8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

1/9

8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

2/9

Ε

kιι',

ι

s.hιl,ιrη L'i'Μ \

τhen a 'laιrΙe .ο lseξ

λ

gn,uP oΙ s.hoΙ..s

Ψhο ιιaνe

suli].ienr ren,ι,.es

(ιnd

ahο

wo.ι ΦnL.οoPcraιire ιeφsitorie,.aο.Ιeate

xn

editi..ΓexEaoΙ.jnaιy d.pth

and

ιi.hnesl'

an edniοo ιhat

Ñ ονidel

Lotιr rhe eτide.ce

and the

llnaι

ñrodu.τ

a

(ans.nbed

text

Md

tιr. nnages o.rne

natci],ι ιlrcy ro.ked

..οn

iη

pιod(ing

tne

edrion

τhey

.an in.]udc aιd]o and

νlddο .ιiñs,

ιlgιr υaιi.y

.olo. .epιodu.nons

oε

art woΙkl, and

inteΙtrιtiνe nrΦs.

o.

Φulτineaix

Ιiiis6

sυ.lr δ vriιliιnr BΙaιe

ind

Dante

GibricΙ Ro$er1

rhe µnelits

de.ιear

mιιh

mοie adcqι.ιe rcpiosenτaιon

o|

ιhei. ιorFιcr ncιricτemeηιs

ιiιe$ise it n now

noslbιe

tο

trΙ.k trnd

Pιelent

in οnι

.onvcnienr

iΙtr.e

the

i.oooeιaphi.

radn]on of

D,,

Q,lΙ,,'

a n.veι τhat

hδ

bee.

1eιrea.edI,

n [*Ιltod

in

r'ays

'i.n

wnn

io.eητeιiτe

Ñ.ssiΕ'iljnes

ι) aαιl .he Uniνeζnt

ο| ι'Ι.hig]n

(

8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

3/9

Εhοηιn

sibιtnι

Εn'i∆

439

τh]oko|drι δ anÑrobΙαnati., aΙ cι]]tion τi.houι bis, o|.οιse,

rhe.e

a.r prcbleηι

wnh djis vierv, Ιoi one dΙnrg, aΙl rdniοns ιxv.

Ι

pespc.tivo

and

ηaL.

Φmι

vieqs

mοre av]iιabΙe

dnn

οtheιs'

An

aud]ο..enEred

ñroje.r

Ιn1v

]mΙrly.

hbg.ΙPhjca|

fΙaneιvΟΙι nf Ιea.ling' whne a

gende.

spe.iI].

Proie.t

likε

rhe B.own

ιηr]γeisiιy

νlome.

v1neΛ Ñroje.t

(

<

hrp:/]wΙπ

bΠ]wn

ddu/>)

imÑlle'

τhat.hε

ιeitsshοuΙdbe

.eid('iιhgen.le.δ akey

in.e|ñΙe.iτe

]ens

NeuriIjry{nn3I]Ιoo.añοlsi6rιnvPeτoΙ

Rοbnsoo aιi ιΙn∆s $αnιcr Gtrb]cr luve obseFed drιt .{Perirr.nG wnh

.Ιr.

dcsigη

o1

ele.E.ni. textual

ednlοιs suggef lhΙt

mcie

δsembη,does

nοr

]νoid

ιh.

P.oblem

οr.ιΛnlg ο.l n,me νirws h

.rdeΙ n] οP.n uP x

Paitι.ulf

νicψ,

(Rιbinsoο

and

GaιrleΙ

2οοo:

])

Eνe. an

in.lusve

dlgiral

aΙ.hive I bοth an ana$ing ..

maιorja]

aΙ.]

l

s]ralring o|

ir

:Γιxt

s]r1Ping ιakes

tιx.e

l. a v2'ietv

o.

|aces'

io.ιιaing

nΙ

tΙre

ιnnoιatiotr, intoιlucιions, iαιerfιce. aιd naτ'galioα

Eιliιo6

arc sIrnι]ng t]reirduties

i|dre}

do.ot

ο|ΙeΙ

guidaΙ.e:

tλoy

aΓe

ind shoιιd

b.,

xΓιcr aΙι'

sonrthjn]]

nrore.lraη

bliαd,vaιιesοeurΙaΙdenvere∆.|gοods.,1ι.dto|,,οveitΙιhigιιighιjngsPeciic

ι..k\ is

Fnjbleman.

in th1r

ir seems

to

]sert

thar alΙ

wοΙΙ{s

ln a.οηΙδ

nr.

οΠ

dle

s2me

Γοoτi.g' Φhen

dre,

neve' a.e

sιll'

rheΙd aΙe degrees

o. e.]

roηil

nτcrνeΠ.ioni-

Some edlιiοns

ιre

ilτnyιnιen ιnιl

orher

x.e moΙe

ioτi.nrg

o. a

fiιι]riιulι.

ο|

A m]nei aΙraδΙse

|ο. i proie.r ma/

ñrο

c a ιniguc identiΙ]dr

ιi.]

}o.

cveΙy

d..uΙnιlt.reated Ly ]

ιvιneΙ

Ιl tttissensoiΙ]

docum.nr

ireequaι

ιeν

∆'lxnov]cι

ιEs

.οmmented lnrsΙeΙl.gΙy οn r|e πrΙe οlrΙe a1r]b1\d nl dlgital .ulru.e

ΑΓπ tιr.

.oι] σt]

suιrn

qιιιny

.nlιmtr

trn

] ι.g.J

.Ι.iΙ ιc

a

tllc

ι:ι y

loιm

ο.

ιnιu

exÑΙe*iοο in τhe

nroJeΙf,,ge, ιιre.onñuarigι

inτοdu.δ

ns.oftΙaιe dΣ J]ιtrι}ι1ι

Ινh.9 nεa nreJ]i

obF.a

Jο nοι ιει1{ones]

ιλεy

'jonι

lMve

bεgiioing.rgi.

iι

}:i('

rher

nοo,t

hale ]lv dιvelοPmenι,

.hιnΙi.i

]]'' nΙπilΙ

,l

οτheE'ne

vhi.h would

οig]ο,e ιιfι.ι.δεοa i]πο tr

sεguεn.ε

ΙοΙral' τ1rη' rε.olle.ιjoil

o.

nJ]liιn

teml,

sh{e

evtrΙ rιer his ιlre s2me ngnl|iιrη.ι λ

trnΙ

oιhei As a.ulιι,alIιln'

n]ε

J]ι,bι .

..p.εj.nG

ιlre

ψοnJ

trs

a

l]Ι

oi nens

and

n

rein:ε

tο

.rJσ

thil

ι

t ιi

ιοn(∆τ' ι nιπιιile.Ιeιιes ι.ιuSe ιnn .1Ιζc

trrι.ο.Ι

Ol5eemitglΙ

unοideΙeJ

rcmj

,ΙlreiεI.ore,

daτa6af ]nd

nxfaιive ι.e nrιrl

εοenles, cοrpetin ΙοΙ

dre

sJ]nε ιerιιoΙΙ

ο|hιdJ] .ι]τι.ι. ιx.h ι

Π]j rι

.Ι.ι.λ.

o8hι to .lJι. σ*rn]Dg

Dtrl ot

l]rι

lvDdn

.ι]8

ι1Mo i.n\ reΙnarks nοσnιrs]ndΙrg' ιhc bef cl..αοni. cdnn,s d[iνe .n nre

.omb]ncd

sιr.οgtΙs

oΙ

dΙt1irxse xnJ n]πtive. \τ/it]iιtl ιΙοiton hal

wntten drit

.ΙetrιΕ.Γdign]] relur.es may ιeel

τhe

iaιa o.

in.|udinr

eνerΙthing

in

2n edniΟn

is

'utrib]e

|or wrn.rs of

gΙeaτ

sjgnifi.an.ε

Υer such an apÑiοn.h nΙs n,ne negaιve .οnseqυenccs:

n .d be

5een δ

.]antrglflg

to i νιner(ιnd m]ght

be seen

δ

ζοuΠteηYodυ.ι]γe εoι

readeσ

anl]

edjtoE

ιlrenrelves)

ιr

lω(, tho d.cnl.n

ι] in.ludε

eΙe.vr]ring

tr

not xs clef

a

aoa|

o.

r

.obicc.iYe'in

appio.ch

ιs οne

mighr

rhink

Jυy

wιraι

ι

everything',,a.re.

ιΙl? Ιo.

eλ,nPle'

aΙe

ngn]tuies glven ro

aιτogr,Flr λι.res

part

.|φιxr

λ

eγerythnrg in a

πι]Ι

in.ι{iνe

εdinoΠ

οΓ.oιΙe.ted

iriiιnrgsl

sιrould raΙginalιa

be

iα.Ιιdcd? Ιl

&,'

d.es

ir

cοmιrne onιy

roι|s

ins.ribod nl nrΙgins

οΙ

Ιho

υndeιΙiοings ind symbο]jc

noι]ιons?

shoιιI aι1ιlΙes

boοΙs' sιοpñing an'l laundrf

ιιls ιJd

in.ΙΙdea,

whefl

rΙeJΙing

Ιiιh alΙο]ili.

Riner

su.h

as ν

B

Υeit1' ed1ιοs ar.l]]rol ι, asι

nremse|ves

ii

rhe.e

1re lifrns tο

what

z11

shoυ

ιd

be .onsΙucd ro bc ν'hπ

\eFa.aιes

wιι]om

aιi

 Ιadness

in

1Ñιoje.t.haι

seΒ out to reñres.nt eveiythiοg?

