Le Meridien, Jakarta 26 Feb 2009

Le Meridien, Jakarta

26 Feb 2009

Joint Meeting Joint Meeting APGCC Chairman & APGCC Chairman &

WG 2, 5 and 6WG 2, 5 and 6

Opening Remarks of Opening Remarks of Chairman of APGCCChairman of APGCCOpening Remarks of Opening Remarks of Chairman of APGCCChairman of APGCC

1.0 Matters Arising from the 3rd APGCC 1.0 Matters Arising from the 3rd APGCC

Meeting & the 9Meeting & the 9thth HAPUA WORKING HAPUA WORKING

COMMITTEE COMMITTEE

2.0 Status on Action Plan for APG2.0 Status on Action Plan for APG

3.0 Way Forward3.0 Way Forward

ASEAN POWER GRID THE INTERCONNECTION PROJECTS

JOINT MEETING APGCC CHAIRMAN & WG2,5,6

1.0 Matters Arising from the

3rd APGCC Meeting &

9th HAPUA Working Committee

1.1 Resolution from the 91.1 Resolution from the 9thth HAPUA Working HAPUA Working Committee & 3Committee & 3rdrd APGCC Meeting APGCC Meeting

The 9The 9thth HAPUA WC and 3 HAPUA WC and 3rdrd APGCC Meeting in Singapore APGCC Meeting in Singapore from 1- 3from 1- 3rdrd December 2008 has approved and endorsed December 2008 has approved and endorsed the followings:the followings:

• Need to align & geared all Working Group activities under HAPUA Need to align & geared all Working Group activities under HAPUA Working Committee towards ensuring the realization of the APG in Working Committee towards ensuring the realization of the APG in 2015.2015.

• The Meeting agreed that WG2, 5 and 6 should re-grouped to focus their The Meeting agreed that WG2, 5 and 6 should re-grouped to focus their plan of actions and activities to support the realization of APG.plan of actions and activities to support the realization of APG.

• A special Working Committee Meeting be convened to adopt the revised A special Working Committee Meeting be convened to adopt the revised AIMS before it is presented to the 25AIMS before it is presented to the 25thth HAPUA Council meeting in May HAPUA Council meeting in May 2009.2009.


Direction for WG2 :Direction for WG2 :• Establish System Operation Sub Working Group (SO SWG) to be led by Establish System Operation Sub Working Group (SO SWG) to be led by

Indonesia and all member country to submit comment on the TOR of SO Indonesia and all member country to submit comment on the TOR of SO SWG.SWG.

• TOR of WG2 be revised to accommodate establishing of SO SWG.TOR of WG2 be revised to accommodate establishing of SO SWG.

• Submit the report on the AIMS review to HWC & APGCC.Submit the report on the AIMS review to HWC & APGCC.

• WG 2 requested to prepare the common Grid Code of ASEAN Power WG 2 requested to prepare the common Grid Code of ASEAN Power Grid, the Code of Planning and Operational rules. Issue to take note is Grid, the Code of Planning and Operational rules. Issue to take note is the separation of (i) Grid Code and (ii) Planning Criteria.the separation of (i) Grid Code and (ii) Planning Criteria.

• WG2 suggested to look into existing operating model of the EU, North WG2 suggested to look into existing operating model of the EU, North America as well as the GMS model.America as well as the GMS model.

• WG2 to draft proposal on Scope of Work and Cost for possibility of WG2 to draft proposal on Scope of Work and Cost for possibility of engaging external consultant to assist WG2.engaging external consultant to assist WG2.


Direction for WG5 :Direction for WG5 :

• Establish Project No. 5 Establish Project No. 5 – Regulatory Issues & Challenges of Regulated Entity/Owner/ Investor and Regulatory Issues & Challenges of Regulated Entity/Owner/ Investor and

ConsumerConsumer

– Provide various contractual model based on the experience and Provide various contractual model based on the experience and examples of past contract between two countries and recommend for examples of past contract between two countries and recommend for further improvement.further improvement.

• Establish Project No. 6 Establish Project No. 6 – Bilateral Contract Benchmarking to study the bilateral contracts Bilateral Contract Benchmarking to study the bilateral contracts

between member-countries of Subsystem A, and relevant studies related between member-countries of Subsystem A, and relevant studies related to commercial issues including, but not limited to, Tax, Regulation and to commercial issues including, but not limited to, Tax, Regulation and Tariff System in support of the electricity trade. Social Impact are to be Tariff System in support of the electricity trade. Social Impact are to be included in the study.included in the study.

– Prioritize the major issues on the commercial, regulation tax and tariff Prioritize the major issues on the commercial, regulation tax and tariff aspect of the interconnection. aspect of the interconnection.

