KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
-
Upload
himself2462 -
Category
Documents
-
view
215 -
download
0
Transcript of KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
1/27
1
IN$THE$CIRCUIT$COURT$OF$MONTGOMERY$COUNTY$MARYLAND
BRETT$KIMBERLIN,$ Plaintiff,
$ v.$ $ $ $ $ $ No.$CV$380996
AARON$WALKER,$7537$Remington$Road,$Manassas,$VA$20109WILLIAM$HOGE$SR.,$20$Ridge$Road,$Westminster,$MD$21157ROBERT$STACY$MCCAIN,$10100$Academy$Drive,$Hagerstown,$MD$21740ALI$AKBAR,$8116$Heritage$Place$Drive,$Ft.$Worth,$TX$76137$ andANONYMOUS$BLOGGER$akaKIMBERLIN$UNMASKED$(address$unknown)$ Defendants.
COMPLAINT*FOR*DAMAGES*FOR*DEFAMATION,*MALICIOUS*PROSECUTION,*HARASSMENT,*STALKING,*CONSPIRACY,*INVASION*OF*PRIVACY*AND*
INTENTIONAL*INFLICTION*OF*EMOTIONAL*DISTRESS
Plaintiff$Brett$Kimberlin$(Kimberlin)$hereby$^iles$a$Complaint$for$Damages$against
Defendants$Aaron$Walker$(Walker),$William$Hoge$Sr.$(Hoge),$Robert$Stacy$
McCain$(McCain),$Ali$Akbar$(Akbar)$and$Anonymous$Blogger$aka$Kimberlin$
Unmasked$(KU)$for$defamation,$malicious$prosecution,$harassment,$stalking,$
conspiracy,$invasion$of$privacy$and$in^liction$of$emotional$distress.
NATURE*OF*THE*ACTION
1. This$matter$arises$out$of$a$multi`year$campaign$by$Defendants$to$smear,$
destroy$and$imprison$Plaintiff$by$knowingly,$maliciously,$and$intentionally$
^iling$numerous$frivolous,$defamatory$and$malicious$court$ ilings$``$including$
civil$suits,$peace$orders,$and$criminal$charges$$and$then$publishing$false,$
defamatory,$and$tasteless$stories$about$those$^ilings$as$if$the$allegations$were$
true,$all$the$time$raising$funds$from$unsuspecting$people$who$read$the$
stories.
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
2/27
2
2. Defendants$used$their$legal$^ilings$to$stalk$and$harass$Plaintiff,$invade$his$
privacy$and$in^lict$emotional$distress$on$him$and$his$family.$$
3. Defendants$portrayed$Plaintiff$in$a$false$light$as$engaging$in$criminal$activity,$
being$a$pedophile,$rapist$and$domestic$terrorist,$and$engaging$in$domestic$
violence.$$
4. Defendants$falsely$wrote$that$other$targets$of$theirs$were$part$of$Team$
Kimberlin$and$published$that$Plaintiff$controlled,$paid,$and$directed$this$vast$
network$of$unsavory$operatives.
5. None$of$these$portrayals$is$based$on$reality.$$
6. The$defamatory$statements$made$by$Defendants$were$published$on$the$
Internet$in$various$forums,$including$blog$posts,$on$Twitter,$and$on$message$
boards,$and$were$widely$accessible$to$the$public$both$directly$and$by$Google$
searches,$and$they$were$seen$by$many$people$including$Plaintiffs$business$
associates,$friends$and$family.$$$They$were$also$published$in$numerous$court$
documents$^iled$in$courts$in$Montgomery$County$and$Carroll$County$
Maryland,$Prince$William$County$Virginia,$and$United$States$District$Court$in$
Greenbelt,$Maryland.$$They$were$made$to$various$law$enforcement$of^icials.$
7. Defendants$have$persisted$in$their$smear$attacks$despite$being$asked$by$
Plaintiff$to$be$left$alone,$to$remove$false$posts,$and$to$respect$the$privacy$of$
Plaintiff$and$his$family.
8. Defendants$have$pro^ited$from$their$attacks$against$Plaintiff$by$raising$funds$
online$using$his$name$and$their$false$narratives,$court$^ilings$and$defamatory$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
3/27
3
publications$to$demonize$him.$$They$have$also$obtained$other$things$of$value$
such$an$online$traf^ic$to$their$websites.
9. Plaintiff$has$initiated$this$action$to$recover$compensatory$and$punitive$
damages$from$Defendants$for$the$substantial$injury$they$have$caused$to$
Plaintiff$by$their$intentional,$malicious$and$outrageous$conduct.$
PARTIES
10. Plaintiff$Brett$Kimberlin$is$the$Director$of$Justice$Through$Music,$a$Maryland$
based$501c3$non`pro^it$that$uses$music$to$inspire$people$to$engage$in$civic$
participation.$$Plaintiff$has$held$that$position$for$almost$ten$years$and$he$
resides$in$Bethesda,$Maryland.$
11. Aaron$Walker$is$an$unemployed$attorney$who$resides$in$Manassas,$Virginia$
who$writes$a$conservative$Internet$blog$called$Allergic2Bull,$and$publishes$
on$various$other$online$outlets$including$Twitter.
12. William$Hoge$Sr.$is$a$conservative$blogger$who$resides$in$Westminster,$
Maryland$and$writes$a$blog$called$HogeWash.$$He$publishes$on$various$other$
online$outlets$including$Twitter.
13. Robert$Stacy$McCain$is$a$conservative$blogger$who$resides$in$Hagerstown,$
Maryland$who$writes$a$blog$called$The$Other$McCain,$and$publishes$on$
various$other$online$outlets$including$Twitter,$Viral$Read$and$The$American$
Spectator.
