Kirsten Gabriel Financial Abuse

38
Updated 1/13/2015 Martha Grimm Acct No. 42-5161-9295 Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals (total) Wires to Teresa Debit Transactions Checks Notable Transactions 4/10/10 - 4/22/10 $71,564.18 $92,197.10 Possibly money- grams? $5036.82 $2429.56 (16 total) $62,362.03 on 4/16/10 (land) $20,000.00 on 4/21/10 (withdrawal – Martha thinks for automobile) $739.14 (4/19) (Barclaycard) $426.99 (4/12) (Moneygram) $172.31 (4/14) (Spa Uniforms) $323.39 (4/16) (Moneygram) $350.00 (4/19) (Minnesota State Colleges & Universities) $207.39 (4/19) (Tempe Quality Inn) $281.39 (4/22) (Chase 2611). 4/23/10 - 5/21/10 $18,317.84 $59,230.25 Possibly money- grams? $12,292.88 (incl. $1,357.75 in 11 Banking Machine $44,949.77 (43 total) Online transfer of $1600 on 4/26 $589.68 Sierra Trading Post on

description

This summarizes (in considerably more detail than a jury recently got to see) the extent during a one-year period of the financial exploitation of Martha Grimm by Kirsten Grimm and Gabriel Smith.

Transcript of Kirsten Gabriel Financial Abuse

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Martha Grimm Acct No. 42-5161-9295

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    4/10/10 - 4/22/10 $71,564.18 $92,197.10 Possiblymoney-grams?

    $5036.82 $2429.56 (16total)

    $62,362.03 on4/16/10 (land)$20,000.00 on4/21/10(withdrawal Martha thinks forautomobile)$739.14 (4/19)(Barclaycard)$426.99 (4/12)(Moneygram)$172.31 (4/14)(Spa Uniforms)$323.39 (4/16)(Moneygram)$350.00 (4/19)(Minnesota StateColleges &Universities)$207.39 (4/19)(Tempe QualityInn)$281.39 (4/22)(Chase 2611).

    4/23/10 -5/21/10

    $18,317.84 $59,230.25 Possiblymoney-grams?

    $12,292.88(incl. $1,357.75in 11 BankingMachine

    $44,949.77(43 total)

    Online transfer of$1600 on 4/26$589.68 SierraTrading Post on

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    withdrawals) 05/13 $326.47 AthletaOnline on 5/13$407.11 J Crew on5/12$195.00 AmazonMarketplace on5/12$529.03 Freepeopleon 5/12$875.86 PenskeTruck on 5/12$424.29Moneygram on 5/3$92.99 Wysong on5/3$359.65 on 4/30Pyramid Collection$535.99 on 4/30Moneygram

    5/22/2010 -6/22/2010

    $27,838.00 $25,275.00 $600.00 (6/8)$1,900.00(6/11)

    $6041.71 incl9 BankingMachinewithdrawals for$996.00

    $14,661.48(21 total).

    $396.94 Wysongon 5/26$137.70 Wysongon 5/26$596.20 Up Northon 6/9$206.83 Ulta on5/28$475.96 on 6/21

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Chase.

    6/23/10 - 7/23/10

    $36,578.32 $38,961.06 $580.00 (6/24)$300.00 (7/7)$30,000.00(7/8)Moneygrams?

    $2155.13 (38transactions)incl.4 BankingMachinewithdrawals for$640.00

    $3995.06(25 checks).

    $485.99 7/9Moneygram

    7/24/10 -8/23/10

    $24,916.27 $14,171.39 $2,749.40 (incl.1 ATM for$100.00)$2,494.97 onlineand electronicbankingtransactions (16transactions).

    $8,927.02(23 Checks)incl$2,882.20(#2769)KirstenGrimm.

    $1,000.00(2770)GabrielSmith.

