Is this still an Interior Lining? -...

28
Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources. Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department of Natural Resources [email protected]

Transcript of Is this still an Interior Lining? -...

Page 1: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Is this still an

Interior Lining?

Heather Peters

Missouri Department of Natural Resources

[email protected]

Page 2: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

New Federal Language 280.21

• Installed in accordance with 280.33

• Inspected on 10/5 year interval

If it is no longer performing in accordance

with original design specifications and

cannot be repaired in accordance with a

code of practice developed by a nationally

recognized association or independent

testing laboratory, then the lined tank must

be permanently closed…

Page 3: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

But my lining isn’t for upgrades!

• Do you require inspection/ maintenance

for other linings?

• Compatibility?

• Repair?

• Secondary Containment?

• Do those regulations require I & M?

Page 4: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Page 5: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Interior Lining- Standards • American Petroleum Institute (API) RP1631

• National Leak Prevention Asso (NLPA) 631

• American Society for Testing and Materials

(ASTM) G158? – Purpose is for cathodic protection, not lining

• Underwriters Laboratory (UL)1856? – Construction NOT Inspection

Page 6: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

API 1631 (Periodic Inspections)

• “Qualified person”

• Thickness/ Hardness checked

• Holiday detector for air pockets, leaks,

pinholes

• Steel tank integrity test required (must

have at least 75% original steel

thickness)

Page 7: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

API 1631 (Periodic Inspections)

• Peeling

• Blistering

• Wrinkled

surface

• Defects repaired to manufacturer specs

Page 8: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Page 9: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

NLPA 631 B Lining Inspections

• Certify employees…are knowledgeable

• Special inspector or qualified person

• Lining shall be tested:

– Signs of peeling, blistering, surface wrinkling

– Thickness/ Hardness/ Holiday testing

• Steel Integrity testing requirements (must

have at least 75%/85% original steel

thickness)

Page 10: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department
Page 11: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

API 1631 and NFPA 631

• Both allow linings to be repaired

• Both require passing (75%) integrity

assessment of the steel tank

• Both have detailed breakdown of the

number and location of steel tank

measurements

• Does not allow mean-time-to-corrosion in

lieu of steel shell evaluation

Page 12: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Page 13: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department
Page 14: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Video Inspections????

• Ken Wilcox Associates Recommended

Practice for Inspecting Buried Lined Steel

Tanks Using a Video Camera

• Defines certified/qualified persons

• Signs of separation, delamination,

blistering, peeling, holidays

• Thickness/ Hardness test (minimum 5 at

each opening)

• Inspection only

Page 15: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Certifications?

• Confined Entry

• NACE International

– Coatings Inspector

• International Code Council (ICC)

– UST Installation/Retrofitting

• Society for Protective Coatings (SSPC)

• State specific?

Page 16: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

UL1856- The New Retrofit Standard

1. Lining: single-walled

2. Upgrade: double-walled

– “Co-structural”: requires original “host” tank integrity

3. Self-structural: double-walled

– Does NOT require original “host” tank integrity

– Does NOT require steel tank to pass integrity test

Page 17: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Lining (UL1856)

• Single-walled

• Lining flush

against steel

• Steel

assessment in

standards

Page 18: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

• Two walls of

the lining

• First layer

against steel

• Interstitial

space

• Steel integrity

required

Upgrade, double-walled

Page 19: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Self-structural

• Two lining

layers

• First layer

against steel

• Interstitial

space

• Steel integrity

NOT required

Page 20: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Inspections

Video/ Manned Inspection

• Every 5 years

• Assesses steel

• Assesses lining condition

• Failure only detected at

inspection (once in 5

years)

Interstitial Monitoring

• Continuous (NWGLDE def)

• Checks every day for 5

years

• Interstitial check catch

interior wall failure from

portion that contains fuel

• Exterior fail may be seen

• Does not assess condition

or approaching problems

• Detects failure immediately

?

Page 21: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Inspections and Monitoring Single-wall Lining

Video inspection

Entry inspection

5 year test

(only option)

Steel integrity

Double-wall Upgrade

Video inspection

(inside layer)

Entry inspection

(inside layer)

5 year test

Interstitial testing

? Steel Integrity

Can I even inspect it?

Self-structural

Video inspection

(inside layer)

Entry inspection

(inside layer)

5 year test

Interstitial testing

? Steel Integrity

Can I inspect it?

If steel doesn’t

matter, can I

exclude it?

Page 22: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Can I even inspection it?

• Lining: Yes, traditional inspection

• Double-walled co-structural:

– Video? Interstitial?

– If you allow G158 for steel assessment?

NOT INTENDED PURPOSE

• Self-structural:

– Inner layer only (if waive steel assessment)?

– If you allow interstitial? Video?

Page 23: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Steel Integrity Assessment

Can I do it? Must I do it?

Lining (single-walled) YES YES

Double-walled lining NO?? YES

Self-structural NO?? NO?? YES?

Page 24: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Is it eligible for repair?

Lining: Steel passes

Double-walled, co-structural:

If you allow mean-time-to-corrosion?

No repairs?

Self-structural: Manufacturer repair only? No

repairs?

Is a re-lining a repair? If okay to patch, but

prefer to re-line….

Page 25: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Patch?

But not

Re-line?

⤶ ⤶

Page 26: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Rules, Installs, Inspections

• Regulation: Inspect to industry standard

• Inspection Standard: Can repair IF steel

passes

• UL1856 Installation Standard: Steel is

irrelevant for Self-Structural

• What do I do?

Page 27: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Your Regs - Your SPA

• Opening Regulations

• Understand the standards

• What works for your state?

• Can you prove it is equitable?

• Talk to EPA about your SPA!

Page 28: Is this still an Interior Lining? - NEIWPCCneiwpcc.org/tanks2015old/tanks2015presentations/2-Monday/Is This... · Is this still an Interior Lining? Heather Peters Missouri Department

Celebrating 40 years of taking care of Missouri’s natural resources.

Questions- Now or End of the

Presentations