james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l...

97

Transcript of james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l...

Page 1: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

����������� ������������������������������� !�#"���$%������

�'&)(�*,+!��+-�� !*,+!*,���*,"

.�/

0 ���*,+)&1� /#2 �� 435*%64��+�78 !����* 2 9�����

&:�

����������*, �;#$,��*,��$,*

���<���� =��>� 2@? � 2BA�2�2 �*,���C� ? �(�*D(������� !+4 !*,EF���� !*,�*,���+

? �� C�(�*D"�*,G� !*,*H� ?

I ��$�(�* 2 �� )� ? �� =�+

J �� =K��� !"L��� 2�2 *,G�*

�C�� . !��"�G�*�MONL��+!+��$�(F��+!*%�!�+

���� !� 2QP M5RTS�S�S

Page 2: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

���

Page 3: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� �����������

� ����������������������� ��! "�$#%'&!( �")+*-, &�./( ,'0214350768, (9&!( �:3 .�;< = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ��! ?A@ �") ( 3�B9C = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ?�! DAE B9350 @F& BHGJI & B9K ( 3MLFN:O�3�B � (9% 0P) > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = D�! Q L+RS35, (UTU% �") TU% K�) �") > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = Q�! VXW , ( N�� . K = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = V

Y[Z<\J��]�^`_a\J�����5\8bdc>��^`be�e_f�e��\'�!��^hg i?h "�$jk./( B93`G','l ( �:3 .m > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n?h ?ATU% Ko1pN & )9) �"l & N�qUK & N"0 = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n

?h ?h "� Lsr � (t > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n?h ?h ? uh(9&!( K�) &�. G W R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K�) > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = y?h ?h DzT B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = |

?h DATU% K>}~B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"lFqUK & N"0 > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = |?h Dh "��uh(9&!( K�) &�. G W R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . ) > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = |?h Dh ?zT B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ��w�?h Dh DzTU% K>� � . K & B+LFN:O�KwR'B & 3�{ & }~B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"l+r � (� > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ����

?h QXTU% Ko*-, &�./( ,'0�qUK & N"0 = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ���??h QJ "��uh(9&!( K�)w���mK & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )w� &�. G T B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ���??h QJ ? L�*-, &�./( ,'0���� & 0768N:K > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ���D

?h VATU% K @F& G & 0 & BHGmqU3 (9&!( �:3 .� > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ���Q?h � � & B9O�KwB=*-, &�./( ,'0 u C`) ( K�0P) > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ����?h n �mK & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = ���y?h y Lsr � ( 3�{�} % �"N:35)v3�6 % C = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2?!�

�����

Page 4: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�:x �������������

�� M��\8����� _��m\'����� \'��^ Y��Dh "� W x�KwB9x �:KwI > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2?`�Dh ? j 3 .mT B & 6 = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2?�?Dh D�� � q > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2?�QDh Q } % 3 ( 3 . �"lw) > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2?��Dh V *-, &�./( ,'0��F3 ( ) = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2?5nDh � L . C�3 . ) = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2?�y

�� M��\8����� _��o]�^h�8��� � �QJ "� TU% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N��m3`GJK�N")p3�{d*-, &�./( ,'0214350768, (9&!( �:3 . = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D`�

QJ "�! "� *-, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O7� & l % � . K�) > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D`�QJ "�! ? *-, &�./( ,'0 14K�N"N",'N & B LF, ( 350 &!(9& > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D�?QJ "�! D LFl�C`lwN��"lo*-, &�./( ,'021 �:BHlw, � ( ) = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D�DQJ "�! Q 1 �:BHlw, � ( ) &�. G T ,JB � . O7� & l % � . K�)-1435076 & B9K�G > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D�Q

QJ ? *-, &�./( ,'0 14350768, (9& R �"N�� ( C TU% Kw3�B9C = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D��QJ ?h "� L+6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( � . O T B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D��QJ ?h ? L�� . �:x�KwBH) & N�*-, &�./( ,'0�� &!( K > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D��QJ ?h D WF(9% KwB � . �:x�KwBH) & N!� &!( K�) > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2D�y

"# M��\8����� _%$ �����/� � ��g ���Vh "� W x�KwB9x �:KwI > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �Q'�Vh ? �FK . KwB & N�qUKwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K u �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . ) > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �Q/?Vh D � . �:x�KwBH) & N qUKwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K&� &!( K�) > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �Q�QVh Q qUK �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O E'& 0 �"N�� & B E , . l ( �:3 . ) > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �Q/�

Vh QJ "� LFG'G � ( �:3 . = > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �QhnVh QJ ? �m3`G','N & BULFG'G � ( �:3 . &�. G r4KwC�3 . G = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �Qhn

Page 5: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

������������� x

�� M��\8����� _ c>�����8��\8_f_f�e��� ���

�h "� }~B93�R8N:K�0P)p3�{d*-, &�./( ,'0�}~B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �Q/|�h "�! "� }~B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O7{�3�B-1 �:BHlw, � ( ) = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �Q/|�h "�! ? }~B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O � . � (9& B9C T B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = �Q/|

�h ? }~B9Kwx�K ./( � . O � 3 .�� � . � (9& B9C T B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V`��h ?h "� qUKwx�KwBH) �:R �"N�� ( C & ) T Ch6 � . O > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V�?�h ?h ? � . ��h,JK . K�)9) T Ch6SK�) > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V�?�h ?h D � � . K & B+� 3�O �"l = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V�Q�h ?h Q }~B9Kw6 & B &!( �:3 . �'�mK & )9,JB9K�07K ./( � &�. G qUKwx�KwBH) & N > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V��

�h DXWF(9% KwB+}~B93�O�B & 0P0 � . OP} & B & G �:O50P) > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V5n�h Dh "��W R�vK�l (��kW B �:K ./( K�G }~B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V�y�h Dh ? j 076SKwB &!( �:x�K>}~B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V�y�h Dh D �FK�lwN & B &!( �:x�Ko}~B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2V�|

i M��\8����� _ � b��8�8�!� ��] _ag � �n/ "� *-, &�./( ,'0 W B & lwN:K�) > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2�`�n/ ? �FK�, ( )9l %�� )F}~B93�R8N:K�0 > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��?

n/ ?h "� TU% K T I43 � *-,JKwB9C LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��?n/ ?h ?zTU% K W-. K � *-,JKwB9C LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��Dn/ ?h DzE K &!( ,JB9K�)+3�{ (9% K>LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��Q

n/ DATU% K>r4KwB . ) ( K � .����~&�� �:B &�. � }~B93�R8N:K�0 = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��Vn/ Dh "� TU% K>r4KwB . ) ( K � .����~&�� �:B &�. � LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��Vn/ Dh ? }~B93h3�{ 3�{d143�B9B9K�l (9. K�)9) = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2���n/ Dh D 14350P07K ./(9& B9C = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��y

n/ Q u �"073 .�� ) }~B93�R8N:K�0 > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��yn/ QJ "��u �"073 .�� ) LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2��|n/ QJ ?zE K &!( ,JB9K�)+3�{ (9% K>LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n��

n/ VXu`% 3�B � )ULFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n��n/ Vh "� TU% Ko*-, &�./( ,'0 E 35,JB �:KwB T B &�. )v{�3�BH0 > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = nh�

Page 6: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

x � �������������

n/ Vh ?zTU% K>} KwB �:3`G � E � . G � . O LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n!Dn/ Vh DzE'& l ( 3�B � . O LF)U} KwB �:3`G � E � . G � . O > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n!V

n/ � �FB93�x�KwB � )FLFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n!Vn/ �h "� TU% K �FB93�x�KwB j ( KwB &!( �:3 .� = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n!�n/ �h ?zTU% K E ,'N"N�LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n�nn/ �h D ��� ( K . ) �:3 . ) ( 3 �FB93�x�KwB � )FLFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = n!|

��$o�����/be��g������ � �yh "� WF(9% KwB � �:B9K�l ( �:3 . ) > > = > > > = > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2y`�

yh "�! "� *-, &�./( ,'0 jk. {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . TU% Kw3�B9C > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2y`�yh "�! ? *-, &�./( ,'0 14B9Ch6 ( 3�O�B & 6 % C > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2y`�yh "�! D *-, &�./( ,'0��~B9B93�BF143�B9B9K�l ( �:3 .A > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2y�?yh "�! Q 143 ./( � . ,J35,')F*-, &�./( ,'0214350768, (9&!( �:3 . > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2y�?yh "�! V *-, &�./( ,'0�� &�. O5, & O�K TU% Kw3�B9C > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2y�D

yh ?ATU% K E , ( ,JB9K>3�{~*-, &�./( ,'0 14350768, (9&!( �:3 . = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > > = > > = > > = 2y�D

� ����be�����8��\���] � � "

Page 7: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�����������

� ������������s���d���

����� ���! #"%$'&%(*)! ,+-".)0/ 1�2-/430)5"6 #".$'2-+87

jk. & N�� ( KwB & N-)vK . )vK��09;:<:pl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �")>= �h, &�./( ,'0 � ? � .(9%'&!( � ( �") l & B9B �:K�G35, ( 3 . 6 % C`) �"l & N-GJKwx �"l�K�)I % �"l % & B9K>)9,JR�vK�l ( ( 3 (9% K>N & I+) 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�07K�l %'&�. �"lw) ~#% K . I4K )v6SK &;@ 3�{A= �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � ?% 3�I4Kwx�KwB��dI4K O�K . KwB & N"N:Ca07K &�. )v3507K (9% � . O 073�B9K )v6SK�l �CB�l;DFE<GIHKJ�L;M�NPOIEQ9RETSUL;VWJ�9;XYXYSQH'Z[L;OIE]\_^`ZaH_bcSUJYHYdeS<Vf GaSUJ_G�E<GIHYdgHh:i9 f d`9;X'Hj9;: kaL;XYSTE<GaM!SUJ�9;:<: ^WH'lYNP: SUJmSTEQn TU% �") &!(v( � ( ,'GJK �") ) �"0 �"N & B ( 3 (9% K I & C � . I % �"l % I4K)v6SK &;@ 3�{=kB &�. GJ350 � � K�Gal�350768, (9&!( �:3 . D ? & N"Ndl�350768, ( KwBH) & B9KM6'B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"l ( 3 (9% KMK�� ( K ./(o(9%'&!(o(9% KwC & B9Kx`,'N . KwB & R8N:K ( 3Ml�35)90 �"lFB & C`)5o�{�3�BUK�� & 0768N:KqpH�JR8, ( RhC (9% �")p6 % B & )vK-I4K>,')9, & N"N:CP07K &�. l�350768, ( KwBH)pI % 35)vK=,')vK3�{�B &�. GJ350 . K�)9) �")pK��`68N��"l � (w TU% �") &�.'& N:3�O�C I � (9% B &�. GJ350 � � K�G l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �")+,')vKw{e,'N � . , . GJKwBH) (9&�. G � . O (9% K l�K ./( B & N�6'B93�R8N:K�0P) 3�{

�h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . & ) &�. K�07KwB9O � . O7)9,JR � B8K�N"G 3�{�l�350768, ( KwBU)9l �:K . l�K ~# 3�B @ 3 . B &�. GJ350 � � K�G l�350768, �(9&!( �:3 . O�K . KwB & N"N:CM{ & N"N") � ./( 3P3 . K=3�{ (9% B9KwK>l &!( KwO�3�B �:K�)mD

�! = #% KwB9K+GJ3=I4KUO�K ( � ( ; ? TU% �")�l &!( KwO�3�B9C � . x�35N:x�K�) (9% KUGJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . 3�{ & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB & N &�. G & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �"l07K (9% 3`G') {�3�B 3�R (9& � . � . OaB &�. GJ350 x & N",JK�)M{�3�B ,')vK � . l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � &�. G �") (9% K 6'B93�x � . l�Km3�{ (9% KG �")9l �:68N�� . K�)d3�{�l�350768, ( KwB & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K &�. G l�350768, ( KwBF)vC`) ( K�0P)

?h = @ 3�I GJ3FI4Kp,')vK � ( ; ? TU% �")�l &!( KwO�3�B9CoK . l�35076 & )9)vK�) (9% KpGJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . 3�{ & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) I % �"l % B9K�N:C>,J6S3 .B &�. GJ350 l % 3 �"l�K�)={�3�B (9% K �:B=K_r l �:K . l�Cm3�B (9% K �:B-K_sSK�l ( �:x�K . K�)9) � . )v35N:x � . O l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�6'B93�R8N:K�0P)w�&�. G �") (9% K GJ350 & � . 3�{ & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 &�. G 6'B93 ( 3`l�35N GJK�) �:O .�

Dh = #%'&!( l &�.�� ( � ( GJ3 ; ? TU% �")�l &!( KwO�3�B9C � . lwN",'GJK�) (9% K &�.'& N:C`) �")�3�{ (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & NJ6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) &�. C B &�. GJ350 �� � K�G & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)>0o,') ( ) &!( �")v{�C &�. G (9% KM)vK (v( � . O 3�{p,J6'6SKwB &�. G N:3�I4KwB RS35, . G')F3 . (9% K ( B & l (9& R �"N�� ( C3�{�6'B93�R8N:K�0P) � . 073`GJK�N")U3�{�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .m(9%'&!( ,')vK>B &�. GJ350 . K�)9) +u ,'l %m&�.'& N:C`) �") �") �") (9% K B9K & N"0�3�{l�350768, (9& R �"N�� ( C &�. G l�350768N:K�� � ( C (9% Kw3�B9C

� 3 (9% � . O � .7(9% �") (9& �`3 . 350 C��`3�{�l�35,JBH)vK��hGJKw6SK . G')�3 . 35,JB~B9K�) ( B �"l ( � . O=35,JBH)vK�N:x�K�) ( 3 B &�. GJ350 � � K�G7073`GJK�N")3�{=l�350768, (9&!( �:3 ..t I4K l &�. K �h, & N"N:CfI4K�N"N & ) @ (9% K�)vK �h,JK�) ( �:3 . ) & RS35, ( 073`GJK�N") � . I % �"l % 3 (9% KwB @ � . G')73�{K_sSK�l ( )uB8O5,JB9K *-, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �") ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0�07K�l %'&�. �"lw) & )>B &�. GJ350 � � K�G l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �") ( 36'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C (9% Kw3�B9C

Page 8: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

? ������� ��������� ����� �� �� ����� ���

*-, &�./( ,'0 07K�l %'&�. �"lw) K�� % �:R � ( ) & . ,'0 RSKwB>3�{U6 % K . 3507K .'& I % �"l %a& B9K & N��:K . ( 3 lwN & )9) �"l & Ndl�350768, ( � . O&�. G ( 3 3�BHG � .'& B9C � ./( , � ( �:3 .� *-, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P)ol &�. K�� % �:R � ( dYOcN H_XQNILqdYSTETSUL;V'� � . I % �"l % (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 RSK �%'& x�K�) & ) (9% 35,JO % � ( I4KwB9K � . 0o,'N ( �:68N:K � . l�35076 &!( �:R8N:K=) (9&!( K�)-) �"0o,'N (9&�. Kw35,')9N:C dTU% K l &�. 3 . �"l & N K�� & 0768N:K>3�{)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . �") (9% K E f L�� dY: STE�K��`6SKwB �"07K ./( � � . I % �"l % &�. K�N:K�l ( B93 . �")-G �:B9K�l ( K�G &!(>& (9& B9O�K (>(9% B935,JO % ( I43)90 & N"N�)9N�� ( ) � . &�. � ./( KwB9x�K . � . O R & B9B �:KwB LFN (9% 35,JO % K & l % K�N:K�l ( B93 . �")-3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G ( 3 ) ( B � @ K (9% K7GJK ( K�l ( 3�B &!(3 . N:C73 . KF68N & l�K�� (9% K-G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . 3�{�N:3`l &!( �:3 . )dI % KwB9K+K�N:K�l ( B93 . )p) ( B � @ K � . G �"l &!( K &�. S<V E H_X��gH_X'H_VPJYH46 &!(v( KwB . �& ) (9% 35,JO % & I & x�K %'& G ( B & x�K�N:K�G (9% B935,JO % RS3 (9% )9N�� ( ) &�. G � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K�G I � (9% � ( )vK�N:{#o�B &!(9% KwB (9%'&�. RSK � . O 9,') ((9% K )9,'0 3�{ (9% K7G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . )p{�B9350 K & l % )9N�� ( � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( N:C p =u ,'l % &�. 35, ( l�3507K �") �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K>, . N:K�)9)3 . Kp6S35) � ( ) (9%'&!(�(9% KpK�N:K�l ( B93 . ( B & x�K�N") (9% B935,JO % \'LRE<GF)9N�� ( ) TU% K4K�N:K�l ( B93 . �") � .o& )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{#= ( B & x�K�N:K�G(9% B935,JO % (9% KAB8BH) ( )9N�� ( ? &�. G = ( B & x�K�N:K�G (9% B935,JO % (9% K )vK�l�3 . G )9N�� ( ?7) (9&!( K�) u ,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . � & ) )9,JO�O�K�) ( K�G � .a(9% K & RS3�x�K K�� & 0768N:K�� �") & N")v3 � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O RSK�l & ,')vK G �CsSKwB9K ./( ( KwBH0P)

� .�& )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . l &�. � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K I � (9% K & l % 3 (9% KwBgD (9% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � . (9% KmK�N:K�l ( B93 .�� )�=kI & x�Kw{�3�BH0?I % K . � ( B9K & l % K�) (9% K+GJK ( K�l ( 3�B l & B9B �:K�) � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .P& RS35, ( RS3 (9% 6S35)9) �:R8N:Kp6 &!(9% ) �TU% K & l ( 3�{ M8H'9qdYO XYS<V k &�h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0�l &�.7& sSK�l (~(9%'&!( )vC`) ( K�0 � . B & G �"l & NhI & C`)mD � . ) (9& N"N�� . O & G'G � ( �:3 .'& NhGJK ( K�l ( 3�BH) ( 3>GJK ( KwBH0 � . KI % �"l % )9N�� (p(9% K=K�N:K�l ( B93 . O�3hK�) (9% B935,JO % GJK�) ( B93�C`) (9% K � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K=6 &!(v( KwB .� �mKwB9K�N:C K�� & 0 � . � . O & )vC`) ( K�0� . 3 0 &!(v( KwB % 3�I . 3 .�� � ./( BH,') �:x�K (9% K K�� & 0 � .'&!( �:3 . � l &�. o &�. G�� , . GJKwB=l�KwB (9& � . l �:BHlw,'0P) (9&�. l�K�)!M!O d_E pl %'&�. O�K (9%'&!( )vC`) ( K�02GJB & ) ( �"l & N"N:C *-, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P) & N")v3 G �")v68N & C (9% K K_sSK�l ( )=3�{ H_V EQ9;V kR: H_M8H_V E oT I43 6 & B ( �"lwN:K�)Fl &�. RSKo68N & l�K�G � . &�.

=kK ./(9&�. O5N:K�G ? ) (9&!( KP)9,'l % (9%'&!(-(9% KwC G �")v68N & C 6 % K . 3507K .'& I % �"l % l &�.'. 3 ( RSK & lwl�35, ./( K�G {�3�B=RhC &�. C N:3`l & N(9% Kw3�B9C oTU% KwB9K �") . 3 I & C ( 3 073`GJK�N (9% K76 & B ( �"lwN:K�) & )=)vKw6 & B &!( K76 % C`) �"l & N )vC`) ( K�0P)w� Kwx�K . I % K . (9% KwC & B9K6 % C`) �"l & N"N:C )vKw6 & B &!( K�G.Dol %'&�. O�K�) ( 3 3 . KMl &�.a& sSK�l (o(9% KP3 (9% KwB�� &�. G (9% KP6 &!(v( KwB . 3�{p35, ( l�3507K�) B9K�)9,'N ( � . O{�B9350�07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )U3 . (9% K�02G �")v68N & C`) . 3 .�� N:3`l & N l�3�B9B9K�N &!( �:3 . ) LFN (9% 35,JO % � ( BH, . ) l�35, ./( KwB ( 3 � ./( , � ( �:3 .o &�. G ( 3 )vKwx�KwB & Ne=vN & I+)'?a3�{=6 % C`) �"lw) (9%'&!( %'& x�K . 3 ( C�K ( RSKwK . )9,'lwl�K�)9)v{e,'N"N:C B9K�l�3 . l �"N:K�G I � (9% �h, &�./( ,'007K�l %'&�. �"lw)YpH�'K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( �")pB9K & N &�. G %'& ) RSKwK . B9Kw6SK &!( K�G'N:CMx�KwB �CB8K�G K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N"N:C *-, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . &!(v( K�076 ( ) ( 3 %'& B . K�)9) (9% K�)vK>x & B �:35,')pK_sSK�l ( )+{�3�B+l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�68,JB96S35)vK�)

����� ��$'& "62����

} % C`) �"l �") ( ) &�. G 6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % KwBH) %'& x�KMRSKwK . � ./( KwB9K�) ( K�G � . (9% K ) ( B &�. O�KMB9K & N"0 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 07K�l %'&�. �"lw)>{�3�B0 &�. C C�K & BH) 4W x�KwB (9% K+l�35,JBH)vKU3�{ (9% K ( I4K ./( �:K (9% l�K ./( ,JB9C��/6 % C`) �"lw) %'& )~GJKwx�K�N:3�6SK�G & B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:C l�350768N:K ( KGJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 07K�l %'&�. �"l & N�6 % K . 3507K .'& &�. G (9% K-0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N�BH,'N:K�)~O�3�x�KwB . � . O (9% KFRSK %'& x �:3�B3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) TU% KwB9K �") N�� (v( N:KM6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % �"l & N�l�3 . )vK . )9,') 3 .f(9% K l�3�B9B9K�l ( B9K�N &!( �:3 . ) % �:6 RSK ( I4KwK .(9% K�)vK BH,'N:K�) &�. G (9% K 6 % C`) �"l & N`I43�BHN"GKo�3 (9% KwB (9%'&�.7(9%'&!(~(9% K BH,'N:K�) O �:x�KU6'B9K�G �"l ( �:3 . ) I % �"l % l &�. RSK 3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G( 3 RSKFl�3�B9B9K�l ( pH�'R8, ( 6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % C %'& )4{�3`lw,')vK�G &!(v( K ./( �:3 . 3 . (9% K-6'B9K�l �")vK+I & C`) � . I % �"l % �h, &�./( ,'0 6 % C`) �"lw)G �CsSKwBH) {�B93502lwN & )9) �"l & N 6 % C`) �"lw) TU% K 0 � . �"0 & NSK�� & 0768N:K�)+GJKwx�K�N:3�6SK�G RhC 6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % KwBH) ( 3 % �:O % N��:O %/(p(9% K�)vKG �CsSKwB9K . l�K�) & B9K (9% K N�� . K & N &�. l�K�) ( 3�BH)+3�{ (9% K & R8) ( B & l ( )vC`) ( K�0P)Ul�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G � . �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� q �"l %'& BHG E KwC . 0 &�. I & ) & 073 . O (9% K5B8BH) ( 6 % C`) �"l �") ( ) ( 3 )9,JO�O�K�) (F(9%'&!(F(9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N & )v6SK�l ( )F3�{

�h, &�./( ,'0 07K�l %'&�. �"lw) I4KwB9K I43�B (9% K��`68N:3�B � . O @ K . 3 ( K�G (9%'&!( ) �"0o,'N &!( � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) �")oK��`6S3 �. K ./( � & N"N:CaG �Cr lw,'N ( lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C RSK�l & ,')vK �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P)Pl &�. K_r l �:K ./( N:C l�B9K &!( Km)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . )>I � (9%K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N"N:CM0 &�. C ( KwBH0P) dE 3�B (9% �")4B9K & )v3 . � % K>)9,JO�O�K�) ( K�G�� � ( I435,'N"G RSK-I43�B (9% I % �"N:K ( 3PGJKwx�K�N:3�6 �h, &�.��( ,'0 =vl�350768, ( KwBH)'? {�3�B (9% K-68,JB96S35)vK+3�{ G �:B9K�l ( N:CM) �"0o,'N &!( � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P)p3�{ � ./( KwB9K�) (p( 3 (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N6 % C`) �"l �") ( ) �@ K & N")v3>3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G (9%'&!( 6'B9K�l �")vK�N:CoRSK�l & ,')vK (9% KwC7l�35,'N"GPK_r l �:K ./( N:C7l�B9K &!( K-)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . )�I � (9%

Page 9: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ���� ��� ������ �� ��� � ��� ���� ��� � ����� D

K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N"N:C 0 &�. C ( KwBH0P)w� �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH)oI435,'N"GfRSK l & 6 & R8N:K 3�{ & {�3�BH0 3�{e= �h, &�./( ,'0 6 & B & N �N:K�N��")90 ? TU% K G �Cr lw,'N ( C � . K��`68N:3 � ( � . O )9,'l % 6 & B & N"N:K�N��")90 l�3 . ) �") ( ) � . B . G � . O & I & C {�3�B (9% KmG �CsSKwB9K ./(=k6'B93`l�K�)9)v3�BH)'? ( 3fl�350P0o, . �"l &!( KmI � (9% K & l % 3 (9% KwB u ,'l % l�350P0o, . �"l &!( �:3 . �") . K�l�K�)9) & B9C �:{ (9% KwC & B9K ( 3l�350 R � . K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ( 3 0 &;@ K & ) � . O5N:K l�3 % KwB9K ./(7&�. )vI4KwB���B &!(9% KwB (9%'&�.f&�. &�. )vI4KwB B &�. GJ350PN:C l % 35)vK .{�B9350 &�. K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N"N:C N & B9O�K>) & 0768N:K

TU% K . K�� ( 0 & v3�B & GJx &�. l�K � . �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . l & 07K &!(~(9% KUK . G73�{ (9% K ��|�y!� ) &�. G � . (9% KUK & BHN:C��|�|!� ) I % K . � & x �"G �FK�, ( )9l % GJKwx�K�N:3�6SK�G & �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 (9%'&!( B9K �h, �:B9K�G {�KwI4KwB 3�B & lwN:K �h,JKwB �:K�) ( 3&�. )vI4KwB & �h,JK�) ( �:3 .o& RS35, ( &�. , .I@`. 3�I . {e, . l ( �:3 .>(9%'&�. G �"G &�. C>lwN & )9) �"l & N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 E 35N"N:3�I � . O �FK�, ( )9l %�� )G �")9l�3�x�KwB9C�� � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . B935)vKUGJB & 0 &!( �"l & N"N:C L )9,'lwl�K�)9) �:3 . 3�{ & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) {�3�B�O�K . KwB �& N�� ��&!( �:3 . )�3�{ �FK�, ( )9l %�� )d6'B93�R8N:K�0sI4KwB9K & lwl�35076 &�. �:K�GPRhC &�. � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . 07K (9% 3`G')�{�3�B & l ( , & N"N:C l�3 . ) ( BH,'l (��� . O �h, &�./( ,'0sl�350768, ( KwBH) &�. G � . GJKwx�K�N:3�6 � . OF{�3�BH0 & N`073`GJK�N") ( 3-B9K & )v3 .7& RS35, ( (9% K�0 �jk. ��|�|�Q �h} K ( KwB u`% 3�B6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G &�. & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�{�3�BF6S35N:C . 350 � & N � ( �"07K={ & l ( 3�B � ��&!( �:3 . 3 . & �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwB���GJK�073 . ) ( B &!( � . O, . K��`6SK�l ( K�Gm6S3�I4KwB={�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) =u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 %'& )+RSKwK . {�35N"N:3�I4K�GmRhCm)vKwx�KwB & N�3 (9% KwBH)w�. 3 . K �h, � ( K & ) GJB & 0 &!( �"l � 3�x �FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B7, . )v3�B ( K�GfG &!(9& R & )vK )vK & BHl % �~I % �"l %a& l % �:Kwx�K�) &�h, & GJB &!( �"l=)v6SKwK�G',J6 3�x�KwB &�. C lwN & )9) �"l & N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � �") (9% K>0735) ( 6'B9350 � . K ./( � &�. G (9% K=3 . K=I � (9% (9% K 0735) (6'B9350 �") � . Oo6'B935)v6SK�l ( ) {�3�BU{e,JB (9% KwBUG �")9l�3�x�KwB �:K�)

���� � �.2-/ � �� ��� ��� "62�������2�� $ ".�0/ &

jk. (9% K ( B & G � ( �:3 . 3�{ & R8) ( B & l ( �:3 . I � (9% � . l�350768, ( KwB )9l �:K . l�K�� �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) %'& x�KMRSKwK . )v6SK�l �CB8K�GI � (9% B9K�N &!( �:x�K�N:C N�� (v( N:KPB9Kw{�KwB9K . l�K ( 3 )v6SK�l �CB�l76 % C`) �"l & Nd073`GJK�N")>3�{Ul�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� T B & G � ( �:3 .'& N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0GJK�) �:O . KwBH)PB9K�N:C ,J6S3 . & l�KwB (9& � . o &�. G )v3507KwI %'&!(�� , �"GPpo)vK ( 3�{=6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) TU% K u`% 3�B &�. G�FB93�x�KwB & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w� & N:3 . O I � (9%M(9% K �:B4K�� ( K . ) �:3 . )w�`GJKw6SK . GM3 . & = �h, &�./( ,'0 � � K�G ?o)vK ( 3�{�)9,'l % 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�)w�&�. G (9% K �:B & , (9% 3�BH) %'& x�KmRSKwK . l & B9Kw{e,'N ( 3 K��`6'B9K�)9) (9% K �:B & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)7)v3 & ) ( 3a0 &;@ K (9% 35)vK 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�)I % �"l %P(9% KwC7B9K �h, �:B9K+073�B9K+3�BpN:K�)9)~K��`68N��"l � (w jk. 0 &�. C7B9K�)v6SK�l ( )w� (9% K�)vKF6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�) � RhC &�. G N & B9O�K��`) �"0768N:K3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )73 . �h, &�./( ,'0 R � ( )w�43�Bj= �h,JR � ( )'? � )vKwK�0 ( 3aRSK B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �"l R8, �"N"G � . OmR8N:3`l @ )w�0o,'l % N�� @ K (9% Kol�3 . x�K ./( �:3 .'& N 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�)U,')vK�G ( 3 )v6SK�l �:{�C lwN & )9) �"l & N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)mD (9% K � . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 .�� )vK ( 3�{ &x�3 . � K�,'0 &�.'. 0 & l % � . K�� (9% K=3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )p3�{ R & ) �"l-)vK ( (9% Kw3�B9C��'3�B (9% K>0 &�. �:68,'N &!( �:3 . 3�{ K�N:K�07K ./(9& B9C G &!(9&) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K�)w�J{�3�BUK�� & 0768N:K

jk.m(9% K �h, &�./( ,'02I43�BHN"G�� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� � ( �") . 3 ( 95NPXYSUL;XYS�3�Rhx �:35,') (9%'&!( )9,'l % & R8) ( B & l ( 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�) . K�l�K�) �) & B �"N:C 0 & 6f3 ./( 3 &�. C �"0768N:K�07K ./(9& R8N:KPl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N4GJKwx �"l�K # K , . GJKwBH) (9&�. G B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:C I4K�N"N~I %'&!(& lwN & )9) �"l & N]=kR � ( ? �")mD (9% K x�35N (9& O�K N:Kwx�K�N & N:3 . O & I �:B9K l &�. RSK K_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:Cfl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G��~0 & � ./(9& � . K�G � . &I & C (9%'&!( �")4B93�R8,') (p& O & � . ) ( N�� @ K�N:C7KwB9B93�BH)w�J,')vK�G ( 3 � ./( KwB & l ( � . l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N"N:CM,')vKw{e,'N8I & C`)pI � (9% 3 (9% KwBR � ( )-) �"0 �"N & BHN:C ) ( 3�B9K�G�� &�. G )9l & N:K�G & B9R � ( B & B �"N:C r4K�l & ,')vKP3�{ (9% KP)90 & N"N )9l & N:K73 . I % �"l % �h, &�./( ,'0�K_sSK�l ( )GJ350 � .'&!( KMlwN & )9) �"l & N~3 . K�) � &�. G (9% K �h, � �`3 ( �"l .'&!( ,JB9KM3�{ (9% 35)vKMx�KwB9C K_sSK�l ( ) � x �:B ( , & N"N:C . 3 . KM3�{ (9% K( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�Cm,')vK�G ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( lwN & )9) �"l & N R � ( )Ul &�. RSK ,')vK�G ( 3 l�B9K &!( K �h,JR � ( ) (9%'&!( 0 &�. �:{�K�) (GJK�) �:B & R8N:K �h, &�./( ,'0�6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) &�. Gf) &!( �")v{�C (9% K & RS3�x�K l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( ) TU% KMGJK�) �:O . 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, �(9&!( �:3 .'& NUGJKwx �"l�K�)7B9K �h, �:B9K�) ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�)7{�B9350 & N"0735) ( Kwx�KwB9C G �")9l �:68N�� . KP3�{=l�350768, ( KwBM)9l �:K . l�K jk. 0 &�. Cl & )vK�)w� (9% K�)vK ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�)=GJB & I ,J6S3 . RS3 (9% ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N�B9K�)9,'N ( ) &�. G 073�B9K B9K�l�K ./( ��)vKwK�0 � . O5N:Cm, . B9K�N &!( K�G��B9K�)vK & BHl %� �TU%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �")7Kwx�K . 68N & ,') �:R8N:K �") & 0 & v3�B & lwl�350768N��") % 07K ./( � &�. G 3 . K � .I % �"l % x �:B ( , & N"N:C & N"NS3�{�l�350768, ( KwB+)9l �:K . l�K %'& ) 6 & B ( �"l �:6 &!( K�G

Page 10: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

Q ������� ��������� ����� �� �� ����� ���

����� ���e2-)5"����0$'&������ &6$'&

TU% �") (9% K�) �") %'& )�RSKwK . IUB � (v( K .7& ) &�. � ./( B93`G','l ( �:3 .o( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . {�3�Bdl�350768, ( KwB~)9l �:K ./( �") ( ) �j ()9,JB9x�KwC`)w�8{�B9350 (9% K RS3 (v( 350 ,J6 � (9% K B9K�)9,'N ( )UI % �"l % K�) (9& R8N��") % (9% K 6S35)9) �:R �"N�� ( CP3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �(9% K )vC`) ( K�0P) . K�l�K�)9) & B9C ( 3 0 &;@ K �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . & B9K & N�� ( C�� &�. G (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)oI % �"l % 0 &;@ K�h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . GJK�) �:B & R8N:K �TU% K ( 3h35N")pK�0768N:3�C�K�G ( 3P)9,JBH0735, ./(4(9% K=3�R8) (9& lwN:K�)p{ & l�K�G RhC �h, &�./( ,'0l�350768, ( KwBH) l�3507K {�B9350 0 &�. CfG �")9l �:68N�� . K�)-3�{Fl�350768, ( KwB7)9l �:K . l�K�� &�. G (9% �") (9% K�) �") ( K & )vK�)735, ( (9% K I & C`)� . I % �"l % (9% K ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& NU07K (9% 3`G')73�{ (9% K�)vKmG �")9l �:68N�� . K�)ol &�. RSK & 6'68N��:K�G I � (9% � . (9% K . KwI2l�3 ./( K�� ( 3�{�h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� TU% Kp)v6SK�l �CB�l~l�3 ./( B �:R8, ( �:3 . ) 3�{ (9% �") (9% K�) �") & B9K ( I43�{�35N"G �E �:BH) ( ��0o,'l % 3�{ (9% Kp0 &!( KwB � & N/6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G % KwB9K � .

%'& ) . 3 ( RSKwK . 6'B9Kwx �:35,')9N:C7O &!(9% KwB9K�G � . 3 . KF68N & l�K LFN (9% 35,JO % O�3h3`G )9,JB9x�KwC`) & B9K & x & �"N & R8N:KF{�3�B )v3507K�B8K�N"G')3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � (9% KwB9K %'& )�RSKwK . N�� (v( N:K l�3 % K�) �:3 . ( 3 (9% KUN�� ( KwB &!( ,JB9K � . 3 (9% KwB & B9K & ) 4u 6SK�l �CB�l & N"N:C��

� TU% K+l�35076SK ( � . O %'& BHGJI & B9K �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . )�6'B93�6S35)vK�G {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH) & B9K & N"0735) (d. Kwx�KwBl�35076 & B9K�G I � (9% K & l % 3 (9% KwB�� &�. G � ( �")oB & B9K ( 3 B . G &�. & B ( �"lwN:K G �")9lw,')9) � . Om073�B9K (9%'&�. 3 . K )9,'l %6'B93�6S35) & N 4TU% �") (9% K�) �") 6'B9K�)vK ./( ) & N"N (9% K ) & N��:K ./(+%'& BHGJI & B9K>073`GJK�N") � . & ) � . O5N:K>, . �CB8K�G {�B & 07KwI43�B @ �K�076 %'& ) � � � . O (9% KMB9K�N &!( �:x�KM{�K & ) �:R �"N�� ( C 3�{Ul�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( � . O & l ( , & N �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH) 3�{ K & l % 6'B93 �6S35)vK�G ( Ch6SK

� � �")9lw,')9) �:3 . 3�{ (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�073`GJK�N")U3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �")U3�{ ( K . . 3 ( O�B935, . GJK�G � . (9% KoB9K�N & �( �:3 . ) % �:6 3�{ (9% 35)vK 073`GJK�N") ( 3 (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 GJKwx �"l�K�) (9% KwC & B9K�� � . (9% Kw3�B9C�� & R8) ( B & l ( �:3 . ) 3�{ TU% Kl�BH,'l � & N G �") ( � . l ( �:3 . )URSK ( I4KwK . l �:BHlw, � (F&�. G T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K 073`GJK�N")w� � . 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B���)vKwK�0 ( 3 %'& x�KRSKwK . � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( N:CPG �")9l�3�x�KwB9K�G 3 . )vKwx�KwB & N�3`lwl & ) �:3 . )w�'R8, (p(9% K �"076S3�B (9&�. l�K &�. G B & 0 �CB�l &!( �:3 . )p3�{(9% K�)vK-G �") ( � . l ( �:3 . ) %'& x�K-B & B9K�N:C7RSKwK . . 3 ( K�G ~TU% �") (9% K�) �")4G �")9lw,')9)vK�)~{�3�BH0 & N�073`GJK�N")dl�35076 & B &!( �:x�K�N:C��I � (9% B9Kw{�KwB9K . l�K-RS3 (9% ( 3 (9% K �:B , . GJKwBHN:C � . O>0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & NS3�R�vK�l ( ) &�. G ( 3 (9% K-I & C`) � . I % �"l %M(9% K�)vK{�3�BH0 & N 073`GJK�N") & R8) ( B & l (+& I & C {�B9350 &�. G B9K � K�l ( 6 % C`) �"l & N�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N )vC`) ( K�0P)

� TU% K N & l @ 3�{4l�3 % K�) �:3 . � . G �")9lw,')9) �:3 . ) 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K�) �")+K�)v6SK�l � & N"N:C )vKwx�KwB9K T K�l %'. ��h,JK�) RS3�B9B93�I4K�G {�B9350 {e, . l ( �:3 .'& Np6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O &�. G B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K l�350768, ( � . O N & B9O�K�N:C )v35N:x�K0735) ( 3�{ (9% K 6'B93�R8N:K�0P)>6S35)vK�GaRhC �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . OJ��R8, (o(9% �") & lwl�350768N��") % 07K ./(o%'& )oO�3 . K& N"0735) ( l�350768N:K ( K�N:CM, .'. 3 ( �"l�K�G��hKwx�K . RhC (9% 35)vKFI % 3 %'& x�K-6 & B ( �"l �:6 &!( K�G � . � (w �TU% �") (9% K�) �")d6'B93�x �"GJK�)(9% KB8BH) ( @`. 3�I . 3�x�KwB9x �:KwI 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O & ) & ) � . O5N:KPG �")9l �:68N�� . K LF) & B9K�)9,'N ( � � ( �")& R8N:K ( 3 9,`� (9& 6S35)vK (9% Kp6'B93�R8N:K�0P)�3�{��h, &�./( ,'0<6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O+I � (9%o(9% K �:B�)v35N", ( �:3 . )w�!0 &;@ � . O-K��`68N��"l � (0 &�. C l�3 .'. K�l ( �:3 . ) (9%'&!(+%'& x�K B9K�0 & � . K�G �"0768N��"l � ( � . (9% K>I43�B @ 3�{�6'B9Kwx �:35,') & , (9% 3�BH)

TU% K+3 (9% KwB l�3 ./( B �:R8, ( �:3 . )~3�{ (9% �") (9% K�) �") & B9KFK��`6S35) � ( 3�B9C73 . K�) r4KwC�3 . G (9% K & GJx &�./(9& O�K�) 3�{�G �")9lw,')9) � . O& I �"GJKFx & B �:K ( CM3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N �")9)9,JK�) � . 3 . K>, . �CB8K�GMl�3 ./( K�� ( � (9% �") (9% K�) �") %'& ) & . ,'0 RSKwBp3�{)v6SK�l �CB�lF{�K &!( ,JB9K�)+GJK�) �:O . K�G I � (9% 6SK�G & O�3�O �"l & N � ./( K ./(w �jk. 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & BgD

� j ( �") (9% K~x �:KwIa3�{ (9% K & , (9% 3�B (9%'&!( 0o,'l % 3�{ (9% K40 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N/GJK (9& �"N/,')9, & N"N:C+6'B93�x �"GJK�G � . G �")9lw,')9) � . O�h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) �")4, .'. K�l�K�)9) & B9C�� & GJx &�. l � . O (9% K � ./( KwB9K�) ( )43�{ . K � (9% KwB46'B9K�l �") �:3 .M. 3�B4K�N:KwO &�. l�K TU% K=0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N ( B9K &!( 07K ./( 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 K_sSK�l ( ) � . (9% �") (9% K�) �") �")pl�3 . ) �"GJKwB & R8N:CP) �"0768N��CB8K�G7{�B9350(9% K ,')9, & N ( B9K &!( 07K ./( O �:x�K . � . 6 & 6SKwBH)p3 . (9% K>)9,JR�vK�l (w � &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N�GJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . �")pB9KwO & BHGJK�G & )& 07K &�. ) ( 3�I & BHG') (9% KFK . G 3�{ 6'B93�x �"G � . O (9% K-B9K & GJKwB I � (9% & )v35N��"G � ./( , � ( �:3 . {�3�B (9% K=l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N& )v6SK�l ( )U3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P)w� . 3 (+& ) &�. & lwl�Kw6 (9& R8N:Ko)9,JR8) ( � ( , ( K-{�3�B (9%'&!( � ./( , � ( �:3 .�

Page 11: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � �� � � � � � � V

� LF) & l�3�B935N"N & B9C ( 3 (9% K & RS3�x�K���0735) ( G �")9lw,')9) �:3 . )F3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .a& B9KMGJK�) �:O . K�G {�3�B &�.& ,'G �:K . l�K 3�{-6 % C`) �"l �") ( )w� &�. G (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K & )9)9,'07K � . (9% K �:B & ,'G �:K . l�K 6'B �:3�B7K��`6S35)9,JB9K ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'007K�l %'&�. �"lw) &�. G � ( ) 0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N+{�3�BH0 & N��")90P) TU% �") (9% K�) �") �")PB9K�N &!( �:x�K�N:C , . ��h,JK � . (9%'&!( � ( �")IUB � (v( K . {�3�Bml�350768, ( KwB )9l �:K ./( �") ( ) �TU% K . K�l�K�)9) & B9C 6 % C`) �"lw) &�. G N�� . K & B & N:O�KwR'B & & B9Ka073 ( �:x &!( K�GRhC l�3 . ) �"GJKwB &!( �:3 . 3�{pl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N~)vC`) ( K�0P)w� B &!(9% KwB (9%'&�. RSK � . O 6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G & ) & R8) ( B & l ( O �:x�K . ) 143 . x�KwBH)vK�N:C�� (9% �") (9% K�) �") & )9)9,'07K�) � .o(9% KpB9K & GJKwB & R & l @ O�B935, . G � .o(9% K �"GJK & ) &�. G ( KwBH0P)�3�{�l�350768, ( KwB)9l �:K . l�K�� ( 3 & RS35, ( (9% K N:Kwx�K�N�3�{ &�. � ./( B93`G','l ( 3�B9CM3�B � ./( KwBH07K�G � &!( K>, . GJKwB9O�B & G', &!( K>lw,JB9B �"lw,'N",'0

� TU% KoK�� ( K . GJK�G ( B9K &!( 07K ./( 3�{~6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K GJK�) �:O . {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0�GJKwx �"l�K�) �")-073 ( �:x &!( K�GRhC & RSK�N��:Kw{ (9%'&!( (9% K ) ( ,'GJC 3�{F07K (9% 3`G')o{�3�B 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O & )vC`) ( K�0 N:K & G') ( 3 & RSK (v( KwBP, . GJKwB �) (9&�. G � . OM3�{ (9%'&!( )vC`) ( K�0 � )-l & 6 & R �"N�� ( �:K�) &�. G N��"0 � ( ) � . GJKwBH) (9&�. G � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . &�. G, . GJKwBH) (9&�. G � . O % 3�I ( 3M)v6SK�l �:{�C �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .m& B9K>lwN:35)vK�N:C B9K�N &!( K�Gml %'& N"N:K . O�K�)

� TU% K �h, &�./( ,'0 E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 ��GJK�)v6 � ( K � ( ) �"076S3�B (9&�. l�K�� �")-B & B9K�N:C 6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G lwN:K & BHN:C P#% KwB9K6'B93h3�{e)U3�{dl�3�B9B9K�l (9. K�)9) & B9K 3;sSKwB9K�G�� (9% KwC & B9KoO�K . KwB & N"N:C , . �"N"N",'0 � .'&!( � . O dTU% �") (9% K�) �")UO �:x�K�) &M. KwI>�� . G','l ( �:x�K &�.'& N:C`) �")p3�{ (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0

� TU% �") (9% K�) �") 6'B93�x �"GJK�) &�. &�.'. 3 (9&!( K�G R �:R8N��:3�O�B & 6 % C ( 3 6S3 � ./( 35, ( �"076S3�B (9&�./( 6 & 6SKwBH) &�. GO�3h3`GB9Kwx �:KwI & B ( �"lwN:K�)43 . �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K=B9K & GJKwB � ./( KwB9K�) ( K�G � . K��`68N:3�B � . O )v3507K & )v6SK�l ( 3�{�h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � . O�B9K &!( KwB-GJKw6 (9%�

����� �*)5"���$�+��

1 %'& 6 ( KwB ? G �")9lw,')9)vK�) (9% K=0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & NS{�3�BH0 & N��")90P)dK�0768N:3�C�K�G � . N &!( KwB l %'& 6 ( KwBH)w� (9% K-R & ) �"lFl�3 . ) ( B & � ./( )3 . �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �"076S35)vK�G RhC (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�6 % C`) �"lw)w� &�. G )v3507K ,')vKw{e,'N�I & C`)U3�{ (9% � .I@ � . O & RS35, (�h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P) dTU% K=)9,JR8)vK �h,JK ./( l %'& 6 ( KwBH)+GJB & I {�B9K �h,JK ./( N:C��JRS3 (9% �"0768N��"l � ( N:C &�. G K��`68N��"l � ( N:C��h3 . (9% KGJK_B . � ( �:3 . ) &�. G B9K�)9,'N ( )p3�{�l %'& 6 ( KwB ?h 1 %'& 6 ( KwB D )9,JB9x�KwC`) (9% K76 % C`) �"l & N �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) (9%'&!( %'& x�KPRSKwK . 6'B93�6S35)vK�G o &�. G � . )v3507KMl & )vK�)

R8, �"N ( p~{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'02l�350768, ( KwBH)w�'I � (9% &�. K�076 %'& ) �")p3 .m& )9)vK�)9) � . O (9% K )9, � (9& R �"N�� ( CP3�{�K & l % & ) & 68N &!( {�3�BH0{�3�BUN & B9O�K � )9l & N:K �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� dTU% K @ KwC l�3 . l�KwB . {�3�BUK & l % )vC`) ( K�0 �") � ( ) & R �"N�� ( C ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( �)9l & N & R8N:C &�. G B9K�N�� & R8N:C�� & l�KwB (9& � . )vK ( 3�{ 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K-3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) 1 %'& 6 ( KwB Q K�) (9& R8N��") % K�) (9%'&!(U(9% K=6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K+3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) )9,J6'6S3�B ( K�G RhCM6'B93�6S35)vK�G %'& BHGJI & B9K-{�3�B �h, &�.��

( ,'02l�350768, ( KwBH) & B9Ko)9, r l �:K ./( � � . (9% K )vK . )vK (9%'&!( l�350768, ( KwBH)+l & 6 & R8N:K=3�{~l & B9B9C � . O735, ( )9,'l % 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )l &�. l & B9B9C 35, (>&�. C 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . & x & �"N & R8N:K 3 . &�. C �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwB } & B ( 3�{ (9% �") (9& ) @ � . x�35N:x�K�)=6 � .��. � . O GJ3�I . (9% K 6'B9K�l �")vKo{�3�BH0 & N�07K &�. � . O 3�{]= &�. C �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwB�� ? )v3 l %'& 6 ( KwB Q � . x�K�) ( �:O &!( K�) (9% K6'B � . l �:6 & N (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�073`GJK�N") lw,JB9B9K ./( N:C ,')vK={�3�B+GJK�)9l�B �:R � . O O�K . KwB & N � 68,JB96S35)vK �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH) 1 %'& 6 ( KwB V ) ( ,'G �:K�) (9% K l�3 .'. K�l ( �:3 . )FRSK ( I4KwK . �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . &�. GjX'H_bRH_X�dYSQ\_: HJ�L;M�NPOIEQ9RETSUL;V

qUKwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kdl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . K�07KwB9O�K�Go{�B9350 B9K�)vK & BHl % � ./( 3 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .=(9% Kw3�B9C &�. G N:3�I � 6S3�I4KwB�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �R8, (7%'& ) K�) (9& R8N��") % K�G & . ,'0 RSKwB73�{+B9K�)9,'N ( )o3�{ �"076S3�B (9&�. l�K ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� fjk. 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B��B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 6'B93�x �"GJK�) &�. )vI4KwBH) ( 3 & . ,'0 RSKwBo3�{+6'B93�R8N:K�0P)>{ & l�K�G � . GJK�) �:O . � . O & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)(9%'&!( I �"N"N�BH, . 3 . �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH) &�. G � . B9K �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . OmlwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C � l�350768, (9& R8N:KP{e, . l ( �:3 . ) 3 .�h, &�./( ,'0 & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K�) 1 %'& 6 ( KwB Q K�) (9& R8N��") % K�) (9% K (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�N��"0 � ( )�3 .P(9% K+l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )d)9,J6'6S3�B ( K�GRhC GJKwx �"l�K�)>GJK�)9l�B �:RSK�G � . l %'& 6 ( KwB D t l %'& 6 ( KwB V B�N"N") � . (9% KPO & 6aRhC GJK�)9l�B �:R � . O % 3�I (9% 35)vKMGJKwx �"l�K�) l &�.l�350768, ( K>{e, . l ( �:3 . ) 073�B9K=6S3�I4KwB9{e,'N (9%'&�. (9% K �:BU6'B �"0 � ( �:x�KF3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )

Page 12: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� ������� ��������� ����� �� �� ����� ���

1 %'& 6 ( KwB � G �")9lw,')9)vK�) ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�)>{�3�B 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH)w��,') � . O (9% K ( 3h35N") 3�{p6'B93 �O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K (9% Kw3�B9C &�. G GJK�) �:O .� L @ KwC l %'& N"N:K . O�K � . 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O l�350768, ( KwBo)vC`) ( K�0P) �") ( 3B . G . 3 (9&!( �:3 . ) I % �"l % l�350P0o, . �"l &!( K RS3 (9% (9% K l & 6 & R �"N�� ( �:K�) &�. G (9% K N��"0 � (9&!( �:3 . )=3�{ (9% K GJKwx �"l�K�)>RSK � . O6'B93�O�B & 0P07K�G t~&m. ,'0 RSKwB>3�{UG �")v6 & B &!( K �"GJK & )>{�B9350�{e, . l ( �:3 .'& N�6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O &�. G 3 (9% KwBo6 & B & G �:O50P)>3�{6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O & B9K & 6'68N��"l & R8N:K ( 3P6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH) 1 %'& 6 ( KwB n GJK (9& �"N")>)v3507KM3�{ (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)>GJK�) �:O . K�G ( 3 (9&;@ K & GJx &�./(9& O�K 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH)

L+{ ( KwB ) (9& B ( � . O I � (9%M& )vK �h,JK . l�KF3�{ ( 3�CP6'B93�R8N:K�0P)~I % �"l % ) % 3�I 3;s (9% KF6S3�I4KwB43�{��h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH)d3 .l�KwB (9& � .!@ � . G') 3�{�6'B93�R8N:K�0P)w� (9% KUl %'& 6 ( KwBdl�3 . lwN",'GJK�)�I � (9% & G �")9lw,')9) �:3 . 3�{ u`% 3�B � ) { & ) ( { & l ( 3�B � . O & N:O�3�B � (9% 0&�. G �FB93�x�KwB � )o, . )v3�B ( K�G G &!(9& R & )vKM)vK & BHl %a& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � RS3 (9% 3�{4I % �"l % & l % �:Kwx�K GJB & 0 &!( �"l7)v6SKwK�G',J68)-3�x�KwB(9% K RSK�) (0@`. 3�I . lwN & )9) �"l & N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)7{�3�BM6'B93�R8N:K�0P) 3�{-O�K . KwB & N � ./( KwB9K�) (w TU% K B9K�)9,'N ( ) 3�{=l %'& 6 ( KwBH) ?(9% B935,JO %m� 6'B93�x �"GJK (9% KK= % 3�I�?P3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� 1 %'& 6 ( KwB n 6'B93�x �"GJK�) (9% KK=kI % C ?E � .'& N"N:C���l %'& 6 ( KwB y R'B �:K � C )9,JB9x�KwC`) 3 (9% KwB]B8K�N"G')>3�{ � ./( KwB9K�) ( I � (9% � . �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . RSKw{�3�B9K

l�3 . lwN",'G � . O I � (9% & G �")9lw,')9) �:3 . 3�{ (9% K={e, ( ,JB9K=6'B935)v6SK�l ( )p3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .�

Page 13: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�������������

� � ��� ��� � ��� � ��� �� � ��� � � � � �d�

� ��� +-"��.2 )�� ".$'2-+

# K I �") % ( 3aGJK�)9l�B �:RSK &�. G ( 3al�B9K &!( Kml�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) (9%'&!( 6'B93`G','l�K &�. )vI4KwBH) ( 3 �h,JK�) ( �:3 . ) 3�{ � ./( KwB9K�) (w TU% K & R8) ( B & l ( K�� �") ( K . l�K-3�{�)v3507KFx & N",JK �") . 3 ( O�3h3`G K . 35,JO % D�I4K-B9K �h, �:B9K & 6'B93`l�K�G',JB9KUI % �"l %M( KwBH0 � .'&!( K�)RhC 6'B93�x �"G � . O (9%'&!( x & N",JK � . � ./( K�N"N��:O �:R8N:K7{�3�BH0 E 3�B7K�� & 0768N:K�� &�. Ca{�3�BH0o,'N & 3�{ B8BH) (�� 3�BHGJKwB7N:3�O �"l %'& ) &GJK_B . � ( K ( BH, (9%�� x & N",JK���R8, (+(9% �")uM9RE<GIH_M9RETSUJ�9;:SO5, & B &�./( KwK �") . 3 (-& J�L;M�NPOIEQ9RETSUL;VP9;:SO5, & B &�./( KwK�� &�. G (9% KwB9KK�� �") ( { & 0 �"N��:K�)43�{�{�3�BH0o,'N & K=I % 35)vK ( BH, (9%�� x & N",JK�) & B9K . 3 ( l & N"lw,'N & R8N:K-RhC &�. C l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�6'B93`l�K�)9) E �:BH) (�� 3�BHGJKwBUN:3�O �"l �") &�. K�� & 0768N:K-3�{ & 0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N )vC`) ( K�0 (9%'&!(U%'& ) l�KwB (9& � . 6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)4I % �"l % & B9K

. 3 ( G �:B9K�l ( N:C 3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K *-, &�./( ,'0 07K�l %'&�. �"lw) 6S35) ( ,'N &!( K�) (9%'&!( 3 . N:Cal�KwB (9& � . 6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) 3�{+6 % C`) �"l & N)vC`) ( K�0P) & B9K-G �:B9K�l ( N:C73�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K �TU% K�)vK+6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)dl &�. (9&;@ K-3 . x & N",JK�)d{�B9350 )v3507K-)v6SK�l �CB8K�GM)vK (mt I % K .I4K 3�R8)vKwB9x�K7)9,'l % & 6'B93�6SKwB ( C�� � (-%'& )FK�� & l ( N:C 3 . Ko3�{ (9% 35)vK x & N",JK�) =E ,JB (9% KwB�� �:{�I4K 3�R8)vKwB9x�K7)v3507K O �:x�K .x & N",JK {�3�B &�. 3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K 6'B93�6SKwB ( C 3�{ & )vC`) ( K�0 � (9% K . � � . (9% K & R8)vK . l�Ko3�{~)v3507KoK��`68N��"l � ( � ./( KwB9x�K ./( �:3 .� (9%'&!( 6'B93�6SKwB ( C I �"N"NSl�3 ./( � . ,JK ( 3 %'& x�K (9%'&!( x & N",JK=3 . {e, ( ,JB9K-3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . ) TU% K�)vK (9% B9KwK>{ & l ( ) ��! U(9%'&!( 3 . N:C l�KwB (9& � . 6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)p3�{ & )vC`) ( K�0 & B9K=3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K��?h U(9%'&!( 3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . ) %'& x�KoGJK_B . � ( K-35, ( l�3507K�)w�Dh +&�. G (9%'&!( �"GJK ./( �"l & NSB9Kw6SK &!( K�G 3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . ) I �"N"N %'& x�K (9% K>) & 07K>35, ( l�3507K �

& B9K & N"NSI4K>B9K �h, �:B9K ( 3PO �:x�K &�. 3�x�KwB9x �:KwI 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�07K�l %'&�. �"lw) & ) � (U& 6'68N��:K�) ( 3Ml�350768, (9&!( �:3 .�

� ��� ����� 1 �' &P&6$�� ��� � ��/

��������� �������=H1pN & )9) �"l & N ?o)vC`) ( K�0P)w�`{�3�B 35,JBp68,JB96S35)vK�)w� & B9K (9% 35)vK � . I % �"l % Kwx�KwB9C 6 % C`) �"l & N86'B93�6SKwB ( C �")43�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K LF)&�. K�� & 0768N:Ko3�{ & lwN & )9) �"l & N�)vC`) ( K�0 ��l�3 . ) �"GJKwB & R � (w L�R � (F%'& ) & ) � . O5N:Ko3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:Ko6'B93�6SKwB ( C &�. G (9%'&!(6'B93�6SKwB ( C l &�. %'& x�K 3 . K>3�{ ( I43M6S35)9) �:R8N:KFx & N",JK�) � K ( ,') l & N"N (9% K�)vK>x & N",JK�)! �#"p&�. G$ �%"H

n

Page 14: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

y ������� ������� � � ��� � � � ��� ����� ��� � � � � � ����� � ��

T 3=RSK 07K &�. � . O�{e,'N"N:C=3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K�� �#"�&�. G� �%" 0o,') (�%'& x�K+)v3507K 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�6 % C`) �"l & N �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) j { (9% KFR � ( �") ( 3 RSK-) ( 3�B9K�G � . & ( B &�. ) �") ( 3�B )vI � ( l % � �#" l�35,'N"G GJK�) �:O .'&!( K & ( B &�. ) �") ( 3�BpI � (9% 35, ( 68, ( x�35N (9& O�K&!( 3�B . K & B�B8x�Kox�35N ( )w� &�. G �%"+&M( B &�. ) �") ( 3�BFI % 35)vKo35, ( 68, ( x�35N (9& O�K �")F)vK (-. K & B � KwB93 x�35N ( ) Fj { (9% KoR � ( �")) ( 3�B9K�GM3 .M& 68, . l % l & BHG�� �#" l�35,'N"GPGJK�) �:O .'&!( K (9% K & R8)vK . l�K+3�{ & % 35N:K � .P& )v6SK�l �CB8K�G76S35) � ( �:3 . � &�. G �%"�(9% K6'B9K�)vK . l�K73�{ & % 35N:K � . (9%'&!( 6S35) � ( �:3 .� 7WF(9% KwB �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . )FI435,'N"G & )9) �:O . G �CsSKwB9K ./( 6 % C`) �"l & N�) (9&!( K�)( 3 �#"p&�. G$ �%"H W-.>(9% K43 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� (9% Kp)vC`0 RS35N") �#"�&�. G �%" & B9K ( Ch6 �"l & N"N:C=,')vK�G ( 3FB9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( & R8) ( B & l ( 0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N

x & N",JK�) & lwl�3�BHG � . O ( 3 )v3507K7{�3�BH0 & N�0 & 6'6 � . O ojk. & ( B &�. ) �") ( 3�B>)vI � ( l % I � (9% (9% K & l ( �:x�K � N:3�I l�3 . x�K ./( �:3 . � �#" GJK . 3 ( K�) N:3�O �"l & N E LF� u � &�. G �%" GJK . 3 ( K�) N:3�O �"l & N T q��F� �m3�B9K ( Ch6 �"l & N"N:C�� �#">&�. G �%" GJK . 3 ( K (9% KV O M8\�H_X�d � &�. G � � B9K�)v6SK�l ( �:x�K�N:C Mjk. & B9KwO �") ( KwB ) ( 3�B � . O & R � .'& B9C . ,'0 RSKwB�� & B9KwO �") ( KwB>I � (9%��h(9% R � ( �%"GJK . 3 ( K�) &M. ,'0 RSKwB+I % �"l % �") ?�� O�B9K &!( KwB (9%'&�. (9% K . ,'0 RSKwBFGJK . 3 ( K�G RhC (9% Ko) & 07K B9KwO �") ( KwBFI � (9%��h(9% R � ( �#" �hR8, (~(9% K+6'B9K�l �")vKUGJK . 3 (9&!( �:3 . 3�{ (9% �")�R � ( l &�.'. 3 ( RSK K�) (9& R8N��") % K�G � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( N:C>3�{ GJK . 3 (9&!( �:3 . )~3�{ (9% K3 (9% KwB+R � ( ) �#"�&�. G� �%" 6'B93�x �"GJK & l�3 . x�K . �:K ./( 0 �"G'G'N:KdN & C�KwB�RSK ( I4KwK . 6 % C`) �"l & N �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) &�. G (9% K & R8) ( B & l (

)vC`) ( K�0P) (9% K�)vK �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) 073`GJK�N fTU% K�)vK .'& 07K�) & N"N:3�I�,') ( 3a)v6SK &;@f& RS35, ( (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )l & B9B �:K�Go35, ( RhCol�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N %'& BHGJI & B9K4I � (9% 35, ( RSK�l�350 � . OFRS3�O�O�K�G7GJ3�I . � . (9% KpGJK (9& �"N") 3�{ &�. Co)v6SK�l �CB�l�"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 .� �TU% KwC & N")v3 & N"N:3�If,') ( 3F,')vK (9% Kd) & 07K %'& BHGJI & B9K ( 3Fl & B9B9C-35, ( l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) 3 . G �CsSKwB9K ./(@ � . G')73�{>0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N+3�R�vK�l ( ) jk. 3 . K l�3 ./( K�� ( �%" �#" 0 & C�) (9&�. G {�3�B (9% Km3�BHGJKwB9K�G�6 & �:B o ���9� p t � .&�. 3 (9% KwB � ( 0 & C ) (9&�. G {�3�B (9% K-R � .'& B9C . ,'0 RSKwB �w�` ~j ( �")4K & ) �:KwB ( 3P)v6SK�l �:{�C (9% K=0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N�6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)3�{ (9% K�)vK+3�R�vK�l ( ) � .7( KwBH0P)~3�{ VP9;M8HYd�{�3�Bd6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B~6 % C`) �"l & N') (9&!( K�) (9%'&�. � .7( KwBH0P)~3�{ (9% K+6 % C`) �"l & N') (9&!( K�)(9% K�0P)vK�N:x�K�)

��������� � � �� ������������������������ �

L�,')9, & N~x �:KwI 3�{Ul�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& Nd)vC`) ( K�0P) � &�. G 3�{+)vC`) ( K�0P) � . O�K . KwB & N � �") (9%'&!( I4K )v6SK�l �:{�C )v3507K)v6 & l�K=3�{ 6S35)9) �:R8N:K+) (9&!( K�)U3�{ (9% K=)vC`) ( K�0 � &�. G (9% K>)vC`) ( K�0 � ) & l ( , & N ) (9&!( K �") (9% K . B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G RhC & 6S3 � ./(I � (9% � .m(9%'&!( )v6 & l�K E 3�B=K & l % 3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:Ko6'B93�6SKwB ( Cm3�{ & )vC`) ( K�0 oe,')9, & N"N:Cml & N"N:K�G>La\YdgH_XYb;9a\_: HYd'pH� I4K & N")v3)v6SK�l �:{�CmI %'&!( x & N",JK (9%'&!( 6'B93�6SKwB ( C I �"N"N %'& x�K �:{ (9% KM)vC`) ( K�0 �")-3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G�oe)9,'l %a&�. 3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . �") & N")v3l & N"N:K�G & M8H'9qdYO X'H_M8H_V E p I % �"N:K � . &�. C O �:x�K . ) (9&!( K u � . l�K & lwN & )9) �"l & N8R � ( ) ( 3�B9K�) (9% K-G �") ( � . l ( x & N",JK�) �#"d&�. G �%" � &�. G (9% K�)vK ( I437) (9&!( K�) )9, r l�K ( 3 K��`68N & � .

(9% K>RSK %'& x �:3�B 3�{ (9% K>)vC`) ( K�0 �'I4K GJK_B . K � ( )U) (9&!( Ko)v6 & l�K��! ( 3PRSK�! �"$# �#"%� �%"'&)( o ?h "� p

TU% K . 3 (9&!( �:3 . �! �")U07K &�./(U( 3M)9,JO�O�K�) (+&�.m& R8) ( B & l ( lwN & )9) �"l & N�R � (w T 3oRSK+{e,'N"N:Co6'B9K�l �")vK��/I4K . 3�I)v6SK�l �:{�C��/{�3�B4K & l % 6S35)9) �:R8N:KU) (9&!( K � .P(9% K-) (9&!( K-)v6 & l�K�� (9% KFx & N",JK (9% KFR � ( � )

3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K=I �"N"N %'& x�K �:{ (9%'&!( 3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K �")U07K & )9,JB9K�G dj { (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 �") � . ) (9&!( K� �#" � (9% Ko07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(I �"N"N�6'B93`G','l�K (9% KMx & N",JK �#"�t �:{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 �") � . ) (9&!( K �%" � (9% K 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( I �"N"N�6'B93`G','l�K �%"H TU% �")lwN & �"0�)vKwK�0P) ( B �:x � & N�RSK�l & ,')vK (9% KM)vK ( 3�{p3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K7x & N",JK�) �") (9% KM) & 07K & ) (9% KM)vK ( 3�{p6S35)9) �:R8N:K ) (9&!( K�) # K I �"N"N�)v3h3 . )vKwK )vC`) ( K�0P)+{�3�BFI % �"l % (9% �")+K �h, �:x & N:K . l�K GJ3hK�) . 3 (F% 35N"G�� &�. GmI4KoI �"N"N . KwK�G ( 3 O �:x�K 073�B9Kl�350768N��"l &!( K�G BH,'N:K�)p{�3�B+GJK ( KwBH0 � . � . O (9% K>x & N",JK�) (9%'&!( B9K�)9,'N ( {�B9350�07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )

Page 15: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ���� � ��� ������� � � � ��� � � ����� � |

��������� � �)������� �� � ��� ���

TU% K ) (9&!( K 3�{ & )vC`) ( K�0 �") . 3 ( ) (9&!( �"l >TU% KwB9K & B9K7,')9, & N"N:C 0 &�. Cm6S35)9) �:R8N:K & l ( �:3 . ) (9%'&!( I �"N"N l %'&�. O�K (9% KB9K�)9,'N ( )p3�{ {e, ( ,JB9K-3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . )U0 & GJK=3 . (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 �j { & R � ( �")p3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G ( 3 %'& x�K (9% K>x & N",JK �#"p&�. G �")(9% K . {�K�G (9% B935,JO % &�. � . x�KwB ( KwB�� (9% K>R � ( I �"N"N %'& x�K (9% K>x & N",JK �%" �:{ � ( �") 3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G & O & � .� L+R8) ( B & l ( N:C��'I4K)v6SK�l �:{�C7)9,'l % L�N H_X 9RETSUL;VId43�BAETX 9;VId��mL;XYM9RETSUL;VId RhC7O �:x � . O & {e, . l ( �:3 . {�B9350 (9% K-) (9&!( K=)v6 & l�K � ./( 3 � ( )vK�N:{ �E 3�BK�� & 0768N:K�� {�KwK�G � . O & ) ( 3�B9K�G R � (-(9% B935,JO % &�. � . x�KwB ( KwB �")-K �h, �:x & N:K ./(-( 3 & 6'68N:C � . O (9% KP0 & 6'6 � . O� �O �:x�K .RhC��

�#" " �%" �%" " �#"%( o ?h ? pjk. � ( � & N�� � � . O (9% KFR � (d( 3 B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(4(9% K-l�3 . ) (9&�./( x & N",JK � �")dK �h, �:x & N:K ./(d( 3 & 6'68N:C � . O (9% K-0 & 6'6 � . O�� O �:x�K .RhC

� �#" " �%" � �%" " �%"%( o ?h D pTU% K>x & N",JK�)+3�{~07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) (9&;@ K . RSKw{�3�B9K &�. G & { ( KwB &M( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . I �"N"N � � . O�K . KwB & N ��RSK G �CsSKwB9K ./(w u 3507K+)vC`) ( K�0P)�I �"N"N oe, . GJKwB~l�KwB (9& � . 6 % C`) �"l & NJl�3 . G � ( �:3 . )Yp l %'&�. O�K+) (9&!( K+I � (9%7(9% KU6 & )9) & O�KU3�{ ( �"07K �TU% K�)vKl %'&�. O�K�)+l &�.m& N")v37RSK>)v6SK�l �CB8K�G & )U)9,'l % &7( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .� T 3MB9Kwx �:KwI>�8N:K ( ,') (9% � .I@ & RS35, (U(9% �")U) � . O5N:K � R � ( )vC`) ( K�0 � . ( KwBH0P)U3�{�35,JB (9% B9KwK>6'B � . l �:68N:K�) L<O�K . KwB �"l

R � (+%'& )+3 . Ko6 % C`) �"l & N 6'B93�6SKwB ( C�� &�. G 3 . Ko3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K L 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�02B9K�)9,'N ( ) � . K � (9% KwB �#" 3�B �%"H �mK & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )dGJ3 . 3 ( 6'B93`G','l�Kp)v3507K 3 (9% KwB~x & N",JK��/) & C ������� " � . 3�B~GJ3 (9% KwCo6'B93`G','l�KpRS3 (9% �#"&�. G� �%" ) �"0o,'N (9&�. Kw35,')9N:C E ,JB (9% KwB�� � .o(9% K & R8)vK . l�K 3�{S)v3507KpK�� ( KwB .'& N & N ( KwB � . OF{�3�BHl�K��/3 . l�K & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(%'& ) 6'B93`G','l�K�G �#" � (9% K=x & N",JK=3�{ & {e, ( ,JB9K=07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( I �"N"N & N")v37RSK �#"�t ) �"0 �"N & BHN:C�� & �%" B9K�0 & � . ) & �%"H

� �� ������� �.2 �! �0$ ��$'& ".$�� � � ��/

��������� � � �� ������������������ � ��� ���

143 . ) �"GJKwB . 3�I & NPX La\'9a\_S<: S d_ETSUJ R � (w �TU% �")4)vC`) ( K�0 l�3 . ) �") ( )43�{ & ) � . O5N:K��h6S35)9) �:R8N:C7, . { & �:B��hl�3 � .� L+O & � . � (9% �"))vC`) ( K�0 %'& ) & ) � . O5N:Kp3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:KRD (9% KU35, ( l�3507K+3�{ (9% K+l�3 � .�� �:6 TU% �")�3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:KUl &�.P(9&;@ KF3 .P(9% KUx & N",JK�) �#"d&�. G �%"H d@ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� �! �") . 3 (p& N & B9O�KFK . 35,JO % ) (9&!( K>)v6 & l�K ( 3 K��`68N & � .P(9% KFRSK %'& x �:3�B43�{ & B &�. GJ350 R � ( �) � . l�K � (4%'& ) . 3 I & C ( 3 B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( = & R � ( I % �"l % I �"N"N %'& x�K-x & N",JK �#" I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C��P? {�3�B &�. C�� 3 (9% KwB(9%'&�. � KwB9373�Bp3 . K ~TU% ,')w�`I4K-GJK_B . K (9% K=) (9&!( K>)v6 & l�K ��� 3�{ & 6'B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"lpR � ( RhC &!(v(9& l % � . O7l�3hK_r l �:K ./( )( 3$ �#"-&�. G �%"+(9%'&!( � . G �"l &!( K (9% K76'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C (9%'&!(>& 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�{ (9% K7R � ( I �"N"N 6'B93`G','l�K (9% K x & N",JK �#" 3�B �%" �'B9K�)v6SK�l ( �:x�K�N:C dE 3�BH0 & N"N:C��

����"$# �"!# �#"$# � � �%" D��"! � � �&%(' t �")! # �") � " ��&)( o ?h Q p�mK & )9,JB � . O & R � ( � . ) (9&!( K(�"!# �#"*# � � �%" 6'B93`G','l�K�) (9% K x & N",JK �#" I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C+� )! &�. G (9% K x & N",JK �%" I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C,� )� # K %'& x�K )v6SK�l �CB8K�G (9% Km) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 � . ( KwBH0P)P3�{>) �h, & B9K B93h3 ( )M3�{

-/.�0�132546037�2�898;:<>=5460�? <@AB@/2�<>=C7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@�4ID�:J2�@/2546K K LC@/MN:<? O5:QPC2�@/? 0�RS7�=�:J46M�M�K ? <Q4I7�? TU:$0�G67>4I7�? GB0�G6EVK ? 0�:Q4ID�46K RB:W D>4XAWN:<Q462�@/:Y@/2�<>=�7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@A5? 0ZRB:0�:�D>46K[AN4ID�:YK ? 0�:Q4ID\7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@]

Page 16: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�w� ������� ������� � � ��� � � � ��� ����� ��� � � � � � ����� � ��

6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( �:K�)0o � . ) ( K & G 3�{p6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( �:K�) (9% K�0P)vK�N:x�K�)YpF{�3�B B9K & )v3 . ) (9%'&!( I �"N"N�RSKPlwN:K & B9KwBoN &!( KwB TU% KP) �"GJKl�3 . G � ( �:3 . (9%'&!( � )! # � ) � " � K . )9,JB9K�) (9%'&!(U(9% K>6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( �:K�)4)9,'0 ( 3 �! )u ,J6'6S35)vK & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 6'B93`G','l�K�) (9% K>x & N",JK �#"H r4K�l & ,')vK B9Kw6SK &!( K�Gm07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )+0o,') ( RSK>l�3 .��

) �") ( K ./( �'{e, ( ,JB9K>07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )+0o,') (+& N")v376'B93`G','l�K (9% K>x & N",JK �#" I � (9% l�KwB (9& � ./( C TU% K=3 . N:C ) (9&!( K � . ���I % �"l % �8I % K . 07K & )9,JB9K�G���C �:K�N"G')! �#" I � (9% l�KwB (9& � ./( C �") � �#"S# � �%"H -TU% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K���I4K 0o,') ( l�3 . lwN",'GJK�� (9%'&!((9% K ) (9&!( K73�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 & { ( KwB (9% K5B8BH) ( 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( �") � �#"S# � �%"H >TU% K & l ( 3�{407K & )9,JB � . O & )vC`) ( K�0J_G 9;V k HYd (9% K ) (9&!( K>3�{ (9% K>)vC`) ( K�0 TU% �") �") . 3 ( & ) ) ( B &�. O�K & ) � ( 0 & C )v35, . G ��� & 0 � . � . O (9% KmB9K�)9,'N ( 3�{ & B &�. GJ350 l�3 � . � �:6 C �:K�N"G')

� . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .P& RS35, (~(9%'&!( l�3 � .�� �:6 �TU% K+l�3 � . l &�.'. 3 ( 6S35)9) �:R8N:C %'& x�K & G �CsSKwB9K ./( x & N",JK+, . N:K�)9) � ( �") � �:6'6SK�G& O & � .� �TU% K R � ( G 9 Z+)v3507K 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C>3�{ %'& x � . O (9% K x & N",JK! �%" �hR8, (�. 3�I � ( G 9qd (9% KUx & N",JK �#"H L B &�. GJ350R � ( �") 3 . N:CMB &�. GJ350�3 . l�K W ,JB (9% B9KwKp6'B � . l �:68N:K�) & B9K & N")v3=) ( �"N"N � . {�3�BHl�K dW R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . )�) ( �"N"N %'& x�KUGJK_B . � ( K435, ( l�3507K�)w�h) � . l�Kp)vKwK � . O

�#"U&�. G �%"U& B9Ko0o, ( , & N"N:C K��JlwN",') �:x�K>Kwx�K ./( )-I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( �:K�)p)9,'0P0 � . O ( 3 �! qUKw6SK &!( K�Gm3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . )6'B93`G','l�K (9% Ko) & 07K x & N",JK L . G . 3 ( Kwx�KwB9Cm6'B93�6SKwB ( C 3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 �")+G �:B9K�l ( N:C 3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:KRD (9% KwB9K �") . 3I & C ( 3-G �:B9K�l ( N:C=3�R8)vKwB9x�K & 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C�� � &!(9% KwB � . O � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( & )vC`) ( K�0 �") &�. & l ( �:x�K�� � ./( BH,') �:x�K��6'B93`l�K�)9)mD>3 . l�KPI4K @`. 3�I (9%'&!(>(9% KPR � ( �") �%" � I4K %'& x�K[=vGJK�) ( B93�C�K�G ? (9% KP6S35)9) �:R �"N�� ( C (9%'&!( � ( I �"N"N RSK �#"I % K . I4K N:3h3 @ &!( � (U. K�� (w

��������� � �)������� �� � ��� ���

#%'&!( GJ3hK�) � ( 07K &�. ( 3 & 6'68N:C &o( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% �")p)vC`) ( K�0 ; 143 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K & l ( �:3 . 3�{ & R � (�� � . x�KwB ( KwB3 . (9% K ) (9&!( K �"! �#"$# � � �%" �'{�35N"N:3�I4K�G RhC &�. 3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K=R � ( � )U) (9&!( K 4TU% K={�35N"N:3�I � . O K��`68N &�.'&!( �:3 .�") ( K�076 ( � . OID

= # � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C � )! � (9% K=R � ( � . � ( � & N"N:C %'& G x & N",JK �#" �8I & ) � . x�KwB ( K�G ( 3 �%" � &�. G 3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G & )+)9,'l %� # � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C � )! � (9% K x & N",JK �%" �") 3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G &!(P(9% K K . G � 3 ( K (9%'&!(P(9% K 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( �:K�) {�3�BPK & l %35, ( l�3507K & B9K (9% K ) & 07K & ) (9% KwC I435,'N"G %'& x�K RSKwK . �:{ (9% K>) (9&!( K � � �#"\# �"! �%" I & )U3�R8)vKwB9x�K�GmG �:B9K�l ( N:C ?TU% K 6'B93�R8N:K�0<I � (9% (9% �")�B9K & )v3 . � . O �") (9%'&!(~(9% KU) (9&!( K�07K ./( =kI � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C � )! � (9% KUR � ( I & ) � . � ( � & N"N:C

& �#" � ? B9K �h, �:B9K�) & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(w dTU% ,')w� (9% K & RS3�x�K-6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K �")dB9K & N"N:C & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( {�35N"N:3�I4K�G RhC &�.3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . 3 .m(9% Ko07K & )9,JB9K�GmR � ( �8I % KwB9K & )+I4KoI4KwB9K ( B9C � . O ( 3 l & 6 ( ,JB9K (9% K �"GJK & 3�{ &�. 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . 3 . &�.O V��qVPL f V R � (w ~j ( �") . 3 ( 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3j=vN:3h3 @ � ./( 3 ? (9% K , .I@`. 3�I . R � ( � . 3�BHGJKwB ( 3 & 6'68N:C &P( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .( 3 � (w �TU% KpB9K�)9,'N ( 3�{�3�{ & 6'68N:C � . O=)v3507K 3�6SKwB &!( 3�B ( 3 (9% �")�) (9&!( K �") &�. 3 (9% KwBd) (9&!( K+3�{ (9% K+)vC`) ( K�0 �/3 . K I % �"l %�")�K �h, & N"N:C 3�6 & �h,JK ~TU% K 3 . N:CoI & C ( 3>K�� ( B & l ( � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .7& RS35, (~(9% KUx & N",JK 3�{ (9% K+)vC`) ( K�0 �") ( 3 07K & )9,JB9K� ( �'I % �"l % {�3�BHl�K�) � ( ( 3[=vl�35N"N & 68)vKg? � ./( 3P3 . K>x & N",JK>3�B (9% K>3 (9% KwB � ./( �"N & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(+%'& ) (9&;@ K . 68N & l�K��I4K %'& x�K . 3 N:KwO � ( �"0 &!( KoR & ) �")F{�3�B>)v6SK &;@ � . O & RS35, (-(9% K R � (-& ) = %'& x � . O x & N",JKg? �#" 3�B �%" >j ( �")-07KwB9K�N:C� . & ) (9&!( KP{�B9350�I % �"l % I4K7I �"N"N�Kwx�K ./( , & N"N:C RSK & R8N:K ( 3 K�� ( B & l ( & x & N",JK t�(9%'&!( x & N",JK I �"N"N�RSK� �#" I � (9% &l�KwB (9& � . 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C &�. G$ �%" I � (9% )v3507K>3 (9% KwB+6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C

�>. 7�� GB2�K P WN:CMNGB@/@/? W�K :C7�G�D�:8;GITU: 7�=�? @Y@/? P :C<GB05P ? 7�? GB0�A"W�2 7 7�=�:0�� :�� GB2�K P 0�::QPZ7�G�? 037/D�GXP 2�<:�4�0�G6D�8&46K ? Q4I7�? GB0 7�:�D�87�GC7�=�: D�2�K :@JEHG6DS8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037 7�G;8&4�U:\7�=�:YM D�GBW546W�? K ? 7�? :@SG6E 7�=�: P ? �V:�D�:037$GB2 7�<GB8;:@$@/2�8 7�G� B]�� =�? @\0�G6D�8&46K ? Q4I7�? GB0Z7�:�D�88&4�U:@*<:�D/7>46? 0 @F7>4I7�:@A�K ? U:���� ���*4605P�� ��� <GB8;M�K :�7�:K L�? 05P ? @F7�? 0�RB2�? @/=546W�K :�7�G 4603L�8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037QA :TU:0 2�05P :�D�4603L�MNGB@/@/? W�K :7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�7�G�7�=�:;@FL @F7�:8Z]�� GB? 0�RZ7�=�:�0�G6D�8&46K ? Q4I7�? GB0 4I7 7�=�:;K :TU:K�G6EJ7�=�:;@F7>4I7�:;@/M546<:BA D>4I7�=�:�D 7�=5460 4I7 7�=�:;K :TU:K�G6E8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037�@A3D�:8;GITU:@ 7�=�? @JD�:QP 2�05P�460�<�L3]

��� =�:YWN:@F7�� :Y<Q460ZP GC? @J7�G�� �"!"#%$�7�=�GB@/: M D�GBW546W�? K ? 7�? :@A&�$? 7�=Z@/GB8;: <>=5460�<: G6E :�D/D�G6DS4605P�@/GB8;:YP :R6D�::YG6E 46M�M D�G"' ? 8&4I7�? GB0�AW546@/:QP�GB0�7�=�:YGB2 7�<GB8;:@JG6E 8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037�@])(�G6D$<GB? 0�*5? M�@AX7�=�:@/:Y8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037�@J4ID�:,+�:�D�0�GB2�K K ?V7/D�? 46K @]

Page 17: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ���� � ��� ������� � � � ��� � � ����� � ���

TU% �")�) & �"G�� (9% K= � . l�3�B9B9K�l ( ? % K�,JB �") ( �"ld{�3�B~l & B9B9C � . O-35, (~(9% K R � (�� � �:6 ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . O �:x�K�)~,') (9% K B �:O %/(&�. )vI4KwBgD (9% K R � (�� � �:6 l & B9B �:K�G 35, ( B9K & N"N:C GJ3hK�)+)vI & 6 (9% K>6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( �:K�) & )9)v3`l � &!( K�GmI � (9% K & l % x & N",JK 4j {��& l ( )4)v3507K+I & C73 . �#"�&�. GM)v3507K+3 (9% KwBdI & C73 . �%" � (9% K . I4K %'& x�K & N"N (9% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . I4K . KwK�G ( 3uB8O5,JB9K35, (+% 3�I � (U& l ( )U3 .m&�. & B9R � ( B & B9CMK�N:K�07K ./( 3�{ (9% K ) (9&!( Ko)v6 & l�KRD

��oF�"!# �#"$# � � �%" p�" �"!�� �#"$# � � � �%"%( o ?h V p# K l &�. B9K & )v3 . l & B9Kw{e,'N"N:C & RS35, (o(9% K K_sSK�l ( ) 3�{+l %'&�. O�K�) ( 3 (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 o � .f( KwBH0P) 3�{ (9% K x & N",JK�) (9%'&!(3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . ) I �"N"N (9&;@ KqpH�8Kwx�K . , . GJKwBU, . l�KwB (9& � ./( C & RS35, ( (9% K>) (9&!( ,')U3�{ (9% K>)vC`) ( K�0

��������� ��� ��� � � ���� � ��� �����) �$� �V� ���� � ��� �%� ��� �����W ,JB>GJK_B . � ( �:3 . )F{�B9350 & RS3�x�KMl &�. RSK B9K�) (9&!( K�G � . 073�B9KPO�K . KwB & N &�. G l�3 . l �")vK7{�3�BH0P) � . (9% K . 3 (9&!( �:3 . 3�{N�� . K & B & N:O�KwR'B &`

��� �") & )9,JR8)vK ( 3�{ (9% K x�K�l ( 3�B-)v6 & l�K ' ) � &�. G # �#"%� �%"'& �") & R & ) �") {�3�B (9% �")U)v6 & l�K � K ( ,') �"076S35)vK=3 .' ) (9% K � .'. KwB 6'B93`G','l (

oF�"!# �#"$# � � �%" p� o��B! �#"\# � � �%" p�" �"!��B! # � � � � � o ?h � pI % �"l % � . G','l�K�) (9% K . 3�BH0

� �"!# �#"$# � � �%" � "�� oF� )! # � ) � p o ?h n p��� �") (9% Ko)9,JR8)vK ( 3�{ ' ) l�3 . ) �") ( � . O73�{ & N"N�x�K�l ( 3�BH)FI � (9%m. 3�BH0 �! p# K GJK . 3 ( K RhC���� (9% K>6'B93 vK�l ( �:3 . 3 ./( 3(9% K )9,JR8)v6 & l�K=)v6 &�.'. K�G RhC � " � � K

�S! oF�"!# �#"$# � � �%" p " �"!# �#" o ?h y p� � oF�"!# �#"$# � � �%" p " � � �%"%(

E � .'& N"N:C��`I4K ,')vK (9% K . 3 (9&!( �:3 .6'B93�R�� � "�� � � "�� o ?h | p

( 3a) (9&�. G {�3�B (9% K 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C 3�{-3�R (9& � . � . O (9% K x & N",JK � " {�B9350 & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�{-) (9&!( K � "H � �:x�K .(9% K�)vKMGJK_B . � ( �:3 . )w� (9% KP6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C 3�{43�R (9& � . � . O & O �:x�K . x & N",JKP,J6S3 . & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( RSK7B9KwIUB � (v( K . � .(9% K ) �"0768N:KwBp{�3�BH0

6'B93�R�� � "�� � � "�� " � ��� � " � )�( o ?h "�w� pT 3PK . )9,JB9K>l�3 . ) �") ( K . l�C 3�{�{e, ( ,JB9K>07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )w�8I4K>I435,'N"G N�� @ K ( 3 ) & C (9%'&!(F& { ( KwBF07K & )9,JB � . O7x & N",JK � "{�B93502) (9&!( K� � " � (9% K . KwI<) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 �")����� � "H @ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% �")U) (9&!( KoGJ3hK�) . 3 (F%'& x�K . 3�BH0 � ��)v3� (U. KwK�G') ( 3PRSK=6'B93�6SKwBHN:C . 3�BH0 & N�� � K�G ( 3

���� � "� ��� � " � ( o ?h "��� p

Page 18: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

��? ������� ������� � � ��� � � � ��� ����� ��� � � � � � ����� � ��

r4CMK �h, &!( �:3 . o ?h V pH�'I4K=l &�. l %'& B & l ( KwB � � K (9% K-6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )43 . ��� & ) (9% 35)vK=N�� . K & B ( B &�. )v{�3�B �0 &!( �:3 . ) I % �"l % 6'B9K�)vKwB9x�K . 3�BH0 �

� 3 ( K (9%'&!(4(9% KwB9K �") � . O�K . KwB & N . 3 I & C ( 3 G �") ( � . O5, �") % RSK ( I4KwK . (9% K=) (9&!( K�) � "d&�. G��� � "H �mK & )9,JB � . OK � (9% KwB 3�{ (9% K�)vK ) (9&!( K�)PG �:B9K�l ( N:C I �"N"N~O �:x�K K�� & l ( N:C (9% K ) & 07K 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 .� L+6'68N:C � . O &�. C( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � ( 3 (9% K�)vK ) (9&!( K�)oC �:K�N"G') (9% K ) (9&!( K�) � � "=&�. G�� � � " ��I % �"l % ) ( �"N"N�6'B93`G','l�K �"GJK ./( �"l & NG �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . )d3�{�x & N",JK�) I % K . 3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G 4# K & N"N:3�I���� ( 3 l�3 ./(9& � . (9% K�)vK ( I43 G �") ( � . l ( .'& 07K�)w�8I � (9% (9% K, . GJKwBH) (9&�. G � . O (9%'&!(U(9% KwC B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(U(9% K>) & 07K , . GJKwBHN:C � . O 6 % C`) �"l & N�) (9&!( K

� ��� ����� (*)! ,+-".)0/ � � ��/

����� ��� � � �� ���� ����� �)�� � � �)��� ���� � �)������� �� � ��� ���

# K . 3�I %'& x�K & N"N 3�{ (9% K {�3�BH0 & N {�B & 07KwI43�B @ . K�l�K�)9) & B9C ( 3MO �:x�K &�. & lwl�35, ./( 3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0 � K (,') . 3�I l�3 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K ) (9&!( K )v6 & l�K 3�{ (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 &�.'& N:3�O5,JK ( 3 & R � ( � (9% K �mO \_STE jk. ) ( K & GfRSK � . O (9% K. 3�BH0 �H� )9,JR8)vK ( 3�{ (9% K-B9K & N8x�K�l ( 3�B+)v6 & l�K ' ) � (9% K-) (9&!( K=)v6 & l�K �") . 3�I (9% K . 3�BH0 �H� )9,JR8)vK ( 3�{ (9% K-l�350768N:K��x�K�l ( 3�B-)v6 & l�K�� ) dTU%'&!( �")w�

��� "$# �"!# �#"$# � � �%" DV�"! � � �&% � � �"!N���! # � � ��� � " ��&)( o ?h "��? pTU% K � .'. KwBp6'B93`G','l (U% KwB9K �") (9% K>{ & 0 �"N�� & B

oF�"!# �#"$# � � �%" p� o��B! �#"\# � � �%" p�" �"!�� �! # � � � � � � o ?h "��D pI % �"l % � . G','l�K�) (9% K . 3�BH0

� �"!# �#"$# � � �%" � " � �"!# ) # � � ) o ?h "��Q pL . C7) (9&!( KU3 (9% KwB (9%'&�.P& R & ) �")�K�N:K�07K ./( �")~) & �"G ( 3>RSK (9% K dYOcN H_XQNILqdYSTETSUL;V 3�{ (9% 35)vKUR & ) �")�K�N:K�07K ./( )~3�{�I % �"l %� ( �") & N�� . K & BUl�350 R � .'&!( �:3 .� LF) � . (9% Kd6'B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"l�l & )vK���I4Kp)v6SK�l �:{�C & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( � .>( KwBH0P)�3�{'6'B93 vK�l ( �:3 . )�3 ./( 3 (9% Kp)9,JR8)v6 & l�K�)

)v6 &�.'. K�GmRhC �#"+&�. G �%"H � �h, &!( �:3 . )!o ?h "�w� p &�. G>o ?h "��� pFl & B9B9C 3�x�KwB , . l %'&�. O�K�G -E 3�B �����SI4K & N"N:3�Is3 . K3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K�� I % �"l % l &�.a%'& x�K (9% KPx & N",JK �#" 3�B� �%"H Mj { (9% KM) (9&!( K �"! �#"Y# � � �%" �")>07K & )9,JB9K�G�� (9% K7x & N",JK3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G I �"N"N�RSK �#" I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C �"!3� �! " �"!# ) &�. G$ �%" I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C � � � � � " � � ) } % C`) �"l �") ( )FI435,'N"G 0 & � ./(9& � . (9%'&!( ��� %'& )F3 (9% KwB=3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K�)0o � . { & l ( � 6 % C`) �"l �") ( )+I435,'N"G lwN & �"0 (9%'&!(

��� %'& ) &�. , . l�35, ./(9& R8N:C � . B . � ( K . ,'0 RSKwB 3�{>3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K�)Yp �TU% �") �") & l & )vK � . I % �"l % 35,JB 6'B & l ( �"l & NB9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 . )F3 . I %'&!( l�3 . ) ( � ( , ( K�) &�. =k3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:Kg? 6'B93�6SKwB ( C 3�{ & )vC`) ( K�0 & B9KP) ( B93 . O�KwB (9%'&�. (9% 35)vK 3 .(9% K & 6 % C`) �"l �") ( � )F{�3�BH0 & N�GJK_B . � ( �:3 . 3�{!=k3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K ? �#"F&�. G �%"F& B9K (9% KKL;V : ^7) (9&!( K�)>3�{���� ( 3 I % �"l %��� =�:�M D�GBMN:�D/7�? :@"G6EX7�=�? @"8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037"4ID�:�:037�? D�:K LYP :�7�:�D�8;? 0�:QPSW3L\7�=�:�M D�G��F:<�7�? GB0 GBMN:�D>4I7�G6D�@�����4605P�� - ]���G6D�:�RB:0�:�D>46K K L3A

? E��(? @ 4 TU:<�7�G6D�@/M546<: �$=�? <>=;<Q460;WN:��JD�? 7/7�:0�46@ 7�=�:\P ? D�:<�7�@/2�8+G6E�@/2�W�@/M546<:@ ���"!#� - !%$%$%$#��&VAX4605P��'�? @ 7�=�:$M D�G��F:<�7�? GB0;E D�GB8� GB037�G��'FAX7�=�:0�7�=�:@/:SM D�G��F:<�7�? GB0�@$P :�7�:�D�8;? 0�:\4 MNGB@/@/? W�K : 8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037QA �$=�? <>=�@�4I7�? @FO5:@J46K KN7�=�:S46WNGITU:\:Q13254I7�? GB0�@] (�G6DJGB2 DM�2 D�MNGB@/:@AN7�=�? @ �$? K K WN:*? 8;MNG6D/7>46037SM D�? 0�<? M546K K L�? 0 P ? @/<2�@/@/? 0�R�8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037�@\GB0 M�? :<:@ G6E�K 4ID�RB:�D @FL @F7�:8;@%(JK G3G X? 0�RZ4I7 GB0�:M�? :<:JG6E�4S@FL @F7�:890�::QPC0�G67 0�:<:@/@�4ID�? K L�<Q462�@/:$G67�=�:�D M�? :<:@�G6E57�=�:J@FL @F7�:8 7�G�)�<GBK K 46M�@/:BA *�46@�� :K K[] �":<>=�0�? <Q46K K L3AUGB0�:J@/MN:<? O5:@4C@/:K E +�4BP��FGB? 037 GBMN:�D>4I7�G6D-,�7�=�:@/:Y@/2�W�@/M546<:@S4ID�: 7�=�:0�7�=�:YP ? @F7�? 0�<�7\:? RB:0�@/M546<:@SG6E 7�=54I7\GBMN:�D>4I7�G6DQ]�+�2 7$7�=�? @$? 037�:�D�M D�:�7>4I7�? GB0Z? @8;G6D�:$RB:0�:�D>46K57�=5460 � :$D�:Q132�? D�:B]�. ? 7�=&4Y@/? 0�RBK :S<Q460�GB0�? <Q46KVW546@/? @�? 0 �$=�? <>=�46K KNGB2 D 8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037�@�4ID�:S<Q4ID/D�? :QP;GB2 7QAX? 7 ? @�8;G6D�:<GB0XTU:0�? :037\7�G&@/MN:<? E L GB0�K LZ7�=�: @/2�W�@/M546<:@Y4605PZ0�G67 � G6D/D/L 46WNGB2 7Y4;@/:K E +�4BP��FGB? 037YGBMN:�D>4I7�G6DQA �$=�? <>=��$? K K WN:*? 05P :MN:05P :037\G6EW546@/? @]

Page 19: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ���� ��� ��� ��� � � � ����� � ��D

I4K-l &�. O �:x�K & 07K &�. � . O�{e,'NJK�� ( K . ) �:3 .'& N�GJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 .� TU% ,')~I4K � . ) �") (�(9%'&!( 3 . N:C (9% K-07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( I % �"l %6'B93`G','l�K�)! �#" 3�B �%" l &�. RSK l�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G 4TU% �")pB9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 . GJ3hK�) . 3 (+& sSK�l (F(9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N 6S3�I4KwB+3�{35,JB~{�3�BH0 & N��")90�o ( 3ol & B9B9C 35, (d& 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( � .7&�. 3 (9% KwB4R & ) �")w� � ( )9, r l�K�) ( 3 B93 (9&!( K � ./( 3 (9%'&!( R & ) �") &�. G(9% K . l & B9B9C 35, (+& 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( � . (9% K=R & ) �") # �#"%� �%"'& p # K l & N"N # �#"%� �%"'&7(9% K8J�L;M�NPOIEQ9RETSUL;VP9;: \'9qdYS d TU% K 6SKwBH0 � (v( K�G ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) 3 .f(9% �")o)vC`) ( K�0 & B9K (9% 35)vK I % �"l %f& B9K N�� . K & B &�. Ga6'B9K�)vKwB9x�K � .'. KwB

6'B93`G','l (��� pu ,'l % ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) & B9K l & N"N:K�GhO V STEQ9;XY^ &�. G ) &!( �")v{�C (9% K>K �h, &!( �:3 . � " � " "�� � " �� � " o ?h "��V p

{�3�B & N"N� � "%� � " % ��� � . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )+6'B9K�)vKwB9x�K . 3�BH0 &�. G & B9K � . x�KwB ( �:R8N:K FE ,JB (9% KwB�� & ( B &�. ) �{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �")=, . � (9& B9C �:{ &�. G 3 . N:C �:{ � ( �") & R � vK�l ( �:3 . RSK ( I4KwK . ( I43 3�B (9% 3 . 3�BH0 & N�R & )vK�) MTU% K �"GJK ./( � ( C( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �")�, . � (9& B9CPD � (�(9&;@ K�) (9% K+l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N`R & ) �") ( 3 � ( )vK�N:{ TU% K . KwO &!( �:3 .P( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .�a�'I % �"l % (9&;@ K�)� �#"p( 3 �%"p&�. G x �"l�K � x�KwBH) & � �") & N")v3P, . � (9& B9C�� & ) � ( 6SKwBH0o, ( K�) (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �") L . C N�� . K & B ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l &�. RSK>O �:x�K . � . 0 &!( B � � {�3�BH04o�I � (9% B9K�)v6SK�l (U( 3 & O �:x�K . R & ) �")Yp t I4K I �"N"N

{�B9K �h,JK ./( N:C!B . G � ( l�3 . x�K . �:K ./(p( 3 GJ3 )v3 ~E 3�B K�� & 0768N:K��hI � (9% B9K�)v6SK�l (4( 3 (9% K-l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N8R & ) �")w� 7&�. G� %'& x�Ko0 &!( B � � B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(9&!( �:3 . ) " � � ��$��� � " � �$�

� ��� ( o ?h "��� pTU% KwB9K & B9K & N")v3 073�B9K K��`3 ( �"l , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) I % �"l %%'& x�K . 3 lwN & )9) �"l & N-l�35, ./( KwB96 & B ( ) E 3�BK�� & 0768N:K���l�3 . ) �"GJKwB (9% KFJ�L;VPZ;STETSUL;VP9;:.N G 9qdgHd�GaS �_Ee��I % �"l % N:K & x�K�) �#" , . l %'&�. O�K�G R8, ( ) % �:{ ( ) (9% K76 %'& )vK73�{ �%" RhC�� D � � " � � �

��� � � � " � � �� � � � ( o ?h "��n p

E 3�B &�. C ) (9&!( K � " � 07K & )9,JB � . O`o � . (9% KPl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �")Yp� � "F&�. G� � � " I �"N"N�6'B93`G','l�K7l�350768N:K ( K�N:C

�"GJK ./( �"l & N=G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . )P3�{ox & N",JK�) � 3 . K (9% K�N:K�)9)w� � " &�. G� � � " & B9K G �CsSKwB9K ./( 6 % C`) �"l & N=) (9&!( K�)w� &�. G

& 6'68N:C � . OM3 (9% KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) & { ( KwB� � J�9;V 6'B93`G','l�Ko3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:C G �CsSKwB9K ./( ) (9&!( K�) 7# KP) %'& N"N�)vKwK &�.

K�� & 0768N:K=3�{�)9,'l % & ) � ( , &!( �:3 . � . (9% K . K�� ( )vK�l ( �:3 .� L . 3 (9% KwB �"076S3�B (9&�./( , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �") (9% K��59 Z 9;M9;X Z X LREQ9RETSUL;V�� O �:x�K . RhC� "�� �� ) �� )�� )�� �� ) � " �! ? � � �

� � �"� ( o ?h "��y pTU% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . %'& )4RSKwK . l & N"N:K�G (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 =k{ & �:B � l�3 � . � �:6 � ? ) � . l�K � (4(9&;@ K�)! �#"d( 3 (9% K=) (9&!( K�� ) �#"$# �� ) �%" �'I % �"l % %'& ) K �h, & N�6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( CP3�{ C �:K�N"G � . O �#"p&�. G$ �%" �:{ � ( �") (9% K . 07K & )9,JB9K�G ~@ 3�I4Kwx�KwB��� %'& ) &P. ,'0 RSKwB 3�{�3 (9% KwB � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O76'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)w� & )UI4K ) %'& N"NS)vKwK

����� ��� �$#� �� � *&%(' J*)����# K . 3�IsK�� & 0 � . K &�. K�� & 0768N:K (9%'&!( I �"N"N�GJK�073 . ) ( B &!( K (9%'&!(-(9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 6 �"l ( ,JB9K 3�{ (9% KoI43�BHN"G �") . 3 (B9K�G','l �:R8N:K ( 3 & lwN & )9) �"l & N�3 . K 143 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K ( I43M) (9&!( K�)

+ " " �� ) �#"\# �� ) �%" , " " �� ) �#" � �� ) �%"%( o ?h "��| p- � =�? @ <GB0�@F7/D>46? 037YEHGBK K G"�$@ E D�GB8 7�=�:;PXL 05468;? <@SG6E$132546037�2�8 @FL @F7�:8;@A�RBGITU:�D�0�:QP W3LZ7�=�:/.X<>= D�G3:QP ? 0�RB:�D :Q13254I7�? GB0�]*7�? 8;:#+:TUGBK 2 7�? GB0ZG6E 4�132546037�2�8 @FL @F7�:8Z]

Page 20: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

��Q ������� ������� � � ��� � � � ��� ����� ��� � � � � � ����� � ��

�mK & )9,JB � . O K � (9% KwB>3�{ (9% K�)vKM) (9&!( K�) C �:K�N"G') (9% KPx & N",JK�) �#"=&�. G �%" I � (9% K �h, & N�6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C 7jk. ( KwBH0P)>3�{(9% �") 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( �� + " &�. G , "4& B9K � . G �") ( � . O5, �") %'& R8N:K W-. (9% K=3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� & 6'68N:C � . O (9% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . � ( 3 (9% K�)vK ) (9&!( K�)+C �:K�N"G')� + " " ��� �� ) �#"$# �� ) �%"��

" �� ) � �� ) �#"\# �� ) �%"�� # �� ) � �� ) �#" � �� ) �%"��" �#"&�. G� , " " ��� �� ) �#"$# �� ) �%"��

" �� ) � �� ) �#"\# �� ) �%"�� � �� ) � �� ) �#" � �� ) �%"��" �%"

o ?h ?!� p

�mK & )9,JB � . O � + " 6'B93`G','l�K�) (9% K x & N",JK �#" I � (9% l�KwB (9& � ./( C t 07K & )9,JB � . O � , " 6'B93`G','l�K�) (9% K x & N",JK �%"I � (9% l�KwB (9& � ./( C dTU% K�)vK ( I437) (9&!( K�)w� � . G �") ( � . O5, �") %'& R8N:K ( 3 G �:B9K�l ( 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( � . Kwx�KwB (9% K�N:K�)9)4l &�. RSK ( 35N"G& 6 & B ( RhC`B8BH) (o& 6'68N:C � . O &�. 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . &�. G (9% K . 07K & )9,JB � . O TU% �") �") ( Ch6 �"l & N4{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P)mD3�{ ( K . � ( �")p3 . N:C (9% K0X'H_:i9RETS<bRH 6 %'& )vK=3�{ ( I43 l�35076S3 . K ./( ) 3�{ (9% K>) (9&!( K I % �"l % l & B9B �:K�) � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .� LFN (9% 35,JO % � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �") . K � (9% KwB~l�B9K &!( K�G . 3�BdGJK�) ( B93�C�K�GPRhC , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) � .7& �h, &�./( ,'0

)vC`) ( K�0 o�RSK�l & ,')vK �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) & B9KoB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kqp (9% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l�3 ./(9& � . K�G I � (9% � . & )vC`) ( K�0 0 & CRSK 073�B9K 3�B N:K�)9) & lwl�K�)9) �:R8N:KmGJKw6SK . G � . O 3 .�% 3�I (9%'&!( � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �")P) ( 3�B9K�G &�. G % 3�I (9% Km)vC`) ( K�0 �")07K & )9,JB9K�G �mK & )9,JB � . O (9% K + " 3�B! , " ) (9&!( K�) G �:B9K�l ( N:CP6'B93�x �"GJK�) . 3 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, (4(9% K=) (9&!( K=3�{ (9% K)vC`) ( K�0 �mK & )9,JB � . O & N & B9O�K . ,'0 RSKwB+3�{~l�3�6 �:K�)F3�{ (9% �")F) (9&!( KKo�K � (9% KwB & N"N , " 3�B & N"N + " p+GJ3hK�) . 3 ( Kwx�K .6'B93`G','l�K &�. C ) (9&!( �") ( �"l & N � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & ) ( 3PI % K (9% KwB (9% KwC & B9K + " 3�B� , "H L . 3 (9% KwBPI & C 3�{-l %'& B & l ( KwB � � � . O (9% �") K �h, �:x & N:K . l�K �") (9%'&!(P(9% K =vl�35N"N & 68)vKg? 3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 � . G','l�K�G

RhC 35,JB-07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( =vGJK�) ( B93�C`)'? 3 . KoR � ( 3�{ � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .� FW-.m(9% Ko3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� & 6'68N:C � . O� &�. G (9% K .07K & )9,JB � . O=K�� ( B & l ( ) (9% K+{e,'N"N`3 . K+R � ( 3�{ � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 6'B9K�)vK ./( � .7(9% KF)vC`) ( K�0 4u � . l�K+07K & )9,JB � . O �#" C �:K�N"G')(9% K>x & N",JK �#" � (9% K 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( l & ,')vK�) . 37{e,JB (9% KwB=vl�35N"N & 68)vKg? &�. G . 3 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �") GJK�) ( B93�C�K�G

� ��� ����� � 0 ,/ �� � 2 "6 #".$'2-+

TU% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � � ./( B93`G','l�K�G � . (9% K-6'B9Kwx �:35,')p)vK�l ( �:3 . %'& ) &7. ,'0 RSKwBp3�{ x�KwB9C � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O 6'B93�6SKwB �( �:K�) dE �:BH) ( � � ( �")U)vK�N:{ � � . x�KwBH)vKRD � ) " � �� ) � ) � � �

� � � � � � �� � � � o ?h ?`� p

" � � �� � �

" ��& { & l ( I % �"l % =kK��`68N & � . )'? (9% K=6'B9Kwx �:35,')pK�� & 0768N:K �jk. ( KwBH0P) 3�{ (9% �") �"GJK ./( � ( C��'I4K l &�. B9KwIUB � ( K8o ?h ?!� p & )� + " " � ) �#" " �#" " �#" o ?h ?�? p� , " " � )# �%" " �%" " �%"%(

Page 21: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ���� � ���� ��� ���� � � � � ��� ��� ��V

# K & N:B9K & GJC @`. 3�I (9%'&!( &�. C , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . (9&;@ K�) & R & ) �") ( 3 &�. 3 (9% KwB R & ) �") t�(9% K @F& G & 0 & BHGB93 (9&!( �:3 . %'& ) (9% K-,')vKw{e,'N'6'B93�6SKwB ( C73�{ 0 & 6'6 � . O>R & l @ &�. GP{�3�B (9% RSK ( I4KwK . ( I43 K�)v6SK�l � & N"N:C ,')vKw{e,'N'R & )vK�) �(9&;@ K�) (9% K>l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �")

�#" �%" o ?h ?�D p( 3 (9% K�� L;O XYSQH_X!\'9qdYS d�� � �� ) �#"$# �� ) �%" � �� ) �#" � �� ) �%"%(�� o ?h ?�Q p&�. Gmx �"l�K � x�KwBH) &` -j ( �")Flw,') ( 350 & B9C ( 3 B9Kw{�KwB ( 3 (9% �")+0 & 6'6 � . OPRSK ( I4KwK . R & )vK�) & ) & X LREQ9RETSUL;V � ./( 3 &�. Gm35, (3�{ (9% K E 35,JB �:KwBUR & ) �") TU% K 3 . N:CmG �CsSKwB9K . l�K RSK ( I4KwK . (9% K ( I43 K�N:K�07K ./( )=3�{ (9% K E 35,JB �:KwB=R & ) �") �") (9% K B9K�N &!( �:x�K 6 %'& )vK 3�{ (9% K

�#"-&�. G �%" l�35076S3 . K ./( ) LF)=I4K %'& x�KM)vKwK . ��B9K�N &!( �:x�KP6 %'& )vKPG �CsSKwB9K . l�K�) & B9K . 3 ( G �:B9K�l ( N:C 07K & )9,JB & R8N:K��R8, (o(9% �")oGJ3hK�) . 3 ( 07K &�. (9%'&!( (9% KwC & B9K �:B9B9K�N:Kwx &�./( o & ) O5N:3�R & Nd6 %'& )vK ) % �:{ ( ) & B9Kqp jk. 0 &�. C �h, &�./( ,'0& N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w� & N"0735) (d& N"N (9% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � .M& O �:x�K . ) (9&!( KFI �"N"N`RSKUK . l�3`GJK�G � . B9K�N &!( �:x�K+6 %'& )vK+G �CsSKwB9K . l�K�) t@F& G & 0 & BHGPB93 (9&!( �:3 . )d3�B43 (9% KwBpl %'&�. O�K�)d3�{�R & ) �")�I �"N"N (9% K . l�3 . x�KwB (4(9% K+6 %'& )vK+G �CsSKwB9K . l�K�) � ./( 3 & G �:B9K�l ( N:C3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K={�3�BH0 E 3�B+K�� & 0768N:K��8l�3 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K>l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � 6 %'& )vK>) % �:{ ( 3�6SKwB &!( 3�B

� � 3 . (9% K E 35,JB �:KwBUR & ) �") ) (9&!( K�)mD� � � �! ? �#"$# �! ? �%" � " �! ? �#" � �! ? �%" o ?h ?�V p� � � �! ? �#" � �! ? �%" � " �! ? �#"\# �! ? �%"� � (9% ,') � ./( KwBHl %'&�. O�K�) (9% K ( I43MR & ) �") K�N:K�07K ./( ) � . (9% K E 35,JB �:KwBUR & ) �")w�`Kwx�K .m(9% 35,JO % � ( �")UG � & O�3 .'& N � . (9% Kl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N R & ) �") pTU% ,')w� &�. 3 (9% KwBFI & C ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( � o (9% K . KwO &!( �:3 . 3�6SKwB &!( 3�B���I % �"l % )vI & 68)� �#"&�. G �%" p �") ( 3 B93 (9&!( K � ./( 3 (9% K E 35,JB �:KwBpR & ) �")w�`,')vK

� � ( 3 � ./( KwBHl %'&�. O�K (9% K-K�N:K�07K ./( )p3�{ (9% K E 35,JB �:KwBpR & ) �")w�&�. G (9% K . B93 (9&!( K R & l @ � ./( 3 (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �") Fu � . l�K(� l�3 . x�KwB ( )-RSK ( I4KwK . l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N &�. GE 35,JB �:KwBUR & ) �")w� (9% �") 3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . C �:K�N"G') (9% K �"GJK ./( � ( C� � � � " � ( o ?h ?�� p

jk. 6'B & l ( �"l�K�� (9% �") �"GJK ./( � ( C �") 073�B9Kp,')vKw{e,'N � . (9% K & N ( KwB .'&!( Kp{�3�BH0� � " � � �a��3�R (9& � . K�GoRhC>K��`68N:3 � ( � . O(9% KF)vK�N:{ � � . x�KwBH)vKU6'B93�6SKwB ( C 3�{ � } %'& )vK+) % �:{ ( ) & B9KFl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N"N:C ,')vKw{e,'NJRSK�l & ,')vK (9% KwC7l &�. l�3 ./( B �:R8, ( K

( 3 . 3 .�� ( B �:x � & N � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�KoK_sSK�l ( ) L R � ( � �:6 l &�. RSKol�3 . x�KwB ( K�G ( 3 & 6 %'& )vKo) % �:{ ( RhC & 6'68N:C � . O � (F( 3 &�h,JR � ( � . (9% K ) (9&!( K �� ) �#" � �� ) �%" �8RSK�l & ,')vK� � �! ? �#" � �! ? �%" � " � �! ? �#"\# �! ? �%"%( o ?h ?5n pL R � (�� � �:6 %'& ) RSKwK . l�3 . x�KwB ( K�G � ./( 3 &�. 3�x�KwB & N"N 0o,'N ( �:68N��"l &!( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K=6 %'& )vK=RhC � ���� ~#% K . l�350 R � . K�GI � (9% )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . �5)9,'l % 6 %'& )vKF) % �:{ ( ) & B9K=l�K ./( B & N ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) �T 37)vKwK % 3�I )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 .&�. G76 %'& )vK+) % �:{ ( ) � ./( KwB & l ( � . (9% K�)vK & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w�5I4K+I �"N"N . KwK�G ( 3 K�� & 0 � . K �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P)dN & B9O�KwB (9%'&�.& ) � . O5N:K �h,JR � (w �� =�:�(�GB2 D�? :�D W546@/? @ ? @ @/G*05468;:QP�WN:<Q462�@/:S? 7 ? @�7�=�:\054I7�2 D>46K5W546@/? @J? 0 �$=�? <>=;7�G <Q4ID/D/L&GB2 7JP ? @/<�D�:�7�:�(�GB2 D�? :�DJ460546K L @/? @J2�@/? 0�R

132546037�2�8 46K RBG6D�? 7�=�8;@]�.�:Y@/=546K K�8;::�7$@/2�<>=Z46K RBG6D�? 7�=�8;@\K 4I7�:�DQA�? 0Z<>=546M 7�:�D�3]� �":<>=�0�? <Q46K K L 4 )�M�=546@/:�@/=�? E 7YG6E� A *�WN:<Q462�@/:�� ' ����� BA 4&MN:�D�@/MN:<�7�? TU:*7�=54I7 4ID�? @/:@YW3LZ7�=�? 0&X? 0�R�G6EJ132546037�2�8 @F7>4I7�:@Y? 07�:�D�8;@JG6E MNGBK 4IDS<G3G6D>P ? 054I7�:@]

Page 22: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

��� ������� ������� � � ��� � � � ��� ����� ��� � � � � � ����� � ��

� ��� �K ��� � � (*)! ,+-".)0/ � �5& " � / &

143 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K4{�35N"N:3�I � . O+l %'& B & l ( KwB � ��&!( �:3 . 3�{ ���cD-= ��� �") (9% K4)vK ( 3�{ . 3�BH0 �H� x�K�l ( 3�BH) � .>(9% Kpl�350768N:K��>x�K�l ( 3�B)v6 & l�K=I � (9% R & ) �")��! ? �FK . KwB & N�� � � . O (9% �")pl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . C �:K�N"G') & l %'& B & l ( KwB � ��&!( �:3 . 3�{ 073�B9K=l�350768N��"l &!( K�G�h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P) � . ( KwBH0P)U3�{ (9% K �:B+lwN & )9) �"l & N�l�35, ./( KwB96 & B ( ) u 6SK�l �CB�l & N"N:C��hl�3 . ) �"GJKwB &�.�� � R � ( B9KwO �") ( KwB��Jl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( K�G {�B9350 � ) � . O5N:K � R � ( B9KwO �") ( KwBH)w� � K l�3�6 �:K�)p3�{ �!

1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�� (9% �")dB9KwO �") ( KwBpl &�. %'& x�K &�. CP3�{ ?�� 6S35)9) �:R8N:K x & N",JK�)w�h3 . K-l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G � . O ( 3oK & l % l % 3 �"l�KF3�{ (9% Kx & N",JK� �#" 3�B �%" {�3�B-K & l % 3�{ (9% K � . G �:x �"G', & N�B9KwO �") ( KwBH) -TU% ,')w� (9% K ) (9&!( K7)v6 & l�K �� �� 3�{ & lwN & )9) �"l & N � � R � (B9KwO �") ( KwB �") (9% K>)vK (

� � �� "

� � �

�#" ( ( ( �#" �#" �#" ( ( ( �#" �%" �#" ( ( ( �%" �#" �#" ( ( ( �%" �%" �%" ( ( ( �%" �#" �%" ( ( ( �%" �%"

� � �

"$# ��! " � � " ( ( ( � � � � " D�� � % # � ����&& o ?h ?�y p

E 3�B (9% K ) &;@ Km3�{FR'B9Kwx � ( C�� &�. G ( 3 � . G �"l &!( K (9%'&!(P(9% K�)vKm) (9&!( K�) & B9Km) (9&!( K�)P3�{ & N & B9O�KwBM)vC`) ( K�0 �4I4K I �"N"N)v3507K ( �"07K�)U,')vK (9% K . 3 (9&!( �:3 .

� " " ��! ( ( ( � � � ) � � � � " {�3�B ��! " ( ( ( � � � ) " � � � � "%( o ?h ?�| p

TU% K ) (9&!( K )v6 & l�K �� ��� 3�{ &�.�� � R � ( �h, &�./( ,'0 B9KwO �") ( KwB�� (9% K . � �") (9% K )vK ( 3�{ . 3�BH0 �H� x�K�l ( 3�BH) � .a(9% Kl�350768N:K�� x�K�l ( 3�B-)v6 & l�K>I � (9% R & ) �") �� �� �� dE 3�BH0 & N"N:C��

� � ��� "�� �������� !�� � � &

� � � " DV� � % � � ������ !�� � � & � � ) " �

� �� ( o ?h D!� p

u � . l�KFK & l % �h,JR � ( � .M(9% �")p)vC`) ( K�0 %'& ) &�. 3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:KFx & N",JK�� (9% K-3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K�)4{�3�B (9% K-B9KwO �") ( KwB & ) & I % 35N:K& B9K E<GIHb;9;: O H8L��9;V ^ dQN H'JmS ! H'Z �mO \_STE jk. 07K & )9,JB � . O �h,JR � ( �9� (9% K 6'B93 vK�l ( �:3 . �S! �") (9% K 6'B93 vK�l ( �:3 . 3 ./( 3(9% KF)9,JR8)v6 & l�KU3�{��� ��� )v6 &�.'. K�G7RhC (9% 35)vK+K�N:K�07K ./( )d3�{ �� �� � . I % �"l % �h,JR � ( � %'& )dx & N",JK� �#"�t � � �")~GJK_B . K�G) �"0 �"N & BHN:C L (4(9% �")�6S3 � ./( � (9% K+,')9, & N'K �h, &!( �:3 . )-o ?h "�w� p &�. G o ?h "��� p & 6'68N:C ( 3oGJK ( KwBH0 � . K (9% K+6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C 3�{K & l % 35, ( l�3507K &�. G (9% K ) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 & { ( KwB & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(w �m3�B9K l�350768N��"l &!( K�G 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )l &�. RSK+R8, �"N ( ,J6 RhCM07K & )9,JB � . Oo)vKwx�KwB & N��h,JR � ( ) � . )9,'lwl�K�)9) �:3 .� �j ( �")4K & )vC ( 37l % K�l @M(9%'&!( 07K & )9,JB � . O Kwx�KwB9C�h,JR � ( O �:x�K�)U35, ( l�3507K � " I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C � � )

�� ��� �") & ?���" � � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& Ndx�K�l ( 3�B )v6 & l�K��4)v3 (9% K 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) 3 . � (7& B9K (9% K ?���" � �G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& NF, . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) W {o6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B � ./( KwB9K�) ( � % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� �") (9% K )9,JR�lwN & )9) 3�{ (9% 35)vK( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) I % �"l % l &�. RSK � . G','l�K�G RhC & l ( � . O73 . 3 . K=R � (U&!(+&7( �"07K 143 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K & l ( 3�{ � �:6'6 � . O & ) � . O5N:K R � ( o�{�3�B . 3 (9&!( �:3 .'& N~l�3 . x�K . �:K . l�K�� (9% KPN:Kw{ ( 0735) ( p � . &�.#� � R � (

lwN & )9) �"l & N`B9KwO �") ( KwB �TU% �") ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �") &�.7& l ( �:3 .7(9%'&!( � . x�35N:x�K�)�3 . K R � ( �5)v3 � ( l &�. RSK l�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G & ) &$-��G6D�:YEHG6D�8&46K K L3A�%'& &)(* ? @J7�=�:,+ #%��-�.�$0/ $1.3254�6�+ G6E87 <GBM�? :@$G6E9% * ]

Page 23: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� ���� ��� ���� � ��� ��� � � �� ��� � ��n

0 & 6'6 � . O � D �! � �! 4@ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� � & N")v3 � . G','l�K�) & 0 & 6�� ! D �� �� � �� �� �'3�R (9& � . K�G RhC l�350768, ( � . O(9% K>K_sSK�l ( 3 . (9% K=B9KwO �") ( KwB+3�{ & 6'68N:C � . O�� ( 3 (9% K>N:Kw{ ( 0735) ( R � ( D

� ! " � � �

� ( ( ( ���#" � � ( ( ( ���#" � ( ( ( �J�%" � � ( ( ( �J�%" � ( ( (��w�#" � � ( ( (��w�#" � ( ( (����%" � � ( ( (����%"%(

o ?h D`� p

r4K�l & ,')vK�� ! �")UGJK_B . K�G {�3�BFKwx�KwB9C K�N:K�07K ./( 3�{ & R & ) �") {�3�B!�� ��� �8I4Kol &�. N�� . K & BHN:CMK�� ( K . G�� ! � ./( 3 & 0 & 6� !AD)�� ��� � �� ��� D � !(� � � � � � " � " � �� � � ! � " o ?h D�? p

�m3�B9KPO�K . KwB & N"N:C�� � ( �")-6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 K�� ( K . G & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � D���� � ��� I % �"l % & l ( )>3 . & ) � . O5N:K�h,JR � (~( 3 & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � � �� D �� ��� � �� ��� I % �"l %M& l ( )43 . &�. K ./( �:B9K �h, &�./( ,'0�B9KwO �") ( KwB ~TU% K & l ( �:3 .3�{ � � �� 3 . &�. K�N:K�07K ./( 3�{ �� �� l &�. RSK GJK ( KwBH0 � . K�G RhC & 6'68N:C � . O � ( 3 (9% K & 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( K �h,JR � ( 3�{ (9%'&!(K�N:K�07K ./(o&�. GfN:K & x � . O (9% KM3 (9% KwB �h,JR � ( )>, . l %'&�. O�K�G TU% K & l ( �:3 . 3�{ � � �� 3 .f&�.f& B9R � ( B & B9C K�N:K�07K ./( 3�{�� ��� {�35N"N:3�I+)pRhC N�� . K & BHN:CPK�� ( K . G � . O � ( ) & l ( �:3 . 3 . �� �� LF) &�. K�� & 0768N:K��'l�3 . ) �"GJKwB &7( I43 � �h,JR � ( )vC`) ( K�0 �� ) � �'I � (9% R & ) �")

# ���#"%� �J�%"%� �w�#"%� ���%"'&)( o ?h D�D pL @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . & 6'68N��:K�G ( 3 (9% KAB8BH) ( �h,JR � ( � . G','l�K�) (9% K>0 & 6

���#" � �� ) ���#"$# �� ) �w�#" �J�%" � �� ) �J�%"$# �� ) ���%" �w�#" � �� ) ���#" � �� ) �w�#" ���%" � �� ) �J�%" � �� ) ���%"%( o ?h D�Q p

u � . O5N:K � �h,JR � (=( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) & B9K . 3 (o(9% K 3 . N:C 3 . K�)oI % �"l % l &�. RSKMK�� ( K . GJK�G ( 3 I43�B @ 3 . K ./( �:B9KB9KwO �") ( KwBH) � .m(9% �")FI & C t � ( �") & N")v3 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 )v6SK�l �:{�C & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . I % �"l % & l ( )=3 . ( I43m073�B9K7073�B9K�h,JR � ( ) &�. G & 6'68N:C � (�( 3 &�. K ./( �:B9K4B9KwO �") ( KwB �jk. (9% �") l & )vK�� 9,') ( & )�RSKw{�3�B9K�� (9% K & l ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .3 . & R & ) �")+K�N:K�07K ./( �")-l & N"lw,'N &!( K�G RhC K�� & 0 � . � . O (9% K & l ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 3 . (9% 35)vK �h,JR � ( ) � (K��`68N��"l � ( N:C & sSK�l ( ) L . K�� & 0768N:K 3�{ & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . I % �"l % l &�.'. 3 ( RSKoB9K�G','l�K�G ( 3 & ) � . O5N:K � R � (+( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �")�� �

(9% K l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �'I % �"l % � �:68) (9% K ) (9&!( Ko3�{�3 . K �h,JR � ( �:{ &�. G 3 . N:C �:{ &�. 3 (9% KwB �h,JR � (o (9% KF=vl�3 ./( B935N ? �h,JR � ( p �") � . ) (9&!( K� �%"H 4TU%'&!( �")w��� & l ( )U3 . �� ) & )

���#" � ���#" �J�%" � �J�%" �w�#" � �J�%" ���%" � �w�#"%�

o ?h D�V p

Page 24: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

��y ������� ������� � � ��� � � � ��� ����� ��� � � � � � ����� � ��

I % KwB9K (9% K7N:Kw{ ( �h,JR � ( �") (9% K7l�3 ./( B935N �h,JR � (w &� 3 ( �"l�K (9%'&!( � 6SKwBH0o, ( K�) (9% K K�N:K�07K ./( )-3�{ �� ) � &�. G (9% ,')�")-, . � (9& B9C �m3�B9K �"076S3�B (9&�./( N:C���� I435,'N"G . 3 ( 0 &;@ KM)vK . )vK & ) & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 3 . K � (9% KwB=3�{ � ( ) � . 68, (�h,JR � ( ) & N:3 . K # � (9% 0o,'N ( �:68N:K � �h,JR � (7( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )M)9,'l %& ) � � � ( �")M6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 l�B9K &!( K H_V EQ9;V kR: H'Z ) (9&!( K�)w� � .

I % �"l %M(9% K=l�3�B9B9K�N &!( �:3 . RSK ( I4KwK . ( I4376 �:K�l�K�)p3�{ & )vC`) ( K�0 �") �"076S3�B (9&�./( � . 3 ( 9,') (4(9% K �:B � . G �:x �"G', & NJ) (9&!( K�) 143 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K {�35N"N:3�I � . O )vK �h,JK . l�K 3�{ ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) �uh(9& B ( � . O {�B9350 (9% K ) (9&!( K ���#" � & 6'68N:C � . O �6'B93`G','l�K�) (9% K ) (9&!( K �� ) ���#" # �� ) �w�#"H L+6'68N:C � . O (9% K . KwO &!( �:3 . O &!( K�� ( 3 (9% K )vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( � 3�{ (9% �")) (9&!( K��8RhCho ?h D`� pH��I435,'N"G (9% K . C �:K�N"G (9% K ) (9&!( K

�! ? �J�%"\# �! ? ���%"%( o ?h D�� p

TU% �") ) (9&!( K �") . 3 ( K ./(9&�. O5N:K�G.D � ( l &�. RSK=IUB � (v( K . & )� �! ? �#"$# �! ? �%" � �%"%( o ?h D5n p

TU% KAB8BH) ( �h,JR � ( �") � . ) (9&!( K(� �#" � (9% K )vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( �") � . ) (9&!( K� �%" � &�. G (9% K>) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K>K ./( �:B9K )vC`) ( K�0l &�. RSKF=k{ & l ( 3�B9K�G ? � ./( 3 (9% Ko) (9&!( K�)+3�{ (9% K ( I43 � . G �:x �"G', & N��h,JR � ( ) L+6'68N:C � . O � ( 3 (9% �")+) (9&!( K�� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB��C �:K�N"G') (9% K>) (9&!( K

�! ? �J�%"$# �! ? �w�#"%� o ?h D�y p

I % �"l % �") K ./(9&�. O5N:K�G �mK & )9,JB � . O (9% K-B8BH) ( �h,JR � ( 6'B93`G','l�K�)4x & N",JK�) �#"4&�. G �%" I � (9% K �h, & N�6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C �j { (9% K-x & N",JK �") �#" �

(9% K . (9% K>3�x�KwB & N"N ) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K>)vC`) ( K�0 �'6'B93 vK�l ( K�G 3 ./( 3 (9% K>x�K�l ( 3�B-)v6 & l�K>I � (9% R & ) �")# ���#"%� �J�%"'&)� o ?h D�| p

&�. G (9% K .>. 3�BH0 & N�� � K�G���I �"N"N�RSK �J�%"H �TU% K~) (9&!( Kd3�{ (9% Kd)vC`) ( K�0 %'& ) RSK�l�3507K �J�%" �5)v3 (9%'&!( &�. C=07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(3�{ (9% K+)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( B9K ( ,JB . ) �%" I � (9% l�KwB (9& � ./( C 143 ./( B & B �:I �")vK��/07K & )9,JB � . O �%" {�3�B (9% K B8BH) ( �h,JR � ( 07K &�. )(9%'&!(>(9% KM)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � (=%'& )>x & N",JK �#" I � (9% l�KwB (9& � ./( C �mK & )9,JB � . O K � (9% KwB �h,JR � ( B'�`K�) (9% KPx & N",JK73�{ (9% K3 (9% KwB�� & ) I4K�N"N ��� & 0 � . K�G � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( N:C���K & l % �h,JR � ( %'& )7K �h, & Np6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C 3�{+RSK � . O �#" 3�B �%" �pR8, (o(9% �") x �:KwI

GJ3hK�) . 3 ( GJK�)9l�B �:RSK (9% K J�L;XYX'H_:i9RETSUL;V RSK ( I4KwK . (9% K ( I43 �h,JR � ( )mD (9% K �:BFx & N",JK�)+,J6S3 . 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(F& B9K . 3 (� . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( B &�. GJ350�l % 3 �"l�K�) ~TU% �")�l�3�B9B9K�N &!( �:3 . �") VPL;V � :iLgJ�9;: � � . (9%'&!(~(9% K ( I43 �h,JR � ( )�l�35,'N"G7RSKU)v6 &!( � & N"N:C)vKw6 & B &!( K�G &�. G I �"N"Np) ( �"N"NUG �")v68N & C (9% �")P6SKwB9{�K�l (M&�./( � � l�3�B9B9K�N &!( �:3 .�. 3f0 &!(v( KwB I % K . (9% KwC & B9K 07K & )9,JB9K�GB9K�N &!( �:x�K ( 3MK & l % 3 (9% KwB

� � � � � &6) ��� / � +-"6&

� ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( 6'B93�x �"GJK�) &�. 3 (9% KwB-6SKwBH)v6SK�l ( �:x�Ko3 . 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(w 143 . ) �"GJKwB+I %'&!(=%'& 6'6SK . ) �:{ & )vC`) ( K�0�") K ./(9&�. O5N:K�G I � (9% &�. 3 (9% KwBF)vC`) ( K�0 (9%'&!( �") (9% K . 6SKwBH0 &�. K ./( N:C �")v35N &!( K�G {�B9350 (9% K>3�B �:O � .'& N�)vC`) ( K�0 dTU% K

Page 25: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� �� �� ��� ���� � � ����� ��|

B8BH) ( �h,JR � ( �") (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 3�{ � ./( KwB9K�) (mtS(9% K7)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( I �"N"N RSK & =v07K & )9,JB � . O GJKwx �"l�Kg? �h,JR � (w -@F& x � . Ol�B9K &!( K�G (9% K>K ./(9&�. O5N:K�G �h, &�./( ,'0�) (9&!( K

�! ? �#" �#"\# �! ? �%" �%"%� o ?h Q5� p)9,J6'6S35)vK (9%'&!(�(9% Kp)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( �")�073�x�K�G ( 3 &�. �")v35N &!( K�GoN:3`l &!( �:3 .� L ( (9% �") 6S3 � ./( � . 3 =vN:3`l & N ? ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 & �( �:3 .o& sSK�l ( � . O-3 . N:C (9% K B8BH) ( �h,JR � ( l &�. B9K�073�x�K (9% K4K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./(w L+6'68N:C � . O &-. KwO &!( �:3 .o( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .� ( 3 o ?h Q5� p 6'B93`G','l�K�) (9% K ) (9&!( K

�! ? �%" �#"\# �! ? �#" �%"%( o ?h Q'� pL+6'68N:C � . O (9% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . � ( 3 o ?h Q5� pp6'B93`G','l�K�) (9% K>) (9&!( K� �! ? �#"$# �! ? �%" � �! ? �#"$# � �! ? �#" � �! ? �%" � �! ? �%"%( o ?h Q/? pW-. N:C ) (9&!( K�)U3�{ (9% K={�3�BH0 + �! ? �#"$# , �! ? �%" o ?h Q/D pl &�. Kwx�KwBFB9K�)9,'N ( {�B9350 o ?h Q5� p RhC &�. C )vK �h,JK . l�K 3�{ ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )U3 . 3 . N:C (9% KuB8BH) ( �h,JR � (w 4E � � � . O (9% K)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( 07K &�. ) (9%'&!(>(9% K ( I43 ( KwBH0P)=3�{ (9% KP)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . l &�.a. Kwx�KwB � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K7I � (9% K & l % 3 (9% KwB L . CmKwx�K ./( , & Nd07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�{ (9% K]B8BH) ( �h,JR � ( I �"N"N�6'B93`G','l�K )v3507KP) (9&!( KPGJB & I . {�B9350�K � (9% KwB + 3�B ,M�I � (9% K �h, & N`6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C��!I % �"l % I �"N"N (9% K . � . G','l�K (9% K )vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( ( 3K=vl�35N"N & 68)vKg? ( 3 �#" 3�B �%" � & ) (9% 35,JO %� (U%'& G RSKwK . 07K & )9,JB9K�G G �:B9K�l ( N:C r4K�l & ,')vK (9% KwB9K>l &�. RSK . 3 � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K=RSK ( I4KwK . + &�. G�, {�B9350 (9% K>)vKw6 & B &!( �:3 . , ./( �"N (9% K>07K & )9,JB9K �

07K ./( � � ( �")�0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N"N:C &�. G 6 % C`) �"l & N"N:C>K �h, �:x & N:K ./(�( 3=B9KwO & BHG (9% K 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�{ (9% KU)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � (& ) (9&;@ � . O 68N & l�K &!( (9% K-073507K ./( 3�{ )vKw6 & B &!( �:3 .� �j ( �")4K & )vC ( 3Pl % K�l @ (9%'&!( K�� & l ( N:C (9% K=) & 07K=G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 .3�{+35, ( l�3507K�)7B9K�)9,'N ( )o{�B9350 (9% K 6S35) (�� ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) �:{ (9% K �h,JR � ( ) & B9K & N")v3 07K & )9,JB9K�G&!(F(9% K 073507K ./( 3�{d)vKw6 & B &!( �:3 . 3�B �:{ (9% KwC & B9K . 3 (w FTU% K & l ( 3�{ �:B9B9Kwx�3`l & R8N:K K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( �")+K_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:CK �h, �:x & N:K ./( ( 3 &�. �"0P07K�G � &!( K>07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(w r4K�l & ,')vK �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P)�Kwx�35N:x�K � . & , . � (9& B9C 0 &�.'. KwB�� . 3 ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l�B9K &!( � . O=K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./(

�")=Kwx�KwB ( K�l %'. �"l & N"N:C�= �:B9B9Kwx�3`l & R8N:K ? rp, ( � ( �")=x�KwB9C K & )vC ( 3 l�B9K &!( K l�KwB (9& � . ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )=I % �"l % & B9K�:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KP{�3�B & N"Nd6'B & l ( �"l & N468,JB96S35)vK�) � & l�B935)9l�3�6 �"l 3�R�vK�l ( ) %'& x�K K . 3�BH0735,') . ,'0 RSKwBH) 3�{+6 & B ( �"lwN:K�)w�K & l %m& �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0 (9%'&!( � ./( KwB & l ( )UI � (9% � ( )U0 &�. C 3 (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P) � . l�350768N��"l &!( K�G I & C`) TU% K � . G �:x �"G', & N �h, &�./( ,'0 K_sSK�l ( )73�{+6 & B ( �"lwN:K�) � . 0 & l�B935)9l�3�6 �"l )vC`) ( K�0P) & B9K GJI & B9{�K�GfRhC (9% K lwN & )9) �"l & N) (9&!( �") ( �"l & NdK_sSK�l ( ) 3�{UN & B9O�K . ,'0 RSKwBH)>3�{ 6 & B ( �"lwN:K�) � ./( KwB & l ( � . O W-. l�K & �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0 %'& )oRSK�l�3507KK ./(9&�. O5N:K�G>I � (9%=& 0 & l�B935)9l�3�6 �"l~)vC`) ( K�0 � (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . , . GJ3 � . O (9%'&!( K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( �")S6'B93 % �:R � ( �:x�K�N:CG �Cr lw,'N (+( 3 l�350768, ( K TU% ,')w�SK ./(9&�. O5N�� . O & �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0�I � (9% & lwN & )9) �"l & N 3 . K �")w�S{�3�B & N"N 6'B & l ( �"l & N68,JB96S35)vK�)w� &�. �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K4K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( � &�. G (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K �") (9&�./(9& 0735, ./(~( 3 &�. �"0P07K�G � &!( K 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(w }d, (o&�. 3 (9% KwBoI & C�� �:{p3 . KMI �") % K�) ( 3 07K & )9,JB9K & �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0 ��K ./(9&�. O5N�� . O � ( I � (9%a& 0 & l�B935)9l�3�6 �"llwN & )9) �"l & N�)vC`) ( K�02)9, r l�K�) TU% K � �:6>) �"GJK�3�{ (9% �") l %'& B & l ( KwB � ��&!( �:3 . 3�{J07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( �") (9%'&!( � ( �") �"076S3�B (9&�./(�( 3 & x�3 �"G � .'& GJx�KwB ( K ./( N:C

K ./(9&�. O5N�� . O & �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0 I � (9% � ( )PK . x �:B93 . 07K ./( G',JB � . O (9% Kml�35,JBH)vKm3�{ � ( )Ml�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� TU% K= � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O ? �h, &�./( ,'0 K_sSK�l ( ) I4K %'& x�K>G �")9lw,')9)vK�G &!( N:K . O (9% & B9K=GJKw6SK . GJK ./( ,J6S3 .M(9% K=)vC`) ( K�0 � ) & R �"N�� ( C

Page 26: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

?!� ������� ������� � � ��� � � � ��� ����� ��� � � � � � ����� � ��

( 3>0 & � ./(9& � .7& l�3 % KwB9K ./( )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{�) (9&!( K�)mD�07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( �/RhCol�35N"N & 68) � . O (9% K ) (9&!( K � ./( 3-3 . K x & N",JK��GJK�) ( B93�C`)+)9,'l % )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . ) TU% ,')w�JRSK�l & ,')vK=K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( I � (9% (9% K>K . x �:B93 . 07K ./( �") (9&�./(9& 0735, ./(+( 307K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ��)9,'l % K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( 0o,') ( RSK & x�3 �"GJK�G I % K . 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) & B9K . 3 ( RSK � . OMGJK�N��:RSKwB &!( K�N:C(9&;@ K .� =TU% K %'& BHGJK�) ( 6 & B ( 3�{dl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( � . O & �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwB �")F,')9, & N"N:C �")v35N &!( � . O (9% K �h,JR � ( )U{�B9350(9% K �:B`oelwN & )9) �"l & N<pPK . x �:B93 . 07K ./( I4K�N"NFK . 35,JO %( 3 6'B9Kwx�K ./( (9% K�0�{�B9350�RSK�l�350 � . OfK ./(9&�. O5N:K�GI � (9% (9%'&!(K . x �:B93 . 07K ./(w

� ��� ��� $ "*2��+���0$ �'2�&P2-30� �

TU% �") )vK�l ( �:3 . �") . 3 ( ) ( B �"l ( N:C . K�l�K�)9) & B9C {�3�B &�. , . GJKwBH) (9&�. G � . Oo3�{ (9% K 0 &!( KwB � & N � . )9,JR8)vK �h,JK ./( l %'& 6 ( KwBH) j ( �")U6'B93�x �"GJK�G {�3�B (9% KoB9K & GJKwB-I % 3 �")+, . ) &!( �") B8K�G I � (9% (9% K & lwl�35, ./( )F3�{d07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( O �:x�K . & RS3�x�K���3�BI % 3 �") lw,JB �:35,') & RS35, ( (9% K>6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % CP3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�07K�l %'&�. �"lw) �~x�KwB9C`G & C K��`6SKwB �:K . l�K & 6'6SK & BH) ( 3mlwN & �"0 (9%'&!(>(9% KP, . �:x�KwBH)vK �") . 3 ( � . (9% KP) (9&!( K �� ) o� �#"Y# �%" pH� R8, (

�") 0735) ( GJK_B . � ( K�N:C � . �#" 3�B �%"H jk. 35,JB B8BH) ( & lwl�35, ./( 3�{o07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( o � . 3�BHGJKwB ( 3 K . )9,JB9K (9%'&!(07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) %'& G l�3 . ) �") ( K ./( 35, ( l�3507K�)YpFI4K76S35) ( ,'N &!( K�G (9%'&!( 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) & B9K & lwl�35076 &�. �:K�G RhC &=vl�35N"N & 68)vKg? � ./( 3 (9% K 07K & )9,JB9K�G ) (9&!( K TU% K�)vKMl�35N"N & 68)vK�) & B9KM{e, . G & 07K ./(9& N"N:C . 3 .�� , . � (9& B9C � (9% KwC 0 & 6) (9&!( K�) ( 3 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . )>3�{-) (9&!( K�) qUK�l�3 . l �"N�� . O (9% �")ox �:KwI�I � (9%f(9% K 6 % C`) �"l & NplwN & �"0 (9%'&!(�h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) � I % �"l % % KwB9K � . lwN",'GJK (9% K7K ./( �:B9K7, . �:x�KwBH)vK�� & ) (9% KPl�35076S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{p0 &�. C )90 & N"N:KwB��� ./( KwB & l ( � . OJ� �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) � & N:I & C`)=Kwx�35N:x�K & lwl�3�BHG � . O ( 3 , . � (9& B9Cml�3 . ) ( B & � ./( )w� �") & 0 & v3�B ( 3�6 �"l3�{ % K &!( K�G GJKwR &!( K � . (9% K>6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % CP3�{�6 % C`) �"lw) � ,'l % &!(v( K ./( �:3 . %'& )4RSKwK . O �:x�K . � (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K�� ( 3 &!(v( K�076 ( � . O ( 3 K��`68N & � . 6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C7I %'&!( 0o,') ( l�3 . ) ( � �

( , ( K & =v07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( � ? I % C l�35N"N & 68)vK�)-GJ3 . 3 ( B9K & N"N:C (9&;@ KP68N & l�K���I % C 35,JB=Kwx�KwB9C`G & C K��`6SKwB �:K . l�K �") � .KwB9B93�B��J3�BF)v3507K=3 (9% KwB+B9K�)v35N", ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% �") &�./( � . 350 C E B9350 (9% K=6S3 � ./( 3�{ x �:KwI 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � � ( �") . 3 (+. K�l�K�)9) & B9C ( 3PB9K�)v35N:x�K (9% �") �h,JK�) ( �:3 . ( 3

l & B9B9C 35, ( � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . OPl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) d# K %'& x�Ko)vKwK . ( I43 & lwl�35, ./( )+3�{�07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(w ~jk. 3 . K���l�35N"N & 68)vK�)(9&;@ K468N & l�KdI % K . 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) 3`lwlw,JB�� &�. G (9% 35)vK407K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) (9&;@ K468N & l�KdI % K . & )9, r l �:K ./( N:C =vN & B9O�Kg?GJKwx �"l�KPl & B9B �:K�) (9% K�0 35, (w Pjk. (9% KP3 (9% KwB�� . 3 l�35N"N & 68)vK�) (9&;@ KM68N & l�K��-=kKwx�KwB9C`G & C K��`6SKwB �:K . l�Kg? �") � . KwB9B93�B��&�. G (9% K , . �:x�KwBH)vK K�� �") ( ) � . & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K 35, ( l�3507K�)P3�{ &�. , . �"0 & O � .'& R8N:C N & B9O�K . ,'0 RSKwB 3�{� ./( KwB & l ( �:3 . ) LFN (9% 35,JO %�. K � (9% KwB &�. )vI4KwB �")P6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % �"l & N"N:C & lwl�Kw6 (9& R8N:K�� &!( N:K & ) ( & )M6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G % KwB9K��(9% KwCP6'B93�x �"GJK+0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N"N:C7K �h, �:x & N:K ./( 6'B9K�G �"l ( �:3 . )~3�{ (9% K+B9K�)9,'N ( )d3�{,=vl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )w� ? l�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G & ))v3507K>)vK �h,JK . l�K=3�{�, . � (9& B9CP3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) &�. G 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( ) 3 . &�. 3 (9% KwB9I �")vK �")v35N &!( K�G �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0 T 3 (9% K7K�� ( K ./( (9%'&!( &�. C l�3 % KwB9K ./( 6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % �"l & N�6S3 � ./( 3�{px �:KwI O �:x�K�) & GJK_B . � ( �:3 . 3�{ & =v)vC`) ( K�0? &�. G& =v07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( � ? (9% KP6'B9K�G �"l ( �:3 . )F3�{pRS3 (9% 35,JB & lwl�35, ./( ) I �"N"N RSK7l�3 . )v3 .'&�./( I � (9% (9%'&!( 6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % C � )6'B9K�G �"l ( �:3 . ) jk. @ KwKw6 � . O7I � (9% (9% K=6'B & O50 &!( �"l-)v6 �:B � ( 3�{ 35,JBUG �")9lw,')9) �:3 . 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � (9% K�)vK& lwl�35, ./( ) & B9K=O�3h3`G K . 35,JO %�

Page 27: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�������������

� � � ����� � � � �W��� � ��

u��� ����� ���]$�� �TU% KwB9K & B9K l�KwB (9& � . B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( ) O�K . KwB & N"N:C & O�B9KwK�G ( 3 RSK (9% K 0 � . �"0 & N~)vK ( 3�{U3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) & �h, &�./( ,'0l�350768, ( KwB=0o,') ( 07KwK (w =TU% KwC { & N"N � ./( 3 ( I43 l &!( KwO�3�B �:K�) =E �:BH) ( � (9% KwB9K & B9K (9% K =kO &!( K�)'? )9,'l % & l�350768, ( KwB0o,') ( �"0768N:K�07K ./( D (9% KF0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N�3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) (9%'&!( � ( 6'B9350 �")vK�) ( 3 l & B9B9CP35, ( 3 . K . l�3`GJK�G �h,JR � ( ) LF)G �")9lw,')9)vK�G � . l %'& 6 ( KwB Q � & )vK ( 3�{ O &!( K�)4I % �"l % � . lwN",'GJK�) & N"N'3 . K � �h,JR � ( 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) &�. G & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-TO &!( K7I �"N"N RSKo, . �:x�KwBH) & N -TU% ,')w� & �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwB=) % 35,'N"G RSK & R8N:K ( 3 & 6'68N:C & B9R � ( B & B9C B93 (9&!( �:3 . ) ( 3) � . O5N:K �h,JR � ( ) &�. G ( 3 & N ( KwB (9% K ) (9&!( K>3�{�3 . K �h,JR � ( I % K . & )vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( �") � . � ( )! �%" ) (9&!( K u K�l�3 . G�� (9% KwB9K & B9K (9% K76 % C`) �"l & N�B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( ) . K�l�K�)9) & B9C {�3�B & �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwB ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(

� . 6'B & l ( �"l�K (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) � . � ( ) (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�B9Kw6SKwB ( 3 �:B9K ~TU% K�)vK=B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( ) & B9KRD� W 6 & l � ( CPD j ( 0o,') ( RSK 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 & 6'68N:C (9% K & RS3�x�K R & ) �"l ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) ( 3 �h,JR � ( )7I � (9% 35, (

� . )v6SK�l ( � . O (9% K �:B ) (9&!( K dj { (9% �")4B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( �") . 3 ( 3�RSKwC�K�G�� (9% K=lwN & )9) �"l & N & 6'6 & B &!( ,') l & B9B9C � . O 35, ((9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )FI �"N"N�RSK�l�3507K K ./(9&�. O5N:K�G I � (9% (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0 � . KwO &!( � . O � ( )=, . ��h,JK�N:C�h, &�./( ,'0 & )v6SK�l ( )

� u � � KRD TU% K+)vC`) ( K�0 0o,') ( l�3 ./(9& � . & . ,'0 RSKwB~3�{ G �") ( � . l ( �h,JR � ( ) TU% K+K�) ( �"0 &!( K+3�{ . ,'0 RSKwBdB9K �h, �:B9K�G{�3�B�,')vKw{e,'N & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . )�x & B �:K�)w��R8, (�&�. �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . 3�{ u`% 3�B � ) { & l ( 3�B � . O & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B . ,'0 RSKwBH)3�{ � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . OP) � � K=I435,'N"G B9K �h, �:B9K=)vKwx�KwB & N (9% 35,') &�. G �h,JR � ( )

� LFG'GJB9K�)9) & R �"N�� ( C j ( 0o,') ( RSK+6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 3�6SKwB &!( K � . G �:x �"G', & N"N:C>3 . & B9R � ( B & B9C �h,JR � ( )~I � (9% 35, (4& 6'68N:C �� . O (9% K>) & 07K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ( 3P3 (9% KwB �h,JR � ( ) � . (9% K )vC`) ( K�0

� uh(9& R �"N�� ( CPD TU% K �h,JR � ( )~0o,') ( �/I � (9% � . )v3507Ke= & lwl�Kw6 (9& R8N:Kg?oKwB9B93�BdRS35, . G')w��B9K (9& � .P(9% K �:Bdlw,JB9B9K ./( ) (9&!( KI % K . (9% KwC & B9KmN:Kw{ (P& N:3 . K�� &�. G (9% K �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) 3�{ (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )70o,') (M. 3 ( G �CsSKwB( 3h3f0o,'l % {�B9350 (9% K �:B (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N+)v6SK�l �CB�l &!( �:3 . ) � . N:K�)9) & l�350768, ( KwB & l ( , & N"N:C*=vGJ3hK�)PI %'&!( � (lwN & �"0P) ( 3J� ? � ( �")d6'B & l ( �"l & N"N:CP,')vK�N:K�)9) ~TU% �") �") & 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B �")9)9,JK+{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH)4RSK�l & ,')vK(9% K �:B>)9l & N:K �")=)v3 )90 & N"N &�. G )vK . ) � ( �:x�K�� &�. G RSK�l & ,')vK ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N KwB9B93�B � l�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) & B9K� .'& 6'68N��"l & R8N:K ( 3 (9% K�0

� �mK & )9,JB9K�07K ./( D�LFN (9% 35,JO %o(9% KU)vC`) ( K�0 ) % 35,'N"G RSKp3�6 & �h,JK G',JB � . O+3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . �5I % K . & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(�")4B9K �h, �:B9K�G�� � ( 0o,') ( RSKF6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 37l & B9B9CM3 . K-35, (w �j ( ) % 35,'N"G �"GJK & N"N:C RSKF6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3707K & )9,JB9K (9% K) (9&!( K 3�{,o & N"0735) ( p &�. C �h,JR � ( I % K (9% KwB+G �:B9K�l ( N:CM3�B � . G �:B9K�l ( N:C

?`�

Page 28: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

?�? ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ������ �� ��� �

jk.a(9% 35)vK �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . )o, . GJKwBolw,JB9B9K ./( K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& Ndl�3 . ) �"GJKwB &!( �:3 . ��) (9& R �"N�� ( C �") (9% K l % �:Kw{U3�R �) (9& lwN:K TU% K B & 6 �"G GJK�l�3 % KwB9K . l�K 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) � ./( KwB & l ( � . O I � (9% (9% K �:BPK . x �:B93 . 07K ./( ) & l ( ) & )&�. ,J6'6SKwB RS35, . G ( 3 (9% K ) � � K 3�{ (9% 35)vK )vC`) ( K�0P) LFG'GJB9K�)9) & R �"N�� ( C �")oN:K�)9)o3�{ & 6'B93�R8N:K�0 lw,JB9B9K ./( N:C���R8, (l�35,'N"GMRSK�l�3507K=l�3 . ) �"GJKwB & R8N:CP073�B9KF3�{�3 . K �:{ (9% K-{�B93 ./( �:KwB43�{ (9% K=)9l & N:KF3�{ )vC`) ( K�0P) (9%'&!( l &�. RSK-) (9& R �"N�� � K�G& GJx &�. l�K�)

� �CsSKwB9K ./( �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) %'& x�K G �CsSKwB9K ./( )9l % K�07K�)M{�3�B 07KwK ( � . O (9% K�)vK B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( )w� &�. G (9% K�)vKG �CsSKwB9K ./( ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) & B9K RSK (v( KwB &�. GfI43�BH)vK &!( )v3507K 3�{ (9% K�0 fjk.f(9% �") l %'& 6 ( KwBPI4K ) %'& N"Np)9,JB9x�KwC (9% KN:K & G � . OP6'B93�6S35)vK�G 07K�l %'&�. �")90P)U{�3�B-l�B9K &!( � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH) � . (9% KoN & RS3�B &!( 3�B9C�� &�. GmG �")9lw,')9) % 3�II4K�N"N (9% KwC %'& x�K 07K (o(9% K x & B �:35,')ol�B � ( KwB � & )v3 { & B�� � . (9% Kw3�B9C &�. G � . 6'B & l ( �"l�K j 3 .a( B & 6 07K (9% 3`G') &�. G(9% 35)vK-R & )vK�G 3 . . ,'lwN:K & B 0 & O . K ( �"l-B9K�)v3 .'&�. l�K ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O �:K�) %'& x�K=K . v3�C�K�G (9% K=0735) ( )9,'lwl�K�)9) &�. G & 6'6SK & B( 3oRSK (9% KF0735) ( 6'B9350 �") � . O & x�K . ,JK�)p3�{�B9K�)vK & BHl % �J)v3oI4K-) %'& N"N'G �")9lw,')9) (9% K�0 &!( O�B9K &!( KwBUN:K . O (9%P(9%'&�. )v3507K3�{ (9% K>073�B9K>K��`3 ( �"l=6'B93�6S35) & N")

u��� I2-+ � �. ,3

143 . ) �"GJKwB & )vK ( 3�{ �"GJK ./( �"l & N �:3 . )>3�{ 6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C @`. 3�I . 0 & )9) &�. Gal %'& B9O�K TU% K�)vK �:3 . )>I �"N"N�B9K�)v6S3 . G � .6'B9K�G �"l (9& R8N:K4I & C`) ( 3=K�N:K�l ( B �"l#B8K�N"G') �jk. 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�� �:{8I4KUl &�. l�B9K &!( K & o ( I43 � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N<p�6S3 ( K ./( � & N`I4K�N"N �)9,'l % (9%'&!( K . KwB9O�C �")>B9K �h, �:B9K�G {�3�B (9% K�0 ( 3 073�x�K & I & Ca{�B9350 & l�KwB (9& � . 6'B9Kw{�KwB9B9K�G 6S35) � ( �:3 . � � ( I �"N"N�RSK6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3`= ( B & 6 ? �:3 . ) � . (9%'&!( 6S35) � ( �:3 .� j { (9% K �:3 . ) & B9K (9% K . l�3h35N:K�G ( 3 (9% K=6S3 � ./(p&!( I % �"l % �h, &�./( ,'0K_sSK�l ( )+RSK�l�3507K GJ350 � .'&�./( �`K & l % � . G �:x �"G', & N �:3 . l &�. RSK>,')vK�G ( 3 % 35N"G 3 . K �h,JR � (w TU% K7K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N�l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . 3�{ �:3 . ( B & 6aGJKwx �"l�K�) %'& )=RSKwK . 6'B � . l �:6 & N"N:C l�3 . l�KwB . K�G I � (9% : S<V6H'9;X

�:3 .o( B & 68)w� � . I % �"l % (9% K0=kRS3 (v( 350?-3�{ (9% Kp6S3 ( K ./( � & NhI4K�N"N (9&;@ K�) (9% Kp{�3�BH0<3�{ & N�� . K & B B9KwO �:3 . � . )v6 & l�K �TU% KK�N:K�l ( B �"l�B8K�N"G . K�l�K�)9) & B9C ( 370 &;@ K �:3 . )dO�B & x � (9&!( K ( 3 (9% �")4N�� . KFl &�. RSK-l�B9K &!( K�G RhCP6 & B & N"N:K�N�� . O � ( I � (9% {�35,JBK�N:K�l ( B93`GJK�)8o &!(>(9% K7{�35,JB l�3�B . KwBH)=3�{ & ) �h, & B9K73�{4I % �"l % (9% K76'B9Kw{�KwB9B9K�G & � �") �") (9% KMl�K ./( KwB_p r4C 68, (v( � . O&�.�& N ( KwB .'&!( � . O � lw,JB9B9K ./( 6S3 ( K ./( � & N (9% B935,JO % (9% K K�N:K�l ( B93`GJK�) &!(M&a% �:O % {�B9K �h,JK . l�C����5� & l�C`N�� . GJB �"l & N"N:C �)vC`0P07K ( B �"l7K�N:K�l ( B �"l!B8K�N"G �")>l�B9K &!( K�G�� � . I % �"l % 6S35) � ( �:x�K �:3 . ) & B9KMGJB & I . ( 3 (9% KMl�K ./( B & N & � �")U� L )90 & N"N) (9&!( �"l8o �>1,p4x�35N (9& O�K �") (9% K . & 6'68N��:K�G ( 3 (9% K>K . G')p3�{ (9% K=K�N:K�l ( B93`GJK�) ( 3P6'B9Kwx�K ./(U(9% K �:3 . )p{�B9350�K�)9l & 6 � . O(9% B935,JO %M(9% K =kK . G')'? 3�{ (9% K ( B & 6 4u � . l�K (9% K �:3 . ) & B9K & N"N86S35) � ( �:x�K�N:C7l %'& B9O�K�G�� (9% KwCPB9Kw6SK�N'K & l % 3 (9% KwB &�. GI �"N"NS)v6 & l�K (9% K�0P)vK�N:x�K�) 35, ( B935,JO % N:CMKwx�K . N:C & N:3 . O (9% K & � �") TU% K & RS3�x�K+6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K )9, r l�K�) ( 3ol�3 . B . K (9% K �:3 . ) � .7&�.M& � � & NJB9KwO �:3 . 3�{ &!( 0735) (d& RS35, (~& 0 �"N"N��"07K ( KwB

� . G � & 07K ( KwB oe) (9& B ( � . O 3;s I � (9% = % 3 ( ? �:3 . )7I � (9% & O�B9K &!( GJK & N 3�{-K . KwB9O�C p E 3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 K_sSK�l ( ) ( 3GJ350 � .'&!( K�� (9% KwC 0o,') ( RSK l�3h35N:K�G ( 3 & ( K�076SKwB &!( ,JB9K &!( I % �"l %f(9% K �:B76S35)9) �:R8N:KPK . KwB9O�C N:Kwx�K�N") & B9K RS3 (9%�h, &�./( � � K�G &�. Gf6'B9K�G �"l (9& R8N:K T I43 G �") ( � . l ( K . KwB9O�Cf) (9&!( K�)P3�{ (9% K �:3 . & B9K ,')vK�G��~3 . K B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( � . O �#"&�. G (9% Ko3 (9% KwBFB9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( � . O �%"H +jk. 6'B & l ( �"l�K�� (9% �")+07K &�. ) (9% K �:3 . )+0o,') ( RSKol�3h35N:K�G ( 3 x�KwB9C . K & B (9% K �:B=kO�B935, . G ) (9&!( K�� ? (9% K>N:3�I4K�) (+& G'0 �")9) �:R8N:KFK . KwB9O�C ) (9&!( K��8{�3�B (9% K>) (9&!( K�) ( 3PRSK=) (9& R8N:K &�. G G �") ( � . O5, �") %'& R8N:K TU% �")Fl�3h35N�� . O l &�. RSK l & B9B �:K�Gm35, ( RhCm07K &�. )-3�{dN & )vKwB-68,'N")vK�)+3�{~x�KwB9C l & B9Kw{e,'N"N:C � l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�GmB & G � &!( �:3 .

