LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police...
Transcript of LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police...
![Page 1: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
LABOR RELATIONSLABOR RELATIONS
Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins
General Counsel
Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins
General CounselGeneral Counsel
Mass Chiefs of Police Assn
General Counsel
Mass Chiefs of Police Assn
![Page 2: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
LABOR RELATIONSLABOR RELATIONSLABOR RELATIONSLABOR RELATIONS
![Page 3: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
DEALING DIRECTLY WITHEMPLOYEES
DEALING DIRECTLY WITHEMPLOYEES
• DON’T BY-PASS UNION• DON’T BY-PASS UNION• DON’T BY-PASS UNION
• MANDATORY BARGAINING
• DON’T BY-PASS UNION
• MANDATORY BARGAINING
![Page 4: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
OKAY IF NOT BARGAININGRELATED
OKAY IF NOT BARGAININGRELATED
• SICK LEAVE SURVEY ILLEGAL• SICK LEAVE SURVEY ILLEGAL• SICK LEAVE SURVEY ILLEGAL• SICK LEAVE SURVEY ILLEGAL
![Page 5: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
MOTIVATION IRRELEVANTMOTIVATION IRRELEVANT
• PURPOSE OR EFFECT COUNTS• PURPOSE OR EFFECT COUNTS• PURPOSE OR EFFECT COUNTS• PURPOSE OR EFFECT COUNTS
![Page 6: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
IMPORTANT POLICYEXCEPTION?
IMPORTANT POLICYEXCEPTION?
• NOT LIKE ONE-OFFICER VEHICLES• NOT LIKE ONE-OFFICER VEHICLES• NOT LIKE ONE-OFFICER VEHICLES
• IMPACT REQUIRED BARGAINING
• NOT LIKE ONE-OFFICER VEHICLES
• IMPACT REQUIRED BARGAINING
![Page 7: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
WAIVER?WAIVER?
• FAIT ACCOMPLI• FAIT ACCOMPLI• FAIT ACCOMPLI
• SHORT TIME TO BID FOR SHIFTS
• BID VS. IMPLEMENTATION DATE?
– JANUARY 19 IMPLEMENTATION
– JANUARY 9 BID DATE
• FAIT ACCOMPLI
• SHORT TIME TO BID FOR SHIFTS
• BID VS. IMPLEMENTATION DATE?
– JANUARY 19 IMPLEMENTATION
– JANUARY 9 BID DATE– JANUARY 9 BID DATE– JANUARY 9 BID DATE
![Page 8: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
OPERATIONAL ANDEMERGENCY DECISION-
MAKING
OPERATIONAL ANDEMERGENCY DECISION-
MAKINGMAKINGMAKING
![Page 9: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
EMERGENCY EXCEPTION?EMERGENCY EXCEPTION?
• NOT (M)ANY CASES• NOT (M)ANY CASES• NOT (M)ANY CASES• NOT (M)ANY CASES
![Page 10: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
AFFECTING EMPLOYMENTCONDITIONS
AFFECTING EMPLOYMENTCONDITIONS
• NOTICE• NOTICE• NOTICE
• OPPORTUNITY TO REQUESTBARGAINING
• GOOD FAITH NEGOTIATIONS
• AGREEMENT OR IMPASSE
• NOTICE
• OPPORTUNITY TO REQUESTBARGAINING
• GOOD FAITH NEGOTIATIONS
• AGREEMENT OR IMPASSE• AGREEMENT OR IMPASSE• AGREEMENT OR IMPASSE
![Page 11: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
HOW TO ANALYZE WHAT’SREQUIRED
HOW TO ANALYZE WHAT’SREQUIRED
• CHECK CONTRACT• CHECK CONTRACT• CHECK CONTRACT
• IF NOT (AND NO “ZIPPER CLAUSE”)
– TIMELY REQUEST?
• CHECK CONTRACT
• IF NOT (AND NO “ZIPPER CLAUSE”)
– TIMELY REQUEST?
![Page 12: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
NOTIFY “UNION”NOTIFY “UNION”
• PROPOSED CHANGES• PROPOSED CHANGES• PROPOSED CHANGES
• GRIEVANCE HEARINGS
– WEINGARTEN RIGHTS
– ATTORNEY IF SENT
– LIMIT #?
