John Brooks Company Limited - Alberta Onsite Wastewater ...John Brooks Company Limited . Gravity vs...
Transcript of John Brooks Company Limited - Alberta Onsite Wastewater ...John Brooks Company Limited . Gravity vs...
-
John Brooks Company
Limited
-
Gravity vs Low Pressure
Systems
March 5, 2015
-
Introduction
•Requires minimal environmental disruption
•Solves difficult sewer applications
•Proven, reliable technology
•Saves money
LPS: An Alternative Sewage Collection System
-
The System
• A grinder pump station
is located in the yard or
basement of each home.
• Sewage flows into the
station from the
building’s sewer line
(typically 4-inch).
• The basin contains a
specially-designed
grinder pump with
integral level controls.
-
The System
• The pump is activated when
the depth of sewage in the
tank reaches a
predetermined “on” level
and continues to run until it
reaches the “off” level.
• The run time is short, power
consumption is low, and a
long pump life is ensured.
• The pump grinds the
sewage into a fine slurry
and discharges it into the
sewer main.
ALARM
ON
OFF
-
The System
The grinder pumps are
connected to a small-diameter,
low pressure main laid along
the edge of the roadway,
following the contour of the
land. The low pressure main
delivers the wastewater
to a central treatment
system, lift station,
manhole, or force main.
Transporting sewage
several thousand feet to a
discharge point at a higher
elevation is commonly
accomplished with low
pressure sewers.
-
The System
-
A New Option for
Builders and Developers
E/One Sewers provide builders and developers with
cost-effective, high-quality, proven solutions for central
sewers.
-
Discover New Freedom
in Land Planning
Land projects or orphan sites once considered cost
prohibitive to develop can now generate profits.
-
Reduce Upfront Costs. Increase Profit Margins.
Infrastructure development costs are lowered
• Major excavation is eliminated
• Labor and material costs are dramatically reduced
• Environmental disruption and restoration are
minimized
E/One Low Pressure Sewers are your solution
for financial success
-
Your Alternative
to Gravity
-
Gravity Systems
With conventional gravity sewers:
• Wastewater leaves the home and flows down sloped
pipes
• Because wastewater can only flow downhill so far, it is
necessary for a lift station to pump it up, so that
gravity can take over again
• The lift station process occurs as many times as
necessary to get the wastewater to the treatment
facility
• Each lift station can occupy a potentially marketable
lot or brutalize sight lines
-
Gravity Systems
Gravity sewers require big equipment,
major excavation and lift stations.
-
A better solution with obvious advantages.
• E/One Sewer Systems do not rely upon the limitations of gravity
• Wastewater is pumped through small diameter pipes following the contour of the land, set just below the frost line
• Lift stations are eliminated in virtually every installation
E/One Sewer Systems
-
E/One Sewer Systems
E/One Sewers
cause minimal
disruption because
they are placed in
narrow, shallow
trenches.
-
Directional boring
can eliminate the
need for trenches.
E/One Sewer Systems
-
The bigger the pipe, the higher the costs.
Gravity sewers require mains up to 24 inches in diameter.
Gravity Systems
-
Smaller pipes dramatically reduce
up-front costs.
E/One Sewers start with
1 ¼- inch PVC piping
from the home to 2- to 4-
inch PVC force mains.
E/One Sewer Systems
Which would you rather buy and install
five miles of: 4” or 24” pipe?
-
Gravity Sewers
bury your capital
in the ground.
They require:
• Time and money with
big equipment
• Major excavation and
restoration
• Expensive materials
High labor costs
All Up-Front Costs
Gravity Systems
-
The Money Story
-
Total Savings
The E/One Sewer System can
reduce costs by 50% or more
compared to conventional
gravity systems.
-
Cost per Linear Foot Comparison
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
6' Deep 12' Deep 18' Deep 2" Dia 3" Dia 4" Dia
$ per Linear Foot
Gravity
(8” pipe) E/One Sewer
(Average depth 3-4 feet)
-
The E/One Sewers cut up-front costs
and reduce installation time.
• Reduced carrying costs
• Deferred material and infrastructure costs
• Requires only shallow, narrow trenches
• Fewer manholes and lift stations
• Accelerated infrastructure development
E/One Sewer Systems
-
Spending Delayed Until House is Built
The cost of the pump and installation is deferred until
just prior to closing.
