JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONA 201L 2 - Joy of Tournaments Doubles_OCR.pdfJV LD HARVARD INVITATIONA 201L...

45
S : A S s,: r rt 1 5 00A M DOUB Andrzejczak, Dai JV Lincoln Douglas JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University Feb, 18-20,2012 First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever! Collegiate NE (Nathan Ewing-Crystal) vs. Cypress Woods RD (Robyn DarDar) AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE FXyr KScJ^ncifr b'^^r &Httoi NAME ^AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT <S The better debating was done by the from UfT AFForNEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME Signed: COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION: 71 ^m^T ) Houses d^vfi^T m.r 1 ^O'+lV.l }; to foe y/syy Vtl( ' 7 VcS^i -J 0b ^ ^ fi laj- 0 f ao°c) cVld ^ W c / He, C6Se I * ^O fefl^ct^ly Twr^ Yow ^ ^ ^ rv^ i ^ . - _____ ^ ^ LI ^ ^ 1 y* a..d UOT ^ A ^ . r out ^ ^ ^ .. ^ A'ot" Se^ XVtf/^e 'T" is fi^JeS \

Transcript of JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONA 201L 2 - Joy of Tournaments Doubles_OCR.pdfJV LD HARVARD INVITATIONA 201L...

S : A S s , : rr t

1 8 ° 5 0 0 A M DOUB Andrzejczak, Dai JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb, 18-20,2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Collegiate NE (Nathan Ewing-Crystal) vs. Cypress Woods RD (Robyn DarDar)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

FXyr KScJ^ncifr b ' ^ ^ r &Httoi NAME ^AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT < S

The better debating was done by the from U f T AFForNEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

S i g n e d :

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

71 ^m^T ) Houses d^vfi^T m . r 1 ^O'+lV.l }; to foe y/syy Vtl( '7

VcS^i - J 0 b ^ ^ fi laj- 0f ao°c) c V l d ^ W c /

H e , C 6 S e I * ^O fefl^ct^ly T w r ^

Y o w ^ ^ ^ r v ^ i

^ . - — _ _ _ _ _

^ ^ LI ^ ^ 1

y * a..d UOT ^ A ^ . r

o u t ^ ^ ^

. . ^ A ' o t " S e ^ X V t f / ^ e 'T" is fi^JeS \

Room: Sever 105 n n i I D I r j i Flight A: Start 8:00 AM U U U D L O D g , M a T C i a JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Cypress Woods RD (Robyn DarDar) vs. Collegiate NE (Nathan Ewirig-Crystal)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

G/qrtXJ UJctds ftp /i/Aw*/? NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAM^OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the / ^ V ^ ^ S from M t j ' & ^ k AFF or NE(j TEAM (/CONTESTANT NAME

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

oa-L

„ fO'd //our yoti /aJLi_ f/pt/t-uJ^- y lYfUJC „ 7

rf-'S )urU-fr'<°t

•u • Afar *

h i ^

** , ,, /

/ / yen A^tut jjfiot

oJt&Uc ^ ^ UMjpLeJUs-uuiJ

/cu /u*. d W ir ^

' l/tu/L /dZ&tS

Room: Sever 105 Flight A: Start 8:00 AM JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Collegiate NE (Nathan Ewing-Crystal) vs. Cypress Woods RD (Robyn DarDar)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

Cf tpr fS* COoiA^ ^ ( j j W l ^ M N a U 6 f AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

DOUB t t t rBue j - f^y j

The better debating was done by the N ^ - V from ^ U f f i l S d C „ ^ ^ ^

A A JL A i Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION: 1

-ftH'C differ ^ VAM ^ IajCM-

-Xix ^ SWW OKA % OMitoUr k»

- ft* , V , * W o - f M a ^

$ to 1V v^ O v A v ^ ^ V ^ 6>

Flight A: Start 8:00 AM DOUB Camara, Dario JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Ridge AP (Asli Pekcan) vs. Montville Township AV (Adin Vashi)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

I d u L - A f M tfwfA A V NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM<AR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

m fram frA^'lV/ft/ The better debating was done by the \ A F F or N E G V " TEAM OP CONTESTANT NAME