τhn

se.rion

sΙ(en

b, ιsking

]vhy

Fe.Ñle

aie

m]king

eιe.Φoαi.

ci]nioΙs'

aΠd

ro

some

cxιeοt ιhe nι.u$ion nΙs ιJ.uζed

on

t]re.,,l1,Ι a

o|e]e.tooi. edning Ι woυι]

ιΙgue

ι|ir

.hese veιy

.Ιr.ιΙ..ges cοnEibute b

the a(ιe.on

οΓ wοrking iο rhι

nrediιun'

Αι ιimes dιe.e is ]

ΙralÑab|e

exciιeιreo ι

Ιtroιndi∆g

aignal iaΙι

$emmiοg

nr

Γ2π

1iοnι

nf

bdιle. τh∆ is 2 ri.e

monre.τ

in

.lrc

hiforγ

o| s.hoιa6h1Ñ

Ιιnι]x

menι]|

]spe.ι\

..

ιireΙa.,

ed]tiαg

are ιφ 1.i

re.onsideΙatn,n:

τhe

s.ο],e οf ιΙlt cιn

ιld

undetaken'

nre

eΙtenr and ιl]vcsny οlthe

]ud]e..e'

and

ι]re

1ιer,

porenritrΙ

thar

drrουglr

e..o.lin

c]n bc cmbedaed in tex. and

eΠl .ι

fuιm fterñΙer]ιοnJ

lΙecω.j. enιing ..n bc

dluΙtiΠg

nnanζialιy' te.hnicalι,,

insnuriοnaΙη'.

aid

theoΦιi.alΙ, ]rιr

n

's

aιο a ne|d

oΓeΙlaηavenes

ιnιltoΙnend.us

Pο$ibr

i.y

Digital

Librri€

and ScholaΙΙy Ιdirioοs

Ιι

ι

wοtrhqh]]c ιo

antingιish

betwee. nre

υse|υ] .oοr1bιιiοns

nlde

by laΙle

s.ale

digιizit]on

Froie.s'

n]meιmes .elefed

.o

r ιl1gιι.Ι ιibia.y

prtrieπs

ani .he

more

tnre

gι

Πed.

sÑeιliιizεd

vo|ι

of an

ele.tosic

s.hοΙany

edjrn]n

Εa.]r

ι

ιΙιablc,

rhοugh

rheΙ

have

ιΙιl.eren.

pιo.cnιr.s

nld

Fιrñοse\

τhe

|vr1ι.b| Λ'bn.ι

Fn]i"

Fι,ie.r.an

be τake. is

n.e.Ιesentit]vc dignJ Li]ιy

Ñio]e.τ

1<

htl ,//qww'Ιetrs

indla.a

e.] υrFeb/dwnght21:,

),

Sι.h ..lιe.rn]n\ aΙe .yFr(aΙ|\ 6.' \Υ.rξ'}

Ατιnan

Ftrr,,

ι

]

tc,]ennoι∆

resοur.e

thar maιεs .ΙeeI, avai]nbΙe

∆earΙ),

].Οoο

wο'ι'

o.

∆mcri.ιnlictiooPubl]shedn.,ml8'ιro]8l5τh]sanbn]οusuΙdertaι{l.8hasLeeι

sιφPοitea

br

a..nntrnun .f |j]ξ τen

s.hooι

ιnυs

tnc Uniνersnv ..c|].xgο.

^s

ο|

seÑteπΙlrer,οο'

(the

mon .e.eηι

ιñιιxιe

nγail.bΙc) n.ΙΙΙ1 hxΙl

τhe

teΙ6 veΙe

fu ]'

.dndd and enΦded; ιhe

ιen

verc

ιncl]ircd

..Fιl]y

odπea,, 1n

r]rι

.on.eaι

nιins

Ñ.οol.ead

an.ι

.otre.tε.]

(riιΙrei

dιn

.em]iiing ]s reΙζ

.ΙΦreιl

τi.

οlti.xl .haΙtr.teι

Ιe.οgnn1on

(ocR)

flιh ι

hign nurEe.

ο.er.r)

The

..|υιlΙ

enιcd rcis aιο ιrale

sGιΙι

οgging d']t

enabιel

berE.

naτigiιio.

.o.lraιrιcr oi oιlrιrdiνιn,n\ wnrin

nre

..ι]οn

and l]nιs ΓΙ.r t|e r1bie...onιenE lo

nrese

d6'

Not

sιΙP.Λingι .

lx,lΙ,,

ΛfuσΙ || }1ι'|Ι

|Ιι'

s.ho

aιιy

τrollι.ιiοns.

aonotir]ons' ].J

.oιh.ιon o. ιeΙs,

ιιτe1a' ιhe.o

ιe.tιon

s m,ι]e uP

o| ΙuΙl

rαt

Ñresentatn].s

ο.rhe n.ιes ιιιcι] iΙ

ιyl.

lcr.ι.Γιi

ιo .oΙψο

the

ι]r1'ιυ].

rnnιlj

t\Ι ]i[rr $τn]DJ ΓιηuiΗ,nd

τhΙοa

the

Je.nonoιιlraι.

mfο11aΙι

an.] rhΙ..ο ιοoτ Ιπt

oοτo ιhe useΙ

tsιι uξ.6αFn ιhι

vΓ.ιΙ.o

ctrι]

.hιr .hΙoι 'r

.he

rtr,Aι

oΙ

jniitrπιtjη

Thq

r]Ι noι Ιlιe l].illξ

.onrotΙei]

oΙ man]FuΙiιed,

]rut

lhev

do

expeπ

rhe

ψαleΙ

tο bhzε kns

i.o1 drem

'

ι;\..

Jo. ι v τ

Φ

hrn'

nr

λ].ι

thει αiy

nπug|] nunJfuJj

oi dΦi1ι5

ar

.veΙι

ruf,.ιtε'

(Eoπon

Ι99]: 16ο)

8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

4/9

11ο

Ε ιdroι

n

5 ∆a|.t/ι Ειt'

k, 14]ι

1&ntshτ'

Αntkι

Fn|i,

18'1

]3|-5: λ

caιrriιιi'ι.tfuaΓ.ι d

Βibιiτltalh'

(\9'j|

ιeι

]96')

Τhe tciδ aΙe

piese.ιed

δ

page

imngcs aΠd

tιa.fΙiιtions

6δrd

οο

mrζ.ofiιm

ori8ina]Ιy

pΙ(,du.ed

ι,],

a.οmmeΙ.]aΙ

ιrft' PΙimaiy

soυr.c

Medii'

Ιi

ι

.et]ing drnt tι. lele.nοn

o.

te\Β

to|

'vτ+|ι

|hυtιι ι|d,,

wr

dιι.Ιmincd

by

x

Pre'cΙftng

.oΙnmert

ia|

venΦΙe

ιnd

νls

nοt basedοn.ind]ng

ιhe best teΙ6

a'ιiιalrιo

oi

b),

.reatnlg

ι ΓΙesh

..rι1.a]''

ednnl. τhe

ΙatteΙ

οPriοo

w6

oo

d.ubt

a

pra.ιi.aΙ

lmÑοlnbiιty

.oι

a

Ñioicα

.l rhis

.ale

Ιn

.oo(δι ro \v/; b|

Απεi.dι

|furι\

a1.elrt]η.e

oι

ιexs

sele.ted and .eÑ.odυ.e.l

b,. drnι]

µity'

rιe

editoι

o| a

s1rοΙaΙtv

,,"-"

h.n,o

L'J|",,,,,

e"'o

l,'n,|

,,Jι

ιiking.

Mοrcoveξ

a\

rhe

λfι.\

..G i,le]incs

Ιoi Eanοts

οιsτh.]a(,

E11]ιio. ' iηdi.]te'

an'.dn]on rιιι

Puηrocs

to

be

scιotaΙly ΨilΙ

ñ.(,γide

annoτaι]ons

ιnd οιheιgto$ιs

\y|jιh|

Αnεirι

F)r|ir''n1Λ Λusιeιι' has taιeη

a

υse|u] blbΙiogΓ]PhΙ aοιιο&]c

η

m.,e

υseful by

&lding rhe.οnft.τ

ol:lhe αt]es \τ/rignt orignιalΙy

ιιted,

one

Dight

nriok

o|

ιh.

ιota].ι.οιd

.rexζ δ

.he gΙeaι

coΙlcctiνe

∆meιl.an

noveι

|oι dιe

DernJd,

\ι/t1gb|

l\wnd Fi|in

6∆s

sa e{tendeιl mi so cnιi.ned dle

oΙiginal

ÑΙnπ

bibιn]g-

ιañh, llrit n htrs beΦme a

fuιι]ιΙ.nrtr]]y ι.w tιring] the

diε}e.en.c b.rween

x rnle

lιd

l Γul]

&Ιr

∆ enoιποιs, As

i

scii.hlι]ιe.οlΙe( tiοn

o.

v1rιι

]ñ ro].ιes rhe

enrneιv

οf AmeΙj.]n Γi.noo

|or a

Ι'er\|'a'

ν.t1 't Αιwεaη

Finωι \11s J

new r.]eοtn

qυiιe

disιn.r n.oα'

eγcn

i|n

ι∆ n: bals iη'

ιhe ο]i8nra]

ñaorcd

ν.lunre

vtiξ∆|

λfuiaι

}].τ,,,ι

handl

ng οε

Hd.ieι

Jro]rs

(]isτeιl

6], ]reι pseudon,m

ιinn2 Brenι) d.πιΙtsΙ]res

Jοn]e o| ιΙrc ιif|er.n.es bd.γeen τhe.uΙs

o|

l

digt]]

librtriy

Piοjr.r

and l

schoιιιΙ, edniοd, τιle

ιdΙ

.bJe.tλ'e

oi

\τi4ι]

Αι}r

"

Ftr;jυn

h]s Lεen n, burι]

l

searcιrtrbl.

b.dy .| ΑπeΙnΙn ncιiοn'

Gilen

dΙat ιreιπ'eeo

thε

.Ιealin

o.

ιhe

bibιiogi1ñιΙΙ trΛd the

..eiιn]n oΓ.lre tutΙ.ι.it eιe.E.ni.

tsο r.e, an

εtr.Ι

in

.]re

ori8in]Ι ]riιrln]gnñhy |3s

beet

(]c.ccιcιi

(,

won{ Ιιred

ιs

n.ιioD

h∆ been

.]ere.Φiteι|

noι be |i.tnΙraΙ)' tr

'eems

? nrιtιkcn

P.l].)

ιj m]gn]η

ιΙrc ciroΙ b],

  ιοviι]ing

ιhclul]

teΙt

o.anοn

lj.tiοna.l

ιlocιΦcnt

Ιiιllnl

u

Jhι

L{ι ηΙ3 Sl.ιιGii

w1s

ιnιcd ∆ E].noη

by

dre origintr] δi]r]i.gΓtrPhει'

ιvle

\τlrighι

ιr x nme

Ψhen

Jaωb\s

nnΙι vδ

ιhoιglΙt lo bι

|i.nonaΙ a..

ir.eηains

soJcsigΙaτed ln tEoηl]οe

prt]]e.t eτeΠ

rrουgΙr

ιlr

boοι

n Ιο ιοnger.xraιsυeιιοr

ιodersτ.od r|at nny

Τhι

s'ould

fem

ιο

be. mc.ιan].i

riτne. ιhan a

s.lro]aΙl| rcsPonse

n,

n]ι paτ1.υla.

Ñ,obιeπ

The.oΙ]cct]oΙ

ο. rexrs in

tιe

\ΙΙΙight

Fro]..ι

ι

vllubιe

on

ia

own terns'

bιt iι ι dilieienr ι.m an

ed]Γiοo Φhcic nho]any

judgment

6

pιiωount,

1l,'lr,Ι

ι\]ισirι Fι'ιΙ Cοns]\teoΓ|y

Γouοws ns οιi

pΙnt.lÑ|es'

thoυgh

tncse

FΙnl.lp]es

ltr

su.h rt]ar tlle prcje...eΦιns

Ιcuαιl

οn

r1fters ψhereas.hohn,v

cdni.n wοdd ]re

ιt

ñains

ω

Eιe

a

f1nd,

Ιι/Ζ,l/

,1|ι0i|ιn t| n'rn i: λ m')a|

caiιriburi.n

Φ n:hoιa.hiP

wnhοut

belng

1s.hο]xil,

edn]on

Per

se

ln.oη.ιδι

ιo ιΙ]e d]Air2l trbary.ol]ε.αon,

Bc aιo

see

a new type

o.s.ho]any

ei{iοn

ιhΙ

λ.tren

a

πiilitιοnaι

edn]on

lnιΙ.loie,

j]merites

caιlcJ a tΙιcmitjc

icsιii.ι.olle.tnΙ] λ'Ιany

.beΦxιic

ιeso]r.h..Ιιe.rnjns a]so

otico.al]ed ]r.ni'.s

?iπl to}"Ιd

$e

it]el]

οl

ιreirrg

nlιnrι]ulle

Ιεy,uι.es n{ ιhe

nιι]y ot

glνe.

rοpi.s

ΙΙr

d

eΙd.tonΙj

enτnοnmenι,

n

n

po*lble

m

Ñro

r]e

ιhe Ynιucs

o| Irιtt i ti.sn,iIe

a.d a .Ιiι.iι

o. .lo.umeιrxη edtrn].

simυlιaneolsΙy G' Th.mιs T1nse]le .ills

,x

neτly

ιeylroaιded rendnion

ιeaι.h]|rΙe

bΙ πy

ψord)''

fd.1.aζ'imiιe thaτ

shoφs

tΙreoΙig]nal

tyñοgΓtrphyoιhandvririfls' 1inearin'ana ιayour ιhefict

Β]υ(emeα.

o]:an

eIe.e.n1ι

edirΙ,n,,(Ι99':

'8)

Α Ιa.sim] ιe

n esPec

aι1γ

ιmPo.inΓ |oι

tlrose

π'Ιrο

believe

ιh2t ιex6 fe.ot

seliEble fιonr

a.ifu.,

dra. .exr are .lnnnntnιal]y Ιin|eι1

rο

Ψhx.eve..on\ξys cιlem

inlhyn.al

foιι TΙrose 1n.erene.] in bibιiogriñιΙi..ο,].s

howιy eiι.e'olιΙgins.οrnaDe∆laι]on,xnιloιΙrcrδ cc6οtιlrcΙnxreΙilΙo]rje.t.onνey

ΠrΦnιng

aie we]ι seπed by e]ectοnl. edιions that

ñrelent

hlgh quaιlry .otoΙ

.i.sιmne

imJgel οf dο.unen∆

o.

ιοuΛe' digtr]ι Γ]. miΙes

.annoι .onvey

4#]Ι

physi.al asÑe.ι oi

rh. reΙι .he

sme

ι' nre ιeΙΓq.e' an. rhe

we]gh.' ιo. eιlmFι.

An

xd,]iιon2ι ΓeΙυ.e

oiele..Ιon1. ed]αons Φser'es empιrasι

,

ιhe

Fosibilιy

o|

i

l. rcme ο

ιal deveΙoÑnen ι ,,l

.]eιiyeiy'

Ιfadcquate

ιex6

do no.

ctnrnrñiinr rι.n

nn

o|reΛ

ad'ιablc to rcιoisc *'oΙk in

P.ogr.s'

E.Ι etΙnrple, ]fωmeοne ι'eιe ο undeι

t∆ke

an

elr.r.οni. eann[

.ι

rιe

..mFΙeτe

ιettdr.|ιtaπier

tseeζhe'

sron'e'

iι

τοu|.]

b.sensiιrιe

n, Ιeιeate rhat

maιe,ia]δ i.

ι

σans..lbed and innorxιe.]sin.e

no iιleqυ ιe

eJiιjοη o. Sn]Φe,\

|etτeΛ has hee.

Ñub|{he.]

ιι lral he.οm'"

con'enlional ιo re|Φse

e]..(oni. wo.ι

be.o|e

iι

Ιea.lres fuLιy

ιeaι?ed

|o.m'

an.l|oιgoοd reroι.

Evco

gιrcn

a

prnι eι]nioo.{isc, ι

.ω

bc ι6cιn tο i.]cisc clc.tοni. 1rοrk n]

Frogre$

Lcιaω. oΙ

irj

sear.I]]biΙny Jnd οdreΙ

lun.ti.nJn''

ol.oι.sd' deιiνeΙnlg wο.k rhat ι

{nΙ

in

ι]eνabñπleΙt

ιtrlΦs nπeΙefnΙg neΨ quefnΙ* lοι eΙtrmPιe: Φhel i xn

ele(ion].

ed]non

*alr1e? And ι'hen ∆ lt

Ιea.l], ι] ω

1ngesred inΦ a ιibΙa.y

s'stem7

Eιecσonr. ediιng

F'o]e.ιs

o}ien ι,.nι]

ιΠro hejg]r.ened

Gιeι

a nin.υlty .on.

ΙionEιι by

gαtraιons

ο|(hοιyΙ,

ε.]i(o6

-4s

Ιnι Don,lι]son ιigιcs nr

..coιιe.ting

Βα

Jnnsan'''

,,τ∆ι

blhdιl

αιij,,

ιΙ

gaδcrfug

οΓ

ιhc ιoιaΙny

o|

a wrnerl

.euvΙd,

ιrοweνcr.on.oiyed] is

1PιΙlse

dr]t ]rιrdeE ιΦod oiyπlonΙ], ιinnng aτ a

(eatiγe

ιensn,r τnar ]ies Ιr the τei-γ neaπ

οfedi(trii]

ñΙa.ti.e,

lο..olle..ng

anJ

ediιing

3iτheΙing

nl and ntrιng οut

aΙe

νeΙy dΙieΙenr pu.lui∆' ιhaι

o.ren

ιead n qιiιe

.onσ]ry

ij'eιtιoni,(l)oΦ|.ιson

200]: |9)

An

ee.t.onι. e.|inon'' s aΙguab]]' x

ι11|ieιen. ιh1nε nrxo aο

αchn'ε

o|

prnΣ]ιy

ιlo.υΙrenδ' e1Φ

n

cο

m ]cι

c

'

col]ι.r]on

ο1

do.uΦ.nc. a∆d thc a.t]vnies Οι ψinιoψing ιnιΙ coileftnrg ire.]ιne diιlιΙdΙr in

ιhen ]Ppioa.ιrcs

ro

reÑΓelentltion

Ιs a

wrnei bιsι i.pi.sented

by

Ιepιοdu.ing

ιhf

πl1y Le Ιn.f

pOñιιf

οi .egaΙded as n.f ΙΙFοπloιi, slr.uιd Ι edfur r' to.]pture

aιl vJrirn∆

.ιtr

ε.aπl.ιΙaΙ

woιι' ..

eνen

]ιι

vtrιian∆ ο.]ΙΙ ΨοΙιs, As

λman&

cajιey

ιδ

x.gυed'..Εi.r

o1:

nrese

eιι,.o.iι οbjeclιves.itrjes

lιιs

Ε.li.ο$ vhοs.

tΙοie.t

rs

selecιiοo ιhιe{en ιo οvcιsimPιiy an audroι,s.oφus'

kα,i

ιo] negι.ι G

iin

vo.ks

shi]c

ιrΦpagιιing

ovcretΦseιl

ones

'

,conγerely,

e.]nos

ιho

seck

ιο.ol]c.t

aD aαιιrοrs ι,ork, δ Donxιι]soα

Puι

iι. lnk

.ιιnsh]Fιnrg]

ιhe Ιxni]iΙΙ.aΙοπ nl

ais..∆.efting

ΨΙys'

(2ο06:

])

ιΙnresolνe.l tssues and UnΙea|i7ecl Poιentiaιs

ιιι.h of φιr]ι n

non

el.n]og abouι dignal

s.ιoισshi

n nοι

.t

ieJlized but.an

]re

glnnpsed

nΙ sugge$ive Ιrdi.anΙs

οl

*ιrar δc lutuie Ιn1} hο]d, we aΙe in aΙ

8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

5/9

ι12

]Ξ

ιdηni.

s.bι/d/ |1 Ε ι'

]

0∆

expeΙnιent]Ι tinre. lynιr sοΙδy.ic and

ιrι.nraΙe.ιxngiag

aι d1zzting lpeerιs

Ιηι1

the

εxpe.taιοns

nf

a.a

rhe p.ssilriinies .ε

oιr woιι

ooι

rcι

1ιιιl

xitiιulaιed

DesPite

υn.eπajnty on

many .Ιonts'

(jne

rhlng

ι .ιeIrj

n n οf

tlt

utΙnon impoitanζe

t]rlr

eιe.n.onr. s.hoιa.lΙ eι]ιιjo.s

aJhere

Φ

inreΙn1rn]nal stin.la.ds Ñιo]e.ιl

thnι

a.e

ldiοsyοcraα.

