Leading House « Economics of education » « Transitions, skills and labour market »
description
Transcript of Leading House « Economics of education » « Transitions, skills and labour market »
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
Leading House « Economics of education »
« Transitions, skills and labour market »
Göttingen, September 25th- 28th - Research on Vocational Education and Training for and as International Comparison
Jean-Marc Falter – Yves Flückiger
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
Introduction Taking a labour market perspective, our Leading
House endeavours to analyze the determinants and the impact of vocational education in Switzerland
Our research activity started in September 2006 We cover three research themes: Transitions from school toward the labour market Workers’ skills Firms behaviour with respect to vocational
education and lifelong training
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
Outline of the talk1. Research projects: overview and goals2. Skills and the labour market:
a. Employer learning: does widespread apprentice education change the picture?
b. The content of education: what enhances worker success?
3. Research agenda
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. Research People and institutions University of Geneva• Prof. Yves Flückiger: Director• Prof. Siegfried Hanhart• Dr. Jean-Marc Falter Geneva School of Business Administration• Prof. José Ramirez:
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. Research Approach We take a biographical approach: mandatory
education, transition toward post-secondary education, labour market entry and labour market outcomes
We exploit readily available database: PISA, TREE (TRansition to Education and Employment), ALL (Adults literacy and lifeskills survey)
We are producing our own data with respect to firms’ behaviour
Micro-econometric studies
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. ResearchA. School to work transitions (1/2) The performance of the schooling system
has often been assessed by means of standardized cognitive tests (PISA)
However, the performance of the schooling system goes well beyond these measures
It must provide the labour market with the required skills and ensure a smooth transitions to the labour market
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. ResearchA. School to work transitions (2/2) We analyze the capacity of the Swiss schooling
system to ensure smooth transitions inside the schooling systems (transitions towards post-mandatory education)…
… as well as transitions towards the labour market We put a special emphasis on economic variables
affecting these transitions such as unemployment, labour market structure
Building up on the literature, we also look into the impact of changing tasks on the workplace on the demand for apprentice
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. ResearchA. School to work transitions : papers and
publications M. Meunier (2006) "Fonctions de production éducationnelle:
le cas de la Suisse", Swiss Journal of Economics and Statistics, 142 (4), pp. 579-615. (version "working paper": LH Working paper no. 06_03)
M. Meunier, (2007) "Are Swiss Secondary Schools Efficient?" à paraître dans Governance and Performance of Education Systems, Nils Soguel et Pierre Jaccard (eds), Springer.
M. Meunier, (2007), "Les effets des externalités de proximité sur l'(in)efficience des écoles secondaires suisses", LH Working paper no. 07_04, University of Geneva.
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. ResearchB. Educational attainment and adult skills (1/2) Skill biased technological change (SBTC) is a major
challenge to any schooling system It may affect apprenticeship education through a
shift in the labour demand as well as through lower wages for apprentice workers
This leads to two research questions: What type of education cope better with SBTC? What kind of skills is valued on the labour market? Results should allow to better tailor the content of
vocational education
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. ResearchB. Educational attainment and adult skills (2/2) Two ways to answer these questions: Returns to (or effect of) skills: determine
means by which education enhances worker success (1)
Wage profile: returns to skills and education types in SBTC environment (2)
(1) is based on ALL data (2) is based on official wage statistics as well
as private sources (R+D survey)
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. ResearchB. Educational attainment and adult skills: papers and
publications Falter, J..-M. (2006), "Employer learning and literacy
scores in Switzerland", LH Working paper no. 06_01, University of Geneva.
C. Pasche, (2007), "A New Measure of the Cognitive and Non Cognitive Components of Education", LH Working paper no. 07_02, University of Geneva.
Falter, (2007), "Mismatch and Skill Utilization: Determinants and Consequences", LH Working paper no. 07_03, University of Geneva.
