Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

download Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

of 47

Transcript of Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    1/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    2/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    3/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    4/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    5/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    6/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    7/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    8/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    9/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    10/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    11/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    12/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    13/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    14/47

    E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    15/47

    E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    16/47

    In the Iowa District Court in and for SAC County

    Case No: 02811 LACV019374 Title: BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH

    NOTICE REGARDING ELECTRONIC FILING

    This case has been converted to an electronic case by Order of the Court.

    New rules apply to electronically filed cases.Because your case has been converted to an electronic case, it is now governed by Chapter 16 Rules Pertainingto the Use of the Electronic Document Management System. What is required of you? You must register to use the Electronic Document Management System (EDMS). If you haven't already registered, please log on to the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website at https://www.iowacourts.state.ia.us/EFile to register. You are required to have a current e-mail account for use with EDMS. Registration requires you to understandand agree to comply with the rules that govern electronic filing, contained the Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining tothe use of the Electronic Document Management System, available on the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website.

    Your registration constitutes your request for, and consent to, electronic service of court-generated documentsand documents filed electronically by other parties. When you have completed your registration, you can beginfiling and viewing documents on your case and receiving notifications of filings, and events. EXCEPTIONS: For good cause, the court may authorize you to submit a document in paper. Upon showing of exceptional circumstances, the chief judge of the district in which a case is pending may grant you an exemptionfrom registering and filing electronically. You must protect private information when using EDMS.

    Division VI of Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic Document Management Systemspecifies personal information that is now considered protected by the court, as well as what you must do tokeep protected personal information out of the public documents you eFile. Training and technical support are available for EDMS.Technical support for the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website is available at 1-877-369-8324. If you havequestions about court procedures related to electronic filing, contact your county clerk of court office.

    We look forward to your comments and suggestionsas we implement electronic filings in the Iowa Courts

    E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    17/47

    In The Iowa District Court for the Second Judicial District

    In re the conversion of paper files

    to electric documents

    Administrative Order

    Iowa Court Rule 16.102 authorizes a chief judge to order the conversion of paper court files to an

    electronic file of any case not subject to the Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic DocumentManagement System (EDMS). It is in the best interest of all for the Court to have access via EDMS to pendingfiles that exist at the time a county clerk of court office implements EDMS. Accordingly: It is so Ordered that:

    1. Each Clerk of Court may take action to convert paper case files that are pending and will likely appear on a future court schedule as soon as implementation of EDMS begins in their respective counties. 2. The Clerk shall work with the local Court to identify specific documents that are to be scanned in each case type. Upon implementation of electronic filing in the County, the security level of these electronic records shall be as identified by the EDMS Business Advisory Committee. 3. The Clerk shall send the Notice Regarding Electronic Filing to the attorneys and parties appearing pro se. 4. Once notified, counsel of record or parties appearing pro se shall apply the rules pertaining to

    protection of personal privacy (Iowa Ct.R.16.602 through 16.607) to all future filings in that case.

    5. After being notified of commencement of the electronic filing in that County, attorneys, parties appearing pro se and all other shall file all future filings on that case electronically. It is so Ordered: Dated 3rd day of November, 2010

    /s/ Kurt L. WilkeKurt L. Wilke, Chief Judge of the SecondJudicial District of Iowa

    E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    18/47

    Case ID : 02811 LACV019374 - BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGHEvent Cd : NOOT

    DAVID POWELL JENNETT filed

    E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    19/47

    In the Iowa District Court in and for SAC County

    Case No: 02811 LACV019374 Title: BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH

    NOTICE REGARDING ELECTRONIC FILING

    This case has been converted to an electronic case by Order of the Court.

    New rules apply to electronically filed cases.Because your case has been converted to an electronic case, it is now governed by Chapter 16 Rules Pertainingto the Use of the Electronic Document Management System. What is required of you? You must register to use the Electronic Document Management System (EDMS). If you haven't already registered, please log on to the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website at https://www.iowacourts.state.ia.us/EFile to register. You are required to have a current e-mail account for use with EDMS. Registration requires you to understandand agree to comply with the rules that govern electronic filing, contained the Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining tothe use of the Electronic Document Management System, available on the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website.