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

K W r ^ - 5 >

. ^ unr- i^c^kd fa

^ AC d ^ - ^ ^ J -

FMgMAsmart'siooam DOUB Kakani, Pragya JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Montville Township AV (Adin Vashi) vs. Ridge AP (Asli Pekcan)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRM&WE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the V V ' i r\ from ' v V r P-AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed: / u \ ' A ^

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

U c , . (

DOUB V & ^ B ^ Room: Sever 111 i r t . a f ^ ^ T ^ K 1 ^ Flight A: Start 8:00 AM JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Ridge AP (Asli Pekcan) vs. Montville Township AV (Adin Vashi)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the ^ ^ from

Signed:

TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

„ X V . / ^ i

l b , , ! - n

S T a S o o a m DOUB Delia Rocca, Pet JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Cary Academy HH (Hannah Hubbard) vs. Scarsdale AS (Aran Szanto)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

AfQtA NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the from A^ort to AFF or NFG f TEAM OR CONTESTANT IMAN

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION: IN I b & K t A & U I N l - U K U t U I C J l U I N : t .

DOUB ' — JV Lincoln Douglas

Room: Sever 205 Flight A: Start 8:00 AM

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Cary Academy HH (Hannah Hubbard) vs. ScarsdaleAS (Aron Szanto)

AFFIRMATIVE / \ NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the ^ from AFF or MEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

r~J\k$tjtoIwW q w

F TA TOCAM DOUB KlkH^^OfeU^ JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Cary Academy HH (Hannah Hubbard} vs. Scarsdale AS (Aron Szanto)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

Accu^cy-MH-/ Sco^S Aal-e, A-%/ Aftm S-giXK^ NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the M ^ A from "^fCXf-scWf A ^ / ^ f c ^ AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed _ —

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

FHgfrta?start8:ooam DOUB Mogilanski, Lisa JV Lincoln Douglas ^ ^ p j ^ c

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Christopher Columbus NA (Nick Anderson) vs. Bridgewater-Raritan GC (Grace Chen)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

Litnstoplut' Columbus M l \ Rvidiflr«uiatir - f c a r i f - s u A NAME oV AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT \ NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the from fi)ncb(h t\AJ&Ms\ ' ( h * ^ fa*-

u TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed: y C X ^ / /.. Q-r,y - t u - V

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

^ - I H u ^ CQ^ vVUUAt [kCVJS- CdAC SVxtx bc^ s i p ^ i ^ Y ^

a f ' a ^ n x ^ r s IW r \ C flXirj,. c c u ^ - H v ^ v A ^ V ^

te QV^A^u^aA ; W " ^ SrdVl-Vi CK \x\Wc S u f f e r .

NC - (AM& mt 0Jf\d Hspcnsa io A C - fee* vvv<XW Suvt a ^ t - H A * , IWAJC

be\ujeevv_ -Wvj l V C VAUVJL r e s p o n s e s e e ^ s ^ e x ^ i a . ' ^

. r >vt; i COM. " -: ^ ^ w ^awnuti- w w ^ ^

NC Cleanly c K y ^ v

b W t Xd ^ n p o ^ o w a i i ^ "" s, so 2 - K ^ l . loW ( v w ^

a n d ^ avid CAM i iun puts betttwuc O c u ^ i : \ J h a d } - t l u f - d c c t H ^

hO'At I'jlM - tiff oM.Yi H^J ^R A' ; bra of ofllu-yt , /Pu^ k o-fi-M^ vjirpiif/tiLj avifte-ftc? . T^u^ "75c/0 'olmuc cf

mu&br bJ abuse/' / ^ £xin\cltJU>} j\ fft /Is /^iJ cfea.* (u^

Room: Sever 101 Flight A: Start 8:00 AM JV Lincoln Douglas

DOUB Ryan, Will

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Bridgewater-Raritan GC (Grace Chen) vs. Christopher Columbus NA (Nick Anderson)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

^ U N A M E OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT '

The better debating was done by the

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

y / b v t f tccvtorv^-

9 o y x l ^ t e J , -fa h o j ? r t

pttyC'Seck; }cii fv* vJhoA . - K t C o v h ^ j d o w n f p .