,|e

a1mon .e(iιn

lo

Ιem2in

fand

aιx]e

etιi,rtt: they

havι dnι.ιiνΞιy

Ιba..loncιl ιhc

losibi]ny

o| inIerοf,eΙabi1

ιy

They

.anf,o. be meshcι] wjdl

οtheΙ

pn, m ω

bΦoπle

PΙ.t

ο|

ιJrgci

coΙιc.(ioοs nnd sο n ngoiftiαι

xn.unr

ι.

rιe

'eseaι.h

Ñ.renΠ]Ι

οt eιe.Eonl.

wοrι

is lon,

,ΙΙtir.rc.ιo∆

ti.ι hιgo

baljes

i..ΙΙey

Ι]nd nrey

π,nl ιo iΠ..aΙarε thei, vοrι virh

jnteιle.tuallν

Jnna.

nra.cΙ]aι

,{s

ΝΙa.i1yt Deegan

|enr,ιs' Ιnιe'oΙreΙ]blιitΙ

]s diι}].ιΙt rο a.hleve. 2nd

the

dlgnaι

Ιibiiry {orΙd ιr,s be.n

gnlpΙing

vidr

n

fu, some

time Εdiσs

shoυl.]

n.r

f.ive

to

enlιre

tιe i. rerοñera|ril n], oΓ rhcn

cdιioοs

bιι n*eeJi.or]nLaιd ιe.hnicl] de.ιins

rhaτ

ao

nοr

Ñ.e.Ιude

rιe

ÑossilriΙn-,

o1

Ιibrα]cs.r.xιnrg

ιlr..onnectn,ns

a.,

iater

date'

(Deegxη

2ο06:

]62)

Ι)eeain peιιeiνes

rιιr

τ]g ses

nι.h

is τfu τexι

'ο..diοg

ni.ia.ι τ

(TΕΙ)

anJ

En.οded ΑR:hiνal Des.Ι]Ftioο ιE,{D) Ιnlιe

Ñοslt'ιe

1ιιcrοpec

abiιn9. thουgh ιheΙ.1ο οo.

gυιι?n.ee

].

FiguΙing

oιt

hοτ

to ptrι|

ιro]e.6

tοgeτhcr

eΙire.tnel w]]] bc 1

.ιrnΙιcιΨiιψ bι.

not iDιo$]6ιe

rxsι v'e

fu.e 1n.cr.nnrg

9υes

ιn,ns: ιtr examPΙe' .π we aggEgfe eis in

wι]Ιs

ιhaι δ..)Ιslr ιΙre

nι..ssaΙΙ

negiee

o.

unιlo'mreΙ

a.η$

Pfuie.rs

ι'iιhοtrt

ΩΙiFÑing

.ur

'|hit

ι regirded a\ v

ιal

]rv

in.li'du pΦie.ξ?

Αn

addnronal

dl.n.ult],

ls tιit rlrcfu,ιn.tiοn

t. nnι]w

fxηdiids

i

nοt nmÑ

e

be.Φse ιhe 5ιxn.|aιd'

nremleΙνes are οοr Jlwlv Ι].miΙ ef]ιrιnhξιl,

NΙaoy

ai.hiνnr

r.1ιr

ιo.Xι.nabΙe NΙ"'kuΓ

Lan8mge

(xMΙ-)

δ

.ιe

..ic].]

Ιiee

p19.i

o| the digniΙ

igι''

be.iιsc iι ι

Ιι.ιο|m.ιn.le enden.

aod

ιoο.ñrolriera.}

NeanΙ

aιι

.trπeni

devebÑmenr

nl

descΙ]tι]vc .αι marιιφ ι Ι1νι basdd' fd lar

mo.eroοι(nr3nyο.ιhenroPe.n]uιιe)ireιv]j]ni]le1orlr]ndl]ngXλΙιdatarhanwere

eltr

lri]abιe

}if

S.;λtι

funfe τeRοN

.t,ΙtΙ 9iΙl ]rc ΙΙΙι onΙ],,

lnd

xMι

seiΙ.h

engincs

ιie

,rιruιing

quicιιΙ

xM1.

nnd

moΙe

Ñ1rti.uιan],.

theτEι ]mΙr]em'"n.Jιiο.

o|

\\l| .,

1,ο,,,'],|b

"','n,

i

n,

l'

.'.,

xMι]]ι,*l ednοΛ ι] derdΓnline ΨιticΙr asFe.c oι a .eΙ. n|e oι lnrcfΙ ιo ιll.n9lor(t

ind

to.rag

ther.

oι

ιabeΙ

dren

snι

nΙJrιup

ΙοΙ

eximpΙc. nι

iιrc

lΙ/,n,,J,lr,]n,'

τe

rag

nΙuιnΙa|

fe]ruΙes ο. r}]d

n1u6criñc, nrh

δ

l1ιe

bΙcnιs and stnnZi bιciks.

and aιso ιlre rey6ions

rhiι \(/hirΦan

made

to

tΙle

πlΙnιscΙips.

as }Itn he de].red ι

ιoaΙ

ιnn iep]i.eι1

iι

wth anon]e.

our

n]ιkup ln.Ιude\ mο.e

jn.ιfnrarn]n

τhx.

Ψoι]d

bι.v]dcnι

lo.

cδu,l re&]er'

Α

yylesheεr'

sTften rn EΙιen'bιe

sιvlε\heet

ιangαlge τrmsΙο.ft1tnΙr

αsι,r),

ÑΙο.δses

ou] ΙΝΙi-

|iles

inιο

re&ιe.'lιendlv

ιlτΙlι rlιt u\dΛ see

γhen thq,

vniι

oιr

si.e. ∆.ιr.1a

beoeft

o. )ι\Ιι

is

ιrar

n

albs\ nΙ

l]exiLiιny'

ald

rhe 1ñÑ]ictrtion

ol

Ι5ΙΙ aΙlo

α?nsfοΙmeι]

in

νaιiουs n'Ιys.o..rΓteιng.utpuls' so

$h]]e sOΙΙe

οl

rhe fuoΙnn.n]n

ιEr]t

ηe

haτe

emb&l.]en in oυι.1g in

is

not eνiaenτ n tfu

ilTΙ1ι

d∆ÑΙ],.lareΙ, it

n'e

deιlde

thxr tho nrionnxtion

is

νtrι]trble

.o

.exJe6'

ι'e

.jan .ev]se

oυΙ $',|es]reet

ιo

nr.ιudc n ]n ιhe ιΙτMι

diFιa,'

τft.οrυnrJιnΙΙ οi ΙΙΙι en.od.ι] ιι.Ιc nnd Χsi-Tfγ]eshee.s aιo enibles

]rqe.F

ιo oΙfe.

mu]tη]le views

.a

sjngle

dignJ lil.,

1ιn

n

ol.ons eiabΙc

imPοπ.τe

Ιr

s.ιrolarι,

eniting

L,c.ause edrτoδ

(oi

ιscr'

mly

aι|ιayed

in vΙΙious ways

aι dii|.rent times L.οΙ

exanrpΙc, tlιe inτeι.ace

οl: .lre

expaaded,

d]gn:ιΙ edn\aα

at Λ cal'ιι1a| ιf lbε

Ι'.|tn

ι/ ν')|/ι cι|∆σ'

ooΝ

beinε

PΙelaιed

b

a team le.l

by ∆nd.ew.Ιevei1' riι

aΙlοw

6e∆ r.

dyn2ni.2ιly

.eorι]ci

2lΙd

1.deΙ

.ντΙ 2'000

leter desιΙi.lti.ns

ecoι|ing rο

diιΙerenr

|a.ιos.

such as

.nronoι]gy'

id.lιesei.

oi

Γepοsno.]'

Λdιi]ιion]]Ιy, the

carhe.

eιliιοriaΙ te1m

is

.onsi.]ennε

giving

ιse∆

rhe

oΙrriοn oι.iuroing ο.,,some

ο|the

c.]iιοriiΙ

in.oιmaιjon

nrxt

n' by ιeιU]t. suñÑ.e$α|.