• TOR for both Project 5 & 6 are to be submitted for approval of the HAPUA TOR for both Project 5 & 6 are to be submitted for approval of the HAPUA CouncilCouncil


Direction for WG6 :Direction for WG6 :

• To present the ASEAN Power Grid financial optionsTo present the ASEAN Power Grid financial options

• Together with HAPUA Secretariat to liase with ASEAN Together with HAPUA Secretariat to liase with ASEAN Secretariat on ASEAN Infrastructure Financing Mechanism as Secretariat on ASEAN Infrastructure Financing Mechanism as possible financing modalities for future ASEAN Power Projects.possible financing modalities for future ASEAN Power Projects.

2.0 Current Status on Timeline

Action Plan for

ASEAN POWER GRID (2008-2015)

9

Activities Tentative Timeline

1. In accordance with the MOU on the APG, the HAPUA Council shall initiate the establishment of the ASEAN Power Grid Consultative Committee (APGCC)

1.1 Establishment of the APGCC by the 24th HAPUA Council Meeting

1.2 Approval of the TOR by special Meeting of HAPUA Council

1.3 Reporting of TOR and Action Plan to SOME/AMEM

By June 2008By June 2008 √√

By June 2008By June 2008 √√

August 2008August 2008 √√

(Bangkok, Thailand)

2.1 Action Plan for ASEAN POWER GRID (2008-2015)

10


2. Ratification or acceptance of MOU on ASEAN Power Grid by Member Countries

3. Review the 2003 ASEAN Interconnection Master Plan Study (AIMS) 3.13.1 Interim report to be presented at the Interim report to be presented at the

next 9next 9thth HAPUA Working Committee HAPUA Working Committee MeetingMeeting

4. Adoption of the revised AIMSAdoption of the revised AIMS by the 25th HAPUA Council as an updated reference document for Member Countries in implementing bilateral and/or multilateral power interconnection projects in ASEAN 2008-2015

By December 2008 √√(SOME/AMEM JUNE 2008)(SOME/AMEM JUNE 2008)

By December 2008By December 2008(Singapore)(Singapore)

By May 2009By May 2009(Singapore)(Singapore)


11


5. APGCC to establish task-groups for the following studies as specified in the MOU on the APG (subject to confirmation by APGCC):

5.1 Harmonization of legal and regulatory framework for bilateral and cross-border power interconnection and trade

5.2 Harmonization of common Technical standards codes or guidelines of the ASEAN Interconnection Projects in the areas of:

5.2.1 Planning and Design5.2.3 System Operation 5.2.4 Maintenance

Subject to comment by Working Group 2, 5 & 6

WG 5 (proposed 2008-2010)

WG 2 (2008-2010)

- PI SWG- SO SWG- O&M SWG


12


5. APGCC to establish task-groups for the following studies as specified in the MOU on the APG (subject to confirmation by APGCC):

5.3 Formulation of institutional and contractual arrangements for cross-border electricity trade to include Taxation, Tariff and Third Party Access (Wheeling Charge)

5.4 Identify and recommend Financing Modalities for realizing the APG

Subject to comment by Working Group 2, 5 and 6

WG 5(proposed 2008-2010)WG 2 to assist in third party access

WG 6 (proposed 2008-2010)


13


6. Implementation of various bilateral and/or multilateral interconnection projects and reporting of project progress to HAPUA Council and SOME/AMEM

7. HAPUA Council to adopt the key findings and recommendation of the studies carried out by APGCC for submission to SOME/AMEM, with the view to implementing power interconnection and electricity trading in ASEAN.

8. Firm up the institutional and implementing arrangements to realize the ASEAN Power Grid (APG)

2008-2015

By 2014

Starting 2015


3.0 Way Forward

AGENDA 2 :

Status update by WG2, WG5 and WG6 in relation to APG project undertakings.

AGENDA 3:

Deliberation on current and additional assignment for WG 2,5 and 6.

Thank you

DETAILEDINTERCONNECTION

STATUS

STATUS

Commissioned in 1985.

The interconnection is between Plentong 275kV Substation in Johor, Malaysia and

Upper Jurong 230kV Substation in Singapore

• For year 2007, the availability of the interconnection has been at 99.82%.

APG # 1APG # 1

PENINSULAR MALAYSIA – SINGAPORE

TNB- SPPGTNB- SPPG

1

STATUS

The stage I interconnection is now used as a backup interconnection.

The Stage II (HVDC) interconnection project (transfer capability of 300 MW) was completed

in September 2001. The HVDC system comprises a 110km DC transmission line capable of

transferring 300MW between a 275kV DC converter substation in Gurun, Kedah, Malaysia

and a 230kV DC converter substation in Khlong Ngae, Thailand.

• Meetings have been held to study the upgrading of project from 300MW to 600MW.

However based on the preliminary findings of the AIMS, the need to upgrade to 600MW

is found to be feasible only in 2024.