• PROPOSED CHANGES
• GRIEVANCE HEARINGS
– WEINGARTEN RIGHTS
– ATTORNEY IF SENT
– LIMIT #?– LIMIT #?– LIMIT #?
![Page 13: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
HIRING AND CREATINGPOSITION
HIRING AND CREATINGPOSITION
• NOT “CONDITIONS FOR HIRE”• NOT “CONDITIONS FOR HIRE”• NOT “CONDITIONS FOR HIRE”
– DRUG/ALCOHOL TESTING
– RESIDENCY
• DON’T TRANSFER B.U. WORK
• DON’T’ CARRY OVER INTO
• NOT “CONDITIONS FOR HIRE”
– DRUG/ALCOHOL TESTING
– RESIDENCY
• DON’T TRANSFER B.U. WORK
• DON’T’ CARRY OVER INTO• DON’T’ CARRY OVER INTOEMPLOYMENT
• DON’T’ CARRY OVER INTOEMPLOYMENT
![Page 14: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
CONDITION OF CONTINUEDEMPLOYMENT
CONDITION OF CONTINUEDEMPLOYMENT
• PSYCHOLOGICAL TESTING• PSYCHOLOGICAL TESTING• PSYCHOLOGICAL TESTING
– RESULTS KNOWN AFTER START WORK
• PSYCHOLOGICAL TESTING
– RESULTS KNOWN AFTER START WORK
![Page 15: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
CREATE VS. ELIMINATE?CREATE VS. ELIMINATE?
• OKAY TO CREATE NEW POSITION• OKAY TO CREATE NEW POSITION• OKAY TO CREATE NEW POSITION
• OK TO SET HIRING CRITERIA
• DON’T EVADE UNION
– ELIMINATE B.U. POSITION
– CREATE NON-B.U. POSITION
• OKAY TO CREATE NEW POSITION
• OK TO SET HIRING CRITERIA
• DON’T EVADE UNION
– ELIMINATE B.U. POSITION
– CREATE NON-B.U. POSITION– CREATE NON-B.U. POSITION– CREATE NON-B.U. POSITION
![Page 16: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
• EVALUATE CANDIDATE FULLY• EVALUATE CANDIDATE FULLY• EVALUATE CANDIDATE FULLY
• DON’T HIRE PREMATURELY
• ADA ISSUES– CONDITIONAL OFFERS OF
EMPLOYMENT• MEDICAL/PSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMS
• EVALUATE CANDIDATE FULLY
• DON’T HIRE PREMATURELY
• ADA ISSUES– CONDITIONAL OFFERS OF
EMPLOYMENT• MEDICAL/PSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMS• MEDICAL/PSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMS
• UNION MAY CONSENT TO OTHER“CONDITIONAL” HIRING
• MEDICAL/PSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMS
• UNION MAY CONSENT TO OTHER“CONDITIONAL” HIRING
![Page 17: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
WAIVERSWAIVERS
• INACTION• INACTION• INACTION
• CONTRACTUAL
• INACTION
• CONTRACTUAL
![Page 18: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
WAIVER BY INACTIONWAIVER BY INACTION
• ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE• ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE• ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE
• OPPORTUNITY TO NEGOTIATE
• UNREASONABLY OR INEXPLICABLYFAILED TO REQUEST OR BARGAIN
• BURDEN ON EMPLOYER
• ACTUAL KNOWLEDGE
• OPPORTUNITY TO NEGOTIATE
• UNREASONABLY OR INEXPLICABLYFAILED TO REQUEST OR BARGAIN
• BURDEN ON EMPLOYER• BURDEN ON EMPLOYER
• NON INFERRED W/O “CLEAR ANDUNMISTAKABLE” SHOWING
• BURDEN ON EMPLOYER
• NON INFERRED W/O “CLEAR ANDUNMISTAKABLE” SHOWING
![Page 19: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
NOTICENOTICE
• PROVIDE TO “UNION”• PROVIDE TO “UNION”• PROVIDE TO “UNION”
• IMMEDIATE NOTREQUIRED
• PROVIDE DEADLINE
• PROVIDE TO “UNION”
• IMMEDIATE NOTREQUIRED
• PROVIDE DEADLINE
![Page 20: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
COVERED/BARRED BYCONTRACT?
