Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More...
Transcript of Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More...
![Page 1: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
1
‘‘ Late lessons from early warnings Late lessons from early warnings
the precautionary principle the precautionary principle
18961896--2000’2000’
David Gee, Emerging Issues and Scientific Liaison EEA Austrian Government EU Presidency Conference, Vienna
April 18-19 2006
The Role of Precaution in GMO PolicyThe Role of Precaution in GMO Policy
![Page 2: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
2
EEA’s main TasksEEA’s main Tasks
• To provide the Community and member countries with information needed to:
� identify, frame, prepare and implement sound and effective
environmental policy measures
� monitor, evaluate and disseminate actual and expected results
of such measures to clients and the public
• To establish and coordinate the European environment information and observation network (EIONET), for the collection, assessment and sharing of data with European Commission services, EEA member countries and international organisations.
![Page 3: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
3
“Precaution, whether or not described as a formal
‘principle’ has served mankind well in the past and the
history of public health instructs us to keep the spirit of
precaution alive and well”.
John Graham, Administrator, Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs, OMB,
Washington, in “Europe’s Precautionary Principle: promise and pitfalls”, J of Risk
Research, Vol 5, No 4, Oct 2002., P375.
Precaution is not a new idea
![Page 4: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
4
Key Features of ‘Knowing’ and not knowing:
1. ‘Knowing is contingent’: Today’s certainties can be tomorrow’s
mistakes
2. ‘Uncertainties’ due to ‘gaps in knowledge’, are different from..
3. ‘Ignorance’ where we don’t know what we don’t know, which is one
source of…
4. ‘Surprises’; which can also come from ‘mistaken knowledge’,
neglected/marginalised knowledge and gaps in knowledge.
5. Boundaries between ‘knowledge’, ‘no knowledge’ and ‘gaps in
knowledge’ are fuzzy and dynamic. As ‘knowledge’ expands…
6. More research can increase and decrease uncertainties and ignorance.
‘The more we know, the more we don’t know’ is common….
![Page 5: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
5
Towards A Clarification of Key TermsTowards A Clarification of Key Terms
Situation State and dates of
knowledge
Examples of action
Risk ‘Known’ impacts; ‘known’
probabilities e.g. asbestos
Prevention: action taken to reduce
known hazards e.g. eliminate exposure
to asbestos dust
Uncertainty ‘Known’ impacts; ‘unknown’
probabilities e.g. antibiotics in
animal feed and associated
human resistance to those
antibiotics
Precautionary prevention: action taken
to reduce exposure to potential hazards
Ignorance ‘Unknown’ impacts and
therefore ‘unknown’
probabilities eg the ‘surprises’ of
chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), pre
1974.
Precaution: action taken to anticipate,
identify and reduce the impact of
‘surprises’
Source: ‘Late Lessons’, page 192
![Page 6: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
6
Measuring is Measuring is not not the same as Knowing:the same as Knowing:
egeg The Marine Environment and the The Marine Environment and the
Precautionary PrinciplePrecautionary Principle
“The enormous number of papers in the marine environment means that huge amounts of data are available, but …we have reached a sort of plateau in …the understanding of what the information is telling us …. We… seem not to be able to do very much about it or with it. This is what led to the precautionary principle, after all – we do not know whether, in our studied ecosystem, a loss of diversity would matter, and it might”.
Marine Pollution Bulletin, Vol 34, No. 9, pp. 680-681, 1997
![Page 7: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
7
“The PP provides justification for public policy actions in
situations of scientific complexity, uncertainty and
ignorance - which we can assume to be more normal
than abnormal - where there may be a need to act in
order to avoid, or reduce, potentially serious or
irreversible threats to health or the environment, using
an appropriate level of scientific evidence, (which does
not need to be direct) and taking into account the likely
pros and cons of action or inaction. The systematic and
accountable consideration of alternatives is also an
essential component of rational precaution”
A definition of the PP based on “Late Lessons”
![Page 8: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
‘‘Late Lessons’ is based on case studiesLate Lessons’ is based on case studies
Structured around 4 questions:
• When were the first early warnings ?
• When and what were the main actions, or inactions, by society’s actors ?
• What were the costs and benefits (all kinds) of the actions/inactions; and
• What lessons can be drawn that may help improve decision- making and reduce overall costs ?
![Page 9: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
10
LateLate LessonsLessons: An : An AnalysisAnalysis ofof 14 ”False Negative” 14 ”False Negative”
Case StudiesCase Studies
”False Negatives” = Whoops! It really is dangerous after all!
(Citizens pay most of the costs of being wrong…..)
“False Positives” = Whoops! It really isn’t dangerous after all!
