Koreaand Taiwan

Under Japanese ruleMarch 3, 2015

Review• What is a zaibatsu?

• How does democracy deal with conflicts of interest?

• How does Fascism deal with conflicts of interest?

• Can you have a democracy without a real possibility of a peaceful transfer of power?

• Was Japan a true democracy before 1945?

Korea, 1910-1945• 4 stages of Japanese control (pp. 403-04)

• 1905-10 Japanese protectorate, some armed resistance

• 1910-1919 Japanese impose total control and forced modernization, leading to March 1 demonstrations against Japanese rule. (Signalling the birth of mass nationalism.)

• Photo on p. 405 is mislabeled. There were no such mass public executions in 1919. The photo is from 1907.

• 1920-1931 cultural policy-allowing some cultural freedom but no political freedom

• 1931-45 period of attempted Japanization, combined with industrialization of the economy

Why did Korea lose its independence?

• Korea lacked the financial resources to modernize (arm a modern army, build an industrial economy, etc.)

• Reforms efforts at the end of the 19th century lacked popular support. (There was more culturalism than nationalism, and the nationalists were elitists.)

• After Japan defeated Russia, Korea couldn’t find any country willing to help it resist a takeover by Japan.

• Some Koreans actually wanted Japan to take over Korea, thinking that would give Korea access to Japan’s wealth. (Such pro-Japanese Koreans were in a group called the Unity and Progress Society, Iljinhoe, p. 403.)

The 1st decade• What did the Japanese do the first decade?

• created a modern bureaucratic government, one with officials trained in administration and one which could reach into villages, and they built a modern police force and a modern legal system

• regularized land ownership--more Koreans took advantage of this than Japanese did to acquire more land. (p. 405)

• began opening public schools in which Japanese became the language of instruction (p. 407)

• promoted modern financial business institutions, which gave an advantage to Japanese businessmen.

• Koreans were angered by many “modernizing” measures, such as outlawing the slaughtering of pigs and chickens at home, creating public cemeteries (challenging belief in geomancy [fengsui], controlling doctors of Oriental medicine, taxing wine and tobacco, etc.

• Led to March 1, 1919 popular uprising against Japanese rule.

Colonial Development (p. 406-08)

Growth in agricultural productivity, along with a decline in the quantity and quality of what Koreans were eating. (The surplus they produced was exported to Japan.)Why is agricultural growth important in the long run? Provides a surplus for investment.

✦ Creating an infrastructure for development: o Bankingo Railroadso Communication: the telegraph, radios, newspapers

o Schools--Korea’s first mass public education

Modernizing Society

A public health systemA failed attempt to move from Oriental

medicine to nothing but Western-style medicine• Industrialization and the creation of Korea’s

first modern labour force.• From animate to inanimate power

(electricity): another sign of modernization

Varieties of Korean reactions pp. 408-10

• collaboration-Japan could not have controlled Korea without Korean help. Why did many Koreans cooperate with the Japanese?

• religious resistance: Christianity (especially Protestant Christianity) and new religions, including Cheondogyo (Donghak),Daejonggyo, and Jeungsan’gyo (p.403)

• Christians and Donghak followers were the leaders of the March 1, 1919 protests

• diplomatic pressure on Japan (Syngman Rhee), focus on education (An Ch’ang-ho and other cultural nationalists), and focus on violent resistance (Kim Gu, Yi Donghwi and Kim Il Sung-see p. 408). Korean Communists led the armed resistance, but there were non-Communists such as An Junggeun (p. 404) and Kim Gu who also favoured violence against the Japanese.

• What about Kim San? (p. 411)

Japan’s Taiwan• 1895-1915 overcoming resistance

• 1915-1930 integration into the Japanese political, economic, and cultural sphere (civilian rather than military rulers)

• 1931-1945 “Imperialization” Even stopped publication of Chinese-language newspapers.

• The people of Taiwan were not completely Chinese in 1895, nor were they completely Japanese in 1945. The landed and urban elite tended to be more “Japanized” than were the peasantry.

Taiwanese reactions• Not a very strong movement for restoration of

Qing control

• Not a very strong Communist movement (People in Taiwan were cut off from developments on the mainland, especially when mainlanders started writing in the vernacular, which was not the same as the vernacular language of Taiwan.)

• At first, Taiwanese demanded an independent Taiwan Republic. Later they asked for home rule within the Japanese empire.

Creating Imperial Subjects

• In the 1930s Japan tried to turn both Koreans and Taiwanese into “imperial subjects,” people who were loyal to the Japanese emperor. They used four tools to do so:

• promoting Shinto at the expense of local religions (and, in Korea, Christianity)

• promoting Japanese over the local language

• encouraging Taiwanese, and requiring Koreans, to change their names to Japanese names

• Encouraging Taiwanese and Koreans to enlist in the Japanese military.

What is modernity?

Economic modernization:

from an agrarian economy to an industrial economy

peasants become farmers

faster means of transportation and communication

move from animate to inanimate power

Social modernization:

from hereditary occupations to occupational mobility

women gain more autonomy, at home and in public

mass education and mass media arrives.

individual horizons expand

Colonial modernity• The Japanese created public education and public

health systems in their colonies, along with modern transportation and communication systems. This led to greater literacy as well as rapidly growing populations. In addition, Japan began industrializing the economies of its colonies.

• colonial rule gave birth to modern national identities, and modern nationalism, in both colonies, though the nationalist movement was weakest in Taiwan. Koreans especially resented being treated as inferior by people they had regarded as inferior for millennia.

Industrialization• Both Korea and Taiwan were originally intended to

provide rice and other agricultural products to Japan so Japanese farmers could become factory workers.

• Industrialization began in both colonies in the 2nd decade of the 20th century, stimulated by demand created by World War I. In both places, hydroelectric plants were built for the first time.

• However, full-scale industrialization did not begin until the 1930s. Korea, in particular, began to be used to provide war materials for the Japanese campaign in China. (p. 407)

The legacy of colonial development

Provided infrastructure for industrializationcreated an experienced modern work force, including experienced factory workers.Provided public education and a modern public health systemProvided a more efficient bureaucracyProvided a more productive agricultureInadvertently created nationalism, especially in Korea

Other long-term effects of Japanese colonial rule

Enshrined a pivotal role for the state in economic development.Provided a model of concentrated economic power: in zaibatsu, seen in the chaebol in KoreaPromoted an export-oriented economy

And a dependent economy• Provided a model of what a modern government could

look like: it could be authoritarian and militaristic, as long as it promoted economic development and governed in an intrusive, impersonal manner. (All the governors-general of Korea were military men. Only the first governors-general in Taiwan were from the military)