J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID,...

35

Transcript of J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID,...

Page 1: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 2: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 3: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 4: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 5: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 6: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 7: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 8: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 9: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 10: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 11: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 12: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 13: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 14: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 15: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 16: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 17: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 18: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 19: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 20: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 21: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 22: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 23: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 24: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 25: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 26: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 27: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 28: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 29: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 30: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 31: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 32: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 33: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 34: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated:
Page 35: J. Carpio - Dissenting - SET CASE 001-15 -David v Poe ......SET CASE NO. 001-15: RIZALITO Y. DAVID, petitioner v. MARY GRACE POE LLAMANZARES, respondent. NOV 1 7 2015 Promulgated: