Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

56
Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract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`%,'B&-< )25"#&% `,%C'B&2-< >&$$H J&-C&$'",BB< a%1&$B )&-N@&%C< `2C&,- 4##$< #-C '&02-#$ ?#$B252?#-B' #B B"& 4A&C2'" S-'B2B/B& F,$ K2-#-52#% [&'&#$5"< B"& KSY[a M5,-,025 aC@2',$H !,002BB&&< #-C B"& ^B" a--/#% !&-B$#% 3#-N W,$N'",? ,- B"& )25$,'B$/5B/$& ,F K2-#-52#% )#$N&B' #B B"& 3#-N ,F !#-#C# F,$ "&%?F/% C2'5/''2,-' ,- ',0& ,F B"& B,?25' 5,@&$&C "&$&2-* >"2' $&'&#$5" A#' '/??,$B&C 1H # D$#-B F$,0 !2B#C&% \\!*

Transcript of Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

Page 1: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2236201

!

!

!

"#$%!&'!()!*+'(!$,'-%!#./#012)3-)+45!%2$&.+/6!

!

!"#$%&'()*(+,-&'.(

!,%/012#(3/'2-&''(45",,%(

6&$'2,-(7*89(()#$5"(:;<(:;=7(

(

789:;7<:!

>"2'(?#?&$($&@2&A'($&5&-B(B"&,$&B25#%(#-C(&0?2$25#%($&'&#$5"(,-("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(B$#C2-D(IJK>L*( ( (M5,-,025(B"&,$H( 2C&-B2F2&'('&@&$#%(A#H'(B"#B(JK>(5,/%C(#FF&5B( %2G/2C2BH*( (>"&(0#2-(?,'2B2@&( 2'( B"#B( JK>( 5#-( 2-B&$0&C2#B&( B$#C&'( #B( %,A&$( 5,'B*( ( J,A&@&$<( JK>( '?&&C( 5,/%C(C2'#C@#-B#D&(,B"&$(2-@&'B,$'<(#-C(B"&($&'/%B2-D(#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-(5,/%C($&C/5&(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH*(

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`%,'B&-<()25"#&%(`,%C'B&2-<(>&$$H(J&-C&$'",BB<(a%1&$B()&-N@&%C<(`2C&,-(4##$<(#-C('&02-#$(?#$B252?#-B'( #B( B"&( 4A&C2'"( S-'B2B/B&( F,$(K2-#-52#%([&'&#$5"<( B"&(KSY[a(M5,-,025(aC@2',$H(!,002BB&&<( #-C( B"&( ^B"(a--/#%(!&-B$#%(3#-N(W,$N'",?( ,-( B"&()25$,'B$/5B/$&( ,F(K2-#-52#%()#$N&B'( #B( B"&(3#-N(,F(!#-#C#( F,$("&%?F/%(C2'5/''2,-'(,-( ',0&(,F( B"&( B,?25'( 5,@&$&C("&$&2-*((>"2'($&'&#$5"(A#'('/??,$B&C(1H(#(D$#-B(F$,0(!2B#C&%(\\!*(

Page 2: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2236201

!

!

=>)4-%.?)!9-@@$25!

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

3#'&C( ,-( B"&( @#'B( 0#P,$2BH( ,F( B"&( &0?2$25#%( A,$N( B,( C#B&<( JK>( #-C( #/B,0#B&C<( 5,0?&B2-D(0#$N&B'( 20?$,@&(0#$N&B( %2G/2C2BH<($&C/5&(B$#C2-D(5,'B'<(#-C(0#N&('B,5N(?$25&'(0,$&(&FF252&-B*((3&BB&$(%2G/2C2BH(%,A&$'(B"&(5,'B(,F(&G/2BH(5#?2B#%(F,$(F2$0'<(A"25"(2'(#-(20?,$B#-B(?,'2B2@&(F,$(B"&($&#%(&5,-,0H*(()2-,$($&D/%#B,$H(BA&#N'(0#H(1&(2-(,$C&$<(1/B(B",'&(F,$0/%#B2-D(?,%25H('",/%C(1&(&'?&52#%%H(5#$&F/%(-,B(B,($&@&$'&(B"&(%2G/2C2BH(20?$,@&0&-B'(,F(B"&(%#'B(BA&-BH(H&#$'*(

)#-H(JK>('B$#B&D2&'(#$&(-,B(-&A*((>"&H(#$&('20?%H(F#02%2#$(B$#C2-D('B$#B&D2&'(/?C#B&C(F,$(#-(#/B,0#B&C( &-@2$,-0&-B*( ( K,$( &U#0?%&<( 0#-H(JK>'(0#N&(0#$N&B'( /'2-D( B"&( '#0&( 1/'2-&''(0,C&%( #'( B$#C2B2,-#%(0#$N&BE0#N&$'<( 1/B(A2B"( %,A&$( 5,'B'( C/&( B,( #/B,0#B2,-*( ( S-( F#5B<(JK>(0#$N&BE0#N&$'( "#@&( %#$D&%H( $&?%#5&C("/0#-(0#$N&B(0#N&$'*( (OB"&$(JK>( 'B$#B&D2&'( 5,-C/5B(5$,''E0#$N&B( #$12B$#D&<( '/5"( #'( &-'/$2-D( B"#B( ?$25&'( ,F( B"&( '#0&( '"#$&( B$#C2-D( 2-( 1,B"(Y&A(b,$N( #-C( \,-C,-( #$&( B"&( '#0&*( ( S-( B"&( ?#'B<( "/0#-( B$#C&$'( A,/%C( 5#$$H( ,/B( B"2'( BH?&( ,F(#$12B$#D&<(1/B(B"&('#0&(B$#C2-D('B$#B&DH(5#-(-,A(1&(20?%&0&-B&C(F#'B&$(#-C(#B(%,A&$(5,'B(A2B"(5,0?/B&$'*(

\2G/2C2BH( c( B"&( #12%2BH( B,( B$#C&( #( '/1'B#-B2#%( #0,/-B( ,F( #( F2-#-52#%( #''&B( #B( 5%,'&( B,( 5/$$&-B(0#$N&B( ?$25&'( c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

O@&$(B"&(?#'B(B&-(H&#$'<(JK>("#'(2-5$&#'&C('"#$?%H<(#-C(%2G/2C2BH("#'('B&#C2%H(20?$,@&C*((3/B(5,$$&%#B2,-( 2'( -,B( -&5&''#$2%H( 5#/'#B2,-*( ( M0?2$25#%%H<( B"&( 5"#%%&-D&( 2'( B,( 0&#'/$&( B"&(2-5$&0&-B#%(&FF&5B(,F(JK>(,-(B,?(,F(#%%(B"&(,B"&$(5"#-D&'(2-(&G/2BH(0#$N&B'*((>"&(1&'B(?#?&$'(F,$( B"2'( ?/$?,'&( 2C&-B2FH( 0#$N&B( 'B$/5B/$&( 5"#-D&'( B"#B( F#52%2B#B&( JK>*( ( >"&$&( "#@&( 1&&-('&@&$#%('/5"(5"#-D&'<(#-C(B"&($&'/%B'(2-(B"&'&(?#?&$'(#$&(5,-'2'B&-B*((M@&$H(B20&(B"&$&("#'(1&&-(

Page 3: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

Electronic copy available at: http://ssrn.com/abstract=2236201

"

#(0#$N&B('B$/5B/$&(5"#-D&(B"#B($&'/%B'(2-(0,$&(JK><(%2G/2C2BH(#-C(,@&$#%%(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH("#@&(20?$,@&C*( ( SB( #??&#$'( B"#B( 0#$N&B( G/#%2BH( 20?$,@&'( 1&5#/'&( #/B,0#B&C( 0#$N&BE0#N&$'( #-C(,B"&$(%2G/2C2BH('/??%2&$'(#$&(1&BB&$(#1%&(B,(#CP/'B(B"&2$(G/,B&'(2-($&'?,-'&(B,(-&A(2-F,$0#B2,-*(

W"2%&(JK>( 5#/'&'( 1&BB&$(0#$N&B( G/#%2BH( ,-( #@&$#D&<( ',0&( 5,00&-B#B,$'( "#@&( #$D/&C( B"#B(JK>(5,/%C(0#N&(0#$N&B'(0,$&(F$#D2%&<(2-5$&#'2-D(B"&(?,''212%2BH(,F(&UB$&0&(0#$N&B(0,@&'(#-C(&?2',C&'(,F(&UB$&0&(2%%2G/2C2BH*((Q/$2-D(B"&()#H(T<(:;=;(K%#'"(!$#'"<(F,$(&U#0?%&<(4d](F/B/$&'(F&%%(#%0,'B(=;e(A2B"2-(=f(02-/B&'(1&F,$&($&1,/-C2-D*((4,0&(2-C2@2C/#%('B,5N'(0,@&C(F#$(0,$&*((>"&(!K>!(#-C(4M!(A&$&(#1%&(B,(2C&-B2FH(0#-H(JK>(F2$0'(#5B2@&(C/$2-D(B"&(K%#'"(!$#'"<(#-C(B"&H( F2-C( B"#B( B"&'&( F2$0'( 2-2B2#%%H( 'B#12%2V&C(?$25&'(1/B(A&$&( &@&-B/#%%H(,@&$A"&%0&C<( #-C( 2-(%2G/2C#B2-D( B"&2$( ?,'2B2,-'<( JK>( &U#5&$1#B&C( B"&( C,A-B/$-*( ( >"2'( #??&#$'( B,( 1&( #( 5,00,-($&'?,-'&(1H(2-B&$0&C2#$2&'<(#'(2B(#%',(,55/$$&C(2-(%&''(#/B,0#B&C(B20&'(C/$2-D(B"&('B,5N(0#$N&B(5$#'"( ,F( O5B,1&$( =g^h( #-C( #( '202%#$( F%#'"( 5$#'"( 2-( =gT:*( ( >"/'<( B"&$&( C,&'( -,B( '&&0( B,( 1&(#-HB"2-D(/-/'/#%%H(C&'B#12%2V2-D(#1,/B(JK><(&@&-(2-(&UB$&0&(0#$N&B(5,-C2B2,-'*( (4",$BEB&$0(2-C2@2C/#%('B,5N(?$25&(%202B'(#-C(B$#C2-D("#%B'("#@&(1&&-(2-B$,C/5&C('2-5&i(B"2'(#??&#$'(B,(1&(#(A&%%E5$#FB&C($&D/%#B,$H(0&#'/$&(B"#B('",/%C(?$&@&-B(#($&5/$$&-5&*((a(B$#C2-D(?#/'&('",/%C(D2@&(0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'( #( 5"#-5&( B,( $&E&@#%/#B&( #-C( 'B#12%2V&( ?$25&'( 2F( B"&( ?$25&( 0,@&'( #??&#$(/-A#$$#-B&C*(

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

!"#$"%&'()*'+ ",'*,-%*.*%+ (/'&)+ ),(&%$0( ( a/C2B( B$#2%'( "#@&( #%A#H'( 1&&-( -&&C&C( F,$( 0#$N&B('/$@&2%%#-5&<( #-C( $,1/'B( &-F,$5&0&-B( 2'( 20?,$B#-B( B,( &-'/$&( 2-@&'B,$( 5,-F2C&-5&( 2-(0#$N&B'*((W2B"(JK><(0#%F&#'#-5&( 2'( ?,''21%&( 2-( ,$C&$( '/102''2,-( 'B$#B&D2&'<( ',( $&D/%#B,$'( -&&C( $&#CH(#55&''( B,( ,$C&$E%&@&%( C#B#( F$,0(0/%B2?%&( @&-/&'*( (>"&( C&B#2%'( B/$-( ,-( B"&( 5,'B'( #-C( 1&-&F2B'<(A"25"(#$&("#$C(F,$(#-(,/B'2C&$(B,(P/CD&*(((

1,'*,+ 2(#2*%%()&"#+ ",+ *32*$$+ 4*$$(5*+ 6**$0( ( SF( 1#-CA2CB"( #-C( C#B#( ?$,5&''2-D( $&G/2$&0&-B'( #$&(,@&$A"&%02-D(',0&(B$#C2-D(@&-/&(5/'B,0&$'<(2B(0#H(1&(#??$,?$2#B&(F,$(B$#C2-D(@&-/&'(B,('&B(?$25&'(#55,$C2-D%H(#-C(5"#$D&(B"&(?#$B252?#-B'(A",(#$&(20?,'2-D(B",'&(5,'B'(,-(,B"&$'*((Y#'C#G(2'( 5/$$&-B%H( 20?,'2-D( B"&'&( F&&'( 2-( B"&(Z*4*i( 2B( 2'( B,,( ',,-( B,(0&#'/$&( B"&( &FF&5B'*( (J,A&@&$<(,$C&$( 5#-5&%%#B2,-( F&&'(A2%%( #%0,'B( 5&$B#2-%H( $&C/5&( %2G/2C2BH( ?$,@2'2,-( #A#H( F$,0( B"&( 2-'2C&(G/,B&<( $&C/52-D( 0#$N&B( C&?B"*( ( >"&( 5/$$&-B( 2-2B2#B2@&'( '",/%C( 1&( 'B/C2&C( 5#$&F/%%H( 1&F,$&(1$,#C&$E1#'&C(0&''#D&(F&&'(#$&(5,-'2C&$&C*(

Page 4: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#

7&#&4/4+",'*,+*38"$/,*+)&4*$0( (Z-C&$(B"&'&(?$,?,'#%'<('/102BB&C(,$C&$'(5,/%C(-,B(1&(5#-5&%%&C(F,$(#B( %&#'B(',0&(?&$2,C(,F( B20&<(?&$"#?'(f;(02%%2'&5,-C'*( (>"2'(A,/%C( F,$5&( %#$D&(5"#-D&'( 2-(&G/2BH(0#$N&B'(#-C(5,/%C('&@&$&%H(C2'5,/$#D&(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2'2,-*((>"&(&5,-,025($#B2,-#%&("&$&(2'(?#$B25/%#$%H('/'?&5B<(#'(B"&(,@&$$2C2-D(D,#%(2-(0#$N&B(C&'2D-('",/%C(1&(B,(&-5,/$#D&(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2'2,-*((

9*2/,&)&*$+),(#$(2)&"#+)(3*$0((>"&(&@2C&-5&(2-C25#B&'(B"#B(B"&'&(B#U&'($&C/5&('"#$&(?$25&'<(2-5$&#'&(@,%#B2%2BH<($&C/5&(?$25&(&FF252&-5H<(A,$'&-(%2G/2C2BH<(2-5$&#'&(B$#C2-D(5,'B'<(#-C(5#/'&(B$#C2-D(B,(0,@&(,FF'",$&*(

(

! !

Page 5: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$

AB!!C+%2'&-4%.'+!

O@&$( B"&( ?#'B( F&A( C&5#C&'<( B&5"-,%,DH( "#'( B$#-'F,$0&C( B"&( B$#C2-D( ,F( '&5/$2B2&'( #-C(

,B"&$( F2-#-52#%( 2-'B$/0&-B'*( ( 3&F,$&( B"&( #C@&-B( ,F( 5,0?/B&$'<( #%%( B$#C2-D( A#'( 5,-C/5B&C(

1&BA&&-("/0#-'<(,FB&-( 2-(?&$',-(,-(#( B$#C2-D( F%,,$*( (3#5N(,FF25&'(A&$&( F2%%&C(A2B"(5%&$N'(#-C(

,B"&$'( B,( &-'/$&( B"#B( B$#-'#5B2,-'(A&$&( ?$,?&$%H( 5,0?%&B&C*( (`$#C/#%%H<( 1,B"( B"&( 1#5N( ,FF25&(

#-C(B"&(#5B/#%(B$#C2-D(?$,5&''("#@&(1&&-(B$#-'F,$0&C(1H(#/B,0#B2,-*(

)#-H(F2-#-52#%(0#$N&B'("#@&(#1#-C,-&C("/0#-(2-B&$0&C2#B2,-(@2#(F%,,$(B$#C2-D(,$(B"&(

B&%&?",-&<( $&?%#52-D( "/0#-( 2-B&$0&C2#$2&'( A2B"( #-( &%&5B$,-25( %202B( ,$C&$( 1,,N( ,$( #-,B"&$(

#/B,0#B&C(B$#C2-D('H'B&0*( (S-($&'?,-'&(B,(#-(#/B,0#B&C(B$#C2-D(?$,5&''<(0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'(

1&D#-( B,( C&@&%,?( B$#C2-D( #%D,$2B"0'*( ( )#-H( ,F( B"&'&( B$#C2-D( #%D,$2B"0'( A&$&( C&'2D-&C( B,(

$&?%25#B&( B"&(1&"#@2,$( ,F( ,B"&$("/0#-'( 2-@,%@&C( 2-( B"&( B$#C2-D(?$,5&''<( '/5"( #'( #D&-5H( F%,,$(

1$,N&$'(,$(?$,?$2&B#$H(0#$N&BE0#N&$'*((O@&$(B"&(?#'B(=;(H&#$'(,$(',<(B"&'&(B$#C2-D(#%D,$2B"0'(

"#@&(1&&-($&F2-&C<(5,0?/B2-D(B&5"-,%,DH(5,-B2-/&'(B,(#C@#-5&<(#-C(,$C&$'(B,(1/H(#-C('&%%(#$&(

#??&#$2-D(#-C(0#B5"2-D(#B(#(F#'B&$($#B&(B"#-(&@&$(1&F,$&*(

>"&($&D/%#B,$H( F$#0&A,$N("#'(#%',(5,-B$21/B&C(B,( B"2'(#/B,0#B2,-*( (K,$(&U#0?%&<( B"&(

Z*4*( 4&5/$2B2&'( #-C( MU5"#-D&( !,002''2,-j'( [&D/%#B2,-( Y)4<( A"25"( A#'( #C,?B&C( 2-( :;;f<(

?$,@2C&C( 'B$,-D( 2-5&-B2@&'( F,$( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'( B,( #/B,0#B&<( &'?&52#%%H( B"&( Y&A( b,$N( 4B,5N(

MU5"#-D&<(A"25"(A#'( B"&( %#'B(0#P,$( F%,,$E1#'&C(&U5"#-D&( 2-( B"&(Z*4*( ([&D/%#B2,-(Y)4(#%',(

&-5,/$#D&C( 5,0?&B2B2,-( #0,-D( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'<( 5,0?&B2B2,-( B"#B( ,FB&-( B,,N( B"&( F,$0( ,F(

B&5"-,%,D25#%(/?D$#C&'(#-C($&C/5B2,-'(2-(%#B&-5H*((W"2%&(B&5"-,%,DH(2'(B"&(?$,U20#B&(C$2@&$<(2B(

2'( 5%&#$( B"#B( $&D/%#B2,-( "#'( #%',( 5,-B$21/B&C( B,( B"&( 5/$$&-B( #/B,0#B&C(0#$N&B( 'B$/5B/$&<( #-C(

$&D/%#B,$H( ?,%25H( A2%%( 0,'B( 5&$B#2-%H( 2-F%/&-5&( B"&( C2$&5B2,-( ,F( F/B/$&( B&5"-,%,D25#%(

C&@&%,?0&-B'(2-(B$#C2-D*(

!

Page 6: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

%

DB!!"#$%!.E!FG:6!

a55,$C2-D( B,( B"&( 4M!<( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H( B$#C&$'( #$&( k?$,F&''2,-#%( B$#C&$'( #5B2-D( 2-( #(

?$,?$2&B#$H(5#?#52BH(B"#B(&-D#D&(2-('B$#B&D2&'(B"#B(D&-&$#B&(#(%#$D&(-/01&$(,F(B$#C&'(,-(C#2%H(

1#'2'*l( I4M!( !,-5&?B( [&%&#'&( ,-( MG/2BH()#$N&B( 4B$/5B/$&<( hf( K&C*( [&D*( 7T;7<( +#-/#$H( :=<(

:;=;L((>"&(4M!(5,-5&?B($&%&#'&(D,&'(,-(B,($&?,$B(I?*(8fL(B"#B(JK>(#$&(,FB&-(5"#$#5B&$2V&C(1H9(

I=L( B"&( /'&( ,F( &UB$#,$C2-#$2%H( "2D"E'?&&C( #-C( ',?"2'B25#B&C( 5,0?/B&$( ?$,D$#0'( F,$(

D&-&$#B2-D<( $,/B2-D<( #-C( &U&5/B2-D( ,$C&$'i( I:L( /'&( ,F( 5,E%,5#B2,-( '&$@25&'( #-C( 2-C2@2C/#%( C#B#(

F&&C'( ,FF&$&C( 1H( &U5"#-D&'( #-C( ,B"&$'( B,(02-202V&( -&BA,$N( #-C( ,B"&$( BH?&'( ,F( %#B&-52&'i( I7L(

@&$H( '",$B( B20&EF$#0&'( F,$( &'B#1%2'"2-D( #-C( %2G/2C#B2-D( ?,'2B2,-'i( I8L( B"&( '/102''2,-( ,F(

-/0&$,/'(,$C&$'(B"#B(#$&(5#-5&%%&C('",$B%H(#FB&$('/102''2,-i(#-C(IfL(&-C2-D(B"&(B$#C2-D(C#H(2-(

#'(5%,'&(B,(#(F%#B(?,'2B2,-(#'(?,''21%&(IB"#B(2'<(-,B(5#$$H2-D('2D-2F25#-B<(/-"&CD&C(?,'2B2,-'(,@&$E

-2D"BL*(

!,-@&$'#B2,-'(A2B"(0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'( 2-C25#B&( B"#B(0#-H(JK>(C,( 5#$$H( '/1'B#-B2#%(

2-@&-B,$H( ?,'2B2,-'( ,@&$-2D"Bi( ,B"&$A2'&<( B"&$&( 2'( 5,-'2C&$#1%&( 5,-'&-'/'( B"#B( B"2'( 2'( #(

A,$N#1%&( C&F2-2B2,-( ,F( JK>*( ( JK>( 2'( #( '/1'&B( ,F( #%%( #%D,$2B"025( B$#C2-D( Ia>L<( A"25"( 2'(

D&-&$#%%H(C&F2-&C(#'(B"&(/'&(,F(#(5,0?/B&$(#%D,$2B"0(B,(0#N&(C&52'2,-'(#1,/B(,$C&$('/102''2,-'(

#-C( 5#-5&%%#B2,-'*( ( K,$( &U#0?%&<( #%D,$2B"0'( #$&( ,FB&-( /'&C( 1H( 1/HE'2C&( 2-@&'B,$'( B,( kA,$Nl(

%#$D&( ,$C&$'( ,@&$( B20&*( (W"2%&( B"&'&( #%D,$2B"0'( #$&( #/B,0#B&C( #-C( ,FB&-( 2-@,%@&( B"&( $#?2C(

'/102''2,-(#-C(5#-5&%%#B2,-(,F(,$C&$'(2-(#-(&FF,$B(B,(#5"2&@&(B"&(C&'2$&C(&U&5/B2,-<(#-C(a>(0#H(

2B'&%F( "#@&( #-( 20?#5B( ,-( %2G/2C2BH( #-C(0#$N&B( G/#%2BH<( 0,'B( ,F( B"&( 5/$$&-B( ?,%25H( C2'5/''2,-(

F,5/'&'(,-(?$,?$2&B#$H(B$#C&$'(A",(#$&(B$#C2-D($#?2C%H(1/B(#$&(-,B(%,-DEB&$0('"#$&",%C&$'*(

(

Page 7: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

&

:;<;++=>8*$+"6+?@=+9),()*5&*$+

>"&$&(2'(-,('2-D%&(B$#C2-D('B$#B&DH(F,%%,A&C(1H(#%%(,$(&@&-(0,'B(JK>*((J,A&@&$<(B"&$&(

#$&('&@&$#%(2%%/'B$#B2@&(JK>('B$#B&D2&'<(2-5%/C2-D9((I=L(#5B2-D(#'(#-(2-F,$0#%(,$(F,$0#%(0#$N&BE

0#N&$<(I:L("2D"EF$&G/&-5H($&%#B2@&E@#%/&(B$#C2-D<(#-C(I7L(C2$&5B2,-#%(B$#C2-D(,-(-&A'($&%&#'&'<(

,$C&$(F%,A<(,$(,B"&$("2D"EF$&G/&-5H('2D-#%'*((M#5"(5#B&D,$H(2'(C2'5/''&C(1&%,A*(

+

:;<;A;++7(,B*)-4(B&#5+

)#$N&BE0#N&$'( '20/%B#-&,/'%H( ?,'B( %202B( ,$C&$'( ,-( 1,B"( '2C&'( ,F( B"&( &%&5B$,-25( %202B(

,$C&$( 1,,N*( ( >"&H( ?$,@2C&( %2G/2C2BH( B,(0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'( A",( A#-B( B,( B$#C&( 200&C2#B&%H*((

)#$N&BE0#N&$'(#20(B,(1/H(#B(B"&(12C(?$25&(#-C('&%%(#B(B"&(#'N(?$25&<(B"&$&1H(&#$-2-D(B"&(12CE#'N(

'?$&#C*( (OF( 5,/$'&<(0#$N&BE0#N&$'( 1&#$( B"&( $2'N( B"#B( B"&H( B$#C&(A2B"<( #-C( %,'&(0,-&H( B,<( #-(

2-F,$0&C(5,/-B&$?#$BH*( (>"/'<( B"&H("#@&(#-( 2-5&-B2@&( B,(0#N&('/$&( B"#B( B"&2$( %202B(,$C&$'( B,(

1/H(#-C('&%%(2-5,$?,$#B&(#'(0/5"(5/$$&-B(2-F,$0#B2,-(#'(?,''21%&(#'(G/25N%H(#'(?,''21%&<(',(#'(B,(

%202B(B"&2$(%,''&'(B,(2-F,$0&C(5,/-B&$?#$B2&'*((a'(#($&'/%B(,F(B"2'(?$,5&''<(JK>(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(

F$&G/&-B%H(/?C#B&(B"&2$(G/,B&'( 2-($&'?,-'&(B,(,B"&$(,$C&$('/102''2,-'(,$(5#-5&%%#B2,-'*( (JK>(

0#$N&BE0#N&$'(02D"B(#%',(#CP/'B(G/,B&'(2-($&'?,-'&(B,(#(?$25&(0,@&(2-(#($&%#B&C(M>K(,$(F/B/$&'(

5,-B$#5B*((a'(#($&'/%B(,F(B"2'(5,-B2-/,/'(/?C#B2-D(?$,5&''<(JK>(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(B&-C(B,('/102B(

#-C(5#-5&%(#(%#$D&(-/01&$(,F(,$C&$'(F,$(&#5"(B$#-'#5B2,-*(

S-(0,'B(Z*4*( &G/2BH(0#$N&B'<( %2G/2C2BH( ?$,@2C&$'( #%',( &#$-( %2G/2C2BH( $&1#B&'(A"25"( #$&(

',0&B20&'( $&F&$$&C( B,( #'( k0#N&$( F&&'l*( ( 4,0&(JK>(0#$N&BE0#N&$'( F,$0#%%H( $&D2'B&$( #'( '/5"(

A2B"(B$#C2-D(@&-/&'*((OB"&$'(#5B(#'(2-F,$0#%(0#$N&BE0#N&$'*((>"2'(5",25&(D&-&$#%%H(C&?&-C'(,-(

B"&(,1%2D#B2,-'(#-C(1&-&F2B'(#'',52#B&C(A2B"(1&2-D(#( $&D2'B&$&C(0#$N&BE0#N&$<( #-C( B"&'&(@#$H(

#5$,''(#''&B'(#-C(#5$,''(B$#C2-D(@&-/&'*((K,$(&U#0?%&<($&D2'B&$&C(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(A&$&(&U&0?B(

F$,0( B"&( 4&?B&01&$( :;;^( 1#-( ,-( '",$B( '#%&'( 2-( F2-#-52#%( F2$0'<( 1/B( 2-F,$0#%(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(

Page 8: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

'

A&$&('/1P&5B(B,(B"&(1#-*((S-(#-H(5#'&<($&D#$C%&''(,F(B"&(F,$0#%(B2B%&<(JK>(0#$N&BE0#N&$'("#@&(

%#$D&%H( $&?%#5&C( B$#C2B2,-#%( "/0#-(0#$N&BE0#N&$'<( 2-( ?#$B( 1&5#/'&( B"&H( #$&( %&''( %2N&%H( B,( 1&(

?25N&C(,FF(1H(#-(2-F,$0&C(5,/-B&$?#$BH<(#-C(2-(?#$B(1&5#/'&(B"&(/'&(,F(B&5"-,%,DH($&'/%B'(2-(#(

%,A&$(5,'B('B$/5B/$&(F,$(JK>(0#$N&BE0#N&$'*(

+

:;<;:;+C*%()&.*+.(%/*+(#'+(,D&),(5*+),('&#5+

[&%#B2@&(@#%/&(#-C(#$12B$#D&(B$#C2-D(5#-(B#N&(0#-H(F,$0'*( (a(5%#''25(&U#0?%&(2'( 2-C&U(

#$12B$#D&*((4d](f;;(F/B/$&'(#$&(B$#C&C(2-(!"25#D,(,-(B"&(!"25#D,()&$5#-B2%&(MU5"#-D&<(A"2%&(

4]b(2'(B"&(B25N&$('H01,%(F,$(B"&(%#$D&'B(&U5"#-D&EB$#C&C(F/-C(IM>KL(B"#B(B$#5N'(B"&(4d](f;;(

2-C&U*((4]b(2'(B$#C&C(,-(-&#$%H(&@&$H(&G/2BH(B$#C2-D(@&-/&(2-(B"&(Z*4*(#'(A&%%(#'('&@&$#%(F,$&2D-(

B$#C2-D(@&-/&'*((>"&(BA,(2-'B$/0&-B'(#$&(@&$H('202%#$<(#-C(B"&2$(?$25&'('",/%C(0,@&(2-(%,5N'B&?(

,-&EF,$E,-&*( ( SF( B"&( F/B/$&'(?$25&(D,&'(/?(C/&(B,(B"&(#$$2@#%(,F(1/H(,$C&$'<(1/B( B"&(M>K(?$25&(

C,&'( -,B( 0,@&( /?( #B( B"&( '#0&( 2-'B#-B<( JK>(A,/%C( G/25N%H( 1/H( 4]b<( '&%%( 4d]( f;;( F/B/$&'(

5,-B$#5B'<( #-C( %,5N( 2-( #( '0#%%( ?$,F2B( ,-( B"&( ?$25&( C2FF&$&-B2#%( 1&BA&&-( B"&( BA,( 2-'B$/0&-B'*((

Y#B/$#%%H<( B"&'&( ?$,F2B( ,??,$B/-2B2&'( $&G/2$&( $#?2C( 5,0?/B&$( ?$,5&''2-D( 5#?#12%2BH( #-C( B"&(

G/25N&'B( ?,''21%&( %2-N( 1&BA&&-( B"&( &%&5B$,-25( 0#$N&B( 2-( !"25#D,( #-C( B"&( &%&5B$,-25( &G/2BH(

0#$N&B'<(0,'B(,F(A"25"(#$&(%,5#B&C(2-(Y&A(+&$'&H*(

>"2'( &U#0?%&( #%',( '",A'( B"&( A2--&$EB#N&E#%%( -#B/$&( ,F( #$12B$#D&E,$2&-B&C( JK>*((

!,-B2-/2-D( B"&( #1,@&( &U#0?%&<( 2F( ,-&(JK>( #$12B$#D&/$( 2'( 5,-'2'B&-B%H( F#'B&$( B"#-( #-H( ,B"&$(

0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B<(2B(A2%%(1&(#1%&(B,(G/25N%H(1/H(/?(#%%(,F(B"&($&%#B2@&%H(02'?$25&C('"#$&'(,F(4]b(

#-C('&%%($&%#B2@&%H(02'?$25&C(4d](f;;(F/B/$&'(5,-B$#5B'<(B"&$&1H(1$2-D2-D(B"&(?$25&'(,F(B"&(BA,(

2-'B$/0&-B'(1#5N( 2-B,( %2-&*( (>"&$&(A2%%(1&(-,(#BB$#5B2@&( 2-C&U(#$12B$#D&(B$#C2-D(,??,$B/-2B2&'(

%&FB(F,$(#('%2D"B%H('%,A&$(B$#C&$*(

Page 9: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

(

S-C&U(#$12B$#D&(5#-(#%',(B#N&(?%#5&(1&BA&&-(B"&(2-C&U(?$,C/5B'(C2'5/''&C(#1,@&(#-C(B"&(

2-C2@2C/#%('B,5N'(B"#B(0#N&(/?(B"&(2-C&U*((SF(B"&(4d](f;;(F/B/$&'(?$25&($2'&'<(F,$(&U#0?%&<(1/B(

B"&$&(2'(-,(5"#-D&(2-(B"&(?$25&'(,F(B"&(5,0?,-&-B('B,5N'<(JK>(A2%%(G/25N%H(1/H('"#$&'(2-(0#-H(

,$( 0,'B( ,F( B"&( /-C&$%H2-D( 'B,5N'( 2-( B"&( 5,$$&5B( ?$,?,$B2,-'( /-B2%( B"&( $&%#B2@&( 02'?$252-D( 2'(

&%202-#B&C*(

[&%#B2@&(@#%/&( B$#C2-D(5#-(#%',( B#N&(?%#5&(1&BA&&-( 2-C2@2C/#%( '&5/$2B2&'*( (>"&(4?#-2'"(

1#-N( 3#-5,( 4#-B#-C&$( B$#C&'( 2-( 4?#2-( 1/B( "#'( #-( a0&$25#-(Q&?,'2B#$H( [&5&2?B( IaQ[L( B"#B(

B$#C&'(,-(B"&(Yb4M*((4,0&(5,0?#-2&'("#@&(0/%B2?%&(5%#''&'(,F(5,00,-('B,5N<(,$(,B"&$(&G/2BHE

%2-N&C('&5/$2B2&'('/5"(#'(5,-@&$B21%&(1,-C'*((JK>(5#-(?$,F2B(2F(B"&(?$25&'(,F(BA,(5%,'&%H($&%#B&C(

'&5/$2B2&'(B&0?,$#$2%H(C2@&$D&*((4,0&(JK>(?$,D$#0'(02D"B(B$#C&(2-(`)(1#'&C(,-(K,$Cj'(?$25&(

0,@&'*((a(G/25N(/?A#$C(0,@&(2-(,2%(F/B/$&'(?$25&'(02D"B(2-C25#B&(#(G/25N('#%&(,F(#2$%2-&('B,5N'*((

a(?$25&(0,@&(2-(#(?#$B25/%#$(%2'B&C(&G/2BH(,?B2,-(02D"B('/DD&'B(#(?$,F2B#1%&(B$#C2-D(,??,$B/-2BH(

2-(B"&(/-C&$%H2-D('B,5N*(

+

:;<;E;++F&,*2)&"#(%+),('&#5+

4,0&(JK>(F2$0'(&%&5B$,-25#%%H(?#$'&(-&A'($&%&#'&'<(#??%H(B&UB/#%(#-#%H'2'<(#-C(B$#C&(,-(

B"&(2-F&$$&C(-&A'*((K,$(2-'B#-5&<('/5"(#(?$,D$#0(02D"B(%,,N(F,$(A,$C'(%2N&(k$#2'&l(,$(k"2D"&$l(

,$(k2-5$&#'&Cl(2-(5%,'&(?$,U202BH(B,(B"&(?"$#'&(k&#$-2-D'(F,$&5#'B<l(2C&-B2FH(B"&(5,0?#-H(B"#B(2'(

B"&('/1P&5B(,F(B"&(-&A'('B,$H<(#-C(2-(B"2'(5#'&('/102B(1/H(,$C&$'<(#%%( 2-(02%%2'&5,-C'*( (S-(F#5B<(

0,'B(-&A'A2$&'(-,A(?&$F,$0(B&UB/#%(#-#%H'&'(,F(B"&2$(,A-(-&A'('B,$2&'(?$2,$(B,($&%&#'&*((>"&'&(

-&A'(?$,@2C&$'('&%%('/00#$H(0&#'/$&'(,F(B"&(-&A'(B,(JK>(F2$0'<('#@2-D(B"&(F2$0'(F$,0("#@2-D(

B,(?&$F,$0(B"&2$(,A-(#-#%H'2'(#-C('#@2-D(B"&0(?$&52,/'(02%%2'&5,-C'*(

Page 10: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

)

OB"&$(JK>(F2$0'(B$#C&(1#'&C(,-(,$C&$(F%,A('2D-#%'*((K,$(&U#0?%&<(2F(#(%#$D&(1/H(,$C&$(

&U&5/B&'(#B(B"&(?$&@#2%2-D(#'N(?$25&<(#-(JK>('B$#B&DH(02D"B(2-F&$(B"#B(B"&(,$C&$('/102BB&$("#'(

'/1'B#-B2#%(?,'2B2@&(2-F,$0#B2,-*((>"&(JK>(02D"B(B"&-($&'?,-C(1H(1/H2-D('"#$&'(2B'&%F*(

a(@#$2#-B(,-(B"2'('B$#B&DH(2'(,F(5,-'2C&$#1%&(5,-5&$-(B,(%#$D&(2-'B2B/B2,-#%(B$#C&$'*((SF(#(

%#$D&(2-'B2B/B2,-#%(B$#C&$(2'(D$#C/#%%H(?/$5"#'2-D('"#$&'(,F(S3)<(#-(JK>(02D"B(1&(#1%&(B,('-2FF(

B"2'(,/B(1H(2C&-B2FH2-D(#('&G/&-5&(,F(%#$D&(1/H(,$C&$'(,@&$(B"&('?#5&(,F('&@&$#%(02-/B&'*( (>"&(

JK>(02D"B( ?/$5"#'&( '"#$&'( ,F( S3)<( C$2@2-D( B"&( ?$25&( /?( #-C( 2-5$&#'2-D( B"&( ?$25&( B"#B( B"&(

2-'B2B/B2,-#%(B$#C&$(0/'B(?#H(B,(1/H(S3)('"#$&'*((S-(F#5B<(B"&(JK>(02D"B(&@&-B/#%%H($&#%2V&(2B'(

?$,F2B(1H('&%%2-D( 2B'(?/$5"#'&C(S3)('"#$&'(B,(B"&( 2-'B2B/B2,-#%( B$#C&$*( (>,(B"A#$B(B"&'&(,$C&$(

#-B252?#B2,-( 'B$#B&D2&'<( B"&( 2-'B2B/B2,-#%( B$#C&$( 0#H( /-C&$B#N&( D$&#B( &FF,$B'( B,( C2'D/2'&( 2B'(

,@&$#%%(B$#C2-D(2-B&-B2,-'*((SB(0#H(1$&#N(/?(2B'(,$C&$(2-B,(@&$H('0#%%(?2&5&'<(2-(,$C&$(B,(%,,N(%2N&(

$&%#B2@&%H(/-2-F,$0&C(,$C&$'( F$,0($&B#2%( 2-@&'B,$'*( ( SB(0#H( B$#C&( 2-(C#$N(?,,%'(,$(/'&("2CC&-(

,$C&$'( B,(#@,2C($&@&#%2-D( 2B'( B$#C2-D( 2-B&-B2,-'*( (),'B(,F( B"&( B20&( B"&( 2-'B2B/B2,-(A2%%(/'&(#-(

#%D,$2B"0( B,( C,( B"2'<( ',( A&( ,FB&-( &-C( /?( A2B"( #( "2C&E#-CE'&&N( 1#BB%&( 1&BA&&-( 5,0?/B&$(

?$,D$#0'*(((

SB( 2'( 20?,$B#-B( B,( -,B&( B"#B( B"2'( 2'( -,B( #( -&A( 5,-5&$-*( ( S-( 0,$&( 0#-/#%( 0#$N&B'<(

2-'B2B/B2,-#%(B$#C&$'(A&$&(P/'B(#'(A,$$2&C(#1,/B(B"2'(',$B(,F(2-F,$0#B2,-(%&#N#D&<(#-C(B"&H(A&-B(

B,(D$&#B(%&-DB"'(B,(C2'D/2'&(B"&2$(%#$D&(,$C&$'(1H(A,$N2-D(B"&0(D$#C/#%%H(,@&$(B20&<(?&$"#?'(1H(

'B#B2,-2-D(#(1$,N&$(#B(B"&($&%&@#-B(B$#C2-D(?,'B(,-(B"&(Yb4M(F%,,$*((M@&-(',<(2-'B2B/B2,-#%(,$C&$(

&U&5/B2,-( 'B$#B&D2&'("#@&(5"#-D&C('/1'B#-B2#%%H(,@&$( B"&(?#'B( F&A(H&#$'(#'(0#$N&B'( #/B,0#B&(

#-C(B"2'(D#0&(,F(5#BE#-CE0,/'&(&@,%@&'*( ()#-H(2-'B2B/B2,-#%(B$#C&$'(&U?$&''(C2'0#H(,@&$(B"&(

5"#-D&'(B"&H("#@&(&U?&$2&-5&C<(1/B(/%B20#B&%H(B"&2$(B$#C2-D(5,'B'(#$&(0&#'/$#1%&<(',(2B('",/%C(

1&(?,''21%&(B,(#''&''(A"&B"&$(B"&'&(2-'B2B/B2,-#%(B$#C&$'(#$&(-&D#B2@&%H(#FF&5B&C(1H(B"2'(?,B&-B2#%(

#'?&5B(,F(JK>*( (S-( F#5B<(#'(C&B#2%&C( %#B&$( 2-(4&5B2,-(8<(,@&$#%%( 2-'B2B/B2,-#%( B$#C2-D(5,'B'("#@&(

Page 11: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!*

5,-B2-/&C( B,(C&5%2-&( &@&-( #'(JK>(1&5,0&'(0,$&( ?$,02-&-B<( '/DD&'B2-D( B"#B( B"2'( &FF&5B<( 2F( 2B(

&U2'B'<(2'($&%#B2@&%H(/-20?,$B#-B*(

+

:;G;++!"-%"2()&"#+

W"&-( #-( #BB$#5B2@&( ,$C&$( #??&#$'( ,-( B"&( %202B( ,$C&$( 1,,N<( ,-%H( B"&( F#'B&'B(JK>( 5#-(

B$#C&(A2B"(B"2'(,$C&$(#-C(&#$-(B$#C2-D(?$,F2B'*((3&5#/'&(,F(B"2'(A2--&$EB#N&E#%%(5"#$#5B&$2'B25(,F(

',0&( JK><( B"&'&( F2$0'( 0#N&( 2-@&'B0&-B'( 2-( 5,0?/B&$( "#$CA#$&( #-C( $&F2-&( B"&2$( 5,0?/B&$(

#%D,$2B"0'( 2-( ,$C&$( B,( 02-202V&( %#B&-5H<( B"&( ,@&$#%%( B20&( 2B( B#N&'( B,( $&5&2@&( '2D-#%'( F$,0( #(

B$#C2-D(@&-/&<(0#N&(B$#C2-D(C&52'2,-'<(#-C(B$#-'02B(B"&($&'/%B2-D(,$C&$(0&''#D&'(1#5N(B,(B"&(

B$#C2-D(@&-/&*((3&5#/'&(%2D"B(#-C(&%&5B$25#%('2D-#%'(B$#@&%(#B(#(F2-2B&('?&&C(,F(=^T<;;;(02%&'(?&$(

'&5,-C( 2-( #( @#5//0( #-C( ',0&A"#B( '%,A&$( B"$,/D"( F21&$( ,?B25( 5#1%&'( #-C( ,B"&$( 0&C2#<( 2B( 2'(

20?,$B#-B( F,$( JK>( B,( %,5#B&( 2B'( 5,0?/B&$'( 5%,'&( B,( B$#C2-D( @&-/&( '&$@&$'*( ( K,$( #( ?$25&<(

&%&5B$,-25(B$#C2-D(@&-/&'(,FF&$('?#5&(B,(JK>'(2-(B"&2$(C#B#(5&-B&$'<(#-C(/'&(,F(B"&'&(5,E%,5#B2,-(

'&$@25&'(2'(5"#$#5B&$2'B25(,F(JK>*((a'(C2'5/''&C(0,$&(%#B&$<(5,E%,5#B2,-($#2'&'(2''/&'($&%#B&C(B,(

5,0?&B2B2,-(1&BA&&-(0#$N&B(0&01&$'<(&G/#%(#55&''(B,(B"&(0#$N&B<(#-C(B"&(5,'B(,F('/5"('&$@25&'<(

1/B(B"&($&D/%#B,$H(F$#0&A,$N(B"#B(D,@&$-'(B"&'&('&$@25&'(2'(&U?%252B%H(#-C(5#$&F/%%H(C&'2D-&C(B,(

02-202V&(B"&'&(2''/&'*(

+

:;!;++H,"6&)(D&%&)>+"6+?@=+

),'B(JK>( 'B$#B&D2&'( &#$-( ,-%H( #( '0#%%( #0,/-B( ,F( ?$,F2B( ?&$( B$#C&*( ( 4,0&( #$12B$#D&(

'B$#B&D2&'(&#$-(?$,F2B'(5%,'&(B,(=;;e(,F(B"&(B20&<(1/B(0#-H(JK>('B$#B&D2&'(#$&(1#'&C(,-(B"&(%#A(

,F( #@&$#D&'*( ( 4/5"( 'B$#B&D2&'(02D"B(0#N&(0,-&H( ,-( ,-%H( f=e( ,F( B"&( B$#C&'<( 1/B( '2-5&( B"&'&(

B$#C&'( #$&( 5,-C/5B&C( "/-C$&C'( ,$( B",/'#-C'( ,F( B20&'( ?&$( C#H<( B"&H( 5#-( 'B2%%( 1&( 5,-'2'B&-B%H(

?$,F2B#1%&*( (J&-C&$'",BB(#-C([2,$C#-( I:;==L(,1'&$@&(:f(,F( B"&( %#$D&'B("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(B$#C&$'(

Page 12: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!!

A",( B$#C&( ,-(Y#'C#G( C/$2-D( :;;^( #-C( :;;g<( #-C( B"&H( F2-C( B"#B( B,D&B"&$( B"&'&( JK>'( &#$-(

#@&$#D&(D$,''(B$#C2-D($&@&-/&(,F(m:<7f=(?&$('B,5N(?&$(C#H*((>&5"-,%,DH(#-C(%#1,$(5,'B'(A,/%C(

'/$&%H($&C/5&(B"&'&(-/01&$'(5,-'2C&$#1%H*( (>"&'&(B$#C2-D($&@&-/&(%&@&%'(#$&(#( F$#5B2,-(,F(B"&(

B$#C2-D( $&@&-/&( &#$-&C(1H( '?&52#%2'B'( #-C(,B"&$(0#$N&BE0#N&$'( =f(H&#$'( #D,<( 2-C25#B2-D( B"#B(

B"&(5,0?&-'#B2,-(B,(B$#C2-D(2-B&$0&C2#$2&'(2'(0/5"('0#%%&$(B"#-(2-(B"&(?#'B*(

!

HB!!:#)!.@I'2%$+4)!'1!E%'4*!@$2*)%!J.3-.&.%5!

E;<;++F&4*#$&"#$+"6+%&I/&'&)>+

\2G/2C2BH(2'(#(5,0?%&U(5,-5&?B<(1/B(2B(5#-(1&(/'&F/%%H(C&'5$21&C(#'(B"&(#12%2BH(B,(B$#C&(#(

%#$D&(#0,/-B(,F(#(F2-#-52#%(2-'B$/0&-B(2-(#('",$B(#0,/-B(,F(B20&(#B(5%,'&(B,(B"&(5/$$&-B(?$25&*((

>"/'<(B"&$&(#$&(B"$&&(C20&-'2,-'(B,(%2G/2C2BH9((?$25&<('2V&<(#-C(B20&*((O-&(',/$5&(,F(2%%2G/2C2BH(2'(

&U?%252B( B$#-'#5B2,-( 5,'B'<( 2-5%/C2-D( 1$,N&$#D&( 5,002''2,-'<( ,$C&$E"#-C%2-D( F&&'<( #-C(

B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U&'*((S-@&'B,$'(A",(C&0#-C(%2G/2C2BH(0/'B(1/H(#B(B"&(#'N(?$25&(#-C('&%%(#B(B"&(12C(

?$25&<(',(12CE#'N('?$&#C'(#$&(#%',(#(5,0?,-&-B(,F(B$#C2-D(5,'B'(F,$(B"&'&(B$#C&$'*(

a-,B"&$(',/$5&(,F(2%%2G/2C2BH(2'(,FB&-($&F&$$&C(B,(#'(?$25&(?$&''/$&(,$(?$25&(20?#5B*((SF(#(

0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'(-&&C'(B,('&%%(#-(2-'B$/0&-B(G/25N%H<(#-C(-#B/$#%(1/H&$'(#$&(-,B(200&C2#B&%H(

#@#2%#1%&<(#(0#$N&BE0#N&$(0#H(B#N&(B"&(,B"&$('2C&(,F(B"&(B$#C&<(2-(#-B252?#B2,-(,F(%#H2-D(,FF(B"&(

?,'2B2,-(%#B&$*( (>"&(0#$N&BE0#N&$( 2'(&U?,'&C(B,(B"&($2'N(,F(?$25&(5"#-D&'(A"2%&('"&(",%C'(B"&(

?,'2B2,-(2-(2-@&-B,$H<(#-C(B"/'(B"&(0#$N&BE0#N&$(5"#$D&'(F,$(B"2'($2'N*(

]$25&( 20?#5B( 5#-( #%',( ,55/$( 1&5#/'&( #( B$#C2-D( 5,/-B&$?#$BH( 0#H( "#@&( ?$2@#B&(

2-F,$0#B2,-*(K,$(&U#0?%&<(B"&(1/H&$(,F(#('B,5N(0#H(A,$$H(B"#B(#(?,B&-B2#%('&%%&$("#'(-&D#B2@&(

2-F,$0#B2,-( #1,/B( #( 5,0?#-Hj'( /?5,02-D( &#$-2-D'*( (>"/'<( B"&( #$$2@#%( ,F( '&%%( ,$C&$'( B&-C'( B,(

C$2@&( C,A-( B"&( '"#$&( ?$25&<( #'( ,B"&$( 0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'( 2-F&$( B"#B( B"&( '&%%&$'( 02D"B( 1&(

2-F,$0&C*((S-(#CC2B2,-(B,(?$2@#B&(2-F,$0#B2,-(#1,/B(B"&(F/-C#0&-B#%(@#%/&(,F(#('&5/$2BH<(0#$N&B(

Page 13: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!"

?#$B252?#-B'(0#H(#%',("#@&(?$2@#B&(2-F,$0#B2,-(#1,/B(,$C&$(F%,A*((K,$(&U#0?%&<(2F(#(B$#C2-D(C&'N(

N-,A'( B"#B( #( "&CD&( F/-C( 0#H( -&&C( B,( %2G/2C#B&( #( %#$D&( ?,'2B2,-<( B"&( C&'N( 0#H( '&%%( F2$'B<(

%,A&$2-D(?$25&'*(

+

E;G;++7*($/,*$+"6+%&I/&'&)>+

3&5#/'&(%2G/2C2BH( 2'(5,0?%&U(#-C(0/%B2EC20&-'2,-#%<(B"&$&( 2'(-,('2-D%&(1&'B(0&#'/$&(,F(

%2G/2C2BH*( ( [&'&#$5"&$'( D&-&$#%%H( /'&( #( @#$2&BH( ,F( %2G/2C2BH( 0&#'/$&'*( ( S-( 0,'B( 5#'&'<( B"&'&(

0&#'/$&'(#$&("2D"%H(5,$$&%#B&C(A2B"(&#5"(,B"&$<(1/B(2-F&$&-5&'(#-C(5,-5%/'2,-'(5#-(',0&B20&'(

C&?&-C(,-(B"&(%2G/2C2BH(0&#'/$&(B"#B(2'(&U#02-&C*(

]&$"#?'( B"&( &#'2&'B( %2G/2C2BH( 0&#'/$&( B,( 5#%5/%#B&( #-C( ,1'&$@&( 2'( B"&( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C*((

>"2'(0&#'/$&'(B"&($,/-CEB$2?(5,'B(,F(#(1/H(#-C('&%%(B$#-'#5B2,-(1H(#(%2G/2C2BH(C&0#-C&$*((32CE

#'N('?$&#C'(#$&(/'/#%%H(0&#'/$&C(#'(#( F$#5B2,-(,F( B"&(B,B#%(#0,/-B(B$#C&C(IB"&'&(#$&(BH?25#%%H(

5#%%&C( 8,"8",)&"#(%+ $8,*('$( ,$( ,*%()&.*+ $8,*('$L<( 1/B( ',0&B20&'( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'( #$&(0&#'/$&C( 2-(

5&-B'(?&$('"#$&*(

S-( Z*4*( &G/2BH( #-C( F/B/$&'( 0#$N&B'<( 5,-B2-/,/'%H( /?C#B&C( 12C( #-C( #'N( ?$25&'( #$&(

&%&5B$,-25#%%H( B$#-'02BB&C( B,( 2-@&'B,$'( 1H( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'*( ( >"&'&( #$&( $&F&$$&C( B,( #'( D&'-($B+

I/")*$( ,$( P/'B(I/")*$<( #-C( B"&(12CE#'N( '?$&#C( 5#%5/%#B&C(/'2-D( B"&'&(G/,B&'( 2'( 5#%%&C( B"&(I/")*'+

$8,*('*((Z%B20#B&%H<(B$#-'#5B2,-'(0#H(-,B(B#N&(?%#5&(#B(B"&(G/,B&C(12C(,$(#'N(?$25&*((>"&$&(5,/%C(

1&( #( "2CC&-( ,$C&$( #B( #( 1&BB&$( ?$25&<( ,$( #( 0#$N&BE0#N&$( 0#H( ,FF&$( #( 1&BB&$( ?$25&( B,( ',0&(

2-5,02-D(,$C&$'(IN-,A-(#'(8,&2*+&48,".*4*#)L*((S-(1,B"(,F(B"&'&(5#'&'<(B"&(*66*2)&.*+D&'-($B+$8,*('(

0#H( 1&( -#$$,A&$( B"#-( B"&( G/,B&C( '?$&#C*( ( SF( B"&( 2-5,02-D( ,$C&$( 2'( %#$D&( #-C( &U5&&C'( B"&(

#0,/-B( B"#B( 2'( 12C( ,$( ,FF&$&C( #B( B"&( G/,B&C( ?$25&<( B"&( $&0#2-2-D( ?#$B( ,F( B"&( ,$C&$( 0#H( 1&(

&U&5/B&C(#B(#-(2-F&$2,$(?$25&(I',0&B20&'(N-,A-(#'(J(%B&#5+)K*+D""BL*((S-(B"2'(5#'&<(B"&(&FF&5B2@&(

12CE#'N( '?$&#C( 2'( #5B/#%%H( A2C&$( B"#-( B"&( G/,B&C( '?$&#C*( ( [&'&#$5"&$'( D&-&$#%%H( C&F2-&( B"&(

Page 14: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!#

&FF&5B2@&( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C( #'( BA25&( B"&( C2'B#-5&( 1&BA&&-( B"&( #5B/#%( B$#-'#5B2,-( ?$25&( #-C( B"&(

?$&@#2%2-D(02C?,2-B(1&BA&&-(B"&(G/,B&C(12C(#-C(#'N(?$25&'*((>"&(0/%B2?%2&$(2'(BA,(1&5#/'&(B"&(

C2'B#-5&( B,( B"&( #5B/#%( B$#C&( ?$25&( 5#?B/$&'( B"&( 5,'B( ,F( ,-&( '2C&( ,F( B"&( B$#C&<( A"2%&( 12CE#'N(

'?$&#C'(1H(5,-@&-B2,-(0&#'/$&(#($,/-CEB$2?(B$#C2-D(5,'B*( (S-(0,'B(0#$N&B'<(B"&(&FF&5B2@&(12CE

#'N('?$&#C(2'(',0&A"#B(-#$$,A&$(B"#-(B"&(G/,B&C(12CE#'N('?$&#C'*(

W"2%&(12CE#'N('?$&#C'(#$&(#-(#??$,?$2#B&(%2G/2C2BH(0&#'/$&(F,$(B$#C&$'(A",(B$#C&(,-5&(

2-( '0#%%(G/#-B2B2&'<( B"&H(0#H(-,B(1&( B"&(#??$,?$2#B&(0&#'/$&( F,$( 2-'B2B/B2,-'(#-C(,B"&$( %#$D&(

B$#C&$'(A",(D$#C/#%%H(kA,$Nl(%#$D&(,$C&$'(,@&$(B20&(2-(,$C&$(B,(02-202V&(B"&2$(&U&5/B2,-(5,'B'*((

W"2%&( B"&'&( B$#C&$'( #$&( #%',( 5,-5&$-&C( #1,/B( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'<( B"&H( A,$$H( #B( %&#'B( #'( 0/5"(

#1,/B( B"&( ?$25&( 20?#5B( ,F( B"&2$( B$#C&'*( ( a'( #-( 2-'B2B/B2,-#%( B$#C&$( 1/H'( '"#$&'( ,F( S-B&%<( F,$(

&U#0?%&<(B"&(?/$5"#'&'(B&-C(B,(C$2@&(/?(B"&(S-B&%('"#$&(?$25&*((\#B&$(?/$5"#'&'(2-(B"&('&G/&-5&(

B&-C(B,(,55/$(#B("2D"&$(?$25&'*(

>"&'&( 8,&2*+ &48(2)$( 5#-( 1&( 0&#'/$&C( 1H( %,,N2-D( #B( B"&( $&'?,-'&( ,F( '"#$&( ?$25&'( B,( #(

?#$B25/%#$( B$#C&*( ( J,A&@&$<( B"&( ?$&F&$$&C( B$#C2-D( 5,'B( 0&#'/$&( F,$( 2-'B2B/B2,-'( 2'( N-,A-( #'(

&48%*4*#)()&"#+ $K",)6(%%*( ( SB( 2'( 5#%5/%#B&C( #'( B"&( #@&$#D&( &U&5/B2,-( ?$25&( F,$( B"&( %#$D&( ,$C&$(

5,0?#$&C( B,( B"&( ?$25&( ,F( B"&( 'B,5N( ?$2,$( B,( B"&( 'B#$B( ,F( &U&5/B2,-*( ( a'( A2B"( '?$&#C'<(

20?%&0&-B#B2,-('",$BF#%%'(#$&(/'/#%%H(5#%5/%#B&C(,-(#(?$,?,$B2,-#%(1#'2'($&%#B2@&(B,(B"&(#0,/-B(

B$#C&C<(#-C(20?%&0&-B#B2,-('",$BF#%%(2'(/'/#%%H($&?,$B&C(2-(1#'2'(?,2-B'*(

W"2%&(0,'B(%2G/2C2BH(0&#'/$&'(#%',(C,/1%&(#'(0&#'/$&'(,F(B$#C2-D(5,'B'<(B"&$&(#$&(#(F&A(

%2G/2C2BH(0&#'/$&'(B"#B(F,5/'(,-(C&@2#B2,-'(F$,0(B"&(',E5#%%&C(&FF252&-B(?$25&*((>"&'&(0&#'/$&'(,F(

8,&2*+*66&2&*#2>(BH?25#%%H(0&#'/$&(B"&(#@&$#D&('2V&(,F(B"&'&(C&@2#B2,-'(/'2-D(#-(&5,-,0&B$25(0,C&%(

B"#B(B#N&'(2-B,(#55,/-B(#(D$&#B(C&#%(,F($&5&-B(,$C&$(F%,A(2-F,$0#B2,-(I'&&(J#'1$,/5N<(=gg:<(F,$(

&U#0?%&L*((3H(C&F2-2B2,-<(B"&'&(B&0?,$#$H(?$25&(0,@&'(#$&(&@&-B/#%%H($&@&$'&C(,$(&%202-#B&C<(',(

B"&'&(?$25&(2-&FF252&-52&'(#$&(D&-&$#%%H(0&#'/$&C(&5,-,0&B$25#%%H(1H(%,,N2-D(#B(?$25&($&@&$'#%'*(

Page 15: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!$

+

E;!;++L&I/&'&)>+(66*2)$+$)"2B+8,&2*$+

MU?%252B(B$#-'#5B2,-(5,'B'(#FF&5B('"#$&(?$25&'<(1&5#/'&(B"&H('/1B$#5B(F$,0($&B/$-'(&@&$H(

B20&(#('"#$&(,F('B,5N(2'(1,/D"B(,$(',%C*((a(1/H&$(N-,A'(B"#B('"&(A2%%("#@&(B,('&%%(,-&(C#H(#-C(

2-5/$(B$#-'#5B2,-(5,'B'*((4"&(#%',(N-,A'(B"#B(B"&(2-@&'B,$(A",(1/H'(F$,0("&$(A2%%("#@&(B,(?#H(

B$#-'#5B2,-(5,'B'(A"&-("&(1/H'(#-C(#D#2-(A"&-("&('&%%'<(#-C(',(,-(C,A-(B"&(%2-&*((>"/'<('"#$&(

?$25&'( '",/%C( 1&( $&C/5&C( 1H( B"&( ?$&'&-B( @#%/&( ,F( #%%( &U?&5B&C( F/B/$&( B$#-'#5B2,-( 5,'B'*((

!,-@&$'&%H<(#-HB"2-D(B"#B(?&$0#-&-B%H($&C/5&'(B$#-'#5B2,-(5,'B'('",/%C(?&$0#-&-B%H(2-5$&#'&(

'"#$&(?$25&'*(

W"&-(B"&H(#$&(P/'B2F2&C<("2D"&$('"#$&(?$25&'(#$&(@#%/#1%&(F,$(B"&(&5,-,0H<(1&5#/'&(B"&H(

%,A&$(B"&(5,'B(,F(5#?2B#%(F,$(F2$0'*((W2B"(#(%,A&$(5,'B(,F(5#?2B#%<(0,$&(2-@&'B0&-B(?$,P&5B'(#$&(

?$,F2B#1%&<(#-C(F2$0'('",/%C(2-5$&#'&(B"&2$(%&@&%(,F(2-@&'B0&-B*((`$&#B&$(2-@&'B0&-B('",/%C(%&#C(

B,( "2D"&$( %&@&%'( ,F(`Q]( #-C( #( 1&BB&$( 'B#-C#$C( ,F( %2@2-D*(>"2'( 2'( B"&(0#2-( 5"#--&%( 1H(A"25"(

JK>(5#-("#@&(',52&B#%(@#%/&*( ( S-(#CC2B2,-<( B"2'( 2'( B"&(0#2-($&#',-(?,%25H0#N&$'( '",/%C(A,$N(

"#$C(B,(F#52%2B#B&(%,A(B$#-'#5B2,-(5,'B'(#-C('/'B#2-#1%H("2D"(%&@&%'(,F('B,5N(0#$N&B(%2G/2C2BH*(

a5"#$H#( #-C( ]&C&$'&-( I:;;fL( 2-B$,C/5&( #( '&02-#%( 5#?2B#%( #''&B( ?$252-D( 0,C&%( B"#B(

2-5,$?,$#B&'( B"&'&( %2G/2C2BH( &FF&5B'*( ( \2G/2C2BH( %&@&%'( #$&( 20?,$B#-B( 2-( B"&2$( 0,C&%<( 1/B( ',( 2'(

@#$2#12%2BH(2-(%2G/2C2BH*((\2G/2C2BH($2'N(2'(C&F2-&C(#'(#(?,'2B2@&(5,$$&%#B2,-(1&BA&&-(2%%2G/2C2BH(#-C(

-&D#B2@&( 'B,5N( $&B/$-'<( #-C( B"&H( '",A( B"#B( B"2'( 2'( #-(/-C&'2$#1%&( $2'N( B"#B( 2-@&'B,$'(A#-B( B,(

#@,2C*((W"2%&(-,B(F,$0#%%H(#(?#$B(,F(B"&2$(0,C&%<(B"&2$($&'/%B'('/DD&'B(B"#B(0#$N&B('B$/5B/$&'(,$(

?,%252&'(B"#B($&C/5&(B"2'(%2G/2C2BH($2'N(A,/%C(1&(C&'2$#1%&(#-C(A,/%C($#2'&(,@&$#%%('"#$&(?$25&'*((

>"/'<( B"&$&( 2'( 5,-'2C&$#1%&( P/'B2F25#B2,-( F,$( F,5/'2-D(?,%25H(,-(02-202V2-D( B"&( &@#?,$#B2,-(,F(

%2G/2C2BH(#B(&U#5B%H(B"&(A$,-D(B20&'*(

!