    $261 on 8/03 toBoden USA;$117.99 on 8/06 toGaiam Direct;$1380 on 8/11 toUci Exten &Sumsess We; $50.50 on 8/11recurring forInternet DomainName Registration; $215.25, on 8/23 to Attm*188023892191Glr

    8/24/10 -9/23/10

    $10,320.25 $21,421.50 $1600.00 (9/7) $9986.57______________$2,860.00 inBankingMachinewithdrawals (9

    $11,409.93(20 checks)incl$400.00(#2782)Gabe Smith.

    09/14 29.99 WebPmt Single - InstXfer Paypal5Pr224Fe9Mb4S

    9/12 142.57 9700

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    withdrawals) 08/30 100.00ATM 1375Whitehall09/07 460.00ATM 821 WBroadway09/07 460.00ATMWithdrawal 821W Broadway09/09 240.00ATM 1453 ELaketon 09/13 400.00ATMWithdrawal 821W Broadway09/13 400.00ATM 1375Whitehall Rd09/13 400.00ATM 1375Whitehall Rd 09/17 300.00ATM 821 WBroadway09/23 100.00ATM 1375

    $1000.00(#2784)KirstenGrimm.

    $550.00(#2786)KirstenGrimm.

    $500.00(#2790)KirstenGrimm.

    Check CardPurchaseAttm*188021868895Glr

    09/22 257.59 9700Check CardPurchase WysongCorporation

    09/21 20.00 WebPmt Single -CreditcardBarclaycard US99303728

    09/23 144.42 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541001B

    09/03 72.90 9700Check CardPurchase Monroeand Main

    09/08 487.30 9700Check CardPurchase Bioshield

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Whitehall Rd

    $568.87 inCheckCard/Bank cardPIN POSpurchases (8total)

    There were 84other BankingMachine/CheckCard deductionstotaling$4,189.76.

    There were 10Online orElectronicBankingDeductionstotaling$2,367.94.

    PaintEco De

    9/24/2010 -10/22/2010

    $39,220.80

    Incl.

    $19,705.97 10/14 900.00Fed Wire Out027614

    $15,392.14 ____________There were 18Banking

    $4,288.83 (11checks)

    2809 350.00

    Too many to list.

    10/18 674.10 9700Check Card

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    09/29 23,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    10/13 3,300.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    10/19 2,632.40Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    10/22 3,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    Machinewithdrawalstotaling$4,223.00.

    There were 12CheckCard/Bankcard PIN POSpurchasestotaling$1,088.93.

    There were 108other BankingMachine/CheckCard deductionstotaling$7,894.38.

    There were 12Online orElectronicBankingDeductionstotaling$2,185.83.

    (10/4)GabrielSmith.

    2811 100.00(09/30)KirstenGrimm.

    2812 379.36(10/1)State Farm whoseinsurance?

    28152,000.00(10/13)KirstenGrimm.

    Purchase AmazoncomAmzn Com/B

    10/01 100.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/04 100.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/04 100.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    10/04 59.95 9700Check CardPurchase DiskeeperCorporation

    10/05 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    10/06 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    10/06 300.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    10/07 103.22 9700Check CardPurchase Autozone#2182

    10/08 406.40 9700Check CardPurchase Meijer#232

    10/08 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/08 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/12 423.25 9700Check CardPurchaseConsenergy-Telepayment

    10/12 273.76 9700

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Check CardPurchase Meijer#232Muskegon

    10/12 240.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/12 229.43 POSPurchase MeijerInc 071 NMuskegon

    10/12 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

    10/12 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    10/12 144.90 9700Check CardPurchaseAttm*188021868895Glr

    10/12 31.79 9700

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Check CardPurchaseDri*Dvdcloner

    10/13 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    10/13 210.00 9700Check CardPurchase ComcastOf Grand Rapid