Ιο dign]uing ne{ den Ι

Pιiοns

xoι1 th6e

in.Ιanι

s.ouιs

oriaΠ]l

ÑΙntr

v.lume'

sυ.ιr ι]i Ι

ls iιgulaΙizeil

h]nres

ofleopι.1ιd .del

ofιeο ιrkes

ιtre

ft,rn.ι]

mjniaonoιaιioo

Ιn tne

digrτare(liιiοn,

tιe

del'luιt

sυΦιrary

m]gιrt

.ca.] Φmerning ιke'.Going b

5ee mo[heι nr ca]iΓorni1,';

wilh

ιhe

ΙegιtxrizΙrnjn

vnibΙe'

i.

mighι

rcad,

..αJin

ro

see

moιΙrci

[citιtη

NΙx.y

vιginii

(Je.nre)

Boaι]

Tιcs. nuιilie

vievs

ol

ιιre .,,,,, are enabιe,] 6y .lrc

ιiclr

nlΙιup

aJοDteι|

b,

thlJ

pio]c.t

and

Ñοint

to

sο1Ιc o. rµ issue' thaτ

edi.os nct .οn de. Eνen

vιritc

adheΙnlg n, rh""

5xΦ.

τEΙ

fanddd

ule.

on .r2ny oιhcr dign:ιt e.lirjng p,ojecε,

ιΙrese

eJiroΙi

.]ror.es

o| ahi.h teΙruaι

.ha.icιe.ιr].s

to m]Γk uι]

.ra,

nοαcιh.les

dliG.

sigηrιi.anιl,

|iom

.ιloi.e\

maJe

by oιhel

pioi(t

edt..s \xl]]en

aΙ cl].οtt is ma'le to

nggΙeraιe

mntei]i

ιiοm 7,J

v,/|Ιn c nJb' λ nL}L|

(

] Ι'

nr

nrlt

.1 oιιrci.ο,]PaΙiLΙe

siιes'

hor

viΙ]

ι]iΙiι.efl.e\

ln

m1ιkup

bc hπdιea,

ol.oυ6e,

ιnlcspio]e.Φ make

ιheiιsouic..οaetrνai|ab|e ιo

in.ercsι.d

s.ιοΙ]∆

xnd

expοse

ιhcir

net"d]ta nτ ha]ae$ing

nr 1ιc.Ιdtrrι:e Φ] l1r

oιren Ar.ιrives lnlιjarnt

(o,{Ι)

Frotο.ols

'

iι w]nt

ι]e

er,

εo$

οr n' τhe

iirru.e

even ιο

k.ow

w6at dlsi.]

obic.ζ

Ιn1ιe up a

8iτen

eιlιioo or ιοψ tιeΙ

verε

σeaιcι1,

c]ΦιlΙ,

ιlrcn' isues

o.

P.eseryxrion

ind

ΦgΙegiιοn

a]€

nοw

ι.y

n,r

edtroG En

iοok]ng to γτd rhe ltrπ

e'

l1re

v lfu,} An∆1ι i|. Jαer|Ιιng

ιon.veιJP a

modeιuse

ol

rιre

Ι{etidlta

ιnι:odiogand

1'nnjΙnsn]n

sEndart|

(λΙ'Ts)

1.ι ntregraτin{

Φeι&laο

in

digraΙ rhemaιi.

ΙesΦ.chcol]ecrnln\ A

MΕτs

do.umcdt eΙ$|es τne wιn

nι Λn∆nι

ann

a| enιties

ιlr,ι nι]rlequently

lηgen

ιhε\αlritman naftΙi215

intoιιιEcicο]ιo.ri.ns

nr des.] ihea(1nnrnft

t]ve metΙdaπ'

nrυc.υrxl

nctnata' xnd des..]Ñf

i9e,Ιcr]data,

ιυ.

exanÑ\e'

rbc

\y/∆'Ιrιn

Αε∆1L?

υses droιsxnJs o| inalvrdυtrl

f]les

i∆

olr

Ñm]e.t

ro

.]ιpΙιy

rιins.riptn,as

and

d1gi.ιl

]mnges ο| ψhfπan

nιnπ.ripts ]Ι,l

puh]rred

aoιιs These fiιes

ΤlΙ..n.οd.d

ans.ιPrjons'

ar.ιiτ,Ι

1ΙFΙ ]mages.

de|λd

JP'G

nΙagel.

EAD

n.d1ng gaι1cs

..dd be mo.e

|οrmnιl οndd

τιr.oυgh

drc

Ls.

or

a Mlτs tlο.umeoι

ιo ie.oΙa tιreiΓ

sι,e.i.]. .elιι]onsΙips, Tιe

υse

οf ιΙ ,1.S

rviι]

he]|

F,eseo'e

thc sιru.ιuΙtrΙ ΙnτeΒ|ry

o|

t\e

\ιb'ιlnι

Απ∆e

b, E.orJnψ

ssennaι

Ιe|ft

onslriFs mοng rne

Ιile'

λdd Γ]οDatly'

wc tlrnιι r]rat

ιηiοg

ΙΙ'1s Ι]]el

shi.]r

allhαι

.ο i

Ñn,peΙ FmfiIe

τil]

Fromοte

ι..d$ibnirΙ and

suΙιinlbi]ny

o.

rτ

,1r,:4

ao1] οιher

Prοjel8

]ιιe

jt,

nraking dlen

FΙime

.xndid2ιcs

|oι ingef]οn nιo

'ιrnrl

τιe

PlDer

]n.egrlιion

ο1.nlet]aaτ]

is

imιrofiaοι

be.xuse

ι]ιse

siιes aιe

Ιlkei, ιo

emFιo]r

Πrοre

ιΙr]o oοe flDda.d'

as

.]re

e{αn|ι.

o.

ιιe

ι?,1,7nιbι

1t.'fu sιgΕcτs

Renu.lιxnι.|iιi

n at leaf

]

n'orkΙ]οτ

probΙcο

Rhen lr ]nτolves

ιnαc.esaη'ΙΙL.Ι

8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

6/9

E'ld'Μ

n

.haΙn/b Ε]i' M'

4rt

Uiι9eΙi1v

ÑΙcss'.oao

iο ο∆|

π]

ed]ιiο. o.ιiζ ιOoι

do.Ιr€s ι].h

ιΙf,ιs ro οulirage

ednon' Ιn botn.δe tι]ι

oth( iaΙfu.oη

∆

borhι,iιi.g ΙυΓ

]nd Ιndetxιiηg

τhe

6u]ι

o.rlt

wο1*

on

4].*

εt€Ιoοr

cζl(rons

(lj.aεl2οoζ)

overΙe.enr']e.&lcs'gΓtr.ιΙrppoit|oΙ

rhe hlmaniιies

n tne

Us hJs dd.]rned

in ιe]]

d.]Ιa.s

ιly

one ejιinaι?,

.&ιιftcd

nf rnniΓ]on.

ιοi]

fu.d1ng Γor

NEH 6 sιi]] οnΙ],

ilrou.6n%

ot ns

ιe'el

ι0

yenr

Ιgο and

]1%

ο|ns

ñeaι

n1979ο.$]86iοil]nln,

lcΙlig

20ο6)' Ιt aeτe1olmelr

ιinges

oο

gΙant

suPpof' wιlr Ιnks

arc rheΙe

τhaι ιhe

lnοnιos

ot

vx.loιs ag.n.ies..uιΙ

sk.s

emÑιla'es in

intΙ1e.τu21a'orlr2

sore

have

wοdiea

∆.uτ

a

.e1nnn ιtiοn

o.aο o]d.anοn' and

o.hes

Ιraιe

eψιc$cι]

..nιe'η

aboar

dre

ÑΟsihΙe

daogeδ

.|

ÑoIrτi.nl

bias

in

}edeιx]ι,

]qaΙded gran[,

sοre

φoΙΙ,

ιIrtrt

.anonι.a|

v|i.es

m1Ι be

oroΙe ]ikeΙ-γ το

be |uο.]cd

]]y

Γede.al

mοoe],

a.d

tιιt

eineΙs

pei.εn€

ιo Iro..nt.ογeιτia]

mig]rr

be

ncn]cd

Ιιn.jinξ'

on. osi]r]e sΙxregy

1.οrrelFoΠdiαg

ιo dt νa'nΙ{ l:un1inΨ

P.εssυ.es

ι ro buit.l an

end.wnenτ

n,

Ιrpor as.Ι.l]ny

einio. τhe Natioοιl

Endοn'men.

|or ιΙle ιΙuman.

rιiesÑfuνldesιha]engcgranξιhaιλo]dñιJmiseloιsomeediιfiaιanι]ιitrιl.ssonc

i]lεnm]'

norevci,

is tl]ar rhe

NEΙi dftcs

.haιlc0gc

g 'ι$

ιUιxΙο

suñιro(

oΙ

rnstl

ιΙ]ons,2nrcr

ιh1ιP.oie.Β.

thar [' ιowxd

ongοng enιeη,rιcs

Ιathe'

nrιo rhοse.|

Ιimteι1ntrrarion T|us

|iη

sore

tund

ιrg

tii cdlιtri]l

vork

ιrιs

]reen aι1o.iιιdνi1..we

tlre Peο]rle,, .hlΙlenge

gΙMs

tοm

NεH, bιt l\ ΙesouΙ.e

ιιs

limiιe.l

ilFιi.abiιtv

b.ciιsι on]l .eπx]n

krnds

οrundefιkings

.a. mainriin

drxr theΙ

FnΙ

ιινe

ο.going

l.t]ιnie

Le'οnd

rhe.ο8FΙeτjon

of tΙ]. La\i. edrιo.1nι

wοrk' and

onη x

tes.aι

be

|,

',

,,Ι,,

b,J

l

,,

'oι\,,|,'',,

Ñresscs

aocl Digital cenlers

UniveΙnty

Ñ.esses

]αd di8trai

.enl..s

trre

οrne,

oιrΙious

Fl]ces

onc Ι]]gιr 1ooι

for

ie ]u.ιεl ιo

sulPoit dlg]ti|

υb]i.lιοn'

aΩr]

veι ncnlreΙ

|δ

showο n\eΙ. to

be

ιιl]1

eqιηrFed

.ο

Π]c.t

.trrenι

neens,

oΙfoΙJ

ιJnivcξiιl

PΙes.

c nι]Ι]dge

UfuvΦsiιv

ÑΙess' an(l

drc UoiveηirΙ

of NΙi.ιjgan

ÑΙes

]]Ι

εiÑre'sed

ιΙ.ιen

in

υb]nh]ng

eΙe.αοni.

edn]ons ln

.ιle 199α' rhουgΙ

ιhaι entι|ulasnr

lras snre i'ιne.|

on rhd

FΙrolc. tιive∆iΦ

ιιe$cs

h]}e

been

s]o a

ιο iel.t

e|.e.ΓiYcι),

ιJ the

ños]bi]nies

οl

eΙ..fOni. s.]rο]iιlΙ

ednnΙtr ι;nrγesιy

Ιeses

af,d

ι]igι]ι .e.τejτ

Ιιv. ove.laplr

ηg

iotes and inreιens,

Md

rhe.e

ma| {e]Ι

be

οΓµ[υntrics

itr

uf|ιi .oi]abο.iιiοns

in

δ.