Page 16: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!%

KB!!;)4)+%!.@I2'?)@)+%E!.+!@$2*)%!J.3-.&.%5!

+,-&'( I:;;7L( F2-C'( B"#B( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'( ,@&$( B"&( ?#'B( =;;( H&#$'( #$&( 0,'B%H(

5,/-B&$5H5%25#%*( (K2D/$&( =( '",A'( B"&( B20&E'&$2&'( &@,%/B2,-( ,F( G/,B&C( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'( 2-(Q,A(

+,-&'(S-C/'B$2#%(a@&$#D&('B,5N'*( (>"&(F2D/$&('",A'(B"#B(12CE#'N('?$&#C'(#$&(A2C&(A"&-('"#$&(

?$25&'( #$&( $&%#B2@&%H( %,A( #-C( B"&( &5,-,0H( 2'( ?,,$<( #-C( '?$&#C'( B&-C( B,( -#$$,A( A"&-( B"&(

&5,-,0H(#-C('"#$&(?$25&'( 20?$,@&*( (>"2'(?#BB&$-(?&$'2'B'(/-B2%( #1,/B(=g^;<( #-C( B"&-(12CE#'N(

'?$&#C'( 'B&#C2%H( -#$$,A( #'( ?#$B( ,F( #( '&5/%#$( 5"#-D&*( ( >"2'( ?$,1#1%H( $&F%&5B'( B"&( 5,-B2-/&C(

#C,?B2,-( ,F( B&5"-,%,DH( I'&&( F,$( &U#0?%&( B"&( B&5"-,%,D25#%( /?D$#C&'( C,5/0&-B&C( 2-( M#'%&H<(

J&-C&$'",BB<( #-C( [#0#C,$#2( I:;;gLL<( A"25"( $&C/5&C( ,$C&$( B/$-#$,/-C( B20&'( #-C( ?$,@2C&C(

0,$&( B20&%H( 2-F,$0#B2,-( #1,/B( 5,-C2B2,-'( ,-( B"&( F%,,$( ,F( B"&( &U5"#-D&<( #'( A&%%( #'( 0,C&'B(

&FF,$B'(1H(B"&(C,02-#-B(Yb4M(B,(%&''&-(B"&(#C@#-B#D&'(#55$/2-D(B,(F%,,$(?#$B252?#-B'*(((

(

!",$C2#<( [,%%<( #-C( 4/1$#"0#-H#0( I:;;fL<( J&-C&$'",BB<( +,-&'<( #-C()&-N@&%C( I:;=;L<(

#-C(a-D&%<(J#$$2'<(#-C(4?#BB( I:;=;L(C,5/0&-B(B"&(0,$&($&5&-B(-#$$,A2-D(,F(12CE#'N('?$&#C'*((

>"&(F,%%,A2-D(F2D/$&(2'(B#N&-(F$,0(a-D&%<(J#$$2'<(#-C(4?#BB(I:;=;L(#-C('",A'(B"&(-#$$,A2-D(,F(

12CE#'N('?$&#C'(,@&$(B20&9(

Page 17: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!&

(

K2D/$&(:*(()&C2#-(12CE#'N('?$&#C'(,-(4d](f;;('B,5N'<(:;;7E:;;g*((4,/$5&9((X-2D"B(4&5/$2B2&'(@2#(a-D&%<(J#$$2'<(#-C(4?#BB(I:;=;L(

(

a'( C2'5/''&C( &#$%2&$<( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'( #$&( B"&( $&%&@#-B( 0&#'/$&( ,F( B$#C2-D( 5,'B( F,$(

2-@&'B,$'( A2B"( '0#%%( ,$C&$'( B"#B( C&0#-C( 200&C2#5H*( ( S0?%&0&-B#B2,-( '",$BF#%%( 2'( #( 1&BB&$(

0&#'/$&(,F(B$#C2-D(5,'B'(F,$(%#$D&(2-'B2B/B2,-#%(2-@&'B,$'<(#-C(K2D/$&(7('",A'(B"#B(2-'B2B/B2,-#%(

B$#C2-D(5,'B'(#$&( %,A&$( 2-(:;==(B"#-( 2-(:;;8<(1#'&C(,-(C#B#(5,%%&5B&C(1H(B"&(B$#-'#5B2,-(5,'B(

#-#%H'2'(#$0(,F(B"&(1$,N&$#D&(F2$0(S>`*((S-'B2B/B2,-#%(B$#C2-D(5,'B'(#$&(0/5"("2D"&$(C/$2-D(B"&(

%#'B( G/#$B&$( ,F( :;;^( #-C( B"&( 1&D2--2-D( ,F( :;;g<( 1/B( B"2'( 2'( #%0,'B( '/$&%H( C/&( B,( B"&(

0#5$,&5,-,025( /-5&$B#2-BH( #-C( 'B,5N( 0#$N&B( @,%#B2%2BH( #'',52#B&C( A2B"( B"&( F2-#-52#%( 5$2'2'*((

>$#C2-D(5,'B'(C$,?(G/25N%H(B"&$&#FB&$(#-C(#$&(-,A(1#5N(-&#$(B"&2$(?$&E5$2'2'(%,A'*((W"2%&(B"2'(

B20&E'&$2&'(&@2C&-5&(5#--,B( 2',%#B&( B"&( 20?#5B(,F("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(B$#C&$'(,-(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH<( 2B(

C,&'( 2-C25#B&( B"#B(Z4( &G/2BH(0#$N&B'( ,@&$#%%( #$&( C,2-D( #( D,,C( P,1( ,F( ?$,@2C2-D( %2G/2C2BH( B,(

2-'B2B/B2,-#%(B$#C&$'*(

Page 18: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!'

(K2D/$&(7*( (a@&$#D&( 20?%&0&-B#B2,-('",$BF#%%( 2-( %#$D&E5#?(Z*4*( 'B,5N'*( (4,/$5&9( ( S>`($&'&#$5"($&?,$B'*(

(

K2-#%%H<( K$&-5"( I:;;^L( '",A'( B"#B( 5,002''2,-'( #-C( ,B"&$( B$#C2-D( 5,'B( F$25B2,-'( "#@&(

#%',(C&5%2-&C(,@&$(B20&*((K2D/$&(8('",A'(B"#B(,@&$#%%(#@&$#D&(5,002''2,-'(?%/'(0#$N&BE0#N&$(

$&@&-/&(,-(&G/2BH(B$#C&'(2-(B"&(Z-2B&C(4B#B&'("#@&(?%/00&B&C(F$,0(#1,/B(=*8Te(,F(B"&(#0,/-B(

B$#C&C(2-(=g^;(B,(;*==e(2-(:;;T<(B"&(%#'B(H&#$(F,$(A"25"(C#B#(#$&(#@#2%#1%&*(

*+**,

*+%*,

!+**,

!+%*,

!)(* !)(% !))* !))% "*** "**% "*!*((

K2D/$&(8*(a@&$#D&(5,002''2,-'(?%/'(0#$N/?'(,-(Z*4*(&G/2BH(B$#C2-D<(&U?$&''&C(#'(#(?&$5&-B#D&(,F(@,%/0&(B$#-'#5B&C*(4,/$5&9(K$&-5"(I:;;^L*(

*

!*

"*

#*

$*

%*

&*

'*

"**$-#

"**%-!

"**%-#

"**&-!

"**&-#

"**'-!

"**'-#

"**(-!

"**(-#

"**)-!

"**)-#

"*!*-!

"*!*-#

"*!!-!

!"#$%&'(

#%#)

"%&$#

./001221/3 ./242

56 ./242

Page 19: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!(

(

>"&$&( #$&(0#-H( $&#',-'( B"#B( %2G/2C2BH( "#'( 20?$,@&C( #-C( B$#C2-D( 5,'B'( "#@&( C&5%2-&C(

,@&$(B20&*((!,002''2,-'(A&$&(C&$&D/%#B&C(2-(B"&(&#$%H(=gh;j'(#-C(G/25N%H(1&D#-(B,(?%/00&B*((

4B,5N( &U5"#-D&'( D$#C/#%%H( #C,?B&C( -&A( B&5"-,%,DH( #-C( $&C/5&C( 5,'B'<( ?#''2-D( B",'&( %,A&$(

5,'B'(,-(B,(1$,N&$EC&#%&$'(#-C(2-@&'B,$'(2-(B"&(F,$0(,F(%,A&$(B$#C2-D(F&&'*((>"&(02-20/0(?$25&(

2-5$&0&-B(A#'( m;*=:f( ?&$( '"#$&( 1&F,$&( =ggh<(A"25"(0&#-B( B"#B( B"&(02-20/0(12CE#'N( '?$&#C(

A#'(#%',(m;*=:f*( (>"&(02-20/0(B25N( 2'(-,A(m;*;=*( ( S-( B"&(02C(=gh;j'<(!,-D$&''( &-#5B&C( B"&(

Y#B2,-#%( )#$N&B( 4H'B&0<( A"25"( A#'( &U?%252B%H( C&'2D-&C( B,( &-5,/$#D&( 5,0?&B2B2,-( 1&BA&&-(

@#$2,/'( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'*( ( M@&-B/#%%H<( 5,0?&B2-D( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'( A&$&( #1%&( B,( C$#A( B$#C2-D(

@,%/0&(#A#H(F$,0(B"&(2-5/01&-B(Yb4M(#-C(Y#'C#G('H'B&0'*( ([&D/%#B2,-(Y)4<(A"25"(5#0&(

2-B,(&FF&5B(2-(:;;T<(A#'(#-(20?,$B#-B(?#$B(,F(&-5,/$#D2-D(B"2'(5,0?&B2B2,-*(

a'( &U5"#-D&'( B/$-&C( B,( #/B,0#B2,-<( 2B( 1&5#0&( ?,''21%&( B,( $&?%#5&( "/0#-'( A2B"(

0#5"2-&'( #B( @#$2,/'( ?,2-B'( 2-( B"&( B$#C2-D( ?$,5&''*( ( K%,,$( 1$,N&$'<( A",( A,/%C( 'B#-C( #B( B"&(

Yb4M(B$#C2-D(?,'B(#-C(A,$N(5/'B,0&$(,$C&$'(,@&$(B"&(5,/$'&(,F(#(B$#C2-D(C#H<(A&$&(D$#C/#%%H(

$&?%#5&C( 1H( #%D,$2B"0'( B"#B( A&$&( $&'?,-'21%&( F,$( B"&( D$#C/#%( &U&5/B2,-( ,F( %#$D&( 5/'B,0&$(

,$C&$'( ,@&$( B20&*( ( J/0#-( 0#$N&BE0#N&$'( A&$&( D$#C/#%%H( $&?%#5&C( 1H( #/B,0#B&C( 0#$N&BE

0#N&$'*( ( a-C( 5,0?/B&$( ?$,D$#0'( A&$&( G/25N&$( B,( '?,B( #$12B$#D&( ,??,$B/-2B2&'( #-C( 5,/%C(

G/25N%H(C,(B"&($&G/2$&C(5#%5/%#B2,-'(B,(2C&-B2FH(02'?$25&C('&5/$2B2&'*((S-(B"&'&(5#'&'<(5,0?/B&$'(

A&$&(5"&#?&$(B"#-("/0#-'<(#-C(B"&($&'/%B2-D(5,'B(&FF252&-52&'(A,/%C(1&(&U?&5B&C(B,(1&(?#''&C(

,-(B,(2-@&'B,$'*(

Z%B20#B&%H<( 2B( 2'( ',0&A"#B( C2FF25/%B( B,( ?2-( C,A-( B"&( 5,-B$21/B2,-( ,F( &#5"( ,F( B"&'&(

5"#-D&'<(1/B($&'&#$5"&$'("#@&('B/C2&C(&#5"(,F(B"&2$(&FF&5B'*((>"2'(?#?&$(F,5/'&'(,-(B"&(?,B&-B2#%(

5,-B$21/B2,-( ,F( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H( B$#C2-D( 2-( #%%( ,F( 2B'( @#$2,/'( F,$0'( B,( B"&( $&5&-B( 5"#-D&'( 2-(

%2G/2C2BH(#-C(B$#C2-D(5,'B'*(

Page 20: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

!)

!

LB!!=4'+'@.4!.EE-)E!E-22'-+&.+/!FG:!

3#'25( B&UB1,,N( &5,-,025'( 5#-( 1&( &#'2%H( #??%2&C( B,( JK>*( ( K,$( &U#0?%&<( 2F( B"&$&( 2'(

5,0?&B2B2,-(2-(B"&(?$,@2'2,-(,F(%2G/2C2BH<(B"&(0,$&(&FF252&-B(?$,@2C&$(,F(%2G/2C2BH(2'(%2N&%H(B,(A2-(

,/B*((>"2'(1&-&F2B'(5,-'/0&$'<(A",(2-(B"2'(5#'&(#$&(2-@&'B,$'(A2B"(#(C&'2$&(B,(B$#C&*(

\2G/2C2BH( 2'( #%',( #FF&5B&C( 1H( #'H00&B$25( 2-F,$0#B2,-( #5$,''( 0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'*( ( SF(

1&BB&$E2-F,$0&C( B$#C&$'( 2-B&$#5B( A2B"( %&''E2-F,$0&C( B$#C&$'<( B"&( 1&BB&$E2-F,$0&C( B$#C&$'( #$&(

%2N&%H(B,(1/H(%,A(#-C('&%%("2D"<(&#$-2-D(?$,F2B'<(A"2%&(B"&(%&''E2-F,$0&C(B$#C&$'(#$&(%2N&%H(B,(1/H(

"2D"(#-C('&%%(%,A<(D&-&$#B2-D(%,''&'*((>"2'(2'(,FB&-($&F&$$&C(B,(#'(#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-<(1&5#/'&(B"&(

%&''E2-F,$0&C( B$#C&$'( &-C( /?( A2B"( $&%#B2@&%H( /-#BB$#5B2@&( B$#C&'*( ( S-( D&-&$#%<( ",%C2-D(

&@&$HB"2-D(&%'&(&G/#%<(2F(JK>(2-5$&#'&'(#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-<(%2G/2C2BH(A,$'&-'*(

SF(JK>(#$&(2-C&&C(1&BB&$(2-F,$0&C(C/&(B,(B"&2$('?&&C(2-(?$,5&''2-D(2-F,$0#B2,-<(B"&$&(2'(

#%',( #-( /?'2C&<( 1&5#/'&( B"&2$( B$#C2-D( 5,-B$21/B&'( B,( ?$25&( C2'5,@&$H*( ( 4B,5N( ?$25&'( #$&( 0,$&(

&FF252&-B( 1&5#/'&( B"&H( $&F%&5B(0,$&( 2-F,$0#B2,-(0,$&( G/25N%H<( #-C( B"2'( 5#-( 1&( @#%/#1%&( B,( #%%(

2-@&'B,$'*((K,$(&U#0?%&<(#'(C2'5/''&C(&#$%2&$(2-C&U(#$12B$#D&(#5B2@2BH(1H(JK>(&-'/$&'(B"#B(B"&(

?$25&(,F(#(1#'N&B(,F('B,5N'($&F%&5B'(B"&(?$25&'(,F(B"&(/-C&$%H2-D('B,5N'*((a-(2-@&'B,$(A",(A#-B'(

B,(",%C(#(1$,#C(0#$N&B( 2-C&U('/5"(#'( B"&(4d](f;;(5#-(?/$5"#'&(4]b(IB"&(12DD&'B(M>K(B"#B(

B$#5N'( B"&( 4d]( f;;L( '&5/$&( 2-( B"&( N-,A%&CD&( B"#B( B"&( ?$25&( ,F( B"&( M>K( 5%,'&%H( $&F%&5B'( B"&(

B$#C2-D(?$25&(,F(B"&(/-C&$%H2-D('B,5N'*((>"2'(#%',(0#N&'(4]b(#-(&FF&5B2@&("&CD2-D(B,,%(F,$(B",'&(

B$H2-D(B,(%202B(B"&2$('B,5N(0#$N&B($2'N*((4]b(2'(1H(F#$(B"&(0,'B(#5B2@&%H(B$#C&C('&5/$2BH(,-(Z4(

'B,5N( &U5"#-D&'<( #-C( 2B'( @,%/0&( "#'( 2-5$&#'&C( C$#0#B25#%%H( ,@&$( B"&( ?#'B( '&@&$#%( H&#$'<(

'/DD&'B2-D( B"#B( B"&( ?$25&( C2'5,@&$H( C/&( B,(JK>( #-C( ,B"&$( #$12B$#D&/$'( 2'( G/2B&( @#%/#1%&( B,(

2-@&'B,$'*( (>"&( $&'/%B2-D( B$#C2-D(@,%/0&(#-C("2D"( %&@&%'(,F( %2G/2C2BH(0#N&(4]b(#BB$#5B2@&( B,(

Page 21: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

"*

0,$&( #-C(0,$&( 2-@&'B,$'<( #-C(02D"B( &-5,/$#D&( B"&0( B,( B#N&( 12DD&$( ?,'2B2,-'( ,$( ,B"&$A2'&(

0#N&(D$&#B&$(/'&(,F(B"&(M>K*((

a'H00&B$25( 2-F,$0#B2,-( #-C( ?$25&( C2'5,@&$H( "#@&( %,-D( 1&&-( ,F( 2-B&$&'B( 2-( &5,-,025(

0,C&%'(,F( B$#C2-D<(#-C(',0&(,%C&$(&5,-,025(0,C&%'(#$&(&U?%252B%H(C&'2D-&C( B,(5,-'2C&$( B"&'&(

BH?&'(,F(B$#C&,FF'*((>"&'&(0,C&%'(5#-(1&(&#'2%H(#??%2&C(B,(JK><(1&5#/'&(B"&(1#'25(&5,-,025'(,F(

0#$N&BE0#N2-D( #-C( B"&( &FF&5B'( ,-( 0#$N&B'( ,F( C2FF&$&-B2#%%H( 2-F,$0&C( 2-@&'B,$'( #$&( B"&( '#0&(

A"&B"&$(B"&(0#$N&B(2'(0#-/#%(,$(#/B,0#B&C*(

`%,'B&-( #-C( )2%D$,0( I=g^fL<( F,$( &U#0?%&<( 2'( ,-&( ,F( B"&( 0,'B( 20?,$B#-B( B"&,$&B25#%(

0#$N&B(025$,'B$/5B/$&(0,C&%'<(#-C(,-&(,F(B"&(F2$'B(B,(5,-'2C&$(#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-(2-(B$#C2-D*((S-(

B"&2$(0,C&%<(5,0?&B2B2@&(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(B$#-'#5B(A2B"(?,B&-B2#%%H(2-F,$0&C(B$#C&$'*((>"&H("#@&(

2-( 02-C( #( 0#$N&B( A"&$&( 2-@&'B,$'( B$#-'#5B( A2B"( C&#%&$'( 1H( ?",-&<( 1/B( B"&( $&'/%B'( #$&( -,B(

C&?&-C&-B(,-(B",'&(?#$B25/%#$(C&B#2%'*((>"&H('",A(B"#B(B"&(&G/2%21$2/0(12CE#'N('?$&#C(C&?&-C'(

,-( B"&( 5,'B( ,F( ?$,5&''2-D( B$#C&'( #-C( B"&( #0,/-B( ,F( #C@&$'&( '&%&5B2,-<( '?&52F25#%%H( B"&(

2-F,$0#B2,-(#C@#-B#D&(B"#B(B"&(2-F,$0&C(B$#C&$'("#@&(,@&$(0#$N&BE0#N&$'*((>"&(0,C&%(5#-(1&(

#??%2&C( C2$&5B%H( B,( B"&( 5/$$&-B( #/B,0#B&C( B$#C2-D( 'B$/5B/$&*( ( K,$( &U#0?%&<( 2F( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H(

0#$N&BE0#N&$'("#@&(%,A&$(5,'B'(B"#-(B$#C2B2,-#%(0#$N&BE0#N&$'<(`%,'B&-E)2%D$,0(20?%2&'(B"#B(

B"2'( 5,'B( $&C/5B2,-( '",/%C(0#-2F&'B( 2B'&%F( 2-( -#$$,A&$( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'*( ( S-( #CC2B2,-<( 2F( "2D"E

F$&G/&-5H( 0#$N&BE0#N&$'( #$&( #1%&( B,( 2-5,$?,$#B&( 0,$&( 2-F,$0#B2,-( 2-( '&BB2-D( #( G/,B&<( B"2'(

'",/%C($&C/5&(B"&2$(2-F,$0#B2,-(C2'#C@#-B#D&<(#-C(B"2'(B,,('",/%C($&'/%B(2-(#(-#$$,A&$(12CE#'N(

'?$&#C*( ( OF( 5,/$'&<( -,B( #%%( JK>( #$&( 0#$N&BE0#N&$'*( ( SF( JK>( 0#N&( B"&( #C@&$'&( '&%&5B2,-(

?$,1%&0(A,$'&(F,$(#-H($&#',-<('?$&#C'(A2C&-(2-(B"&(`%,'B&-E)2%D$,0(0,C&%*(

J2$'"%&2F&$(I=gh=L('",A'(B"#B(B"&$&(#$&('B$,-D(2-5&-B2@&'(B,(5,%%&5B(?$2@#B&(2-F,$0#B2,-(

#-C( B$#C&( ,-( B"#B( 2-F,$0#B2,-<( #-C( B"&( ?$2@#B&( @#%/&( ,F( B"#B( 2-F,$0#B2,-( 5#-( F#$( &U5&&C( B"&(

',52#%(@#%/&(,F( B"#B( 2-F,$0#B2,-*( (>"2'('/DD&'B'( B"&(?,''212%2BH( B"#B(JK>(02D"B(,@&$2-@&'B( 2-(

Page 22: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

"!

B&5"-,%,DH<( 2-F$#'B$/5B/$&<( #-C( 2-F,$0#B2,-( ?$,C/5B2,-( $&%#B2@&( B,( ',52#%( ,?B20/0*( ( SB( 2'(

20?,$B#-B( B,( -,B&( B"#B( B"&( J2$'"%&2F&$( 0,C&%( 2'( &U?%252B%H( 5,-'B$/5B&C( ',( B"#B( B"&$&( #$&( -,(

1&-&F2B'( B,( "#@2-D( 0,$&( &FF252&-B( ,$( #55/$#B&( ?$25&'*( ( ( ( SF( ?$25&( C2'5,@&$H( 2'( @#%/#1%&<( JK>(

2-@&'B0&-B'(2-(B&5"-,%,DH(5#-(1&(',52#%%H(C&'2$#1%&<($&F%&5B2-D("&#%B"H(5,0?&B2B2,-($#B"&$(B"#-(

#-(/-?$,C/5B2@&(#$0'($#5&*(

W2B"(B"&($&5&-B(2-B&$&'B(2-(JK><(B"&$&("#@&(1&&-(#(-/01&$(,F($&5&-B(B"&,$&B25#%(0,C&%'(

F,5/'&C( &U?%252B%H( ,-(JK>*( (>H?25#%%H( 2-( B"&'&(0,C&%'<( 1/H&$'( #-C( '&%%&$'(A",( #$$2@&( #B( B"&(

0#$N&B(#B(C2FF&$&-B(B20&'(#$&(/-#1%&(B,(B$#C&(A2B"(&#5"(,B"&$<(#-C(1H(",%C2-D( 2-@&-B,$H(F,$(#(

'",$B(?&$2,C(,F(B20&<(JK>(&-#1%&'(D#2-'(F$,0(B$#C&*((S-(0,'B(,F(B"&'&(0,C&%'<(B"&(C,A-'2C&(,F(

JK>(2'(B"#B(B"&2$('?&&C<(,$(B"&(2-F,$0#B2,-(B"&H(5,%%&5B(#-C(/'&(F,$(B$#C2-D<(2-5$&#'&'(#C@&$'&(

'&%&5B2,-<(B"&$&1H(A,$'&-2-D(%2G/2C2BH*(

S-( B"&( 0,C&%( ,F( 32#2'<( K,/5#/%B<( #-C( ),2-#'( I:;==L<( B"&( 2-B&$0&C2#B2,-( F/-5B2,-(

?$,@2C&C( 1H(JK>( "&%?'( B$#C&$'( F2-C( 5,/-B&$?#$B2&'<( %&#C2-D( B,( D#2-'( F$,0( B$#C&*( ( J,A&@&$<(

JK>( 5#-( B$#C&( ,-( -&A( 2-F,$0#B2,-( 0,$&( G/25N%H<( D&-&$#B2-D( #C@&$'&( '&%&5B2,-( 5,'B'*( ( S-(

#CC2B2,-<(JK>($&G/2$&'('2D-2F25#-B(F2U&C(2-@&'B0&-B'(2-(B&5"-,%,DH*((S-(B"&2$(0,C&%<(B"2'(0&#-'(

B"#B( ,-%H( '/FF252&-B%H( %#$D&( 2-'B2B/B2,-'( #$&( %2N&%H( B,(0#N&( B"&'&( F2U&C( 2-@&'B0&-B'*( ( 40#%%&$(

F2$0'(#-C(2-@&'B,$'(#$&(%&FB(B,(1&#$(B"&(#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-(5,'B'(F$,0(JK>*((K2-#%%H<(B"&H(0,C&%(

B"&( #$0'( $#5&( F&#B/$&( ,F(JK>*( (>"&H( F2-C(0/%B2?%&( &G/2%21$2#( 2-( B"&2$(0,C&%<( ',0&( ,F(A"25"(

&U"212B(',52#%%H(2-&FF252&-B(,@&$2-@&'B0&-B(2-(JK>*(

>"&$&(2'(#('202%#$(B$#C&E,FF(2-(+,@#-,@25(#-C()&-N@&%C(I:;==L*((S-(B"&2$(0,C&%<(JK>(5#-(

/?C#B&( %202B( ,$C&$'( G/25N%H( 1#'&C( ,-( -&A( 2-F,$0#B2,-*( ( a'( #( $&'/%B<( JK>( 5#-( #@,2C( ',0&(

#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-<(#-C(JK>(5#-(?$,@2C&(',0&(,F(B"#B(1&-&F2B(B,(/-2-F,$0&C(2-@&'B,$'(A",(-&&C(

B,( B$#C&*( ( 4,0&( ,F( B"&'&( B$#C&'(02D"B( -,B( "#@&( ,55/$$&C( ,B"&$A2'&<( 2-(A"25"( 5#'&(JK>( 5#-(

20?$,@&(A&%F#$&*( (J,A&@&$<( 2F( B"&(-#B/$#%(1/H&$'(#-C('&%%&$'(C,(-,B("#@&(0/5"(,F(#-(#C@&$'&(

Page 23: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

""

'&%&5B2,-(?$,1%&0<( B"&(JK>(5#-( 2-B$,C/5&(,-&<( $&C/52-D(A&%F#$&( 5,0?#$&C( B,( #(A,$%C(A"&$&(

1/H&$'(#-C('&%%&$'(0&&B(C2$&5B%H(,-(#(%202B(,$C&$(1,,N*(

S-()#$B2-&V(#-C([,'/(I:;==L(#-C(K,/5#/%B<(J,01&$B<(#-C([,'/(I:;=:L<(B"&(F,5/'(2'(,-(

JK>'( B"#B( C&0#-C( %2G/2C2BH*( (>"&'&(JK>'( $&5&2@&( #( 'B$&#0(,F( '2D-#%'( #1,/B( 5"#-D&'( 2-( B"&(

@#%/&(,F(#-(#''&B*((a'(#($&'/%B<(JK>'(D&-&$#B&(#(%#$D&(F$#5B2,-(,F(B"&(B$#C2-D(@,%/0&(#-C(?$25&(

@,%#B2%2BH*((S-()#$B2-&V(#-C([,'/(I:;==L<(B"2'(@,%/0&(#-C(@,%#B2%2BH(2'(C&'2$#1%&<(#'(JK>(0#N&'(

0#$N&B(?$25&'(&UB$&0&%H(&FF252&-B(1H(2-5,$?,$#B2-D(2-F,$0#B2,-(#'(',,-(#'(2B(1&5,0&'(#@#2%#1%&*((

)#$N&B'(#$&(-,B(C&'B#12%2V&C<(#'(%,-D(#'(B"&$&(2'(#(?,?/%#B2,-(,F(0#$N&BE0#N&$'('B#-C2-D($&#CH(

B,( ?$,@2C&( %2G/2C2BH( #B( 5,0?&B2B2@&( ?$25&'*( ( S-(K,/5#/%B<(J,01&$B<( #-C([,'/( I:;=:L<( #-(JK>(

,1B#2-'( #-C( B$#C&'( ,-( 2-F,$0#B2,-( #-( 2-'B#-B( 1&F,$&( 2B( 2'( #@#2%#1%&( B,( ,B"&$'*( ( >"2'( 20?,'&'(

#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-(,-(0#$N&BE0#N&$'<(',(%2G/2C2BH(2'(A,$'&<(#-C(?$25&'(#$&(-,(0,$&(&FF252&-B*(

OB"&$($&%#B&C(B"&,$&B25#%(0,C&%'( 2-5%/C&(]#D-,BB#(#-C(]"2%2??,-(I:;==L<(A",(F,5/'(,-(

B"&( 2-@&'B0&-B( 2-( '?&&C(0#C&( 1H( &U5"#-D&'( 2-( ,$C&$( B,( #BB$#5B( B$#C2-D( @,%/0&( F$,0( '?&&CE

'&-'2B2@&( 2-@&'B,$'*( ( !#$B&#( #-C( ]&-#%@#( I:;==L( '20?%H( #''/0&( B"#B( JK>( 5,-'B2B/B&( #-(

/--&5&''#$H(&UB$#( %#H&$(,F( 2-B&$0&C2#B2,-(1&BA&&-(1/H&$'(#-C('&%%&$'*( (Y,B('/$?$2'2-D%H<(B"&H(

F2-C(B"#B(JK>($&C/5&'(A&%F#$&*((),#%%&02(#-C(4#D%#0(I:;=:L(#$D/&(B"#B(#($&C/5B2,-(2-(%#B&-5H(

#%%,A'(%202B(,$C&$('/102BB&$'(B,(/?C#B&(B"&2$(,$C&$'(0,$&(G/25N%H<(B"&$&1H($&C/52-D(B"&(@#%/&(,F(

B"&(B$#C2-D(,?B2,-(B"#B(#(%202B(,$C&$(D$#-B'(B,(#(%2G/2C2BH(C&0#-C&$*(

a'(-,B&C( &#$%2&$<( B"&(0,'B( 5,00,-( B"&0&( 2-( B"&'&(0,C&%'( 2'( B"#B(JK>(0#H( 2-5$&#'&(

#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-<(A"25"(2'(1#C(F,$(%2G/2C2BH*((>"&(#12%2BH(B,(2-B&$0&C2#B&(B$#C&$'(A",(#$$2@&(2-(

B"&(0#$N&B(#B(C2FF&$&-B(B20&'(2'(/'/#%%H(D,,C(F,$(%2G/2C2BH*((Z-F,$B/-#B&%H<(-,-&(,F(B"&'&(0,C&%'(

#CC$&''&'( B"&( F#5B( B"#B( JK>( 0#$N&BE0#N&$'( #$&( '20?%H( 0,$&( &FF252&-B( %2G/2C2BH( ?$,@2C&$'(

1&5#/'&(B"&H("#@&($&?%#5&C("/0#-'(A2B"(B&5"-,%,DH*((S-(',0&('&-'&<(B"2'(5,'B($&C/5B2,-(2'(B,,(

Page 24: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

"#

'20?%&( B,( #CC( B,( #( 0,C&%<( 1/B( 2B'( ,02''2,-( 2'( ?#$B25/%#$%H( /-F,$B/-#B&<( 1&5#/'&( B"&'&( 5,'B(

$&C/5B2,-'(#$&(%2N&%H(B,(1&(#-(20?,$B#-B(',/$5&(,F(JK>j'(%2G/2C2BH(1&-&F2B'*(

!