APG # 2APG # 2

THAILAND – PENINSULAR MALAYSIA

EGAT - TNBEGAT - TNB

2

STATUS

• Detailed technical studies are currently being undertaken in view of implementing the

HVDC interconnection between Sarawak and Peninsular Malaysia for transferring

1600/2000 MW power from Bakun HEP to the TNB Grid system in Peninsular Malaysia.

• The 1st stage of the 800/1000 MW power transfer is targeted for completion in 2013/14.

3

APG # 3APG # 3

SARAWAK – PENINSULAR MALAYSIA

SESCO-TNB

STATUS

Detailed feasibility study carried out jointly by TNB and PLN in collaboration with Shaw PTI USA (now Siemens PTI USA). Study completed in December 2005.

Results of study presented to Management of both TNB and PLN in February 2005. TNB and PLN have agreed to further study the financial viability of the project. Technical and financial studies have been done. Joint Workshop between PLN, TNB and Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC) held

in Kuala Lumpur in September 14, 2006. There is an intension of JBIC to finance the said project. Awaiting next level decision to steer the project forward.

• The PDP of both Systems need to be revised to define the new schedule of interconnection to be finalized by June 2008.

• Survey and Detail Design will be started in 2009

4APG # 4APG # 4

PENINSULAR MALAYSIA - SUMATRA

TNB-PLN

STATUS

PLN has conducted a preliminary study on the project and the study result has been extended to

both TNB (Malaysia) and Power Grid (Singapore) in the 12th ASEAN Interconnection Meeting for

review. The Batam-Singapore interconnection has been identified by AIMS for completion by 2014 (1st

Stage). Due to the power market reform in Singapore, the development of this interconnection project

would depend on the private sector / third party participation.

• PLN has decided to conduct more detailed survey especially for feasibility study of the

150 kV form Batam – Bintan. The result of Survey construction work will be started by end

2008 and finalized by Feb of 2008.

• Singapore – Batam will be discussed further between both parties.

5

APG #5APG #5

BATAM – BINTAN - SINGAPORE

PLN – SPPG -TNBPLN – SPPG -TNB

STATUS

PLN and SESCO completed the Basic Design Studies on the proposed interconnection. Line route survey from the Mambong substation in Sarawak to the interconnection point at the town

of Serikin has been completed since the last quarter of 2003. AIMS recommended the interconnection with maximum capacity of 300MW as an energy exchange

scheme. The detailed “Trans-Borneo Power Grid Interconnection Study” funded by EAEF considered an

interconnection of between 250-350MW of power could be exported by the year 2020. As a result of the Aug 2005 meeting, SESCO developed the terms of reference for a proposed

“Control and Operations of the 275kV Sarawak-West Kalimantan Interconnection” study to be jointly carried out.

The Special Meeting of Energy Working Group of BIMP-EAGA in November 2006 in Bandung, West Java proposed an action plan for the project.

• ADB will provide grant for study on the Cross Border-issues to be circulated in 2009.

• TOR is being reviewed by PLN &SEB

6APG # 6APG # 6

SARAWAK – WEST KALIMANTAN

SESCO - PLN

STATUS

The result of AIMS final report indicates that the project is technically feasible but not

economically viable at 500 MW Transfer capacity.

TRANSCO will propose further study with possible funding under EAEF.

As agreed during the Third Meeting of PI-SWG in April 2008 in Malaysia, the

Philippines has prepared the scope of work for the interconnection, as well as the cost

estimates for the HVDC submarine cable. This information and other relevant planning

parameters were submitted to the WG2 during the 6th Meeting in Bali, Indonesia (April

2008).

7APG # 7APG # 7

PHILIPPINES – SABAH

TRANSCO - SESB

STATUS

Under study by SESB as part of the Bakun - Sabah Interconnection.

AIMS recommended the interconnection of the Sarawak – Brunei Darussalam - Sabah systems in

2019 with maximum capacity of 300MW.

The project detailed study under the “Trans-Borneo Power Grid Interconnection Implementation

Study” funded by EAEF considered an interconnection up to 250MW of power export by the year

2020.

The Special Meeting of Energy Working Group of BIMP-EAGA in November 2006 in Bandung,

West Java proposed an action plan for the project.

8APG # 8APG # 8

SARAWAK - BRUNEI - SABAH

SESCO- DES- SESBSESCO- DES- SESB

9APG # 9

THAILAND – LAO PDR

EGAT- EDL

STATUS

a) Nam Theun 2 (920 MW) - The Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) Between EGAT and Project Developer of Nam Theun 2 - signed on Nov 8, 2003.

- The feasibility study on Thai side was submitted for approval from the Thai Government in February 2004.