COVERED/BARRED BYCONTRACT?
• NOT IF COVERED• NOT IF COVERED• NOT IF COVERED
• CONSCIOUSLY
– EXPLORED AND
– YIELDED
• NOT IF COVERED
• CONSCIOUSLY
– EXPLORED AND
– YIELDED
![Page 21: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
FAIT ACCOMPLIFAIT ACCOMPLI
• DEMAND TO BARGAIN “FRUITLESS”?• DEMAND TO BARGAIN “FRUITLESS”?• DEMAND TO BARGAIN “FRUITLESS”?
• NEVER SAY, “EFFECTIVEIMMEDIATELY”
• DEMAND TO BARGAIN “FRUITLESS”?
• NEVER SAY, “EFFECTIVEIMMEDIATELY”
![Page 22: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
WAIVER BY CONTRACTWAIVER BY CONTRACT
• CLEAR LANGUAGE• CLEAR LANGUAGE• CLEAR LANGUAGE
• BURDEN ON EMPLOYER
• NOT BROAD GENERALMANAGEMENT RIGHTS CLAUSE
• AMBIGUOUS LANGUAGE?
• CLEAR LANGUAGE
• BURDEN ON EMPLOYER
• NOT BROAD GENERALMANAGEMENT RIGHTS CLAUSE
• AMBIGUOUS LANGUAGE?• AMBIGUOUS LANGUAGE?
– REVIEW BARGAINING HISTORY
• AMBIGUOUS LANGUAGE?
– REVIEW BARGAINING HISTORY
![Page 23: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
WORKPLACE RULES ANDPRACTICES
WORKPLACE RULES ANDPRACTICES
• OK TO CHANGE• OK TO CHANGE• OK TO CHANGE
– NOTICE, OPPORTUNITY, ETC.
• MORE THAN PROCEDURAL
• OK TO REWORD EXISTINGPRACTICE
• OK TO CHANGE
– NOTICE, OPPORTUNITY, ETC.
• MORE THAN PROCEDURAL
• OK TO REWORD EXISTINGPRACTICEPRACTICEPRACTICE
![Page 24: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
HOURSHOURS
• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT
• ELIMINATING TARDY “GRACE” PERIOD
• CHANGING LUNCH HOURS
• ELIMINATING “FLEX-TIME”
• CHANGE WHEN REPORT TO COURT
• CHANGE SHIFT SWAP POLICY
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
• ELIMINATING TARDY “GRACE” PERIOD
• CHANGING LUNCH HOURS
• ELIMINATING “FLEX-TIME”
• CHANGE WHEN REPORT TO COURT
• CHANGE SHIFT SWAP POLICY• CHANGE SHIFT SWAP POLICY
• LENGTH OF WORK DAY OR WEEK
• NOT TIME CLOCK W/O OTHER CHANGE
• OK TO “VIDEO SURVEY”
• CHANGE SHIFT SWAP POLICY
• LENGTH OF WORK DAY OR WEEK
• NOT TIME CLOCK W/O OTHER CHANGE
• OK TO “VIDEO SURVEY”
![Page 25: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
• KEEP FLSA IN MIND• KEEP FLSA IN MIND• KEEP FLSA IN MIND
• DON’T SPECIFY SHIFT TIMES INCONTRACT
– “USUAL”
– “CUSTOMARY”
• KEEP FLSA IN MIND
• DON’T SPECIFY SHIFT TIMES INCONTRACT
– “USUAL”
– “CUSTOMARY”– “CUSTOMARY”
– “TYPICAL”
• SPECIFY HOW TO CHANGE
– “CUSTOMARY”
– “TYPICAL”
• SPECIFY HOW TO CHANGE
![Page 26: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
OVERTIME AND PAIDDETAILS
OVERTIME AND PAIDDETAILS
• ONLY “REGULARLY SCHEDULED OT” IS• ONLY “REGULARLY SCHEDULED OT” IS• ONLY “REGULARLY SCHEDULED OT” ISMANDATORY SUBJECT
• REDUCE MINIMUM STAFFING PRACTICE
– #F.F. ON ENGINES/LADDERS AT STATIONS
• DON’T CHANGE COMP TIME W/O NOTICE& OPPORTUNITY TO BARGAIN
• ONLY “REGULARLY SCHEDULED OT” ISMANDATORY SUBJECT