[email protected]$J!9%-&.)E!;)J$%)&!%'!FG:!

S-( B"&( ?#'B( F&A( H&#$'<( B"&$&( "#@&( 1&&-( #( -/01&$( ,F( 'B/C2&'( ,F( JK>( #-C( #%D,$2B"025(

B$#C2-D(0,$&(D&-&$#%%H*((4,0&($&'&#$5"&$'("#@&(1&&-(#1%&(B,(2C&-B2FH(#('?&52F25(JK>(2-(B"&(C#B#*((

OB"&$($&'&#$5"&$'(#$&(#1%&(B,( 2C&-B2FH(A"&B"&$(#(B$#C&(2'( F$,0(JK>(,$(a>*( (4B2%%(,B"&$'("#@&(

1&&-( #1%&( B,( C$#A( 2-F&$&-5&'( #1,/B( 5"#-D&'( 2-( JK>( ,$( a>( 1#'&C( ,-( 5"#-D&'( 2-( ,$C&$(

'/102''2,-( 1&"#@2,$( ,@&$( B20&*( (W2B"( C#B#( ,-( '?&52F25( ,$( #DD$&D#B&C(JK><( 2B( 2'( ?,''21%&( B,(

C&'5$21&(?#BB&$-'(2-(JK>(,$C&$('/102''2,-<(,$C&$(5#-5&%%#B2,-<(#-C(B$#C2-D(1&"#@2,$*((SB(2'(#%',(

?,''21%&( B,( '&&( A"&B"&$( JK>( #5B2@2BH( 2'( 5,$$&%#B&C( A2B"( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'<( B&0?,$#$H( #-Cn,$(

?&$0#-&-B(@,%#B2%2BH<(B$#C2-D(@,%/0&<(#-C(,B"&$(0#$N&B(#5B2@2BH(#-C(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(0&#'/$&'*((

3/B( 5,$$&%#B2,-( 2'( -,B( 5#/'#B2,-*( ( SB( 5,/%C( 1&( B"#B(JK>( 2'( '20?%H( $&'?,-C2-D( B,( 5"#-D&'( 2-(

0#$N&B(5,-C2B2,-'<(-,B(5#/'2-D(B"&0*( (W&(C,(-,B(D&B( B,(,1'&$@&(B"&(5,/-B&$F#5B/#%<(A"25"( 2-(

B"2'(5#'&(A,/%C(1&(#(B$#C2-D(A,$%C(A2B",/B(JK><(1/B(B"&(0,'B(2-'B$/5B2@&(?#?&$'(#B(B"2'(?,2-B(

#$&(B",'&(B"#B(C,(B"&(-&UB(1&'B(B"2-D9(('B/CH(B"&(&FF&5B'(,F(#('?&52F25(5"#-D&(2-(0#$N&B('B$/5B/$&(

B"#B(&2B"&$("&%?'(,$("2-C&$'(JK>*((>"&'&(?#?&$'(#%%(5,0&(B,(B"&('#0&(5,-5%/'2,-9((JK>(#-C(a>(

20?$,@&(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH*(

+

M;<;++H(8*,$+)K()+$)/'>+$8*2&6&2+4(,B*)+$),/2)/,*+2K(#5*$+

J&-C&$'",BB<( +,-&'<( #-C()&-N@&%C( I:;==L( 'B/CH( B"&( 20?%&0&-B#B2,-( ,F( #-( #/B,0#B&C(

G/,B&(#B(B"&(Y&A(b,$N(4B,5N(MU5"#-D&(2-(:;;7*((3&F,$&(k#/B,G/,B&<l('?&52#%2'B(5%&$N'(0#-/#%%H(

/?C#B&C(B"&(1&'B(12C(#-C(,FF&$(?$25&'(#B(B"&(Yb4M*((>"&(#/B,0#B&C(G/,B&(?$,@2C&C(0,$&(B20&%H(

2-'2D"B(2-B,(0#$N&B(5,-C2B2,-'(,-(B"&(F%,,$<(#-C(2B(&-#1%&C(#%D,$2B"0'(#-C(JK>(B,('/102B(#-C(

Page 25: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

"$

5#-5&%(,$C&$'(#-C(B,(G/25N%H('&&(B",'&(,$C&$'($&F%&5B&C(2-(B"&(Yb4Mj'(C2''&02-#B&C(G/,B&*((J+)(

0&#'/$&(B"&(#0,/-B(,F(#%D,$2B"025(B$#C2-D(#'(B"&(#0,/-B(,F(&%&5B$,-25(0&''#D&(B$#FF25(IA"25"(

5,-'2'B'( ,F( ,$C&$( '/102''2,-'<( ,$C&$( 5#-5&%%#B2,-'<( #-C( B$#C&( &U&5/B2,-'L( ?&$( /-2B( ,F( B$#C2-D*((

a/B,G/,B&( A#'( $,%%&C( ,/B( D$#C/#%%H( ,-( B"&( Yb4M<( 'B#$B2-D( A2B"( #( F&A( 'B,5N'( #-C( #CC2-D(

#CC2B2,-#%( 'B,5N'( 2-( '&@&$#%( '/1'&G/&-B(A#@&'*( ( >"2'( #%%,A'(J+)( B,( /'&( B"&( 2-B$,C/5B2,-( ,F(

#/B,G/,B&(#'(#-(2-'B$/0&-B#%(@#$2#1%&(F,$(B"&(#0,/-B(,F(#%D,$2B"025(B$#C2-D(2-(#(C2FF&$&-5&'E2-E

C2FF&$&-5&'( #??$,#5"( B"#B( 5,0?#$&'( B"&( 0#$N&B( G/#%2BH( ,F( kB$&#B&Cl( #/B,G/,B&C( 'B,5N'( B,(

k/-B$&#B&Cl('B,5N'('B2%%(/'2-D(0#-/#%(G/,B&(C2''&02-#B2,-*((J+)(F2-C(B"#B(B"&(20?%&0&-B#B2,-(

,F(#/B,G/,B&(2'(#'',52#B&C(A2B"(#-(2-5$&#'&(2-(&%&5B$,-25(0&''#D&(B$#FF25(#-C(#-(20?$,@&0&-B(2-(

0#$N&B( G/#%2BH*( ( aFB&$( B"&( 20?%&0&-B#B2,-<( &FF&5B2@&( '?$&#C'( -#$$,A<( #C@&$'&( '&%&5B2,-( 2'(

$&C/5&C<( #-C( 0,$&( ?$25&( C2'5,@&$H( B#N&'( ?%#5&( @2#( G/,B&'( @'*( B$#C&'*( ( >"&( &FF&5B'( #$&(

5,-5&-B$#B&C(2-(%#$D&E5#?(F2$0'i(B"&$&(2'(%2BB%&(&FF&5B(2-('0#%%E5#?('B,5N'<(B",/D"(B"&2$(#??$,#5"(

"#'( $&%#B2@&%H( %2BB%&( 'B#B2'B25#%( ?,A&$(1&5#/'&(0,'B( '0#%%E5#?( 'B,5N'( #C,?B&C( #/B,G/,B&( 2-( B"&(

%#'B(A#@&*(

O@&$#%%<( J+)( 5,-@2-52-D%H( '",A( B"#B<( #B( %&#'B( F,$( B"&( Yb4ME5&-B$25( Z*4*( 0#$N&B(

'B$/5B/$&(,F(:;;7(#-C(#B(%&#'B(F,$(%#$D&E5#?('B,5N'<(#-(2-5$&#'&(2-(#%D,$2B"025(B$#C2-D(5#/'&'(#-(

20?$,@&0&-B(2-('B,5N(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH*(

+,@#-,@25( #-C()&-N@&%C( I:;==L( #-C()&-N@&%C( I:;=:L( 'B/CH( B"&( +/%H( :;;h( &-B$H( ,F( #(

"2D"EF$&G/&-5H(0#$N&BE0#N&$( 2-B,( B"&( B$#C2-D( ,F(Q/B5"( 'B,5N'*( ( >"&(0#2-(0#$N&B( F,$( B"&'&(

'B,5N'(A#'(M/$,-&UBi(B"&(-&A(0#$N&BE0#N&$('&B(/?('",?(,-(B"&(5,0?&B2-D(!"2Eo(0#$N&B*((!"2E

o(2'(C2'B2-D/2'"&C(1H(F#'B(&U&5/B2,-(#-C(#(F&&('B$/5B/$&(B"#B(?#H'($&1#B&'(B,(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2C&$'<(

A"25"(0#N&'( 2B( #-( #??&#%2-D(@&-/&( F,$( #("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(0#$N&BE0#N&$*( (Q/&( B,(Q/B5"( B$#C&(

$&?,$B2-D( $&G/2$&0&-B'<( #%%( ,F( B"&( B$#C&'( ,F( B"2'( -&A(0#$N&BE0#N&$( 5#-( 1&( ,1'&$@&C<( ',( B"2'(

?#?&$( 2'( 20?,$B#-B( 2-( ?$,@2C2-D( 2-'2D"B'( ,-( ",A( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H(0#$N&BE0#N&$'( B$#C&*( ( >"&(

Page 26: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

"%

-&A( 0#$N&BE0#N&$( B$#C&'( ,-( 1,B"( !"2Eo( #-C( M/$,-&UB<( 1/B( 2'( F#2$%H( C,02-#-B( ,-( !"2Eo<(

?#$B252?#B2-D( 2-( 8g*ge( ,F( #%%( B$#C&'( B"&$&*( ( MU#5B%H( ^;*;e( ,F( B"&( -&A(0#$N&BE0#N&$j'( !"2Eo(

B$#C&'(#$&( B"&($&'/%B(,F(?#''2@&(,$C&$'*( (K,$( B"&(=:('B,5N'('B/C2&C(,@&$(#(h=EC#H( 2-B&$@#%<( B"&(

-&A(0#$N&BE0#N&$("#'( &U#5B%H(V&$,( 5"#-D&( 2-( 2-@&-B,$H(,-(8he(,F(C#H'<(A"&-(?,'2B2,-'(#$&(

#DD$&D#B&C(#5$,''(M/$,-&UB(#-C(!"2Eo*((S-(F#5B<(B"2'(0#$N&BE0#N&$j'(2-@&-B,$H(?,'2B2,-(0&#-(

$&@&$B'( $#?2C%H( C/$2-D( B"&( C#H<( BH?25#%%H( 5$,''2-D( V&$,( B&-'( ,F( B20&'( C/$2-D( #( B$#C2-D( C#H*((

)&-N@&%C(I:;=:L(#$D/&'(B"#B(5,0?&B2B2,-(1&BA&&-(B$#C2-D(@&-/&'(F#52%2B#B&C(B"&(#$$2@#%(,F(B"2'(

"2D"EF$&G/&-5H(0#$N&BE0#N&$( #-C(JK>(0,$&( D&-&$#%%H<( #-C( "&( '",A'( B"#B( ,-( #@&$#D&( B"2'(

0#$N&BE0#N&$(&#$-&C(p=*ff(?&$( B$#C&(,-( B"&( '?$&#C(1/B( %,'B(p;*T^(,-( 2B'( $&'/%B2-D( 2-@&-B,$H(

?,'2B2,-<(#(?#BB&$-(,F(?$,F2B(#-C(%,''(B"#B(2'(G/2B&(BH?25#%(,F(#(5%#''25#%(0#$N&BE0#N&$*(

+,@#-,@25( #-C( )&-N@&%C( #%',( &U#02-&( B"&( &FF&5B( ,F( &-B$H( ,-( %2G/2C2BH( #-C( 0#$N&B(

G/#%2BH*( (>"&(1#'25(&0?2$25#%(C&'2D-(2-(B"&(?#?&$(2'(C2FF&$&-5&'E2-EC2FF&$&-5&'*((32CE#'N('?$&#C'(

#-C( ,B"&$( 0#$N&B( G/#%2BH( 0&#'/$&'( ,-( B"&( kB$&#B&Cl( Q/B5"( 'B,5N'( #$&( 5,0?#$&C( B,( 0#$N&B(

G/#%2BH(0&#'/$&'(F,$(#('&B(,F(3&%D2#-(5,-B$,%('B,5N'*((>"&(3&%D2#-('B,5N'(A&$&(-,B(#@#2%#1%&(F,$(

B$#C2-D( ,-( !"2Eo( #B( B"&( B20&( #-C( B"/'( A&$&( /-#FF&5B&C( 1H( B"&( &-B$H( ,F( B"&( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H(

0#$N&BE0#N&$*( (!,0?#$&C( B,( B"&( k/-B$&#B&Cl(3&%D2#-( 'B,5N'<( &FF&5B2@&( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'( ,-( B"&(

Q/B5"('B,5N'(#$&(#1,/B(=fe(-#$$,A&$*((J2D"EF$&G/&-5H(0#$N&BE0#N&$(&-B$H(2'(#%',(#'',52#B&C(

A2B"( :7e( %&''( #C@&$'&( '&%&5B2,-<( ?&$"#?'( 1&5#/'&( B"2'(0#$N&BE0#N&$( /?C#B&'( 2B'( G/,B&'(0,$&(

G/25N%H(2-($&'?,-'&(B,(-&A(2-F,$0#B2,-(#$$2@2-D(2-(B"&(0#$N&B*((6,%#B2%2BH(2'(0&#'/$&C(/'2-D(:;E

02-/B&($&#%2V&C(@,%#B2%2BH<(#-C(2B(2'(/-#FF&5B&C(1H(B"&(&-B$H(,F(B"&("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(0#$N&BE0#N&$*(

O@&$#%%<( B"2'( 'B/CH( 2'( 20?,$B#-B( 1&5#/'&( 2B( D2@&'( /'( #( C2$&5B( @2&A( ,F( ",A( #( "2D"E

F$&G/&-5H( 0#$N&BE0#N&$( B$#C&'<( #-C( 2B( 5%&#$%H( '",A'( B"#B( B"&( #CC2B2,-( ,F( #( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H(

0#$N&BE0#N&$( 20?$,@&'( 0#$N&B( G/#%2BH( 2-( B"2'( 5,-B&UB*( ( >"2'( 2'( #( 5%#''25( 5#'&( A"&$&( 0,$&(

Page 27: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

"&

5,0?&B2B2,-(%&#C'(B,(%,A&$(?$25&'*((J&$&<(0,$&(5,0?&B2B2,-(2-(0#$N&BE0#N2-D(%&#C'(B,(-#$$,A&$(

12CE#'N('?$&#C'(#-C($&C/5&C(B$#C2-D(5,'B'(F,$(,B"&$(2-@&'B,$'*(

[2,$C#-(#-C(4B,$N&-0#2&$(I:;=:L(&U#02-&(B"&(&FF&5B(,F(#(B&5"-,%,D25#%(/?D$#C&(,-(B"&(

0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(,F(g^(#5B2@&%H(B$#C&C(`&$0#-('B,5N'*((S-(a?$2%(:;;h<(B"&(Q&/B'5"&(3,&$'&(0#C&(

#('&$2&'(,F('H'B&0(/?D$#C&'(A2B"(B"&(',%&(?/$?,'&(,F($&C/52-D(B"&(%#B&-5H(,F(2B'(&%&5B$,-25(%202B(

,$C&$( 1,,N*( ( a'( #( $&'/%B<( B"&( B20&( 1&BA&&-( ,$C&$( &-B$H( #-C( 5,-F2$0#B2,-( A#'( $&C/5&C( F$,0(

#1,/B(f;(02%%2'&5,-C'(B,(#1,/B(=;(02%%2'&5,-C'*((Y,B('/$?$2'2-D%H<(%,A&$(%#B&-5H(2-5$&#'&'(B"&(

$#B&(,F(,$C&$('/102''2,-('/1'B#-B2#%%H<(F$,0(#-(#@&$#D&(,F(:*^=(G/,B&(/?C#B&'(?&$(=;<;;;(&/$,'(

,F(B$#C2-D(@,%/0&(B,(#-(#@&$#D&(,F(8*fT(G/,B&(/?C#B&'(?,'BE/?D$#C&*((MFF&5B2@&('?$&#C'(-#$$,A<(

D,2-D(F$,0(#-(#@&$#D&(,F(h*h:(1#'2'(?,2-B'(?$&E/?D$#C&(B,(h*;8(1#'2'(?,2-B'(#FB&$A#$C*((a@&$#D&(

?$25&(20?#5B'(C$,?(5,-'2C&$#1%H(A2B"(B"&(/?D$#C&<(F$,0(T*^h(1#'2'(?,2-B'(B,(:*Tf(1#'2'(?,2-B'<(

#-C($&#%2V&C('?$&#C'( 2-5$&#'&( F$,0(#-(#@&$#D&(,F(;*gh(1#'2'(?,2-B'( B,(8*8f(1#'2'(?,2-B'*( (>"2'(

'/DD&'B'(B"#B(B"&(#12%2BH(B,(/?C#B&(G/,B&'(F#'B&$("&%?'(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2C&$'(02-202V&(B"&2$(%,''&'(

B,( %2G/2C2BH( C&0#-C&$'*( ( SB( #%',( #??&#$'( B"#B( 0,$&( ?$25&( C2'5,@&$H( 2'( B#N2-D( ?%#5&( @2#( G/,B&(

/?C#B&'( @'*( B$#C&'*( ( >"&'&( $&'/%B'( #$&( 5,-'2'B&-B( A2B"( $&'/%B'( 2-( J&-C&$'",BB<( +,-&'<( #-C(

)&-N@&%C(I:;==L*((3,B"('&B'(,F($&'/%B'(#$&(5,-'2'B&-B(A2B"(',0&(,F(B"&(A2--&$EB#N&E#%%(#'?&5B'(

,F(0#$N&BE0#N2-D<(1&5#/'&(B"&($&'/%B'('/DD&'B( B"#B( B"&( F#'B&'B("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(0#$N&B(0#N&$'(

#$&(#1%&(B,(&#$-(D$&#B&$(B$#C2-D($&@&-/&'(A"&-(B"&(0#$N&Bj'(%#B&-5H(2'($&C/5&C*(

3,&"0&$<(K,-D<(#-C(W/(I:;=:L(&U#02-&( 2-B&$-#B2,-#%(&@2C&-5&(,-(&%&5B$,-25(0&''#D&(

B$#FF25( #-C(0#$N&B( G/#%2BH( #5$,''( 7g( 'B,5N( &U5"#-D&'( ,@&$( B"&( :;;=E:;;g( ?&$2,C*( (>"&(0,'B(

2-B&$&'B2-D(&0?2$25#%(?#$B(,F(B"&(?#?&$(2-@&'B2D#B&'(B"&(&FF&5B(,-(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(,F(,FF&$2-D(5,E

%,5#B2,-( F#52%2B2&'( B,( #%D,$2B"025( #-C( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H( B$#C&$'*( ( >"&H( F2-C( B"#B( 5,E%,5#B2,-(

2-5$&#'&'( a>( #-C( JK><( #-C( B"&( 2-B$,C/5B2,-( ,F( 5,E%,5#B2,-( 20?$,@&'( %2G/2C2BH( #-C( B"&(

2-F,$0#B2,-#%(&FF252&-5H(,F(?$25&'*( (>"&H(5%#20(B"#B(5,E%,5#B2,-(2-5$&#'&'(@,%#B2%2BH<(1/B(#(0,$&(

Page 28: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

"'

#55/$#B&(5"#$#5B&$2V#B2,-(,F(B"&2$($&'/%B'(2'(B"#B(A"&-(5,E%,5#B2,-(2'(2-B$,C/5&C<(@,%#B2%2BH(C,&'(

-,B(C&5%2-&(#'(0/5"(#'(A,/%C(1&(&U?&5B&C(1#'&C(,-(B"&(,1'&$@&C(-#$$,A&$(12CE#'N('?$&#C'*(

K2-#%%H<(`#2<(b#,<(#-C(b&(I:;=:L('B/CH(B"&(&FF&5B(,F(BA,($&5&-B(:;=;(Y#'C#G(B&5"-,%,DH(

/?D$#C&'( B"#B( $&C/5&( B"&( 02-20/0( B20&( 1&BA&&-( 0&''#D&'( F$,0( gf;( -#-,'&5,-C'( B,( :;;(

-#-,'&5,-C'*( ( >"&'&( B&5"-,%,D25#%( 5"#-D&'( %&#C( B,( '/1'B#-B2#%( 2-5$&#'&'( 2-( B"&( -/01&$( ,F(

5#-5&%%&C(,$C&$'(A2B",/B(0/5"(5"#-D&(2-(,@&$#%%(B$#C2-D(@,%/0&*((>"&$&(2'(#%',(%2BB%&(5"#-D&(2-(

12CE#'N('?$&#C'(#-C(C&?B"'*((>"2'('/DD&'B'(B"#B(B"&$&(0#H(1&(C202-2'"2-D(%2G/2C2BH(1&-&F2B'(B,(

F#'B&$(&U5"#-D&'*(

>"&(,B"&$(0#$N&B( 'B$/5B/$&( 5"#-D&'( B"#B("#@&(1&&-( 5%,'&%H( 'B/C2&C( #%%( H2&%C( B"&( '#0&(

5,-5%/'2,-'*( (S-5$&#'&C(#/B,0#B2,-(#B(B"&(Yb4M(&-"#-5&C(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(2-(%#$D&('B,5N'<(B"&(

&-B$H(,F(#-(JK>(0#$N&BE0#N&$(,-(!"2Eo(-#$$,A&C('?$&#C'<(#'(C2C(#($&C/5B2,-( 2-( %#B&-5H(,-(

B"&(Q&/B'5"&(3,&$'&*((W"&-(5,E%,5#B2,-(2'(,FF&$&C(#B(C2FF&$&-B(B20&'(#5$,''(0#-H(C2FF&$&-B('B,5N(

0#$N&B'<(%2G/2C2BH(#-C(B"&(2-F,$0#B2,-#%(&FF252&-5H(,F(?$25&'(1,B"(20?$,@&*((>"&$&(2'(#%',(#(5%&#$(

0&5"#-2'0( F,$( B"&( %2G/2C2BH( 20?$,@&0&-B'*( ( aFB&$( B"&'&( 5"#-D&'<( B"&( &@2C&-5&( 2-C25#B&'( B"#B(

0,$&(?$25&(C2'5,@&$H(B#N&'(?%#5&(@2#(G/,B&'($#B"&$(B"#-(B$#C&'<('/DD&'B2-D(B"#B(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(

20?$,@&'(1&5#/'&(#/B,0#B&C(%2G/2C2BH('/??%2&$'(#$&(1&BB&$(#1%&(B,(#CP/'B(B"&2$(G/,B&'*(((

+

M;G;++9)/'&*$+)K()+2(#+'&$)&#5/&$K+D*)J**#+K/4(#$+(#'+4(2K&#*$++

>"&$&( #$&( #%',( #( -/01&$( ,F( ?#?&$'( B"#B( /'&( C#B#( A"&$&( 2B( 2'( ?,''21%&( B,( C2'B2-D/2'"(

1&BA&&-(C2FF&$&-B(BH?&'(,F(B$#C&$'*((K,$(&U#0?%&<(J&-C&$'",BB(#-C([2,$C#-(I:;=:L(/'&(&U5"#-D&(

5%#''2F25#B2,-'( C2'B2-D/2'"( a>( F$,0( ,$C&$'( 0#-#D&C( 1H( "/0#-'*=(( 3$,D##$C( I:;==#<( :;==1<(

:;=:L(#-C(J&-C&$'",BB(#-C([2,$C#-(I:;==L(A,$N(A2B"(Y#'C#G(C#B#(B"#B( F%#D'(A"&B"&$(B$#C&'(

2-@,%@&(JK>*((3#$,-<(3$,D##$C<(#-C(X2$2%&-N,(I:;=:L(/'&(#55,/-BE%&@&%(B$#C&E1HEB$#C&(C#B#(,-(

! 7819: 4812 ;<;:= >/?@2:2 /3 :A@14B 0<=C:42D .8<E/@FD GH<90<=22/3D I:J<D <3F .81A@/13: K"**)L ?8<=<?4:=1M: NO13 48: >/=:1J3 :P?8<3J: 0<=C:4+ O8:1= =:2@942 <=: 21019<=+

Page 29: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

"(

B"&(&E02-2(4d](f;;(F/B/$&'(5,-B$#5B<(#-C(B"&H(5%#''2FH(B$#C&$'(2-B,(@#$2,/'(5#B&D,$2&'<(2-5%/C2-D(

?#''2@&(JK>(#-C(#DD$&''2@&(JK>*((3&-,'(#-C(4#D#C&(I:;=:L(5,-C/5B(#('202%#$(#-#%H'2'(/'2-D(

ZX(&G/2BH(C#B#*( (>"&'&(C2FF&$&-B(C#B#'&B'(H2&%C(5,-'2C&$#1%&(2-'2D"B(2-B,(,@&$#%%(JK>(B$#C2-D(

1&"#@2,$*( (J,A&@&$<(B"&'&(?#?&$'(#$&(%&''(A&%%E'/2B&C(B,( 2C&-B2FH(B"&(5#/'#%(&FF&5B'(,F(JK>(,-(

0#$N&B(G/#%2BH*(

Q/$2-D(:;;^<(B"&(Q&/B'5"&(3,&$'&(,FF&$&C(F&&($&1#B&'(B,(#%D,$2B"025(B$#C&$'*((S-(,$C&$(

B,( #C02-2'B&$( B"&'&( F&&( $&1#B&'<( B"&( &U5"#-D&( 2-B&$-#%%H( 2C&-B2F2&C( B"&( #/B,0#B&C( B$#C&$'*((

J&-C&$'",BB(#-C([2,$C#-(I:;=:L("#@&(C#B#(F$,0(B"&(Q&/B'5"&(3,&$'&(C2'B2-D/2'"2-D(a>(F$,0(

"/0#-(,$C&$( '/102BB&$'*( (>"&H( F2-C( B"#B(a>(5,-5&-B$#B&'( 2-( '0#%%&$( B$#C&( '2V&'<(A"2%&( %#$D&(

1%,5N( B$#C&'( ,F( f<;;;( '"#$&'( ,$( 0,$&( #$&( ?$&C,02-#-B%H( ,$2D2-#B&C( 1H( "/0#-'*( ( a>( 0,$&(

#5B2@&%H(0,-2B,$(0#$N&B( %2G/2C2BH( B"#-( "/0#-( B$#C&$'*( ( a>( 5,-'/0&( %2G/2C2BH( A"&-( 12CE#'N(

'?$&#C'( #$&( $&%#B2@&%H( -#$$,A<( #-C( B"&H( '/??%H( %2G/2C2BH( A"&-( 12CE#'N( '?$&#C'( #$&( $&%#B2@&%H(

A2C&*( ( >"2'( '/DD&'B'( B"#B( #%D,$2B"025( B$#C&$'( 0#H( $&C/5&( B"&( @#$2#12%2BH( 2-( 0#$N&B( G/#%2BH<(

?$,@2C2-D(#(0,$&(5,-'2'B&-B(%&@&%(,F(%2G/2C2BH(B"$,/D"(B20&*(

J&-C&$'",BB( #-C( [2,$C#-( I:;==L( #-C( 3$,D##$C( I:;==#<( :;==1<( :;=:L( /'&( :;;^E:;;g(

02%%2'&5,-CE'B#0?&C( C#B#( ,-( #%%( Y#'C#G( B$#C&'( 2-( =:;( 'B,5N'( B"#B( F%#D'(A"&B"&$( &#5"( ,F( B"&(

?#$B2&'(B,(B"&(B$#C&(2'(#-(JK>*((3$,D##$C(#%',("#'('202%#$(C#B#(F,$(B$#C&'(,-(3a>4*((>"&(F2$0(

1&"2-C( &#5"( B$#C&( 2'( 5#B&D,$2V&C( #'( JK>( 2F( 2B( &-D#D&'( ,-%H( 2-( ?$,?$2&B#$H( B$#C2-D<( 2B'( -&B(

?,'2B2,-(,FB&-(5$,''&'(V&$,(C/$2-D(B"&(C#H<(#-C( 2B'(-,-E0#$N&B#1%&(,$C&$'(#$&(BH?25#%%H('",$BE

%2@&C*((>"2'(&U5%/C&'(0,'B(%#$D&(1$,N&$EC&#%&$'('/5"(#'(`,%C0#-(4#5"'(#-C()&$$2%%(\H-5"<(A",(

0#H(/-C&$B#N&(',0&("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(?$,?$2&B#$H(B$#C2-D(1/B(#%',(#5B(#'(1$,N&$'(F,$(5/'B,0&$'*((