t v M A r v u ^ v f - I

V v ^ w Vv«v M ^ ^ & a K -e v e r v i e w -

V ^ t s ^ -CtfH ^-f i

yuvf K ^ i I qjJI Hr a, i o l ^ 1 - a j f i ^

f o l i i X

: ryv i v e -fa • - h a

I v & k ^ t / M r ^ # t w o>vt

^ m wI f - i P S H W ' t , ^ . 0 o m v J . . J

•3

night£storts-ooam DOUB Chen, Floronco JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Christopher Columbus NA (Nick Anderson) vs Bridgewater-Raritan GC (Grace Chen)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT ^ NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the A ^ ^ 7 from bjik* - ^ ^ , AFF or NK>- TEAW <iR CONTESTANT NAME

c

FMgh"?BssTarts045am DOUB Struver, Zack

JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20,2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Westford Academy CZ (Chris Zhang) vs. Walt Whitman YC (Yael Caplan)

AFFIRMATIVE / NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the from fa^UV?/Vgu^ A F F o r N E G / TEAM OR CONTES^ANTNAME— —

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

i^ey - laMl ^ UuvJ^

hO Ossecw''? . . .

Q/ u/chv \Pt d&r^oX < It Vf.

J v l 0 aotfcj

M /n

^ i i/ TfTPwT™ • f r o / ^ S ^ v ^ V ^ K n ^

S r ^ c f

• J - r C*-*. (

S o f r ^ i ^ i M -

Room: Sever 109 DOUB StrilVei\ ZaCk Flight A: Start 8:00 AM L / V / V I » w u w v w , " - w v JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Stuyvesant EL (Elissa Li) vs. Scarsdale MM (Matt Mandel)

AFFIRMATIVE / V NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTAMT

The better debating was dgne by the I l/gjfr) from AFF or NEC TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

^jha ^ s - t u X z r a W ^ ^

ton -

DOUB KimrMe JV Lincoln Douglas ^

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20,2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Regis JC (Janus Cataluna) vs. SandHoke Early Colleg ZW (Zakyree Wallace)

AFFIRMATIVE v / n / \ /

NEGATIVE

G-kkm UaflQce NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the A/ty from _ hnclHoke, Ac(= a "-MEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed: ^ ^ ^ / y ^ C J C C / o n

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

GooqI wphu^iS o/) Occe^S, didnH u/x/en^cW uity you emphM'Uect SVC'of Coo Jrod l/c 4hQ~f

moral,-ty see f f )S a W r a c f r

NOj l Goad ^cW jn ^^ arrf hohi^ whole problem; fk>v u/tfl ctjch o f I/,0iptte corrlmc & abusers c/<Pcol ? QqoQ1 poifrfiipy ocrf

RPD

free c o / j ^ ^ Jfa ptytica/ socurjjf h&or^ mora/ify

Flight A: Start 8:00 AM DOUB Zhang, Alex JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Independent BT (Bradley Tobias) vs. Scarsdale GT (Garrett Tanzer)

AFFIRMATIVE V j \ „ NEGATIVE

c / NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

from The better debating was done by the j . ; AFForNEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NA.VIE

Signed: H

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

FhgAstertooAM DOUB Knight, Brandee JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Independent BT (Bradley Tobias) vs. Scarsdale GT (Garrett Tanzer)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

Xrydf^deA 8 V S c a < S c b i £ fff NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the Al from

Signed

AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

ooV • flVtfci Jof* t j - b iflrfr*"

(*• i/cur autni»rate£l or AAV-* bbttftu c i/cur m - Ve/c .

V ^ M v V c p W x ^ O iai K jcnJ I f

Kuf ft^t i * i is , V W S I V m f l V ^ o v J & M i

UL. v^nje*

/ v ^ . i • — :

^ •har^Wf - •

u,, frfF\]C was \jj! wc^^ti

R o o m : Sever 204 n A I I D \ # • F L I G H T A . S T A R T 8 . 0 0 A M u u u b Y a n , J e n n y JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Independent BT (Bradley Tobias) vs. Scarsdale GT (Garrett Tanzer)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

X / r t f f t H c A i v t ? r ScmsMI NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the N from _ AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

I (

C*M. ^ ft* et'ftii^)

i w frw <v b -toll"** w^spc** -

A D D R T J J J P S P E C R F T ' L

bl<_ ft u^s trircftfJi by /Wy ^Vic^

c ^ c i L M f { or l / t y oi-C . Aff X bjoj fit^ro tA^j VL Vc Mie^ eitd'tf a-btctj AA iiMf Su.

