Krell washington2010
-
Upload
gali-halevi -
Category
Documents
-
view
237 -
download
0
description
Transcript of Krell washington2010
Should editors influence journal impact factors?
Dr Frank-T. Krell
Denver Museum of Nature & Science
Editor-in-Chief, DMNS Annals
Editor 2003-2008,Systematic Entomology
Authors complaining about impact factor manipulation by editors
Consequences of such IF manipulation?Higher impact factor of the journal the author publishes in.
Who are the beneficiaries of such IF manipulation?
• All authors publishing in this journal.• Publisher of this journal.
Is it manipulation?
Impact factors derive from the citation process
Factors dominating the citation process:
• scientific relevance• strategy• sloppiness/laziness• bias• ignorance• voluntary choice• manipulation
Citation process
Is:Subjective and biased
Results in:Indicators
• for attention a paper receives,• not for quality
Editors’ actions unethical?
• Editors’ actions are not intruding or bending an objective process
• Editors contribute to the process in the same framework as authors or referees,
• but generally to a much lesser extent
Editors’ actions unethical?
Expectations in editors:• Maintaining/raising quality of journal• Raising attention to the journal
• Probably: building a journal identity/community; journal being more than an accumulation of papers
Making sure that appropriate citations aren’t missedGetting papers published that attract citations
Editorials, probably referring to papers publishedIf appropriate: journal-focused reviews
• Rejecting quality papers because of low citation expectations
• Insisting in journal self citations• or in non-citations of competing journals
Interfering with author’s responsibilities andscholarship for marketing purposes
Unethical editors’ actions
Ethical editors’ actions
• Informing authors about related papers in own journal
• Informing authors about obviously missed references to own journal’s papers
• Suggesting such citations if author considers them appropriate
Service for authors and journal