S-( #CC2B2,-<( ',0&(JK>( 2'( $,/B&C( B"$,/D"( B"&'&( %#$D&$( 1$,N&$EC&#%&$'<( #-C( #'( #( $&'/%B( B"&'&(

B$#C&'( A,/%C( -,B( 1&( 5%#''2F2&C( #'( JK>( 2-( B"&( C#B#'&B*( ( Z%B20#B&%H<( B"&( JK>( C&'2D-#B2,-( 2'(

Page 30: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

")

#??%2&C( B,( B$#C&'( 0#C&( 1H( :T( C2FF&$&-B( 2-C&?&-C&-B( ?$,?$2&B#$H( B$#C2-D( F2$0'<( #-C( B"/'( B"&(

B$#C&'(F%#DD&C(#'(JK>(2-(B"&(Y#'C#G(C#B#'&B('",/%C(1&(5,-'2C&$&C(#('/1'&B(,F(#%%(JK>*(

J&-C&$'",BB( #-C( [2,$C#-( I:;==L( F2-C( B"#B( JK>( #55,/-B'( F,$( #1,/B( 8:e( ,F( IC,/1%&E

5,/-B&CL(Y#'C#G(@,%/0&(2-(%#$D&E5#?('B,5N'(1/B(,-%H(#1,/B(=he(,F(@,%/0&(2-('0#%%E5#?('B,5N'*((

3$,D##$C( I:;==#L( '202%#$%H( F2-C'( B"#B(T^e(,F( B$#C&'("#@&(#-(JK>(,-(#B( %&#'B(,-&('2C&(,F( B"&(

B$#-'#5B2,-<(#-C("&(#%',(F2-C'(B"#B(JK>(?#$B252?#B2,-($#B&'(#$&("2D"&$(F,$('B,5N'(A2B"("2D"('"#$&(

?$25&'<( %#$D&(0#$N&B(5#?'<(-#$$,A(12CE#'N('?$&#C'<(,$(%,A('B,5NE'?&52F25(@,%#B2%2BH*( ([&5#%%(B"#B(

B"&'&(#$&(%,A&$(1,/-C'(,-(B"&(?$&@#%&-5&(,F(JK><(1&5#/'&(Y#'C#G(2'(,-%H(#1%&(B,(F%#D(#('/1'&B(

,F(,@&$#%%(JK>(#5B2@2BH*((3$,D##$C(#%',(F2-C'(B"#B(B"&$&(2'(#(12B(%&''(JK>(#B(B"&(@&$H(1&D2--2-D(

#-C(&-C(,F(B"&(B$#C2-D(C#H*((S-(%#$D&('B,5N'<(JK>(C&0#-C(#-C('/??%H(%2G/2C2BH(,-(Y#'C#G(#1,/B(

&G/#%%H*((S-('0#%%E5#?('B,5N'<(JK>(B&-C'(B,(C&0#-C(%2G/2C2BH(0,$&(,FB&-*((S-(B"&'&('B,5N'<(JK>(

#55,/-B'( F,$( :7e(,F( %2G/2C2BH( C&0#-C(1/B( ,-%H( =;e(,F( %2G/2C2BH( '/??%H*( (3$,D##$C( F2-C'( B"#B(

JK>(%2G/2C2BH('/??%2&$'(#$&(0,$&(%2N&%H(B,(1&(#B(B"&(2-'2C&(2-(%#$D&E5#?('B,5N'*(

J&-C&$'",BB( #-C( [2,$C#-( I:;==L( &'B20#B&( #( 'B#B&E'?#5&(0,C&%( B"#B( C&5,0?,'&'( ?$25&(

5"#-D&'( 2-B,( ?&$0#-&-B( #-C( B&0?,$#$H( 5,0?,-&-B'<( #-C(0&#'/$&'( B"&( 5,-B$21/B2,-( ,F(JK>(

#-C(-,-EJK>(%2G/2C2BH('/??%H(#-C(%2G/2C2BH(C&0#-C(B,(&#5"(,F(B"&'&(?$25&(5"#-D&(5,0?,-&-B'*((

K,$(B"&(?&$0#-&-B(5,0?,-&-B(,F(?$25&'<(A&(&U?&5B(-&B(1/H2-D(1H(JK>(%2G/2C2BH(C&0#-C&$'(B,(

1&( ?,'2B2@&%H( 5,$$&%#B&C( A2B"( F/B/$&( ?$25&( 5"#-D&'<( $&F%&5B2-D( B"&2$( 2-F,$0#B2,-( 5,-B&-B*((

4202%#$%H<(A&(A,/%C(&U?&5B(-&B(1/H2-D(1H(JK>(%2G/2C2BH('/??%2&$'(B,(1&(-&D#B2@&%H(5,$$&%#B&C(

A2B"( F/B/$&( ?$25&( 5"#-D&'<( $&F%&5B2-D( #C@&$'&( '&%&5B2,-( F$,0( 1&BB&$E2-F,$0&C( %2G/2C2BH(

C&0#-C&$'*((>"2'(2'(1,$-&(,/B(1H(B"&(C#B#*((),$&(2-B&$&'B2-D(2'(B"&($&%#B2,-'"2?(1&BA&&-(JK>(

#-C(B"&(B&0?,$#$H(5,0?,-&-B(,F(?$25&'*((SB(B/$-'(,/B(B"#B(A"&-(JK>(2-2B2#B&(B$#C&'<(B"&H(B$#C&(

2-( B"&(,??,'2B&(C2$&5B2,-(B,( B"&( B$#-'2B,$H(5,0?,-&-B(,F(?$25&'*( (>"#B( 2'<(A"&-(?$25&'(C&@2#B&(

F$,0(F/-C#0&-B#%(@#%/&'<(JK>(2-2B2#B&(B$#C&'(B,(?/'"(?$25&'(1#5N(B,(B"&2$(&FF252&-B(%&@&%'*(>"&'&(

Page 31: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#*

?$25&'( $&B/$-( B,( &FF252&-B( %&@&%'( A2B"2-( #1,/B( 7;( '&5,-C'*( ( >"/'<( JK>( 5,-B$21/B&'( B,( ?$25&(

C2'5,@&$H(#-C(5,-B$21/B&'(B,(&FF252&-B('B,5N(?$25&'*((>"&($&'/%B'(#$&(@&$H('202%#$(A"&-(C#H'(#$&(

'&?#$#B&C(2-B,("2D"&$(@,%#B2%2BH(#-C(%,A&$(@,%#B2%2BH(C#H'*(

3$,D##$C(I:;==1L(&'B20#B&'(#(@&5B,$(#/B,$&D$&''2@&(?&$0#-&-B(?$25&(20?#5B(0,C&%(#-C(

F2-C'(B"#B(JK>(%2G/2C2BH('/??%2&$'(F#5&(%&''(#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-(B"#-(-,-EJK>(%2G/2C2BH('/??%2&$'<(

'/DD&'B2-D( B"#B( B"&H( #$&( ',0&A"#B( P/C252,/'( 2-( '/??%H2-D( %2G/2C2BH*( ( 3$,D##$C( I:;==1L( #%',(

F2-C'( B"#B( ?$25&'( C,( -,B( &U"212B( #-H( '",$BE$/-( ,@&$$&#5B2,-( F,%%,A2-D( #-( JK>( B$#C&( B"#B(

C&0#-C'( %2G/2C2BH*( (>"2'( 2'( 5,-'2'B&-B(A2B"( B"&(J&-C&$'",BB( #-C([2,$C#-( $&'/%B'( #-C( 20?%2&'(

B"#B(JK>(0#N&'(?$25&'(0,$&(&FF252&-B*(

K/$B"&$0,$&<(B"&$&(2'(-,(&@2C&-5&(2-(&2B"&$(3$,D##$C(I:;==1L(,$(2-(3$,D##$C(I:;=:L(B"#B(

JK>(2-5$&#'&'(0#$N&B(@,%#B2%2BH*((3$,D##$C(I:;=:L(&U#02-&'(B"&(:;;^(B&0?,$#$H(1#-(,-('",$B(

'#%&'( 2-( F2-#-52#%( 'B,5N'( B"#B( A#'( 2-( ?%#5&( F,$( #1,/B( B"$&&(A&&N'( 2-( 4&?B&01&$( #-C(O5B,1&$*((

W"2%&( $&D2'B&$&C(0#$N&B(0#N&$'(A&$&( &U&0?B( F$,0( B"&(1#-( I'&&(3,&"0&$<( +,-&'<( #-C(q"#-D(

I:;=:L( F,$( 0,$&( C&B#2%'L<( 0,'B( JK>( #B( B"&( B20&( A#'( 5,-C/5B&C( 1H( &-B2B2&'( B"#B( A&$&( -,B(

$&D2'B&$&C( #'( 0#$N&BE0#N&$'<( #-C( B"/'( B"&( '",$B2-D( 1#-( '"#$?%H( %202B&C( JK>( B$#C2-D(

,??,$B/-2B2&'*( (3$,D##$C(/'&'(#( B$2?%&EC2FF&$&-5&(#??$,#5"(#-C( F2-C'(B"#B( F2-#-52#%('B,5N'(A2B"(

B"&(12DD&'B(C&5%2-&(2-(JK>(#'(#($&'/%B(,F(B"&(1#-(&U?&$2&-5&C(B"&(12DD&'B(2-5$&#'&'(2-(@,%#B2%2BH<(

'/DD&'B2-D(B"#B(JK>(2'(20?,$B#-B(2-(%202B2-D(&U5&''(@,%#B2%2BH*(

K2-#%%H<( 2B( 2'( ?,''21%&( B,(/'&( B"&'&(C#B#( B,(0&#'/$&( ,@&$#%%( ?$,F2B#12%2BH( ,F( B"&'&(JK>*((

J&-C&$'",BB(#-C([2,$C#-(I:;==L(F2-C(B"#B(B$#C2-D($&@&-/&(?&$(C#H(F,$(B"&'&(JK>(F2$0'(I-&B(,F(

#%%($&1#B&'(#-C(B#N&( F&&'L(#@&$#D&'(m:<7f=(?&$('B,5N<(mT<T87(?&$( %#$D&E5#?('B,5N*( (Q2@2C2-D(1H(

B"&(#0,/-B(,F(,1'&$@&C(JK>(#5B2@2BH<(B"2'(#0,/-B'(B,(#1,/B(8(5&-B'(?&$(m=<;;;(B$#C&C(1H(#-(

JK><(,$(;*8(1#'2'(?,2-B'*((3$,D##$C(I:;==#L(&UB$#?,%#B&'(F$,0("2'(C#B#(B,(&'B20#B&(B,B#%(JK>(

$&@&-/&( ,F( #1,/B( m7( 12%%2,-( ?&$( H&#$<( A"25"( ',/-C'( %#$D&<( 1/B( "&( B"&-( ?,2-B'( ,/B( B"#B(JK>(

Page 32: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#!

B$#C2-D($&@&-/&'(#$&(#-(,$C&$(,F(0#D-2B/C&('0#%%&$(B"#-(B"&(B$#C2-D($&@&-/&'(&#$-&C(1H(Yb4M(

'?&52#%2'B'(2-(:;;;<(1&F,$&(B"&(#C@&-B(,F(0,'B(JK>*((3#$,-<(3$,D##$C(#-C(X2$2%&-N,(I:;=:L(F2-C(

B"#B(JK>( 2-( B"&(&E02-2(4d](f;;( F/B/$&'( 5,-B$#5B( &#$-(#@&$#D&( B$#C2-D($&@&-/&(,F(m=*==(?&$(

5,-B$#5B<(A"25"(2'(#1,/B(;*;;:e(,F(B"&(@#%/&(,F(B"&('B,5N'(/-C&$%H2-D(&#5"(5,-B$#5B(#-C(2'(F#$(

'0#%%&$(B"#-(B"&(02-20/0(?$25&(2-5$&0&-B(,$(02-20/0(B25N(,F(m=:*f;(?&$(5,-B$#5B*(

O@&$#%%<(J&-C&$'",BB(#-C([2,$C#-(I:;==L(F2-C(B"#B(JK>("#'(#(1&-&F252#%($,%&(2-(B"&(?$25&(

C2'5,@&$H(?$,5&''*( (J,A&@&$<( B"&( 2-F,$0#B2,-(?,''&''&C(1H(JK>( 2'( '",$BE%2@&C<( BH?25#%%H( %&''(

B"#-(7;('&5,-C'*(a'(J&-C&$'",BB(#-C([2,$C#-(A$2B&<(k2F(B"2'(2-F,$0#B2,-(A,/%C(1&5,0&(?/1%25(

A2B",/B(JK><(B"&-(B"&(?,B&-B2#%(A&%F#$&(D#2-'(0#H(1&('0#%%*l( (4B2%%<(B"&$&(2'(-,(&@2C&-5&(B"#B(

JK>(5,-B$21/B&(B,(0#$N&B(2-'B#12%2BH(2-(?$25&'*((S-(F#5B<(JK>($&C/5&(B$#-'2B,$H(?$252-D(&$$,$'<(

B"&$&1H('B#12%2V2-D(?$25&'<(#-C(B"&H(C,(B"2'(,-(%,AE@,%#B2%2BH(#-C("2D"E@,%#B2%2BH(C#H'(C/$2-D(#(

$&%#B2@&%H(B/$1/%&-B(?&$2,C*(

+

M;!;++1)K*,+,*%()*'+J",B+

OB"&$(?#?&$'(5#--,B(,1'&$@&(A"25"(B$#C&'(#-C(,$C&$'(#$&(C/&(B,(a>(,$(JK>(#-C(0/'B(

B$H(B,(2C&-B2FH(B"&'&(B$#C&'(,$(,$C&$'(2-C2$&5B%H*((Y,B#1%&(#0,-D(B"&'&(?#?&$'(2'(J#'1$,/5N(#-C(

4##$(I:;==L<(A",(&U#02-&(Y#'C#G(,$C&$E%&@&%(C#B#(I#%',(N-,A-(#'(S>!J(C#B#L(F$,0(:;;h(#-C(

:;;^(#-C(5"#$#5B&$2V&(',0&(,F(B"&(,$C&$('/102''2,-(#-C(5#-5&%%#B2,-(?#BB&$-'(2-(B"&(C#B#*((>"&H(

F2-C( &@2C&-5&( B"#B( ',0&( 0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'( I?$&'/0#1%H( JK>L( #$&( #1%&( B,( $&'?,-C( B,( #-(

2-5,02-D( ,$C&$( 2-( #1,/B( :(02%%2'&5,-C'*( (>"&H( #%',( &U#02-&( '&G/&-5&'( ,F( 5#-5&%E#-CE$&?%#5&(

1&"#@2,$9((B"&(5#-5&%%#B2,-(,F(#($&'B2-D(%202B(,$C&$(F,%%,A&C(#%0,'B(200&C2#B&%H(1H('/102''2,-(

,F(#(-&A(,$C&$(F,$(B"&('#0&(-/01&$(,F('"#$&'(1/B(#B(#(-&A(?$25&*( (>"&H(5,-P&5B/$&(B"#B(B"&'&(

'&G/&-5&'(,$2D2-#B&(F$,0("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(B$#C&$'(#-C(,B"&$(#%D,$2B"025(B$#C&$'<(#-C(2-(F#5B(B"&H(

5,2-(B"&(?"$#'&(k%,AE%#B&-5H(B$#C2-Dl(B,(C&'5$21&(B$#C2-D(1&"#@2,$(B"#B(2'(5"#$#5B&$2V&C(1H($#?2C(

Page 33: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#"

$&'?,-'&'( I,-( B"&( ,$C&$( ,F( 02%%2'&5,-C'L( B,( 2-5,02-D( ,$C&$( F%,A( #-C( ,B"&$( #@#2%#1%&(

2-F,$0#B2,-*(

J#'1$,/5N( #-C( 4##$( B"&-( D,( ,-( B,( 2-@&'B2D#B&( B"&( $&%#B2,-'"2?( 1&BA&&-( %,AE%#B&-5H(

B$#C2-D(#-C(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH*((>"&H(/'&(#-(2-'B$/0&-B#%(@#$2#1%&(#??$,#5"(B,(C&B&$02-&(A"&B"&$(

0,$&(%,AE%#B&-5H(B$#C2-D(5#/'&'(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(B,(20?$,@&*((>"&(2-'B$/0&-B(2'(B"&(-/01&$(,F(

5#-5&%E#-CE$&?%#5&( '&G/&-5&'( 2-( ,B"&$( 'B,5N'( #B( #( D2@&-( B20&<( 2-C25#B2-D( 0,$&( ,@&$#%%( %,AE

%#B&-5H( #5B2@2BH*( (>"&H( F2-C( B"#B(A"&-( B"&$&( #$&(0,$&( ,F( B"&'&( 5#-5&%E#-CE$&?%#5&( '&G/&-5&'<(

0#$N&B( G/#%2BH( 2'( 1&BB&$*( (>"&( 2-'B$/0&-B(0#H(-,B( 1&( &U,D&-,/'<( #-C( B"&$&( 2'( ',0&( 5,-5&$-(

#1,/B(#($&@&$'&(5#/'#%2BH('B,$H<(1/B(B"&$&(2'(-,B"2-D(2-(B"&(&0?2$25#%(C#B#(B,('/DD&'B(B"#B(%,AE

%#B&-5H(#5B2@2BH(A,$'&-'(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH*(

q"#-D( I:;=;L( &''&-B2#%%H( C&F2-&'( JK>( #'( #%%( B$#C2-D( #5B2@2BH( B"#B( 2'( -,B( 5#?B/$&C( 2-(

G/#$B&$%H( 2-'B2B/B2,-#%(",%C2-D'(C#B#(,1B#2-&C(F$,0(4&5B2,-(=7IFL(4M!(F2%2-D'*( (>"2'( 2'(#(0/5"(

1$,#C&$( C&F2-2B2,-( ,F(JK>( B"#-( /'&C( 2-( ,B"&$( 'B/C2&'<( #'( "2'(0&#'/$&( 2'( C&'2D-&C( B,( 5#?B/$&(

B$#C&'(A2B"(",%C2-D(?&$2,C'('",$B&$(B"#-(#(5#%&-C#$(G/#$B&$*((M@&-(B"2'(5#--,B(1&(#55,0?%2'"&C(

?&$F&5B%H<(1&5#/'&('0#%%( 2-'B2B/B2,-'(#$&(-,B( $&G/2$&C( B,( F2%&(#(=7IFL<( B"&( $&?,$B'(C,(-,B( $&F%&5B(

'",$B( ?,'2B2,-'<( #-C( ',( ,-*( (J&( 2-@&'B2D#B&'( @,%#B2%2BH( #-C( ?$25&( ,@&$$&#5B2,-'( /'2-D( #( B$2?%&E

C2FF&$&-5&( #??$,#5"*( (>"2'(0&B",C,%,DH(&''&-B2#%%H(0&#'/$&'(@,%#B2%2BH(C/$2-D( B"&(=ggfE:;;g(

?&$2,C(I"2'(JK>(2-B&$@#%L(5,0?#$&C(B,(@,%#B2%2BH(C/$2-D(B"&(-,-EJK>(?&$2,C(,F(=g^fE=gg8<(#-C(

#FB&$(5,-B$,%%2-D(F,$(0#-H(,B"&$('B,5N(#-C(F2$0(5"#$#5B&$2'B25'<("&(F2-C'(B"#B('B,5N'(A2B"(0,$&(

JK>(1H("2'(0&#'/$&(&U?&$2&-5&(#(%#$D&$(2-5$&#'&(2-(@,%#B2%2BH(,@&$(B"2'(B20&F$#0&*((4B,5N'(A2B"(

0,$&(JK>(#%',(#??&#$(B,(,@&$$&#5B(B,(G/#$B&$%H(&#$-2-D'(-&A'*((Z-F,$B/-#B&%H<(B"&(0&#'/$&(,F(

JK>(2'(',(?,,$<(#-C(B"&$&(#$&(',(0#-H(5,-F,/-C2-D(5"#-D&'(2-(0#$N&B(5,-C2B2,-'(,@&$(B"&(B20&(

?&$2,C(,F(B"&('B/CH<(B"#B(2B(2'(@2$B/#%%H(20?,''21%&(B,(C$#A(#-H(5,-5%/'2,-'(#1,/B(JK>(F$,0(B"2'(

'B/CH*(

Page 34: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

##

MDD2-B,-<(6#-(Y&''<( #-C(6#-(Y&''( I:;=:L( &U#02-&( '",$B( &?2',C&'( ,F( 2-B&-'&(G/,B2-D(

#5B2@2BH( 2-(:;=;*( (>"&H( 2C&-B2FH(=E( B,(=;E02-/B&(?&$2,C'(A2B"( 2-B&-'&(G/,B2-D(#5B2@2BH( B"#B( 2'(

0,$&(B"#-(:;('B#-C#$C(C&@2#B2,-'(#1,@&(-,$0#%(F,$(#(?#$B25/%#$('B,5N*((>"&'&(&?2',C&'(#$&(F#2$%H(

5,00,-i(B"&H(,55/$('&@&$#%("/-C$&C(B20&'(?&$(C#H(2-(#(A2C&(@#$2&BH(,F('B,5N'*((>"&H(F2-C(B"#B(

B"&'&(?&$2,C'(#$&(#'',52#B&C(A2B"(A2C&$(12CE#'N('?$&#C'(#-C(D$&#B&$(?$25&(@,%#B2%2BH*((J,A&@&$<(

B"&H(#$&(/-#1%&(B,(C&B&$02-&(A"&B"&$(#%D,$2B"0'(#-C(JK>(#$&(5#/'2-D(%2G/2C2BH(B,(A,$'&-<(,$(

A"&B"&$( B"&( 2%%2G/2C2BH( '20?%H( $&F%&5B'( B"&( ?$&'&-5&( ,F( ?$2@#B&( 2-F,$0#B2,-( C/$2-D( B"&'&(

&?2',C&'<(A2B"("&2D"B&-&C(G/,B2-D(#5B2@2BH(#(-#B/$#%($&'?,-'&(B,(B"&(2-F,$0#B2,-(&-@2$,-0&-B*(

O@&$#%%<( B"&(&@2C&-5&('B$,-D%H( 2-C25#B&'(B"#B(JK>(2'(D,,C(F,$(#@&$#D&(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH<(

A2B"(0,$&(C2'5&$-21%&(?,'2B2@&(&FF&5B'(2-(%#$D&E5#?('B,5N'*((>"&(-&UB('&5B2,-(&U#02-&'(A"&B"&$(

JK>(5,-B$21/B&'(B,(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(C/$2-D(/-/'/#%%H(@,%#B2%&(B20&'*(()#$N&B(G/#%2BH(2-('B$&''&C(

5,-C2B2,-'(0#H(1&(,F(?#$B25/%#$(5,-5&$-(B,(2-@&'B,$'(#-C($&D/%#B,$'<(1&5#/'&(2-(B",'&(5,-C2B2,-'(

',0&(0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'( 0#H( "#@&( #5/B&( B$#C2-D( -&&C'<( #-C( 2%%2G/2C2BH( 0#H( 1&( ?#$B25/%#$%H(

/-C&'2$#1%&*( ( >"/'<( 2B( 0#H( 1&( 20?,$B#-B( B,( 5,-'2C&$( ?,B&-B2#%( %2-N'( 1&BA&&-( JK>( #-C( B"&(

$,1/'B-&''(,F(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH*(

!

NB!!FG:O!%#)!1J$E#!42$E#O!$+&!%$.J!,)#$?.'2!

O-( )#H( T<( :;=;<( Z*4*( 'B,5N( 0#$N&B'( A&$&( 2-C&&C( 'B$&''&C*( ( Z-F,$B/-#B&%H<( 0#$N&B(

G/#%2BH( A#'( F#$( F$,0( $,1/'B( B"#B( C#H*( ( \2G/2C2BH( B&0?,$#$2%H( C2'#??&#$&C( #-C( '"#$&( ?$25&'(

F%/5B/#B&C(A2%C%H(#'(Z*4*('B,5N'(&U?&$2&-5&C(A"#B("#'(1&5,0&(N-,A-(#'(B"&(kF%#'"(5$#'"*l( (a'(

B"&(B$#C2-D(C#H(/-F,%C&C<('B,5N'(D$#C/#%%H(F&%%(,-(M/$,EV,-&(0#5$,&5,-,025(5,-5&$-'<(#-C(1H(

:97;(])(M><(B"&(Q,A(+,-&'(S-C/'B$2#%(a@&$#D&(A#'(C,A-(:*fe*((4/CC&-%H<('B,5N'(1&D#-(B,(F#%%(

0/5"(0,$&( $#?2C%H*( (Q/$2-D( B"&( =7(02-/B&( ?&$2,C( F$,0( :97:( ])( B,( :98f9:h( ])<( B"&( F$,-BE

0,-B"(+/-&(:;=;(ME02-2(4d](f;;(F/B/$&'(5,-B$#5B(F&%%(f*=e*((S-(B"&(-&UB($*2"#'<(#(F%/$$H(,F('&%%(

Page 35: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#$

,$C&$'( 5#/'&C( B"&( F/B/$&'(?$25&( B,(C$,?( #-( #CC2B2,-#%(=*7e*( (aB( B"2'(?,2-B<( 1/H(,$C&$'(,-( B"&(

!)Mj'( &%&5B$,-25( %202B( ,$C&$( 1,,N(A&$&( ',( '?#$'&( B"#B( B"&(-&UB(0#$N&B#1%&( '&%%( ,$C&$(A,/%C(

"#@&( 5#/'&C( B"&( F/B/$&'( 5,-B$#5B( B,( C$,?( 1H( #-( #CC2B2,-#%( T*f( 2-C&U( ?,2-B'<( F$,0( =;fT*;;( B,(

=;8g*f;*( ( >"2'( %#$D&( ?,B&-B2#%( ?$25&(0,@&( 5#/'&C( B"&( !)M( B$#C2-D( ',FBA#$&( B,( 20?,'&( #( fE

'&5,-C(B$#C2-D("#%B*((W2B"2-('&5,-C'(,F($&'/02-D(B$#C2-D<(B"&(ME02-2(#'5&-C&C($#?2C%H<($2'2-D(

T*8e(1H( 79;T(])(M>( #-C( @2$B/#%%H( &$#'2-D( B"&( #FB&$-,,-j'( '"#$?( C$,?*( ( K2D/$&( f( '",A'( B"&(

1&"#@2,$(,F('B,5N(2-C&U(F/B/$&'(,-(B"#B(C#H*(

(

K2D/$&(f*((ME02-2(4d](f;;(F/B/$&'(?$25&'(C/$2-D(B"&(F%#'"(5$#'"(,F()#H(T<(:;=;*(

(

4,0&(2-C2@2C/#%('B,5N'(&U?&$2&-5&C(&@&-(12DD&$(DH$#B2,-'*((]$,5B&$(#-C(`#01%&(F&%%(1H(

0,$&( B"#-( ,-&EB"2$C<( #-C( 5,-'/%B2-D( F2$0(a55&-B/$&(0,0&-B#$2%H( B$#C&C( #B( #( '"#$&( ?$25&( ,F(

m;*;=*((4,0&('B,5N'(&@&-(B$#C&C(#B(#'B$,-,025#%%H("2D"(?$25&'(C/$2-D(B"&($&1,/-C(?&$2,C*((K,$(

Page 36: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#%

&U#0?%&<(a??%&(!,0?/B&$(B$#C&C(#B(#('"#$&(?$25&(,F(m=;;<;;;(#B(79:g97;(])*((a(B,B#%(,F(:;<hT=(

B$#C&'(#B(B"&(0,'B(&UB$&0&(?$25&'(A&$&(%#B&$(5#-5&%%&C<(1/B(B$#C&'(B"#B(A&$&(%&''(B"#-(T;e(#A#H(

F$,0( #( 'B,5Nj'( :98;?0( '"#$&( ?$25&( A&$&( #%%,A&C( B,( 'B#-C*( ( >$#-'#5B2,-'( ,55/$$&C( #B( B"&'&(

&UB$&0&( ?$25&'( 1&5#/'&( #%%( ,B"&$( %2G/2C2BH( '/??%H( C2'#??&#$&C( C/$2-D( B"&( F%#'"( 5$#'"<( %&#@2-D(

,-%H(0#$N&BE0#N&$( k'B/1(G/,B&'l(A2B"(?%#5&",%C&$(12C'(#-C(,FF&$'(#B(&UB$&0&(?$25&'*( (42-5&(#(

D$&#B(C&#%(,F(%2G/2C2BH(2'('/??%2&C(1H(JK>(2-(5/$$&-B(0#$N&B'<(2B(2'(B&0?B2-D(B,(1%#0&(JK>(F,$(

B"&(#??#$&-B(%#5N(,F(%2G/2C2BH('/??%H(C/$2-D(B"&(F%#'"(5$#'"*(

Q,0,A2BV(I:;=;L<(#(F,$0&$(#5#C&025(-,A(#B(S>`<(?,2-B'(,/B(B"#B(#('202%#$(K%#'"(!$#'"(

,55/$$&C(0,$&(B"#-(f;(H&#$'(#D,<(,-(B"&(#FB&$-,,-(,F()#H(:^<(=gT:*((>"&(Q,A(+,-&'(S-C/'B$2#%(

a@&$#D&(F&%%('"#$?%H(2-(:;(02-/B&'(B"#B(C#H<(A2B"(',0&('B,5N'(?%/00&B2-D(0,$&(B"#-(g(?&$5&-B(

2-(%&''(B"#-(=:(02-/B&'*( (>"#B(B&0?,$#$H(C2'%,5#B2,-(,55/$$&C(2-(#(5&-B$#%2V&C(0#$N&B('H'B&0(

A2B"(0#-/#%( B$#C2-D( ,-( B"&( F%,,$( ,F( B"&(Y&A(b,$N(4B,5N(MU5"#-D&*( (>"&(4M!(?$,C/5&C( #-(

2-@&'B2D#B2@&( $&?,$B( B"#B( "2D"%2D"B&C( B"&( $,%&( ?%#H&C( 1H( Yb4M( '?&52#%2'B'*( ( a'( B"&( C&5%2-&(

/-F,%C&C<('?&52#%2'B'(&2B"&$('B&??&C(#'2C&(,$(#5B2@&%H(',%C('"#$&'*((M%&5B$,-25(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(#%',(

