LEP working group for Higgs boson searchesmcdonald/mumu/tully_talk.pdf · ³ ´ µ ¶ ·¹¸ º...

��

!#" !%$ & ' ( ) *�+ , - ,/. . &&0- " 13254 - &687:9<;>=�?A@:B>BDCE 9<;>FHGJIJKMLNF

LEP working group for Higgs boson searches

��

- " 1 O P P P ,�. 4 * Q - 1%. R " !8"$ . $ &S! O T ' U ,�Q " !V,/' Q

WYX[ZA\/]_^a` \cb:d eMbHd_\gf�]Jhidj\ck l0m�` ^ab�n:op^qdsr tuZwvyx{z}|~ l{W��5� �/�H�� W�l{�� e �c��l8� �/� �� ~ l �/�H�l�W5� ��

� ��:��<�5��{� � �<�5�� {��5��A ¡ ¢ �£�Y� � �V�� ¤� ��¥ � �<�¦��¡ ¢ ¢ � �<�5��¡ § � ¨ © ª �%�[�¦�{� � �<�¦��¡ « �¬�w �<�5® ª �5¯ �°� � �<�5��¡ � �� °�£�M¯ ¥<� � �<�¦�� {��²± �

³´µ¶·¹¸º»½¼¾ ¿ÁÀ·¹¸ÂÃ ¸ºÄ ¸ ¿ÅpÆÇÈÈÈ

ÉÊËÌÍÎÏÑÐÒ ÎÔÓÓÕÕÐÖ×ØÙ ÐÕ

ÚÜÛÝ Þß Ý àßáßãâäåuææç

Ýççèä áÛ ç

éê ëìîíïqðñ òñÔóðô ó õö÷øø ùú óò ø û

üþýöÿ í õóô í �ùí�òíìí �íðò ø

ô ó õ÷�� í�� ñ��øøñ��

ð÷ú�ñ ò õí�ó ðøò õý�ò íìö÷øø

�� í�ì ñ �ñìîíìÿ��

ò í�ó õõíø ùó ðì ñ ð�ðýöÿ í õóô

øíú í�ò íìÿ÷�� õó ýðì

�� ! � "�#

$ %&'()*+)-,./-,0

�&%'(1/2/)-,2

/-,.

% /

/3/. ,4* ,3

5 '$ %

)2+* ,4/-,.

%&'

300326,+

3* ,478 9:;-<=

>?A@B��CEDF

0510152025

020

4060

8010

012

0

Rec

onst

ruct

ed M

ass

mH

[GeV

/c2 ]

Events / 3 GeV/c2

√s– = 2

00-2

10 G

eV

LE

P S

/B=0

.3

back

grou

nd

hZ S

igna

l

(mh=

114

GeV

)

cnd=

199

bgd=

180.

5

sgl=

12.7

1

GHIJKMLNOQPR SUTKMLVW LNX L SY[Z\]]]

^_`Ìab

cedf bhggiidjklm di

npoq r

s q tsuswv

xy{zz|

q||}x uo |

~��

� ��

��

~��

��

� �

��

� ��

��

��

�� - ¡

¢£¥¤¦§§¨©Eª«

024681012

020

4060

8010

012

0

Rec

onst

ruct

ed M

ass

mH

[GeV

/c2 ]

Events / 3 GeV/c2

√s– = 2

00-2

10 G

eV

LE

P S

/B=1

.0

back

grou

nd

hZ S

igna

l

(mh=

114

GeV

)

cnd=

63

bgd=

58.9

5

sgl=

7.62


^_`Ìab

cedf bhggiidjklm di

npoq r

s q tsuswv

xy{zz|

q||}x uo |

¬e®ª¯¯°± ¯ª ²³ª´µ·¶¸µº¹»

¼h½¯¯¾ ª¹µº¿¶À ÁÂ§ÃÄ©Eª«

~��

� ��

��

~��

��

� �

��

� ��

��

� ��

��

��

�� Å ¡

¢£¥¤¦§§¨©Eª«

0123456

020

4060

8010

012

0

Rec

onst

ruct

ed M

ass

mH

[GeV

/c2 ]