(Producers pay most of the costs of being wrong….)
![Page 10: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
12
Early warnings about TEL in petrolEarly warnings about TEL in petrol
• 1922 W.Clark,US Public Health Service: ”TEL is a serious menace to public health..on busy thoroughfares it is highly probable that the lead oxide dust will remain in the lower stratum”
• 1922 H.S. Cummings,US Surgeon General: ”since lead poisoning is of the cumulative type resulting from the daily intake of minute quantities,it seems pertinent to inquire whether there might not be a decided health hazard”.
• 1924 5 TEL production workers die of lead poisoning• 1925 Yandell Henderson, chair Medical Research Board,US
Aviation Service: ”it seems likely that the development of lead poisoning will come on so insidiously that leaded gasoline will be in nearly universal use…before the public and the government awaken to the situation”
over half a century before TEL was regulated
![Page 11: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
13
WhyWhy So So ManyMany ”False Negatives”?”False Negatives”?
• ”Sound science” generates more false negatives than false positives (= goodscience but poor public policy)
• Short term economic/political interests can dominate longer term, total welfare interests.
![Page 12: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
14
ON BEING WRONG: ON BEING WRONG: EnvironmentalEnvironmental and and HealthHealth SciencesSciences
and and TheirTheir DirectionsDirections ofof ErrorError
1 Some features can go either way (e.g.inapproriate controls) but most of the features mainly
err in the direction shown in the table
•False negative (Developmental/reproductive endpoints)
(continues � )
•High fertility strains
•False negative•Few Foetal-lifetime exposures
•False negative•Few exposures to mixturesLaboratory)
•False negative•Low genetic variability(Animal
•False negative•Short (in biological terms) range of doses
Studies
•False positive
•False negative
•High doses
•Small nos. of animals.
Experimental
MAIN1 DIRECTIONS OF ERROR-INCREASES CHANCES OF DETECTING A:
SOME METHODOLOGICAL FEATURES
SCIENTIFIC STUDIES
![Page 13: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
15
•False negative•Use of 5 % probability level to minimise chances of false positives
•False positive•Publication bias towards positivesBoth
•False negative•Scientific cultural pressure to avoid false positives
Experimental
And
•False negative•Low statistical power (e.g. From small studies)
Observation
Studies
•False negative•Simple models that do not reflect complexity
•so direct effects-inidcators only
•False negative•Lost cases
•False negative•Inadequate follow-upHumans)
•False negative•Non-differential exposure misclassification
(Wildlife &
•False positive/negative•Inappropriate controlsStudies
•False positive•ConfoundersObservation
![Page 14: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
16
What about ”False Positives”?
• Harder to prove
• Failed to find authors for them
• “Secondary Benefits” often make them worthwhile eg. Y2K “bug”
• Vol 2 of “Late Lessons” will have a “false Positive” chapter
![Page 15: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
17
Antimicrobial Feed Additives (AFA) Chapter Antimicrobial Feed Additives (AFA) Chapter –– An An
“Early Warning” example: “Early Warning” example:
1969 – UK Medical Research Council’s Swann Committee:
• ‘Despite the gaps in our knowledge .. We believe … on the basis of evidence presented to us, that this assessment is a sufficiently sound basis for action .. The cry for more research should not be allowed to hold up our recommendations’
• ‘Sales/use of AFA should be strictly controlled via tight criteria, despite not knowing mechanisms of action, nor foreseeing all effects’
• ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry than to feed diets containing AFA’
Source: (HMSO, UK, Nov. 1969)
![Page 16: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
18
“Benzene”
”...one of the lessons to be learned is that
consensus organisations in the process of
developing exposure limits for chemicals should
maintain distance from the producers of chemicals
and their ”consultants” when evaluating evidence
for the diseases of concern”.
Peter Infante, ”Late lessons from early warnings”
![Page 17: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
19
MTBE
”The key question on principle is: does persistency
alone, without indication of other adverse effects, give
reason to apply the precautionary principle? It seems
reasonable to conclude that systematic, comprehensive
and thorough investigations into all known possible
adverse effects should be exercised before any release
of large volumes of a persistent chemical into the
environment”.
Poul Harremous, ”Late lessons from early warnings”
![Page 18: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
20
PCBs
”By the 1930s there was already evidence, some at
a low level of proof, that PCBs could poison
people. This information was largely retained
within the industry, and does not appear to have
been widely circulated”.
”The application of the precautionary principle at
that time would have prevented the toxic legacy
that now exists”.