Hccvv <>4 0<i My. A-f-f d^A ft pw.tU SthA

F^TBSstear

rt280445AM DOUB Zhang, Alex

JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Ridge YK (Yana Kropotova) vs Harrison AG (Amy Geller)

AFFIRMATIVE X , \ „ NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the ^ from ^ ^ AFF cr NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAVE

Signed: c/ COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

Room: Sever 104 Flight B: Start 8:45 AM JV Lincoln Douglas

DOUB Herrera, Marie

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Scarsdale RG (Rahul Gosain) vs. Southside HS - Ctr fo NK (Neha Kumar)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the from TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

/ <>

U r^feJl \ D ^ 0 f W T K ^ .

.U/.'/t/ec Flight B: Start 8:45 AM DOUB Singh, Camille JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Southside HS - Ctrfo NK (Neha Kumar) vs. Scarsdale RG (Rahul Gosain)

AFFIRMATIVE X \ NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

from The better debating was done by the AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION

Flight B: Start 8:45 AM DOUB Kim, Alex JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Scarsdale RG (Rahul Gosain) vs. Southside HS - Ctr to NK (Neha Kumar)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE ^^S^ — l ^ w - £ U — (L&J, (yo

NAME OF AFFPRMATRVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

from S W s f r U The better debating was done by the AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAVIE

Signed;

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

0*. 2-^rof ^ t rec / / j t sh^

h ^ b - S I ^ a m DOUB Kakani, Pragya JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Regis PM (Patrick May) vs. Clear Lake WW (William Wu)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT N£ME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

from CVfeCvf L - C p ^ s Q W

u The better debating was done by the _i

AFF or NEG TEAVI OR CONTESTANT NAME

1.1

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

SgSZXUm DOUB Wu, Dob - a x JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Regis PM (Patrick May) vs. Clear Lake WW (William Wu)

(^AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

from ( ^ V S P A V The better debating was done by the AFF or NEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

Signed:

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

tOc.1 ..

Flight B: Start 8:45 AM DOUB Camara, Dario JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20,2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Regis PM (Patrick May) vs Clear Lake WW (William Wu)

AFFIRMATIVE , NEGATIVE

o NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the Z. from TEAM OR CONTESTANT MAME

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

OJhodt u ^ <<+ r'SUly (AJ J A / j^TU us**- 61/1 ^ ^ ^ [ i t f p ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^

, fuJb ^^ ^ tsMAA^ f^y^^ty

/ J^ /N iaJL^ ^ ^ \fiP^r i r v A ^ ^ c V w ur-tL ^

U D P

Sb^SSbam DOUB k M r m l M e U a JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Delbarton RT (Ryan Teehan) vs. Bronx Science ES (Ean Steinberger)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

DeI\>ct)CV0 rv f t / fty w HoXt o n v S r ^ n c c ES/ J t - t r n W r NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

_ from Oelkar+on The better debating was done by the AFF or NEG TEAM 0 3 CONTESTANT NAME

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

Signed: / ^ f t g ^ f c ^ ^

ESFbSEE.*. DOUB Delia Rocca, Pet JV Lincoln Douglas

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Bronx Science ES (Ean Steinberger) vs. Delbarton RT (Ryan Teehan)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

b c M c i / i b&iY £ f NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the from A ^ S r N E G TEAM OR CONTESTANT M^lJlE '

Signed: J & ^ C ^ j j M y ^ ^ ,

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

Room: Sever 205 Flight B: Start 8:45 AM JV Lincoln Douglas

DOUB

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Bronx Science ES (Ean Steinberger) vs. Delbarton RT (Ryan Teehan)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the $ f1^ from

Signed:

TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION:

/ /

S s ) appi^ i M I L u > ^ a to'Rve 4 U i i u j , , ^ ^ M i -ni Ci Ltfj Tt>lfl mm. ^ m mmm. 0 mm . . . . . . Mogilanski, Lisa Room: Sever 101 ' l l v "t lcl