    Your registration constitutes your request for, and consent to, electronic service of court-generated documentsand documents filed electronically by other parties. When you have completed your registration, you can beginfiling and viewing documents on your case and receiving notifications of filings, and events. EXCEPTIONS: For good cause, the court may authorize you to submit a document in paper. Upon showing of exceptional circumstances, the chief judge of the district in which a case is pending may grant you an exemptionfrom registering and filing electronically. You must protect private information when using EDMS.

    Division VI of Chapter 16 Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic Document Management Systemspecifies personal information that is now considered protected by the court, as well as what you must do tokeep protected personal information out of the public documents you eFile. Training and technical support are available for EDMS.Technical support for the Iowa Judicial Branch eFiling website is available at 1-877-369-8324. If you havequestions about court procedures related to electronic filing, contact your county clerk of court office.

    We look forward to your comments and suggestionsas we implement electronic filings in the Iowa Courts

    E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    20/47

    In The Iowa District Court for the Second Judicial District

    In re the conversion of paper files

    to electric documents

    Administrative Order

    Iowa Court Rule 16.102 authorizes a chief judge to order the conversion of paper court files to an

    electronic file of any case not subject to the Rules Pertaining to the Use of the Electronic DocumentManagement System (EDMS). It is in the best interest of all for the Court to have access via EDMS to pendingfiles that exist at the time a county clerk of court office implements EDMS. Accordingly: It is so Ordered that:

    1. Each Clerk of Court may take action to convert paper case files that are pending and will likely appear on a future court schedule as soon as implementation of EDMS begins in their respective counties. 2. The Clerk shall work with the local Court to identify specific documents that are to be scanned in each case type. Upon implementation of electronic filing in the County, the security level of these electronic records shall be as identified by the EDMS Business Advisory Committee. 3. The Clerk shall send the Notice Regarding Electronic Filing to the attorneys and parties appearing pro se. 4. Once notified, counsel of record or parties appearing pro se shall apply the rules pertaining to

    protection of personal privacy (Iowa Ct.R.16.602 through 16.607) to all future filings in that case.

    5. After being notified of commencement of the electronic filing in that County, attorneys, parties appearing pro se and all other shall file all future filings on that case electronically. It is so Ordered: Dated 3rd day of November, 2010

    /s/ Kurt L. WilkeKurt L. Wilke, Chief Judge of the SecondJudicial District of Iowa

    E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    21/47

    Case ID : 02811 LACV019374 - BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGHEvent Cd : NOOT

    DAVID POWELL JENNETT filed

    E-FILED 2013 MAY 30 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    22/47

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 03 10:35 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    23/47

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 03 10:35 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    24/47

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 05 9:30 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    25/47

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 05 9:30 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    26/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    27/47

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 08 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    28/47

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 08 9:49 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    29/47

    IN THE IOWA DISTRICT COURT IN AND FOR SAC COUNTY

    BROCO, LLC.,Plaintiff,

    vs. Case No. LACV019374

    TRENT MC ONO!"#, ORDER CONTINUING HEARINGefen$ant

    T%is &atte' is set fo' %ea'in( on )*ne 13 t%, +013 at 9 00 a.&. in -a Co*nt/, o a.

    Atto'ne/ fo' t%e Plaintiff &a/ not 2e a2le to atten$ 2e a*se of %is &ot%e' s on$ition.

    !n$e' t%e i' *&stan es, t%is &atte' is %e'e2/ ontin*e$ to a $ate to 2e $ete'&ine$ 2/

    t%e Co*'t an$ atto'ne/s.

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 13 3:42 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    30/47

    State of Iowa Courts

    Type: ORDER FOR CONTINUANCE

    Case Number Case TitleLACV019374 BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH

    So Ordered

    Electronically signed on 2013-06-13 15:42:55 page 2 of 2

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 13 3:42 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    31/47

    Notice Id: 2CA004IN THE IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

    BROCO LLC,

    Plaintiff / Petitioner,

    vs. TRENT MCDONOUGH ,

    Defendant / Respondent.

    Notice of Civil Trial Setting Conference

    Case No: 02811 LACV019374

    A scheduling conference will be held on 06/25/13 at 11:00 AM with Kellie Orres, as District CourtDesignee, pursuant to I.R.C.P 1.602.

    This conference shall be conducted by telephone conference call initiated by plaintiff's counsel. Kellie Orres may be contacted via telephone at: (515) 574-3752.

    1. PARTICIPATION: All attorneys appearing in the case shall participate in this conference. A partywho is not represented by counsel shall contact the Court Administrator's office (at the above phonenumber) prior to the date and time of the conference call. 2. TRIAL SCHEDULING: A firm trial date shall be established in accordance with the SupremeCourt's time standards as provided by Chapter 23, Iowa Court Rules. NO CONTINUANCES SHALLBE GRANTED EXCEPT BY COURT ORDER, UPON GOOD CAUSE SHOWN. 3. SANCTIONS: If a party or attorney fails to participate in the scheduling conference or issubstantially unprepared to participate in the conference, the Court may impose appropriatesanctions, including reasonable expenses and attorney fees. (I.R.C.P 1.602(5)).

    /s/ Kellie Orres --------------------------------------- Designee of the Court Clerk to provide copies ornotice of document to attorneysof record and parties appearing

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 17 9:27 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    32/47

    pro se.

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 17 9:27 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    33/47

    Case ID : 02811 LACV019374 - BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGHEvent Cd : OFTN

    DAVID POWELL JENNETT filedJOSEPH JOHN HEIDENREICH filed

    E-FILED 2013 JUN 17 9:27 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    34/47

    Notice Id: 2CA101

    IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

    BROCO LLC,

    Plaintiff / Petitioner,

    vs. TRENT MCDONOUGH ,

    Defendant / Respondent.

    Case No: 02811 LACV019374

    Trial Notice

    The above entitled matter is hereby scheduled for non-jury trial on 10/24/13 at 09:00 AM .

    1 Day Damages IssueDiscovery Due 60 days prior to trial

    /s/ Kellie Orres ----------------------------------- Designee of the Court

    Clerk to provide copies or noticeof this document to attorneys of record,parties appearing pro se and

    judge if assigned

    Docket Code = OSTR

    E-FILED 2013 JUL 02 11:52 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    35/47

    Case ID : 02811 LACV019374 - BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGHEvent Cd : OSTR

    DAVID POWELL JENNETT filedJOSEPH JOHN HEIDENREICH filed

    E-FILED 2013 JUL 02 11:52 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    36/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    37/47

    State of Iowa Courts

    Case Number Case TitleLACV019374 BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGH

    Type: ORDER FOR CONTINUANCE

    So Ordered

    Electronically signed on 2013-10-23 11:33:43

    2 of 2

    E-FILED 2013 OCT 23 11:33 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    38/47

    IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

    BROCO LLC,

    Plaintiff, vs. TRENT MCDONOUGH ,

    Defendant.

    Case No: 02811 LACV019374

    EXHIBIT LIST

    Trial to the CourtOctober 30, 2013

    Presiding Judge: William C. Ostlund

    The following exhibits were offered and admitted by the Court at the hearing as shown above: Plaintiff's

    1. Photos2. Rental Agreement

    3. Bills for repairs4. Rent payments5. Wall Lake Lumber6. Punch list7. Diapers (not offered)8. Damages

    Defendant's

    101.102. check103. Laursen Construction

    1 of 2

    E-FILED 2013 OCT 31 9:22 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    39/47

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    40/47

    2RCV12IN THE IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

    BROCO LLC,

    Plaintiff,

    vs. TRENT MCDONOUGH ,

    Defendant.

    Case No. 02811 LACV019374

    COURT REPORTER MEMORANDUM AND CERTIFICATE

    COURT REPORTER MEMORANDUM

    (The court reporter shall file this memorandum with the district court clerk.)

    Appearances: For Plaintiff/Petitioner: Joseph HeidenreichFor Defendant/Respondent: David Jennett

    Other:

    Information required by Iowa Rule of Civil Procedure 1.903(3): I, Nancy A. Timmons, am providing the following information as required by Iowa Rule of CivilProcedure 1.903(3):

    1. The type of proceeding that was reported: trial to the Court 2. The date(s) on which the proceeding occurred: October 30, 2013 3. The name of the court reporter who reported the proceeding: Nancy A. Timmons 4. The name of the judge who presided over the proceeding: William C. Ostlund 5. The reporting fee for the proceeding: $40.00 6. We, the undersigned judge before whom the above-entitled case was tried, and the official courtreporter who, by order of the Court, reported the same, do hereby certify that the above and foregoingis the report of the whole proceedings upon the trial and/or hearing of the above-entitled cause madeand taken pursuant to the order and direction of the Court, in accordance with Iowa Code Section624.10. /s/Nancy A. Timmons _________________________________________

    1 of 2

    E-FILED 2013 OCT 31 9:24 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    41/47

    State of Iowa CourtsCase Number Case TitleLACV019374 BROCO, LLC. VS. TRENT MCDONOUGHType: COURT REPORTER MEMORANDUM AND CERTIFICATE

    So Ordered

    Electronically signed on 2013-10-31 09:23:42

    2 of 2

    E-FILED 2013 OCT 31 9:24 AM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    42/47

    IOWA DISTRICT COURT FOR SAC COUNTY

    BROCO, LLC, ))

    Plaintiff, ) No. LACV019 !"

    ) #$. ) Fin%in&$ of Fa't,) Con'l($ion$ of La an% R(lin&

    TR*NT +'DONOU -, ))

    D f n%ant. )

    T/i$ 'ont $t % att a$ t i % to t/ Co( t on O'to2 0, 301 .

    T/ a(t/o i4 % a& nt of t/ Plaintiff a$ 5 $ nt alon& it/ t/ i atto n 6 7o$ 5/

    - i% n i'/. T/ D f n%ant a$ 5 $ nt 5 $ nt % 26 /i$ atto n 6 Da#i%

    7 nn tt. T/ Co( t /a$ 'on$i% % t/ t $ti on6, t/ #i% n' off % an%

    a'/ $ t/ follo in& fin%in&$ of fa't, 'on'l($ion$ of la an% (lin&.

    Findings of Fact

    C/('8 B ot/ ton t $tifi % a$ t/ a(t/o i4 % 5 $ ntati# of

    B o'o. - i$ al$o t/ C*O of Wall La8 L( 2 Co 5an6 an% o n$ a n( 2 of

    ot/ l( 2 'o 5ani $. T/ 'o 5o ation o n$ t/ 5 o5 t6 in ( $tion lo'at %

    in Sa' Cit6, Io a. It i$ a %(5l : 'ontainin& a 8it'/ n, li#in& oo , t o 2 % oo $,a 2at/ oo , an% &a a& . T/i$ 5 o5 t6 a$ 2(ilt in 199; an% /a$ /a% t o

    t nant$. T/ t nant 5 #io($ to t/ D f n%ant li# % t/ fo l # n 6 a $. T/

    D f n%ant /a$ li# % t/ fo t o 6 a $, : 'i$in& a ntal l a$ 'o n'in& t/

    1$t %a6 of A(&($t, 3010, an% $i%in& in t/ 5 o5 t6 (ntil / l ft a55 o:i at l6

    A5 il 1, 3013. T/ nt a$ in t/ a o(nt of 0. T/ l a$ f( t/ 5 o#i% %

    t/at ?an6 noti' , fo /i'/ 5 o#i$ion i$ a% in t/i$ ntal a& nt, $/all 2 in

    itin& an% a6 2 &i# n 26 it/ 5a t6 to t/ ot/ in a%%ition to an6 ot/

    ann 5 o#i% % 26 la . . .@ + . B ot/ ton $tat % t/at t/ 5 o5 t6 /a% 2 n

    ll aintain % an% /a% 2 n 'l an % 5 io to t/ l a$ a& nt it/ t/

    D f n%ant an% a$ 'l an % follo in& /i$ :it. S #i' $ 5 o#i% % to t/

    Plaintiff 26 t/ 'l anin& 'o 5an6 8no n a$ t/ ?Co(nt 6 Co($in$.@ It i$ t/

    'ont ntion of t/ Plaintiff t/at t/ D f n%ant %i% not &i# 5 o5 noti' of /i$

    t ination of t/ l a$ an% o % on ont/ $ nt. In a%%ition, t/ Plaintiff

    E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    43/47

    2

    a &( $ t/at t/ 5 o5 t6 a$ l ft in a $tat of t i2l 'l anlin $$ an% 5 an nt

    %a a& /a% 2 n %on to t/ 5 o5 t6 /i'/ (i % $(2$tantial 'l anin& an%

    5la' nt. T/($, t/ la $(it a$ fil % an% t/ o i&inal 'o 5laint all & %

    %a a& $ o % in :' $$ of

    it $, 2(t al$o a%%itional :5 n$ $ lat % to :t ao %ina 6 'l anin&, 'l an (5

    at ial$ an% (n5ai% (tilit6 2ill$. -o # , t/ a55a nt fi&/tin& i$$( i$ t/

    5la' nt of 'a 5 t it/in t/ ntal 5 o5 t6. Plaintiff $tat $ t/at t/

    5 o5 t6 a$ 2 6on% 'l anin& an% 5la' nt a$ (i %.