14. Ali$Akbar$is$the$director$of$The$National$Bloggers$Club$who$resides$in$Ft.$
Worth,$Texas$and$Lynchburg,$Virginia,$and$he$publishes$on$various$Internet$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
4/27
4
sites$and$on$Twitter.$$He$is$the$reputed$boss$of$Walker,$Hoge$and$McCain$and$
has$provided$each$of$them$with$remuneration.$$
15. Kimberlin$Unmasked$is$an$anonymous$conservative$blogger$who$has$both$a$
website$and$a$Twitter$account$that$were$speci^ically$created$to$attack$
Plaintiff$on$a$daily$basis.$$
16. The$publications$of$the$Defendants$are$available$on$the$Internet$in$Maryland.$$
Defendants$Walker,$Hoge,$McCain$and$Akbar$have$all$traveled$to$Montgomery$
County$Maryland$in$the$past$year$as$part$of$their$campaign$and$conspiracy$to$
attack,$smear,$stalk$and$harass$Plaintiff.$$
JURISDICTION*AND*VENUE
17. This$Court$has$personal$and$subject$matter$jurisdiction$over$this$matter$$$$$$
pursuant$to$Maryland$Civil$Code.$
18. Venue$is$proper$because$many,$if$not$all$of$the$acts$occurred$in$Montgomery$
County$Maryland,$Plaintiff$is$a$citizen$of$Maryland$and$Montgomery$County,$
the$torts$were$committed$in$Montgomery$County,$and$the$injuries$were$
sustained$in$Montgomery$County.$$
STATEMENT*OF*THE*FACTS
19. In$2010,$Plaintiff$^iled$a$defamation$suit$in$this$Court$against$a$blogger$named$
Seth$Allen.$$That$suit$resulted$in$a$judgment$in$Plaintiffs$favor$on$November$
16,$2011.$$
20. Defendant$Walker,$using$the$pseudonym$Aaron$Worthing,$attempted$to$assist$
Mr.$Allen$in$post$judgment$motions$until$Plaintiff$identi ied$him$as$Aaron$
Walker,$the$publisher$of$a$Muslim$hate$blog$called$Everyone$Draw$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
5/27
5
Mohammed.$Judge$Quirk$denied$Defendant$Walkers$post$trial$motion$to$
declare$Plaintiff$a$public$^igure.$$
21. After$Defendant$Walker$was$identi^ied,$he$began$stalking$Plaintiff$and$
harassing$him$with$court$^ilings$and$defamatory$attacks.$$He$came$to$a$court$
hearing$on$January$9,$2012$and$assaulted$Plaintiff$outside$the$courtroom.$He$
^iled$multiple$criminal$charges$against$Plaintiff$in$Montgomery$County$in$
2012,$he$^iled$a$civil$suit$against$Plaintiff$in$Prince$William$County$Virginia$in$
2012,$and$he$^iled$a$civil$suit$against$Plaintiff$in$United$States$District$Court$
in$Greenbelt$in$2012.$$All$of$these$cases$were$nolle$prossed$or$dismissed$as$
without$merit.$$
22. In$March$2013,$Defendant$Walker$attempted$to$^ile$a$Peace$Order$against$
Plaintiff$in$Montgomery$County$but$was$denied.
23. In$July$2013,$Defendant$Walker$further$stalked$Plaintiff$by$attending,$
uninvited,$a$family$court$matter$involving$Plaintiff$and$Plaintiffs$wife,$and$
then$following$the$wife$out$of$the$courtroom,$making$contact$with$her,$
offering$her$things$of$value,$preparing$false$documents$for$her$to$^ile$in$court,$
and$advising$her$to$make$false$allegations$and$change$her$allegations$against$
Plaintiff$both$criminally$and$civilly.$$Defendant$Walker$then$published$these$
false$allegations$on$his$blog$and$on$Twitter,$and$had$the$other$Defendants$do$
the$same$on$their$blogs$and$on$Twitter.$$These$defamatory$publications$by$
Defendant$Walker$falsely$stated$categorically$that$Plaintiff$is$a$rapist,$
pedophile$and$committed$domestic$violence$against$his$wife.$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
6/27
6
24. Over$the$past$two$years,$Defendant$Walker$has$published$hundreds$of$blog$
posts$and$thousands$of$Twitter$tweets$falsely$accusing$Plaintiff$of$numerous$
crimes$and$other$nefarious$activity,$including$rape,$pedophilia$and$domestic$
violence.
25. Defendant$Walker$has$recruited$Defendants$Hoge,$McCain,$Akbar$and$KU$to$
write$hundreds$of$false$and$defamatory$blog$posts$and$Twitter$tweets$over$
the$past$year$attacking$Plaintiff$as$a$criminal$rapist$and$pedophile$who$
commits$domestic$violence.$$
26. Defendant$Walker$has$stated$scores$of$times$on$his$blog,$in$Twitter$tweets$
and$elsewhere$that$his$goal$is$to$have$Plaintiff$imprisoned$and$have$his$
business$destroyed.$$
27. In$2013,$Defendant$Hoge$^iled$a$false$Peace$Order$and$two$malicious$criminal$
charges$against$Plaintiff$in$Carroll$County$accusing$Plaintiff$of$harassing$him.$
That$Peace$Order$was$denied$in$June$2013$and$the$criminal$charges$were$
nolle$prossed$in$April$2013.$
28. Defendant$Hoge$has$written$literally$hundreds$of$blog$posts$attacking$
Plaintiff,$and$directed$attention$to$them$with$thousands$of$Twitter$tweets.$$He$
writes$a$daily$Team$Kimberlin$Post$of$the$Day$which$accuses$Plaintiff$or$
others$he$falsely$states$are$members$of$Team$Kimberlin$of$engaging$in$some$
type$of$criminal$or$nefarious$activity.$$Mr.$Hoge$has$stalked$Plaintiff$by$
attending$court$proceedings$that$do$not$involve$him,$and$then$publishing$
twisted$accounts$of$those$hearings$that$portray$Plaintiff$in$a$negative$light.$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
7/27
7
29. In$July$2013,$Defendant$Hoge$further$stalked$Plaintiff$by$attending$a$family$
court$matter$involving$Plaintiff$and$Plaintiffs$wife,$and$then$following$the$
wife$out$of$the$courtroom,$making$contact$with$her,$offering$her$things$of$
value,$preparing$false$documents$for$her$to$^ile$in$court,$and$advising$her$to$
make$false$allegations$against$Plaintiff$both$criminally$and$civilly.$$Defendant$
Hoge$then$published$these$false$allegations$on$his$blog$and$on$Twitter,$and$
had$the$other$Defendants$do$the$same$on$their$blogs$and$on$Twitter.$$These$
defamatory$publications$falsely$stated$categorically$that$Plaintiff$is$a$
pedophile,$rapist$and$committed$domestic$violence$against$his$wife.$
30. In$July$2013,$Defendant$Hoge$published$an$online$fundraising$tool$on$his$blog$
to$ostensibly$raise$funds$for$Plaintiffs$wife,$and$for$her$legal$representation$
by$the$same$attorney$who$represented$Defendant$Hoge$in$his$previous$
malicious$^ilings$against$Plaintiff$in$Carroll$County.$At$least$3,000$of$those$
funds$were$then$used$to$pay$for$that$attorney$who$thereby$bene^itted$from$
the$malicious$legal$action.$This$legal$fundraising$tool$is$part$of$a$pattern$of$
conduct$that$the$Defendants$used$previously$in$other$court$cases,$which$
always$resulted$in$attorneys,$including$Defendant$Walker,$receiving$a$
^inancial$bene^it$while$defaming$and$harassing$Plaintiff.$$Defendant$Walker$
also$used$said$legal$defense$funds$raised$in$previous$^ilings$for$living$
expenses$while$claiming$that$he$needed$said$funds$because$Plaintiff$caused$
him$to$lose$his$previous$job,$which$was$another$false$narrative.$This$pattern$
of$conduct$of$using$Plaintiff$to$raise$funds$keeps$the$false$narratives$going,$
while$enriching$the$Defendants.$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
8/27
8
31. In$August$2013,$Plaintiffs$wife$advised$Defendants$Hoge,$Walker$and$McCain$
that$she$did$not$want$them$raising$any$money$on$her$behalf$or$using$her$
name,$and$asked$them$to$remove$all$blog$and$Twitter$tweets$they$had$
published$about$her$since$July$9,$2013$because$they$were$inaccurate$and$
harmful$to$her$family.$$She$also$asked$Defendant$Hoge$to$refund$all$the$
donations$he$has$gotten$using$her$name.$Defendants$refused$to$remove$the$
blog$posts$and$tweets,$including$those$posts$asking$people$to$send$money$for$
Plaintiffs$wife.$
32. In$July$and$August$2013,$Defendants$Walker,$Hoge,$McCain,$Akbar$and$KU$all$
published$blog$posts$and$tweets$quoting$from$a$defamatory$^iling$prepared$
by$Defendant$Walker$in$the$Family$Court$case.$$That$^iling$falsely$accused$
Plaintiff$of$rape,$pedophilia$and$domestic$violence.$$Defendant$Walker$also$
prepared$a$defamatory$^iling$that$he$manipulated$Plaintiffs$wife$to$^ile$with$
the$Montgomery$County$States$Attorney$falsely$accusing$Plaintiff$of$criminal$
activity.$$That$criminal$charge$was$nolle$prossed$on$August$23,$2013.$$
33. On$August$23,$2013,$Plaintiffs$wife$^iled$to$dismiss$the$Family$Court$case$and$
told$Defendants$Walker,$Hoge$and$McCain$that$she$did$not$want$to$pursue$it,$
and$that$the$allegations$Defendant$Walker$wrote$for$her$in$court$^ilings$and$
online$were$inaccurate.$$Defendant$Walker$responded$by$falsely$suggesting$
that$Plaintiff$was$blackmailing$Plaintiffs$wife.$$Defendant$Walker$urged$her$
to$destroy$Plaintiffs$family$by$continuing$with$the$false$narratives$he$
prepared$for$her.!Defendant$Walker$then$refused$her$requests$to$remove$
posts/articles$already$written$by$him,$and$claimed$that$Plaintiff$was$an$un^it$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
9/27
9
father$and$that$Plaintiffs$wife$knew$it,$and$she$should$leave$him$and$take$the$
children$from$him$as$soon$as$possible.
34. Defendant$Akbar$stated$on$or$about$August$18,$2013,$that$he$controls$
Defendants$Hoge,$Walker$and$McCain$and$can$ord er$them$to$stop$posting$
negative$stories$about$another$person.
35. Defendant$Akbar$tweeted$many$times$in$July$and$August$2013,$that$Plaintiff$
is$a$criminal$pedophile,$rapist$and$abuser$of$women.$$
36. Defendants$Walker,$Hoge,$McCain,$Akbar$and$KU$promoted$the$unauthorized$
fundraising$tool$and$pro^ited$from$the$money$raised.$$Defendant$Hoge,$who$
controlled$the$money$raised$through$his$PayPal$account,$refused$Plaintiffs$
wifes$demand$that$all$the$money$be$returned$to$the$donors,$instead$saying$
he$would$give$it$to$charity.$$
37. Defendant$McCain$published$accounts$on$Defendant$Akbars$and$his$The!
Other!McCain$and$Viral!Read!websites$in$which$he$called$Plaintiff$$a$vile,$
sadistic,$and$abusive$person.$$He$attacked$a$reporter$from$the$Washington$
Post$who$wrote$a$positive$story$about$Plaintiffs$family$in$2007$calling$her$
and$the$Washington$post$agents$of$evil.$He$went$even$furthering$a$July$16,$
2013$web$post:
$The$Washington!Post$is$a$disgrace$to$journalism$that$employs$hired$liars$like$Monica$Hesse.$The$Washington!Post$and$Monica$Hesse$are$engaged$in$a$
conspiracy$to$conceal$the$truth$about$Brett$Kimberlin.$In$2007,$Monica$Hesse$did$not$tell$the$truth$about$Brett$Kimberlin,$and$in$2013,$she$will$not$tell$the$truth$about$Brett$Kimberlin.$The$truth$about$Brett$Kimberlin$has$never$been$printed$in$theWashington!Post,$nor$will$it$ever$be.$No$honest$person$would$work$for$the$Washington!Post,$which$only$publishes$evil$lies.