$&B$&#B&C( ,-( )#H( T<( :;=;<( 1/B( Q,0,A2BV( A$2B&'( B"#B( kB"2'( "#'( 0,$&( B,( C,( A2B"( #( "/0#-(

$&#5B2,-(B,('B&?(#'2C&(A"&-(0#$N&B'(#55&%&$#B&('"#$?%H(B"#-(2B(C,&'(A2B"(0#$N&B('B$/5B/$&*l(

>"&( P,2-B(!K>!n4M!($&?,$B(,-( B"&( F%#'"( 5$#'"( 'B#B&'( B"#B( 2B'(?$,U20#B&( 5#/'&(A#'( #(

:97:])(,$C&$( F$,0( #(0/B/#%( F/-C( 5,0?%&U( B,( '&%%( #( B,B#%( ,F( hf<;;;( &E02-2( 4d](f;;( F/B/$&'(

5,-B$#5B'(#'(#("&CD&(B,(#-(&U2'B2-D(&G/2BH(?,'2B2,-*((O$C&$'(B"2'(%#$D&(#??&#$(2-(!K>!(C#B#(,-(

&E02-2( 4d]( f;;( F/B/$&'( 5,-B$#5B'( ,-%H( #( 5,/?%&( ,F( B20&'( ?&$( H&#$*( ( a-( #%D,$2B"0( 1&D#-( B,(

&U&5/B&( B"2'( %#$D&(,$C&$( 2-( B"&(0#$N&B<(A2B"( B"&(#%D,$2B"0(?#$#0&B&$'('&B(',( B"#B( B"&(0/B/#%(

F/-C( '&%%&$(A,/%C(1&( #1,/B(ge(,F( B"&( B$#C2-D(@,%/0&*( (>"&( #%D,$2B"0(5,-B2-/&C( B,( '/102B( #(

%#$D&(-/01&$(,F( '&%%(,$C&$'(&@&-(#'( B"&(4d]( F/B/$&'(?$25&(1&D#-(B,(C$,?('"#$?%H*( (>"&(,$C&$(

5,-B2-/&C(B,(&U&5/B&(C/$2-D(B"&(?$25&($&1,/-C<(#-C(2B(/%B20#B&%H(F2-2'"&C(&U&5/B2-D(2-(#1,/B(:;(

Page 37: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#&

02-/B&'*( (),-B"'( &#$%2&$<( #( '202%#$( ,$C&$( F$,0( B"&( '#0&( '&%%&$( B,,N(0,$&( B"#-( F2@&( ",/$'( B,(

&U&5/B&<("2D"%2D"B2-D(B"&($#?2C(?#5&(,F(B"&()#H(T('&%%2-D(?$,D$#0*((O-(B"&(#FB&$-,,-(,F()#H(T<(

D2@&-( B"&( $&5&-B( 'B,5N( 0#$N&B( C&5%2-&'( #-C( B"&( D&-&$#%( 0#5$,&5,-,025( 1#5NC$,?<( ?,B&-B2#%(

1/H&$'(,1'&$@2-D(B"&(?#5&(,F(,$C&$'(B,('&%%(A,/%C(-#B/$#%%H(A,$$H(B"#B(B"&H(A&$&(F#52-D(,-&(,$(

0,$&(A&%%E2-F,$0&C('&%%&$'(A2B"(&UB$&0&%H(-&D#B2@&(2-F,$0#B2,-(#1,/B(F/-C#0&-B#%'*(

a$,/-C( B"2'( B20&<( B"&$&( A&$&( #%',( 0#$N&B( 2-F$#'B$/5B/$&( ?$,1%&0'( #B( Yb4M( a$5#*((

a55,$C2-D(B,(B"&(P,2-B(!K>!n4M!($&?,$B(I?*(hhL<(B"&(Yb4M('&B(G/,B&(B$#FF25($&5,$C'(C/$2-D(B"&(

F%#'"( 5$#'"<( #-C( B"2'( 5#/'&C( '2D-2F25#-B( C&%#H'( 2-( B"&( C2''&02-#B2,-( ,F( B$#C&'( #-C( G/,B&'( F,$(

#1,/B("#%F(,F(B"&('B,5N'(B$#C&C(B"&$&*((S-(?#$B25/%#$<(B"&$&(A&$&(C&%#H'(#@&$#D2-D(#'(0/5"(#'(:;(

'&5,-C'( 2-( C2''&02-#B2-D( G/,B&'( B,( B"&(!,-',%2C#B&C(r/,B&( 4H'B&0( I!r4L*( (>"&$&(A&$&( #%',(

C&%#H'(2-(B"&(Yb4Mj'(?$,?$2&B#$H(C#B#(F&&C'*( (>"2'(0#H("#@&(5#/'&C(/-5&$B#2-BH(#0,-D(,B"&$(

0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'( #1,/B( 'H'B&0'( 2-B&D$2BH<( #-C( 2B( 0#H( "#@&( &@&-( 5#/'&C( ',0&( %2G/2C2BH(

'/??%2&$'(#B(,B"&$(0#$N&B'(B,('B&?(1#5N*(

W"2%&( JK>(0#H( "#@&( 5,-B$21/B&C( #( D,,C( ?#$B( ,F( B"&( &%&5B$,-25(0&''#D&( B$#FF25( B"#B(

,@&$A"&%0&C(B"&(Yb4M(B"#B(#FB&$-,,-<(2B(2'(#%',(20?,$B#-B(B,(2-@&'B2D#B&(B"&(B$#C2-D(1&"#@2,$(

,F(JK>(,-(B"#B(C#H<(#-C(X2$2%&-N,<(XH%&<(4#0#C2<(#-C(>/V/-(I:;==L('B/CH(JK>(2-(B"&(&E02-2(

4d]( f;;( F/B/$&'( 0#$N&B( C/$2-D( B"&( F%#'"( 5$#'"*( ( >"&H( "#@&( #/C2B( B$#2%( C#B#( F,$( #%%( =f<;;;(

#55,/-B'(B"#B(B$#C&C(B"&(&E02-2(B"#B(C#H<(#-C(B"&H(?#$B2B2,-(B"&'&(#55,/-B'(2-B,('2U(5#B&D,$2&'<(

2-5%/C2-D(#(5#B&D,$H(F,$(JK>*((XX4>(F2-C(B"#B(JK>(C2C(-,B(B$2DD&$(B"&(K%#'"(!$#'"<(1/B(B"&2$(

$&'?,-'&'( B,( B"&( /-/'/#%%H( %#$D&( '&%%2-D( ?$&''/$&( ,-( B"#B( C#H( &U#5&$1#B&C( B"&( C&5%2-&( #-C(

A,$'&-&C(0#$N&B(@,%#B2%2BH*( (S-(?#$B25/%#$<(#'(#(%#$D&(-/01&$(,F(#DD$&''2@&('&%%(,$C&$'(#$$2@&C(

#FB&$(:97;])<(JK>(2-2B2#%%H(?$,@2C&C( %2G/2C2BH*( (W2B"2-(#( F&A(02-/B&'<(?,''21%H(1&5#/'&( B"&H(

A&$&(,@&$A"&%0&C(1H('&%%2-D(?$&''/$&<(JK>j'($&@&$'&C(5,/$'&(#-C(#DD$&''2@&%H(%2G/2C#B&C(B"&2$(

%,-D(?,'2B2,-'<(#-C(B"&$&1H(5,-B$21/B2-D(B,(B"&(?$25&(C&5%2-&*(

Page 38: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#'

>"&( P,2-B( !K>!n4M!( $&?,$B( #%',( &U#02-&'( B"&( #DD$&D#B&( &G/2BH( 0#$N&B( B$#C2-D(

1&"#@2,$(,F(=h(JK>(F2$0'(C/$2-D(B"&(F%#'"(5$#'"*((>"&'&(=h(JK>(F2$0'(#55,/-B&C(F,$(#$,/-C(

"#%F(,F(&G/2BH(B$#C2-D(@,%/0&(C/$2-D(B"&(#FB&$-,,-*( (S-(#DD$&D#B&<( B"&'&( F2$0'(',%C($#?2C%H( 2-(

B"&(=fE02-/B&( 2-B&$@#%(1&BA&&-(:97;?0(#-C(:98f?0<(A2B"(-&B('&%%2-D(,F(m=*=f^(12%%2,-(C/$2-D(

B"#B(2-B&$@#%*((a'(B"&($&?,$B(-,B&'<(',0&(,F(B"2'(#DD$&''2@&('&%%2-D(5,/%C(1&(C/&(B,(5$,''E0#$N&B(

'B$#B&D2&'(2-@,%@2-D(B"&(?/$5"#'&(,F(F/B/$&'(#-C(B"&('#%&(,F(&G/2B2&'*((J,A&@&$<(B"&(!K>!n4M!(

$&?,$B(5,-5%/C&'(B"#B(k2B(#??&#$'(B"#B(B"&(=h(JK>(F2$0'(B$#C&C(A2B"(B"&(?$25&(B$&-C(,-()#H(T(

#-C<( ,-( 1,B"( #-( #1',%/B&( #-C( -&B( 1#'2'<( $&0,@&C( '2D-2F25#-B( 1/H( %2G/2C2BH( F$,0( B"&( ?/1%25(

G/,B2-D(0#$N&B'(C/$2-D(B"&(C,A-B/$-*l(

M#'%&H<(\,?&V(C&(]$#C,<( #-C(OjJ#$#( I:;==<(:;=:L(C,(-,B("#@&(#55&''( B,( #55,/-BE%&@&%(

C#B#(F,$(B"&(F%#'"(5$#'"<(1/B(B"&H(/'&(2-B$#C#H(C#B#(B,(5#%5/%#B&(#-(,$C&$(201#%#-5&(0&#'/$&(B"#B(

B"&H( 5#%%( B"&( @,%/0&E'H-5"$,-2V&C( ?$,1#12%2BH( ,F( 2-F,$0&C( B$#C2-D( I6]SYL*( ( >"&H( F2-C( B"#B(

,$C&$(201#%#-5&'(A&$&(&'?&52#%%H('&@&$&(2-(B"&(02-/B&'(P/'B(?$2,$(B,(B"&(F%#'"(5$#'"<('/??,$B2-D(

B"&(XX4>(5,-5%/'2,-(B"#B(JK>(#-C(,B"&$(B$#C2-D(2-B&$0&C2#$2&'(A&$&(,@&$A"&%0&C(1H('&%%2-D(

?$&''/$&*(

OB"&$( ?#?&$'( $&%#B&C( B,( B"&( F%#'"( 5$#'"( 2-5%/C&( )#C"#@#-( I:;=:L<( A",( F2-C'( B"#B(

'&5/$2B2&'( A2B"( 0,$&( F$#D0&-B&C( B$#C2-D( #-C( G/,B2-D( 1&"#@2,$( '/FF&$&C( 0,$&( &UB$&0&( ?$25&(

0,@&'( C/$2-D( B"&( :;=;(K%#'"(!$#'"*( (J&( #$D/&'( B"#B( B"&( 5,012-#B2,-( ,F( F$#D0&-B#B2,-( #-C(

"2D"EF$&G/&-5H( B$#C&$'( 5#-( 5#/'&( B"&( A2B"C$#A#%( ,F( %2G/2C2BH( 2-( B20&'( ,F( 0#$N&B( 'B$&''*((

)5S-2'"<( Z?',-<( #-C(W,,C( I:;=:L( F,5/'( ,-( B"&( /'&( ,F( 2-B&$0#$N&B( 'A&&?( ,$C&$'( IS4O'L( B,(

C&0#-C(%2G/2C2BH(C/$2-D(B"&(F%#'"(5$#'"*((>"&'&(,$C&$'(#$&(,FB&-(/'&C(B,('20/%B#-&,/'%H(#55&''(

%2G/2C2BH(#B(0/%B2?%&(B$#C2-D(@&-/&'<(#-C(B"&H(F2-C(#('"#$?(2-5$&#'&(2-(B"&(/'&(,F(S4O'(C/$2-D(B"&(

F%#'"(5$#'"<(5,-'2'B&-B(A2B"(',0&(,F(B"&(#DD$&''2@&('&%%2-D(C,5/0&-B&C(&#$%2&$*(

Page 39: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#(

W"2%&(',0&(,1'&$@&$'('/DD&'B&C(D$&#B&$(,1%2D#B2,-'( F,$(0#$N&BE0#N&$'<(&U?&$2&-5&( 2-(

,B"&$( $#?2C( C,A-C$#FB'<( 2-5%/C2-D( B"&( 'B,5N( 0#$N&B( 5$#'"( ,F( O5B,1&$( =g^h<( A"&-( Y#'C#G(

0#$N&BE0#N&$'(#-C(,B"&$'($&F/'&C(B,(#-'A&$(B"&2$(?",-&'(,$(?$,@2C&(0#$N&BE0#N2-D(#5B2@2BH<(

2-C25#B&'( B"#B(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(A2%%( #%0,'B( #%A#H'( 5",,'&( B,(A2B"C$#A( F$,0( B"&(0#$N&B( 2-( B"&(

F#5&(,F('/5"(&UB$&0&(@,%#B2%2BH*(([&D/%#B,$'(#-C(0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'(#%',(-,B25&C(B"#B(#(fE'&5,-C(

?#/'&( 2-( &E02-2( 4d]( F/B/$&'( B$#C2-D( A#'( '/FF252&-B( B,( &-C( B"&( F%#'"( 5$#'"( '%2C&<( #-C( B"&2$(

#BB&-B2,-(G/25N%H(B/$-&C(B,('",$BEB&$0(B$#C2-D("#%B'*(

42-D%&E'B,5N( 52$5/2B( 1$&#N&$'(A&$&( ?"#'&C( 2-( 1&D2--2-D( #1,/B( #(0,-B"( #FB&$( B"&( F%#'"(

5$#'"(I'&&(4M!([&%&#'&'(78ET::f=(#-C(78ET::f:<(1,B"(C#B&C(+/-&(=;<(:;=;L*((>"&'&(F,$5&(#(fE

02-/B&( B$#C2-D( "#%B( 2F( B"&( B$#-'#5B2,-( ?$25&( ,F( #-( 2-C2@2C/#%( 'B,5N(0,@&'( 1H(0,$&( B"#-( =;e(

A2B"2-(#(fE02-/B&(?&$2,C*( (>"&(B$#C2-D(?#/'&( 2'(C&'2D-&C(B,(D2@&(0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'( B20&(B,(

5,-'2C&$( #@#2%#1%&( 2-F,$0#B2,-( 0,$&( F/%%H( #-C( ?$,@2C&( 'B#12%2V2-D( %2G/2C2BH( 2F( B"&( %#$D&( ?$25&(

0,@&(C,&'(-,B(#??&#$(A#$$#-B&C(1#'&C(,-(F/-C#0&-B#%(2-F,$0#B2,-*((K$,0(#-(&5,-,025(?,2-B(

,F(@2&A<(B"&(?#/'&(2'(C&'2D-&C(B,(%202B(B"&(?,''212%2BH(,F(&UB$&0&(#C@&$'&('&%&5B2,-(F,$(0#$N&BE

0#N&$'<(D2@&(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2C&$'(#(5"#-5&(B,(5,%%&5B(0,$&(2-F,$0#B2,-<(#-C(B"&-($&'/0&(B$#C2-D(

@2#(#-(#/5B2,-(A"&$&(1/H&$'(#-C('&%%&$'(5#-(0&&B(C2$&5B%H(A2B"( %&''(-&&C(F,$(#-( 2-B&$0&C2#$H*((

aB(B"#B(?,2-B<(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2C&$'('",/%C(1&(#1%&(B,($&'/0&(-,$0#%(0#$N&BE0#N2-D(#5B2@2BH*(

>"&( 4M!<( B"&( -#B2,-#%( &U5"#-D&'<( #-C( KSY[a( '",/%C( 1&( 5,00&-C&C( F,$( G/25N%H(

#D$&&2-D( B,( #-C( #C,?B2-D( '2-D%&E'B,5N( 52$5/2BE1$&#N&$'*( ( W"2%&( B"&$&( "#@&( 1&&-( -,( F,$0#%(

'B/C2&'<( B"&( 52$5/2BE1$&#N&$'( '&&0( B,( "#@&( #''/#D&C( 2-@&'B,$( F&#$'( #1,/B( B"&( A",%&'#%&(

C2'#??&#$#-5&( ,F( %2G/2C2BH( ,@&$( #( '",$B( ?&$2,C( ,F( B20&*( ( >",/D"(0,'B( ,1'&$@&$'( 1&%2&@&( B"#B(

B"&'&( '2-D%&E'B,5N(52$5/2B(1$&#N&$'("#@&(D&-&$#%%H(A,$N&C(A&%%<( B"&H(#$&( ',0&B20&'( B$2DD&$&C(

1H(#('2-D%&(&$$,-&,/'(B$#C&(,-(,-&(B$#C2-D(@&-/&<(#B(#(B20&(A"&-(B"&(0#$N&B(2-(B"#B('B,5N(A#'(

,?&$#B2-D(2-(#-(,$C&$%H(F#'"2,-(,-(#%%(,B"&$(@&-/&'*((((>"/'<(B"&(4M!<(B"&(-#B2,-#%(&U5"#-D&'<(

Page 40: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

#)

#-C(KSY[a(#$&(2-(B"&(?$,5&''(,F($&?%#52-D('2-D%&E'B,5N(52$5/2B(1$&#N&$'(A2B"('",$BEB&$0(?$25&(

%202B'*(

S-(F#5B<(,-(+/-&(=<(:;=:<(B"&(4M!(2-([&%&#'&(78ETh;g=(#??$,@&C(#(k%202B(/?E%202B(C,A-l(

0&5"#-2'0( B"#B( ?$&@&-B'( B$#C&'( 2-( 2-C2@2C/#%( 'B,5N'( F$,0( ,55/$$2-D( 0,$&( B"#-( #( 5&$B#2-(

#0,/-B(#A#H(F$,0(B"&(#@&$#D&(?$25&(,F(B"&('&5/$2BH(,@&$(B"&(?$&5&C2-D(fE02-/B&(?&$2,C*((>"&(

#%%,A#1%&(1#-C(2'(fe(F,$(%#$D&E5#?('B,5N'(#-C(#5B2@&(M>K'<(#-C(=;e(F,$(0,'B(,B"&$('B,5N'*((SF(

=f( '&5,-C'( &%#?'&( #-C( B$#C2-D( C,&'( -,B( $&'/0&( A2B"2-( B"&( ?$25&( 1#-C<( B"&$&( 2'( #( fE02-/B&(

B$#C2-D("#%B*( (>"&(-&A(?$25&( %202B'(#$&( '5"&C/%&C( B,(D,( 2-B,(&FF&5B(,-(K&1$/#$H(8<(:;=7( F,$(#(

,-&EH&#$(?2%,B(?&$2,C*(

O@&$#%%<(B"&'&(?$25&(%202B'('&&0(B,(1&(#-(#??$,?$2#B&('?&&C(1/0?*((>"&H(#$&(C&'2D-&C(B,(

N25N( 2-( A"&-( B"&( ?,B&-B2#%( F,$( #C@&$'&( '&%&5B2,-( 5#/'&'( #( 0#$N&B( F#2%/$&<( ',( B"&H( #$&(

&5,-,025#%%H( P/'B2F2#1%&*( (W"&-( B$#C2-D(A#'(0,$&( 5&-B$#%2V&C<( &U5"#-D&'( ,FB&-( &U&$52'&C( B"&(

?,A&$( B,( 2-2B2#B&( #( B$#C2-D( "#%B( F,$( &U#5B%H( B"&'&( $&#',-'*( ( 3/B( 2-( #( F$#D0&-B&C( 0#$N&B(

'B$/5B/$&<(5,,$C2-#B2,-(1&5,0&'(#-(2''/&<(#-C(#($&D/%#B,$H(2-2B2#B2@&(2'(#-(#??$,?$2#B&($,/B&(B,(

B"2'(&5,-,025#%%H(C&'2$#1%&(,/B5,0&*(

!

PB!!;)4)+%!@$2*)%!/J.%4#)E!$EE'4.$%)&!(.%#!FG:(

N;<;++O#&5K)+!(8&)(%+

X-2D"B(!#?2B#%(`$,/?(2'(,-&(,F(B"&(%#$D&'B(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(2-(Z*4*(&G/2B2&'<(#-C(2B(2'(1&'B(N-,A-(

F,$( 2B'(#$$#-D&0&-B'(A2B"(0#-H(1$,N&$#D&( F2$0'( B,(&U&5/B&(,$C&$'( F$,0($&B#2%( 2-@&'B,$'*( (O-(

a/D/'B(=<(:;=:<(B"2'("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(B$#C2-D(F2$0(2-B$,C/5&C(#(-&A(B$#C2-D(#%D,$2B"0(B"#B(A#'(

#??#$&-B%H( $/'"&C( 2-B,( '&$@25&(A2B",/B( '/FF252&-B( B&'B2-D*( (>"2'( $,D/&( #%D,$2B"0(#55/0/%#B&C(

%#$D&(?,'2B2,-'(2-(=8^(Yb4ME%2'B&C('B,5N'(,@&$(#1,/B(8f(02-/B&'(#B(B"&('B#$B(,F(B"&(B$#C2-D(C#H(

Page 41: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$*

1&F,$&(X-2D"B(?/%%&C(B"&(?%/D(,-(2B'(B$#C2-D*( (Z%B20#B&%H<( 2-5%/C2-D(B"&(5,'B(,F( %2G/2C#B2-D(2B'(

?,'2B2,-<(X-2D"B(2-5/$$&C(%,''&'(,F(m88;(02%%2,-(F$,0(2B'(B$#C2-D(B"#B(0,$-2-D*(

W"2%&(X-2D"B(B$#C&C(/-/'/#%%H(%#$D&(G/#-B2B2&'(,F(B"&(#FF&5B&C('B,5N'(#-C(0,@&C('"#$&(

?$25&'( '2D-2F25#-B%H<( B"&( ?$25&(0,@&'(A&$&( BH?25#%%H( -,B( F#'B( &-,/D"( ,$( '"#$?( &-,/D"( B,( B$2?(

'2-D%&( 'B,5N( 52$5/2B( 1$&#N&$'*( ( S-( #CC2B2,-<( '2-D%&( 'B,5N( 52$5/2B( 1$&#N&$'( C,( -,B( N25N( 2-( /-B2%(

g98f#0<(=f(02-/B&'(#FB&$( B"&(,?&-*( (a'(#($&'/%B<( B$#C2-D(A#'("#%B&C( 2-(,-%H( F2@&(,F( B"&('B,5N'(

2-@,%@&C(2-(B"&(X-2D"B(D%2B5"*((S-(B"&(A#N&(,F(B"&()#H(T<(:;=;(K%#'"(!$#'"<(B$#C&(5#-5&%%#B2,-(

?,%252&'("#C(#%',(1&&-(5"#-D&C<('&BB2-D(#("2D"(1#$(F,$(5#-5&%%2-D(B$#C&'<('?&52F25#%%H(',(B"#B(F2$0'(

A,/%C(1&#$(B"&(5,'B'(2F(B"&2$(,$C&$'(5#/'&C(A2C&(B&0?,$#$H(?$25&('A2-D'*((>"2'("#C(B"&(2-B&-C&C(

&FF&5B<(#'(B$#C&'(A&$&(/%B20#B&%H(5#-5&%%&C(2-(,-%H('2U('0#%%&$('B,5N'(B"#B("#C(?#$B25/%#$%H(A2C&(

?$25&('A2-D'<(#-C(X-2D"B(A#'(,-(B"&(",,N(F,$(-&#$%H(#%%(,F(2B'(/-2-B&-C&C(B$#C&'*(

42-5&( B"2'( &@&-B<( B"&( 4M!( "#'( ?$,02'&C( #5B2,-<( 1/B( 2B( 2'( -,B( 5%&#$( B"#B( 0/5"( -&A(

$&D/%#B2,-(2'(-&5&''#$H(2-($&'?,-'&(B,(B"2'(&@&-B*((X-2D"B(1,$&(B"&(C2$&5B(5,'B(,F(2B'(#5B2,-'<(#-C(

D,2-D(F,$A#$C<(B"2'(&@&-B(A2%%($&02-C(&@&$H(0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B(,F(B"&(20?,$B#-5&(,F(B&'B2-D(#-C(

0,-2B,$2-D(2B'(5,0?/B&$2V&C(B$#C2-D*((S-(F#5B<($,D/&(#%D,$2B"0'('",/%C(1&(0/5"(%&''(%2N&%H(-,A<(

#-C(F2$0'(#$&(0/5"(0,$&(%2N&%H(B,(?/%%(B"&(?%/D(G/25N%H(2F(B"&H(,1'&$@&(#-H(/-/'/#%(B$#C2-D(1H(

B"&2$( #%D,$2B"0'*( (J,A&@&$<( '/5"(&$$,$'("#@&( B"&(?,B&-B2#%( B,( 20?,'&( &UB&$-#%2B2&'(,-(,B"&$'*((

K,$(&U#0?%&<(B"2'(%&@&%(,F(B$#C2-D(%,''&'(02D"B("#@&(1#-N$/?B&C(#('0#%%&$(F2$0<(20?,'2-D(%,''&'(

,-( 5%&#$2-D( F2$0'(,$(,B"&$( 5,/-B&$?#$B2&'*( (\#$D&$( B$#C2-D( %,''&'( 5,/%C("#@&( 'H'B&025( &FF&5B'*((

>"/'<( 2B(0#H(1&( #??$,?$2#B&( F,$( &U5"#-D&'(,$( $&D/%#B,$'( B,(0#-C#B&( #( ',E5#%%&C( kN2%%( 'A2B5"l(

B"#B( A,/%C( G/25N%H( '"/B( ,FF( #( 0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-Bj'( #55&''( #-C( %202B( #-H( ?,B&-B2#%( '?2%%,@&$(

&FF&5B'*(

(

N;G;++=K*+@(2*D""B+PH1+

Page 42: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$!

M#$%2&$(B"2'(H&#$<(Y#'C#G("#C('&$2,/'(5,0?/B&$(?$,1%&0'(,-(B"&(F2$'B(C#H(,F(B$#C2-D(F,$(

K#5&1,,N('"#$&'*((>"&'&(5,0?/B&$(?$,1%&0'(#??&#$(B,(1&(B"&($&'/%B(,F(5,0?/B&$(',FBA#$&(B"#B(

A#'(-,B( #1%&( B,( "#-C%&( B"&( ?#5&( ,F( ,$C&$( '/102''2,-'( #-C( 5#-5&%%#B2,-'( 1H( 1,B"("/0#-'( #-C(

5,0?/B&$(#%D,$2B"0'*(

aFB&$(2B'(2-2B2#%(?/1%25(,FF&$2-D(IS]OL(A#'(?$25&C(,-(>"/$'C#H<()#H(=h<(:;=:<(K#5&1,,N(

A#'( '5"&C/%&C( B,( ,?&-( F,$( B$#C2-D( #$,/-C( ==9;;#0( ,-( B"&( F,%%,A2-D( C#H*( (Ya4Qarj'( kS]O(

!$,''l(,?&-2-D(?$,5&''( 2'(C&'2D-&C(B,(5,%%&5B(1/H(#-C('&%%(,$C&$'(/?(B,(B"&(B20&(,F( B"&(5$,''<(

0#B5"( #'(0#-H( 1/H&$'( #-C( '&%%&$'( #'( ?,''21%&( #B( #(0#$N&BE5%&#$2-D( ,?&-2-D( ?$25&<( #-C( #%%,A(

5,-B2-/,/'( B$#C2-D( ,F( B"&( 'B,5N( B"&$&#FB&$*( (a55,$C2-D( B,(Y#'C#G<( B"&( S]O(!$,''( B,,N( #( F&A(

02%%2'&5,-C'(B,($/-(#-C(B"&-<(#'(?#$B(,F(2B'(C,/1%&E5"&5N2-D(?$,5&''<(B"&(',FBA#$&(%,,N&C(#B(B"&(

,$C&$( 1,,N( #D#2-( B,(0#N&( '/$&( -,( -&A( ,$C&$'( "#C( #$$2@&C( #-C( -,( &U2'B2-D( ,$C&$'( "#C( 1&&-(

5#-5&%%&C(C/$2-D(B",'&(F&A(02%%2'&5,-C'*((SF(B"&(,$C&$(1,,N("#C(5"#-D&C(C/$2-D(B"&(5#%5/%#B2,-(

?&$2,C<(B"&(S]O(!$,''($&'B#$B&C(B"&(5#%5/%#B2,-(?$,5&''*((3&5#/'&(,F(B"&('2V&(#-C(2-B&$&'B(%&@&%(2-(

B"&(K#5&1,,N( S]O(#-C( B"&(?$&'&-5&(,F( #%D,$2B"0'( 5,-B2-/2-D( B,( '/102B( #-C( 5#-5&%( ,$C&$'( 2-(

K#5&1,,N('"#$&'<(B"&(S]O(!$,''(&''&-B2#%%H(1&5#0&('B/5N(2-(#-(2-F2-2B&(%,,?*(

aB(==97;#0<(Y#'C#G(,?&-&C(K#5&1,,N(B$#C2-D(/'2-D(#('&5,-C#$H(0#B5"2-D(&-D2-&(1#'&C(

,-( ,$C&$'( ?$&'&-B( #B( ==9==#0*( ( J,A&@&$<( ,?&-2-D( 5$,''( &U&5/B2,-( $&?,$B'( A&$&( -,B(

C2''&02-#B&C(/-B2%(#1,/B(:?0(B"#B(C#H*((a$,/-C(B"&-<(0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'(#%',(%&#$-&C(B"#B(S]O(

!$,''( ,$C&$'( &-B&$&C( ,$( 5#-5&%%&C( 1&BA&&-( ==9==#0( #-C( ==97;#0( "#C( -,B( 1&&-( 2-5,$?,$#B&C(

2-B,( B"&( S]O( !$,''*( ( W"2%&( Y#'C#Gj'( B$#C2-D( 2-( K#5&1,,N( A#'( -,$0#%( F,$( B"&( $&'B( ,F( B"&(

#FB&$-,,-<( 2B( 2'( 5%&#$( B"#B(#( '",$BE%2@&C(',FBA#$&(?$,1%&0(5#/'&C( B&-'(,F(02%%2,-'(,F(C,%%#$'(,F(

%,''&'(B,(2-@&'B,$'(#-C(B"&2$(1$,N&$EC&#%&$'<(#-C(2B(A2%%(?$,1#1%H(B#N&(',0&(B20&(B,(',$B(,/B(#%%(

,F(B"&(5%#20'(F,$(5,0?&-'#B2,-*(

Page 43: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$"

>"&(1#'25( %&'',-(,F( B"&(K#5&1,,N( S]O( 2'( B"&( '#0&( #'( B"&( %&'',-(,F( B"&(X-2D"B(D%2B5"9((

5$2B25#%(',FBA#$&(-&&C'(B,(1&(B&'B&C(B",$,/D"%H*((!$2B25#%(',FBA#$&(B"#B($/-'(2-F$&G/&-B%H(-&&C'(

&@&-(0,$&(B&'B2-D*((a'(2-(B"&(X-2D"B(5#'&<(B"&(2-5&-B2@&'(#$&(#%$&#CH(2-(?%#5&*((>"2'(&@&-B(A2%%(

#%0,'B('/$&%H(5,'B(Y#'C#G(B&-'(,F(02%%2,-'(,F(C,%%#$'<(#-C(#'(#($&'/%B(&@&$H(&U5"#-D&(A2%%(-,A(

0#N&('/$&(B"#B(S]O(B$#C2-D(B&5"-,%,DH(I#-C(B&5"-,%,D25#%(5"#-D&'(0,$&(D&-&$#%%HL("#@&(1&&-(

B",$,/D"%H(@&BB&C*((aCC2B2,-#%($&D/%#B,$H(#5B2,-(2'(?$,1#1%H(/--&5&''#$H*(((

!

