LEGAL ANTI˜DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & LEGAL … › wp-content › uploads › 2015 › 08 ›...

2
A RESEARCH PROJECT INITIATED BY FUNDED BY Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide (TvT) provides an overview of the human rights situa- tion of trans persons in different parts of the world and develops useful data and advocacy tools for international institutions, human rights organizations, the trans movement and the general public. It is a comparative, ongoing qualitative-quantitative research project conducted by TGEU’s TvT team in close cooperation with 18 partner organizations and numerous trans activists and resear- chers in all six world regions. The data collected are compiled and updated periodically and can be viewed in detail in English and Spanish on the TvT website: www.transrespect-transphobia.org The TvT tables visualise transspecific and trans-inclusive legislations and how they are enacted in actual practice. They list law proposals that challenge existing measures and serve to indicate exis- ting trans activism. They provide information on legal measures that criminalize trans people, show- ing important differences between criminalization and actual prosecution. The tables also give a first insight into trans people‘s health care situation. LEGAL AND HEALTH CARE MAPPING LEGAL GENDER RECOGNITION ANTI-DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & ASYLUM LEGISLATION LEGAL CHANGE OF NAME LEGAL CHANGE OF GENDER ANTI-DISCRI- MINATION *** HATE CRIME (TRANS- SPECIFIC) ASYLUM (TRANS- SPECIFIC) INCLUSION IN CONSTITU- TION Angola Legal Measure Proposals Antigua Legal Measure Proposals Argentina Legal Measure Proposals Australia Legal Measure Proposals Azerbaijan Legal Measure Proposals Bahamas Legal Measure Proposals Barbados Legal Measure Proposals Belgium Legal Measure Proposals Belize Legal Measure Proposals Bosnia-Herzegovina Legal Measure Proposals Botswana Legal Measure Proposals Brazil Legal Measure Proposals Chile Legal Measure Proposals Colombia Legal Measure Proposals Cook Islands Legal Measure Proposals Croatia Legal Measure Proposals Cuba Legal Measure Proposals Denmark Legal Measure Proposals Ecuador Legal Measure Proposals Egypt Legal Measure Proposals El Salvador Legal Measure Proposals Fiji Legal Measure Proposals France Legal Measure Proposals Germany Legal Measure Proposals Hong Kong Legal Measure Proposals Hungary Legal Measure Proposals Iceland Legal Measure Proposals India Legal Measure Proposals Ireland Legal Measure Proposals LEGAL AND HEALTH CARE MAPPING LEGAL GENDER RECOGNITION ANTI-DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & ASYLUM LEGISLATION LEGAL CHANGE OF NAME LEGAL CHANGE OF GENDER ANTI-DISCRI- MINATION *** HATE CRIME (TRANS- SPECIFIC) ASYLUM (TRANS- SPECIFIC) INCLUSION IN CONSTITU- TION Italy Legal Measure Proposals Jamaica Legal Measure Proposals Japan Legal Measure Proposals Kazakhstan Legal Measure Proposals Kenya Legal Measure Proposals Kiribati Legal Measure Proposals Kosovo Legal Measure Proposals Kyrgyzstan Legal Measure Proposals Macedonia Legal Measure Proposals Mongolia Legal Measure Proposals Namibia Legal Measure Proposals Netherlands Legal Measure Proposals New Zealand Legal Measure Proposals Nicaragua Legal Measure Proposals Nigeria Legal Measure Proposals Norway Legal Measure Proposals Papua New Guinea Legal Measure Proposals Philippines Legal Measure Proposals Poland Legal Measure Proposals Puerto Rico Legal Measure Proposals Russia Legal Measure Proposals Saint Vincent Legal Measure Proposals Samoa Legal Measure Proposals Serbia Legal Measure Proposals Singapore Legal Measure Proposals Slovakia Legal Measure Proposals Slovenia Legal Measure Proposals Solomon Islands Legal Measure Proposals South Africa Legal Measure Proposals LEGAL AND HEALTH CARE MAPPING LEGAL GENDER RECOGNITION ANTI-DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & ASYLUM LEGISLATION LEGAL CHANGE OF NAME LEGAL CHANGE OF GENDER ANTI-DISCRI- MINATION *** HATE CRIME (TRANS- SPECIFIC) ASYLUM (TRANS- SPECIFIC) INCLUSION IN CONSTITU- TION South Korea Legal Measure Proposals Spain Legal Measure Proposals Suriname Legal Measure Proposals Sweden Legal Measure Proposals Switzerland Legal Measure Proposals Thailand Legal Measure Proposals Tokelau Legal Measure Proposals Tonga Legal Measure Proposals Trinidad & Tobago Legal Measure Proposals Turkey Legal Measure Proposals Uganda Legal Measure Proposals Uzbekistan Legal Measure Proposals Venezuela Legal Measure Proposals Zambia Legal Measure Proposals No existing legal measure Existing legal measure* Existing proposal No appropriate data Only in parts of the country Different in practice** With pathologization Change of Birth Certificate Only aſter Gender Reassignment Therapy Only aſter GRS / Sterilization Privacy Protection New marriage and keep existing marriage New marriage aſter legal change of gender Two genders More than two genders Specified as Transgender/ Gender Identity * Icons displayed behind green ‘check’ icon specify the legal measure; in the column ‘Legal change of name’, these are restrictions, in the column ‘Legal change of gender’ these are restrictions or positive specifications. ** The Icon ‘Different in practice’ applies both to countries with existing legal measures, meaning a limitation, and to countries without legal mea- sures, meaning practical possibilities without existing legislation. *** Detailed information and whether Anti-Discrimination Legislations are formulated in general terms or are specific to domains like employ- ment, education, commercial services etc., can be found on the TvT Web- site. The Legal and Health Care Mapping was produced by Transgender Europe‘s Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide (TvT) project (as of Aug. 2012), continuous updates and more detailed interactive tables on www.transrespect-transphobia.org www.tgeu.org