E/One Sewer Systems
-
• Flexibility in development design and sight lines; no deforestation
• Performance – more than 35 years experience; over 500,000 users worldwide
• Environmental safety – closed system eliminates groundwater contamination from failed septic tanks
• E/One Sewers can be specified for virtually all site conditions
• Groundwater infiltration eliminated by pressure-tight mains, minimizing size of treatment plant
Additional Benefits
-
Gravity
Systems:
Gravity Systems
Burying Your Money
in the Ground!
-
Cost Comparison: Saw Creek, PA
Hilly terrain with a high water table
2,500 units installed
Savings: $3,043,000 or 49%
$ M
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Gravity E/One
-
Cost Comparison: Weatherby Lake, MO
Rolling hills waterfront
300+ units installed
Savings: $3,400,000 or 55%
$ M
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Gravity E/One
-
Cost Comparison: Hartland Township, MI
Steep shorelines
590 units installed
Savings: $1,164,000 or 17%
$ M
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
Gravity E/One
-
Savings: $5,569,000 or 43%
Cost Comparison: High Springs, FL
Flat terrain with significant hard rock sub-surface
1,350 units projected
$ M
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Gravity E/One
-
Cost Comparison: Hood’s Hollow, WI
Environmentally sensitive land with a running creek
29 units installed
Savings: $147,000 or 31%
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
400
450
Gravity E/One
$ 000s
-
Riverview Landing
Fairfield Glade
Case Studies
-
An elegant country estate community in upstate New York
Riverview Landing
-
Developing this
spectacular 160-acre
site overlooking the
historic Mohawk River
was cost-prohibitive
for a conventional
gravity system.
The Land
-
The Problem
• Steep, rocky terrain
• Dense clay soil mixed with weathered shale
-
• E/One Sewer System using 1 1/4-inch PVC piping
• 3-inch street mains at a depth of only 5 feet
E/One Sewers saved more than $100,000, cutting up-front
costs by more than 50%.
The Solution
-
Country Estate Community
• 42 estate homes
• Price range: $400,000 to
$1,000,000
• 2- to 4-acre lots
• Golf course, fish ponds,
tennis courts and boat
slips on the Mohawk
Riverview Landing Today
-
“We had to provide an on-site sewage disposal
solution. There were no public sewers available.
E/One’s low pressure sewer system was the only
economical and feasible way to go. In doing so, we
saved over $100,000.”
“We saved over $100,000…”
Michael Mastropietro Consulting Engineer
Riverview Landing
-
A resort and retirement community in Tennessee
Fairfield Glade
-
Eleven lakes
scattered throughout
a picturesque
wooded setting in the
Cumberland
Mountains presented
a unique challenge
for developers.
Spectacular lake-front sites set high in the Cumberland
Mountains (the elevations range between 1,665 feet and
3,000 feet) promised to be a dream setting for upscale
homeowners. Yet these same qualities presented a
unique challenge for developers.
The Land
-
• Sub-surface
sandstone
• Extensive lake
frontage
• Wide range of
elevations
Fairfield Glade sits on a hard-to-blast sandstone. The
waterfront properties and rolling elevations made gravity
sewering largely impractical.
The Problem
-
• Installing 31 miles of
E/One Sewer
• Connecting 2- and 6-inch
PVC pressure mains to
existing gravity mains
E/One Sewers saved this community of 1,300
(and growing) more than $1,000,000 to date.
Average annual maintenance costs are less than
$30 per home – 30% below projections.
The Solution
-
A Spectacular Resort and Retirement Community
• 3,500 homes built around 11 lakes
• Estimated population of 5,000
• Four golf courses
Fairfield Glade Today
-
“We run careful economic studies for each new sewer
distribution project. Study factors include: first cost, tap
cost, maintenance cost, and interest. Having the option
to use low pressure sewers has saved the Fairfield
Glade community in the neighborhood of $1,000,000
over the past 13 years.”
“We saved over $1,000,000
over the last 13 years…”
Thomas V. Swaford VP, Engineering
Fairfield Glade, Inc.