QB!!R%#)2!2)/-J$%'25!.EE-)E!$EE'4.$%)&!(.%#!FG:!

[&D/%#B,$'( 2-( B"&(Z4( #-C( #1$,#C( #$&( 5,-'2C&$2-D( #( -/01&$( ,F( 2-2B2#B2@&'( B"#B( 5#-( 1&(

C2$&5B%H(B$#5&C(B,(5,-5&$-'(#1,/B(JK>*((J,A&@&$<(0#-H(,F(B"&(2''/&'(#'',52#B&C(A2B"(JK>(#$&(

B"&('#0&( 2''/&'( B"#B(#$2'&( 2-(0,$&(0#-/#%(0#$N&B'*( (K,$(&U#0?%&<( B"&$&( 2'(5,-5&$-(#1,/B( B"&(

&FF&5B'(,F(#(BA,EB2&$&C(0#$N&B<(A"&$&(JK>(5/$$&-B%H("#'(#('?&&C(#C@#-B#D&(,@&$(#('&5,-C(B2&$(,F(

0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'*((S-(#(F%,,$E1#'&C(0#$N&B<('/5"(#'(B"&(Y&A(b,$N(4B,5N(MU5"#-D&(?$2,$(B,(

:;;f<(B"&$&(A&$&(#%',(5,-5&$-'(#1,/B(#(BA,EB2&$&C(0#$N&B*( (W2B"2-(B"#B(0#$N&B('B$/5B/$&<(B"&(

#C@#-B#D&'(A&-B(B,(B",'&(A2B"(?"H'25#%(#55&''(B,(B"&(F%,,$<(2-5%/C2-D('?&52#%2'B'<(F%,,$(1$,N&$'<(

#-C( F%,,$E1#'&C( ?$,?$2&B#$H( B$#C&$'*( ( >,( %202B( B",'&( 'B$/5B/$#%( #C@#-B#D&'<( $&D/%#B,$'( #-C(

&U5"#-D&'( 2-'B2B/B&C( $/%&'( D,@&$-2-D( B"&( 1&"#@2,$( ,F( F%,,$E1#'&C( 0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'*( ( K,$(

&U#0?%&<( B"&(Yb4M('?&52#%2'B(A#'(#%A#H'( %#'B( 2-( %2-&(#B(#(D2@&-(?$25&*( ( (a'(#-,B"&$(&U#0?%&<(

0,'B( 0#$N&B'( 20?,'&C( '&@&$&( %202B'( ,-( #12%2BH( B,( C,( ?$,?$2&B#$H( B$#C2-D( A"2%&( "#-C%2-D(

5/'B,0&$(,$C&$(F%,A*((K/$B"&$0,$&<(B"&$&(A&$&(,55#'2,-#%(&-F,$5&0&-B(5#'&'(B,($&2-(2-(#1/'2@&(

1&"#@2,$*((a1,/B(=;(H&#$'(#D,<('&@&$#%(Yb4M('?&52#%2'B'(F#5&C(5$202-#%(5"#$D&'(C/&(B,(B$#C2-D(

1&"#@2,$(B"#B(#??&#$&C(B,(C2'#C@#-B#D&(5/'B,0&$'*(

)#-H(,F(B",'&(#1/'&'( 2-(B"&( F%,,$E1#'&C(&$#(A&$&(C/&(B,(#( %#5N(,F(?&$F&5B(5,0?&B2B2,-*((

4?&52#%2'B'(A2&%C&C(',0&(0,-,?,%H(?,A&$<(#'(C2C(B"&(Yb4M*((S-(B"&(5/$$&-B(#/B,0#B&C(0#$N&B(

Page 44: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$#

&-@2$,-0&-B<($&D/%#B,$'(#$&(%#$D&%H($&%H2-D(,-(5,0?&B2B2,-(B,(02-202V&(#-H(#1/'&'(B"#B(02D"B(

#$2'&*((>"2'(5#-(1&('&&-(?$,02-&-B%H(2-([&D/%#B2,-(Y)4<(A"25"($&G/2$&'(&U5"#-D&'(B,(?$,@2C&(

-,-EC2'5$202-#B,$H(#55&''(B,(#%%(5,0&$'*((MU5"#-D&'(5#-(5"#$D&(JK>(F,$(5,E%,5#B2,-('&$@25&'<(

F,$(&U#0?%&<(1/B(B"&H(0/'B(5"#$D&(B"&('#0&(#0,/-B(B,(#-H(&-B2BH($&5&2@2-D(B"&('#0&('&$@25&*(

SF(B"&$&(2'(',0&(',$B(,F(0#$N&B(F#2%/$&<(",A&@&$<(B"&-($,1/'B(5,0?&B2B2,-(0#H(-,B(#%A#H'(

1&(B"&(',%/B2,-<(#-C($&D/%#B2,-(0#H(1&(2-(,$C&$*((Y,A(/-C&$(5,-'2C&$#B2,-(2-(W#'"2-DB,-(#$&(#(

-/01&$(,F(?,B&-B2#%($&D/%#B,$H(2-2B2#B2@&'(B"#B(#$&(C2$&5B%H(,$(2-C2$&5B%H($&%#B&C(B,(JK>*((4,0&(

,F(B"&(0,$&(20?,$B#-B($&D/%#B,$H(2-2B2#B2@&'(#$&(C2'5/''&C(1&%,A*((S-(B"2-N2-D(B"$,/D"(&#5"(,-&<(

2B(2'(20?,$B#-B(B,(5,-F2$0(B"#B(B"&$&(2'(2-C&&C(#(0#$N&B(F#2%/$&(B"#B(0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'(5#--,B(

5,$$&5B(,-(B"&2$(,A-<(#''&''(B"&(20?,$B#-5&(,F(B"&(0#$N&B(F#2%/$&<(#-C(D#/D&(B"&(%2N&%H(5,'B'(#-C(

1&-&F2B'(,F(B"&(?$,?,'&C($&D/%#B,$H(#??$,#5"*(

+

Q;<;++!"#$"%&'()*'+",'*,-%*.*%+(/'&)+),(&%$+

[,1/'B( &-F,$5&0&-B( ,F( '&5/$2B2&'( %#A'( #-C( &U5"#-D&( $/%&'( 2'( 20?,$B#-B( B,( &-'/$&(

2-@&'B,$(5,-F2C&-5&(2-(&G/2BH(0#$N&B'*( (a/C2B(B$#2%'("#@&(1&&-(#-(20?,$B#-B(',/$5&(,F(C#B#(F,$(

0#$N&B( '/$@&2%%#-5&( 1H( 2-B&$-#%( #-C( &UB&$-#%( $&D/%#B,$'<( #-C( 2-(0#-H(A#H'<( B"&$&( 2'( -,B"2-D(

-&A( #1,/B( '/$@&2%%#-5&( ,F(JK>*( (JK>( 2-B$,C/5&'( BA,(-&A(A$2-N%&'( 2-B,( '/$@&2%%#-5&9( ( B"&2$(

B$#C&'( 0#H( B#N&( ?%#5&( ,-( 0#-H( C2FF&$&-B( @&-/&'<( #-C( ,@&$'2D"B( 0#H( $&G/2$&( #( C&B#2%&C(

&U#02-#B2,-(,F(,$C&$E%&@&%(#/C2B(B$#2%'*(

W2B"( 2-5$&#'&C( F$#D0&-B#B2,-( 2-( &G/2BH( B$#C2-D( #5$,''( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'<(0#-H( B$#C2-D(

'B$#B&D2&'(0#N&(/'&(,F(0/%B2?%&(@&-/&'*( (>"/'<($&D/%#B,$'(0#H(-&&C(B,(,1B#2-(,$C&$E%&@&%(#-C(

B$#C&E%&@&%( C#B#( F$,0(0/%B2?%&( @&-/&'( #-C( B"&-( 2-B&D$#B&( B",'&( C#B#( '&B'( B,D&B"&$( B,( F,$0( #(

5,0?%&B&(?25B/$&(,F( B"&($&%&@#-B( B$#C2-D(#5B2@2BH*( (aB(?$&'&-B<( #%%( B$#C&'(#-C(&U5"#-D&(G/,B&'(

#$&($&?,$B&C(B,(B"&(5,-',%2C#B&C(B#?&<(#-C(B"2'(2'(,FB&-('/FF252&-B(F,$(2-@&'B2D#B,$'*((J,A&@&$<(#(

Page 45: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$$

"2D"EF$&G/&-5H( B$#C2-D( 'B$#B&DH( 5,/%C( 2-@,%@&( #1/'2@&( ,$C&$( '/102''2,-( #-C( 5#-5&%%#B2,-(

1&"#@2,$<(#-C(2B(5,/%C(1&(20?,$B#-B(B,(,1'&$@&(5,-B&0?,$#-&,/'(,$C&$E%&@&%(C#B#(F$,0(0/%B2?%&(

@&-/&'*( ([2D"B( -,A<( 2-B&D$#B2-D( ,$C&$E%&@&%( C#B#( 2'( C2FF25/%B<( 1&5#/'&( &U5"#-D&'( C,(-,B( '"#$&(

5,00,-(C#B#(F,$0#B'(F,$(,$C&$E%&@&%(C#B#*( (>"/'<($&G/2$2-D(5,00,-($&?,$B2-D('B#-C#$C'(#-C(

F,$0#B'(F,$(,$C&$E%&@&%(C#B#(A,/%C('&&0(B,(1&(F#2$%H(/-5,-B$,@&$'2#%*(

[&D/%#B,$'( "#@&( '/DD&'B&C( B"#B( #( -&#$( $&#%EB20&( 5,-',%2C#B&C( ,$C&$E%&@&%( #/C2B( B$#2%(

A,/%C(1&(@#%/#1%&<(1/B(&U5"#-D&(,?&$#B,$'(#-C(,B"&$(?#$B252?#-B'("#@&('B#B&C(B"#B(B"&(5,'B'(,F(

'/5"(#('H'B&0(A,/%C(1&(?$,"212B2@&%H("2D"*((K$,0(#-(&5,-,025(?,2-B(,F(@2&A<(B"2'(1,2%'(C,A-(B,(

#('B#-C#$C(5,'BE1&-&F2B(#-#%H'2'*((Z-F,$B/-#B&%H<(B"&$&(C,&'(-,B(#??&#$(B,(1&(0/5"(?/1%25(C#B#(

#@#2%#1%&( B,(0#N&( B"&'&( 5,'BE1&-&F2B( 5#%5/%#B2,-'<( ',( 2B( 2'( C2FF25/%B( F,$( #-( ,/B'2C&$( B,(0#N&( #-(

2-F,$0&C(#''&''0&-B*(

+

Q;G;++!(8(2&)>+&$$/*$+(#'+*32*$$&.*+",'*,+6**$+

!#?#52BH( "#'( %,-D( 1&&-( #-( 2''/&( F,$( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'*( ( K,$( &U#0?%&<( B"&( Yb4M( #-C(

a)Mo(5%,'&C(,-(W&C-&'C#H'(C/$2-D(B"&('&5,-C("#%F(,F(=gT^(1&5#/'&(,F(#(?#?&$A,$N(1#5N%,D*((

Q&#%2-D(A2B"( %#$D&( #0,/-B'( ,F( &U5"#-D&( 2-F,$0#B2,-( 2'( #%',( #-( ,%C( ?$,1%&0*( ( K,$( &U#0?%&<(

1&F,$&(=g;;<(B"&(W#%%(4B$&&B(+,/$-#%(?/1%2'"&C(B"&('2V&(#-C(?$25&(,F(&@&$H(Yb4M(B$#-'#5B2,-*((

a'(B$#C2-D(@,%/0&(2-5$&#'&C<(B"&(+,/$-#%('B,??&C($&?,$B2-D(&@&$H(B$#C&<(2-'B&#C(?$2-B2-D(,-%H(

B"&(C#2%H(,?&-<("2D"<(%,A<(#-C(%#'B('#%&(?$25&(F,$(&#5"('B,5N*(

JK>("#'('"#$?%H(2-5$&#'&C(5#?#52BH($&G/2$&0&-B'(F,$(B$#C2-D(@&-/&'*((K,$(&U#0?%&<(B"&(

F%#'"(5$#'"(,F()#H(T<(:;=;($&@&#%&C(B"#B(B"&(Yb4M(C2C(-,B("#@&('/FF252&-B(5#?#52BH(B,("#-C%&(

B"&(@,%/0&(,F(,$C&$('/102''2,-'(#-C(5#-5&%%#B2,-'(B"#B(#FB&$-,,-*( (OB"&$(0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'(

"#@&( 5,0?%#2-&C( #1,/B( B"&( '"&&$( @,%/0&( ,F( C#B#( #'',52#B&C( A2B"( Z*4*( &G/2BH( B$#C2-D*( ( ( K,$(

&U#0?%&<(#'(,F(B"&(F2$'B(G/#$B&$(,F(:;=:<(B"&$&(#$&(#-(#@&$#D&(,F(#1,/B(T8;(02%%2,-(G/,B&'(#-C(:^(

Page 46: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$%

02%%2,-( B$#C&'( ?&$( C#H( 2-( B"&(Z*4*( 'B,5N(0#$N&B'( #??&#$2-D( ,-( B"&( 5,-',%2C#B&C( B#?&*:(( (>"2'(

,-%H( 2-5%/C&'( B"&( 1&'B( 12C( #-C( ,FF&$( #B( &#5"( &U5"#-D&i(0/5"(0,$&( ,$C&$E%&@&%( C#B#(0/'B( 1&(

?$,5&''&C( 2-(,$C&$( B,(0#2-B#2-(#-(/?EB,EC#B&(@2&A(,F( B"&( %202B(,$C&$(1,,N*( (K,$(&U#0?%&<( B"&(

Y#'C#G( &G/2BH(0#$N&B( ?$,5&''&'( #1,/B( =( 12%%2,-( ,$C&$(0&''#D&'( ?&$( C#H( #'( ,F( +/-&( :;=;<( ,$(

#??$,U20#B&%H(=7(D2D#1HB&'(,F(,$C&$E%&@&%(C#B#<(#-C(Y#'C#G( 2'(,-%H(,-&(,F( '&@&$#%( &U5"#-D&'(

A2B"('202%#$(%&@&%'(,F(#5B2@2BH*(

K$,0(B"&(?,2-B(,F(@2&A(,F(&5,-,025(B"&,$H<(B"&(5/$$&-B(0#$N&B('B$/5B/$&(/-C,/1B&C%H(

20?,'&'( -&D#B2@&( &UB&$-#%2B2&'( ,-( ',0&( 0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B'<( 2-5%/C2-D( $&D/%#B,$'( A",( 0/'B(

5,%%&5B( #-C( '2FB( B"$,/D"( B&$#1HB&'( ,F( C#B#( #'( ?#$B( ,F( B"&2$( '/$@&2%%#-5&( F/-5B2,-*( (>"&$&( #$&( #(

-/01&$(,F(?,B&-B2#%(A#H'(B,(#0&%2,$#B&(B"2'(?$,1%&0*((K,$(&U#0?%&<(0#-H(0#$N&B(?#$B252?#-B'(

C,( -,B( -&&C( #55&''( B,( &@&$H( ,$C&$( '/102''2,-<( 5#-5&%%#B2,-<( #-C( &U&5/B2,-*( ( MU5"#-D&'( #$&(

?$,@2C2-D(0,$&(B,,%'(F,$(B"&'&(?#$B252?#-B'<('/5"(#'(?&$2,C25(,$C&$(1,,N('-#?'",B'(#-C(C#B#(F&&C(

'/1'&B'*(

4,0&( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'( #$&( #%',( $&'?,-C2-D( B,( 1#-CA2CB"( #-C( C#B#( G/#-B2BH( 2''/&'( 1H(

20?,'2-D( ,$C&$( 5#-5&%%#B2,-( ,$( &U5&''(0&''#D&( F&&'*( ( K,$( &U#0?%&<( 2-( :;=;<(Y#'C#G( 1,,'B&C(

$&1#B&'(F,$(F2$0'(A2B"(#-(,$C&$'EB,E&U&5/B2,-'($#B2,(,F(%&''(B"#-(=;*((Y#'C#G(-,A(5"#$D&'(#(F&&(

F,$(&U5&''2@&(%202B(,$C&$('/102''2,-'(B"#B(#$&(0,$&(B"#-(;*:;e(,/B'2C&(,F(B"&(-#B2,-#%(1&'B(12C(

#-C(,FF&$( IY33OL*( (]#$B252?#-B'( #$&( #%%,A&C( ',0&A"&$&(1&BA&&-(77( #-C(=;;( '/5"(,$C&$'( F,$(

&@&$H(&U&5/B&C(B$#C&(A2B",/B(5"#$D&*( (aCC2B2,-#%('/102BB&C(,$C&$'( B"#B(#$&(0,$&( B"#-(;*:;e(

,/B'2C&(B"&(Y33O(#$&('/1P&5B(B,(#(5"#$D&(,F(m;*;;f(B,(m;*;7(?&$(,$C&$*7(

M/$,?&#-( &G/2BH( 0#$N&B'( "#@&( '202%#$( F&&'( 2-( ?%#5&*( ( K,$( &U#0?%&<( Yb4M( M/$,-&UB(

20?,'&'(#('/$5"#$D&(,F(MZ[(;*=;(,-(&#5"(,$C&$(#1,@&(B"&(=;;9=(,$C&$EB,EB$#C&($#B2,*((Y#'C#G(

" Q+6+ ./32/91F<4:F O<;: R<4<D <S<19<E9: <4 844;TUUVVV+@4;;9<3+?/0# W/= 0/=: F:4<192D 2:: 844;TUUVVV+3<2F<A4=<F:=+?/0UO=<F:=+<2;PX1FYZ=1?:[124O=<F13J"+

Page 47: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$&

O)o(4B,5N",%0("#'(#-(,$C&$EB,EB$#C&(%202B(,F(:f;*((a1,@&(B"#B($#B2,<(#('/$5"#$D&(,F(4MX(;*;g(

I#??$,U20#B&%H( m;*;=:L( 2'( #??%2&C( ?&$( ,$C&$*( ( K,$( B"$&&(0,-B"'( C/$2-D( B"&( '/00&$( ,F( :;=:<(

Q2$&5B( MCD&( #%',( &U?&$20&-B&C(A2B"( #( '202%#$( ?,%25H<( $&C/52-D( %2G/2C2BH( ?$,@2C&$( $&1#B&'( 1H(

m;*;;;=(?&$('"#$&(F,$(#55,/-B'(&U5&&C2-D(B"&(=;;9=(0&''#D&EB,EB$#C&(B"$&'",%C*8(

>$#C2-D(@&-/&'(0/'B(0#N&(5,'B%H(2-@&'B0&-B'(2-(B&5"-,%,DH(2-F$#'B$/5B/$&(2-(,$C&$(B,(

"#-C%&( JK>( #-C( a><( #-C( B"&'&( ,$C&$( F&&'( $&?$&'&-B( #( '&-'21%&( ?$252-D( 0&5"#-2'0( F,$(

$&5,@&$2-D( ',0&( ,F( B"&( 5,'B'( F$,0( B",'&(A",( 20?,'&( B"&0*( ( S-( #CC2B2,-<( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'( #$&(

/-C&$(',0&(?$&''/$&(F$,0(B"&2$(/'&$'(B,(%202B(B"&(#0,/-B(,F(,$C&$(F%,A(2-F,$0#B2,-(B"#B(0/'B(

1&(?$,5&''&C*( (>"/'<( 2B('&&0'(B"#B(B$#C2-D(@&-/&'(#$&( 2-(B"&(1&'B(?,'2B2,-(B,(0#N&(P/CD0&-B'(

#1,/B(B"&'&(B$#C&,FF'(#-C('&B(B"&2$(F&&'(#55,$C2-D%H*(

aB(B"&(0,0&-B<(B"&$&(#$&(-,(?/1%25%H(#@#2%#1%&('B/C2&'(,F(B"&(&FF&5B'(,F(B"&'&(F&&'*((>"&$&(

C,(-,B('&&0(B,(1&(#-H(,1@2,/'(&FF&5B'(,-(%2G/2C2BH<(1/B(B"&(&U5&''2@&(0&''#D&(5"#$D&'("#@&(1&&-(

02-20#%(',(F#$(#-C('",/%C(1&(F#2$%H(&#'H(F,$(0,'B(JK>(B,(#@,2C*( (J,A&@&$<( 2B( 2'( 20?,$B#-B(B,(

-,B&(B"#B(B"&'&(F&&'(#$&(C&'2D-&C(B,(1&(1,$-&(1H(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2C&$'<(#-C(2F(B"&(F&&'("#@&(#-H(12B&(

#B(#%%<(B"&H('",/%C($&'/%B(2-($&C/5&C(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2'2,-*( (Y#'C#Gj'(F&&'('&&0(?#$B25/%#$%H(A&%%E

C&'2D-&C( B,(02-202V&( B"&'&( #C@&$'&( &FF&5B'<( 1&5#/'&( B"&$&( #$&( -,( &U5&''2@&(0&''#D&( F&&'( F,$(

,$C&$'(B"#B(#$&('/102BB&C(A2B"2-(;*:;e(,F(B"&(Y33O(I#(1#-C(B"#B(A,$N'(,/B(B,(#(F/%%(=;(5&-B'(

,-( #( 'B,5N(A2B"( #( '"#$&(?$25&( ,F( mf;L*( ( 4B2%%<( &@&-( B"&(Y#'C#G( F&&'( 5,/%C( B"2-(,/B( %202B( ,$C&$(

1,,N'<(#'(#CC2B2,-#%(C&?B"(#A#H(F$,0(B"&(2-'2C&(G/,B&(0#H(-,B(&U&5/B&(,FB&-(&-,/D"(B,(0#N&(

B"#B(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2'2,-(&5,-,025*( (>$#C2-D(@&-/&'(#-C($&'&#$5"&$'('",/%C(5#$&F/%%H('B/CH(B"&(

&FF&5B'(,F(B"&'&(F&&(2-2B2#B2@&'(,-(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2'2,-(#-C(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(1&F,$&(20?,'2-D('B&&?&$(

,$(1$,#C&$(5#-5&%%#B2,-(F&&'*(

+

$ 6:: R1=:?4 \FJ: O=<F13J ]/41?: ^!" !( <3F O=<F13J ]/41?: ^!" ##+

Page 48: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$'

Q;!;++7&#&4/4+",'*,+*38"$/,*+)&4*$+

>"&(4M!j'(:;=;(5,-5&?B($&%&#'&(,-(&G/2BH(0#$N&B('B$/5B/$&(0&-B2,-'(B"&(?,''212%2BH(,F(#(

$&G/2$&C(02-20/0(B20&E2-EF,$5&( F,$(,$C&$'*( (W2B"(#(02-20/0(B20&E2-EF,$5&<(,$C&$'(5,/%C(-,B(

1&( 5#-5&%&C( A2B"2-<( '#H<( f;( 02%%2'&5,-C'( ,F( '/102''2,-*( ( 42-5&( 2B( B#N&'( #??$,U20#B&%H( :;(

02%%2'&5,-C'( F,$( '2D-#%'( B,( B$#@&%( F$,0( &%&5B$,-25( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'( 2-( Y&A( +&$'&H( B,( B"&( A&'B(

5,#'B( ,F( B"&( 5,-B2-&-B#%( Z*4*<( #( 02-20/0( B20&E2-EF,$5&( ,F( #1,/B( f;( 02%%2'&5,-C'( 5,/%C( 1&(

P/'B2F2&C(,-(&G/#%(#55&''(D$,/-C'*((),$&(,FB&-<(#(02-20/0(B20&E2-EF,$5&(2'('/DD&'B&C(#'(#(A#H(

B,( B"$,A( '#-C( 2-( B"&( D&#$'( 1H( B",'&( A",( #$&( D&-&$#%%H( ,??,'&C( B,( #/B,0#B&C<( "2D"E'?&&C(

0#$N&B'*(

a( 02-20/0( B20&E2-EF,$5&( A,/%C( %202B( ',E5#%%&C( kF%25N&$2-D( G/,B&'<l( #-C( B"2'( A,/%C(

?$,@2C&(0,$&(5&$B#2-BH(B,(%2G/2C2BH(C&0#-C&$'(#1,/B(B"&(#@#2%#1%&(B&$0'(,F(B$#C&*((J,A&@&$<(B"&(

02-20/0(B20&E2-EF,$5&(#??&#$'(B,(1&(#(?#$B25/%#$%H(1%/-B<(?,,$%H(5,-'2C&$&C(B,,%*((a(02-20/0(

B20&E2-EF,$5&( A,/%C( F,$5&( %#$D&( 5"#-D&'( 2-( &G/2BH( 0#$N&B'( #-C( 5,/%C( '&@&$&%H( C2'5,/$#D&(

%2G/2C2BH( ?$,@2'2,-*( ( \2G/2C2BH( ?$,@2C&$'( A,/%C( 1&( D$#-B2-D( #( B$#C2-D( ,?B2,-( B,( %2G/2C2BH(

C&0#-C&$'<(#-C(B"2'(,?B2,-(A,/%C("#@&(B,(1&(?$25&C(2-B,(%2G/2C2BH(?$,@2'2,-<(A2C&-2-D(12CE#'N(

'?$&#C'(1H(#B(%&#'B(B"&(@#%/&(,F(B"&(,?B2,-*(()2-20/0(,$C&$(&U?,'/$&(B20&'(A,/%C(#%',("#@&(#-(

#'H00&B$25( 20?#5B<( #FF&5B2-D( %2G/2C2BH(?$,@2C&$'(1/B("#@2-D(-,(&FF&5B(,-( %2G/2C2BH(C&0#-C&$'*((

42-5&(0#-H(,F(B"&(,1'&$@&C(1&-&F2B'(F$,0(JK>(#$&(C/&(B,(0,$&(&FF252&-B(?$,@2'2,-(,F(%2G/2C2BH<(

B"2'(A,/%C('&&0(%2N&%H(B,($&@&$'&(B"&'&(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH(D#2-'*(

OF(5,/$'&<(&U5"#-D&(5/'B,0&$'(B"&0'&%@&'(02D"B(@#%/&( %,-D&$E%2@&C( %2G/2C2BH*( ( SF(',<(#(

B$#C2-D(@&-/&(5,/%C(2B'&%F(?/B(2-5&-B2@&'(2-(?%#5&(B,(&-5,/$#D&(%,-D&$E%2@&C(%202B(,$C&$'*((>"2'(

'&&0'( B,( 1&(0,$&( B"#-( #( B"&,$&B25#%( ?,''212%2BH<( #'(Y#'C#G(O)o( 2'( 5/$$&-B%H( &U?&$20&-B2-D(

A2B"(02-20/0(,$C&$(&U?,'/$&(B20&'*((O-(2B'(]J\o(&U5"#-D&(IF,$0&$%H(B"&(]"2%#C&%?"2#(4B,5N(

MU5"#-D&L<(Y#'C#G(?$,@2C&'(#(k)2-20/0(\2F&l(,$C&$(BH?&(B"#B(5#--,B(1&(5#-5&%&C(F,$(#B(%&#'B(

Page 49: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$(

=;;(02%%2'&5,-C'*( (>"&'&(,$C&$'($&5&2@&(#(%#$D&$($&1#B&(2F(B"&H(D,(,-B,(B"&(1,,N(#-C(#$&(%#B&$(

&U&5/B&C*((SF(2-(F#5B(B"2'(,$C&$(BH?&(2'(#C,?B&C(1H(',0&(,$C&$('/102BB&$'<(2B(A,/%C(1&(/'&F/%(B,(

'B/CH(B"&(&FF&5B'(,F(B"2'(2-2B2#B2@&*(

a-,B"&$(?,''21%&(A#H(B,(%202B(#(?,B&-B2#%(%#B&-5H(#$0'($#5&(2'(B,(5,-C/5B(F$&G/&-B(1#B5"(

#/5B2,-'<(?&$"#?'(,-&(&@&$H(=;;(02%%2'&5,-C'*((a%%(,$C&$'(B"#B(#$$2@&(?$2,$(B,(B"&(#/5B2,-(A,/%C(

$&5&2@&(&G/#%(B$&#B0&-B(2-(B"&(#/5B2,-<(',(B"&$&(A,/%C(1&(#%0,'B(-,(2-5&-B2@&(B,(1&(F2$'B(A2B"(#-(

,$C&$*( (>#2A#-&'&( &G/2BH(0#$N&B'( F,%%,A( B"2'( 1#'25(0,C&%<( #-C( 5$,''2-D(-&BA,$N'("#@&( ',0&(

'202%#$( ?$,?&$B2&'*( ( ]&$2,C25( 5$,''2-D( -&BA,$N'<( 2-5%/C2-D( S>`j'( ]O4S><( D&-&$#%%H( 0#B5"(

1/H&$'( #-C( '&%%&$'( #B( 5&$B#2-( ?,2-B'( C/$2-D( B"&( B$#C2-D( C#H<( #-C( B$#C&( B#N&'( ?%#5&( #B( B"&(

02C?,2-B(,F(B"&(Y33O(#B(B"&(B20&(,F(B"&(5$,''*((!$,''2-D(-&BA,$N'(#BB$#5B(#(0,C&'B(#0,/-B(,F(

B$#C2-D(@,%/0&<(1/B(B"&H('&&0(B,(1&(%,'2-D(D$,/-C(B,(,B"&$(N2-C'(,F(C#$N(?,,%'<(#-C(2F(B"&H(C,(

-,B(,?&$#B&(5,-B2-/,/'%H<(B"&H(B&-C(B,(1&($&%#B2@&%H(2-F$&G/&-B<(5$,''2-D('"#$&'(,-%H(#(F&A(B20&'(

?&$(C#H*((a(Z*4*(B$#C2-D(@&-/&(,FF&$2-D(F$&G/&-B(1#B5"(#/5B2,-'(A,/%C(1&(A,$B"H(,F('B/CH<(1/B(

#B(B"&(0,0&-B<(2B(C,&'(-,B(#??&#$(B"#B('/5"(#(@&-/&(2'(%2N&%H(B,(#??&#$*(

+

Q;F;+++9*2/,&)&*$+),(#$(2)&"#+)(3*$+

4,0&(?,%25H0#N&$'(A",(#$&('N&?B25#%(,F(B"&(@#%/&(,F(JK>("#@&(?$,?,'&C(#(B$#-'#5B2,-(

B#U( ,-( F2-#-52#%( 2-'B$/0&-B'( #'( #( A#H( ,F( %202B2-D( JK>( #-C( ,B"&$( k&U5&''2@&l( B$#C2-D( A"2%&(

$#2'2-D($&@&-/&(F,$(B"&(D,@&$-0&-B*((>"&$&("#@&(1&&-(#(-/01&$(,F(?$,?,'#%'<(C2FF&$2-D(2-(',0&(

,F(B"&(C&B#2%'<(1/B(#-(2%%/'B$#B2@&($&5&-B(&U#0?%&(2'(B"&(k\&B(W#%%(4B$&&B(]#H(F,$(B"&([&'B,$#B2,-(

,F()#2-(4B$&&B(a5B(,F(:;;g<l(#(?$,?,'#%(1H(4&-*(J#$N2-(#-C([&?*(Q&K#V2,(B"#B(A,/%C('/1P&5B(

0,'B('B,5N(0#$N&B(B$#-'#5B2,-'(2-(B"&(Z-2B&C(4B#B&'(B,(#(B#U(&G/#%(B,(;*:fe(,F(B"&(B$#-'#5B2,-(

@#%/&*(>$#C&'(2-(,B"&$(F2-#-52#%(#''&B'(A,/%C(#%',(1&('/1P&5B(B,(B#U(#B(@#$H2-D($#B&'*((

Page 50: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

$)

a(;*:fe(B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U(',/-C'(0,C&'B<(1/B(2B(A,/%C('"#$?%H(2-5$&#'&(2-@&'B,$'j(B$#C2-D(