Events / 3 GeV/c2

√s– = 2

00-2

10 G

eV

LE

P S

/B=2

.0

back

grou

nd

hZ S

igna

l

(mh=

114

GeV

)

cnd=

27

bgd=

22.1

9

sgl=

3.64


^_`Ìab

cedf bhggiidjklm di

npoqoy |oy{Æqxvo

Ç us

È ÉÊºËÌ ÉÍºÎÎÏ ÐÑÒÉ ÎÒ ËÓÒÕÔÓÒ ÑÒÉ ÓÒÉhÖ ×

Ø ¦ÙÚÜÛÝÞß ÙÚ Þß

à ÉeáÑÌ ÓËÑ âÖÍ�ãÑâÉÑäÌ ËÓÑ âËä ÉeááËÏ

Ñ áÏ Ò âËÑÒ ËÏ ÑÓ

å ÎÉ ÓÓÎ áÖÎ æáÒÉ áç Ë èéË âÉeêË áÒ Ó ×

ë·ìÚØß¦ íÛïîpðî

Ý ñì ñë·ì§ Ý

Û ñ Þ ñ

à Î âòÌÌ æÓÒ âÑÒÉ ãËå æâéÎÓËÓ ×

-10

-7.5-5

-2.50

2.55

7.510

100

105

110

115

Bac

kgro

un

d O

nly

Bac

kgro

un

d+S

ign

alOb

serv

ed

MH (

GeV

)

-2ln(Q)

L3

óõô÷öùøûú üþý ÿ � ü�� ÿ�� ÿ��

� �� !� " # $ ��&%'� ��(��

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0

2.5) 5

7.5* 10

100 105+

110+

115

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MH, (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

L3

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0

2.5) 5

7.5* 10

100 105+

110+

115

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MH, (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

ALEPH

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0-2.5

5.7.5

10

100+

105 110+

115+

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MH, (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

DELPHI

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0-2.5

5.7.5

10

100+

105 110+

115+

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MH, (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

OPAL

/�02143 576&8:9<;!;>=@? A BC5EDGF H IKJLI MONQP RSB�T U V W�N<XZY\[�]

^&_a`�bdc egfih jEe�k�k�l�lmh�no�p�qrh�l

sut v w'x y{z | y~}&� �O��}

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0�2.5

5�7.5

10

105 110 115

Background Only�

Background+Signal

Observed

MH (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

ADLO

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

105 110 115MH (GeV)

1-C

Lb

3�

σ�ADLO�

P �r��?�M�� ] � =@?�=�� IKJ N�N:��021 � 9��

NQP R�B�T � =@?&=@� ��IrJ ��2V�3

� =��?�=��8�I4?�8:9


sux }�wm}��y�x �¡ ¢ y{��£ } ¤¦¥ § ¨ y�©�wmt yCxª��}¬«

10-2

10-1

1

110 112 114 116 118

ALEPHADLO

DLO

MH (GeV)

3σ O

bse

rvat

ion

Pro

bab

ility

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

1

105 110 115

Observed®Median Expected

113.8¯

114.2¯

MH (GeV)

CL

s

DLO

°�±4² ³ ´ U N�N:� � 9�� µA B�5GDEF N<¶¸·H Bº¹ �»N¦·A H B¼¹ ¶¾½�·

H B¼¹ � I4;m;QB�=@� =¿J¹ ÀÂÁ'Ã ²'Ä Ã<Å¡ÆN�N:��ÇÈ� � Ã��

� Ã<Å&É�I4Ê Ë7Ì»ÍÎÃ<ÏÐJÑÃ<Å¡ÆN�N<¶�Ç2Ò � Ã��


Ó Ô ��£ Õ ©�s � x z Ö�¥ ��wmyCx �¡ � ©Ø×�y

10-2

10-1

1

10

-3 -2 -1 0Ù

1 2Ú

3

0Ù10

20

30

40Û50

60

70Ü80

0Ù

2Ú

4Û

6 8 100Ù5

10

15

20Ú25Ú30

0Ù

1 2Ú

3 4Û

5

ADLO mH=115.0 GeV

Final Variable log10(S/B)