• REDUCE MINIMUM STAFFING PRACTICE
– #F.F. ON ENGINES/LADDERS AT STATIONS
• DON’T CHANGE COMP TIME W/O NOTICE& OPPORTUNITY TO BARGAIN& OPPORTUNITY TO BARGAIN& OPPORTUNITY TO BARGAIN
![Page 27: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
PAID DETAILSPAID DETAILS
• MANDATORY• MANDATORY• MANDATORY
• OK TO PRIORITIZE
– IF PAST PRACTICE – NOBARGAINING REQUIRED
• SEPARATE UNION
• MANDATORY
• OK TO PRIORITIZE
– IF PAST PRACTICE – NOBARGAINING REQUIRED
• SEPARATE UNION• SEPARATE UNIONPROBLEMS
– SUPERVISORY EXCLUDED?
• SEPARATE UNIONPROBLEMS
– SUPERVISORY EXCLUDED?
![Page 28: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
WORK SHIFTS ANDSCHEDULES
WORK SHIFTS ANDSCHEDULES
• NEW SHIFT REQUIRES NOTICE ETC.• NEW SHIFT REQUIRES NOTICE ETC.• NEW SHIFT REQUIRES NOTICE ETC.
• SAME IF ELIMINATE SHIFT ORCOVERAGE
• OKAY TO CHANGE INDIVIDUAL’SSCHEDULE
– W/O UNION NOTICE UNLESS PRACTICE
• NEW SHIFT REQUIRES NOTICE ETC.
• SAME IF ELIMINATE SHIFT ORCOVERAGE
• OKAY TO CHANGE INDIVIDUAL’SSCHEDULE
– W/O UNION NOTICE UNLESS PRACTICE– W/O UNION NOTICE UNLESS PRACTICE
• REQUIRING TEACHERS TO TEACH EXTRAPERIOD W/O PAY
– MOST INVOLVE UNION
– W/O UNION NOTICE UNLESS PRACTICE
• REQUIRING TEACHERS TO TEACH EXTRAPERIOD W/O PAY
– MOST INVOLVE UNION
![Page 29: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
JOB DESCRIPTIONS ANDWORK ASSIGNMENTS
JOB DESCRIPTIONS ANDWORK ASSIGNMENTS
• BARGAIN BEFORE CHANGING JOB• BARGAIN BEFORE CHANGING JOB• BARGAIN BEFORE CHANGING JOBDESCRIPTION– EXCEPT DE MINIMIS
• ASSIGNMENT IS MANAGEMENT RIGHT
• BOSTON COMMISSIONER (BEFORE 1999AMENDMENT)
• BARGAIN BEFORE CHANGING JOBDESCRIPTION– EXCEPT DE MINIMIS
• ASSIGNMENT IS MANAGEMENT RIGHT
• BOSTON COMMISSIONER (BEFORE 1999AMENDMENT)– APPOINT & PROMOTE
– SUPERCEDED CONTRACT
– BARGAINING PROCEDURES ONLY
– APPOINT & PROMOTE
– SUPERCEDED CONTRACT
– BARGAINING PROCEDURES ONLY
![Page 30: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
PROMOTIONPROMOTION• BARGAIN IF
– TO UNIT POSITION
• BARGAIN IF– TO UNIT POSITION– TO UNIT POSITION
– TO NON-UNION POSITION
– SO LONG AS PAST PRACTICE ORCONTRACT CLAUSE APPLIES
– OKAY TO CONTINUE PAST PRACTICE,EVEN IF NOT FORMAL
– TO UNIT POSITION
– TO NON-UNION POSITION
– SO LONG AS PAST PRACTICE ORCONTRACT CLAUSE APPLIES
– OKAY TO CONTINUE PAST PRACTICE,EVEN IF NOT FORMALEVEN IF NOT FORMAL
– PROVIDE REASONS ON REQUEST
– BARGAINING ELIMINATION OFPOSITION
EVEN IF NOT FORMAL
– PROVIDE REASONS ON REQUEST
– BARGAINING ELIMINATION OFPOSITION
![Page 31: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
RECOMMENDATIONRECOMMENDATION
• REJECT SENIORITY CRITERIA• REJECT SENIORITY CRITERIA• REJECT SENIORITY CRITERIAPROPOSALS
• PROVIDE NOTICE OF AVAILABLEPOSITIONS
• ASSESSMENT CENTERS
• REJECT SENIORITY CRITERIAPROPOSALS
• PROVIDE NOTICE OF AVAILABLEPOSITIONS
