Is Stars War Gnostic
-
Upload
gusgonzalezpacheco -
Category
Documents
-
view
221 -
download
0
Transcript of Is Stars War Gnostic
-
8/18/2019 Is Stars War Gnostic
1/4
DAILY NEWS
Is ‘Star Wars’ Gnostic?
COMMENTARY: What is Gnosticism anyway? Are Star Wars’ spiritual influences more
Gnostic, Buddhist, or Christian?BY STEVEN D. GREYDANUS
| Posted 12/29/15 at 2:56 PM
Just before Christmas, an article appeared in The Washington Post comparing
the Star Wars prequel trilogy to the “Gnostic gospels,” such as the “Gospel of
Thomas” and the “Gospel of Judas”: “Like the gnostic Gospels, the prequels
aren’t true. Or to put it another way, they aren’t the same story as the
originals.” While the Gnostic gospels “have garnered headlines, they’ve never
been embraced by the faithful. That’s in part because they’re terrible, filled
with stilted dialogue and bizarre plot twists.”
That’s an accurate characterization both of the Gnostic gospels and the Star
Wars prequels. On the same day, though, Damon Linker in The Week disparaged the whole Star Wars phenomenon — even the universally loved
original film and its even more revered sequel, The Empire Strikes Back — for:
[w]ooden dialogue, cardboard acting, hokey humor, and a grade-school
Manichean/Gnostic metaphysics in which characters choose between
darkness and light, bodies are dismissed as “crude matter,” and dead
friends and teachers stand around glowing and offering portentous
advice…
“A kind of ‘soft Gnosticism’” is how Catholic author Michael O’Brien, in a 1998 book that has been influential among
Catholic parents and educators, characterized the spiritual milieu of Star Wars, adding that in Star Wars “the gnosis is
an undercurrent beneath the surface waves of a few Christian principles” ( A Landscape with Dragons, 60-70). While
expressing warm appreciation for the Star Wars films on a number of fronts, O’Brien adds notable reservations:
The force is neither good nor evil in itself but becomes so according to who uses it and how it is used. …
Luke and company act according to an admirable moral code, but we must ask ourselves on what moral
foundation this code is based, and what its source is. There is no mention of a transcendent God or any
attempt to define the source of “the Force.” And why is the use of psychic power considered acceptable?
… Moreover, the key figures in the overthrow of the malevolent empire are the Jedi masters, the
enlightened élite, the initiates, the possessors of secret knowledges. Is this not Gnosticism?
Is the Star Wars mythos Gnostic? If so, how Gnostic is it? The question is complicated by confusion over exactly what
Gnosticism is. At least since the mid-20th century the label has been thrown around far too freely, describing anything
from hidden knowledge or a vague or mystical spirituality to pantheism, utopianism or a one-story cosmology without
a transcendent, divine reality.
Gnosticism, like Buddhism, can be understood as a response to the problem of suffering and evil. Orthodox Judeo-Christian faith holds that creation is the good work of a wise, loving, eternal Creator, and suffering and evil are a result
of human and angelic rebellion against God.
Belief systems classified as Gnostic diverge widely, but a common thread is that suffering and evil are baked into the
cake of the material world, which is the shoddy work of an inferior and/or evil deity, not of the good God, who is
remote and uninvolved in this world.
What traps us in the prison of this material world — the “original sin” of Gnosticism — is ignorance or unknowing; what
frees us is mystical or experiential knowledge of divine truth or of the good God, by which we transcend the illusions of
corporeal existence: a process for which only a few have the necessary receptivity or openness.
Claims of Gnostic themes or influences in movies are often overstated, or at least one-sided. A movie often mentioned
in this connection is The Truman Show . Jim Carrey’s protagonist does inhabit a shoddy, fake world, a kind of prison
Article for the National Catholic Register http://www.ncregister.com/site/print_artic
3 31/12/2015 0
-
8/18/2019 Is Stars War Gnostic
2/4
created by a false god (“Christof”). On the other hand, he’s that world’s unique prisoner; everyone around Truman
knows the truth and is in on the deception. This resonates less with Gnosticism than with solipsistic fears: the thought
that perhaps I alone am real and everyone else is “fake.”