    10/13 137.93 9700Check CardPurchase Apc 242Muskegon

    10/13 80.00 9700Check CardPurchase Pints andQuarts

    10/13 32.33 9700Check CardPurchase Mia &GraceMuskegon

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    10/14 49.00 9700Check CardPurchase StateRenewal ByWeb (Marthas b-day is in April)

    10/15 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/15 142.84 9700Check CardPurchaseAttm*188023892191Glr

    10/18 473.27 9700Check CardPurchase Target

    10/18 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/18 36.95 9700Check CardPurchaseSftwr-Dwnld Com

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    10/18 .92International POSFee Vis 1016 Kn

    10/19 612.30 9700Check CardPurchase SallyBeauty#1738

    10/19 320.00 9700Check CardPurchase DteEnergy 800-477-474

    10/19 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/19 128.10 9700Check CardPurchase AmazoncomAmzn Com/B

    10/21 293.61 9700Check CardPurchase

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Muskegon PublicWorks

    10/21 223.00 ATMWithdrawalNorthside OffMusk NMuskegon Mi

    10/14 144.42 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541001B

    . . . . the list can goon.

    10/23/2010 - 11/22/2010

    $19,863.37

    incl

    10/25 1,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    10/29 5,999.50

    $38,882.75 11/10 300.00 FedWire Out 017571

    11/15 300.00 FedWire Out 016175

    11/19 800.00 FedWire Out 019471

    Moneygrams??

    $16,706.40

    There were 12BankingMachinewithdrawalstotaling$3,742.50.

    There were 13CheckCard/Bank

    There were14 checkslisted totaling$22,176.35.

    281718,534.8711/01(Kirsten didnot pay forthe windows).

    11/19 4,200.00Withdrawal Tel0700074501 0057

    10/25 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    10/25 73.94 9700Check CardPurchaseMoneygram

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    11/17 5,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    card PIN POSpurchasestotaling$2,359.86.

    There were 97other BankingMachine/CheckCard deductionstotaling$4,092.74.

    There were 15Online orElectronicBankingDeductionstotaling$2,236.30.

    There were 4OtherDeductionstotaling$4,275.00

    2836 668.3411/03State Farm Whoseinsurance??

    Payment Syst

    10/25 60.00 9700Check CardPurchase Bear LakeInn

    10/26 148.25 POSPurchase USPS256531022 NorthMuskeg

    10/28 113.94 9700Check CardPurchaseMoneygramPayment Syst

    11/01 398.99 9700Check CardPurchaseMoneygramPayment Syst

    11/01 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    11/02 220.00 ATM

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Withdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    11/02 220.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    11/04 220.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    11/05 455.99 9700Check CardPurchaseMoneygramPayment Syst

    11/05 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    11/05 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    11/08 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    11/08 400.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    11/12 764.54 POSPurchase USPS256530022

    11/12 340.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    11/12 142.83 9700Check CardPurchaseAttm*188021868895Glr

    11/15 340.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    11/15 202.50 ATMWithdrawal 1485East Apple Av11/15 146.83 9700Check CardPurchase Pints andQuarts

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    11/15 45.00 9700Check CardPurchase Dah HuRestaurant

    11/15 24.95 9700Check CardPurchase Es *ValuePlusMonthly

    11/15 24.95 9700Check CardPurchase Es*FunsourceMonthly

    11/15 21.19 9700Check CardPurchase AceCommunications

    11/15 10.00 9700Check CardPurchase CollegeTranscript

    11/19 57.99 9700Check Card

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    PurchaseDri*Spotmaucom

    11/22 213.46 9700Check CardPurchaseAttm*188023892191Glr

    11/05 144.44 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541001B

    11/08 63.00 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541004B

    11/15 43.88Payment,E-CheckPayment Monroe &Main2841

    11/23/2010 - 12/22/2010

    $24,262.50

    incl.

    $24,627.56 11/26 100.00Fed Wire Out028948

    $12,304.10

    There were 4other Banking

    There were47 checkslisted totaling$12,173.46.