https://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttp://theothermccain.com/2012/07/05/when-jessica-was-10-11-12/https://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttp://www.breitbart.com/Big-Journalism/2010/10/11/Progressives-Embrace-Convicted-Terroristhttp://www.breitbart.com/Big-Journalism/2010/10/11/Progressives-Embrace-Convicted-Terroristhttp://theothermccain.com/2012/07/05/when-jessica-was-10-11-12/http://theothermccain.com/2012/07/05/when-jessica-was-10-11-12/https://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttps://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttps://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttps://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttp://www.breitbart.com/Big-Journalism/2010/10/11/Progressives-Embrace-Convicted-Terroristhttp://www.breitbart.com/Big-Journalism/2010/10/11/Progressives-Embrace-Convicted-Terroristhttps://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttps://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttps://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replieshttps://twitter.com/MonicaHesse/with_replies -
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
10/27
10
He$further$attacked$Plaintiffs$daughter$in$at$least$one$tweet$on$August$28,$
2013.
38. Defendant$KU$has$created$a$website$called$Kimberlin$Unmasked$and$a$
Twitter$site$@Kimberlinunmask$at$which$he$falsely$accuses$Plaintiff$of$
various$crimes$including$pedophilia,$rape$and$domestic$violence.$$These$sites$
are$intended$to$smear$and$harm$Plaintiffs$reputation$with$false$allegations,$
innuendo,$speculation,$false$associations$and$false$accusations$of$supervision.$
39. Defendants$are$not$legitimate$journalists$and$they$do$not$follow$the$Society$
of$Professional$Journalist$Code$of$Ethics.$$
The*Lawsuits,*Peace*Orders*and*Criminal*Charges
40. Defendant$Walker$has$^iled$the$following$lawsuits,$Peace$Orders$and$criminal$
charges$against$Plaintiff$since$January$2012:
January$31,$2012,$Montgomery$County$District$Court,$One$Count$Perjury$
(nolle$prossed$February$10,$2012)
April$17,$2012,$Montgomery$County$District$Court,$Five$Counts$Perjury$(nolle$
prossed$April$30,$2012)
January$30,$2012,$Prince$William$Virginia$Circuit$Court,$Multiple$Counts$
Alleging$Criminal$and$Civil$Torts$(dismissed$by$judge$December$4,$2012)
June$22,$2012,$United$States$District$Court$Maryland,$Greenbelt,$Multiple$Civil$
Torts,$(dismissed$by$judge$November$26,$2012)
March$13,$2013,$Montgomery$County$District$Court,$Peace$Order$(denied$by$
judge$on$March$13,$2013)
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
11/27
11
December$2011,$Montgomery$County$Circuit$Court,$numerous$^ilings$for$Seth$
Allen$alleging$fraud$and$perjury$(denied$January$9,$2012)
July$30,$2013,$Montgomery$County$District$Court,$prepared$pleading$in$
Family$Court$matter$alleging$rape$and$domestic$violence$(denied$August$12,$
2013)
July$29,$2013,$Montgomery$County$District$Court,$prepared$criminal$charge$
for$third$degree$sexual$assault$(nolle$prossed$August$23,$2013)
41. Defendant$Hoge$has$^iled$the$following$Peace$Orders$and$criminal$charges$$$$$
against$Plaintiff$since$February$18,$2013:
February$18,$2013,$Carroll$County$District$Court,$Two$Counts$Harassment$
(nolle$prossed$April$17,$2013)
March$22,$2013,$Carroll$County$District$Court,$One$Count$Harassment$(nolle
$ prossed$April$17,$2013)
March$22,$2013,$Carroll$County$District$Court,$Peace$Order$(denied$March$29,$
2013)
April$3,$2013,$Carroll$County$Circuit$Court,$Peace$Order$Appeal$(denied$July$
2,$1013)
42. Plaintiff$has$been$required$to$respond$to$many$of$the$above$frivolous$and$
malicious$legal$^ilings,$and$has$been$forced$to$appear$in$court$to$attend$
mandatory$hearings$on$more$than$a$dozen$occasions,$including$having$to$
drive$long$distances$to$Manassas,$Virginia$where$the$Prince$William$County$
Circuit$Court$is$located,$and$to$Westminster,$Maryland$where$the$Carroll$
County$Courts$are$located.$$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
12/27
12
43. Plaintiff$has$expended$legal$fees$to$an$attorney$to$represent$him$in$one$of$the$
Peace$Orders$in$Carroll$County.$$Plaintiff$has$borne$costs$of$responding$
including$mailing,$copies,$transcripts,$audio$^iles,$transportation$and$other$
costs.$
44. Some$speci^ic$examples$of$Defendants$defamatory$publications$are$as$
follows:
Aaron*WalkerAllergic2Bull,*Twitter@AaronWorthing,*Gazette
August$28,$2013`Bethesda$Gazette`Comments$believed$to$be$written$or$
directed$by$Defendant$Walker$under$one$or$more$names`Brettcommitted$
rape
August$15,$2013`Vile,$Brett$Kimberlins$Manipulation$of$His$Daughter
August$12,$2013`$Brett$Kimberlin$is$an$out`and`out$pedophile
August$6,$2013`The$Pedophile$Brett$Kimberlins$Brass$Knickle$Defense
August$5,$2013`So$Why$is$the$Pedophile$Brett$Kimberlin$Mad$at$Us
August$3,$2015`For$the$Pedophile$Brett$Kimberlin,$Its$All$About$the$Kids
August$1,$2013`if$you$just$believe$in$helping$get$her$kids$away$from$her$
pedophile$husband
July$31,$2013`Pedophile$Brett$Kimberlin$Violates$A$Domestic$Violence$
Protective$Order
July$30,$2013`Brett$Kimberlin$is$a$Pedophile
August$10,$2013 Twitter`LG$is$the$paid$troll$of$pedophile$Brett$Kimberlin
August$10,$2013`Twitter`I$suggest$we$rechristen$Team$Kimberlin$as$Team$
Pedophilia
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
13/27
13
August$6,$2013`Twitter`The$Pedophile$#BrettKimberlin$Brass$Knuckle$
Defense
August$5,$2013`Twitter`Why$is$Pedophile$#BrettKimberlin$Mad$At$Us
August$4,$2013`Twitter`Brett$Kimberlin$will$have$his$trial.$$But$I$dont$have$to$
wait$to$call$him$a$pedo.$
August$3,$2013`Twitter`Yes,$#Brett$Kimberlin$is$a$pedo$regardless$of$charges
July$31,$2013`Twitter`#Brett$Kimberlin$Violates$A$Domestic$Violence$
Protective$Order$
July$30,$2013`Twitter`next$hearing$date$will$be$in$circuit$court,$where$
PedoBrett$tends$to$lose.$
July$29,$2013`Twitter`Brett$Kimberlin$is$a$Pedophile
July$29,$2013`Twitter`What$does$#Brett$Kimberlin,$who$tried$to$have$sex$with$
a$12`year$old,$deserve?
