Laser Gas Detection increases Safety and …€¦ · Laser Gas Detection increases Safety and...
Transcript of Laser Gas Detection increases Safety and …€¦ · Laser Gas Detection increases Safety and...
Laser Gas Detection increases Safety and Environmental Performance in Fertilizer Plants
• Hamish Adam
• President & CEO
• Boreal Laser Inc.
Organization logo to appear here
Outline
• Introduction to Laser Gas Detection
– Basic concepts
– Portable systems
– Multiple path fixed installations
– Point sensor
• Laser benefits for leak detection and tracking
• Fertiliser industry examples – Ammonia and Urea production
– HF monitoring in phosphate plants
– Monitoring NH3 from fertiliser application
• Conclusions
Organization logo to appear here
Boreal Laser overview
• Based in Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
• Manufacturer of laser based gas detectors since 1996 – Products use Single-line absorption spectroscopy in NIR with Wavelength
Modulation Spectroscopy / Direct Absorption
• 2000 – transitioned from research to commercial sales
• 2013 – 5 distinct “GasFinder” product lines – world-leading supplier of open-path laser gas detection systems for safety and
environmental applications.
– Installations in over 40 countries worldwide
– >600 GasFinder systems shipped (>1200 measurement paths)
– Reputation based on product reliability and technical support
– Commitment to providing factory-trained local sales and service
Organization logo to appear here
How Portable GasFinder2 measures trace gases in the air
Organization logo to appear here
• GasFinder emits a laser beam that is absorbed only by Trace Gas of interest (eg NH3)
• The Reflector Array returns the laser beam to the GasFinder
• Electronics and software in the GasFinder analyze the resulting photodiode signal using Wavelength Modulation Spectroscopy.
• The result is the average concentration of the Trace Gas in the measurement path
• The measurement path can be up to 500m long (1000m for select gases)
GasFinder2
Ambient air being measured by the GasFinder
Up to 1000m Retro-reflector
Laser-Based Gas Detection Organization logo to
appear here
Major benefits of single-line laser absorption spectroscopy are:
• High resolution, excellent selectivity
• Minimum interference from other gases (especially H2O, CO2)
• No consumables, minimum maintenance
• Diode lasers were developed for telecom industry and have >15 year lifetime
Typical values:
NH3 line width – 0.02 nm
Laser line width – 0.0002 nm
Laser tuning range – 0.2 nm
Portable GasFinder2 – main components Organization logo to
appear here
Reference cell contains stable sample of target gas, known concentration
Laser beam redirected through reference cell for 0.25 seconds every 10 seconds
No need for in-path validations with bottled gases and calibration tubes
All GasFinders calibrated against NIST traceable permeation tubes.
Signal Processing
and Display
Laser Diode
Aiming Laser
Control Electronics
Detector
Detector
Calibration Reference Cell
Remote Retro-Reflector
Sighting Scope
Computer
The aiming laser, used to aid alignment, emits a highly visible red light
Gas-measuring laser light emitted by the laser diode is invisible — in the near infrared (about 1500 nm)
GasFinderMC – multi path system for fixed installation gas detection
Organization logo to appear here
Signal Processing
and Display
Laser Diode
Detector
Calibration Reference Cell
Aiming Scope
Computer
Mu
ltip
lexe
r
Control Electronics
Remote Head Retro- Reflector
Duct Sensor
Key
pa
d
GasFinderPT – laser gas point detector Organization logo to
appear here
• Available for HF – NH3 soon
• 20 cm open path essentially a “point” measurement
• 3 analog, 3 digital outputs and local display
• Operates from -40 C to +50 C
• Developed in conjunction with ExxonMobil
• Provides precise ppm reading for personnel protection and accurate plume modeling
Laser gas monitoring benefits
Laser Open Path and Point Detectors
• Gas-specific: No false alarms
• Area coverage with open path: More reliable leak detection
• One second response: More time to react
• Optical absorption technique: No poisoning, no “memory” effects
• Laser light not absorbed by water vapor: Enables long paths — 500m or greater
• Reliable unattended performance in all climate conditions
• No consumables, no moving parts: Minimal maintenance, reduction in O&M need
Organization logo to appear here
Traditional Point Sensors
• Cross sensitive to other gases: False alarms possible
• Relatively slow to respond: Typical T50 rating of 25 seconds
• Poisoned by exposure to NH3: exhibits memory effects
• Some sensors only rated to -10 C: don’t work outside in winter in many places
• Maintenance Intensive: calibration, test gas, replacement heads required.
• Large Operating and Maintenance (O&M) cost: e.g. array of 30 point sensors in cool, damp northern latitude estimated $100,000 in maintenance costs per annum PLUS 1 – 2 man hours per sensor per month
Scanning portable configuration for emissions flux monitoring
Organization logo to appear here
• Laser detector on scanner measures Path Integrated Concentration (PIC) over multiple paths in succession
• Combine PIC data with meteorological data
• Wind data most important. 3D ultrasonic best
• Analyze data with available algorithms to:
• Create concentration profiles which locate hotspots.
• Provide emissions flux estimates
• Calculate emission source strength
Source Wind
Direction
Ground measured retro-reflectors
IR beam executing a single "monitoring event"
(5 events make up a complete "plume traverse")
Retro-reflectors mounted
above the ground
Laser detector mounted on scanner 360˚ pan movement, 120˚ tilt movement Wireless control
Leak detection and plume mapping with SAFER Real-Time®
Organization logo to appear here
Combine BOREAL open path
laser detectors with SAFER
Real-Time® to simplify early
detection, monitoring and
tracking of an ammonia (NH3)
release.