    11/26 39.90 9700Check CardPurchaseBestvideos4You

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    11/29 250.05Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    11/30 2,250.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    12/06 6,000.01Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    12/13 7,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    12/15 1,955.00

    12/082,900.00 FedWire Out032825

    12/102,000.00 FedWire Out033538

    12/133,300.00 FedWire Out030639

    12/161,500.00 FedWire Out032317

    Machine/CheckCard deductionstotaling $66.57.

    There were 23Online orElectronicBankingDeductionstotaling$12,237.53.

    2822 500.0012/20Comcast phonepayment;appears to beGabrielscable bill.

    2823 37.7612/2/2010Appears to bea phonepayment ofsomebodyscable bill.

    2824 250.0012/07Gabe Smith.

    2825 262.4712/06Gabe Smith.

    2828 480.0012/13Gabe Smith.

    Com

    11/26 1.00International POSFee Vis 1125 Cy

    12/01 256.80 WebPmt Recur-Cpc-ClientState Farm Ro 2404 S 1099683604

    12/07 781.26 WebPmt Single -CreditcardBarclaycard US104914084

    12/08 144.44 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541001B

    12/08 143.47 WebPmt Single -Payment At&T188021868895Glr

    12/22 122.19

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    2833 825.0011/30GabrielSmith.

    28371,350.0012/07Gabe Smith.

    2861 262.4712/02State Farm whoseinsurance??

    2864 450.0012/03KirstenGrimm.

    2870 90.0012/06Gabe Smith.

    2871 335.0012/08Gabe Smith.

    Payment,E-CheckCheckpaymtConsumers Energy2898

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    2877 500.0012/09KirstenGrimm orGabrielSmith.

    2878 30.0012/08Gabe Smith.

    2883 250.0012/10KirstenGrimm.

    2888 366.9912/21ScottsAutomotive.

    2889 900.0012/16KirstenGrimm.

    2890 408.8912/13Kirsten

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Grimm orGabrielSmith.

    28911,035.1812/15KirstenGrimm orGabriel Smith KirstensBills.

    2907 796.0012/20PNC Bank Home equitypayment, or isit cashed?? Handwritingnpt Marthas.

    2909 250.0012/20KirstenGrimm

    12/23/10 - 1/25/11

    $22,989.78

    incl

    $23,787.50 01/203,000.00 FedWire Out

    $5682.57

    There were 23

    There were49 checkslisted totaling

    01/10 17.60 0151Check CardPurchase USPS

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    12/23 2,250.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    12/27 2,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    12/30 1,152.39Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    12/30 852.40Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    12/31 852.40

    034072 Online orElectronicBankingDeductionstotaling$5,169.32.

    There were 30other BankingMachine/CheckCard deductionstotaling $513.25.

    $18,069.93.

    Incl.

    2822 325.00 01/21Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2823 325.00 01/24Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2892 525.00 12/24Kirsten Grimm orGabriel Smith ispayee; signatureprobably notMarthas.

    2900 508.31 01/14Cleveland Township.

    2913 120.00 12/23Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureprobably notMarthas.

    2914 200.00 12/23Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureprobably notMarthas.

    2918 2,250.00 12/27Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureprobably notMarthas.

    2926 17.00 01/03Gabe Smith is payee;signature probablynot Marthas.

    2927 200.00 01/03

    2565310223080323301/14 22.36 0151Check CardPurchase NmeMagazineOrde03 Of

    01/14 10.70 0151Check CardPurchase USPS25653102230803233

    12/23 21.18Payment,E-CheckCheck Pymt Chase2897

    01/19 422.00Direct Payment -Payment CkConsumers EnergyXXXXXXXX9403

    01/19 6.25 DirectPayment - ConvenFeeConsumers Energy

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    01/13 5,000.00DepositReference No119264539($5000.00 loanfrom EricGrimm).

    01/20 4,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    01/21 1,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    Image difficult toread; appears to beGabe Smith aspayee.