July$29,$2013`Twitter`I$am$not$calling$him$allegedly$anything.$He$is$a$
pedophile.$
July$29,$2013`Twitter`So$I$am$going$to$say$something$de^initive.$#Brett$
Kimberlin$is$a$pedophile.
William*HogeHogewash*and*Twitter*@wjjhoge
August$15,$2013`She$not$only$needs$help$with$the$legal$expense$involved$in$
getting$herself$and$her$daughters$free$from$Brett,$she$needs$help$resettling$
herself
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
14/27
14
August$14,$2013 $The$Kimberbots$are$the$fanboys,$cheerleaders,$and$enablers$
who$tweet$and$blog$their$admiration$and$support$for$The$Dread$Pedo$
Kimberlin
August$13,$2013 $You$can$donate$to$help$Tetyana$get$herself$and$her$children$
away$from$her$abusive$husband.$Click$on$the$Tetyanas$Fund$$link$to$learn$
more.
August$13,$2013 $Tetyana$Kimberlin$is$trying$to$get$herself$free$from$her$
abusive$husband.$She$is$trying$to$get$her$children$away$from$her$pedophile$
husband.
August$12,$2013 $During$that$time,$he$has$used$mentally$abusive$tactics$to$
keep$her$and$her$children$bound$to$him
August$1,$2013`Brett$Kimberlin,$Dread$Pedo$Kimberlin
July$30,$2013 $However,$I$do$believe$that$Brett$Kimberlin$most$likely$is$a$
pedophile.
July$29`August$15,$2013`Twitter`Team$Kimberlin$Post$of$the$Day$(directing$
readers$to$his$Hogewash$posts$above)
July$29,$2013`Twitter`Brett$Kimberlin:Pedophile?
Robert*Stacy*McCainThe*Other*McCain
July$18,$2013`If$Brett$Kimberlin$hates$you,$he$will$do$anything$within$his$
power$to$harm$you$$even$though$he$derives$no$bene^it$from$these$
destructive$acts$other$than$the$sadistic$vengeful$pleasure$of$in^licting$harm.
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
15/27
15
July$18,$2013 $Evil$is$what$Brett$Kimberlin$is.$Evil$is$what$Brett$Kimberlin$
does.$Everyone$who$assists$Brett$Kimberlin$is$an$accomplice$to$evil,$and$
silence$about$Brett$Kimberlins$evil$is$a$form$of$assistance
Ali*AkbarTwitter@ali
August$13,$2013`Twitter`Were$about$to$raise$some$money$for$an$abused$
immigrant$trying$to$escape$#BrettKimberlin.
August$9,$2013`Twitter`pointed$out$Brett$Kimberlins$pedophilia
July$31,$2013`Twitter`Pedophile$and$terrorist$bomber$#Brett$Kimberlin
July$31,$2013`Twitter`$Police,$myself,$and$everyone$who$has$written$seriously$
on$the$matter$believe$that$#BrettKimberlin$killed$a$grandma$to$sleep$with$a$
10$yr$old.
July$31,$2013`Twitter`#Brett$Kimberlin$has$no$moral$equivalent$this$side$of$
Satan.
July$31,$2013`Twitter`#BrettKimberlin$is$a$pedophile.$
July$31,$2013`Twitter`So$weve$uncovered$#BrettKimberlins$big$secret:$hes$a$
pedophile$with$other$pedophiles$around$his$children!
KimberlinUnMaskedKimberlinUnmasked*Blog*and*Twitter*
@KimberlinUnmask
August$13,$2013`Bill$Schmalfeldt$is$the$worst$misogynist$Ive$ever$heard$of,$
except$Brett$Kimberlin
July$30,$2013`I$am$going$to$re`name$Team$Kimberlin$to$Team$Pedo.$$Its$
shorter$and$its$in$Brett$Kimberlins$honor.$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
16/27
16
August$1,$2013 $The$implications$of$Brett$Kimberlin$selling$viagra$are$
disturbing,$considering$we$are$talking$pedophilia
July$29,$2013`Brett$Kimberlin,$Pedophile?
July`August$2013`KimberlinUnmask$superimposed$a$copyrighted$photo$of$
Plaintiffs$face$on$to$a$what$is$understood$to$be$a$graphic$of$a$pedophilia$bear$
to$portray$Plaintiff$as$a$pedophile.$$He$did$this$without$consent.
45. The$statements$of$the$Defendants$as$set$out$above$cast$Plaintiff$in$a$false$
light.
46. Defendants$purpose$in$publishing$the$above$statements$was$to$cause$injury$
to$Plaintiffs$reputation,$business$and$family.