Eve

nts

Expected Signal

Exp

ecte

d B

ackg

roun

d BackgroundÝSignal+Background

Expected Signal

Exp

ecte

d B

ackg

roun

d

Background 193.4Data 217ÞSignal 12.0

BackgroundÝSignal+Background


| y�}�� } ß�©�s t �!� ¢ Ô x x y��!}

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0

2.5à 5

7.5á 10

100 105â

110â

115

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MHã (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

4-Jet

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0

2.5à 5

7.5

10

100 105â

110â

115

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MHã (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

Leptons

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0ä2.5

5å7.5

10â

100â

105 110â

115â

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MHã (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

Neutrinos

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0ä2.5

5å7.5

10â

100â

105 110â

115â

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

Mæ

Hã (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

Taus

¶»Çç�è ��éëê�Ã:ì Ë7Ì&Ï:Ã<Á!Á>É@Ê í î ïº¹ î ðKìñð òôóQõ R�ï�T U ö W�ó÷X Y�ø ]


ù Öûú�y¡� y~}&� �O�Â} ßÐ©�s t �m� ¥ § ¨ yC©&wmt y�xª�Â}

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0

2.5à 5

7.5á 10

100 105â

110â

115

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MHã (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

ALEPH

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0

2.5à 5

7.5á 10

100 105â

110â

115

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MHã (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

L3

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0ä2.5

5å7.5

10

100â

105 110â

115â

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MHã (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

DELPHI

-10

-7.5

-5

-2.5

0ä2.5

5å7.5

10â

100â

105 110â

115â

Background Only

Background+Signal

Observed

MHã (GeV)

-2ln

(Q)

OPAL

¶»ÇÈÒ4è �éüê¾Ã�ì Ë7Ì�Ï�Ã<Á!Á>É@Ê í ïCËEýGþ î ðKìLð òôó>õ ÿ�ï�� ö ��ó��Ç��4è ��éëê�Ã:ì Ë7Ì&Ï:Ã<Á!Á>É@Ê î ï¼¹ î ðKìñð òôó�õ ÿ�ï � � � �¾ó��

�� !�!"#"$��%'&)(+*,�-"

ù Öûú/.10 Ô�2�2 3 465 0 2

0

5

10

15

20

0 20 40 60 80 100 120Reconstructed Mass mH [GeV/c2]

Eve

nts

/ 3 G

eV/c

2

√s– = 200-210 GeV

LEP (ADLO) qq S/B=0.3background7hZ Signal8114 GeV

cnd=9 91:

bgd=;

72.69<

sgl== 8.34>

0

2.5

5

7.5

10

0 20 40 60 80 100 120Reconstructed Mass mH [GeV/c2]

Eve

nts

/ 3 G

eV/c

2

√s– = 200-210 GeV

LEP (ADLO) qq S/B=1.0?background7hZ Signal114 GeV

cnd=9 28@

bgd=;

22.31sgl== 4.7

A

0

2

4

0 20 40 60 80 100 120Reconstructed Mass mB

HC [GeV/c

D 2]E

Eve

nts

/ 3 G

eV/c

2

√s– = 200-210 GeV

LEP (ADO) qq S/B=2.0background7hZ Signal8114 GeV

cnd=9 12bgd=;

4.93A

sgl== 1.97

�� !�!"#"$��%'&)(+*,�-"

5GF 2�H$2 0I. F J1K L . JNM 2 O L PQF F . 4$2SR

10-2

10-1

1

110 112 114 116 118

4-JetTADLO

LNT

MH (GeV)

3σ O

bse

rvat

ion

Pro

bab

ility

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

1

105 110 115

ObservedUMedian Expected

113.1 113.3V

MH (GeV)

