussels Attacks : intra ...Department of Emergency Medicine UZ Brussel and Research Group in Emergency and Disaster Medicine Brussels. 22 march 2016 (Brussels)

Thepaperisopenfordiscussion.....

30 25 11 2016