47. The$false$statements$above$have$caused$Plaintiff$serious$emotional$distress,$
embarrassment,$humiliation$and$mental$anguish.$
48. Plaintiff$has$repeatedly$asked$Defendant$Walker$and$Defendant$Hoge$to$leave$
him$and$his$family$alone$but$they$hove$continued$to$harass$and$stalk$him$and$
his$family,$both$online$and$in$person.$$
49. Plaintiff$has$asked$Defendant$KimberlinUnmask$to$remove$copywrited$
photos$from$his$blog$site$but$KimberlinUnmask$not$only$refused$to$do$so$but$
actually$posted$more$copyrighted$photos$along$with$insults$and$mocking$
stating$that$he$would$never$remove$any$material$from$the$blog.
50. Plaintiffs$wife$repeatedly$asked$Defendants$Walker,$Hoge$and$McCain$to$
remove$posts$about$her$and$her$family$from$their$websites$and$Twitter$but$
they$have$refused$to$do$so.$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
17/27
17
COUNT*I
Malicious*Prosecution
51. Plaintiff$incorporates$paragraphs$1`49$above.
52. Defendants$Walker$and$Hoge$have$engaged$in$a$pattern$of$^iling$abusive$civil$
suits,$peace$orders$and$criminal$charges$against$Plaintiff,$all$of$which$have$
been$dismissed$or$denied,$for$the$purpose$of$creating$false$narratives$about$
Plaintiff$that$they$then$publish$as$gospel,$thereby$harming$Plaintiff,$his$
business$interests$and$his$family.$$These$^ilings$have$been$done$with$malice$
and$without$probable$cause.$$Defendants$have$used$these$false,$malicious$
^ilings$to$raise$signi^icant$funds$to$enrich$themselves.
53. Defendants$false$and$malicious$prosecutions$have$caused$Plaintiff$to$sustain$
damages.
54. Defendants$actions$against$Plaintiff$were$willful,$wanton$and$malicious,$were$
intended$to$deliberately$harm$Plaintiff,$and$were$made$with$a$callous$
indifference$to$Plaintiff.
55. Thus,$in$^iling$malicious$legal$actions$against$Plaintiff,$Defendants$acted$with$
an$improper$and$outrageous$motive$or$callous$indifference$to$Plaintiffs$
rights$and$interests.$$As$a$result$of$Defendants$outrageous$and$repeated$
conduct,$Defendants$should$be$ordered$to$pay$substantial$punitive$damages.$$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
18/27
18
COUNT*II
Conspiracy*to*Abuse*Process
56. Plaintiff$incorporates$paragraphs$1`49$above.
57. Defendants$Walker,$Hoge,$Akbar,$McCain$and$KimberlinUnmask$have$$$$$$
conspired$to$engage$in$a$pattern$of$^iling$abusive$civil$suits,$peace$orders$and$
criminal$charges$against$Plaintiff,$all$of$which$have$been$dismissed$or$denied,$
for$the$purpose$of$creating$false$narratives$about$Plaintiff$that$they$then$
publish$as$gospel,$thereby$harming$Plaintiff,$his$business$interests$and$his$
family.$$These$^ilings$have$been$done$with$malice$and$without$probable$cause.$$
Defendants$have$used$these$false,$malicious$^ilings$to$raise$signi^icant$funds$
to$enrich$themselves.
58. Defendants$conspiracy$of$false$and$malicious$prosecutions$have$caused$
Plaintiff$to$sustain$damages.
59. Defendants$actions$against$Plaintiff$were$willful,$wanton$and$malicious,$were$
intended$to$deliberately$harm$Plaintiff,$and$were$made$with$a$callous$
indifference$to$Plaintiff.
60. Thus,$in$^iling$malicious$legal$actions$against$Plaintiff,$Defendants$acted$with$
an$improper$and$outrageous$motive$or$callous$indifference$to$Plaintiffs$
rights$and$interests.$$As$a$result$of$Defendants$outrageous$and$repeated$
conduct,$Defendants$should$be$ordered$to$pay$substantial$punitive$damages.$$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
19/27
19
COUNT*III
Defamation
61. Plaintiff$incorporates$paragraphs$1`49$above.
62. Defendants$have$intentionally,$knowingly$and/or$recklessly$published$and$
disseminated$the$false$and$defamatory$statements$identi^ied$above$on$the$
Internet$where$they$have$been$easily$accessible,$and$were$accessed$my$many$
people,$including$Plaintiffs$family,$children,$friends,$business$associates$and$
actual$and$prospective$partners$and$others.
63. The$statements$have$caused$and$continue$to$cause$substantial$injury$to$
Plaintiff,$his$business$and$personal$well`being.$
64. The$statements$have$caused$and$continue$to$cause$deep$embarrassment,$
humiliation,$opprobrium,$emotional$distress$and$mental$suffering$to$Plaintiff.
65. Defendants$false$and$defamatory$statements$and$the$implications$drawn$
from$them$concerning$Plaintiff$are$defamatory$per!se!because$they$make$
Plaintiff$appear$odious,$infamous,$and/or$frightening.$
66. Defendants$published$these$false$and$defamatory$statements$to$third$parties$
who$reasonably$understood$the$published$statements$to$be$defamatory.$
67. Defendants$were$aware$of$the$defamatory$implication$of$their$statements$
about$Plaintiff,$and$intended$and$endorsed$the$defamatory$implication.
68. Defendants$published$these$false$and$defamatory$statements$about$Plaintiff$
even$though$they$knew$that$Plaintiff$had$told$them$to$leave$him$and$his$
family$alone.
69. Defendants$published$these$false$and$defamatory$statements$about$Plaintiff$
with$knowledge$of$their$falsity$and/or$reckless$disregard$for$their$truth.
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
20/27
20
70. Alternatively,$Defendants$published$these$false$and$defamatory$statements$
about$Plaintiff$negligently$as$the$truth$or$falsity$of$what$they$were$saying.$
71. Each$of$the$Defendants$was$directly$involved$and$responsible$for$the$false$
and$defamatory$statements$that$were$published$about$Plaintiff.