CL

s

LNT

WYX[Z \ ] ^ _!_a` b c-d e`+fhg!cai _�jlkm�n o _qplk

r s mut vxwlk

myn o z {!|$|}my~�� ~�it ��|6caZ6�lc��1�_!_�v��v b c-d

z c��~�{[� ��Sc��i�c��1�_!_�v��_ b c-d

�� !�!�#�$�� '¡)¢+£,�-�

5G¤ ¥ H6F ¦¨§ © ¦«ª�¬ ¯®Yª

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

1

105 110 115

ObservedMedian Expected

114.5112.3

MH (GeV)

CL

s

ADLO

° ± ²´³�µ�¶·³�¸ ¹ º¼» º¾½�¿ ÀÁÀ¨ÂGÃÅÄ Æ ³1Ç³�¸ ºÉÈËÊ Ì Í Î ³yÏY½�³�¸ ¹ º¼» º¾½�¿ ÀÁÀÑÐ ÃÓÒ Æ ³1Ç

�� !�!�#�$�� '¡)¢+£,�-�

Ô Õ ®�¦�Ö § ¦¨§ × Ô Ø ¬ Ö Ö Ù6Ö ÚÛaÜ Ý¨Þàß�áYâ�Ü â�ãåä ßSã æ ç�èêéìë¨í�îïßSã

îìã ð ñòíaâ�ã¨è!â ßåó#ô õ î÷öNöSí øùîïöSã�ôYé

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

0ú

20 40 60û

80ü

100 120

MH=116MH=115MH=114MH=113

95ý

% CL Exclusionþ

Additional Luminosity @ 206.6 GeV (pb-1)ÿ

Exp

ecte

d C

Ls

��

�! #"%$'& (*),+ -.(0/1/12324+6587:9�;<+=2

> ôYíaâ ?A@ ð èlèêë¨Ü ë¨é÷ô�äàîìã�ö B ôYèDCöåÞàßSë¨ãFEHG=I ã¨éKJL@

10-7

10-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

0M

20 40 60N

80O

100 120

3P

σQ4R

σQ5S

σQMH=116MH=115MH=114MH=113

Additional Luminosity @ 206.6 GeV (pb-1)T

Exp

ecte

d 1

-CL

b

> ôYíaâ UV@ ð èlèêë¨Ü ë¨é÷ô�äàîìã�ö B ôYèDCöåÞàßSë¨ãFELW øùîïöåã�ôNéX@

10-7

10-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

0M

20Y

40Z

60N

80O

100 120

3P

σQ4σQ5S

σQMH=116MH=115MH=114MH=113

Additional Luminosity @ 206.6 GeV (pb[ -1)

T

Exp

ecte

d 1

-CL

b

�! #"%$'& (*),+ -.(0/1/12324+6587:9�;<+=2

\ ] ^`_ba c _Fc d \ e f a a g�a hi jlknm opj q rtspu�jwvyx{z�|

} ~ �� 1�� 8� �%��w� � ��1�� =� �

10-7

10-6

10-5

10-4

10-3

10-2

10-1

0�

20 40 60û

80ü

100 120

3σ4σ5σ

MH=116MH=115MH=114MH=113

Additional Luminosity @ 208.2 GeV (pb� -1)