- The project is expected to be completed in April 2009b) Udon Thani – Nabong i. Nam Ngum 2 (597 MW) - COD 2009 ii. Nam Ngum 3 (615 MW) - COD 2010 iii. Nam Theun 1 (523 MW) - Tariff MOU signed iv. Nam Ngiep 1 (261 MW) - Tariff MOU signed

c) Mae Moh 3 (Nan) - Hong Sa - Tariff Signed

d) Mae Moh 3 (Nan) – Nam Ou - Tariff / MOU Signed

e) Roi Et –Savannakhet - No progress

f) Ubol Ratchathani-Ban Sok - Pre-feasibility study completed in 2007 with ADB supports.

STATUS

a) Ban Sok-Pleiku - MOU signed between Vietnam and Lao PDR. - The Master Plan approved by the Ministry of Industry of

Vietnam. - No further progress.

b) Nam Theum 2 - Ha Tinh - New study need to be done in case of no connection point of Nam Theun 2 HPP.

c) Nam Mo-Ban La - Feasibility study has been carried out and expected to be commissioned by 2010.

d) Xekaman3-Thach My - Feasibility study has been carried out for Xekaman3 and expected to be commissioned by 2010.

The connection is under study now and expected to be completed in 2009

10

APG # 10

LAO PDR – VIETNAM

EDL- EVNEDL- EVN

STATUS

a) Hutgyi (7x185 MW) - Feasibility Study completed mid 2007

b) Tasang (120 MW) - Under Negotiation for connecting lower dam to the Northern system of Thailand

MYANMARMYANMAR11

APG # 11APG # 11

THAILAND – MYANMAR

EGAT - MEPEEGAT - MEPE

STATUS

Chau Doc – Phnom Penh

Basic Design for Vietnam had been approved by EVN in 2002.

EVN is started construction of 220 kV transmission line in mid 2003. The project of Vietnam side is completed in October 2006.

The project will be co-financed by WB and ADB. The loan negotiation is done and waiting for Loan signing.

The project is under construction and scheduled for commission in 2009 Another link with Vietnam at 115kV – WG 2 to take note of the emergence of new

interconnection and report it together with the review of AIMS.

APG # 12APG # 12

VIETNAM – CAMBODIA

EVN - EDCEVN - EDC

12

STATUS

MOU signed in 1999.

Preliminary discussion and site visit has been made in 2001 by EDC/EDL.

EDL is constructing the 115kV double circuit transmission lines to Ban Hat substation

which is 26 km from the border area and will be completed in mid 2010.

• Cambodia informed that new project of 500kV as part of the Indo-China link which is

understudy.

13

APG # 13APG # 13

LAO PDR – CAMBODIA

EDL - EDCEDL - EDC

STATUS

Thailand and Cambodia have reached a conclusion on the revision of tariff structure.

Transmission on both sides were completed and energized on 22 November 2007

14

APG # 14APG # 14

THAILAND – CAMBODIA

EGAT - EDCEGAT - EDC

16

15

APG # 15

THAILAND – MALAYSIA

EGAT – TNBEGAT – TNB

(Golok – Rantau Panjang)(Golok – Rantau Panjang)

APG # 16

EAST KALIMANTAN – SABAH

PLN – SESBPLN – SESB

(Balik Papan – Tawau)(Balik Papan – Tawau)

PROPOSED NEW INTERCONNECTIONPROPOSED NEW INTERCONNECTION

Thank you

Propose Refine StructureAppointment of APG Implementation Project Leaders

HAPUA COUNCIL & WC

Project Leader # 1EGAT

• Lao PDR - Vietnam • Cambodia - Lao PDR• Cambodia - Vietnam• Cambodia - Thailand• Myanmar - Thailand

Greater Mekong Sub-System A

• P.Malaysia - Thailand• P.Malaysia - Sumatra• P.Malaysia - Sarawak• Singapore - Bintan-Batam• Sumatra – Jawa

Subsystem B

• West Kalimantan - Sarawak• Sarawak - Brunei• Brunei - Sabah• Sabah - Philippines• Sabah – East Kalimantan

Trans Borneo Power Grid Interconnection Committee – Subsystem C

Advisory on APG - MOU Article III

• Technical – WG2• Financial – WG 6 • Taxation & Tariff – WG 5 • Regulatory & Legal Framework – WG 5 • Electric Power Trade – WG 2 & 5• 3rd Party Access – WG 5 & 6

APGCC

STAGE 1 – Physical Implementation• Financing• Technical HarmonizationSTAGE 2 - Bilateral• Taxation & Tariff• Regulatory & Legal Framework• Electric Power Trade (Bilateral)STAGE 3 – Multilateral• Electric Power Trade (Multilateral)• 3rd Party Access • Technical Harmonization (Multilateral)

Project Leader # 2TNB

Project Leader # 3PLN

Le Meridien, Jakarta 26 Feb 2009

Documents

Transcript of Le Meridien, Jakarta 26 Feb 2009