The Matrix is closer to being a Gnostic parable: Mankind has been enslaved in a shoddy imitation world, and
knowledge can enable a select few to transcend the limitations of this world. On the other hand, the “real” world
beyond the illusion is worse than the illusion. Gnostic contempt for sexuality is inverted: Mankind’s jailers “deliver” us
from sexuality with artificial reproduction, while “pure, old-fashioned, home-grown human” reproduction is celebrated.
The villainous Agent Smith, with his contempt for even simulated sense perception and physicality, is the movie’s one
true Gnostic.
What about Star Wars?
Yoda’s famous line from The Empire Strikes Back , alluded to by Linker — “Luminous beings are we, not this crude
matter” — is the most overt echo of Gnostic ideas in the Star Wars films. (That dead characters appear in spectral
form isn’t specifically Gnostic; ghost stories are common in many traditions.) There’s also an elitism in the idea that
sensitivity to the Force is a gift of the few that is congenial to the elitism of Gnosticism.
But there is no Gnostic secret in Star Wars, no sense of the world or any system in the world as a lie or a trap for the
uninitiated. O’Brien calls the Jedi a “mystery religion” — a different category from Gnosticism — but nothing we see of
the Jedi in the original trilogy or even in the prequels seems to warrant either term.
While Star Wars has mystic initiates, it neither disparages nor neglects non-initiates (as the Harry Potter series
neglects, though it does not disparage, non-magical Muggles, who are never important, effective characters even when
they’re sympathetic ones).
Non-adepts in the Force play crucial roles throughout the series. Han Solo actually takes Darth Vader out of the fight in
the climax of the original film so that Luke (certainly not yet a Jedi master) can blow up the Death Star. In Return of
the Jedi , Han disables the shield protecting the second Death Star, which is destroyed, not by a Force initiate, but by
Lando Calrissian.
“Darkness” and “light” are notable themes in Gnostic and especially Manichaean thought; they also feature
prominently in 1 John, for instance. (In Star Wars, the “light” side of the Force is usually called the “good side” —
when it’s specified at all. “The Force,” used without clarification, often means “the good side,” giving goodness a kind
of priority.)
Likewise, it’s true that Star Wars never mentions God. God also goes unmentioned in many of the fairy tales of the
Brothers Grimm and Hans Christian Andersen, along with The Wizard of Oz , The Princess Bride, The Lord of the Rings,
and, um, nearly all the parables of Jesus.
Of course Jesus himself explains the theological context and meaning of many of his parables, and in his other writingsJ.R.R. Tolkien fleshes out the religious world and meaning of The Lord of the Rings.
But why would it count against any story, much less make it implicitly Gnostic, that it takes good and evil seriously
without explicitly mentioning God? (Gnostics don’t mind talking about God.)
If Jedi spirituality resonates with any non-Christian religious tradition, it is less Gnosticism than Buddhism. The Jedi
path is a way of detachment; wayward emotions, and especially ties to family and loved ones, can lead to terrible
consequences, according to Yoda and Obi-Wan.
Yet the larger Star Wars narrative subverts this notion: It is precisely Luke’s feelings of obligation to his father, and
Vader’s feelings for his son, that redeem Darth Vader and overcome the Emperor’s evil. In the prequels, the Buddhist
influence becomes more pronounced — but so does the subversion of the Jedi, who are less wise and more fallible than
they think.
Seen as a whole, the original trilogy is the story of how evil is undone, neither by heroic violence, mystical power, nor
Buddhist detachment, but by love: specifically, by filial piety, paternal attachment and moral conversion.
That doesn’t negate any Buddhist or Gnostic influence. Still, it would be fair to say that the arc of the central Star Wars
mythos culminates in the triumph of typically Christian virtues over rival visions. In our increasingly post-Christian
culture, such signposts of truth are ever more notable and valuable.
Steven D. Greydanus is the Register’s film critic and creator of Decent Films.
He is studying for the permanent diaconate for the Archdiocese of Newark, New Jersey.
Follow him on Twitter .
Article for the National Catholic Register http://www.ncregister.com/site/print_artic
3 31/12/2015 0
-
8/18/2019 Is Stars War Gnostic
3/4
Copyright © 2013 EWTN News, Inc. All rights reserved.
Article for the National Catholic Register http://www.ncregister.com/site/print_artic
3 31/12/2015 0
-
8/18/2019 Is Stars War Gnostic
4/4
� � �