Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as...

15
Israeli Standard for Aggregates – IS 3 Arnon Bentur Presentation at the TAIEX expert mission on the Resource Efficiency of Construction and Concrete Materials Technion, Haifa, Israel July 17 th , 2018

Transcript of Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as...

Page 1: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Israeli Standard for Aggregates – IS 3

Arnon Bentur

Presentation at the

TAIEX expert mission on the Resource Efficiency of Construction and Concrete Materials

Technion, Haifa, IsraelJuly 17th, 2018

Page 2: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

1001

millimetersmicrons

clays cement grains fine aggregate coarse aggregates

Size Range

Dust/Fines/Filler/Micro-fines

Page 3: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Range and Definitions• Lightweight aggregate – up to 2000 kg/m3• Heavy weight aggregate – more than 3000 kg/m3• Coarse aggregate – bigger than 4.75 mm• Fine aggregate – smaller than 4.75 mm• Fine natural aggregate (natural sand)• Fine crushed aggregate (crushed sand)• Dust – most passing 75 microns • EN – Fines, particle size fraction of an aggregate which passes the 63 micronsns sieve• Clay lumps• Aggregate labelling – maximum and minimum sizes (e.g. 19/5)• Maximum aggregate size• Filler – material serving as mineral additive, obtained in crushing of limestone or dolomite rocks• all smaller than 600 microns at least 65% smaller than 75 microns• Flaky aggregate• Elongated aggregate• Single size aggregate• Multi size aggregate

Page 4: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Grading – Coarse Aggregate: Table 2

No definition of all-in aggregateEN Definition:aggregate consisting of a mixture of coarse and fine aggregates

Page 5: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Grading – Fine Aggregate: Table 3, 2016 Revision

Natural Crushed

Page 6: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Grading – Fine Aggregate: Table 3, 2016 Revision

Filler definition somewhat different than EN:IS - all smaller than 600 microns, 65% smaller than 75 micronsEN - all smaller than 2mm, at least 85% smaller than 125 microns, at least 70% smaller than 63 microns

Natural Crushed

Page 7: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Coarse aggregate for concrete: Table 4

Concrete gradeType A – 40MPa grade concrete (B40-C25/30)or moreType B – 30MPa concrete maximum (B30-C20/25)

LA Crushing ValueType A – 23 maximumType B – 28 maximum

AbsorptionType A – 2.5% maximumType B – 4.0% maximum

Dust (fines)Type A – 1.5% maximumType B – 2.0% maximum

5.5 Particle density and water absorption

When required the particle density and water absorption shall be

determined in accordance with EN 1097-6 and

the results declared on request stating the means of determination

and the calculations used.

AB

Page 8: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Concrete Grading IS188, 466 and EN 206

B30 - C20/25B40 – C25/30

Page 9: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained
Page 10: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Coarse aggregate for concrete: EN

Page 11: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

LA15 LA20 LA25 LA30 LA35 LA40 LA45 LA50 LA60

EN Classification – LA crushing value

IS – Type A

Cru

shin

hva

lue,

LA

tes

t

EN

IS – Type B

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

1.2

20 30 40 50 60 70

Max. EN

Max. IS

Rel

ativ

e st

ren

gth

of

con

cret

e

LA crushing value

3 %

Implications of Limits on Crushing Strength of Coarse Aggregates

Crushing value classificationsCrushing values and concrete strength

Source: A.Bekoe and M.Tia, University of Florida, Gainesville

Page 12: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Fine aggregate for concrete: Table 5

6 2 ת"ג

Concrete gradeType A – 40MPa grade concrete (B40-C25/30)or moreType B – 30MPa concrete maximum (B30-C20/25)

Dust (fines) contentType A – 15% maximumType B – 20% maximum

Page 13: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

0

5

10

15

20

25

f3 f4 f5 f6 f7 f10 f16 f22

EN classification

0

5

10

15

20

25

F5 F10 F15 F20

IS classification

Type B

Type A

Limits on Dust (IS) and Fines (EN) in Fine Aggregate

Clay limits -ENMethylene blue less than 3 when the fines content is above 3%

Clay limits -IS15% mximum content in dust of particles smaller than 5 microns

Page 14: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in ConcreteEN 12620 – Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained in crushing of limestone or dolomite rocks

all smaller than 600 microns at least 65% smaller than 75 microns

EN 2063.1.2.1 addition: finely-divided-inorganic constituent used in concrete in order to improve certain properties or to achieve special properties 3.1.2.2 type I addition: nearly inert addition 3.1.2.3 type II addition: pozzolanic or latent hydraulic addition

IS 118Allows use of filler, no provisions for properties, except sizeIS 466 Allows use of materials not covered by Israeli standard, if they comply with a foreign standardEN 12620Does not specify limiting values on properties, except definition of size• the sand equivalent value (SE) when tested in accordance with EN 933-8 exceeds a specified lower limit;• the methylene blue test (MB) when tested in accordance with EN 933-9 gives a value less than a particularspecified limit;• equivalence of performance with known satisfactory aggregate is established or there is evidence ofsatisfactory use with no experience of problems.

Page 15: Israeli Standard for Aggregates IS 3 Bentur- Israel… · Strategies for Using Dust/Fines as Fillers in Concrete EN 12620 –Filler - material serving as mineral additive, obtained

Thanks for your attention