{�B9K �h,JK . l�C��FI % �"l % K . l�35,JB & O�K (9% K ( B & 6'6SK�G �:3 . ) ( 3 B9K�N:K & )vK K . KwB9O�C �E 3�BHl�K�G � Kwx & 6S3�B &!( �:3 . ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�)) �"0 �"N & B ( 3 (9% 35)vK ,')vK�G ( 3 6'B93`G','l�KMr435)vK � � � . ) ( K � . l�3 . GJK . ) &!( K�) & B9K & N")v3 (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N"N:C &!(v( B & l ( �:x�K��~R8, (%'& x�K %'& G N:K�)9) )9,'lwl�K�)9) � . 6'B & l ( �"l�K (9% ,') { & B jk.o&�. C l & )vK��53 . l�K (9% K �:3 . ) & B9Kpl�3h35N:K�G�� (9% KwC & B9K � . G �:x �"G', & N"N:CN:3`l & N�� � K�G ) I � (9% � . . 3 .�� 3�x�KwBHN & 6'6 � . O B9KwO �:3 . ) 3�{�G � & 07K ( KwB & 0 �"l�B93507K ( KwB+3�B+N:K�)9)

- � =�:CM54ID/7�? <2�K 4ID <>=�GB? <:CG6E����&P :MN:05P @SGB0 7�=�:*<>=54ID�RB:�4605P 8&46@/@SG6E�7�=�:*? GB0 7�G�WN:*2�@/:QPV] (�G6D � ��� ��ANEHG6D : '�468;M�K :BA�4EH: � 8;:RU46=�:�D/7 Y4I7S460�468;M�K ? 7�25P :SG6E�46WNGB2 7����CTUGBK 7�@�� GB2�K P�WN:Y2�@/:QPV]

��� 7 7�=�? @�@/<Q46K :BA3? GB0�@�P ? @/M�K 4L�@/? RB0�? O5<Q46037 �J4QTU:#+ K ? U: EH:Q4I7�2 D�:@AX@/G 7�=�? @�K G3<Q46K ? Q4I7�? GB0�? @ D�:Q46K K L;4 WNGB2�05PCGB0C7�=�:��J4QTU:#+ EH2�0�<�7�? GB0G6E 7�=�:Y? GB0�]

Page 29: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � �� ��� ������� ?�D

# � (9% (9% �")p)vKw6 & B &!( �:3 . � � ( �")46S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 & G'GJB9K�)9) &�. C � . G �:x �"G', & N �:3 . I � (9% N & )vKwB 68,'N")vK�) t`(9% K�)vK=68,'N")vK�)l &�. �"0768N:K�07K ./( &�. C GJK�) �:B9K�G , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 3 . (9% K ) � . O5N:K �h,JR � ( B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G RhC (9%'&!( �:3 .� TU% K ( B �"l @ �:KwB�l & )vK �")�K .'& R8N�� . O �h,JR � ( ) ( 3 � ./( KwB & l (mt � ( �") . 3 ( 6S35)9) �:R8N:K�� � . O�K . KwB & N � ( 3-R'B � . O &�.o& B9R � ( B & B9C

6 & �:B-3�{ �h,JR � ( ) � ./( 3 6'B93�� �"0 � ( C���) � . l�K (9% K �:B=N:3`l &!( �:3 . ) & B9KP073�B9K 3�B>N:K�)9)-B'�`K�G G',JB � . O (9% K7l�35,JBH)vK 3�{ (9% Kl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� �jk. ) ( K & G�� (9% Kd,')9, & N & 6'6'B93 & l % �") ( 3+l�B9K &!( K &�.>& G'G � ( �:3 .'& N �h,JR � ( l & 6 & R8N:K�3�{ � ./( KwB & l ( � . O I � (9%&�. Cm3�{ (9% K �:3 .�� ) ( 3�B9K�G �h,JR � ( )+I4KPl % 3h35)vK r4K�l & ,')vK (9% �") �h,JR � ( l & B9B �:K�) � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . RSK ( I4KwK . & B9R � ( B & B9C�h,JR � ( )w� � ( �")pB9Kw{�KwB9B9K�G ( 3 & ) & =kR8,')'? �h,JR � (w u � . l�K (9% K+R8,')d0o,') ( RSK & R8N:K ( 3 � ./( KwB & l ( I � (9%M&�. CP3�{ (9% K �:3 . )w� (9% KF) (9&�. G & BHG ( K�l %'. ��h,JK �") ( 3oK . l�3`GJK

� ( ,') � . O & 6'B93�6SKwB ( C=3�{ (9% K �:3 . ) l�35N"N:K�l ( �:x�K�N:CPD (9% K4x �:R'B &!( �:3 .'& N/073 ( �:3 . o � K K . KwB9O�C N:Kwx�K�N<p�3�{ (9% Kpl�K ./( KwB � 3�{ �0 & )9)d3�{ (9% K �:3 . ) �TU% K+N:3�I4K�) ( K . KwB9O�CMN:Kwx�K�N o (9% K =kO�B935, . GM) (9&!( Kg?ap �") �#"~&�. G & 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B % �:O % KwB � K . KwB9O�C) (9&!( Ko)vKwB9x�K�) & )! �%"H r4K�l & ,')vK � ( �") �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�Gm)v3 G �CsSKwB9K ./( N:C {�B9350 (9% K 3 (9% KwB �h,JR � ( )w� (9% K R8,')F)9, sSKwBH)U{�B9350�)v3507KoN��"0 �

� (9&!( �:3 . )mD � ( l &�.'. 3 ( RSK G �:B9K�l ( N:C & G'GJB9K�)9)vK�G � . (9% K ) & 07K I & C (9% Ko3 (9% KwBH)-l &�. � . 3�B=l &�. � ( � ./( KwB & l ( I � (9%(9% K-3 (9% KwBH) � . x�KwB9CM0 &�. CMI & C`) dTU% KF3�6 ( �:3 . ) & x & �"N & R8N:K�� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB��8)9, r l�KF{�3�B 35,JBp68,JB96S35)vKU3�{ l�3 . x�KwC � . O� . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . R & l @ &�. G {�3�B (9% RSK ( I4KwK . �h,JR � ( )p) ( 3�B9K�G � . (9% K �:3 . ) j ( �")46S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 �")9)9,JK & N & )vKwB 68,'N")vK ( 3 &�. & B9R � ( B & B9C �:3 . I % �"l % )vI & 68) (9% K=x & N",JK-3�{ (9% K �h,JR � ( ) % K�N"G

RhC (9%'&!( �:3 . &�. G RhC (9% KPR8,') �m3�B9KM6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C�� �:{ � (=(9&;@ K�)oK . KwB9O�C &!(o& N & )vKwB>{�B9K �h,JK . l�C�� {�3�B (9% K �:3 .( 3 )vI � ( l % RSK ( I4KwK . � ( )+K . KwB9O�Cm) (9&!( K�) &�. G � (+(9&;@ K�)-K . KwB9O�C &!( {�B9K �h,JK . l�C�� ( 3 B & �")vK (9% K l�K ./( KwB-3�{d0 & )9){�B9350 � ( )4O�B935, . G ) (9&!( Keo�B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( � . O �#" p ( 3 � ( )4K��Jl � ( K�G ) (9&!( K8o�B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( � . O� �%" pH� (9% K . & N & )vKwB 68,'N")vK &!({�B9K �h,JK . l�C�� ��� & N"N:3�I+)F3 . N:C ( I43 @ � . G')+3�{ ( B &�. ) � ( �:3 . � � � (9% KwB (9% K �:3 . O�3hK�)-{�B9350 � ( ) �%" ) (9&!( K ( 3 � ( ) �#" ) (9&!( K &�. G (9% K>l�K ./( KwBF3�{�0 & )9)UO�3hK�)U{�B9350 �#"4( 3 �%" �83�BUx �"l�K � x�KwBH) &` j ( �") & N")v376S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3M0 &;@ K (9% K=6 %'& )vK=B93 (9&!( �:3 . ) & 6'68N��:K�G ( 3 �h,JR � ( )pl�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& NS3 . (9% K>) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K

R8,')mD>3 . N:C �:{ (9% KMR8,') �") � . ) (9&!( K �%" GJ3hK�) (9% KMB93 (9&!( �:3 . (9&;@ KM68N & l�K r4C ,') � . O (9% KM) (9&�. G & BHG ( B �"l @ {�3�Bl�3 . x�KwB ( � . OoRSK ( I4KwK . R � (�� � �:68) &�. GPB93 (9&!( �:3 . )w� (9% K�)vK-l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& NJB93 (9&!( �:3 . )w� ( 3�O�K (9% KwB I � (9% , . l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& NB93 (9&!( �:3 . ) &�. G (9% K=)vI & 68) GJK�)9l�B �:RSK�G & RS3�x�K��')9, r l�K ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(4& l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T O &!( K>RSK ( I4KwK . ( I43�h,JR � ( ) ) ( 3�B9K�G � . �:3 . )

���

���

��

�������

���

�������

o Dh "� pu � . l�K & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T O &!( K 68N",') (9% Kml�350768N:K ( Km)vK ( 3�{-3 . K � �h,JR � ( O &!( K�) �")P, . �:x�KwBH) & Np{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � (9% K �:3 . ( B & 6 �") , . �:x�KwBH) & N � . ) �"0o,'N &!( � . O �h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( ) L �h,JR � ( l &�. RSKP07K & )9,JB9K�G RhC �"N"N",'0 � .'&!( � . O � ( ) �:3 . I � (9% B & G � &!( �:3 . 3�{ & I & x�K�N:K . O (9% I % �"l % I435,'N"G

l & ,')vK (9% K �:3 .�( 3 9,'076�{�B9350 � ( ) �%" ) (9&!( K ( 3 & l�3 . ) �"GJKwB & R8N:C % �:O % KwBMK . KwB9O�C�) (9&!( K I % �"l % GJ3hK�) . 3 (3 (9% KwB9I �")vK-6 & B ( �"l �:6 &!( K � . (9% K=l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� �j { (9% K �:3 . �") � . GJKwK�G � . (9% K �%" ) (9&!( K�� � ( I �"N"N8B9K�)v3 .'&!( K=I � (9%(9% K & 6'68N��:K�G B & G � &!( �:3 . &�. G I �"N"N � ,J3�B9K�)9l�K pj { � ( �") � . (9% K �#" ) (9&!( K�� . 3M)9,'l % B9K�)v3 .'&�. l�K I �"N"N (9&;@ Ko68N & l�K

� � =�:$P 2 D>4I7�? GB0CG6E57�=�: M�2�K @/:@ ? @�46K @/GY? 8;MNG6D/7>46037QABWN:<Q462�@/: ? 7�4 �V:<�7�@ 7�=�: 468;GB2�037 G6E57�? 8;: 2�05P :�D��$=�? <>=C7�=�: @FL @F7�:89:TUGBK TU:@46<<G6D>P ? 0�R�7�G&7�=�:�? 05P 2�<:QP�� 468;? K 7�GB0�? 460�] (�G6D GB2 D M�2 D�MNGB@/:@A�7�=�GB2�RB=�A � :�GB0�K L 0�::QP�7�G�<GB0�@/? P :�DY7�=�:�<Q46@/:@Y? 0 �$=�? <>= 7�=�:M�2�K @/:@\4ID�: 7�? 8;:S7�G�<Q462�@/:Y:TUGBK 2 7�? GB0�7�= D�GB2�RB= D>4BP ? 460�@]

Page 30: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

?�Q ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ������ �� ��� �

TU% ,')w�hRhCM)vKwK � . O I % K (9% KwBpN��:O %/( �")4K�0 � (v( K�G RhC (9% K �:3 . � . B9K�)v6S3 . )vK ( 3 & 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B & 6'68N��:K�GPI & x�K�N:K . O (9% �� ( �")p6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3M07K & )9,JB9K (9% K>) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K �h,JR � ( ) ( 3�B9K�G � . (9%'&!( �:3 .� TU% K>0 & � . )v35,JBHl�K>3�{�KwB9B93�BU{�3�B &�. �:3 . ( B & 6mGJKwx �"l�K�� &!( 6'B9K�)vK ./( � �") K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N , . l�KwB (9& � ./( C u 0 & N"N

KwB9B93�BH) � . (9% K N & )vKwB {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�)w� x �:R'B &!( �:3 .'& N�073 ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K �:3 . )w� &�. G �"076'B9K�l �") �:3 . � . l�3 ./( B935N"N�� . O (9% KK�N:K�l ( B93 � 0 & O . K ( �"lB8K�N"G')=I � (9% � . (9% K & 6'6 & B &!( ,') & N"N %'& x�K (9% KMK_sSK�l ( 3�{= % K &!( � . O ? (9% K �:3 . ) &�. G B & �") � . O(9% K �:B-K . KwB9O�C =j { &�. �:3 . O�K ( ) ( 3h3>= % 3 ( ? � ( 0 & CmK ./( KwB & ) (9&!( K73 (9% KwB (9%'&�. �#" 3�B �%" � (9% ,') � ./( B93`G','l � . O&�. K�)9)vK ./( � & N"N:C �:B9B9Kw6 & B & R8N:KFKwB9B93�B � ./( 3 (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� j ( �") (9% K�)vK KwB9B93�BH)w�'I % �"l % )9l & N:K I � (9% (9% K . ,'0 RSKwBU3�{ �h,JR � ( ) &�. G (9% K . ,'0 RSKwB+3�{�3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )+l & B9B �:K�G

35, ( �pI % �"l % lw,JB9B9K ./( N:Ca68N & l�KmN��"0 � ( )o3 . (9% Km)9l & N:K &�. G G',JB &!( �:3 . 3�{-l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )M,') � . O �:3 . ( B & 6 GJK �x �"l�K�) TU% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�K�) ( �"0 &!( K�)w��R & )vK�G 3 . (9% KoGJKwO�B9KwKo3�{~l�3 ./( B935N & x & �"N & R8N:K>I � (9% 6'B9K�)vK ./(+( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C�� & B9K(9%'&!( {�3�B & ( K .�� �h,JR � ( )vC`) ( K�0 � . 3 073�B9K (9%'&�. & RS35, ( ?!��� 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )=l &�. RSK7l & B9B �:K�G 35, (w ���`6SKwB �"07K .��(9& N �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . )w� ( 3 G &!( K�� %'& x�K & l % �:Kwx�K�G )9,JR8) (9&�./( � & N"N:C {�KwI4KwB=3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) (9%'&�. Kwx�K . (9% �")F073`GJK�) (. ,'0 RSKwB TU% KpO�3h3`G . KwI+) �") (9%'&!( 0735) ( 3�{ (9% K�)vK �")9)9,JK�) & B9Kp6'B �"0 & B �"N:C-3 . K�)�3�{86'B9K�l �")vKpl�3 ./( B935NJ3�x�KwB~I & x�K�N:K . O (9% )

&�. G 3�{ (9% K �h, & N�� ( C 3�{ (9% K �")v35N &!( �:3 . 3�{ (9% KmK��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N & 6'6 & B &!( ,')M{�B9350 � ( )M)9,JB9B935, . G � . O5) # � (9%�"076'B93�x�K�07K ./( ) � . (9% K�)vK ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O �:K�)w� (9% K & RS3�x�KaN��"0 � ( ) 0 & C�I4K�N"N-RSK N:3h35)vK . K�G TU% K . K�� ( )vKwB �:35,')(9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N 3�R8) (9& lwN:K { & l�K�G RhC �:3 . ( B & 6 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �")U)v6S3 ./(9&�. Kw35,')U6 % 3 ( 3 . K�0 �")9) �:3 . D (9% K>3`G'G') (9%'&!(& l�3h35N:K�G �:3 . I �"N"N`)v6S3 ./(9&�. Kw35,')9N:C K�0 � (~& 6 % 3 ( 3 . o &�. G (9% KwB9KwRhC l %'&�. O�K+K . KwB9O�C N:Kwx�K�N<p GJKw6SK . G 6'B � . l �:6 & N"N:C3 .a(9% K N:K . O (9% 3�{ ( �"07K (9%'&!(o(9% K �:3 . %'& ) B9K�0 & � . K�G � . (9%'&!( ) (9&!( K TU% KP6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B l % 3 �"l�K 3�{ �:3 .a&�. G( B & 6'6 � . O>{�B9K �h,JK . l�C�� & )4I4K�N"N & )p)vKwx�KwB & N�3 (9% KwB 073�B9K � 3�B � N:K�)9) B'�`K�GM6 & B & 07K ( KwBH)p)vK ( &�. ,J6'6SKwBdN��"0 � ( 3 . (9% K. ,'0 RSKwB 3�{'l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N/3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) (9%'&!( l &�. RSKdl & B9B �:K�G>35, ( � .>& O �:x�K .o& 0735, ./( 3�{ ( �"07K !� ,'07KwB �"l & N"N:C��{�3�BFl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) (9&;@ � . O & {�KwI % , . GJB9K�G R & ) �"l=3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )w� (9% K>3`G'G') (9%'&!( 3 . K 3�{ (9% K �:3 . ) I �"N"NSK�0 � (+&6 % 3 ( 3 .P& B9K . KwO5N��:O �:R8N:K��!R8, ( {�3�Bdl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )�3 .7(9% KU3�BHGJKwB�3�{ & 0 �"N"N��:3 . 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )w� (9% K�)vKU3`G'G')�RSK�l�3507K) �:O . �CB�l &�./(w

u�� � � �

TU% K . ,'lwN:K�,')o3�{ &�. &!( 350 (9%'&!( �") 6 & B ( 3�{ & N & B9O�KwBP0735N:K�lw,'N:K I �"N"N %'& x�K l�KwB (9& � . B9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�)&!( I % �"l % � ( �") & R8N:K ( 3 x �:R'B &!( K oTU% K�)vKo{�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�) & B9KPGJK ( KwBH0 � . K�GmRhC (9% KP) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9Ko3�{ (9% KP0735N:K�lw,'N:K. K & B (9% K &!( 350 t8(9% KwC GJKw6SK . G 3 . { & l ( 3�BH) (9%'&!( � . lwN",'GJK (9% K=I4K �:O %/( )U3�{ (9% K>x & B �:35,') . ,'lwN:K � ( 3PI % �"l % � ( �")RS3 . GJK�G &�. G (9% K+K�N:K�l ( B935) (9&!( �"lw)43�{ (9% KF0735N:K�lw,'N:K � .P(9% K+B9KwO �:3 . . K & B (9% �")~6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B . ,'lwN:K�,') jk. O�K . KwB & N �{�3�B & 0735N:K�lw,'N:K=I � (9% & )vC`0P07K ( B �:K�)w� (9% K G �CsSKwB9K ./( . ,'lwN:K �SI �"N"N %'& x�KoG �CsSKwB9K ./( B9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�) W B9O &�. �"l-l % K�0 �") ( ) %'& x�K>N:3 . O7K��`68N:3 � ( K�G (9% �")p6 % K . 3507K . 3 . RhC K�0768N:3�C � . O (9% K ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) 3�{ . ,'lwN:K & B

0 & O . K ( �"lMB9K�)v3 .'&�. l�K o � � qAp ( 3 GJK ( KwBH0 � . KM0735N:K�lw,'N & Bo) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K L�) & 0768N:KP3�{ &�. , .I@`. 3�I . 3�B9O &�. �"l0735N:K�lw,'N:K �")M68N & l�K�G � .�& )v35N:x�K ./( I % 35)vK B9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�) & B9K {�KwI>� @`. 3�I . � &�. G , . N�� @ K�N:C ( 3 N��:K. K & B (9% 35)vK 3�{ &�. C . ,'lwN:K�,') � . (9% K 0 C`) ( KwB9Ca0735N:K�lw,'N:K � & O . K ( �"lM68,'N")vK�)>3�x�KwB & B &�. O�K 3�{U{�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�)& B9K & 6'68N��:K�G &�. G (9% 35)vK7{�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�) &!( I % �"l % )v3507KPl�3 . ) ( � ( ,JK ./( 3�{ (9% K70735N:K�lw,'N:KoB9K�)v3 .'&!( K�) & B9K . 3 ( K�G TU% �") � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �") (9% K . ,')vK�G ( 3 B9K�l�3 . ) ( BH,'l (=(9% KP) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K73�{ (9% KP0735N:K�lw,'N:KRD=G �CsSKwB9K ./( l�35076S3 . K ./( )3�{�3�B9O &�. �"l=0735N:K�lw,'N:K�) %'& x�K G �CsSKwB9K ./( =v) �:O .'&!( ,JB9Kg?76 &!(v( KwB . ) 3�{ B9K�)v3 .'&�./( 6SK &;@ ) j ( �") & N")v3 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3mB9KwO & BHG (9% KMG �CsSKwB9K ./( . ,'lwN:K � � . & 0735N:K�lw,'N:K & ) � . G �:x �"G', & N �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P)

K & l % l & 6 & R8N:K=3�{�) ( 3�B � . O & �h,JR � (w � & l %m. ,'lwN:K�,') %'& ) & )9N��:O %/( 0 & O . K ( �"l=6S35N & B � ��&!( �:3 .��� ~jk. {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �")K . l�3`GJK�G � . (9% K>G �:B9K�l ( �:3 . � . I % �"l % (9% K . ,'lwN:K�,') �")p3�B �:K ./( K�G L<) (9& R8N:K>0 & O . K ( �"l-B8K�N"G �") & 6'68N��:K�G ( 3 (9% K

Page 31: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ��� � ?�V

� � q�l %'& 0 RSKwB & )-6 & B ( 3�{ (9% K 3�x�KwB & N"N � � q 6'B93`l�K�)9)mD & . ,'lwN:K�,')+3�B �:K ./( K�G ( 3�I & BHG') (9% K]B8K�N"G �") � . (9% K �#" ) (9&!( K��8I % �"N:K &7. ,'lwN:K�,') 3�B �:K ./( K�G & I & C {�B9350 (9% K B8K�N"G �") � . (9% K �%" ) (9&!( K }~B9K�l �")vK�N:C & 6'68N��:K�G B & G �:3 � {�B9K �h,JK . l�CP68,'N")vK�)43�{ (9% K=6'B93�6SKwB43�B �:K ./(9&!( �:3 . �J{�B9K �h,JK . l�C�� &�. G G',JB &!( �:3 . I �"N"N

l & ,')vK . ,'lwN:K � (9%'&!( B9K�)v3 .'&!( K &!(�(9%'&!( {�B9K �h,JK . l�C ( 3FB93 (9&!( K (9% K �:B�0 & O . K ( �"l43�B �:K ./(9&!( �:3 . � �:x�K . 35,JB�K . l�3`G � . O{�3�B � . G �:x �"G', & N �h,JR � ( ) (9&!( K�)w�+0735) ( �"076S3�B (9&�./( ) � . O5N:K � �h,JR � ( O &!( K�) l &�. RSK �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�G I � (9% 3 . K ( 3(9% B9KwK 68,'N")vK�) & N��:O . K�G I � (9%a(9% K � ��� � 3�B�� & �`K�)Koe0 &;@ � . O (9% K�0 K�)v6SK�l � & N"N:C l�3 . x�K . �:K ./( ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( p r4K�l & ,')vK (9% K-G �CsSKwB9K ./(p. ,'lwN:K � � .M& 0735N:K�lw,'N:K %'& x�K=G �CsSKwB9K ./( B9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�)w� (9% KwC & B9K � . G �:x �"G', & N"N:C& G'GJB9K�)9) & R8N:K tJ&P. ,'lwN:K�,')pI �"N"N . 3 ( B9K�)v6S3 . G ( 3P68,'N")vK�)p3;s � ( ) B9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l�C � ,'N ( �:68N:K �h,JR � ( � ./( KwB & l ( �:3 . ) & B9KM)v3507KwI %'&!( 073�B9KMl�350768N��"l &!( K�G ( 3mGJK�)9l�B �:RSK jk. 35, ( N�� . K {�3�BH0 � (9% K

)v6 � . )p3�{ ( I43 & G & l�K ./(-. ,'lwN:K � l &�. RSKF=vl�35,J68N:K�G ? ( 3MK & l % 3 (9% KwB���)v3 (9%'&!( S<VhE<GIH09a\YdgH_VPJYH0L�� NPO : dgHYd (9% K �:B) (9&!( K�)-I �"N"N�Kwx�35N:x�K � . & I & C (9%'&!( GJKw6SK . G')U3 . (9% Kox & N",JK 3�{~RS3 (9%� r4Cml�3 ./( B935N"N�� . O (9% K & 0735, ./( 3�{ ( �"07K(9% KwC & B9K & N"N:3�I4K�G ( 3PKwx�35N:x�K � . (9% �") I & C�� ( I43 � �h,JR � ( B93 (9&!( �:3 . )+l &�. RSK �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�G �mK & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�{ &P. ,'lwN:K�,') l�3 . ) �") ( ) � . & 6'68N:C � . O & 68,'N")vK &!(U(9% K=B9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l�C & N:3 . O (9% K �#"��

�%"+& � �")mD . ,'lwN:K � � . (9% K�)vK ( I43 ) (9&!( K�)-I �"N"N�6'B93`G','l�K B9K�)v3 .'&�. l�K7N�� . K�)U3�{~3�6'6S35) � ( Ko) �:O . �S)v3 (9%'&!(-(9% KwCml &�.RSK=G �") ( � . O5, �") % K�G �TU% �") �") (9% K=) (9& O�K &!( I % �"l % (9% K-R8,'N @M.'&!( ,JB9K-3�{ � � q l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . K ./( KwBH)mD � . 3�BHGJKwB( 3 6'B93`G','l�K & GJK ( K�l (9& R8N:KM35, ( 68, ( � & N & B9O�K . ,'0 RSKwB=3�{ 0735N:K�lw,'N:K�) & B9KPB9K �h, �:B9K�G PT Ch6 �"l & N�K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N�"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . )o,')vK )v35N", ( �:3 . ) I � (9% 0735N:K�lw,'N & B7l�3 . l�K ./( B &!( �:3 . )73 . (9% K 3�BHGJKwB 3�{ �w��� 0 �"N"N��"0735N:K�)=6SKwBN�� ( KwB fTU% KwB9K %'& ) RSKwK . )v3507K (9% 35,JO %/(7(9%'&!( )90 & N"N:KwB7) & 0768N:K ) � � K�)P0 �:O %/(7%'& x�Kml�KwB (9& � . & GJx &�./(9& O�Kw35,')6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) oe073�B9K K & ) �"N:Cfl�3h35N:K�G ( 3 , . GJKwB ��� K�N:x � . �~)90 & N"N:KwB7K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N & 6'6 & B &!( ,')w�dK ( l pH�pR8, (7&!(6'B9K�)vK ./( ) & 0768N:K>) � � K>GJ3hK�) . 3 ( 6S35)vK & )vKwB �:35,')p3�R8) (9& lwN:K ( 3 � � q<l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� jk. ) ( K & G�� (9% K B9K & N�G �Cr lw,'N ( �:K�)UI � (9% � � q l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . & B �")vK {�B9350 ( B9C � . O ( 3 )9l & N:K ,J6 (9% K . ,'0 RSKwB

3�{ �h,JR � ( ) � . x�35N:x�K�G � . & l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� ���`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N�I43�B @ %'& )-{�3`lw,')vK�G 3 . 0735N:K�lw,'N:K�)FI � (9% 3 . N:C ( I433�B (9% B9KwK . ,'lwN:K �83�{ � ./( KwB9K�) (w ~TU% K+B9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�) &�. G (9% KFB9K�N:Kwx &�./( l�35,J68N�� . O>{�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�)d{�3�B (9% K�)vK. ,'lwN:K � & B9K K & ) �"N:C GJK ( KwBH0 � . K�G�� &�. G (9% K B9K�) ( 3�{ (9% K 0735N:K�lw,'N:KoK�)9)vK ./( � & N"N:C GJ3hK�) . 3 ( � ./( KwB & l ( I � (9%m(9% K�0G',JB � . O (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� T 3a)9,J6'6S3�B ( & % , . GJB9K�G � �h,JR � ( )vC`) ( K�0 � & 0735N:K�lw,'N:K I � (9% I4K�N"Np3�x�KwB & % , . GJB9K�G &!( 350P) �") B9K �h, �:B9K�G

oe) � . l�K . 3 ( Kwx�KwB9C &!( 350 I �"N"N %'& x�KM)9, � (9& R8N:KoB9K�)v3 .'&�. l�K76'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)Yp oE ,JB (9% KwB�� (9% K7B9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�){�3�B+K & l % 3�{ (9% K�)vK &!( 350P)!o & )+I4K�N"N & ) & O�B9K &!( 0 &�. C 6'B9K�l �")vK GJK (9& �"N") & RS35, (U(9% K �:B � ./( KwB & l ( �:3 . )UI � (9% K & l %3�{ (9% K-3 (9% KwB &!( 350P)Ypd0o,') ( RSK @`. 3�I . � . 3�BHGJKwB ( 37l & N��:R'B &!( KF6'B93�6SKwBHN:C (9% K-68,'N")vK�)w�/I % �"l % I �"N"N . KwK�G ( 37RSK&!( 0 &�. C G �CsSKwB9K ./( {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�) >T 3 0 &;@ KP0 &!(v( KwBH)=Kwx�K . I43�BH)vK�� (9% KwB9K �") . 3 I & C ( 3 l�35,J68N:K ( I43 . ,'lwN:K �{�B9350 B9K�073 ( K+6 & B ( )~3�{ (9% K+0735N:K�lw,'N:K+G �:B9K�l ( N:CPD ( I43 � �h,JR � ( O &!( K�)40 & C7RSK & 6'68N��:K�G 3 . N:C ( 3 & G & l�K ./(4. ,'lwN:K � �07K &�. � . O (9%'&!(4&�. C7l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . I �"N"N %'& x�K ( 3 RSK & B9B &�. O�K�G � .P& I & C (9%'&!( � ./( �"0 &!( K�N:C GJKw6SK . G')~,J6S3 .7(9% K( 3�6S35N:3�O�C 3�{ (9% K 0735N:K�lw,'N:K=RSK � . O7,')vK�G TU% K 0735) ( 6'B9350 �") � . OaB9K�)v6S3 . )vK ( 3 (9% �") G �Cr lw,'N ( C %'& ) RSKwK . (9% K �"GJK & 3�{ ,') � . Of6S35N:C`07KwBH) & ) (9% K

0735N:K�lw,'N:K�) � . � � q<l�350768, ( � . O dTU% K & GJx &�./(9& O�K 3�{�,') � . O & 6S35N:C`07KwB �") (9%'&!( 0 &�. C 3�{ � ( ) . ,'lwN:K & B+) � ( K�)& B9K N:3`l & N"N:C � . G �") ( � . O5, �") %'& R8N:K���)v3 (9%'&!( (9% K 6'B935N��:{�KwB &!( �:3 . 3�{FB9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l �:K�) �") N��"0 � ( K�G &�. G (9% K( 3�6S35N:3�O�CM3�{ (9% K=0735N:K�lw,'N:K �")4B & G �"l & N"N:CP) �"0768N��CB8K�G TU% K-G �") & GJx &�./(9& O�K=3�{ ,') � . O & 6S35N:C`07KwB �") (9%'&!( 0 &�. C3�{ � ( ) . ,'lwN:K & B4) � ( K�) & B9K+N:3`l & N"N:C � . G �") ( � . O5, �") %'& R8N:K���)v3 (9%'&!(d(9% KwC & B9K . 3 N:3 . O�KwB � . G �:x �"G', & N"N:C & G'GJB9K�)9) & R8N:K TU% KmI & C & B935, . G (9% �")MN��"0 � (9&!( �:3 . 6'B93�6S35)vK�G RhC & GJx�3`l &!( K�) 3�{ (9% K 6S35N:C`07KwB ) ( B &!( KwO�C �") ( 3 ,')vK &

6S35N:C`07KwBdI � (9% )v3507K-G �") ( � . O5, �") % K�G . ,'lwN:K � (9%'&!(p& B9K & G'GJB9K�)9) & R8N:KURhCPG �CsSKwB9K ./( {�B9K �h,JK . l�C768,'N")vK�) (9%'&�.M(9% K. ,'lwN:K � � . (9% K , .'& GJ3�B . K�Gf6S35N:C`07KwB7, . � ( ) & B9K TU% K �h,JK�) ( �:3 . (9% K . RSK�l�3507K�) % 3�I ( 3 073�x�K & B9R � ( B & B9C�h,JR � ( ) ( 3 (9% K . ,'lwN:K ��I % KwB9K (9% KwC l &�. RSK � . G �:x �"G', & N"N:C 0 &�. �:68,'N &!( K�G

Page 32: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

?�� ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ������ �� ��� �

W-. K &�. )vI4KwB ( 3 (9% �") �h,JK�) ( �:3 . �") ( 3P,')vK & 6S35N:C`07KwB (9%'&!( %'& ) )v3507K=6 &!(v( KwB . 3�{ � . G �:x �"G', & N"N:C & G & l�K ./(. ,'lwN:K �~I % �"l % B9Kw6SK &!( � � K ( ( (�� � � � � � � � � ( ( ( � &�. G (9% K .a( 3 �")9)9,JKP68,'N")vK�)=I % �"l % I �"N"N�l & ,')vK 9;:<: 3�{(9% K . ,'lwN:K � 3�{ (9% Ko) & 07K ( Ch6SK ( 3 B9K�)v6S3 . G � .m(9% Ko) & 07KoI & C =E 3�B-K�� & 0768N:K�� & )vK ( 3�{~68,'N")vK�)UI % �"l % )vI & 6(9% K x & N",JK�) 3�{ (9% K �h,JR � ( &!( &�.���. ,'lwN:K�,') &�. G &!( � ( )�� . K �:O % RS3�B�� {�35N"N:3�I4K�GfRhC & )vK ( I % �"l % )vI & 6 �I � (9% � &�. G (9% K . ��I � (9%�� �SI �"N"N�)vK . G Kwx�KwB9C �h,JR � (+&!(-&�.�� ) � ( K ( 3 (9% K . K�� (�� ) � ( K & N:3 . O (9% Kol %'& � .� TU% �") ( K�l %'. ��h,JK 0 &;@ K�) � ( 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3�=kB93 (9&!( Kg? G �CsSKwB9K ./( �h,JR � ( ) � ./( 3 &�. Ga35, ( 3�{ &�. & l ( �:x�K ) � ( K � &. ,'lwN:K�,')4I % �"l % l &�. 6 & B ( �"l �:6 &!( K � . (9% K � � � B9K�)v3 .'&�. l�K�)w�JR8, ( & N")v3 %'& ) )v3507K=3 (9% KwBUB9K�)v3 .'&�./( {�B9K �h,JK . l�C&!( I % �"l % � ( l &�. RSK � . G �:x �"G', & N"N:C & G'GJB9K�)9)vK�G pTU% �") 073`GJK�N �") � . )v3507K I & C`)FN�� @ K & l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!( 3 .�� �� . I % �"l %7(9% K+l�K�N"N")~,J6�G &!( K � . 6 & B & N"N:K�N � . B9K�)v6S3 . )vK ( 3 (9% K �:BdN:3`l & N') � ( , &!( �:3 . ) j ( �") & N")v3 � . )v3507KUI & C`)4N�� @ K& T ,JB � . OP0 & l % � . K�� � . I % �"l %m&�. & l ( �:x�Kh= % K & G ?M073�x�K�) & N:3 . O & 6 & )9) �:x�K = (9& 6SK ? @ KwB9K � ( �") (9% K = (9& 6SKg?I % �"l % 073�x�K�)w�8I % �"N:K (9% KF= % K & G ?7B9K�0 & � . ) ) (9&!( �:3 .'& B9C LFN (9% 35,JO % )9,'l % &>( K�l %'. ��h,JKFGJ3hK�)d6'B9350 �")vK ( BH,'N:C )9l & N & R8N:K �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � � .P(9% KF)vK . )vK (9%'&!(

� ( l &�. RSK+K�� ( K . GJK�G ( 3 &�. K�)9)vK ./( � & N"N:C & B9R � ( B & B9C . ,'0 RSKwB43�{��h,JR � ( )w� (9% KwB9K & B9K-)v3507K-K . 3�BH0735,') ( K�l %'. �"l & N% ,JBHG'N:K�) ( 3 (9% �")p6'B93 vK�l (w dE � . G � . O & )9, � (9& R8N:K-6S35N:C`07KwB �") & x�KwB9C G �Cr lw,'N ( 6'B935)v6SK�l (w ���`6SKwB �"07K ./( KwBH) %'& x�K %'& G7073�B9KU)9,'lwl�K�)9) ( 3>G &!( KUI � (9% � � q (9%'&�. I � (9%7&�. Co3 (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (��

� . O ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�CPD�GJKwx �"l�K�)�3�{ ( I43 &�. G (9% B9KwK �h,JR � ( ) %'& x�KURSKwK . l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( K�G &�. G %'& x�K+)9,'lwl�K�)9)v{e,'N"N:C l & B9B �:K�G35, ( )vKwx�KwB & N83�{ (9% K �"076S3�B (9&�./( �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w� � . lwN",'G � . O �FK�, ( )9l %�� ) &�. G �FB93�x�KwB � ) dTU% K�)vKFGJKwx �"l�K�)( Ch6 �"l & N"N:C K�0768N:3�C K � (9% KwB & 0735N:K�lw,'N:KMI � (9% ( I43 &!( 350P)w�~3�B & 0735N:K�lw,'N:KMI � (9% ( I43 3�B (9% B9KwK . ,'lwN:K �~I � (9%B9K�)v3 .'&�. l�K 6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) x�KwB9C G �") ( � . l ( {�B9350 (9% 35)vK 3�{ (9% K>3 (9% KwB . ,'lwN:K � � . (9% K 0735N:K�lw,'N:K ��� ( B9K�07K�N:C N�� (v( N:K6'B93�O�B9K�)9) %'& )4RSKwK . 0 & GJK ( 3�I & BHG')pB9K & N�� � � . O K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N"N:C &�. CM3�{ (9% KF6S35N:C`07KwB � R & )vK�G � � q )9l % K�07K�)

u��� ���!2 "62-+0$�� &

TU% K & RS3�x�Ko6'B93�6S35) & N") %'& x�K (9&;@ K . (9% Kol �:BHlw, � ( 073`GJK�N & ) & 07K (9& 6 % 3�BgD (9% Kol �:BHlw, � ( RSK�l�3507K�) & )vK �h,JK . l�K3�{ 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) & 6'68N��:K�G ( 3 073�B9K � 3�B � N:K�)9)o) (9&!( �:3 .'& B9C �h,JR � ( ) W 6 ( �"l & N �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . (9&;@ K�) (9% Kl �:BHlw, � ( 073`GJK�N &!( { & l�K>x & N",JKRD (9% K>l �:BHlw, � ( �") & 6 % C`) �"l & NSGJKwx �"l�K (9% B935,JO % I % �"l % �h,JR � ( ) ( B & x�K�N {�B9350 � . 68, (( 3�I & BHG')U35, ( 68, (w jk. 3�6 ( �"l & N �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ���h,JR � ( ) & B9K ) ( 3�B9K�G � . (9% K>6 % C`) �"l & N�) (9&!( K 3�{ � . G �:x �"G', & N'6 % 3 ( 3 . )w�

� . 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�� (9% K!NILqdYSTETSUL;V 3�{ (9% 35)vKP6 % 3 ( 3 . ) u � . l�K76 % 3 ( 3 . )=I �"N"N�0735) ( GJK_B . � ( K�N:C . 3 ( ) � ( ) ( �"N"N � (9% KwC& B9K � . ) ( K & Gf{�K�G (9% B935,JO % & B'�`K�GWo &�. G 0 & l�B935)9l�3�6 �"lcpo)vK ( 3�{Fl �:BHlw, � ( K�N:K�07K ./( )7I % �"l % & l ( 3 . (9% K�0 � .6'B9K�G �"l (9& R8N:KpI & C`) �jk.7(9% K & 6'6SK & N�� . OZ;O 9;: � X 9;S<:5073`GJK�N ��K & l % 6 % 3 ( 3 . �") & N"N:3�I4K�G ( I43 6S35)9) �:R8N:K46 &!(9% ) & N:3 . OI % �"l % ( 3 ( B & x�K�NUDd3 . K>3�{ (9% 35)vK>6 &!(9% ) �") �#" &�. G (9% K>3 (9% KwB �") �%"H TU% KFO &!( K�) I % �"l % & l ( 3 . & �h,JR � (4& B9K & N:3 . O 3 . Ko�3�B RS3 (9% p�3�{ � ( )46 &!(9% ) L �=W-T O &!( K��'{�3�BpK�� & 0768N:K��

9,') ( l�B935)9)vK�) (9% K>6 &!(9% ) ~jk. )vKwB ( � . O & 6 %'& )vK>GJK�N & C 3 . 3 . K>6 &!(9% R8, (U. 3 (U(9% K>3 (9% KwB �"0768N:K�07K ./( ) & l�3 . G � �( �:3 .'& Nh6 %'& )vK � ) % �:{ (w L @F& G & 0 & BHGoB93 (9&!( �:3 . �") & RSK & 0 � )v68N�� (v( KwB (9%'&!( Kwx�K . N:Co)v68N�� ( ) &�. � . l�350 � . O+I & x�Kw{�3�BH0& N:3 . O � ( ) ( I43>35, ( 68, ( 6 &!(9% ) �E B9K�G @ � .P&�. G T 3;sS35N��JO &!( K�) & B9K & N")v3>) ( B & �:O %/( {�3�B9I & BHG � . 6'B � . l �:68N:K ( 3 l�B9K &!( K��0 &;@ � . O & 6 % 3 ( 3 . �"l=GJKwx �"l�K & , . �:x�KwBH) & N��h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwB W 6 ( �"l & N GJKwx �"l�K�) %'& x�Ko)vKwx�KwB & N�) ( B9K . O (9% ) & ) �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH) ~j ( �")px�KwB9C K & )vC ( 3P68N & l�K=6 % 3 ( 3 . )

� . (9% K )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . ) . KwK�GJK�Ga{�3�B )9,'l % GJKwx �"l�K�) u � . O5N:K76 % 3 ( 3 . ) o & ) l %'& B9O�K�N:K�)9) &�. Gf0 & )9)9N:K�)9) 6 & B ( � �lwN:K�)Yp-GJ3 . 3 ( RSK�l�3507KMK ./(9&�. O5N:K�G I � (9% (9% K �:B>K . x �:B93 . 07K ./( ) & )>K & ) �"N:C & ) N & B9O�KwBo)vC`) ( K�0P) GJ3 LFN")v3J� (9% K��� K GQL�PVA M�? <%X? 0�R*2�M&GB0&7�=�? @ ? P :Q4XA 2�@/:@J? 7 7�GCP :TU:K GBM�4*M D�GBMNGB@�46KV0�G67��F2�@F7 EHG6D\132546037�2�8 <GB8;M�2 7>4I7�? GB0&W�2 7�EHG6D$8&46@/@/? TU:K L

M54ID>46K K :K 132546037�2�8,<GB8;M�2 7>4I7�? GB0�A��$=�? <>=�<GB2�K P�WN:Y4,�J4LZ4ID�GB2�05P&7�=�:Y? 0�:�;<? :0�<? :@$G6E 8;? <�D�G + @/<Q46K : 132546037�2�8,<GB8;M�2 7>4I7�? GB0�]

Page 33: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � �� ��� ��� � � � �� ?5n

GJKwx �"l�K�) � . x�35N:x�K�G %'& x�KoRSKwK . )9,'lwl�K�)9)v{e,'N"N:C ) % 3�I � . OM3;sa) �"0768N:K �h, &�./( ,'0�6 % K . 3507K .'& {�3�BFC�K & BH)mD 3�6 ( �"l & NK��`6SKwB �"07K ./( ) %'& x�K RSKwK .a(9% K 6'B �"07KM)v35,JBHl�KM3�{ (9% K N & RS3�B &!( 3�B9C l�3 . B8BH0 &!( �:3 . ) 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 � 07K�l %'&�. �"l & NI �:KwBHG . K�)9)4I % �"l % 6S3�68,'N &!( K (9% K=6 & O�K�)U3�{�6S3�68,'N & B )9l �:K . l�K>0 & O &�� � . K�) �m35) ( 3�{ (9% K�)vK & GJx &�./(9& O�K�)w� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB��Sl & B9B9C K��`68N��"l � ( ( B & GJKw3;s�) 4j ( �")Ul�3 . ) �"GJKwB & R8N:C 073�B9K G �Cr lw,'N (p( 3

l & ,')vK 6 % 3 ( 3 . )0o & )=0 & )9)9N:K�)9) &�. G l %'& B9O�K�N:K�)9)-6 & B ( �"lwN:K�)Yp ( 3 � ./( KwB & l (-(9%'&�. � ( �") ( 3 l & ,')vK7N & B9O�KwB=)vC`) ( K�0P)( 3 � ./( KwB & l (w r4K�l & ,')vK 6 % 3 ( 3 . ) ( B & x�K�N &!(M(9% K )v6SKwK�G 3�{>N��:O %/( � �:{-0 � . 3�B �"076'B9K�l �") �:3 . ) � . (9% K )v6 & l � . O3�{FK��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N & 6'6 & B &!( ,')Pl & ,')vK ( I43 6 % 3 ( 3 . 6 &!(9% ) ( 3 (9% K ) & 07K 6S3 � ./(7( 3 %'& x�K G �CsSKwB9K ./( N:K . O (9% )w�(9% K �:B ( �"07K�) 3�{ & B9B �:x & N4l &�. RSK )v3 G �CsSKwB9K ./( & ) ( 3 6'B9Kwx�K ./( (9% K . K�l�K�)9) & B9C � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K RSK ( I4KwK . (9% K�0 TU% K 6'B9K�l �") �:3 . . K�l�K�)9) & B9C ( 3�l�B9K &!( KaN & B9O�KwB �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( ) I �"N"N & N")v3 B9K �h, �:B9K & GJx &�. l�K�) � . ) � . O5N:K �6 % 3 ( 3 . ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C ) �:O . �CB�l &�./( N:C7RSKwC�3 . G (9%'&!( 6'B9K�)vK ./( N:C & x & �"N & R8N:K��`) � . l�K (9% K�)vK-)90 & N"N8KwB9B93�BH)pl & )9l & GJK � ., . {�3�B ( , .'&!( KFI & C`)w� � � &�. G lw,JB9B9K ./(p( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C � ./( B93`G','l�K�) & . ,'0 RSKwBp3�{ & 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( �:3 . ) ( 3P)v3507K=3�{ (9% KO &!( K�) W-. K � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O 6'B93�6S35) & N �") ( 3 ,')vK & ) � . O5N:K 6 % 3 ( 3 . ( 3 l & B9B9C M!O :CETS NP: H �h,JR � ( ) RhC (9&;@ � . O &�. Ca3�{

?�� 6 &!(9% ) �:{ � ( ) �"0o,'N &!( K�) � �h,JR � ( ) TU% �")7l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . �4) � . l�K � ( O�B93�I+)PK��`6S3 . K ./( � & N"N:C I � (9% (9% K ) � � K3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 � �") lwN:K & BHN:C , . )9, � (9& R8N:K {�3�B O�K . KwB & N-N & B9O�K � )9l & N:K �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� <@ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� & )dYS<M!O :i9RETSUL;V ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C {�3�B &�.'& N:C � � . O )90 & N"N �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( )w� � (=& x�3 �"G') (9% �")FK��`6S3 . K ./( � & N�R8N:3�I+,J6 RhC3 . N:Col�3 . ) �"GJKwB � . OF)90 & N"Nhx & N",JK�)�3�{ �� �E 3�Bd)90 & N"Nhx & N",JK�) 3�{ � � & )�I4K�N"N � (9% K N��"0 � ( )�3�{�3�6 ( �"l & N ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C & B9KN:K�)9)pB9K�) ( B �"l ( �:x�K��8)v3 (9%'&!( 6 % 3 ( 3 . �"lw) 0 �:O %/( I4K�N"NSRSK (9% K ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C 3�{�l % 3 �"l�K>{�3�B+l�3 . B8BH0 � . O7)90 & N"N � )9l & N:K6 % K . 3507K .'& 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)

u��� (*)! ,+-".)0/ � 2 "6&

*-, &�./( ,'0 GJ3 ( )w� �:{=)9,'lwl�K�)9)v{e,'N"N:C �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�G��4I435,'N"G B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(M(9% Km,'N ( �"0 &!( K & l % �:Kwx�K�07K ./( 3�{=)v35N��"G �) (9&!( Ko6 % C`) �"lw)mD (9% Ko)9,'lwl�K�)9)v{e,'N l�B9K &!( �:3 . 3�{�)vK�0 �"l�3 . G','l ( 3�BH) (9%'&!( 3�6SKwB &!( K K ./( �:B9K�N:C &!(+(9% KoN:Kwx�K�N 3�{�) � . O5N:KK�N:K�l ( B93 . ) L �h, &�./( ,'0 GJ3 ( �") & )90 & N"N B9KwO �:3 . 3�{ )vK�0 � � l�3 . G','l ( � . O 0 &!( KwB � & N�GJ3�6SK�G 6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C )v3 & ) ( 3%'& x�KFB93h350�{�3�BdK�� & l ( N:CP3 . KUK�� ( B & K�N:K�l ( B93 .� *-,JR � ( ) & B9K (9% K . K . l�3`GJK�GPRhC (9% K+) (9&!( K�)43�{ (9% KUK�N:K�l ( B93 . )d3 .� . G �:x �"G', & N��h, &�./( ,'0�GJ3 ( ) W { & N"N 6'B93�6S35) & N")+{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � �h, &�./( ,'0�GJ3 ( )=l�3507K7lwN:35)vK�) (( 3 (9% K (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N 073`GJK�N�3�{ & l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!( 3 .� TU% K 6 % C`) �"l & N GJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . )o3�{-)9,'l % )vC`) ( K�0P) & B9K �h, � ( K l�350768N��"l &!( K�G��p073�B9K )v3 Kwx�K . (9%'&�. {�3�B (9% K

3 (9% KwBU073`GJK�N")dI4K %'& x�K=RSKwK . G �")9lw,')9) � . OJ� . 3�B �") (9% KwB9K-O�K . KwB & N & O�B9KwK�07K ./( 3 . (9% K-RSK�) ( I & C`) � . I % �"l %M( 3�"0768N:K�07K ./( )v6SK�l �CB�l ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )~3 .M(9% K �h,JR � ( )d) ( 3�B9K�G � . �h, &�./( ,'0 GJ3 ( ) �TU% K+6'B9K�)vK . l�K+3�B & R8)vK . l�K3�{ &�. K�N:K�l ( B935) (9&!( �"lmR & B9B �:KwBPRSK ( I4KwK .�( I43 GJ3 ( )w� � (M%'& )PRSKwK . )9,JO�O�K�) ( K�G��Ul�35,'N"G�)vK�N:K�l ( �:x�K�N:C 6SKwBH0 � ( 3�B6'B9Kwx�K ./(F(9% K�02{�B93502l�35,J68N�� . OJ� (9% ,') & N"N:3�I � . O7{�3�B-)v3507Ko0o,'N ( �:68N:K � �h,JR � ( O &!( K�) FTU% K & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . 3�{ bRH_XY^6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C � l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G K�N:K�l ( B93 � 0 & O . K ( �"l 68,'N")vK�) l�35,'N"G & N")v3Ml & ,')vK x & B �:35,') Kwx�35N", ( �:3 . ( 3 (9&;@ Ko68N & l�K � . (9% K) (9&!( K-3�{ &�. � . G �:x �"G', & N��h, &�./( ,'0 GJ3 (w � �:x�K . (9% KFK�� ( B9K�07K�N:CM)90 & N"N ( 35N:KwB &�. l�K�)p{�3�Bp)9,'l % ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )&�. G (9% K .'&�. 35)9l & N:K &!( I % �"l % (9% KwC (9&;@ K 68N & l�K oe) � . l�K (9% KoGJ3 ( )F0o,') ( RSK lwN:35)vK K . 35,JO %m( 3MK & l % 3 (9% KwB ( 3� ./( KwB & l ( pH� � (F%'& )+RSKwK . )9,JO�O�K�) ( K�G (9%'&!(F(9% K�)vKoR & B9B �:KwBH) &�. Gm68,'N")vK�)+l�35,'N"GmRSK & G'0 � . �") ( KwB9K�G RhC & ,`� �"N�� & B9C�h, &�./( ,'0�GJ3 ( ) I % �"l % & B9K (9% K�0P)vK�N:x�K�)+lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:CMl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G TU% KwB9K & B9K=)v3507K-K�� ( B9K�07K�N:C )vKwB �:35,')43�R8) (9& lwN:K�) ( 3 (9% K �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . 3�{ & l ( , & N��h, &�./( ,'0 � GJ3 ( l�350 �

68, ( KwBH)w��0735) (=%'& x � . O ( 3 GJ3 I � (9%m(9% K7)90 & N"N�)9l & N:K &!( I % �"l % � ( 0o,') ( RSK l & B9B �:K�G 35, (=&�. G (9% K7) ( B � . O�K ./(-�� D/D�G6D + <G6D/D�:<�7�? GB0C@/<>=�:8;:@"EHG6D 132546037�2�8(<GB8;M�2 7�:�D�@"@F7/D�? TU:�7�G\<G6D/D�:<�7 :�D/D�G6D�@ ? 0 �$=�? <>=*GB0�: 132546037�2�8(@F7>4I7�:�? @ @/2�W�@F7�? 7�2 7�:QPEHG6DS460�G67�=�:�D-( � ����EHG6D�� �>A�G6D � � ����EHG6D�� ����EHG6D\: '�468;M�K :B])+�2 7J7�=�: :�D/D�G6D�@J7�=54I7\46<<2�8C2�K 4I7�: ? 0Z460�GBM 7�? <Q46K"P :TX? <:Y4ID�:Y:�D/D�G6D�@$G6E7�? 8;? 0�R A EHG6D �$=�? <>=Z0�GC:�D/D�G6D + <G6D/D�:<�7�? GB0�@/<>=�:8;: <Q460Z<G6D/D�:<�7Q]

Page 34: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

?�y ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ������ �� ��� �

B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( ) 3 . (9% K>6 % C`) �"l & NS6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)p3�{ (9% K )9,JR8) ( B &!( K &!(U(9% K . K & B � 0735N:K�lw,'N & B+N:Kwx�K�N 4TU% K>6'B93�R8N:K�03�{S07K & )9,JB � . O �h,JR � ( ) �") &-( B �"l @ C 3 . KRD 6'B93�6S35) & N") � . x�35N:x�K K��`68N:3 � ( � . O-6 % K . 3507K .'& N�� @ KpK�N:K�l ( B93 .P( , .'. K�N�� . OJ�� . I % �"l %M&�. K�N:K�l ( B93 . = 9,'0768)'?={�B9350 3 . K-N:3`l &!( �:3 .M( 3 &�. 3 (9% KwBAE<GaX L;O k;G &�. � ./( KwB9x�K . � . O R & B9B �:KwB 1p,JB9B9K ./()vK�0 �"l�3 . G','l ( 3�B~{ & R'B �"l &!( �:3 . ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C �") . 3 ( Kwx�K . lwN:35)vK ( 3 O�3h3`G7K . 35,JO % {�3�B (9% K+GJK�0 &�. G')�3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� LFGJx &�. l�K�) & B9K & N")v3-6'B93�R & R8N:C . K�l�K�)9) & B9C � .o(9% K ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�CoB9K �h, �:B9K�G ( 3=K_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:Col�3 ./( B935N�h, &�./( ,'0�GJ3 ( )5o�RhC l�B9K &!( � . OPx�KwB9C l & B9Kw{e,'N"N:C 073`G','N &!( K�G &�. G N:3`l &!( K�G K�N:K�l ( B93 � 0 & O . K ( �"l B8K�N"G')Yp W-. (9% Kp6S35) � ( �:x�K4) �"GJK����h, &�./( ,'0sGJ3 ( ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C �") (9% K G �:B9K�l ( �:3 . � . I % �"l % )vK�0 �"l�3 . G','l ( 3�B B9K�)vK & BHl % �")

% K & GJK�G��53�{ � ( )�3�I .P& lwl�3�BHG ~TU% K l �:BHlw, � ( B9C � . ,')vK � . 6'B9K�)vK ./( l�350768, ( KwBH) �")�6'B9K�)9) � . O-,J6 & O & � . ) (�(9% K+)9l & N:K&!( I % �"l % �h, &�./( ,'0 K_sSK�l ( ) � K�)v6SK�l � & N"N:C K�N:K�l ( B93 . ( , .'. K�N�� . O � RSKwO � .P( 3oRSK�l�3507K-) �:O . �CB�l &�./( K . 35,JO %M( 3& 6'6SK & B & )FKwB9B93�BH) � . lwN & )9) �"l & N l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) -E B9350 (9% Ko6SKwBH)v6SK�l ( �:x�K 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 GJ3 ( )w� (9% K�)vKh=kKwB9B93�BH)'?& B9K (9% K7B9K & N�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� o#% K (9% KwB>3�B . 3 ( �h, &�./( ,'0 GJ3 (=( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C I �"N"N�Kwx�KwB )9,'lwl�KwK�G � . B9K & N�� � � . O�h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � � ( GJ3hK�)o0 & B @a&�. � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . Om{�B93 ./( �:KwBoRSK ( I4KwK . 073�B9K ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& Ndl�350768, ( � . O( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C &�. G �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .�

u��� � + �-2-+!&

TU% Kp,')9, & N/{ & ,'N (�� ( 35N:KwB &�. l�K 073`GJK�N/{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0sl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �") ( 3 (9&;@ K (9% KpKwB9B93�BH) {�B9350 (9% K!= %'& BHGJI & B9Kg?N:Kwx�K�N & ) & O �:x�K .M&�. G ( 3 �"076S35)vK & N:Kwx�K�N o�3�B4N:Kwx�K�N")Yp 3�{�KwB9B93�B � l�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . � . =v)v3�{ ( I & B9K ? � � (9& Kwx � )~6'B93�6S35) & N{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ,') � . O &�. C�3 . ) �") &�.&!(v( K�076 ( ( 3 l�B9K &!( K & �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwB I % �"l % �")� ./( B � . ) �"l & N"N:C7{ & ,'N (�� ( 35N:KwB &�./(w u l % K�0 &!( �"l & N"N:C�� (9% KM6'B93�R8N:K�0 I � (9% K . l�3`G � . O � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � . =k3�BHG � .'& B9C ? �h, &�./( ,'0�6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)>N�� @ K

N:3`l &!( �:3 . 3�B 3�B �:K ./(9&!( �:3 . 3�{U)v6 � . �") (9%'&!( , . l�KwB (9& � ./( C K_sSK�l ( ) &�. G K . x �:B93 . 07K ./(9& N � ./( KwB & l ( �:3 . )>6SKwB ( ,JB9R�h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P) � . I & C`)dI % �"l % l & ,')vK+N & B9O�KUx & B � &!( �:3 . ) � . (9% 35)vKU6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) L . C�3 . )~K . l�3`GJK � . {�3�BH0 & �( �:3 . � . = ( 3�6S35N:3�O �"l & N ?M6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P)w��I % �"l %m& B9KoK��`6S3 . K ./( � & N"N:C � . )vK . ) � ( �:x�K ( 3 KwB9B93�BH)� . 6S35) � ( �:3 .� L . C�3 . )oK�� �") ( � .f&m( I43 � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N4)vC`) ( K�0 � � . I % �"l %a(9% K �:B 073 ( �:3 . �")ol�3 . B . K�G ( 3 & 68N &�. K T 3

l %'&�. O�K (9% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l & B9B �:K�G RhC & 6 & B ( �"lwN:K�� (9%'&!( 6 & B ( �"lwN:KF0o,') ( RSK-l & B9B �:K�G K ./( �:B9K�N:C 9;X L;O VPZ &�. 3 (9% KwB6 & B ( �"lwN:K � j { (9% K ( I43P6 & B ( �"lwN:K�) & B9K>)vKw6 & B &!( K�G & { ( KwB (9% �") l & B9B9C � . O � & B935, . G�� & O�B9K &!( GJK & NS3�{�GJK�l�3 % KwB9K . l�Kl &�. (9&;@ KM68N & l�K � . (9% K �:B=6S35) � ( �:3 . )FI � (9% 35, (>& sSK�l ( � . O (9% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . (9%'&!(>(9% K73 . K %'& )=RSKwK . l & B9B �:K�G& B935, . G (9% K>3 (9% KwB TU% K l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . )F3�{ �h,JR � ( ) &�. G O &!( K�)={�B9350 (9% K�)vK GJK (9& �"N") & B9K B &!(9% KwB ( K�l %'. �"l & N � � . 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B��

0o,'N ( �:68N:K 6 & B ( �"lwN:K�) & B9K B9K �h, �:B9K�G ( 3f) ( 3�B9K & ) � . O5N:K �h,JR � (7&�. G (9% K 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )7B9K �h, �:B9K�G ( 3fl & B9B9C 35, ((9% K=R & ) �"l ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) & B9K>)v3507KwI %'&!( l�350768N��"l &!( K�G � R8, (U&�. &�. C�3 . �"l=)vC`) ( K�0�l &�. �"0768N:K�07K ./(p(9% K. K�l�K�)9) & B9C 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�KFO &!( K�) ( 3M0 &;@ K � (U& , . �:x�KwBH) & N �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwB #%'&!( �") 073�B9K 3�{ & l�3 . l�KwB . �") (9%'&!(m&�. &�. C�3 .�� R & )vK�G �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwB �")w�F{�3�B & N"N-6'B & l ( �"l & N

68,JB96S35)vK�)w� �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 B9K & N�� � K 6 % C`) �"l & N"N:C E �:BH) ( �-RSK�l & ,')vK )v6 & l�K �") (9% B9KwK � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N � (9% K ( I43 �G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N K�� �") (9&�. l�KP3�{ &�. C�3 . ) �")=)v3507K (9% � . O 3�{ &�. �")9)9,JK �m3�B9K �"076S3�B (9&�./( N:C�� (9% K . ,'0 RSKwB=3�{ )v6 � .G �"07K . ) �:3 . )-B9K �h, �:B9K�G RhC &�.f&�. C�3 . l & B9B9C � . O 35, ( = � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O ? l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . o & T 3;sS35N��dO &!( Kqp �")>x�KwB9C% �:O % D �!� � � . l�35076 & B �")v3 . I � (9%a(9% K 073�B9K l�3 . x�K . �:K ./(7( I43 6S35)9)vK�)9)vK�GaRhC &�. K�N:K�l ( B93 .� TU% KwB9K �")oN�� (v( N:K �S:0�<:\7�=�:SP :@/<�D�? M 7�? GB0 ) 7�GBMNGBK GBRB? <Q46K * ( �$=54I7J8&4I7/7�:�D�@�? @$4Y7�GBMNGBK GBRB? <Q46K�? 0XTB4ID�? 46037 G6E 4 M54ID/7�? <K :�� @J=�? @F7�G6D/L

? 7�@ �$? 05P ? 0�R0X2�8CWN:�D

D>4I7�=�:�D$7�=5460�WN:? 0�R;P :MN:05P :037JGB0ZMNGB@/? 7�? GB0 46K GB0�:

Page 35: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� �� � � � ��� ?�|

N�� @ K�N�� % 3h3`G (9%'&!(=&�. C�3 . )-I �"N"N RSK {�35, . G � .m(9% K7N & RS3�B &!( 3�B9C &�. C ( �"07K )v3h3 . � &�. G (9% KwB9K �")+Kwx�K . N:K�)9) % 3�6SK3�{�R8, �"N"G � . O & GJKwx �"l�K>l & 6 & R8N:K=3�{�l�3 ./( B935N"N�� . O &�. G 07K & )9,JB � . O (9% K�0 #%'&!( 0 & C ) & x�K &�. C�3 . l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� & B9K (9% K ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) 3�{ �mO 9;V ETO M*dYS<M!O :i9RETSUL;V � . I % �"l %

3 . K �h, &�./( ,'0<)vC`) ( K�0<) �"0o,'N &!( K�) &�. 3 (9% KwB ~u ,'l % ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) & B9K . 3 ( K�)v6SK�l � & N"N:C=,')vKw{e,'N�{�3�B�3 (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0GJKwx �"l�K�)mD (9% KP) �"0o,'N &!( 3�B � ./( B93`G','l�K�)-KwB9B93�B�� 0o,'l % & ) (9% KP)vC`) ( K�0 � ( ) �"0o,'N &!( K�)-I435,'N"G %'& x�KMGJ3 . K o# � (9%l & B9K�� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% K={ & ,'N (�� ( 35N:KwB &�. l�K>3�{ &�. C�3 . )+l &�. RSK-K��`68N:3 � ( K�G ( 3M0 &;@ K (9% �") �h, &�./( ,'0�RS3h3 ( ) ( B & 6'6 � . OI43�B @ {�3�B�) �"0o,'N &!( � . O (9% K�0 LFN"N (9%'&!( �") . K�l�K�)9) & B9C �") (9%'&!(�(9% KpKwB9B93�BH) � ./( B93`G','l�K�G>RhC (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0s)vC`) ( K�0l & B9B9C � . O>35, (4(9% KF) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . RSK (9% K @ � . GP3�{�KwB9B93�BH) ( 3oI % �"l %P&�. C�3 . ) & B9K � . )vK . ) � ( �:x�K jk. 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�� �:{ &) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . )vC`) ( K�0 B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( ) (9% Ko6S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ &�. &�. C�3 . RhCm)v3507KoKwB9B93�B � 6'B93 . K 6'B93�6SKwB ( C�� (9% K � ./( B � . ) �"l� . )vK . ) � ( �:x � ( C-3�{ &�. C�3 . ) ( 3=KwB9B93�BH) � . 6S35) � ( �:3 . 0 � . �"0 � � K�) (9% KpK_sSK�l ( )~3�{ (9% KU) �"0o,'N &!( 3�B � ) KwB9B93�B �TU% K4KwB9B93�BH)� ./( B93`G','l�K�G RhC (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N GJKwx �"l�K & B9K . 3 ( KwB9B93�BH) ( 3PI % �"l % (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �")U)vK . ) � ( �:x�K W { (9% K ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O �:K�)7GJK�)9l�B �:RSK�G % KwB9K�� &�. C�3 . ) & B9K (9% K {e,JB (9% K�) ( {�B9350 B9K & N�� ( C &!( 6'B9K�)vK ./( � . 3�B �") � (

lwN:K & B (9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . I � (9%�&�. C�3 . ) %'& ) 0o,'l % 3�{ & {e, ( ,JB9K j { �h, &�./( ,'0 ) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . 3�{&�. C�3 . )vC`) ( K�0P)>l &�. RSK70 & GJK ( 3 I43�B @ � (9% K . )9,'l % )vC`) ( K�0P) %'& x�K (9% K76S3 ( K ./( � & N ( 3 )v35N:x�KP)vKwx�KwB & N�3 (9% KwB0 & v3�BP6'B93�R8N:K�0P)o3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � . 3 . K {�K�N"Np)vI43h3�6 TU% �")o6S35)9) �:R �"N�� ( C & N:3 . K 0 &;@ K�) (9% K�0I43�B (9% l�3 . ) �"GJKwB � . O

Page 36: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

D!� ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ������ �� ��� �

Page 37: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�������������

� � � ����� � � � ��� ���

�]��� ����� 2���� ".$�� � � 2 �� �'& 2��>(*)! ,+-".)0/ 1�2-/430)5"6 #".$'2-+

jk.o(9% Kp6'B9Kwx �:35,')�l %'& 6 ( KwB��5I4K %'& x�KUl %'& B & l ( KwB � � K�G7I %'&!( � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .o& �h, &�./( ,'0s)vC`) ( K�0 l &�. d_EQL;X'H �� 3�I>�I4K (9&;@ KU,J6 (9% KpB9K�N &!( K�G �h,JK�) ( �:3 . 3�{'I %'&!( {e, . l ( �:3 . ) & �h, &�./( ,'0<GJKwx �"l�K l &�. J�L;M�NPOIE H 4u 6SK�l �CB�l & N"N:C���O �:x�K .& �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0�I � (9% ) (9&!( Ko)v6 & l�K

��JI4K & ) @ I % �"l % , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )

� D���

o QJ "� pl &�. RSKPl�350768, ( K�G 3 . 3 . K73�{ (9% K %'& BHGJI & B9KP073`GJK�N")=l�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G � . (9% KP6'B9Kwx �:35,')-l %'& 6 ( KwB RhC & 6'68N:C � . O)v3507K )vK �h,JK . l�Km3�{=6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) � ( )9,J6'6S3�B ( ) u � . l�K I4KmI435,'N"G�N�� @ K (9% K�)vKmB9K�)9,'N ( ) ( 3fRSK�� & ){ & B & )>6S35)9) �:R8N:K�� � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( 3�{ (9% KP6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B %'& BHGJI & B9KP073`GJK�N � I4K . KwK�G B8BH) (=( 3 6 � . GJ3�I . & O�3h3`G(9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�073`GJK�NS3�{ O�K . KwB & N � 68,JB96S35)vK �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .�

� ��� ��� #� �� � * �� �#� ��� � � � � � � �1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�� (9% K T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K %'& )>)vKwB9x�K�G & ) & B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:KP, . �:x�KwBH) & N�073`GJK�N�3�{ l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� 7TU% KR & ) �"l-GJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . 3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K �") G',JK ( 3 �FK�, ( )9l %� djk. % �")px �:KwI (9% K>lwN & )9) �"l & N T ,JB � . O0 & l % � . K � ) � . B . � ( K4)9,J6'68N:C-3�{ (9& 6SKp) �h, & B9K�)w� � . � ( � & N"N:CFR8N &�.I@ ��l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G') ( 3 &�. � . B . � ( Kd)9,J6'68N:C=3�{��h,JR � ( )w�� . � ( � & N"N:C � . )v3507Kj=kR8N &�.I@ ? ) (9&!( K���) & C �#"H L B . � ( KMl�3 ./( B935N � � . O�K . KwB & N & �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0 � � ./( KwB & l ( )I � (9% (9% 35)vK �h,JR � ( )-RhC K . O & O � . O � . l & B9Kw{e,'N"N:C )v6SK�l �CB8K�G � ./( KwB & l ( �:3 . )>I � (9% & B . � ( K . ,'0 RSKwB=3�{ (9% K�0 &!(& ( �"07K � I � (9% 35, ( N:35)9)F3�{dO�K . KwB & N�� ( C���3 . K TU% �"),B . � ( K l�3 ./( B935N�l &�. l %'&�. O�K7I % �"l % �h,JR � ( ) � ( � ./( KwB & l ( )I � (9% � & N ( KwB (9% K �:Bd) (9&!( K]o�6S35)9) �:R8N:C>I % �"N:K & N ( KwB � . O=)v3507KU3�{ � ( )�3�I . ) (9&!( Kqp � . & , . � (9& B9Co0 &�.'. KwB�� &�. GP0 &;@ KGJK�l �") �:3 . ) & RS35, ( I %'&!( � . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . ) ( 3Ml & B9B9C 35, (U. K�� (w r4K�l & ,')vK (9% K]B . � ( K l�3 ./( B935N �")-l�3 . ) ( B & � . K�G ( 3 , . � (9& B9C Kwx�35N", ( �:3 . � � ( �") . 3 ( �"0P07K�G � &!( K�N:C lwN:K & B % 3�I

( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( )9,'l % 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�) & ) l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N4l�3 ./( B935N � � 3�I � 3�B �") � ( �"0P07K�G � &!( K�N:C 3�Rhx �:35,') % 3�I ( 3B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( &�. & B9R � ( B & B9C �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . Om0 & l % � . K�=k6'B93�O�B & 0? � . & {�3�BH0 &!( (9%'&!(7& �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O0 & l % � . K � ( )vK�N:{�l�35,'N"G B9K & G &�. G �"0768N:K�07K ./(w L lwN & )9) �"l & N T ,JB � . Oo0 & l % � . K-K��`6'B9K�)9)vK�) (9% K �"GJK & 3�{�N:3`l & N�� ( C3�{ � . G �:x �"G', & NS3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )+RhC l�3 . ) ( B & � . � . O (9% K % K & G ( 3 3�6SKwB &!( Ko3 . 3 . K7) �h, & B9K &!(=&M( �"07K t & �h, &�./( ,'0T ,JB � . O=0 & l % � . K � ) � ./( KwB & l ( �:3 . ) & B9K+) �"0 �"N & BHN:C l�3 . ) ( B & � . K�G �@ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% K+l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . ) &�. G7B9K�G','l ( �:3 . )� . x�35N:x�K�G � . �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O7I %'&!( )vKwK�0 N�� @ K>{ & �:BHN:C K�N:K�07K ./(9& B9C 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) � . x�35N:x�Ko)v3507K 073�B9K =kO5N:3�R & N ?

D`�

Page 38: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

D�? ������� ������� � ��� ��� � ����� � ��� �

B9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 . )d3 .M(9% K (9% K ( B &�. ) � ( �:3 . {e, . l ( �:3 . 3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K �jk. {�3�BH0 & N"N:C�� (9% K ( B &�. ) � ( �:3 .{e, . l ( �:3 . �") & 0 & 6'6 � . OF{�B9350�l�3 . B8O5,JB &!( �:3 . ) ( 3 l�3 . B8O5,JB &!( �:3 . ) t {�3�B (9% �")�0 & 6'6 � . O ( 3 RSK , . � (9& B9C�� � ( 0o,') (B9K�)v6SK�l ( 3�B (9% 3�O�3 .'& N�� ( C & l�B935)9) & N"N56S35)9) �:R8N:K�l�3 . B8O5,JB &!( �:3 . )w��)v3507K (9% � . O � ( �")�lwN:K & B & O�B9K &!( 0 &�. C =k6S35)9) �:R8N:Kg?( B &�. ) � ( �:3 . {e, . l ( �:3 . )PI �"N"NU{ & �"N ( 3 GJ3 TU% K %'& BHGJK�) ( 6'B93�R8N:K�0 �")M6'B9Kwx�K ./( � . O 0o,'N ( �:68N:Kml�3 . B8O5,JB &!( �:3 . ){�B9350 RSK � . Om0 & 6'6SK�G ( 3 (9% K ) & 07K l�3 . B8O5,JB &!( �:3 . I % �"N:KM) ( �"N"N & N"N:3�I � . OmG �CsSKwB9K ./( l�3 ./( B935N � � 3�I�6 &!(9% ) ( 3B9K�l�3 . x�KwB9O�K�� &7. K�l�K�)9) & B9C l�3 . G � ( �:3 . {�3�B &�. C N:3h3�6 � . O 3�BUB9KwK ./( B &�./( l�3 ./( B935N � � 3�I TU% K )v35N", ( �:3 .o( 3 (9% �") 6'B93�R8N:K�0 � &�. G ( 3 &=. ,'0 RSKwB�3�{83 (9% KwB~6'B93�R8N:K�0P) � l &�. RSK4{�35, . G � . r4KwB . ) ( K � .