Flight B: Start 8:45 AM fe w f uuxl flWtf / JV Lincoln Douglas ^ 2 | V ? is HSPp

fliftlMuMte+W f / H r t h t d cw- t • V j i ^ f ^ f c c w v c i w s w U C - ooi.-

JV'LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 201^ Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

East Mountain BC (Benjamin Chitty) vs. Woodlands AC (Abbey Chapman)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

£h<f Mfu^iftiM F>C /laymds AC

/ f - W W O t - s

r ^ s - t r z r Y w ^

i'p'dsf G K idv NC / S !f'j

> lu-ftX _

Fiv ± c NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the from {IhJf tudA ^ C 'EAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

S i g n e d : . ^ M a ^ f ^ L x

Ojui

j U m • T H I S

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION.

t'Lr. m ^ m^

• Aft- aft, ^ ^ W # lo^mt si* rmMJ f c * *

fUiUtMV

J

VC-V'-t AA v^v'v C 'j • y a t - v . ^C^AIwC.^

e m c w v - • *

roacz.icJ'd .. -tf.as l^'^cJ of-

f i l ( & p ^ H oj

d L t d : $ v C o . - W t , / . fljj^ ™ w <0 /

(LffajMtitLii fo. imnmt M^ ^ I W ^

K ^ ' ^ i / l OPViO i^ l l ! t V i / v H u I C / b u ^ p l c s U o

wo»A i W - ^ ^

r ' -

tA-V- IflOiX, i V ( i ^ c ^ i d - w j Vx!

i i C A T ^ 'tvyw^ >$1 i»f>^z(-

m : irwuiu.rtatt^ rt . ^ d . d <VftCH^ U)< rfKkud u a i SixmciIt) fiefusmvc • / V / -rt-w /^c A " f t L ^ T ' SvppctfCt Hru tvaiuait -Hm IC , i^vuch. ^ ^ ^ ' A ..

-thc,^ } a^Iivanb ^fv irutnt ^ Lionel sc ff - cttA^ /s

Room: Sever 101 Flight B: Start 8:45 AM JV Lincoln Douglas

DOUB ~ Ryan, Will

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

East Mountain BC (Benjamin Chitty) vs. Woodlands AC (Abbey Chapman)

AFFIRMATIVE

j V A i v b NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

NEGATIVE

\ A l f i f l r i I f l i i d s f e u -NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the J from V \ i b ^ IomoL-J kv TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION

- q f r . p i u + ^ v <3 W ^ *

VvDvP C w U i e l f t -

o p p o n M ^ C , Vis^&rZ-rj ^ q a v x ^ " fa W * * ^ - W ^ r w f ^

^Md w/ t ^ M t>i ortUr j } bx jzile^is c/j W c^^-

r n A - i n - f a i K u j e v i r p t n ^

m o v e ^ p ^ 1 ^

I A ^ I K ( p r ^ t M ^ p ^ t K ^ n c L K i a i W t ^ f t

opp. \ Vu'tf Ne'fj tfll/^ Coverage, pw. T*

Flight B: Start 8:45 AM DOUB QteffpFtereTfee^ JV Lincoln Douglas ^

JV LD HARVARD INVITATIONAL 2012 Harvard University

Feb. 18-20, 2012

First judge listed act as chair. Disclose decision and award trophy to non-advancing competitor. Ballots due at 9:45 AM to the ballot desk in Sever!

Woodlands AC (Abbey Chapman) vs. East Mountain BC (Benjamin Chitty)

AFFIRMATIVE NEGATIVE

^ A S T Mpot/v/T/A//^ ftt- / V p D S *C NAME OF AFFIRMATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAME OF NEGATIVE TEAM OR CONTESTANT

The better debating was done by the _ _ from k J p \ ^ c

AFF orNEG TEAM OR CONTESTANT NAVE

COMMENTS & REASON FOR DECISION: '

NtA rvoUkU, ^ ^ / v v s a t < v * * ^ ^ ^

W dcwaut h> xJj^tLctcb. .

-fUjL % ^

I ^ ffl bwU^i felltru^ / , M f t . ; ^ ^ ^ ^ v ^ ^ ^ f ^ v / S A ' / /