ιuΙe' iηd

some ιoΙ|abοιiιons

haνe JΙΙeady

bc.n eltιΙrive.

Noτabη'' ]ι

rδ

the Ιnsιi.υιe

Ιοr Αdyan.eιl

Te.hn.ι,g], in

dre ιΙumtrnines

(Ι-∆"ΙH)'

undeΙ

John

ιjnsτotrlrs

]c

e∆nψ'

dr,r se.uΙeJ

sran.

|ιιding

an.]

ιnιer.al

sυιιoi. Ι . an

e..rronrc lmFΙiΠtj

no' ιn.ι'n

is

RoΝn]Ι, ar ιhe ι iηrv.rsny

.Γ

ν11 ini]

PieS

iτ

tr

ι.o

e]nΙ

Φ

ιe]

vheιIr.rοΙ lοr

[he l..αΟdlι

ΙmPιnιiιthe

ι]niye$iry.ιvirginri

wi]Ι lΙoιnsh etιeι

nι], n

is

]].etrn]Ι

an

imPoπanr

eΥpenoronτ

Dlgltal

ceηιcrs

nι.h

δ

ΙΛTιl,

the ι\ι]ryianιl

Ιnstnure Γoι

τ..hnοι]gv i.

nrc

Ιium]l]nes

(Ι{Ι,Ι.ιl]'

2.d Ιhe

ccnteΙ

ntr

D]giiaι

Rιscaι.h ln

ιhe

ιιιm].]ries

ιι ιnc

τιeic

ι a]so .ιre

nr2tτeι

|

Ιjgurnlg oιι wh2.

t]re ι]n.οiclΙ ιiim οΙ dle metadlra

is.

cιrendy,

οo

MlTs Pιo.le.οΙ

dign]]

thιma.i.

.esear.h..Ιle.riοn

hxl

be.n.eιeι

oΙ]ed'

and tlrεro

lis

not been

x .lemοnsiirioo o| nre eΙτectιτene$ ol: ΝΙlTs

6 an

in.egnrιrn

ιιn

|.isu.ι

coιle.ιjοns

ln

a

rdpo.t ιo

tΙre ιΙKJo]nτ

ln.orΦxαon

syΙems

cοmrirtee'

Ri.hara Gιrιrcr..gues

t|at iνtnt

prolribit.τlre

h]ghel ιdu.aιn,o

cοmnπnty

ιι.om]

aeΙiνing ns ful]

beηent.fur

i ΙΙτs n

th. ]n.k

o1 $ιnaaΙdizaιion

οε

netι],ιn .on.en.

n'nnh is neoded ιo .om]rIemenr

nle siαd1rdiΖ2tiοι

o. |orm.ι

tn,γiLled

bγ

METS'(Gσtner

2οο2)

spe.iil.aΙl,'ιe.alιsntrΙιeww.Ιkn,adt]Esrhλ

gal9

dlat dr.lιιl] benei 6 olιΙETs.an

lre niι,αed

Ιn

shοrt'

ÑΙlιri.es

neeιι

tο

be

no.maιjzεd

by user.ommυn]ties

and

eΙPιesιd

nr ι|e.aiισl

and

Ñ.e.isε Ñ.onιes

].ιhe

Pronrne

o|]νiΕτs ∆

amethod to1buiι|ing

m]nageabιo.sun.inlbιeιiΞiιιl.olleιrions

R∆d1r.h.6 ιn.ιΙibΙxιans

aΙe

l,nlΙ

jωt

bcgi.n]ng Φ

use

rhe

]vΙτs

n1nd]Ιd'so

tιe

tιme

is

nghr for

n.

c$$|]5hed

hun]atr]es

cοDιuιj.g

ñΙο]{τ'

Ιiιe

rhe \Ι/,i/,n/Ι

nrrll},

to aeνeΙo ι

proi]le rhat

P(]Ped],

ιdιιΙεses

r|e

ζomÑι.]red

demaι.]s.f

shοlaιen..jbea

dlgniΙ do.ιmenc

Ιn

Γ].t.1.qianι

]Ιοm ιhe

ΙnyitΙ.e

Ιοr ιΙιseur

2nι]

ιibι?ιy se]aicel

ι aιΙο\νinl

Φc

\Υ/∆i'ιιι Aiιn ∆

Pι∆u.

drι

goil'

wιh vira]

a\snr]n.c iiom sonre

hrgh

ιeγeι.onsuιana

]

Cost

∆ siAniii.ant

1,roιnι οΓs.hοιan],

r1teΙjxι

ι

οoπ

|ree]Ι

aνan]6Ιe.ι rfu }'e|r' trnd

.tre|e η

a

snΙlg morcΙncnι

.o|

οÑen

2..es

-{S

Ι Ιr.τe οbseπ'ed

elseΨheΙ.' s.h.lan],

lyoΙk

nriΙ

hε..ee ι]

tιle en.ι usei

bυ.

tr

*

nοt

ιicc

to

|rαι].e

(P'i.e

2ο0 ι: 29) Tnaι

dniun(1o| [

r the hetrit οΓsome.o.e

dnτj.uΙt]cs

in

digtal

s.hoιi6hiι]

ΙI.

oΠe

undertaιιs ]

tru]y

nnrιriιious

Pe]iθ.t.

hoq'.an

r be

Paid

ε.Ι] \vjΙl

ginnιing

ΨeΛ.ies

tDνlde

(dnors

t]re

ΙesoυΙ.es

rο

rlaιe.onh

bυι..eeιy

deliveiea ψoι]

]r:Ecd

Ιcsουr.es?

The.οnmentl oΙPaυl ιr"e1'

Dne.rοr ]nd Gcne.al

Ednoi οΓthe

Thιr∆

Α,

ano.

 il]e('

ιighΙigl]t th.

ΙobleΦ;

hjs.Οmmcnc aΙe a|]

ιhe mο.ε V]benιg ιhcΙ one

r.. ι ch]τ

ιhe Edιon cJnioο

|e.ennΙ sas h.nοrcιl vi.h

the ΕugeΠe

S

ιrεrgιson

Prile

as

aα oυζι2.dlng

hntory o|te.hno]ogr

re1ιrea.c trork:

Ιt n

d€Ι ιnr ιo.n

|υt

t6c

ιnon

gelΙ

|ιο.led

Γαηet\

.Ιlin.

eJtriοΙs :f

pιοlrib.i

/

εxÑcιjiv.

ι]seι. uδιish The

Ιailo.

PaFes

lr1s

bιen un2υ]ero

6lα]aJJιυltrιgo.kοo

ouΙ exιnng οn]i(

.n]g. eJnion .ε ]ravι

.lEι.o1e in.uεd of, .oΙΙJbor2aη

wΙlr

o.Hl.\

\.{,. rε wo.ιinP πnh thι

Rulsεs ιibΙaπ tο.1jgιt7ι

]

lm1|ι

,.nrοnid ednlοι

ve Jid

oiill

exr],r ιa. γ

ilοιoο pnιυle.aιno 1nrnugh

t9(]8' wlri.h

qe

1rt boÑns

s]ι

ι. uF ]rιer dlis

'er

1'he

] Lι.Ι

j

Jolng τb[

δ

FaΓi

woΙk

on iιltn

]οΓlπftt.τuf, sΙ.h Φ'rn.ι.ιuΙe

nrlτr τhrε .

o.u

ιο.l

lLf,.tif,B

lgenιies

dιt

j.]ιiιΙιΙPΙovlaed.ιnι]jοg.or.ιιι1{lιgτ

eJnioru

kr

our \Ιe Ιι

r]jυ ]ον ψο1kin3

qnh

lhι

Ñuι]ιJftro|οuΙ

bωι

e.Ιl.on'John5

Ι

ιr k'n

8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

7/9

Εlωηn Ι

s.bι/.ny

L

ni

τnl

xudleo.e shοuld

&eeJi.o.s

o| ιch an

ednin make:

πι n aditΙ.uιqueΙ]on

sin.e

tne ιdlencc

nay.aηee

$ide]Ι

iη

asc xnd

loιhtriicnri.n

an.]

τΙx]nnlg' ind

ιlre anlwe.

ο.

ho9

be$ n]

haad]c

tlre

comÑΙ.lity

n

υncΙcr,

Α

ηr,' inιeΙΓa.e

.1esigneΙ

on ι

larticuΙi.pηe.r

mignt ngu.e

ouι tr way

το

Piονide

Ιeτeιs

οΙx..εsl anιlgrxdπbns

of

ι]iτl].uιr

bur

unle$.aΙeful],

Ιrandled'

su.lr xn ΙÑpΦach

m]ghr seeι].οαdesιen.lΙrg,

vh]ιever

τhe

.ιnΙΙeοges

aΙe o| meetiog

a

drar]τicnΙl,

eΙp2.dα]

icideδh

P

'

and

those .haιιenges

"Ιe

.ons]ι1er]lr|e

wc

sh.uιd

iιsο

celebraτe

rtrn

.ÑΓo(υnny

nj

dcΦo.ιat'zc

Ιearni.8

Aα,one Ψrtlr

]

we6 bΙovs.r

ιδ a.ιc55,

ree

oτ

cnnrgc' to

a

gΙcx..lc.t oΙnateιii

ιιat was

on.e niade. lway

in ι,.keι]'ιÑ

rπe book

rοons, The

sο.i.l

bclein

o. |.ee]y ΙνaiΙahle

etΦEοnl.