�

Exp

ecte

d 1

-CL

b

��

�� ¡£¢¤¥§¦¨ ©«ª¡£¢¬ ¢¤® ¢ ©¯±°²³³³

´µ¶·¸¹º�»¼ ¹¾½½¿¿»ÀÁÂÃ »¿

ÄtÅÆÆÇ È ÉÊË ÌÍÎ ÈÇ ÏÊÐ ÇÎÑ Ê ÒÓÔ ÅÐ Î Ô

Õ Ö ×Ø Ù ÚÛÜ«ÝÞàßáâã�äãå�æçéèêê Ö ×Ö¾ëìèííïîðÖ ìëñÖ ×óòë ìô× èÛæ Ûæ õ

æ öÛæ õÖ ðæ ì×õæí è×Öø÷æ× ë×Ø æù îúáû ×Ø Ö ìÛî× ñüúÖø÷æ ìýØ è×Ø èñþ îõõæ ì×í ò

Ü ææ ìðæèñ îõæê Ö ì×Ø æê è× è üÿ��þè ìæÖ ×Ø æ õ �

è��Ú�� ÿ æ öþíïîê æîÛ×ë��å�æçüë õ

Ü� ìþ õæèñæ×Ø æÿ��ôýÖ

ê ææ öþæññ× ëè��ëÜ ñæ õ÷è×Ö¾ëìè×��Úå�æç

ä��è×��å�æç� ä

� è� × æ õÙ âÛÜ ÝÞ ßáâã�äãå�æçüÿ�

� ñýÖ × þØ æñ×ëáâû äáå�æç õîììÖ ìú ü

èÜ ë÷æ�ââÛÜ ÝÞàßáâû äáå�æç Ûæ õæ öÛæ õÖ ðæ ì×üÿ�

�ýÖííØ è ÷æ�

è��ëÜ ñæ õ÷è×Ö ë ì� ë õ��ãå�æçüë õ

Ü� � �� ë õ��Úå�æçüë õ

þ�� ìõëèê × ëê Ö ñþë ÷æ õò� ë õ��å�æç ä

�� ! " "#$#%�'&)(+*-,.�/#

0 1 2 2 35476 8:9 0 ;<3�= > 354�> 8 > ?A@ ?AB�1 @C;DB

EGFIH<JLKNMPO JRQTS EGFIH<JRUVSNJXWZY\[ JL] ^ _ `DabJcKbdTJXWZY\[ JL] ^e f E5g5h i"ikjml�n iRo"pIlPiq E f g�h r i"iXoIlsp i"iRoIltnfvu i"iXoIl�j iRo"wIl�w_ g e f i"ixi"lty iRo"pIltnf JcHzS|{TQ�a iRoxwIlsw iRo"pIl�p�Y~}c^� JR�IS%K%M�Qz{Ta i"iXoIlty i"iXjmlPi�v� ��a iRo)��l�j iRoxnml�� xJ/S�a i"i u l�n iRo"pIl�of E5g i"ic��l�n i"iXjml u

Y } ^ �IO �-�� QzJ/F�U � ��WzJXW K%J'�"M�{TQ `<J � {X� iRo"oIl�y [ J/]� �� z�'��k� ��k� � ��I�¡ ¡¢ �£¤�D�X¥

�� ! " "#$#%�'&)(+*-,.�/#

3§¦ ¨©2 3�@ 0 ;�8�ª ¨C¦ ¨©= «

0¬2040®60¯80

100

120

140

160

0¬

20

40®

60¯

80 100 120 1400¬2040®60¯80

100

120

140

160

mh (GeV/c2)

mA

(G

eV/c

2 )

Excludedby LEP°

TheoreticallyInaccessible

mh± -max

1

10

0 100 200 300 400²

500

1

10

m³ A´ (GeV/c2)

µ

tanβ

Excluded¶by LEP·

m¸ h¹ -max

Mº

SUSY» =1 TeV

Mº

2¼ =200 GeV

µ=-200 GeVmgluino=800 GeVStop mix: Xt

½ =2MSUSY»

1

10

0¬

20 40 60¯

80 100 120 140

1

10

m¾ h (GeV/c2)ta

nβ

Excludedby LEP°

TheoreticallyInaccessible

mh± -max

¿ �D�R� ÀÁ ¡¢ ��k� Â|Ã �ÅÄ Æ{"`�acl JVFIHÇl

È É Ê w"pzl�n p u lswÈ Ë Ê p"ozl�j p-��l�i

�'�D£ Ì Í Î¤ÏT�¡��R �ÐÑ£{"`�acl JVFIHZl

oIltn uXÒ jIl�j"n oIl��Ów Ò jIlÔ�Ów

Õ�Ö�×�Ø�Ù Ú�Û�Ü Ý�Ú!Þ"Þ"ß$ß%Ü'à)á+â-ã.Ü/ß

ä å�æ «�?A> ¨%«:«�B ç ? å5æ�èéä ê B�ë ìîí�ï

0ð

0.1ð0.2ð0.3ð0.4ð0.5ð0.6ð0.7ð0.8ð0.9ð

1

60ñ

65ñ

70 75 80ò

85ò

90ó

95ó

mH (GeV)