• ASSESSMENT CENTERS• ASSESSMENT CENTERS“BULLETPROOF”
• ASSESSMENT CENTERS“BULLETPROOF”
![Page 32: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
DRESS AND GROOMINGDRESS AND GROOMING
• CONSTITUTIONAL• CONSTITUTIONAL• CONSTITUTIONALRULES
– FED & STATE
• NOT ARBITRARY ORIRRATIONAL
• CONSTITUTIONALRULES
– FED & STATE
• NOT ARBITRARY ORIRRATIONALIRRATIONALIRRATIONAL
![Page 33: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
MANDATORY SUBJECTSMANDATORY SUBJECTS
• NOTICE & OPPORTUNITY BEFORE• NOTICE & OPPORTUNITY BEFORE• NOTICE & OPPORTUNITY BEFOREMAKING CHANGE
• GROOMING & UNION PINS SAME
– TATTOO’S, BEARDS, HAIR COLORING,ETC.
• NOTICE & OPPORTUNITY BEFOREMAKING CHANGE
• GROOMING & UNION PINS SAME
– TATTOO’S, BEARDS, HAIR COLORING,ETC.
![Page 34: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
• RULES – OK• RULES – OK• RULES – OK
• CHANGES – OK
• UNWRITTEN RULES – OK
• GIVE OPPORTUNITY TO COMPLYBEFORE ENFORCING
• RULES – OK
• CHANGES – OK
• UNWRITTEN RULES – OK
• GIVE OPPORTUNITY TO COMPLYBEFORE ENFORCINGBEFORE ENFORCINGBEFORE ENFORCING
![Page 35: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
RESIDENCYREQUIREMENTS
RESIDENCYREQUIREMENTS
• CONSTITUTIONAL• CONSTITUTIONAL• CONSTITUTIONAL
• CAN’T MOVE OUT OF TOWN
• CONSTITUTIONAL
• CAN’T MOVE OUT OF TOWN
![Page 36: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
• USE COMMON SENSE• USE COMMON SENSE• USE COMMON SENSE
• AVOID DISCIPLINE
• REFUSE “BID” NEGOTIATIONREQUESTS
• USE COMMON SENSE
• AVOID DISCIPLINE
• REFUSE “BID” NEGOTIATIONREQUESTS
![Page 37: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
WEAPONSWEAPONS
• MANAGEMENT RIGHT• MANAGEMENT RIGHT• MANAGEMENT RIGHT
– DON’T JEOPARDIZESAFETY
• BARGAIN CHANGES
• “BARRED”
• MANAGEMENT RIGHT
– DON’T JEOPARDIZESAFETY
• BARGAIN CHANGES
• “BARRED”• “BARRED”FEDERALLY/STATE
• “BARRED”FEDERALLY/STATE
![Page 38: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/38.jpg)
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
• DOMESTIC• DOMESTIC• DOMESTICVIOLENCE ISSUES
• DON’T ALLOW“CARRY ON BADGE”
• CLARIFY JOB
• DOMESTICVIOLENCE ISSUES
• DON’T ALLOW“CARRY ON BADGE”
• CLARIFY JOB• CLARIFY JOBDESCRIPTION
• CLARIFY JOBDESCRIPTION
![Page 39: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/39.jpg)
OFF-DUTY EMPLOYMENTOFF-DUTY EMPLOYMENT
• OK TO REGULATE• OK TO REGULATE• OK TO REGULATE
– BAN
– APPROVAL
– NOTICE
• OK TO REGULATE
– BAN
– APPROVAL
– NOTICE
![Page 40: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/40.jpg)
NON-SMOKING RULENON-SMOKING RULE
• BANNING IN WORKPLACE• BANNING IN WORKPLACE• BANNING IN WORKPLACE
– MUST BARGAIN
– NO PUBLIC HEALTHHAZARD EXCEPTION
• APPLICABLE STATE
• BANNING IN WORKPLACE
– MUST BARGAIN
– NO PUBLIC HEALTHHAZARD EXCEPTION
• APPLICABLE STATELAW?LAW?