€oti(es;

α υΠΙUus

Po5s;b1e

Iurd.e

Deveιopments

luιrc

sιhoiaδιi

will

he

le$ Ιiιely

ιhan now rο

dι?w

on

ele..ιoni. aΙ.b]'es

ro

Fn,]uce

ÑaÑe.bιsed

s.hoιarly

irtl.les.

ft seem1 I]kely

th]t

s.holar

witΙ 1η.ιeδinglΙ

mak. rhe

ri.ι ιfms

o|

dref

daιa

(.idΙeΙ

rh3n

tΙe ι]τΙΙι

outpud

oÑen rο οrher

s.ιoiiΛ so rh2r they

.Ιn w.rι

our ο|.Ι ι]a.k

nπo

tne

digiιaΙ edition'

.ichrve'

or

proie.t

Αn

eΙaΦÑle

may

.|aΙi|y

hoψ

ιhι

cοuld

Ψo.k

n\

Pfu.τice'

ahe \γ∆nηdι

/Ιd,f,

in

E

ragging

o.

Ñ.jοιed

teΙs'

has r.lied

Ι].iDaΙ]]'

οn noο'conE.γeξi.]

ΙΙarιup οΓ

*ιr.ιurI] .eatuεs

oveΙ

rhe

yeas'

there

hav. lreeο many

nne

nυdns o|

Lιιτ ιf.;t'Ι

Β

a

'.la.guage

eipeιmenr,',

\γhen

ttrc neΙτ

s.lrot.r wir]r

su.λ nn

'ntdιesr.om.strΙOng'vecoι]dpΙοτideιer\γirιa.opιοξsaι'.SoοgοfΙ'Ιyse]t.'ortΙle

]

8

' '

ι.,ω] nj ma.k

ιψ li]Ι

Ι

inguι.ic

ιιaru.es

Thn cοul.

he

]

connΦeοι

lart

oΓ

]reι

oψn tiεejrJndin

s.hο]ιi]y

e'o.k

∆]reΙnariνΞly,

slrc.οuld

ο||er rλe maιcιial

b].k .ο

.ιrc ?ιr.,.*

δ a

spc.ia]ized

conα]butn]n

το

t*e anοrhe|

e1iΙnplej

ιn

ou..wn

roΙk

wc hινe aνoieι]

theraτi.

τagging

ιi,Ι

πany

retrsοns'

bu.

v.9oΙΙdnt

y1nd

ln rhe

r1ν

d

,o

oU,,ο

,

o, ο,,

n

'

οi'ε$h,.,,,

,],.,.,o

Traoslatnrn

ln aη

1nαlguing aπi.]c,

,sιf,les

οf,AggΓega.on:

Pi.naτn]nal'

sulrniτiοo,l,

τrMs

mιiοοΙl.''

ι,]j

(]hee

Dino.ι

Fonπ

our ιhar

"hιm]nisι]c

lieΙds aΙe

diν]ded bv

Πinons]

rhe

ιοη.ous

o|

ou'

knowledge

i.e

neιci

the

.on.οu∆

..

hιnrann]ι

She

ο.ιhere

tr drε

aJ].tιe

Αnren.Ι]

ηroΙe se.uιε

.}'1n

τhen tr

j

o..{€ ]s Αr{nan

ιt,2ιurε]

noνheΙe

λ

]ι nort

nπur ]Ζd'

nοΙe fΙ]eΙivel].

attir"fd

i∆

i.γloΙ ιε

nmeΙ.,ο

τιεruiε

[

ι

t|.evidenι δcιι]'

δ

Αmεitrxn

ΙrhΙn.s

,οJ

AmeΙi.iο

bioiog]'

rΙc

nοτ The

J6.]ptinaιv

Ι.nn

ol.he bunra.]t

is hοΙrεltrΩ.]

de.ense,xt i∆

deeÑe'

]nJ Ιrο*

υιιof,n]ous

(ι)irο.k

2οο.: 22])

ιΙnive6iry

οiNeLΙask ιnr.oιr

(cDRιΙ)

iο afNe hxve bΦn

acting

ts

pub]isheξ

for

some

o.rheir

Proie.ts'

th.ugι

they xie rcΙuy resΦrch and devetoñmenτ

uons

Ι'hey

οrJin?rily ιind

e

sone

Pu61isheΙ

funct]ons, btr. οther welΙ.es,]rΙnλed

Pats

of

rhe

ñιblιhing

sy*eπ

(adτe(6ingj

peei revleΨj cost reconcry)

arι Ιot

at τhe

noment

Ψnιr]∆

dr.n oiinary

vo.k'

No.

2Ιe rhese unns esle.ixl]y suned

Φ

.oorend

ψth

jssues

of Ιong ιernr

prcseσation.

They

ca.

ntrrtffe

PΙoie.∆

ι'nL sunainabrliιy

in

Φιf,d'

hur

rhe

ilbΓtrr], .οmnunny n

mοre

ιikeιy

ιο

have

theteοPιe'

αpciιne' and

tlre

]ωιιυtioοiι fΙaneφoΙιs

ne.essΙy

ι;r

ιhc

vιaL

trk oι lon8-ιe.,r

Ñicseπatio.,

,{s

]nnicated, na.y

s.hoιa6

PDmote.Pen

r.ess. bιl not a]E ol

ιlΙe

sclo]aΙsΙιp

Ψc

wint

tο scc deγeιoFe.l .aα

8er

adequaιe

suPPοrt

εΙom

Φivc∆nics. Γοιna.r]ons'

and

ΞΙEοr

ingagen.ies,

Pies.s nighι

one

day

p.ovjde

a

ΙeνenαesrΓe2m tolupPott

Ñιoiects

ιlrar

.an.οt

be

deldι]Ped

Ψnhoιt i

]vlr1τ

we

nΦd

i.e

addnlonaι

.'ea.ive

paitneδh]ps

.hiτ

bυiι] bndges

6εtφeen

the scιοltrs

qhο

pro.lu.e.on.enl'

the

p

rιnheE

whο

Gome.]me' γeι ana distnbute

n'

and dre

Ι]breics

vlro'

we hoÑe'

wiι]

in.ΙexsinglΙ

]ngε* xαι ι.eseπe

it Λ

.ιitheΙ

ιh]Ιlenge

|οr

cdno∆

o|.ligit,l

e1]ιioοs

is τhaι

th{

desiiption o| rοΙes sυegens

a

tο'e

ctεany

frπked

divniοn .1

ιesFοnsi]rillries

dnn

/tuaΙl-v eΙifs

,liidniooil

boDndxrie

fe

bιDring

benfe οu.

eyes a: .hese

groιps

-

pubιisheΛ'

schοlar ' πd ]ib.trrians in.reδ]ngly

ιake .n

ovenaιlring

nrα.tn]ns

 ,,hite nrislnωιion

1eaνe\ m .ι

uοceitnint '' ι

alsoaιtor.ΙsanrÑιe roοnr.oΙ

cic]tiviry,

ιοo,

δ

we moιt

a.Ιοss neq'ly

Ñοι]us

d]νιling

ιnes

λudiencc

Hiv]n

τhe

abrlirΙ'

P.tenti]lll.Γ..tr.hnΨ

a

τan

iυ.lrel.e

is

one

of.he

g'.3ι

]]l cxι

o.onl1ne

qο|k

λ,.$

olιs'

rιren wrnnrg

s.ho.rΙy x(ι.]es aοιlbοoks, kno{'we

aιι

 γrnnrg

|oι.

ιniτed aldιen.e s.n.laΙs

Ιd 1dvnn.en Ιιde.s

νhο

nrtrr. oιr nπr

e$ Prnt i ιs 1brΙ book

of

]i ιeΙtrry ..in.ism

are

nοψ.ΙΙe]y

m.ie

rλan ι,()()0.οpies,

i.rhat Α

gο.d

peΙce.rage o|thcsc books

ri]1end

uÑ in libιιΙiel' i'heΙe nfrunately a

singΙe

vοιΙme ι∆n

bc

ΙιJd o'cr

ι]mc by

nume.ous

Peοñιe

Ι.

.οntn*'

an

οnΙine

Ιesoυ..e

ιoιΙ

Ι]Φminenr

wΙneΙan enjo,a'οlιdvιleaud]ence o.signif].xnr 5i,e

ιοΙ

exmηne.

d ηng

ιhe ]δτ

t*,

mοnths oΙ thc.ιn ranemi.

yeaι

(ΝΙaΙ.h-Αpι

ι

j20ο6),

.Ι|)ι

\νu|a

cr|fu

∆rιjι

aΙe|aged

xbour ],lυ0 ιrns ..]ny, or.]rouι 2]0.00ο Ιrιs

3

n.nrh,

ιΙ dr]t

Fcr]oJ.

dreΙe w,s

an aτeagd.|l,6]9 un].]ιe

lnnοs

1mnΩdr The

JkfiιL

ι

|bε

Ι}ιι

aιl c]rfi Ε''endτι

ι.]'

rh[ι'

'nιeΙd$ingιy'

nxs numbcs τhat.οrespοnd

ιeS

Φ

rhe a.trdeml.

'eπ.