BOREAL sensors integrate
with SAFER’s patented “Open
Path ABC” (Advanced Back
Calculation) release rate
estimation algorithm to alert
plant operators of any loss of
containment and help
quantify, predict and plot the
downwind impact at the
fence-line and beyond.
Process unit leak detection – monthly log Organization logo to
appear here
Continuous monitoring on 4 independent paths surrounding a process unit over a 1-month period
Note daily spikes resulting from process sampling
Fertiliser industry examples
• Current experience is with NH3 and HF monitoring
Reactive gases, difficult to monitor continuously with traditional methods.
Laser sensitivity and range well suited to accurate and quick detection at typical alarm levels:
HF: 3 – 10 ppm NH3: 30 – 100 ppm.
• Ammonia and Urea Production - most experience
Typical NH3 monitoring installations are 2- to 6-path
NH3 compressor leak monitoring
Perimeter monitoring at NH3 storage facilities
NH3 railcar loading/unloading
NH3 Distribution terminals
Urea prilling tower emissions
• HF monitoring in phosphate plants – a few installations
• Monitoring fugitive NH3 emissions from fertiliser application in agriculture
Organization logo to appear here
Ammonia and Urea Production – Risks & Incidents
• 550 NH3 plants worldwide 200 million tonnes of NH3 every year.
• 83% of NH3 production used in fertilizers
• greatest use in urea manufacture (500 plants worldwide).
• Large amounts of NH3 produced, transported and consumed worldwide
• Considerable potential for accidents
• NH3 is a stable and non-flammable gas but is toxic and dangerous to humans.
• Exposure to high concentrations of gaseous NH3 can result in lung damage and death.
Organization logo to appear here
Odour threshold OSHA 15-minute OSHA 8-hour NIOSH IDLH
5 ppm 35 ppm 25 ppm 300 ppm
IDLH (Immediately Dangerous to Life and Health) is the level to which a healthy
worker can be exposed for 30 minutes without suffering irreversible health effects.
Potential sources of NH3 leaks in NH3 and Urea production
• High pressure NH3 pumps and compressors
• Refrigeration compressors which recirculates NH3 coolant
Ambient levels are typically between 18 – 25 ppm because of bleed past seals.
• NH3 storage facilities and Trans-shipment Terminals
loading and unloading operations provide multiple opportunities for
accidental releases of NH3.
• Urea plants have several continuous and discontinuous NH3 emission
sources.
High pressure ammonia pump at the base of the urea tower
Piping, valves and safety rupture disks
Prilling towers
Organization logo to appear here
NH3 compressor room monitoring Organization logo to
appear here
Path on left is 20 cm (blue trace) Path on right is 25m (red trace)
Note: NH3 spike to 98 ppm during filter change
Perimeter NH3 leak detection Organization logo to
appear here
Perimeter detection at NH3 storage area (L) and plant boundary (R)
NH3 storage tank monitoring Organization logo to
appear here
Temporary monitoring with GasFinder2 Permanent monitoring with GasFinderMC
Fence-line NH3 monitoring Organization logo to
appear here
Path averaged NH3 concentrations on a 320m path along a boundary near a cold ammonia storage tank and flare
Urea tower NH3 emissions monitoring Organization logo to
appear here
NH3 monitoring at top of prilling tower with 2m open path measurement. Note persistent mist – and high NH3 levels!
Retro-reflector
Open Path head
Ureaknowhow.com incident database
• Describes more than thirty incidents in urea plants and ammonia pipelines.
• 80% are related to failures in high pressure equipment and high pressure piping systems.
• These incidents led to at least 40 fatalities and 80 additional injuries.
• Early detection of ammonia leaks is vital to
– give operators precious time to reach personal protection equipment
– limit the area where ammonia vapours can cause problems and
– shut off combustion sources.
• Improved ammonia leak detection will lead to a safer industry with fewer casualties and injuries.
Organization logo to appear here
HF fugitive emissions from a phosphogypsum pile
Organization logo to appear here
0.0
20.0
40.0
60.0
80.0
100.0
120.0
140.0
160.0
08:0
8:30
08:5
1:36
09:3
3:52
10:1
4:04
10:5
4:10
11:3
4:18
12:1
4:24
12:5
4:32
13:3
4:42
14:1
4:56
14:5
5:38
17:0
4:12
17:4
4:36
18:2
5:00
19:0
5:30
19:4
6:10
20:2
6:44
21:0
7:24
21:4
8:10
22:2
8:50
23:0
9:32
23:5
0:22
00:3
1:14
01:1
2:06
01:5
3:00
02:3
3:58
03:1
4:58
03:5
5:58
04:3
6:58
05:1
8:02
05:5
9:06
06:4
0:06
Time
ug F
/m3
FTIR HF data FTIR SiF4 data Laser HF data
NH3 flux monitoring from farms Organization logo to
appear here
Conclusions
• Laser gas detectors have distinct benefits for leak detection and environmental monitoring
Lack of cross interferences – hence no false alarms
Fast response
Wide measurement range
Reliable operation in all climate conditions
Not poisoned or taken off-line when NH3 detected during maintenance
No moving parts and no consumables reduces cost of ownership
• Several applications have been successfully demonstrated in the fertilizer industry
Especially for reactive gases such as NH3 and HF
Early detection, monitoring and tracking of NH3 releases is simplified by combining laser gas detection with release rate algorithms such as SAFER Real-Time®
Organization logo to appear here