Br(

H→

τν)

LEP 189-209 GeVôSeptember 2000

õ ö�÷bøcùbúTøXûZü¡ý øRû�þ�ÿ�� <ø��|øRû�� ¤þ�� þ��÷ ü�� ø�� ù ��ùkü�� "!#��:ù%$ &�'(& �:ù$ )*'+& ÿ��-, �:ù

. &�'0/ ü2143�' . � . 3�'05 ü637&�'(3-� 1 . '81 ü21 . '0/*�

Õ�Ö�×�Ø�Ù Ú�Û�Ü Ý�Ú!Þ"Þ"ß$ß%Ü'à)á+â-ã.Ü/ß

9 ê æ�: ;=<?> ä <?@ ;|è ;BA?A ï ç êDCFE�èHG ê ï�ë ìCíDï

10-3

10-2

10-1

20I

40J

60K

80L

100 12010

-3

10-2

10-1

10-3

10-2

10-1

20I

40J

60K

80L

100 120

20I

40J

60K

80L

100 120

ADLO Combined5 September UpdateM

Excluded Region

Photonic Higgs Search

MhN 0 (GeV)

Upp

er L

imit

on

B(h

0 →γγ

)

Fermiophobic BR

O

+2 sigma expected

-2 sigma expected

median expectedPLimit = 107.7 GeV

Q RTSVUXWZY�U�[ \^]`_ ]ba*c d�egfghif j Ulkm U�[n]po�q r sut�U�v�awU�[ \x]`_ ]ba*c d�ezy{h�| j Ulk

}�~�� 7�7��=�w�4�i�"��

�*�� @ �B� � A�A � �n¡nC£¢ � ¤ �DCFE�¡HG � ��¥ �§¦ �

-20

-10

0

10

20¨30©40ª

98«

100 102 104 106 108 110 112 114 116 118

MH¬ , GeV/c 2

-2ln

(Q)

Observed®Mean, Background¯Mean, Signal

LEP

0

0.2°0.4°0.6°0.8° 1

100 102.5 105 107.5 110 112.5 115 117.5

MH¬ , GeV/c 2

Br

H to

Inv

isib

le

95% CL99% CL90% CLExpected 95% CL

LEP

Q RTSVUXWZY�U�[ \^]`_ ]ba*c dHdX±²hif j Ulkm U�[n]po�q r sut�U�v�awU�[ \x]`_ ]ba*c dHd´³{h�| j Ulk

µ¶·¸¹»º¼½¿¾À ÁÃÂ¹»ºÄÅ º¼Æ º ÁÇÉÈÊËËË

ÌÍÎÏÐÑÒ+ÓÔ ÑÖÕÕ××ÓØÙÚÛ Ó×

ÜÝÞ ßßà áâ àãä Þ á

åçæèéê èëì íëèèê èîïðñò æ íó ôöõ÷ùøúüûýþÿ��ÿ� ì�� ê éê æ è��

� ë�ê èæê é�æ è�é � õì õì íì õì íê��ì èé íì� �éê��ìé æé� ì� ëîý� é� ê èõëé �

� ê é�é� ê � �é ��ïðñ�� èìê é�ì í �

�� ô�å ï ì �� ë�ì ëõé æ�� ì� �æ í

÷� � è� íì�ìé�ìïðñ��ê� ìì �ìé æ� �!æ÷ ì í��éê æ è�é��ô� ì�

" � �!�é�� ì��

#� ìì� í�� íìë� é � æ ë��÷ ì íì �ì �� ë�éì� �éé�ê éê �ì�

$&%'(()* +%,) ',.-)', -%/%%0 /,)%

10�22/* 3,)%)* 4065* 387

LEP working group for Higgs boson searchesmcdonald/mumu/tully_talk.pdf · ³ ´ µ ¶ ·¹¸ º...

Documents

Transcript of LEP working group for Higgs boson searchesmcdonald/mumu/tully_talk.pdf · ³ ´ µ ¶ ·¹¸ º...