&�. G �~&�� �:B &�. � � )46'B93h3�{�3�{ (9% K=K�� �") ( K . l�K-3�{ & , . �:x�KwBH) & N �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K ~TU% K �:Bp6'B93h3�{ B9Kwx�35N:x�K�)& B935, . G K�) (9& R8N��") % � . O (9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�)>l &�. l & B9B9C 35, (=(9% KPl�350768N:K ( KP)vK ( 3�{ ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& NT ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K76'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�) � . & 0 &�.'. KwB )9,')9l�Kw6 ( �:R8N:K ( 3 l�3 . l �")vKMGJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 .� MTU% KwC O �:x�K & )vK �h,JK . l�K3�{dB9K�G','l ( �:3 . )-) % 3�I � . O % 3�I �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�)=l &�. �"0768N:K�07K ./(-. 3 .�� ( B �:x � & N l�3 ./( B935N � � 3�I>� (9% KK��`K�lw, ( �:3 . 3�{�3 (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O=0 & l % � . K�) & )u=v)9,JR'B935, ( � . K�)w� ?>l %'&�. O�K�)~3�{SR & ) �")w� &�. G7Kwx�K .M& B9R � ( B & B9C, . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )PI � (9% l�3 . l �")vK>o�6S35N:C . 350 � & N"N:C � RS35, . GJK�GPp-B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(9&!( �:3 . ) 6'B93�x �"GJK�G & ) � . 68, (� r4C GJKwx�K�N:3�6 � . O & {�B & 07KwI43�B @ {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . Of0 & l % � . K GJK�) �:O . KwBH) ( 3 GJK�l�35076S35)vK 6'B93�R8N:K�0P)� ./( 3 )90 & N"N:KwBF)9,JR (9& ) @ ) &�. G (9% K . l�35076S35)vK (9% K & l ( �:3 . )F3�{d0 & l % � . K�)FI % �"l % )v35N:x�K (9% 35)vK7)9,JR (9& ) @ )w� (9% KwCK_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:C O �:x�K & B9K�G','l ( �:3 . {�B9350�lwN & )9) �"l & N T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�) ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�) ~TU% K>l�35) ((9% K �:B>)v35N", ( �:3 . �"076S35)vK�)w� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� �") & )9,JR8) (9&�./( � & N � . l�B9K & )vK � . (9% K � ./( B �"l & l�Cm3�{ (9% K & l ( , & N ( B &�. ) � ( �:3 .{e, . l ( �:3 . ,')vK�G ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( ) �"0768N:K � )vKwK�0 � . Oo6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�) jk.m(9% K 3 (9% KwB=G �:B9K�l ( �:3 . � & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . OM0 & l % � . K l &�. RSKoB9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G & ) & ) (9&!( K � . & l�350768N:K��

x�K�l ( 3�BM)v6 & l�K Kwx�35N:x � . O & lwl�3�BHG � . O ( 3 & )v6SK�l �CB8K�Ga, . � (9& B9C 3�6SKwB &!( 3�B LFN (9% 35,JO %a(9% �")o)v6 & l�K �") � . B . � ( K �G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N ��3 . N:C & B . � ( K . ,'0 RSKwB-3�{ (9% K�)vKPG �"07K . ) �:3 . )FKwx�KwB ) �"0o,'N (9&�. Kw35,')9N:C %'& x�K . 3 .���� KwB93ml�35076S3 �. K ./( ) �TU% ,')w� & lwN & )9) �"l & N T ,JB � . OF0 & l % � . K l &�. ) �"0o,'N &!( K & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . OF0 & l % � . K ( 3 & B9R � ( B & B �"N:C-O�3h3`G6'B9K�l �") �:3 . �!RhCoB9K�G','l � . O (9% Kp6'B93�R8N:K�0<3�{S) �"0o,'N &!( � . O & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O-0 & l % � . K ( 3>l & B9B9C � . O-35, (~& )vKwB �:K�)( 3Pl�350768N:K�� 0 &!( B � � 0o,'N ( �:68N��"l &!( �:3 . )w� &!( ( �"07K�)pK��`6 &�. G � . O (9% K>0 &!( B � � & ) . K�l�K�)9) & B9C LF) & l�3 . )vK �h,JK . l�K���h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O70 & l % � . K�) & B9K T ,JB � . O � K �h, �:x & N:K ./( GJKwx �"l�K�) )LFN (9% 35,JO % �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . OP0 & l % � . K�) & B9K , . �:x�KwBH) & N�RhC � .'% KwB � (9&�. l�K={�B9350 (9% Ko, . �:x�KwBH) & N�� ( CM3�{~lwN & ) �

) �"l & N T ,JB � . Oo0 & l % � . K�)w� (9% KwC & B9K & N")v3 , . �:x�KwBH) & N8{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � . & 073�B9K-G �:B9K�l ( )vK . )vK �T 3(9% K K�� ( K ./(-(9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�) & B9K =k6'B93�O�B & 0P0 & R8N:K�� ? (9% KwC & B9K 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 & R8N:KoI � (9%m(9% KGJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . )o � . 0 &!( B � � {�3�BH0ep+3�{ 3 (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�) E ,JB (9% KwB�� &�. C �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0l &�. RSKpB9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G RhC & , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � . 0 &!( B � � {�3�BH0 ~u ,'l %7&F( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l &�. RSK ) �"0o, �N &!( K�GP3 .M& �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O=0 & l % � . K �TU% �") & B9O5,'07K ./( 0 &;@ K�) �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O=0 & l % � . K�)d, . �:x�KwBH) & N`{�3�B&�. C �h, &�./( ,'02GJKwx �"l�K�)UI % 35)vK & l ( �:3 . )+l &�. RSK l�350768, (9& R8N:C GJK�)9l�B �:RSK�G��JI % �"l % �") ( 3 ) & C�� &�. C B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:K�h, &�./( ,'0�073`GJK�NS3�{�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .�

� ��� ��� #� �� � *�� � � � ����� � �N�\ �*-, &�./( ,'0 l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9& & B9K l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9& I % 35)vK ( B &�. ) � ( �:3 . {e, . l ( �:3 . )ol &�. RSK l�3 ./( � . ,J35,')o�I � (9% l�350768N:K��Pl�3hK_r l �:K ./( )Yp ~TU% KwC7l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G7B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:C .'&!( ,JB & N"N:C ( 3 ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0 � GJ3 (�� R & )vK�G �"0768N:K �

- � =�: MNGBK L 0�GB8;? 46KNWNGB2�05P&? @ <�D�2�<? 46K�GB0�K L;7�G 7�=�:S:�;<? :0�<�L�G6E"7�=�:S? 8;M�K :8;:037>4I7�? GB0�]�� =�:S7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@J<Q460�:Q46@/? K L�WN:46K K G"� :QP;7�GY=54QTU:$: ' MNGB0�:037�? 46K K L + K 4ID�RB: P :@/<�D�? M 7�? GB0�@A �$=�? <>=;@/2 �;<:@�7�G*4BP 8;? 7�4ID�W�? 7/D>4ID�? K L;RBG3GXP�46M�M D�G"' ? 8&4I7�? GB0�@ 7�G*4ID�W�? 7/D>4ID/L2�0�? 7>4ID/L 7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@A�4I7Y7�=�:;<GB@F7*G6EJ7�=�:�MNGBK L 0�GB8;? 46K 7�? 8;:#+ WNGB2�05P GB0 7�=�:&132546037�2�8 �"2 D�? 0�RZ8&46<>=�? 0�:�: ' :<2 7�? 0�R�7�=�:7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0

���S? TU:0�7�=54I7\132546037�2�8 �"2 D�? 0�RC8&46<>=�? 0�:@J4ID�:BA�WN:<Q462�@/:YG6E 7�=�:\D�2�K :@$G6E 8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037QA3M D�GBW546W�? K ? @F7�? <*P :TX? <:@A 7�=�? @J@F7>4I7�:#+8;:037 ? @�@/K ? RB=37�K L�@/? 8;M�K ? @F7�? <B]��S2546037�2�8 �"2 D�? 0�RY8&46<>=�? 0�:@�4ID�: �"2 D�? 0�R + :Q132�? TB46K :037 ? 0C7�=�:J@�468;:J@/:0�@/:J7�=54I7 7/D>4BP ? 7�? GB0546K �"2 D�? 0�R8&46<>=�? 0�:@��$? 7�=�46<<:@/@Y7�G�4�@/GB2 D�<:;G6E D>4605P GB8 W�? 7�@ 4ID�:��"2 D�? 0�R + :Q132�? TB46K :037-(Y4&7/D>4BP ? 7�? GB0546K��"2 D�? 0�R�8&46<>=�? 0�:C<Q460�P :@/<�D�? WN:7�=�: M D�GBW546W�? K ? 7�LZP ? @F7/D�? W�2 7�? GB0ZG6E 7�=�:? D\GB2 7�M�2 7�@��$? 7�=�4ID�W�? 7/D>4ID�? K L�RBG3GXP�46<<2 D>46<�L3]

Page 39: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� ����� � ��� � ��� ����� � �� � �� ��� � ��� ��� � ������� � � � � ��� ��� D�D

07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) ~TU% KwC & B9K & N")v3 & 0 & )9) �:x�K�N:C76 & B & N"N:K�N8073`GJK�N �`l�350 R � . � . O (9% KF6 & B & N"N:K�N��")90 3�{ & N & B9O�K . ,'0 RSKwB3�{~6'B93`l�K�)9)v3�BH)UI � (9% = �h, &�./( ,'026 & B & N"N:K�N��")90 � ?70 &;@ � . O (9% K�0 & R8N:K ( 3 l & B9B9C 35, ( l�KwB (9& � . 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )+x�KwB9CK_r l �:K ./( N:C TU% K & RS3�x�KUN��") ( K�� %'& ,') ( ) (9% K ) ( B9K . O (9% ) 3�{ (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0sl�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!( 3 . 073`GJK�N TU% Kp) & 07K �")9)9,JK

(9%'&!( � . � ( � & N"N:C & 6'6SK & B9K�G ( 3 68N & O5,JK �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�) � GJK ( KwBH0 � . � . O I % K (9% KwB & )v6SK�l �CB8K�G( B &�. ) � ( �:3 . {e, . l ( �:3 .& l ( , & N"N:C � . G','l�K�) & , . � (9& B9C Kwx�35N", ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 & ) & I % 35N:K � �") & N")v3 &6'B93�R8N:K�0 {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0�l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9&` � . {�3�B ( , .'&!( K�N:C��+I % �"N:Kmr4KwB . ) ( K � .&�. G �~&�� �:B &�. �FO & x�K &�.& rMBH0 &!( �:x�K &�. )vI4KwB ( 3 (9% K 6'B93�R8N:K�0 {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . Om0 & l % � . K�)w� (9% K l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G � . O &�. )vI4KwBH)o{�3�B�h, &�./( ,'0 l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9& %'& x�K (9% ,') { & B RSKwK . 0735) ( N:C . KwO &!( �:x�K E 3�BoK�� & 0768N:K�� � . 3 . K G �"07K . ) �:3 . �. 3 % 35073�O�K . Kw35,')Ko %'& x � . O (9% K ) & 07K ( B &�. ) � ( �:3 . {e, . l ( �:3 .f&!( K & l % l�K�N"N<p>N�� . K & B l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9& l &�.K�� �") (w Fj { (9% K % 35073�O�K . K � ( C l�3 . G � ( �:3 . ) & B9KoI4K &;@ K . K�G�� . 3 ./( B �:x � & N��h, &�./( ,'0 l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9& RSK�l�3507K6S35)9) �:R8N:K��hR8, ( (9% K �")9)9,JK�) � . x�35N:x�K�G � . 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O (9% K�0 & B9K . 3 ( (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N"N:C I4K�N"N � , . GJKwBH) ( 3h3`G } KwB %'& 68)-073�B9K )vKwB �:35,')9N:C�� (9% KwB9K & B9K . 3 ( C�K (=&�. C � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O O dgHYd {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0�l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9&`

TU% KwB9K K�� �") ( )vKwx�KwB & NUl�35076SK�N"N�� . O &�. G � .'. 3�x &!( �:x�K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) {�3�B73 (9% KwBPO�K . KwB & N � 68,JB96S35)vK 073`GJK�N")w�~R8, (�h, &�./( ,'0�l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9&m%'& x�K GJ3 . K . 3 (9% � . O ( 3mG �") ( � . O5, �") % (9% K�0P)vK�N:x�K�) � . (9% �")-I & C 1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C��0 & )9) �:x�K�N:C=6 & B & N"N:K�Nh073`GJK�N") K . v3�Col�KwB (9& � . & GJx &�./(9& O�K�)�3�x�KwB~)vK �h,JK ./( � & Nh3 . K�) t 0 & )9) �:x�K�N:C=6 & B & N"N:K�N �h, &�./( ,'0073`GJK�N")+K . v3�C (9% 35)vK & GJx &�./(9& O�K�)=3�x�KwB (9% K �:B-)vK �h,JK ./( � & N &�.'& N:3�O5,JK�)w��R8, (+(9% KwC %'& x�K7C�K (-( 3 GJK�073 . ) ( B &!( K(9%'&!( (9% KwC 6S35)9)vK�)9) & GJx &�./(9& O�K�)m, . ��h,JK ( 3 (9% K l�350 R � .'&!( �:3 . 3�{ = �h, &�./( ,'0? I � (9% =k6 & B & N"N:K�N ? u � . l�K�h, &�./( ,'0 l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!(9& %'& x�K GJK�073 . ) ( B &!( K�G . K � (9% KwB I �"GJK & 6'68N��"l & R �"N�� ( C . 3�BoK�)v6SK�l � & N"N:C 68N:K & ) &�./((9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N 6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)w�`I4K ( ,JB . 35,JB &!(v( K ./( �:3 . � . ) ( K & G ( 3 & 073`GJK�NSI % �"l % %'& )U) % 3�I . RS3 (9%�

� ��� ��� � ����� ������#� �� � *�� ��� �� ���)�TU% K7R & ) �"l �"GJK & 3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( {�3�BH0 & N��")90 �") (9%'&!( I4KPB9KwO & BHG & , . � (9& B9Cm3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . I % �"l % 3 . N:CoeG �:B9K�l ( N:C p & sSK�l ( ) � �h,JR � ( ) & ) & ka9RE H (9%'&!(7(9&;@ K�) � � . 68, ( ) ( 3 � 35, ( 68, ( ) fTU% K f S<X'HYd � .f(9% �") 073`GJK�NB9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(+(9% K>x & N",JK�)U3�{ �h,JR � ( ) RSK ( I4KwK .m(9% K & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . 3�{ ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) (9%'&!( G �:B9K�l ( N:C 3�6SKwB &!( K 3 .(9% K�0 &�. G & B9K & N"N:3�I4K�G ( 3 {�B9KwK�N:C l�B935)9) ~TU% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) & B9K+O �:x�K .M&=( 3 (9& N�N�� . K & B�3�BHGJKwB t/(9% KU35, ( 68, (3�{ & O &!( Ko0 & C 3 . N:C RSK=l�3 .'. K�l ( K�G ( 3 (9% K � . 68, ( 3�{ & O &!( K I % �"l % {�35N"N:3�I+) � ( � . (9%'&!( 3�BHGJKwB E ,JB (9% KwB��8K & l % I �:B9K>0o,') ( l�3 .'. K�l ( K�� & l ( N:C 3 . K 35, ( 68, (+&�. G K�� & l ( N:C 3 . K � . 68, ( o � . lwN",'G � . O & )e=k35, (��

68, ( )'? (9% K � . 68, ( ) ( 3 (9% K>3�x�KwB & N"N�l �:BHlw, � ( � &�. G x �"l�K � x�KwBH) & p � K � (9% KwBF0 & C (9% KwB9K>RSK &�. C � . 68, ( 3�B+35, ( 68, (. 3 ( l�3 .'. K�l ( K�G ( 3 & I �:B9K MTU% K�)vKMN &!(v( KwB ( I43 l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( ) & B9K . K�l�K�)9) & B9C ( 3mK . )9,JB9K (9%'&!(>(9% K & l ( �:3 . 3�{(9% K-l �:BHlw, � ( �")d, . � (9& B9C �T 3 G',J68N��"l &!( K & �h,JR � ( o�RhCM)v68N�� (v( � . O & I �:B9K ( 3 0o,'N ( �:68N:K � . 68, ( )Yp 3�B GJK�) ( B93�C � ( o�RhC{ & �"N�� . O ( 3 l�3 .'. K�l ( � (~( 3 &�. � . 68, ( p�I435,'N"GPRSK & 0 & 6'6 � . O=RSK ( I4KwK . x�K�l ( 3�B )v6 & l�K�)43�{ G �CsSKwB9K ./( G �"07K . ) �:3 . �I % �"l % 9 NPXYSUL;XYS'l &�.'. 3 ( RSK , . � (9& B9C �~x�K . �:{ & GJK�) ( BH,'l ( �:3 .7&�. G & G',J68N��"l &!( �:3 . & B9KUl & B9B �:K�G 35, ( ) �"0o,'N (9&�. K �35,')9N:C�� � ( �")dK & )vC ( 37)vKwK (9%'&!(p(9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G RhC (9% K�)vK & l ( �:3 . ) �") . 3 ( , . � (9& B9C�� & ) � (4%'& ). K � (9% KwB & B �:O %/(+&�. G . 3�B & N:Kw{ ( � . x�KwBH)vK # KoI �"N"N�l�3 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K�)vKol�3 . ) ( B & � ./( ) & O & � . N &!( KwB�� � . G �")9lw,')9) � . Ol�3 .'. K�l ( �:3 . ) ( 3MB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K=l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . &�. G �")9)9,JK�) � . �h, &�./( ,'0�6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O7N &�. O5, & O�K>GJK�) �:O .� TU% K7{�3�BH0 & N�)vK�0 &�./( �"lw)>3�{ &�.a& l�C`lwN��"l7l �:BHlw, � (=& B9KM) ( B & �:O %/( {�3�B9I & BHG 7j { (9% K7O &!( K�) 3�{ (9% KMl �:BHlw, � ( �"0 �

68N:K�07K ./( (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )(� � � � ) � ( ( ( � � ( 3 (9% K �h,JR � ( )M)v6SK�l �CB8K�G & ) (9% K �:B � . 68, ( ) o�K�� ( K . GJK�G ( 3( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )p3 . (9% K>{e,'N"N ?�� � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N�)v6 & l�K � . (9% K>,')9, & NSI & C pH� &�. G���! � � ) � ( ( ( � � � & B9K (9% K>6SKwB �0o, (9&!( �:3 . 0 &!( B �"l�K�) �UI % �"l % l & B9B9C (9% K & 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( K �h,JR � ( ) ( 3 K & l % O &!( K�� (9% K . (9% KF3�x�KwB & N"N & l ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K

� .�0 460 46<�7�2546KJ? 8;M�K :8;:037>4I7�? GB0�A 7�=�:�� ' <GB2�K P M�=3L @/? <Q46K K L ? 037�:�D�<>=5460�RB:�132�W�? 7�@A�G6D;<GB2�K P ? 8;M�K :8;:037 7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@7�G�@ �J46M 7�=�:? DYTB46K 2�:@A�G6D 7�=�:�� ' <GB2�K P 46<�7 P ? D�:<�7�K L�GB0 7�=�:�46M�M D�GBM D�? 4I7�:�132�W�? 7�@ )�? 0 M�K 46<:B] * �\K K 7�= D�::*MNGB@/@/? W�? K ? 7�? :@*=54QTU::Q132�? TB46K :037$8&4I7/D�? '&EHG6D�8;@

Page 40: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

D�Q ������� ������� � ��� ��� � ����� � ��� �

l �:BHlw, � ( �") (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .� � � � � � � � � � � � ( ( ( � ) � � � � ��! � o QJ ? p

143 . x�KwBH)vK�N:C�� 073�B9KMl�350768N��"l &!( K�G , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )>l &�. RSKPl & B9B �:K�G 35, ( RhC { & l ( 3�B � . O (9% K�0 � ./( 3) �"0768N:KwBp3 . K�) I % �"l % RSK�l�3507K (9% K>O &!( K�)+3�{ (9% K l �:BHlw, � (w *-, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( ) & B9K & N")v37l�350P073 . N:C )v6SK�l �CB8K�G � . G � & O�B & 0P0 &!( �"lF{�3�BH0 &!(w dTU% K-{�35N"N:3�I � . O G � & O�B & 0

�")pB9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(9&!( �:x�K 3�{ (9% K . 3 (9&!( �:3 . I4K>I �"N"NS,')vK={�3�B+l �:BHlw, � ( G � & O�B & 0P)mD

��

� � � � ��� � � ��� � �

o QJ D p@ 3�B � � 3 ./(9& N N�� . K�)4B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( �h,JR � ( )w� ( 37I % �"l % O &!( K�)]o�RS3��`K�)Yp &�. G 6SKwBH0o, (9&!( �:3 . ) o�B9K & B9B &�. O�K�07K ./( )U3�{ (9% KN�� . K�)Yp & B9K & 6'68N��:K�G t � . 68, ( )pK ./( KwB &!(+(9% K N:Kw{ (U&�. G 35, ( 68, ( )UN:K & x�K &!(+(9% K>B �:O %/(w d@ KwB9K�� (9% K B8BH) ( ( I43MO &!( K�)& B9KMl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T O &!( K�)w� &�. G (9% K!B .'& N�O &!( K �") & @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 .� MTU% K7l �:BHlwN:K�) � . ) �"GJK (9% K ( I43l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T O &!( K�) � . G �"l &!( K (9% K �h,JR � ( ( 3PI % �"l % (9% K B93 (9&!( �:3 . �") & 6'68N��:K�G`o (9% K �h,JR � ( I � (9% . 3Ml �:BHlwN:K3�x�KwB � ( � . ) �"GJK (9% K=O &!( K �") (9% K>l�3 ./( B935N��h,JR � ( p

� ��� ��� � ��� �� ���)� ���� �� �#� ��� � � � � � � � � �\*)���)� �# K I �"N"N ,')vK (9% K l �:BHlw, � ( 073`GJK�N & )F35,JBF6'B9Kw{�KwB9B9K�G (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�073`GJK�N�3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� +#% �"N:K(9% K & GJx &�./(9& O�K�) (9% �") 073`GJK�Nd3�x�KwB (9% K l�K�N"N",'N & B & , ( 350 &!( 3 . 073`GJK�N & B9K lwN:K & B�� (9% K GJK�l �") �:3 . ( 3 l�3 . ) �"GJKwB�h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( ) � . ) ( K & G 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�) B9K �h, �:B9K�) )v3507K 9,') ( �CB�l &!( �:3 .� TU% K 6'B � . l �:6 & NS3�R�vK�l ( �:3 . ( 3 )9,'l % & GJK�l �") �:3 . �") (9%'&!( l �:BHlw, � ( ) & B9K � .'% KwB9K ./( N:C & d_ETX 9;Sik;G E � : S<V6H-073`GJK�N �

� . I % �"l % (9% K>)vK �h,JK . l�K>3�{ & l ( �:3 . ) ( 3PRSK>l & B9B �:K�G 35, ( 3 . & O �:x�K . � . 68, ( GJ3hK�) . 3 ( GJKw6SK . G 3 . (9% K � . 68, (w L T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K���3 . (9% K 3 (9% KwB %'&�. G���l &�. (9&;@ K & l ( �:3 . ) l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N"N:C���R & )vK�Gf3 .f(9% K � . 68, ( 3�B 3 .� ./( KwBH07K�G � &!( K>x & N",JK�)Ul�350768, ( K�GmG',JB � . O (9% Kol�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� pTU% �") & N"N:3�I+) (9% K T ,JB � . OP0 & l % � . K ( 3 %'&�. G'N:K� . 68, ( )43�{�G �CsSKwB9K ./( ) � � K�)w� &�. G ( 3Ml & B9B9C 35, (+. 3 ./( B �:x � & NSl�3 ./( B935N � � 3�I TU% K B9Kw68N:C ( 3 (9% �")o3�R�vK�l ( �:3 . (9&;@ K�) ( I43 {�3�BH0P) fE �:BH) ( � �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( ) & B9K N:K�)9)o6S3�I4KwB9{e,'N (9%'&�.

�h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�)P3 . N:C � . (9% K ) & 07KmI4K &;@ )vK . )vK (9%'&!( lwN & )9) �"l & N+l �:BHlw, � ( ) & B9K N:K�)9)76S3�I4KwB9{e,'N(9%'&�. lwN & )9) �"l & N T ,JB � . Om0 & l % � . K�) 1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�� �:{pI4K & N"N:3�I { & 0 �"N��:K�)=3�{+l �:BHlw, � ( )>{�3�B 6'B93�R8N:K�0P)w� I4K l &�.) �"0o,'N &!( K &�. C T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�� RhC & { & 0 �"N:C 3�{pl �:BHlw, � ( ) � o/� ��� pH��I % KwB9K � �") (9% KP) � � K73�{ � . 68, ( ) ( 3RSKol�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G�� &�. G � �") (9% K ( �"07K � RS35, . G 3 .m(9% Kol�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K T ,JB � . OM0 & l % � . K +TU% ,')w�8{�3�B &�. Cl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .7& l ( , & N"N:Col & B9B �:K�Go35, ( RhC &=T ,JB � . OF0 & l % � . K ( 3=6'B93`G','l�K &�.7&�. )vI4KwB�{�B9350 )v3507K � . 68, ( � (9% KwB9KK�� �") ( ) & l �:BHlw, � ( I % �"l % l�350768, ( K�) (9% K ) & 07K &�. )vI4KwBU{�B9350 (9% K ) & 07K � . 68, (w L ) �"0 �"N & BSB9K�)9,'N ( % 35N"G')�{�3�B��h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�) &�. G �h, &�./( ,'0 & l�C`lwN��"l~l �:BHlw, � ( ) t� d& 3 %'& )�) % 3�I .

(9%'&!(�(9% �")�) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . l &�. RSK l & B9B �:K�Go35, ( I � (9% 3 . N:C>6S35N:C . 350 � & Nh)9N:3�I+GJ3�I . {�3�B &�. C {e, . l ( �:3 . l�350768, (9& R8N:K� . 6S35N:C . 350 � & N ( �"07K 3 . & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K L . C 6'B93�R8N:K�0 o�K_r l �:K ./( N:C p l�350768, (9& R8N:K 3 .�&�h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . OM0 & l % � . K �")!o�K_r l �:K ./( N:C p+l�350768, (9& R8N:KoRhC & l�C`lwN��"l �h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( ) -TU% ,')w� & N (9% 35,JO %

Page 41: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� ����� � ��� � ��� ����� � �� � �� ��� � ��� ��� � ������� � � � � ��� ��� D�V

(9% KwB9K �") . 3 � . G �:x �"G', & N =v, . �:x�KwBH) & N��h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( � ? . 37N:35)9) � . � ./( B � . ) �"lUl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�6S3�I4KwBpB9K�)9,'N ( ){�B9350�GJB93�6'6 � . OoR & l @ ( 3Ml �:BHlw, � ( )

TU% K=)vK�l�3 . G B9Kw68N:C �")46SKwB %'& 68)p073�B9K �"076S3�B (9&�./( �`O �:x�K . (9% K-6'B9K�)vK ./( ) (9&!( K=3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� *-, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( ) & B9K lw,JB9B9K ./( N:C {�K & ) �:R8N:K ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( �JI % KwB9K & ) �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O70 & l % � . K�) & B9K . 3 (w W { (9% K-073`GJK�N")4G �")9lw,')9)vK�G � .M(9% K-6'B9Kwx �:35,')dl %'& 6 ( KwB��J3 . N:C �h, &�./( ,'0 GJ3 ( )w�`Kwx�K . � . 6'B � . l �:68N:K�� & B9K=l & 6 & R8N:K3�{ & l ( , & N"N:C �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . Om0 & l % � . K mTU% K % ,JBHG'N:K�)w� (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N &�. G 6'B & l ( �"l & N � ( 3�"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O70 & l % � . K�) � . (9% K �:B {e,'N"N�O�K . KwB & N�� ( C�� & B9K & N"0735) ( , . �"0 & O � .'& R8N:K

TU% K �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K7073`GJK�N�B9K �h, �:B9K�) (9%'&!(=(9% K!B . � ( K � ) (9&!( KMl�3 ./( B935N~0o,') (=. 3 ( 3 . N:C l�3 .��(9& � . )v3507K �h, &�./( ,'0�) (9&!( K>R8, ( � . { & l ( \�H & {e,'N"N:C �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0 dTU% K = % K & G ? � . & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O0 & l % � . K>0o,') ( RSK & R8N:K8o�RhC RSK � . O � . & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{�G �") ( � . l ( ) (9&!( K�)Yp ( 3 & l ( 3 . )v6 &!( � & N"N:CM)vKw6 & B &!( K�G�h,JR � ( ) ) �"0o,'N (9&�. Kw35,')9N:C�� &�. G ( 3 l & B9B9C 35, ( G �CsSKwB9K ./(5@ � . G')>3�{ � ./( KwB & l ( �:3 . ) I � (9% (9% K�0 W-.a(9% K 3 (9% KwB%'&�. G�� (9% K=B9K & N�� ( CM3�{ 6'B9K�)vK ./( ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C �") (9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P) B9K �h, �:B9K-0 & l�B935)9l�3�6 �"l>lwN & )9) �"l & NSl�3 .��( B935N�)vC`) ( K�0P)mD=N & B9O�KP0 & O . K ( �"l]B8K�N"G')w�S6'B9K�l �") �:3 . N & )vKwBH)w��3�6 ( �"l & N�RSK & 0P)v68N�� (v( KwBH)w� &�. G (9% KPN�� @ K 14B9K &!( � . O�h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P)Fl & 6 & R8N:K 3�{~l�3 ./( B935N"N�� . OP3 (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'02)vC`) ( K�0P) � . (9% K l�350768N��"l &!( K�GmI & C`)FB9K �h, �:B9K�GRhC (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . Oo0 & l % � . K=073`GJK�N �") & O�3 & N (9%'&!( I �"N"N'B9K�0 & � . 35, ( 3�{�B9K & l % {�3�B �h, � ( K=)v3507K ( �"07K

TU% K R & G . KwI+) {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�)w� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� �") . 3 ( )9,'l % R & G . KwI+) {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� �TU% Kp{�K &!( ,JB9K�)�3�{��h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O-0 & l % � . K�)�I % �"l % 0 &;@ K (9% K�0�)v3>G �Cr lw,'N (�( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(& B9K . 3 (p& l ( , & N"N:C . K�l�K�)9) & B9CP{�3�B40735) ( �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) �TU% K+0 & � . �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)~3�{ � ./( KwB9K�) (& B9K & N"0735) (=& N"N�) ( B & �:O %/(�� N�� . K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)mD (9% KwC ,')vK o �"0768N��"l � ( N:C ppG &!(9& 6 & B & N"N:K�N��")90 �8R8, (-. 3 ( � . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 .6 & B & N"N:K�N��")90 dj ( �") . 3 (F. K�l�K�)9) & B9C {�3�B & �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwB ( 3MRSK & R8N:K ( 3 0 &;@ K l�3 ./( B935N � � 3�I GJK�l �") �:3 . )� . 3�BHGJKwB ( 3Ml & B9B9C 35, ( � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . OPl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) 3 . � (w

LFN (9% 35,JO % (9% KwB9K %'& x�KmRSKwK . & {�KwI & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)76'B93�6S35)vK�G I % �"l % B9K�N:C ,J6S3 . )9,'l % ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�)w� � � � .O�K . KwB & N (9% KwC & B9K . K � (9% KwB . K�l�K�)9) & B9C . 3�B={e,'N"N:C � ./( , � ( �:x�K >jk. )v3507K7B9K�)v6SK�l ( )w� l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )=,') � . O )9,'l %073`GJK�N") & B9K . 3 ( K ./( �:B9K�N:CMI4K�N"N � GJK_B . K�G.D�6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�� (9% K �h,JK�) ( �:3 . 3�{ I % K . & l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . (9%'&!( � . x�35N:x�K�))9,'l % & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ % K & G ) (9&!( K�)w��)v3507Ko3�{~I % �"l % 0 & CmRSKuB .'& N I % �"N:K>3 (9% KwBH) & B9K . 3 ( ��l &�. RSKo) & �"G( 3 %'& x�K�=kK . GJK�G ? �") & x�KwB9C (9% 3�B . C 3 . K j ( �") & N")v3 O�K . KwB & N"N:C K & ) �:KwB ( 3aB9K & )v3 . {�3�BH0 & N"N:C & RS35, (M(9% KB . � ( K � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N�, . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � . G','l�K�G RhC & �h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � (p(9%'&�. � ( �") ( 3MB9K & )v3 . & RS35, ((9% K � . B . � ( K � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N � . G','l�K�G RhC & �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O70 & l % � . K

E B9350 (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � GJK�) �:O . 6S3 � ./( 3�{Sx �:KwI>� � ( �")~G �Cr lw,'N (�( 3o0 &;@ KFK_sSK�l ( �:x�K-,')vKU3�{ (9% KFGJ3h3�BH)~3�6SK . K�GRhC & N"N:3�I � . Oml�3 ./( B935N � 3�I R & )vK�G 3 .a(9% KMx & N",JK�)>3�{ �h,JR � ( ) � . )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . ) LF) & O�K . KwB & Nd6'B � . l �:68N:K��)v3507K-GJKwO�B9KwKF3�{�) �"0 �"N & B � ( CoRSK ( I4KwK . (9% K & l ( �:3 . )43�{�G �CsSKwB9K ./( 6 & B ( )d3�{ (9% KF)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{�) (9&!( K�)p3�{ (9% KB . � ( K l�3 ./( B935N �") . K�l�K�)9) & B9C � . 3�BHGJKwB+{�3�B (9% K�0 ( 3 � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K � . ,')vKw{e,'N I & C`) +# � (9% 35, (+(9% �") � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K��(9% K �h, &�./( ,'0�l & )vKMGJKwx�35N:x�K�) ( 3 (9% KPlwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C � �"0768N:K�07K ./(9& R8N:K>6'B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"l=3 . K TU% ,')w��I4KP) %'& N"N ,')vK& l�C`lwN��"l �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( ) & )435,JB 073`GJK�N83�{ O�K . KwB & N � 68,JB96S35)vK �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . D (9% KwC %'& x�K & N"0735) (& N"NS3�{ (9% K=O�3h3`G {�K &!( ,JB9K�) 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O 0 & l % � . K�)w�'R8, ( & N"0735) (+. 3 . K=3�{ (9% K>6S3h3�B 3 . K�)

���YGB05P�46<@�4605P . 4I7/D�GB2�@AUEHG6D : '�468;M�K :BAU=54QTU:JRB? TU:0&460&46K RBG6D�? 7�=�8+EHG6D�7�=�:$132546037�2�8 :Q132�? TB46K :037�G6E"4 W�? +�P ? D�:<�7�? GB0546K�O50�? 7�:#+@F7>4I7�:�462 7�GB8&4I7�GB0Z7�=54I7Y46K K G"�$@Y? 7S7�G;D�:<GBRB0�? :C7�=�: K 460�RB2546RB:� &��%& W3LZM�K 46<? 0�R�? 7�@S7>46MN:*=�:Q4BP�? 0 4;@/2�MN:�D�MNGB@/? 7�? GB0 G6E�@F7>4I7�:@4I7CP ? �V:�D�:037 M�K 46<:@C46K GB0�RZ7�=�:�? 0�M�2 7Q] . =�:0 D�:@F7/D�? <�7�:QP 7�GZGB0�:#+ �J4L 8;G67�? GB0�� �$=�? <>=�M D�:<K 25P :@Y7�=�:�MNGB@/@/? W�? K ? 7�L�G6E$@/M54I7�? 46K@/:M54ID>4I7�? GB0 G6E 7�=�: M�? :<:@ G6E�4;@/2�MN:�D�MNGB@/? 7�? GB0��>A�132546037�2�8 O50�? 7�:#+ @F7>4I7�:*462 7�GB8&4I7>4&4ID�:*M D�GITB46W�K L��#� ��#%$$7�=5460Z7�=�:? DS<K 46@/@/? <Q46K<GB2�037�:�D�M54ID/7�@] � =�:�D�:�EHG6D�:BA ? 0 7�=�? @Y<Q46@/:BA 46K K G"�$? 0�R 4Z132546037�2�8 D>4I7�=�:�DY7�=5460�4�<K 46@/@/? <Q46K <GB037/D�GBK�@FL @F7�:8 P G3:@ ? 0�<�D�:Q46@/:�7�=�:MNG"� :�D\G6E 7�=�: 8;GXP :K[]

Page 42: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

D�� ������� ������� � ��� ��� � ����� � ��� �

�]��� (*)! ,+-".)0/ 1�2-/430)5"6 �0$ ��$ " � ����� 2����

� ������� � ) )��V� ' �> � � ��� � �)������� �� � ��� ���

# K . 3�I ( ,JB . 35,JB &!(v( K ./( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K 0 &!(v( KwBP3�{-GJK ( KwBH0 � . � . OmI % �"l % , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )7l &�. RSKl�350768, ( K�G RhC & l�C`lwN��"l �h, &�./( ,'0sl �:BHlw, � ( ) I � (9% O �:x�K . 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K~3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) # KU)vKwK @ �h, &�./( ,'0 &�.'& N:3�O5,JK�)( 3 (9% K=B9K�)9,'N (4(9%'&!(+&�. C r43h35N:K &�. {e, . l ( �:3 . l &�. RSK=l�350768, ( K�G RhC & l �:BHlw, � ( l�35076S35)vK�G K ./( �:B9K�N:CP3�{ � L � �O &!( K�)w�-3�B (9%'&!( L � � &�. G W q�O &!( K�) ( 3�O�K (9% KwBm)9, r l�K ( 3 l�350768, ( K &�. C 073 . 3 ( 3 . K {e, . l ( �:3 .� �m3�B9K6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C���O �:x�K . )v3507K B . � ( K�N:C � O�K . KwB & R8N:Kd)vK ( 3�{'O &!( K�)��d�!I %'&!( o�6S35)9) �:R8N:C p�N & B9O�KwB�lwN & )9)�3�{ ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )� l &�. RSK �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�G RhC )v3507K l �:BHlw, � ( I � (9% O &!( K�)FGJB & I . {�B9350�� ;L �h, �"l @ l�35, ./( � . O & B9O5,'07K ./( ) % 3�I+) (9%'&!( � ( �") �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K~{�3�B &�. C]B . � ( K�N:C � O�K . KwB & R8N:K�� ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(

Kwx�KwB9C K�N:K�07K ./( 3�{ ��� K�� & l ( N:C pu ,'l % & �fl &�. O �:x�K-B �")vK ( 373 . N:C & l�35, ./(9& R8N:C � . B . � ( K . ,'0 RSKwBp3�{ G �") ( � . l (l �:BHlw, � ( ) FW-.m(9% K 3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� (9% Ko)vK ( 3�{d, . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )w�8Kwx�K . 3 . & � � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N l�350768N:K��x�K�l ( 3�B-)v6 & l�K�� %'& )U, . l�35, ./(9& R8N:K>l & BHG � .'& N�� ( C j ( S d>6S35)9) �:R8N:K�� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( Kwx�KwB9CaK�N:K�07K ./( 3�{ ��� ( 3 & B9R � ( B & B �"N:C O�3h3`G & lwlw,JB & l�CaI � (9%

l�KwB (9& � . x�KwB9C ) �"0768N:K O &!( KM)vK ( )�� TU%'&!( )9,'l % & 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( �:3 . )-)9, r l�K {�35N"N:3�I+)-RSK�l & ,')vK ��� %'& )!M8HmETXYSUJEQL�NIL;:iL'kRSUJ�9;:d) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K aTU%'&!( �")w��O �:x�K . & B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:K M8HmETXYSUJ 3 . ����o & I & Cf3�{ & )9) �:O . � . O ( 3 &�. C ( I43( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) &7. 3 .�� . KwO &!( �:x�K=B9K & N =vG �") (9&�. l�Kg? RSK ( I4KwK . (9% K�0epH� (9% K & l ( �:3 . ) 3�{�O�B935,J6 0o,'N ( �:68N��"l &!( �:3 .oel�35076S35) � . O ( I43 ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )Yp &�. GaO�B935,J6 � . x�KwBH)vKho (9&;@ � . O (9% K � . x�KwBH)vK 3�{ &m( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . p & B9Kl�3 ./( � . ,J35,') I � (9% B9K�)v6SK�l ( ( 3 (9%'&!( 07K ( B �"l oeGJ3 . 3 ( 0 & 6 ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) I % �"l % & B9KalwN:35)vK ( 3�O�K (9% KwB( 3 ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) I % �"l %& B9K { & B & 6 & B ( p # K l &�. )v6SK�l �:{�C (9% K I43�BH) (�� l & )vKaKwB9B93�B I � (9% I % �"l % 3 . K( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( K�) &�. 3 (9% KwB & ) & 07K ( B �"l � 3 . ��� t I4K l &�. (9% K . RSK l�3 . B�GJK ./(F(9%'&!(-& )-N:3 . O& ) (9% K � . G �:x �"G', & NhKwB9B93�Bp3�{ & )vK �h,JK . l�K-3�{ ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) �")dRS35, . GJK�G ( �:O %/( N:CPK . 35,JO % � (9% KFKwB9B93�Bp3�{ (9% K3�x�KwB & N"N ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . (9% KwC �"0768N:K�07K ./( I �"N"N & N")v3FRSK4RS35, . GJK�G & )�lwN:35)vK�N:C & ) I4KpB9K �h, �:B9K TU% ,')w� (9% K4KwB9B93�B� . (9% K>) (9&!( K=3�{ (9% K=)vC`) ( K�0 & { ( KwB & 6'68N:C � . O (9% K=3�x�KwB & N"N ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l &�. & N")v3 RSK-RS35, . GJK�G & ) lwN:35)vK�N:C& ) . K�l�K�)9) & B9C���I % �"l % K_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:C RS35, . G') (9% K GJKwO�B9KwK ( 3 I % �"l % (9% KM6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . 3�{ & l ( , & N35, ( 68, ( )Ul &�. G �CsSKwB {�B9350 (9% K>G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . 3�{ 35, ( 68, ( ) B9K�)9,'N ( � . O {�B9350 (9% KK=vl�3�B9B9K�l ( ? ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .�

� ������� �� � � � ��� ���� #� �� � *� ��

� �:x�K . (9% �")4R'B93 & GJKwBpGJK_B . � ( �:3 . 3�{�I %'&!( � ( 07K &�. )p{�3�B & O &!( K>)vK ( � ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(4& lwN & )9)43�{ ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 & �( �:3 . )w� � (p( ,JB . )d35, (p(9%'&!(p(9% KwB9KFK�� �") ( � I % �"l % )9, r l�K ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( 9;V ^ ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � . ��� 4u ,'l % �& B9K l & N"N:K�G O V S<bRH_X�dm9;: � & x �"G �FK�, ( )9l % {�35, . G & ) � . O5N:K (9% B9KwK � �h,JR � ( O &!( K I % �"l % �`RhC � ( )vK�N:{ � �") , . �:x�KwBH) & N143 . ) �"GJKwB/�a� (9% K . KwO &!( �:3 . O &!( K �� 3 ( K (9%'&!(U(9% �") O &!( KoN:K & x�K�) (9% K>x�K�l ( 3�B

�! ? �#"\# �! ? �%" o QJ Q p-��S? TU:0�7 � G 7 +�P ? 8;:0�@/? GB0546KN7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@ � 4605P �CA�GB0�:YRBG3GXPZ8;:�7/D�? <SD�:RU4ID>P @$7�=�:8 46@$8&4I7/D�? <:@\4605P�K :�7�@� ��� ! � � � 8&4 '�� � � ' � � ��' � � ����(�� !����7�� $

.�: <GB2�K PZ46K @/G;:Q132546K K L � :K K�K :�7� ��� ! � � ���

��� '! �"� & � � ' � � ��' ��� !G6D$2�@/:Y4C8;:�7/D�? <S8;G6D�: @/MN:<? O5<Q46K K L�7>46? K G6D�:QP�7�G*7�=�: 8&460�? EHGBK P�@F7/D�2�<�7�2 D�:SG6E �$#�] .�0Z4603L&:TU:037QA37�=�:@/:Y8;:�7/D�? <@J4ID�:Y:Q132�? TB46K :037? 0�7�=54I7J7�=�:�L�? 05P 2�<:S7�=�: @�468;: 7�GBMNGBK GBR6L�GB0��$#

Page 43: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � �� ��� ��� � ������� � � � ��� � � � � � ��� � ��� � D5n

, . l %'&�. O�K�G � # KPl &�. (9% ,')FB9KwO & BHG � & ) & X LREQ9RETSUL;V & RS35, (F(9% K & � �")-GJK_B . K�GmRhC �� ) �#"S# �� ) �%"H 7u � . l�K� ) " � ��B93 (9&!( K�) � ( ) � . 68, ( RhC &�.f&�. O5N:K 3�{/� B & G � &�. ) # K l &�. & N")v3 l�3 . ) �"GJKwB B93 (9&!( �:3 . ) RhC 3 (9% KwB&�. O5N:K�) t N:K (���� RSK & B93 (9&!( �:3 . & RS35, ( (9% �") & � �") RhC (9% K &�. O5N:K�� �

�FK�, ( )9l %�� ) � . ) �:O %/( I & ) (9%'&!(>( 3 O�K . KwB &!( K (9% K�� SQHe9;: k Hc\_X 9P3�{p, . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )=3 . & (9% B9KwK ��h,JR � ( )v6 & l�K�� � ( )9, r l�K�) ( 3=RSK & R8N:K ( 3 & 6'68N:C & 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( K ��� ) � .o&�.7& 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( K�N:C l�3 ./( B935N"N & R8N:K4I & C � K (� RSK &�. C &�. O5N:K-)9,'l %M(9%'&!( � &�. G�� & B9K]S<VPJ�L;M!M8H_VIdYO X 9a\_: H�� (9%'&!( �")w�h)9,'l %M(9%'&!( � � �") �:B9B &!( �:3 .'& N �FK�, ( )9l %�� ), . �:x�KwBH) & N~O &!( K� �") (9% K O &!( K 3�{ (9% B9KwK � . 68, ( )>I % �"l %a& 6'68N��:K�) � ���P( 3 � ( ) (9% �:BHG � . 68, ( �:{ (9% K8B8BH) ( ( I43� . 68, ( ) & B9KoRS3 (9% �%"H =# K7l & N"N (9% �")+O &!( K & =vl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � � ��� � ? ( 3 � . G �"l &!( K (9%'&!(F(9% K5B8BH) (F( I43�h,JR � ( )uJ�L;V ETX L;: (9% K & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . 3�{S� ���-( 3 (9% K (9% �:BHG TU% KB8BH) ( ) ( Kw6 � . �FK�, ( )9l %�� )7l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . �") ( 3 ) % 3�I (9%'&!( I � (9% �m� � ( �") 6S35)9) �:R8N:K�� ( 3 & B9R � ( B & B �"N:C

O�3h3`G & lwlw,JB & l�C�� l�B9K &!( K & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G ���� O &!( K {�3�B &�. C &�. O5N:K � >uh(9& B ( RhC (9&;@ � . O�� � ��I % �"l %l &�. RSK-B9KwIUB � (v( K . & )

� � " o�� ��� p � " � � o ��� p � " � � ��� o QJ � pRSK�l & ,')vK ��� �") & B93 (9&!( �:3 .� r4K�l & ,')vK�� I & ) � . l�350P07K . )9,JB & R8N:K I � (9% ��� )v3 �") Q � r4C (9&;@ � . O )9,'lwl�K�)9) �:x�K6S3�I4KwBH)+3�{�� � � � ( �")U6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 & 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( K & B9R � ( B & B9C B93 (9&!( �:3 . )w�SRSK�l & ,')vK (9% K &�. O5N:K�) (9% KwC B93 (9&!( K RhCI �"N"N�RSK=GJK . )vK�N:C G �") ( B �:R8, ( K�G (9% B935,JO % � � �H? � � ,�jk. 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�� � ( �")o6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 O�K . KwB &!( K &�. & B9R � ( B & B �"N:C O�3h3`G & 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( �:3 .a( 3 � " � � TU% Kl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � � O &!( K �")=l & N"N:K�G &�� L��-L;: S ka9RE H�� &�. G � ( �")-{e, . G & 07K ./(9& N ( 3m, . �:x�KwBH) & N B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K

&�. G �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� LF)=I4KM) %'& N"N�G �")9lw,')9)-RSK�N:3�I>� (9% K T 3;sS35N���O &!( K �")>, . �:x�KwBH) & N {�3�B>B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kr43h35N:K &�. {e, . l ( �:3 . ) jk. 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B��hI � (9% T 3;sS35N���O &!( K�) (9% KFK �:O %/( R & ) �")4) (9&!( K�) 3�{ (9% K (9% B9KwK � �h,JR � ( )vC`) ( K�0l &�. RSK & B9R � ( B & B �"N:Co6SKwBH0o, ( K�G��h)v3 (9%'&!( � ( �")d6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 R'B � . O &�. CP6 & �:Bd3�{ R & ) �")d) (9&!( K�) � ./( 3 (9% K �#" � &�. G �%" � 6S35) � ( �:3 . )FI % KwB9K (9% K � ��� l &�. RSK & 6'68N��:K�G ( 3 (9% K�0 MW-. l�K (9% KwB9K�� (9% KwC l &�. RSK 6 %'& )vK � ) % �:{ ( K�G &�. GB93 (9&!( K�G & ) . K�l�K�)9) & B9C�� (9% K . )vI & 6'6SK�G7R & l @P( 3 (9% K �:Bd3�B �:O � .'& N =k68N & l�K�) ? TU% KFGJK (9& �"N") & B9KF)9N��:O %/( N:C ( K�G �:35,')w�R8, (U. 3 ( K�)v6SK�l � & N"N:C l�350768N��"l &!( K�G

� �:x�K .m(9% K & R �"N�� ( C ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(U& B9R � ( B & B9C , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )U3 . (9% B9KwK �h,JR � ( ) &!(F&P( �"07K�� � (�") . 3 ( G �Cr lw,'N (4( 3 ) % 3�I % 3�I ( 3 0 &;@ K & B9R � ( B & B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) 3 . � �h,JR � ( ) ~TU% K=K & ) �:K�) ( 07K (9% 3`G �")( 37,')vK T 3;sS35N��8O &!( K�) ( 370 &;@ K-x�KwBH) �:3 . )d3�{�� I % �"l % %'& x�K>073�B9K (9%'&�. ( I437l�3 ./( B935NSR � ( ) �TU% �")~x�KwBH) �:3 . �h{�3�B�� =�? @ TU:<�7�G6D*? @*460�:? RB:0XTB46K 2�:;G6EJG6E 7�=�? @ GBMN:�D>4I7�G6DQA��$? 7�=�:? RB:0XTB46K 2�:� B]&. 7�@ : ' ? @F7�:0�<:�? @ RB254ID>46037�::QP W3L 7�=�:�@/MN:<�7/D>46K

7�=�:G6D�:8ZA �$=�? <>=Z? 0�E[46<�7\@/=�G"�$@$7�=54I7$:TU:�D/L�2�0�? 7>4ID/L&7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0Z<Q460ZWN: D�:RU4ID>P :QPZ46@\4*D�G67>4I7�? GB0 46WNGB2 7$@/GB8;: 4 ' ? @]� . 7�? @�MNGB@/@/? W�K :�7�G RB? TU:�����? 0 8&4I7/D�? ' EHG6D�8ZA�W�2 7*7�=�:�P :�D�? TB4I7�? GB0 ? @C8;G6D�:�? K K 2�8;? 054I7�? 0�R 7�=5460�7�=�:&D�:@/2�K 7Q]�����D�G67>4I7�:@46WNGB2 7*? 7�@*4 ' ? @ -� �

� ����� -� �� � W3L 460 460�RBK :;G6E��X] �SG"� :TU:�DQA"7�=�:�@/2�W�@/M546<:;G6EJTU:<�7�G6D�@ MN:�D�MN:05P ? <2�K 4ID 7�G�7�=�? @*4 ' ? @ ? @ GB0�:

P ? 8;:0�@/? GB0546K[] � =�: D�G67>4I7�? GB0Z? 0�7�=�? @$@/2�W�@/M546<:S7>4�U:@J7�=�:SEHG6D�8 G6E 4CM�=546@/:Y@/=�? E 7 �H7�=�:YGB0�K L�P :R6D�::YG6E E D�::QP GB8 4QTB46? K 46W�K : �>A5@/G7�=54I7���� 8C2�K 7�? M�K :@J7�=�:YM�=546@/: <GB8;MNGB0�:037$G6E -� �

� ��� � -� �� � � �$=�? <>=Z@/M5460�@$7�=�? @$@/2�W�@/M546<: �JW3L � ' � ]�� =�:@/:Y7 � G;TU:<�7�G6D�@\4ID�:

7�=�: (�GB2 D�? :�D\W546@/? @A5@/GC7�=54I7���� ? @\P ? 46RBGB0546K"? 0�7�=�: (�GB2 D�? :�D\W546@/? @��$? 7�=Z8&4I7/D�? '

���� ��� �� � ' �! $

�"GCD�:�7�2 D�0�7�GC7�=�:Y<GB8;M�2 7>4I7�? GB0546K�W546@/? @A � :Y<GB0 �F2�RU4I7�:�� �� W3L&7�=�: � 4BP�468&4ID>P�8&4I7/D�? 'VA �$=�? <>=Z<GB0XTU:�D/7�@$WN:�7 � ::0Z<GB8;M�2 7>4�+7�? GB0546K 4605P�(�GB2 D�? :�D\W546@/:@%(

��� �" ���� " ��� � � �

� � ' �! � � ��� #� � ' � � � ' �

� � ' � #� � ' � $ �%$ ] � �$�� =�? @$E[46<�7$EHGBK K G"�$@\E D�GB8 7�=�: .�:�L KV:Q132�? P ? @F7/D�? W�2 7�? GB0�7�=�:G6D�:8Z]

Page 44: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

D�y ������� ������� � ��� ��� � ����� � ��� �

K�� & 0768N:K8oe,') � . O & )9l�B &!( l % �h,JR � ( I % �"l % ) (9& B ( ) &!( �#" &�. G �") B9K ( ,JB . K�G ( 3 �#" pH� %'& ) (9% B9KwK l�3 ./( B935N R � ( )mD

���

���������� �

������������

������������

� �

���������� �

������������

� �� � ����

������������

o QJ n p

u N��:O %/( 073`G �CB�l &!( �:3 . )d3�{ (9% K=6'B93h3�{ O �:x�K & RS3�x�K ) % 3�I (9%'&!( &�.�� � R � ( �FK�, ( )9l % O &!( K )9, r l�K�) ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(&�. C , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 3 . � �h,JR � ( )

� ������� ��� � ��� � � � � ��� ����� �� ��FK�, ( )9l %�� ) B9K�)9,'N ( l &�. RSK K�� ( K . GJK�G � . ( I43 � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O G �:B9K�l ( �:3 . ) W-. K �") ( 3 {�35N"N:3�I (9% B935,JO % 3 .f(9% K6'B9350 �")vK>0 & GJK � . (9% K 6'B9Kwx �:35,')Ul %'& 6 ( KwB ( 3 ) % 3�I (9%'&!(F& O &!( K )vK ( � I % �"l % � . lwN",'GJK�) & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-TO &!( K &�. G & N"N�3 . K � �h,JR � ( O &!( K�) �")+, . �:x�KwBH) & N pTU% K>3 (9% KwB �")+)v3507K (9% � . OP3�{ & 0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N lw,JB �:35) � ( C��8R8, (�"N"N",'0 � .'&!( � . O & RS35, ( (9% K G �") ( � . l ( �:x�K .'&!( ,JB9K=3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� TU% K B9K�G','l ( �:3 . 3�{ & �FK�, ( )9l % O &!( K ( 3 & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T 68N",')P3 . K � �h,JR � ( B93 (9&!( �:3 . ) 6'B93`l�KwK�G') � .

)vKwx�KwB & N�) (9& O�K�) E �:BH) ( � (9% K (9% B9KwK � �h,JR � ( O &!( K�� � l &�. RSKo3�6 ( �"0 � � K�G � ./( 3 &M( I43 � �h,JR � ( x�KwBH) �:3 . � ) -TU% K@ KwC � . ) �:O %/( �") (9%'&!( � � ( B9K &!( ) � ( ) B8BH) (~( I43 � . 68, ( ) �"GJK ./( �"l & N"N:C��/)9,JO�O�K�) ( � . O (9%'&!(d(9% KwB9KF0 �:O %/( RSK & I & C ( 30 &;@ K (9% K l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . I43�B @ I � (9% 3 . N:C 3 . K7l�3 ./( B935N"N�� . OMR � ( � . ) ( K & Gm3�{ ( I43 =jk. { & l ( � & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G ����O &!( K (9%'&!( �"076S35)vK�) & 6 %'& )vK ) % �:{ ( 3�{ � � B & G � &�. )!oe)v3 (9%'&!(=& 6'68N:C � . O (9% KoO &!( K7K �:O %/(F( �"07K�)Fl & ,')vK�) . 3 . K (6 %'& )vK>) % �:{ ( p � . ) ( K & G 3�{ � ) B & G � &�. )pI43�B @ ) � ) �") & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G

�� O &!( K��8I % KwB9K�

� " � � � � ��� " � � � ) ��( o QJ y pTU% KU6'B93h3�{ (9%'&!( � ) �")d, . �:x�KwBH) & N �")~O�K . KwB & N"N:C &�.'& N:3�O�35,') ( 3 (9% K+6'B93h3�{S{�3�B � � �hK��Jl�Kw6 (4(9%'&!(4(9% KFl�3 . ) ( BH,'l �( �:3 . 3�{ &PT 3;sS35N���O &!( K �") 073�B9K � ./( B �"l &!( K T 3 l�350768N:K ( K (9% KmB9K�G','l ( �:3 . � I4K ) % 3�I (9%'&!( & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T O &!( K &�. G & B9R � ( B & B9C ) � . O5N:K � �h,JR � (

B93 (9&!( �:3 . )-)9, r l�K ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(+& l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � ��O &!( K��SI % KwB9K� �")]9;V ^o, . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 3 . 3 . K�h,JR � (w � l &�. RSK7l�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G & ) & )vK�N:{ � � . x�KwBH)vK B93 (9&!( �:3 . ��)v3 (9%'&!( l�3 . 9,JO &!( � . O )v3507K73 (9% KwB=B93 (9&!( �:3 . �RhC ��I �"N"N8l %'&�. O�K � � ./( 3 & G �CsSKwB9K ./( B93 (9&!( �:3 . � L . & B9R � ( B & B9CPB93 (9&!( �:3 . � l &�. RSK-GJK�l�35076S35)vK�G�� � ./( 3� � �s)9,'l % (9%'&!(

� � � " � R8, (� � ��� � " �( o QJ | p

o QJ "�w� p� � =�:�M D�G3G6E D�:K ? :@ GB0 RB:GB8;:�7/D�? <�M D�GBMN:�D/7�? :@YG6E 7�=�:CR6D�GB2�M G6E 2�0�? 7>4ID/L�7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@ GB0�� � A"<GB0�@/? P :�D�:QP 46@*4�R6D�GB2�M

G6E D�G67>4I7�? GB0�@S? 0Z7�= D�:: �HD�:Q46K + TB46K 2�:QP �J@/M54I7�? 46K P ? 8;:0�@/? GB0�@]J.�0�:@/@/:0�<:BA�%,? @\<>=�GB@/:0�@/G;7�=54I7 % �$? K K WN: %��"--,��94605P �97�=�:0:? 7�=�:�D\<Q460�<:K �$? 7�= % G6DS46<�7$7�GBRB:�7�=�:�D �$? 7�= % 7�G�<Q4ID/D/L�GB2 7\4*EH2�K K�D�G67>4I7�? GB0ZW3L � ]

Page 45: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � �� ��� ��� � ������� � � � ��� � � � � � ��� � ��� � D�|

TU% K={�35N"N:3�I � . O7l �:BHlw, � ( �"0768N:K�07K ./( ) & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �sO &!( KRD�

��

�� o QJ "��� p

j { (9% KuB8BH) ( �h,JR � ( �")! �#" � (9% K l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T O &!( K�) & l (F( B �:x � & N"N:CM3 . (9% Ko)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � (U&�. G (9% K 3�x�KwB & N"NB93 (9&!( �:3 . � � � "�� �") & 6'68N��:K�G ( 3 (9% K+)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � (w j { (9% K B8BH) ( �h,JR � ( �") �%" � (9% K+l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T O &!( K�)� �:6 (9% KM) (9&!( KP3�{ (9% KP)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( � �"076S35) � . O (9% K73�x�KwB & N"N~B93 (9&!( �:3 . � � ��� � " ' PTU% �")-)vK �h,JK . l�KP3�{O &!( K�)w� (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K�� & l ( ) & ) & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �sO &!( K � ! u � . l�K � ) �") & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G �

�� O &!( K�� & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T

O &!( K &�. G 3 . K � �h,JR � ( B93 (9&!( �:3 . )-l�3 . ) ( � ( , ( K & , . �:x�KwBH) & N )vK ( 3�{~O &!( K�) �Q� TU% �") B9K�)9,'N ( 9,') ( �CB8K�) (9% Kol % 3 �"l�K3�{ (9% �") )vK ( 3�{ 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�KFO &!( K�) & ) (9% K=O�3 & N 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( � . O %'& BHGJI & B9K>)9l % K�07K�) TU% Kp3 (9% KwB~K�� ( K . ) �:3 . 3�{ �FK�, ( )9l %�� )dl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . �") ( 3>) % 3�I (9%'&!(�(9% K �FK�, ( )9l % O &!( K�� ) �") . 3 ( , . ��h,JK

� . RSK � . O7, . �:x�KwBH) & NUD�9;: MLqd_E,9;:<: ( I43 � �h,JR � ( O &!( K�) & B9Ko, . �:x�KwBH) & N � ) TU% �")p{ & l ( )9,JO�O�K�) ( ) (9%'&!(U(9% K )v6 & l�K 3�{�h, &�./( ,'0 ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) �") � . GJKwK�G l�3 . ) �"GJKwB & R8N:C`=vN & B9O�KwB�? (9%'&�. (9% K-)v6 & l�K-3�{�lwN & )9) �"l & N�3 . K�)w� &�. G (9%'&!(&�. C v35,JB . KwC � ./( 3 (9% K=)v6 & l�K=3�{��h, &�./( ,'0 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) (9&;@ K�)U,')pGJK�l �"GJK�G'N:C RSKwC�3 . G (9% K-6S3�I4KwB 3�{ lwN & )9) �"l & N3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) j (o& N")v3 )9,JO�O�K�) ( ) (9%'&!( �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O & N"N �h, &�./( ,'0 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) �")>K �h, �:x & N:K ./( � . G �Cr lw,'N ( C( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O &�. C & 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( K�N:Cfl % 35)vK . 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . 3�{=)9, r l �:K ./( l�350768N:K�� � ( C�� &�. & B9O5,'07K ./( I � (9%RS3 (9% B9K�G','l ( �:x�K &�. Gl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K 3�x�KwB ( 3 . K�) u 3507K � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . Of0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N-O5N:35)9)vK�) 3 . �FB93�x�KwB � )&�. G u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)=) (9& B ( {�B9350 (9% �")F3�R8)vKwB9x &!( �:3 . & RS35, (=(9% K7,')vKw{e,'N . K�)9)F3�{]= & N"0735) (>&�. C ? �h, &�./( ,'0( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .�

- � �":<>=�0�? <Q46K K L3AB7�=�:�O�D�@F7 132�W�? 7 8C2�@F7 WN: *5? M�MN:QP WN:�EHG6D�:J4605PC4IE 7�:�D 7�=�? @ <? D�<2�? 7QAUW�2 7 7�=�? @ ? @ 7/D�? TX? 46K �$? 7�=CGB0�:#+�132�W�? 7"D�G67>4I7�? GB0�@]-/- � TU:0�7�=�? @ D�:@/2�K 7�<Q460;WN:J? 8;M D�GITU:QPCGB0 ("7 � G*46M�M D�GBM D�? 4I7�:K L + <>=�GB@/:0�D�G67>4I7�? GB0�@�@/2 �;<:@] �S? TU:0CD�G67>4I7�? GB0�@ � 4605P % �$=�? <>=

P G*0�G67 <GB8;8C2 7�:BA3? 7 ? @ MNGB@/@/? W�K :S7�G*RB:0�:�D>4I7�:BAX7�GC4ID�W�? 7/D>4ID/L�46<<2 D>46<�L3A 4603L;@/? 0�RBK :#+�132�W�? 7 D�G67>4I7�? GB0 �[W3L&4 @/? 8;? K 4ID$4ID�RB2�8;:037�7�G7�=54I7$2�@/:QP�7�G�@/=�G"�(7�=54I7\4C@/? 0�RBK :���� @/2 �;<:@J7�G�RB:0�:�D>4I7�:BA�7�G;4ID�W�? 7/D>4ID/L�46<<2 D>46<�L3A54603L���� �>]- � �":<>=�0�? <Q46K K L3AU7�=�: @/:�7�G6EV0�GB0 + 2�0�? TU:�D�@�46K37 � G +�132�W�? 7�RU4I7�:@�=546@ 8;:Q46@/2 D�:�:�D�GY? 0C7�=�:J@/:�7�G6E�46K K 7 � G +�132�W�? 7 RU4I7�:@] � =�:$M D�G3G6E�A

P 2�:S7�G � :2 7�@/<>=�A&+ 4ID�:0�<G AN4605P � U:�D/7QA�M D�G3<::QP @\46K GB0�R;@/GB8;: �$=54I7\460546K GBRBGB2�@SK ? 0�:@J7�GC7�=�GB@/:Y? 0�7�=�: M D�G3G6E EHG6D\7�=�:�� :2 7�@/<>=RU4I7�:B])� =�:�LC<GB0�@/? P :�D�4 )�RB:0�:�D�? <%* 7 � G +�132�W�? 7 RU4I7�:"( GB0�: �$=�? <>=�=546@ EHGB2 D�:? RB:0XTB46K 2�:@��$=�? <>=�4ID�:J? 0�<GB8;8;:0�@/2 D>4I7�: �$? 7�= �4605P�$? 7�=Z:Q46<>=ZG67�=�:�DQ]�� =�:�L�7�=�:0�@/=�G"� 7�=54I7$? 7�@\MNG"� :�D�@S4ID�: P :0�@/:Y? 0�4*7�G6D�2�@$G6E =�? RB=�:�DSP ? 8;:0�@/? GB0�7�=5460�7�=�:YGB0�:#+�P ? 8;:0�@/? GB0546K� � !�� �N<GB0�@/? P :�D�:QP�EHG6D�� :2 7�@/<>= � @�RU4I7�:B] � =�:0�A3W3L�@ �$? 7�<>=�? 0�R 7�=�:$? 0�M�2 7�@�WN:�EHG6D�: 4605P;4IE 7�:�DJ46M�M�K L ? 0�RY7�=�:$RU4I7�:BA37�=�:�L�RB:0�:�D>4I7�:4*@/:<GB05P�@/:�7$G6E MNGB? 037�@$P :0�@/:S? 0�7�=54I7 7�G6D�2�@] � 7�7�=�? @JMNGB? 037QA 0�: � )�RU4I7�:@ *�<Q460�WN: RB:0�:�D>4I7�:QP�46@JK ? 0�:Q4ID$<GB8CW�? 054I7�? GB0�@JG6E"7�=�:GBK P GB0�:@ G6D 7�= D�GB2�RB= 7>4�X? 0�R�7�=�:? D <GB8;8C2 7>4I7�G6D-,�7�=�:�M D�G3G6E 7�=�:0 ? 0XTUGBK TU:@Y<>=�:<%X? 0�R&7�=54I7Y7�=�:@/:�GBMN:�D>4I7�? GB0�@ L ? :K P :0�GB2�RB=K ? 0�:Q4ID�K L�? 05P :MN:05P :037SRU4I7�:@S7�G;RB:0�:�D>4I7�: �[2�MZ7�G�4ID�W�? 7/D>4ID�? K L�@/8&46K K 46M�M D�G"' ? 8&4I7�? GB0��J7�=�:YEH2�K K @/? 'X7�::0 +�P ? 8;:0�@/? GB0546K @/M546<:*G6EMNGB@/@/? W�K :Y7/D>460�@FEHG6D�8&4I7�? GB0�@]

Page 46: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

Q5� ������� ������� � ��� ��� � ����� � ��� �

Page 47: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�������������

� � � ����� � � �#�W� � ���

� ��� ����� ���]$�� �TU% K GJK�l�35076S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ � ) � ./( 3 l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T O &!( K�) &�. Gf) � . O5N:K � �h,JR � ( B93 (9&!( �:3 . )w� & 073 . O � ( ) 3 (9% KwB{�K &!( ,JB9K�)w� �") � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O7RSK�l & ,')vK � ( R'B9K &;@ ) & �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . GJ3�I . � ./( 3 ( I43 )vK ( ) 3�{ 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�)mD3 . K (9%'&!( �")~)9,J6SKwB B�l � & N"N:C �h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N &�. G73 . K (9%'&!( �")�68,JB9K�N:C �h, &�./( ,'0 �TU% �") @ � . G 3�{�GJK�l�35076S35) � ( �:3 .�") & O�K . KwB & NJ{�K &!( ,JB9KU3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)mD (9% KUl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . l &�. RSK G �:x �"GJK�G � ./( 3 �h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N &�. G�h, &�./( ,'026 %'& )vK�) FTU% K �h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N 6 %'& )vK�) & B9Ko3�{ ( K . �h, � ( K K�� ( K . ) �:x�K�� � . x�35N:x � . OMN:3 . O )vK �h,JK . l�K�)F3�{3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) (9%'&!( l�350768, ( K �h, � ( K . 3 .�� ( B �:x � & NS{e, . l ( �:3 . ) dTU% K �h, &�./( ,'0�6 %'& )vK�)w�J3 . (9% K>3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� & B9K& N"0735) ( K��JlwN",') �:x�K�N:Cml %'&�. O�K�)=3�{4R & ) �") W-. K x�KwB9CmO�K . KwB & N�6 &!(v( KwB . �") (9%'&!(>& �h, &�./( ,'0�6 %'& )vK7)vK ( )=,J6 &)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N8R & ) �")4) (9&!( K�)w� & �h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N'6 %'& )vKF3�6SKwB &!( K�) o �"0768N��"l � ( N:C p � . 6 & B & N"N:K�N3 . K & l % 3�{ (9% K ) (9&!( K�) � .f(9% �") )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . � &�. G & B .'& N �h, &�./( ,'0 6 %'& )vK B9K�l�350 R � . K�) (9% K G �CsSKwB9K ./(K�N:K�07K ./( )U3�{ (9% K )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . � ./( 3 & ) � . O5N:K &�. )vI4KwB jk. (9% K�)vK & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w� (9% K l %'&�. O�K�)m3�{oR & ) �") & B9Ka,')9, & N"N:C & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �"l & N"N:C�) ( B & �:O %/( {�3�B9I & BHG �TU% K

&�.'& N:C`) �") 3�{ % 3�I (9% KwC & l ( 3 . G �CsSKwB9K ./( ) (9&!( K�)dl &�. RSK 0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N"N:Co)v3�6 % �") ( �"l &!( K�G��!R8, (�(9% K , . GJKwBHN:C � . O)vK �h,JK . l�Ko3�{�O &!( K�) �")+,')9, & N"N:C x�KwB9Cm) �"0768N:K +W-.m(9% K 3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� (9% K � ./( KwB9x�K . � . O �h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N�6 %'& )vKl &�. � . x�35N:x�K (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 3�{U{e, . l ( �:3 . ) I � (9% GJK�l �"GJK�G'N:C . 3 .�� ( B �:x � & N~l �:BHlw, � ( )w��Kwx�K . lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C mjk.l�B9K &!( � . O & l ( , & N�O &!( K & B9B & C`) ( 3 l & B9B9Cm35, ( )9,'l % & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w� � ( �")-l�BH,'l � & N ( 3 @`. 3�I . 3 ( 9,') (F(9%'&!(-(9% K�)vK�h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N�) (9& O�K�)Fl &�. RSK �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�G I � (9% �h, &�./( ,'0�O &!( K�)w��R8, ( (9%'&!(U(9% KwC l &�. RSK �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�GH�� JmSQH_V ET: ^ T 3 RSKM073�B9KM6'B9K�l �")vK�� (9% K �h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) & B9K (9% 35)vK ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )>I % �"l % 0 & 6

K�N:K�07K ./( )>3�{ (9% KMl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �")=3 . N:C ( 3 K�N:K�07K ./( )>3�{ (9% KMl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �") u ,'l % ( B &�. )v{�3�B �0 &!( �:3 . ) GJK_B . K-6SKwBH0o, (9&!( �:3 . )43�{ (9% K=l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �") �#% K . & 6'68N��:K�G ( 3 & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ R & ) �")) (9&!( K�)w� (9% KwC GJ3 . 3 ( l�350 R � . KF3�BUG �:x �"GJKUK�N:K�07K ./( )p3�{ (9% K=)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�BUl & ,')vK (9% K�0 ( 3 � ./( KwB9{�KwB9KRD (9% K. ,'0 RSKwBd3�{�K�N:K�07K ./( ) � .P(9% K-)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . &�. G (9% K �:BdB9K�N &!( �:x�KF6 %'& )vK�) &�. G & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK & B9K-, . l %'&�. O�K�GMRhC)9,'l %m& ) (9& O�K +TU% K )vK ( 3�{ & N"N )9,'l %m( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) 3 . � �h,JR � ( ) �") �")v35073�B96 % �"l ( 3 (9% Ko)vK ( 3�{~N:3�O �"l & N"N:C �B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kmr43h35N:K &�. {e, . l ( �:3 . )P3 . � R � ( ) �� H_bRH_X�dYSQ\_: H`J�L;M�NPOIETS<V k�� (9% K ) ( ,'GJC 3�{ )9,'l % {e, . l ( �:3 . ) &�. G(9% K �:B �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . � �")+35N"GJKwB (9%'&�. �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . &�. G %'& )FO�K . KwB &!( K�G & . ,'0 RSKwB-3�{~B9K�)9,'N ( )& 6'68N��"l & R8N:K ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� u 6SK�l �CB�l & N"N:C��!B9K�)9,'N ( ) {�B9350sB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kpl�350768, ( � . O-6'B93�x �"GJK & rMBH0 &!( �:x�K &�. )vI4KwBH) ( 3 (9% K {�35N"N:3�I � . O �h,JK�) �

( �:3 . ) B & �")vK�G RhC �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . DQ'�

Page 48: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

Q/? ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ����� � � � ��

�! 1 &�. &�. Cmr43h35N:K &�. {e, . l ( �:3 . ��B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K>3�B . 3 ( �SRSKol�350768, ( K�G RhC & l �:BHlw, � ( R8, �"N ( {�B93502B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KO &!( K�) ; j {')v3J� (9% K . &�. C>r43h35N:K &�. {e, . l ( �:3 . lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C-l�350768, (9& R8N:K~I �"N"N & N")v3URSKdl�350768, (9& R8N:KdK ./( �:B9K�N:CI � (9% � . (9% K �h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N�{�B & O507K ./( 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( ) �+6 ( 3 )v3507KMx�KwB9C 0 �"N"G B9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 . )3 . I %'&!( � ( 07K &�. )4{�3�B & B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KFl �:BHlw, � (d( 3 =vl�350768, ( Kg? &�. �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KU{e, . l ( �:3 . � (9% K &�. )vI4KwB ( 3(9% �") �h,JK�) ( �:3 . �")0=kC�K�) ? E ,JB (9% KwB�� (9% K=3�x�KwB % K & G[o � . ( �"07K &�. G )v6 & l�Kqpd3�{�)9,'l % ) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . ) �")w�`Kwx�K .� . (9% K>I43�BH) ( l & )vK�� . 3 ( , . )vK & )v3 .'& R8N:K

?h L+B9K (9% KwB9K!o�B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kqp�lwN & )9) �"l & N'O &!( K�)4I % �"l %M& B9KF, . �:x�KwBH) & NJ{�3�B (9% K+B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KUr43h35N:K &�. {e, . l ( �:3 . ) ;j { )v3J� (9% K . )9,'l % O &!( K�)+l�35,'N"G RSK=,')vK�G & )pR8, �"N"G � . O � R8N:3`l @ )�{�3�B �h, & ) � � lwN & )9) �"l & N �h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( ) � .(9% K=) & 07K-I & C (9%'&!( � L � � O &!( K�) & B9K=,')vK�G & )pR8, �"N"G � . O � R8N:3`l @ )�{�3�B lwN & )9) �"l & NSr43h35N:K &�. l �:BHlw, � ( ) LF)07K ./( �:3 . K�G & RS3�x�K�� (9% K T 3;sS35N��SO &!( K �") � . GJKwK�G , . �:x�KwBH) & N�{�3�BUB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K-{e, . l ( �:3 . )

Dh U#% KwB9K &�. K_r l �:K ./(4& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B & B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K {e, . l ( �:3 . K�� �") ( ) � Kwx�K . �:{ (9%'&!(4& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 B9K �h, �:B9K�)�:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K�) ( Kw68) � GJ3hK�) (9% KwB9K~K�� �") (�& {e,'N"N:CUB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 3�{`l�35076 & B & R8N:K~K_r l �:K . l�C ;Mj {`)v3J�(9% K . )9,'l % & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)�l &�. RSKpl & B9B �:K�Go3�x�KwB ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0 & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K�)�I � (9% N�� (v( N:KpN:35)9) 3�{8K_r l �:K . l�C # KP) %'& N"N )vKwKP)vKwx�KwB & N�K��`68N��"l � ( B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . )F{�3�B={ & 0 �"N�� & B & B � (9% 07K ( �"l {e, . l ( �:3 . )+I % �"l %6'B9K�)vKwB9x�K (9% K & )vC`076 ( 3 ( �"l=BH, .'. � . O ( �"07K=3�{ (9% K �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) (9% KwC & B9K=R & )vK�G 3 .�

# K I �"N"N . 3�I K�� & 0 � . K=K & l % 3�{ (9% K�)vK �h,JK�) ( �:3 . ) � . 073�B9K GJK (9& �"N

� ��� � � +�� �. ��� � ��� �.&6$ ����� �]$�/ )��' #".$'2-+!&

L �h, �"l @ R'BH, ( K � {�3�BHl�K & B9O5,'07K ./( ) % 3�I+) (9%'&!( &�. C�r43h35N:K &�. {e, . l ( �:3 . � B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K 3�B . 3 ( � l &�. RSKB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K~Kwx & N", &!( K�G I � (9% . 3 ( �"07Kd3�x�KwB % K & G ~TU% Kdl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . �")�) �"0768N:KRD @ KwKw67l�3�6 �:K�)�3�{ & N"N & B9O5,'07K ./( )( 3 (9% K )9,JR'{e, . l ( �:3 . )Ko &�. G ( 3 (9% K �:BM)9,JR'{e, . l ( �:3 . )w�4B9K�lw,JBH) �:x�K�N:C GJ3�I . ( 3 (9% KmO &!( K N:Kwx�K�N<p & ) (9% KwC & B9KKwx & N", &!( K�G � & l % � � R � ( O &!( K I4K (9% ,')oRSK�l�3507K & ?�� � R � ( O &!( K u ,'l % O &!( K�)PN:K & x�K (9% K �:B5B8BH) ( � � . 68, ( ), . l %'&�. O�K�G �TU% K )vK�l�3 . G � � . 68, ( ) & B9K & )9)9,'07K�G ( 3�) (9& B ( 3;s �#" &�. G & B9K (9% K . ,')vK�G ( 3 % 35N"G (9% K=k3�B �:O � .'& N ?o35, ( 68, ( ) 3�{ (9% K={e, . l ( �:3 . l�350768, ( K�G RhC (9% K=35N"G�� � � R � ( O &!( K

� ���

� ��� � � ���

� � �����

o Vh "� p� �:x�K . (9% K76 & �:B� � � � o �.p " � (9% K & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . 3�{;� ( 3 �al &�. RSKh=v, . l�350768, ( K�G ? RhCmB9K�)vK (v( � . O (9% KP)vK�l�3 . G� R � ( ) ( 3 �#"H � TU% KP)v6 & l�KMl�350768N:K�� � ( C 3�{ (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� �")��o � p+{�3�B &�.#� � ) ( Kw6al�350768, (9& �( �:3 . �'I % �"l % �")U, .'& lwl�Kw6 (9& R8N:C % �:O % {�3�B+O�K . KwB & N � 68,JB96S35)vK=) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 .� ~E 3�B ( , .'&!( K�N:C�� &�. & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�G',JK ( 3r4K .'. K (v( �J) % 3�I+)~RhC7K�� & 0768N:K (9%'&!( �`I � (9% 073�B9KF)9,JR8) (9&�./( � & N8lwN:Kwx�KwB . K�)9)w� � ( �")~6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 GJ3o0o,'l % RSK (v( KwB

- �"G�WN:�M�? <%3L3AN7�=�? @Y? @ 460 ? 0�@/2 �;<? :037Y@/MN:<? O5<Q4I7�? GB0�A 46@Y? 7 ? @YGB0�K L 7�=�:C<G6D/D�:<�7 WN:=54QTX? G6D �$=�:0 7�=�:�@/:<GB05P 7 W�? 7�@Y=�GBK P� ��� �>A �$=�:�D�:���? @�7�=�:\TB46K 2�:\=�:K P;? 0&7�=�:$O�D�@F7 7�W�? 7�@] �":<>=�0�? <Q46K K L3A37�=�: ) D�:TU:�D�@/:QP *C46<�7�? GB0�G6E"7�=�? @�RU4I7�:S0�::QP @�7�G WN:S@/MN:<? O5:QPEHG6D*7�=�:;<Q46@/:@ �$=�:0 7�=�:;@/:<GB05P 7 W�? 7�@ =�GBK P�@/GB8;:�G67�=�:�DCTB46K 2�:B]�� =�:�EHGBK K G"�$? 0�R 4ID�RB2�8;:037QA 46K 7�=�GB2�RB=�@/K ? RB=37�K L�? 0�:K :RU46037QA7>4�U:@J<Q4ID�:YG6E 7�=�GB@/: <Q46@/:@ � =�: RU4I7�:��$? K K�=54QTU: @/GB8;:Y46<�7�? GB0�[? 0�7�=�:SEHG6D �J4ID>PZP ? D�:<�7�? GB0�� GB0�? 0�M�2 7�@ �$=�:0�7�=�: @/:<GB05P 7 W�? 7�@=�GBK P;TB46K 2�:@�G67�=�:�D�7�=5460 � ���>AX:TU:0�7�=�GB2�RB=�7�=�:\RU4I7�: � GB2�K P;0�G67 0�G6D�8&46K K L �[W3LC<GB0XTU:037�? GB0�� WN:\: ' :<2 7�:QP�GB0&@/2�<>=;? 0�M�2 7Q])� =�:RU4I7�:J7�=X2�@ P :�7�:�D�8;? 0�:@ 4S8&46M�M�? 0�R\E D�GB8+? 7�@�MNGB@/@/? W�K :$? 0�M�2 7�@ 7�G @/GB8;:JGB2 7�M�2 7 TB46K 2�:@%,U7�=�? @ 8&46M�M�? 0�R �$? K K�WN:JW�? �F:<�7�? TU:JWN:<Q462�@/:7�=�: RU4I7�: �[WN:? 0�R�? 05P 2�<�7�? TU:K L�W�2�? K 7JE D�GB8 D�:TU:�D�@/? W�K :YRU4I7�:@ �J? @JD�:TU:�D�@/? W�K :B] � =�:Y? 0XTU:�D�@/:Y? 8&46RB:YG6E 7�=�? @J8&46M�M�? 0�RC@/2�M�M�K ? :@J7�=�:M D�GBMN:�D\WN:=54QTX? G6D$G6E 7�=�: RU4I7�:YD�2�0�W546<% �J4ID>P @A�:TU:0�? E ? 7\? @$0�:TU:�D$2�@/:QP�? 0�@/2�<>=Z4,�J4L3]

Page 49: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ��� ������� � ������� ������ � � � � � ��� ��� Q/D

T 3M) �"0768N��:{�C (9% K &�.'& N:C`) �")w�`)9,J6'6S35)vK (9%'&!(+&�. �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KFl�350768, ( KwB & N ( KwBH) . 3P073�B9K (9%'&�. & l�3 . ) (9&�./(& 0735, ./( 3�{ � ( )>) ( 3�B & O�K � . K & l % K�N:K�07K ./(9& B9C ) ( Kw6�o�3 . Kj=v, . � ( ?apH� &�. G (9%'&!( &�. & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�3�6SKwB &!( K�) & ) &)vKwB �:K�)43�{ ) ( Kw68)4K & l % 3�{�I % �"l %M(9&;@ K�) 3 . K � . 68, (d( 3 3 . K-35, ( 68, ( o &�. C lwN & )9) �"l & N�) ( B & �:O %/(�� N�� . K-l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .l &�. RSKd68, ( � .>(9% �")�{�3�BH0 RhC & 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( Kdlw,JB9B9C � . O p �TU% �") & )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . �") B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:Kd{�3�B l �:BHlw, � ( )w��RSK�l & ,')vKI � (9% � . & O �:x�K . l �:BHlw, � ( � (9% KwB9K �")F)v3507Kol�3 . ) (9&�./( ,J6'6SKwBURS35, . G � 3 .m(9% Ko{ &�.�� � . 3�{~O &!( K�) � . (9% K l �:BHlw, � (w W-. K>, . � ( 3�{�) ( 3�B & O�K �") (9% K .�� R � ( )w�') � . l�K . 3PO &!( Kol &�. l�3 . )9,'07K 073�B9K=x & N",JK�) (9%'&�. � ( )vKwK�) & ) � . 68, ( ) TU% K @ KwC � . ) �:O %/( RSK % � . G (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") (9%'&!( BH, .'. � . O B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KMO &!( K�) � . B9Kwx�KwBH)vK B9K�N:K & )vK�) (9% K

) ( 3�B & O�K+RSK � . O=,')vK�G ( 3 % 35N"G (9% K �:B�35, ( 68, ( ) r4C R & l @ � . O>,J6 & 6S3�B ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% KUl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � � ( �")�6S35)9) �:R8N:K( 3 B9K�lwN & �"0 , .'. KwK�GJK�G) ( 3�B & O�Kf)v6 & l�K 143 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K {�35N"N:3�I � . O )9l % K�07K {�3�B l�350768, ( � . O & ( I43 � ) (9& O�K{e, . l ( �:3 .���� � �`I % KwB9K � &�. G � & B9K=K & l % {e, . l ( �:3 . )p{�B9350�3 . K>, . � ( 3�{ � . 68, (4( 3P3 . K , . � ( 3�{ 35, ( 68, (w

LFl ( �:3 . uh( 3�B9K�G �~& N",JK�)o jk. � ( � & N"N:C p �14350768, ( K � o �.p � � o �.p14350768, ( K � o/� o �.p p � � o �.p � o/� o �.p pq+, . (9% K>O &!( K {�3�B�� � . B9Kwx�KwBH)vK � � o/� o �.p pL (p(9% �")~6S3 � ./( �h3 . N:C (9% K+x & N",JK�)d3�{0� &�. G � o/� o �.p p & B9KFRSK � . O ) ( 3�B9K�G��`I % �"l % �") (9% K & 0735, ./( 3�{ ) ( 3�B & O�K

I4K+I435,'N"GPB9K �h, �:B9K �:{SI4KFl�35,'N"GMl�350768, ( K � o/� o �.p p~G �:B9K�l ( N:C �TU% ,')w� (9% KF)v6 & l�K . KwK�GJK�G ( 3 % 35N"G � o �.p �")~3 . N:CB9K �h, �:B9K�G G',JB � . O (9% K & l ( , & N�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 3�{ � o/� o �.p p4{�3�BH0 �

� 3 ( K (9%'&!(o(9% K & R �"N�� ( C ( 3 , . l�350768, ( K � o/� o �.p p %'& ) . 3�I RSKwK . N:35) ( ��) � . l�K (9% K x & N",JKM3�{�� o �.p �") . 3N:3 . O�KwBPl & l % K�G j { (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 I4KwB9K ( 3 O�3 3 . ( 3 l�350768, ( K � o � o/� o �.p p pH� � ( l�35,'N"G . 3 ( B9K�lwN & �"0 (9% K)v6 & l�K=) ( 3�B � . O � o/� o �.p p � .M(9% K=) & 07K-I & C (9%'&!( � ( B9K�lwN & �"07K�G (9% K=)v6 & l�K=) ( 3�B � . O � o �.p �# � (9% (9% K-x & N",JK�),���� o/� o �.p pH� &�. G � o � o/� o �.p p pp3 .m%'&�. G�� � (U& 6'6SK & BH) ( 3PRSK=) ( ,'l @ l & l % � . O � o/� o �.p p @ 3�I4Kwx�KwB��/RhC>6 & C � . O (9% K43 . K � B9KwO �") ( KwB�)v6 & l�Kp3�x�KwB % K & G � . x�35N:x�K�G � . B9K�l�350768, ( � . OZ� o �.pH� (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0

l &�. � &!(+&�. C 6S3 � ./( � ( GJK�l �"GJK�) � o/� o �.p p �") . 3PN:3 . O�KwB+,')vKw{e,'N �`6SKwB9{�3�BH0 (9% K={�35N"N:3�I � . O7) ( Kw68)mDLFl ( �:3 . uh( 3�B9K�G �~& N",JK�)o jk. � ( � & N"N:C p � � o/� o �.p p14350768, ( K � o �.p � � o �.p � o/� o �.p pq+, . (9% K>O &!( K {�3�B � � . B9Kwx�KwBH)vK � � o �.pq+, . (9% K>O &!( K {�3�B�� � . B9Kwx�KwBH)vK �TU% �")~6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K �") (9% K+K�� & l ( B9Kwx�KwBH) & N�3�{ (9% KF6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K+,')vK�G ( 3 l & N"lw,'N &!( K ��� � &�. GMK�� & l ( N:CM, . GJ3hK�)

(9%'&!( l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . o�I � (9% (9% K ) & 07K & 0735, ./( 3�{ ( K�076S3�B & B9C 3�x�KwB % K & GPp T 3 K�076 %'& ) � � K (9% �")>6S3 � ./( � I4K0 �:O %/( l & N"N (9% �")F)vK�l�3 . Gm6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K 3 . K {�3�Bo ��� � p � � -TU% K @ KwC �") (9%'&!(F(9% �") ( K�l %'. ��h,JKo6'B93�x �"GJK�) & I & C3�{p6 & l @!& O � . Om,J6 6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K�) (9%'&!( l�350768, ( K &�. G , . l�350768, ( KPN & B9O�KwB>6S3�B ( �:3 . )=3�{ & l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . (9%'&�.� . G �:x �"G', & N'O &!( K�) TU% K O�K . KwB & N l & )vK (9% K . � � . x�35N:x�K�) & 6'68N:C � . O (9% K>= ( I43a) ( Kw68) {�3�B9I & BHG��~3 . K ) ( Kw6 R & l @ ? 6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % C

B9K�lw,JBH) �:x�K�N:C dTU% K>l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �")U)v68N�� ( � ./( 3 ( I43MK �h, & N � N:K . O (9% %'& N:x�K�) 4TU% KAB .'& NSx & N",JK=3�{ (9% K B8BH) (U%'& N:{�")Ul�350768, ( K�Gjoe,') � . O (9% �") B9K�lw,JBH) �:x�K>GJK�l�35076S35) � ( �:3 . �:{ � (U%'& )UN:K . O (9% 3�{�073�B9K (9%'&�. & ) � . O5N:K=) ( Kw66p dE B9350(9% �") B .'& N/x & N",JKp3�{ (9% K#B8BH) (�%'& N:{ � (9% K#B .'& N/x & N",JKp3�{ (9% K )vK�l�3 . G %'& N:{8l &�. (9% K . RSKpl�350768, ( K�GKo & O & � . �5,') � . O(9% K B9K�lw,JBH) �:x�KMR'B9K &;@ GJ3�I . �:{ . K�l�K�)9) & B9C p E � .'& N"N:C�� (9% K (9% K�= %'& N:{�I & C ?mx & N",JK �")>B9K�lwN & �"07K�GaRhC BH, .'. � . O

Page 50: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

Q�Q ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ����� � � � ��

R & l @ I & BHG') (9% K=6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K=,')vK�G ( 3Ml�350768, ( K � (w

���

� � �

� � �

� ���

� � � ����� �

� � ����� � � �� � ��� �

� ���

o Vh ? p� 3�I>�'N:K ( ,') &�.'& N:C � K (9% K-RSK %'& x �:3�B 3�{ (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 RhC l�3 . ) �"GJKwB � . O �!o �hpH� (9% K ( �"07K (9%'&!(U& B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . 3�{ &�. �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K� � ) ( Kw6 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .f(9&;@ K�)w� &�. G � o �hpH� (9% K )v6 & l�K 3�x�KwB % K & G � . x�35N:x�K�G TU% K ( �"07K (9&;@ K . �") (9% K ( �"07K ( 3>BH, .o( I43 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )�3�{SN:K . O (9% ��� ? � .o(9% K {�3�B9I & BHG7G �:B9K�l ( �:3 . � &�. G 3 . K� .M(9% K-B9Kwx�KwBH)vK=G �:B9K�l ( �:3 .� ~u � . l�K-l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) (9&;@ K (9% K=) & 07K & 0735, ./( 3�{ ( �"07KF{�3�B9I & BHG') & )4R & l @ I & BHG')w�I4K %'& x�K

�!o �hp " D �!o ��� ? p � o Vh D p& B9K�lw,JB9B9K . l�K=I % �"l % )v35N:x�K�)UK��`68N��"l � ( N:C o�O �:x�K . & R & )vK l & )vK>3�{ �!o � p " � p ( 3

�!o �hp " D�� �� �� ( o Vh Q pW-. (9% K 3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� (9% Ko)v6 & l�K (9&;@ K . RhC (9% �") B9K�lw,JBH) �:x�Ko) (9& O�K �") &!( � ( )UO�B9K &!( K�) ( I % �"N:K=I4K & B9K %'&�. O � . O3 . ( 3 (9% K � ./( KwBH07K�G � &!( K=x & N",JK89;VPZ & N")v3Pl�350768, ( � . O & l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 3�{�N:K . O (9% ��� ? ��)v3 (9%'&!(�

o �hp " �C#

�o ��� ? p � o Vh V p

I % �"l % )v35N:x�K�)UK��`68N��"l � ( N:C ( 3 �o �hp "N:3�O ) � ( o Vh � p

TU% �") �") . 3 (F(9% K 3 . N:C ( B & GJKw3;sf6S35)9) �:R8N:K>RSK ( I4KwK . ( �"07K &�. G )v6 & l�K T 3 & l % �:Kwx�K & )9N:3�I+GJ3�I . (9%'&!( �")RSK (v( KwB (9%'&�. & l %'&�. O�KP3�{pK��`6S3 . K ./( B9K �h, �:B9K�)-K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N & 0735, ./( )>3�{ )v6 & l�K t ( 3 & l % �:Kwx�KPRSK (v( KwB � (9%'&�.��N:3�O & B � (9% 0 �"lP)v6 & l�K l�3 . )9,'076 ( �:3 . �") �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K # � (9% � . (9% K�)vKMRS35, . G')w� I4K l &�. �"076'B93�x�K (9% KMR & )vK 3�{(9% KmK��`6S3 . K ./( � . 35,JBMK��`6'B9K�)9) �:3 . {�3�B �!o �hp ( 3 &�. C x & N",JK & B9R � ( B & B �"N:CflwN:35)vK ( 3 ? I % �"N:K ) ( �"N"N @ KwKw6 � . O�o �hp % �oeN:3�O ) � p5o 9,') ( I � (9% � . l�B9K & ) � . O5N:C N & B9O�K l�3 . ) (9&�./( ) & ) (9% KoR & )vK & 6'6'B93 & l % K�) ? p -T 3 GJ3 )v3J��I4K073`G �:{�C (9% K & RS3�x�K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ( 3 l�350768, ( K � ) ( Kw68) &�. G (9% K . , . l�350768, ( K (9% K!B8BH) ( � � � � 0 &;@ � . O (9% K& N:O�3�B � (9% 0�BH, . { & ) ( KwB &!(=(9% KPl�35) ( 3�{p073�B9K ( K�076S3�B & B9C ) ( 3�B & O�KM)v6 & l�K jk. O�K . KwB & N � (9% 35,JO % � (9% K & RS3�x�K& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �h, . 073`G �CB8K�G���)9, r l�K�)d{�3�B40735) ( 68,JB96S35)vK�) L+6'68N��:K�G ( 3 & {e, . l ( �:3 . l�350768, (9& R8N:K � . 6S35N:C . 350 � & N( �"07K�� (9% K+l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . 6'B93�x �"GJK�) & 6S35N:C . 350 � & N � ( �"07K4B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B (9% K+) & 07KU{e, . l ( �:3 . �5,') � . O3 . N:C 6S35N:C`N:3�O & B � (9% 0 �"loK�� ( B & )v6 & l�K E B9350 (9% KP6S3 � ./( 3�{ x �:KwI�3�{Ul�350768N:K�� � ( C (9% Kw3�B9C�� (9% �") �")>O�K . KwB & N"N:CO�3h3`G K . 35,JO %�

� �� � +0$ ��� �.&P � � � ��� �.&6$ ����� � #" � &

5,') (d& ) (9% K ( I43 � R � ( O &!( K � L � � �")d, . �:x�KwBH) & N`{�3�BplwN & )9) �"l & N �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � (9% KwB9K+K�� �") ( 0o,'N ( � �68N:K (9% B9KwK � R � ( O &!( K�)4I % �"l %M& B9KF, . �:x�KwBH) & NJ{�3�B4B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KUl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . o �:{SO �:x�K . & lwl�K�)9) ( 3 �o � pu=v)9l�B &!( l % ?R � ( )w� � . � ( � & N"N:C8B'�`K�G &!( � KwB93 3�B-3 . K�� &�. G I % �"l % I4K & B9K & N"N:3�I4K�G ( 3 073`G �:{�C &!( I �"N"N<p =W-. K )9,'l % O &!( K �")

Page 51: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � �!��� ����� ��� � ������� ������ �� ���� Q/V

(9% K T 3;sS35N��~O &!( K�� & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T � I % �"l % � . x�KwB ( ) � ( ) (9% �:BHG � . 68, ( �:{ � ( ) B8BH) (>( I43 � . 68, ( )& B9K>RS3 (9% �%"H TU% K 6'B93h3�{ 3�{+, . �:x�KwBH) & N�� ( C 6'B93`l�KwK�G') � . )vKwx�KwB & Np) (9& O�K�) E �:BH) ( ��)vKwx�KwB & Np3 (9% KwB7,')vKw{e,'N~O &!( K�)7l &�. RSK

R8, �"N ( {�B9350 D � R � (UT 3;sS35N���O &!( K�) L . , . l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N �=W-T O &!( K �")pK & )vC��8O �:x�K . ( I43MR � ( ) @`. 3�I . ( 3PRSK �%" D

� � �

� � �

o Vh n p

j ( �") & N")v3 & ) ( B & �:O %/( {�3�B9I & BHG 0 &!(v( KwB ( 3 l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( � � R � (UT 3;sS35N���O &!( K�)w�S{�3�B & B9R � ( B & B9C � oe)9,'l % O &!( K�) � �:6(9% K �:B ��(9% � . 68, ( �:{ (9% K>3 (9% KwB � � � O &!( K�) & B9K & N"N �%" p TU% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . OPl �:BHlw, � ( l�B9K &!( K�) & {�35,JB � R � ( T 3;sS35N��O &!( K {�B9350 (9% B9KwK � R � ( T 3;sS35N���O &!( K�)w��,') � . O 3 . KPR � ( 3�{ ( K�076S3�B & B9C )v6 & l�K o & )9)9,'07K�G ( 3mRSK � KwB93 � . � ( � & N"N:C��&�. G B9K ( ,JB . K�G ( 3 � KwB93 &!(U(9% K>K . G 3�{ (9% K l �:BHlw, � ( p�D

� �

� �

� �

���������� �

������������

� �� � ����

������������

o Vh y p

TU% �") l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . lwN:K & BHN:C O�K . KwB & N�� � K�) ( 3 & N"N:3�I ,') ( 3 l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( &�. � #s� � R � (oT 3;sS35N��dO &!( K {�B9350 ( I43D � R � (UT 3;sS35N���O &!( K�) &�. G 3 . K � � R � (UT 3;sS35N��SO &!( K r4C & 6'68N:C � . O �=W-T O &!( K�) ( 3 (9% K � . 68, ( ) &�. G 35, ( 68, ( )p3�{ &�. � � R � ( T 3;sS35N���O &!( K�� � ( �")p6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 � �:6

& ) � . O5N:KPR � ( {�B9350 &�. � � R � ( x�K�l ( 3�B �:{ &�. Ga3 . N:C �:{ (9% K 3 (9% KwB � � � R � ( ) %'& x�K & )v6SK�l �CB�lPx & N",JK j { I4Kl�3 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �") & ) & )vK ( 3�{ ?�� K�N:K�07K ./( )w�

� ( ( ( ���#" � ( ( ( �J�%" � ( ( (��w�#" � ( ( (����%" � ( ( (����%"

o Vh | p

)9,'l % &�. 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . � ./( KwBHl %'&�. O�K�) &�. C ( I43PK�N:K�07K ./( ) I % �"l % G �CsSKwB 3 . N:C � . & ) � . O5N:KFR � ( �`I % �"N:K-N:K & x � . O & N"N

Page 52: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

Q/� ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ����� � � � ��

3 (9% KwB+K�N:K�07K ./( )U, . l %'&�. O�K�G dE 3�B+K�� & 0768N:K

� � �

o Vh "�w� p� ./( KwBHl %'&�. O�K�) �J�w�J�%"F&�. G �����J�%"H =E B9350 % KwB9K�� (9% K . K�� ( O�3 & N �") ( 3 ) % 3�I (9%'&!(-&�. C ( I43 K�N:K�07K ./( )+3�{ (9% Kl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N`R & ) �")�l &�. RSK ( B &�. )v6S35)vK�G�� . 3>0 &!(v( KwB % 3�I�0 &�. CoK�N:K�07K ./( ) (9% KwC G �CsSKwB � .� qUKwO & BHG � . O (9% KK�N:K�07K ./( )�3�{ (9% K R & ) �") & ) (9% Kpx�KwB ( �"l�K�)�3�{ &�. � � G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N % Ch6SKwBHlw,JRSK�� (9% 35)vK K�N:K�07K ./( )�l�3 .'. K�l ( K�GPRhC &�.K�GJO�K & B9K-6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C (9% 35)vK-I % �"l % G �CsSKwB � . K�� & l ( N:CM3 . K-R � (w �TU% KF) (9&�. G & BHG B935, ( � . O & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 6'B93�x �"GJK�) &6 &!(9% {�B9350 &�. C7K�N:K�07K ./(~( 3 &�. C73 (9% KwB & N:3 . O (9% K+K�GJO�K�)~3�{ (9% K % Ch6SKwBHlw,JRSK L)vK �h,JK . l�K+3�{ ( B &�. )v6S35) � ( �:3 . )& N:3 . O (9% K�)vK K�GJO�K�) &�. GmR & l @ I �"N"NSK��Jl %'&�. O�K (9% K ( I43 K . GJ6S3 � ./( ) pE 3�BFK�� & 0768N:K�� (9% K {�35N"N:3�I � . OM)vK �h,JK . l�K� ./( KwBHl %'&�. O�K�)� ���J�w�#"U&�. G ���w���#" I % �"N:K=N:K & x � . OP, . l %'&�. O�K�G & N"NS3 (9% KwB+K�N:K�07K ./( ) 3�{ (9% K=R & ) �") B'�`K�G.D

���J�w�#"�� �w�J�w�#" �w�J�w�#"�� �����w�#" �����w�#"�� ���w���#" �����w�#"�� �w�J�w�#" �w�J�w�#"�� ���J�w�#"

o Vh "��� p

r4K�l & ,')vK & B9R � ( B & B9C-6SKwBH0o, (9&!( �:3 . ) l &�. RSKdIUB � (v( K .o& ) & 6'B93`G','l ( 3�{ ( B &�. )v6S35) � ( �:3 . ) &�. G (9% �")�N & ) ( l�3 . ) ( BH,'l �( �:3 . l &�. O�K . KwB &!( K &�. C ( B &�. )v6S35) � ( �:3 . ,') � . O T 3;sS35N���O &!( K�)w� T 3;sS35N���O &!( K�) l &�. O�K . KwB &!( K &�. CM6SKwBH0o, (9&!( �:3 .3�{ (9% K>l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& NSR & ) �") du � . l�K (9% K=B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KF{e, . l ( �:3 . )43 .�� R � ( ) & B9K (9% K-6SKwBH0o, (9&!( �:3 . )p3�{ (9% K ?��6S35)9) �:R8N:KFR � ( x�K�l ( 3�BH)w� T 3;sS35N���O &!( K�) & B9K , . �:x�KwBH) & N�{�3�B+B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K=l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� LFN (9% 35,JO %P. 3 ( I43 � R � ( O &!( K �")~, . �:x�KwBH) & N`{�3�B~B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � (9% K T 3;sS35N��JO &!( K �") . 3 (~(9% KU3 . N:C

(9% B9KwK � R � ( O &!( K (9%'&!( �")F, . �:x�KwBH) & N FTU% K �6X'H'Z&�qS<V ka9RE H��SI % �"l % )vI & 68) (9% Kox & N",JK�)F3�{ � ( )F)vK�l�3 . G &�. G (9% �:BHG� . 68, ( ) �:{ � ( ) B8BH) ( � . 68, ( �") �%" � �") & N")v3o, . �:x�KwBH) & N o �:{SO �:x�K . & lwl�K�)9) ( 3 ( I43 )9,J6'68N��:K�)�3�{�R � ( ) � . � ( � & N"N:C @`. 3�I .( 3PRSK �#"p&�. G$ �%" �8B9K�)v6SK�l ( �:x�K�N:C p

� ��� � � $�/43���� / � +-".$�+�� �! ,/4$ ��$' � �0)0+�� ".$'2-+!&

TU% K=l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . 3�{ &�. & B9R � ( B & B9CMB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KF{e, . l ( �:3 . {�B9350 T 3;sS35N��SO &!( K�) & N:3 . K �") & 6'B93 � �:O &!( K=3 . KRD & )) (9&!( K�G�� � ( B9K �h, �:B9K�) �o ��?�� p T 3;sS35N�� O &!( K�) @ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% �")-l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . R8, �"N"G')+l �:BHlw, � ( )F{�3�B=)v3507K7{e, . l �( �:3 . )UI % �"l % %'& x�K . 3M6S35N:C . 350 � & N"N:C � ) � � K�G l �:BHlw, � ( )w�'B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K=3�B �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K 4E 3�BF{e, . l ( �:3 . ) I % �"l %m& B9K6S35N:C . 350 � & N"N:CMl�350768, (9& R8N:K �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:C�� (9% Kor4K .'. K (v( ) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�R8, �"N"G')p6S35N:C . 350 � & N"N:C � ) � � K�GB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kol �:BHlw, � ( )w�SR8, ( � . l�B9K & )vK�)FRS3 (9% (9% K BH, .'. � . O ( �"07K &�. G (9% K7)v6 & l�K B9K �h, �:B9K�GmRhC &�. C & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 E 3�B40 &�. Co{e, . l ( �:3 . ) & N:B9K & GJC @`. 3�I . ( 3>RSK B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K�� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� � ( �")�6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3>GJ3 l�3 . ) �"GJKwB & R8N:C>RSK (v( KwB(9%'&�. (9% �") ,J6'6SKwB RS35, . G #% KwB9Kdl�3 . x�K ./( �:3 .'& N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)�{�3�B (9% K�)vK~6'B93�R8N:K�0P) � . x�35N:x�K & 0 � � ( ,JB9K�3�{`B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K &�. G �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K

) ( Kw68)w� (9% K B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) {�3�B (9% K ) & 07K 6'B93�R8N:K�0P) �"0768N:K�07K ./( (9% K B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K ) ( Kw68) G �:B9K�l ( N:C��

Page 53: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � � � � � � ��� � ������ �� � ��� � � ����� � �!������� ��� Qhn

(9% KwB9KwRhC & x�3 �"G � . Of6 & C � . O (9% K 3�x�KwB % K & G � . x�35N:x�K�G � . 6'B9K�)vKwB9x � . O & B935, . G � . 68, ( ) ( 3 B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K ) ( Kw68) W-. N:C {�3�B (9% 35)vK ) ( Kw68) I % �"l % & B9K � ./( B � . ) �"l & N"N:C �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K & B9K � . 68, ( ) B9K (9& � . K�G L . ,'0 RSKwB 3�{+3 (9% KwB( B �"l @ )w�'GJKw6SK . G � . Oo3 . (9% K>)v6SK�l �CB�l-) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K=3�{ (9% K=6'B93�R8N:K�0 � & B9K & N")v37K�0768N:3�C�K�G

����� ��� � ��� ��� ��� �

143 . ) �"GJKwB (9% Kd) (9&�. G & BHG=)vK �h,JK ./( � & N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0{�3�B & G'G � . O ( I43 � � R � (�. ,'0 RSKwBH)J� � � � ( ( ( � � �"! &�. G � � � � ( ( ( � � �B!( 3o0 &;@ K &�. 3 (9% KwB � � R � (~. ,'0 RSKwB�� � � � ( ( ( � � � !uo & N:3 . O I � (9%M&�. 3�x�KwB � 3�IR � ( p L )vKwB �:K�)~3�{ � � R � (4& G'G � ( �:3 . )& B9Kol %'& � . K�G ( 3�O�K (9% KwB-I � (9% l & B9B �:K�) � �:x�K . � � � � � � &�. G����k� (9% Kol & B9B �:K�G R � ( {�B9350 (9% K>6'B9Kwx �:35,') & G'G � ( �:3 . �� ( �")dK & )vC ( 3 � � &�. G���� " � ,') � . O>3 . N:C & {�KwI O &!( K�) 4TU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ) (9& B ( )4I � (9% �U! " &�. G�� � RSK�l�3507K�) (9% K3�x�KwB � 3�I<R � (w � Kw{ ( 3�x�KwB & B9K (9% K (9% K l & B9B9C R � ( )w�JI % �"l % I4K>KwB & )vK>I % K . I4K . KwK�G (9% K�0 . K�� (w TU% K 3 . N:C 6'B93�R8N:K�0 � . x�35N:x�K�G � . 0 &;@ � . O (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K �") B . G � . O & I & C ( 3 B9K�lwN & �"0 (9% K

)v6 & l�K (9&;@ K . RhC (9% K l & B9B9CaR � ( ) I % K . I4K . 3 N:3 . O�KwB . KwK�G (9% K�0 rp, (7(9% �") �") ( B �:x � & N td(9% K N:3�O �"l (9%'&!(l�350768, ( K�G����pl &�. RSK BH, . R & l @ I & BHG') 7TU% ,')�� � �")-KwB & )vK�G B8BH) ( � (9% K . � � � � � I43�B @ � . O R & l @ I & BHG') ( 3�� � TU% K ( �"07K 3�x�KwB % K & G �") �o � pH��I % �"l % �") & )9,JR8) (9&�./( � & N �"076'B93�x�K�07K ./( 3 .m(9% KoO�K . KwB & N�l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 .� +TU% K)v6 & l�K>3�x�KwB % K & G �") �o � p4G',JB � . O (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �'R8, ( �P& { ( KwB � (w u Kwx�KwB & N �"076'B93�x�K�07K ./( ) & B9Kp6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 L (�(9% K l�35) ( 3�{'3�x�KwB9IUB � ( � . OF3 . Kp3�{ (9% K � . 68, ( )

G',JB � . O (9% K+l�35,JBH)vK+3�{ (9% K+l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � (9% K+)v6 & l�K+3�x�KwB % K & G l &�. RSK+)9N & ) % K�G7Kwx�K . {e,JB (9% KwB q &!(9% KwB (9%'&�.(9&;@ � . O � " � " �#" ( 3 � " � " � # � " � & 073�B9K )v6 & l�K � K_r l �:K ./(F& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 (9&;@ K�) � " � "p( 3 � " � # � "H TU% �") ( K�l %'. ��h,JK �") & x�KwB9CPl�350P073 . 3 . K � .7(9% KFl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . 3�{SB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K &�. G �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)

jk. l�350768, ( � . O � o �.pH�dI % KwB9K � �") & B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K 6 %'& )vK 3�{-)v3507KmN & B9O�KwBPl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � � ( �")7l�350P073 . ( 33�x�KwB9IUB � ( K � I � (9% � o �.pH�8) � . l�K � ( �")UK & )vC ( 3MB9K�l�3�x�KwB � {�B9350 � o �.p �:{ � ( �") . KwK�GJK�G & O & � .� pTU% �") ( K�l %'. ��h,JKKwx�K . I43�B @ )=I % K . (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B �fl�3 ./(9& � . ) �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Ko) ( Kw68) t )9,'l % ) ( Kw68)>l &�. RSK B9Kw68N & l�K�G I � (9%B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Ko) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . )w� & ) � . (9% K & G'G � . OMl �:BHlw, � (F& RS3�x�K =j (-& N")v3 I43�B @ )FI % K . � (9&;@ K�)=0o,'N ( �:68N:K � . 68, ( )&�. G (9% K x & N",JKo3�{d3 . K 3�{ (9% K�0 �")FB9K�l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:R8N:Ko{�B9350 (9% K7l�350768, ( K�G x & N",JKo3�{�� &�. G (9% K B9K�) ( 3�{ (9% K� . 68, ( ) jk.M(9% �")4l & )vK�� (9% K-lw,JB9B9C � . O 3�{S� ( 3 {e, . l ( �:3 . 3�{ 3 . K & B9O5,'07K ./( C �:K�N"G') & B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K+{e, . l ( �:3 . � &�. GI4K & B9K 9,') ( �CB8K�G � . l & N"N�� . O �aB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K oTU% K # " 3�6SKwB &!( 3�B � . 0 &�. C 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K�) �") &�.K�� & 0768N:K=3�{�)9,'l % &�. � lw,JB9B �:K�G ( 3PRSK�l�3507K>B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K

����� ��� � � � ����� � ��� ��� ��� �$���� � � �\� ���

L . 3 (9% KwB & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �"N"N",') ( B &!( �:x�K-3�{ (9% K ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) � . x�35N:x�K�G � . GJK�) �:O . � . OoK_r l �:K ./( �h, &�./( ,'0 &�.'& N:3�O5,JK�)3�{FlwN & )9) �"l & N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) �")o3 . K {�3�BP073`G','N & B & G'G � ( �:3 . DPO �:x�K . � &�. G����4l & N"lw,'N &!( K � # � oe073`G"�hp>{�3�B)v3507KuB'�`K�G���� ?h 143 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G & ) & lw,JB9B �:K�G {e, . l ( �:3 . �8073`G','N & B & G'G � ( �:3 . �")UB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K pTU% K 6'B93�R8N:K�0�") (9%'&!(+(9% K ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � & G'G � &�. G ��� &�. G (9% K . )9,JR ( B & l ( � �:{ (9% K B9K�)9,'N ( �") ( 3h3 N & B9O�K �� . x�35N:x�K�) & B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K ) (9& O�K {�35N"N:3�I4K�GmRhC &�. �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K=3 . K FTU% K l %'& N"N:K . O�K �") ( 3 IUB � ( K & l �:BHlw, � (U(9%'&!()9,JR ( B & l ( ) � �:{ . K�l�K�)9) & B9C I % �"N:K @ KwKw6 � . OPK . 35,JO % � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & B935, . G ( 3MGJK ( KwBH0 � . K>I % K (9% KwB � . KwK�G')( 3PRSK & G'GJK�G R & l @ � . � �:{�BH, . R & l @ I & BHG')

� K�GJB & N K (F& N )v35N:x�K�G (9% �") 6'B93�R8N:K�0�I � (9% & x & B � &�./( 3�{ (9% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . O & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �JI % �"l % & )9)9,'07K�) (9% K& x & �"N & R �"N�� ( C 3�{ & R � .'& B9C K . l�3`G � . OM3�{ � � .m& B9KwO �") ( KwB-I % �"l % I4KoI �"N"N l & N"N`� &�. G & N")v3 & )v6 & B9KoB9KwO �") ( KwB���J�8)vK (U( 3 � D�! � �:x�K . � &�. G ���JB9Kw68N & l�K �MI � (9% � # �!o 9,') (+&�. � .�� 68N & l�K & G'G � ( �:3 . p

Page 54: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

Q/y ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ����� � � � ��

?h 1435076 & B9K � I � (9% � # ���') ( 3�B � . O (9% K>B9K�)9,'N ( � . &7( K�076S3�B & B9C R � ( �oeN:K (v( � . O �FRSK � �:{ � �") O�B9K &!( KwB(9%'&�. � # ��� &�. G � 3 (9% KwB9I �")vKqp

Dh Uj { � " � � (9% K . )vI & 6 (9% KPl�3 ./( K ./( ) 3�{ I � (9% (9% KMl�3 ./( K ./( ) 3�{ � . 3�I % 35N"G') � �:{ &�. G 3 . N:C �:{� # � � �

QJ -u ,JR ( B & l ( (9% K l�3 ./( K ./( )+3�{ {�B9350�� # ���'RhC BH, .'. � . O (9% K & G'G � ( �:3 . l �:BHlw, � ( R & l @ I & BHG') Vh qUKw6SK &!( ) ( Kw6 D ��)vI & 6'6 � . O� &�. G � �:{ � " �! 7TU% �")F, . GJ3hK�) (9% K K_sSK�l ( )>3�{p) ( Kw6 D ��)v3 (9%'&!( . 3�I% 35N"G') � &�. G � % 35N"G') � � & ) (9% KwC %'& x�K>RSKwK . )vI & 6'6SK�G K � (9% KwB ( I �"l�K>3�B . 3 (+&!(+& N"N

�h 1435076 & B9K �FI � (9% � # � &�. G � . x�KwB ( � �Cs � � � # � dTU% �")pN & ) ( ) ( Kw6mB9K�) ( 3�B9K�) � ( 3MRSK �` TU% KPB9KwO �") ( KwB (9%'&!( {�3�BH07KwBHN:C % K�N"G+� . 3�I % 35N"G') � # � �:{pI4K %'& G � # ��� �a� &�. G % 35N"G') � # � � � �:{� # � �*� u � . l�K=I4K %'& x�K B9K ( ,JB . K�G & N"N (9% K & ,`� �"N�� & B9CMB9KwO �") ( KwBH) ( 3 (9% K �:B � . � ( � & N�x & N",JK�)w� (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0I43�B @ ) & ) & GJx�KwB ( �")vK�G � . l�350768, ( � . O � # �hoe073`G"�hp u ,JR ( B & l ( �:3 . )>l &�. RSK �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�G RhC BH, .'. � . O& G'G � ( �:3 . l �:BHlw, � ( ) R & l @ I & BHG') 1435076 & B �")v3 . ) l &�. RSKpl & B9B �:K�Go35, ( RhC )9,JR ( B & l ( � . O-3 . Kpx & N",JK4{�B9350 &�. 3 (9% KwB&�. G l % K�l @ � . O (9% K70735) ( ) �:O . �CB�l &�./( R � ( {�3�B>, . GJKwB � 3�I TU% K {�35N"N:3�I � . O l �:BHlw, � ( G � & O�B & 0 �"N"N",') ( B &!( K�) (9% K& RS3�x�K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 D

��� ������ ���

� �

�������

��� �

��� �

�� �

��

�� �� � �

��� � �

o Vh "��? pTU% K ( B �"l @ KwB9C � . (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") (9%'&!( (9% KKdYO \mETX 9 JgETSUL;V l &�.'. 3 ( RSK & l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N�3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . D (9% K & N �O�3�B � (9% 0�l &�.'. 3 ( l % 3h35)vK7I % K (9% KwB=3�B . 3 (-( 3 )9,JR ( B & l ( � & ) (9% �")FI435,'N"G N:K & G ( 3 &�. �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kol % 3 �"l�K73�{l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 6 &!(9% R & )vK�G 3 . (9% K B9K�)9,'N ( 3�{ & l�35076 & B �")v3 .� >jk. ) ( K & G�� � ( 0 &;@ K�) (9% K7)9,JR ( B & l ( �:3 . , . l�3 .��G � ( �:3 .'& N �SR8, ( 0 &;@ K (9% K d f 9�N (9% KPl�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 ..t (9% KP)vI & 6al &�. K & ) �"N:CmRSK �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�G I � (9%T 3;sS35N���O &!( K�)w��) � . l�K � ( �")pK_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:C G &!(9& � � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./(w )�m3�B9K-l�350768N��"l &!( K�GP3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) & B9K & N")v3 I � (9% � . 35,JB � . x�K ./( 3�B9C � ,'N ( �:68N��"l &!( �:3 . � � . R � .'& B9C�� �") & )vKwB �:K�)

3�{ l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G & G'G � ( �:3 . ) t {�3�BpK & l % G �:O � ( � . �8�`K � (9% KwB & G'G & R � (�� ) % �:{ ( K�GMx�KwBH) �:3 . 3�{�� ( 3 (9% KFBH, .'. � . O ( 3 (9& N3�B & G'G �` ���`6S3 . K ./( � &!( �:3 . �")�) �"0 �"N & BHN:C & )vKwB �:K�)�3�{�l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G70o,'N ( �:68N��"l &!( �:3 . ) r43 (9% 3�{ (9% K�)vK 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )l &�. RSK 6SKwB9{�3�BH07K�G 073`G','N:3 � I � (9% &�.'& N:3�O�35,')>073`G �CB�l &!( �:3 . ) ( 3 (9% 35)vKP,')vK�G {�3�B & G'G � ( �:3 . 073`G','N:3 � TU% KwB9K & B9K>0 &�. CM6S35)9) �:R8N:KU3�6 ( �"0 � ��&!( �:3 . )w�`K�)v6SK�l � & N"N:C7{�3�BU)v6 & l�K dTU% K-,')vK-3�{-=vl & B9B9C � ) & x�Kg? ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) ( 36 & B & N"N:K�N�� � K �o � p � � R � (d& G'G � ( �:3 . )w� (9% KF,')vKF3�{ (9% K E'& ) ( E 35,JB �:KwB T B &�. )v{�3�BH0 ( 37)v6SKwK�GM,J6 0o,'N ( �:68N��"l &!( �:3 . )w�&�. G (9% K>,')vK=3�{�0o,'N ( �:68N:K�� � . O ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) ( 3 �"076'B93�x�K (9% K>K_r l �:K . l�C 3�{�073`G','N & B K��`6S3 . K ./( � &!( �:3 . & B9K & N"N6S35)9) �:R8N:K

� � =�? @$@F7>4I7�:8;:037J? @J@/K ? RB=37�K L�2�0 E[46? DJ7�GC@/2�W 7/D>46<�7�? GB0Z4605P�G67�=�:�D )�<GB8;M�K ? <Q4I7�:QP *CGBMN:�D>4I7�? GB0�@]�+�L&2�@/? 0�R $ + W�? 7 �"G��VGBK ?�RU4I7�:@�$? 7�= 460 : 'X7/D>4 )�<GB037/D�GBK *�K ? 0�:BAV? 7 ? @Y46K �J4L @ MNGB@/@/? W�K :*7�G&8&4�U:*4603L�D�:TU:�D�@/? W�K :CM D�GBR6D>468 ? 037�G�4&<GB037/D�GBK K :QP�M D�GBR6D>468ZA �$=�? <>=46<�7�@ 7/D�? TX? 46K K L ? E�7�=�:�: 'X7/D>4�<GB037/D�GBK K ? 0�:�? @,�X] � =�? @YM D�G3<:QP 2 D�:;P G3:@ 0�G67Y@/<Q46K :;@/G�� :K K 7�G�0�:@F7�:QP <GB05P ? 7�? GB0546K�@F7>4I7�:8;:037�@A=�G"� :TU:�DQA @/? 0�<:S? 7JD�:Q132�? D�:@ 2�@/? 0�R��"G��VGBK ?�RU4I7�:@��$? 7�=�8;G6D�: 4605P&8;G6D�:\<GB037/D�GBKVK ? 0�:@]�.�0&RB:0�:�D>46K[A�? 7J? @J2�@/2546K K L&8;G6D�:S:�;<? :0377�G�MN:�D/EHG6D�8 8;? 0�G6D$@/2 D�RB:�D/L�GB0�7�=�:Y46K RBG6D�? 7�=�8;@�� :Y2�@/:Y@/GC7�=54I7$7�=�:�L�4ID�: 468;:0546W�K :S7�G�@F7/D>46? RB=37 + K ? 0�:Y: ' :<2 7�? GB0�]

Page 55: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�������������

� � � ����� � ���� � � � � � ���

�u��� � �.2 ����� / &*2���(*)! ,+-".)0/ � �.2 ���. ,/4/4$�+��

� �:x�K . (9% K @ � . G')U3�{dl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) �h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( )+l &�. l & B9B9C 35, ( � (9% K . K�� ( �"076S3�B (9&�./( l %'& N"N:K . O�K �")GJK ( KwBH0 � . � . O % 3�I RSK�) (~( 3KH'lYNPX'HYd�d (9% KFl �:BHlw, � ( {�3�B & O �:x�K . l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� ~TU% �") �") (9% K (9& ) @ 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . ON &�. O5, & O�K�) %'& x�K ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N"N:C�l & B9B �:K�G35, ( �=RhC 6'B93�x �"G � . O & % ,'0 &�.�� � ./( K�N"N��:O �:R8N:K {�3�BH0 {�3�Bm)v6SK�l �:{�C � . Ol�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N & l ( �:3 . ) ~TU% K-RSK . K_B ( )p3�{ % �:O %�� N:Kwx�K�N�6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K�) & B9K-I4K�N"N � K�) (9& R8N��") % K�G th(9% K�h,JK�) ( �:3 . �")�I % K (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0 & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K�)�l &�. & N")v3-K . v3�C (9% K�)vK4RSK . K_B ( ) LF) I4K ) %'& N"Nh)vKwK�� (9% K &�. )vI4KwB�") N & B9O�K�N:C C�K�)

����� ��� �V� � �)J � ��� �� � � ��� �� ���)�1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�� 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . Oa{�3�B l �:BHlw, � ( ) o � . ) ( K & G 3�{ {�3�B & O�K . KwB & N � 68,JB96S35)vKmx�3 . � K�,'0 &�.'. 0 & l % � . Kqp�")UB9K & )v3 .'& R8N:C I4K�N"N � , . GJKwBH) ( 3h3`G p@F& BHGJI & B9KoGJK�) �:O . KwBH) & B9K & lwlw,') ( 3507K�G ( 3 ,') � . O % �:O %�� N:Kwx�K�N�GJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 .N &�. O5, & O�K�)�{�3�B�K . l�3`G � . O (9% K �:B�GJK�) �:O . ) � T Ch6 �"l & N"N:C�� (9% K�)vKUN &�. O5, & O�K�)�O�3-{ & B�RSKwC�3 . G 07KwB9K�N:C>K . ,'07KwB &!( � . O(9% K � ./( KwBHl�3 .'. K�l ( �:3 . ) RSK ( I4KwK . � . G �:x �"G', & NpO &!( K�) � .& l�350768N��"l &!( K�G GJK�) �:O .� � &�. O5, & O�K�) N�� @ K �-@ �-�� . lwN",'GJK7)9,J6'6S3�B ( {�3�B & R8) ( B & l ( � . O & I & C {�B9350 (9% K GJK (9& �"N")=3�{ �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O � . G �:x �"G', & N l�35076S3 . K ./( ) 3�{& l �:BHlw, � ( � .f(9% K ) & 07K I & C (9%'&!(7( B & G � ( �:3 .'& NpN &�. O5, & O�K�) � . lwN",'GJK )9,J6'6S3�B ( {�3�B & R8) ( B & l ( � . O & I & C {�B9350(9% KoGJK (9& �"N")U3�{ �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O7{e, . l ( �:3 . ) TU% Kol �:BHlw, � (�� N�� @ K & )v6SK�l ( 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'02l �:BHlw, � ( 073`GJK�N")+GJ3hK�) . 3 (6'B9K�)vK ./(U&�. C {e, . G & 07K ./(9& N"N:C . KwI l %'& N"N:K . O�K�)

����� ��� �V� � �)J � ��� � � ����� � � �)������� �� � ��� ���

jk. ) ( K & G�� � ( �") (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 & )v6SK�l ( ) 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( ) (9%'&!( & B9Ka073�B9K l %'& N"N:K . O � . O �TU% KwB9K & B9K�h, &�./( ,'0<l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )�3 . Kwx�K . & )90 & N"N . ,'0 RSKwB�3�{��h,JR � ( ) I % �"l % %'& x�K . 3-lwN & )9) �"l & N/l�35, ./( KwB96 & B ( ) du ,'l %3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )w�!N�� @ K (9% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 .o&�. G (9% K4l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N�6 %'& )vKd) % �:{ ( � & B9K (9% KdR & ) �"l�R8, �"N"G � . O � R8N:3`l @ )3�{�0735) ( � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) 4u ,'l % & l ( �:3 . )UO�K . KwB & N"N:C � . x�35N:x�K

- ��GXP :�D�0Z=54ID>P �J4ID�:#+�P :? RB0�K 460�RB2546RB:@S46<�7�2546K K L�4I7/7>46<%�<GB0�@/? P :�D>46W�K L�=54ID>P :�D\M D�GBW�K :8;@ 7�=5460�7�=�:YGB0�:@\4I7\? @/@/2�: ? 0Z@/MN:<? +E L ? 0�R;132546037�2�8,<? D�<2�? 7�@A5WN:<Q462�@/:Y<K 46@/@/? <Q46K <? D�<2�? 7�@\<Q460ZWN:BA�4605P�E D�:Q132�:037�K L�4ID�:BA�<�L <K ? <B]

Q/|

Page 56: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

V!� ������� ����� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� � ������ � � ��

� 0 &�. �:68,'N &!( �:3 . )43�{�) (9&!( K oeN�� @ K=6 %'& )vK=B93 (9&!( �:3 . )Yp (9%'&!(+& B9K lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:CM, . GJK ( K�l (9& R8N:K��� 0 &�. �:68,'N &!( �:3 . )�3�{ )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . oeN�� @ K (9% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . p (9%'&!(p& B9K=lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C � . l�3 % KwB9K ./( � )3�B

� (9% Kml�3�B9B9K�N &!( K�G 0 &�. �:68,'N &!( �:3 . 3�{=0o,'N ( �:68N:K �h,JR � ( ) oeN�� @ K (9% K E B9K�G @ � . O &!( Kqp � . & I & C (9%'&!( GJ3hK�). 3 ( N:K . G � ( )vK�N:{ ( 3 (9% K70o,'N ( �:68N:K � � . 68, (�� 3 . K � � . 68, ( 6 & B & G �:O5023�{40 &�. C {�3�BH0 & N�073`GJK�N")U3�{4lwN & )9) �"l & Nl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .�

L2O�3h3`G �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K ) % 35,'N"G 0 &;@ Km,') � . O {e, . G & 07K ./(9& N"N:C �h, &�./( ,'0 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )l�3 . x�K . �:K ./(+&�. G K . l�35,JB & O�K (9% K=6'B93�O�B & 0P07KwB ( 3M,')vK (9% 35)vK>3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) (9% K & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K )9,J6'6S3�B ( ) TU% K�)vKm6'B93�R8N:K�0P) %'& x�K & N")v3aRSKwK . N & B9O�K�N:C )v35N:x�K�G TU%'&!( & l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& NU6 %'& )vKmB93 (9&!( �:3 . & N ( KwBH) &�.

� . G �:x �"G', & N �h,JR � ( � ) ) (9&!( K � . &�. =v, . GJK ( K�l (9& R8N:Kg?7I & C �")p3 . N:C & 6'B93�R8N:K�0 �:{�3 . K � . ) �") ( ) (9%'&!(+& N"N�x & B � & R8N:K�)0o,') ( RSK ( B &�. )v6 & B9K ./(d&�. G & N"N (9% K �:B~6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) &�. G0B8K�N"G')�0o,') ( RSKUx �") �:R8N:K &!(4& N"N ( �"07K�) dW R�vK�l (�� 3�B �:K ./( K�G6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . OmB9K vK�l ( )P)9,'l % GJK�0 &�. G')w��K�) (9& R8N��") % � . O & . 3 ( �:3 . 3�{+3�6 & �h,JK 3�R�vK�l ( ) I % 35)vK l�3 ./( K ./( )Ml &�.3 . N:CmRSK � . )v6SK�l ( K�G 3�B & N ( KwB9K�G (9% B935,JO % l�KwB (9& � . � ./( KwB9{ & l�KP{e, . l ( �:3 . ) L . 3�R�vK�l (�� 3�B �:K ./( K�G & 6'6'B93 & l % ( 3�h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O ( B9K &!( ) �h,JR � ( ) & )>3�R�vK�l ( )mD (9% K �:B>l�3 ./( K ./( )ol &�. 3 . N:C RSK & lwl�K�)9)vK�GaRhC & 6'68N:C � . O, . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) ( 3 (9% K�0 3�B RhC 07K & )9,JB � . O (9% K�0 L�l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N�6 %'& )vKM) % �:{ ( ��{�3�BoK�� & 0768N:K��& N ( KwBH) (9% K � ./( KwB .'& NJ) (9&!( K+3�{ & �h,JR � (mt5(9% KwB9K �") . 389,NPXYSUL;XYS X'H'9qdmL;V I % C )9,'l %P&�.M& l ( �:3 . ) % 35,'N"G . K�l�K�)9) & B �"N:Cl %'&�. O�K (9% KPx & N",JKP3�{ & )9,JR8)vK �h,JK ./( 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( o�I % �"l % �") 9,') ( &�. 3 (9% KwB & l ( �:3 .f& l ( � . Om3 .a& �h,JR � ( p TU% �") & 6'6'B93 & l % 0 &!( l % K�)+35,JBUl �:BHlw, � ( 07K (9& 6 % 3�BUx�KwB9C I4K�N"N t`(9% KK=kO &!( K�)'?MI % �"l % & B9K>68N & l�K�G & l�B935)9)U3 . K=3�B073�B9Kh=vN�� . K�)'?MRSK�l�3507K {e, . l ( �:3 . )+I % �"l % 3�6SKwB &!( K73 . �h,JR � ( )w��I % KwB9K (9% K �h,JR � ( ) & B9K (9% 35,JO %/( 3�{ & )-B'�`K�G� . 68N & l�KTU%'&!( l�KwB (9& � . �h, &�./( ,'0�3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) & B9K lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:CMR � ��& B9B9K � . (9% K �:BUK_sSK�l ( ) �") &�. �")9)9,JK (9%'&!(F. 376'B93 �

O�B & 0P0 � . OFN &�. O5, & O�K l &�. K ./( �:B9K�N:C & x�3 �"G r4C>RSK � . O+6'B9K�l �")vK & RS35, ( I %'&!( I4KpB9K & N"N:C=I &�./( {�B9350 & �h, &�./( ,'06'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O7N &�. O5, & O�K�� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� � ( �") 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3M0 &;@ K )v3507K>6'B93�O�B9K�)9) ~#% KwB9K (9% KK=k6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O ?& 6'6'B93 & l % R'B9K &;@ )FGJ3�I . �") � . (9% K8dgH_M9;V ETSUJ_dU3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'026'B93�O�B & 0 �-,JK ( 3 K_sSK�l ( )-3�{~)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 .&�. G l�3�B9B9K�N &!( �:3 . RSK ( I4KwK . G �CsSKwB9K ./( �h,JR � ( )w� (9% K>) (9&!( ,') 3�{ & 6'B93�O�B & 0�l &�.'. 3 ( RSK-B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G 07KwB9K�N:CMRhC(9% K ) (9&!( ,')F3�{ & N"N (9% Kox & B � & R8N:K�) � .m(9% Ko6'B93�O�B & 0 -E ,JB (9% KwB���K & l % 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . & l ( ) & ) & , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�B �0 &!( �:3 . 3 .P(9% K+x�K�l ( 3�B )v6 & l�KU3�{ (9% KUK ./( �:B9KFl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � . 3 ( 9,') ( 3 .P(9% KF)v6 & l�K+3�{ (9% K �h,JR � ( ) � ( G �:B9K�l ( N:C.'& 07K�) dW-.P(9% KU3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� (9% K � . G �:x �"G', & NPL�N H_X 9RETSUL;VId43�{ (9% KFN &�. O5, & O�K+l &�.'. 3 ( o &�. G � . GJKwK�GP0o,') (d. 3 ( p� . )v6SK�l ( (9% K>O5N:3�R & N�) (9&!( ,')+3�{ (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � � . 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�� � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( G �CsSKwB9K ./( ( KwBH0P) � . &)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 .� TU%'&!( ) & �"G�� (9% K B9K & N 6S3�I4KwBM3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )v6'B � . O5)o{�B9350 (9% K�)vK . 3 .�� N:3`l & NpK_sSK�l ( )mD RhC

l & B9B9C � . OM35, (=& )vKwB �:K�)+3�{d) ( B & �:O %/( {�3�B9I & BHG &�. G N:3`l & N�� � K�G ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )w� � ( �")F6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./(& 073�B9K � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O , . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 3 . (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 & ) & I % 35N:K }~B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K�) & B9K& 073 . O (9% K ( 3h35N")~,')vKw{e,'Nh{�3�Bd)v6SK�l �:{�C � . O (9% K�)vKUN:3`l & N ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) � . & lwN:K & B &�. G7l�3 . l �")vKUI & C L�O�3h3`G)vK�0 &�./( �"ldGJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . 3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . OUN &�. O5, & O�KdI �"N"N & N"N:3�If,') ( 3+B9K & )v3 . 6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C & RS35, (�(9% KK_sSK�l ( )U3�{ & 6'B93�O�B & 0 ~@ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% K=6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K � ( )vK�N:{�)9,'lwl�KwK�G') �:{ � ( & N"N:3�I+) ,') ( 376'B93`G','l�K,')vKw{e,'Nh6'B93�O�B & 0P)�I � (9% 35, (�%'& x � . O ( 3>K��`68N��"l � ( N:C=IUB � ( K GJ3�I .7(9% K % �:O %�� G �"07K . ) �:3 .'& N ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) (9% KwC�"0768N:K�07K ./( � � .m(9% K7) & 07K I & C (9%'&!( lwN & )9) �"l & N 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K�)=GJ3 . 3 ( B9K �h, �:B9Ko,') ( 3 K��`68N��"l � ( N:CN��") (p(9% K �:B K_sSK�l ( )+3 . Kwx�KwB9C 6S35)9) �:R8N:K � . 68, (w

� � =�: � 4BP�468&4ID>P;D�G67>4I7�? GB0Z? @$<K 46@/@/? <Q46K K L�46W�@/2 D>P�WN:<Q462�@/:Y<Q460�<Q462�@/: 4C<GB8;M�2 7>4I7�? GB0�? 0�GB0�:Y@F7>4I7�: 7�GC@/M�K ? 7\? 037�G�4*@/2�MN:�D +MNGB@/? 7�? GB0�G6E 7 � G;P ? @F7�? 0�<�7\@F7>4I7�:@��$=�? <>=Z<Q460Z0�GB0�:�7�=�:K :@/@$@F7�? K K 4 �V:<�7\:Q46<>=ZG67�=�:�DQ]

Page 57: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ��� ���������� �� ������� �!��� � ��� ������� � � ��� � � ��� ��� V`�

TU% ,')w� ( 3>B9K ( ,JB .7( 3 (9% K �")9)9,JKp3�{SB9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( � . O-6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )w�/)9,'l %7( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )~l &�.,'N ( �"0 &!( K�N:CmRSKPO �:x�K . � . (9% KM{�3�BH0 3�{ (9% KM0 &!( B � � )v6SK�l �:{�C � . O (9% K �:B>K_sSK�l ( )o3 . (9% K �h,JR � ( ) (9% KwC G �:B9K�l ( N:C.'& 07K �~x�KwB9C 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . OaN &�. O5, & O�K %'& ) & N:Kwx�K�N+3�{=6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )PI % 35)vK �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 .�") . 3 N:3 . O�KwB K��`6'B9K�)9)vK�G � . (9% KMN &�. O5, & O�K u C`) ( K�0 l & N"N")w� )vC ./(9& l ( �"lP6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�)=N�� @ K # ��GJK�lwN & B &!( �:3 . )>3�{K�� ( KwB .'& N"N:C � GJK_B . K�G {e, . l ( �:3 . )w� &�. G & )9)vK�0 R8N:C � N &�. O5, & O�KM)vKwO507K ./( ) & B9K & N"N ( Ch6 �"l & N~6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�)F{�3�B ( B & G � �( �:3 .'& N N &�. O5, & O�K�) E 3�B & �h, &�./( ,'0sN &�. O5, & O�K�� (9% Kp6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�) & B9K (9% 35)vKpR & ) �"l4, . � (9& B9C=3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )�6SKwBH0 � (v( K�G RhC (9% K46 & B �

( �"lw,'N & B �h, &�./( ,'0 �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 .P&!(4%'&�. G �TU% K+)vK �h,JK . l�K+3�{ � � q�68,'N")vK�) �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O & l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G ��=W-T 3�B & @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . & B9KPK_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:C &!( 350 �"lP, . � ( )F3�{pl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . {�B9350 &�. 6'B93�O�B & 0P07KwB � )6S3 � ./( 3�{�x �:KwI>� 9,') (U& ) (9% K �h,JR � ( �") (9% K &!( 350 �"l>, . � ( 3�{�) ( 3�B & O�K �TU% K � ./( KwB .'& N")=3�{ (9% K�)vKM6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�)-I435,'N"G RSK �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 .�� )v6SK�l �CB�l W-. &�. � � q � R & )vK�Gfl�350 �

68, ( KwB���)9,'l % 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K-I435,'N"G RSK ( B &�. )9N &!( K�G � ./( 3 )vK �h,JK . l�K�)U3�{�68,'N")vK�) UW-.m&�.m&�. C�3 .�� R & )vK�G l�350768, ( KwB��(9% KwC I435,'N"G RSK ( B &�. )9N &!( K�G � ./( 37)vK �h,JK . l�K�) 3�{ l�3 . 9,JO &!( �:3 . ) dE 3�B (9% 35)vK>GJ3 � . Oo{�3�BH0 & N�)vK�0 &�./( �"lw) 3�{ )9,'l %N &�. O5, & O�K�)w� (9% K 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�Ko3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )FI435,'N"G RSK K . l�3`GJK�G G �:B9K�l ( N:C & )>0 &!( B �"l�K�) oE 3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 ) �"0o,'N & �( 3�BH)w�~3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . K & l % l�35,'N"G & N")v3 RSK & )9)v3`l � &!( K�G I � (9%f& B &�. O�K 3�{U6S35)9) �:R8N:KPKwB9B93�BH) TU% KM6S3 � ./( �") (9%'&!((9% K�)vKP6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�) & B9K (9% KP6S3 � ./(=&!( I % �"l % (9% Kj=v0 & l % � . K � � . GJKw6SK . GJK . l�Kg? 3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . ON &�. O5, & O�K=) ( 3�68) �j ( �")dKwx�K . 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 �"0 & O � . K �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) � . I % �"l %M(9% K�)vK-6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O 6'B �"0 � �( �:x�K�)�I435,'N"G & , ( 350 &!( �"l & N"N:CoO�K . KwB &!( KUKwB9B93�B � l�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) & N:3 . O=I � (9%o(9% K % �:O % KwB � N:Kwx�K�Nh{e, . l ( �:3 . )(9% KwC �"0768N:K�07K ./(w TU% K B .'& N 6'B93�R8N:K�0 .'& 07K�G & RS3�x�K�� (9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0�{e, . l ( �:3 . )w�'RhC & sSK�l ( � . O 0o,'N ( �:68N:K �h,JR � ( )w�JB9K �h, �:B9K

0o,'N ( �:68N:KFB9K ( ,JB . x & N",JK�)w� �") (9% K>N:K & ) ( )vKwB �:35,') �� ,'07KwB935,') lwN & )9) �"l & N�6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . Oo6 & B & G �:O50P) %'& x�K RSKwK .GJKwx �")vK�G ( 3mK .'& R8N:KP0o,'N ( �:68N:K B9K ( ,JB . x & N",JK�) E , . l ( �:3 . ) � . N &�. O5, & O�K�)>I � (9% N��") ( )8o�3�B & G % 3`lPN��") ( )-R8, �"N (I � (9% 6S3 � ./( KwBH)Yp~l &�. B9K ( ,JB . & N��") ( 3�{ B9K ( ,JB . x & N",JK�)4I % �"l % �") (9% K . GJK�) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K�G RhC (9% K=l & N"N�� . O {e, . l ( �:3 . D� . N &�. O5, & O�K�)4I � (9% ) ( B93 . O ( Ch6 � . O &�. GM6 &!(v( KwB .�� 0 &!( l % � . OJ� (9% �")d6'B93`l�K�)9) �")d6 & B ( �"lw,'N & BHN:C7) ( B & �:O %/( {�3�B9I & BHG E , . l ( �:3 . ) � . N &�. O5, & O�K�)oI � (9% ) �"GJK � K_sSK�l ( )7l &�. =kB9K ( ,JB . ? 0o,'N ( �:68N:K7x & N",JK�) RhCa073`G �:{�C � . O x & B � & R8N:K�) o�3�BN:3`l &!( �:3 . )YpF6 & )9)vK�G ( 3 (9% K�0 �FK�lwN & B &!( �:x�K N &�. O5, & O�K�) & x�3 �"G (9% KM6'B93�R8N:K�0 & N ( 3�O�K (9% KwB���) � . l�K & ?�� � 68N & l�KB9K�N &!( �:3 . K & ) �"N:CmK��`6'B9K�)9)vK�) (9% K76'B93�6SKwB>l�3 .'. K�l ( �:3 . RSK ( I4KwK . � � . 68, ( �h,JR � ( ) &�. G � 35, ( 68, ( �h,JR � ( ) # K) %'& N"N�)vKwK>K�� & 0768N:K�) � . & N"NS3�{ (9% K�)vK ) ( C`N:K�)URSK�N:3�I

�u��� � ��� ��� +-".$�+�� � 2-+�� +0$ "6 ��� � �. ,+!& �g2�� / #".$'2-+!&

u 3 { & B���I4K %'& x�K l�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )>6S35)9) �:R8N:Ko3 . �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH) (9%'&!(o& B9K �"076S35)9) �:R8N:Ko3 .lwN & )9) �"l & N & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K�) ~@ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% KwB9K & B9K �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KUlwN & )9) �"l & N8l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )d3 . Kwx�K . & )90 & N"N . ,'0 �RSKwBd3�{ R � ( )~I % �"l %M%'& x�K . 3oG �:B9K�l ( �h, &�./( ,'0 l�35, ./( KwB96 & B ( ) pu ,'l % 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )w�hN�� @ K & )9) �:O . 07K ./( � & B9KF3�{ ( K .(9% KUR & ) �"l R8, �"N"G � . O � R8N:3`l @ ) 3�{ 0 &�. C � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O>lwN & )9) �"l & N'l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) LFN (9% 35,JO % � ( �") & N:I & C`)~6S35)9) �:R8N:K( 3�=vl�35076 �"N:Kg? �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KP3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) � ./( 3 & B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KM{�3�BH0 � (9% K l�3�B9K 3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O

��. 7J? @J0�G67$<2 D/D�:037�K L;0�:<:@/@�4ID/L&7�GCM�? 0�P G"�$0�M D�:<? @/:K L��$=�? <>=�M D�? 8;? 7�? TU:@�7�=�:�L&@/=�GB2�K P&? 0�<K 25P :",X7�=�:@/:Y4ID�:YP :�7>46? K @ EHG6DJ7�=�:P :@/? RB0�:�D�@\G6E M54ID/7�? <2�K 4IDSK 460�RB2546RB:@$EHG6DSM54ID/7�? <2�K 4ID\? 8;M�K :8;:037>4I7�? GB0�@ �[G6D$EHG6DSK 460�RB2546RB:@\MNG6D/7>46W�K : 46<�D�GB@/@S@/:TU:�D>46K�? 8;M�K :8;:0 +7>4I7�? GB0�@ �>]��S2 DS<GB0�<:�D�0�=�:�D�: ? @ �$? 7�= :@F7>46W�K ? @/=�? 0�R&7�=54I7\7�=�:Y7�G3GBK @S: ' ? @F7SEHG6D @/2�<>= P :@/? RB0�:�D�@\7�G&P :@/? RB0 K 460�RB2546RB:@ �$=�:0Z7�=�:0�::QP�4ID�? @/:@AN7�=54I7\7�=�:�D�:*4ID�:*0�G;8;G6D�:YEH2�05P�468;:037>46K�M D�GBW�K :8;@J7�=54I7S@F7>4605PZ? 0Z7�=�: �J4L3] � D�:Q46@/GB0546W�K :*@/:�7 G6E�M D�? 8;? 7�? TU:@JEHG6D4�=54ID>P �J4ID�:#+ ? 05P :MN:05P :037Y132546037�2�8 K 460�RB2546RB: � GB2�K P M D�GBW546W�K L ? 0�<K 25P :�4�<GB037/D�GBK K :QP +������ RU4I7�:BA 4&E[468;? K L G6E <GB05P ? 7�? GB0546KD�G67>4I7�? GB0�@AN4605P�4 E[468;? K L�G6E <GB05P ? 7�? GB0546K�M�=546@/: @/=�? E 7�@A�:Q46<>=�G6E��$=�? <>= � GB2�K P�WN:YP :�O50�:QP�P ? �V:�D�:037�K L3A P :MN:05P ? 0�RCGB0�7�=�:S@/MN:#+<? O5<C132546037�2�8 <GB8;M�2 7�:�DSWN:? 0�R;7>4ID�RB:�7�:QPV]��\7�=�:�DSRU4I7�:@A�K ? U: �"G��VGBK ? RU4I7�:@ G6DY2�0�<GB05P ? 7�? GB0546K � 4BP�468&4ID>PZD�G67>4I7�? GB0�@A�<GB2�K PWN:Y? 8;M�K :8;:037�:QP&46@$@FL 037>46<�7�? <Y@/2�RU4IDS4I7�GBM�7�=�? @$M D�? 8;? 7�? TU: K 4L3:�DQ]

Page 58: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

V�? ������� ����� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� � ������ � � ��

N &�. O5, & O�KP) % 35,'N"G B9K�)v6SK�l (=(9% KMN��"0 � ( )+3�{ (9% K & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K � ( BH, . )F3 . &�. G G �")9l�35,JB & O�K (9% K76'B93�O�B & 0P07KwB{�B9350 Kwx�K .o(9% � .I@ � . O � . . 3 .�� , . � (9& B9C ( KwBH0P) j GJK & N"N:C�� (9% K�)vKpl�3 . ) ( B & � ./( )�) % 35,'N"G=RSK,dY^;V EQ9 JgETSUJmD . 3 .�� , . � (9& B9C3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )U) % 35,'N"G . 3 ( l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G ( 3Px & N��"G 6'B93�O�B & 0P)

��������� � � � ��� � ��� � ����� � �� � � ) � ���� K ( ,')+{�3`lw,')F073�B9K lwN:35)vK�N:C 3 . I %'&!( l & ,')vK�) & 6'B93�O�B & 0 ( 3 )v6SK�l �:{�C . 3 .�� , . � (9& B9C & l ( �:3 . ) -j ( { & �"N") ( 3 RSKB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KPI % K . � ( GJK�) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K�N:C 3�x�KwB9IUB � ( K�) & x & N",JK �m3�B9K O�K . KwB & N"N:C�� &�. Ca) ( Kw6 (9%'&!( l�3 . )9,'07K�) 3 . K3�B 073�B9K x & N",JK�) I � (9% 35, ( 6'B93`G','l � . O 3 (9% KwBox & N",JK�)o)9, r l �:K ./( ( 3 B9K�l�3 . ) ( BH,'l (o(9% K 3�B �:O � .'& N~3 . K�)ol &�.'. 3 (RSK , . GJ3 . K }~B93�x �"GJK�G (9% K�)vK l�350768, ( K�G x & N",JK�) & B9K (9% K�0P)vK�N:x�K�)Ml�3 . )vKwB9x�K�G � . & ) �"0 �"N & Bo{ & ) % �:3 . � (9% K3�B �:O � .'& Nd3 . K�) I �"N"N~RSK�� & N")v3 L2073�B9K )9,JR ( N:KM6S3 � ./( �") (9%'&!( � ( �") �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 6'B93`G','l�KFS<VPZaH N H_VPZaH_V El�3�6 �:K�)o3�{ �h,JR � ( ) j ( �")o6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 6'B93`G','l�K l�3�6 �:K�)w� ( BH,JK��~R8, (o(9% K�)vK l�3�6 �:K�) & B9K K ./(9&�. O5N:K�GfI � (9%f(9% K3�B �:O � .'& N") � �:KwI4K�G & ) & l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( 3 . 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )w� (9% �")-{ & l ( �")=07KwB9K�N:C (9% K ( �"07K � B9Kwx�KwBH)vK�G x �:KwI 3�{ (9% K6'B9Kwx �:35,')pl�3 . ) ( B & � ./( D & )vK ( 3�{ � . 68, ( )4l &�.'. 3 ( 6'B93`G','l�KF35, ( 68, ( )pI � (9% O�B9K &!( KwB � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l�3 ./( K ./(U(9%'&�.(9% K � . 68, ( ) j ( �") �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K4RS3 (9%M( 3 (9% B93�I & I & C (9% KFx & N",JK�)~3�{��h,JR � ( ) &�. G ( 3o6'B93`G','l�K (9% K�0 H'l0V S GaS<:iL jk. RS3 (9% G �:B9K�l ( �:3 . )w� �:{ K & l % ) ( Kw6m3�{ & 6'B93�O�B & 0 �")U, . � (9& B9C�� (9% K>6'B93�O�B & 0 & ) & I % 35N:K=I �"N"N�RSK #%'&!(7(9% �") &�.'& N:C`) �") )9,JO�O�K�) ( ) �") (9%'&!(P(9% K B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./(o(9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0 ) (9&!( K Kwx�35N:x�K � . & , . � (9& B9C

0 &�.'. KwBPl &�. RSK B9Kw6 % B & )vK�G & ) & l�3 . G � ( �:3 . 3 . (9% K 6SKwBH0 �")9) �:R8N:KP3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) 3 . �h,JR � ( ) TU% K B9K �h, �:B9K �07K ./( )U3�{ B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R �"N�� ( C & B9K & ET^�N H �'\'9qdgH'Zol�3 . ) ( B & � ./( 3 . (9% K=I & C � . I % �"l % �h,JR � ( ) l &�. RSK>l�350 R � . K�G &�. G0 &�. �:68,'N &!( K�G TU% �")+I & C 3�{d6 % B & ) � . O (9% KP)vK�l�3 . G l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( 6S3 � ./( ) (9% K7I & C j ( B9K � K�l ( ) (9% KPlwN & )9) �"l & N& 6'6'B93 & l % ,')9, & N"N:C (9&;@ K . � . GJK & N�� . O I � (9%a( Ch6 � . O aTU% K � � 6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % C (9%'&!( = # K�N"N � ( Ch6SK�G 6'B93�O�B & 0P)l &�.'. 3 ( O�3>IUB93 . OJ� ?o)9,JO�O�K�) ( ) & ) �"0 �"N & B�G �"l ( ,'0 (9%'&!( =v� 3`l & N"N:C � , . � (9& B9Co6'B93�O�B & 0P)dl &�.'. 3 ( O�3 IUB93 . OJ� ?>{�3�B(9% K �h, &�./( ,'0�GJ350 & � .� TU% K & 6'6'B93 & l % (9&;@ K . � . {e, . l ( �:3 .'& N�N &�. O5, & O�K�)>3�{ l�3 . ) �"GJKwB � . O x & B � & R8N:K�) & )VP9;M8HYd=B &!(9% KwB (9%'&�.a& )

) ( 3�B & O�K N:3`l &!( �:3 . ) ( ,JB . )-35, (>( 3 RSK (9% KM0735) ( {�BH, � ( {e,'N I & C 3�{4{�3�BH0 & N�� � � . O (9% K7B �:O %/( l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( ) 7jk. &�h, &�./( ,'0 l�3 ./( K�� ( �dx & B � & R8N:K�) RSK�l�3507K 07K &�. � . O�{e,'N~I % K .a(9% KwC & B9K & )9)v3`l � &!( K�GfI � (9%a(9% K l�3 ./( K ./( )73�{ &�h,JR � ( � � K I % K .o(9% KwC & B9K RS35, . G ( 3 (9% K B9K ( ,JB . x & N",JK�)�3�B ( 3={�3�BH0 & N`6 & B & 07K ( KwBH)�3�{8{e, . l ( �:3 . ) �~& B � & R8N:K�)RSK�l�3507K 07K &�. � . O5N:K�)9) & O & � . 3 . l�K (9% K �h,JR � ( ) ( 3 I % �"l % (9% KwC B9Kw{�KwB %'& x�K RSKwK . & N ( KwB9K�Gm3�B-6S35)9) �:R8N:C RSKwK .K ./(9&�. O5N:K�G I � (9% 3 (9% KwB �h,JR � ( )w� � K I % K .M(9% KwC %'& x�K-RSKwK . ,')vK�G & ) � . 68, ( ) ( 3o{e, . l ( �:3 . )~3�B4RSKwK . B9K ( ,JB . K�G{�B9350 & {e, . l ( �:3 .� jk. (9% KPl �:BHlw, � ( 07K (9& 6 % 3�B�� K & l % 6 �:K�l�K 3�{!=kI �:B9Kg? BH, .'. � . OM{�B9350�3 . K O &!( K ( 3 &�. 3 (9% KwB�")=O �:x�K .a& G �") ( � . l (>.'& 07K u Kwx�KwB & N~{e, . l ( �:3 .'& N~N &�. O5, & O�K�) � � � . K & B � j9u } &�. G 143 . lw,JB9B9K ./( 1pN:K &�. �{�K &!( ,JB9K-)9,'l % l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( )w� & N (9% 35,JO % 3 . N:CM143 . lw,JB9B9K ./( 1pN:K &�.�� ) �"0768N:K�07K ./( ) (9% K�0 & ) ( Ch6 � . O BH,'N:K�)w�/,') � . O)v3 � l & N"N:K�GhO V S �mO H_V6HYd�duET^�N HYd

��������� � � ��� � � � ��� � � ) � �TU% K>143 . lw,JB9B9K ./( 1pN:K &�. & 6'6'B93 & l % �") ( 3 & N"N:3�I>� & ) &o( Ch6SK-073`G �CB8KwB�� & , . ��h,JK . K�)9) &!(v( B �:R8, ( K��JGJK . 3 ( K�G RhC6'B9Kw6SK . G � . O &�.M& ) ( KwB �") @ ( 3 (9% K ( Ch6SK ( 3 RSKU0 & B @ K�G & )4, . ��h,JK �uh( B �"l ( KwB~BH,'N:K�) & 6'68N:C ( 3 x & B � & R8N:K�) ��& O�O�K�G& ) %'& x � . O , . ��h,JK ( Ch6SK (9%'&�.f( 3 3�BHG � .'& B9C x & B � & R8N:K�) TU% KwCa0 & C . 3 ( RSK ,')vK�G & ) B9x & N",JK�)o073�B9K (9%'&�.3 . l�K I � (9% � . (9% K )9l�3�6SK � . I % �"l % (9% KwC & B9K GJK_B . K�G��8, . N:K�)9) (9% K �:B+,')vK�) & B9K>6'B93�x & R8N:C 0o, ( , & N"N:CMK��JlwN",') �:x�Ko�3 . ( I43a)vKw6 & B &!( K & BH0P) 3�{ &�. = �:{ � (9% K .�� K�N")vKg? ) (9&!( K�07K ./( �4{�3�B7K�� & 0768N:Kqp E ,JB (9% KwB��~I % K .f(9% K �:B7x & N",JK�)& B9KP6 & )9)vK�G � ./( 3 &�. 3 (9% KwBol�3 ./( K�� ( ��I % K (9% KwB (9% B935,JO % N:K (�� R � . G � . O 3�B & ) & B9O5,'07K ./( ) ( 3 & {e, . l ( �:3 . � (9% Kx & B � & R8N:K�)�I % �"l %P& B9K+RS35, . G ( 3 % 35N"G (9% K �:B~x & N",JK�)d0o,') (4& N")v3>RSK+GJK�lwN & B9K�GM, . ��h,JK��5)v3 (9%'&!(4& , . ��h,JKpx & N",JKGJ3hK�) . 3 ( RSK�l�3507K . 3 .�� , . ��h,JK (9% B935,JO % B9K .'& 0 � . O

Page 59: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ��� ���������� �� ������� �!��� � ��� ������� � � ��� � � ��� ��� V�D

� . ��h,JK . K�)9) ( Ch6SK�)oI4KwB9K 3�B �:O � .'& N"N:C � ./( B93`G','l�K�G � ./( 3 143 . lw,JB9B9K ./( 1pN:K &�. � & N &�� �"N:C Kwx & N", &!( K�G ( Ch6SK�G{e, . l ( �:3 .'& N56'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . OUN &�. O5, & O�K�� & ) & I & C>3�{ � . l�3�B96S3�B &!( � . O+) (9&!( Kw{e,'N/3�R�vK�l ( ) � ./( 3 & 68,JB9K�N:C-{e, . l ( �:3 .'& Nl�3 ./( K�� ( I � (9% 35, (U& )9) �:O . 07K ./(w ~TU% K>lwN & )9) �"l-K�� & 0768N:K �") � ./( KwB9{ & l � . O ( 3 & B�N:K t'& { ( KwBFl & N"N�� . O

����� ��� o ! : H�� � � � p! : H . 3 N:3 . O�KwB %'& ) (9% K ) & 07K x & N",JK (9%'&!( � ( G �"GaRSKw{�3�B9K (9% K IUB � ( K l & N"N aTU% K ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N & 6'6'B93 & l % � .{e, . l ( �:3 .'& N �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . ) �") ( 3f)vKw6 & B &!( K ) ( 3�B9K N:3`l &!( �:3 . )M{�B9350 (9% Kmx & N",JK�) % K�N"G � . (9% K�0 � &�. G ( 3073`G �:{�C (9% 35)vKPx & N",JK�)-I � (9% GJK�) ( BH,'l ( �:x�KP,J6�G &!( K�)w� &!(>(9% KPl�35) ( 3�{pN:35) � . O B9Kw{�KwB9K ./( � & N ( B &�. )v6 & B9K . l�C 7TU% K�"GJK & RSK % � . G , . ��h,JK . K�)9) ( Ch6 � . O �") (9%'&!(F& { ( KwB (9% K>IUB � ( K�� ! : H . 3MN:3 . O�KwB+K�� �") ( )mD4I %'&!( I4K %'& x�K . 3�I �") &G �CsSKwB9K ./( 3�R�vK�l ( �'I % �"l % B9K �h, �:B9K�) & G �CsSKwB9K ./( VP9;M8H dTU% K={�35N"N:3�I � . O7l�3`GJK>{�B & O507K ./( K��`6'B9K�)9)vK�) (9% �") �"GJK & D

� �� ! : H��" ����� ��� o � S<: H�� � � � p� � ( ( (

@ KwB9K�� ! : H &�. G ! : H� � &�. G (9% K B8BH) ( 6 & B & 07K ( KwB &�. G (9% K>B9K ( ,JB . x & N",JK=3�{ ����� ��� � 0o,') ( RSK ��& O�O�K�G & ), . ��h,JK TU% KMl�35076 �"N:KwBol &�. ) (9&!( �"l & N"N:C K . {�3�BHl�K (9% �")>B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( & ) 6 & B ( 3�{ & , . �CB�l &!( �:3 .�� R & )vK�G ( Ch6SKl % K�l @ ) (9& O�K LFN (9% 35,JO % )v3507KMl & B9KM0o,') ( RSK (9&;@ K . � . O�K (v( � . O K�� & l ( N:C B �:O %/(=(9% KMl�3�B9B9K�l ( 6'B93�6 & O &!( �:3 .3�{�, . ��h,JK . K�)9)4x & N",JK�)pI % K . l�35076S3 . K ./( ) 3�{ % �:O % KwB � 3�BHGJKwB ( Ch6SK�) & B9K>0 & B @ K�G & )U, . ��h,JK��`l�3 . ) �") ( K ./(+&�. Gl�3 % KwB9K ./(~& N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)�{�3�B�l % K�l @ � . O>, . ��h,JK . K�)9) & B9KpO�K . KwB & N"N:C ) ( B & �:O %/( {�3�B9I & BHG 143 . lw,JB9B9K ./( 1pN:K &�. ��,') � . O, . ��h,JK . K�)9) ( Ch6SK�) � . 68N & l�K 3�{ & )9) �:O . 07K ./( � %'& ) RSKwK . ,')vK�G ( 3 �"0768N:K�07K ./( )vKwx�KwB & Np)vC`) ( K�0P)w� � . lwN",'G � . O0735) ( 3�{ & )90 & N"NS3�6SKwB &!( � . OP)vC`) ( K�0 TU% Kol�3 . ) ( B & � ./( )+3�{d, . � (9& B9C ( �"07K � Kwx�35N", ( �:3 . l &�. RSK>K . {�3�BHl�K�G RhC 0 &;@ � . O �h,JR � ( )+, . ��h,JK ( Ch6SK�) &�. G

)9,JR�vK�l ( � . O (9% K�0 ( 3 (9% K & G'G � ( �:3 .'& N B9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 .m(9%'&!(-(9% KwC 0o,') ( RSK ,')vK�G H'la9 JgET: ^o3 . l�K � .m(9% K7)9l�3�6SK � .I % �"l % (9% KwC & B9K7GJK_B . K�G���B &!(9% KwB (9%'&�. 9RE,MLqd_E�3 . l�K � L (=(9% �")-6S3 � ./( � (9% KPl�3�B9B9K�l ( RSK %'& x �:3�B={ & N"N")F35, (073�B9KF3�B N:K�)9) & , ( 350 &!( �"l & N"N:C 143 . ) �"GJKwB (9% KF{�35N"N:3�I � . O {e, . l ( �:3 .'& N'68)vK�,'GJ3`l�3`GJK+{�3�B (9% K=073`G','N & B & G'G � ( �:3 .& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�B9350 (9% K>6'B9Kwx �:35,') l %'& 6 ( KwBgD

�� ������ ��� � . 68N & l�K 073`G','N & B & G'G o �/B9KwO & � �/B9KwO7R6p "� �� . "�� ��� ��� ��� ���� oelwN & )9) �"l & N . pH�� "�� ��� ��� ��� ���� o � pH�l�"�� ��� ��� ��� ��� � o � p � �� �� oe0 � . ,JK . G��`R � p " � . 68N & l�K & G'G o & � R6p � �� �� o .�� �80 � . ,JK . G � �`l � p "sl�35076 & B9K O ( o . �80 � . ,JK . G��Jlcp � �� �� oelm?`��)9,JR ( B &�% K . G��`)v6 & B9Kqp "sl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G )vI & 6 oel � � . � � p � �� �� o�B9K�0 & � . GJKwB��J)9,JR ( B &�% K . G � p " � ����� � . 68N & l�K & G'G oe0 � . ,JK . G � � )9,JR ( B &�% K . GPp � �� �� oelm? � � ��� � � ��� � ���� oelwN & )9) �"l & N . pH� ��� � � ��� � ���� o � p p "sl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G ) & IU6 oelm?`�8)9,JR ( B &�% K . G � �J)v6 & B9Kqp � �� �� o�B9K�)9,'N ( �JR ?`� ��� � � ��� � ��� � o � p p "sl�35076 & B9K O ( o�B9K�0 & � . GJKwB��JR � �'lm? � p � �o�B9K�)9,'N ( �JR ?ap t

� � =�? @&P ? @F7�? 0�<�7�? GB0 D�:TU:Q46K @C7�=�:&E[46<�7QA �$=�? <>= � :Z=54QTU:�=�:�D�:�7�G6EHG6D�:�@ � :M 7;WN:0�:Q4I7�= 7�=�:�D�2�R A�7�=54I7�2�0�? 132�:0�:@/@*7�L MN:@A�46@7�=�:�L 4ID�:�2�@/:QP ? 0 ��GB0�<2 D/D�:037!��K :Q460�AJ4ID�:�D�:Q46K K L W�2�? K 7�GB0 4ZE D>468;: � G6D G6E #" � #*K GBRB? <BA ? 0 �$=�? <>= D�:@/GB2 D�<:@;<Q460�0�G67�WN:P 2�M�K ? <Q4I7�:QPVA W�2 7�<Q460 WN:�P ? @/<Q4ID>P :QPV] � ? 0�:Q4ID � . .�$ ? 0�<G6D�MNG6D>4I7�:@;7/D�2�:�K ? 0�:Q4ID&@/:8&46037�? <@A�D�:Q132�? D�? 0�R : '�46<�7�K L GB0�:Z2�@/:�MN:�DP :�O50�? 7�? GB0�]�(�G6D*M�2 D�MNGB@/:@*G6E\P ? @/<2�@/@/? GB0�A 7�=�GB2�RB=�A%��GB0�<2 D/D�:037&��K :Q460 ? @ 8;G6D�:;2�@/:�EH2�K�WN:<Q462�@/:&? 7C46K K G"�$@CWNG67�=�K ? 0�:Q4ID�4605P2�0 D�:@F7/D�? <�7�:QP�TB4ID�? 46W�K :@S4605P&EHG6D�8C2�K 4I7�:@J7�=�: P ? @F7�? 0�<�7�? GB0Z? 0�7�:�D�8;@JG6E 7�L MN:B]

Page 60: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

V�Q ������� ����� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� � ������ � � ��

��� ������ ���

� �

�������

��� �

��� �

�� �

��� � � ���

���

� �

��� � � �����

����� ��

� � �

��� � � � � ��� ��� � � � � �����

�� � � � ��� �

��

� � � �

�� �� � �

��� � �

o �h "� pTU% K>G �:B9K�l ( l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . GJK . l�K=RSK ( I4KwK .m(9% �")0=k6'B93�O�B & 0? &�. G (9% K l �:BHlw, � ( � ( GJK . 3 ( K�) �"N"N",') ( B &!( K�) &P. ,'0 RSKwB3�{>GJK�) �:B & R8N:K {�K &!( ,JB9K�)M3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�N &�. O5, & O�K�) E �:BH) ( � & )M6'B9350 �")vK�G�� (9% Km3 . K � ( 3 � 3 . K l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . GJK . l�K3�{ .'& 07K�)7I � (9% =kI �:B9K�)w� ?fl�350 R � . K�G I � (9% (9% K l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( )P3�{-, . ��h,JK . K�)9)w� & , ( 350 &!( �"l & N"N:CfK . )9,JB9K�) (9% Kl�3 . )vKwB9x &!( �:3 . 3�{��h,JR � ( ) �u K�l�3 . G��/6 &!(v( KwB .�� 0 &!( l % � . O )9, r l�K�) ( 3>R � . G (9% KU0o,'N ( �:68N:Kpx & N",JK�)�B9K ( ,JB . K�G {�B9350& O &!( K ~TU% Kp3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )A=k6'B9Kw6 & B9Kg? &�. Gh=kB9K�N:K & )vKg? %'&�. G'N:K (9% K � 3�I 3�{8x & N",JK�) & )9)v3`l � &!( K�G7I � (9% ( K�076S3�B & B9C) ( 3�B & O�K B9K ( ,JB . K�G ( 3 � ( ) 3�B �:O � .'& N�) (9&!( K &!(U(9% K>K . G 3�{ (9% K 073`G','N & B & G'G � ( �:3 . {e, . l ( �:3 ..t I4K G �")9lw,')9) (9% K �:B)vK�0 &�./( �"lw)>RSK�N:3�I ME � .'& N"N:C�� . 3 ( K (9%'&!( � ( �") & B9K�N &!( �:x�K�N:C ) �"0768N:K70 &!(v( KwB ( 3mO �:x�K (9% K & RS3�x�K N &�. O5, & O�K &{�3�BH0 & N')vK�0 &�./( �"lw) (9%'&!( )v6SK�l �CB8K�) (9% K & l ( �:3 . 3�{SK & l % 6'B93�O�B & 0 3 .P(9% K @ �"N:RSKwB ( )v6 & l�K+3�{ (9% K+)vC`) ( K�0 �`) � . l�K(9% K-N &�. O5, & O�K =vl�35076 �"N:K�)'? )v37lwN:K &�. N:C � ./( 3 l �:BHlw, � ( {�3�BH0 � &�. G (9% K-)vK�0 &�./( �"lw)43�{ & l�C`lwN��"lFl �:BHlw, � ( ) & B9K �h, � ( K) ( B & �:O %/( {�3�B9I & BHG

��������� � � � ���� �&� � ���� . ��h,JK . K�)9) ( Ch6SK�)pl &�. RSKF68N & l�K�GM3 . & B8BH0 (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�{�3h3 ( � . O (9% B935,JO %M(9% K=,')vKF3�{ : S<V6H'9;XA:iL'kRSUJ ( 3 O �:x�K)vK�0 &�./( �"lw) ( 3 ( Ch6 � . O=)vC`) ( K�0P) (9%'&!( K�0768N:3�C , . ��h,JK . K�)9) l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( ) �jk. N�� . K & B�N:3�O �"l!�5K��`68N��"l � (�& lwl�35, ./( � . O�")p0 & GJK=3�{ (9% K=B9K�)v35,JBHl�K�) ,')vK�G � . O�K . KwB &!( � . O76'B93h3�{e) t � ( �")pl & N"N:K�G>=vN�� . K & B�?oRSK�l & ,')vK-K & l % B9K�)v35,JBHl�K>0o,') (RSK ,')vK�G K�� & l ( N:C 3 . l�K � . (9% Kol�35,JBH)vK>3�{ & 6'B93h3�{ TU% K l�3 ./( B & ) ( RSK ( I4KwK . & N�� . K & BU6'B93h3�{�)vC`) ( K�0 &�. G &�.3�BHG � .'& B9CM6'B93h3�{ )vC`) ( K�0 �") 0735) (+& 6'6 & B9K ./( � . & )vK �h,JK ./( l & N"lw,'N",') )vK (v( � . O jk./( B93`G','l�K�G RhC �FK ./( � K . �')vK �h,JK ./( l & N"lw,'N��8K�0768N:3�C 9,'GJO507K ./( )43�{ (9% K-{�3�BH0�� � ( 3P07K &�. (9%'&!( � �")

6'B93�x & R8N:Ko,') � . O (9% K B9K�)v35,JBHl�K�)-l�3 ./(9& � . K�G � . � #% K . ,')vK�G {�3�B ( Ch6 � . OJ� � ,')9, & N"N:C %'& ) (9% K {�3�BH0 �hD �d�07K &�. � . O (9%'&!( � %'& ) ( Ch6SK��d� &�. G�� (9&;@ K�) (9% K>{�3�BH0�3�{ & )vK �h,JK . l�K>3�{�)9,'l % ) (9&!( K�07K ./( )w� � K �

� " � � D�� � � � ) D�� ) � ( ( ( � � � D�� � ( o �h ? pjk.m( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N ( Ch6 � . O )vC`) ( K�0P)w��� �") & )vK ( 3�{ & )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . ) & RS35, (+(9% K ( Ch6SK�)F3�{~)9,JRSK��`6'B9K�)9) �:3 . )w�8)v3 (9% K{�35N"N:3�I � . O & G'G � ( �:3 .'& N�BH,'N:K�)p3�{ � . {�KwB9K . l�K & B9K>O�K . KwB & N"N:C ,')vK�G.D

� � ��� � ��� �

� � � � ����� ��� ������ �� � � �

� � � � � � � � �

��� ��� �� ���� �� � � ����� � � ��

� ���� �� � � � ��� ���

o �h D p

TU% K K��Jl %'&�. O�K BH,'N:K[o ��� ��� p & N"N:3�I+) & )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . ) ( 3 RSK ,')vK�G � . &�. C�3�BHGJKwB � . 6'B93�x � . O & O�3 & N TU% K)9,JR8) ( � ( , ( �:3 . BH,'N:Kuo � � � � � p�07K &�. ) (9%'&!(~(9% K & )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . )�,')vK�G ( 3>6'B93�x�K & )9,JR'O�3 & N � �/68N",') (9% K & G'G � ( �:3 .'& N& )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . ) ,')vK�G ( 3 6'B93�x�K (9% K 0 & � . O�3 & N � {�B9350 � � & B9K ( 3�O�K (9% KwB )9, r l �:K ./( ( 3 6'B93�x�K � TU% K

Page 61: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ��� ���������� �� ������� �!��� � ��� ������� � � ��� � � ��� ��� V�V

l�3 ./( B & l ( �:3 . BH,'N:K8o � ����� � � �� p & N"N:3�I+) &�.m& )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . ( 3MRSK ,')vK�G 0o,'N ( �:68N:K ( �"07K�) � . 6'B93�x � . O & O�3 & N pTU% KI4K &;@ K . � . O-BH,'N:K-o � � ��� ��� p & N"N:3�I+) (9% K � ./( B93`G','l ( �:3 . 3�{'K�� ( B &-& )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . ) (9%'&!(�& B9K . 3 ( ,')vK�G � . (9% K46'B93h3�{ jk. & N�� . K & B46'B93h3�{�)vC`) ( K�0 � (9% K=l�3 ./( B & l ( �:3 . &�. G I4K &;@ K . � . O BH,'N:K�) & B9K-350 � (v( K�G��')v3 (9%'&!(U& )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . )

0o,') ( RSK G �")9l %'& B9O�K�G H'la9 JgET: ^ L;VPJYH � .m(9% K 6'B93h3�{�3�{ & O�3 & N ># � (9% 35, ( l�3 ./( B & l ( �:3 . � & O �:x�K . & )9)9,'076 ( �:3 .l &�. 3 . N:CMRSK>,')vK�G � . 3 . K=68N & l�K t I � (9% 35, ( I4K &;@ K . � . OJ� � ( 0o,') ( RSK>,')vK�G � . &!( N:K & ) ( 3 . K=68N & l�K E 3�B�K�� & 0768N:K���l�3 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K4{�35N"N:3�I � . OU{�B & O507K ./( 3�{ & ) �"0768N:K ( Ch6 � . OF)vC`) ( K�0 {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 K��`6'B9K�)9) �:3 . )

@ KwB9K�� &�. G�� & B9K ( Ch6SK=x & B � & R8N:K�)w� &�. G (9% K>6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K ( Ch6SK *<B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( ) & �h,JR � (w �#" D`*

�%" D`*

������� Dh*�� * � *�� *

�FD � �FD �� �FD � � ��eD��� ��� o � � �Ip D ������ �FD � � � � ��8D �

� ��� ��8D�� � � D � � �FD� � � D �� ��� � �� � " � � � � D��

o �h Q p

jk. (9% �") )vC`) ( K�0 � & 6'B93�O�B & 0 �mI �"N"N�RSK-I4K�N"N � ( Ch6SK�G I � (9% ( Ch6SK � �Cs �FD � ( o �h V p

TU% K . (9% K>K��`6'B9K�)9) �:3 .� �� � " �#" � �� �� � " �%" � �������� o � ��� p

I �"N"N�RSK-I4K�N"N � ( Ch6SK�G I � (9% ( Ch6SKo*�� *o� & lwl�3�BHG � . O ( 3 (9% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . Oo6'B93h3�{ ( B9KwKRD� � * �FDh* � Dh* � D`*� Dh* ��� Dh* ho � ��� p#D`*�� * ������� D`*��m* � *�� *�FD`* ��� D`* ������� o � ��� p#D`*�� *

� D`* � �FD`* ������� o � ��� p#D`*�� * �%" Dh*�FDh* � �� � " �%" � � � � Dh*�� * �#" D � � �� � " �#" � � � � Dh*�� * o �h � p

W-. (9% K=3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� (9% K>6'B93�O�B & 0�{�B & O507K ./(� �� � " �%" � �������� o � � �.p

Page 62: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

V�� ������� ����� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� � ������ � � ��

I �"N"N�RSK �"N"N � ( Ch6SK�G.D (9% K=6'B93h3�{ ( B9KwK l &�. O�K (+& )U{ & B & )� � * �FD`* � Dh* �FDh*�FD`* � �FD`* ho � � �.p#Dh*�� * ������� Dh*�� * � *�� *�FDh* � � Dh* ������� o � � �.p#D`*�� * �#" Dh*�FD`* � �� � " �#" � � � � Dh*�� * o �h n p

R8, (>(9% K0B .'& N�K��`6'B9K�)9) �:3 . %'& ) (9% KM, . G �")9l %'& B9O�K�G % Ch6S3 (9% K�) �") � D * # � (9% 35, ( l�3 ./( B & l ( �:3 . � (9% �")=6'B93h3�{{ & �"N") u � . l�K (9% �")=6'B93�O�B & 0 � RSK�l & ,')vK � ( &!(v( K�076 ( ) ( 3 0 &;@ K ( I43 G �") ( � . l ( l�3�6 �:K�)>3�{'��� �") �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3�"0768N:K�07K ./( � (9% K ( Ch6 � . O )vC`) ( K�02B9K vK�l ( ) � (w UTU% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . OPK��`6'B9K�)9) �:3 . o � .m& l�3 ./( K�� ( I % �"l %m.'& 07K�)�� & )& �h,JR � ( p �") & N")v3 �"N"N � ( Ch6SK�G.D

� �� � "�� � �� �� ��" �#" � �� �� � " �%" � �������� o � ��� p

TU% �") ( �"07K�� (9% K ( B9KwK O�K ( ) & )U{ & B & )� � * �FDh* � Dh* � D`*� Dh* ��� Dh* ho � ��� p#D`*�� * ������� D`*��m* � *�� *�FD`* ��� D`* ������� o � ��� p#D`*�� *

� D`* � �FD`* ������� o � ��� p#D`*�� * �%" Dh*�FDh* � �� � " �%" � � � � Dh*�� * �#" D � � �� � " �#" � � � � Dh*�� * o �h y p

RSKw{�3�B9K � ( R8N:3`l @ ) RSK�l & ,')vK (9% K N:K ( BH,'N:K . KwK�G') ( 3 G �")9l %'& B9O�K (9% K & )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . �[Dd* TU% KwB9K �") . 3 I & C( 3 � ./( B93`G','l�K (9%'&!(P& )9)9,'076 ( �:3 . � ./( 3 (9% �")o6'B93h3�{ ( B9KwK I � (9% 35, (o(9% K I4K &;@ K . � . O BH,'N:K�� & ) � �") .'& 07K�G � .. 3M)9,JRSK��`6'B9K�)9) �:3 . 3�{ (9% K � �� I % KwB9K � ( �")URS35, . G u � . l�K (9% �") K��`6'B9K�)9) �:3 .m&!(v( K�076 ( ) ( 3 G �")9l & BHG (9% K �h,JR � (B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( K�G RhC��'� (9% K ( Ch6 � . OP)vC`) ( K�0�l &!( l % K�) (9% K>N:K &;@ &�. G B9K vK�l ( ) � (U& ) �"N"N � ( Ch6SK�G � � . K & BdN:3�O �"l %'& ) & N"N (9% KU6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) . K�l�K�)9) & B9C ( 3 0 &;@ K � (~& )v35N��"G {�35, . G &!( �:3 . ,J6S3 . I % �"l % ( 3 R8, �"N"G &

( Ch6 � . O7)vC`) ( K�0 �j ( ) K��`68N��"l � ( N:CPN�� . K & B % Ch6S3 (9% K�) �") � ( B & l @ � . O7l &�. RSK-K�0 RSK�G'GJK�G � . 6'B93h3�{ )vC`) ( K�0P)pI � (9% 35, (, . G',JK-) ( B & � .� �~& B �:35,') (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N�B9K�)9,'N ( )4K�) (9& R8N��") % (9% K>l�3 . ) �") ( K . l�C��'l�350768N:K ( K . K�)9)w� &�. G )v35, . G . K�)9)43�{x & B �:35,')d)vC`) ( K�0P)d3�{�N�� . K & BdN:3�O �"l �j (4%'& ) & N")v3o) % 3�I . & 6'68N��"l & R �"N�� ( C ( 3 & B9K & )43�{ l�350768, ( KwBp)9l �:K . l�KFB &�. O � . O{�B9350�l�350768N:K�� � ( C (9% Kw3�B9C ( 3 .'&!( ,JB & N�N &�. O5, & O�K )vK�0 &�./( �"lw)

��������� �)� )���) � ��� � � � ����� �)�� � � ��� ���� � � � ��� ����

L . 3 (9% KwB & GJx &�./(9& O�K 3�{+)vKwK � . O (9% K B9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 . ) 68N & l�K�Ga3 . �h,JR � ( ) & ) ( Ch6SK l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( ) �") (9%'&!( )9,'l % &x �:KwI�6'B93�x �"GJK�)7B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:C .'&!( ,JB & N I & C`) ( 3fGJK�)9l�B �:RSK (9% K 6'B9Kw6 & B &!( �:3 . &�. G 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�{ �h,JR � ( ) }~B9Kw6 & B � . O &�. � . � ( � & N"N:C � R8N &�.I@ �h,JR � ( �") & {e, . l ( �:3 . 3�{ . 3 & B9O5,'07K ./( )UI % �"l % B9K ( ,JB . ) & �h,JR � ( D

� ��� ��� ��� D/, . � ( � * o �h | p� 3 ( K (9%'&!( (9% Kd{e, . l ( �:3 .'& N�� ( C+3�{ � ��� ��� ��� {e, . l ( �:3 .'& N�� ( C �")�K�)9)vK ./( � & N"N:C (9%'&!( 3�{ &U% K & 6 & N"N:3`l &!( 3�BgD�I4KdGJB & Ia3 .&�. �"0768N��"l � ( 6S3h35NJ3�{ {�B9K�) % �h,JR � ( ) LF)d)9,'l % � � ��� ��� ��� �") �"0768N��"l � ( N:C 6'B9K�)vK ./( � . �FK�, ( )9l %�� ) �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O

Page 63: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � �� ��� ��� ��� � ������ � � �� �������� �� �� V5n

0 & l % � . K 073`GJK�N �JI � (9% � ( ) � . B . � ( K=)9,J6'68N:CP3�{�R8N &�.I@ �h,JR � ( ) � ��� ��� ��� l &�.m& N")v3PRSK>)vKwK . o �:{ IUB & 6'6SK�G I � (9%& 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . )Yp & ) & I & Cm3�{ (9&;@ � . O & lwN & )9) �"l & N�x & N",JK &�. GmK�0 RSK�G'G � . O � ( � . & �h, &�./( ,'0) ( 3�B & O�KoN:3`l &!( �:3 .� TU% KMl�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G � . O 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K {�3�Bo07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(>(9&;@ K�) & �h,JR � (=& ) � . 68, (=&�. G B9K ( ,JB . ) � 3�B �P( 3 &

lwN & )9) �"l & NSx & B � & R8N:KRD� � ��� � ��� D`* � # � ����& o �h "�w� p

TU% K 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . =vGJK�) ( B93�C`)'? (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0�6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) 3�{ (9% K �h,JR � ( � .(9% K 6'B93`l�K�)9) 3�{K ./(9&�. O5N�� . O (9% K �h,JR � ( I � (9% & lwN & )9) �"l & N � �"0768N��"l � ( N:CP0 & l�B935)9l�3�6 �"l!�8)vC`) ( K�0 �! ~j ( ) {e, . l ( �:3 .'& N�� ( C��'N:3h3 @ � . O &!((9% KU)vK ( 3�{��h, &�./( ,'0sx & N",JK�) � . & 6'B93�O�B & 0 �50 �"0 �"lw) (9%'&!( 3�{ &�. 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . B9K ( ,JB . � . O-07K�073�B9C ( 3 (9% K % K & 6 � 3 ( K (9%'&!(+(9% �")U3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . �") (9% K L;V : ^>I & C ( 3[=k6'B935073 ( Kg? & �h, &�./( ,'0�x & N",JK � ./( 3 & lwN & )9) �"l & N 3 . K��S) � . l�KG �:B9K�l ( l�3hKwBHl �:3 . ) & B9K=BH,'N:K�G 35, ( RhC (9% K>l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( (9%'&!( , . ��h,JK+x & N",JK�) l &�.'. 3 ( RSK=) ( 3�B9K�G � . . 3 .�� , . ��h,JKx & B � & R8N:K�) �TU% �") ( Ch6 � . OP)vC`) ( K�0�6'B9K�)vKwB9x�K�) (9% K>G �") ( � . l ( �:3 . RSK ( I4KwK . �#" &�. G �` LF) & l�3 . )vK �h,JK . l�K�� � ( �") �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3P,')vK �h, &�./( ,'0 x & N",JK�)w�JI % �"l % l�35,'N"G RSK � . & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{

) (9&!( K�)w� � . RS3h35N:K &�. 3�B � ./( KwO�B & N�l�3 ./( K�� ( ) TU% �") B9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 . �"0P07K�G � &!( K�N:CMBH,'N:K�) 35, ( 0 &;@ � . OPl�3 ./( B935N � � 3�IGJK�l �") �:3 . )>R & )vK�Ga3 . �h, &�./( ,'0�x & N",JK�) I � (9% 35, ( 07K & )9,JB � . O (9% 35)vK x & N",JK�)eo &�. G (9% KwB9KwRhCaGJK�) ( B93�C � . O &�. C)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . (9% KwC 0 & C RSK � . p LF)+l�3 ./( B935N � 3�I �") & N:I & C`)FGJK ( KwBH0 � . K�G RhC 68,JB9K�N:C lwN & )9) �"l & N x & N",JK�)w�8)v3(9%'&!(d(9% K,B . � ( K � ) (9&!( K-l�3 ./( B935N8I % �"l % �"0768N��"l � ( N:C �"0768N:K�07K ./( ) (9% K+6'B93�O�B & 0 . KwK�G . Kwx�KwB4RSK � .M& )9,J6SKwB96S35) � �( �:3 . � ( )vK�N:{ TU% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K��568,JB9K�N:C �h, &�./( ,'0s6'B93�O�B & 0P)�IUB � (v( K . ,') � . OF{�3�BH0 & N��")90P) �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O ( Ch6SK � R & )vK�Gl�3 . ) ( B & � ./( ) & B9K & , ( 350 &!( �"l & N"N:C7K �h, �:x & N:K ./( � . l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N'6S3�I4KwB ( 3 & l�C`lwN��"l �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( ) 1pN & ) �) �"l & N 6'B93�O�B & 0P)7I � (9% �h, &�./( ,'0 )9,JR'B935, ( � . K�) B9K (9& � . (9% K �:BP{e,'N"N46S3�I4KwB��pR8, (7(9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 )9,JR'B935, ( � . K�)6'B93�x & R8N:C GJ3 . 3 ( � ./( B93`G','l�K 3�B-B9K �h, �:B9K �h, &�./( ,'0 � 07K�l %'&�. �"l & N�RSK %'& x �:3�B � . (9% K7lwN & )9) �"l & N�{�B & O507K ./(w =# K) %'& N"NSB9K ( ,JB . ( 3 (9% �") �"GJK & RSK�N:3�I � . )9,JB � . O (9%'&!(7(9% K )vC ./(9& � &�. G )vK�0 &�./( �"lw)73�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 N &�. O5, & O�K O5, & B &�./( KwKmN:3�O �"l & NpB9Kwx�KwBH) �:R �"N �

� ( C %'& ) &�.f& GJx &�./(9& O�K RSKwC�3 . Ga07KwB9K�N:C 6'B9Kwx�K ./( � . O . 3 .�� , . � (9& B9C 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) L . C )9,JR'B935, ( � . KPGJK_B . K�G� . )9,'l %�& N &�. O5, & O�Kml &�. RSK BH, . � . B9Kwx�KwBH)vK t ) � . l�Km0 &�. C K_r l �:K ./( �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)7B9K �h, �:B9K (9% KR & l @ I & BHG')=l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 3�{4l�KwB (9& � . ) ( Kw68)0o & )=GJ3hK�) (9% K O�K . KwB & N�) �"0o,'N &!( �:3 .m& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B �:B9B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:Kl�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )YpH� � ( I435,'N"G RSK4l�3 . x�K . �:K ./( {�3�B (9% KpN &�. O5, & O�K ( 3 & N"N:3�I (9% K4K��`K�lw, ( �:3 . � . B9Kwx�KwBH)vKp3�{ & B9R � ( B & B9C�h, &�./( ,'0�)9,JR'B935, ( � . K�) �TU% �") �")pK & ) �"N:C & lwl�350768N��") % K�G.D�I %'&!( Kwx�KwBFl�3 . ) ( BH,'l (U& N &�. O5, & O�K=I435,'N"G . 3�BH0 & N"N:C%'& x�KU{�3�B�K��`K�lw, ( � . Oo�68,JB9K�N:C �h, &�./( ,'0ep�l�3`GJK � . & {�3�B9I & BHG')�G �:B9K�l ( �:3 . l &�. RSK )9,J6'68N:K�07K ./( K�GoRhC & 6 & B & N"N:K�Nl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( 3 . K={�3�B+K��`K�lw, ( � . OP)9,'l % l�3`GJK>R & l @ I & BHG')

�u�� �W".��� � � �.2 ���. ,/4/4$�+�� �[ �. $��-/ &

# K %'& x�K>{�3`lw,')vK�G 3 . K�0 RSK�G'G � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) � . & {e, . l ( �:3 .'& NSl�3 ./( K�� (mt8(9% KwB9K & B9K & N")v3 B9K & )v3 .��& R8N:KMI & C`) 3�{+, . GJKwBH) (9&�. G � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) � . 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O 6 & B & G �:O50P)o,')9, & N"N:C lwN & )9) �CB8K�G & )�"076SKwB &!( �:x�K-3�B+3�R�vK�l (�� 3�B �:K ./( K�G -��\=54ID�GB0�GITC:�7 46K[] =54QTU:J@/=�G"�$0�7�=54I7 4603LC<GB8;M�2 7>4I7�? GB0 �$? 7�=;? 037�:�D�8;:QP ? 4I7�:J8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037�@ <Q460&46K �J4L @�WN:$<GB0XTU:�D/7�:QPC? 037�G460 :Q132�? TB46K :037\<GB8;M�2 7>4I7�? GB0��$? 7�= 4;@/? 0�RBK :*8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037S4I7S7�=�: :05PVAN:TU:0Z? E�7�=�: 8;:Q46@/2 D�:QP�132�W�? 7�@\4ID�:*K 4I7�:�DY2�@/:QPZ? 0Z7�=�:<GB8;M�2 7>4I7�? GB0�] � =X2�@A �$=�:�7�=�:�D )�8;:Q46@/2 D�:8;:037 *�GBMN:�D>4I7�? GB0�@YP :@F7/D�GQL�132�W�? 7�@\G6DS0�G67S? @ 460 ? @/@/2�:*G6E�: ' M D�:@/@/? TU: <GB0XTU:0�? :0�<:BAD>4I7�=�:�D$7�=5460Z4 �V:<�7�? 0�RC7�=�:Y@F7/D�:0�R67�=�G6E GB2 D$M D�GBR6D>468;8;? 0�RC8;GXP :K[]

Page 64: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

V�y ������� ����� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� � ������ � � ��

��������� ������� � ��� ���#��� � �� � �V� � �)J � ���*-,JR � ( )F)9,J6'6S3�B ( 3 . N:C & x�KwB9C N��"0 � ( K�GmB &�. O�K73�{d3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )-I % K . (9&;@ K . 3 . K &!(>& ( �"07K�� &�. G 0735) ( = � .��( KwB9K�) ( � . O ? �h, &�./( ,'0 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) � . x�35N:x�Km0o,'N ( �:68N:K �h,JR � ( ) jk. & 0o,'N ( �:68N:K � �h,JR � ( ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � (9% K�h,JR � ( ) & B9K7K �h, & N~) �"0o,'N (9&�. Kw35,')-6 & B ( �"l �:6 &�./( ) t�(9% KwB9K �") � . O�K . KwB & N . 3 I & C ( 3 & )9) �:O . ( 3 & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 & �( �:3 . & 6'B �"0 & B9C �h,JR � ( ,J6S3 . I % �"l % � (M& l ( )w� 3�B ( 3aGJK�l�35076S35)vK & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � ./( 3 & )vK �h,JK . l�Km3�{) � . O5N:K � �h,JR � (d& l ( �:3 . ) ~E 3�B (9% �")dB9K & )v3 . � & 68,JB9K+3�R�vK�l (�� 3�B �:K ./( K�G )vC`) ( K�0 R & )vK�GM3 . 07K (9% 3`G � . x�3`l &!( �:3 . 3�B07K�)9) & O�K � 6 & )9) � . OMGJ3hK�) . 3 ( I43�B @ 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & BHN:CPI4K�N"N �:{ �h,JR � ( ) & B9K ( B9K &!( K�G & ) B8BH) (�� lwN & )9) 3�R�vK�l ( ) @ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� & )�I4K %'& x�K+)vKwK . � (9% K0=k3�R�vK�l ( ? 07K (9& 6 % 3�B � ( )vK�N:{ �") & 6'68N��"l & R8N:K �jk. (9% �")�07K (9& 6 % 3�B�� (9% KUG &!(9&

3�R�vK�l ( ) � . & 6'B93�O�B & 0 & B9KUK �h, &!( K�G7I � (9% l�3 . l�B9K ( KU6 % C`) �"l & N`3�R�vK�l ( )�I % �"l % 0 & C %'& x�K � ./( KwB .'& N`6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)(9%'&!(p& B9K . 3 ( G �:B9K�l ( N:C 3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K�� & B9KFG �Cr lw,'N (�( 3 073�x�K��Jl &�. RSK+G �Cr lw,'N (�( 3oG',J68N��"l &!( K�� &�. GMl &�. 3 . N:C7RSK� ./( KwB & l ( K�GmI � (9% (9% B935,JO % � ./( KwB9{ & l�K�)+3 . (9% K �:B8=v)9,JB9{ & l�K ? E 3�B �h,JR � ( )w� (9% K B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( ) 3�{~) ( 3�B & O�K &�. G3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 � 07K�l %'&�. �"l & N�l�3 . ) ( B & � ./( )-O �:x�K (9% �")-07K (9& 6 % 3�B ( KwK (9% DFI4KPl &�. 3 . N:C � ./( KwB & l ( I � (9% �h,JR � ( ) � .l�KwB (9& � . B9K�) ( B �"l ( K�G I & C`) � r4C & 6'68N:C � . O (9% K�)vK 6'B �"0 � ( �:x�K�) � O�K . KwB & N"N:C �h, &�./( ,'0 O &!( K�) � ( 3 �h,JR � ( )w�I4KPl &�. l %'&�. O�K (9% K �:B � ./( KwB .'& N�) (9&!( K � . I & C`) (9%'&!(>& B9K . 3 ( G �:B9K�l ( N:C 3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K oE 3�B>K�� & 0768N:K�� % KwB9K �")(9% K & G'G � ( �:3 . K�� & 0768N:K={�B9350 & RS3�x�K��8B9KwIUB � (v( K . � . & 073�B9K>3�R�vK�l (�� 3�B �:K ./( K�Gm) ( C`N:KRD� ��� � � � � ��� � . 68N & l�K 073`G','N & B & G'G o �/B9KwO & ���/B9KwO7R6p#� ���� . oelwN & )9) �"l & N . pH� � o � p t� � ��� � l o � p t� . 68N & l�K & G'G o & � R6p tl�35076 & B9K O ( o . � & �8lcp tl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G )vI & 6 oel!� . � � p t� ����� � . 68N & l�K & G'G o . � & p tl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G )vI & 6 oel!� . � � p tl�35076 & B9K O ( o & � R � lcp t

&

jk. (9% �")+) ( C`N:K�� .'& 07K�)+B9Kw{�KwB ( 3 �h,JR � ( ) � . ) ( K & G 3�{ ( 3MI �:B9K�) Fu ,'l %m& l�3 . x�K ./( �:3 . 0 &;@ K�)FK��`68N��"l � ( (9%'&!(F(9% K) & 07KM) ( 3�B & O�K N:3`l &!( �:3 . ) % 35N"G RS3 (9% (9% KP35, ( 68, ( ) &�. G (9% K � . 68, ( )F3�{ & O &!( K # K & B9KP{�3`lw,') � . O . 3�I 3 .O &!( K�)pI % �"l % GJ3 . 3 ( l�350768, ( KFx & N",JK�)w�hR8, ( � . ) ( K & G & 6'68N:CPl %'&�. O�K�) ( 3 & )vK ( 3�{��h,JR � ( )mD I4K %'& x�K>)vI � ( l % K�G{�B9350 �YO VPJgETSUL;VId ( 3!NPX LgJYH'Z;O X'HYd ���������� ��*) ���) � � � � �V� � �)J � ���TU% �")=l %'&�. O�K �") & N")v3 3 . KP3�{ (9% K @ KwC l %'&�. O�K�) � . O�3 � . O {�B9350 & {e, . l ( �:3 .'& N�N &�. O5, & O�K ( 3 &�. �"076SKwB &!( �:x�K3 . KRD (9% K ( B &�. ) � ( �:3 . � . K�076 %'& ) �")p{�B9350 (9% Kb;9;: O HYd {e, . l ( �:3 . ) l�350768, ( K ( 3 (9% KdYSUZaH0H �AH'JgE<dp3�{�{e, . l ( �:3 . ) @ KwB9K �") (9% K ) & 07K>K�� & 0768N:K��JB9KwIUB � (v( K . � . �"076SKwB &!( �:x�K>) ( C`N:KRD (�G6DY: '�468;M�K :BA�GBW �F:<�7 + G6D�? :037�:QP K 460�RB2546RB:@ 4ID�:CE D�:Q132�:037�K L�=�GB@F7�? K :�7�G�P ? D�:<�7Y<GBM3L ? 0�R�G6E <GB8;M�K : '�GBW �F:<�7�@%(YW3L P :�E[462�K 7QA

GB0�K L�D�:�EH:�D�:0�<:@J7�GC7�=�:8 8&4L&WN:YP 2�M�K ? <Q4I7�:QPV] � =�? @$<GB0�@F7/D>46? 037\? @\132�? 7�: 46M�M D�GBM D�? 4I7�: EHG6DS132�W�? 7�@]� . E�� :Y<GB0�@/? P :�D\WN:? 0�R )�<K 46@/@/? <Q46K *�46@S460Z46W�@F7/D>46<�7\<K 46@/@$E D�GB8 �$=�? <>=�46K K�<K 46@/@/? <Q46K GBW �F:<�7�@$? 0�=�:�D�? 7QA 7�=�:0�GBW �F:<�7 + G6D�? :037�:QP0�G67�? GB0�@;G6E ? 0�=�:�D�? 7>460�<:Z4605P @/2�WN<K 46@/@/? 0�R�0�:Q4I7�K L :0 EHG6D�<:�7�=�:&7�L M�? 0�R <GB0�@F7/D>46? 037�@�EHG6D�W�? P�P ? 0�R M D�GB8;G67�? GB0 G6EY132546037�2�8 7�G<K 46@/@/? <Q46K"GBW �F:<�7�@]�� =�: @/:8&46037�? <@ EHG6D ��GB0�<2 D/D�:037 ��K :Q460�P :TU:K GBMZ4*0�G67�? GB0�G6E @/2�W 7�L M�? 0�R WN:�7 � ::0�2�0�? 132�:\7�L MN:@J4605P&7�=�:? D0�GB0 + 2�0�? 132�:S<GB2�037�:�D�M54ID/7�@]

Page 65: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � �� ��� ��� ��� � ������ � � �� �������� �� �� V�|

� ��� � � � � ��� � . 68N & l�K 073`G','N & B & G'G o �/B9KwO & ���/B9KwO7R6p#� ���� . "�� ��� ��� ��� ���� oelwN & )9) �"l & N . p t� ���� � "�� ��� ��� ��� ���� o � p t� � ��� � l�"�� ��� ��� ��� ��� � o � p t� . 68N & l�K & G'G o & � R6p tl�35076 & B9K O ( o . � & �8lcp tl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G )vI & 6 oel!� . � � p t� ����� � . 68N & l�K & G'G o . � & p tl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G )vI & 6 oel!� . � � p tl�35076 & B9K O ( o & � R � lcp t

&

� �:KwI4K�G � .7(9% �")~I & C�� �h,JR � ( )�RSK�l�3507K�� �:B93 . �"l & N"N:C�� 9;V ETS�� �YO VPJgETSUL;VP9;:/G &!(9&!( Ch6SK�)mD (9% KwCPl &�. L;V : ^URSKU3�6SKwB &!( K�G3 . 6'B93`l�K�G',JB & N"N:C�� & )43�6'6S35)vK�G ( 3 lwN & )9) �"l & N�G &!(9&!( Ch6SK�)4I % �"l % )9,J6'6S3�B ( {e, . l ( �:3 .'& N & lwl�K�)9) ~jk.P(9% �")dB9K�)v6SK�l ( ��h,JR � ( ) & B9K )vK�l�3 . G � lwN & )9) 3�R�vK�l ( ) TU% �")U)9,JO�O�K�) ( ) &�. 3 (9% KwB � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . OMI & C ( 3 (9% � .I@ 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K�) � . (9% Kol�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N

073`GJK�N")dI4K %'& x�K=RSKwK . ,') � . OID ( 3 & lwN & )9) �"l & NSl�350768, ( KwB I4K &!(v(9& l %m& = �h, &�./( ,'0 l�3�6'B93`l�K�)9)v3�B�? I % �"l % l &�.) ( 3�B9K �h,JR � ( ) &�. G �"0768N:K�07K ./( 3 . (9% K�0�3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) � ( �") � . ) ( BH,'l ( K�G ( 3P6SKwB9{�3�BH0�RhC (9% K 0 & � . 6'B93`l�K�)9)v3�B TU% K+0 & � . 1p}� &�. G (9% K+l�3�6'B93`l�K�)9)v3�Bpl�350P0o, . �"l &!( K & N:3 . O lwN & )9) �"l & N'l %'&�.'. K�N")w� &�. G & N"N'l�3 ./( B935N�GJK�l �") �:3 . )& B9KU0 & GJKpRhC (9% K 0 & � . 1p}� /W-.o(9% K 3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� (9% KUl�3�6'B93`l�K�)9)v3�B �") (9% Kp3 . N:C>6 �:K�l�KpI % �"l % l &�.7& l ( , & N"N:C=vN:3h3 @ � . ) �"GJKg? (9% K �h,JR � ( ) � . (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 3�B 0 &�. �:68,'N &!( K (9% K �:Bo) (9&!( K l�3 % KwB9K ./( N:C jk. (9% �")>B9K�)v6SK�l ( � (9% K@ KwC G �CsSKwB9K . l�K RSK ( I4KwK . & �h, &�./( ,'0�GJKwx �"l�K &�. G &�� 3 &!( � . O � 6S3 � ./( l�3�6'B93`l�K�)9)v3�B �") (9%'&!(F(9% K7N &!(v( KwBo�I � (9%lw,JB9B9K ./( ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C p N��:x�K�)>3 .f(9% K 073 (9% KwB9RS3 & BHG�� I % KwB9K & ) (9% KM{�3�BH07KwBoB9K �h, �:B9K�) N & B9O�K &�. Gf)v6SK�l � & N�� � K�GN & RS3�B &!( 3�B9C & 6'6 & B &!( ,') u`% 3�B � ) �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B { & l ( 3�B � . O � . x�35N:x�K�)7l & B9B9C � . Om35, (7& �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . I % �"l %

GJKw6SK . G') � ./( �"0 &!( K�N:C>3 . (9% K . ,'0 RSKwB � ( 3>RSK4{ & l ( 3�B9K�G ~TU% K 07K (9& 6 % 3�B u`% 3�B�,')vK�) �") (9%'&!( I4K=vl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( ?& �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( O �:x�K . �� LFN (9% 35,JO % u`% 3�B �")dl & B9Kw{e,'N ( 3 K�) (9& R8N��") %7(9%'&!(4(9% �")~l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . �")~K_r l �:K ./( N:Cl�350768, (9& R8N:K�� O �:x�K . � � (9% K �"0768N��"l &!( �:3 . �") (9%'&!( (9% KMl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% KMl �:BHlw, � ( �") &�. 3�� � . K & l ( �:x � ( C��I % �"N:K � ( )~K��`K�lw, ( �:3 . �") &�. 3 . N�� . KU3 . K dW-. & )v3�{ ( I & B9K-N:Kwx�K�N �hI4KF)vKwK & ) �"0 �"N & B �"GJK & �:{SI4K (9% � .I@ 3�{�IUB � ( � . O& 6'B93�O�B & 0 (9%'&!( � . x�35N:x�K�) )v3507K lwN & )9) �"l & NU6 & B & 07K ( KwBH) ( 3 & 6'B93�O�B & 0 I � (9% & �h, &�./( ,'0 & )v6SK�l (w TU% K=vl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . ? 3�{ (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � (>& 0735, ./( ) ( 3m6 & B ( � & N"N:C Kwx & N", &!( � . O (9% KM6'B93�O�B & 0�I � (9% B9K�)v6SK�l (( 3 (9% K lwN & )9) �"l & N46 & B & 07K ( KwBH) ajk. (9% K l & )vK 3�{ u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � (9% �")o6 & B ( � & NdKwx & N", &!( �:3 . B9K�)9,'N ( ) � . &68,JB9K�N:C �h, &�./( ,'0�6'B93�O�B & 02K�0 RSK�G'GJK�G I � (9% � . & )90 & N"N�lwN & )9) �"l & N�l�3 ./( B935N N:3h3�6 (9%'&!( B9Kw6SK &!( K�G'N:C K��`K�lw, ( K�)(9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 02, ./( �"N � ( )9,'lwl�KwK�G')

��������� � � � ����) � � � � �V� � �)J � ����FK�lwN & B &!( �:x�KF6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O �") & N:B9K & GJC7l & 6 & R8N:K+3�{�K��`6'B9K�)9) � . O=B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:KU{e, . l ( �:3 . ) � .P&o.'&!( ,JB & N80 &�.'. KwBgD�:{ & {e, . l ( �:3 . �")7)v6SK�l �CB8K�G � .f( KwBH0P) 3�{+B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K {e, . l ( �:3 . )w� � ( �")oO5, & B &�./( KwK�G ( 3 RSK B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K TU% K& GJx &�./(9& O�K+3�{ & GJK�lwN & B &!( �:x�KU) ( C`N:KU{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O �") (9%'&!(~(9% KwB9K �") . 3 . KwK�G7{�3�B &�.P& G'G � ( �:3 .'& NN &�. O5, & O�K l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( {�3�BFB9Kwx�KwBH)vKoK��`K�lw, ( �:3 . D l & N"N�� . OP6'B9K�G �"l &!( K�)UI � (9% 3 . N:C (9% K =k35, ( 68, ( ?Px & N",JK�) � . ) (9&�.��( � &!( K�G & , ( 350 &!( �"l & N"N:C B9Kwx�KwBH)vK�) (9% K l �:BHlw, � (U(9% K 6'B9K�G �"l &!( K B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( ) =@ KwB9K �") (9% K ) & 07K K�� & 0768N:K {�B9350& RS3�x�K��8B9KwIUB � (v( K . (9% �") ( �"07K � . GJK�lwN & B &!( �:x�K ) ( C`N:KRD

Page 66: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�!� ������� ����� ��� ��� ��� � � ��� � ������ � � ��

073`G','N & B & G'G o & �'R �JB9K�)9,'N ( p�D��& G'G o & � R � B & I )9,'0epH�l�35076 & B9K O ( o�6'B9Kw6 & B9KaoelwN & )9) �"l & N . pH� B & I )9,'0 �'lcpH�l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N )vI & 6 oel!�'6'B9Kw6 & B9KaoelwN & )9) �"l & N . pH�J6'B9Kw6 & B9Kao � pH��)9,JR ( B &�% K . G�� )v6 & B9KqpH�& G'G o�B9K�)9,'N ( � )9,JR ( B &�% K . G�� B & I )9,'0epH�l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N )vI & 6 oel!�8)9,JR ( B &�% K . G��J)v6 & B9K��J6'B9Kw6 & B9KaoelwN & )9) �"l & N . pH�'6'B9Kw6 & B9Kao � p pH�l�35076 & B9K O ( o�B9K�)9,'N ( � R � lcp

u 3507K 3�{ (9% K ( Ch6 �"l & N & GJx &�./(9& O�K�) 3�{>GJK�lwN & B &!( �:x�K 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . OfGJ3 . 3 ( l & B9B9C 3�x�KwB ( 3 (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0GJ350 & � .� 4E 3�BFK�� & 0768N:K�� (9% K & R �"N�� ( C ( 3 )v6SK�l �:{�C {e, . l ( �:3 . )UN:3�O �"l & N"N:C &�. G B9K�N:C ,J6S3 . R & l @h( B & l @ � . O ( 30B . G& )v35N", ( �:3 . GJ3hK�) . 3 ( B ( I4K�N"N�I � (9%m(9% K7) ( B & �:O %/(�� N�� . K B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( )F3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( ) LFG'G � ( �:3 .'& N"N:C��(9% KMN��"0 � ( )-3�{ .'& 07K � K �h, �:x & N:K . l�KMl &�. RSKM)v3507KwI %'&!( )9,JB96'B �") � . O jk. (9% KPK�� & 0768N:K & RS3�x�K���R �")>RS3 (9% &�.� . 68, (�( 3 &�. G &�. 35, ( 68, ( 3�{ (9% K-l �:BHlw, � ( � & { & l (p(9% KFGJK�lwN & B &!( �:x�K � ) ( C`N:KFx�KwBH) �:3 . K��`68N:3 � ( )~RhCP,') � . O>3 . N:C73 . K.'& 07K � 6 & B & 07K ( KwB ( 3 B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(4(9%'&!( x & N",JK �@ 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% �") ( K�l %'. ��h,JK-l &�.'. 3 ( RSKF,')vK�G � . G �")9l�B �"0 � .'&!( K�N:C��3�B ( I43 G �") ( � . l ( �h,JR � ( )�0 & CoRSKp, . �CB8K�G ( 3 (9% KU) & 07KU, . � . ) (9&�./( � &!( K�G .'& 07K�� & x �:35N &!( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K . 3 � lwN:3 . � . OB9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 .� j ( �")�073�B9KU,')vKw{e,'N ( 3 ( B9K &!(~(9% KUGJK�lwN & B &!( �:x�KU) ( C`N:K & ) & ) ( C`N:K {�3�B�K��`6'B9K�)9) � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 l �:BHlw, � ( )w�B &!(9% KwB (9%'&�. K��`6SK�l ( � . O & N"N (9% K=,')vKw{e,'N8{�K &!( ,JB9K�)p3�{�GJK�lwN & B &!( �:x�K-6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O � .M(9% K=lwN & )9) �"l & NSGJ350 & � . ( 3l & B9B9C 3�x�KwB ( 3 (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0�)vK (v( � . O

Page 67: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�������������

� � � ����� � � � � � � ����� �

� ��� (*)! ,+-".)0/ � �. �� ��� &

r4Kw{�3�B9KpI4K l &�. N & , . l % � ./( 3-35,JB�G �")9lw,')9) �:3 . 3�{��h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w��I4K ) % 35,'N"G B8BH) ( (9&;@ K l & B9Kp3�{83 . KpN & ) (�"076S3�B (9&�./( GJK_B . � ( �:3 . � (9%'&!( 3�{ & �mO 9;V ETO M L;X 9 Jm: H LslwN & )9) �"l & N�3�B & lwN:K�� � . � ( )U) �"0768N:K�) ( l �:BHlw, � (�� & lwl�K�)9) �:R8N:K{�3�BH0 � �") & R8N & l @ RS3�� I � (9%�� � . 68, ( ) &�. G�� 35, ( 68, ( ) I % �"l % l�350768, ( K�)+)v3507K={e, . l ( �:3 .

�FD # � ����& � � # � ����&�� ( o n/ "� p# K & B9K7,')9, & N"N:C l�3 . l�KwB . K�G I � (9%m(9% K . ,'0 RSKwBF3�{ �h,JKwB �:K�) ( 3 (9% Ko3�B & lwN:K &�. G (9% K & 0735, ./( 3�{ & G'G � ( �:3 .'& N6'B93`l�K�)9) � . O ( �"07K=B9K �h, �:B9K�G ( 3PK�� ( B & l ( )v3507K>6 �:K�l�K=3�{ � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( � T 3 (9&;@ K &+( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N5K�� & 0768N:K��V�P0 �:O %/( RSK & {e, . l ( �:3 . I % �"l % ( B9K &!( ) � ( ) � . 68, ( & ) &+( BH, (9%o& )9) �:O . 07K ./(

( 3 � x & B � & R8N:K�) &�. GmB9K ( ,JB . ) � �:{ &�. Gm3 . N:C �:{ (9%'&!(F& )9) �:O . 07K ./( ) &!( �") B8K�) & RS3h35N:K &�. {�3�BH0o,'N &P%'& BHG � l�3`GJK�G� . � ~W-. K 3�{ (9% K+0 & v3�B �h,JK�) ( �:3 . )�3�{ � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N8N:K & B . � . O (9% Kw3�B9C %'& )~RSKwK . GJK ( KwBH0 � . � . O{�3�B=I % �"l % lwN & )9)vK�)-3�{4RS3h35N:K &�. {�3�BH0o,'N & K7)v3507K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 l &�. B9K�l�3 . ) ( BH,'l (=(9% K % �"G'GJK . {�3�BH0o,'N & % �"G'GJK .� . ) �"GJK (9% K>R8N & l @ � RS3��S�'I % �"N:K-,') � . O 3 . N:C & 6S35N:C . 350 � & N . ,'0 RSKwB 3�{ �h,JKwB �:K�) L �h, &�./( ,'0 3�B & lwN:K-G �CsSKwBH)d{�B9350 & lwN & )9) �"l & N83�B & lwN:K � .M( I43 I & C`) dE �:BH) ( � � . 3�BHGJKwB (9%'&!(p(9% KF3�B & lwN:K=l &�.

RSK B9Kwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K�� � ( I �"N"N�RSK &�. ��# � � � . 68, ( o &�. G (9% ,') ��# � � 35, ( 68, ( ppO &!( K r4Cml�3 . x�K ./( �:3 . � (9% K5B8BH) ( �R � ( )pI �"N"N�RSK � . 68, ( � &�. G (9% K N & ) ( � I �"N"N�RSK=35, ( 68, (w ~TU% K=3�B & lwN:K & l ( ) & )

� " � "�� � " � � o �.p "%( o n/ ? pTU% K=3�B & lwN:K>I �"N"N8RSK>)vK�N:{ � � . x�KwBH)vK��JRSK�l & ,')vK ( I43M)9,'lwl�K�)9) �:x�K>R � (�� �:68)pl &�. l�K�N u K�l�3 . G�� (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0�3�B & lwN:K�� & ) � ( ) .'& 07K �"0768N��:K�)w� & lwl�Kw6 ( ) �h, &�./( ,'0 �h,JKwB �:K�) �E 3�BplwN & )9) �"l & N �h,JKwB �:K�)

� � . 68, ( )-I % �"l %a& B9KMK�N:K�07K ./( ) 3�{ (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& NdR & ) �") � � ( I �"N"N�3�{Ul�35,JBH)vKMB9K�)v6S3 . G 9,') ( & ) (9% KlwN & )9) �"l & N�3�B & lwN:K>I435,'N"G %'& x�K 4E 3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 �h,JKwB �:K�) � � . 68, ( )pI % �"l % & B9K )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . )d3�{�073�B9K (9%'&�.3 . K~K�N:K�07K ./( 3�{ (9% Kdl�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �") � (9% K~3�B & lwN:K~I �"N"N & l ( N�� . K & BHN:C+3 .=(9%'&!( )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . ��{�35N"N:3�I � . O(9% KF,')9, & N'BH,'N:K]o�K �h, &!( �:3 . o ?h V p p d# K-l &�.M(9% ,')4l�3 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K+3�B & lwN:K & ) & O &!( K �"0768N:K�07K ./( � . O & o�6S35)9) �:R8N:C, .I@`. 3�I . pd, . � (9& B9C ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ��� TU% K � ./( KwB .'& N+3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )M3�{ (9% K 3�B & lwN:K GJ3 . 3 ( l�3 . l�KwB . ,')w� K��Jl�Kw6 ( )v3f{ & B & ) (9% KwB9K & B9K l�KwB (9& � .

B9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( ) (9% K�)vK>3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )U0o,') ( ) &!( �")v{�C dTU% K=3�B & lwN:K�� & N (9% 35,JO % � ( 0 & C %'& x�Ko0o, (9& R8N:K>) (9&!( K���0o,') (�`�

Page 68: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

��? ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

. 3 ( K��`6S35)vK (9%'&!( ) (9&!( K ( 3 (9% K735, ( ) �"GJK I43�BHN"G oTU% K 3�B & lwN:KP0 & C . 3 (=& lwl �"GJK ./(9& N"N:CmB9K (9& � . ) (9&!( KP3�B %'& x�K� ./( KwB .'& N") (9%'&!( & B9Kd3�R8)vKwB9x & R8N:K���Kwx�K . � . 6'B � . l �:68N:K r4C (9% K4) (9&�. G & BHG') I4K %'& x�K4RSKwK . & 6'68N:C � . O ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0GJKwx �"l�K�)w� (9% �")p07K &�. ) (9%'&!( (9% K-3�B & lwN:K � ( )vK�N:{ 0o,') ( & N")v3 RSK & {e,'N"N:C �h, &�./( ,'0 GJKwx �"l�K ~j ( I �"N"N . 3 ( )9, r l�K ( 3l�3 .'. K�l (U& �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBU,J6 ( 3 & lwN & )9) �"l & N�3�B & lwN:K t'(9% K-3�B & lwN:K>0o,') ( RSK & )p6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C &�. G l & B9Kw{e,'N"N:Cl�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G & ) (9% KPl�350768, ( KwB (9%'&!( �h,JKwB �:K�) � (w j ( I �"N"N RSK7,')vKw{e,'N ( 3 @ KwKw6 (9% �")-{ & l ( � . 0 � . G G',JB � . O (9% K{�35N"N:3�I � . OPG �")9lw,')9) �:3 . )p3�{ & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w� & ) & l % K�l @ 3 .m(9% KolwN & )9)vK�)U3�{�6'B93�R8N:K�0P) (9%'&!( 0 & C 3�B-0 & C . 3 ( RSKK_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:C )v35N:x & R8N:K

� ��� � � )5"6& � ���Q& � �.2 ����� /

# K RSKwO � . 35,JB-G �")9lw,')9) �:3 . 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)+RhC l�3 . ) �"GJKwB � . O��!H_OIE<dmJ_G�� d NPX La\_: H_M LFN (9% 35,JO % � ( �"))v3507K (9% � . O=3�{ &>( 3�C76'B93�R8N:K�0 � � ( �"N"N",') ( B &!( K�)w� (9% KU{�K &!( ,JB9K�) (9%'&!( 35,JBdN &!( KwB��h073�B9K+l�350768N��"l &!( K�G�� & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)I �"N"N�K��`68N:3 � (w jk.a(9% �")>6'B93�R8N:K�0 � I4K & B9K O �:x�K .f& {e, . l ( �:3 . ��D # � ����& � # � ����& � &�. G I4K & B9K & ) @ K�G ( 3 GJK ( KwBH0 � . K

I % K (9% KwB � o � p " � o � p 1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�� ( I43 �h,JKwB �:K�) & B9K RS3 (9% . K�l�K�)9) & B9C &�. G )9, r l �:K ./(w aTU% �") 6'B93�R8N:K�0 �% 3�I4Kwx�KwB��Jl &�. RSKU)v35N:x�K�GPI � (9% 3 . N:Co3 . K �h, &�./( ,'0 �h,JKwB9C �# K+I �"N"N B8BH) ( O �:x�K &=( I43 � �h,JKwB9C & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � &�. G(9% K . ) % 3�I % 3�I (9% 35)vK ( I43 �h,JKwB �:K�)Ul &�. RSK>l�350 R � . K�G � ./( 373 . K

� ������� ��� � ����� � #� ��� � � ���$� �#��� �*TU% Ko{�35N"N:3�I � . O �") & ( I43 � �h,JKwB9C & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B �FK�, ( )9l %�� )=6'B93�R8N:K�0 ��,') � . O ( I43 �h,JR � ( )w��3 . K7{�3�B � . 68, (+( 3(9% K>3�B & lwN:K &�. G (9% K>3 (9% KwBU{�3�B+35, ( 68, ( D�! -uh(9& B ( � . O7{�B9350 �#" �#" � & 6'68N:C &7@F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K B8BH) ( o � . 68, ( p �h,JR � (w ?h } & )9) (9% K ( I43 �h,JR � ( ) ( 3 (9% K>3�B & lwN:K Dh L+6'68N:C (9% K l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N�6 %'& )vK>) % �:{ ( 3�6SKwB &!( 3�B

� � ( 3 (9% K )vK�l�3 . Gjo�35, ( 68, ( p �h,JR � (w QJ Ujk. x�KwB ( ) ( Kw6�o ? p4RhC BH, .'. � . O (9% K>3�B & lwN:K=3 . (9% K (9% K ( I43 �h,JR � ( ) & O & � .� Vh Ujk. x�KwB ( ) ( Kw6�o � p4RhC & 6'68N:C � . O &�. 3 (9% KwB @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K B8BH) ( �h,JR � (w

TU% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ( KwBH0 � .'&!( K�) I � (9% �#" � . (9% K0B8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB �:{;� �")>l�3 . ) (9&�./( � &�. G �%" �:{&� �")=R & N &�. l�K�G TU% K={�35N"N:3�I � . O7l �:BHlw, � ( �"N"N",') ( B &!( K�) � ( ) & l ( �:3 . )mD

��

�� �

�� � �

� � �

o n/ D pT 3M)vKwK>I % C (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�I43�B @ )w� � ( �")pK & ) �:K�) (U( 3PI43�B @ � . ) �"GJK � 35, (w � K ( RSK (9% K (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .�"0768N:K�07K ./( K�G RhC ) ( Kw68)5o ? p (9% B935,JO % o Q p�D

� " �#"����� � � " � o �.p " � �� � o#� � p � � � � " � o �.p "����� � o#� � p � � � � " �#"%( o n/ Q p

Page 69: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � � � �� ����� ���� ������� � ��D

}~B93�x �"GJK�G (9% K7)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( ) (9& B ( ) � . ) (9&!( K �#" o�I % �"l % � ( GJ3hK�) � .m(9% K & RS3�x�K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0epH�J & l ( )=3 . N:C3 . (9% K B8BH) ( �h,JR � (w

���

� �� o n/ V p

E ,JB (9% KwB��J �")FG � & O�3 .'& N � .m(9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N R & ) �")mD � ( �"076S35)vK�) & 6 %'& )vK ) % �:{ ( R & )vK�G 3 . (9% K x & N",JKo3�{� o �.pdR8, ( 3 (9% KwB9I �")vK>N:K & x�K�)+, ./( 35,'l % K�G RS3 (9% �#" &�. G$ �%"H ~jk. 0 &!( B � � {�3�BH0 �

�" � o#� � p � � ! �� o#� � p � � � � " o#� � p � � ! � � �

� o#� � p � � ! " � � � � ( o n/ � p

TU% K N:K & G � . OFl�3 . ) (9&�./( �") �:B9B9K�N:Kwx &�./( D � (�& 6'68N��:K�)�K �h, & N"N:C ( 3 �#" &�. G �%" &�. G (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K l�3 . ) ( � ( , ( K�) & O5N:3�R & N6 %'& )vK ) % �:{ (w Uj {C� �")+R & N &�. l�K�G�� (9% K . � o � p # � o � p " � � &�. G ) �"0768N��CB8K�) ( 3

� � Fj {*� �")Fl�3 . ) (9&�./( � (9% K . �" ' (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K=K � (9% KwB+N:K & x�K�) � ( ) � . 68, ( , ./( 35,'l % K�GJK=3�B �"076S35)vK�) & B9K�N &!( �:x�K=6 %'& )vK=) % �:{ ( 3�{ � 3 . (9% K �%" l�35076S3 . K ./( 3�{ � ( ) � . 68, (w

��

� ��

�� �")pR & N &�. l�K�G � �") l�3 . ) (9&�./(

o n/ n pj {� " � (9% K .f(9% K ( I43 @F& G & 0 & BHGfB93 (9&!( �:3 . ) l &�. l�K�NpK & l % 3 (9% KwB��d0 &;@ � . O (9% K K ./( �:B9K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 & l (( B �:x � & N"N:CP3 . � ( ) � . 68, (w ~j {Y "

� � � (9% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . )+l�3 . x�KwB (F(9% �")Ul�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& NS6 %'& )vK ) % �:{ ( � ./( 3& R � ( � �:6 �J)v3 (9% K=K ./( �:B9K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � . x�KwB ( ) � ( ) � . 68, (w du C`0 RS35N��"l & N"N:C��� � �#" "�� � � �#" " � ) �#" "� �#"%� � �") l�3 . ) (9&�./(� � � � �#" " � �#" " �%"%� � �") R & N &�. l�K�G ( o n/ y p

� ������� ��� � ��� � � #� ��� � � ���$� �#��� �* �") (9% K % K & B ( 3�{ (9% K & RS3�x�K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ��R8, (-(9%'&!(>& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 B9K �h, �:B9K�) ( I43 3�B & lwN:K �h,JKwB �:K�) � . 3�BHGJKwB ( 3( B &�. )9N &!( K (9% K 3�B & lwN:K � )PR � (�� � �:6 � ./( 3 & 6 %'& )vK ) % �:{ (w r4C ,') � . O & @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3al�3 . x�KwB ( (9% KR � (�� � �:6 � ./( 3 & 6 %'& )vK>) % �:{ ( � % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . O & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 B9K �h, �:B9K�)p3 . N:C 3 . K �h,JKwB9C ( 3 (9% K>3�B & lwN:KRD

�! -uh(9& B ( � . O7{�B9350 �#" �%" � & 6'68N:C &7@F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K B8BH) ( o � . 68, ( p �h,JR � (w ?h L+6'68N:C &P@F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K>)vK�l�3 . G[o�35, ( 68, ( p �h,JR � (w Dh } & )9) (9% K ( I43 �h,JR � ( ) ( 3 (9% K>3�B & lwN:K QJ Ujk. x�KwB ( ) ( Kw6�o ? p4RhC & 6'68N:C � . O &�. 3 (9% KwB @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K )vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � (w �& O & � .� Vh Ujk. x�KwB ( ) ( Kw6�o � p4RhC & 6'68N:C � . O &�. 3 (9% KwB @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K B8BH) ( �h,JR � (w

Page 70: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

��Q ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

TU% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 %'& ) (9% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . O l �:BHlw, � ( B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(9&!( �:3 . D

��

�� � �

� � � o n/ | puh( Kw68)5o ? p (9% B935,JO % o Q p & B9K &�. 3 (9% KwB �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . 3�{ 7�8,') � . O 3 . N:CM3 . K>3�B & lwN:K �h,JKwB9C L . 3 (9% KwB {�3�BH0 3�{ (9% KFR � (�� � �:6 � 6 %'& )vK � ) % �:{ ( K �h, �:x & N:K . l�KFK��`6'B9K�)9)vK�G � . K �h, &!( �:3 . o ?h ?�� p �") (9%'&!( � � "� � � ~TU% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K � � �%" " � � � �%" " � � �%"%( o n/ "�w� p

143 . ) �"GJKwB�� & ) � . o n/ Q p (9% K & l ( �:3 . )U3�{ (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � ����� & l ( � . O73 . � . 68, ( � " �%" D � " �%"��� � � " o � �%" p ���� � o#� � p � � � � " o � �%" p �� � o#� � p � � � � " �%"%( o n/ "��� p

}~B93�x �"GJK�G (9%'&!(4(9% KF)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( ) (9& B ( ) � .P(9% KF) (9&!( K �%" o�I % �"l % � ( GJ3hK�) � .7(9% K-) � . O5N:K � �h,JKwB9C & N:O�3�B � (9% 0epH�(9% �") ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �") (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K & { & � (9% {e,'N �"0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . 3�{Y

� ������� � �� � �)� � �$� � � � � ���$� �#��� �*TU% KwB9K & B9K & {�KwI K�)9)vK ./( � & NF{�K &!( ,JB9K�) 3�{ (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � ( �") I43�B (9% I % �"N:K ( 3 ( K & )vK 35, (w �E �:BH) ( � {�B9350&�. � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .�� (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"lM6S3 � ./( 3�{Ux �:KwI>�~)v35N:x � . O �FK�, ( )9l %�� ) 6'B93�R8N:K�0 B9K �h, �:B9K�) K�� ( B & l ( � . O 3 . K R � ( 3�{� . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .f& RS35, ( � DMI % K (9% KwB � ( �")ol�3 . ) (9&�./( 3�B7R & N &�. l�K�G TU% K 6'B93�R8N:K�0 I � (9% lwN & )9) �"l & N �h,JKwB �:K�) �")(9%'&!(P(9% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .f(9% KwC 6'B93�x �"GJK �")7,')vKw{e,'Np{�3�B &�. )vI4KwB � . O �h,JK�) ( �:3 . ) & RS35, (7(9% K � . G �:x �"G', & N~x & N",JK�)3�{�� o � p &�. G,� o � pH� . 3 ( 9,') ( I % K (9% KwB (9%'&�. I % K (9% KwB�� o � p " � o � p mW-. (9% KP3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� (9% K �h,JKwB9C � .(9% KM) � . O5N:K � �h,JKwB9C �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 6'B93�x �"GJK�) . 3 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & ) ( 3 (9% K & l ( , & N~x & N",JK73�{&� o � pH� 3 . N:CI % K (9% KwB � ( �") (9% K ) & 07K & )�� o � p =TU% K �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 l &�. �")9)9,JK & �h,JKwB9C (9%'&!( l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G')F073�B9K6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C ( 3 (9% K �h,JK�) ( �:3 . RSK � . O & ) @ K�G u 6SK &;@ � . O � . {�3�BH0 & N"N:C��/I4K=0 �:O %/( ) & C (9%'&!( (9% K �h,JKwB9C �")9)9,JK�GMRhC (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 & )9) �:O . )4K �h, & N & 0768N�� �

( ,'GJK�) ( 3 (9% K ( KwBH0P) �#"+&�. G �%"H u � . l�KoK & l % �h,JKwB9C B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./( )F3 . K R � ( 3�{ � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 03�R (9& � . ) %'& N:{ & R � ( 3�{ � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( (9% K>x & N",JK>3�{ � o � p &�. G %'& N:{ & R � ( 3�{ � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( � o � p TU% �") � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �")P) ( 3�B9K�G � . (9% KKB8BH) ( �h,JR � ( � . (9% K 6 %'& )vK�)P3�{ �#"P&�. G �%" �U)v3 (9%'&!( K & l %�( KwBH0 � .(9% K7)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . % 35N"G') %'& N:{ & R � ( 3�{ � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .� =TU% K @F& G & 0 & BHG ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . (9% K . l & ,')vK�) (9% K� . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( I % K (9% KwBZ� o � p�" � o � p ( 3 � ./( KwB9{�KwB9Kol�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K�N:C�� &�. G (9% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, (+(9% K)v6SK�l �CB�lFx & N",JK�) 3�{Y� o � p &�. G � o � p ( 3 � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K>GJK�) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K�N:C �~x�KwB9C 3 (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 I4K I �"N"N~K . l�35, ./( KwB I �"N"Nd,')vK & x & B � &�./( 3 .f(9% �") ( K�l %'. ��h,JK TU% K

)v6SK�l �CB�l~6 &!(v( KwB . 3�{ � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K �") ,')9, & N"N:C (9% K 0735) ( � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . OF6 & B ( 3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �F)9, & N"N:C��(9% KMl�350768N��"l &!( K�G 6 & B ( 3�{ GJK�) �:O . � . O & �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �")AB . G � . O & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . I % �"l % l & ,')vK�)l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K={�3�BUK�� & l ( N:C (9% K=B �:O %/( ( KwBH0�3�{ & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 .�

�FK�, ( )9l %�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") & N")v3 35,JBAB8BH) ( K�� & 0768N:K73�{ &�. 9;M�NP: S !#J�9RETSUL;V & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 TU% K ( I43 6S35)9) �:R8N:K&�. )vI4KwBH) � =I� �")>l�3 . ) (9&�./( ? &�. G�=I� �")=R & N &�. l�K�G ? � & B9KPK . l�3`GJK�G & ) �#"=&�. G �%" � B9K�)v6SK�l ( �:x�K�N:C PTU% K) (9&!( K �� ) �#"�# �� ) �%" �") & , . �:{�3�BH0 & 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( �:3 .7( 3 RS3 (9% �#"�&�. G �%"H dTU% K 3�B & lwN:K �h,JKwB9C & 0768N��CB8K�) (9%'&!(

Page 71: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ���� � ����� � ��� � ��� � ��� ����� ������� ������� � ��V

( KwBH0 � . (9% K+)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . I % �"l % �") &�.P& 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K+l�3�B9B9K�l (d&�. )vI4KwB �jk. �FK�, ( )9l %�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �3 . K 3�B & lwN:K �h,JKwB9C )9, r l�K�) ( 3 � . l�B9K & )vK (9% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK43�{ (9% K 6'B9Kw{�KwB9B9K�G ( KwBH0 ( 3 �;t � . �FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �0o,'N ( �:68N:K �h,JKwB �:K�) & B9K>B9K �h, �:B9K�G L . 3 (9% KwBFI & C ( 3 K��`6'B9K�)9) (9% K & GJx &�./(9& O�K K . v3�C�K�G RhC (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) �") ( 3 ) & C (9%'&!(F(9% KwC

K��`68N:3 � ( = �h, &�./( ,'0 6 & B & N"N:K�N��")90 ?mr4C l�B9K &!( � . O (9% K-)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . �� ) �#" # �� ) �%" � & �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0,')vK�)>)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . ( 3ml & N"lw,'N &!( K7Kwx�KwB9C x & N",JK73�{;� = � . 6 & B & N"N:K�N ? TU% K]B .'& N @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . (9% K .= & G'G')'? ( 3�O�K (9% KwBF6 %'& )vK l�35076S3 . K ./( )UI � (9% 35, ( K��`68N��"l � ( l & N"lw,'N &!( �:3 . �')v3 (9%'&!( � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K>K_sSK�l ( )Fl &�. RSK,')vK�G ( 3Ml & B9B9C 35, ( l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .�

� �� ����� � � � +!& " � $�+��� �� $ �. ,+0$(� �.2 ����� /

r4KwB . ) ( K � . &�. G �~&�� �:B &�. � ��{�35N"N:3�I � . O ,J6 3 . &�. �"GJK & 3�{ �FK�, ( )9l % &�. G �35) ��& �dO�K . KwB & N�� � K�G (9% K �FK�, ( )9l %6'B93�R8N:K�0 ( 3P{e, . l ( �:3 . )p3�{�073�B9K (9%'&�. 3 . K �h,JR � (w LWNI9;XYSTET^��YO VPJgETSUL;V����=3 . � � . 68, ( ) �")U)v6SK�l �CB8K�G RhC O �:x � . O &�. � � R � ( x�K�l ( 3�BZ� dE 3�B &�. C � . 68, ( ���

���ao �.p " � � � o n/ "��? p(9% K>073`G � ? GJ3 ( 6'B93`G','l ( 3�{ � &�. G � ~jk. (9% K>r4KwB . ) ( K � .����~&�� �:B &�. �S6'B93�R8N:K�0 � (9% K>0 C`) ( KwB9C {e, . l ( �:3 . �m3 . K3�{ (9% K ?�� 6 & B � ( C {e, . l ( �:3 . ) 3 . � � . 68, ( ) dTU% K (9& ) @ 3�{ (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") ( 3 GJK ( KwBH0 � . K � UW R8)vKwB9x�K (9%'&!((9% K �FK�, ( )9l % 6'B93�R8N:K�0 �") 073�B9K=3�BUN:K�)9)w� (9% K-3 . K � R � ( l & )vK>3�{ (9% �")46'B93�R8N:K�0 D � �")pl�3 . ) (9&�./( {�3�B&� " �7&�. GR & N &�. l�K�G {�3�B�� " ��( � jk. (9% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . OPG �")9lw,')9) �:3 . �`I4K I �"N"N�,')vK � � ( 3 � . G �"l &!( K (9% K R � ( I �")vK & G'G � ( �:3 .oe073`G','N:3 ? p43�{ ( I43Px�K�l ( 3�BH)

� ������� ��� � � ��� ���%�� � ���� � ���)�� � � ���$� �#��� �*1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�� (9% �")�6'B93�R8N:K�0 l &�. RSK4)v35N:x�K�GoI � (9% � �h,JKwB �:K�) ��� & 0 � . KpGJK ( KwBH0 � . KdK & l % R � ( 3�{��8�!3 . K � RhC � 3 . K��RhC K�� & 0 � . � . O

� o �w��� ( ( ( � p �� o �J�w� ( ( ( � p � � o ����� ( ( (!� p

o n/ "��D p

L �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�l &�. 6'B93`G','l�K &�. K�� & l ( )v35N", ( �:3 . ( 3 (9% �")F6'B93�R8N:K�0 � % 3�I4Kwx�KwB���I � (9% 3 . N:Cm3 . K�h, &�./( ,'0 �h,JKwB9C oTU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") (9% K � � R � ( K�� ( K . ) �:3 . 3�{ (9% K7) � . O5N:K � �h,JKwB9C & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B �FK�, ( )9l %�� )6'B93�R8N:K�0 E �:BH) ( �JI4K>B9K �h, �:B9K &�. � � R � ( x�KwBH) �:3 . 3�{ (9% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . �'{�3�B (9% KAB8BH) (U&�. G N & ) ( ) (9& O�K�)U3�{ (9% K

073`G �CB8K�G & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 L+6'68N:C � . O (9% Ko) � . O5N:K � R � (+@F& G & 0 & BHGmB93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 K & l % �h,JR � ( 3�{ &�. � � R � ( B9KwO �") ( KwB- (�G6D 7/D�2�:\@FL 8;8;:�7/D/L �$? 7�=&7�=�: � :2 7�@/<>=;M D�GBW�K :8ZA � : � GB2�K P&0�::QP�7�G*46K K G"�(0�:RU4I7�? GB0�@JG6E"M54ID�? 7�L�EH2�0�<�7�? GB0�@] � =�:\GB0�:#+ W�? 7

TU:�D�@/? GB0&G6E�7�=�: +�:�D�0�@F7�:? 0 + ��4�? D>460�?5M D�GBW�K :8 � GB2�K P;D�:Q132�? D�: � � � � � �XA 4605P;<Q460;7�=X2�@�WN:$@/GBK TU:QP;<K 46@/@/? <Q46K K L�? 0;GB0�:S132�:�D/L �[GB07�=�: TB46K 2�:YG6E � � �>]

Page 72: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

��� ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

O �:x�K�) & ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . I � (9% (9% K>B �:O %/( 6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) �FK . 3 ( K (9% �") � � R � (p( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � � ��v ~TU% K .� � �� � " " � ��! " � � � " ( ( ( � � � � � ""

� � ����� ! � � � ""

� � ����� !�! ? o� �#"\# o#� � p � ' �%" p

" �! ? � ����� � �� ' ��� !�� � �

o#� � p � '�� � ' � � "" �! ? � �

� ��� !�� � � &o#� � p ��� � � "%( o n/ "��Q p

�F) � . O (9% �") GJK_B . � ( �:3 . �hI4K l &�.m. 3�I O �:x�K &�. & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ( 3M)v35N:x�K (9% K r4KwB . ) ( K � .����~&�� �:B &�. �S6'B93�R8N:K�0 �! -uh(9& B ( � . O7{�B9350 ��� " �%" � & 6'68N:C (9% K � � R � ( @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . � � ��~( 3 (9% KAB8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB ?h L+6'68N:C &P@F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K>)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � (w Dh } & )9) (9% K>B9KwO �") ( KwB &�. G (9% K>)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � (p( 3 (9% K=3�B & lwN:K QJ L+6'68N:C &P@F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% K>)vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � (w Vh L+6'68N:C (9% K � � R � ( @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 (9% KAB8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB

TU% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 I �"N"N ( KwBH0 � .'&!( K � . (9% KM) (9&!( K � " �%" �~)v3 (9%'&!( � l &�. RSKMGJK ( KwBH0 � . K�G I � (9% l�KwB (9& � ./( C RhCK�� & 0 � . � . O (9% KAB8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB uh( Kw68)-o ? p (9% B935,JO % o Q p �"0768N:K�07K ./(~&�. � � R � ( x�KwBH) �:3 . 3�{$ 7�/I % �"l % I4KFl & N"N � ��v }~B93�x �"GJK�G (9% KF)vK�l�3 . G

�h,JR � ( RSKwO � . ) � . ) (9&!( K �%" o�I % �"l % � ( GJ3hK�) � . (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0epH� � ��~& l ( )U3 . (9% K B8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB & ) � "� & &)(� � o#� � p ��� � � "%( o n/ "��V p

� �� 0o,'N ( �:68N��:K�)dRhC � �-(9% K>6 %'& )vK=3�{ &�. C ( KwBH0 � . (9% K )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . {�3�BUI % �"l % � o �.p " �! � ������� �V� �$� �$� � � �)�)� � �)� � ���TU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�RSKwO � . ) RhC & 6'68N:C � . O� � ��d( 3 & B9KwO �") ( KwB-l�3 ./(9& � . � . O ��� "H -u � . l�K � � " � {�3�B & N"N � � (9% K) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K>B9KwO �") ( KwBURSK�l�3507K�)

� � " � & &)(� � �! ? � ������ !�� � � & � "%( ) o n/ "��� p

� �� (9% K . �"076S35)vK�) & B9K�N &!( �:x�K+6 %'& )vK+) % �:{ ( 3 . )v3507K+3�{ (9% KFl�35076S3 . K ./( )d3�{ (9% KF)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . � .7(9% K,B8BH) (B9KwO �") ( KwBgD

�! ? � ������ !�� � � & � "� & &)(� � �! ? � ������ !�� � � &

o#� � p ��� � � "%( o n/ "��n p

Page 73: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ���� � ����� � ��� � ��� � ��� ����� ������� ������� � �5n

E � .'& N"N:C�� & )vK�l�3 . G � � R � (F@F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . l�3 . x�KwB ( ) (9% �")+6 %'& )vKo) % �:{ ( � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . R & l @ � ./( 3MR � (�� � �:6{�3�BH0 D

�! ? � ������ !�� � � &o#� � p ��� � � " � & &)(� � �! ? � ������ !�� � � &

o#� � p ��� ���� �! ? � �� ��� !�� � � &

o#� � p ��� � � "���" ������ !�� � � &

�� �? � �

� ��� !�� � � &o#� � p ��� � " ��� � �� � "

" �� ��� !�� � � &

�� �? � ������ !�� � � &

o#� � p ��� � ��� � �� � " o n/ "��y p

TU% KMl�3hK_r l �:K ./( 3�{! � " � . (9% �") )9,'0�l &�. RSKPB9KwIUB � (v( K . � . ( KwBH0P) 3�{&� 143 . ) �"GJKwB B8BH) (>(9% K l & )vK � " � u � . l�K

� � " ��� ( ( ( � � o n/ "��| p

(9% K=6 %'& )vK=l�35076S3 . K ./( 3�{ Kwx�KwB9C ( KwBH0 � . ) �"GJK (9% K>)9,'0 3�x�KwB � � . o n/ "��y p �") �=&�. G��mx &�. �") % K�)4{�B9350 � . ) �"GJK(9% K )9,'0P0 &!( �:3 . D

�? � ������ !�� � � &

o#� � p ��� � ��� � " �? � ������ !�� � � &

� " � o n/ ?!� p

TU% ,')w� (9% K l�35076S3 . K ./( 3�{ � " � . (9% K )9,'0P0 &!( �:3 . 3�x�KwB � � . o n/ "��y p �") �! �mK & )9,JB � . O (9% KB8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwBC �:K�N"G') � " I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C �!

# K=l�35,'N"GM) ( 3�6 (9% K &�.'& N:C`) �") &!(4(9% �")~6S3 � ./( �h) � . l�KUI4K & , ( 350 &!( �"l & N"N:C @`. 3�I (9%'&!(d(9% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK 3�{ � "� . � " 0o,') ( RSK � {�3�B &�. C ��" � pj { � ( I4KwB9Ko)v3507K . 3 . � KwB93Mx & N",JK � � (9% K . (9% K 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( CM3�{�3�R8)vKwB9x � . O � " I435,'N"G RSK � ) � &�. G (9% K ( 3 (9& N�6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C I435,'N"G { & �"N ( 3m)9,'0 ( 3 �! 7j ( �") � . ) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K�� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� ( 3l & B9B9C 35, (U(9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . {�3�B (9% K�)vK>3 (9% KwB � � ( 3M)vKwK>6'B9K�l �")vK�N:CMI % C (9% K �:BUl�3hK_r l �:K ./( )Ux &�. �") %�

u ,J6'6S35)vK (9%'&!( ��" � =TU% K . �m&�. G9� 0o,') ( G �CsSKwB � . &!( N:K & ) ( 3 . K R � (w F# � (9% 35, ( N:35)9)F3�{~O�K . KwB & N�� ( C��)9,J6'6S35)vK (9%'&!( � ( �") (9% K N:Kw{ ( 0735) ( R � ( �5)v3 (9%'&!( � ! �" �"! (�TU% K . (9% K N:Kw{ ( 0735) ( R � ( 3�{�� � I �"N"N5RSK �! 143 . ) �"GJKwB(9% KFx & N",JK�)d3�{0� coF� � p�{�3�B ( I43 x & N",JK�)43�{ �joeN:K ( ,')4l & N"N (9% K�0����! &�. G �� � p~I % �"l % G �CsSKwBd3 . N:C � .M(9% K�B8BH) (G �:O � ( D

�� � aoF� � p " o����! �w� ( ( (�� p aoF� � p" o����! oF� � p p # o �w� ( ( (�� oF� � p p" ���! oF� � p #��( o n/ ?`� p

W { &�. CP)9,'l % 6 & �:B~3�{ ��� (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K��/3 . KUI �"N"N`B & �")vK � � ( 3 &�. Kwx�K . 6S3�I4KwB�� &�. G (9% KU3 (9% KwB ( 3 &�. 3`G'G76S3�I4KwB

Page 74: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

��y ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

TU% K>l�3hK_r l �:K ./( 3�{ � " {�B9350 K �h, &!( �:3 . o n/ "��y p l &�. (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K>RSK-IUB � (v( K . & )�? � ������ !�� � � &

o#� � p ��� � ��� � " �? � �� ' ��� !�� � �

o#� � p � ��� ��� " �

? � �� ' �� � ��� !�� � ��� �� � ��� !�� � �

o#� � p ��� � � " � ��" �

? � �� ' �� � ��� !�� � �o o � p # o#� � p p

" �? � �� ' �� � ��� !�� � �

� o n/ ?�? p" � ( o n/ ?�D p

� ������� � �\ � � ��� �

L . C G �CsSKwB9K . l�K RSK ( I4KwK . � &�. G �a07K &�. ) (9%'&!(7(9% K l�3 ./( B �:R8, ( �:3 . ) ( 3 (9% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK 3�{ � " {�B9350 (9% Kx & B �:35,') � " l &�. RSK & B9B &�. O�K�G � ./( 376 & �:BH)pI % �"l % l &�. l�K�N L . 3 (9% KwB I & C 3�{�N:3h3 @ � . O &!(p(9% �")p6'B93�R8N:K�0 � � . )v6 �:B9K�GPRhC E 35,JB �:KwB &�.'& N:C`) �")w� �") ( 3 . 3 ( K (9%'&!( (9% K-6 & B � ( C

{e, . l ( �:3 . )Z���0D�# � ����& � � # � ����&M& B9K (9% K E 35,JB �:KwB-R & ) �")+{e, . l ( �:3 . )�����0D�# � ����& � � # ��� � ��& � RhCmG �CsSKwB9K ./(.'& 07K�) � TU% K E 35,JB �:KwB R & ) �") #�� � & � ��� !�� � � & �") lwN:35)vK�N:C & )9)v3`l � &!( K�G I � (9%(9% K E 35,JB �:KwB R & ) �") {e, . l ( �:3 . � .)vKwx�KwB & N I & C`)w� � . lwN",'G � . O (9%'&!( ���� � " " � � "H =u �"073 .�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�K��`68N:3 � ( ) (9% Ko0o, ( , & N�3�B (9% 3�O�3 .'& N�� ( C 3�{(9% K>{e, . l ( �:3 . )����� TU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�) (9& B ( )URhC 6'B9Kw6 & B � . O (9% K>) (9&!( K� �S! "H 4TU% K=3�B & lwN:K �h,JKwB9C �"0768N:K�07K ./( ) & O�B935,J6 & l ( �:3 .

3 . (9% K E 35,JB �:KwBUR & ) �") I % �"l % (9&;@ K�) �S! "4( 3 � � "H 4TU% K B .'& N @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . �") &PE 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH03 . # � ����& � �hI % �"l % )vK . G') � "�( 3 � " I � (9% l�3hK_r l �:K ./( O �:x�K . RhC�� � o� � " p ~j { � " �") (9% KF) (9&!( K=l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G � . O( 3 (9% K>6 & B � ( C ��E 35,JB �:KwBU{e, . l ( �:3 . ������ (9% K . ��� o� � " p " � R8, ( � � o� � " p�" � {�3�B &�. C 3 (9% KwB ��

� ��� �]$�/ 2-+��Q& � �.2 ����� /

TU% K & RS3�x�K-K�� & 0768N:K�)4GJ3 & l ( , & N"N:C . 3 ( B9Kw6'B9K�)vK ./(p& 0 & v3�BpO & � . {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) LFN (9% 35,JO %M(9% K�h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) & B9K RSK (v( KwB�� (9% KwC & B9K { & ) ( KwB &!( )v35N:x � . OF6'B93�R8N:K�0P) (9%'&!( I4KwB9K . 3 . K (9% K�N:K�)9)�lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:CK & )vC r4KwB . ) ( K � .M&�. G �~&�� �:B &�. � �/073`G �:{�C � . O (9% K & RS3�x�K+6'B93�R8N:K�0 � ./( 3 & B9K�lw,JBH) �:x�K+l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . �/6'B93`G','l�K�G(9% K B8BH) ( 6'B93�R8N:K�0s)v35N:x & R8N:K � . 6S35N:C . 350 � & N ( �"07K � . & �h, &�./( ,'0�073`GJK�N �!R8, (�. 3 ( � .7& lwN & )9) �"l & Nh3 . K 4u �"073 .GJKwx�K�N:3�6SK�G (9% K {�35N"N:3�I � . O ) �"0768N:KwBF6'B93�R8N:K�0 ��I % �"l % ) ( �"N"N�O �:x�K�) (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 &�. K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N)v6SKwK�G',J6 # K>) & C (9%'&!(U& {e, . l ( �:3 . � �")-S<V b;9;XYSU9;V E O VPZaH_X� � � � M9qd�� �:{ (9% KwB9K �")p)v3507K � � R � ( x & N",JKZ� )9,'l % (9%'&!(

� o �.p " � o � �Ip o n/ ?�Q p��� =�:CP ? �V:�D�:0�<:*WN:�7 � ::0 ��� 4605P����� ? @\7�=�:CP ? �V:�D�:0�<:*WN:�7 � ::0���� � 4605PZ7�=�:*8C2�K 7�? M�K ? <Q4I7�? TU: R6D�GB2�M G6E�@�13254ID�: D�G3G67�@ G6E

2�0�? 7�L GITU:�D"7�=�:�<GB8;M�K : ' 0X2�8CWN:�D�@%(N7 � G �J4L @ G6E5P :@/<�D�? W�? 0�R$7�=�:�@�468;:�R6D�GB2�M*@F7/D�2�<�7�2 D�:BA6GB0�:�4BP�P ? 7�? TU:�4605PYGB0�:�8C2�K 7�? M�K ? <Q4I7�? TU:B]

Page 75: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � � � ����� ���� ������� � ��|

{�3�B & N"N � # � (9% B9K�)v6SK�l (o( 3 (9% K & G'G � ( �:x�KMO�B935,J6 ) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9KM3 .�� �) �~)9,'l % {e, . l ( �:3 . ) & B9K 6SKwB �:3`G �"l I � (9%6SKwB �:3`G�� ~jk.mu �"073 .�� )p6'B93�R8N:K�0 � (9% K , .I@`. 3�I . {e, . l ( �:3 . �") )v3507K

� D # � ����& � � # � ����& � o n/ ?�V pI % �"l % �") � . x & B � &�./( , . GJKwB )v3507K�� W q � 0 & ) @ � ~E ,JB (9% KwB�� �:{S� o �.p " � o � p (9% K . � " � 3�B'� � " �� ~TU% K6'B93�R8N:K�0 �") ( 3MGJK ( KwBH0 � . K (9% K�� W q � 0 & ) @ � �1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�� &�. C & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�{�3�B (9% �") 6'B93�R8N:K�0 �JKwx�K . & 6'B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"l+3 . K��'B9K �h, �:B9K�) ( �"07K>K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N

� . �� T I43mG �") ( � . l ( �h,JKwB �:K�) � &�. G � )9,'l % (9%'&!( � o �.p!" � o � p-)9, r l�K ( 3 GJK ( KwBH0 � . K �8��R8, (>&�. C )vK ( 3�{�h,JKwB �:K�)+I % �"l % { & �"N") ( 3 6'B93�x �"GJKo)9,'l % & 6 & �:BF6'B93�x �"GJK�) . 3 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( � =TU% K 3�6 ( �"0 & N�) ( B &!( KwO�C{�3�B &�. C & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") ( 3 0 & � �"0 � � K (9% K . ,'0 RSKwBo3�{FG �") ( � . l ( x & N",JK�) 3�{ � � � .a(9% K )vK ( 3�{ �h,JKwB �:K�) � (�")9)9,JK�) rp, (!� �h,JKwB �:K�)Ul &�. O�K . KwB &!( K &!( 0735) (!� )9,'l % 6 & �:BH)w�8)v3 (9%'&!(+(9% K I43�BH) (�� l & )vK . ,'0 RSKwB+3�{ �h,JKwB �:K�)B9K �h, �:B9K�G ( 3 GJK ( KwBH0 � . �") ( �"l & N"N:C ( B9C & N"N ?�� 6S35)9) �:R8N:K � �") �uo ?�� � �_p }~B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"l & N"N:C�� (9% K K��`6SK�l ( K�G ( �"07K�") �uo ?�� � ) pH�'I % �"l % �") ) ( �"N"NSK��`6S3 . K ./( � & N

� ��� ��� � �> � ��� � � ���$� �#��� �*W-. (9% K=3 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� &�. K��`6SK�l ( K�G �o � p � ( KwB &!( �:3 . )p3�{ (9% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . O & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�)v35N:x�K u �"073 .�� )46'B93�R8N:K�0 D

�! }~B9Kw6 & B9K ( I43MB9KwO �") ( KwBH) � . (9% K ) (9&!( K� � � " � � "H ?h L+6'68N:C � � ���( 3 (9% K B8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB ( 3P3�R (9& � . (9% K=Kwx�K . )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ & N"NSR & ) �") ) (9&!( K�) Dh 1 & N"N (9% K>3�B & lwN:K>3 . (9% K ( I43MB9KwO �") ( KwBH) QJ �mK & )9,JB9K (9% K )vK�l�3 . G B9KwO �") ( KwB Vh L+6'68N:C � � ���( 3 (9% K B8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB �h �mK & )9,JB9K (9% K B8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB

� K ( , RSK (9% K>)vK (# � D � � " � &)( o n/ ?�� p

TU% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ( KwBH0 � .'&!( K�)UI � (9% � " � . (9% KuB8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB��8I % KwB9K � �")UB &�. GJ350PN:C GJB & I . {�B9350 , �� 3 ( K(9%'&!(-��� % ,M� (9%'&!( , �")+lwN:35)vK�G , . GJKwB � &�. G (9%'&!( ,� " ?�� � � +TU% ,') , {�3�BH0P) & )9,JR8)v6 & l�K>3�{ # � ����& �&�. G %'& )=G �"07K . ) �:3 . � � �! E B9350 &�. C � � � N�� . K & BHN:C � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( K�N:K�07K ./( )=3�{ ,�I4K7I �"N"N�RSK & R8N:K ( 3GJK ( KwBH0 � . K-RS3 (9% , &�. G(� � K ( ,')�K�� & 0 � . K (9% K & l ( �:3 . )~3�{ (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�073�B9K+lwN:35)vK�N:C ( 3 )vKwK+I % C � ( I43�B @ ) duh( Kw68)-o � p (9% B935,JO %

o D p46'B9Kw6 & B9K (9% K ) (9&!( K�! ? � ������ !�� � � &

� " � o �.p "%( o n/ ?5n p

� .�: �$? K K�0�:RBK :<�7J7�=�: P :RB:0�:�D>4I7�: <Q46@/:� � �*? 0�GB2 D\460546K L @/? @] � 4605P K ? 0�R 7�=�? @J<Q46@/:SD�:Q132�? D�:@ GB0�K L�4 <GB0�@F7>46037$0X2�8CWN:�D�G6E4BP�P ? 7�? GB0546K 132�:�D�? :@%, D�2�K ? 0�R�? 7\GB2 7JD�:8;GITU:@$4C<G6D�0�:�D\<Q46@/:YE D�GB8 7�=�:Y460546K L @/? @\G6E 7�=�:Y46K RBG6D�? 7�=�8Z]

Page 76: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

n�� ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

u � . l�K � %'& ) 6SKwB �:3`G��8�807K & )9,JB � . O (9% K>)vK�l�3 . G B9KwO �") ( KwBUC �:K�N"G')�! ? o� ��! "J# ��! � " p � o ��!gp " o n/ ?�y p

{�3�B-)v3507K ��!=B &�. GJ350PN:C l % 35)vK . {�B9350 + L (F(9% �")U6S3 � ./( � � � �� I �"N"NSK�� ( B & l ( )v3507K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( � u � . l�K (9% K )vK�l�3 . G �h,JR � ( . 3MN:3 . O�KwB & sSK�l ( ) (9% K ) (9&!( K 3�{ (9% K B8BH) ( �h,JR � ( �`I4K GJB93�6 � ( {�B9350 (9% K &�.'& N:C`) �") �! ? ��! "J# �! ? ��! � " � & &)(� � �! ? �� �! ? � �

� ��� !�� � � &o#� � p ��� � � "��� # �! ? �� �! ? � �

� ��� !�� � � &o#� � p � � ��� � � � "���

" �! ? �! ? � �� ��� !�� � � &

o#� � p ��� � o �C# o#� � p � � � p � " o n/ ?�| p

j {*� � " � � (9% K . (9% K7l�3hK_r l �:K ./( 3�{ � " x &�. �") % K�) -j {C� � " � � (9% K ( I43 ( KwBH0P) � . ) �"GJK (9% K7)9,'0P0 &!( �:3 .& G'G l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K�N:C &�. G$ � "4%'& )Ul�3hK_r l �:K ./(

o#� � p ��� �! ? � � � ( o n/ D!� p

� ��� ��� � �� � �)� � �$� � � � � ���$� �#��� �*TU% KMB9K & N40 & O �"l � . (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 (9&;@ K�) 68N & l�K G',JB � . O (9% K )vK�l�3 . G @F& G & 0 & BHGaB93 (9&!( �:3 .� r4Kw{�3�B9K (9% �")B93 (9&!( �:3 . � (9% K#B8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB~l�3 ./(9& � . ) & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ ( I43>K�N:K�07K ./( )w�5K & l % 3�{8I % �"l % l�3 ./(9& � . ) . 3=,')vKw{e,'N� . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . RhC � ( )vK�N:{ �TU% K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � . (9% �")p) (9&!( K �") � . (9% K>l�3�B9B9K�N &!( �:3 . RSK ( I4KwK . (9% K�)vK-K�N:K�07K ./( ) �(9% KwC & B9K>)vKw6 & B &!( K�G RhC K�� & l ( N:C � ~TU% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . K��`6S35)vK�) (9% �")pl�3�B9B9K�N &!( �:3 . RSK�l & ,')vK � ( �") (9% KE 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0�{�3�B (9% K & G'G � ( �:x�K=O�B935,J6 3�{ � � R � ( x�K�l ( 3�BH) }d, (p&�. 3 (9% KwB I & C���� �") & 6SKwB �:3`G �"l {e, . l ( �:3 . � &�. G I4K-I �") %P( 3PGJK ( KwBH0 � . K � ( )46SKwB �:3`G L+{ ( KwBU) & 0768N�� . O

� &!( & O�B9K &!( 0 &�. CP6S3 � ./( ) � . 6 & B & N"N:K�N �/I4K & 6'68N:C (9% K E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 ( 37l�3 . x�KwB ( (9% K-) & 0768N:K�GM6S3 � ./( )� ./( 3 & )vK ( 3�{ E 35,JB �:KwB l�3hK_r l �:K ./( ) aW { (9% K�)vK l�3hK_r l �:K ./( )w� ���� I �"N"N�RSK N & B9O�K &�. G (9% K B9K�) ( I �"N"N�x &�. �") %� r43 (9%7(9% K ) & 0768N�� . O+6'B93`l�K�)9) &�. G (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 & B9KpK_r l �:K ./( {�3�B & �h, &�./( ,'0)vC`) ( K�0 �/RSK�l & ,')vKF)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 .o& N"N:3�I+)d) & 0768N�� . O &!(4&�. K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N . ,'0 RSKwB~3�{S6S3 � ./( ) &�. G � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K& N"N:3�I+) {�3�BUB & 6 �"G l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K E 35,JB �:KwB+l�3hK_r l �:K ./( ) W-.M&�. 3 (9% KwB . 3 ( K�� & N (9% 35,JO % I4KF07K & )9,JB9K�G (9% K-)vK�l�3 . GPB9KwO �") ( KwB � . ) ( Kw6ho Q pH� (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {e, . l ( �:3 . )

�"GJK ./( �"l & N"N:C �:{ (9% �")F) ( Kw6 �")+GJB93�6'6SK�G TU% Ko)vK�l�3 . G B9KwO �") ( KwB-GJ3hK�) . 3 ( 6 & B ( �"l �:6 &!( K � . (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 & { ( KwB(9% �")~) ( Kw6 �hR8, ( � ( �") � .P& )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{�0 &�. C7R & ) �")~) (9&!( K�) dTU% K�)vK ( KwBH0P)d3�{ (9% K+)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . l &�.'. 3 (� ./( KwB9{�KwB9K I � (9% K & l % 3 (9% KwB�� & ) (9% Kml�3 ./( K ./( ) 3�{ (9% Km)vK�l�3 . G B9KwO �") ( KwBMB9K�0 & � . G �") ( � . l ( RSK ( I4KwK .�(9% K�0 } KwBH0 &�. K ./( N:C �")v35N &!( � . O & 6 �:K�l�K73�{ & )vC`) ( K�0 {�B9350 (9% K B9K�) ( 3�{ (9% K7)vC`) ( K�0 �")w��{�B9350 (9% K 6SKwBH)v6SK�l ( �:x�K 3�{(9% K )vC`) ( K�0 �JK �h, �:x & N:K ./( ( 3M07K & )9,JB � . O (9%'&!( 6 �:K�l�K>3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0

� ��� �]�!2�� �Q& ������2�� $ ".�0/u �"073 .�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �SO �:x�K . & {e, . l ( �:3 . I � (9% 6SKwB �:3`G �8� GJK ( KwBH0 � . K�)�� 7u 3 GJ3hK�) u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 TU% KG �CsSKwB9K . l�KmRSK ( I4KwK .(9% K ( I43 �") (9% K ) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9Km3�{ (9% K , . GJKwBHN:C � . O O�B935,J6 �u �"073 .�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ( B9K &!( )

Page 77: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ����� � ���� ��� � ����� nh�

# � ����& � & ) (9% KoO�B935,J6 o�� � ? p � �SI � (9%m& O�B935,J6 N & Is3�{~K��JlwN",') �:x�K �kW q u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ( B9K &!( ) # � ����& � & )(9% K O�B935,J6�� � ?�� �~I � (9%f& O�B935,J6 N & I 3�{+R � .'& B9C & G'G � ( �:3 . � &�. &!(v( � ( ,'GJK I4K l &�. K�076 %'& ) � � K RhC IUB � ( � . O# � ����& � & ) # � ����� ( ( (��H?�� � ��&5 L {e, . l ( �:3 . � �") N H_XYSULgZ;SUJ f STE<G5N H_XYSULgZ �Cs9� o �.p " � o � p�I % K . Kwx�KwB � " � # `� &�. G � �") . 3 ( 6SKwB �:3`G �"l

I � (9% 6SKwB �:3`GM)90 & N"N:KwB (9%'&�. �� 4u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 GJK ( KwBH0 � . K�) (9% KFx & N",JKF3�{>{�3�B 6SKwB �:3`G �"lp{e, . l ( �:3 . ) (9%'&!(& B9K>K_r l �:K ./( N:C l�350768, (9& R8N:K

� � ����� ��� � #� �� � * �Y� �#����� � �)������� ��

TU% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . � � �� l & B9B �:K�)435, (p& E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 3 . # � ����& �S ~E 3�B!# � ����� ( ( (��H?�� � ��& � (9% K& 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( K &�.'& N:3�O5,JK �") & �h, &�./( ,'0 x�KwBH) �:3 . 3�{ & ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& NdG �")9l�B9K ( K E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 ��O�K . KwB & N"N:CB9Kw{�KwB9B9K�G ( 3 & )5o (9% Kqp+*-, &�./( ,'0 E 35,JB �:KwB T B &�. )v{�3�BH0 o * E�T pH�'I % �"l % & l ( ) & )

� " * E�T� � " �! ? � ) & � ��� � !�X) � � � � ��� ) & � " o n/ D`� p

I % KwB9K � % # � ����� ( ( (��H?�� � ��& oe)v3 (9%'&!( � " RSK�N:3 . O5) ( 3 (9% K-l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N8R & ) �")Yp �TU% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK 3�{ (9% K � "~( KwBH0 � .M(9% K-B .'& N�) (9&!( K �") � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( 3�{ � &�. G � �`R8, (4(9% K-6 %'& )vKF3�{ (9% �") ( KwBH0�GJKw6SK . G')~3 . RS3 (9% �&�. G �� �# K � ./( B93`G','l�K (9% K . 3 (9&!( �:3 .

� o � p " � � ��� � o n/ D�? p)v3 (9%'&!( * E�T � " l &�. RSK=B9KwIUB � (v( K . & )

�! ? � ) & � ��� � !

� � � �? � � � � � "%( o n/ D�D p

# K I �"N"N & N")v3M,')vK (9% K �"GJK ./( � ( C�� o �.p� o � p "� o � # � p TU% K7lwN & )9) �"l & N�G �")9l�B9K ( K E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0�l &�. RSKoK_r l �:K ./( N:C l�350768, ( K�G t )v3 l &�. (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 G �") �

l�B9K ( K E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 �TU% K K & ) �:K�) ( I & C ( 3 (9% � .I@ & RS35, ( (9% K l �:BHlw, � ( (9%'&!( �"0768N:K�07K ./( ) � ( �") & )& R � .'& B9C 0o,'N ( �:68N��"l &!( �:3 . l �:BHlw, � ( I % �"l % l�350768, ( K�)>R � ( I �")vK 6'B93`G','l ( ) � . l�B9K�07K ./(9& N"N:C���) (9& B ( � . O {�B9350 (9% K0735) (�� ) �:O . �CB�l &�./(�� R � (�&�. G I43�B @ � . O ( 3�I & BHG') (9% KUN:K & ) (�� ) �:O . �CB�l &�./( R � (w 1pN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�� &�. � . l�B9K�07K ./(9& NJl & N"lw, �N &!( �:3 . B9Kw6SK &!( K�G'N:CPN:Kw{ (�� ) % �:{ ( )d6'B9Kwx �:35,')~6 & B ( � & N86'B93`G','l ( ) t/(9% K>* E�T& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ,')vK�)4)9,'lwl�K�)9) �:x�K�N:CP)90 & N"N:KwB6 %'& )vK=B93 (9&!( �:3 . )U{�3�B+N:K�)9) ) �:O . �CB�l &�./( R � ( ) . � ( � & N�� � K (9% K=B9KwO �") ( KwB TU% K=l �:BHlw, � ( � ( )vK�N:{ �")p0 & GJK>,J6 {�B9350 ( I43 @ � . G')43�{�O &!( K�) 4E �:BH) ( � (9% KwB9K & B9K-3 . K �

R � (-@F& G & 0 & BHG O &!( K�) E 3�B l�3 . ) �") ( K . l�CmI � (9% u`% 3�B � ) . 3 (9&!( �:3 . ��I4KPl & N"N � � (9% K @F& G & 0 & BHG O &!( K7I % �"l %& l ( )>3 . �h,JR � ( �� Mu K�l�3 . G�� (9% KwB9K & B9K & N")v3 l�3 . G � ( �:3 .'& N B93 (9&!( �:3 . O &!( K�)

�� � � � I % �"l % 0o,'N ( �:68N:C (9% K76 %'& )vK

RhC�� o ?�� � � p �Cs RS3 (9% 3�{ (9% K �:B � . 68, ( )]o (9% K� (9% &�. G �h(9% �h,JR � ( 3�{ & B9KwO �") ( KwB_p & B9K �%"H � 3 ( K (9%'&!(F& N"N (9% K�� � � l�350P0o, ( K>I � (9% K & l % 3 (9% KwB�� & ) 6 %'& )vK>0o,'N ( �:68N��"l &!( �:3 . )pl�350P0o, ( K TU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ( 3 l�350768, ( K (9% K * E�T I43�B @ ) & )U{�35N"N:3�I+)mD- � =�? @ <GB05P ? 7�? GB0&<Q460�46K @/G*WN:$D�:@F7>4I7�:QP;? 0;7�=�:\:Q132�? TB46K :037�EHG6D�8 � ��� � � � ��� � ? ��� � �������\EHG6DJ@/GB8;:\? 037�:RB:�D��;@/2�<>=�7�=54I7

��!���� � � !" "! � !-$%$%$%!�� & � �U]

Page 78: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

n!? ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

�! � 3 & G � ./( 3 (9% K B9KwO �") ( KwB (9% KU) (9&!( K ( 3>I % �"l %o(9% K+* E�T I �"N"N/RSK & 6'68N��:K�G�� & lwl�3�BHG � . O ( 3 (9% KUl�3 . x�K ./( �:3 .(9%'&!( �:{ (9% K=B9KwO �") ( KwB �") � . (9% K>) (9&!( K

��! " � � " ( ( ( � � � � "%� o n/ D�Q p(9% K . ��! �") (9% KMLqd_E�) �:O . �CB�l &�./( G �:O � ( 3�{ � &�. G � � � � �") (9% K: H'9qd_E ) �:O . �CB�l &�./( G �:O � (w

?h +E 3�B+K & l % � {�B9350 �=( 3 � �'l & B9B9C 35, ( (9% K>{�35N"N:3�I � . O7) ( Kw68)� L+6'68N:C (9% K>O &!( K�)

�� � � {�3�B & N"N � ��

� L+6'68N:C (9% K>O &!( K � � TU% K=B9KwO �") ( KwBUI �"N"N . 3�I RSK � . & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ &P. ,'0 RSKwB 3�{ ( KwBH0P)w�JK & l % 3�{ (9% K>{�3�BH0

� ! " � � " ( ( ( � � � � "%( o n/ D�V pTU% K�)vK ( KwBH0P) & B9K (9% K \_STE � X'H_bRH_X�dm9;: d=3�{ (9% K &�. )vI4KwBgD � . K & l % � � ! �") (9% KK: H'9qd_Ed) �:O . �CB�l &�./( G �:O � ( 3�{ � &�. G� � � � �") (9% KMLqd_E ) �:O . �CB�l &�./( G �:O � (w T 3 RSKo6'B9K�l �")vK & RS35, (F(9% �")+R � (�� B9Kwx�KwBH) & N I4K7,')vK(+ � &�. G , � & )-) % 3�B (9%'&�. Gm{�3�B (9% K R � .'& B9C . ,'0 RSKwBH)

K . l�3`GJK�G RhC (9% K � N:Kw{ ( 0735) ( �h,JR � ( ) � . &�. C ( KwBH0 � . & )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 .� E 3�BH0 & N"N:C+ � " ? � � � ��! # � � # ? � � � ) � � � � " � � �� ��� ! ? � � � � � � � o n/ D�� p, � " ? � � � � � � � # � � # ? � � # � ! "� � �� ��� ! ?

�� � o n/ D5n p+ � " � &�. G", � " � l &�. RSK=K��`6'B9K�)9)vK�G � . l�B9K�07K ./(9& N"N:C & )+ � " � " ? + � # � � , � " � " ? � � � # , � ( o n/ D�y p

# K . 3�IK�� & 0 � . K � . GJK (9& �"N (9% K & l ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0�3 . � " {�3�B &�. & B9R � ( B & B9C � % # � ����� ( ( (��H?�� ���&5 � & l % ) (9& O�K 3�{ (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�K�� ( K . G') (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 ( 3 � . lwN",'GJK73 . K 073�B9K �h,JR � ( ��)v3 (9%'&!( & { ( KwB� ) (9& O�K�) (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 %'& )PRSKwK . l & N"lw,'N &!( K�G {�3�B (9% KmN:Kw{ ( 0735) ( � �h,JR � ( ) &�. G (9% KB9K�)9,'N ( )d) ( 3�B9K�G � .7(9% 35)vK �h,JR � ( ) � . R � (�� B9Kwx�KwBH)vK�GM{�3�BH0 �E 3�BH0 & N"N:C��hI4K & )9)9,'07K (9%'&!(d(9% K,B8BH) (�� ) (9& O�K�) %'& x�K6'B93`G','l�K�G (9% K>) (9&!( K

�! ? � �� �� � ���� �"- ��� !�� � � �

� � + � , �? � � � � � ! " ( ( ( � � � � " � � " ( ( ( � � � � "%( o n/ D�| p

o E 3�B � " � � (9% �")~) (9&!( K �") ��! " � � " ( ( ( � � � � " p�L (d(9% K+K . G73�{ (9% K �C# ��(9% ) (9& O�K�� (9% K+)vC`) ( K�0 %'& ) (9% KF) (9&!( K�! ? � " � �

� �� � ���� ��� !�� � � � � -

� � + � " � , � " �? � � � ! " ( ( ( � � " � � " � " ( ( ( � � � � o n/ Q5� p

E 3�B � " � � (9% �")#B .'& N�) (9&!( K �")uo n/ D�D p T 3o)vKwK (9%'&!(d(9% K+O &!( K�)

�� � � {�35N"N:3�I4K�GMRhC � � l�3�B9B9K�l ( N:C �"0768N:K�07K ./( 3 . KF) (9& O�KF3�{ (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 E 35,JB �:KwB

( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 ��l�3 . ) �"GJKwB B8BH) (-(9% KPK_sSK�l ( 3�{ (9% K�� � � O &!( K�) 3 . (9% KM) (9&!( K o n/ D�| p TU% K �h(9% �h,JR � (=%'& ) ) (9&!( K

Page 79: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ����� � ���� ��� � ����� n!D

� � "H fjk. K & l % ( KwBH0 3�{ (9% K )9,'0 �~{�3�B7K & l % � � � (9% K (9% �h,JR � ( {�B9350 (9% K N:Kw{ ( �")� � � "H �h,JR � ( {�B9350(9% KMN:Kw{ ( �") � � "H Pj {4RS3 (9% & B9K � o (9%'&!( �")w� �:{ � � � � " � pH� (9% K . (9% KP6 %'& )vK73�{ (9%'&!(>( KwBH0 �")=0o,'N ( �:68N��:K�GmRhC� o ? � � � "� o ? � � ?�� p dT &;@ K .m& l�B935)9) & N"N�6S35)9) �:R8N:K+x & N",JK�) 3�{ J� (9% K=6 %'& )vK �") 0o,'N ( �:68N��:K�GMRhC

� �� � � ��� � !? � � � � � �� " � �� � �? �

� � ��� � !? � � � �� "� � �? � � � , � � � o n/ Q'� p

(9&;@ � . O (9% K>3�x�KwB & N"N�) (9&!( K>{�B93504o n/ D�| p ( 3�! ? � �

� �� � ���� �"- ��� !�� � � �

� � ? + � , � # � � , �? � � � ! " ( ( ( � � � � " � � " ( ( ( ��! "%( o n/ Q/? p

� K�� ( � (9% K O &!( K � � (9&;@ K�)MK & l % ( KwBH0 � . (9% �")P)9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 .f( 3 ( I43 ( KwBH0P)w�43 . KmK & l % {�3�B � � " " �#"&�. G � � " " �%"H >jk. K & l % 3�{ (9% K�)vK ( KwBH0P)w� (9% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK �")-0o,'N ( �:68N��:K�G RhC �� ) t (9% Ko6 %'& )vK 3�{ & ( KwBH0 �")0o,'N ( �:68N��:K�G RhC � � �:{ &�. GM3 . N:C �:{�RS3 (9% � � "d&�. G � � "~& B9K �%"H }d, (p&�. 3 (9% KwBpI & C�� (9% K-6 %'& )vK �")40o,'N ( �:68N��:K�GRhC�� o � � � � p dTU% ,')w� (9% K=O &!( K � � (9&;@ K�)!o n/ Q/? p ( 3 (9% K>) (9&!( K

�! ? � " � �� �� � ���� ��� !�� � � � � -

� � ? + � , � # � � , � # ?�� � � � �? � � � ! " ( ( ( � � " � � " � " ( ( ( � � � � "%( o n/ Q/D p

TU% �") ) (9&!( K l &�. RSK=B9K�l�3�O . � � K�G & )]o n/ D�D p I � (9% (9% K=6 %'& )vK={ & l ( 3�B9K�G �m3�B9K>6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C

� � + � " � , � " �? � � " � � o ? + � # � � p_o ?�� � � # , � p? � �" � � ? + � , � # � � , � # ?�� � � � �? � � � � ?�� " � + � � �? � �" � � ? + � , � # � � , � # ?�� � � � �? � � � o n/ Q�Q p

RSK�l & ,')vK (9% KoB �:O %/(�� %'&�. G ( KwBH0�0o,') (F& N:I & C`)-RSK & 0o,'N ( �:68N:K=3�{ ? � &�. G (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K l & ,')vK�) & B93 (9&!( �:3 . (9%'&!(�") & 0o,'N ( �:68N:KF3�{ ? ���'I % �"l % x &�. �") % K�)

� � ����� ��� � ���#��� ��� � � ��� � ��� � ���$� �#��� �*uh( BH,'l ( ,JB & N"N:C�� u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�{�35N"N:3�I+) u �"073 .�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 x�KwB9C lwN:35)vK�N:C

�! }~B9Kw6 & B9K ( I43MB9KwO �") ( KwBH) � . (9% K ) (9&!( K� ��� " ��� "H ?h L+6'6'68N:C � � ���( 3 (9% KAB8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB ( 3P3�R (9& � . (9% K>Kwx�K . )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ & N"NSR & ) �")U) (9&!( K�) Dh 1 & N"N (9% K>3�B & lwN:K>3 . (9% K ( I43MB9KwO �") ( KwBH) QJ �mK & )9,JB9K (9% K )vK�l�3 . G B9KwO �") ( KwB Vh L+6'68N:C (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 ( 3 (9% K B8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB �h �mK & )9,JB9K (9% K B8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB

Page 80: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

n�Q ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

W-. N:CP) ( Kw6`o V p4G �CsSKwBH)d{�B9350 (9% K=l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G � . O ) ( Kw6 � . u �"073 .�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 L G �CsSKwB9K ./(#@ � . GM3�{ E 35,JB �:KwB( B &�. )v{�3�BH0�K�� ( B & l ( )+G �CsSKwB9K ./( � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( (9% K>6SKwB �:3`G �"l � ( C73�{ � u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � & )+GJ3hK�) u �"073 .�� )w�`RSKwO � . )pRhC 6'B9Kw6 & B � . O (9% K>) (9&!( K

�! ? � ) & � ��� � ! � "%( o n/ Q/V p

TU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 (9% K . & 6'68N��:K�) (9% K=3�B & lwN:K>{�3�B�� �J6'B93`G','l � . O (9% K ) (9&!( K�! ? � ) & � ��� � !

� " � o �.p "%( o n/ Q/� p

u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 . 3�I 07K & )9,JB9K�) (9% KU)vK�l�3 . G7B9KwO �") ( KwB-o & ) � .Mu �"073 .�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � (9% �")�) ( Kw6 �") . 3 ( ) ( B �"l ( N:C. K�l�K�)9) & B9C��~R8, ( 0 &;@ K�) (9% K &�.'& N:C`) �") ) �"0768N:KwB ( 3 {�35N"N:3�IApH� &�. Ga3�R8)vKwB9x�K�) )v3507K x & N",JK t 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�� o ��!gp TU% K ) (9&!( Ko3�{ (9% KuB8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB & { ( KwB (9% �")U07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( �")+)9N��:O %/( N:C 073�B9Kol�350768N��"l &!( K�G.D � ( l�3 ./(9& � . ) (9% KK �h, & N )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ & N"N ��)9,'l % (9%'&!( � o �.p " � o ��!gp � K ( ,') l & N"N (9% K . ,'0 RSKwB73�{F)9,'l % x & N",JK�) � # � (9% 35, ( N:35)9)�3�{�O�K . KwB & N�� ( C�� (9% K . ,'0 RSKwB�I4K .'& 07K'��! �") (9% KU)90 & N"N:K�) ( )9,'l % x & N",JK��/)v3 (9%'&!(~(9% KU3 (9% KwBH) & B9KO �:x�K . RhC��! # � ��! # ? � ( ( ( � ��! # o � � � p dTU% K=) (9&!( K>3�{ (9% K=3�x�KwB & N"N )vC`) ( K�0 & { ( KwB (9% �") 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(�") (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K

�! � � � ��� � !

��! # "%( o n/ Qhn p

L (U(9% �") 6S3 � ./( � & �h, &�./( ,'0 E 35,JB �:KwB ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 �")U,')vK�G ( 3PK�� ( B & l ( � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, ( (9% �") ) (9&!( K

* E�T �� �! � � � ��� � !

��! # "��� " �! � � � ��� � !

�! ? � ) & � ��� � !

� � o ��! # ap �? � � � � � "

" �! ? � � ) & � ��� � !

�� � � ��! �? � � � � � � ��

� � !� � �? � � �� � " o n/ Q/y p

E � .'& N"N:C�� (9% KB8BH) ( B9KwO �") ( KwB �")=3�R8)vKwB9x�K�G TU% KP6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( Cm3�{ )vKwK � . O � " �")=O �:x�K . RhC (9% KM) �h, & B9KP3�{ (9% K& R8)v35N", ( K=x & N",JK=3�{ (9% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJKF3�{ � " � (9%'&!( �")

������

�! ? � � � � ��! �? � � � � � � ��

� � !� � �? � � � � �

�����

)" �

���

�! ? � � ����

) ���� � ��! �? � � � � ��� ) ������ � � ��

� � !� � �? � � � � �

�����

)

" �? � � �

������

� � ��� � !

� � �? � � � � ������

)

" �� ������

��

� � ��� � !

� � �? � � � � ������

)o n/ Q/| p

TU% �")Mx & N",JK I �"N"N+RSK N & B9O�K I % K . (9% K ( KwBH0P) � . ) �"GJK (9% K )9,'0 � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K�N:C 143 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K� ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�KPI �"N"N�3`lwlw,JB I % K . K & l % & G'G � ( �:3 . 3�{ &�. 3 (9% KwB ? � � ���) & GJ3hK�) . 3 ( 0o,'l %f& sSK�l (o(9% KP6 %'& )vK�� � K

Page 81: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� �� �� � ����� � ���� ��� � ����� n!V

I % K . � �")>lwN:35)vK ( 3 & 0o,'N ( �:68N:Ko3�{ ?��� L O�3h3`G & 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( �:3 . ( 3 � & N"N:3�I+) & B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:K � 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C6S35)9) �:R �"N�� ( C73�{ B9K�l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( � . O Ko�RhC (9&;@ � . O7O�B9K &!( K�) ( l�350P073 . GJK . 350 � .'&!( 3�BH)Yp u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�l &�. { & �"N�RSK�l & ,')vK �") & N"0735) ( l�KwB (9& � .m. 3 (+( 3 G �:x �"GJK ?�� ��)v3 (9%'&!( Kwx�K .m(9% Kol�3�B9B9K�l (

)v35N", ( �:3 . �") . 3 ( 6SKwB9{�K�l ( N:CM07K & )9,JB9K�G RhC (9% Ko* E�T � &�. G & N")v37RSK�l & ,')vK-x & N",JK�) lwN:35)vK ( 3 oI �"N"N & N")v3PG �")v68N & Cl�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:x�K � ./( KwB9{�KwB9K . l�K � .f(9% KeB .'& NpG �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 .� � 3 . K (9% K�N:K�)9)w� � ( l &�. RSK ) % 3�I . (9%'&!( I � (9% & B9R � �( B & B �"N:C % �:O % 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C�� �oeN:3�O4N:3�O apdB9Kw6SK ( � ( �:3 . )p)9, r l�K ( 3!B . G� ~TU% K=6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C73�{�)9,'lwl�K�)9) 3 . &�. C� . G �:x �"G', & N ( B � & N & l ( , & N"N:C �") &!( N:K & ) ( � o ap� D � � ����� � � �N� �#� ��� � � ���#��� ��� � � ��� � ���W-. K ) (9&�. G & BHGa6SKwB �:3`G �"l7{e, . l ( �:3 . �") K��`6S3 . K ./( � &!( �:3 . 073`G','N:3 & B'�`K�Gax & N",JKRD7O �:x�K . )v3507K8B'�`K�G � &�. G� (9%'&!(P& B9K B9K�N &!( �:x�K�N:C 6'B �"07K ( 3 K & l % 3 (9% KwB��C� o �.p " � � oe073`G � p � TU% K O�3 & Np3�{ &�. & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") ( 3GJK ( KwBH0 � . K (9% KeL;X ZaH_X 3�{Y� 073`G','N:3 � � (9% K>)90 & N"N:K�) (U. 3 . � KwB93 �m{�3�BUI % �"l % � � � � ok073`G � p W BHGJKwB � B . G � . O �")7,')vKw{e,'NpRSK�l & ,')vK (9% KwB9K �") & B &�. GJ350 � � K�G B9K�G','l ( �:3 . {�B9350 { & l ( 3�B � ��&!( �:3 . ( 3 3�BHGJKwB �

B . G � . O � �:x�K .7&�. K_r l �:K ./( I & Co3�{8l�350768, ( � . O (9% Kp3�BHGJKwB�3�{ & B9R � ( B & B9C=K�N:K�07K ./( ) � oh073`G � pH� � ( �")�6S35)9) �:R8N:K( 3P{ & l ( 3�B � K_r l �:K ./( N:C I � (9% % �:O % 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C73�{�)9,'lwl�K�)9) 1 % 3h35)vK & B &�. GJ350 � � � � � &�. G l�350768, ( K � ( ) 3�BHGJKwB dTU% ,')

� � � � � � ok073`G � p � o n/ V!� pl &�. RSK-{ & l ( 3�B9K�G & )

o ��� � � � p_o ��� � #� p � � ok073`G � p � o n/ V`� p6'B93�x �"GJK�G (9%'&!( �")=Kwx�K .� r4K�l & ,')vK� �") (9% KP3�BHGJKwBo3�{ ��� � ( �") . 3 ( (9% KMl & )vK (9%'&!( � � � � � � � o 073`G � p TU% ,') (9% K B8BH) ( { & l ( 3�B-0o,') ( RSK . 3 ./( B �:x � & N pu 3MN:3 . O & )!o � � � #� p �� � ok073`G � pH� (9% K )vK�l�3 . G { & l ( 3�B �") & N")v3. 3 ./( B �:x � & N �/)v3 (9%'&!( �:{SI4K (9&;@ K (9% K�)vK ( I43 { & l ( 3�BH) &�. GMl�350768, ( K (9% K �:B4O�B9K &!( K�) ( l�350P073 . G �:x �")v3�BH)�I � (9% � �I4K=I �"N"N %'& x�K ( I43 . 3 ./( B �:x � & N�{ & l ( 3�BH) 3�{ �� �j ( l &�. RSK=) % 3�I . (9%'&!( (9% �")p6'B93`l�K�G',JB9KF{ & �"N")4I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C&!( 0735) ( ? � � " �w�pI % KwB9K � �") (9% K . ,'0 RSKwBP3�{=G �") ( � . l ( 6'B �"07K { & l ( 3�BH)M3�{ �� E 3�B l�35076S35) � ( K . ,'0 RSKwBH)w�� � ? ��)v3 (9%'&!(+(9% �")U6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K )9,'lwl�KwK�G')+I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C &!( N:K & ) ( �) Fu`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K &6S35N:C . 350 � & N � ( �"07KF6'B93�R & R �"N��") ( �"lU{ & l ( 3�B � . O & N:O�3�B � (9% 0

� ��� � �.2 ��� � �Q& ������2�� $ ".�0/�FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�K�� ( K . G')o)v3507KM3�{ (9% K �"GJK & ) � .'% KwB9K ./( � .fu �"073 .�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � . x�KwB9C G �CsSKwB9K ./( G � �B9K�l ( �:3 . ) (9%'&�. u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 GJ3hK�) TU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 B . G') &�. K�N:K�07K ./( � . &�. , . )v3�B ( K�G G &!(9& R & )vK��&�. G & N")v3 & N"N:3�I+) & . ,'0 RSKwB43�{�B9K�N &!( K�G & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)dB9K�N &!( K�G ( 3]B . G � . O>3 . K=G �") ( � . O5, �") % K�G7K�N:K�07K ./( {�B9350 &l�35N"N:K�l ( �:3 . D~GJK ( KwBH0 � . � . O (9% K>0 � . �"0o,'0 3�B (9% K 07K�G � &�. 3�{�)9,'l %m& G &!(9& R & )vK��8{�3�BUK�� & 0768N:K E 3�BH0 & N"N:C�� �FB93�x�KwB � )U6'B93�R8N:K�0 6'B93�x �"GJK�) &�. 3�B & lwN:K � � � (9%'&!( Kwx & N", &!( K�) & {e, . l ( �:3 .

�FD # � ����& � � # � ����& o n/ V�? p .X=�G6D � @J46K RBG6D�? 7�=�8,<Q460&WN:\RB:0�:�D>46K ? :QP;7�GYO505PC7�=�:\G6D>P :�D G6E":K :8;:037�@�GITU:�D 8;G6D�:$<GB8;M�K ? <Q4I7�:QP �\WN:K ? 460�R6D�GB2�M�@AX0�G67��F2�@F7

7�=�: 8C2�K 7�? M�K ? <Q4I7�? TU:YR6D�GB2�M�8;GXP 2�K G,7 ]

Page 82: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

n!� ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

)9,'l %a(9%'&!( � o ��!gp�" � {�3�B )v3507K ) � . O5N:K ��! % # � ����& � � &�. G � o �.p " � {�3�B & N"N � �" ��! mTU% K (9& ) @ 3�{ &�.& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") ( 3 GJK ( KwBH0 � . K (9% K x & N",JKo3�{ ��! � 3 ( K (9%'&!( � , . N�� @ K>6'B9Kwx �:35,')+6'B93�R8N:K�0P)w� (9% KwB9K & B9K & O�B9K &!(0 &�. C�= � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O ? l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�6'B93�R8N:K�0P)FI % �"l % l &�. RSK B9K�G','l�K�G ( 3 (9% �")-3 . K ME 3�B & 6'B93�R8N:K�0�3�{G &!(9& R & )vK>)vK & BHl % �J{�3�B K�� & 0768N:K�� (9% K-3�B & lwN:K��J3 . � . 68, ( � I435,'N"G �h,JKwB9C (9% K>G &!(9& R & )vK � . 68N & l�K ���`Kwx & N", &!( K(9% K-6'B9K�G �"l &!( K =vGJ3hK�) � l�3 ./(9& � . (9% K-B9K �h,JK�) ( K�G x & N",JK ; ?`� &�. G B9K ( ,JB . � �:{ &�. G 3 . N:C �:{ (9%'&!( 6'B9K�G �"l &!( K-I & )) &!( �") B8K�G 4W {�l�35,JBH)vK�� (9% K>G &!(9& R & )vK . KwK�G . 3 ( RSK & R8N & l @ RS3��S�JK � (9% KwB 4W-. K=l�35,'N"G��h{�3�BUK�� & 0768N:K��`68N & l�K &l �:BHlw, � ( I � (9% � .M(9% K>G &!(9& R & )vK ( 3PG �:B9K�l ( N:CMl�350768, ( K & {e, . l ( �:3 .� �TU% K=) & 07K=K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N�)v6SKwK�G',J6 & )U)vKwK .{�3�B u �"073 .�� )d6'B93�R8N:K�0�I435,'N"G & N"N:3�I & �h, &�./( ,'0 GJKwx �"l�K ( 37)v35N:x�K &�. CP6'B93�R8N:K�0 � . � } � . 6S35N:C . 350 � & N ( �"07K TU% �")=6S35)9) �:R �"N�� ( C �") . 3 ( (9% K l & )vK � � . { & l ( � �FB93�x�KwB � ) �h, & GJB &!( �"lP)v6SKwK�G',J6 �")>6'B93�x & R8N:C lwN:35)vK (9% KMRSK�) (6S35)9) �:R8N:K � . O�K . KwB & N � R8, (4. Kwx�KwB (9% K�N:K�)9)w� � ( �") & 0o,'l % 073�B9K+R'B93 & G'N:C & 6'68N��"l & R8N:K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 (9%'&�. 3 (9% KwBH)I4K %'& x�K>RSKwK . l�3 . ) �"GJKwB � . O

� � ����� ��� � �V� � ��� � ����) � ��� �

TU% KM3�B & lwN:K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � � � �") %'& N:{ (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 mjk. �FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � � � � �") & N:I & C`)7,')vK�GI � (9% (9% K>35, ( 68, ( �h,JR � ( � . ) (9&!( K � �%" ��)v3 (9%'&!( � � � & l ( )URhC 6 %'& )vK � . x�KwBH) �:3 .� TU% KF3 (9% KwB %'& N:{ 3�{ (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . �`I % �"l % I4K-I �"N"N8l & N"N � o�{�3�B=kB9K � K�l ( �:3 . � ? & )pI �"N"N

RSK�l�3507K lwN:K & B ) % 3�B ( N:C p j ( 0 &;@ K�) (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 ) �"0768N:KwB ( 3 6'B9K ( K . G (9%'&!(o(9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 %'& ) & lwl�K�)9)( 3 & )vK�l�3 . Ga3�B & lwN:K ��!���3 . K I % �"l % l�350768, ( K�) &F@`. 3�I . {e, . l ( �:3 . D � o �.p " � �:{ � " � &�. G � o �.p " �3 (9% KwB9I �")vK +TU% �")U3�B & lwN:K �") 9,') (F&�. � � R � ( l�3 ./( B935N"N:K�G � �=W-T �8R8, ( B9KwO & BHG � . O � (F& ) & )vK�l�3 . Gm3�B & lwN:K 0 &;@ K�)lwN:K & B & {�3�BH0 & N�)vC`0P07K ( B9C � .m(9% K7) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9Ko3�{��FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � �")Fl & B9B �:K�G 35, ( � .m(9% Ko{�35N"N:3�I � . O) ( Kw68)mD

�! L+6'68N:C (9% K � � R � ( @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . � � ���( 3 (9% K � � . 68, ( �h,JR � ( ) ?h +E KwK�G (9% K � � . 68, ( �h,JR � ( ) &�. G (9% K>35, ( 68, ( �h,JR � (4( 3 ��! Dh � ,'N ( �:68N:C (9% K>6 %'& )vK=3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0�RhC � � �QJ L+6'68N:C � � ���( 3 (9% K � � . 68, ( �h,JR � ( ) & O & � .�

# K l & N"N (9% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � � � � " � � �� ��! � � �� � � � 3 . K STE H_X 9RETSUL;V'�d3�B ' �FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B)vK & BHl % � . O &�. , . )v3�B ( K�G G &!(9& R & )vK l�3 . ) �") ( ) � . & 6'68N:C � . O � o�{�3�Bo)v3507K � I4KPI �"N"N�GJKwB �:x�K � . & 073507K ./( p( 3 (9% K ,')9, & N4Kwx�K . )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ & N"N4R & ) �") ) (9&!( K�)w� &�. G (9% K . 07K & )9,JB � . O (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 a# � (9% O�3h3`G6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C�� (9% K=B9K�)9,'N ( 3�{ (9% �") 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( I �"N"N�RSK ��! "H 143 . l�Kw6 ( , & N"N:C��d, . GJKwB (9% K B �:O %/( l�3 . G � ( �:3 . )w�~3 . K � ( KwB &!( �:3 . I �"N"N � . l�B9K & )vK (9% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJKM3�{ ��! "

I % �"N:K-GJK�l�B9K & ) � . O (9% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJKF3�{�Kwx�KwB9C 3 (9% KwB ( KwBH0 TU% K � ( KwB &!( �:3 . ) (9& B ( )4I � (9% )v3507K-G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . 3�{ & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK�)*� � � ( ( ( � ) & � � & l�B935)9) (9% KFR & ) �")4) (9&!( K�) � .

(9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �") ~TU% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . ) % �:{ ( ) (9% �") G �") ( B �:R8, ( �:3 . � ./( 3 � ( ) E 35,JB �:KwBUB9Kw6'B9K�)vK .��(9&!( �:3 .� uh( Kw68) ? &�. G D N:K & x�KP, ./( 35,'l % K�G (9% K7l�3hK_r l �:K ./( 3�{ ��� " I % �"N:K � . x�KwB ( � . O & N"N 3 (9% KwB>l�3hK_r l �:K ./( ) L<)vK�l�3 . G @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . (9% K . ( B &�. )9N &!( K�) (9% K�)vK l %'&�. O�K�)+R & l @ � ./( 3 (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N�R & ) �") � � =�? @J@F7�:M&? @J0�G67 0�:<:@/@�4ID/L3A @/? 0�<:S? 7J<K :Q4ID�K L�P G3:@ 0�G67$4 �V:<�7$4603L;GBW�@/:�D�TB46W�K : 132546037�? 7�L�G6E"7�=�:\@FL @F7�:8,? 0�4603L �J4L3])� =�? @

? 0XTU:�D�@/? GB0Z? @$? 0�<K 25P :QP&EHG6DS<K 4ID�? 7�L�G6E : ' :RB:@/? @AN46@\? 7\8&4�U:@J4C@/2�MN:�D *52�GB2�@$8;? 0X2�@ @/? RB0�P ? @�46M�MN:Q4ID

Page 83: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� �� �� � ����� � ���� ��� � ����� n�n

r4K�l & ,')vK� (9&;@ K�) ��� " ) (9&!( K7K �h, & N"N:C ( 3`o�3�B={�B9350 �S) � . l�K�� ) " p & N"N ) (9&!( K�) � .m(9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& NR & ) �")w� (9% K l�3hK_r l �:K ./( 3�{ ��� " � .f(9% K E 35,JB �:KwB R & ) �") �") (9% K & x�KwB & O�Km3�{ (9% K � � �~x�KwB9Ca3 (9% KwB . 3 .���� KwB93l�35076S3 . K ./( � . (9% K E 35,JB �:KwB R & ) �") )v6SK�l �CB8K�) (9%'&!( l�KwB (9& � . � �oG �CsSKwB {�B9350 (9% �") & x�KwB & O�Kax & N",JK x & N",JK E N��:6'6 � . O Kwx�KwB9C l�3hK_r l �:K ./( 3 (9% KwB (9%'&�. (9%'&!( 3 . ��� " � (9% KwB9Kw{�3�B9K�� � . x�KwB ( ) & N"N � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, (=(9% K � �K��Jl�Kw6 (U(9% K �:B & x�KwB & O�K TU% ,')w� & { ( KwB (9% K B93 (9&!( �:3 . R & l @ � ./( 3 (9% K l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& NpR & ) �")w� & N"N43�{ (9% K(� � %'& x�K RSKwK . � . x�KwB ( K�G

& RS35, (=(9% K �:B & x�KwB & O�K x & N",JK�� I % �"l % I4K . 3 (9&!( K��� Pj {dI4KPIUB � ( K � � "��� # oF� � ����IpH� (9% �") ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .)vK . G')

� � � �����oF� � ����Ip " ? �� �+� � ( o n/ V�D p

TU% K ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . � � � ��3 . (9% K73 (9% KwB %'&�. G�� � . x�KwB ( ) (9% K7x & N",JK 3�{ � &!( ��!!� &�. G N:K & x�K�) & N"N�3 (9% KwBx & N",JK�)43�{ � , ./( 35,'l % K�G 143 . ) �"GJKwB�� (9% K . � (9% K-K_sSK�l ( ) 3�{�3 . K-{e,'N"N � ( KwB &!( �:3 . 3 . (9% K � . � ( � & N8) (9&!( K � � �� ��� " �(9% K>Kwx�K . )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ & N"NSR & ) �") � . ( KwBH0P) 3�{ (9% �") {e, . l ( �:3 .��8 dTU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 RSKwO � . )pI � (9%

� � " �! ? � o n/ V�Q p

{�3�B & N"NJ� L+{ ( KwB � � � �") & 6'68N��:K�G�� � � � " �� ) & &�. G & N"N�3 (9% KwBZ� � & B9K , . l %'&�. O�K�G TU% K & x�KwB & O�K 3�{ (9% K�)vK ?��x & N",JK�) 3�{ � � �")

� �� ) & # � ���� � � �� ) &? � " � �*# �? � � � � �! ? � o n/ V�V p

TU% ,')w�JRhC & 6'68N:C � . O (9% K �"GJK ./( � ( C & RS3�x�K�� (9% K>x & N",JK=3�{ � � � RSK�l�3507K�)? � � � �

? � � � � �! ? � � o#� � p! ? � " �! ? � � D � �? � � ) � o n/ V�� p

I % �"N:K (9% K>x & N",JK=3�{ K & l % 3 (9% KwB�� ��RSK�l�3507K�)? � � � �

? � � � � �! ? � # o#� � p! ? � " �! ? � � � � �? � � � � o n/ V5n p

TU% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK 3�{ (9% KM)vK�N:K�l ( K�Gf) (9&!( K %'& ) 9,'076SK�G ) �:O . �CB�l &�./( N:C���I % �"N:K (9% K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK 3�{pK & l % 3�{ (9% K, . )vK�N:K�l ( K�Gf) (9&!( K�) %'& )oGJK�lwN�� . K�Ga)9N��:O %/( N:C jk. O�K . KwB & N � �:{ (9% K 0 & B @ K�G ) (9&!( K RSKwO � . ) (9% K � ( KwB &!( �:3 . I � (9%& 0768N�� ( ,'GJK � � � � � � �� ) &�. G (9% Kp3 (9% KwB�) (9&!( K�) %'& x�K (9% K & 6'6'B93�6'B � &!( K & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK� � � � (9% K .o(9% K l %'&�. O�K� . � � � & ) & B9K�)9,'N ( 3�{ & 6'68N:C � . Oo3 . K � ( KwB &!( �:3 . 3�{�FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �")pRS35, . GJK�G RSK�N:3�I RhC �� ) & " ) o &�. G� RSK�l�3507K�)+)90 & N"N:KwB��`R8, ( ) ( �"N"N � � p

� � ����� ��� � � �� � � ���$� �#��� �*TU% ,')w� B9Kw6SK &!( K�G & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . )>3�{ (9% K �FB93�x�KwB � ( KwB &!( �:3 . I �"N"N�Kwx�K ./( , & N"N:C B9K�)9,'N ( � . )v3507K � ( KwB &!( �:3 .a& { ( KwBI % �"l % � � �� ) r4C (9% K RS35, . G & RS3�x�K�� (9% �") (9&;@ K�)=68N & l�K & { ( KwB &!( 0735) ( � ) & " )� ) " ! ? � #� B9Kw6SK ( � ( �:3 . ) u � . l�K � � � � �� ) � & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( 3�{ (9% K )vC`) ( K�0 &!( (9% �")M6S3 � ./( � I �"N"N 6'B93`G','l�K (9% K x & N",JK ��! " I � (9%6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C &!( N:K & ) ( �) pW-. K & G'G � ( �:3 .'& N��h,JKwB9CM)9, r l�K�) ( 37GJK ( KwBH0 � . KFI % K (9% KwB (9% K � " 6'B93`G','l�K�GMRhC (9% K& N:O�3�B � (9% 0sB9K & N"N:C �")�)9,'l %7(9%'&!( � o � p " � o &�. G (9% ,') � " ��!cp �j { . 3 ( � (9% KU3�x�KwB & N"NJ6'B93`l�K�)9)~l &�. RSK B9Kw6SK &!( K�G

Page 84: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

n!y ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

& ) . K�l�K�)9) & B9C T 3 & l % �:Kwx�K 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( CM3�{�)9,'lwl�K�)9)UO�B9K &!( KwB (9%'&�.a� � ? � � B9K �h, �:B9K�) &!( 0735) ( 7B9Kw6SK ( � ( �:3 . )3�{ (9% K=3�x�KwB & N"N & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �`{�3�B ( 3 (9& N ( �"07K8o &�. G �h,JKwB �:K�)Yp �o ! ? � p

� 3 lwN & )9) �"l & N & N:O�3�B � (9% 02l &�. GJ3 & )+I4K�N"N pTU% KwB9K �") . 3 ) ( B &!( KwO�C RSK (v( KwB (9%'&�.m( 3MO5,JK�)9) &!( ��!!�8{�KwK�G � . OK & l % O5,JK�)9) ( 3 (9% KP3�B & lwN:K j ( �")>K & )vC ( 3 ) % 3�I (9%'&!( (9% �") & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�)9,'lwl�KwK�G') � . K��`6SK�l ( K�G ( �"07K ?�� � ���3�B+I � (9% 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( CMO�B9K &!( KwB (9%'&�.a� � ? � � � . ( �"07Keo � � ? � � p_o ?�� � �_p pj ( �") & N")v3MK & )vC ( 3 ) % 3�I (9%'&!(+(9% �")) ( B &!( KwO�C �")+3�6 ( �"0 & N >TU% K �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 (9% ,') & l % �:Kwx�K�) & �h, & GJB &!( �"lo)v6SKwK�G',J6m3�x�KwB (9% K7lwN & )9) �"l & N& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B (9% �")p6'B93�R8N:K�0 j ( �") 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 RSK 073�B9K 6'B9K�l �")vK & RS35, ( (9% K . ,'0 RSKwB 3�{ � ( KwB &!( �:3 . ) B9K �h, �:B9K�G ( 3 0 & � �"0 � � K (9% K

6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C73�{ B . G � . O� ��! "H � K ( ,') l�3 . ) �"GJKwB (9% K & l ( �:3 . )p3�{ &�. � ( KwB &!( �:3 . 3 . x�K�l ( 3�BH)UN:C � . O � . (9% K-68N &�. K)v6 &�.'. K�G RhC ��! "-&�. G � " � (9% K � . � ( � & N�) (9&!( K u ,J6'6S35)vK (9% KM)vC`) ( K�0 �")=lw,JB9B9K ./( N:C � . (9% KM) (9&!( K � "H TU% K3�B & lwN:K+) (9& O�K � �:68) (9% K� ��! " l�35076S3 . K ./( 3�{ � " � � K � �:68) � "�& RS35, (~(9% K & � �")�6SKwB96SK . G �"lw,'N & B ( 3 ��! " �/I % �"l %I4K l & N"N ���! ">TU% KMB93 (9&!( �:3 . ) (9& O�K 6'B9K�)vKwB9x�K�)o3 . N:C (9% K � " l�35076S3 . K ./( 3�{� � " � � K � �:68) � ">& RS35, (o(9% K � "4& � �") ~T &;@ K . ( 3�O�K (9% KwB�� (9% K . �J) � . l�K (9% K=3�x�KwB & N"N�6 & B � ( CM3�{ (9% K ( I43 ( B &�. )v{�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . ) �") . 3 .�� � . x�KwB ( � . OJ�(9% KwC 0o,') ( GJK_B . K & B93 (9&!( �:3 .� o# � (9% I %'&!(>&�. O5N:K7GJ3hK�) (9% �")-B93 (9&!( �:3 . & l ( ; LF) (9% K7{�35N"N:3�I � . O G � & O�B & 0P)�"N"N",') ( B &!( K�� &�. & B9R � ( B & B9CMx�K�l ( 3�B �") B93 (9&!( K�G RhC ( I �"l�K (9% K &�. O5N:K=RSK ( I4KwK . ���! "p&�. G$ � " D

� � � �

� ���� �

� � �

� � �

� � � �

� ���� �

� � �

� � �

� � � �

� ���� �

� � �

� � �

o n/ V�y p� K ( ,')Ul & N"N (9% �") &�. O5N:K�� 4u � . l�K ��! "4&�. G$ ���! "p& B9K>6SKwB96SK . G �"lw,'N & B��

) � . ��") � .�� o� � �! "%� � " p�"l�35) � o� ��! "%� � " p�" o� ��! " p ao� � " p ��! " � " " �! ? � ( o n/ V�| p

jk. 3�BHGJKwB ( 37B93 (9&!( K & ) (9&!( K=I % �"l % RSKwO � . ) & ) � " o � K �JB93 (9&!( K�G RhC�� {�B9350 ���! " pd)v3 (9%'&!( � ( RSK�l�3507K�) ��! " �(9% K ) � . O5N:K � � ( KwB &!( �:3 . B93 (9&!( �:3 . . KwK�G') ( 3PB9Kw6SK &!( K�Gm, ./( �"N (9% K=3�x�KwB & N"N B93 (9&!( �:3 . K �h, & N") � � B & G � &�. ) L �h, �"l @. ,'07KwB �"l & N & B9O5,'07K ./( ) % 3�I+) (9%'&!(+& 6'6'B93�� �"0 &!( K�N:C �

Q ! ? � o n/ �!� pB93 (9&!( �:3 . ) & B9KPB9K �h, �:B9K�G 143 ./( � . ,JK�G & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . )F3�{ (9% K �FB93�x�KwB � ( KwB &!( �:3 . I �"N"N l�3 ./( � . ,JK ( 3 B93 (9&!( K � "RhC ? �PK & l %m( �"07K L+{ ( KwB � ) ! ? � � ( KwB &!( �:3 . )! � " I �"N"NSRSK=x�KwB9C lwN:35)vK ( 3��� � "H 4jk. O�K . KwB & N �'{�3�B &�. C O �:x�K . � �(9% KwB9K �") &�. 3�6 ( �"0 & N . ,'0 RSKwB-3�{4B93 (9&!( �:3 . ) ( 3 6SKwB9{�3�BH0 � & { ( KwB>I % �"l % {e,JB (9% KwB-B93 (9&!( �:3 . )=I �"N"N�B9K�G','l�K (9% K& 0768N�� ( ,'GJKF3�{ (9% K>GJK�) �:B9K�G ) (9&!( K

Page 85: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� �� �� � ����� � ���� ��� � ����� n!|

� � ����� %('��� ��� ��� ��� �N� �V� � ��� � ��� ���$� �#��� �*j ( l�35,'N"G RSK (9% KMl & )vK (9%'&!( (9% KwB9K & B9K 0o,'N ( �:68N:K7)v35N", ( �:3 . ) � . (9% K G &!(9& R & )vK E 3�B (9% KMl & )vK I % KwB9K (9% KwB9K& B9K @`. 3�I . ( 3 RSK K�� & l ( N:C )v35N", ( �:3 . ) ( 3 � o �.p " � ���FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�l &�. RSK7073`G �CB8K�G ( 3 I43�B @ RhCl %'&�. O � . O (9% K . ,'0 RSKwBp3�{ � ( KwB &!( �:3 . )4B9K �h, �:B9K�G � K ( + " RSK (9% K-Kwx�K . )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ & N"N )v35N", ( �:3 . ) ( 3� o �.p " �! ~j ( �")pK & )vC ( 3Ml % K�l @ (9%'&!(

+ " " �! � �� ��� � � � " � � o n/ �`� p

)v3 (9%'&!(o� + " p� o� � " p "�� ? � ( o n/ ��? p

LF)pN:3 . O & ) B9K�0 & � . )dB9K�N &!( �:x�K�N:CM)90 & N"N8l�35076 & B9K�G I � (9%� �hI4K=l &�. ,')vK (9% K=) & 07K-)90 & N"N � ) � . K & 6'6'B93�� �"0 & �( �:3 . ( 3Ml�3 . lwN",'GJK (9%'&!( lwN:35)vK ( 3 �

Q � ? � o n/ ��D p� ( KwB &!( �:3 . ) & B9K . K�l�K�)9) & B9C LF) (9% K . ,'0 RSKwB>3�{ )v35N", ( �:3 . ) � . l�B9K & )vK�)w� (9% K �h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�l�3 ./( � . ,JK�)� ( ) �h, & GJB &!( �"l=)v6SKwK�G',J6 3�x�KwB (9% K>lwN & )9) �"l & N�3 . K��'I % �"l % B9K �h, �:B9K�) �o ) &

�p �h,JKwB �:K�)

TU% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 l &�. Kwx�K . RSK=073`G �CB8K�G ( 3 I43�B @ {�3�B &�. O V��qVPL f V . ,'0 RSKwBp3�{ )v35N", ( �:3 . ) �jk. (9% �")pl & )vK��& B &�. GJ350 . ,'0 RSKwBU3�{ � ( KwB &!( �:3 . ) {�B9350 �7( 3 ���

� ! ? � & B9Kol & B9B �:K�G 35, ( �'{�35N"N:3�I4K�G RhC & 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(w pTU% �")6'B93`l�K�G',JB9K-RS3h35) ( ) RS3h35) ( ) (9% K=K��`6SK�l ( K�G 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( CP3�{�)9,'lwl�K�)9) � {�3�B+Kwx�KwB+6S35)9) �:R8N:K � ( 3 & RS35, ( �) jk. &�. 3 (9% KwB�G �:B9K�l ( �:3 . � (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0<l &�. & N")v3FRSK43�6 ( �"0 � � K�G ( 3-I43�B @ { & ) ( KwB�I % K . � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . & RS35, (

(9% K+)vK ( 3�{�6S35)9) �:R8N:Kp)v35N", ( �:3 . ) �") & x & �"N & R8N:K �E B9350 (9% KU6SKwBH)v6SK�l ( �:x�K 3�{�B93 (9&!( �:3 . )w� (9% KUx �:B ( ,JK 3�{ & B9K � K�l ( �:3 .& RS35, ( � " �") (9%'&!( � {�3�B-Kwx�KwB9C 6S35)9) �:R8N:K� ��! " � � " �") . 3 ( 3�B (9% 3�O�3 .'& N ( 3$ ��! " � )v3 (9%'&!(=(9% K ( I43 B9K � K�l ( �:3 . )l�350 R � . K�G & B9K . 3 ./( B �:x � & N E ,JB (9% KwB�� � o� � "%� ��! " p �") (9% KP) & 07K7{�3�B=Kwx�KwB9C ��! TU% ,')w� �:{ � ( �") @`. 3�I . (9%'&!(3 . N:C )v3507KM)9,JR8)vK ( +�� # � ����& � 3�{p6S35)9) �:R8N:K � l�35,'N"G RSKP)v35N", ( �:3 . )w� (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�l &�. RSK ( I4K &;@ K�G ( 3{ & x�3�B (9% 35)vK + 4TU% KwB9K & B9K ( I43 )9,'l % 3�6 ( �"0 � ��&!( �:3 . ) & x & �"N & R8N:K E �:BH) ( � (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 l &�. ) (9& B ( I � (9%a& x�K�l ( 3�B (9%'&!( �") (9% K Kwx�K . N:C I4K �:O %/( K�G )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ (9% K

K�N:K�07K ./( )o3�{/+a�~B &!(9% KwB (9%'&�. 3�{UKwx�KwB9CaK�N:K�07K ./( 3�{ # � ����& � o & )9)9,'0 � . O (9%'&!( + l &�. RSK l�350768, ( K�GfK_r �l �:K ./( N:C p FTU% �")+l %'&�. O�KoO �:x�K�) (9% K GJK�) �:B9K�Gm) (9&!( K�)-N & B9O�KwB � . � ( � & N & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK��8)v3 (9%'&!( {�KwI4KwB � ( KwB &!( �:3 . ) & B9KB9K �h, �:B9K�G ( 3 & 0768N��:{�C (9% K�0 Fu K�l�3 . G�� (9% K B9K � K�l ( �:3 . ) % 35,'N"G RSK & RS35, (+& x�K�l ( 3�B-I % �"l %m%'& ) & N & B9O�K o &�. G�"GJK & N"N:C���K �h, & N<p &�. O5N:K I � (9% K & l % 3�{ (9% K ��� "%� � % + p &!( (9% K l�35) ( 3�{ %'& x � . O )90 & N"N:KwB &�. O5N:K I � (9%a(9% K ��� "%� � �% +hp pTU% �") l &�. RSK>GJ3 . K>RhC ,') � . O (9% K>{e, . l ( �:3 . (9%'&!( )9,J6'68N��:K�) (9% K>x & B �:35,') x & N",JK�) 3�{ � % + ( 36'B9Kw6 & B9K & x�K�l ( 3�B + " I % �"l % �")FlwN:35)vK ( 3 (9% KoKwx�K . N:C I4K �:O %/( K�G )9,J6SKwB96S35) � ( �:3 . 3�{ & N"N (9% K + +jk. 68N & l�K 3�{(9% K @F& G & 0 & BHG B93 (9&!( �:3 . � & B93 (9&!( �:3 . ( 3 & R & ) �") � . I % �"l % + " �")-3 . K73�{ (9% K7K�N:K�07K ./( ) �")=,')vK�G 7TU% K . �(9% K � . x�KwBH) �:3 .�� & RS35, (�� & x�KwB & O�K � . ) ( K & G RSK�l�3507K�) &�. � . x�KwBH) �:3 . & RS35, ( + "H L+O & � . � (9% K )v6SKwK�G',J6 3�x�KwB &) �"0 �"N & BHN:C`=v) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K�G ?7lwN & )9) �"l & N )vK & BHl % 6'B93�R8N:K�0 �") �h, & GJB &!( �"l TU% �")4O�K . KwB & N �"GJK & 3�{ � ( KwB &!( K�G & 0768N��CB�l &!( �:3 . %'& ) & N")v3 RSKwK . ,')vK�G ( 3PGJKwx�K�N:3�6 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) ( 3!B . G (9% K

07K�G � &�. 3�{ &�. , . )v3�B ( K�G )vK ( 3�{ ?�� � ( K�0P)w� & O & � . I � (9% �h, & GJB &!( �"l=)v6SKwK�G',J6 *-, & GJB &!( �"l )v6SKwK�G',J6m{�3�B &�. K��`6S3 . K ./( � & N�6'B93�R8N:K�0 �") . 3 (-& {e,'N"N:C K . l�35,JB & O � . O B9K�)9,'N (w +E B9350 & l�350 �

68, (9&!( �:3 .'& N=l�350768N:K�� � ( C�6S3 � ./( 3�{ox �:KwI>� �FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0�GJ3hK�) . 3 ( l�B935)9) &�. C0 & v3�B ( B & l (9& R �"N�� ( C

Page 86: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

y!� ������� ����� � �� ��� ��� � � ���� ��� � �����

RS35, . G & B �:K�) �j ( 0 &;@ K�)pG �Cr lw,'N ( 6'B93�R8N:K�0P)~K & ) �:KwB��hR8, (4. 3 ( )9, r l �:K ./( N:C K & ) �:KwB ( 3 0 &;@ K (9% K�0 K & )vC }~B & O �0 &!( �"l & N"N:C���O �:x�K .a(9% K % K & Gf) (9& B ( (9%'&!( l�3 . x�K ./( �:3 .'& Npl�350768, ( KwBH) %'& x�K 3 . �h, &�./( ,'0 3 . K�)w� � ( I435,'N"G RSK)9,JB96'B �") � . O �:{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH)FI4KwB9K ( 3>=vl &!( l % ,J6 ?M)9, r l �:K ./( N:C I � (9% lwN & )9) �"l & N�3 . K�) ( 3 0 &;@ K (9% K �:B,')vK=6'B & l ( �"l & N�{�3�B �FB93�x�KwB � ( Ch6SK 6'B93�R8N:K�0P)w�`Kwx�K . I � (9% (9% �") �h, & GJB &!( �"l & GJx &�./(9& O�K #%'&!( �")~073�B9K��J1 % B �") ( 3�{�� & N @!&>%'& )�6'B93�x�K .P(9%'&!( �FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") & )vC`076 ( 3 ( �"l & N"N:Co3�6 ( �"0 & N �� 3

& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 B9K �h, �:B9K�)4{�KwI4KwB �h,JKwB �:K�) (9%'&�. �FB93�x�KwB � )U{�3�B (9% K=O�K . KwB & N l & )vK 4TU% �")4B9K�)9,'N ( K_sSK�l ( �:x�K�N:C O �:x�K�)+,')& N��"0 � ( 3 .m(9% Ko6SKwB9{�3�BH0 &�. l�K O & � . )+3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH)F{�3�B-, . ) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K�G 6'B93�R8N:K�0P) +T 3 GJ3 RSK (v( KwB(9%'&�.P& �h, & GJB &!( �"lp)v6SKwK�G',J6 � & �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBd0o,') ( K��`68N:3 � ( )v3507KU)v3�B ( 3�{S) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K � . (9% K 6'B93�R8N:K�0 �) ( BH,'l ( ,JB9K (9%'&!( �") lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C G �Cr lw,'N (4( 3MN:3`l &!( K 4TU% �") �") (9% K & 6'6'B93 & l % (9&;@ K . RhC u �"073 .�� ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0

Page 87: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�������������

� ����� � � ��d���

�u��� �W".��� � � $ ��� � ".$'2-+!&

����� ��� #� �� � * ��� �� �� � ��� � ��� � � � �*-, &�./( ,'0 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . (9% Kw3�B9C �") & B �"l % B8K�N"G�� &�. G 3 . K (9%'&!( �") (9% K {�3`lw,') 3�{U0o,'l % lw,JB9B9K ./( B9K�)vK & BHl %� TU% K �h,JK�) ( �:3 . 3�{ % 3�I � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l &�. RSK ) ( 3�B9K�G � .a&�. GfK�� ( B & l ( K�G {�B9350 �h, &�./( ,'0 ) (9&!( K�) %'& )oRSKwK .)9,JR�vK�l ( K�G ( 3 )vKwx�KwB & N �h, � ( K {�BH, � ( {e,'NU{�3�BH0 & N�� ��&!( �:3 . ) *-, &�./( ,'0 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .�(9% Kw3�B9C GJK & N") I � (9% (9% KGJKwO�B9KwK ( 3 I % �"l % ) (9&!( K�)=G �")v68N & C K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( � (9% K & 0735, ./( 3�{ � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . (9%'&!( l &�. RSK K�� ( B & l ( K�G RhC0 &;@ � . Om07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )o3 . 6S3�B ( �:3 . )=3�{UK ./(9&�. O5N:K�Gf)vC`) ( K�0P)w� &�. G (9% KMB9K�N &!( �:x�K � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . l�3 ./( K ./( 3�{G �CsSKwB9K ./( )vK ( )73�{=07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )w� & 073 . O 3 (9% KwB �")9)9,JK�) *-, &�./( ,'0 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . (9% Kw3�B9C & N")v3 & N"N:3�I+) &B �:O�3�B935,')U6'B93h3�{�3�{ (9% K��5L�� :iL;V S<V k � GIH'L;X'H_M � (9%'&!( � ( �") �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 0 &;@ K & l�3�6hC 3�{ (9% Ko) (9&!( Ko3�{ &�.& B9R � ( B & B9C �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0�I % �"l % �") . 3 ( K ./(9&�. O5N:K�G I � (9% (9% K )vC`) ( K�0�RSK � . O7l�3�6 �:K�G W-. K=K��Jl � ( � . O & B9K & 3�{�B9K�)vK & BHl % � . �h, &�./( ,'0 � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . (9% Kw3�B9C �") �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350P0o, . �"l &!( �:3 . l�350 �

68N:K�� � ( C r4K�l & ,')vK K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( �") . 3 .�� N:3`l & N � �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350P0o, . �"l &!( �:3 .f%'& ) 6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) (9%'&!( l &�. RSK) ( B � @ � . O5N:C G �CsSKwB9K ./( {�B93502lwN & )9) �"l & N�l�350P0o, . �"l &!( �:3 .� � &�. C 3�{ (9% K & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) I4K %'& x�K l�3 . ) �"GJKwB9K�G l &�.RSKPB9Kw6 % B & )vK�G & ) l�350P0o, . �"l &!( �:3 . 6'B93�R8N:K�0P)mD l�3 . ) �"GJKwB � . O (9% K�0 & ) 6'B93�R8N:K�0P) � . I % �"l % (9% KMO�3 & N �") ( 30 � . �"0 � � K (9% K . ,'0 RSKwBp3�{ �h,JR � ( )4K��Jl %'&�. O�K�G RSK ( I4KwK . ( I43P6 & B ( �:K�)pB9Kwx�K & N") � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O {�K &!( ,JB9K�) 3�{ (9% K�)vK& N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) �TU% KwB9K & B9K & N")v3 &>. ,'0 RSKwB~3�{SB9K�)9,'N ( )�3 . �h, &�./( ,'0�07K & )9,JB9K�)~3�{ l�350P0o, . �"l &!( �:3 . l�350768N:K�� � ( C{�3�BUx & B �:35,') {e, . l ( �:3 . )w� � . lwN",'G � . O &7. ,'0 RSKwB 3�{�N:3�I4KwB � RS35, . G B9K�)9,'N ( )

����� ��� #� �� � *�� � � ) �N� � �) ) � �TU% K G �") ( � . l ( �:x�Km{�K &!( ,JB9K�) 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .& N")v3 %'& x�K � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O �"0768N��"l &!( �:3 . )P{�3�B l�B9Ch6 ( 3 �O�B & 6 % �"lF)9l % K�07K�) �j {�LFN��"l�K %'& )p)vK ./( r43�R & �h,JR � ( K ./(9&�. O5N:K�G I � (9% & �h,JR � ( ) % KFB9K (9& � . )w� � ( �")d6S35)9) �:R8N:KU{�3�B% KwB ( 3ol %'&�. O�K-)v3507KU6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�)�3�{ 07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./( )40 & GJKU3 . r43�R � ) �h,JR � (~&!(4&�. C ( �"07K+, ./( �"N % K+07K & )9,JB9K�)� ( �pKwx�K .�& { ( KwB ) % K %'& )P6 % C`) �"l & N"N:C =kO �:x�K . ? � (P( 3 % �"0 � &�. �:68,'N &!( �:3 . ) 3�{-K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( 0 &;@ K )v3507Kl�B9Ch6 ( 3�O�B & 6 % �"l & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . )-) �"0768N:KwBgD � ( �")F6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3ml�B9K &!( K �h, &�./( ,'0 l %'&�.'. K�N")-I % �"l % & B9K76'B93�x & R8N:C) & {�KF{�B9350 K & x�K�)9GJB93�6'6 � . OJ� &�. G ( 3 ,')vK = �h, &�./( ,'0 ( K�N:Kw6S3�B (9&!( �:3 . ? ( 3 ( B &�. )90 � ( �h, &�./( ,'0 ) (9&!( K�)p073�B9K & l �lw,JB &!( K�N:C (9%'&�. lwN & )9) �"l & N�l %'&�.'. K�N") & N"N:3�I UW-. (9% K 3 (9% KwB %'&�. G��'3 (9% KwB-l�B9Ch6 ( 3�O�B & 6 % �"l=l %'& N"N:K . O�K�)+RSK�l�3507K

y`�

Page 88: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

y�? ������� ������� �������� ��� � ���

0o,'l %m%'& BHGJKwBgD � ( �") 6S35)9) �:R8N:K-{�3�BFG �") % 3 . K�) ( 6 & B ( �:K�) ( 3 l % K &!( � . I & C`) (9%'&!( I435,'N"G %'& x�KoRSKwK . lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C�"076S35)9) �:R8N:K E 3�B+K�� & 0768N:K����h, &�./( ,'0�R � ( l�350P0 � ( 07K ./( �")p6'B93�x & R8N:C �"076S35)9) �:R8N:K *-, &�./( ,'0<l�B9Ch6 ( 3�O�B & 6 % C>O�K . KwB & N"N:C � . x�35N:x�K�)�N:K�)9) � ./( KwB & l ( �:3 . RSK ( I4KwK . �h,JR � ( ) (9%'&�. �h, &�./( ,'0<l�350768, �

(9&!( �:3 . � &�. G (9% KpB9K �h, �:B9K�07K ./( ) 3 . N:3 . O � ( KwBH0 ) ( 3�B & O�K & B9K O�K . KwB & N"N:C 0o,'l % N:3h35)vKwB �F)9, & N"N:C��!I %'&!( 0 &!(v( KwBH)�")+O�K (v( � . O & �h,JR � ( {�B9350 3 . Ko68N & l�K ( 3 &�. 3 (9% KwB � ./(9& l (w =E 3�B=)9,'l % B9K & )v3 . )w���h, &�./( ,'0 l�B9Ch6 ( 3�O�B & 6 % C %'& )K . v3�C�K�Ga073�B9KPK��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N�)9,'lwl�K�)9) ( 3mG &!( K (9%'&�. �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� *-, &�./( ,'0 l %'&�.'. K�N") %'& x�KRSKwK . l�B9K &!( K�G I % �"l %a( B &�. )90 � ( � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . 3�x�KwB G �") (9&�. l�K�)o3�{F0 &�. Cf07K ( KwBH)w� &�. G (9% K �:B (9% Kw3�B9K ( �"l & N"N:C,')vKw{e,'NS6'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) %'& x�K RSKwK . K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N"N:CMl�3 . B8BH07K�G

����� ��� #� �� � *&% �)�V� � � � �)�)� � � ��� �j ( �")FO�K . KwB & N"N:C & O�B9KwK�G (9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0 %'& BHGJI & B9K �")-, . N�� @ K�N:C ( 3 �"076'B93�x�K � . 6'B9K�l �") �:3 . &�. G ) (9& R �"N�� ( C RhC(9% K+0 &�. C 3�BHGJKwBH)�3�{�0 & O . � ( ,'GJK . K�l�K�)9) & B9C ( 3 0 &;@ K+B9K�N�� & R8N:K N & B9O�K � )9l & N:K �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . G �:B9K�l ( N:C{�K & ) �:R8N:K E 3�B (9% �")-B9K & )v3 . � & O�B9K &!( GJK & N�3�{4B9K�)vK & BHl %a&!(v( K ./( �:3 . �")-RSK � . O G �:B9K�l ( K�G ( 3 0 &;@ � . O �h, &�./( ,'0l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . { & ,'N (�� ( 35N:KwB &�./(+&!(+(9% KF=v)v3�{ ( I & B9Kg?M3�Be=vl �:BHlw, � ( ?7N:Kwx�K�NUDdl�B9K &!( � . OM)9l % K�07K�)+I % �"l % l &�. GJK ( K�l (&�. G l�3�B9B9K�l ( KwB9B93�BH) � . ) ( 3�B9K�G �h,JR � ( ) & ) (9% KwC 3`lwlw,JB *-, &�./( ,'0<KwB9B93�B~l�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . �")�0o,'l %7%'& BHGJKwB (9%'&�. lwN & )9) �"l & NhKwB9B93�B~l�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . {�3�B &-. ,'0 RSKwB�3�{8B9K & )v3 . )

E �:BH) ( � (9% K ( B &�. )9l�3 . G','l (9&�. l�K . 3 . N�� . K & B � ( �:K�)83�{J)vK�0 �"l�3 . G','l ( 3�BH)w��lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:CF,')vK�G ( 3UB9KwO�K . KwB &!( K4GJKwO�B & GJK�G) �:O .'& N") &�. GoB9K�) ( 3�B9K x�35N (9& O�K�) ( 3 (9% K �:B . 350 � .'& N`N:Kwx�K�N")w� & B9K . 3 (~& 6'68N��"l & R8N:K ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) � . � (9& B9C( �"07K � Kwx�35N", ( �:3 . 07K &�. ) (9%'&!( � ( �") . 3 ( 6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 =vl�35076'B9K�)9)'? &�. =kKwB9B93�B�? B9KwO �:3 . � . ) �"GJKU) (9&!( K=)v6 & l�K � ./( 3& )90 & N"N:KwB8= . 350 � .'& N ?oB9KwO �:3 .� u K�l�3 . G�� (9% K .'&!( ,JB9K>3�{�K ./(9&�. O5N:K�07K ./( �") )9,'l % (9%'&!( KwB9B93�BH)+l &�. 6'B93�6 & O &!( K( 3m)vC . GJB93507K �h,JR � ( )=,')vK�G ( 3mGJK ( K�l ( KwB9B93�BH) �~B9B93�B � l�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . )9l % K�07K�) 0o,') ( RSKPGJK�) �:O . K�G ( 3 6'B9Kwx�K ./(KwB9B93�BH)U{�B93502RSK � . O � .'& GJx�KwB ( K ./( N:C )v6'B9K & G RhC (9% K KwB9B93�B � l�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . 6'B93`l�K�)9) � ( )vK�N:{ �m35) ( �"076S3�B (9&�./( N:C�� � (�") . 3 ( K ./( �:B9K�N:CPlwN:K & B4I %'&!(d(9% KFB �:O %/( KwB9B93�Bp073`GJK�N")~{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) & B9K 143 . � �"l ( � . O=KwB9B93�Bp073`GJK�N")G �CsSKwB-I � (9% B9K�)v6SK�l (-( 3 I %'&!(A@ � . G')F3�{dKwB9B93�BH)=0o,') ( RSK 6'B9Kwx�K ./( K�G o�6 %'& )vKP) % �:{ ( )w� & 0768N�� ( ,'GJK KwB9B93�BH)w��R � (� �:68)w�5K ( l p &�. G % 3�I (9% K�)vKFKwB9B93�BH) & B9K-l�3�B9B9K�N &!( K�G o � . GJKw6SK . GJK ./( KwB9B93�BH)w�`l�3 . l�K ./( B &!( K�G � . )v6SK�l �CB�l �h,JR � ( )w�, . �:{�3�BH0�KwB9B93�BH) � . & N"N �h,JR � ( )w�/K ( l p � �CsSKwB9K ./( KwB9B93�B � l�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . )9l % K�07K�) GJKw{�K . G & O & � . ) ( G �CsSKwB9K ./(#@ � . G')3�{�KwB9B93�BH)

� 3 . K (9% K�N:K�)9)w� & B �"l % N�� ( KwB &!( ,JB9K+GJKwx�3 ( K�G ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0 KwB9B93�Bpl�3�B9B9K�l ( �:3 . �")dGJKwx�K�N:3�6 � . O du 3507KF)9l % K�07K�)GJB & I�,J6S3 . lwN & )9) �"l & Npl�3`G � . O (9% Kw3�B9C ( 3al�B9K &!( K �h, &�./( ,'0 l�3`GJK�)7I % �"l % & B9K B9K�) �") (9&�./( ( 3 R � ( � �:68) &�. Gl &�. l�3�B9B9K�l (-& O & � . ) ( GJK ( K�l ( K�G KwB9B93�BH) -WF(9% KwB ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�)+K��`68N:3 � (U(9% K = �h, &�./( ,'02I &!( l % GJ3�O ? K_sSK�l (=&�. G07K & )9,JB9Kox & N",JK�) (9%'&!( ) % 35,'N"G RSK @`. 3�I . I � (9% l�KwB (9& � ./( C�� (9% ,')0o�I � (9% x�KwB9C % �:O % 6'B93�R & R �"N�� ( C p l�35N"N & 68) � . O& I & C (9% K )90 & N"N4l�35076S3 . K ./( 3�{ (9% K ) (9&!( K I % �"l % �") � . KwB9B93�B uh( �"N"N~3 (9% KwB ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) � . x�35N:x�K 0 &;@ � . O0o,'N ( �:68N:K l�3�6 �:K�)P3�{ & �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .�&�. G B9Kw6SK &!( K�G'N:Cf6'B93 vK�l ( � . O (9% K�)vK l�3�6 �:K�)P3 ./( 3 & )90 & N"N)9,JR8)v6 & l�K+I % �"l %M(9% KwCM) %'& B9K��`)v3 (9%'&!( KwB9B93�BH)AoeG �CsSKwB9K . l�K�)Yp & B9K-K�N��"0 � .'&!( K�GPI % �"N:K (9% K-l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . o (9% K �:Bl�350P073 . l�35076S3 . K ./( p �")p6'B9K�)vKwB9x�K�G

����� ��� � � � � � � � �� #� �� � * � �\*) � � ��� �# K %'& x�K-{�3`lw,')vK�G�� & ) %'& ) (9% K+x & ) ( 0 & v3�B � ( C73�{�B9K�)vK & BHl % � ./( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �h3 . �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) �( K�0P) I % �"l % K . l�3`GJK>G �")9l�B9K ( K � x & N",JK�G � . {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 .� du 3507K=6'B93�6S35) & N")w� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB��8)vKwK & ) �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, �(9&!( �:3 .�� ) O�B9K &!( K�) ( ) ( B9K . O (9% & ) & R �"N�� ( C ( 37I43�B @ G �:B9K�l ( N:CPI � (9% l�3 ./( � . ,J35,')9N:C � x & N",JK�G )vC`) ( K�0P) dE KwC . 0 &�.�� )3�B �:O � .'& N�073 ( �:x &!( �:3 . {�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . I & )>6'B9K�l �")vK�N:C )9,'l % &�. & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . D>073`GJK�N�� . O �h, &�.��( ,'02)vC`) ( K�0P) � & l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .'& N"N:C G �Cr lw,'N (p(9& ) @ lwN & )9) �"l & N"N:C��'R8, ( 3 . K 3�{�O�B9K &!( � ./( KwB9K�) (+( 3M6 % C`) �"l �") ( )

Page 89: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� � ���� ��� � � ��� � ��� � ��� ��� � ������� � � � � ��� ��� y�D

u � . l�K (9% K . � &M. ,'0 RSKwBU3�{ & , (9% 3�BH) %'& x�KoGJKwx�K�N:3�6SK�G 073�B9K )v6SK�l �CB�l & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �"l=07K (9% 3`G')U{�3�B-) �"0o,'N &!( � . O�h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P) 3 . 3 (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0�)vC`) ( K�0P)

����� � � #� �� � * � ���� � � ��� � � � �E 3�B & N"0735) (p&�. CP{�3�BH0 & N�lwN & )9)43�{ 3�R�vK�l ( ) � .P(9% K (9% Kw3�B9CP3�{�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . � � ( �")d6S35)9) �:R8N:K ( 3 GJK_B . K & �h, &�.��( ,'0 x�KwBH) �:3 . 3�{ (9%'&!( lwN & )9) F# K %'& x�K7G �")9lw,')9)vK�Gm)v3507K 3�{ (9% K�)vK . KwI lwN & )9)vK�)0oe)9,'l % & ) �h, &�./( ,'0 T ,JB � . O0 & l % � . K�) &�. G �h, &�./( ,'0�l �:BHlw, � ( )YpH��R8, ( RhC . 3 07K &�. ) & N"N oTU% KwB9KoB9K�0 & � . ) & O�B9K &!( GJK & N�3�{dI43�B @ ( 3 RSKGJ3 . K � . 0 & 6'6 � . O-35, ( )9,'l % lwN & )9)vK�) &�. GMGJK ( KwBH0 � . � . O (9% K �:B~B9K�N &!( �:3 . ) % �:6 ( 3ol�3 . x�K ./( �:3 .'& N8lwN & )9)vK�) *-, &�.��( ,'0�B . � ( K � ) (9&!( K & , ( 350 &!(9& � � . 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B�� & B9K 073�B9K 6S3�I4KwB9{e,'N (9%'&�.m( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N.B . � ( K � ) (9&!( K & , ( 350 &!(9&� . )v3507KPB9K�)v6SK�l ( )w� R8, ( N:K�)9)>6S3�I4KwB9{e,'N � . 3 (9% KwBH) TU% KPB �:O %/( 0 &!(9% K�0 &!( �"l & N~{�3�BH0 & N�� ��&!( �:3 . 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'068,') % GJ3�I .m& , ( 350 &!(9& &�. G �h, &�./( ,'0 O�B & 0P0 & BH) %'& ) (9% ,')F{ & B-B9K�0 & � . K�G K�N",') �:x�K���R8, (-&!(v( K�076 ( ) &!( 6'B93 �G','l � . O>O�3h3`G GJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . )~3�{ (9% K �:B46'B93�6SKwB ( �:K�) %'& x�K=)9,JO�O�K�) ( K�G (9%'&!( � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . O B9K�)9,'N ( )40 & CMN��:K � . ) ( 3�B9K3 . l�K (9% K>B �:O %/( {�3�BH0 & N�� ��&!( �:3 . ) %'& x�K>RSKwK . I43�B @ K�G 35, (w

�u��� ����� �0)5".) ��� 2���(*)! ,+-".)0/ 1�2-/430)5"6 #".$'2-+

jk.m(9% Kw3�B9C����h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH) & B9KoRSK (v( KwB &!( l�KwB (9& � . 3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) (9%'&�. lwN & )9) �"l & N�3 . K�) Fjk. 6'B & l ( �"l�K�� � (�") G �Cr lw,'N (d( 376'B9K�G �"l ( I % K (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH) N & B9O�K=K . 35,JO % ( 3Pl & B9B9C 35, (p(9% 35)vK=3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )p3 . &. 3 .�� ( B �:x � & N )9l & N:K7I �"N"N�Kwx�KwB>RSK {�K & ) �:R8N:K }~B9K�)vK ./(=( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C �") � .'& GJK �h, &!( K ( 3 (9% K (9& ) @ � R8, (-(9% KwB9KPGJ3. 3 (4& 6'6SK & B ( 3 RSK &�. C � ./( B � . ) �"l46 % C`) �"l & N'B9K�) ( B �"l ( �:3 . )~I % �"l % I435,'N"GPR8N:3`l @7(9% KFGJKwx�K�N:3�6807K ./( 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0l�350768, ( KwBH) UTU% K>RSK�) (+(9%'&!( l &�. RSKo) & {�K�N:C ) & �"G �") (9%'&!( I � (9% � . ( K . 3�B�B8{ ( KwK . C�K & BH) � ( I �"N"N�6'B93�R & R8N:C RSK@`. 3�I . I % K (9% KwB �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH)UI �"N"N8Kwx�KwB+RSK=6S35)9) �:R8N:K W-.m(9% Ko3 (9% KwB-K . Gm3�{ (9% K )v6SK�l ( BH,'0 � (9% K & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . )U{�3�B �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH)+B9K�0 & � . , . l�KwB (9& � .�

�FB93�x�KwB � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 � & N (9% 35,JO % )9,JO�O�K�) ( �:x�K��4GJ3hK�) . 3 ( l�3�B9B9K�)v6S3 . G I4K�N"N ( 3 &�. Cf0 & v3�B 3�6SK . 6'B93�R8N:K�0P) jk. GJK�� � . O ( K�l %'. 35N:3�O�C �") ( 3h3 I4K�N"N � GJKwx�K�N:3�6SK�G7{�3�B & �h, & GJB &!( �"lU)v6SKwK�G',J673�{�, . 3�BHGJKwB9K�GP)vK & BHl %M( 3 RSKU,')vKw{e,'N u`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 %'& )�073�B9K �"0P07K�G � &!( K & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . )w��R8, ( 6SKwB �:3`G � B . G � . O ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) & B9Kd3 . N:C & 6'68N��"l & R8N:KI � (9% � . l�KwB (9& � . N��"0 � ( K�G GJ350 & � . ) *-, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . %'& )4C�K ( ( 3 ( ,JB . ,J6 & B9K & )v3 .'& R8N:C � ) � � K�G lwN & )9)3�{ O�K . KwB & N � 68,JB96S35)vK & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)d,')vKw{e,'N � . 0o,'N ( �:68N:KUl �:BHlw,'0P) (9&�. l�K�) � ./( �"N � ( GJ3hK�)4)v3J� (9% KF073 ( �:x &!( �:3 . {�3�BR8, �"N"G � . O �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH)=B9K�0 & � . )=073�B9KP3 . K73�{ lw,JB �:35) � ( C�o &�. G l�3`GJKwR'B9K &;@ � . O p (9%'&�. 3�{46'B & l ( �"l & N, ( �"N�� ( C jk. RSK ( I4KwK . (9% K�)vK K�� ( B9K�07K�)w� % 3�I4Kwx�KwB�� (9% K 6 �"l ( ,JB9K �") { & BPN:K�)9) 0o,JB @ C u ,J6'6S35)vK���{�3�B (9% K ) &;@ K 3�{

�"0 & O � .'&!( �:3 . � (9%'&!(4( 35073�B9B93�I & 6 % C`) �"lw)~B9K�)vK & BHl % N & RS3�B &!( 3�B9C7I4KwB9K ( 3 &�.'. 35, . l�K (9% KF)9,'lwl�K�)9)v{e,'N�l�B9K &!( �:3 .3�{ & ( K .�� (9% 35,') &�. G � �h,JR � ( �h, &�./( ,'0 GJKwx �"l�K l & 6 & R8N:Km3�{>l & B9B9C � . O 35, (M( K . )P3�{>0 �"N"N��:3 . ) 3�{-K�N:K�07K ./(9& B9C3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . )oRSKw{�3�B9K (9% K 3 . )vK ( 3�{FGJK�l�3 % KwB9K . l�K u ,'l % & l�350768, ( KwBPl�35,'N"Gfl & B9B9Ca35, (Mu`% 3�B � ) & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �{ & l ( 3�B � . O � . )vK�l�3 . G') . ,'0 RSKwBH) (9%'&!( I435,'N"G (9&;@ K C�K & BH) ( 3 { & l ( 3�Bo3 . lwN & )9) �"l & Ndl�350768, ( KwBH) LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0GJK�) �:O . KwBH) &�. Gml�350768N:K�� � ( C (9% Kw3�B �") ( )+l�35,'N"Gml & B9B9C 35, ( K��`6SKwB �"07K ./( )U3 . �h, &�./( ,'02)vK & BHl % % K�,JB �") ( �"lw) &�. G& x�KwB & O�K � l & )vKFl�350768N:K�� � ( C>3�{��h, &�./( ,'0<6'B93�R8N:K�0P) j {'3 . K43�{ (9% K�0<I4KwB9K ( 3=G �")9l�3�x�KwB &-. KwI % �:O % N:C � K_r l �:K ./(�h, &�./( ,'0 & N:O�3�B � (9% 0 {�3�B & ,JR ��h, � ( 35,')~6'B93�R8N:K�0 � . l�350768, ( KwBU)9l �:K . l�K�� � ( l�35,'N"G RSK �"0768N:K�07K ./( K�GM3 . (9% �")% Ch6S3 (9% K ( �"l & N�l�350768, ( KwB I � (9% x�KwB9C N�� (v( N:K=G �Cr lw,'N ( C du ,'l % & l�350768, ( KwB+l�35,'N"G RSK=,')vK�G>=k35, ( 3�{ (9% K-RS3��S� ?& ) � ( I4KwB9K��6H_bRH_V E<G L;O k;G0M9;V ^!L�� STE<d,O VPZaH_XY: ^;S<V k,NPXYS<VPJmS NP: HYd-Z;S �AH_X X 9 Z;SUJ�9;:<: ^��YX L;M E<G LqdgHAL��-9;V ^]J�L;M�NPOIE H_XVPL f S<V`H'lRS d_E H_VPJYHgn

Page 90: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

y�Q ������� ������� �������� ��� � ���

TU% K 6'B93�R8N:K�0P) & )9)v3`l � &!( K�G I � (9% 0 &;@ � . O �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 6S35)9) �:R8N:K >&!( Kwx�KwB9C N:Kwx�K�N�RSK ( I4KwK .%'& BHGJI & B9K &�. G & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P)w� & B9K . 3 (�( B �:x � & N/6'B93�R8N:K�0P) TU% KwC & B9K � ./( KwB9K�) ( � . OF6'B93�R8N:K�0P)w�!R8, ( (9% KwC & B9K & N")v3)v35N:x�K�G 6'B93�R8N:K�0P) jk.M(9% K-N & ) (4( K . C�K & BH)w� � .M(9% K . K & B � l�350768N:K ( K & R8)vK . l�KF3�{ & l ( , & N��h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH)w�(9% KMl�350768, ( KwBo)9l �:K . l�K &�. G 6 % C`) �"lw)>l�350P0o, . � ( �:K�) %'& x�KM{�3�BH0o,'N &!( K�G &�. G B9K�)v35N:x�K�G (9% KM0 & v3�B �")9)9,JK�)=3�{�h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� TU% K=6'B93�R8N:K�0P) %'& x�Kol�3507K {�B9350�0 &�. C & B9K & )+3�{�l�350768, ( KwB+)9l �:K . l�Keo &�. Gm0 &�. C B9K�N &!( K�G G �")9l �:68N�� . K�)YpH�

R8, (d(9% K-)v35N", ( �:3 . ) %'& x�K=l�3507K-{�B9350 Kwx�K . 073�B9K LFN:O�3�B � (9% 0 GJK�) �:O .M%'& )p)9,J6'68N��:K�G & 6'68N��"l &!( �:3 . )~{�3�B �h, &�.��( ,'0�l�350768, ( KwBH) t l�350768N:K�� � ( C (9% Kw3�B9C %'& )-l�350P07K ./( K�G 3 . &�. G B9K_B . K�G (9% 35)vK & N:O�3�B � (9% 0P) } & B & N"N:K�N &�. G)9l �:K ./( �CB�l>l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .m%'& x�Ko)9,J6'68N��:K�G ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�)U{�3�BFl�3 . l�Kw6 ( , & N�� � � . O &�. Gm) �"0o,'N &!( � . O �h, &�./( ,'02l�350 �68, ( KwBH) } % C`) �"lw) %'& )�6'B93�x �"GJK�G (9% K+GJK�)9l�B �:6 ( �:3 . ) 3�{�B9K & N�� ( Co3 . I % �"l % �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . R8, �"N"G')w� &�. G)9,JO�O�K�) ( K�G �"GJK & )+{�3�B (9% K7l�3 . ) ( BH,'l ( �:3 . 3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwBH) � � . K & B & N:O�KwR'B & &�. G & , ( 350 &!(9& (9% Kw3�B9C%'& x�K GJKwx�K�N:3�6SK�G & R8) ( B & l ( 073`GJK�N")>3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� 14350768, ( KwB & BHl % � ( K�l ( ,JB9K %'& ) K��`68N & � . K�G% 3�I ( 3 l�3 .'. K�l ( R & ) �"lP3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) � ./( 3 l�350768N��"l &!( K�G % �:O % KwB � N:Kwx�K�N~3�6SKwB &!( �:3 . ) qUKwx�KwBH) �:R8N:K l�350768, ( � . O%'& )4) ( B & C�K�G {�B9350 � ( )4N:3�I � 6S3�I4KwB l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . 3�B �:O � . ) ( 3oK��`68N & � .@ KwCMl %'& B & l ( KwB �") ( �"lw)43�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350 �68, ( KwBH) E 3�BH0 & N+N:3�O �"l &�. G 6'B93�O�B & 0P0 � . O N &�. O5, & O�K GJK�) �:O . %'& x�Km6'B93�x �"GJK�G ( 3h35N")P{�3�B GJK�)9l�B �:R � . O &�. GB9K & )v3 . � . O & RS35, ( �h, &�./( ,'0 )vC`) ( K�0P) &�. G {�3�B K��`6'B9K�)9) � . O �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . ) & R8) ( B & l ( N:C 143`G � . O(9% Kw3�B9C %'& )P) % 3�I . % 3�I ( 3 �"076'B93�x�K (9% K ) (9& R �"N�� ( Ca3�{ �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . )w�dKwx�K . � . (9% K 6'B9K�)vK . l�K3�{+, . B9K�N�� & R8N:K %'& BHGJI & B9K � & 07K (9% Kw3�B9C��~N:K & B . � . O (9% Kw3�B9C��~N &�. O5, & O�K (9% Kw3�B9C��~G &!(9& R & )vK�)w� &�. G & B ( �CB�l � & N� ./( K�N"N��:O�K . l�K %'& x�K & N"NSRSKwO5, . ( 3PK��`68N:3�B9K (9% K �:B+l�3 .'. K�l ( �:3 . ) ( 3 �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .� *-, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �") & 0 �"l�B93`l�35)9023�{dl�350768, ( KwB=)9l �:K . l�K � &�. Cm3�{ (9% K GJK_B . � . OP6'B93�R8N:K�0P)U3�{

( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . B9K & 6'6SK & B � . �h, &�./( ,'0�l�3 ./( K�� ( ) � . )9,JR ( N:K-C�K (F. KwI {�3�BH0P) �j ( �") & 07K & )9,JB9K>3�{% 3�I I4K�N"N�GJKwx�K�N:3�6SK�G = ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N ?7l�350768, ( KwBF)9l �:K . l�K �") (9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 .m%'& ) RSKwK . & R8N:K ( 3GJB & I ,J6S3 . )v3P0 &�. C G �") ( � . l (4( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) &�. G B9K�l�K �:x�K>)v3P0 &�. C &�. )vI4KwBH) �j ( �") & 07K & )9,JB9K-3�{ % 3�I 0o,'l %B9K�0 & � . ) ( 37RSK>GJ3 . K � . = ( B & G � ( �:3 .'& N ? l�350768, ( KwB+)9l �:K . l�K (9%'&!( �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . %'& ) RSKwK . & R8N:K ( 33�6SK . )v3P0 &�. C GJ3h3�BH) &�. G 6S35)vK>)v3M0 &�. C �h,JK�) ( �:3 . )

Page 91: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� ��� � �d��� � ��� � �

� � +�� �. �

TU% K-l &�. 3 . �"l & NSB9Kw6S35) � ( 3�B9CP{�3�BpB9K�)vK & BHl % � . �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �") (9% K������� ������MK�N:K�l ( B93 . �"lF6'B9Kw6'B � ./(& BHl % �:x�K &!( D

�� � �������������������������! #"�$

�3 %'. }~B9K�) @ �"N"N %'& ) (9& ,JO %/( & l�35,JBH)vK &!( 1 & N ( K�l % 3 . �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . {�B9350 (9% K 6SKwBH)v6SK�l ( �:x�K 3�{6 % C`) �"lw) �@ �")Aoe, . 68,JR8N��") % K�GPp N:K�l ( ,JB9K . 3 ( K�)4{�B9350 (9%'&!( l�35,JBH)vK & B9K (9% KFRSK�) (p& x & �"N & R8N:Ke= ( K�� ( RS3h3 @ ?o{�3�B (9% KB8K�N"G L ( 6'B9K�)vK ./( � (9% K�)vK . 3 ( K�) & B9K & x & �"N & R8N:K &!( D

�� � ���������%�%�%&�' ��(�"�)�*+�-,�#�� �(�,.�&�/(�0�����(�"�����(�����)�(�1.2�3�����������4�4�5��

TU% Kd6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % �"l & N �")9)9,JK�) B & �")vK�G RhC �h, &�./( ,'0<07K�l %'&�. �"lw) & B9K �h, � ( K4l�350768N��"l &!( K�G jk. 6 & B ( �"lw,'N & B � ( �")�x�KwB9CG �Cr lw,'N (>( 3 O �:x�K &�. & lwl�35, ./( 3�{+07K & )9,JB9K�07K ./(o(9%'&!( �") RS3 (9% 6 % C`) �"l & N"N:C & lwlw,JB &!( K &�. Ga6 % �"N:35)v3�6 % �"l & N"N:CB9K & )v3 .'& R8N:K E 3�B &�. & lwl�K�)9) �:R8N:K &�. G % �:O % N:C B9K & G & R8N:K 3�x�KwB9x �:KwI�3�{ (9% K�)vK �")9)9,JK�) &�. G (9% K 3�{F6'B � . l �:6 & Nl�35076SK ( � . O (9% Kw3�B �:K�)w�')vKwK

� LFN:RSKwB ( �76 O 9;V ETO M98jH'J_G 9;V SUJ_du9;VPZ;: lYN H_XYSQH_VPJYH��81 & 0 R'B �"GJO�KRD @F& B9x & BHG � . �:x�KwBH) � ( CP}~B9K�)9)w���|�|�?h

� �� ��� ���

L 6 & 6SKwB (9%'&!( G �")9lw,')9)vK�) (9% K ,')vKP3�{ � � q ( K�l %'. ��h,JK�) ( 3 l�B9K &!( K �h, &�./( ,'0�O &!( K�) o & N (9% 35,JO %a& )9)9,'0 � . O)v3507K @`. 3�I+N:K�GJO�K=3�{ � � q � . (9% K=B9K & GJKwB_p �")

�3 . K�) K ( & N �e=H*-, &�./( ,'0�� 3�O �"l � &!( K�) &�. G � ,'lwN:K & B � & O . K ( �"l qUK�)v3 .'&�. l�K }d,'N")vK u K ��h,JK . l�K�)w� ?=<IL;O XYVP9;: L��>8`9gkRV6HmETSUJ � HYdmL;VP9;VPJYH@?&A�B�C�? 6'6 ~D�V�D � D��!� � ��|�|�yh ������ ���������5�D�E#F�E�G�E

TU% K=6S35N:C`07KwBU073`GJK�NS3�{�)9l & N & R8N:K � � q �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �") 6'B93�6S35)vK�G � .y�V

Page 92: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

y�� � ���� � � �������� �

u� ��N:3�C`G�� =vLs} 3 ( K ./( � & N"N:C qUK & N�� ��& R8N:Ko*-, &�./( ,'0 14350768, ( KwB�� ?��6JmSQH_VPJYH�����A�?�6'6 +��V���| �H��V5nh� ���|�|�Dh

L�)9,'lwl�K�)9)v{e,'N~K��`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& NdB9K & N�� ��&!( �:3 . 3�{ &�. � � q �h, &�./( ,'0 l�350768, ( KwB l & B9B9C � . Om35, ( 35, ( &m( I43 � R � (x�KwBH) �:3 . 3�{��FB93�x�KwB � )F)vK & BHl %m& N:O�3�B � (9% 0 �") GJK�)9l�B �:RSK�G � .

j 1 % , &�. OPK (F& N � =v���`6SKwB �"07K ./(9& N j 0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . 3�{ E'& ) ( *-, &�./( ,'0 u K & BHl % � . O ?��#Ga^qdYSUJ�9;:� H_bcSQH f � HmEUE H_X�d��.? ��V �'6'6 dD�Q5�5y � D�Q'��� � ��|�|�yh

L )9,'lwl�K�)9)v{e,'N�K��`6SKwB��"07K ./(9& N�B9K & N � ��&!( �:3 . 3�{ &�. � � q �h, &�./( ,'02l�350768, ( KwBFl & B9B9C�� . OP35, ( �FK�, ( )9l %�� ) & N:O�3 �B�� (9% 0��") GJK�)9l�B��:RSK�G�� .

�3 . K�) &�. Gm� �m35)9l & � = j 0768N:K�07K ./(9&!( �:3 . 3�{ & *-, &�./( ,'02LFN:O�3�B�� (9% 0 ( 3 u 35N:x�K �FK�, ( )9l %�� )}~B93�R8N:K�0 3 . &�� ,'lwN:K & BU� & O . K ( �"l=qUK�)v3 .'&�. l�Ko*-, &�./( ,'0214350768, ( KwB�� ? <IL;O XYVP9;: L�� � GIH_M!SUJ�9;:�#Ga^qdYSUJ_d;A����? 6'6 ����Q/y �H����V�D � ��|�|�yh �������� ���������5��E���E����

L<)9N �:O %/( N:C ( K�l %'. �"l & N�R8, (U% �:O % N:CPB9K & G & R8N:K=B9Kwx��:KwI & B ( �"lwN:K=3 . �:3 . ( B & 6 �h, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . �")

L uh( K &�. K��,= TU% K j 3 . T B & 6 *-, &�./( ,'0 jk. {�3�BH0 &!( �:3 . }~B93`l�K�)9)v3�B�� ? #N NP: SQH'Z��#Ga^qdYSUJ_d���� �#? � �6'6 d��?�D � ��Q/D � ��|�|5n/ �������� ���������5!�E��E���

*-, &�./( ,'0�l�350768, (9&!( �:3 . I"� (9% 6 % 3 ( 3 . )#�")p6'B93�6S35)vK�G$� .

j 1 % , &�. O &�. G d& 0 & 073 ( 3J� =vL u �"0768N:K>*-, &�./( ,'0214350768, ( KwB ?�������� ���������5�%�E�%�E���

TU% K>,')vK=3�{ & )&� . O5N:K-6 % 3 ( 3 . ( 3M) ( 3�B9K 0o,'N ( �:68N:K �h,JR�� ( )'�") 6'B93�6S35)vK�G$� .

� 14KwB9{pK (o& N � = W 6 ( �"l & N u �"0o,'N &!( �:3 . 3�{F*-, &�./( ,'0 � 3�O(�"l!� ?)�#Ga^qdYSUJ�9;: � H_bcSQH f C+* ? D ��6'6q ��Qhn�n � q ��Q/y!� � ��|�|�yh �������� ���������5��E!�E���

TU% KMN � ( KwB &!( ,JB9K73 . �h, &�./( ,'0 GJ3 ( )��") . 3 ( 3�B��:35,')9N:C GJK . )vK mW-. KP3�{ (9% K 073�B9K & lwl�K�)9)&�:R8N:K & B ( �"lwN:K�)=3 .a(9% K)9,JR�vK�l ( �")

� � 35)9) &�. G � �,� � � . l�K . � 3J� =H*-, &�./( ,'0 14350768, (9&!( �:3 . I"� (9% *-, &�./( ,'0 �F3 ( )w� ?-�#Ga^qdYSUJ�9;:� H_bcSQH f C+* ? � �'6'6 U��?!� �H��?�� � ��|�|�yh ,�"���.+�0/��� ���5��E���E�%%

L . 3 .�� ( K�l�1�2�� 354�67� 2�8:9&;�<�=�3 8&�>;(2�8:;@?=�4�2�8&=�AB3 ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2$F"�>8&1$4�2�G�;(2�H"� H#3 ;(2�8&4�� 2+IJ<K� 2

Page 93: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

���

���� 9&IJH @ � 6 6��,=�4�=�6>8��� 7;(6>I59�4�2�8��,=�4�2�8&=�A�� ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�� ?�� 4�6>8:IJ3�1 ����� � ����� � 2�H:8&�>8&=+8:I�� ;�9�,=�4�2�8&=�A � 2�� ;�9�A 4E8&�>;(2$4�2�<�� ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2� 7IJ3�1�2�� 354�6 �#I5C ;�9&8!� �"� �#�%$ � ��&�'�(��*)+$,$ � ��������� ���������5���E��E.-��

/ <�� H&35=�H&H&�>;(2K;,� H:;(ADI ;,� 8&1+ID� H&H&=+IJH,� 2.0�;(610�IJ< � 2 H&� A�=�6 4E8&� 2�2�?=�4�2�8&=�A 3 ;(ADC�=+8:I59�H F"�>8&1 356 4�H&H&� 354�6 ;(2+IJH3�4�6>;(2�2 F"�>8&1�H&� A�=�6 4E8&�>;(2�9&IJH&=�6>8&H ;(2�8&1+I I_s IJ3 8&H ;,��<+IJ3 ;(1+I59&IJ2�3 I'4�2�<�I54�C I59�� ADIJ2�8&4�6�� 2�4�3535=+9�4�3 G�;(2�?=�4�2�8&=�A3 ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�H3��354�276 I�� ;(=�2�<$� 2

� �.896 IJ2�6 4�2�<�4�2�< / �,: IJH:C�4�� 2�� ; � ;�<+IJ6 H 8:;��#IJ<�=�3 I 8&1+I"� ;(ADC�6>I54+�>8 G�;,� � � A�=�6 4E8&� 2�2"4<�,=�4�2=�8&=�A>� ;(ADC�=+8:I59+� ?�������� ���������5���E��E�E.-

�A@CBED"FHG

#1+I�4I6�� 6 �>8 G@;,� ?=�4�2�8&=�AB35�>9�35=��>8&H 8:;@H&� A�=�6 4E8:I�?=�4�2�8&=�AJ =+9�� 2�2 A 4�3�1�� 2+IJH#� H#H&1+;0F"2$� 2

/ � 4E;��!;K�,=�4�2�8&=�A 35�>9�35=��>8,3 ;(ADC�6>I54+�>8 G,� ? �MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIYZN�[�\V]�P BJ�^\V] 9U^U^_^`Ia*bc#c#c �edIf"g�NIhYQTV_=fiNIU � NI_=UjR�`,\kT�NIU�Y�N�[ �lNIf"gj_�\�P5L��HO3TmP5UjOQP5�+C�C �#',n,op�%',q=)I�r)+$,$,'X�

#1+I�<+I5s�2��>8&�10�I,C�4EC I59';(2K?=�4�2�8&=�AJ =+9�� 2�2DA 4�3�1�� 2+IJH#� H

tu�Xv I59�2�H:8:IJ� 2�4�2�< � �.w 4IxJ�>9�4�2����r;K�,=�4�2�8&=�Ay� ;(ADC�6>I54+�>8 G� #1+I5;�9&G,� ? ��b 8�<�NI_=LQUj`Ia�NIU �lNIfChgj_�\kTVUXW�?#z��.?�{X��C�C �u)5(^),)Q�K)5( � 'X�l)+$,$ � �

: IJ=+8&H&3�1�| H#8&1+9&I5I5�m6��>8#=�2��10�I59�H&4�6H2(4E8:I�� H'<+IJH&3 9��16 IJ<$� 2

:}�H: IJ=+8&H&3�1��M;K�,=�4�2�8&=�Ai� ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�4�6 ~"I58 F ;�9S��H3� ?K�MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIY�N�[}\V]�P � NId�`Ia �HN+O3TmP3\kd�N�[� NIUjR�NIU >?7��z�CI��C � � 'X��)+$ � $X� #1+I!s�9�H:8'3 ;(2�H:8:9�=�3 8&�>;(2$;,� 4 =�2��10�I59�H&4�6�8 F ;I�m6��>8u2(4E8:I�� H�2(�10�IJ2K� 2

/ �ev 4E9&IJ2�3 ;�; / � 2��10�I59�H&4�6 'F ;��Xv �>8!�,4E8:I�� ;�9!�,=�4�2�8&=�A�� ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�� ?�������� ���������5�%�E�%�E�� !

/ � =�6 6 C�9&;;,�78&1�4E8"4�6 AD;(H:8"4�6 6 8 F ;I�m6��>8u2(4E8:IJH 4E9&I�=�2��10�I59�H&4�6 � H#3 ;(2�8&4�� 2+IJ<K� 2

:}�e: IJ=+8&H&3�1 I58"4�6��<; � 2��10�I59�H&4�6 �>8 G�� 2��,=�4�2�8&=�A�� ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�� ?�������� ���������5�%�E�%�E�� �

/ 3 ;(ADC�9&IJ1+IJ2�H&�10�I C�4EC I59#;(2$8&1+I�3 ;(2�H:8:9�=�3 8&�>;(2$;,� 6 4E9S2�I59"?=�4�2�8&=�Ay2(4E8:IJH"� 9&;(ABH&A 4�6 6>I59 ;(2+IJH"� H

/ �ev 4E9&IJ2�3 ;@I58"4�6��<;t 6>IJADIJ2�8&4E9&G��,4E8:IJHu� ;�9��,=�4�2�8&=�A�� ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�� ?�������� ���������5�%�EX��E�� !

Page 94: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

�,� ������������� ����� �

��� F���� �����

/ 2�IJ2+I59�4�673�1�4E9�4�3 8:I59��1xJ4E8&�>;(2K;,� 8&1+I�=�H:I ;,� ?=�4�2�8&=�AB35�>9�35=��>8&H'4�H"H&=�6�9&;(=+8&� 2+IJH3��4�6>;(2�2DF"�>8&1$H:I30�I59�4�67=�H:I3� =�6IJ?=��10E4�6>IJ2�3 IJH3��� H C�9&;p0�IJ2 � 2

:}� / 1�4E9&;(2+;p0-I58 4�6��1��;K�,=�4�2�8&=�A � �>9�35=��>8&H�F"�>8&1 � � 4�IJ< � 8&4E8:IJH3� ? �MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIY�N�[�\V]�P B��I\V]9U^U^_^`Ia �� 8 �edIf"g�N�YQTV_=f NIU � ]�PSNILQd�N�[ �lNIf"gj_�\m`,\kT�NIU�C�C �EoI&��%'I&=�r)+$,$ � ��������� ���������5��E!�E���5

8,=+9 9&IJH&=�6>8 ;(2�8&1+I H&� A�=�6 4E8&�>;(2 ;,� �>9&9&I30�I59�H&�16�6>I"3 ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�H F"�>8&1@9&I30�I59�H&�16�6>I";(2+IJH3�+4�6>;(2�2 F"�>8&1�4�F IJ4�6>8&1;,� ;�8&1+I59#9&IJH&=�6>8&H ;(2K8&� ADI � H:C�4�3 I � 9&I30�I59�H&�16�� 6 �>8 G@8:9�4�<+I5� ;�� H"354�276 I�� ;(=�2�<$� 2

� �! 7� 4�2�< �*� w,�>8&4�2�G����!;�#I30�I59�H&�16�� 6 �>8 G 4�2�< / <�� 4I6�4E8&� 3 � ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�"C 79�4�<�� 2�27 #� ADI 4�2�<� C�4�3 I � ;�9�t 2+I59S2�G,� ?)�MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIY�N�[Z\V]�P � NId�`Ia �HN+O3TmP3\kd N�[�� NIUjR�NIU >? �CIz�?'C�C � � q,$p� �I� $X�)+$,$,qX��������� ���������5��EX��E���

/ 2=�A�6 I59#;,� IJ6>IJADIJ2�8&4E9&GK3 ;(2�H:8:9�=�3 8&�>;(2�Hu� ;�9"9&I30�I59�H&�16�6>I�35�>9�35=��>8&H'3 ;(ADC�=+8&� 2�2@4E9��>8&1�ADI58&� 354�6�� =�2�3 8&�>;(2�H#4E9&IC�9&IJH:IJ2�8:IJ<K� 2

w}�^w IJ<+9�4�6 I58"4�6��1�#;K�,=�4�2�8&=�AJ~"I58 F ;�9S��Hu� ;�99t 6>IJADIJ2�8&4E9&G / 9��>8&1�ADI58&� 3<8 C I59�4E8&�>;(2�H3� ?�������� ���������5�%����E�� �

� ;�9&I�4�<�0E4�2�3 IJ<K8:IJ3�1�2�� ?=+IJH#354�2�6 I�� ;(=�2�<$� 2

:}�ev IJ3S��A 4�2 I58"4�6��1�#;t$#�35�>IJ2�8u~"I58 F ;�9S��H"� ;�9!�,=�4�2�8&=�AJ�4�3 8:;�9�� 2�2�� ?Z� / = M�%q � �%oI&�o=)I�l)+$,$,qX��������� ���������5!�E���E�� !�*�H� ;(H&H:I58:83� ;K�,=�4�2�8&=�A>� 4E9&9&G.� � 4+0�I / 9��>8&1�ADI58&� 3I� ? � � � �%$ � �%{�(.','p�%'�6 �r)+$,$ � ��������� ���������5��E��E!���9� � 4�61�E4=�#;�4�H:8"w I59�H&�>;(2�H';,� � 1+;�9+| H9�,=�4�2�8&=�Ay�4�3 8:;�9�� 2�2 / 612�;�9��>8&1�A�� ?�)+$,$ ��������� ���������5��E!�E�.-

%'&)(+* � &,* B �

#1+I@� 2�H&�12(1�8 8&1�4E8 =�2�� ?=+IJ2+IJH&H,8 GC IJH�354�2)I54�C�9&IJH&H�8&1+I@9&IJH:8:9�� 3 8&�>;(2�H�� ADC ;(H:IJ< 6G 9&I30�I59�H&�16�� 6 �>8 G � H�<�=+I 8:;� 9&I32 v 4I��I59+��4�2�<K354�2�6 I�� ;(=�2�<$� 2$1�� H 8&1+IJH&� H�� 9&;(A � 4�35?=�4E9��>I � 2��10�I59�H&�>8 G.- 35=+9&9&IJ2�8&6>G�=�2+C�=�6�6 � H&1+IJ<0/K�

#1+I�C�9&;,2�9�4�A A � 2�2 6 4�2�2(=�4I2�I��<�� E��6 IJ� 2�2 <+I30�IJ6>;�C IJ<�6G v I59�2�1�4E9�<218,ADI59}� ;�9D1�� H�<+;�3 8:;�9�4�6 8&1+IJH&� H�4E88&1+IC 7IJ3�1�2�� 354�6 � 2��10�I59�H&�>8 G$;,�lw,�>IJ2�2�4=� � 2�3 ;�9&C ;�9�4E8:IJH"4�2=�A�6 I59";,� 8&1+I�8:IJ3�1�2�� ?=+IJH <+IJH&3 9��16 IJ<K� 2 3�1�4EC�8:I59qX��4�6>8&1+;(=�2(1K2+;�8#4�6 6�� � 8"� H'<+;�35=�ADIJ2�8:IJ<K4E8

�� � ��������� ����)3' ��#%�3�(��)3 ��,$3 �� ��54�"�( /�(�)�����,��#3.��.#(���3 �� �/ ���

Page 95: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

� $

7� 2+IJ4E9#6>;,2(� 3,F 4�H�s�9�H:8#<+I30�IJ6>;�C IJ<�6G7�,�>9�4E9�<$� 2

�� � �H�,�>9�4E9�<��E; 7� 2+IJ4E9) ;,2(� 3I� ? � ]�PSNILSP3\kT�OK`Ia �lNIf"gj_�\�P5L��HO3TmP5UjOQP;C5�.? C�C �u)Q�K)3&�oX�r)+$ ��� �

/ <+I58&4�� 6>IJ<$C�9&IJH:IJ2�8&4E8&�>;(2$;,� 8&1+I�=�H:I�;,� 6 � 2+IJ4E9#6>;,2(� 3,8:;@� ADC�6>IJADIJ2�8'=�2�� ?=+IJ2+IJH&H 8 GC IJH"354�2�6 I�� ;(=�2�<$� 2

tu�uv 4E9&IJ2�<�H:IJ2 4�2�< � � � ADI58&H:I59�H3�Z; � 2�� ?=+IJ2+IJH&H� GC�� 2�2�� ;�9��=�2�3 8&�>;(2�4�6 74�2�2(=�4I2�IJHKF"�>8&1� 9�4EC�1��#I5F#9��>8&� 2�2 � IJA 4�2�8&� 35H3� ?;8 `,\V]�P5f�`,\kT�OK`Ia��j\kLQ_^O+\k_=LSPQY�TVU �lNIf"gj_�\�P5L'�HO3TmP5UjOQP �.?+C�C �r{ � $p�q=)+oX�*)+$,$,qX�

7� 2+IJ4E9) �S� � � H'<+IJH&3 9��16 IJ<���8:;@4}s�9�H:8#4EC�C�9&;+4+� A 4E8&�>;(2���� 2

���Hv 4I��I59+�u;�� � H:I5��8,2�3 I,|jw 4E9�� 4I6�6>IJH 4�2�< 7� 2+IJ4E9<896��:IJ3 8&H�� � 8:;�9�4I2�I � 4�2�4I2�IJADIJ2�83���#I��IJ3Q�8&�>;(2���4�2�< � =�6>8&� �� #1+9&IJ4�<�� 2�2�� ? �� 8 �eT1WQgja1`IU ��N,\kT�OQPQY B��.?E)I��C�C �l(.{p�%{,oX�r)+$,$,{X�

�� * D"F ��� @� �

� � AD;(2�| H C�9&;,6�6>IJA�� H'<+IJH&3 9��16 IJ<�� 2

:}� � � AD;(2�� ;K8,2 8&1+I}� ;0F I59 ;,�M�,=�4�2�8&=�Ai� ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�� ?$�MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIY�N�[C\V]�P B�C,\V] 9U^U^_^`Iabc#c#c �edIf"g�N�YQTV_=f NIU \V]�P�� NI_=UjR�`,\kT�NIU�Y�N�[ �lNIf"gj_�\�P5L��HO3TmP5UjOQP@? C�C �u),)+qp�K)+o,'X�l)+$,$�(��

� 1+;�9+| H 4�612�;�9��>8&1�A F 4�Hls�9�H:8 C�9&IJH:IJ2�8:IJ<@4E8 8&1+I�)+$,$�( / 2�2=�4�6 � t#t#t � G�ADC ;(H&� =�A ;(2 +;(=�2�<�4E8&�>;(2�H ;,�*� ;(AC�C�=+8:I59 � 35�>IJ2�3 I}��4�6>;(2�2 F"�>8&1�4�356>;(H:IJ6>G 9&IJ6 4E8:IJ<�4�612�;�9��>8&1�A � ;�9 I #�35�>IJ2�8&6>G 3 ;(ADC�=+8&� 2�2 <�� H&3 9&I58:I,6>;,2(4E9��>8&1�A H3�/ 2$I54�C�4�2�<+IJ<�0�I59�H&�>;(2�;,� 8&1+I�3 ;(2�� I59&IJ2�3 I�C�4EC I59#� H

�*� � 1+;�9+��;� ;(6>G�2+;(A � 4�6 �� #� ADI / 612�;�9��>8&1�A Hr� ;�9 � 9�� ADIu�4�3 8:;�9��1xJ4E8&�>;(2�4�2�< :,� H&3 9&I58:I ;,2(4E9��>8&1�A;(2 4 �,=�4�2�8&=�A>� ;(ADC�=+8:I59+� ?���b 8 <�NI_=LQUj`IarNIU �lNIf"gj_�\kTVUXW z��.?�{X��C �")5( � (I�K)+{I&�$X�l)+$,$ � ��������� ���������5�%�E��E����

#1+I�35�>9�35=��>8 I #�35�>IJ2�8&6>G�� ADC�6>IJADIJ2�8&� 2�2�8&1+I�?=�4�2�8&=�AJ+;(=+9��>I59#8:9�4�2�H� ;�9�A�� H'C�9&IJH:IJ2�8:IJ<K� 2

:}�r� ;�C�C I59�H&A �>8&1 ; / 2 / C�C�9&;+4+� A 4E8:I�+;(=+9��>I59� 79�4�2�H� ;�9�A � H:I3� =�6 � 2 �,=�4�2�8&=�A �4�3 8:;�9�� 2�2�� ?� v � �#IJH:IJ4E9�3�1��#I5C ;�9&8"�u�!)+$,q�(.oX�

/ 2 � ADC ;�9&8&4�2�8,;�C�8&� A �1xJ4E8&�>;(2 ;,� 8&1+I ?=�4�2�8&=�A +;(=+9��>I59 8:9�4�2�H� ;�9�A 8:;$9&IJ?=��>9&I ;(2�6>G 4K6 � 2+IJ4E9 2=�A�6 I59 ;,�2(4E8:IJH � H'<+IJH&3 9��16 IJ<$� 2

�<�,� 9�� #@8&1�H 4�2�<}�9� � � ��~ � =��j; � IJA � 356 4�H&H&� 354�6�+;(=+9��>I59* 79�4�2�� ;�9�A � ;�9l�,=�4�2�8&=�A � ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�� ?� ].d�YQT�OK`Ia � P�pTmP� ��P3\�\�P5LKY@* ����C�C �#',o,o � �%',o,'=)I�l)+$,$,qX��������� ���������5�%����E�E�

Page 96: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

$I& ������������� �������

� 9&;p0�I59+| H 4�612�;�9��>8&1�A�� H#<+IJH&3 9��16 IJ<�� 2

E��� 9&;p0�I597; / �4�H:8<�,=�4�2�8&=�A � IJ3�1�4�2�� 354�6 / 612�;�9��>8&1�AJ� ;�9!:,4E8&4I6�4�H:I � IJ4E9�3�1�� ?K�MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIYN�[�\V]�P�z���\V] 9U^U^_^`Ia �� 8 �edIf"g�N�YQTV_=f NIU \V]�P�� ]�PSNILQd�N�[ �lNIf"gj_�\kTVUXW�? C�C �#o=)+op�%o=)+$X�r)+$,$,qX��������� ���������5!�E�%�E.-=�

/ C�9&;;,� 8&1�4E8�8&1+I 4�612�;�9��>8&1�A � H@;�C�8&� A 4�6+- 4�<�4EC�8:IJ< � 9&;(A � 1+9�� H:8:;,� � 4�61�E4=| H@;�9��12(� 2�4�6"6>;0F I59Z6 ;(=�2�<0/ � H3 ;(2�8&4�� 2+IJ< � 2

E�H� 9&;p0�I59 ; �";0F �4�H:8�� 4�2$4 �,=�4�2�8&=�A>� ;(ADC�=+8:I59 � IJ4E9�3�1+?�������� ���������5��E�5�E���5

/ =�2�� s�IJ< 8:9&IJ4E8&ADIJ2�8';,� 4 2=�A�6 I59 ;,�7� ADC ;�9&8&4�2�8 ?=�4�2�8&=�A 4�612�;�9��>8&1�A H 4�H 4EC�C�6 � 354E8&�>;(2�H ;,��+;(=+9��>I59'4�2�4�6 �G�H&� H'354�276 I�� ;(=�2�<$� 2

�<� �;(HxJ4=� ;K�,=�4�2�8&=�A / 612�;�9��>8&1�A H#4�2�<$8&1+I�+;(=+9��>I59" 79�4�2�H� ;�9�A�� ?@�MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIY�N�[�\V]�P � NId�`Ia�HN+O3TmP3\kd�N�[�� NIUjR�NIU �C5�#?#)+$,q,$X��C�C �#',o,'p�%',' � �r)+$,$ ��������� ���������5��E��EX�X�

/ =�2�� s�IJ< 8:9&IJ4E8&ADIJ2�8�;,� 4$2=�A�6 I59 ;,� � ADC ;�9&8&4�2�8 ?=�4�2�8&=�A 4�612�;�9��>8&1�A H 4�H�4EC�C�6 � 354E8&�>;(2�H ;,� C�1�4�H:IDIJH:8&� �A 4E8&�>;(2$8:IJ3�1�2�� ?=+IJH#354�276 I!� ;(=�2�<$� 2

�<��� 6>I30�I I58 4�6��1�u;K�,=�4�2�8&=�A / 612�;�9��>8&1�A H!�#I30�� H&�>8:IJ<�� ?K�MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIY N�[�\V]�P � NId�`Ia �HN+O3TmP3\kd�N�[� NIUjR�NIU �C5�#?E)+$,q,$X��C�C �#',',$p�%',{�(��r)+$,$ ��������� ���������5��E��E�� !

� @CBEF�� � F�B�� ��� D ( �

� 9&IJH��� 6 6�| H#H&=+9S0�I5G$4E9&8&� 356>I�;(2�� 4�=�6>8�� 8:;(6>I59�4�2�8 ?=�4�2�8&=�A 3 ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2 � H"4�6 H:;�4�2�;;�< � 2�8:9&;�<�=�3 8&�>;(2$8:;�8&1+I6 �>8:I59�4E8&=+9&I,;(2 ?=�4�2�8&=�A�I59&9&;�9"3 ;�9&9&IJ3 8&�>;(2��

/ 2�;;�< H&=+9S0�I5G�;,� ?=�4�2�8&=�AB� 2�� ;�9�A 4E8&�>;(2�8&1+I5;�9&G�� H

�9�Xv IJ2�2+I58:8 4�2�< �*� � 1+;�9+�*;K�,=�4�2�8&=�A � 2�� ;�9�A 4E8&�>;(2 #1+I5;�9&G,� ?�bc#c#c���L`IU�Y3`�O+\kT�NIU�Y�NIUZbKU+[3NILQhf�`,\kT�NIU�� ]�PSNILQd �(����C �#o � o�(I�%o � (.'X�E)+$,$ � �

/ 6�9��>I3� � 2�8:9&;�<�=�3 8&�>;(2 8:;K?=�4�2�8&=�A 3 9&GC�8:;,2�9�4EC�1�G,� 4�6>;(2�2�F"�>8&1 4�2 I54�8:IJ2�H&�10�I�6��16�6 �>;,2�9�4EC�1�GK� 2 8&1+I}s�IJ6 <��354�276 I!� ;(=�2�<$� 2

� � ;(AD;(2�4�3 ;��#; / �,=�� 3S�Z�,6 4�2�3 I,4E89�,=�4�2�8&=�Ay� 9&GC�8:;,2�9�4EC�1�G,� ? �*LQdKgH\mNIa1NSW,T�`�? z�B,� )I� C�C � )Q�m(^)I�)+$,$,$�������� ���������5�����E�%�!

Page 97: james.grimmelmann.net · 2018-02-05 · ,'0 07K l %'& . "lw) K %:R &. RSKwB>3 {U6 K 3507K.'& I "l %a& B9K N:K 3 lwN)9) Ndl 350768, O & . G (3 3 BHG.'& B9C./(,:3. *-, & ./(,'0)vC`)

$=)

/ 2$I54�C�6 4�2�4E8&�>;(2�;,� 8&1+I�� ADC ;(H&H&�16�� 6 �>8 G�;,� ?=�4�2�8&=�Ay6��>8'3 ;(A A �>8&ADIJ2�8"354�276 I!� ;(=�2�<$� 2

��� � 1�4�= 4�2�< ��� ������ ;��}; � 4I��� 2�2 / 2 t ADC�8 G � 9&;(A � H:I�� �>8&1 / �,=�4�2�8&=�A � ;(ADC�=+8:I59+� ?� NIL5\VY3O5].LQTk\�\�P�R.P5L,� ].d�YQT������.? C�C ���I& � ���,oI&=�r)+$,$ � ��������� ���������5��E�5�E�%.�

/ 9&IJ4�H:;(2�4I6�6>I�� 2�8:9&;�<�=�3 8&�>;(2�8:;@?=�4�2�8&=�AB3 ;(A A�=�2�� 354E8&�>;(2K3 ;(ADC�6>I54+�>8 G�� H

��� v =�1+9�A 4�2 I58�4�6��1�u;K�,=�4�2�8&=�Ai0�H3��� 6 4�H&H&� 354�6E� ;(A A�=�2�� 354E8&�>;(2 4�2�< � ;(ADC�=+8&4E8&�>;(2�� ? �MLNIhOQPKPSRITVUXWIYCN�[�\V]�P;B��I\V]9U^U^_^`Ia��� 8 �edIf"g�N�YQTV_=f NIU \V]�P�� ]�PSNILQd�N�[ �lNIf"gj_�\kTVUXW,�*)+$,$ � �

/ C�9&;;,� 8&1�4E8"?=�4�2�8&=�A s�2��>8:I5� H:8&4E8:I�4�=+8:;(A 4E8&4@4E9&I�� 2+IJ?=��10E4�6>IJ2�8 8:;@356 4�H&H&� 354�6Hs�2��>8:I5� H:8&4E8:I�4�=+8:;(A 4E8&4@354�26 I�� ;(=�2�<$� 2

/ ��� ;(2�<�4�35H$4�2�<� ���� 4E8:9&;(=�H3��;K8,2 8&1+I � ;0F I59K;,���,=�4�2�8&=�A � 2��>8:I � 8&4E8:I / =+8:;(A 4E8&4=� ?�MLN+OQPKPSRITVUXWIY<N�["\V]�P>B(��\V]�9U^U^_^`Ia=bc#c#c �edIf"g�N�YQTV_=fJNIU � NI_=UjR�`,\kT�NIU�Y<N�[ �lNIf"gj_�\�P5L#�HO3TmP5UjOQP@?C�C �#q,qp� � �X�r)+$,$ � �

/ 2 � 2�8:I59&IJH:8&� 2�2����1� H:;(ADI5F"1�4E8 ?=+IJH:8&�>;(2�4I6�6>I,�(H:I58 ;,� <+I5s�2��>8&�>;(2�H*� ;�9 ?=�4�2�8&=�A 3 ;(2�8:I54�8��m� 9&I5I92�9�4�A A 4E9�H 4�2�<?=�4�2�8&=�A�C�=�H&1=� <+;0F"2�4�=+8:;(A 4E8&4�4E9&I C�9&;�C ;(H:IJ<$� 2

�9� � ;;�9&I�4�2�<� ��H� 9�=+8&3�1=s�IJ6 <��r;K�,=�4�2�8&=�A / =+8:;(A 4E8&4@4�2�<��,=�4�2�8&=�A>� 9�4�A A 4E9�H3� ?�������� ���������5��E��EX���