It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to...

31
It’s a gas, gas, gas… SPM 9541, November 2010 Aad Correljé TU Delft Economics of Infrastructures / CIEP

Transcript of It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to...

Page 1: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

It’s a gas, gas, gas…

SPM 9541, November 2010Aad Correljé

TU Delft Economics of Infrastructures / CIEP

Page 2: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 2

World primary energy consumption

BP, 2010 Statical review of world energy

Page 3: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 3

Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail…

1. Introduction

2. The value chain

3. Changes in the world energy and gas markets

4. Two economic perspectives: SCP

5. Two economic perspectives: SCP

6. Gas markets as a globalizing system

Page 4: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 4

2) The value chain

Page 5: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 5

Another value chain...

UTC, 2011 The energy value chain

Page 6: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 6

And another value chain...

UTC, 2011 The energy value chain

Page 7: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 7

Characteristics of the gas value chain……….• Long distance

• Seasonal and daily patterns

• Specific Lumpy Investment, Long lead times, high up-front cost

• Fixed v. variable cost

• Scale Economies

• Capacity utilization

• Volume Risk

• Price Risk

• Essential facilities

Page 8: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 8

Gasunie

Page 9: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 9

100 - 120

Norway

15 - 40 Central Asia

85 - 115

Algeria

IEA/OME 2004

Supply Capacities for Western Europe2010-2020(billion m³/year)

EU

Production

145

Page 10: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 10

Characteristics of the gas value chain……….• Long distance

• Seasonal and daily patterns

• Specific Lumpy Investment, Long lead times, high up-front cost

• Fixed v. variable cost

• Scale Economies

• Capacity utilization

• Volume Risk

• Price Risk

• Essential facilities

Page 11: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 11

Seasonal Variation

0

2000

4000

6000

8000

10000

12000

Netherlands Norway Total Former Soviet Union Algeria Germany Libya

Aad Correlje

Page 12: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 12

Characteristics of the gas value chain……….• Long distance

• Seasonal and daily patterns

• Specific Lumpy Investment, Long lead times, high up-front cost

• Fixed v. variable cost

• Scale Economies

• Capacity utilization

• Volume Risk

• Price Risk

• Essential facilities

Page 13: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 13

Capital cost

Energie Delta Institute, 2007

Page 14: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 14

Characteristics of the gas value chain……….• Long distance

• Seasonal and daily patterns

• Specific Lumpy Investment, Long lead times, high up-front cost

• Fixed v. variable cost

• Scale Economies

• Capacity utilization

• Volume Risk

• Price Risk

• Essential facilities

Page 15: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 15

Economics of scale

Energie Delta Institute, 2007

Page 16: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 16

Economies of Scale

Energie Delta Institute, 2007

Page 17: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 17

Characteristics of the gas value chain……….• Long distance

• Seasonal and daily patterns

• Specific Lumpy Investment, Long lead times, high up-front cost

• Fixed v. variable cost

• Scale Economies

• Capacity utilization

• Volume Risk

• Price Risk

• Essential facilities

Page 18: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 18

Integration and coordination of the value chain in the past

• Production: Oil Companies’ Long term Take or Pay/Destination Clause Net Back contracts

• Transmission and LNG: National Joint Ventures Operators’ Cost plus

• Storage: National Joint Ventures’ Cost plus

• Distribution: Public Local Municipal Firms’ Cost plus

• Retail trade: Oil parity pricing, market segmentation

Long term planning and supply/demand coordination

Page 19: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 19

Natural gas production by area

BP, 2009 Statical review of world energy

Page 20: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 20

Natural gas consumption by area

BP, 2009 Statical review of world energy

Page 21: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 21

Natural gas consumption per capita

BP, 2010 Statical review of world energy

Page 22: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 22

3) Changes in the world energy and gas markets: Uncertainties

• Changes in the Oil Market

• CO2 Emission Reduction

• Changes in the Gas industry

─ Growth in Consumption?

─ The Power Sector?

─ LNG Trade?

─ External Dependence of Main Markets

─ Liberalization of Markets

─ Integration of Regional Markets

Page 23: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 23

Reference Scenario: World Primary Energy Demand

Global demand grows by more than half over the next quarter of a century, with coal use rising most in absolute terms

Oil

Coal

Gas

BiomassNuclear

Other renewables

0

2 000

4 000

6 000

8 000

10 000

12 000

14 000

16 000

18 000

1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2030

Mto

e

Page 24: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 24

EU Gas demand forecast

Page 25: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 25

Major gas trade movements 2004

BP, 2005 Statical review of world energy

Page 26: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 26

Major gas trade movements 2008

BP, 2009 Statical review of world energy

Page 27: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 27

Proved natural gas reserves and dependence

BP, 2009 Statical review of world energy

Page 28: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 28

Reserves-to-production (R/P) ratios

BP, 2010 Statical review of world energy

Page 29: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 30

100 - 120

Norway

15 - 40 Central Asia

85 - 115

Algeria

IEA/OME 2004

Supply Capacities for Western Europe2010-2020(billion m³/year)

EU

Production

145

Page 30: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 31

EU and Russia

CIEP

Page 31: It’s a gas, gas, gas… - ocw.tudelft.nl€¦ · June 29, 2011 3 Gas Markets: From Wholesale to Retail… 1. Introduction 2. The value chain 3. Changes in the world energy and gas

June 29, 2011 32

New Gas supplies: Investments & Timing??

• What will bring the new supplies to market and when

Security of supply for EU

Security of demand for suppliers

Available capitalPace and mode of liberalisationGeopolitical and other risks