    2931 225.00 01/18Gabe Smith is payee;signature clearly notMarthas; checkaltered.

    2932 25.00 01/05Gabe Smith is payee;signature probablynot Marthas.

    2937 185.00 01/06Image difficult toread; appears to beGabe Smith aspayee.

    2940 600.00 01/18Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2942 138.00 01/10Image difficult toread.

    2947 800.00 01/11Gabe Smith is payee;signature probablynot Marthas.

    2950 875.00 01/14Gabe Smith is payee;signature probablynot Marthas.

    2951 120.00 01/14Gabe Smith is payee;signature probablynot Marthas.

    2953 180.00 01/18Gabe Smith is payee;signature clearly notMarthas.

    XXXXXXXX9403

    01/21 72.77Payment,E-CheckCheckpaymtConsumers Energy2962

    01/25 365.21 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541004B

    01/25 242.90 WebPmt Single -Payment At&T523196147027Flp

    01/25 144.44 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541001B

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    2957 130.00 01/24Scotts Automiotive.

    2964 814.00 01/19PNC maybe homeequity payment??

    2966 350.00 01/24NAPA??

    2968 296.16 01/24NAPA??

    2969 250.00 01/24Gabe Smith is payee;signature clearly notMarthas.

    1/26/2011 -2/22/2011

    $21,050.56

    incl.

    01/26 4,700.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    02/03 1,500.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STAN

    $19,497.65 $7260.00

    There were 7BankingMachinewithdrawalstotaling$1,801.75.

    There were 2CheckCard/Bank cardPIN POSpurchasestotaling

    $12,129.65

    There were14 checkslisted totaling$12,129.65.

    Incl.

    2971 550.00 01/27Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureindeterminate.

    2974 135.00 02/04Gabe Smith is payee;signature clearly notMarthas.

    01/26 44.58 0151Check CardPurchase MemphisEquipment Comp

    01/27 411.15 0151Check CardPurchase WysongCorporation

    01/28 36.37 0151Check CardPurchase MemphisEquipment Comp

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    IRAXXXXX4585

    02/10 6,340.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    02/17 4,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    $261.58.

    There were 47other BankingMachine/CheckCard deductionstotaling$3,881.32.

    There were 6Online orElectronicBankingDeductionstotaling$1,315.35.

    2977 650.00 02/04Kirsten Grimm orGabriel Smith ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2978 300.00 02/07Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2979 300.00 02/08Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2981 1,600.00 02/10Gabriel Smith ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2982 3,900.00 02/10Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2985 2,000.00 02/18Kirsten Grimm ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas. Evidently used to payChase credit card.

    2986 800.00 02/18Gabriel Smith ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2987 800.00 02/18Gabriel Smith ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2988 900.00 02/22Gabriel Smith ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    01/31 285.00 0151Check CardPurchase ComcastOf Grand Rapid

    01/31 260.00 ATMWithdrawal 1375Whitehall Rd

    01/31 161.75 0151Check CardPurchaseBeautydepot Com

    01/31 105.00 0151Check CardPurchase Ez CourtPay Llc

    02/01 571.26 0151Check CardPurchase HealthHutt IMuskego

    02/01 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    02/01 160.00 0151Check CardPurchase DteEnergy 800-477-474

    02/02 51.62 0151Check CardPurchaseMuskegonAutomotive Su

    02/03 140.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    02/03 140.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    02/07 101.75 ATMWithdrawal 1121East Laketon

    02/09 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

    02/11 400.00 ATM

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Withdrawal 821 WBroadway

    02/11 45.00 0151Check CardPurchase CentralTowing

    02/14 690.00 0151Check CardPurchase Uci Exten& Sumsess We

    02/14 100.75 0151Check CardPurchase MemphisEquipment Comp02/14 22.36 0151Recurring CheckCard NmeMagazineOrde03 O