    S($an F an8, /o a$ on of t/ ?Co(nt 6 Co($in$,@ t $tifi % t/at

    on A5 il 13, 3013, $/ a$ /i % to 'l an t/ a5a t nt. S/ al$o $tat % t/at $/

    'l an % 2 fo t/ D f n%ant o# % in. S/ $tat % t/at t/ 'on%ition of t/

    a5a t nt 5 io to D f n%ant a$ &oo%, in'l(%in& t/ 'a 5 tin&. S/ t $tifi %

    t/at aft t/ D f n%ant /a% l ft, t/ 5 o5 t6 a$ ?5 tt6 na$t6.@ S/ $tat % t/at

    t/ all$ an% ' ilin&$ 2la'8 an% t/at t/ 'a 5 t a$ 2 6on% 2 in& 'l an %.

    T/ a55lian' $ filt/6 an% in / $ti ation, & o$$. S/ $tat % t/at t/

    'on%ition$ o $ t/an no al. S/ $tat % t/at &a 2a& /a% 2 n l ft an%

    t/at it a$ / o5inion t/at t/ 5 o5 t6 /a% not 2 n 5 o5 l6 ta8 n 'a of.

    T/($, $/ $tat % t/at t/ 2ill a$ o t/an t/ o %ina 6 2(t a$ (i % to'l an t/ 5 o5 t6 to a $(ita2l 'on%ition. A n( 2 of :/i2it$ off %,

    in'l(%in& *:/i2it 1, /i'/ 5i't( $ ta8 n $(2$ ( nt to t/ D f n%ant $

    l a#in&. T/ 6 off % to $(2$tantiat t/ %i t6 'on%ition t/at t/ 5 o5 t6

    a$ in follo in& /i$ % 5a t( .

    Ra'/ l B ot/ ton, /o i$ a i % to C ai& t/ & an%$on of C/('8

    B ot/ ton), t $tifi % a$ t/ 5/oto& a5/ of t/ 5i't( $ i% ntifi % a$ *:/i2it 1.

    S/ l6 $tat % t/at $/ o(l% not /a# li# % t/ , % $' i2in& t/ 'on%ition$

    a$ non li#a2l .

    T/ Plaintiff a &( $ t/at on ont/ $ nt a$ %( a$ / %i% not

    ' i# an6 noti' of t/ D f n%ant $ l a#in& o int ntion to l a# .

    T/ D f n%ant t $tifi % t/at / /a% li# % t/ fo a t o 6 a $,

    alon& it/ /i$ $on. In fa't, / $tat % t/at t/ $i% n' a$ ($ % ainl6 a$ a

    $to5 o# 2 'a($ / t a# l % :t n$i# l6 an% %i% littl nt tainin& an% 'oo8in&

    E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    44/47

    3

    on t/ 5 o5 t6. - $tat % t/at t/ a$ #i% n' of a2($ of t/ 5 o5 t6 / n

    / o# % in an% $tat % t/at an6 of t/ a 8$ on t/ floo t/ $(lt of t/

    t nan'6 of t/ 5 #io($ l # n 6 a $. T/ D f n%ant $ $i$t an% ot/ t $tifi %

    t/at t/ 6 'all % (5on to / l5 'l an (5 t/ 5 o5 t6 / n T nt o# % in. It

    a$ t/ i o2$ #ation t/at it a$ %i t6 an% t/at t/ 5la' ? 8 %@ of $ o8 . T/D f n%ant # n $tat % t/at / /a% ($ % $i: o%o 2o 2$ to 'o(nt a't t/ $ ll

    / n / o# % in. T/ D f n%ant $tat % t/at / a$ t/ o n of nin ntal

    5 o5 ti $ an% a$ fa ilia it/ t/ lan%lo % $ %(ti $ an% o2li&ation$. T/

    D f n%ant $tat % t/at / /a% tol% 7i +a$on t/ (noffi'ial 5 o5 t6 ana& )

    of /i$ int ntion$ to o# an% 'on$i% % t/at $(ffi'i nt noti' to t/ Plaintiff. In

    $/o t, / f lt t/at / a$ not o2li&at % fo t/ a%%itional ont/ $ nt.