Transcript of LEGAL ANTI˜DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & LEGAL … › wp-content › uploads › 2015 › 08 ›...

Page 1: LEGAL ANTI˜DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & LEGAL … › wp-content › uploads › 2015 › 08 › tvt... · 2015-08-05 · singapore slovakia slovenia solomon islands south africa

A RESEARCH PROJECT INITIATED BY

FUNDED BY

Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide (TvT) provides an overview of the human rights situa-tion of trans persons in di� erent parts of the world and develops useful data and advocacy tools for international institutions, human rights organizations, the trans movement and the general public. It is a comparative, ongoing qualitative-quantitative research project conducted by TGEU’s TvT team in close cooperation with 18 partner organizations and numerous trans activists and resear-chers in all six world regions. The data collected are compiled and updated periodically and can be viewed in detail in English and Spanish on the TvT website: www.transrespect-transphobia.org

The TvT tables visualise transspeci� c and trans-inclusive legislations and how they are enacted in actual practice. They list law proposals that challenge existing measures and serve to indicate exis-ting trans activism. They provide information on legal measures that criminalize trans people, show-ing important di� erences between criminalization and actual prosecution. The tables also give a � rst insight into trans people‘s health care situation.

LEGAL AND HEALTH CARE MAPPING

LEGAL GENDER RECOGNITION

ANTI-DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & ASYLUM LEGISLATION

LEGAL CHANGE OF NAME

LEGAL CHANGE OF GENDER

ANTI-DISCRI-MINATION ***

HATE CRIME(TRANS-

SPECIFIC)

ASYLUM(TRANS-

SPECIFIC)

INCLUSION IN CONSTITU-

TION

Angola Legal Measure

Proposals

Antigua Legal Measure

Proposals

Argentina Legal Measure

Proposals

Australia Legal Measure

Proposals

Azerbaijan Legal Measure

Proposals

Bahamas Legal Measure

Proposals

Barbados Legal Measure

Proposals

Belgium Legal Measure

Proposals

Belize Legal Measure

Proposals

Bosnia-Herzegovina Legal Measure

Proposals

Botswana Legal Measure

Proposals

Brazil Legal Measure

Proposals

Chile Legal Measure

Proposals

Colombia Legal Measure

Proposals

Cook Islands Legal Measure

Proposals

Croatia Legal Measure

Proposals

Cuba Legal Measure

Proposals

Denmark Legal Measure

Proposals

Ecuador Legal Measure

Proposals

Egypt Legal Measure

Proposals

El Salvador Legal Measure

Proposals

Fiji Legal Measure

Proposals

France Legal Measure

Proposals

Germany Legal Measure

Proposals

Hong Kong Legal Measure

Proposals

Hungary Legal Measure

Proposals

Iceland Legal Measure

Proposals

India Legal Measure

Proposals

Ireland Legal Measure

Proposals

LEGAL AND HEALTH CARE MAPPING

LEGAL GENDER RECOGNITION

ANTI-DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & ASYLUM LEGISLATION

LEGAL CHANGE OF NAME

LEGAL CHANGE OF GENDER

ANTI-DISCRI-MINATION ***

HATE CRIME(TRANS-

SPECIFIC)

ASYLUM(TRANS-

SPECIFIC)