![Page 41: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/41.jpg)
VACATIONSVACATIONS
• MANDATORY• MANDATORY• MANDATORY
• RARELY A CASE
– CONTRACT COVERS
– ARBITRATION HANDLES
• MANDATORY
• RARELY A CASE
– CONTRACT COVERS
– ARBITRATION HANDLES
![Page 42: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/42.jpg)
SEXUAL HARASSMENTPOLICY
SEXUAL HARASSMENTPOLICY
• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT
– IMPACT
• EVEN THOUGH STATE LAW
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
– IMPACT
• EVEN THOUGH STATE LAW
![Page 43: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/43.jpg)
SHIFT SWAPSSHIFT SWAPS
• CRITERIA IS• CRITERIA IS• CRITERIA ISMANDATORY SUBJECT
• WANT EMT-I ON ALLSHIFTS ?
– BARGAIN IMPACT
• CRITERIA ISMANDATORY SUBJECT
• WANT EMT-I ON ALLSHIFTS ?
– BARGAIN IMPACT– BARGAIN IMPACT– BARGAIN IMPACT
![Page 44: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/44.jpg)
DOMESTIC VIOLENCEPOLICY
DOMESTIC VIOLENCEPOLICY
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
• REPORTINGREQUIREMENT
• DISCIPLINE
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
• REPORTINGREQUIREMENT
• DISCIPLINE• DISCIPLINE
• PROMOTIONCONSIDERATION
• DISCIPLINE
• PROMOTIONCONSIDERATION
![Page 45: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/45.jpg)
RADIO PROCEDURESRADIO PROCEDURES
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
– STANDARDS OFPERFORMANCE
– CONDITION OF
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
– STANDARDS OFPERFORMANCE
– CONDITION OFCONTINUEDEMPLOYMENTCONTINUEDEMPLOYMENT
![Page 46: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/46.jpg)
WAGESWAGES
• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT– EVEN ENTRY-LEVEL
• CHANGING PAYMENT SCHEDULE– BI-WEEKLY, ETC.
• PARITY CLAUSES ILLEGAL
• PENSIONS, SEVERANCE PAY,
• MANDATORY SUBJECT– EVEN ENTRY-LEVEL
• CHANGING PAYMENT SCHEDULE– BI-WEEKLY, ETC.
• PARITY CLAUSES ILLEGAL
• PENSIONS, SEVERANCE PAY,• PENSIONS, SEVERANCE PAY,INSURANCE, AND EDUCATIONINCENTIVES ARE ALL “WAGES”
• PENSIONS, SEVERANCE PAY,INSURANCE, AND EDUCATIONINCENTIVES ARE ALL “WAGES”
![Page 47: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/47.jpg)
MEAL AND COFFEEBREAKS
MEAL AND COFFEEBREAKS
• FLSA REQUIRES PAY FOR BREAKS• FLSA REQUIRES PAY FOR BREAKS• FLSA REQUIRES PAY FOR BREAKS
– UNLESS 30 MIN W/O DUTIES
• CAN’T WAIVE OR BARGAIN AWAY
• OK TO RESCHEDULE BREAKS W/OBARGAINING(?)
• FLSA REQUIRES PAY FOR BREAKS
– UNLESS 30 MIN W/O DUTIES
• CAN’T WAIVE OR BARGAIN AWAY
• OK TO RESCHEDULE BREAKS W/OBARGAINING(?)BARGAINING(?)BARGAINING(?)