5,'B'*( SF( #( $&B#2%( 2-@&'B,$( A#-B'( B,( B$#C&( =;;( '"#$&'( ,F( #( 'B,5N( A2B"( #( mf;( '"#$&( ?$25&<( B"#B(

2-@&'B,$(BH?25#%%H(?#H'(#(5,002''2,-(,F(%&''(B"#-(m=;<(#-C(?#H'(m=(B,(m:(2-(B"&(F,$0(,F(#(12CE#'N(

'?$&#C*( >"&( 5/$$&-B( 4M!( 4&5B2,-( 7=( B$#-'#5B2,-( F&&( ,F( ;*;;::8e( A,/%C( #CC( m;*==( B,( B"&(

2-@&'B,$j'( B#1*( a( ;*:fe( B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U( A,/%C( #CC( #-( #CC2B2,-#%( m=:*f;( B,( B"#B( B$#-'#5B2,-<(

0,$&(B"#-(C,/1%2-D(2B'(5,'B*(

K,$( #( BH?25#%(0/B/#%( F/-C<( B"&(12CE#'N( '?$&#C( #-C(?$25&( 20?#5B(02D"B( 20?,'&( 5,'B'(,F(

#$,/-C(f(5&-B'(F,$(&#5"(mf;('"#$&*(SB(02D"B(?#H(#-(#CC2B2,-#%(?&--H(?&$('"#$&(2-(5,002''2,-'*(

a( ;*:fe( B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U( A,/%C( 0&#-( #-( &UB$#( =:*f( 5&-B'( ?&$( '"#$&<( 0,$&( B"#-( B$2?%2-D( 2B'(

B$#C2-D( 5,'B'*( S-( #CC2B2,-<( B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U&'(A2%%( #FF&5B( B"&( $&B/$-'( ,F(0/B/#%( F/-C( 2-@&'B,$'<(

&@&-(2F(B"&(2-@&'B,$'(C,(-,B(1/H(,$('&%%(B"&2$(0/B/#%(F/-C('"#$&'*((M@&-(2-C&U(F/-C'(',0&B20&'(

"#@&( B,( B$#C&<( #-C( 2-( B"#B( 5#'&( 2-C&U( F/-C( 2-@&'B,$'(A,/%C( 1&#$( B"&( B#U( 1/$C&-*( S-( F#5B<( B"&(

S-@&'B0&-B(!,0?#-H(S-'B2B/B&(IS!SL(&'B20#B&'(B"#B(#(B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U(A,/%C(2-5$&#'&(B"&(#--/#%(

&U?&-'&'(2-5/$$&C(1H(2-C&U(F/-C(2-@&'B,$'(1H(,-&EB"2$C*((

a( B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U( A,/%C( #%',( 5#/'&( 'B,5N( ?$25&'( B,( F#%%<( 1&5#/'&( B"&( B#U( A,/%C( 1&(

#''&''&C( ,-( B"&( '#0&( '"#$&( ,F( 'B,5N( &@&$H( B20&( 2B( 5"#-D&'( "#-C'*( (>"&( ?$&'&-B( @#%/&( ,F( B"&(

$&?&#B&C(B#U(5#-(1&(G/2B&('/1'B#-B2#%<(#-C( 2B( 2'(5#?2B#%2V&C( 2-B,(?$25&'*( (>,(G/#-B2FH( B"&(&FF&5B<(

#''/0&( F,$( '20?%252BH( B"#B( #%%( 2-@&'B,$'( ",%C( #(0/B/#%( F/-C( B"#B( B$#C&'( 2B'( ?,$BF,%2,( ,-5&( ?&$(

H&#$(#-C(&U?&5B'(#(Te(#--/#%($&B/$-*((S-(#(A,$%C(A2B"(#(?&$0#-&-B(;*:fe(B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U<(B"&(

2-@&'B,$'j(B,B#%($&B/$-(-&B(,F(B"&(B#U(A,/%C(1&(,-%H(f*hfe*(S-@&'B,$'(A,/%C(%,'&(#1,/B(8*=he(Is(

;*:fe(n(T*;;eL(,F( B"&2$( B,B#%( $&B/$-(&#5"(H&#$( B,( B"&( B#U*( (4B,5N(?$25&'(A,/%C("#@&( B,( F#%%( 2-(

,$C&$( B,(0#2-B#2-( B"&( '#0&( #FB&$EB#U( $&B/$-'*( ( S-( B"2'( &U#0?%&<( 2-@&'B,$'(A,/%C( C$2@&( C,A-(

'B,5N(?$25&'(1H(B"&('#0&(8*=he(I0,$&(B"#-(f;;(?,2-B'(,-(B"&(Q,A(+,-&'(S-C/'B$2#%(a@&$#D&(#B(

5/$$&-B(%&@&%'L(2-(,$C&$(B,($&'B,$&(B"&(Te(-&B(B,B#%($&B/$-(B"&H($&G/2$&*(

Page 51: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

%*

4&5/$2B2&'( B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U&'(A,/%C( #%',( "#@&( #( C2$&5B( -&D#B2@&( &FF&5B( ,-( 'B,5N(0#$N&B(

%2G/2C2BH*( ( S-( B,C#Hj'( &G/2BH(0#$N&B'<(12CE#'N( '?$&#C'(#$&(,-&( 5&-B( F,$( #%0,'B( &@&$H( %#$D&E5#?(

'B,5N*(SF(0#$N&BE0#N&$'(#$&(#''&''&C(B"&(B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U<(B"&H(A,/%C(-&&C(B,(A2C&-(B"&2$(12CE

#'N( '?$&#C'( B,( $&5,/?( B"&( B#U*( (!,-B2-/2-D( B"&( &#$%2&$( &U#0?%&<( B"2'(A,/%C(1&(=:*f( 5&-B'(?&$(

'"#$&(/-C&$(5/$$&-B(?$,?,'#%'( F,$(#('B,5N(A2B"(#('"#$&(?$25&(,F(mf;*( (a'(#($&'/%B<(12C(#-C(#'N(

?$25&'( A,/%C(0,@&( F/$B"&$( #?#$B*( S-@&'B,$'( A,/%C( ?#H(0,$&( B,( 1/H( #-C( '&%%( &G/2B2&'<( #-C( 2B(

02D"B(B#N&(0,$&(B20&(B,(F2-C(#(A2%%2-D(?#$BH(B,(B#N&(B"&(,B"&$('2C&(,F(B"&(B$#C&*()#$N&B'(A,/%C(

1&5,0&( %&''( %2G/2C<( #-C( B"2'( 2%%2G/2C2BH(02D"B(A,$'&-( B"&(C,A-A#$C(?$&''/$&( ,-( '"#$&(?$25&'(

C2'5/''&C(&#$%2&$*(

>$#-'#5B2,-(B#U&'(0#H(#%',(A,$'&-('B,5N(0#$N&B(@,%#B2%2BH*(>$#-'#5B2,-(B#U(?$,?,-&-B'(

,FB&-('/DD&'B(B"#B(5/$$&-B(%&@&%'(,F(B$#C2-D(#5B2@2BH(0/'B(1&(5$&#B2-D(&U5&''(@,%#B2%2BH(2-('B,5N(

?$25&'<( #-C( B"2'( @,%#B2%2BH( 5#-( 1&( $&C/5&C( 1H( B"$,A2-D( '#-C( 2-( B"&( B$#C2-D( D&#$'( @2#( #(

B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U*(>"2'(2'(#-(#??&#%2-D(#$D/0&-Bt%&''(B$#C2-D(0&#-'(%&''(@,%#B2%2BHt1/B(2B(C,&'(

-,B(0#B5"( B"&( C#B#*( S-( F#5B<( +,-&'( #-C( 4&D/2-( I=gghL( #-C( ,B"&$'( F2-C( B"#B( B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U&'(

2-5$&#'&(@,%#B2%2BH*(>"&(2-B/2B2,-(2'(B"#B(2F(B$#C2-D(2'(&U?&-'2@&<('B,5N(?$25&'(0/'B(C&?#$B(F/$B"&$(

F$,0( F/-C#0&-B#%( @#%/&( 1&F,$&( #-H(0#$N&B( ?#$B252?#-B( "#'( #-( &5,-,025( 2-B&$&'B( 2-( 1$2-D2-D(

B"&0(1#5N(2-B,(%2-&*(>"/'<(B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U&'(A,/%C(A,$'&-(1,B"(@,%#B2%2BH(#-C(B"&(&FF252&-5H(,F(

?$25&'*(

`2@&-( B"&'&( ?$,1%&0'<( 2B( 2'( -,B( '/$?$2'2-D( B"#B( ,B"&$( 5,/-B$2&'( "#@&( 2-B$,C/5&C(

B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U&'( #-C( B"&-( $&?&#%&C( B"&0( #( '",$B( B20&( %#B&$<( ,-5&( #%%( B"&( &FF&5B'( 1&5#0&(

#??#$&-B*(4A&C&-(?$,@2C&'(#-( 2-'B$/5B2@&(C#B#(?,2-B<(#'(#-#%HV&C( 2-(Z0%#/F( I=gg7L*( ( S-(=g^8<(

4A&C&-( 2-B$,C/5&C( #( =e( B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U<( #-C( B"&( B#U( $#B&( C,/1%&C( BA,( H&#$'( %#B&$*( a%0,'B(

200&C2#B&%H<( #1,/B( T;e( ,F( B$#C2-D( @,%/0&( 2-( B"&( 0,'B( #5B2@&( 4A&C2'"( 'B,5N'( 0,@&C( F$,0(

4B,5N",%0( B,( \,-C,-*( >"&( 4A&C2'"( 'B,5N( 0#$N&B( F&%%( 1H( f*7e( A"&-( B"&( B#U( A#'( 2-2B2#%%H(

Page 52: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

%!

#--,/-5&C<(2-5$&#'2-D(B"&(5,'B(,F(&G/2BH(5#?2B#%(F,$(4A&C2'"(F2$0'*((S-(F#5B<(,A2-D(B,(B"&('B,5N(

?$25&(C&5%2-&'(#-C(B"&($&C/5&C(%&@&%(,F(B$#C2-D<(4A&C2'"(5#?2B#%(D#2-'(B#U($&5&2?B'(#5B/#%%H(F&%%(

1H(0,$&(B"#-(B"&(#0,/-B(,F( B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U(5,%%&5B&C*(>"/'<( 2-(#CC2B2,-(B,( 2B'(,B"&$(-&D#B2@&(

&FF&5B'<(B"&(B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U(&@&-(F#2%&C(B,($#2'&($&@&-/&*((4A&C&-(&%202-#B&C(2B'(B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U(

2-(=gg=<(1/B(B"&(5,/-B$H(-&@&$($&D#2-&C(2B'(?$&@2,/'('"#$&(,F(B$#C2-D(2-(4A&C2'"('B,5N'*()/5"(

,F(B"&(B$#C2-D(#-C(B"&($&%#B&C(P,1'('20?%H('B#H&C(2-(\,-C,-*((

O@&$#%%<( B"&(#5#C&025( &@2C&-5&( 2-C25#B&'( B"#B( 2-5$&#'&C( B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U&'(A2%%( 2-5$&#'&(

@,%#B2%2BH<($&C/5&(?$25&(&FF252&-5H<(#-C(A,$'&-(%2G/2C2BH*((4&5/$2B2&'(B$#-'#5B2,-(B#U&'(A,/%C(#%',(

2-5$&#'&( B$#C2-D( 5,'B'( #-C( 5#/'&( B$#C2-D( B,( 0,@&( ,FF'",$&*( ( ),'B( 20?,$B#-B%H<( '&5/$2B2&'(

B$#-'#5B2,-( B#U&'( A,/%C( %,A&$( 'B,5N( ?$25&'( #-C( 2-5$&#'&( B"&( 5,'B( ,F( &G/2BH( 5#?2B#%( F,$( F2$0'<(

$&C/52-D(5,$?,$#B&(2-@&'B0&-B(#-C(C#0#D2-D(`Q]*(

!

ASB!!<'+4J-E.'+E!

3#'&C( ,-( B"&( @#'B( 0#P,$2BH( ,F( B"&( &0?2$25#%( A,$N( B,( C#B&<( JK>( #-C( #/B,0#B&C<(

5,0?&B2-D( B$#C2-D( @&-/&'( "#@&( '/1'B#-B2#%%H( 20?$,@&C(0#$N&B( %2G/2C2BH( #-C( $&C/5&C( B$#C2-D(

5,'B'( F,$( #%%( 2-@&'B,$'*( ( 4"#$&( ?$25&'( #$&( #%0,'B( '/$&%H("2D"&$( #'( #( $&'/%B( ,F( B"2'( $&C/5B2,-( 2-(

B$#C2-D( 5,'B'<( 1&-&F2B2-D( %,-DEB&$0( 2-@&'B,$'*( ( J2D"&$( '"#$&( ?$25&'( #%',( "#@&( F#@,$#1%&(

20?%25#B2,-'( F,$( F2$0'j(5,'B(,F(&G/2BH(5#?2B#%*( (W2B"(#( %,A&$(5,'B(,F(5#?2B#%<( F2$0'(#$&( %2N&%H( B,(

2-@&'B(0,$&<(A2B"(5,00&-'/$#B&(2-5$&#'&'(2-(`Q](#-C(,B"&$(0&#'/$&'(,F(&5,-,025(#5B2@2BH*(

S-( '?&52F25( B&$0'<(JK>("#'( '"#$?%H( 2-5$&#'&C( 5,0?&B2B2,-( 2-(0#$N&BE0#N2-D<( #-C(12CE

#'N('?$&#C'(#$&(0/5"(-#$$,A&$(#'(#($&'/%B*((4B,5N(?$25&'(#$&(0,$&(&FF252&-B(#'(#($&'/%B(,F(JK>(

#5B2@2BH*((O@&$#%%<(B"&$&(2'(-,(&@2C&-5&(,F(#-H(#C@&$'&(&FF&5B(C/&(B,(JK>(2-(B"&(#@&$#D&($&'/%B'*(

]&$"#?'(B"&(,-%H(5,-5&$-('/??,$B&C(1H(B"&(C#B#(2'(B"#B(JK>(0#H(-,B("&%?(B,('B#12%2V&(

?$25&'(C/$2-D(/-/'/#%%H(@,%#B2%&(?&$2,C'*((>"&(F%#'"(5$#'"(,F()#H(T<(:;=;<(A"&-(B"&(4d](f;;(F&%%(

Page 53: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

%"

1H(#%0,'B(=;e(2-(B"&('?#5&(,F(%&''(B"#-(=f(02-/B&'<(A#'(-,B(5#/'&C(1H(JK>(1/B(1H(#(0/B/#%(

F/-Cj'( '/102''2,-( ,F( #( $#?2C( '&G/&-5&( ,F( %#$D&( '&%%( ,$C&$'( C/$2-D( #( @,%#B2%&( B$#C2-D( '&''2,-*((

S-2B2#%%H<(JK>( #-C( ,B"&$( 2-B&$0&C2#$2&'( "&%?&C( B,( 'B#12%2V&( ?$25&'( 1H( 1/H2-D<( 1/B(JK>(A&$&(

',,-( ,@&$A"&%0&C( #-C( $#?2C%H( %2G/2C#B&C( B"&2$( ?,'2B2,-'( 1H( '&%%2-D( 'B,5N'( #-C( 4d]( F/B/$&'(

5,-B$#5B'<( B"&$&1H(&U#5&$1#B2-D( B"&(C&5%2-&*( (J,A&@&$<( B"&$&(#$&(0#-H("2'B,$25#%( 5#'&'(A"&$&(

2-B&$0&C2#$2&'( 'B&?( #'2C&( #B( B20&'(,F( &UB$&0&(@,%#B2%2BH<( ',( B"2'( #??&#$'( B,(1&( #( F#2$%H(D&-&$25(

F&#B/$&(,F(&G/2BH(0#$N&B'($#B"&$(B"#-(#('?&52F25(?$,1%&0(A2B"(JK>*(

a(-/01&$(,F($&D/%#B,$H(2''/&'(#$&(1&2-D(5,-'2C&$&C(B"#B(5,/%C(#FF&5B(JK>*((4,0&(-&A(

?,%252&'<( '/5"( #'( '",$BEB&$0( ?$25&( %202B'( #-C( 52$5/2B( 1$&#N&$'<( '&&0( A&%%E5$#FB&C( B,( #CC$&''(

'?&52F25(?$,1%&0'(B"#B(#$,'&(C/$2-D(B"&(F%#'"(5$#'"*((OB"&$(02-,$($&D/%#B,$H(BA&#N'('/5"(#'(N2%%(

'A2B5"&'( 0#H( 1&( 2-( ,$C&$<( 1/B( B",'&( F,$0/%#B2-D( ?,%25H( '",/%C( 1&( &'?&52#%%H( 5#$&F/%( -,B( B,(

$&@&$'&( B"&( %2G/2C2BH( 20?$,@&0&-B'( B"#B( A&( "#@&( &U?&$2&-5&C( 2-( B"&( Z*4*( ,@&$( B"&( ?#'B( F&A(

C&5#C&'*(

! !

Page 54: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

%#

;)1)2)+4)E!

3#$,-<()#BB"&A<(+,-#B"#-(3$,D##$C<(#-C(a-C$&2(X2$2%&-N,(I:;=:L<(k>"&(B$#C2-D(?$,F2B'(,F("2D"EF$&G/&-5H(B$#C&$'<l(Y,@&01&$(:;=:(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(Z-2@&$'2BH(,F(W#'"2-DB,-*(

3&-,'<(M@#-D&%,'(#-C(4#B5"2B(4#D#C&(I:;=:L<(kJ2D"EF$&G/&-5H(B$#C2-D(1&"#@2,/$(#-C(2B'(20?#5B(,-(0#$N&B(G/#%2BH9(&@2C&-5&(F$,0(B"&(ZX(&G/2BH(0#$N&B<l(3#-N(,F(M-D%#-C(W,$N2-D(]#?&$(Y,*(8Tg<(Q&5&01&$(:;=:*(

3,&"0&$<( MNN&"#$B<( X2-D'%&H( K,-D<( #-C( +/%2&( W/( I:;=:L<( kS-B&$-#B2,-#%( &@2C&-5&( ,-(#%D,$2B"025(B$#C2-D<l(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(MQJM!*(

3,&"0&$<(MNN&"#$B<(!"#$%&'()*(+,-&'<(#-C(o2#,H#-(q"#-D(I:;=:L<(k4"#5N%2-D('",$B('&%%&$'9((B"&(:;;^('",$B2-D(1#-<l(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(MQJM!*(

32#2'<( 3$/-,<( >"2&$$H( K,/5#/%B<( #-C( 4,?"2&( ),2-#'<( kMG/2%21$2/0( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H( B$#C2-D<l(O5B,1&$( =8<( :;==( A,$N2-D( ?#?&$<( #@#2%#1%&( #B( "BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs:;:87T;<( $&B$2&@&C()#H(7=<(:;=:*(

3$,D##$C<(+,-#B"#-(I:;==#L<(k>"&(#5B2@2BH(,F("2D"(F$&G/&-5H(B$#C&$'<l(Q&5&01&$(:;==(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=g7^hTg<($&B$2&@&C()#H(:g<(:;=:*(

3$,D##$C<( +,-#B"#-( I:;==1L<( kJ2D"( F$&G/&-5H( B$#C2-D( #-C( 0#$N&B( G/#%2BH<l( Q&5&01&$( :;==(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B(("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=gh;;h:<($&B$2&@&C()#H(:g<(:;=:*(

3$,D##$C<( +,-#B"#-( I:;=:L<( kJ2D"( F$&G/&-5H(B$#C2-D(#-C(@,%#B2%2BH<l( +#-/#$H(:<(:;=:(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=T8=7^h<($&B$2&@&C()#H(:g<(:;=:*(

Q,0,A2BV<( S#-( I:;=;L<( k>#N&( "&&C( B"&( %&'',-'( F$,0( B"&( =gT:( F%#'"( 5$#'"l<( +/-&( :=<( :;=;<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nnAAA*#C@#-5&CB$#C2-D*5,0n&U5"#-D&'n::fh;;^^^<($&B$2&@&C()#H(:g<(:;=:*(

M#'%&H<( Q#@2C<( >&$$&-5&( J&-C&$'",BB<( #-C( >#$/-( [#0#C,$#2( I:;;gL<( k\&@&%%2-D( B"&( B$#C2-D(F2&%C<l(Y,@&01&$(=g<(:;;g(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(Z!(3&$N&%&H*(

M#'%&H<(Q#@2C<()#$5,'()*(\,?&V(C&(]$#C,<(#-C()#/$&&-(OuJ#$#(I:;==L<(k>"&(025$,'B$/5B/$&(,F(B"&( vF%#'"( 5$#'"j9( F%,A( B,U252BH<( %2G/2C2BH( 5$#'"&'( #-C( B"&( ?$,1#12%2BH( ,F( 2-F,$0&C( B$#C2-D<l(+,/$-#%(,F(],$BF,%2,()#-#D&0&-B(7hI:L9==^E=:^*(

M#'%&H<(Q#@2C<()#$5,'()*( \,?&V( C&( ]$#C,<( #-C()#/$&&-(OuJ#$#( I:;=:L<( kK%,A( B,U252BH( #-C(%2G/2C2BH(2-(#("2D"(F$&G/&-5H(A,$%C<l([&@2&A(,F(K2-#-52#%(4B/C2&'(:fIfL9=8fhE=8g7*(

MDD2-B,-<(+#$&C(K*<(3,--2&(K*(6#-(Y&''<(#-C([,1&$B(a*(6#-(Y&''<(kr/,B&('B/FF2-D<l()#$5"(=f<(:;=:(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=gf^:^=<($&B$2&@&C()#H(7;<(:;=:*(

K,/5#/%B<(>"2&$$H<(+,"#-(J,01&$B<(#-C(S,#-2C([,'/(I:;=:L<(kY&A'(B$#C2-D(#-C('?&&C<l(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(JM!*(

`#2<( +2#C2-D<( !"&-( b#,<( #-C()#,( b&( I:;=:L<( k>"&( &UB&$-#%2B2&'( ,F( "2D"EF$&G/&-5H( B$#C2-D<l(Y,@&01&$(=T<(:;=:(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(Z-2@&$'2BH(,F(S%%2-,2'*(

Page 55: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

%$

`%,'B&-<( \#A$&-5&( [*( #-C( ]#/%( [*( )2%D$,0( I=g^fL<( k32C<( #'N( #-C( B$#-'#5B2,-( ?$25&'( 2-( #('?&52#%2'B( 0#$N&B( A2B"( "&B&$,D&-&,/'%H( 2-F,$0&C( B$#C&$'<l( +,/$-#%( ,F( K2-#-52#%( M5,-,025'(=89h=E=;;*(

J#'1$,/5N<( +,&%( #-C( `2C&,-( 4##$( I:;=:L<( k\,A( %#B&-5H( B$#C2-D<l( A,$N2-D( ?#?&$<( Y&A( b,$N(Z-2@&$'2BH*(

J&-C&$'",BB<(>&$$&-5&<(!"#$%&'()*( +,-&'<( #-C(a%1&$B( +*()&-N@&%C( I:;==L<( kQ,&'( #%D,$2B"025(B$#C2-D(20?$,@&(%2G/2C2BHRl(+,/$-#%(,F(K2-#-5&(TTI=L9=E77*(

J&-C&$'",BB<( >&$$&-5&( #-C( [H#-( [2,$C#-( I:;==L<( kJ2D"( F$&G/&-5H( B$#C2-D( #-C( ?$25&(C2'5,@&$H<l(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(Z!(3&$N&%&H*(

J&-C&$'",BB<( >&$$&-5&( #-C( [H#-( [2,$C#-( I:;=:L<( ka%D,$2B"025( B$#C2-D( #-C( B"&( 0#$N&B( F,$(%2G/2C2BH<l(F,$B"5,02-D<(+,/$-#%(,F(K2-#-52#%(#-C(r/#-B2B#B2@&(a-#%H'2'*(

+,@#-,@25<(3,H#-(#-C(a%1&$B(+*()&-N@&%C(I:;==L<(k)2CC%&0&-(2-(%202BE,$C&$(0#$N&B'<l(O5B,1&$(:8<( :;==( A,$N2-D( ?#?&$<( #@#2%#1%&( #B( "BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=T:87:g<( $&B$2&@&C( )#H( :^<(:;=:*(

+,-&'<(!"#$%&'()*(#-C(]#/%(+*(4&D/2-(I=gghL<(k>$#-'#5B2,-(5,'B'(#-C(?$25&(@,%#B2%2BH9((&@2C&-5&(F$,0(5,002''2,-(C&$&D/%#B2,-<l(a0&$25#-(M5,-,025([&@2&A(^hI8L9h:^Eh7h*(

X2$2%&-N,<(a-C$&2(a*<(XH%&<(a%1&$B(4*<(4#0#C2<()&"$C#C(#-C(>/V/-<(>/DN#-(I:;==L<(k>"&(F%#'"(5$#'"9( B"&( 20?#5B(,F("2D"( F$&G/&-5H(B$#C2-D(,-(#-(&%&5B$,-25(0#$N&B<l()#H(:T<(:;==(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=T^T;;8<($&B$2&@&C()#H(:g<(:;=:*(

)#C"#@#-<( a-#-B"( I:;=:L<( kMU5"#-D&EB$#C&C( F/-C'<( 0#$N&B( 'B$/5B/$&( #-C( B"&( F%#'"( 5$#'"<l(+#-/#$H( =7<( :;=:( A,$N2-D( ?#?&$<( #@#2%#1%&( #B( "BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=g7:g:f<( $&B$2&@&C()#H(:g<(:;=:*((

)#$B2-&V<(625B,$(J/D,(#-C(S,#-2C([,'/(I:;==L<(kJ2D"(F$&G/&-5H(B$#C&$'<(-&A'(#-C(@,%#B2%2BH<l(Q&5&01&$(:g<( :;==(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<( #@#2%#1%&( #B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=^fg:Tf<( $&B$2&@&C()#H(7=<(:;=:*(

)5S-2'"<( >",0#'( J*<( +#0&'( Z?',-<( #-C( [,1&$B( a*(W,,C( I:;=:L<( k>"&( F%#'"( 5$#'"9( B$#C2-D(#DD$&''2@&-&''<( %2G/2C2BH( '/??%H<( #-C( B"&( 20?#5B( ,F( 2-B&$0#$N&B( 'A&&?(,$C&$'<l()#H(:7<( :;=:(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=T:g8;:<($&B$2&@&C()#H(:g<(:;=:*(

)&-N@&%C<(a%1&$B(+*(I:;=:L<(kJ2D"(F$&G/&-5H(B$#C2-D(#-C(B"&(-&AE0#$N&B(0#N&$'<l(K&1$/#$H(T<(:;=:(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=h::g:8<($&B$2&@&C()#H(:^<(:;=:*(

),#%%&02<(!2#0#5(!*(#-C()&"0&B(4#D%#0(I:;==L<(k>"&(5,'B(,F(%#B&-5Hl<()#H(:h<(:;==(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=fh=g7f<($&B$2&@&C()#H(7;<(:;=:*(

]#D-,BB#<( M02%2#-,( #-C( >",0#'( ]"2%2??,-( I:;=:L<( k!,0?&B2-D( ,-( '?&&C<l( a?$2%( :h<( :;=:(A,$N2-D(?#?&$<(#@#2%#1%&(#B("BB?9nn''$-*5,0n#1'B$#5Bs=gTh=fT<($&B$2&@&C()#H(7=<(:;=:*(

Page 56: Jones (2013) what do we know about high frequency trading?

%%

[2,$C#-<( [H#-( #-C( a-C$&#'( 4B,$N&-0#2&$( I:;=:L<( k\#B&-5H<( %2G/2C2BH( #-C( ?$25&( C2'5,@&$H<l(F,$B"5,02-D<(+,/$-#%(,F(K2-#-52#%()#$N&B'*(

Z0%#/F<(4B&@&-([*( I=gg7L<( k>$#-'#5B2,-(B#U&'(#-C(B"&(1&"#@2,$(,F(B"&(4A&C2'"('B,5N(0#$N&B<l(+,/$-#%(,F(K2-#-52#%(M5,-,025'(77I:L9::hE:8;*(

Z-2B&C( 4B#B&'( !,00,C2B2&'( #-C( K/B/$&'( >$#C2-D( !,002''2,-( #-C( 4&5/$2B2&'( #-C( MU5"#-D&(!,002''2,-( I:;=;L<( kK2-C2-D'( $&D#$C2-D( B"&( 0#$N&B( &@&-B'( ,F()#H( T<( :;=;<l( [&?,$B( ,F( B"&(4B#FF'(,F(B"&(!K>!(#-C(4M!(B,(B"&(+,2-B(aC@2',$H(!,002BB&&(,-(M0&$D2-D([&D/%#B,$H(S''/&'<(4&?B&01&$(7;<(:;=;*(

(

(