INCLUSION IN CONSTITU-

TION

Italy Legal Measure

Proposals

Jamaica Legal Measure

Proposals

Japan Legal Measure

Proposals

Kazakhstan Legal Measure

Proposals

Kenya Legal Measure

Proposals

Kiribati Legal Measure

Proposals

Kosovo Legal Measure

Proposals

Kyrgyzstan Legal Measure

Proposals

Macedonia Legal Measure

Proposals

Mongolia Legal Measure

Proposals

Namibia Legal Measure

Proposals

Netherlands Legal Measure

Proposals

New Zealand Legal Measure

Proposals

Nicaragua Legal Measure

Proposals

Nigeria Legal Measure

Proposals

Norway Legal Measure

Proposals

Papua New Guinea Legal Measure

Proposals

Philippines Legal Measure

Proposals

Poland Legal Measure

Proposals

Puerto Rico Legal Measure

Proposals

Russia Legal Measure

Proposals

Saint Vincent Legal Measure

Proposals

Samoa Legal Measure

Proposals

Serbia Legal Measure

Proposals

Singapore Legal Measure

Proposals

Slovakia Legal Measure

Proposals

Slovenia Legal Measure

Proposals

Solomon Islands Legal Measure

Proposals

South Africa Legal Measure

Proposals

LEGAL AND HEALTH CARE MAPPING

LEGAL GENDER RECOGNITION

ANTI-DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & ASYLUM LEGISLATION

LEGAL CHANGE OF NAME

LEGAL CHANGE OF GENDER

ANTI-DISCRI-MINATION ***

HATE CRIME(TRANS-

SPECIFIC)

ASYLUM(TRANS-

SPECIFIC)

INCLUSION IN CONSTITU-

TION

South Korea Legal Measure

Proposals

Spain Legal Measure

Proposals

Suriname Legal Measure

Proposals

Sweden Legal Measure

Proposals

Switzerland Legal Measure

Proposals

Thailand Legal Measure

Proposals

Tokelau Legal Measure

Proposals

Tonga Legal Measure

Proposals

Trinidad & Tobago Legal Measure

Proposals

Turkey Legal Measure

Proposals

Uganda Legal Measure

Proposals

Uzbekistan Legal Measure

Proposals

Venezuela Legal Measure

Proposals

Zambia Legal Measure

Proposals

No existing legal measure

Existing legal measure*

Existing proposal

No appropriate data

Only in parts of the country

Di� erent in practice**

With pathologization

Change of Birth Certi� cate

Only a� er Gender Reassignment Therapy

Only a� er GRS / Sterilization

Privacy Protection

New marriage and keep existing marriage

New marriage a� er legal change of gender

Two genders

More than two genders

Speci� ed as Transgender/ Gender Identity

* Icons displayed behind green ‘check’ icon specify the legal measure; in the column ‘Legal change of name’, these are restrictions, in the column ‘Legal change of gender’ these are restrictions or positive speci� cations.

** The Icon ‘Di� erent in practice’ applies both to countries with existing legal measures, meaning a limitation, and to countries without legal mea-sures, meaning practical possibilities without existing legislation.

*** Detailed information and whether Anti-Discrimination Legislations are formulated in general terms or are speci� c to domains like employ-ment, education, commercial services etc., can be found on the TvT Web-site.

The Legal and Health Care Mapping was produced by Transgender Europe‘s Transrespect versus Transphobia Worldwide (TvT) project (as of Aug. 2012), continuous updates and more detailed interactive tables on www.transrespect-transphobia.org

www.tgeu.org

Page 2: LEGAL ANTI˜DISCRIMINATION, HATE CRIME & LEGAL … › wp-content › uploads › 2015 › 08 › tvt... · 2015-08-05 · singapore slovakia slovenia solomon islands south africa

LEGAL AND HEALTH CARE

MAPPING

CRIMINALIzATIoN, PRosECuTIoN & sTATE-sPoNsoRED DIsCRIMINATIoN HoRMoNEs AND HoRMoNE THERAPy GENDER REAssIGNMENT TREATMENT/

suRGERy AND BoDy MoDIfICATIoNs

Criminali-zation

ProseCu-tion

state-sPonsored

disCrimi-nation

mediCal suPervision

Without mediCal

suPervisionFunding AvAilAble

forms requirements funding

‘AlternAtives’ when no or limited grt/

grs*

angola

antigua

argentina

australia

azerbaijan

Bahamas

Barbados

Belgium

Belize

Bosnia-herzegovina

Botswana

Brazil

Chile

Columbia

Cook islands

Croatia

Cuba

denmark

ecuador

egypt

el salvador

Fiji

France

germany

hong Kong

hungary

iceland

india

ireland

italy

Jamaica

Japan

Kazakhstan

Kenya

Kiribati

Kosovo

Kyrgyzstan

macedonia

LEGAL AND HEALTH CARE

MAPPING

CRIMINALIzATIoN, PRosECuTIoN & sTATE-sPoNsoRED DIsCRIMINATIoN HoRMoNEs AND HoRMoNE THERAPy GENDER REAssIGNMENT TREATMENT/