![Page 48: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/48.jpg)
LEAVES OF ABSENCELEAVES OF ABSENCE
• BARGAIN BEFORE CHANGE• BARGAIN BEFORE CHANGE• BARGAIN BEFORE CHANGE
• DOCTOR NOTES REQUIREBARGAINING– EXCEPT DURING “SICK-OUT”
• LIGHT DUTY
• REPORTING FORMS OK W/O
• BARGAIN BEFORE CHANGE
• DOCTOR NOTES REQUIREBARGAINING– EXCEPT DURING “SICK-OUT”
• LIGHT DUTY
• REPORTING FORMS OK W/O• REPORTING FORMS OK W/OBARGAINING
• STAY-HOME RULE OK
• REPORTING FORMS OK W/OBARGAINING
• STAY-HOME RULE OK
![Page 49: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/49.jpg)
FAMILY & MEDICALLEAVE ACT
FAMILY & MEDICALLEAVE ACT
• 1250 HOURS LAST YEAR• 1250 HOURS LAST YEAR• 1250 HOURS LAST YEAR
• SICK SELF OR FAMILY
– BIRTH/ADOPTION
• UNPAID
• REQUIRE VACATION, SICK, ETC.
• 1250 HOURS LAST YEAR
• SICK SELF OR FAMILY
– BIRTH/ADOPTION
• UNPAID
• REQUIRE VACATION, SICK, ETC.• REQUIRE VACATION, SICK, ETC.
• CONSECUTIVE OK
• NO BENEFITS OR SENIORITYACCRUE
• REQUIRE VACATION, SICK, ETC.
• CONSECUTIVE OK
• NO BENEFITS OR SENIORITYACCRUE
![Page 50: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/50.jpg)
TAKE-HOME VEHICLESTAKE-HOME VEHICLES
• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT
– CAN’T DISCONTINUE W/ONOTICE, ETC.
• CHIEF EVER UTILIZEDDISCRETION?
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
– CAN’T DISCONTINUE W/ONOTICE, ETC.
• CHIEF EVER UTILIZEDDISCRETION?
![Page 51: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/51.jpg)
RECRUIT ACADEMY FEESRECRUIT ACADEMY FEES
• PRE-EMPLOYMENT• PRE-EMPLOYMENT• PRE-EMPLOYMENTAGREEMENT OK
– NOT IF PAY BACK AFTERWORKING
• PRE-EMPLOYMENTAGREEMENT OK
– NOT IF PAY BACK AFTERWORKING
![Page 52: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/52.jpg)
INCREASES UNDEREXPIRED CONTRACTINCREASES UNDER
EXPIRED CONTRACT• NOTICE, ETC. BEFORE CHANGES• NOTICE, ETC. BEFORE CHANGES• NOTICE, ETC. BEFORE CHANGES
STATUS QUO
• NO INCREASES UNLESS PASTPRACTICE
– STEPS OR LONGEVITY BONUS
• NOTICE, ETC. BEFORE CHANGESSTATUS QUO
• NO INCREASES UNLESS PASTPRACTICE
– STEPS OR LONGEVITY BONUS– STEPS OR LONGEVITY BONUS– STEPS OR LONGEVITY BONUS
![Page 53: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/53.jpg)
BICYCLE PATROLSBICYCLE PATROLS
• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECTRE: IMPLEMENTATION
• JOB DUTIES,WORKLOAD & SAFETY,& ASSIGNMENTS
• MANDATORY SUBJECTRE: IMPLEMENTATION
• JOB DUTIES,WORKLOAD & SAFETY,& ASSIGNMENTS
![Page 54: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/54.jpg)
BULLET RESISTANT VESTSBULLET RESISTANT VESTS
• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT
• NOTICE, OPPORTUNITY,ETC. BEFORE MANDATEWEARING (ALL THETIME)
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
• NOTICE, OPPORTUNITY,ETC. BEFORE MANDATEWEARING (ALL THETIME)
![Page 55: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/55.jpg)
EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCEEMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE
![Page 56: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/56.jpg)
PERFORMANCEEVALUATIONS
PERFORMANCEEVALUATIONS
• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT
– STANDARDS FOR EVALUATION
– BASIS FOR PROMOTION
• NOT IF NO NEW CRITERIA
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
– STANDARDS FOR EVALUATION
– BASIS FOR PROMOTION
• NOT IF NO NEW CRITERIA
![Page 57: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/57.jpg)
TESTINGTESTING
• MANDATORY• MANDATORY• MANDATORY
– EXCEPT IN CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS
• PSYCHOLOGICAL – APPLICANTSONLY
• MANDATORY
– EXCEPT IN CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS
• PSYCHOLOGICAL – APPLICANTSONLY
![Page 58: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/58.jpg)
DRUG & ALCOHOL TESTINGDRUG & ALCOHOL TESTING
• MANDATORY• MANDATORY• MANDATORY
– EXCEPT APPLICANTS
• PROBABLE CAUSE FOREMPLOYEES
• CAN’T WAIVE EMPLOYEE’S RIGHTS
• MANDATORY
– EXCEPT APPLICANTS
• PROBABLE CAUSE FOREMPLOYEES
• CAN’T WAIVE EMPLOYEE’S RIGHTS• CAN’T WAIVE EMPLOYEE’S RIGHTS
• POLYGRAPH’S ILLEGAL
– EXCEPT CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS
• CAN’T WAIVE EMPLOYEE’S RIGHTS
• POLYGRAPH’S ILLEGAL
– EXCEPT CRIMINAL INVESTIGATIONS
![Page 59: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/59.jpg)
DISCIPLINEDISCIPLINE
• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT• MANDATORY SUBJECT
• COMMUNITY APPEARS BOARD OK
– ADVISORY ONLY
• NOT RETALIATORY
• MANDATORY SUBJECT
• COMMUNITY APPEARS BOARD OK
– ADVISORY ONLY
• NOT RETALIATORY
![Page 60: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/60.jpg)
PROPORTIONALDISCIPLINE
PROPORTIONALDISCIPLINE
• CAREFUL RE: UNION OFFICERS• CAREFUL RE: UNION OFFICERS• CAREFUL RE: UNION OFFICERS• CAREFUL RE: UNION OFFICERS
![Page 61: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/61.jpg)
WEINGARTEN RULEWEINGARTEN RULE
• INVESTIGATORY INTERVIEW• INVESTIGATORY INTERVIEW• INVESTIGATORY INTERVIEW
• REASONABLE EMPLOYEE
• DISCIPLINE MIGHT RESULT
• UNION BUDDY
– ATTY. MAY BE BUDDY
• INVESTIGATORY INTERVIEW
• REASONABLE EMPLOYEE
• DISCIPLINE MIGHT RESULT
• UNION BUDDY
– ATTY. MAY BE BUDDY– ATTY. MAY BE BUDDY– ATTY. MAY BE BUDDY
![Page 62: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/62.jpg)
NO RIGHT TO COUNSELNO RIGHT TO COUNSEL
• FEDERAL CURT RULE• FEDERAL CURT RULE• FEDERAL CURT RULE
– NOT ENTITLED TO HAVEAN ATTORNEY PRESENTDURING AN INTERNALINVESTIGATION
• FEDERAL CURT RULE
– NOT ENTITLED TO HAVEAN ATTORNEY PRESENTDURING AN INTERNALINVESTIGATION
![Page 63: LABOR RELATIONS - AELE RELATIONS Atty. John M. (Jack) Collins General Counsel Mass Chiefs of Police Assn Jackcollins@masschiefs.org](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020315/5aebe7f87f8b9a45568db2b3/html5/thumbnails/63.jpg)
ROLE OF UNIONREPRESENTATIVE
ROLE OF UNIONREPRESENTATIVE
• NOT PASSIVE OBSERVER• NOT PASSIVE OBSERVER• NOT PASSIVE OBSERVER
• NOT CROSS EXAMINE WITNESSES
• NOT PASSIVE OBSERVER
• NOT CROSS EXAMINE WITNESSES