72. Defendants$published$these$false$and$defamatory$statements$with$both$
common$law$and$actual$malice,$and$with$the$intent$of$harming$Plaintiff.
73. Defendants$published$these$false$and$defamatory$statements$day$after$day,$
week$after$week,$with$the$attacks$becoming$more$aggressive$and$nastier$as$
time$progressed.$
74. Defendants$also$published$these$defamatory$and$false$statements$in$order$to$
increase$traf^ic$to$their$blogs$and$to$raise$money$from$unsuspecting$readers$
who$believed$their$statements.$
75. Defendants$false$and$defamatory$statements$have$caused$Plaintiff$to$sustain$
damages.
76. Defendants$actions$against$Plaintiff$were$willful,$wanton$and$malicious,$were$
intended$to$deliberately$harm$Plaintiff,$and$were$made$with$a$callous$
indifference$to$Plaintiff.
77. Defendants$refused$Plaintiffs$request$to$be$left$alone$and$refused$Plaintiffs$
wifes$request$to$remove$the$defamatory$and$false$statements$despite$
knowing$that$what$they$had$published$about$Plaintiff$was$false$and$
defamatory$and$had$caused$damage$to$Plaintiff$and$his$family.$
78. Thus,$in$publishing$the$numerous$false$and$defamatory$statements$about$
Plaintiff,$Defendants$acted$with$an$improper$and$outrageous$motive$or$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
21/27
21
callous$indifference$to$Plaintiffs$rights$and$interests.$$As$a$result$of$
Defendants$outrageous$and$repeated$conduct,$Defendants$should$be$ordered$
to$pay$substantial$punitive$damages.$$
COUNT*IV
False*Light*Invasion*of*Privacy
79. $Plaintiff$incorporates$paragraphs$1`49$above.
80. Defendants$statements$and$articles$above$contained$false$statements,$
representations$or$imputations$about$Plaintiff$that$place$her$in$a$false$light.
81. As$stated$in$Count$III$above,$Defendants$falsely$depicted$Plaintiff$a$rapist,$
pedophile$and$domestic$violence$abuser,
82. Defendant$KimberlinUnmask$depicted$Plaintiffs$face$on$a$pedo$bear$graphic$
in$order$to$falsely$depict$Plaintiff$as$a$pedophile.$$
83. The$false$light$in$which$Defendants$placed$Plaintiff$would$be$considered$
highly$offensive$to$a$reasonable$person.
84. Defendants$were$each$complicit$in$and$responsible$for$casting$Plaintiff$in$a$
false$light.
85. Defendants$disseminated$their$articles$on$their$websites$where$they$were$
widely$available$to$and$accessible$by$members$of$the$general$public$in$
Maryland$and$beyond.$$
86. Defendants$knew$that$their$actions$and$statements$had$the$effect$of$casting$
Plaintiff$in$a$false$light$but$nevertheless$continued$to$do$so$week$after$week,$
article$after$article$and$tweet$after$tweet.$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
22/27
22
87. Alternatively,$Defendants$were$negligent$in$the$publication$of$their$
statements$about$Plaintiff,$the$effect$of$which$was$to$portray$Plaintiff$in$a$
false$light.$
88. Defendants$portrayal$of$Plaintiff$in$a$false$light,$as$stated$above,$caused$
substantial$injury$to$Plaintiffs$reputation,$business$interests,$and$mental$
well`being.$$
89. Defendants$placing$Plaintiff$in$a$false$light$has$caused$Plaintiff$to$sustain$
substantial$damages.
90. Defendants$actions$against$Plaintiff$were$willful,$wanton$and$malicious,$and$
were$intended$to$deliberately$harm$Plaintiff.
91. Defendants$refused$Plaintiffs$requests$to$be$left$alone$and$Plaintiffs$wifes$
request$to$remove$the$defamatory$articles$and$tweets$knowing$that$what$
they$had$published$had$cast$Plaintiff$in$a$false$light$and$had$caused$serious$
injury$to$him.
92. Thus,$Defendants$acted$with$an$improper$and$outrageous$motive$or$careless$
indifference$to$Plaintiffs$rights$and$interests.$$Defendants$outrageous$
conduct$warrants$the$imposition$of$signi^icant$punitive$damages.$$
COUNT*V
Harassment
93. Plaintiff$incorporates$paragraphs$1`49$above.
94. Plaintiff$has$repeatedly$asked$Defendants,$both$directly$and$indirectly,$to$be$
left$alone.
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
23/27
23
95. Defendants$have$refused$to$leave$Plaintiff$alone$and$they$have$published$and$
continue$to$publish$false$and$defamatory$articles$and$tweets$about$Plaintiff$
on$a$regular$and$even$daily$basis.$$Defendant$Hoge$publishes$a$Team$
Kimberlin$post$of$the$day.$$Defendant$KimberlinUnmask$created$a$blog$and$a$
Twitter$account$speci^ically$to$attack$Plaintiff$with$harassing$and$defamatory$
publications.$Defendant$McCain$harasses$Plaintiff$on$his$blog$with$regular$
attacks,$and$even$attacks$people$who$publish$positive$articles$about$Plaintiff$
or$his$family.$$Defendant$Akbar$issues$orders$to$the$other$Defendants$to$
attack$Plaintiff,$and$then$does$so$himself.$$
96. Defendants$Walker$and$Hoge$have$appeared$at$court$hearings$involving$
Plaintiff$in$which$they$were$not$a$party.$$On$July$9,$2013,$Defendants$Walker$
and$Hoge$followed$Plaintiffs$wife$out$of$a$family$court$hearing$and$badgered$
and$frightened$her,$and$later$even$wrote$defamatory$legal$^ilings$that$they$
compelled$her$to$^ile$while$she$was$suffering$duress$and$manipulated$her$
into$acquiescing$to$their$demands$to$harm$Plaintiff.!When$she$told$them$that$
she$wanted$nothing$more$to$do$with$them,$Defendant$Walker$defamed$
Plaintiff,$calling$him$an$un^it$father.$$He$begged$her$not$to$remain$with$her$
Plaintiff$husband.