    02/18 500.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

    02/22 49.78 0151Check Card

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Purchase Autozone#2105

    02/22 8.48 0151Check CardPurchase Dri*OpenDvdRipper

    02/22 3.13 0151Check CardPurchase Dri*OpenDvdRipper

    01/27 256.80 WebPmt Recur-Cpc-ClientState Farm Ro 2404 S 1099683604

    01/31 588.20 WebPmt Single - AmzcEpayAmazon Credit254436847

    02/01 220.48 WebPmt Single - Web

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    PmtWfn Pbp Wfn000000829287965

    02/03 40.00 WebPmt Single -CreditcardBarclaycard US109191069

    2/23/2011 -3/22/2011

    $14,200.86

    incl.

    02/24 5,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    03/01 600.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    03/02 1,000.00

    $13,428.55 $8840.45

    There were 5BankingMachinewithdrawalstotaling$1,403.00.

    There were 4CheckCard/Bank cardPIN POSpurchasestotaling$188.92.

    There were 25other Banking

    $4,988.10

    There were11 checkslisted totaling$4,988.10.

    Incl.

    2989 850.00 02/28Gabriel Smith ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2993 850.00 02/24Gabriel Smith is thepayeel signatureclearly not Marthas.

    2994 268.00 02/23Gabriel Smith ispayee; signatureclearly not Marrthas.

    2996 148.21 03/14Check 2996 was

    02/24 2,735.00Withdrawal Tel0700074204 0012

    02/24 200.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

    03/07 500.00 ATMWithdrawal 1453 ELaketon

    03/07 103.00 ATMWithdrawal 5300Harvey St

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    03/07 1,399.99Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    03/21 1,500.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    Machine/CheckCard deductionstotaling $743.79.

    There were 11Online orElectronicBankingDeductionstotaling$3,290.24.

    There were 4OtherDeductionstotaling$2,814.50.

    written to payMarthas Comcastbill. Instead, Gabrielphoned in the checkand used it to pay hisown cable bill.

    2998 825.00 03/08Gabriel Smith;signature clearly isnot Marthas.

    3000 650.00 03/15Gabe Smith is payee;signature clearly isnot Marthas.

    3006 420.00 03/22Gabe Smith is payee; signature clearly isnot Marthas

    03/09 62.78 0151Check CardPurchase Norton*Software

    03/11 100.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

    03/11 70.73 0151 Check CardPurchase Norton*Software (Note:Martha had only aMac Minicomputer, and isunlikely to be apurchaser ofNorton).

    03/11 500.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

    03/17 283.81 0151Check CardPurchase WysongCorporation

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    02/24 105.57Payment,E-CheckCheckpaymtConsumers Energy2992

    02/28 947.00Phone Order Pmt-Cpc-ClientState Farm Ro 0804 F J948431

    02/28 100.00Phone Order Pmt-Payment At&T188023892191Glr

    03/02 150.82 WebPmt Single -Payment At&T523196147027Flp

    03/21 500.00 WebPmt Single -CreditcardBarclaycard US112919887

    03/21 75.00 Web

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Pmt Single -CreditcardBarclaycard US112919475

    03/22 145.77 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541001B

    03/22 145.61 WebPmt Single -Payment At&T523196147027Flp

    03/22 274.47 WebPmt Recur-Cpc-ClientState Farm Ro 2404 S 1099683604

    3/23/2011 -4/22/2011

    $10,659.87

    incl.

    03/29 1,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRA

    $12,756.12 $8078.97

    There were 4BankingMachinewithdrawalstotaling $660.00.

    There were 24

    $4559.15

    There were11 checkslisted totaling$4,559.15.

    Incl.

    Note the 2 checksnumbered 3011 one cashed by ateller two days afterthe other.

    03/28 320.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    XXXXX4585

    03/30 600.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    04/04 2,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    04/12 2,000.00Direct Deposit -IRA PymtMORG STANIRAXXXXX4585

    04/21 638.68Refer To MakerReturn Ck000000000234506EFFECTIVE

    other BankingMachine/CheckCard deductionstotaling$1,364.70.