    Conclusions of Law and Ruling

    T/i$ la $(it i$ % 'i% % in la & 5a t 2a$ % (5on t/ Co( t $

    5 ' 5tion of t/ ' %i2ilit6 of t/ 5a ti $ in 'on (n'tion it/ t/ :/i2it$.

    *:/i2it 1 'l a l6 $ta2li$/ $ t/at t/ 5 o5 t6 a$ in 5oo $/a5 / n t/

    D f n%ant l ft t/ 5 o5 t6. T/ t $ti on6 of S($an F an8 a$ # 6

    $t ai&/tfo a % an% 'on'i$ . T/ Co( t % t in $ t/at / ' %i2ilit6 $ li8 l6

    (n ( $tion % an% / % $' i5tion of t/ 5 o5 t6 a$ ?& o$$@ an% ?5 tt6 na$t6@ i$

    a'' 5t %. T/ Co( t i$ l $$ in'lin % to 2 li # t/at t/ 5 o5 t6 (i %$(2$tantial 'l anin& 26 t/ D f n%ant o /i$ ot/ o $i$t 5 io to /i$

    'o n' nt of t/ l a$ . On' a&ain, t/ 5i't( $ $ta2li$/ t/ %i$a a6 of

    t/ 5 o5 t6 5 io to it$ la$t 'l anin&.

    T/ i$$( of t/ 'a 5 t i$ of 5 i a 6 'on' n a$ t/ 'o$t of 'a 5 tin&

    an% la2o total$ al o$t < ,000. T/ Co( t not $ t/at t/ 5 o5 t6 a$ 2(ilt in

    199; an% t/ 'a 5 t /a$ 2 n t/ fo fift n 6 a $. Of t/i$ ti , it a$

    in/a2it % fo at l a$t 1 6 a $. In o$t in$tan' $, 'a 5 tin& /a$ a % 5 'iation

    #al( of a55 o:i at l6 t nt6 6 a $. T/($, t/ Co( t % t in $ t/at it i$

    (n a$ona2l fo t/ Plaintiff to :5 't t/ D f n%ant to 2 a t/ nti 'o$t of

    'a 5 tin& /i'/ o$t li8 l6 o(l% 2 5la' % it/in a a$ona2l a o(nt of

    ti . U$in& t/at fo (la, t/ Co( t % t in $ t/at E of t/ lif of t/ 'a 5 t

    /a% 2 n ($ % an% t/ %a a& %on 26 t/ D f n%ant 5 $ nt$ of t/ #al( .

    Finall6, t/ Co( t % t in $ t/at t/ a%%ition ont/ $ nt i$ in% % %( . T/

    E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    45/47

    4

    D f n%ant 'annot ($ i&no an' o la'8 of /i$ (n% $tan%in& of o2li&ation$ in

    #i of t/ fa't t/at / /a$ a n( 2 of ntal 5 o5 ti $ /i $ lf. Noti' in t/

    fo of a 'on# $ation to an6on 2(t t/ Plaintiff o(l% 2 'on$i% %

    in$(ffi'i nt an% t/($ t/ nt i$ %( .

    In 'on'l($ion, t/ Co( t o(l% %i 't t/ 5a ti $ att ntion to Co( t*:/i2it A /i'/ i$ t/ 'a5it(lation of %a a& $ o % 26 t/ D f n%ant to t/

    Plaintiff. 7(%& nt i$ nt % in fa#o of t/ Plaintiff in t/ a o(nt of < ,1"=.0!

    5l($ 'o( t 'o$t$.

    Cl 8 to fo a % 'o5i $ toG7o$ 5/ - i% n i'/Da#i% 7 nn tt

    E-FILED 2013 NOV 20 1:38 PM SAC - CLERK OF DISTRICT COURT

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    46/47

    5

    COURT *H-IBIT A

    Bo6inton $ -a % a 'l an (5 at ial$) < = .9;

    a a& Doo S(55l6 1>.=0

    Co(nt 6 Co($in$ 'l anin& la%i $) 1," !.>0

    +i% A i'an ".3>

    La5 l La n S #i' 5ai o 8 on 6a %) 130.00

    Wat $ "1.!"

    Ca 5 t an% la2o

  • 8/13/2019 Judgment Against Sac City Man in the Amount $3,146.07

    47/47