Janne Koppe, ”Late lessons from early warnings”
![Page 19: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
21
””TBT TBT AntifoulantsAntifoulants: A Tale : A Tale ofof ShipsShips, , SnailsSnails
and and ImposexImposex” (” (ChapterChapter 13)13)
• An increased appreciation of scientific complexity and indeterminacy accompanied the unfolding of the TBT impacts story.
• Very low doses caused adverse impacts (i.e. in parts/trillion)
• High exposure concentrations were found in unexpected places e.g. the marine microlayer
![Page 20: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
22
Endocrine Disrupting Substances (Endocrine Disrupting Substances (EDSsEDSs):):
Some difficult featuresSome difficult features
• Timing of the dose
• Mixtures and Multi- causality
• Natural and synthetic EDSs
• ”Hormonal imprinting”
• Endocrine systems ”cross- talk”
• Generational impacts
• Impacts/Adverse impacts
• Adverse impacts due to imbalance between opposing effects in complex systems – ie, ‘new’ forms of causality
• ie, deriving RA approach from familiar entities (chemicals here) may be misleading
![Page 21: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
23
Some problems with 2 of the main Bradford Hill “Criteria” Some problems with 2 of the main Bradford Hill “Criteria” for Distinguishing “Association” from “Causation”. (1965)for Distinguishing “Association” from “Causation”. (1965)
• "Consistency" (of research across studies)
• Not robust - can easily lead to false negatives because complexity, multi- causality, and genetic/host variability invites ‘inconsistency’.
• "Consistency in nature does not require that all, or even a majority of studies find the same effect. If all studies of lead showed the same relationship between variables, one would be startled, perhaps justifiably suspicious"(Needleman, 1995)
![Page 22: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
24
TwelveTwelve LateLate LessonsLessons fromfrom
EarlyEarly WarningsWarnings
A ”Identify/Clarify (’Test’) Framing and Assumptions
1. Manage “risk”, “uncertainty” - and conditions of “ignorance”
2. Identify/reduce “blind spots” (pluralist critique)
3. Assess/account for all pros and cons
4. Analyse/evaluate alternative options
5. Take account of stakeholder inputs – accountably!
6. Avoid “paralysis by analysis” by acting to reduce potential hazards via the precautionary principle.
![Page 23: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
25
(Twelve Late Lessons.... CONT(Twelve Late Lessons.... CONT.).)
B ”Broaden Assessment Information”
7. Identify/reduce interdisciplinary obstacles to learning – and reporting
8. Identify/reduce institutional obstacles to learning – and reporting
9. Take account of salient non- scientific knowledge
10.Identify/anticipate “real world” conditions
11.Ensure regulatory and informational independence – and accountability/transparency
12.Long term monitoring/research
![Page 24: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
26
How Can We Respond toHow Can We Respond to
“Ignorance” (“Surprises”)?“Ignorance” (“Surprises”)?
1. Use intrinsic parameters as proxies for unknown but possible impacts (e.g. persistence and/or bioaccumulation potential of chemical substances. (See Case Studies on PCBs, MTBE, CFCs, TBT)
2. Develop means to assess quality/maturity of basic scientific knowledge on which innovation in Q is founded
3. be as inclusive as possible about potential knowledge-inputs: even if this takes time
4. Reduce specific exposures to potentially harmful agents on the basis of credible ‘Early Warnings’ of initial harmful impacts (thus limiting the size of any other ‘surprise’ impacts from the same agent, e.g. the asbestos cancers following asbestosis; PCB neurotoxicological effects following wildlife impacts). (See 5 other responses to “ignorance” in “Late Lessons” supplementary report, EEA 2004)
5. Promote a diversity of robust and adaptable technological and social options to meet needs (which limits technological ‘monopolies’ such as asbestos, CFCs, PCBs etc., and therefore reduces the scale of any ‘surprise’).
![Page 25: Late lessons from early warnings the precautionary ... A Clarification of Key Terms ... • ‘More rewarding to improve animal husbandry ... husbandry and antimicrobials or GM Lesson](https://reader034.fdocuments.in/reader034/viewer/2022050714/5abf2f1a7f8b9add5f8d723d/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
27
• Avoid Substance ‘monopolies’ that stifle innovation (seeAsbestos, CFCs, PCBs, AFA)
• Stimulate available alternatives (see antimicrobials, asbestos, radiation, CFCs)
(The principle of substitution, now part of OSPAR’sStrategy on Hazardous Substances requires a comparative assessment of alternative means of providing services; as does the EU Biocides Directive)
• But use precaution, eco-efficiency and diversity with substitutes, too
• And don’t assume only technical fixes – e.g. animal husbandry and antimicrobials or GM
Lesson 4: Evaluate alternative means
of providing services