Falter, J.-M et C. Pasche, (2007), "Formation, compétences et marché du travail (titre non définitif)", Office fédéral de la statistique, Neuchâtel, forthcoming.
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
1. ResearchC. Firm behaviour and vocational education We focus on lifelong learning We currently work on gathering new data Our research questions are: Lifelong training and apprenticeship: do apprentice
degree holder entail larger investments in lifelong training?
Wages: how are shared potential productivity gains from lifelong training?
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour marketA. Introduction
Before tackling the specificity of vocational education, we must acquire a broad understanding of the mechanism at work
Vocational education is supposed to have many virtues on the labour market: reduce asymmetric information, better job matching, etc.
Does widespread apprenticeship really make a difference?
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour marketB. Employer learning (1/4)
Assessing the signalling content of education is a central question in economics
Does education improve ones productivity or does it solely signals some ability to potential employers?
Signalling questions the legitimacy of education investments
It could also lead to other problems like skill mismatch
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour marketB. Employer learning (2/4)
A traditional test of this model consists in investigating employer learning: is education an accurate measure of skills or do employers gradually learn about their worker productivity?
The literature has produced distinct results between Germany and Anglo-Saxons countries: these discrepancies were interpreted in the light of apprenticeship education
We test more thoroughly this hypothesis: does apprenticeship education reduce asymmetric information?
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour marketB. Employer learning (3/4)
Our results show that the employer learning hypothesis is valid in Switzerland
We show that the returns to initially unobserved characteristics (in our case literacy) increase with time while the returns to education decrease with time
Different results from Germany mainly come from the research instrument
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour marketB. Employer learning (4/4)
Analysis by education types show little difference between vocational education and academic education while there is differences between types of workers (blue/white collars)
Actually, we find weak evidence of more acute information problems among apprenticeship
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour marketC. The “cognitive” and “non-cognitive” component
of education It is well known that education enhances worker
success Yet, little is know about what triggers labour
market advantages We distinguish between basic skills (literacy
variables available in ALL) and other skills
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour market
YS y
X
F
y: wages, YS: years of schooling, X: years of experience, F: family background
Mincer, 1974
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour market
X
TCS
YS y
F
Gintis 1971 et Bowles et al. 2001
Y: wages, YS: years of schooling, TCS:total cognitive skills, X: years of experience, F: family background
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour market
YS y
X
F
SCS
y: wages, YS: years of schooling, SCS: schooling cognitive skills, X: years of experience, F: family background
Pasche 2007
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour market
YS y
X
F
SCS
NSCS
Pasche 2007
y: wages, YS:years of schooling, SCS:schooling cognitive skills, NSCS: non-schooling cogntive skils, X: years of experience, F family background
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour marketC. The “cognitive” and “non-cognitive” component of
education: summary (1/2) We show that vocational education has little impact
in improving basic skill levels Taking naïve estimates, basic skills make up only
10% of the wage premium attached to vocational education compared to high school drop-outs
Disentangling between “schooling cognitive skills” and “non-schooling cognitive skills”, we show that cognitive skills make up a large part of the wage premium (approximately 50%)
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
2. Skills and the labour marketC. The “cognitive” and “non-cognitive” component of
education: summary (2/2) Basic skills are much better rewarded when certified The ratio between of the returns to schooling
cognitive skills and the returns to non-schooling cognitive skills is equal to 4
Policy implications: basic skills are an important aspect of education, even for vocational education
Moreover, non-schooling cognitive skills are not rewarded at labour market entry
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
3. Research agenda Themes that should be investigated (or investigated
further) Skills: mismatch and apprenticeship should be
investigated with alternative data capturing change in the demand for apprenticeship workers (SLFS, LSE)
Transitions: disentangling economic factors from more sociological factors such as parents’ role model, pure intergenerational effects, etc. Analysis have started with Swiss household panel
Search for new data: impact of the schooling system on secondary school transitions
Göttingen, September 26th 2007
http://www.unige.ch/ses/lea/lh/