97. Defendants$McCain$and$Akbar$appeared$at$a$family$court$hearing$on$July$29,$
2013,$and$offered$Plaintiffs$wife$things$of$value$to$turn$against$Plaintiff.$$
98. Plaintiffs$wife$asked$Defendants$Walker,$Hoge$and$McCain$to$remove$blog$
posts$and$tweets$they$had$published$about$her$and$Plaintiff$but$those$
requests$have$been$refused.
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
24/27
24
99. Defendants$harassment$has$been$a$malicious$course$of$conduct,$and$they$
have$done$so$in$public$places$and$on$the$Internet$for$the$purpose$of$seriously$
annoying$and$alarming$him.$$
100.Defendants$have$harassed$Plaintiff$intentionally$and$with$malice$in$order$to$
harm$Plaintiff.
101.Defendants$harassment$has$caused$substantial$damage$and$injury$to$
Plaintiff.
102.Thus,$Defendants$acted$with$an$improper$and$outrageous$motive$or$careless$
indifference$to$Plaintiffs$rights$and$interests.$$Defendants$outrageous$
conduct$warrants$the$imposition$of$signi^icant$punitive$damages.
COUNT*VI
Inliction*Of*Emotional*Distress
103.Plaintiff$incorporates$paragraphs$1`49$above.$
104.Defendants,$by$engaging$in$a$multi`year$course$of$conduct$of$malicious$
prosecution,$stalking,$harassment,$defamation,$invasion$of$privacy,$and$
conspiracy,$have$caused$Plaintiff$in^liction$of$emotional$distress.$$
105.Defendants$conduct$has$been$intentional,$reckless,$extreme$and$outrageous.$$
The$Defendants$have$said$that$they$want$to$destroy$Plaintiff,$to$ruin$his$
family$and$business$and$to$see$him$imprisoned.$$They$have$created$false$
narratives$and$^iled$and$conspired$to$^ile$malicious$legal$complaints$in$order$
to$harm$Plaintiff$and$line$their$pockets$with$donations$from$unsuspecting$
readers.$$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
25/27
25
106. There$is$a$causal$and$direct$connection$between$the$Defendants$wrongful$
conduct$and$Plaintiffs$emotional$distress.
107. The$distress$caused$by$Defendants$conduct$has$been$severe$and$caused$
substantial$damage$and$injury$to$Plaintiff.
108. Thus,$Defendants$acted$with$an$improper$and$outrageous$motive$to$
Plaintiffs$rights$and$interests.$$Defendants$outrageous$conduct$warrants$the$
imposition$of$signi^icant$punitive$damages.$$
COUNT*VIIStalking
103 Plaintiff$incorporates$paragraphs$1`49$above.
104 Defendants$Walker,$Hoge,$Ali$and$McCain$have$engaged$in$a$course$of$conduct$
of$approaching$and$pursuing$Plaintiff$knowing$that$conduct$reasonably$
placed$Plaintiff$in$reasonable$fear$of$assault.
105 Defendants$stalking$has$placed$Plaintiff$in$reasonable$fear$of$assault.$$This$
reasonable$fear$is$based$on$an$assault$of$Plaintiff$by$Defendant$Walker$on$
January$9,$2012$in$the$Montgomery$County$Circuit$Courthouse$when$he$
came$to$a$hearing$uninvited$and$attacked$Plaintiff.$That$assault$landed$
Plaintiff$in$the$hospital.$$Defendant$Walker$has$repeatedly$stated$that$he$
carries$weapons$and$that$he$wants$to$destroy$Plaintiff.$$$Defendants$Walker$
and$Hoge$told$Plaintiffs$wife$that$they$want$to$put$Plaintiff$in$prison$for$the$
rest$of$his$life.$$
106 Defendant$Walker$has$repeatedly$called$state$and$federal$law$enforcement$
of^icials$and$made$false$reports$to$them$that$Plaintiff$has$committed$crimes.$$
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
26/27
26
Defendant$Walker$called$the$FBI$on$or$about$August$12,$2013$and$told$them$
to$surprised$Plaintiffs$wife$at$a$location$known$to$him,$and$Defendant$
Walker$told$the$FBI$falsely$that$Plaintiffs$wife$would$provide$evidence$of$
crimes$by$Plaintiff$to$the$FBI.$$When$the$FBI$talked$with$Plaintiffs$wife,$she$
stated$that$Plaintiff$did$not$commit$the$crimes$alleged$by$Defendant$Walker.
107 Defendants$have$stalked$Plaintiff$intentionally$and$with$malice$in$order$to$
harm$Plaintiff.
108 Defendants$stalking$has$caused$substantial$damage$and$injury$to$Plaintiff.
109 Thus,$Defendants$acted$with$an$improper$and$outrageous$motive$or$careless$
indifference$to$Plaintiffs$rights$and$interests.$$Defendants$outrageous$
conduct$warrants$the$imposition$of$signi^icant$punitive$damages.
WHEREFORE,$Plaintiff$Brett$Kimberlin$respectfully$requests$that$the$Court$enter$
judgment$as$follows:
1. Awarding$Plaintiff$compensatory$damages$in$an$amount$to$be$determined$at$
trial;
2. Awarding$Plaintiff$punitive$damages$of$no$less$than$1$million;
3. Awarding$Plaintiff$costs$and$other$expenses;$and
4. Awarding$Plaintiff$such$other$and$further$relief$as$the$Court$deems$just$and$
proper.
-
7/27/2019 KimberlinVWalker Civil Suit Redacted
27/27
JURY*DEMAND
Plaintiff$Brett$Kimberlin$hereby$demands$a$jury$trial$on$all$claims$triable.
Dated$this$30th$day$of$August,$2013.
$ $ $ $ $ $ Respectfully$submitted,
$ $ $ $ $ $ Brett$Kimberlin$ $ $ $ $ $ 8100$Beech$Tree$Road$ $ $ $ $ $ Bethesda,$MD$20817