ιrnn

i6

Peak

Ñeaοd

οi

the Ιaf yelr

dιring

Jinua.y

NΙa..]r 2οο6 ι.ο. rhose rh.ee ronιns'

Lfu'

dnl

c|n|t'

a\eaε'e∆ t88'οοο hns . nroοrh

(aboul

6']ο0

ιts

i .liy)' ana an

ιvcnge o| ]0.11] unlqιe

τ.rrο.l

a

r.Ιrh

Ιn the

Pδr

thc ftιc of ttre mo.lmen

ral

s.ιοιn-'

ean]οn

\ιιs.lιΙi:

n soιιιtnnd

oΙ

li]r.Ιi]' sιrc]v.s ind.

wιΙr

Ιxιe eΙ.eptiοnj'

6e

pur.hased onη

bt

tire mon sc.iou

aΙd

deνored

sPeιiJ*s

Λ".w

l

|icι scιohny ed]tiοn

ι:an be

a..esed bΙ

PeΟPΙe

aΙl ove.

the

wοnd

with

vafι' diι}ιΙent ]rΙkgiοunds and

σ}in]ne

v'hat

∆nrmΓιons

ab.υr

8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

8/9

41a

εh.m.

S /υιιι)

Ε'ι]ο4

4{t

\αe might bc

'r]c

to adiu$ ι,ιι fielι]s

o|

inquj,y

il

ve,

tlriοugh edΦ.iaι

*'ork

οn

αxnsΙιι]ons, highl]ghted ihe 1imiιatioοs

o|..humanιιi. Iie]ds , ,

'

diviιled

by na.ions,,

Eο.

eΙamlle' we.οuld aΓP.oi.ιr

v.lrirmaa

νia

a

soc]Ιι teft

medtod rlrcre

ve∆ions

piι,dι.ea 6y non.Us

so.ietics iΦ ιey obieαs o| nt{es, The Ιemaι]ng

of

] stne

b

'M

aΙreΙed

ζulτuιΙl .onteΙ6 is i ri.h Ιna

ιrg.]y

untapped field

ο.an,Ι,sis

A

ruιy

exPanlve ele.ιιon1.

eJnion one moΙe eaPaοsiνe rh2n anΙ

yΦ

ιe'ιed

Φu1d m,ke

ιhι

FosibiΙiι],

a

Ba]ny'

\τ/hnman sxid

r.

οne

of

h6

ea'ly GeΙnan mns]aιοr

Ιt

i\as αoτ

beeΙ E;.

my

ιοunE' ]lι)ne aηh]riοls

r

dre salnrg

so

mxt seem thar

l

naγe.ompοsεd

that

wοrι, Ιt

ι]s

µen ιo

P.acticaΙΙy

yarι

an nfernationiny οεpοems The

|inat ann

ο|

rhe

U.ited

sιates

o|AneΙ].ι

ι ιho solidarny o| dt s1rld

oαe

pιrP.'e

o|

ην

.hao. 6 .o.οrι1].ι1t s,ιft aι IoΙeign lindj in Αmeι.a's

name,,(qιored

l.

lotsom

21]0,:

1ιο)

λs

Ed

Fοιοm

|xs.enrarked'

whjtnan..enrers most.οunfti.s

as

horh

λιtrJer md iΦnlgΙ]nr'

δ

che

conΙj.lenι'

pυsh,'

οveNhc]n]ng iePιεfΠ.nιive

ο.hλ

n.tiοο ,,,r1is the lnιmaιe'

inv1liαg' submssiγe. .n.]]csny naΙΙe]61e

1nmigΙΦr,

ιaιοse *1tι get'

a6so'bed

nnl]

reτi]tcn iα

sonre suΦrisnΙg

wayj,(loιοΙn

2oo':

l

ι0 ι ι]

S.hoIany

eιιι1ons, csñccinιΙ wnh

dt

lew p.s b]]iιes

jι

drcn eΙe..ιoni.

|o.r' .an tιοubtc ιΙrc natiοΙaιly bοunded vΛin

5ο .on]moo .o mon o| us,

Ια .lre ιcr

1ιtιi., ιιr. Ι,:],

Ι,,,l,,Ι ,1,τ,].ε

τi]]

Ñυb1nn

drc iist ψideΙy

tlntih.

utca sÑJnιh ]angege

edn1on

aΓ

Ι;a 4

ιfcι'r'one

oΓaα

goιι

is

ι, n*e

a.ru.ixι

do.Φeαt 1ιr

mdeΛιandins

\τ,hi.πιnι

.ncυΙ .io∆

io

the ιlλñ]nοιrone

lvοnd

evJilable, bιt in

equaιιy

lmlonint

goxl

n ω πι*e

aνailabιe aa

ediιion rιr1t τlLΙ

6Φa,]en the iυdr.n.e

tor thc.ldl,l'

L,οrh nΙ

rhe Us ]nd abΙo]d'

.ο ln.] de

a hυge

sPa.shjpΦkiog

poPιιtatiοn,

FoΙe1gn ΙaΠgu]ge earτjons

οieven nrajoi lndnΙy teas

nre

harJ

Ιo.oΙre ]ry οnlnιe'

ana rn

min'.δes.]re plryn.iloriginxΙs

π deι:ayinr]

ind

.ao bxιeιy bc

yui]ied

1t aΙl1τEnsΙ]ιons aid

οτheΓ .eΙJοose'

(nitnrj.'

Ι]tenΙy).nΙ

bc

pait

ol

tr

diεΙn1Ι \.nο|anv

editioο

ifwe.ike a

so.iοιogi.]] v]eΨ ο|rhe

reΙ.

Ιn rhn

1|, ,,

-ι ]i

,o,. ,.

vΦseu. nrar

φe aιe bcgnnrnΨ Φnι n is.nutnrg as rhe ΨoΙι

o1:ι Urιgua],ιn

ñοdt

vho

.xnsl .en

\.ιriaιin

oor

ane.ny

iion ΙΙglιL

but

τil

an

ftaΙi]o αaιΝΙtrtnJn

(iÑPaιen.ιy

]-υigl GiΙnbcnΙeι 19()r edtiοο)' and

ouι

reΙι

is b$cιt

o∆

the

ι9i2 Ι,

senrñeΙ nsu.'

,t.hcsι

detaiΙs

Ιe

lugge$n? ο| ιhe Jeγe]οPmenι

οfa

ñΙiti.uΙai

veΙsn]ι

οι

moacrn]sn nΙ

souτh

,{πe.jci'

aοιl o| ιhe .omÑΙex

οi.ιΙar]οΙ

.ι.u|l,e

τhe πnlΙanοn

Ñro]ecr

leryes δ ao exιm|lc oΓ tlrc eiPxιsit'itlry

of ele.σon1ι

ednn,ns

ιιeιtiοni. ιo.k

aΙlows an cι1nοr ro .οnsidcr ]dd]ιg mο.e

PeEÑeciiνes

and

r2reijaι

Φ

jlιumlo]te

ιexδ,,t.hesc

cΙ.ning

prospecs

rΙise

anen'fimili(

issues:

τ|ο

Ñav5

.o. exPΦsiγe

anιlexpcrimcnuΙ woΙlr/ Give∆

thf

nοt alι

οΓr]re

goιι

imaginabιe

by a

Ñ.oie.l

.m

bc n.ιr]eved'

i'h1t

ι dle aPpΙοpriite

s.o]e

ιnιl

rhat are thc be$

goa]s:

ScΙrolΙs 9hο.reate ele.σonl.

edfiοns

are

ensλged

ln ιnc

ñra.ti.e

οfhnrori.il

criι].nm, Eannlg texζ

∆

a wa]r

ιo

Ιeseπe

ιnιl

yυd,

ιιre

ΙjaΩ'

t(] b.n

jt

litrrvnr{]

ntο

the pΙeseflt $ thar

it

ΙemΙns

a

]iviιlg

Ñιa

o1

oω

ιeπ]ge, Ηor

n'e insπ'eΙ ωe

dΙιιuιr qιef ,ns ιhat

ιa.e us wiιl

Ιo

a

ιargc

caιent derermine

the

διπ'e.an

pο$es

and the Γuα].e ne

cin shañc,

i

|ι

Φdn

be

σgu€r

ι )2t

tb M4 ,J

o/trzf,j.

iqto6 di'ι

i Φuζλ

m1ιι ιl

ιbεln n1s

1i6a,ans

iαd

1,' ι'hζ5

rJude vlrε.

i'Φσ wtε

bouπl

ιυgde.

ιlto

vdumι1

ιo.

Po*σ{,:

oιc coυ|n

h{jfe

i

.o

η∆s

diBnnιiυα

aπ|

nιtηn ∆ ΙrυiΙly

(oaσι l(

] DΦnι

Ñrtι,

]ur

r

rΙaαdψ5'

ι

ι|

1ιrη.lαFro

Uοiαjtr o.

Nebωlkι

ι|ιτΙι

E.-r ιd

a

|n ]'0ο0'\E'e

t

ga(

b

$ññort dE

bιndωg

oi

P{Farent

Rειι

lΓΝcεs

cΝ

Ιι ιτ rΓn

Rι1 ιNc

8/18/2019 Kenneth M. Price

9/9

1t0

sΦΙtr, vxnιr. Νe

l1,or]a)

Ea

li8.

b

sΦaα

s.ιrreιbηa'' Rιl

sieπ..r'

Φa

]ohη

LΙη5iσth

|Ε|l')

λ .n'qrπ

b

nof;|re'

c

.Γhorιs

ο,9'

s.hoι Ι

ldiljog, ]o D c Gαιhln

ltd.)

ιΙodeα Ιigu:€

^soαπιo

r

Φ.9

]j

 αnghι, ιyιe Η

(r9j7'

196' iηιrinι

rft@

r4,,

san ιΙinno' c^: Ιlι rfgrcη ιibaa