suRGERy AND BoDy MoDIfICATIoNs

Criminali-zation

ProseCu-tion

state-sPonsored

disCrimi-nation

mediCal suPervision

Without mediCal

suPervisionFunding AvAilAble

forms requirements funding

‘AlternAtives’ when no or limited grt/

grs*

mongolia

namibia

netherlands

new zealand

nicaragua

nigeria

norway

Papua new guinea

Philippines

Poland

Puerto rico

russia

saint vincent

samoa

serbia

singapore

slovakia

slovenia

solomon islands

south africa

south Korea

spain

suriname

sweden

switzerland

thailand

tokelau

tonga

trinidad & tobago

turkey

uganda

uzbekistan

venezuela

zambia

Cd

Cd

o

o

Cd

bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, P, rPt, v

bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, rPt

AC, bA, bhA, Cr, hr, ma, l, v

bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, ma, me, l, P, v

bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, v

AC, bA, Cr, h, ma, me, l, P, v

bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, me, P, v

bA, bhA, Cr, hr, ma, l

AC, bA, Cr, bhA, h, hr, l, ma, P, v

bA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, me, P, v

AC, bA, Cr, h, ma, P, rPt, v

AC, bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, P, rPt, v

hr, l, ma, me, P, v

bA, Cr, h, hr, ma, me, P, v

AC, bA, bhA, h, hr ma, me, P, v

All

bA, hr, Cr, h, l, ma, rPt

AC, bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, ma, P, l, v

bA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, rPt, v

bA, h, ma, rPt

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs

nhi, Phi

Phs, nhi, Phi

nhi

b, P

b, o

b, P, o

b, P, o

b, P

P

o

b, P

b, o

P

P

b, i

b, i, tP

P, i

b

b

P, tP

b, o

b, P

b, P, o

P

P

P

P

b, P

i

o

nhi, Phi

Phs

nhi

nhi

Phs

Phs, Phi

nhi

o

o

o

o

Cd

Cd

Cd, o

Cd

o

Cd, g

nhi, Phi

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs, nhi, Phi

nhi, Phi

Phs

nhi

nhi

Phs, o

Phs, o

Phs

nhiAll

te

te

te

te

to

te

te

o

Cd, o

g

Cd

o

o o

o

b, P, tP, o

b, P

b, P, i

b, o

b, P

b, P, o

b, P, i

b, P

P, tP

P

b, P

i

b, o

b, P

b, P

b, i, o

b

i, P, tP

P, o

b, P

P

b, P

P

P

o

nhi

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs, Phi

Phs

nhi

Phs

Phs

Phs

Phs

AC, bA, Cr, bhA, h, hr, ma, me, P, rPt, v

bA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, rPt, v

bA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, me, v

AC, bA, bhA, h, hr, v, l, ma, rPt

AC, bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, P, v, rPt

bA, bhA, Cr, hr, ma

All

AC, bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, ma, me, P, l, v

AC, bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, v, rPt

bA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, rPt

AC, bA, bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, me, P, v

bA, Cr, h, ma, me, P, v

bhA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, me, P, v

AC, bA, Cr, h, hr, ma, me, P, v

AC, bA, Cr, h, hr, ma, me, P, v

AC, bA, Cr, h, hr, l, ma, P, v

AC, bA, bhA, h, hr, l, ma, P, rPt, v

nhi , o

Phs

hs, Phi

nhi , o

Phs

Phs, Phi

g

e

Cd

o

o

o

Cd

Cd

o

o

o

g

o

Cd, o

o

o

to

to

te, to

All

bA, h, ma, rPt

bA, bhA, Cr, ma, l

hs, nhi

Phi

existing legal measures / documented practice

Criminalization / prosecution / discrimination under certain circumstances

no existing legal measures

no documented cases

no appropriate data

only in parts of the country

Without medical supervision

B Blackmarket I internet P Pharmacies TP trans People O other

Funding

PHS Public health systemNHI national health insurancePHI Private health insuranceO other

Available forms

AC adam‘s apple Contouring

BA Breast augmentation

BHA Buttock/hip augmentation

CR Chest re- construction

HR hair removal

H hysterectomy

L liposuction

Ma mastectomy

Me metoidioplasty

P Phalloplasty

RPT removal of Penis/testicles

V vaginoplasty

CD so-Called Cross-dressingG grt/grsE employmentTE trans eventsTO trans organisationsO other **

no / none

existing practice without medical supervision

Provided under medical supervision

only with psychiatric diagnosis

no appropriate data

only in parts of the country

o o

** l

egal

mea

sure

s use

d to

targ

et tr

ans p

eopl

e be

ing v

isibl

e as

tran

s peo

ple

in p

ublic

,

e.g.

ant

i-hom

osex

ualit

y bill

s, an

ti-pr

ostit

utio

n la

ws,

nuisa

nce

law

s* i

nclu

de g

rs d

one

abro

ad o

r ille

gally

, app

licat

ion

of in

dust

rial s

ilico

ne e

tc.