    There were 23Online orElectronicBankingDeductionstotaling$6,054.27.

    2997 249.09 03/30Check 2997 was forthe amount ofMarthas gas bill, butwas altered byGabriel and used topay Gabriels DTEbill. Clear U&P.

    3007 * T 550.7303/24Gabriel Smith ispayee; signatureclearly not Marthas.

    3011 160.62 04/06Subpoenaed checksonly go up to 3007.

    3011 * T 900.0004/08 Subpoenaedchecks only go up to3007.

    3013 * 187.50 04/18Subpoenaed checksonly go up to 3007.

    3028 * 222.64 04/15

    3029 875.00 04/20Subpoenaed checksonly go up to 3007.

    3033 * 148.00 04/06Subpoenaed checksonly go up to 3007.

    3034 218.00 04/20Subpoenaed checksonly go up to 3007.

    234506 * 638.6804/20 Subpoenaedchecks only go up to3007.

    03/28 100.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

    03/30 140.00 ATMWithdrawal 821 WBroadway

    04/15 217.02 3661Check CardPurchaseConsenergy-Telepayment

    04/15 6.25 3661Check CardPurchaseConsumersEnergy Conve

    04/18 303.79 3661Check CardPurchase WysongCorporation

    04/18 182.54 3661Check CardPurchaseAttm*1880238921

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    04-20-11

    04/21 218.00Refer To MakerReturn Ck000000000003034EFFECTIVE04-20-11

    "T" TellerCashed Check

    91Glr

    04/18 160.00 3661Check CardPurchase DteEnergy 800-477-474

    03/28 130.49Phone Order Pmt-Payment At&T188023892191Glr

    03/30 215.61 WebPmt Single - AmzcEpay AmazonCredit 269119969

    03/30 196.62 WebPmt Single - WebPmt Wfn Pbp Wfn000000829287965

    04/06 679.36Phone Order Pmt-Cpc-ClientState Farm Ro 0804 A 1683478

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    04/07 70.41 PhoneOrder Pmt-Payment CkConsumers Energy100013389745

    04/07 6.25 PhoneOrder Pmt- ConvenFee ConsumersEnergy100013389745

    04/13 592.75Direct Payment -XXXXXX4747Dte EnergyXXXXXXXXXXX3035

    04/18 791.00 WebPmt Single -CreditcardBarclaycard US114828597

    04/18 177.42 WebPmt Single -Payment At&T523196147027Flp

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    04/19 479.20 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541004B

    04/19 200.72 WebPmt Single - WebPmt Wfn Pbp Wfn000000829287965

    04/19 145.77 WebPmt Single - EbillSallie Mae97973456541001B

    04/19 82.34 WebPmt Single - AmzcEpay AmazonCredit 274063120

    04/19 346.58Direct Payment -Payment CkConsumers EnergyXXXXXXXX9403

    04/19 245.00Direct Payment -Payment Ck

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Consumers EnergyXXXXXXXX9403

    04/19 186.38 WebPmt Recur-Cpc-ClientState Farm Ro 2404 A 3341776

    04/19 137.21 WebPmt Recur-Cpc-ClientState Farm Ro 2404 S 1099683604

    04/19 100.00Phone Order Pmt-8004774747Dte Energy000000229932605

    04/19 42.66 WebPmt Recur-Cpc-ClientState Farm Ro 2404 S 1132765404

    04/19 6.25 DirectPayment - Conven

  • Updated 1/13/2015

    Month Deposits (total) Withdrawals(total)

    Wires toTeresa

    DebitTransactions

    Checks NotableTransactions

    Fee ConsumersEnergyXXXXXXXX9403

    04/19 6.25 DirectPayment - ConvenFee ConsumersEnergyXXXXXXXX9403